Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by nsoam on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:23AM
(#50497246)
How did they access users photos without consent? Did they run some exploit on Android to access the photo without showing the user the consent prompt? The article is really lacking in details.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by aprilthird2021 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:32AM
(#50498333)
That's kind of ridiculous though? Should there be multiple permissions for every different thing the app might want to do with your camera roll? Should a user constantly have to affirm access to the camera roll while using the app? Once should be enough!
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by microtonal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:06PM
(#50500299)
Or, you know, just don't aim to go through user's photos by default and just ask consent in the case a user enables/uses a feature that requires a photo to be sent to Facebook?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Doohickey-d on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:28PM
(#50499981)
This isn't the case for me on Android anyway. You can turn off access for media & photos in settings, and then yes, it nags you to enable it, but there's still two ways to send photos:
* either share from an outside app, e.g. the gallery, choose "share", choose "whatsapp". This gives it access only to the photo you shared from the other app.
* and in Android's settings you can give Whatsapp access to a subset of photos, then it works normally on only that subset. Then you can always add more from outside that set, by pressing the paperclip icon when you write the message, there you see the "gallery option", then you see the limited subset of photos you gave access to, at the bottom right you have a folder picker icon which opens the system's gallery picker view (google photos in my case), where you can see all photos, and it can then access that photo too.
* if you chose no access to media at all, but if whatsapp has camera access, click on the paperclip icon in the message box, then, "camera", then the "gallery" icon, there you get a screen prompting for gallery access, but on the bottom right it has the same folder icon that gives access to the system photo picker, which again will only allow access to the photo you pick there.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by drewfax on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:24AM
(#50505727)
GrapheneOS supports sandboxed storage called Storage Scope. You can make any app think it has full Storage and "Photos and Videos" permission while it is fully sandboxed and user can selectively pick the files to add to the scope.
I believe Android 17 also offers "Limited" storage option to allow permission to select Photos and Videos.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:02AM
(#50497565)
I had an HMD Nokia Android phone where the camera app had Facebook integration. It reached out to their servers every time the app started despite my not ever having had a Facebook account. I wouldn't be surprised if they also used this backdoor to access photos via the camera app's permissions.
Suffice to say, Nokia is on my blacklist of companies to never patronize again.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by contubernio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:20PM
(#50499372)
In Europe, unlike the US, consent has to be real. It's bad faith to offer ten pages of stuff no one reads and no one understands and interpret a click as consent. EU law generally requires a good faith offer and informed consent.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:07PM
(#50499813)
Do you think the "allow photo access? yes/no" dialogue has ten pages of legalese? I promise, it does not. Really unclear what Meta should do differently.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by microtonal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:01PM
(#50500257)
Just asking 'Allow photo access' is not enough under the GDPR, you have to ask consent for every different purpose that you are going to use the data for. The case is exactly about this:
Facebook requested access to users' photo galleries through a single app-wide authorisation. According to the Italian regulator, a preceding notice did not make clear that this would also allow Facebook to generate suggestions based on photos in their gallery.
They should have explicitly asked separate consent to generate suggestions based on photos.
They know this. They just made the judgement that they could get away with an 'oopsie' or a fine that is just doing cost of business. These >1B fines are good, make them feel it, so that the next time they won't violate the GDPR.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:37PM
(#50500581)
> They should have explicitly asked separate consent to generate suggestions based on photos.
I mean, this is kind of nuts. Should they ask consent every time you click to navigate to a new page, just in case you didn't want to see it? What level of granularity is acceptable?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by pamcake on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:44PM
(#50500642)
> I mean, this is kind of nuts. Should they ask consent every time you click to navigate to a new page, just in case you didn't want to see it? What level of granularity is acceptable?
I think you are obtuse and did not actually try to understand what the GDPR is saying but anyway no, it doesn't concern itself about that dimension at all. There would need to be new informed consent from the user before their data can be shared with new parties or for new purposes.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by polyomino on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:26PM
(#50501014)
GDPR advocates always assume that their own interpretation of the law is aligned with the court, but obviously we don't know that's the case until after the trial
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:39PM
(#50501186)
The data was not transmitted/processed/stored in this case! So the question remains, how granular is a "new" use? Do you need to individually consent for every photo you take? Is it even possible for Europeans to consent to a class of actions? What scope is permissible and what isn't? These are seemingly unanswered questions.
Consent should be give per purpose. So, if you asked consent to access photos for performing an upload when the user requested it, you cannot use that to do an ML analysis of all the photos. But obviously, if the users gave consent to e.g. analyzing all photos for face recognition, you do not have to ask this for every photo, every scan, etc. It should just be easy to revoke the consent and remove any data stored.
(IANAL blah blah)
The GDPR is really a straightforward law. It only isn't if you want to collect private data without telling the user about it. Or if you want to use dark patterns to make the user accept data collection without them giving free, informed consent.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by loeg on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:03PM
(#50509635)
The GDPR and its advocates caricaturize themselves. We've just moved the generality to a different term. What is a single "purpose" vs multiple purposes? The courts decided these were different purposes, but a reasonable person could decide it was all one purpose, actually.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by freecodeio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:30PM
(#50501068)
mate you are missing the point, if you have a photo editing app and you ask for consent to edit a photo, that's not consent to also use the photo to do something else with it
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:19PM
(#50501560)
It's not, Facebook processes the photos on their end and now also apparently feeds it to generative models to offer something (don't remember what exactly, managed to avoid this). At least that's what some options said last time I went exploring the app's settings page.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:48PM
(#50501822)
Well then the next one might be. What I'm saying is that, per my recent memory, the options in Facebook settings menu around camera roll suggestions don't, in any way, even suggest the processing might be happening on-device only.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by berkes on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:17PM
(#50501547)
It does not.
But if you say "We need to access your photos so you can share a few with your friends" and then proceed to upload all the photo's, you are in violation.
Which is similar to what happened here and what the Italian judge ruled to be illegal.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:32PM
(#50501680)
> But if you say "We need to access your photos so you can share a few with your friends" and then proceed to upload all the photo's, you are in violation.
> Which is similar to what happened here
In fact, it has nothing to do with what happened here; why lie? No photos were uploaded by the feature the fine was assessed for.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by AngryData on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:44PM
(#50503782)
Theoretically those terms and contracts are also not valid in the US if the average user doesn't read them. But our courts are bought and paid for so in practice it doesn't matter.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by crystaln on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:10PM
(#50500331)
Meta has a history of using simple features, like sending a photo to a contact in WhatsApp, to gain access to the user’s entire library for other purposes. This is illegal in Europe.
They use dark patterns and deception, and without knowing the details here I suspect Meta is guilty.
Meta’s response even stinks of these dark patterns, glossing over informed consent.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:04PM
(#50500802)
Yes it says so in the article. Users gave permission to access photos for one purpose and Meta abused it to access all photos for other purposes. They tried to weasel out of it by using a fine print "and other purposes" in the consent dialog, it didn't work.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by crystaln on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:14AM
(#50507488)
I just noticed the Facebook app now forces you to give access to all your photos in order to save images from the app to your photo roll. That has to be a violation of Apple’s policies.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by holgerschurig on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:23AM
(#50504802)
In a german radio news item about this they said that Meta only asked some general question "Can we access data?" that enable many different data types at one.
So the issue is a) that people had no choice ("Okay, I'll give you access to this folder, but not to my nude photos there") and b) that the text was so wishy washy that people had no idea that suddenly Meta access all of their photos now.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by robin_reala on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:13AM
(#50497670)
It’s a reasonable question, but not one that I have the answer for as I assume that information isn’t released unless there’s some failure in Meta’s payment.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:00PM
(#50500245)
Imagine I am a policeman and I come to your house and take away two months of your income as a fine for something bad you did (stole a TV from a store, say). Is that a wrist slap or is it actually quite a lot of money? I also take back the TV.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by jeltz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:41PM
(#50503467)
Yes. It would be a pretty mild punishment. Maybe not a slap on the wrist, but not much more than that. For a first time offense it would feel fair, but if I was a repeat offender I should serve prison time.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by robin_reala on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:08AM
(#50498132)
Meta made €13.11B from Europe (not the EU but close enough) in 26Q3,[1] so this is more like 1.37 months only-Europe revenue. Having said that, even this paltry amount is enough to get the US administration threatening trade wars, so I guess that’s a factor that plays into the EU’s reticence to fine more. Well, that and the fact that the Irish DPC are corrupt to the core.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by AngryData on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:43PM
(#50503777)
Do you have any examples in mind? From my view it seems like we trade extensively with the baddies and spend extraordinary effort shitting on countries who are zero threat at all.
Like what is Cuba or most of South America doing that is such a threat to the US, and yet we stomp on them all the time. We trade and make deals with dictators, often supporting the regime against their citizens for our personal gain.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by ohlookcake on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:38PM
(#50500587)
There have been multiple presidents from both parties since Facebook/Meta started getting bad press. If the reality was what you proposed, one of the parties should have taken up the case?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by ivewonyoung on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:19AM
(#50497718)
I am not saying this is the case here but it's possible that those are much more likely to be upvoted(and hence submitted).
This does seem to happen a lot with SpaceX and Tesla since about 4 years. There is no thread on Starship's latest launch yester, but the false news claiming that Hawaiian airspace was shutdown due to Starship debris rocketed up to #2 on the front page.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by mso3i on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:02AM
(#50498082)
HN is a small echo chamber of mostly tech/engineering folk.
Move to a finance echo chamber and the focus is on Meta as a money printer. Attention being a currency. Meta therefore looks almost like a Central Bank of the Attention Economy. Using the word "almost" cause there are other Central Banks like Google, TikTok etc
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by lukeschlather on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:50AM
(#50498473)
SAM (Segment Anything Model) is an underappreciated line of open weights transformer models, which Facebook has released and are absolute magic for computer vision.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by lukeschlather on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:02AM
(#50507956)
I don't really believe in "offseting evil" but it definitely benefits the public. It's not something where you can draw a straight line for the benefit, there are lots of medical applications, for example, but you're not likely to know from the research or tools that it generates that SAM was involved.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by microtonal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:54PM
(#50500194)
WhatsApp was already great before Facebook bought it. Though they did switch it to the Signal protocol for E2E encryption, which was great. Nowadays, it's still pretty useful. The AI button is annoying. There were some kerfuffles about linking WhatsApp data to Facebook/Insta data, which they promised to (I think the EU) not to do when they acquired WhatsApp, but did it anyway [1].
For the rest of Meta, just read Careless People and the linked submission is not surprising at all.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by gustavus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:23PM
(#50499401)
You know I hear people act like social media is always a net negative, but an example I like to point is the several shootings that happened during the "No kings" protest. Because of dozens of people recording and having access to social media the incident in all of its messy details came out quickly and in a way that couldn't be shut down. Now think in a world without social media how does that actually get widespread coverage? Who gets the first word out, is it random people videoing on their phones or is it the government with an official report of the incident that produces their spin?
I'm not saying social media is ideal, but it has done a lot to democratize the ability of people to share what is happening around them. Now whether that is a good or bad thing has more to do with how you feel about democracy and that's a different discussion. But although it is taking time to adapt I'd say that one now has more opportunities to be informed about the things that are going on them ever before.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by tygon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:34PM
(#50499504)
Well, the play devil's advocate, the Meta Quest series of VR headsets have been a boon for healthy exercise. It stands to reason the headsets would not have had as much reach if only Oculus sold them. Then, there is the benefits like the FB marketplace, which as been a boon for small businesses and individuals. Facebook more generally has had a lasting impact on the way we communicate online and social media.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Aurornis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:47PM
(#50499631)
Answering this question feels like walking into a downvote trap on HN, but commenters here constantly underestimate how much small and local businesses around the world operate on Meta services: It’s how they find and connect with customers, communicate with them, and engage with the communities.
The sentiment toward Meta is completely different when I talk to friends who are not in tech and who have small, local businesses. Like I’m talking to people who live in two completely different worlds and wouldn’t understand each other’s perspectives.
I usually hold my tongue on this topic, as I expect many others do, because commenting with anything other than pure anti-Meta sentiment is just asking for downvotes on this website, but since you asked what I presume to be an honest question I think it’s worth an honest answer.
Note that I’m not trying to say that this makes up for that or to cancel out other complaints people might have. I’m only trying to answer the question above.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Aurornis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:55PM
(#50502835)
It’s like this all over the world. USA and Europe included.
> I'd never, ever do any sort of business over fb
Meta is more than Facebook. In some parts of the world you will be using a Meta product to keep up with and communicate with small businesses and you can’t avoid it. In other places like the USA it’s mostly an optional channel but one that many people use, and businesses will be losing out if they don’t have a presence there because a lot of people want to see them there.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by willyharam on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:56AM
(#50506268)
Its like this in Europe, at least in Norway, where i do marketing for small companies. We use Meta-ads to reach customers. But local and regional facebook-groups are competing with ads. The reason for this is that members of groups, put out posts of their needs, and get replies from companies which offer their services. Often are those providers doing this without paying tax, and is a threat to real businesses which follow the rules.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by ronnier on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:55AM
(#50498512)
HN itself is a very negative. It shifted from a positive tech/startup focus aggregator to shifting to reddit levels of negativity and hate that drives outrage and anger. I often leave HN less happy than when I first opened it up. I don't want to read reddit levels of hate and destruction, I just wanted to read tech news and learn new things
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by icantevenhold on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:27PM
(#50498840)
It always was negative or rather very critical of big tech and “innovation” (aka thinly veiled turbo capitalism) and very positive about open source projects and small startups.
There are certain threads that always invite a lot of negativity just because of the subject matter. It’s relatively easy to avoid those once you spot the pattern …
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:54AM
(#50505553)
X/Twitter tried this, a bunch of political accounts had Russian flags but they got deleted and all the new ones had US flags. It doesn't stop determined actors.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by gustavus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:17PM
(#50499345)
I've been noticing that a lot lately. There was a period of like 8-12 months where I took a break from HN, and when I came back it seemed like HN had changed a lot.
Every comment thread got dragged into talking about the same few dozen things (or people) no matter where it started and the same shallow reddit level comments seemed to be all over the place.
Whereas before even on contentious topics there would be viewpoints like X s negative in these ways but if we also consider Y, W and Z these could be confounding factors, people were open to alternative takes and wanted to learn. Even on subjects I disagreed with I came out of it feeling like I better understood things, and other viewpoints. Nowadays though it feels like if the headline read "SpaceX space craft contacted by extra-terrestrials" it'd take 30 minutes to turn into a discussion of Musk.
Problem is I need to stay in the loop on the tech news scene that isn't shallow stories written by "tech journalists" who have a PHB understanding of the issue they're covering, or thinly vieled marketing brochures.
If anyone has any pointers to where I could find that I'd appreciate it. Moreover if anyone knows of some semi-private communities that would take in a poor internet refuge seeking a new tech land to call home I'd appreciate an introduction.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by rtp4me on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:23PM
(#50499396)
If you find one, please let me know. Over the past year or so, HN has drifted toward Reddit-level discourse. It’s getting harder to find threads that don’t quickly spiral into politics, country bashing (usually the US or Europe, depending on the article), or just mean-spirited sniping.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by jeltz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:29PM
(#50500500)
I blame the LLMs. There are much less interesting content these days on HN so as there is little intersting to discuss people just rehash the same boring old arguments.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by alex1138 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:20PM
(#50500936)
And if one exists can we please make it harder to just have a comment or post immediately [flagged] and buried? Dumb personal attacks, spam, things like that - yeah, sure. But HN is baaaad when it comes to this
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by matheusmoreira on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:10AM
(#50507460)
I believe those are reports that go directly to the moderators, not flags.
So long as there are no user visible consequences, it should be fine. Otherwise, it will turn into a super downvote and crowds will manipulate it to punish people they don't like.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by matheusmoreira on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:23AM
(#50507581)
It's not hard to get invited. I got mine on IRC after an article of mine was independently posted there. I've also seen people on HN and even on X simply ask for invites and get it.
Just be sure you're ideologically aligned with the people there before you join. If you like LLMs, it's probably not for you.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by fidotron on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:20PM
(#50499377)
Is the more positive tech/startup stuff actually happening in public online any more? Seems to be a bit on X but mainly in private Discords or (madness) in person these days.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Aurornis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:34PM
(#50499510)
I wish there was more of it, but in my experience most of the interesting, thoughtful, and civil discussion has retreated to private group chats which mostly follow in-person networks. It’s a challenge because you need to find your way into those networks and then keep up interactions across different groups and communication platforms.
Somewhat unexpectedly, Twitter/X has been growing as a place for quality discussion for me. That claim will be unbelievable to many here, because the average quality of posts on that site is extremely low. The killer feature is being able to cultivate your follow list and your block list together. If you can stay away from the ragebait, block the anger engagement farmers who worm their way into every discussion (Theo and similar accounts) and follow people when you see high quality posts of theirs shared, you start moving toward a feed with good signal.
Some people can’t help but get pulled into the vortex of ragebait and clickbait on sites like that. Those people should stay away, of course. If you can’t help but click on today’s drama or you get distracted or outraged easily, the Twitter firehose is not a good place to be.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by afavour on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:33PM
(#50499502)
I think HN is reflective of the tech industry.
I’m in my 40s and have been working in tech for a long time. I remember a time when it genuinely felt like the industry was a force for good in the world, opening doors for people to do things they never used to be able to do. And the companies were so open, e.g. I remember Facebook’s OpenGraph opening up a world of new social apps that were exciting to develop and to use.
That still happens today but to a far less degree. Nowadays it feels like every major tech player is all about lockin, about dark patterns that draw users into their services whether they’re happy about it or not. So yeah, I’m often negative on HN.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Aurornis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:37PM
(#50499535)
I think this is more reflective of your own position in the tech industry.
Your perspective is common and I see it a lot, but primarily in older and jaded developers.
When I switch cohorts and work with younger people in the real world (not chronically online) it’s a complete 180: Back to being excited about tech and the future, not really dwelling on the things that HNers complain about because they’re too busy looking forward than back at the tech world.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by afavour on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:40PM
(#50499566)
Are you sure it’s because they’re “too busy looking forward” and not because they didn't get to experience how free and open things used to be, and thus don’t have the context to see how far we’ve fallen?
How does this younger cohort feel about locked down devices, App Store distribution and the like? In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Aurornis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:58PM
(#50499741)
> and not because they didn't get to experience how free and open things used to be, and thus don’t have the context to see how far we’ve fallen?
I am 110% sure, because the young people I socialize with are operating in a tech environment that is more free and open than what I had as a kid.
The amount of open software and platforms we have right now would be mind blowing to younger me. The fact that I can run high quality LLMs on my laptop and even use them to open up old, closed games I had as a kid is incredible.
> How does this younger cohort feel about locked down devices, App Store distribution and the like?
Honestly? They DGAF. Their phones are communication devices and convenience things in their pocket. They have so many actual computers, SBCs, and microcontrollers to play with and they just want their phones to be phones.
Those who do care about open platforms vote with their wallet and buy one. They’re pragmatic. They don’t buy an iPhone and then whine about it being locked down because they know that the iPhone is not what you buy if that’s your goal.
You also have to remember that they grew up in the age of janky jailbroken phone mods. Jailbreaking your phone wasn’t equivalent to freedom, it was what people did when they wanted crazy fonts and colors and widgets on their phone until it bugged out and broke so bad they had to wipe it and start over. They got their fill of jailbreaking and moved on.
> In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
I think this mindset is unfairly smug and dismissive. Like only the old people are capable of understanding technology and the world. In my experience the young people know more about the current open alternatives and their options than I do if for no other reason than they’re more online, have more free time, and have probably watched 80 YouTube videos talking about it this year.
Would you be open to accepting the idea that maybe they do know what’s out there, and they just have different priorities than you?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:55PM
(#50500197)
"they grew up in the age of janky jailbroken phone mods" - the generation before grew up in the age of not needing them because you could just run programs on hardware. Seems less open to me.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by kalleboo on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:15AM
(#50506380)
I could just Bluetooth J2ME JAR files I built from my laptop onto my Sony Ericsson and Nokia phones, there was no kind of protection. The Sony Ericsson Walkman phones let you bluetooth MP3 files between them. The lockdown started with Apple, the iPod and the iPhone.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by pogue on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:57PM
(#50500211)
>I am 110% sure, because the young people I socialize with are operating in a tech environment that is more free and open than what I had as a kid.
What tech environments are you using that are more open now than in the past? It certainly seems you're conflating LLMs and their ability to 'create anything (regardless of quality or level of skill of the creator) on demand' rather than the software & services currently provided by Microsoft/Meta/Google/Amazon et al. that have slowly monopolized essentially everything and pushed the smaller players out. I'm referring to the majority of software and services available to the general tech using public.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by joquarky on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:13PM
(#50500358)
> smug and dismissive
But then you're talking about highly privileged people being optimistic.
It's easy to be positive when you grow up with the kind of wealth that gives you access to expensive hardware, as indicated by your statements "LLMs on my laptop" and "They have so many actual computers, SBCs, and microcontrollers to play with".
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by freecodeio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:25PM
(#50500990)
> Open source is more exciting than ever, imo.
On a side note, so are the bugs.
These excessive daily updates I get on my linux are exhausting. For example, libre office started lagging on a large document I frequent daily and I had to rollback.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Karrot_Kream on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:33PM
(#50503415)
> How does this younger cohort feel about locked down devices, App Store distribution and the like? In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
Everything you could do before social media and App Stores you can still do now. You can still connect to Usenet. You can still telnet onto servers. You can still write and publish blogs. You can still setup forums or write on them. You can still read and write to news aggregators (you're doing so right now in fact.) You can still setup your own email servers. You can still buy an SBC like a Raspberry Pi, hook up a display to it, plug in an LTE SIM and get connected to the internet.
The difference is that attention has moved away from open platforms to closed platforms. Did Gen Xers and older Millenials grow up with a negativity and malaise towards malls when, historically, most Western countries were dominated by small, independently run businesses? Did they dislike the big brands and corporations of the '50s which were previously smaller appliance makers? Consolidation and commodification are forces that have played out in many parts of the economy in many places.
> In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
This adds more anecdotal evidence to the feeling I get that there's a cohort of angry, older posters who mostly set the tone on this site these days.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by xboxnolifes on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:41AM
(#50505823)
All of my friends in the tech industry (including myself) are young and jaded about the tech industry. It feels like 99% of the tech industry is just bait and switch products developed to harvest as much information from their users as possible.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by fdsajfkldsfklds on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:40PM
(#50500073)
My take is that that very openness is what encouraged people to pour their hearts and souls into an online presence and directly resulted in the situation we see today. It was an aberration caused by the development of new and exciting tech, and not the potential start of a new and sustainable form of improved life.
As a side note, the "openness" at the times you discussed were still very limited in demography and geography.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by freecodeio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:05PM
(#50501447)
I mean yeah governments do, institutions do. But normal people always say it's your fault for smoking. Maybe the same mentality should be about using some certain things from the internet.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by NalNezumi on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:15AM
(#50505057)
I think you got time frame wrong.
People also blamed cigarettes more than the smoker, that's why a lot of regulations and warnings about its adverse effects was put in place. SOME people now blame the smokers because they feel like they should've known better, with all the warnings and information provided. That happened way later after systematic change. The behavior change was second order.
Nobody blamed the smoker when it wasn't regulated or still debated whether it was bad. "certain things from the internet" is still at that stage so it's understandable that people blame "it" over the users
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by freecodeio on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:09AM
(#50507050)
I see. Then I suppose a "Social media fries your brain" sticker with black font that you can't close on facebook or any algorithmic infinite scroll feed should only be fair then.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:48AM
(#50505506)
Cigarettes used to be thought to be innocuous and fun, much like soda is today (yes it's full of sugar, which isn't that bad compared to everything else). This was largely because of disinformation spread by cigarette companies.
Today, if you start smoking, everyone, even other smokers, even the cigarette packets, is telling you that it will ruin your life. At that point you're literally saying "yes I want to ruin my life" and it kinda is your fault.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by WarmWash on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:57PM
(#50500215)
Who would you rather be?
Apple, Google, or Meta?
Apple obviously. They protect their users and still have a generally positive social vibe.
Meta and Google are largely only spoken of in negative light socially, and constantly castigated for their "user hostile" behavior.
But what is the ultimate irony here?
Apple only exists for people with money. It's a pay-to-play enterprise, and only a small sliver of the global population can afford to be part of it.
Google and Meta welcome everyone, and give everyone access to the same services and features (by and large).
I think there are a lot of people, who if they truly stepped back and understood this whole picture, would be left in a tornado of a soul search. How could the free companies with no bias towards wealth possibly end up as the bad guys?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by lukan on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:46PM
(#50501810)
"How could the free companies with no bias towards wealth possibly end up as the bad guys?"
Is that a serious question? They are ad companies. They don't do charity.
And one company had as a slogan "don't be evil" - they got rid of.
And the other one was started with the words about their users
"they trust me. Dumb fucks"
They literally are the bad guys. Google started different, but now I don't see any value they care for except making more money by more web dominance. And with that dominance, spy, sell the data or use it to hijack peoples attention and manipulate it.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by jonahx on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:29AM
(#50505757)
> Or is their business taking money from the wealthy and giving free services to the poor?
Upvoted because I enjoyed this rhetorical flourish, even though I don't buy it.
Their motivation is to make money, and the reach people give them the money. Therefore the GP's description feels more accurate. Perhaps "As a side effect of their business model of helping rich people influence poor people, the poor people get some genuine value" would be fair, while still keeping the spirit of your riposte.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by skew-aberration on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:27AM
(#50506783)
It is more like a bank loan. You get a free service now, and you pay for it later by purchasing (statistically) more of their customer's goods/services than you otherwise would.
Does a bank take money from wealthy investors, and distribute it to poor prospective homeowners? Yes, technically.
> kids in India using the exact same google office suite that fortune 500's are using
When I walk down Billionaires' Row, I see the same facades as the residents who live there.
Fortune 500s are paying google billions of dollars to monitor millions of Indian children, minute by minute, using advanced mathematics, psychology and supercomputers, in the hopes of guiding their lifelong purchasing decisions.
Then they enter their figures into Google Sheets.
Meanwhile, those children are not given the opportunity to monitor Fortune 500s CEOs and investors and fill up their devices and screens with imagery and video of their choice.
> No one makes me click an ad. Ad-block on and all systems still go
We can safely ignore this line of reasoning as a general explanation, because we know the manipulation works statistically - customers keep coming back to the tune of hundreds of billions annually.
Of course, none of this translates to a straightforward moral ruling. The transaction (like a loan) does bring benefits to both parties. It is not clear to me though that all participants in this transaction have true agency. I'd be more comfortable buying cigarettes for myself than for Indian children.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by CMay on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:17AM
(#50504220)
Advertising is not that expensive and you shouldn't really be doing it unless you already have a good sense that you'll make your money back, because you have free ways to test your idea before you ever get to that. Advertising is largely for spending money to scale up something that you know works.
If you have something that you know works and you have data for it, you can try getting loans or investors. If you can establish trust that what you'll do can reach an audience who will gladly pay for it, money is the easy part.
It's a way for ideas that have traction to self-propel. No doubt that can be abused, but a lot of it is simply honest business.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by bigyabai on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:34PM
(#50503092)
> Who would you rather be?
> Apple, Google, or Meta?
I only get to choose between 3 different CIA fronts?
The answer isn't obvious at all, unless you're jaded and predisposed to one company or the other. I'd rather be none of them, and keep my principles instead of buying gold trophies for Trump, renaming landmarks or footing the ballroom bill. They're all pathetic.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by dizhn on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:52AM
(#50504628)
As long as I have you here. Back up my pet theory. Before social media ever existed and frankly sounded absurd it was being pushed like an inevitability. That and micro payments. This would be the early 2000s.
I think it was the CIA from the very beginning. What do you say?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by bigyabai on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:15AM
(#50504763)
Who knows. It's well-understood that Intel and ARPANET were practically eating out of the DoD's hand. Then you have blatantly backdoored orgs like Microsoft, and plausibly deniable consumer brands like Apple and Google (ssl added and removed here ;^)). US intelligence learned to stop shitting where people eat, so now everyone points fingers at each other instead of questioning the obvious federal collusion that big tech clearly acquiesces to.
If you're asking me, there were definitely honeypot sites, and definitely organically popular social media too. 4chan got increasingly radicalized after Chris Poole started meeting with the international intelligence community, and anyone that denies X being CIA-operated should probably get their head checked. It's obvious that the alphabet agencies couldn't steer everything online, but it remains possible that our culture of oversharing and FOMO was part of an influence operation to bolster FVEY.
I hate presenting speculation as fact, but I think we've seen enough to know the score by now. Nobody in FAANG can afford to treat the state like an adversary, their only option is to buddy up and take on the rest of the world together. Jensen could be an example of what happens to insubordinates that outlive their usefulness to the feds.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by dizhn on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:20AM
(#50505346)
Right. Good insight. I am particularly iffy about the actual push for social media when even its earlier seeds didn't exist. In hindsight it looks like early 2000s was a time when the tech media was all about "there's this thing coming called social media and it's going to be awesome" when it might have been that they were actually trying to make it happen not report that it was actually coming.
Basically I really wonder if it was an organic tech/entrepreneur eventuality or was designed and pushed from the beginning by an actor and for its current widely known purpose.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:43AM
(#50505468)
Small tech too. The Jia Tan xz backdoor which failed was obviously some nation state actor, and plausibly so was *sshole - if so, it was successful and left a lot of stuff backdoored for a long time.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by freecodeio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:20PM
(#50500938)
Blame the algorithm x shareholder combo. Hell I'm 30 and I thought the tech industry might be just the force that sets the world straight because it was all about making human lives better.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by qwerpy on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:16PM
(#50501541)
As everyone loves to point out here, there are so many options to escape the stuff you don't like. I'm in my 40s too, and although I gripe about ads and dark patterns occasionally, I actively work on eliminating those things from my digital life. As a result I'm generally happy with the state of tech. There's very little unpleasantness that I really can't escape from. I've debloated windows, run a good ad blocker, use LLMs to filter the garbage out of HN and reddit, avoid social media apps, use LLMs to set up my local-first homelab and mod games to my liking, etc.
There's a few ways to go here. 1) (vast majority of people) don't even notice what's going on and generally fine with things. 2) notice, and sink into negativity and helplessness. 3) notice, and actively weed out the garbage.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by keyringlight on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:00PM
(#50501933)
I think the point would be that you don't eliminate the stuff you don't like permanently, that you need to "actively work" against them, and they will persist in changing their side so you've got to indefinitely continue active work to keep your personal device to your liking.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by johnfn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:56PM
(#50502838)
No, HN is not reflective of the tech industry. This place is reflective of a very negative segment of the tech industry. The negativity exists, don't get me wrong, but it's not representative. Easy proof - ask 10 people in your office what they think of HN. I bet you dollars to donuts most of them say "it's super negative, I don't go there".
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Jach on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:25PM
(#50503372)
That's possibly better than the last time I worked from an office, where the answer would most likely be "What's HN?" I used to think HN was getting monotonically worse, but it's better now in certain ways than it was e.g. 4 years ago. I think dang and other moderators have helped a lot. (And at the same time, I've gotten better at self-filtering to avoid threads I know are unlikely to have any comments worth their bits (this is one but sometimes I take a gander anyway), and a little userscript to mute persistently annoying/negative/whatever usernames.)
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by georgemcbay on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:29AM
(#50504278)
> Easy proof - ask 10 people in your office what they think of HN. I bet you dollars to donuts most of them say "it's super negative, I don't go there".
In the vast majority of offices the most common answer would be "huh? what is HN?"
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by NalNezumi on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:06AM
(#50505014)
Yeah was about to say the same. If you can ask 10 coworkers about HN and not get a puzzled reply, you're definitely in a chronically tech online bubble.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by AlecSchueler on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:52PM
(#50500178)
Exactly, I also come here for tech news and to learn new things but the tech news and the new things being developed increasingly make me want to live entirely offline
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by robby_w_g on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:17PM
(#50502517)
In the past 10 years, I went from naive optimism and dreams of possibility to the crushing reality of data theft and manipulation that is the current tech industry.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by nicce on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:42PM
(#50499594)
> I often leave HN less happy than when I first opened it up. I don't want to read reddit levels of hate and destruction, I just wanted to read tech news and learn new things
Usually it is the titles and posts underneath rather than users who make me less happy
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by vrganj on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:00PM
(#50499754)
Have you considered that maybe tech's role in the world and its impact might've become more and more undeniably negative and as such talking about tech inevitably brings negativity?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by joquarky on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:02PM
(#50500265)
It's also full of people who stay in ivory towers and complain about first world problems while a lot of real suffering is occuring right outside their bubble.
You're fooling yourself if you think your opinions, particularly on matters outside of your direct experience, can exist independent of well funded influence campaigns.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by alpineman on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:02PM
(#50500773)
I mean isn’t that a fair reflection to the tech industry’s direction in recent years? Tech became obsessed with money over everything else, of course people are cynical about that, how could they not be?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Loughla on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:16PM
(#50501534)
From the outside looking in, it seemed like tech was very much always about making assloads of money. Hell, Uber started in 2009 and was, in my opinion, plainly about making money regardless of the consequences and impacts.
I think the difference I'm seeing, again from the outside, is that (a) people who don't eat, sleep, and breathe tech are entering the field because it pays well, and (b) the people who do finally took notice that their passion is a trap (a well paying trap, but a trap nonetheless).
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by benoau on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:34PM
(#50503422)
Making tonnes of money used to be a byproduct of making something people loved. You did something hundreds of millions of people loved and that scale ensured a company worth billions of dollars.
But trillions... are upheld by monopolization, violating privacy laws, violating competition laws, defying regulators, subverting regulations, lobbying to prevent regulation, and armies of lawyers running obstruction.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by alpineman on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:08AM
(#50504713)
I would suggest Uber was the very start of the wave. It was really the birth of the 'tech bro' and where 'capital as a weapon' really first became a thing.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by account42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:13AM
(#50517276)
Tech was always making more money per employee than most other industries, which is exactly why it attracted the money-obsessed management that is now ruining it.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:52AM
(#50505528)
It instils a desire to post short quippy soundbites as they get the most upvotes.
E.g. on a post about a Rust safety bug you might post something that amounts to "rust is bad" or "rust is good" and because it's easily digestible it brings upvotes from that side.
HN also has this effect. Every platform with upvotes has it, even if they don't do much as long as the poster can observe them.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by hellohello2 on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:08AM
(#50514557)
Yes exactly. The more people on the site the worse the effect becomes, basically small subreddits still reward you for largely reasonable behavior but larger ones don't.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by gelly321 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:50PM
(#50502326)
We're talking about an investment platform that discusses tech stuff. There is plenty of positive and interesting discussion on here. I just don't see the need for blind positivity towards any new thing that comes into view.
HN is full of people who want to take other people's money. It should be in the forefront of your mind anytime someone wants to push something here. Nerdy tech discussions are a side effect, and has nothing to do with the motivations of this platform.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by drinkinghorn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:36PM
(#50503752)
It could have something to do with Meta being a positive thing for Zuck, it's shareholders and demagogues the world ovrler but ultimately a net negative for wider humanity.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by epihelix on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:50PM
(#50504111)
For what it's worth, I find HN one of the last bastions of relative tech positivity online.
Obviously, Meta news is mostly going to be bad news, and attract negativity. No matter what tinted lenses you're looking at that company with, it's generally going to appear brown. But for most areas of tech, I've found this site in general to represent the sunny, glass-half-filled side of things. Discussions are generally pretty balanced and civil, and nastiness tends to get downvoted more often than not.
And of course this is a broad generalisation, and no site is ever going to be perfect. But if HN is your bar for too much hate online, I'm not sure how you're navigating the rest of the internet right now :(
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by lnxg33k1 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:23AM
(#50507584)
I am not on reddit, and never been, so it's not reddit like hate when I tell that you are a corporate useful idiot and should shut the fuck up, like companies manipulate you , spy on you , steal personal data without telling you but a fucking fucktard comes here and the issue is that people is negative
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Auracle on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:45PM
(#50499037)
I can’t think of a single way they’ve made my life worse. Messenger makes it easier to connect with friends. Facebook marketplace is a better Craigslist. Facebook itself is fine for sharing photos of life events with family (that’s about all I use it for and I’d prefer higher quality photos but whatever). The Meta VR headsets are great for their price. Back when I had a photography business running ads that could target newly engaged couples was great both for me and those couples that otherwise wouldn’t have discovered a photographer that matched their preferred style and budget.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by tweetle_beetle on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:17AM
(#50505676)
If all they did was make a better Craigslist and good value VR hardware, no one would have an issue. Genuinely.
But the other features are only good because of market share. There's no reason why facebook is better for sharing photos or messenger is better for chats beyond the enormous user base (which was far from organically grown). So how can another business ever unseat them from that position - everyone uses it and it's good enough.
And you've snuck in a little bit at the end which touches on that - you get more money because they track marital status of its user base globally.
If you can't extend the thought experiment to what else could be tracked, what the usual effects of bigcorp monopolies are and why that could be a problem for other people (or future you), you're choosing to keep your head in the sand and (like many, many others) sacrificing the common good for a petty personal benefit.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by taylorfinley on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:49PM
(#50499648)
It would be lovely if that was true, but meta does not care about consent. My android phone came with Facebook pre-installed and I can only remove it over adb, something probably 0.1% of people will bother to learn how to do. They also collect shadow profiles [0] on people who have never made an account
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by RebeccaTheDev on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:31PM
(#50502651)
Facebook has their tentacles in so many places that walking away from it is difficult, especially if you are involved in local community activities.
My neighborhood exclusively uses Facebook for neighborhood communication.
My kid's school PTA exclusively uses Facebook.
Most of the local food trucks and some businesses only post their schedules on Facebook or Instagram.
Marketplace killed all the alternatives.
It honestly drives me be crazy how this company has wormed their way into being such an essential piece of communication infrastructure for so many people that I can’t quit without sacrificing my ability to participate in some of the things I really enjoy.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by vovavili on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:14PM
(#50509234)
You can choose to use a social media platform carefully and intentionally. Having free ("pay with your data") access to all of the things you describe sounds like a worthwhile deal to me.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:58AM
(#50505578)
Context as not everyone might know it: Facebook deliberately spread pro-Rohingya genocide propaganda to millions of people in Myanmar, and since propaganda works, the general population got very angry at the Rohingya people and genocide them.
Facebook in the Rohingya genocide had basically the same role as the RTLM in the Rwanda genocide.
Why did they do it? Well, getting people angry keeps them engaged, so they click more and you can show more ads.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:25PM
(#50501620)
That's still true. The GDPR needs to have stronger teeth though, because the solution isn't for me to be wary of who has data about my bedroom activities, but rather making having that data into a problem for them.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by lormayna on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:31AM
(#50498317)
Italian here.
The usage of spyware is allowed only for people that are suspected by a specific list of violations and must be approved by a judge.
The other option is about national security threat and must be approved by a specific parliament commission.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by qubex on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:23PM
(#50498799)
Another Italian here. Definitely we’re not saints, and definitely there have been worrying behaviours in the past, and maybe it’s ongoing or will happen again, but the point is that it became known and there are mechanisms for legal redress.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by lormayna on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:12PM
(#50499303)
As I said, the usage of the spyware is authorized by a judge (that is a separated entity from government and not really friend of the actual government, in general) or by the COPASIR (that is composed by a balanced mix of all parties and the president is from the oppositions).
Italy has some critical issues, but it's still a rule of law state.
I think that in the past, the situation was a lot more worrying than now. Think about Ustica, Bologna station bombing, etc.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by aprilthird2021 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:34AM
(#50498342)
Idk why this comment is down voted. The users actively consented to giving access to the camera roll, in what world does that mean accessing the camera roll after that consent is a hundreds of millions of dollars fine?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by naggreg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:49AM
(#50498465)
Users consent to give access to the camera roll so to be able to upload specific photos from the gallery, not for Meta to get photos from there like it's an open buffet.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:14PM
(#50499863)
Meta is not even accused of "getting" photos from there! It just suggests to the user they might want to upload them. No action is taken independently.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by lokar on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:58AM
(#50498048)
They should be required to put a warning at the top of all future permission prompts explaining that meta has a history of lying about data use and violating privacy law.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by jareklupinski on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:55AM
(#50498511)
introducing the public to the Internet was the first mistake
cant think of any other pool shared by walks of life as diverse as us, North Korean hackers, grandmas, school children, actual criminals, actual activists, mom n pops, mega corp businesses, big banks, small credit unions, governments / spies...
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by k0morebi on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:45PM
(#50500115)
I always blame iphone (here come the down votes). Appified the web. Brought everyone online who wasn't already online, causing everything to be dumbed down and sterilized. Absolutely accelerated the commercialization of the web, though that was already in motion for a while. Normalized lack of control and agency over electronic devices. It's always celebrated for bringing the web to everyone; that's the worst thing it's responsible for aside from the slave human labor used to make them.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:01AM
(#50505589)
It's probably more phones than social media. Or it's their combination. When social media was only accessible from the living room computer at your house, it was somewhat contained.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by dmix on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:19PM
(#50498737)
There is a never ending set of regulations in Europe so they could hypothetically just keep doing this indefinitely.
The vast majority of regulations are poorly enforced in most countries because they require extensive administrative efforts and legal costs, while politics push them to focus on the new boogieman. But if a government wants to find something against you they can. There's a large short term financial incentive with these ones.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:03AM
(#50505594)
Partially true. There are lots of regulations. But as we see here, they usually don't apply a very heavy touch. Even after endless repeated warnings they're only losing 1/12 of their European revenue. It never starts with a fine, it starts with a demand to comply and if you comply at that stage it's all good.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by simonebrunozzi on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:55AM
(#50498517)
Besides the fine itself (probably good news? Probably too little to matter? Unsure), the topic of Meta/Facebook being a menace to our lives is an ever important one to me, in relation to my family.
It is well known, and discussed, that young kids are particularly weak in relation to social media. Meta probably represents the strongest, "evilest" company in that regard.
What will we do, as a society, to make our lives better? Possibly without pitch forks.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Footnote7341 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:01PM
(#50498570)
They were fined almost a billion dollars over a UI feature where you select which photos to upload. The app itself doesn't actually access your camera roll randomly and upload your photos or anything.
Isn't the EU making more money from fining US tech companies than their own tech companies are paying in taxes at this point?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by dmix on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:12PM
(#50498672)
After a few big payouts it will be difficult for these governments to stop putting their hand in the cookie jar. They will find something new every year.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by qubex on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:19PM
(#50498744)
It’s entirely possible to operate in accordance with local laws, or they can leave the market entirely. As an Italian I’d be delighted if Meta upped and left, heaven knows it’s not done any good to society.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Footnote7341 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:48PM
(#50499093)
They are being fined over the normal android gallery permissions flow, it doesn't make any sense at all. Fines aren't the same thing as taxes you aren't supposed to just randomly fine people for no reason.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by qubex on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:54PM
(#50499136)
If they were being fined over ordinary Android gallery permissions flow, it would’ve been Google and not Meta on the hook. The fact that that isn’t the case (and that if they made that argument in their defence, it failed to hold sway) strongly suggests otherwise.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:07PM
(#50500830)
They aren't being fined over a permissions flow, they are being fined over using user data. I don't know how many fines it will take before the programming community realises that you can't weasel out of breaking the law by abusing a technical measure.
"Your honour, I did not break into this man's house. Last week he gave me his key ring so I could copy his car keys, so I took the liberty to write down all his bitting codes and made a copy of his keyring later. Since he gave me his key, I was authorised to be there and did not break in."
... is literally the excuse Meta is trying to use, except it's about photos.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by etiennebausson on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:19PM
(#50502992)
Maybe if those company actually paid taxes in said countries, the government would be willing to negotiate.
But every U.S. tech company operate from Ireland, which is a tax haven, so since those tech giants do nothing for the local economy, fining them repeatedly (and deservingly) is a reasonable defense mechanism.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Solololo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:58PM
(#50499733)
> Isn't the EU making more money from fining US tech companies than their own tech companies are paying in taxes at this point?
No, this is a common piece of Trump era propaganda. The EU does not levy such a general corporate tax, fines are not recurring as taxes are, fines like this one are done by a single member state (Italy in this case) and do nothing for the EU's budget, and the big tech companies within the EU are private companies whereas this misleading stat picks the rare public ones for its comparison
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by aboringusername on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:09PM
(#50498640)
This has basically just become a stealth tax at this point.
You can't raise VAT as that would be massively unpopular, so this is the next best option.
1: Fine tech bros for $reason and $amount must be in the billions
2: $business raises costs to cover the fine, now their AI is 50 cents more expensive
3: EU collects sweet money under the guise that tech bros are bad, and who would disagree?
4: go to step 1.
There are no other legitimate reasons to fine such an absurd amount and since the EU needs to fine a way to stealth tax the population this is a great way to do it.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by qubex on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:26PM
(#50498827)
This is awfully rude. It’s entirely possible to do business without violating local laws. Furthermore a government would be in dereliction of its duties if it did not enforce the laws that it has passed. If Meta doesn’t wish to comply with local laws it can just withdraw from the local market, as an Italian I’d be delighted if they packed up and left, heaven knows they’ve done nothing but harm to society.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by akshatjiwan on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:42PM
(#50499597)
I don't think these fines are even making the slightest difference. Meta probably writes them off as the cost of doing business. As do other big tech companies.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by jeltz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:53PM
(#50499690)
This forgets that every fine like this comes with a court order they have to follow and Meta usually complies with court orders. It is a cat and mouse game where Meta constantly looks for new ways to break the regulators looking for things to shut down but without the court orders Meta's abuses would likely be way worse.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by akshatjiwan on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:23AM
(#50504252)
Yes. What you say is true. Laws, regulations and court orders do exist. But enforcing them to the letter and spirit is a different matter. For example laws exist that KYC details must always be stored encrypted and in devices that are pen tested. They rarely, if ever, are. The administration has no way to verify whether laws are being followed. Hardly a week goes by where a new massive breach does not surface.
As you say it's a cat and mouse game. But not quite as benign as you put it.Its what I would call a more hand in glove type of arrangement.
Government organisations benefit by social media platforms acting as large scale soft surveillance systems that allow them to enforce control. The act tough by occasionally 'fining' and punishing the 'bad' behaviour to 'demonstrate' how they care about the rule of the law. But the law is either uneforcable political messaging or full of holes that could be exploited.
This fine needs to be interpreted with the background understanding what's about to happen in Italy. Elections, and Meloni's image of being a strong leader being fractured.
And frankly Meta's abuses could not possibly be any worse. Its already fully totalitarian. Its as bad as it could have been despite decades of litigations and privacy right advocacy. They failed because they assumed that big tech and the state are two seperate entities. They are not.
You know how big meta is? UKs former deputy prime minister was just a low ranking employee in their organisation.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by poody on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:48PM
(#50499637)
I have never seen any proof that they actually pay these.. Can someone enlighten me? (I would just ignore 'em... maybe I would get a strongly worded letter..)
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by nujabe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:59PM
(#50499752)
My understanding is they seem to only pay them in justifications where they are making enough profit to justify paying them. If Uganda for example levied these fines they’d just threaten to pull out, and would likely follow through on that.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by jeltz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:03PM
(#50499780)
Why do you think they can ignore it? Meta has physical presence in the EU and most likely in Italy too. I doubt Meta's stock would like the Italian Government confiscating Meta's assets.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by jeltz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:42PM
(#50500623)
Why did you ignore the rest of my comment? Meta has bank accounts in EU countries and servers in EU countries that obviously will be confiscated if Meta refuses to pay.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by Havoc on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:51PM
(#50501845)
They would be paying yes.
By the time the public hears about it like this it means attempts to avert it by the army of corporate lawyers & compliance experts have already failed
>I would just ignore 'em
That goes about as well as you refusing to pay your taxes. Pointless because while governments are slow they do eventually come for their pound of flesh
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by jeltz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:24PM
(#50503362)
Yeah, I do not get why some people here on HN belive that American tech companies have the option to refuse to pay a fine in the EU. Paying fines is not optional in a market where you have offices, customers and assets.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:02PM
(#50499774)
> Finding the company had accessed Android users' photographs and videos without obtaining their consent or informing them.
> Users must grant permission on their device before the feature can operate, and they can change that permission at any time in their settings.
> The fine is equivalent to about 0.47% of the group's global revenue.
What is Italy protecting Italians from here? I think it's clear consent was given at some point. So the objection is what? They need to ask consent again periodically? Or on a feature-by-feature basis? Who was conceivably harmed, and how?
How does Meta accept user content in the future without running afoul of the exact same rule again?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by dwattttt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:10PM
(#50499838)
> > Finding the company had accessed Android users' photographs and videos without obtaining their consent or informing them.
> I think it's clear consent was given at some point
That's not what was found. I don't know the facts of the case, but it's possible that "consent" mechanisms were found to be insufficient. As an example, if you ask for permission for one purpose, then use it for another, that would probably not meet the "inform users" bar.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by cowlevel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:04AM
(#50505595)
You can read TFA, and that's exactly what they did. Consent to access photos in order to share one photo was treated as consent to AI-scan all photos on the device.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by microtonal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:08PM
(#50500320)
Clear consent under the GDPR requires that you state the purpose for every different use of data and ask consent separately.
Giving access to photos so that the user can upload a photo is not giving consent to analyze all the photos of the user on a phone.
The main principle of the GDPR is to store and use as little private data as possible and only get/store data when the user explicitly asks for it/consents to it.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by LaFolle on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:11PM
(#50502481)
If Meta indeed is at fault then why Meta's iOS app is also not charged with same exploit as its android app? Does how consent work in iOS different from that in Android?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
by claaams on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:28PM
(#50503387)
I think nations should start treating these tech companies like a bank account. Whenever they need a billion dollars or two they can find some crime that the company is doing, fine them, build the project and move on. Meta will eat the cost because to them its nothing and cost of doing business and at least some social good will come from their existence (because their billionaire owners are paying fuck all in taxes).
Yes? Just because I want to share some pictures through an app doesn't mean I want it to go and do anything it wants with any picture on the device.
TL;DR: they didn't thoroughly explain the users what they were consenting to when giving the app access to the gallery.
* either share from an outside app, e.g. the gallery, choose "share", choose "whatsapp". This gives it access only to the photo you shared from the other app.
* and in Android's settings you can give Whatsapp access to a subset of photos, then it works normally on only that subset. Then you can always add more from outside that set, by pressing the paperclip icon when you write the message, there you see the "gallery option", then you see the limited subset of photos you gave access to, at the bottom right you have a folder picker icon which opens the system's gallery picker view (google photos in my case), where you can see all photos, and it can then access that photo too.
* if you chose no access to media at all, but if whatsapp has camera access, click on the paperclip icon in the message box, then, "camera", then the "gallery" icon, there you get a screen prompting for gallery access, but on the bottom right it has the same folder icon that gives access to the system photo picker, which again will only allow access to the photo you pick there.
The first two cases are pretty low-friction.
I believe Android 17 also offers "Limited" storage option to allow permission to select Photos and Videos.
Suffice to say, Nokia is on my blacklist of companies to never patronize again.
Facebook requested access to users' photo galleries through a single app-wide authorisation. According to the Italian regulator, a preceding notice did not make clear that this would also allow Facebook to generate suggestions based on photos in their gallery.
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwn83gxemk35o
They should have explicitly asked separate consent to generate suggestions based on photos.
They know this. They just made the judgement that they could get away with an 'oopsie' or a fine that is just doing cost of business. These >1B fines are good, make them feel it, so that the next time they won't violate the GDPR.
I mean, this is kind of nuts. Should they ask consent every time you click to navigate to a new page, just in case you didn't want to see it? What level of granularity is acceptable?
I think you are obtuse and did not actually try to understand what the GDPR is saying but anyway no, it doesn't concern itself about that dimension at all. There would need to be new informed consent from the user before their data can be shared with new parties or for new purposes.
Yes. I suggest you actually read the GDPR rather than drawing caricatures of it based on not actually knowing the law. It is very readable.
https://www.privacy-regulation.eu/en/recital-32-GDPR.htm
Consent should be give per purpose. So, if you asked consent to access photos for performing an upload when the user requested it, you cannot use that to do an ML analysis of all the photos. But obviously, if the users gave consent to e.g. analyzing all photos for face recognition, you do not have to ask this for every photo, every scan, etc. It should just be easy to revoke the consent and remove any data stored.
(IANAL blah blah)
The GDPR is really a straightforward law. It only isn't if you want to collect private data without telling the user about it. Or if you want to use dark patterns to make the user accept data collection without them giving free, informed consent.
But if you say "We need to access your photos so you can share a few with your friends" and then proceed to upload all the photo's, you are in violation.
Which is similar to what happened here and what the Italian judge ruled to be illegal.
> Which is similar to what happened here
In fact, it has nothing to do with what happened here; why lie? No photos were uploaded by the feature the fine was assessed for.
They use dark patterns and deception, and without knowing the details here I suspect Meta is guilty.
Meta’s response even stinks of these dark patterns, glossing over informed consent.
So the issue is a) that people had no choice ("Okay, I'll give you access to this folder, but not to my nude photos there") and b) that the text was so wishy washy that people had no idea that suddenly Meta access all of their photos now.
- Meta Platforms Ireland Limited: €4,514M
- Facebook Ireland Ltd.: €60M
- WhatsApp Ireland Ltd.: €225M
- Meta Platforms, Inc.: €405M
That totals €5.204B.
and you know how much governments love pumping their sources... especially once they start drying...
im just saying it wont be up to the governments making billions off this entire scheme to stop them
if Meta followed the law in the first place, the EU would be down 6 billion
Two months of income are far from a mere "slap on the wrist".
[1] https://s21.q4cdn.com/399680738/files/content_files/Earnings...
Like what is Cuba or most of South America doing that is such a threat to the US, and yet we stomp on them all the time. We trade and make deals with dictators, often supporting the regime against their citizens for our personal gain.
Either ban it or stop bitching about it.
Would you like to know why its not banned? It's a fantastic source of revenue!
If its was awful as you claim, you'd ban it instead of profiting from it.
quite like a hostile foreign government
This does seem to happen a lot with SpaceX and Tesla since about 4 years. There is no thread on Starship's latest launch yester, but the false news claiming that Hawaiian airspace was shutdown due to Starship debris rocketed up to #2 on the front page.
When I was a kid this was not possible / very expensive.
(Of course personally I prefer more privacy focused options like Signal, but still)
For the rest of Meta, just read Careless People and the linked submission is not surprising at all.
[1] https://www.irishtimes.com/business/technology/whatsapp-says...
I used WhatsApp before it was bought but it’s still heavily associated with meta
But that's about it.
I'm not saying social media is ideal, but it has done a lot to democratize the ability of people to share what is happening around them. Now whether that is a good or bad thing has more to do with how you feel about democracy and that's a different discussion. But although it is taking time to adapt I'd say that one now has more opportunities to be informed about the things that are going on them ever before.
The sentiment toward Meta is completely different when I talk to friends who are not in tech and who have small, local businesses. Like I’m talking to people who live in two completely different worlds and wouldn’t understand each other’s perspectives.
I usually hold my tongue on this topic, as I expect many others do, because commenting with anything other than pure anti-Meta sentiment is just asking for downvotes on this website, but since you asked what I presume to be an honest question I think it’s worth an honest answer.
Note that I’m not trying to say that this makes up for that or to cancel out other complaints people might have. I’m only trying to answer the question above.
> I'd never, ever do any sort of business over fb
Meta is more than Facebook. In some parts of the world you will be using a Meta product to keep up with and communicate with small businesses and you can’t avoid it. In other places like the USA it’s mostly an optional channel but one that many people use, and businesses will be losing out if they don’t have a presence there because a lot of people want to see them there.
Actually would say IT people are less negative to Meta than the average person in my country.
Now it may be some consider those negatives as well.
I think you would be hard pressed to find much positive sentiment about a company like Facebook here; eg a post 6 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25662215
There are certain threads that always invite a lot of negativity just because of the subject matter. It’s relatively easy to avoid those once you spot the pattern …
But isn’t it just shift of the tech in general?
From quirky, optimistic, positive, “don’t be evil”, inclusive ~20 years ago.
To corporate, creepy, fascist, ultra greedy since ~10 years[1] ago and onwards to this day.
I could feel gradual change of comments more into right political spectrum, since 7-8 years.
[1] Personally - Cambridge Analytica and Facebook scandal is that point for me.
Every comment thread got dragged into talking about the same few dozen things (or people) no matter where it started and the same shallow reddit level comments seemed to be all over the place.
Whereas before even on contentious topics there would be viewpoints like X s negative in these ways but if we also consider Y, W and Z these could be confounding factors, people were open to alternative takes and wanted to learn. Even on subjects I disagreed with I came out of it feeling like I better understood things, and other viewpoints. Nowadays though it feels like if the headline read "SpaceX space craft contacted by extra-terrestrials" it'd take 30 minutes to turn into a discussion of Musk.
Problem is I need to stay in the loop on the tech news scene that isn't shallow stories written by "tech journalists" who have a PHB understanding of the issue they're covering, or thinly vieled marketing brochures.
If anyone has any pointers to where I could find that I'd appreciate it. Moreover if anyone knows of some semi-private communities that would take in a poor internet refuge seeking a new tech land to call home I'd appreciate an introduction.
So long as there are no user visible consequences, it should be fine. Otherwise, it will turn into a super downvote and crowds will manipulate it to punish people they don't like.
It is semi-private as it is invite-based but still big. Compared to here it has less "industry news" and more "hacker content"
Just be sure you're ideologically aligned with the people there before you join. If you like LLMs, it's probably not for you.
Somewhat unexpectedly, Twitter/X has been growing as a place for quality discussion for me. That claim will be unbelievable to many here, because the average quality of posts on that site is extremely low. The killer feature is being able to cultivate your follow list and your block list together. If you can stay away from the ragebait, block the anger engagement farmers who worm their way into every discussion (Theo and similar accounts) and follow people when you see high quality posts of theirs shared, you start moving toward a feed with good signal.
Some people can’t help but get pulled into the vortex of ragebait and clickbait on sites like that. Those people should stay away, of course. If you can’t help but click on today’s drama or you get distracted or outraged easily, the Twitter firehose is not a good place to be.
I’m in my 40s and have been working in tech for a long time. I remember a time when it genuinely felt like the industry was a force for good in the world, opening doors for people to do things they never used to be able to do. And the companies were so open, e.g. I remember Facebook’s OpenGraph opening up a world of new social apps that were exciting to develop and to use.
That still happens today but to a far less degree. Nowadays it feels like every major tech player is all about lockin, about dark patterns that draw users into their services whether they’re happy about it or not. So yeah, I’m often negative on HN.
Your perspective is common and I see it a lot, but primarily in older and jaded developers.
When I switch cohorts and work with younger people in the real world (not chronically online) it’s a complete 180: Back to being excited about tech and the future, not really dwelling on the things that HNers complain about because they’re too busy looking forward than back at the tech world.
How does this younger cohort feel about locked down devices, App Store distribution and the like? In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
I am 110% sure, because the young people I socialize with are operating in a tech environment that is more free and open than what I had as a kid.
The amount of open software and platforms we have right now would be mind blowing to younger me. The fact that I can run high quality LLMs on my laptop and even use them to open up old, closed games I had as a kid is incredible.
> How does this younger cohort feel about locked down devices, App Store distribution and the like?
Honestly? They DGAF. Their phones are communication devices and convenience things in their pocket. They have so many actual computers, SBCs, and microcontrollers to play with and they just want their phones to be phones.
Those who do care about open platforms vote with their wallet and buy one. They’re pragmatic. They don’t buy an iPhone and then whine about it being locked down because they know that the iPhone is not what you buy if that’s your goal.
You also have to remember that they grew up in the age of janky jailbroken phone mods. Jailbreaking your phone wasn’t equivalent to freedom, it was what people did when they wanted crazy fonts and colors and widgets on their phone until it bugged out and broke so bad they had to wipe it and start over. They got their fill of jailbreaking and moved on.
> In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
I think this mindset is unfairly smug and dismissive. Like only the old people are capable of understanding technology and the world. In my experience the young people know more about the current open alternatives and their options than I do if for no other reason than they’re more online, have more free time, and have probably watched 80 YouTube videos talking about it this year.
Would you be open to accepting the idea that maybe they do know what’s out there, and they just have different priorities than you?
What tech environments are you using that are more open now than in the past? It certainly seems you're conflating LLMs and their ability to 'create anything (regardless of quality or level of skill of the creator) on demand' rather than the software & services currently provided by Microsoft/Meta/Google/Amazon et al. that have slowly monopolized essentially everything and pushed the smaller players out. I'm referring to the majority of software and services available to the general tech using public.
But then you're talking about highly privileged people being optimistic.
It's easy to be positive when you grow up with the kind of wealth that gives you access to expensive hardware, as indicated by your statements "LLMs on my laptop" and "They have so many actual computers, SBCs, and microcontrollers to play with".
On a side note, so are the bugs.
These excessive daily updates I get on my linux are exhausting. For example, libre office started lagging on a large document I frequent daily and I had to rollback.
Everything you could do before social media and App Stores you can still do now. You can still connect to Usenet. You can still telnet onto servers. You can still write and publish blogs. You can still setup forums or write on them. You can still read and write to news aggregators (you're doing so right now in fact.) You can still setup your own email servers. You can still buy an SBC like a Raspberry Pi, hook up a display to it, plug in an LTE SIM and get connected to the internet.
The difference is that attention has moved away from open platforms to closed platforms. Did Gen Xers and older Millenials grow up with a negativity and malaise towards malls when, historically, most Western countries were dominated by small, independently run businesses? Did they dislike the big brands and corporations of the '50s which were previously smaller appliance makers? Consolidation and commodification are forces that have played out in many parts of the economy in many places.
> In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
This adds more anecdotal evidence to the feeling I get that there's a cohort of angry, older posters who mostly set the tone on this site these days.
As a side note, the "openness" at the times you discussed were still very limited in demography and geography.
People also blamed cigarettes more than the smoker, that's why a lot of regulations and warnings about its adverse effects was put in place. SOME people now blame the smokers because they feel like they should've known better, with all the warnings and information provided. That happened way later after systematic change. The behavior change was second order.
Nobody blamed the smoker when it wasn't regulated or still debated whether it was bad. "certain things from the internet" is still at that stage so it's understandable that people blame "it" over the users
Today, if you start smoking, everyone, even other smokers, even the cigarette packets, is telling you that it will ruin your life. At that point you're literally saying "yes I want to ruin my life" and it kinda is your fault.
Apple, Google, or Meta?
Apple obviously. They protect their users and still have a generally positive social vibe.
Meta and Google are largely only spoken of in negative light socially, and constantly castigated for their "user hostile" behavior.
But what is the ultimate irony here?
Apple only exists for people with money. It's a pay-to-play enterprise, and only a small sliver of the global population can afford to be part of it.
Google and Meta welcome everyone, and give everyone access to the same services and features (by and large).
I think there are a lot of people, who if they truly stepped back and understood this whole picture, would be left in a tornado of a soul search. How could the free companies with no bias towards wealth possibly end up as the bad guys?
Is that a serious question? They are ad companies. They don't do charity.
And one company had as a slogan "don't be evil" - they got rid of. And the other one was started with the words about their users
"they trust me. Dumb fucks"
They literally are the bad guys. Google started different, but now I don't see any value they care for except making more money by more web dominance. And with that dominance, spy, sell the data or use it to hijack peoples attention and manipulate it.
Their business model is selling manipulation of the public to the wealthy.
Starting prices are around $1500/month.
Apple sells phones. You can buy a usable refurbished one for less than $200 total.
Or is their business taking money from the wealthy and giving free services to the poor?
No one makes me click an ad. Ad-block on and all systems still go.
Upvoted because I enjoyed this rhetorical flourish, even though I don't buy it.
Their motivation is to make money, and the reach people give them the money. Therefore the GP's description feels more accurate. Perhaps "As a side effect of their business model of helping rich people influence poor people, the poor people get some genuine value" would be fair, while still keeping the spirit of your riposte.
Does a bank take money from wealthy investors, and distribute it to poor prospective homeowners? Yes, technically.
> kids in India using the exact same google office suite that fortune 500's are using
When I walk down Billionaires' Row, I see the same facades as the residents who live there.
Fortune 500s are paying google billions of dollars to monitor millions of Indian children, minute by minute, using advanced mathematics, psychology and supercomputers, in the hopes of guiding their lifelong purchasing decisions.
Then they enter their figures into Google Sheets.
Meanwhile, those children are not given the opportunity to monitor Fortune 500s CEOs and investors and fill up their devices and screens with imagery and video of their choice.
> No one makes me click an ad. Ad-block on and all systems still go
We can safely ignore this line of reasoning as a general explanation, because we know the manipulation works statistically - customers keep coming back to the tune of hundreds of billions annually.
Of course, none of this translates to a straightforward moral ruling. The transaction (like a loan) does bring benefits to both parties. It is not clear to me though that all participants in this transaction have true agency. I'd be more comfortable buying cigarettes for myself than for Indian children.
If you have something that you know works and you have data for it, you can try getting loans or investors. If you can establish trust that what you'll do can reach an audience who will gladly pay for it, money is the easy part.
It's a way for ideas that have traction to self-propel. No doubt that can be abused, but a lot of it is simply honest business.
> Apple, Google, or Meta?
I only get to choose between 3 different CIA fronts?
The answer isn't obvious at all, unless you're jaded and predisposed to one company or the other. I'd rather be none of them, and keep my principles instead of buying gold trophies for Trump, renaming landmarks or footing the ballroom bill. They're all pathetic.
I think it was the CIA from the very beginning. What do you say?
If you're asking me, there were definitely honeypot sites, and definitely organically popular social media too. 4chan got increasingly radicalized after Chris Poole started meeting with the international intelligence community, and anyone that denies X being CIA-operated should probably get their head checked. It's obvious that the alphabet agencies couldn't steer everything online, but it remains possible that our culture of oversharing and FOMO was part of an influence operation to bolster FVEY.
I hate presenting speculation as fact, but I think we've seen enough to know the score by now. Nobody in FAANG can afford to treat the state like an adversary, their only option is to buddy up and take on the rest of the world together. Jensen could be an example of what happens to insubordinates that outlive their usefulness to the feds.
Basically I really wonder if it was an organic tech/entrepreneur eventuality or was designed and pushed from the beginning by an actor and for its current widely known purpose.
There's a few ways to go here. 1) (vast majority of people) don't even notice what's going on and generally fine with things. 2) notice, and sink into negativity and helplessness. 3) notice, and actively weed out the garbage.
In the vast majority of offices the most common answer would be "huh? what is HN?"
Using word like "proof" is cherry on the cake
LLMs somehow conjure both feelings for me.
Usually it is the titles and posts underneath rather than users who make me less happy
You're fooling yourself if you think your opinions, particularly on matters outside of your direct experience, can exist independent of well funded influence campaigns.
I think the difference I'm seeing, again from the outside, is that (a) people who don't eat, sleep, and breathe tech are entering the field because it pays well, and (b) the people who do finally took notice that their passion is a trap (a well paying trap, but a trap nonetheless).
But trillions... are upheld by monopolization, violating privacy laws, violating competition laws, defying regulators, subverting regulations, lobbying to prevent regulation, and armies of lawyers running obstruction.
There’s a reason it spawned so many cults historically.
E.g. on a post about a Rust safety bug you might post something that amounts to "rust is bad" or "rust is good" and because it's easily digestible it brings upvotes from that side.
HN also has this effect. Every platform with upvotes has it, even if they don't do much as long as the poster can observe them.
HN is full of people who want to take other people's money. It should be in the forefront of your mind anytime someone wants to push something here. Nerdy tech discussions are a side effect, and has nothing to do with the motivations of this platform.
Obviously, Meta news is mostly going to be bad news, and attract negativity. No matter what tinted lenses you're looking at that company with, it's generally going to appear brown. But for most areas of tech, I've found this site in general to represent the sunny, glass-half-filled side of things. Discussions are generally pretty balanced and civil, and nastiness tends to get downvoted more often than not.
And of course this is a broad generalisation, and no site is ever going to be perfect. But if HN is your bar for too much hate online, I'm not sure how you're navigating the rest of the internet right now :(
Seriously - how is my life worse because of them?
But the other features are only good because of market share. There's no reason why facebook is better for sharing photos or messenger is better for chats beyond the enormous user base (which was far from organically grown). So how can another business ever unseat them from that position - everyone uses it and it's good enough.
And you've snuck in a little bit at the end which touches on that - you get more money because they track marital status of its user base globally.
If you can't extend the thought experiment to what else could be tracked, what the usual effects of bigcorp monopolies are and why that could be a problem for other people (or future you), you're choosing to keep your head in the sand and (like many, many others) sacrificing the common good for a petty personal benefit.
[0] https://www.howtogeek.com/768652/what-are-facebook-shadow-pr...
They knowingly facilitated genocide and gave zero shits.
They intentionally manipulate elections for the far right.
My kid's school PTA exclusively uses Facebook.
Most of the local food trucks and some businesses only post their schedules on Facebook or Instagram.
Marketplace killed all the alternatives.
It honestly drives me be crazy how this company has wormed their way into being such an essential piece of communication infrastructure for so many people that I can’t quit without sacrificing my ability to participate in some of the things I really enjoy.
Facebook in the Rohingya genocide had basically the same role as the RTLM in the Rwanda genocide.
Why did they do it? Well, getting people angry keeps them engaged, so they click more and you can show more ads.
https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/why-is-there-no-go...
But Meta is Meta, fr.
Predictably, fewer upvotes. HN users (and probably humans in general) like to vote up stories that reinforce their worldview.
One is about Facebook the product, the other about some technical detail
Coincidentally, in both cases of surveillance, GrapheneOS or iPhones would have prevented it.
Italy has some critical issues, but it's still a rule of law state.
I think that in the past, the situation was a lot more worrying than now. Think about Ustica, Bologna station bombing, etc.
Edit: I see another commenter linked https://enforcementtracker.com/. Very useful resource
Or leave the market altogether. Society here would be better off without Meta, for sure.
cant think of any other pool shared by walks of life as diverse as us, North Korean hackers, grandmas, school children, actual criminals, actual activists, mom n pops, mega corp businesses, big banks, small credit unions, governments / spies...
The vast majority of regulations are poorly enforced in most countries because they require extensive administrative efforts and legal costs, while politics push them to focus on the new boogieman. But if a government wants to find something against you they can. There's a large short term financial incentive with these ones.
https://www.theweek.in/news/biz-tech/2026/08/27/meta-settlem...
It is well known, and discussed, that young kids are particularly weak in relation to social media. Meta probably represents the strongest, "evilest" company in that regard.
What will we do, as a society, to make our lives better? Possibly without pitch forks.
Isn't the EU making more money from fining US tech companies than their own tech companies are paying in taxes at this point?
"Your honour, I did not break into this man's house. Last week he gave me his key ring so I could copy his car keys, so I took the liberty to write down all his bitting codes and made a copy of his keyring later. Since he gave me his key, I was authorised to be there and did not break in."
... is literally the excuse Meta is trying to use, except it's about photos.
But every U.S. tech company operate from Ireland, which is a tax haven, so since those tech giants do nothing for the local economy, fining them repeatedly (and deservingly) is a reasonable defense mechanism.
No, this is a common piece of Trump era propaganda. The EU does not levy such a general corporate tax, fines are not recurring as taxes are, fines like this one are done by a single member state (Italy in this case) and do nothing for the EU's budget, and the big tech companies within the EU are private companies whereas this misleading stat picks the rare public ones for its comparison
You can't raise VAT as that would be massively unpopular, so this is the next best option.
1: Fine tech bros for $reason and $amount must be in the billions
2: $business raises costs to cover the fine, now their AI is 50 cents more expensive
3: EU collects sweet money under the guise that tech bros are bad, and who would disagree?
4: go to step 1.
There are no other legitimate reasons to fine such an absurd amount and since the EU needs to fine a way to stealth tax the population this is a great way to do it.
As you say it's a cat and mouse game. But not quite as benign as you put it.Its what I would call a more hand in glove type of arrangement.
Government organisations benefit by social media platforms acting as large scale soft surveillance systems that allow them to enforce control. The act tough by occasionally 'fining' and punishing the 'bad' behaviour to 'demonstrate' how they care about the rule of the law. But the law is either uneforcable political messaging or full of holes that could be exploited.
This fine needs to be interpreted with the background understanding what's about to happen in Italy. Elections, and Meloni's image of being a strong leader being fractured.
And frankly Meta's abuses could not possibly be any worse. Its already fully totalitarian. Its as bad as it could have been despite decades of litigations and privacy right advocacy. They failed because they assumed that big tech and the state are two seperate entities. They are not.
You know how big meta is? UKs former deputy prime minister was just a low ranking employee in their organisation.
FYI here is Meta threatening to pull of Nigeria after being fined $290 million for privacy violations. They didn’t end up paying.
https://african.business/2025/05/technology-information/meta...
By the time the public hears about it like this it means attempts to avert it by the army of corporate lawyers & compliance experts have already failed
>I would just ignore 'em
That goes about as well as you refusing to pay your taxes. Pointless because while governments are slow they do eventually come for their pound of flesh
> Users must grant permission on their device before the feature can operate, and they can change that permission at any time in their settings.
> The fine is equivalent to about 0.47% of the group's global revenue.
What is Italy protecting Italians from here? I think it's clear consent was given at some point. So the objection is what? They need to ask consent again periodically? Or on a feature-by-feature basis? Who was conceivably harmed, and how?
How does Meta accept user content in the future without running afoul of the exact same rule again?
> I think it's clear consent was given at some point
That's not what was found. I don't know the facts of the case, but it's possible that "consent" mechanisms were found to be insufficient. As an example, if you ask for permission for one purpose, then use it for another, that would probably not meet the "inform users" bar.
Giving access to photos so that the user can upload a photo is not giving consent to analyze all the photos of the user on a phone.
The main principle of the GDPR is to store and use as little private data as possible and only get/store data when the user explicitly asks for it/consents to it.
(IANAL of course.)
What they were found guilty of doing is suggesting to the user they might want to upload a photo. All on-device, not uploading anything.