Upvoted because I enjoyed this rhetorical flourish, even though I don't buy it.
Their motivation is to make money, and the reach people give them the money. Therefore the GP's description feels more accurate. Perhaps "As a side effect of their business model of helping rich people influence poor people, the poor people get some genuine value" would be fair, while still keeping the spirit of your riposte.
Does a bank take money from wealthy investors, and distribute it to poor prospective homeowners? Yes, technically.
> kids in India using the exact same google office suite that fortune 500's are using
When I walk down Billionaires' Row, I see the same facades as the residents who live there.
Fortune 500s are paying google billions of dollars to monitor millions of Indian children, minute by minute, using advanced mathematics, psychology and supercomputers, in the hopes of guiding their lifelong purchasing decisions.
Then they enter their figures into Google Sheets.
Meanwhile, those children are not given the opportunity to monitor Fortune 500s CEOs and investors and fill up their devices and screens with imagery and video of their choice.
> No one makes me click an ad. Ad-block on and all systems still go
We can safely ignore this line of reasoning as a general explanation, because we know the manipulation works statistically - customers keep coming back to the tune of hundreds of billions annually.
Of course, none of this translates to a straightforward moral ruling. The transaction (like a loan) does bring benefits to both parties. It is not clear to me though that all participants in this transaction have true agency. I'd be more comfortable buying cigarettes for myself than for Indian children.
Or is their business taking money from the wealthy and giving free services to the poor?
No one makes me click an ad. Ad-block on and all systems still go.