News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by nsoam on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:23AM (#50497246)
How did they access users photos without consent? Did they run some exploit on Android to access the photo without showing the user the consent prompt? The article is really lacking in details.
[dead]
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by aprilthird2021 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:32AM (#50498333)
That's kind of ridiculous though? Should there be multiple permissions for every different thing the app might want to do with your camera roll? Should a user constantly have to affirm access to the camera roll while using the app? Once should be enough!
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by nsoam on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:08PM (#50498635)
When all you have is a huge hole in your national budget, everything looks like a finable offence.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by bathtub365 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:48PM (#50499086)
[delayed]
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by ahtihn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:49PM (#50499094)
> Should there be multiple permissions for every different thing the app might want to do with your camera roll?

Yes? Just because I want to share some pictures through an app doesn't mean I want it to go and do anything it wants with any picture on the device.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:09PM (#50499835)
Only for Facebook, lmao. Smaller apps without deep pockets aren't held to this standard.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by microtonal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:06PM (#50500299)
Or, you know, just don't aim to go through user's photos by default and just ask consent in the case a user enables/uses a feature that requires a photo to be sent to Facebook?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:39PM (#50500609)
The photos weren't sent to Facebook! This fine was for a feature that did not share any data with Facebook.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by klez on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:41AM (#50497390)
This explains a bit better what the issue is: https://en.ilsole24ore.com/art/facebooks-data-protection-reg...

TL;DR: they didn't thoroughly explain the users what they were consenting to when giving the app access to the gallery.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by mikelward on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:51AM (#50498483)
WhatsApp has a similar issue. You can't share just one photo, you have to give it access to all photos.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by notimetorelax on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:30PM (#50499475)
Hm, at least on iPhone I used to be able to allow only some photos.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by gib444 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:31PM (#50499483)
[delayed]
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by Doohickey-d on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:28PM (#50499981)
This isn't the case for me on Android anyway. You can turn off access for media & photos in settings, and then yes, it nags you to enable it, but there's still two ways to send photos:

* either share from an outside app, e.g. the gallery, choose "share", choose "whatsapp". This gives it access only to the photo you shared from the other app.

* and in Android's settings you can give Whatsapp access to a subset of photos, then it works normally on only that subset. Then you can always add more from outside that set, by pressing the paperclip icon when you write the message, there you see the "gallery option", then you see the limited subset of photos you gave access to, at the bottom right you have a folder picker icon which opens the system's gallery picker view (google photos in my case), where you can see all photos, and it can then access that photo too.

* if you chose no access to media at all, but if whatsapp has camera access, click on the paperclip icon in the message box, then, "camera", then the "gallery" icon, there you get a screen prompting for gallery access, but on the bottom right it has the same folder icon that gives access to the system photo picker, which again will only allow access to the photo you pick there.

The first two cases are pretty low-friction.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by drewfax on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:24AM (#50505727)
GrapheneOS supports sandboxed storage called Storage Scope. You can make any app think it has full Storage and "Photos and Videos" permission while it is fully sandboxed and user can selectively pick the files to add to the scope.

I believe Android 17 also offers "Limited" storage option to allow permission to select Photos and Videos.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:02AM (#50497565)
I had an HMD Nokia Android phone where the camera app had Facebook integration. It reached out to their servers every time the app started despite my not ever having had a Facebook account. I wouldn't be surprised if they also used this backdoor to access photos via the camera app's permissions.

Suffice to say, Nokia is on my blacklist of companies to never patronize again.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by bahmboo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:17AM (#50497704)
They didn't
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by skrebbel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:20AM (#50497725)
Found the Meta employee!
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by lokar on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:56AM (#50498030)
IME, many, if not most, meta employees (including me) are neutral to negative on the behavior of the company.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by Ylpertnodi on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:24AM (#50498265)
The fines should come out of your paychecks.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by valicord on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:41AM (#50498395)
That's literally what RSU is
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by contubernio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:20PM (#50499372)
In Europe, unlike the US, consent has to be real. It's bad faith to offer ten pages of stuff no one reads and no one understands and interpret a click as consent. EU law generally requires a good faith offer and informed consent.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:07PM (#50499813)
Do you think the "allow photo access? yes/no" dialogue has ten pages of legalese? I promise, it does not. Really unclear what Meta should do differently.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by microtonal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:01PM (#50500257)
Just asking 'Allow photo access' is not enough under the GDPR, you have to ask consent for every different purpose that you are going to use the data for. The case is exactly about this:

Facebook requested access to users' photo galleries through a single app-wide authorisation. According to the Italian regulator, a preceding notice did not make clear that this would also allow Facebook to generate suggestions based on photos in their gallery.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwn83gxemk35o

They should have explicitly asked separate consent to generate suggestions based on photos.

They know this. They just made the judgement that they could get away with an 'oopsie' or a fine that is just doing cost of business. These >1B fines are good, make them feel it, so that the next time they won't violate the GDPR.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:37PM (#50500581)
> They should have explicitly asked separate consent to generate suggestions based on photos.

I mean, this is kind of nuts. Should they ask consent every time you click to navigate to a new page, just in case you didn't want to see it? What level of granularity is acceptable?

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by pamcake on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:44PM (#50500642)
> I mean, this is kind of nuts. Should they ask consent every time you click to navigate to a new page, just in case you didn't want to see it? What level of granularity is acceptable?

I think you are obtuse and did not actually try to understand what the GDPR is saying but anyway no, it doesn't concern itself about that dimension at all. There would need to be new informed consent from the user before their data can be shared with new parties or for new purposes.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by polyomino on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:26PM (#50501014)
GDPR advocates always assume that their own interpretation of the law is aligned with the court, but obviously we don't know that's the case until after the trial
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:39PM (#50501186)
The data was not transmitted/processed/stored in this case! So the question remains, how granular is a "new" use? Do you need to individually consent for every photo you take? Is it even possible for Europeans to consent to a class of actions? What scope is permissible and what isn't? These are seemingly unanswered questions.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by microtonal on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:13AM (#50504748)
Is it even possible for Europeans to consent to a class of actions?

Yes. I suggest you actually read the GDPR rather than drawing caricatures of it based on not actually knowing the law. It is very readable.

https://www.privacy-regulation.eu/en/recital-32-GDPR.htm

Consent should be give per purpose. So, if you asked consent to access photos for performing an upload when the user requested it, you cannot use that to do an ML analysis of all the photos. But obviously, if the users gave consent to e.g. analyzing all photos for face recognition, you do not have to ask this for every photo, every scan, etc. It should just be easy to revoke the consent and remove any data stored.

(IANAL blah blah)

The GDPR is really a straightforward law. It only isn't if you want to collect private data without telling the user about it. Or if you want to use dark patterns to make the user accept data collection without them giving free, informed consent.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:03PM (#50509635)
The GDPR and its advocates caricaturize themselves. We've just moved the generality to a different term. What is a single "purpose" vs multiple purposes? The courts decided these were different purposes, but a reasonable person could decide it was all one purpose, actually.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by freecodeio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:30PM (#50501068)
mate you are missing the point, if you have a photo editing app and you ask for consent to edit a photo, that's not consent to also use the photo to do something else with it
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:37PM (#50501151)
The "something else" in this metaphor is "suggest to the user they might want to edit a photo."
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:19PM (#50501560)
It's not, Facebook processes the photos on their end and now also apparently feeds it to generative models to offer something (don't remember what exactly, managed to avoid this). At least that's what some options said last time I went exploring the app's settings page.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:32PM (#50501684)
This case was not about generative models at all.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by TeMPOraL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:48PM (#50501822)
Well then the next one might be. What I'm saying is that, per my recent memory, the options in Facebook settings menu around camera roll suggestions don't, in any way, even suggest the processing might be happening on-device only.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by berkes on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:21PM (#50501574)
no, the "something else" was sending far more photos to their servers than the one they were, in the methaphor, "editing".
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:33PM (#50501695)
No. The Italians are not accusing Meta of sending the photos in question to their servers -- just suggesting to users they might want to upload them.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by freecodeio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:28PM (#50501645)
so you're saying it's ok and consensual if I asked to get a drink from your fridge, and just ate all your food as well?
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:34PM (#50501699)
I'm saying, if you're going to my fridge, it's ok to ask me if I want a drink too.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by berkes on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:17PM (#50501547)
It does not.

But if you say "We need to access your photos so you can share a few with your friends" and then proceed to upload all the photo's, you are in violation.

Which is similar to what happened here and what the Italian judge ruled to be illegal.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by loeg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:32PM (#50501680)
> But if you say "We need to access your photos so you can share a few with your friends" and then proceed to upload all the photo's, you are in violation.

> Which is similar to what happened here

In fact, it has nothing to do with what happened here; why lie? No photos were uploaded by the feature the fine was assessed for.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by dvdyzag on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:35PM (#50502676)
It seems that the US honor system isn't applied to the tech enclave
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by AngryData on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:44PM (#50503782)
Theoretically those terms and contracts are also not valid in the US if the average user doesn't read them. But our courts are bought and paid for so in practice it doesn't matter.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by crystaln on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:10PM (#50500331)
Meta has a history of using simple features, like sending a photo to a contact in WhatsApp, to gain access to the user’s entire library for other purposes. This is illegal in Europe.

They use dark patterns and deception, and without knowing the details here I suspect Meta is guilty.

Meta’s response even stinks of these dark patterns, glossing over informed consent.

Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by cowlevel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:04PM (#50500802)
Yes it says so in the article. Users gave permission to access photos for one purpose and Meta abused it to access all photos for other purposes. They tried to weasel out of it by using a fine print "and other purposes" in the consent dialog, it didn't work.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by crystaln on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:14AM (#50507488)
I just noticed the Facebook app now forces you to give access to all your photos in order to save images from the app to your photo roll. That has to be a violation of Apple’s policies.
Re:Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access by holgerschurig on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:23AM (#50504802)
In a german radio news item about this they said that Meta only asked some general question "Can we access data?" that enable many different data types at one.

So the issue is a) that people had no choice ("Okay, I'll give you access to this folder, but not to my nude photos there") and b) that the text was so wishy washy that people had no idea that suddenly Meta access all of their photos now.