I think you would be hard pressed to find much positive sentiment about a company like Facebook here; eg a post 6 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25662215
There are certain threads that always invite a lot of negativity just because of the subject matter. It’s relatively easy to avoid those once you spot the pattern …
But isn’t it just shift of the tech in general?
From quirky, optimistic, positive, “don’t be evil”, inclusive ~20 years ago.
To corporate, creepy, fascist, ultra greedy since ~10 years[1] ago and onwards to this day.
I could feel gradual change of comments more into right political spectrum, since 7-8 years.
[1] Personally - Cambridge Analytica and Facebook scandal is that point for me.
Every comment thread got dragged into talking about the same few dozen things (or people) no matter where it started and the same shallow reddit level comments seemed to be all over the place.
Whereas before even on contentious topics there would be viewpoints like X s negative in these ways but if we also consider Y, W and Z these could be confounding factors, people were open to alternative takes and wanted to learn. Even on subjects I disagreed with I came out of it feeling like I better understood things, and other viewpoints. Nowadays though it feels like if the headline read "SpaceX space craft contacted by extra-terrestrials" it'd take 30 minutes to turn into a discussion of Musk.
Problem is I need to stay in the loop on the tech news scene that isn't shallow stories written by "tech journalists" who have a PHB understanding of the issue they're covering, or thinly vieled marketing brochures.
If anyone has any pointers to where I could find that I'd appreciate it. Moreover if anyone knows of some semi-private communities that would take in a poor internet refuge seeking a new tech land to call home I'd appreciate an introduction.
So long as there are no user visible consequences, it should be fine. Otherwise, it will turn into a super downvote and crowds will manipulate it to punish people they don't like.
It is semi-private as it is invite-based but still big. Compared to here it has less "industry news" and more "hacker content"
Just be sure you're ideologically aligned with the people there before you join. If you like LLMs, it's probably not for you.
Somewhat unexpectedly, Twitter/X has been growing as a place for quality discussion for me. That claim will be unbelievable to many here, because the average quality of posts on that site is extremely low. The killer feature is being able to cultivate your follow list and your block list together. If you can stay away from the ragebait, block the anger engagement farmers who worm their way into every discussion (Theo and similar accounts) and follow people when you see high quality posts of theirs shared, you start moving toward a feed with good signal.
Some people can’t help but get pulled into the vortex of ragebait and clickbait on sites like that. Those people should stay away, of course. If you can’t help but click on today’s drama or you get distracted or outraged easily, the Twitter firehose is not a good place to be.
I’m in my 40s and have been working in tech for a long time. I remember a time when it genuinely felt like the industry was a force for good in the world, opening doors for people to do things they never used to be able to do. And the companies were so open, e.g. I remember Facebook’s OpenGraph opening up a world of new social apps that were exciting to develop and to use.
That still happens today but to a far less degree. Nowadays it feels like every major tech player is all about lockin, about dark patterns that draw users into their services whether they’re happy about it or not. So yeah, I’m often negative on HN.
Your perspective is common and I see it a lot, but primarily in older and jaded developers.
When I switch cohorts and work with younger people in the real world (not chronically online) it’s a complete 180: Back to being excited about tech and the future, not really dwelling on the things that HNers complain about because they’re too busy looking forward than back at the tech world.
How does this younger cohort feel about locked down devices, App Store distribution and the like? In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
I am 110% sure, because the young people I socialize with are operating in a tech environment that is more free and open than what I had as a kid.
The amount of open software and platforms we have right now would be mind blowing to younger me. The fact that I can run high quality LLMs on my laptop and even use them to open up old, closed games I had as a kid is incredible.
> How does this younger cohort feel about locked down devices, App Store distribution and the like?
Honestly? They DGAF. Their phones are communication devices and convenience things in their pocket. They have so many actual computers, SBCs, and microcontrollers to play with and they just want their phones to be phones.
Those who do care about open platforms vote with their wallet and buy one. They’re pragmatic. They don’t buy an iPhone and then whine about it being locked down because they know that the iPhone is not what you buy if that’s your goal.
You also have to remember that they grew up in the age of janky jailbroken phone mods. Jailbreaking your phone wasn’t equivalent to freedom, it was what people did when they wanted crazy fonts and colors and widgets on their phone until it bugged out and broke so bad they had to wipe it and start over. They got their fill of jailbreaking and moved on.
> In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
I think this mindset is unfairly smug and dismissive. Like only the old people are capable of understanding technology and the world. In my experience the young people know more about the current open alternatives and their options than I do if for no other reason than they’re more online, have more free time, and have probably watched 80 YouTube videos talking about it this year.
Would you be open to accepting the idea that maybe they do know what’s out there, and they just have different priorities than you?
What tech environments are you using that are more open now than in the past? It certainly seems you're conflating LLMs and their ability to 'create anything (regardless of quality or level of skill of the creator) on demand' rather than the software & services currently provided by Microsoft/Meta/Google/Amazon et al. that have slowly monopolized essentially everything and pushed the smaller players out. I'm referring to the majority of software and services available to the general tech using public.
But then you're talking about highly privileged people being optimistic.
It's easy to be positive when you grow up with the kind of wealth that gives you access to expensive hardware, as indicated by your statements "LLMs on my laptop" and "They have so many actual computers, SBCs, and microcontrollers to play with".
On a side note, so are the bugs.
These excessive daily updates I get on my linux are exhausting. For example, libre office started lagging on a large document I frequent daily and I had to rollback.
Everything you could do before social media and App Stores you can still do now. You can still connect to Usenet. You can still telnet onto servers. You can still write and publish blogs. You can still setup forums or write on them. You can still read and write to news aggregators (you're doing so right now in fact.) You can still setup your own email servers. You can still buy an SBC like a Raspberry Pi, hook up a display to it, plug in an LTE SIM and get connected to the internet.
The difference is that attention has moved away from open platforms to closed platforms. Did Gen Xers and older Millenials grow up with a negativity and malaise towards malls when, historically, most Western countries were dominated by small, independently run businesses? Did they dislike the big brands and corporations of the '50s which were previously smaller appliance makers? Consolidation and commodification are forces that have played out in many parts of the economy in many places.
> In my experience younger people don’t think about it at all, because they aren’t aware of what the alternative could even be.
This adds more anecdotal evidence to the feeling I get that there's a cohort of angry, older posters who mostly set the tone on this site these days.
As a side note, the "openness" at the times you discussed were still very limited in demography and geography.
People also blamed cigarettes more than the smoker, that's why a lot of regulations and warnings about its adverse effects was put in place. SOME people now blame the smokers because they feel like they should've known better, with all the warnings and information provided. That happened way later after systematic change. The behavior change was second order.
Nobody blamed the smoker when it wasn't regulated or still debated whether it was bad. "certain things from the internet" is still at that stage so it's understandable that people blame "it" over the users
Today, if you start smoking, everyone, even other smokers, even the cigarette packets, is telling you that it will ruin your life. At that point you're literally saying "yes I want to ruin my life" and it kinda is your fault.
Apple, Google, or Meta?
Apple obviously. They protect their users and still have a generally positive social vibe.
Meta and Google are largely only spoken of in negative light socially, and constantly castigated for their "user hostile" behavior.
But what is the ultimate irony here?
Apple only exists for people with money. It's a pay-to-play enterprise, and only a small sliver of the global population can afford to be part of it.
Google and Meta welcome everyone, and give everyone access to the same services and features (by and large).
I think there are a lot of people, who if they truly stepped back and understood this whole picture, would be left in a tornado of a soul search. How could the free companies with no bias towards wealth possibly end up as the bad guys?
Is that a serious question? They are ad companies. They don't do charity.
And one company had as a slogan "don't be evil" - they got rid of. And the other one was started with the words about their users
"they trust me. Dumb fucks"
They literally are the bad guys. Google started different, but now I don't see any value they care for except making more money by more web dominance. And with that dominance, spy, sell the data or use it to hijack peoples attention and manipulate it.
Their business model is selling manipulation of the public to the wealthy.
Starting prices are around $1500/month.
Apple sells phones. You can buy a usable refurbished one for less than $200 total.
Or is their business taking money from the wealthy and giving free services to the poor?
No one makes me click an ad. Ad-block on and all systems still go.
Upvoted because I enjoyed this rhetorical flourish, even though I don't buy it.
Their motivation is to make money, and the reach people give them the money. Therefore the GP's description feels more accurate. Perhaps "As a side effect of their business model of helping rich people influence poor people, the poor people get some genuine value" would be fair, while still keeping the spirit of your riposte.
Does a bank take money from wealthy investors, and distribute it to poor prospective homeowners? Yes, technically.
> kids in India using the exact same google office suite that fortune 500's are using
When I walk down Billionaires' Row, I see the same facades as the residents who live there.
Fortune 500s are paying google billions of dollars to monitor millions of Indian children, minute by minute, using advanced mathematics, psychology and supercomputers, in the hopes of guiding their lifelong purchasing decisions.
Then they enter their figures into Google Sheets.
Meanwhile, those children are not given the opportunity to monitor Fortune 500s CEOs and investors and fill up their devices and screens with imagery and video of their choice.
> No one makes me click an ad. Ad-block on and all systems still go
We can safely ignore this line of reasoning as a general explanation, because we know the manipulation works statistically - customers keep coming back to the tune of hundreds of billions annually.
Of course, none of this translates to a straightforward moral ruling. The transaction (like a loan) does bring benefits to both parties. It is not clear to me though that all participants in this transaction have true agency. I'd be more comfortable buying cigarettes for myself than for Indian children.
If you have something that you know works and you have data for it, you can try getting loans or investors. If you can establish trust that what you'll do can reach an audience who will gladly pay for it, money is the easy part.
It's a way for ideas that have traction to self-propel. No doubt that can be abused, but a lot of it is simply honest business.
> Apple, Google, or Meta?
I only get to choose between 3 different CIA fronts?
The answer isn't obvious at all, unless you're jaded and predisposed to one company or the other. I'd rather be none of them, and keep my principles instead of buying gold trophies for Trump, renaming landmarks or footing the ballroom bill. They're all pathetic.
I think it was the CIA from the very beginning. What do you say?
If you're asking me, there were definitely honeypot sites, and definitely organically popular social media too. 4chan got increasingly radicalized after Chris Poole started meeting with the international intelligence community, and anyone that denies X being CIA-operated should probably get their head checked. It's obvious that the alphabet agencies couldn't steer everything online, but it remains possible that our culture of oversharing and FOMO was part of an influence operation to bolster FVEY.
I hate presenting speculation as fact, but I think we've seen enough to know the score by now. Nobody in FAANG can afford to treat the state like an adversary, their only option is to buddy up and take on the rest of the world together. Jensen could be an example of what happens to insubordinates that outlive their usefulness to the feds.
Basically I really wonder if it was an organic tech/entrepreneur eventuality or was designed and pushed from the beginning by an actor and for its current widely known purpose.
There's a few ways to go here. 1) (vast majority of people) don't even notice what's going on and generally fine with things. 2) notice, and sink into negativity and helplessness. 3) notice, and actively weed out the garbage.
In the vast majority of offices the most common answer would be "huh? what is HN?"
Using word like "proof" is cherry on the cake
LLMs somehow conjure both feelings for me.
Usually it is the titles and posts underneath rather than users who make me less happy
You're fooling yourself if you think your opinions, particularly on matters outside of your direct experience, can exist independent of well funded influence campaigns.
I think the difference I'm seeing, again from the outside, is that (a) people who don't eat, sleep, and breathe tech are entering the field because it pays well, and (b) the people who do finally took notice that their passion is a trap (a well paying trap, but a trap nonetheless).
But trillions... are upheld by monopolization, violating privacy laws, violating competition laws, defying regulators, subverting regulations, lobbying to prevent regulation, and armies of lawyers running obstruction.
There’s a reason it spawned so many cults historically.
E.g. on a post about a Rust safety bug you might post something that amounts to "rust is bad" or "rust is good" and because it's easily digestible it brings upvotes from that side.
HN also has this effect. Every platform with upvotes has it, even if they don't do much as long as the poster can observe them.
HN is full of people who want to take other people's money. It should be in the forefront of your mind anytime someone wants to push something here. Nerdy tech discussions are a side effect, and has nothing to do with the motivations of this platform.
Obviously, Meta news is mostly going to be bad news, and attract negativity. No matter what tinted lenses you're looking at that company with, it's generally going to appear brown. But for most areas of tech, I've found this site in general to represent the sunny, glass-half-filled side of things. Discussions are generally pretty balanced and civil, and nastiness tends to get downvoted more often than not.
And of course this is a broad generalisation, and no site is ever going to be perfect. But if HN is your bar for too much hate online, I'm not sure how you're navigating the rest of the internet right now :(