News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by eigenspace on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:33AM (#49978211)
Its quite interesting to see that at least the early days of AI so far have not been a winner-take-all runaway acceleration game where catchup is impossible.

I certainly wouldnt have predicted that 10 years ago.

Very glad to see Mistral still in the game even after some big stumbles with Large 3. I deeply hope that this model is 'good enough' that it becomes the European go-to, giving them the resources to keep the pace up.

I'm excited to try this out today.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by apexalpha on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:35AM (#49978256)
I think a big part of that is the Chinese publishing the solution for everywhere hurdle in the road they've encountered in the form of a paper.

Deepseek essentially releases instruction manuals in paper form.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by baxtr on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:58AM (#49979495)
I think it might have accelerated things but on a much more basic level, there seems to be no real moat in synthesizing the world’s knowledge into LLMs.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by rpozarickij on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:10PM (#49980569)
There's no question that training leading LLMs requires some serious expertise and know-how, but surely already having advanced LLMs/agents must be helping tremendously not only for software engineers but also for those working on LLMs themselves.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by joe_the_user on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:03PM (#49981216)
I think one could describe LLM optimization as "hard but not a moat". Years ago, optimizing neural nets was described "graduate student descent" - it's tricky but throw enough conventionally smart people at it and it will happen. It's like tuning a hot rod and finding a reproducible bug in a large code base. It's hard and there are tricks but not absolute hurdles, no problems waiting for a conceptual breakthrough (and at today's scales, are there any problems waiting for an Einstein to solve? That's an open (AI) question).
Re:Mistral Large 4 by cyanydeez on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:34AM (#49980050)
I also think we're seeing the sigmoid approaching.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by spwa4 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:48AM (#49980269)
What is really going on: all the AI labs are doing panicked model releases (and panicked training of new ones) because Qwen4 is rumored to come out end of October and is rumored to be very nice. Question is: is it another "Deepseek-moment" nice? Or just nice?

Btw: with Qwen4 I mean the next large Qwen model that is based on the Qwen4 architecture (Qwen 3.8 flash next was "almost" based on the new arch but obviously was a small model)

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ejeje12a on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:00PM (#49980447)
It doesn’t matter.

What matters more is if firm’s start using a bundle of American and Chinese models and when they find their feet - how large is the market for frontier?

Frontier has to displace labour one for one at some point or it’s over.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by christkv on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:06PM (#49980521)
Awesome 3.8 next runs great on my Framework Desktop so I'm loving more local models.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by hypercube33 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:07PM (#49981265)
I have similar hardware - what specific version of the 3.8 Next model are you running and how many tokens/s are you seeing? 3.6 35B A3B gets about 68t/s for me so I've been sticking with that model for the mean time.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by throwa356262 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:53PM (#49981829)
The thing with 3.8 next is that it uses a variant of ngrams. Part of the network is replaced by a lookup table you can store on a fast ssd.

In practice, you will be able to run models a bit bigger than 35B.

https://unsloth.ai/docs/models/qwen3.8-next

Re:Mistral Large 4 by cyanydeez on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @03:12PM (#49982709)
https://github.com/peonist-ai/halogen-server is beating the pants off of anything I've tried.

38GB of vram resident. more tk/s, more prefill.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by christkv on Thursday October 08, 2026 @02:54PM (#50010323)
I have been using Q4 and running it with https://github.com/gufo-org/gufo which seems to be working pretty well. But I have to get off bazzite as my distro. I love the fedora atomic in principle but it's a pain for normal installs.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by verdverm on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:29PM (#49980784)
I wondered if there would be a Qwen 4 or we would go straight to 5, re: tetraphobia, but perhaps it's more like an uno reverse card in this case

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraphobia

Re:Mistral Large 4 by satvikpendem on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:07PM (#49981280)
DeepSeek being Chinese also has 4 so I don't think it's a big deal for model makers.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by verdverm on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:32PM (#49981601)
GLM moved through their 4-series without consequence

I wonder if the next DS models will also graduate to 5.x, I think I saw they are training up a 10T model, and just raised $12B too

Re:Mistral Large 4 by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:53AM (#49990039)
> and just raised $12B too

It's important to realise that Deepseek are a very unconventional model lab, as they were originally funded by the founder's work in quantitative trading.

They mostly don't need that much money, the reason they took funding is to provide employees with equity, as lots of their good people were getting poached by other Chinese model startups.

(I have no inside info, just read the FT articles about them).

Re:Mistral Large 4 by cyanydeez on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @03:11PM (#49982695)
I'm pretty sure the point of Qwen3.8-Flash-Next was to get the open source engines to integrate the qwen4 architecture.

The fact that it basically broke open the local model supremacy was just a nice side effect.

I'm running: https://github.com/peonist-ai/halogen-server with a quant4, PLE offloaded, and it's resident VRAM is 36GB at 265k context.

Shave 10 more GB off and the TAM openai and anthropic are targeting is a lost cause. Local models are what 90% of people will need.

If the world governments can get a handle on the memory cartel, then there's no more moat for most normal humans.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ben_w on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @03:55PM (#49983225)
I want that to be true (assuming you mean specifically the second half of the sigmoid) just to give me room to adapt to the changes we've already seen; but I've seen comments saying things are slowing down since around when GPT-4 came out.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by scotty79 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:28AM (#49979976)
I think the moat is going to be compute. So far compute needed to push the frontier is still extremely cheap so the capital can afford to spread its bets. But when further improvement is going to cost in trillions, capital will have to pick a winner and bet only on him. It won't be a matter of finding the best bet, it will be a matter of survival.

This will cause the picked winner to get massively ahead with sheer compute alone used both for training and inference dedicated to recursive self improvement.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by pennomi on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:32AM (#49980034)
Surely there is a point where algorithmic improvements will be more cost effective than buying more hardware.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by scotty79 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:47AM (#49980259)
I'm afraid it might be the other way around. RSI might pick all of the low hanging fruit soon. There must be a physical limit of how much intelligence you can squeeze out of some amount of parameters and compute.

There are going to still be worthwhile improvements but they are going to be more like not how to make transformers 10x cheaper but how to make next training run cost 9 trillions instead of 10 with a very particular optimization designed at the cost of hundreds of millions for this one specific run.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by LPisGood on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:01PM (#49980450)
I think we’re no where near a physical information theoretic limit.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by thfuran on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:52PM (#49981066)
The hardware also is, so there ought to be a whole lot more room for improvement.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ejeje12a on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:02PM (#49980467)
“ RSI might pick all of the low hanging fruit soon”

Scam Altman is that you?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by bee_rider on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:41PM (#49981696)
It is just occurring to me that “RSI” expands to recursive self improvement. Thought people were talking about repetitive stress injuries; either in regards to programmers writing too much code/not having to write code anymore, or the frontier AI companies and their tendency to applaud themselves.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Zigurd on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:45PM (#49980986)
If you're actually applying LLMs, all of the things around the LLM that adapt it to coding, for example, that enable it to use existing validation tools for code, and enable it to diagnose and fix tool chain issues that aren't directly coding problems, are what makes the difference between a model that that scores a little higher on a coding benchmark and a model that's useful in a particular code base on a particular platform.

Are there any use cases that have enabled one customer of a frontier LLM to outperform a competitor using a different frontier LLM? Or is this why we are seeing confected points of comparison like solving challenge problems in mathematics?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by bushbaba on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:35AM (#49980080)
Not just compute but energy. Most of Europe has no access to the cost effective power generation needed
Re:Mistral Large 4 by pyrale on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:23PM (#49980712)
Europe has lots of zero-cost windows for electricity, and areas with cheap prices. The real issue is access to oil and gas.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by randomNumber7 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:52PM (#49981077)
Maybe for training big models one can wait for times when the wind is blowing.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by flir on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:44PM (#49981737)
There are worse ideas.

I could imagine a belt of data centres around the equator, that hand off their computational loads as the sun sets. Good scifi-esque premise.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by kergonath on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:19PM (#49982118)
That does not really sound practical to let datacenters costing billions idle half the time.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Danox on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:17PM (#49980653)
Build Nuclear, Build Thorium the Chinese are building whatever they can. They’re not locked in by special interest. Is that because they have lots of engineers on the job in government?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by oakesm9 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:03PM (#49980481)
France is actually pretty cheap in Europe. About 15% more than average USA electric prices (but I know that varies a lot across the states so still likely much more than the cheaper areas)
Re:Mistral Large 4 by jsw97 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:54AM (#49980352)
Training location is flexible. Iceland?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by jayd16 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:38AM (#49980119)
But the old models still exist at trivial marginal cost. The frontier models would need to dominate every price point to really take all and so far they haven't been.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ambicapter on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:01PM (#49980455)
Don't worry, AI boosters will be in here soon denigrating anyone that uses anything but the latest and greatest models as irrelevant.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by flir on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:28PM (#49980763)
I guess all predictions age like milk, but here's one:

There's a law of diminishing returns at play here, and doubling the energy cost of training to wring 2% more performance out of the technology isn't going to be very useful, because most of the problems it is capable of solving will be solvable with the previous-gen 98%-as-good model.

("there's a law of diminishing returns at play here" is an article of faith. But then, so is the belief that these models will keep getting better).

Re:Mistral Large 4 by londons_explore on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:39PM (#49980905)
As soon as you can demonstrate decent financial returns (ie. the AI can run a company better than humans can), suddenly it makes sense to put a lot more $$$ in even if returns are diminishing - since whoever runs companies the best gets control of a big chunk of the world economy.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ejeje12a on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:46PM (#49980999)
“ ie. the AI can run a company better than humans can”

lol You can always tell who has never ran a business before with comments like this

Re:Mistral Large 4 by satvikpendem on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:08PM (#49981290)
I understood their point, if we truly get AGI then no reason to think AI would be worse than a human.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by asplake on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:57PM (#49982543)
AGI with people skills?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by scotty79 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:14PM (#49987657)
Do you doubt? Already plenty of people prefer people skills of AI chatbots to those of other people.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by satvikpendem on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:52AM (#49988357)
Chatbots are more considerate than many people I know. They at least explain things in a calm way.
[dead]
Re:Mistral Large 4 by cheevly on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:09PM (#49982000)
You are literally an AI spambot account, that's the hilarious irony here.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by satvikpendem on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:20PM (#49981452)
Well yes that's the worry isn't it? That people will soon all be unemployed? Just because it sounds farfetched doesn't mean you should stick your head in the sand, seeing the pace of development these days, that is "reasoning properly" and it just seems you are trying to block out what seems inconvenient to hear.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by flir on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:56PM (#49981132)
If that works... why not just jump straight to a planned economy run by LLM? Skip the whole messy "free market" thing altogether?

(I don't think it will work).

Re:Mistral Large 4 by allendoerfer on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:11PM (#49981319)
What do you have against multi-agent reinforcement learning systems and why do you think they are not AI?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by flir on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:39PM (#49981682)
londons_explore is arguing for a winner-takes-all scenario, with an early advantage locking everyone and everything else out.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by wg0 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:39AM (#49978305)
My spend on DeepSeek is not much and I regularly top up my balance every month as my support for all the good work DeepSeek is doing for the open science.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by fsmedberg on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:43AM (#49978374)
DeepSeek, and other Chinese models, are heavily subsidised by the Chinese government. The reason they release the AI models is economic warfare against US, not because of charity or kindness. It's great for us consumers, but the goal is not to help humanity or open-source.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by piva00 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:16AM (#49978876)
Framing it that way hides all the levers used to tilt the playing field for US companies, no?

The government that removed restrictions on how private companies can access capital after a certain scale (the JOBS Act), that removed the need for private companies to report as if they were a public company after a shareholder threshold was crossed, superpowering the access of wealthy private investors to get in earlier in a growing company while at the same blocking the public from participating in funding growing enterprises at an earlier stage (since it required companies to IPO much earlier to access capital) which allowed retail investors to also reap the rewards on funding them early when they grew to become behemoths (like Amazon, Meta/Facebook, Google, etc.).

It's not fair in either place, the USA has its own model of unfairness, China has a completely different one. The difference is that in the USA the government allows private investors to become more powerful than the State (outside of the monopoly of violence) while plunging the rest of society into increasingly more precarious lives while in China the State is the power and its legitimacy only exists while the population feel they have a better life.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by atwrk on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:39AM (#49979226)
IMO the selective enforcement of regulatory requirements should be added to the list. Observing from the outside, I have a hard time believing that e.g. musks gas powered data centers really follow all the environmental laws, for example, or that the authorities really see no grounds for indictment if Altmans company hacks hundreds of third parties, or that there's really no one at the SEC having a problem with Anthropics fear mongering prior to the IPO.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by shwaj on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:38AM (#49980126)
In a list describing how the USA system works, sure: selective enforcement is there.

As a differentiator from the Chinese system, not so much. For two otherwise equal companies, the one that says things against the party line will experience selective enforcement too.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by gpt5 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:35PM (#49981628)
Except that in China, the people who do that will disappear.

The propaganda of trying to make US and China government appear the same is making people dumber. and is one of the most heavily used tools in China’s online propaganda arsenal.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by p_j_w on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:51PM (#49981808)
>The propaganda of trying to make US and China government appear the same [...] is one of the most heavily used tools in China’s online propaganda arsenal.

The government could do some very easy things to remove this tool from China's toolbelt. Like you know, prosecuting rich people when they've earned it.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by gpt5 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:28PM (#49984410)
No. They would need to kidnap rich and poor people and their families regardless of "earning" it. Then they. will start to get closer.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by shwaj on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:42PM (#49986897)
Who was trying to make the US and China appear the same? I think you have reading comprehension problems, buddy.

If you look at the comment I responded to, they were remarking on selective enforcement in the USA. I merely observed that this isn’t a unique feature of the US system, it happens in China too. I said nothing about the severity of the consequences.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by K0balt on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @05:41AM (#49990392)
In the USA, they don’t disappear, they commit suicide in their car typically. In Russia, they fall out of windows and off of balconies. I don’t think it’s accurate to call the circumstances equivalent, or the regimes equivalent. But there are some remarkable similarities, and their goals are similarly structured - to keep those in power powerful and to enrich the wealthy.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by 010ED67913 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:29PM (#49981564)
he's not really "framing" it that way. that's just simply exactly what it is.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by piva00 on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:14AM (#49991130)
There's a framing though, by mentioning only Chinese tactics as nefarious/malicious it leaves the USA as the morally superior model (and for many it will be assumed as the "fair" option), which it definitely isn't.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by throwa356262 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:00AM (#49978642)
If you think about it, the US labs are heavily subsidised too. Not only they receive billions in state funding, the administration is also prepared to engage in trade wars to help them.

I think the Chinese government is backing their labs by less direct means. For example cheap electricity and investing in chip manufacturers such as Huawei and cxmt.

Deepseek specifically, is known to operate with minimal resources. The entire company has around 160 employees and every model they release must break even within ten months.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by dataviz1000 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:00AM (#49979517)
SpaceX has been awarded roughly $22 billion to nearly $30 billion in cumulative public federal contracts, the $280 billion CHIP act, and who knows how much the CIA + NSA are spending.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by philipallstar on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:09AM (#49979665)
Awarded that for doing work, though, not to clone someone else's work and release it for less money.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by throwa356262 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:26AM (#49979949)
I think this is different for different labs. Some innovate while others copy.

Same goes for US labs, not everyone are as innovative as google deepmind:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/antoniopequenoiv/2026/04/30/elo...

Re:Mistral Large 4 by dataviz1000 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:20AM (#49979861)
> not to clone someone else's work

Ironically your comment will be cloned and used for training.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by philipallstar on Friday October 09, 2026 @10:54AM (#50021383)
Maybe embedding things about a derivative AI's company will be the Reflections on Trusting Trust[0] vulnerability of the 21st century.

[0] https://people.cs.umass.edu/~emery/classes/cmpsci691st/readi...

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ta20240528 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:31AM (#49980008)
Whose work on KV-cache reduction did Deepskeep clone? Please be specific.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by philipallstar on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @11:22AM (#49994100)
It seems obviously dustortionary to highlight the niche, optional part of the process they did spend time on, that would be utterly worthless without the difficult bit being done elsewhere. Please be less specific.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by deaux on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:20PM (#49980685)
> Awarded that for doing work, though

Yes, just that. Being a huge supporter of the regime - at a time running a department - surely has nothing to do with it.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by philipallstar on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @11:23AM (#49994111)
Yes. If you think SpaceX is some sort of terrible also-ran that can only get contracts through political links, then honestly I don't think I can help you there. I don't think anyone can.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Implicated on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:44PM (#49980980)
> not to clone someone else's work and release it for less money.

... You're saying this about _deepseek_?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by lnxg33k1 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:02PM (#49981920)
You see why there are so many conspiracy theories about US landing on the moon, one is left wondering how is it possible that a countries of such retards did something like that
Re:Mistral Large 4 by novaRom on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:10PM (#49980568)
When one player tries to monopolize AI tech and market by all means, others are those who don't want to be hooked to a foreign will in the future. I think this is the reason in doing open research, and it's likely positive for all of us.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by 50or05 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:24AM (#49979008)
I'm pretty sure, the training/fine tune through Claude/OpenAi would not be possible without the army/China's hacking teams (and legal protection). So it's more than just a cheap electricity.

Supporting deepseek is just like supporting the Chinese army, no need for that. Though it goes both ways, OpenAi subscription just lowers the cost of the US army as well.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ndriscoll on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:53AM (#49979416)
Sorry, are you saying that it's a subsidy that it's legal for them to distill other models, or what? It's not even clear that there's any kind of protection for models in Western countries. Why would they be worried about the legality of distillation? And what does the army have to do with distilling models? Like you're saying it's a subsidy that China protects their borders from invasion by the US?

It's not a subsidy for the Chinese to say they're going to ignore our IP laws. It's a subsidy for us to say we're going to make them and try to push them on the world. It's literally granting a monopoly by legal force. It's very obviously not aligned with the interests of the American people, while China releasing things in the open is.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ismael_rr on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:54AM (#49979436)
Same with the US legal system protecting Anthropic from copyright laws from all the books and other stuff used for pretraining...
Re:Mistral Large 4 by IOT_Apprentice on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:14AM (#49979748)
The Chinese army isn’t bombing countries around the world or overthrowing governments and stealing gold and oil around the planet. Meanwhile the US military is doing so and is preparing to Do more of that. The Chinese have a rational approach to trade, national infrastructure, education, safety nets, healthcare and much more.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by sys32768 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:41AM (#49980175)
China also has a very "rational" approach to dissidents, Tibetan activists, Uyghurs, Hong Kong pro-democracy activists, and Taiwan.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Danox on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:35PM (#49980850)
In the US, it’s only a matter of time before El Presidente decides to take away those reservations from the Indians and sell them off and the same goes for Camp Pendleton in Taco’s favorite American state.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by metobehonest on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:30AM (#49979100)
>Supporting deepseek is just like supporting the Chinese army

Good, where do I sign up? At least they aren't exploding little children and generating chaos in the oil market.

https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/anthropi...

Re:Mistral Large 4 by stickfigure on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:55AM (#49980360)
I want you to come here and apologize in public when Xi starts bombing Taiwan like he's promising.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Danox on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:36PM (#49980874)
I want the current president who has lost his mind to apologize to two California cities.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by stickfigure on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:00PM (#49999925)
You and me both. But he'll be irrelevant in two years, maybe less. Xi is in for life.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by metobehonest on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:54PM (#49981109)
As bad as casualties get in a future war like that, it's still very likely to be a symmetric war where the main targets are military infrastructure. No systematic annihilation of universities, hospitals, religious sites, journalists and health workers like certain genocidal regimes backed by the tech oligarchies have been doing.

https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2025/06/israeli-atta...

https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/unesco-presents-assessmen...

I want you to publicly say that this turtle biologist and this journalist are Hamas: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/jun/20/mona-khalil-tu... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/apr/23/lebanon-journa...

Re:Mistral Large 4 by parineum on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:14AM (#49978842)
> I think the Chinese government is backing their labs by less direct means.

It may be that the effect of the backing in both places is essentially equal but this statement is strange. The Chinese government invests directly in Deepseek[1]. Notice the article, in addition to saying the CCP is investing, says Tencent is also a major backer. CCP owns a golden share of Tencent.

[1]https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/06/deepseek-funding-round.html

Re:Mistral Large 4 by atwrk on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:48AM (#49979350)
Ok, but Trump stated that the US is in active talks to take over parts of both OpenAI and Anthropic, too: https://www.cnbc.com/2026/06/05/trump-open-ai-altman-stake.h...
Re:Mistral Large 4 by parineum on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:11PM (#49980580)
I'm not arguing about a comparison here. I'm trying to correct a misconception about China that I see a lot from Western perspectives.

Everything a Chinese company does has the explicit backing of the CCP, at least ideologically and usually financially in some fashion. While DeepSeek may not be the CCP, it couldn't exist if it was expressing any kind of ideology that wasn't inline with them and, in this case, is explicitly funded by them.

A Chinese company has no freedom to say Taiwan is a country the way someone in the US could suggest California succeed from the nation.

Any public message you hear coming out of China has the implicit approval of the Chinese government.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by deaux on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:24PM (#49980727)
> Everything a Chinese company does has the explicit backing of the CCP, at least ideologically and usually financially in some fashion.

If you're not arguing about comparison then don't state this as if it's any different from the US. Because you make it sound that way. Or do you think that if tomorrow OpenAI came out vocally supporting the DSA - that suddenly they wouldn't see lots of barriers rise up out of nowhere?

Come on now. That's fairy tale land.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by parineum on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:42PM (#49986364)
Retaliation is different than what happens in China. In China, the DeepSeek CEO drafts a press release about Taiwan's independence and he's promptly fired and sent to prison.

If OpenAI comes out in support of _any_ political party, they may lose business from the government in the future.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by deaux on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @02:15AM (#49988982)
> If OpenAI comes out in support of _any_ political party, they may lose business from the government in the future.

Fairy tale land it is. Consequences for what I said would be far bigger than "lose business from government".

Re:Mistral Large 4 by Danox on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:40PM (#49980926)
Well, there was one happy audience in Nebraska with the blessing of El Presidente that was happy if two California cities get the shaft.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by pyrale on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:46PM (#49981004)
I would like to point out that a lawsuit is currently live about the us govt forcing US tech companies to retaliate against us citizen criticizing the govt’s policy.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ygjb on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:58AM (#49978594)
Well, they are helping 17% of the world's population, and the US is currently actively engaged in trade wars and economic warfare or explicitly attempting to leverage it's hegemony against its long term alliea for short term gain.

There is as much to criticize about American hyper scalers and AI labs and the lack of interest in helping humanity or contributing to open source, but that might not be as popular an opinions on this site.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by gpugreg on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:24AM (#49979002)
Only 17%? I'd say driving down the price of AI helps at least 95% of the world's population. It certainly helps me.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ygjb on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:47AM (#49980252)
17% is the approximate population of Earth in China. I was using a simple example as a counter to the anglocentric view the parent poster was expressing by trying to paint China as a villain.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by benterix on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:49AM (#49979360)
I assume 17% is roughly the percentage of people that use LLMs globally (the numbers vary between 15 and 20 percent).
Re:Mistral Large 4 by bredren on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:01AM (#49979548)
Amazingly low, given potential impact. Where is this use concentrated? Who has the best data on use right now.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by locknitpicker on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:18PM (#49980660)
> Well, they are helping 17% of the world's population,

Any open weights model that Chinese companies are releasing for free are allowing everyone in the world to have access to high quality realizations of these tools without the risk of the US regime arbitrarily cutting you off.

Also, it's funny how all the neoliberal mantras of how free market drives progress through competition stops when it's a US company that's being challenged.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by 1234letshaveatw on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:17AM (#49979811)
I suppose in some sense preventing nuclear holocaust is a short term gain...
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ygjb on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:49AM (#49980278)
What nuclear holocaust has the only country to use a nuclear weapon against a target prevented?

Do you think the world is closer to or more distant from large scale global conflict today than it was 10 years ago, or even 3 years ago?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by 1234letshaveatw on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:10PM (#49980552)
Iran has expressed a willingness/eagerness to nuke Israel and the US. That outcome would be less than ideal
Re:Mistral Large 4 by overfeed on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:12PM (#49982026)
> Iran has expressed a willingness/eagerness to nuke Israel and the US.

Source? The last Supreme Leader of Iran issued a fatwa against nukes, way before he and his extended family where bombed in their home in a failed attempt at a decapitation strike.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by juiceland on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:18AM (#49978894)
> The reason they release the AI models is economic warfare against US

The story is so much more complicated than that, to the point that this economic warfare theory is basically a meme.

Chinese models are open because they don’t have a choice. “When you trail the frontier, openness maximizes reputation per unit of capability. The moment you lead, you close.” [0]

[0] https://earnedintuition.substack.com/p/involution-without-ex...

Re:Mistral Large 4 by yorwba on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:11PM (#49981325)
They do have a choice, as evidenced by all the times when the other option gets picked. The article you link tries to acknowledge ByteDance's Doubao and Alibaba's Qwen Max as exceptions, but forgets about Baidu's Ernie and iFlytek's Spark, which are also closed-weight. There's simply no consensus yet on which strategy is better, so different companies end up making different bets.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by juiceland on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:52PM (#49981825)
That’s because Baidu sells model access and iFlytek sells integrated products. Also both have released open models, just older ones. They just close their latest ones because they got the reputation they needed out of them and have transitioned to a product. Notice that both of these explain the motivation without resorting to unfalsifiable claims about "economic warfare".
Re:Mistral Large 4 by yorwba on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:35PM (#49982296)
Huh, when XHToken released a model named Spark, I assumed it was just a name collision, since iFlytek appears nowhere in the documentation. But on iFlytek's model marketplace, it's listed as their self-developed model: https://maas.xfyun.cn/modelSquare So they actually released an open model quite recently! Thanks for letting me know.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by tacomagick on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:46AM (#49978423)
So is American models. They are subsidised heavily but still can't provide cheaper access. Their fault is to assume all countries can afford them.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by rafram on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:55AM (#49978567)
By whom?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by gabriel666smith on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:30AM (#49979105)
If you want a direct example of the US subsidising a major AI lab, we can use Microsoft's investment in OpenAI. Microsoft has the largest ownership stake - 27%.

Microsoft did not pay with money - it paid (mostly) with Azure cloud computing credits. MSOFT is then able to write this off as a loss against tax.

It is generally far more tax-efficient in the US to write a loss in this way than it is to write a loss for a cash investment.

In this case, I believe the difference was ultimately highly significant. When including MSOFT eventually writing-off the deprecating Azure hardware it had used to buy the OpenAI equity, the result was MSOFT's tax reduction being either close-to or exceeding the actual cash value of MSOFT's investment in OpenAI - IIRC.

These examples represent taxes that the US chooses not to collect - the US could choose to make investments like these less tax-efficient. Instead, by making them extremely tax-efficient, the US subsidises the transaction hugely.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by _aavaa_ on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:59AM (#49978615)
This is a joke right?

Even ignoring monetary subsidies, there are the non-monetary ones: not being sued into oblivious by the government for their countless hacks of other companies and countries, the slaps on the wrist for massive piracy, the waving of environmental (and other) regulations in order to allow their data centres to be built an operated.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by rafram on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:30AM (#49979097)
> Even ignoring monetary subsidies

That's what I'm asking - which monetary subsidies?

> not being sued into oblivious by the government for their countless hacks of other companies and countries

That isn't normally how enforcement works, and it hasn't been very long since they disclosed those breaches. If the victims want to pursue legal action, they can, and they still may!

> the slaps on the wrist for massive piracy

So judges and juries are involved in the subsidization conspiracy, too?

> the waving of environmental (and other) regulations in order to allow their data centres to be built an operated

Sure, though if you think this isn't happening in China too, I have a bridge to sell you.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by dghlsakjg on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:02AM (#49979549)
CHIPS act, OBBA, defense, AI upskill grants.

That's just the ones i know off the top of my head in the US. Those programs account for more than 60 billion in committed spend.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by _aavaa_ on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:56AM (#49979458)
The original comments is "DeepSeek, and other Chinese models, are heavily subsidised by the Chinese government"

> That's what I'm asking - which monetary subsidies?

I am listing for you the non-monetary subsidies, which are just as real and equally important.

> not being sued into oblivious by the government for their countless hacks of other companies and countries

If it was one of the Chinese labs doing this hacking, the government would be stepping in. If it was European labs they'd be stepping in. If it was you or I the government would be stepping in. That is a massive subsidy (they don't have to worry about the same legal fees and exposure) and being allowed to continue doing business is in fact priceless.

> So judges and juries are involved in the subsidization conspiracy, too?

There is no conspiracy. They are objectively operating by a different set of rules than you or I could operate in this market.

> Sure, though if you think this isn't happening in China too, I have a bridge to sell you.

I never said it wasn't, I'm saying that it's happening here and it's a very real subsidy.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by stickfigure on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:59AM (#49980412)
> equally important

They really aren't. Nothing in the development of these systems, absolutely nothing, is as important as money. Stop these silly false equivalences.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by _aavaa_ on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:24PM (#49981517)
These are not silly equivalences.

All the major labs would be dead in the water if the government acted on the things I mentioned. If they treated the labs the way they would have treated us for all those hacks. Or if they enforced pollution measures (or god forbid ban on-prem turbines because of the climate damage). Or rule that training on data is not fair use, or that ingesting GPL3 code and then turning that into weights counts as a derivative work. Or. Or. Or.

Those are all just as important as cash.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by stickfigure on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:57PM (#49981864)
Nah, nothing here is a special advantage of US firms.

The hacks are pretty bland as long as there is no mens rea and the hacked victims do not want to press charges. This isn't a "subsidy", it's just our normal legal process at work.

The pollution question is winding its way through court systems and getting a lot of pushback. I wouldn't call this a subsidy, just a slow bureaucracy. And at any rate this isn't special to the US; certainly China's environmental policy is far more lenient.

With the training data, again there's nothing specific to US corporations here. Anyone can use that dataset. It's just how our legal system works. You might not like it, but it's the accepted law right now. This doesn't meet any reasonable definition of "subsidy".

On the other hand, shoveling billions of dollars of taxpayer funds into corporations is by definition a subsidy. Full stop.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by koe123 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:08AM (#49978743)
Investors, but also the government in allowing these companies to siphon electricity away passing the increased cost to the consumers
Re:Mistral Large 4 by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:23AM (#49978982)
>Investors, but also the government in allowing these companies to siphon electricity away passing the increased cost to the consumers

Not arbitrarily banning companies from buying a product from a supplier doesn't meet my definition of the term "subsidy".

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ta20240528 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:35AM (#49980069)
Fair enough, but it sure meets the definition of 'helpful intervention'.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:56AM (#49980377)
>Fair enough, but it sure meets the definition of 'helpful intervention'.

I don't see how. Anyone can buy electricity without any intervention from the government. An intervention is an action that changes what would happen by default.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by antonyt on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:02AM (#49978669)
By investors. OpenAI and Anthropic are not profitable (Anthropic is profitable if you allow them to invent what profitability means).
Re:Mistral Large 4 by oblio on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:15AM (#49978860)
I heard someone calling the key metric in Anthropic financial reports EBBT: Earnings Before Bad Things[1] :-)

[1] Where "Bad Things" would be the typical interest, taxes, depreciation, amortisation plus the Anthropic specific employee compensation, LLM training (you know, for the LLM lab), revenue sharing agreements (which is a form of paying for infrastructure), etc.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by staticman2 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:28AM (#49979073)
A recent YouTube video by Patrick Boyle said the same thing. They are only profitable if you ignore all the costs that make them unprofitable such as paying employees and developing A models.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ai-x on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:56AM (#49979459)
That's not how gross margin works.

For LLMs, marginal cost is just electricity

Re:Mistral Large 4 by staticman2 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:00PM (#49980431)
I made a statement about whether Anthropic was profitable I don't understand your reply.

Assuming you meant to reply to me and not someone else are you saying under GAAP accounting standards Anthropic is a profitable business because under GAAP accounting their only expense is electricity?

(I see what happened you skimmed the conversation and didn't follow what was being discussed.)

Re:Mistral Large 4 by rhdunn on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:55PM (#49981843)
There's also things like training costs, spend on AI data centres and GPUs, R&D, sales and marketing, etc. See e.g. https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/anthropics-ipo-pros....
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ai-x on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:16PM (#49982084)
Those are not marginal cost or unit economics
Re:Mistral Large 4 by oblio on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:56PM (#49984677)
If the "fixed costs" kill you unit economics won't save you. Scare quotes because true fixed costs generally have a long shelf life. Right now AI models die every 6-9 months.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by oblio on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:54PM (#49984668)
1. And that marginal cost is large, much larger than the marginal cost of serving a Google Search query

2. The marginal cost is electricity until the hardware overflows. So it's continuous for electricity and a step function for hardware capacity.

Plus you don't address the core point. Frontier AI is capital intensive. A lot more capital intensive than regular software. The existing clouds supporting the entire internet (!!!!) were built for a fraction of the cost of AI infrastructure, and there isn't even an end in sight to this continuous hardware investment.

Let alone hardware refresh cycles.

AI is basically investment into roads.

Software used to be a magical place, closer to selling music albums but even better.

AI is a much worse business margin wise than regular software.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by Bud on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:19AM (#49978914)
Investment is not a subsidy. Words still have meanings. Nobody in this thread has successfully answered the question: subsidized by whom?

Non-punishment is also not a subsidy; again, words have meanings. Let's use the correct words.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by rfrey on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:11PM (#49980574)
Indirect subsidies are an accepted economic concept and well studied. The posts you replied to are obviously talking about indirect subsidies and dismissing them because they didn't say "indirect" everywhere is just sophism.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by johnbellone on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:43PM (#49981721)
But some investments are subsidized (tax liabilities) among all the other things.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by tacomagick on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:58AM (#49978608)
The government, specifically Trump's government and the current money circle in AI inflating American company stocks. In addition to all that American models do not share their papers like Deepseek and Qwen do. So you can literally say Chinese models are doing it for charity at this point.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by rafram on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:27AM (#49979049)
Of course you can say that, but you literally cannot be serious if you do!
Re:Mistral Large 4 by tacomagick on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:40AM (#49979243)
Oh I am serious!
Re:Mistral Large 4 by necovek on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:09PM (#49981298)
Can you say a US company donating to a non-profit and writing off taxes on the basis of it is donating to charity?

Would you say you could be serious in stating this?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by rafram on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @03:46PM (#49983119)
Sure, but I couldn't say that a US company writing about some work they did in paper form is charity. At least not seriously! If it were charity, Google might be the most charitable company of all time, since their researchers published "Attention Is All You Need." But it is not.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by necovek on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:23PM (#49983563)
Google has published a lot of open source software and a lot of research papers: I do believe they used to be very charitable even if they are less so today.

They have other issues as well, but among other things, I'd classify them as somewhat charitable too.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by runarberg on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:56AM (#49979468)
Capitalistic exploitation against the working classes.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by deaux on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:25PM (#49980740)
The US regime, which includes the ruling class: the US VCs and megacorps are just as much of an extension of the US regime. They're incredibly intertwined.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by GuB-42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:14PM (#49980629)
Which is the best kind of reason.

It is great for everyone except for a few people who want power over everyone else, and the fact it is not charity of kindness makes it more sustainable, because charity and kindness is quick to go when big money and politics is involved.

I want more warfare like this. Building stuff instead of destroying stuff.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by gabriel666smith on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:11AM (#49978796)
> The reason they release the AI models is economic warfare against US, not because of charity or kindness

There are many other reasons Chinese companies releasing models open-source or open-weight makes strategic sense.

A really easy-to-understand example is a company who has a near-monopoly on "serving video content" releasing a video model openly.

If you can be relatively certain that video content created by a model (which you have trained, using data from your own platform) will be ultimately served on your own platform, thus generating revenue from watch-hours, it makes sense to make those models as widely-available as possible.

It's also a net-positive if people use your public research to build better video models, because - again - you are reasonably certain that the even-better content those new models produce will be watched on your platform.

The alternative would making models harder to access and learn from (broadly, the current western model). Many would argue that Google, in choosing to not optimise its video generation models for "availability", is directly causing less content to be uploaded to YouTube. This is the trade-off.

I don't know much about DeepSeek's financing specifically, which obviously doesn't release video models - so I don't know how directly this analogy runs, or who directly benefits from the extremely evident rising tide that the public release of DeepSeek's research creates. However, this does not negate the broader rising-tide effect of the scientific method.

It's certainly also true that it's geopolitically beneficial to be able to undercut American labs' models. If I ran a global superpower, I would probably want my country to be technologically competitive too.

But Chinese companies are already serving a huge volume of customers in a complex, existing marketplace, before even thinking about the US market, and it's overly simplistic to assume that their entire strategy revolves around economic warfare directed specifically at the US. It's more nuanced than that.

This is, of course, without even getting into opening the can-of-worms around whether US economic policy also results in the US state functionally subsidising technological innovation, how comparable that is to China's model, etc.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by _puk on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:47PM (#49981007)
Interestingly if Google did release readily available video models then they'd likely be dealing with an order of magnitude of scale in the same way GitHub has had to.

Causing less content to be uploaded, when you are clearly the gorilla in the room, looks to be a wise strategy not a trade off.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by gabriel666smith on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @05:54AM (#49990495)
I'm not sure I follow - do you mean an order of magnitude of compute demand?

Releasing models openly doesn't mean providing the compute. It's beneficial for relatively GPU-poor Chinese orgs to let users run models themselves - by releasing the models openly - as it means the orgs don't have to provide the compute to run their own models.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:45AM (#49978402)
> DeepSeek, and other Chinese models, are heavily subsidised by the Chinese government.

DeepSeek is basically a research lab founded by a hedge fund guy, more than anything else.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by shmel on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:38AM (#49979218)
I'm not sure "subsidised" is the right word. If a government funds research and the results are released openly, that's just publicly funded research. It's how a lot of science works in the US and Europe too.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by sajithdilshan on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:23AM (#49979906)
Same goes for the US companies as well. Current US administration wants US to win the AI race at any cost and China is the only competitor left in the race. Winners always write the history or in this case the future of humanity
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Shitty-kitty on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:03AM (#49979574)
The open-weight models are a great boon to all American companies other than a handfull of Mega Corps in the A.I business. Care to explain how this is "economic warfare against the U.S"
Re:Mistral Large 4 by 1234letshaveatw on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:19AM (#49979840)
Do you not see the risk inherit in sourcing everything from a antagonist?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by brabel on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:23PM (#49980720)
Yes we see that in all other countries trying to avoid dependence on the US for everything. What we don’t see is competition with other countries having anything to do with warfare.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by matsemann on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:50PM (#49981043)
Yes, hence why I'm happy there's competition so we're not stuck with US tech. After all, you've proven to be very unreliable allies to us.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by 1234letshaveatw on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:18PM (#49994925)
and you've proven to be parasitic and free riding allies in return
Re:Mistral Large 4 by oefrha on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:59AM (#49980419)
So you’re telling me warfare doesn’t having to be blowing up schools and children, skyrocketing prices, crippling sanctions, and all that shit? Can I sign up for more of this warfare.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by LPisGood on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:06PM (#49980520)
Claude, and other American models, are heavily subsidized by investors (and the United States government).
Re:Mistral Large 4 by lbreakjai on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:35AM (#49979168)
And OpenAI and Anthropic are just in for the love of the game? Our of sheer desire to help humanity?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by 1234letshaveatw on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:22AM (#49979882)
Obviously not but they employ American researchers and aren't beholden to the CCP
Re:Mistral Large 4 by kaffekaka on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:55AM (#49978553)
Well, US models are economic warfare too, of course.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by horacemorace on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:37AM (#49980094)
It just so happens that helping open source is the result. Image how far behind we’d (the hackers, not the moneymen) be as a sharing community be without them.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by jetdeng on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:31AM (#49980018)
At least DeepSeek didn't build its models on government subsidies. It came out of a quantitative hedge fund, so funding was never really an issue for them.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by subarctic on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:00AM (#49979524)
Economic warfare against the US? I mean maybe against specific US companies and stakeholders but on the whole it seems like it's good for the US economy as well as the rest of the world, kind of like supplying free electricity would be
Re:Mistral Large 4 by infecto on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:53AM (#49978521)
Not sure why so many people will vehemently refuse this idea. I won’t say it’s 100% true but it would be foolish to dismiss it. China is very much an adversary to America and has made it pretty clear they want to be a dominant leader of not the new world leader. Not here to evaluate what is good or bad. Keep in mind historically China has aggressively fostered industry (not unlike the west) but sometimes even more aggressively.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by lifeisloving on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:25AM (#49979015)
Americans need to travel to China. The Chinese have zero issues with us. They quite like Americans. This is such a weird propagandist take. Idk if you remember but both country's leaders just had a slumber party for 3 days in DC. This is not what enemies do.

Not even our leaders say China is an enemy, ita mostly businessmen who are scared of competition and trying to regulate chinese out of their markets so they can make more money milking us.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by infecto on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:54AM (#49979438)
I have been to China many times. The citizens and visiting the country has nothing to do with global politics. Your take is just as propagandist as any other. China is not unlike the US and China has also made it subtly clear their desire to be a dominant global force. I am not marking judgement on it but don’t be a fool thinking that China is not some level of threat. This is how these discussions become weird. I don’t think China is going to blow up the US and I think it’s often a weird talking point by some US politicians but I also don’t think they are a peaceful actor but folks like you will suggest I am repeating propaganda. No, just pointing out that if you look at their language and actions they are an actor to pay attention to. Just because leaders meet means nothing.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by lifeisloving on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:14AM (#49979759)
Sounds like some Falun Gong conspiracy. Im not worried about China.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by fearmerchant on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:56AM (#49979464)
The same is true of the Iranian people. There's sometimes a difference between the government and their own citizens.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by tsunamifury on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:59AM (#49978616)
Your just saying it’s beating america at its own game and crying fowl.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by infecto on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:40PM (#49983781)
When did I cry fowl? I am simply saying that the truth is probably somewhere in the middle.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by fluidcruft on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:44AM (#49979298)
That would have been a scathing criticism if anyone believed any of the American companies have the goal of helping humanity or open-source.

Notwithstanding that Chinese publishing methods actually does help both humanity and open-source.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by sourdecor on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:39AM (#49979224)
If your belief is accurate, we should expect China to short the IPOs of Anthropic and OpenAI and release better frontier models immediately after their IPOs.

Does anyone think that likely? I have no clue or bias.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by pianopatrick on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:06AM (#49979625)
I don't think that's likely because my understanding is that Chinese people in mainland China have a tricky time shorting American stocks due to Chinese capital controls.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by benterix on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:45AM (#49979314)
It's one of these rare cases where intention is not what is the most important - the net benefit for consumers and companies outside of the USA is indisputable.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by mcv on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:45AM (#49979307)
Whatever their reason, I'm glad they do it. This tech shouldn't be monopolised by a handful of closed, profit-seeking corporations.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by 1234letshaveatw on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:23AM (#49979907)
And likewise, it shouldn't be monopolized by the CCP
Re:Mistral Large 4 by brabel on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:29PM (#49980789)
What do you think your comment is refuting!!? Chinese are publishing their research publicly and opening their models! How on Earth would they monopolize anything?? Such nonsense. If and when they start copying the Americans and closing everything down, you can say stuff like that. Until then, ffs stop this nonsense.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by 1234letshaveatw on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:16PM (#49994887)
Please look up predatory pricing. The only nonsense is assuming that publishing their research publicly and opening their models is altruistic
Re:Mistral Large 4 by brabel on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @03:53PM (#49997975)
It doesn't matter if they are doing it out of altruism, the result benefits everyone anyway. It feels silly to have to explain this kind of thing. Are you trolling?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by 1234letshaveatw on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @01:55PM (#50075850)
trolling? you have a habit of making inaccurate assumptions
Re:Mistral Large 4 by MomsAVoxell on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:19AM (#49979835)
How do you know? You’re not speaking for the Chinese government, are you?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by locknitpicker on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:07PM (#49980534)
> DeepSeek, and other Chinese models, are heavily subsidised by the Chinese government.

US companies are burning colossal piles of cash in ways that makes it unclear if it qualifies as dumping, not to mention their deep ties with the country's regime.

Claiming that companies from a country have ties to the regime and burn through cash is a very miopic accusation.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by spyckie2 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:53AM (#49979407)
To be completely fair, write this kind of paragraph for every AI category. Would love to see your take.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Buttons840 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:48AM (#49979345)
If the means of achieving their goal are sometimes mistaken for charity and kindness... are they the good guys?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by waterheater on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:24AM (#49978995)
Precisely. It's similar to their practice of aluminum dumping to depress US aluminum prices, which causes our aluminum mines and mills to close.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by yomismoaqui on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:32AM (#49979126)
I like when bad intentions produce good results, I'm tired of seeing the opposite in practice.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by sicktriple on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:23AM (#49978976)
Economic warfare against the US is charity and kindness to a sizable portion of the world's population, especially when the US uses it's global hegemony as warfare against them. Neither system is perfect, but lets not be disingenuous.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by broabprobe on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:37AM (#49979195)
At some point though _the purpose of a system is what it does_, regardless of their intent.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by vagrantJin on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:39AM (#49979233)
> DeepSeek, and other Chinese models, are heavily subsidised by the Chinese government.

Yes, because everything China does is against the US. That's all they think about day and night. God forbid they want to corner the global market or have a genuine business case. How dare they provide options for those who can't afford a measly $200 a month? How can we let Chinese labs publish research for free for the whole world so that they can benefit? The nerve! To think they can use soft power instead of military might! I mean, Anthropic and OpenAI are the last bastions of human kindness and charity. Right?

Right?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by joquarky on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @03:11PM (#49982698)
Poe's Law applies here.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by scotty79 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:32AM (#49980024)
I wish US was rich enough to subsidise development of open source science and useful open AI models. I wouldn't mind US waging this kind of wconomic warefare against China or everyone else on the world.

Charity and kindness is not a motivation, it's an outcome of what you do.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by reacharavindh on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:01AM (#49978648)
I’m neither in the camp of Chinese or the Americans(collective West) in general..

As a neutral party, this characterization is crazy.

As if the AI companies - Claude and OpenAI are guardians of freedom and humanity and very charitable to the global society without any self interests… “Chinese models are subsidized by the Chinese Government, therefore they’re inherently bad for humanity” is a highly propagandist argument. The politics of US vs China may be whatever it is in reality.. You have one company releasing their models for cheap, actually open sourcing their trained weights, and publishing details of their optimizations and learnings for others to use. The other camp actively “aligning” their models, nerfing their capabilities, hyping their swarm activities from poor sandboxes, and trying their best to lock users into their harnesses and walled platforms. They are subsidized by the capitalist VCs who are essentially waiting for their payouts..

At some point, one has to see things for what they are and evaluate their own reasoning..

I’m happy to stay provider agnostic, try all models and cheer any useful progress as open as possible.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by SecretDreams on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:35AM (#49979170)
Meanwhile, American AI models are heavily subsidized by stock market speculation. Ultimately, the subsidies from both countries are flowing out of the pockets of individuals.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by fearmerchant on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:57AM (#49979478)
That's an interesting definition of subsidized. I don't thing I've ever heard it used like that before.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by SecretDreams on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @08:16AM (#49991701)
Ha! 10-15 years ago, I wouldn't have used it that way either. But the stock markets these days just feel entirely speculative. It is not clear to me if individuals are buying these AI stocks based on their expected future revenue/profit or the whole space is just momentum plays and the funds are directly being transferred back to the companies to keep the train moving, despite there being no clear profitable destination for any of the LLM sellers. The hardware folks are making out like bandits, though.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by NicoJuicy on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:35AM (#49979163)
US is basically doing economic warfare and bullying against everyone else ATM :)
Re:Mistral Large 4 by vrganj on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:14AM (#49978841)
What if economic warfare against the US does help humanity?

Why are we assuming a strong US is necessarily good? As a European, I have seen plenty of evidence against that stance lately.

I understand that Americans might prefer a strong US. But conflating them with humanity is a leap that I don't think one can make without any backing.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by fearmerchant on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:51AM (#49979381)
What evidence is that? Please share.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by sixothree on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:56AM (#49978578)
> are heavily subsidised by the Chinese government

We hear this about literally every industry the Chinese excel in - that it's only because the government subsidizes them that they succeed. For chip manufacturing, for batteries, for EVs, for solar, for AI. I don't see how the chinese government can afford to subsidize all of these industries and still have them contribute to the GDP.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ozgung on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:10AM (#49979679)
What's wrong with governments subsidizing scientific work?

You think extremely US-centric. China has a different economic model than US and your rules for a specific kind of Capitalism may not apply to them. You assume a country of 1.4 Billion people is obsessed with a couple of foreign AI companies. What if they don't care.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by bparsons on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:06AM (#49978723)
A conspiracy to make the US look bad by being better at producing all the goods and services the world needs at a reasonable price. Have they no shame?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by IOT_Apprentice on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:05AM (#49979603)
Why the anti China propaganda from you? The United States is doing the same thing here and making American multi-billionaires even wealthier. The greed of American AI, GPU and memory and storage corporations is a black hole on availability to humans around the World. The result is a massive financial bubble promoted by the American Government to the detriment of our citizens. The USA has an AI ponzy scheme shuffling the same money between data center owners (Oracle & X), Nvidia and memory & storage vendors.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by lifeisloving on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:52AM (#49978513)
Not really this is an X algo conspiracy. Up until recently the Chinese government wasn't even that invested in these companies. We're talking very very small grants compared to training costs.

Its very xenophobic of you to say China has zero intention of helping humanity, and just wants to "wage economic warfare".

Last time I checked, it was ourselves (USA) waging economic warfare on 2/3rds of the world.

I dont get this cope people have where people have this idea that its impossible for a Chinese company (that make billions of dollars) to have done something by their own merit, but instead its always some Chinese Communist Party conspiracy where the main goal is to destroy America.

Lay off twitter for a bit.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by drstewart on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:06AM (#49978721)
>Up until recently the Chinese government wasn't even that invested in these companies

>Last time I checked, it was ourselves (USA) waging economic warefare on 2/3rds of the world.

Up until recently the USA Wasn't waging economic "warefare" on 2/3rds of the world

Re:Mistral Large 4 by lifeisloving on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:14AM (#49978844)
The USA has been using financial sanctions, aka, financial warfare on anyone it's deemed an enemy for going on 4 decades.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by drstewart on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:16AM (#49978864)
China has been owning and controlling key companies in its industry for going on 6 decades.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by lifeisloving on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:18AM (#49978903)
Every country does this. Do you think the US government doesnt fund, regulate and control key companies?

China is not a threat to you, or anyone in the West.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by anon-3988 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:31PM (#49980801)
They are also releasing the weights so I am more inclined to think they are better than most.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by deaux on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:33PM (#49980824)
> DeepSeek, and other Chinese models, are heavily subsidised by the Chinese government.

So were Amazon and Uber by the US, which have now established monopolies across the globe. To the countries suffering from those, there's zero difference with China doing it to solar. Actually there is, at least solar got them cheap renewable energy in return. This would never have happened in the US because big oil interests would make it take decades. That's the reality.

You need to spend 10 years outside the US, deprogram, and then go back.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by nutjob2 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:44PM (#49980983)
> but the goal is not to help humanity or open-source

Ok, but so what? That's what happening so far. Even a repressive totalitarian government I wouldn't wish on my worst enemy does some good sometimes.

If the Chinese cheap/open models rise up and destroy us, thats on us for giving them access to the tools to do so.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by vintermann on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:57PM (#49981148)
What about cheap solar panels and electric cars, is that economic warfare too?

To say that US model providers have a close relationship with their government would be putting it mildly.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by shinyshadowdonu on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @03:22PM (#49982833)
> The reason they release the AI models is economic warfare against US, not because of charity or kindness. It's great for us consumers, but the goal is not to help humanity or open-source.

You put it like US has a goal of help humanity or open-source

Re:Mistral Large 4 by swalsh on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:27AM (#49979047)
They're trying to pull digitally what they already pulled physically. The reason we can't manufacture a grill brush for a reasonable price is the result of years of Americans choosing the cheapest price. We gave up our manufacture base. They want us to give up our labs.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by toenail on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:33AM (#49979143)
Deindustrializing a country is not something consumers can achieve. It starts at the top level, with politicians who construct a financial system where it's more profitable to speculate than to build or invest in real businesses.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by stanac on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:33AM (#49979138)
Except they are open with the tech which is easy to replicate. All new models lowering cache prices is the result of DeepSeek's publications.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by wg0 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:48AM (#49979354)
US economy is driven on quarter to quarter short-sightedness of stock gamblers and CEOs that have to secure their bonuses and perks.

Its them who chose to outsource heavily, not US consumers.

There are no victims here however, both benefited from the arrangement. The consumers and capitalists.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by deaux on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:29PM (#49980777)
> The reason we can't manufacture a grill brush for a reasonable price is the result of years of Americans choosing the cheapest price.

No, it's the result of US leadership letting this happen. This is clear since China themselves would not let this happen. US leadership did nothing because they were best friends with the people who did it, and did not care one bit about their population.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by typ on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:17AM (#49978882)
Architectural/algorithmic tweaks do advance the efficiency frontier nicely. But raw intelligence mostly comes from data (not just its sheer quantity, but also how it's curated & cleansed) and the scaling law. The know-how about data curation doesn't seem to get published much, even among the open-weight labs, though.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by porridgeraisin on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:35AM (#49979171)
This. Even in the efficiency frontier, it is a lot of data curation that actually makes many of those tweaks actually work at scale in practice.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by jamienk on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:20AM (#49979851)
I'm not sure I like this framing - so much of AI research has been academic, in the open, building on others people's work. Much less comp sci generally, math & philosophy, etc. The idea that rich companies can just build stuff in secret because they have resources is a fantasy.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by bushbaba on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:35AM (#49980066)
How it should be. Knowledge should not be copyrighted. The world will be a better place with such information democratized
Re:Mistral Large 4 by dvduval on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:15AM (#49978855)
So boring to see conversations moved over to Chinese models when that’s not even what we’re talking about here. This is about Mistral.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by swingandamiss on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:47AM (#49979329)
Europeans are irrelevant these days, surpassed by China, S Korea, Japan, Hong Kong, Singapore, etc. Europe is coasting on former glory and now has regulated itself to death and vacationed its advantages away.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by kirill5pol on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:23AM (#49979910)
Evidently not given that this model is on the open source frontier.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by swingandamiss on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:30AM (#49979998)
cost is higher than Chinese models that are better
Re:Mistral Large 4 by fittom on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:40AM (#49979246)
Also, the field moves fast, but slower than people do. Researchers and engineers switch companies every year or two, and the know-how walks out the door with them.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by xnx on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:06AM (#49978728)
There would be a lot of competition even without DeepSeek. Workers can freely exfiltrate trade secrets without noncompetes in California.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by apexalpha on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:08AM (#49978745)
Proprietary competition, yes.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by tokai on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:48AM (#49978447)
>instruction manuals in paper form

So the most common way to publish manuals?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by jorl17 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:49AM (#49978461)
In research paper form.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ZiiS on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:51AM (#49978483)
I think the mean 'paper' in the scientific journal meaning; these are unfortunately often extremely bad 'instruction manuals'.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by velcrovan on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:00AM (#49978635)
Maybe 30 years ago
Re:Mistral Large 4 by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:22PM (#49980699)
Am I reading this correctly?

This appears to be roughly as good as Sol 6.1 (which is quite good), considerably faster in terms of wall clock for complete tasks, and considerably cheaper (where Sol 6.1 is already good value - just really slow).

That seems too good to be true...

But I really hope it is true...

Re:Mistral Large 4 by nonadhocproblem on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:17PM (#49981406)
I can confirm that you're reading this incorrectly. There's a reason behind them only comparing it to open-source models released months ago. Here's a good aggregator: https://artificialanalysis.ai/#intelligence
Re:Mistral Large 4 by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:14PM (#49984247)
Okay, so instead it's just another slower more expensive DeepSeek v4.1 Flash.

That seems much more realistic.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by amelius on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:26AM (#49979038)
> have not been a winner-take-all runaway acceleration game where catchup is impossible

From the Mistral site:

> ML4 was trained from scratch on 3,800 NVIDIA Grace Blackwell GPUs in Mistral’s own datacenters in Europe.

It is pretty capital intensive!

Re:Mistral Large 4 by eigenspace on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:27AM (#49979965)
That cluster is literally orders of magnitude smaller than the compute pools used by Anthropic or OpenAI.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by amelius on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:39PM (#49980919)
For training or for inference?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ricardobeat on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:21PM (#49981476)
They don't publish numbers, but Anthropic has a single DC with 200k+ GPUs for inference, GPT-6 Astra is said to have trained on 100k+ GPUs.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by anvuong on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:03PM (#49981932)
Both, especially for training. Astra and Fable were presumably trained on cluster of 100,000k GPUs, or at least a couple of 10Ks.

3,800 GPUs is nothing in the frontier side.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by dannyw on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:17PM (#49980647)
That’s kinda very small and light for modern trillion-param LLMs.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by bjenkins358 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:45AM (#49979310)
I’m pretty impressed that they managed to get that close to the frontier with such a small cluster!
Re:Mistral Large 4 by locknitpicker on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:34PM (#49980838)
> I’m pretty impressed that they managed to get that close to the frontier with such a small cluster

Chinese companies also managed to put together their models with relatively small clusters.

Perhaps US companies are desperately trying to brute force their way into workable models?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by jayd16 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:46AM (#49980236)
These cards are like $3k each? That's, what, $12M and you keep the hardware? Honestly doesn't seem too bad.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by amelius on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:01PM (#49980458)
More like $30k each.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by jayd16 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:14PM (#49980623)
Oh the server chip is 10x. That makes a lot more sense.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by everfrustrated on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:43AM (#49979275)
According to Grok thats 7-10 MW. Tiny numbers.

To put that into context, the last wave of capacity SpaceXAI added 400-450 MW.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by amelius on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:03AM (#49979565)
But how much of that are they using for training versus inference? They're serving quite a large user base.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by nickpinkston on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:17PM (#49980648)
Hear! Hear! I really want European models / AI labs to succeed.

I trust them and their populations to provide a more societal-friendly version of AI, putting pressure on the US tech oligarchy, while also providing democracy-friendly open models that I don't trust to happen with the Chinese labs.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by AIblemblio on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:36AM (#49978259)
For sure people who don't grasp the difference between models, might be stuck in 'good enough' models.

But Opus 5.5/GPT is such a game changer in comparison to sooo many others, its still a moat for now.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by SyneRyder on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:51AM (#49978488)
You've got to think the comments about "good enough" are people who have not yet tried Opus 5.5. I haven't been this struck by a step change since 4.5/4.6. It's a bigger jump even than when Fable first arrived.

As for Mistral - I got really excited when they said Large 4 was focusing on being #1 in cybersecurity, because that's somewhere that they genuinely could edge out Anthropic & OpenAI. Have it actually solve problems, instead of Anthropic flagging "you tried to find a null pointer exception bug in your own code, we're now reporting you to the US government". But on the Mistral benchmarks I'm seeing, this looks very disappointing, but at least they haven't entirely given up. I genuinely thought Mistral had given up on new general models. They need to learn the bitter lesson all over again.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by Systemerror7A69 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:03AM (#49978676)
I feel like the "good enough" argument isn't about how big the gap between models is but about how good they are at solving the tasks at hand.

The capabilities of all models increasing so much all the time means there are simply less and less tasks you need a frontier model for.

Even if Opus 5.5 is 500x better than Deepseek, if deepseek can solve all my problems, why do I need to pay for more?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by user43928 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:25AM (#49979025)
Many on HN still have the opinion that you must understand every line of code in the project, and that all is lost should you merge code that wasn't reviewed.

Obviously any model will do if you use it as a better autocomplete.

I believe that there is a large gap in expectations between different workflows.

Until the AI like reads my mind and produces perfectly production ready apps with minimal intervention from my side, there is still going to be room for improvement.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by RealityVoid on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:01PM (#49984094)
> Many on HN still have the opinion that you must understand every line of code in the project, and that all is lost should you merge code that wasn't reviewed.

Uhm, yes?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by kragen on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @07:48PM (#49985843)
Last week I elicited a parametric 3-D design model of a sand battery, a simplified thermal circuit model of it for rough exploration, a backward Euler multiphysics solver to evaluate its performance more accurately, and a volumetric visualization for the resulting temperature distributions, including some custom WebGL shaders: http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/sandbattery/

It's about 12000 lines of code. I could probably understand every line of it if I spent a couple of months on it, although I'd need to learn some things about WebGL, numerical computation, and solid-state physics. But I elicited it in four days. Probably I'd be better off spending the next couple of months doing something else instead.

So, I was faced with the question of how I could keep the artifact thus created from being completely valueless. My solution was to export the heat-equation solution produced by the solver as (gzipped!) CSV, so that I can use my own code (that I do understand every line of!) to check that the solutions found by the solver are, in fact, solutions.

If that check checks out, the backward Euler solver may be of some value even if I don't understand every line of it.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by pimeys on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @06:56PM (#49985347)
How I feel it Opus 5.5 and Astra 6 are both quite disappointing. They still write shit Rust. And they are very slow.

Now my provider serves DeepSeek around 300 tokens a second. The code is shit but I can have a few more rounds of corrections.

DeepSeek was maybe a dollar for the full PR. Opus/Astra over 50 dollars. And double that if you use their fast variants which matches the DeepSeek speeds on certain providers.

Yes, it is so good I rarely test new models anymore. Or think about cost.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ashdksnndck on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:56PM (#49987957)
The Rust I’m getting from Opus 5.5 works great. What’s the complaint?

Actually I felt since 4.5, it was “good enough” for basic coding (and competing models have reached that level as well). The big improvements since then have been longer-horizon tasks. Giving it a vague description of a problem, then come back hours later and find it did a better job than I would have. And since 5.5 I haven’t encountered any more load bearing seams.

Maybe it’s slow, but I’m not interacting with the models in a live chat anymore for most work. I’m giving them tasks to do async. The limiting factor is actually my bandwidth reviewing their output.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by pimeys on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @03:08AM (#49989357)
> You're absolutely right, I should not use a global mutex.

I am eyeing a huge codebase built with Opus. Did multiple passes of refactoring for things like using traits not just free functions. And using the Rust types like PathBuf from the damn standard library not just strings everywhere.

Oh and it is so hard to use a crate. Let's just vibe an inferior version and push another 5k line PR. Nobody reads them anyway right? Logos schlogos, a lexer is easy to write, right?

Maybe I am just getting old, but I remember a time when we were proud on the code we wrote. Now I read some of the old stuff and get a bit sad for what we lost.

Don't get me wrong DeepSeek also does this. But if the model is 100x more expensive I expect better. Of course if you never read the code it's ok. But it does the same mistakes and cannot design great architecture...

Re:Mistral Large 4 by ashdksnndck on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @02:11PM (#49996599)
Hmm, I wonder if the difference is that I’m working on an existing large codebase that wasn’t originally written with AI. It might be picking up practices from the surrounding code. It’s happily using the same crates that are already there, and occasionally bringing in new ones. Some of the code is “weird” but I also learn from it.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by kragen on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:53AM (#49979417)
If Opus 5.5 is 500x better than Deepseek, but Deepseek can solve all your problems, maybe you need to work on better problems. If you don't, and you're in business, your competitors will work on the better problems. If you're an employee, your employer might prefer to pay Anthropic instead of you. If you're doing projects you're interested in, you can tackle more ambitious projects with a more capable model.

This morning I elicited a microkernel operating system from Opus 5.5. Well, mostly. It doesn't implement task switching yet; we'll see if it runs into a wall at some point. But it boots in QEMU, and it's running a user process in ring 3 and serving web pages.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by sashank_1509 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:12AM (#49979723)
Yeah no, if you elicit Opus 5.5 , anyone else can, and you have no moat either.

But if on the other hand, I mostly use my human intelligence and just need a dumb model to complement my human intelligence at low cost and high speed (say review every commit to catch obvious bugs), I have a much better chance of building an actual moat than you do.

But outside of coding, it’s even more clear that you don’t need frontier intelligence. My customer service agent is very happy with a 100B param Deepseek flash model, thank you!

Re:Mistral Large 4 by TuxSH on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:49PM (#49981036)
> say review every commit to catch obvious bugs

I’m using subscription models for exactly that, better models catch more subtle bugs, and they catch them faster. It works out far better in terms of work-hours saved.

Also A/ then OAI slashed token pricing by 2x~5x on their latest models

Re:Mistral Large 4 by kragen on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @06:38PM (#49985150)
Yes, obviously a microkernel operating system that you can vibecode in a morning is not a salable product. But it's still a perfectly good operating system, and sometimes people need those, and they're a huge pain in the ass to write, especially to debug. But sometimes off-the-shelf OSes aren't good enough. Something like 50% of the embedded operating system market is still "Other/Custom".
Re:Mistral Large 4 by fultonn on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:51PM (#49981056)
> maybe you need to work on better problems

I have enough real problems in life. I don't need to invent new ones just because a new technology is available.

Many of my problems in life are fully solved far past my satiation point by a 3b model that costs me nothing to run.

Many others are not.

But in either case, when I am acting and living wisely, almost all of my problems exist prior to the existence of technological solutions to those problems.

This is also true for the customers and employers that I care to work with. This has changed in me over time, but I now try my best to avoid inventing new problems. The world has enough big, important problems already.

> This morning I elicited a microkernel operating system from Opus 5.5.

This is cool but also a good example. I don't need a personalized microkernel just because it's possible to have one.

Maybe I need one and I don't know it, but the problem statement definitely isn't "I have inherent desire for a personalized microkernel".

Re:Mistral Large 4 by kragen on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @06:36PM (#49985138)
You've misunderstood what I was talking about; that's a different meaning of the word "problem". Possibly you did not intend to start a merely semantic argument, but that's what you ended up doing, so I am unfortunately going to have to point at the dictionary.

You're talking about definition 1 in https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/problem, "A difficulty that has to be resolved or dealt with," with the examples given being racism, addictions, and lack of access to health care. Those aren't the kind of problems AI can help with.

The kind of "problem" that AI can help with is definition 2, "A question to be answered, schoolwork exercise." That is the character of engineering "problems", although they are more open-ended than schoolwork exercises, because there are many defensible tradeoffs. "How can I build a bridge here?" or "How can I improve the fuel efficiency of this vehicle?" is a "problem" in the sense of a question to be answered with knowledge and effort, not in the sense of being similar to racism or addiction.

If the questions you're thinking of are so easy to answer that they can be easily answered by a hypothetical AI model 1/500th as good as Opus 5.5 — well, think up some harder questions.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by fultonn on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @10:09AM (#49993109)
Thanks for clarfying.

> well, think up some harder questions.

There's nothing wrong with this mindset, but your insistence that other people must have your values is off-putting.

To wit: at the end of my phd I was offered several tenure-track positions where "work on problems that are hard" would've been a big part of my job.

I turned those offers down due to my distaste with "because it's hard" as a justification for working on problems.

I'm much more interested in helping people and solving (def'n 1) problems. Those problems are almost always too large and messy to one-shot, but very often contain many components that can be solved with non-sota models, and make sense to solve with non-sota models for any number of economic/scaling reasons. E.g.: "can I serve this thing that costs $0.25 per run on even c.2024 sota models to 100,000 K12 students who will use it dozens of times a day on a non-profit's budget of ~$0.00."

P.S. The "problem" definition thing is very confusing to your readers because the person you responded to was clearly using the first definition! It would have been helpful for you to sign-post that you are using the same word as the person you are replying to but changing the meaning out from under your reader.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by kragen on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @08:10PM (#50000461)
The person I responded to said:

I feel like the "good enough" argument isn't about how big the gap between models is but about how good they are at solving the tasks at hand.

The capabilities of all models increasing so much all the time means there are simply less and less tasks you need a frontier model for.

Even if Opus 5.5 is 500x better than Deepseek, if deepseek can solve all my problems, why do I need to pay for more?

They are clearly talking about "problems" that DeepSeek can solve, and they seem to be using the term "task" as a synonym for "problem", even using the problem verb "solve" with "tasks" as its object. To me, that makes it clear that they are not talking about problem₁s such as racism, addiction, and lack of access to health insurance; while you could imagine "solving" such problems, they are not tasks, and DeepSeek certainly cannot solve them. Rather, I think they are talking about "engineering problems", which are examples of problem₂, more analogous to math questions (to be diligently sought out) than to troubles (to be avoided).

It is certainly the case that the proposition that such problems should be diligently sought out is a value judgment, and therefore it derives from the value system employed by me, the writer. Would you prefer that I refrain from making normative statements in general, or just those with which you might disagree? In either case, is your preference specific to me personally, or do you consider it a duty incumbent upon everyone?

— ⁂ —

The 01913 edition of Webster's dictionary offers:

1. A question proposed for solution; a matter stated for examination or proof; hence, a matter difficult of solution or settlement; a doubtful case; a question involving doubt. --Bacon.

2. (Math.) Anything which is required to be done; as, in geometry, to bisect a line, to draw a perpendicular; or, in algebra, to find an unknown quantity.

Note: Problem differs from theorem in this, that a problem is something to be done, as to bisect a triangle, to describe a circle, etc.; a theorem is something to be proved, as that all the angles of a triangle are equal to two right angles.

The absence of the "trouble" definition suggests that perhaps it is derived from the "question" definition, and, surprisingly, very recently.

You gotta problem wit that?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by fultonn on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:55AM (#50057327)
That might be how that word was used in 1913, I don't know. It is not 1913.

Returning to the substantive matter, I'm happy to try to re-state the topic at hand using your preferred symbols.

Suppose:

1. Someone has a type of task to be done.

2. Finding a systematic way to complete that type of task has immediate value.

3. That type of task can be solved at lower per-unit cost without paying for tokens from the latest Anthropic or OpenAI model release.

Then why would you tell that person that they need to "think of better problems"? They have a task to be done, and they can do that task. Assuming the task has sufficient value to justify the time invested in crafting a solution, I'm not sure I see the need for "better" problems.

There is nothing wrong with being the type of consumer that adopts a product early and then works on things to which that product is congruent.

But there is also nothing wrong with using a plain old nail gun to drive a plain old nail into two pieces of plain old wood that someone with money needs fastened together.

Stick framing may be a "solved" "problem". The task of building individual houses remains at hand. The carpenters framing those houses do not need "better problems" to "solve". They would probably benefit from lower per-unit cost of nails or lumber, though.

I hope this makes the meaning of my position clear.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by breuleux on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:40PM (#49981694)
The best problems to work on are not necessarily the hardest ones, nor the ones that need the most intelligence. They're the problems you, or other people, actually have. Are you going to give up on painting your deck because it's too easy and you don't need a 500x genius to do it?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by eigenspace on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:16AM (#49978866)
I use Opus 5.5 daily for my job. I am aware (and in awe of) it's capabilities.

Look at the context in which I used that term 'good enough'.

What i was saying is that there are tasks for which a dumber model can be good enough, and for organizations with sovereignty/ privacy concerns, those concerns can be strong enough to incentivize the use of a dumber model.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by skerit on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:06AM (#49978729)
> I haven't been this struck by a step change since 4.5/4.6. It's a bigger jump even than when Fable first arrived.

I had the exact same experience. And unlike Fable, it doesn't gobble up your entire usage limit in a few hours.

I always wonder what the "good enough" people are actually using it for.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by sashank_1509 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:16AM (#49979787)
“Good enough” as in we don’t see any point in 1-shotting everything we want to build in lightning speed. If Opus 5.5 can 1 shot it then that product is essentially commodified, no point in any one building it except as an internal tool.

If Opus can’t 1-shot it, then it must rely on our human intelligence which can be complemented well enough with a dumb model as a frontier model.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by nonadhocproblem on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:20PM (#49981451)
I assume that you'd also argue in favour of working in a team with an average IQ of 80 as opposed to 120.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by blahblaher on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:42PM (#49981710)
The thing is, for how long? Are they going to keep giving you "so much intelligence" for a "small" subscription dollar amount? When they really, for real, need to start making money to cover their costs, what do you think it's going to happen? Suddenly you will start having tasks that a "good enough" model is going to be fine.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by user43928 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:18PM (#49983503)
These comments were also around for the Opus 4.5 release.

Prices for the same task (ARC-AGI-2) have since dropped by factor 10 if you compare to Opus 5.5 Low.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by wg0 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:41AM (#49978347)
No it is not. Only maybe for the noobs or vibe coders.

People who aren't afraid of rolling their sleeves into any code base? The difference is practically zero.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by AIblemblio on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:09AM (#49979663)
Try a bigger code base or more complex stuff and you will easily see that the solution, speed and amount of problems Opus5.5 solves vs older models is relevant.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Slartie on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:16AM (#49979781)
I am frequently running agents on a multi-microservice application workspace where I really need the 1M context windows, because they are filled to the brim when implementing features that require changes on several services and APIs.

This works fine with Opus 5.5. But it also works fine with GPT 6.1 Sol, Kimi K3 and MiMo 2.6 Pro.

It doesn't work equally well with Sonnet 5.5, interestingly.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by CharlieDigital on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:53AM (#49978534)
I agree; yes, I can see that they need a bit less hand holding each cycle, but I also see these "frontier" agents do some absolutely dumb shit that I have to correct and then I'm wondering if I'm the looney one here.

Maybe it's because people stopped watching what their agents are doing and stopped looking at the quality of the output. But I still see agents being absolutely mindless like a junior dev.

Recent example: it updated an an API to add newly released models to the backend. There's a list of models that require specific configuration for the reasoning effort and temperature or the API call fails. GPT 6.1 Sol misses this and code fails at runtime because the newer models need to be added to the list for special handling of temp and reasoning. Fixes it for one model and tests it for that model using an E2E test. But doesn't test the other models that were added for the same error condition...I had to explicitly ask it to do so and it finds them and adds them to the list and says "that's on me."

Yeah, not that smart.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by marmarama on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:41PM (#49980937)
You're not looney at all. Frontier models do dumb things all the time, especially on mature codebases. Just yesterday Opus 5.5 butchered the OOP model in a codebase I work on - it duplicated a load of classes that should have just been subclasses. A junior checked it in very satisfied that it was perfect. The LLM review passed it, the tests were fine, and it implemented the feature successfully. It's just the code design had poor taste and poor long-term maintainability.

I keep seeing this kind of thing over and over, and honestly it's not got _that_ much better since the big breakthroughs about a year ago.

For sure I happily vibecode stuff without worrying about it when it's a greenfield project, and if the LLM has written it entirely from scratch then usually it's well structured and sane. But making changes in messy, mostly human-written mature codebases is still a minefield.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by balder1991 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:21PM (#49980695)
I’ve been saying that. When you have no idea what you’re doing, you *need* the latest greatest model because it’s the only way to reduce errors.

For people who have some expertise, the models accelerate the grunt work, but you’re the one validating it.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by calgoo on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:41AM (#49978346)
Please, give it another 6 months and they catch up. The American labs are currently trying everything they can to block others instead of advancing their models, trying to build an artificial moat. The American models are not that great, they are good, and they have a lot of agentic workflows in the back, but its basically a hardware limitation at this point. Once the HW makers catch up, and we can move away from the Nvidia monopoly, things will speed up quite a lot IMO.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by u8080 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:54AM (#49978541)
Just one more release cycle bro, I swear
Re:Mistral Large 4 by senordevnyc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:44AM (#49978391)
We've been hearing the line about them only being a few months behind for a year now, during which time O/A have grown their revenue like 10x, haven't they?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by n6242 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:57AM (#49978585)
We've also been hearing we're 6 months from AGI for about three years, and here we are.

"Now, here, you see, it takes all the running you can do, to keep in the same place. If you want to get somewhere else, you must run at least twice as fast as that!"

Re:Mistral Large 4 by totallykvothe on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:04AM (#49978699)
Phantom Tollbooth?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by gjm11 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @03:35PM (#49982980)
Nope, wrong bit of slightly-surreal children's literature. Through the Looking-Glass and what Alice Found There by C L Dodgson, otherwise known as Lewis Carroll.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by senordevnyc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:12PM (#49982029)
How is that relevant to this discussion?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by _aavaa_ on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:01AM (#49978653)
Those are two different things. The market is expanding, so even if competitors are catching up, you can have your own revenue, in absolute terms, grow.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by senordevnyc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:13PM (#49982037)
That's fair, I left out a part of what I keep hearing in relation to the open weight models only being a few months behind, which is that they're going to eat the big labs' lunch, but then the big labs keep growing...
Re:Mistral Large 4 by bigbadfeline on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:07PM (#49984153)
> but then the big labs keep growing...

Yeah, I could buy a bigger and bigger vehicle when a new one goes to market, but using a semi-truck to drive myself around would not only be significantly more wasteful but also more inconvenient and limiting compared to a sedan. Very much like advanced closed models vs performant open ones.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by senordevnyc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:10PM (#49987154)
And yet the labs keep growing revenue like crazy…
Re:Mistral Large 4 by calgoo on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @06:15AM (#49990682)
A lot of big enterprise customers are already starting to question their spend and there is more and more pushback in regards to sharing private data with both AI orgs, even with the enterprise agreements in place. There might be growing revenue at the moment, but enterprise finance moves slowly, so the next couple of years will be the deciding factor.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ezomode on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:51AM (#49978492)
The thing is O/A have been much louder on pacing the frontier, lately.

And yes, open weights are still behind, but are catching up.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by eigenspace on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:40AM (#49978327)
I agree that Opus and GPT are almsot surely better, but so many real users are nervous enough about giving Anthropic and OpenAI access to all of their internal information that they may be willing to stomach worse models if it gives them more security.

The real question is if this model is good enough that it can still accelerate work, and not be a hindrance to real work like older Mistral models often were.

If they can do that, they'll have customers.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by hajile on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:53AM (#49979419)
The Navier-Stokes fiasco made me push for local/controlled models very hard. "Can't rule out" that they stole data (backed up by their backdoor offers of sharing credit).

If these companies will steal from deep pockets like Disney or Sony (some of the most infamously litigious copyright trolls to ever exist), they won't think twice of stealing every bit of code you upload to them.

If your code passes through an AI company's servers, you can assume you just gave it to them. In turn, when your competitor tries to copy that new feature you just added, the AI is now trained in exactly how to copy you and eliminate your competitive edge. Unlike your employees, the AI isn't bound by the same rules and even if it were and violated them, your company probably doesn't have enough money to prove it in court (and that's if we somehow reverse some of the stupid "AI is the most transformative use of copyright I've ever seen" judges who have drunk the coolaid).

Most companies could build the compute to run GLM or Kimi models for way less than the potential loss due to IP theft from using third-party systems.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by sashank_1509 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:22AM (#49979883)
I would also add to this, there are ways to use customer data to improve your model outside of just using it as “training-data”.

A simple loophole, use the code to create an RLVR environment where the resultant code is the end goal / max reward. Technically the customer data is never trained upon, but effectively you’re using it. Even better, use the code as a seed to generate synthetic data similar to it and use that synthetic data as rewards in an RLVR model.

Unless you can host the ChatGPT model on your own servers, which I know some enterprises are doing, I don’t think there’s any hope of protecting your data / competitive advantage from these frontier companies. Better to be paranoid, than be commodified by these companies.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by phillmv on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:12PM (#49980586)
tbh to me if the AI company writes all of your code & your eng don't even review it anymore then… the AI company _controls your company_. maybe that's ok if you make widgets but less ok if you do anything in dev tooling, security, or [insert market they may suddenly decide to compete in].
Re:Mistral Large 4 by FabHK on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:03AM (#49979568)
If I'm not mistaken, they did rule out that they stole data from the mathematicians in question.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by eigenspace on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:08AM (#49979651)
"We investigated ourselves and determined that we are not to blame"
Re:Mistral Large 4 by chihuahua on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:07PM (#49980528)
Surely Sam Altman would not lie to anybody.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by airstrike on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:14PM (#49981365)
IIRC they ruled out that humans knowingly stole that data, but they didn't rule out that the AI agent might have
Re:Mistral Large 4 by user43928 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:42PM (#49983808)
I don't think that's correct.

> Following an investigation, we have confirmed that Buckmaster’s Codex prompts over the two months preceding this announcement and paper on September 8, 2026, could not have influenced the system in any way, including through training. The OpenAI internal model used for this result was developed through large-scale reinforcement learning on top of a previously pretrained model. Our proofs also differ significantly. In the Euler case, Alpöge and Buckmaster proved a result with external forcing, while OpenAI’s system proved a result without external forcing.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by segmondy on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:30AM (#49979107)
I use Opus 5.5 at work.

I use MiMov2.6Pro, DeepSeekv4.1Flash, GLM5.3, Hy4, Qwen3.8 and KimiK3 at home. Opus5.5 is not a game changer.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by AIblemblio on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:02AM (#49979560)
I do a broad amount of diverse experiments/projects I always wanted to do and throwing Opus5.5 against it just works

I have to admit, Sonnet got really good too.

But Opus just uses tools, a broad spectrum of it, etc. it feels like sure if you add some router behind it you could split it up if you need to but if you give me the choice, its opus allll day long.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by xiconfjs on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:07PM (#49981970)
What is your hardware running GLM5.3?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ygjb on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:07AM (#49978734)
It's an improvement, but game changer might be a bit of a stretch. If I lost access to Anthropic or OpenAI models tomorrow, I would be annoyed, but would reach for a slightly inferior model. Last year I wouldnt be able to say the same, and rhe challenge is that the moat is drying up fast. Whether its general improvements in model training by other competitors, or straight up distillation of SOTA models, the moat is shrinking and the available capital and spend for American model providers is going to dry up quickly as competing good enough models are adopted by more consumers.

It's especially the case as more non-Americans look to self hosted models and domestic cloud inference providers using open models that the US providers who are still leading the charge need to drastically drop their prices and find a path to profitability in order to maintain their lead and retain the advantage they had as AI turns into a commodity (which is happening faster than I think even the frontier labs initially predicted).

Re:Mistral Large 4 by wavemode on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:51AM (#49978485)
People say this exact thing every single time a new frontier model comes out.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by jayd16 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:48AM (#49980266)
Let me know when the game changes are more than a month apart.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by bakugo on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:52AM (#49978500)
> X is such a game changer

I hear this literally every other week about whatever the newest FoTM model is.

Unless you can provide concrete examples of things you can do with them that you simply couldn't do with last week's model, it's absolutely meaningless.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by spaceman_2020 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:58AM (#49978597)
My todo app generator does not need opus 5.5
Re:Mistral Large 4 by spiderfarmer on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:40AM (#49978331)
Less and less work requires a frontier model though.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by senordevnyc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:41AM (#49978336)
Yeah, I agree with this. I think the "the models are good enough" narrative is a myth. I've heard it so many times over the last year, but the model number keeps changing...

There is no ceiling on what you can accomplish with more intelligence, so there will always be a market for the best models, and that market is likely to just keep growing. If Opus 13.5 can one-shot a profitable company or discover a new disease treatment or whatever you can think of that a swarm of relentless super-geniuses could accomplish, companies (and governments) will throw money at it.

I also think there will always be a market for many sub-frontier models that will continue to grow rapidly as well, because "good enough" is definitely a thing for a given task.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by sajithdilshan on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:28AM (#49979975)
One could still argue that models are good enough for a given task. I primarily use Opus at work for writing code and I realized that for my usage the intelligence of Opus 4.8 is more than enough. Sure the newer models are better but I can still do my work with having access to newer models
Re:Mistral Large 4 by suddenlybananas on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:36AM (#49979176)
>If Opus 13.5 can one-shot a profitable company

No company would ever release such a thing

Re:Mistral Large 4 by Aldipower on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:47AM (#49978432)
Despite Opus 5.5 got really bad the last days for me. Looks like they nerfed it again. This is extremely unreliable.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by r2_pilot on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:49AM (#49978463)
Or maybe they secretly believe you are trying to distill their models and are deliberately degrading your experience. Who knows with them?
Re:Mistral Large 4 by Aldipower on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:54AM (#49978545)
You are laughing. Until it happens to you! :-)
Re:Mistral Large 4 by StrauXX on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:42AM (#49980176)
We haven't reached RSI yet. Once any entity reaches RSI, the runway scenario will happen.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by MiloLeo on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:49AM (#49980284)
Assuming RSI is something that is possible as you envision it in the near term. I think that it will happen at some point, but I think we could still be a long way off. I don't think anyone can truthfully say that it is right around the corner.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by yeahforsureman on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:47PM (#49981770)
Truly, this is what the Lord's prophets have revealed to us! (Eliezer 11:52) Keep strong in your P(singularity), for when the Kingdom arrives, He shall judge us in His righteous glory, whether to eternal annihilation, or rebirth and life in His Memory Eternal!
Re:Mistral Large 4 by samplifier on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:16AM (#49979780)
What do you mean "good enough"? Did you mean "large enough"? ;)

Disclaimer: I'm not sure how much of an IYKYK factor applies to this joke.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by blueaquilae on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:17PM (#49980651)
It's a retrain of asian model.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by divbzero on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:51AM (#49978494)
Yes, so far the competitive dynamics feel more like cloud computing than web search.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by cyanydeez on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:12AM (#49979710)
I think it's a mistaken belief that AI as we found it is the exponential runaway train.

So it makes sense, since all you need is compute, that there's a ceiling and specialization is going to be more valuable then some super AGI.

Especially since the worst people seem to be the ones who think they'll all run away with the bag.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by doctorpangloss on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:13AM (#49978809)
How do you figure? I haven't met a single person who doesn't use Claude or Codex for programming in any serious way.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by eigenspace on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:15AM (#49978848)
Then you dont know people working on highly sensitive info with stringent privancy concerns.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by doctorpangloss on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:59AM (#49980416)
they just use claude on bedrock.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ragall on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:08PM (#49980538)
I'm happy I've never met you.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by saberience on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:18AM (#49978900)
I mean, Mistral is about 9-12 months behind here when you look at its overall benchmarks versus the models released around a year ago.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by kaffekaka on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:46AM (#49979323)
Sounds ok to me. Claude was fine at the start of the year, and now with Mistral you also get EU sovereignty? I'll take that.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by senordevnyc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:36AM (#49978272)
On a purely technical level, maybe? But in terms of actual revenue, is there really any chance of anyone catching the big labs?

Obviously, this is only a valid question if you don't believe that open weights are about to eat their lunch and their revenue is about to collapse, or they're running a super unprofitable ponzi scheme propped up by investor money that's about to collapse like a house of cards. I don't find those positions credible at all though.

If you do, then this question isn't really for you, as I'm more interested in thoughts from those who think that OpenAI and Anthropic in particular are about to be the largest companies on earth in a couple years. Could anyone catch them at that point?

Re:Mistral Large 4 by swiftcoder on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:40AM (#49978325)
> But in terms of actual revenue, is there really any chance of anyone catching the big labs?

I don't know about revenue, but I suspect multiple other labs are already beating OpenAI/Anthropic on profitability. Staying on the frontier is expensive, and it's hard to recoup those R&D costs when you have a bunch of other labs nipping at your heels.

If you concede the previous point, then the only way for OpenAI/Anthropic to keep growing long term is to swallow the whole economy (i.e. mass job replacemnt), and that's a bet I wouldn't take.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by richardw on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:53AM (#49978519)
I think the actual plan is to swallow a good portion of the job market. It’s the only thing that makes sense and I hear VC podcast debates on which percentage of jobs justifies the market cap.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by senordevnyc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:42AM (#49978358)
Maybe. I can't freaking wait for the IPO filings so we can finally put all this to rest. (haha, like that'll actually put it to rest on HN, but at least we'll have better data)
Re:Mistral Large 4 by notfromhere on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:03AM (#49978681)
They are very unprofitable…? I don’t think that’s really in dispute. We haven’t yet seen a profitable frontier lab and model pricing remains fairly subsidized
Re:Mistral Large 4 by eigenspace on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:41AM (#49978345)
The big lab revenue may not be catchable, but im not sure it needs to be.

If they can carve out a niche of industrial and governmental partners who rely on them for sovereignty reasons, it may be enough.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by senordevnyc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:45AM (#49978408)
I completely agree, I think AI is a vast ecosystem will all kinds of profitable niches and sub-markets.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by intrasight on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:46AM (#49980228)
It's an open question as to whether or not superintelligence will create a monopoly/duopoly. My opinion is that it will.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by WarmWash on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:41AM (#49978338)
No, because compute, not model ability, is the moat.

The second moat is convenience, which all the big labs make it (comparatively) easy to glide into their models.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by notfromhere on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:04AM (#49978691)
I don’t know if convenient is a moat when it makes switching very easy
Re:Mistral Large 4 by qoez on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:50AM (#49978476)
Seems silly not to have predicted that 10 years ago. I feel like it's long been obvious that smarter models being available will mean way easier cheap synthetic data and access to tools that will speed up competitors as well as consumers.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by ikoorng on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:51AM (#49980305)
I strongly disagree with this "early days" framing.

AI is an idea 60 years old. We are on the 3rd or 4th generation of AI development. Three years into the current iteration of products.

This is not early days by any measure. LLMs are a result of a very, very mature research field.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by locknitpicker on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:32PM (#49980817)
> Its quite interesting to see that at least the early days of AI so far have not been a winner-take-all runaway acceleration game where catchup is impossible.

Mistral is also an European company. As we live in a time where the US regime is engaged in pyrrhic geopolitical tactics, it's good to know that it can't threaten to cut access to models during s period where everyone is rushing to incorporate them more and more in our life.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by bryanlarsen on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:36PM (#49980869)
Even "runaway acceleration" isn't instantaneous. People imagine the singularity as something that happens almost instantaneously. But obviously it happens over time, and that time might be decades. It might still end up looking like a vertical line on a long-term graph.

If the singularity is defined as an AI sufficiently intelligent to improve itself independently, that AI is still limited by the resources required to do this improvement.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by livvy on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:18PM (#49981431)
It's shaping up to be much more like a game of 'chicken' where each company tries to raise more cash without going bust... Ultimately the game of musical chairs is going to have to stop. In the US it looks like they are trying to get a government sanctioned truce in the form of regulation. That's what 'Pacing the frontier' means...
Re:Mistral Large 4 by api on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:26PM (#49981538)
I don't think it is, and I think that is what will pop the bubble. All these companies have winner take all valuations, and that won't happen.

... unless they can legislate it, which is why they are flattering heads of state and scare mongering about dangerous AI.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by londons_explore on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:55PM (#49981849)
It will become winner take all when AI companies manage to really get value from user logs.

Right now they don't even get good feedback from local sessions - I can see it make the same mistake two days running, and then months later when a new model comes out, presumably trained on my data, it still makes the same mistake.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by asah on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:05PM (#49981952)
law of diminishing returns? i.e. any reasonable frontier lab will have enough user logs...
Re:Mistral Large 4 by londons_explore on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:23PM (#49982166)
My theory is there is actual knowledge in the user logs.

When a user says "I'm struggling to undo a bolt on my 1952 Mustang" and the AI responds "try hitting it with a hammer" and the user replies with "that worked thanks" - that is a tiny piece of knowledge which exists nowhere else.

Future AI's can say with more confidence that hitting it with a hammer will probably work.

Across billions of conversations, that can add up to more knowledge than all books.

Re:Mistral Large 4 by tootie on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @02:38PM (#49982335)
Especially with Mistral taking a fraction of the investment of the big guys. They can maintain the position pretty comfortably just by staying within a standard deviation of the leaders.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by asadotzler on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:45PM (#49983845)
Hard to do that with a commodity that's easily replicated.
Re:Mistral Large 4 by electroglyph on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:30PM (#49986231)
this will be quite obsolete by the time the weights are released. still though, it's always good to see open weight releases