News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gizmo on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:03AM (#42971657)
Based on the encyclopedic knowledge LLMs have of written works I assume all parties did the same. But I think there is a broader point to make here. Youtube was initially a ghost town (it started as a dating site) and it only got traction once people started uploading copyrighted TV shows to it. Google itself got big by indexing other people's data without compensation. Spotify's music library was also pirated in the early days. The contracts with the music labels came later. GPL violations by commercial products fits the theme also.

Companies aggressively protect their own intellectual property but have no qualms about violating the IP rights of others. Companies. Individuals have no such privilege. If you plug a laptop into a closet at MIT to download some scientific papers you forfeit your life.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by illegalmemory on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:32AM (#42971834)
" If you plug a laptop into a closet at MIT to download some scientific papers you forfeit your life."

This is exactly what I immediately thought while reading the article. It almost feels like the legal system only punishes general public, while most of these guys are above it.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rahton on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:37AM (#42971888)
The legal system is built to favor large corps and capital owners. See Katharina Pistor books for instance.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cheschire on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:51AM (#42971996)
I think it’s the other way around. Those large entities break all the same laws and rules as others and then get to the point where they can influence the creation of a regulatory moat around themselves to prevent competitors from taking the same path as them.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ttoinou on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:56AM (#42972021)
True but lets take examples one by one to see what we can learn : Spotify was doing illegal things until they made a deal to become legal and not to be trialed over what they done. Seems like business deals is what saved them, not regulatory capture (the regulations around IP for music pre existed Spotify)
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cheschire on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:10AM (#42972124)
Sure that is what saved them initially, but following that early 2010’s period of hemorrhaging money and eventual recovery, then they started digging that moat.

https://www.politico.com/story/2015/04/spotify-washington-lo...

https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/clients/issues?...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ttoinou on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:23AM (#42972227)
Very interesting thank you for the links. I'm not knowledgeable in the Music Modernization Act, but maybe some of this lobbying is to avoid being sued rather than building legal long term moat
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:53AM (#42973256)
Same would be the case for YouTube. Google case was different in that AFAIK there wasn't any obvious legal problem with indexing, and, back then, they were actually doing everyone a favor.

Hardly anyone had any issue with Google search until the time when news media screwed themselves over by going all in on ads, overdoing it, then trying to bring back the paywall, only to realize no one is actually browsing their sites but instead relies on Google to find specific articles. All kinds of legal and technical nonsense started happening (and then Google improved the blurbs under search results and added the "answer box", leading publishers big and small to collectively lose their minds...).

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nayuki on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:26AM (#42973721)
And then news media in Canada got even worse a few years ago. They demanded the government make a law so that when Google or Facebook even links to an article, they must pay the news org. Google decided to pay the link tax. Facebook decided to block all news links. From talking to people, most think that Facebook is the villain, in reality it's the news orgs in collusion with state power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_News_Act , https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/csj-sjc/pl/charter-charte/c18_...
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gardnr on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:28AM (#42974514)
Then Facebook complied with the new law which had negative outcomes for Canadians. The politicians then blamed Facebook for the negative outcomes: https://www.wired.com/story/meta-facebook-instagram-news-blo...

I do believe that large companies should be taxed to help improve society. This law was not the right way to do it.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Workaccount2 on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:54AM (#42973270)
I guess I sort of understand where this idea comes from, and when I was young I was totally into it, but now being in the corporate world for a decade and having my own small business, I just don't really see it anymore.

Big corps tend to be extremely conscientious of the the law. The law may not be ideal, but they tend to be hyper aware of it and have lawyers to ensure it. Small companies on the other hand are the wild fucking west, and tend to be overflowing with "turn a blind eye to that".

What big corps love is regulation that is expensive for small shops to overcome. They can drop $500k on a product cert no problem, be legally in the clear (and graciously compliant!), while making it near impossible for small guys to compete.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by isaacremuant on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:00AM (#42972048)
It doesn't "seem". The entire system in most countries works, by design, that way because the people in power trade in influence at a different plane.

That's why democracy often feels "failed" in that no change can be achieved because "it's just more of the same". Few Lobbyists representing the interests of a few people have more power than millions voting differently.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by vladms on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:32AM (#42972311)
What happens in US right now shows that change is achieved through voting. There are other examples as well in Europe where things did change because of how people voted. If the change is good or bad depends on your perspective.

For me the annoying part is that people vote for a guy because of a couple heavily advertised issues, ignoring all the other plans or the fact that he might not keep his word. Then they are unhappy that things "fail" for them.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by brookst on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:31AM (#42972955)
I like your optimistic take. My more cynical one is that what’s happening in the US shows that real change is achieved through corruption and lying: honest policy discussions and iterative improvement stand no chance against a charismatic populist who will say anything to entrench an oligarchy.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by vladms on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:32AM (#42974565)
It's not primarily optimistic. I just think that education of the people can bring the best improvement on the long run, and not adjusting democracy, demonizing rich guys or another "new" system.

While I hope iterative improvement is the way, I think there are people that have it (or feel) so bad (due to various reasons) that they would take a 50% chance to die for the chance to live better.

The charismatic populists are not supported only by people that are well off, without any worry (neither in US, nor in Europe). (ex: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1535295/presidential-ele...)

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by amanaplanacanal on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:20AM (#42972808)
It's unclear yet whether anything will really change. It is a perfect example though of how the rich are above the law.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by daedrdev on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:42AM (#42973936)
USAID has already been shut down
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by amanaplanacanal on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:51PM (#42976727)
What I mean is that people are going to sue, and they will go to the courts. It's unclear how much will really stick.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by isaacremuant on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:13PM (#42976305)
Yes. US and places where people can elect a democracy have a higher chance of some change than European countries with parliamentary systems where a sudden populist candidate won't make it through that system.

I'd argue that, even if some change does happen in the US. Most change (see healthcare, military spending, etc) won't happen because big money will beat the majority of the populace every time.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by G_o_D on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:37AM (#42971885)
Money speaks ! Money buys !
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by veggieroll on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:24AM (#42972231)
Wilhoit’s law:

> There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:36AM (#42973028)
Is that a prescriptive or descriptive law?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by qup on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:50AM (#42973212)
He left out part of the quote, which is misappropriated as well. Wikipedia:

> This quotation is often incorrectly attributed to Francis M. Wilhoit:

> Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition, to wit: There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.

> However, it was actually a 2018 blog response by 59-year-old Ohio composer Frank Wilhoit, years after Francis Wilhoit's death.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_M._Wilhoit

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by diogocp on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:52AM (#42974067)
A restatement of Orwell's "all animals are equal, but some are more equal than others".

The irony must have been lost on him.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TZubiri on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:52AM (#42974070)
Lol, that's clearly a descriptive law/maxim not an actual law.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jamesbfb on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:30AM (#42972297)
RIP Aaron
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rchaud on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:38AM (#42972363)
Airbnb and Uber have showed us that laws matter only to the extent that the political will to enforce them exists. Throw enough lawyers and lobbying money at the problem and the laws can simply be re-written to be friendlier to your business model.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by DebtDeflation on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:50AM (#42972476)
The reason there was no political will to punish Airbnb and Uber for violating the law was that initially they were subsidized with VC money and so were able to undercut traditional hotels and taxis on price. In the world of tradable goods, pricing below cost with the intent of putting competition out of business so you can raise prices later is known as "dumping" and is itself illegal.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by johnebgd on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:21AM (#42973660)
I rooted for Uber to smash the Taxi cartels. Let us not forget that Taxi Cartels were also insidious beasts. Taxi drivers abused their walled garden with their price gouging by taking longer routes, refusal to take a credit card, and extremely poorly maintained fleets of vehicles. I have had mostly good experiences with Uber, whereas I had experiences that mostly bordered on general condescension toward me whenever I took a ride in a Taxi. I am glad the political will to block Uber never materialized.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by burningion on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:41AM (#42973914)
This argument ignores the fact that there were other alternatives to Uber at the time, ones that didn't break the law! Believe it or not, there were multiple ride hailing apps on the iPhone, but none were as great at accumulating capital or breaking the law without recourse.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:37PM (#42975280)
The laws they allegedly broke were the taxi medallion cartel laws, which were the things keeping taxis terrible by limiting supply and competition. And those laws in general apply to the drivers rather than the ride hailing service. There is also a lot of ambiguity there, e.g. if you have a ride sharing service where people go on the app to find people to carpool with on a trip they'd be making anyway and then contribute gas money, is that a taxi service?

But the taxi services obviously hated the competition and waged a continuing media campaign to paint the renegades as the villains.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by burningion on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:41PM (#42975322)
No, these are not only the laws they allegedly broke.

They created a project named Greyball to identify law enforcement and mislead them.

They created a kill switch for the event of a government raid to gather evidence.

They ordered and then canceled rides on competitor apps.

They tracked journalists and politicians...

The list goes on and on: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_surrounding_Uber

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:50PM (#42975421)
The best thing to ever happen to corpo scum was that social media took over most of the news. Now there’s no trusted journalists to write a big article about this kind of stuff, instead folks just defend the corpo scum’s actions and spread lies for them, while the truth is still putting on its shoes.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rbanffy on Saturday February 08, 2025 @06:15AM (#42982173)
It would have worked if we didn’t find out the hard way a lot of social media and alternative news outlets weren’t even scummier.

We need good journalism courses with heavy emphasis on ethics and the importance of journalism to democracy.

We also need a way to punish entertainment that passes as journalism (maybe fewer legal protections) and to incentive actual journalism (and find a decent way to distinguish between the two).

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:49PM (#42975409)
Several of those things aren't even necessarily illegal and are the sort of things they shouldn't have had have any reason to do unless they were being targeted by a media campaign or captured government. There is also some dispute about whether some of those even happened or are just mischaracterizations from the media campaign.

It's like saying "well, they weren't only violating the taxi medallion cartel laws, they were also violating laws against evading enforcement of the taxi medallion cartel laws". There is a central cause here.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:52PM (#42975437)
Move the goalposts any more and they’re going to be outside the stadium. What laws matter to you? I agree there are shit laws but why can uber break them with impunity but individuals are jailed for smoking some fun lettuce?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by thwarted on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:05PM (#42975595)
Because more money and special interests are behind fun lettuce smoking enforcement than local taxi companies could put behind protecting their own cartel from interlopers. If the taxi companies had more money to dump on politicians than is poured into drug enforcement, then the priorities would have changed.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:03PM (#42975568)
The question you should be asking is, what do you want to do about it? Throw the people challenging the taxi cartels in prison, or get rid of the laws against fun lettuce?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by opello on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:23PM (#42977045)
Why isn't at least one of those things actually addressing (disbanding, regulating, whatever--left to people experienced in policy or with context to have some remediation plan) those taxi cartels' behavior?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:26PM (#42977667)
The argument is that getting rid of the bad laws is better than enforcing them more rigorously. This can be applied to the laws propping up the taxi medallion cartels as well as the ones prohibiting personal drug use. Then anyone (not just Uber) could compete with them and thereby disband the taxi cartels previously using those laws to constrain competition.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by opello on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:14PM (#42979018)
I agree that removing bad laws is good. I think by introducing the second, culturally charged topic (1.) taxi cartels, 2.) recreational drugs) you diminish the possible interpretations of your perspective.

The other downstream conclusions make sense too, but the linkage is more opaque making it difficult to appreciate.

Also hard to acknowledge is--who decides which laws are "bad"? Generally, societal outcomes should test the efficacy (toward some comparably abstract societal good) of laws, which then prompts the legislature to do something between patting themselves on the back and authoring actually effective law.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday February 09, 2025 @02:58AM (#42989228)
> who decides which laws are "bad"?

It's better to ask the question in a different way. We know what bad laws are. They're laws that benefit some interest group at the expense of the general public, e.g. by constraining competition or diverting tax dollars to cronies.

So the question is, how do you eliminate bad laws? This isn't a question of what a hypothetical legislature should do if it was full of good faith actors, it's a question of how to structurally align the incentives of a real legislature with the interests of the general public so that they're inhibited from passing bad laws.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by opello on Sunday February 09, 2025 @07:53PM (#42995786)
That makes sense but seems like it would only actually be a subset of bad laws. I mainly mean to highlight that it's not a comprehensive way to identify bad law.

> how to structurally align the incentives of a real legislature with the interests of the general public

This seems like a critical nuance that, like you said, needs a structural solution. I have no actual idea, but conceptually this seems like it would eliminate a subset of particularly bad laws and actions (e.g. members of the legislature trading on their insider information) which have outsized, negative outcomes for the public. But we also rely on that very rule making body to essentially self-govern. And such a grass-roots movement of reforms to put the public first seem unlikely given the attitudes and sensationalizing behaviors present in the members of that body.

I avoid politics because of just how disaffecting it is to think about most of these details.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:44PM (#42976029)
Something else, I’m not sure what yet. Honestly, I’m not the best guy to ask but I know that I don’t want startups to continue breaking laws with impunity and I don’t want individuals to get imprisoned for stuff they do that isn’t affecting others in a meaningful way.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:06PM (#42976241)
There isn't really a something else. You have bad laws that are in practice only enforced against the little guy. You could demand they also be enforced against the big guy, but that's hard to do when they're bad laws, isn't really a great outcome because they're bad laws, and its primary benefit would be in service of calling attention to the flaw so the bad laws can be repealed. And then maybe you should just start there to begin with.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BrenBarn on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:30PM (#42977130)
That is partly true, but it's also true that vastly increased enforcement against the big guys would still be better than what we have now.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:39PM (#42977226)
Suppose that the status quo is the worst option, the second worst is enforcing the bad laws against the big guys, the best is getting rid of those laws.

Now, that might not be the case. Given the existence of bad laws, having someone who is able to break out of the bad cage might be better than if no one can, but let's consider what happens if we assume that it's worse.

Regardless of how they're ranked relative to each other, you would only pick either of the two worse options over the best if it was easier to do it. But getting bad laws enforced against well-heeled players is actually the hardest thing to do because they're doing something sympathetic and have the resources to fight, which is harder to do than repealing the bad laws.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BrenBarn on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:44PM (#42977267)
I don't agree. Getting more comprehensive enforcement of laws in general against well-heeled players is a good thing. We would have a lot less bad law if laws were enforced more evenly, because people would more quickly see their true effects, rather than having to wait until companies exploited the loopholes in enforcement so egregiously.

(I also don't agree that the only problem here is bad laws. Yes, some of the laws that big players break are bad; some are fine. I'm not just talking about Uber here.)

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:20PM (#42977605)
> Getting more comprehensive enforcement of laws in general against well-heeled players is a good thing.

Whether something is good independent of what it takes to achieve it is a separate question from whether that's where you should focus your efforts.

> We would have a lot less bad law if laws were enforced more evenly, because people would more quickly see their true effects, rather than having to wait until companies exploited the loopholes in enforcement so egregiously.

Which is exactly why it's so hard to do it. The status quo is: Pass lots of laws that make everything illegal so that anyone without resources can be brought up on charges if they ruffle the wrong feathers. If you wanted to actually enforce all of those laws, they would immediately have to be repealed or everyone would be in jail. Which isn't in the interests of the people who want to keep them on the books to use for selective enforcement, so they don't enforce them that way in order to keep them on the books.

The consequence is that it takes even more political capital to have those laws rigorously enforced than to have them repealed, because then you have to fight both the big guys who don't want short-term enforcement against themselves and the autocrats who don't want to long-term have the laws repealed, instead of only the latter.

> I also don't agree that the only problem here is bad laws.

When laws are enforced against the little guys but not the big guys, it's usually because they're bad laws, because letting the rich openly get away with literal murder is highly unpopular.

The most significant category of good laws that big companies regularly violate with impunity is antitrust laws, but those also don't often get enforced against the little guy because the little guy isn't even in a position to violate them.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:54PM (#42979950)
So I get your argument, but by that logic the only bad laws that get repealed will be those that affect big business, and the laws against individuals without resources will still be in place. I think we all agree that it’s unfair there’s a very large difference in enforcement of law between those with resources and those without, but I think to prevent that we need to figure out how to prevent the capture of the government by those with large resources. I could agree in concept that less laws are better for that overall, but also then there’s the question of who benefits from less laws and I bet those with resources will still benefit.

It’s almost like we need to ensure no one has much more resources than anyone else (ya know, workers owning the means of production) so there’s a more level field!

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BrenBarn on Saturday February 08, 2025 @12:50AM (#42980718)
> It’s almost like we need to ensure no one has much more resources than anyone else (ya know, workers owning the means of production) so there’s a more level field!

Heh, yeah, I was going to post to add this as well. That is the underlying problem. I don't necessarily think it has to mean "workers owning the means of production" per se, more like "the richest person's wealth cannot be more than X times the poorest" and "the largest participant in a market cannot have more than Y% market share", but the idea is similar. :-)

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday February 09, 2025 @02:30AM (#42989133)
> So I get your argument, but by that logic the only bad laws that get repealed will be those that affect big business, and the laws against individuals without resources will still be in place.

Quite the opposite.

You have a bad law which is only enforced against the little guy. Right now, when it's not enforced against the big guy, stories are written about it to get people riled up, but that's the wrong target.

Right now, when those laws are enforced against the little guy, people say "well they broke the law". Which is true, because everyone is breaking the law all the time, because there are so many bad laws. So what should be happening is, every time they try to enforce a bad law against the little guy, that should be the thing that gets people ruled up -- even if they're guilty. Because everyone is guilty, because the laws are crazy. So get people worked up about that so that the laws can be changed. Don't accept that people guilty of violating bad laws deserve to be punished. Drag the prosecutors through the mud. Flood the legislators with complaints whenever it happens. Use jury nullification and publicize to everyone that it's their right. Get those laws repealed.

> I think to prevent that we need to figure out how to prevent the capture of the government by those with large resources.

This was supposed to be checks and balances and limited government. As soon as you unchain legislators to micromanage the economy, anyone who captures them can shape the law to their advantage and then become rich and use the money to make sure the government stays captured.

The government needs to be constrained from making laws that inhibit competition.

> It’s almost like we need to ensure no one has much more resources than anyone else (ya know, workers owning the means of production) so there’s a more level field!

The words you're looking for are "antitrust enforcement".

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by WorldMaker on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:25PM (#42975825)
Taxi Medallion laws were also a Reputation Engine that was publicly queryable, subject to FOIA laws and generally had easy to search public databases for them, with detailed notes. Sure Uber/Lyft boil that into a "friendly" 5-star UI, but do you have any idea what data contributed to that star rating? Do you always trust the algorithms that compute them from a bucket of metrics you can't directly request?

Sure, Medallion laws had problems, and got Regulatory Captured in some cities to also become terrible Trusts controlling prices that needed busting. But the answer to "fix the Regulation" isn't always "break the Regulation", and the Regulation had a lot of good intent of having public accessible information about drivers and that data not just owned by a single company and locked in their opaque algorithms. It might have been nicer to fix the Regulatory Capture and Bust the Trusts.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:19PM (#42976385)
> Taxi Medallion laws were also a Reputation Engine that was publicly queryable, subject to FOIA laws and generally had easy to search public databases for them, with detailed notes.

You just landed at the airport and need a cab. You fax your FOIA requests for each of the hundred cab companies in the area, which they're required to provide within 20 business days. Your return flight is in 3 days and it would be nice to leave the airport before then.

> Sure Uber/Lyft boil that into a "friendly" 5-star UI, but do you have any idea what data contributed to that star rating? Do you always trust the algorithms that compute them from a bucket of metrics you can't directly request?

So compete with them instead of banning them. Fund an open source ride hailing app with open data. Don't require anyone to use it. If it's better, they will. If it's not better, why should they be forced to?

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by WorldMaker on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:52PM (#42976748)
> You just landed at the airport and need a cab. You fax your FOIA requests for each of the hundred cab companies in the area, which they're required to provide within 20 business days. Your return flight is in 3 days and it would be nice to leave the airport before then.

If you just landed at the airport, you rely on police enforcement keeping bad actors from having medallions. The medallion itself is the primary "this person is a reputable cab driver". That's also entirely why the Regulatory Capture in some cities was so effective in controlling supply of medallions, because it was city police enforced.

Many cities required taxis to have their medallion number painted on the outside, and there were phone numbers you could quickly call (in the days of payphones even) to get quick information about a medallion or to report a complaint/problem with one.

Today a few cities have updated that external paint requirement (and inside the car medallion papers) to include QR codes for even quicker lookup on modern phones or to even use an app to do nice things like pay for the Taxi without needing to broker/negotiate it. Those kind of technological improvements have kind of gotten lost in the wash of the speed of which Uber/Lyft moved fast and broke things, but were always possible.

> So compete with them instead of banning them. Fund an open source ride hailing app with open data. Don't require anyone to use it. If it's better, they will. If it's not better, why should they be forced to?

The history of taxi companies say that they are only as open as they are forced to be. I never said anything about banning Uber/Lyft. Competition is not the problem; destroying public safety regulations in the name of competition is the problem. I said that Uber/Lyft should have been required to do the same or similar paperwork that medallions represent, that both of their data should be open under the previously existing laws, as a public good. Break the artificial scarcity, sure, give Uber/Lyft a license to "print medallions" if that breaks existing Trusts. But get that data open and available to the public (and enforceable by the public's law enforcement). Neither would want to do that because their rating systems are secret sauce and "competitive advantage", they would need to be coerced by regulations. That's what regulations are for, the public good that competition doesn't care about/can't care about/needs to keep "secret sauce" for advantages.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by standyro on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:36PM (#42977196)
Let's recap the past: Taxis were borderline unusable in almost all American cities before Uber (except for NYC)

I certainly didn't love their ruthless business practices, but let's not delude ourselves and admit that Uber or Lyft wouldn't exist if they didn't break the laws around taxi medallions.

Sometimes laws do more harm than good (by limiting supply and slowing innovation) and it requires creatively skirting regulations.

Things were always possible to improve the taxi industry. Smartphones had been around a few years. But it would've taken the industry 20 years to implement it correctly. In the same way that rampant music and movie piracy in the early 2000s hastened the development of iTunes and Netflix's subscription model way of doing business.

Uber shows the driver's name, their photo, and has a process for flagging drivers. Public safety is important to their business. As someone who's driven an Uber and Lyft and been through their process, I've seen it firsthand.

It's not like "medallions" worked - I remember driving in multiple taxis in pre 2010 days where the photo DID NOT MATCH UP to the driver. My high school physics teacher who grew up in Brooklyn in the late 1970s told stories about how he learned how to drive by illegally working and driving taxis around as a 15 year old.

Right now, we're just going through the same thing with AI again, and Silicon Valley is applying it's ethos of the past few decades.

There are reasons why in various industries, China is "winning the race", so to speak.

Regulations exist, but sometimes people who creatively ignore the "regulations" can win the tide of the public. It's one of America's best (and incredibly divisive) cultural capabilities.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by WorldMaker on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:57PM (#42977398)
> Let's recap the past: Taxis were borderline unusable in almost all American cities before Uber (except for NYC)

My experience was very different and "almost all" doesn't feel correct. It's certainly fun hyperbole. NYC the systems worked more than they didn't. In part because of spot lights from famous TV shows and 70s corruption documentaries/news exposes. Most smaller cities the taxis quietly worked with little corruption and a lot of trustworthiness. In the early oughts I had good experiences hailing cabs in cities a lot smaller than NYC that people didn't believe you could even hail cabs in.

Because Taxi regulations were so wildly different from cities, it's hard to generalize what the experience used to be. It varied a lot from city to city and was a massive spectrum, with a few national certainties like some of the big Franchises to help smooth things a bit.

> I certainly didn't love their ruthless business practices, but let's not delude ourselves and admit that Uber or Lyft wouldn't exist if they didn't break the laws around taxi medallions.

In the early oughts, a few cities like Seattle were pressuring the big national Franchise companies like Yellow Cab through a mixture of regulatory body pressure (but not actual laws) and bottom up consumer messaging/volume customer requirements to move to "Computer Dispatch". There was a growing competition in that space, and a bunch of innovation happening between the competitors, including some of the things Uber and Lyft take credit for today because Yellow Cab mostly broke apart in the onslaught of VC subsidization and rule breaking.

I don't think it would have taken "20 years" to implement it "correctly". We don't know because the whole thing got disrupted so sideways by the gig economy. (Which also really didn't care about making the taxi business better, but about making the labor market worse. We should also not forget that breaking the worst parts of taxi medallion laws also broke the good ones that helped build useful labor-side things like taxi driver unions and paid for things like healthcare.)

All I'm saying is that there was a path that this could have all been done under the old regulations, legally. It's a path not taken here, and probably to our detriment. Though I can't prove that just as much as you can't prove that innovations like smarter apps would have taken "20 years" in that other timeline.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:22PM (#42977033)
> If you just landed at the airport, you rely on police enforcement keeping bad actors from having medallions.

Well that's not going to work. You now have people from outside the jurisdiction having a government they didn't elect cast in the role of their protectors. Instead what happens is the local government protects the incumbents, which is what we've seen in practice.

> Many cities required taxis to have their medallion number painted on the outside, and there were phone numbers you could quickly call (in the days of payphones even) to get quick information about a medallion or to report a complaint/problem with one.

As opposed to the license plates already on all cars?

> The history of taxi companies say that they are only as open as they are forced to be.

People keep trying to regard Uber as a taxi company. They keep claiming to be an app, because... they are. So replace the app with an open source one. Create an independent non-profit to handle payments and maintain a server to hold the driver ratings and take a small cut of the payments to cover its costs. Operate it as a live auction where drivers list how much they'll charge per mile and riders pick a driver based on their rating and price. Publish all the data.

If you do it well, people will use it voluntarily. If you do it poorly, you haven't demonstrated enough competence to be trusted making regulations that people would have to follow even if they're dumb.

> Competition is not the problem; destroying public safety regulations in the name of competition is the problem.

The problem is that incumbents call the things they use to destroy competition "public safety regulations".

> Neither would want to do that because their rating systems are secret sauce and "competitive advantage", they would need to be coerced by regulations.

Not when you can "coerce" them through competition. If people like the ratings system which is more open or the one that extracts lower margins and the app is otherwise fungible with theirs, they don't even exist unless they can be better than the competing system you created to do better, which implies that you failed to actually do better and then they're supposed to win. Which in turn applies pressure on the public system to do better itself, instead of getting captured, because if it gets captured then it becomes uncompetitive and actually has competition.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by averageRoyalty on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:28PM (#42977687)
You understand they're a global company and broke many laws in many countries, right?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mikepurvis on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:51PM (#42975429)
The only alternative I remember is "black car" services, eg airport limos and the like. But there was very little automation around it; you had to speak on the phone with someone to book, and it was always like 24+ hours out rather than "go to the place now" the way a cab is.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by kmoser on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:23PM (#42977038)
Most taxi services will send a car to your address immediately, no reservation required. Problem is, you have to know the exact address where you want to be picked up, which can sometimes be difficult to determine if you're new in town and/or standing on a street with no obvious sign or address, e.g. on the edge of a large university campus. That's where GPS-driven apps really shine, plus the ability to see the car's location in near real-time, and why I will never be sad at the demise of traditional way of having to call a cab.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mikepurvis on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:45PM (#42977283)
Indeed, but I was referring specifically to the charge that taxi alternatives (eg, outside the medallion system) existed pre-Uber. And I think, they did, but only in very limited use cases like airport shuttles, and not with fleets anywhere near large enough to have a car five minutes from anywhere at all times— hence the need to book those things ahead.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wand3r on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:13PM (#42978594)
> This argument ignores the fact that there were other alternatives to Uber at the time, ones that didn't break the law!

Yes, and they owe their current existence to Uber paving the way for them.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by slashdev on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:58AM (#42974872)
Uber definitely improved things.

When traveling it’s also so much safer than taxis.

My brother was robbed at gunpoint in a taxi. My wife had to jump from more than one moving taxi to escape. My ex girlfriend too. My Swiss friend had his camera and wallet stolen.

You can have issues with Uber too, but not as frequently because there’s a digital audit trail, you can report them to the platform and the police. The threat of those consequences lead to better behavior.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by kmoser on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:24PM (#42977059)
Were these acts committed by the drivers or somebody else?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by slashdev on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:20PM (#42978176)
Drivers
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by leshow on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:07PM (#42978051)
It didn't improve things for the drivers
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by slashdev on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:22PM (#42978190)
That’s not universally true
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cookie_monsta on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:49PM (#42979917)
Here's another data point: I have taken literally thousands of taxis on 5 continents and none of this has ever happened to me
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by thatcat on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:49AM (#42974762)
Political will shouldn't be required to enforce existing law. If i started a 1 man illegal taxi service it would be shut down even though it has little effect on the community, but saudi vc funded startup wasn't shut down even though it violated laws in every major city. That is a weird asymmetry as a us citizen.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:43PM (#42975340)
What's really happening here is that the laws are supposed to reflect the political will, i.e. the will of the people, but in many cases they don't, because the lawmakers have been captured by incumbents.

Then if a little guy comes in and tries to challenge them, they don't have the resources to resist the incumbents' pocket government officials and get destroyed. But if a big fish does it, people actually notice if the government tries to enforce stupid laws against them, and then government officials are afraid to do it because the public would not only not like it but actually notice the unreasonableness of the law.

But the problem here isn't that the law isn't being enforced against a well-heeled challenger, it's that those laws exist to be enforced against the little guy, when they should instead be repealed.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by thatcat on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:45PM (#42977281)
There are plenty of cases where the public notices the unreasonableness of the law and nothing changes... copyright, cannabis, property zoning, it goes on. I think what you mean by well-heeled is rich - if you have money the state will support you in making more money regardless the law and many times won't even bother to change it so that it can still be used against the poor or to stifle competition.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:10PM (#42978079)
So there are two different categories of things here. One is, they ban cannabis and put individuals in prison for it, but then if you pay thousands a year for overpriced health insurance and the insurance pays thousands of dollars for a doctor to ask you some cursory questions and a pharma company to manufacture the drug, you can get a prescription for opioids, which are way more dangerous. But that isn't the big guys violating the law, it's them following a law that they bought and paid for. That's bad in a different way.

The relevant thing here would be that they pass excessive copyright laws, but then Meta violates them and maybe gets away with it because they're doing it in a sympathetic way and the government doesn't want to hamstring emerging industries in their country, whereas if an individual would be sued into oblivion even if the thing they were doing was equally sympathetic.

Because it's not just about the public noticing it, it's about the public noticing it in time to do something about it. If an individual gets sued or arrested, they're immediately screwed and will be under pressure to settle or plea bargain before they're bankrupted by legal fees. But once they do, the case is over. Whereas large companies can fight, or pay lawyers to stall while they wage a media campaign to counter the usual imperious press releases from the prosecution, or use their money to lobby the government while public opinion is in their favor.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by thatcat on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:55PM (#42980509)
I mean there are examples in the same category as well: how many years was it illegally exported from dispensaties between states? New state legalizes? day one the corporate dispensary is stocked which is curious since it takes several months to grow. Also, lots of foriegn capital involved in the industry.

Not just meta, Open AI, spotify, youtube...its become a routine exception and can now be relied upon.

I agree that the legal fees could be a big factor, but it seems cases aren't even filed.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by arp242 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:58AM (#42974862)
It really screwed over a lot of regular working-class people. In some European cities getting a taxi license was a serious monetary investment. People took our huge loans for this. This was now suddenly worthless. It's like being told your very expensive university education is no longer accredited, but the student loan still exists. kthxbye.

I'm not saying the existing systems were always good (they weren't), but you need to be willing to overlook a lot of real-world suffering to be "rooting for Uber". Phrases like "taxi cartels" sound nice, but they're hardly neutral phrasings that simplify things to the point of being useless phrases.

And "I'm just going to willingly and knowingly ignore laws I don't like for personal profit" is not a great take-away either. This isn't Aaron Swartz breaking a law as a matter of "civil disobedience" – it's just a plain "how can we make money?"

And where does that leave competitors who are NOT willing to break the law? It's an unlevel playing field; there can be no free market if some people don't need to follow the same set of rules. Uber's actions are fundamentally anti-capitalist and anti-free market.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 6510 on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:31PM (#42975214)
I always tell the story of this restaurant 18 km from my house. If I order their cheapest 6 euro hamburger they deliver it for free within 30 minutes. If I take a taxi to the restaurant I may have to wait for an hour and it costs about 100 euro and another 100 to get back.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by arp242 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:22PM (#42977027)
I took a ~20 minute 12km taxi ride just last Monday, and it was about €22. That's in Ireland. Considering fuel, the drive back for the driver, and that taxis have a lot of downtime, that seems like a reasonable price.

You live in Netherlands according to a recent comment; I can't believe taxis are almost 4x more expensive, unless you're stuck in traffic for a long time, but then your burger can't arrive in 30 mins?

And free delivery on €6 food item is almost certainly netting them a loss.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by decimalenough on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:50PM (#42976721)
There is no way anybody is making a profit on driving 36 km to deliver a hamburger for 6 euros, and it's a matter of time until whatever faucet of VC money subsidizing this runs dry.

In much of the world the price of food delivery has risen to the level needed to make it profitable, and it's not cheap. I paid around $10 in fees plus Uber's 30-50% markups on the food itself to get a couple of burritos yesterday from a shop a mile down the road.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 6510 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @01:47PM (#42985149)
A 30 min drive would be 7 euro and 3 cent in minimum wage. Then you need a car and you have to fuel or charge it.

The only solution to the riddle I can think of is that (like postal services) they can cleverly combine orders and rarely lose money on delivery. The fast delivery would have to be luck or perhaps the burger preserves poorly?

That the food is absolutely fantastic might also have something to do with it. If they can get food into your mouth repetition is almost guaranteed.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by twelve40 on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:52PM (#42975445)
> getting a taxi license was a serious monetary investment. People took our huge loans for this

it was a terrible system that sucked for everyone involved. For all of Uber's flaws, would you rather go back to that today? really??

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by arp242 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:10PM (#42976910)
> would you rather go back to that today? really??

I absolutely said said no such thing. There are good ways to change things and bad ways to change things. Allowing a private entity reap huge profits by blatantly breaking rules and screwing people is not a good way to change things.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by CamperBob2 on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:07PM (#42978553)
There was no other way to change things on less than a generational timescale.

If governments don't like it, well, bummer. They were supposed to serve the people, not the incumbent taxi cartels. They failed, so "we the people" routed around them.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by brisky on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:06AM (#42974233)
It is possible that digitization and improvement of taxi services was inevitable anyway
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ToucanLoucan on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:29AM (#42974531)
Not only was it inevitable, if we were so inclined and willing to use the regulatory pen, we could've simply written into law that for Taxi's to operate, they must be well maintained and must accept all major forms of payment. And yeah, the Taxi industry would've fought it because every company ever has fought every regulation ever no matter how much it stands to benefit both their customers and they them-fucking-selves but companies having a say in how they are regulated is both how a Taxi company would fight this, and how Uber, AirBnb, OpenAI, Meta, etc. blatantly and flagrantly violate the law and instead of consequences, they get fines, and court hearings. So maybe we just shouldn't be allowing that?

It drives me up the goddamn wall how people will say shit like "the Taxi industry needed to be upended" when like... I mean, maybe? But on balance, given all the negative externalities associated with these companies, are they really a gain? Or are they just a different set of overlords, equally disinterested in providing a good service once they reach the scale where they no longer are required to give a shit?

Just... regulate the fuckers. Are you sick of filthy Taxis that break down? Put a regulation down that says if a cab breaks down during a trip, they owe the customer a free ride and five thousand dollars. You bet your ASS those cabs will be serviced as soon as humanly possible. This isn't rocket science y'all. Make whatever consequence the government is going to dispense immeasurably, clearly worse than whatever the business is trying to weasel out of doing, and boom. Solved.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by drdaeman on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:37PM (#42975949)
> Just... regulate the fuckers.

That's true, however we must also keep in mind that Uber (and alikes) happened because regular institutions failed to do this for some reason or another. I won't try to speculate why, because I have no idea (and of course it looks obvious in the hindsight).

There was a demand for safer and more reliable taxis. There was not enough supply for that. Government haven't paid enough attention to the sector. So, naturally, someone came and used that whole situation to provide supply for this demand.

Of course it's not this simple, and there were a lot of other things going on. But if we narrow the scope down to just this, then we can see that the core problem here wasn't Uber, it was that that governments were too slow to react in time.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:48PM (#42976072)
> Not only was it inevitable, if we were so inclined and willing to use the regulatory pen, we could've simply written into law that for Taxi's to operate, they must be well maintained and must accept all major forms of payment.

That was frequently already the case. They were required to accept credit cards but then the card reader would be "broken" and it wasn't worth anybody's time to dispute it instead of just paying in cash.

You also... don't really want laws like that. They're required to accept "all payment methods", which ones? Do they have to take American Express, even though the fees are much higher? Do they have to take PayPal if the customer has funds in a PayPal account? What about niche card networks like store cards accepted at more than one merchant? If not those and just Visa and Mastercard, you now have a law entrenching that duopoly in the law.

> Are you sick of filthy Taxis that break down? Put a regulation down that says if a cab breaks down during a trip, they owe the customer a free ride and five thousand dollars. You bet your ASS those cabs will be serviced as soon as humanly possible. This isn't rocket science y'all.

It's not rocket science, it's trade offs.

Is there a $5000 fine for a breakdown? You just made cab service much more expensive, because they're either going to have to pay the fines as a cost of doing business and then pass them on, or propylactically do excessive maintenance like doing full engine rebuilds every year because it costs less than getting caught out once, and then passing on the cost of that. And even then, there is no such thing as perfect. The cabbie paid to have the whole engine rebuilt by the dealership just yesterday and the dealer under-tightened one of the bolts when putting it back in, so there's a coolant leak? Normally that's just re-tightening the bolt and $20 worth of coolant, but now it's a $5000 fine on top of the $4000 engine rebuild.

The way you actually want to solve this is with competition, not rigid rules and onerous fines. If someone is always having breakdowns then they get bad rating, customers can see that when choosing and then opt for a different driver that costs slightly more -- but only if the cost is worth the difference to them. Maybe it's worth $2 for the difference between two stars and five but it isn't worth $50 for the difference between 4.7 and 4.8. Either way you shouldn't be deciding for people, you should be giving them the choice.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by vdqtp3 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @12:18AM (#42980602)
> That was frequently already the case. ...the card reader would be "broken"

I traveled a lot to a smallish town for work before Uber got there and ran into this several times. After the second or third time, I started just saying "well that sucks for you" and starting to leave. Suddenly it would work.

Yes it sucked, but it didn't really impact much.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rangestransform on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:05PM (#42977472)
I would rather ruin the taxi livelihood than have to argue with my driver about turning on the meter again
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by clarkmoody on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:00PM (#42976183)
Possible, yes. Probable?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rangestransform on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:03PM (#42977445)
They still haven’t properly digitized, curb sucks ass, I had to report a driver to curb when he made me Zelle him because “curb payment wasn’t working”
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by walrus01 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:33AM (#42973811)
What's interesting is that in many cities now, Uber and Lyft are in fact more expensive than taxis. And the experience is equally mediocre. The pendulum has swung back the other way. The only thing they have going for them now is the app based convenience, which is eroding as more "yellow cab" type traditional taxis band together and get set up with their own sort of city-specific app.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by phil21 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:10AM (#42974272)
> What's interesting is that in many cities now, Uber and Lyft are in fact more expensive than taxis.

Sure, agreed.

> And the experience is equally mediocre.

Absolutely not. I regret using a taxi nearly every time I opt for the cheaper option. It's only the "better" choice if you happen to be standing right in front of one. This experience is nearly universal no matter where I travel.

I think people really forget how utterly terrible Taxis were pre-Uber. I have no idea about competing apps these days, maybe they are similar to Uber, but the typical Taxi experience is nearly as awful as it's always been at least in the US.

Uber/Lyft certainly has gotten worse - but at least I can fairly reliably get a car when I need it with reasonable reliability. The rest of the "soft" product or pricing I really care far, far, less about than that simple fact.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by haswell on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:46AM (#42974723)
> the typical Taxi experience is nearly as awful as it's always been at least in the US

It seems impossible/problematic to generalize the taxi experience to “The US”.

If you’re in a city center, cabs can be far easier. The number of times I’ve ordered an Uber or Lyft and regretted it while watching taxi after taxi drive by has been increasing. But I expect the Chicago loop experience to be quite different from say, the suburbs.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mrguyorama on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:16PM (#42975064)
> quite different from say, the suburbs.

My small rural town of 9000 people had multiple taxi services that poorer people relied on to do even their grocery shopping. We didn't need "disruption"

Tech bros generalizing a negative experience from NYC or SV to the entire US has been so stupid.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tmnvdb on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:31PM (#42979137)
If you didn't need disruption, why did people choose to use the new service?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by haswell on Saturday February 08, 2025 @08:48PM (#42987804)
Couldn’t the same thing be said about Walmart killing small businesses?

The fact that disruption occurred doesn’t necessarily mean that the end result is better.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Supermancho on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:19PM (#42979754)
> Uber and Lyft are in fact more expensive than taxis.

I doubt that.

I double checked, just to be sure since I paid for taxis for years for a specific trip, each way. Uber is still cheaper TODAY than taxis were when I switched 10 years ago. One way 5 minute trip, Friday 6pm in orange county, ca still under 20$ today.

20$ was a good deal (or ripoff, depending on your attitude) for a taxi in 2015, for the same distance and a variable waiting time. Let's just say it's about equal for sake of discussion. There was no app, but there was a dispatcher you could call. There was no incentive to improve, until then.

Companies have had to adapt and prices have come down. It would no doubt be 30$+ today for taxis, if not for rideshare companies.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gardnr on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:43AM (#42973947)
I remember calling a taxi 3 hours before my flight to get to SFO. After an hour and four different phone calls to the taxi company, I took BART and barely made it before the counter closed.

The feedback system incentivizes drivers and riders to behave.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by GuB-42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:17AM (#42974367)
This is getting off-topic, but I am curious, why didn't you go with BART in the first place? If you had an hour to call the taxi company and still arrive in time, presumably, you had more than enough time.

I know there are reasons for not going with public transport, but preferring to take a taxi/uber when a train line can get you there in time maybe has more to say about public transport than about taxis. Well functioning rail is typically one of the most effective and reliable way of getting to an airport, and often much cheaper than taxis.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by godot on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:48AM (#42974746)
Not OP but many many reasons. If you have the money and you prefer comfort (and/or have kids along) taking a taxi/uber/etc. is much more preferable than dragging several (probably heavy) luggages up and down platforms (elevators may or may not work), walking long paths, etc. especially when you consider the alternative is simply putting luggages in a trunk, sit down and relax, and most likely get there faster. And all of this is before we even talk about any safety issues with BART.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rangestransform on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:59PM (#42977414)
I refuse to take public transit with a checked bag until the NYC subway has 99.9% escalator uptime and escalators at every station, realistically possible with redundant escalators. We will never have nice things as long as we let the trade unions bend us over
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ryandrake on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:16PM (#42976356)
I’ve waited an hour for a Lyft while driver after driver accepted then canceled the ride. Ridesharing does not have great reliability either.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by potato3732842 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:46AM (#42973983)
The price people are willing to pay sets how nice a cab fleet can be while still turning a profit.

Same reason you don't see landscaping crews filled out with stellar employees.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by oremolten on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:58AM (#42974138)
It does always seem like a race to the bottom.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cratermoon on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:53AM (#42974080)
> What's interesting is that in many cities now, Uber and Lyft are in fact more expensive than taxis. And the experience is equally mediocre.

That, of course, was the plan all along. Such august figures as JP Morgan, Cornelius Vanderbilt, John D. Rockefeller,and Andrew Carnegie all made their fortune by undercutting the competition, putting them out of business through means legal and otherwise, and finally monopolizing the markets. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robber_baron_(industrialist)

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:57PM (#42976149)
It's not really that surprising when the cities are passing laws to try to turn Uber back into the taxi cartel by e.g. making it harder for them to use part-time and on-demand contract drivers. The way you get the price down is by reducing friction, increasing flexibility and supply and taking advantage of efficiencies like people willing to do a dozen rides a week during surge pricing without making it a full-time job. Pass bad laws that make things more rigid and they get more expensive.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by immibis on Saturday February 08, 2025 @05:04AM (#42981877)
You think that workers having certainty of their work hours is a bad law? What are your work hours?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:34AM (#42988921)
Forcing them to have certainty? Yeah, that's a bad law that screws over the workers. There are people who are at home doing chores or making stuff for Etsy or doing some other contract work who would like to leave the app open and then accept a fare whenever there is one, or would like to open the app to see if anyone else would pay them for a trip they were going to make themselves anyway, regardless of whether the app can guarantee back to back fares.

Instead, laws like that cause Uber to set their hours and then they can't switch on and off whenever they please and have to work miserable graveyard shifts or split shifts if that's what they're assigned.

Meanwhile there is nothing stopping anyone from taking a job with contractually guaranteed hours if that's what they want. There are plenty of jobs like that, you don't have to mandate all jobs be like that and screw over anyone who wants something different.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rangestransform on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:02PM (#42977435)
Last time I used curb, the cabbie told me that the curb payment wasn’t working and I had to Zelle him, ended up needing to report the driver to Curb to get my money back. Shoulda taken an uber!
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mschuster91 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:47AM (#42974741)
The solution to that would not have been rabid capitalism just bulldozing over laws because the laws suck and further entrenching that "laws only matter for the poor".

The solution to the pre-Uber state of the taxi industry would be to actually have the regulations authorities enforce the regulation. But it seems across the Western world that having regulations authorities do their job and regulate is like the devil and holy water.

Additionally, in some cases the regulations themselves were crap.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Domenic_S on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:42PM (#42975335)
Let's not pretend that the taxi situation was hunkey-dory before big-bad-tech came onto the scene. There's no regulation that says if I call dispatch to request a taxi one has to show up, and "we'll pick you up when we pick you up" was (and is still) a common mode of operation.

In NYC, it was (is?) against the law to hail a black car on the street, even if they were sitting there ready willing and able to drive you, because the taxi cartel got _regulations_ to make it that way.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mschuster91 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:51PM (#42977341)
> In NYC, it was (is?) against the law to hail a black car on the street, even if they were sitting there ready willing and able to drive you, because the taxi cartel got _regulations_ to make it that way.

That's precisely what I meant with "in some cases the regulations themselves were crap". But that doesn't imply the idea of regulation is bad - it is saying that maybe voters should make their voice clear to lawmakers and parties to get stuff changed. Regulation can only be as good or bad as the voters allow it to be.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BolexNOLA on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:39PM (#42975976)
Unfortunately now Ubers are exactly the same experience but more expensive/unpredictable. It’s only nicer if you spend more on black and such, which makes it easily double a standard cab fare.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by consteval on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:13PM (#42979010)
The problem with Uber is that it's a lose-lose-lose money pit scenario.

Customers pay significantly more, drivers make significantly less, and Uber is still running hundreds of millions in the red. Turns out hiring thousands of devs and dumping absurd capital into... driving people around... doesn't really work.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rzz3 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @02:37AM (#42981232)
You should look at what’s going on in Cancun Mexico with Uber and the taxis right now. Your description in the first sentence is quite accurate.

Your comment also points out the power that regulation has to enforce and protect monopolies. I’m not saying all regulation is bad obviously, but I think we can see exactly what effect it had on the taxi industry, and I’m sure glad that Uber managed to disrupt it.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by buran77 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:58AM (#42972563)
The reason is that everyone who was supposed to do something about it was "subsidized with VC money".
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by grepfru_it on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:34AM (#42972995)
Or in Ubers case, used to actively hinder those doing the investigation
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by _heimdall on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:12AM (#42973529)
Speed had a lot to do with this as well.

VC funding allowed them to move quickly enough that they got to a scale where they could afford legal and lobbying protection when challenges eventually happened.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by lupusreal on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:09PM (#42975001)
Part of the reason Airbnb got a pass must be how profitable it was to people who own many properties, despite the harm it does to the communities of people who only own one property.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by harrison_clarke on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:41AM (#42973902)
shouldn't there be a lot of political will from the traditional hotels and taxis, and their lawyers? i can see that the answer is "no", but i don't know why

especially with hotels, i would have expected there to be small enough oligopoly to overcome the freerider problem (taxis are more regional, so i don't expect them to be able to fight an (inter)national company very easily)

plus the president owning a hotel chain

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by lupusreal on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:15PM (#42975056)
There are a lot more people who own a few properties as investments than there are hotel owners. Even if these people don't plan to rent through Airbnb, the way Airbnb distorts the housing market is still beneficial for their investments. Also, by the time Trump became president Airbnb was already entrenched for years.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rangestransform on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:07PM (#42977488)
> shouldn't there be a lot of political will from the traditional hotels and taxis, and their lawyers?

Yes there is, I am reminded of this every time I take an uber by the yellow cab medallion buyout fee that I’m charged because of the lobbying power of the TLC lobby in NYC

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by umanwizard on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:11AM (#42974282)
Taxis and hotels suck compared to Airbnb and uber even at the same price, so I find it hard to be upset.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by hylaride on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:52AM (#42973251)
The traditional taxi industry was rife with corruption, bad experiences, and poor service in many jurisdictions before uber/lyft. As terrible of a human being that I think Travis Kalanick is, it was only going to take lawbreaking to overcome such a tainted system.

Medallion systems often prevented any competition, sometimes to absurd effect. The number of licenced taxis often didn't keep pace with population growth, sometimes even staying flat. Many drivers didn't own their own medallians then had to rent from owners, often making little money. In my city (Toronto) cabs were often dirty, broken, refused short distance fares (illegal) and smelled of cigarette smoke that was obviously from the driver.

Examples (paywalls, but you get the idea):

https://www.nytimes.com/1992/07/26/nyregion/amid-a-heritage-...

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-drive/adventure/red-li...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nayuki on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:21AM (#42973669)
Moreover, I believe Uber fundamentally solved two problems with taxis:

The driver can't scam the passenger. The driver can't set the meter wrong, drive an unnecessarily long route, or just be an outright unlicensed taxi. Instead, the driver maintains a relationship with Uber, and the passenger can preview the fare before committing.

The passenger can't scam the driver. In a traditional taxi, you could theoretically just walk out ("dine and dash" style). The passenger can also make a call to dispatch and not show up for the ride. Instead, the passenger maintains a relationship with Uber, and the driver doesn't need to handle any payments.

> Medallion systems often prevented any competition, sometimes to absurd effect. The number of licenced taxis often didn't keep pace with population growth, sometimes even staying flat.

And thus medallion owners collect economic rent on their artificially scarce resource, distorting the free market. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_rent

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by andrewaylett on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:02AM (#42974195)
Meanwhile, in places with sensible rules about taxis and private hire, the only thing that Uber did was make it easier for people to break the rules. And rack up an enormous tax bill that they somehow believed they'd be able to get out of paying.

https://www.londonreconnections.com/2021/uber-loses-appeal-a...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cratermoon on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:56AM (#42974112)
> The driver can't scam the passenger

> The passenger can't scam the driver.

Progress! Uber scams both passenger and driver. Hooray for Free Markets™!

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nayuki on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:15AM (#42974333)
> Uber scams both passenger and driver.

Then why do people keep using it? It seems like a pretty transactional relationship to me. If drivers aren't getting paid as much as they wanted, they should find another job with a higher price. If passengers are paying more than they wanted, then they should find another way to call a taxi with a lower price.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cratermoon on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:41PM (#42977253)
> they should find another way to call a taxi with a lower price.

like what? Uber's business plan was always about eliminating competition. The company successfully did so by undercutting prices, only to jack them up when they had the market to themselves. There is no Free Market Fairy way to fix that.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by umanwizard on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:13AM (#42974314)
Under what definition of “scam” is that the case?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cratermoon on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:44PM (#42977274)
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:08AM (#42973484)
It sucked, but not everywhere equally. Meanwhile, Uber rode their one-trick pony (an app), which everyone quickly replicated, all the way to upending taxi businesses worldwide, thanks to their infinite money supply letting them survive long enough in any new market to get the public behind them, which took away support from local regulators trying to keep the market from being gutted by what at this point was a multinational corporation (and technically a criminal enterprise).

Sure, taxi services aren't usually known to be paragons of virtue, but then they weren't that bad everywhere; Uber is just another case of an US org trying to address an US-specific problem and then bludgeoning the entire world with their solution, whether the rest of the planet has such problems or not.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ChadNauseam on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:02AM (#42974192)
That seems a little dramatic. They never forced anyone to take an uber right? If taxis were so amazing in other countries why would anyone be interested in switching to uber?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mrguyorama on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:19PM (#42975093)
Uber was able to subsidize prices, that's why.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by theshackleford on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:54PM (#42975479)
> It sucked, but not everywhere equally.

Ok, but “everywhere” isn’t my problem. They sucked everywhere I had to use one which is my problem.

> they weren’t that bad everywhere

They were beyond a joke where I am from, which is not the US. Even today, they remain a worse option.

> US specific problem

There was nothing US specific about it.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by slices on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:01AM (#42973374)
I've never been a huge user of either, but my worst Uber ride was much better than my best taxi ride.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ses1984 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:22AM (#42973681)
The last time I dragged my family into a taxi because of my anti Uber ideology, the driver stank to hell of body odor, asked me to input directions on his phone covered with dried snot from him sneezing with his mouth open, he drove dangerously under the speed limit on the freeway, and it took twice as long to get home as normal.

But at least I didn’t give Uber any money…

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by derektank on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:40AM (#42973892)
I'm immediately reminded of the Slavoj Zizek quote,

"I already am eating from the trashcan all the time. The name of this trashcan is ideology"

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jamespo on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:34AM (#42973819)
Strange, my last Uber driver had BO. Normally they are fine however.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by harrison_clarke on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:48AM (#42974005)
in my experience, taxi quality varies wildly depending on where you are

in bay area, it absolutely makes sense to invent uber, because the taxis were awful. and in vancouver (canada), they're also awful, and deserve the disruption: they would often tell you it'd be a 40 minute wait, and then just not show up

taxis in new york were and continue to be totally fine. you just stand outside and get in ~20 seconds later, with no hassles or apps. i've been in an uber/lyft a handful of times in nyc, but they're just worse (possibly cheaper, but the subway also gives them stiff competition, and i don't care that much if i'm in enough of a hurry to take a cab)

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by selectodude on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:56AM (#42974115)
>taxis in new york were and continue to be totally fine. you just stand outside and get in ~20 seconds later, with no hassles or apps

Unless you weren't white, or you wanted to leave Manhattan (or even go north of 96th street). Otherwise, yeah I guess they were okay.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by umanwizard on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:15AM (#42974345)
> taxis in new york were and continue to be totally fine. you just stand outside and get in ~20 seconds later, with no hassles or apps.

This is only true in a small subset of New York.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by dboreham on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:57PM (#42979956)
When it's not raining.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by avidiax on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:53PM (#42975449)
Vancouver was a great example of the corruption inherent in monopolies. Vancouver had neither Lyft nor Uber until 2020. I heard (internally, when I used to work for Uber) that the reason is that some politicians there had a personal stake in the taxis, so they got a $50 minimum fare passed for all booked rides.

The thing that Uber and Lyft really provided was a surveillance economy to keep both the drivers and riders somewhat in-line. Without it, every ride is an almost anonymous one-shot transaction with almost no recourse on one side, so the game theory suggests that service only has to be good enough that the police aren't called.

https://www.urbanyvr.com/uber-lyft-vancouver-launches/

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mapt on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:35AM (#42973012)
Is it? Really?

Or is it just "illegal" for an overseas competitor to a domestic industry, in trade disputes?

What is the fine? How many days in jail does the company spend? What portion is its stock diluted by?

We remember the tale of Jeff Bezouis the Wise, who tragically lost his company when he decided he didn't want to buy diapers.com at the offered price, and instead wanted to dump 200 million dollars into selling diapers well below cost until their site folded.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by hammock on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:44AM (#42973126)
You're right. Dumping refers to international trade. I believe parent commenter was thinking of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AnthonyMouse on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:26PM (#42975158)
> The reason there was no political will to punish Airbnb and Uber for violating the law was that initially they were subsidized with VC money and so were able to undercut traditional hotels and taxis on price.

That's just a trope. They were initially losing money because they had high fixed costs (developing a platform, spending enough on advertising to get a critical mass of people using it), which are long-term investments. If you only spread the cost of the long-term investment over the short-term sales, they were "losing money" in the early years, but that's how all long-term investments work.

Dumping is when you sell below the unit cost, e.g. paying drivers more than you charge customers, which isn't what they were doing in general. And as long as they weren't doing that, the incumbents could have responded by lowering their own prices (and therefore margins) without themselves losing money on each sale, which is competition working as intended. Unless the competition is too hidebound to accept a reduction in profits in order to stay competitive or otherwise insists on using a less efficient method of operating, in which case they go under.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AlexCoventry on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:32PM (#42979503)
Uber is still undercutting taxis in Boston, FWIW. I looked up a ride on Curb (a taxi app) and Uber today, and the prices were $17 and $12, respectively.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by elzbardico on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:16PM (#42979732)
Every time we talk about VC money in the last 20 years, we’re really talking about a wealth transfer from workers and the middle class to the rich via the Cantillon Effect. Cheap money enters the system through banks, funds, and corporations, not through wages. The people who get access to it first (asset holders, investors, VCs) deploy it into equities, real estate, and startups before inflation devalues the currency for everyone else.

Post-2008, ZIRP and QE pumped trillions into financial markets, making capital nearly free for those who could borrow at scale. That money didn’t go into raising wages; it went into inflating asset prices. If you owned stocks or real estate, you got richer. If you earned a paycheck, you watched housing and living costs go up while your wages stagnated.

VC was one of the biggest beneficiaries. With bonds yielding nothing, institutional investors had to chase returns, flooding venture funds with capital. That’s how we got an era of insane startup valuations, SoftBank-style mega-funds, and entire sectors built on free money. Growth-at-all-costs became the norm because the cost of capital was effectively zero.

Then COVID hit, and the Fed doubled down—more QE, more stimulus, even lower rates. Another massive wealth transfer. Money printer go brrr, asset prices moon, and suddenly we have SPACs, meme stocks, and a startup funding frenzy. Meanwhile, workers got a couple of stimulus checks, and by the time the dust settled, everything from rent to food to cars was way more expensive.

Now AI companies are running the same playbook that cloud megascalers ran before them—monetizing open-source work while locking out the people who actually built it. Cloud providers took open-source databases, infrastructure, and developer tools, turned them into managed services, and extracted billions in profit without meaningfully compensating the people who did the work. AI companies are now doing the same thing—scraping open-source repositories, academic papers, and public datasets, building models upon it then slapping on proprietary fine-tuning and charging for API access all the while blatantly raising capital by promising to make the same workers they stole from obsolte. All of it built on the backs of researchers, engineers, and artists who never see a dime, but also on the backs of everyone else via the cantillon effect.

Now rates go up, the bubble deflates, and who gets left holding the bag? Not the VCs who cashed out early. Not the bankers who took their fees. It’s the workers, the middle class, the open-source devs, and the late-stage startup employees who thought they had something real. The cycle repeats.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by pdntspa on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:45AM (#42974712)
This has always been the case. Laws are only as good as their enforcement. This is why the business class is so aggressive about tearing down regulation until they can wield it as a weapon. Do as I say, not as I do, etc etc

If you as an individual can prevent the enforcement of a law, or be sure that it will not be enforced against you, then it does not apply to you.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by deegles on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:51AM (#42974053)
I've also heard the term "regulatory arbitrage" to describe this.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by turtlesdown11 on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:58PM (#42976165)
its a term used to describe "corporate criminal acts" yes
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cpursley on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:45AM (#42973150)
The hotel and taxi industry were legit terrible before those two disrupted them.

Laws are ment to be broken. Especially in cronist systems where incumbents write the laws.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 999900000999 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:10AM (#42973505)
Hotels were just fine.

Taxis were discriminatory and "uncool" to the point were Uber has saved thousands by preventing drunk driving.

Now if you go out with the boys and get drunk, it's a 30 second casual call to get an Uber and get home.

Live in a neighborhood Taxis are afraid to service,you can either make some extra income working for Uber or use it yourself. When Ubers used as its intended purpose, to basically make a quick buck, it's a lifeline to many low income people .

Say your rents it's going to be late, you can pick up 20 or 30 hours of Uber this month to make it happen. It's not really a career though...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Marsymars on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:48AM (#42974020)
> Say your rents it's going to be late, you can pick up 20 or 30 hours of Uber this month to make it happen.

Maybe... I really don't get how the economics work out here though. If you look at the numbers, it mostly just seems like you're converting car equity into cash via depreciation.

But also, I'd guess that for a big chunk of people who are going to have trouble paying rent with any regularity, they'd have to overpay for their car in the first place to get something that's Uber-appropriate. My car's a couple years too old for Uber now, but is still perfectly functional, and there's just no way the math would work for me to buy a newer car so that I can convert its capital cost into cash via Uber.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 4ggr0 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:22AM (#42973673)
> Say your rents it's going to be late, you can pick up 20 or 30 hours of Uber this month to make it happen

that sounds so incredibly dystopian, not sure if that was the intention :(

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by verall on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:38AM (#42973880)
It's super dystopian and it creates bad incentives (the harder the underclass is squeezed the better a product it is for the middle class), but I have to agree that gig work is often a lifeline for poor people.

I consider it similar to access to unsecured credit that way - it's easy to feel like "wow this industry is scamming these people it should be illegal" but people without any other backstop will probably need access to unsecured credit sometime and it's better than losing their house/car/job/pet/family etc..

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gardnr on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:00AM (#42974167)
maintaining a precarious class benefits those in power
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 999900000999 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:32AM (#42973795)
I forgot to mention, Jitney cabs( unlicensed cabs primarily serving minority neighborhoods)came long before Ubers. They're more of less gone now though.

What's better. Taking out a 300% APR payday loan, getting evicted or working an extra 20, 30 hours of Uber.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BrandonM on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:35AM (#42973828)
Maybe to you, but I was broke during and shortly after college. If I could have picked up some gig work when I needed it, that would have been a huge help.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by __loam on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:20AM (#42974406)
The level of casual criminality in this industry is astounding sometimes.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by dboreham on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:00AM (#42973357)
Not terrible everywhere.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by classified on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:10AM (#42973500)
That's what makes a banana republic, and for all intents and purposes the U.S. are exhibit A.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by infamouscow on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:38AM (#42974637)
The purpose of having an executive branch of government is explicitly to apply the law based on subjective opinions.

There's no purpose of having an executive branch of government separate from the other two branches if not to cushion the inflexible and glacial nature of the other branches of government.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mrguyorama on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:23PM (#42975127)
>The purpose of having an executive branch of government is explicitly to apply the law based on subjective opinions.

What? No, the purpose of having a separate executive is separation of powers and checks and balances.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by infamouscow on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:27PM (#42975842)
You haven't explained why there is an executive branch in the first place.

Why does the executive branch exist at all if it's simply to enforce written law?

Why do we elect the executive at all if they are merely to enforce written law?

Why do executives have the power to pardon someone when a court of law finds a person guilty of breaking law?

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Dylan16807 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:22PM (#42977026)
> Why does the executive branch exist at all if it's simply to enforce written law?

Someone has to be in charge of enforcing things.

> Why do we elect the executive at all if they are merely to enforce written law?

Do you have a suggestion of another way to do it that doesn't put congress in charge?

Also the president has some other very important roles.

> Why do executives have the power to pardon someone when a court of law finds a person guilty of breaking law?

That one is definitely subjective by its nature, but also the average number of pardons is around two thousand, a very small fraction of cases.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mrguyorama on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:56PM (#42977379)
The executive exists to enforce the law the legislature writes primarily to make sure the legislature isn't in charge of enforcing the laws. It's a check on the power of the legislature.

You could still have discretion with the legislature in charge of executing on their own laws. I think countries exist like that, but I don't know enough to say which.

A separate executive is not necessary to have discretion or pardons or flexibility in law. A separate executive is necessary if you want physically different human beings controlling the organizations who enforce the law (DOJ, FBI, etc)

Consider that Judges and the judicial branch of the government ALSO gets to use subjectivity and their own opinion in adjudicating cases. Another check.

The entire point of the Constitution was to put the power of a King in a bunch of different hands, and then tie some of those hands with specific constraints, and then give a couple different options on how to change those constraints over time. Leeway and discretion goes both ways, so Congress does have the ability to further constrain such discretion. A previous president tried to argue he could choose to not spend money congress told him to spend, so they wrote up a bill saying very clearly, Uh, no, if we say spend, you spend. They have that power as a check on the power of the executive. All three branches are ostensibly MEANT to be vying for power. It's an antagonistic system, like the court system. The founders loved that shit. In reality, it probably is a dysfunctional system that modern systems engineers would not like, and other countries get that "system fights and moderates itself" effect by encouraging coalitions between parties in a strong parliament. IMO those have demonstrated better stability. I'm not convinced the US would have survived getting it's whole shit blown up like the UK did.

Checks. And. Balances. 5th grade civics class.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by CamperBob2 on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:41PM (#42975318)
Airbnb and Uber have showed us that laws matter only to the extent that the political will to enforce them exists.

Laws matter to the extent that they don't interfere with actual progress. Laws that would have prevented the LLMs we have today from being developed should be ignored, as should laws requiring us to pay tribute to taxi and hotel cartels.

Respect for the law is going to be an increasingly-hard sell going forward, and that's mostly the lawmakers' own fault. When the law does not respect the people, the people will not respect the law.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by censorfree on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:43AM (#42972415)
>This is exactly what I immediately thought while reading the article. It almost feels like the legal system only punishes general public, while most of these guys are above it.

Welcome to the modern day aristocracy. Not only what you mentioned, this world is also divided into a group of insider who can get capital from 0 - 2%, while rest of us has a cost of 17%, 22% or 30%?

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jeffwask on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:13AM (#42972721)
Welcome to the two-tier legal system of the modern world. Why obey the law when the penalty is a rounding error?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ossobuco on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:43AM (#42973119)
It's an oligarchy, always has been. I don't know how colossal the pile of evidence supporting this has to get before people finally accept it.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by rixed on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:32AM (#42974576)
Conscious life in general seems possible to me unless our brain tells us a better story than reality.

A story in which we are the hero, in which we are not mortal, in which we are important, in which people care about us, in which we are intelligent and our perceptions rarely fail us, in which our life has a meaning and also in which the social game we play is determined, or at least influenced, by some just principles. We would despair if we were aware of the full extent of our meaninglessness and powerlessness.

I believe that it is the core reason why we love to believe that God/Nature is good, that the king is legitimate and that the laws are fair.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 52-6F-62 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:03AM (#42973401)
They are paid, handsomely, by it. Or otherwise brainwashed by it. And pummelled into ignorance by it, as they are told that to understand is stupid or delusional, knowledge ends at STEM, and the world only exists for efficient production of capital products.

The poets write laments about such false ages. Prophecies were written about such ages thousands of years ago.

The cycles are larger than us all.

One stable insight is that the chaos breeds possibility, and thus hope. In the meantime, however…

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by meeech on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:59AM (#42973336)
At this point, I think it's safe to say it doesn't 'feel' that way. It is that way. Sorry if you were being facetious and I didn't pick up on it.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gscott on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:59AM (#42973348)
It is more a money thing. Meta can pay x billion like pocket change. Regular people are run through the ringer to teach the plebs to not get out of line.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jmount on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:24AM (#42973697)
They may have just been the friendly step A. We didn't end up seeing where that was going to go.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nico on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:26AM (#42973724)
> the legal system only punishes general public, while most of these guys are above it

It’s because the legal system is not about justice, it’s about money

Most people can’t afford lawyers or expensive legal battles

On the other hand, individuals and organizations with a lot of money get to weaponize and exploit the legal system to their advantage

“To my friends, anything; to my enemies, the law”

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by btown on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:49AM (#42974021)
At the risk of wading into politics - consider a legal environment, in any country, where laws become increasingly strict, but where prosecutorial discretion, pardon powers, and a justice system designed to allow well-resourced law firms to delay cases indefinitely, are all transparently used for political purposes. Such an environment could easily exhibit a feedback loop that allows justice to be arbitrary and opposition voices to be silenced.

I'll refrain from value judgments on the above - but for heaven's sake, we're on a site called "Hacker News." We should understand that a machine like this could turn on any one of us in an instant for any reason.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by devwastaken on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:27AM (#42973733)
if you get a group of people and call it an llc then criminal elements are largely eliminated.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by bmitc on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:34AM (#42973825)
It's not a feeling. It's exactly what happens. It's completely blatant.

For some reason, whenever you're a billionaire or company, things suddenly get so difficult that you can claim that it's impossible to be held accountable for anything. Murder, insider trading, laundering, treason, etc.

OpenAI complained about this, as did Google and everyone else. If your company can't exist without stealing data, then it's not a viable company. Companies don't have a constitutional right to exist.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TZubiri on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:50AM (#42974043)
How so? It is still illegal if meta does it, they will face trial.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by yoyohello13 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:04AM (#42974214)
It's not "almost" like that. The legal system IS that.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by kordlessagain on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:29AM (#42974540)
When individuals are assigned heroic status despite clear evidence of mental illness and crimes, such as “breaking and entering”, it prevents society from having rational discussions about both law enforcement and mental health support. This dynamic repeats across multiple high-profile cases.

People often elevate deeply flawed figures to heroic status when those figures seem to challenge authority or "the system." This happens especially with individuals who present themselves as outsiders fighting the establishment, have a compelling personal struggle narrative, or voice grievances that resonate with public frustrations

Trump fits this pattern - his supporters overlook concerning behaviors and statements because they see him as fighting a system they distrust. Like Manning and Swartz, his mental state and fitness are often ignored in favor of the "hero against the system" narrative.

This dynamic creates a feedback loop where legitimate criticism becomes harder to discuss rationally.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jimmySixDOF on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:33AM (#42974579)
> MIT

I think Aaron Swartz went to Harvard, not MIT

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by xemoka on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:36AM (#42974614)
Yes, he went to Harvard; the laptop was plugged in at MIT using his Harvard Fellow credentials to access JSTOR.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by quaintdev on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:39AM (#42974642)
I read the same thing earlier today on Reddit, weird!
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by arp242 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:48AM (#42974745)
If you do something wrong then you, as a person, are held responsible and accountable.

If you do something wrong as "part of your job" then you're typically not held responsible and accountable but the company is (the exceptions being spectacular fraud: Enron, VW diesel).

It's not hard to see how this can go off the rails.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by toomuchtodo on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:08PM (#42974987)
“The revolution will be incorporated.”
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by artyom on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:40PM (#42978785)
> the legal system only punishes general public.

In more general terms, the legal system punishes what can be made a profit or an example when punishing.

Also, I don't think the legal system itself wants to get too much into "big institutions against the work of others", save for the fictional TV representations of smart lawyers and clever arguments, 99.9% of the legal system output is copy/paste.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by bayindirh on Saturday February 08, 2025 @06:42AM (#42982288)
As Venus Theory elaborates the issue on his video [0]:

"This problem will be solved in the favor of the (party) which has the most money to throw into the problem" (paraphrase mine).

So, yeah.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrkAORPiaEA

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Wowfunhappy on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:56AM (#42972018)
> Based on the encyclopedic knowledge LLMs have of written works I assume all parties did the same.

I don't understand why you wouldn't just buy copies of the books. Seems like such a relatively inexpensive way to strengthen your legal case.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jokethrowaway on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:14AM (#42972147)
Buying the books won't automatically give you permission to use the content commercially
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gosub100 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:13AM (#42972143)
thanks to the byzantine copyright system, you can't easily do it. Plus, just speculating, but maybe by paying, it establishes "consideration" for some implied contract? "You implicitly entered a contract with us by purchasing the book, then violated the contract by 'distributing' the material for commercial use" ?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by almatabata on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:14PM (#42976325)
There must be a publisher out there that forbids you from training an AI on the copy you buy from them by now.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cess11 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:07AM (#42972108)
Too much paperwork, too much effort. These are important people, doing much more important stuff than whatever book authors do.

Or so they think, I think.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:44AM (#42973959)
I doubt they think that way, but even if they did, they'd be right - for 99% of the works in question, the biggest value they gave to the world is, by far, being part of the LLM training corpus.

There's lots of content out there. Most of it is noise. People forget because they're only ever exposed to an aggressively curated fraction of it.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cess11 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:24AM (#42974470)
No, it's not.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by londons_explore on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:25AM (#42972245)
Pretty sure that even if you gave a purchasing team enough money for retail price and a list of all books ever published, they wouldn't be able to buy even a quarter of them.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by oblio on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:33AM (#42972324)
Plus some people will just not sell at any price.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by freeone3000 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:41AM (#42972393)
Buying a copy of the book doesn’t grant you the right to copy it. That is what copyright is for.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by qup on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:56AM (#42973300)
It grants you the right to read & study it though.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:42AM (#42973918)
The right to read and study you have by default. It's getting your hands on a book that has legal caveats attached.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by qup on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:54AM (#42974086)
Yes, but getting your hands on the material isn't a very interesting legal question IMO.

Whether you can train your LLM on it is a very interesting question.

I've personally never been in favor of punishing people for downloading (or seeding) things.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:57AM (#42974133)
One which buying books for your LLM doesn't answer either. In analogy to humans, you might as well give your LLM a library card.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ivell on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:45AM (#42973144)
They might even have gotten away with legitimate use argument if it was not seeded.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jml7c5 on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:36PM (#42975935)
Anna's Archive has 40 million books and 100 million papers. It's unlikely they could achieve similar coverage.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ysofunny on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:28AM (#42971823)
the english empire once tried to mantain a monopoly over steam loom machines

the americans cheated their way to competition,

heck, even before that, the english empire got jumpstarted by stealing gold from the spanish (who were themselves exploiting it away from aztec and other mexican natives)

I'm saying it's business as usual, but also, culture doesn't work like tangible physical widgets so we must stop letting a few steal this boon of digital copying by means of silly ideas like DRM, copyright, patents. all means to cause scarcity

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by choult on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:33AM (#42971845)
Hollywood became popular for filmmaking because they were literally the opposite side of the country from Thomas Edison and his patents...
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by anotherhue on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:29AM (#42972281)
That and the predictable weather (old film needs lots of light).
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by kristianp on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:09PM (#42977504)
This is interesting, is it really true?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by emporas on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:29PM (#42979817)
United Kingdom was the first to steal a Chinese invention called gunpowder, use it to maximum effect and they were also at the opposite sides of the world.

Do not forget the first law passed by a new nation in which every citizen has the right to burn trees and produce potassium a critical mineral in gunpowder. That nation was either Greece or America, i forget which one.

In the Western civilizations, when we are stealing copyrighted material and patents we are not messing around. I remember when the Byzantine empire tried to steal secrets of silk production also from Chinese, that was so much fun. Great times we lived in the past, even greater now!

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by miltonlost on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:37AM (#42971877)
People criming in the past is not an excuse for companies committing crimes today. You’re excusing lawlessness.

Cain killed Abel and got away with it!! I can kill someone today too!!!

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by appreciatorBus on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:04AM (#42972076)
I think it’s fine to criticize the hypocrisy of viciously defending the copyrights you own, while gleefully running roughshod over the ones you don’t.

But it’s also possible that copyright as a concept, or in its current implementation, is bad and unjust.

I’m sure some copyright holders would like nothing more than to see an argument that elevates copyright violation to the level of murder, morally or legally. But I think it’s more akin to jaywalking - violating an unjust law that mostly shouldn’t exist.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by CptFribble on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:16AM (#42972758)
the reform needs to happen at the layer where whether a copyright is valid or not is decided upon, not before (at the point of "should copyright exist") and not after (enforcement).

a world without copyright means those with the largest advertising budgets will reap nearly all the rewards from new IP created by small artists. BigCorp Inc. can just sit around and wait for talented musicians to post something interesting on soundcloud, for example, then just have their in-house people copy it and push it out to radio and streaming platforms via their massive ad budgets and favorable relationships for getting new material onto the waves immediately. meanwhile the original artist gets nothing.

the position of advocating against all copyright protections at all only makes sense for people who are already wealthy enough that they don't need proceeds from their art to survive.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by brookst on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:35AM (#42973008)
I don’t think this is true. At least in music, bands make far more money from touring and merch than they do from music sales.

If copyright disappeared altogether, most smaller artists would be just fine because they have loyal fans and adjacent monetization strategies.

See: Grateful Dead. They did just fine despite encouraging infringement of IP.

IMO copyright mostly serves to protect the very biggest artists and companies, not the small ones.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gmokki on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:10AM (#42973504)
I think the point was that the big corporations get the money from selling music.

And saying that bands currently make more money from touring kind of proves the point. They get too low % cut of music sales.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:31AM (#42973791)
But the point of the response is that "getting money from selling music" is, in digital era, artificial scarcity. I.e. the copyright laws that big corporations are lobbying for continued enforcement and tightening, are the very thing that create this artificial scarcity that they are best positioned to profit off.

Cut out copyright, and no one will be getting any money from selling music per copy (or equivalent) - as it should be.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by CptFribble on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:51PM (#42976096)
digital music is not artificial scarcity, because it's not the copied bits that are the resource, it's attention. we only have so much time and attention for consuming media, and only so much attention and memory space in our brains for keeping track of where to find it. large budgets can easily dominate these channels and limit the average person's apparent choice.

this is what I mean when large players would outcompete smaller players in a digital marketplace with no copyright. the only way for this to work would be with a benevolent neutral 3rd party managing the marketplace, like Steam, so users can easily see when a large player is cloning a smaller players work - but even then it still depends on the good will of the general public to prefer the "original" artist which is not guaranteed.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by brookst on Saturday February 08, 2025 @11:42AM (#42984165)
Are you talking about mere distribution? In that case, a few large players leveraging scale to drive costs down to near zero sounds great.

I’m still not seeing how lack of copyright hurts small artists or consumers. Small distributors, maybe, but that’s not doing harm to the arts.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by appreciatorBus on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:43PM (#42978367)
> the position of advocating against all copyright protections at all only makes sense for people who are already wealthy enough that they don't need proceeds from their art to survive.

This makes it sound like the majority of people produce more content than they consume.

The reality is that 99.99999% of people do not produce "art", let alone with the intention of living of it.

Whatever harms you might envision for the tiny minority who do want to try living off copyright, those concerns are dwarfed by the benefits for the rest of us.

Further, not many people who are serious about reform are literally "advocating against all copyright" A reform that simply curbed the duration to something less insane than 150 years would resolve much of what makes copyright bad, even if it continued to exist.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by fortran77 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:08AM (#42972113)
Cain was severely punished.

וְעַתָּ֖ה אָר֣וּר אָ֑תָּה מִן־הָֽאֲדָמָה֙ אֲשֶׁ֣ר פָּצְתָ֣ה אֶת־פִּ֔יהָ לָקַ֛חַת אֶת־דְּמֵ֥י אָחִ֖יךָ מִיָּדֶֽךָ׃ Therefore, you shall be more cursed than the ground, which opened its mouth to receive your brother’s blood from your hand.

https://www.sefaria.org/Genesis.4.12

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by miltonlost on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:16AM (#42972158)
Jack the Ripper killed people and got away with it!!! Happy?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by fortran77 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:24AM (#42972239)
Better! Thanks.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by roenxi on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:29AM (#42972288)
But the crime is creating something new. If laws are enforced that criminalise creation, then the world will be rather static.

It seems to be a consistent direction of history's arc that the people who make it easy to create and innovate get ahead.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by miltonlost on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:40AM (#42972382)
We don’t allow indiscriminate human experimentation in medicine. We have crimes against this, and yet we still have new medicines. Sure, it won’t be as quick if we could just use humans as test subjects from the start, but that’s an unethical line. Innovation done immorally is progress that shouldn’t have been made. The ends don’t justify the means, but I’m not an ethical nihilist.

The crime is downloading and copying and distributing copyrighted materials! Not creating the LLM! Get the crime right

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by roenxi on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:08AM (#42972673)
Those medical policies have condemned thousands, possibly millions, to lives of unnecessary pain and suffering. They're more damaging than copyright.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:36AM (#42974607)
You actually don’t know that. The question would be, what proportion of human experiments are successful, and you don’t know the answer to that question, so the victims of experiments could dwarf the beneficiaries of successful research. That’s always the hard thing with basic utilitarianism.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by roenxi on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:08PM (#42979358)
1) It is an experiment. The point is to test something that nobody is sure about. Whether the result is expected or unexpected there isn't really such a thing as "unsuccessful"; even duplication of work is considered useful.

2) If you think the cost-benefits are bad, my advice is don't sign up to be experimented on. Nobody has to be experimented on if they don't want to be.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:01PM (#42979662)
1) Experiments, by their nature, must spend resources in order to produce tangible results. In this case the relevant results are saved lives, and the expenditure is often going to be lives. You framed your comment in these terms, I’m arguing the costs very well may not be justifiable by the benefits. You’d need to make a case for that.

2) What if the families of experimentees receive payment? Allowing that would be a short way down the slippery slope from allowing the experimentation, and would make the matter of consent more difficult to assess.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by miltonlost on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:15AM (#42972746)
Ok, I’ll go tell the Nazis that their medical experiments using live humans were A-OK!!!
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nottorp on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:53AM (#42972003)
Interesting, if we're to trust what NotOpenAI and Facebook say about their IP, the US should pay the UK reparations for IP theft based on textile industry profits starting in the 1850s until today?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by portaouflop on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:51AM (#42971994)
Why do I get sued when I share some BitTorrents but $bigcorp can just do it with 1000 scale without problems?

The issue here is not copyright/patents/etc - the issue is that the law is applied selectively — the issue is that Aaron Schwartz is dead for sharing knowledge with the public and Zuccborg is a billionaire building his torment nexus

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by brookst on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:36AM (#42973029)
I mean this news broke today. It may be premature to declare that nobody will sue Meta. In fact I would cheerfully bet that someone will, and that they will spend more in defense/settlement than any 1000 individuals would.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by sebzim4500 on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:01AM (#42972597)
I don't think I've heard the term "English empire". Is it an attempt by the Scottish to pretend they weren't involved?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nkozyra on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:25AM (#42972873)
I was assuming they were talking about pre-1706 given the Spanish gold context.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by HideousKojima on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:05AM (#42972634)
Just like Austria's greatest historical accomplishment: convincing the world the Hitler was German
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 52-6F-62 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:12AM (#42973527)
Is this an attempt to imply the Scots had imperial ambitions and have not been fighting to keep their homes free of invasion for several thousand years?

Fuck this sounds familiar right now

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by sebzim4500 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:51AM (#42974060)
>Is this an attempt to imply the Scots had imperial ambitions and have not been fighting to keep their homes free of invasion for several thousand years?

Obviously yes. Who have they been fighting to avoid invasion exactly?

>Fuck this sounds familiar right now

Maybe you read it in a history textbook.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 52-6F-62 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:20PM (#42979428)
Hmm, no you misunderstand. Scotland was consumed by monied interests from across the water long ago. Now there’s just scattered populations, many of us dispossessed of our ancestral homes and not all by choice.

The past doesn’t vanish because of what Rome and its inheritors accords as history. Some of us have long memories.

It is particularly a prescient notion because I happen to be living in Canada. If you’ve read the news you should understand what I’m saying.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jodrellblank on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:43PM (#42980172)
Didn't Scotland try to make an empire in Eastern Canada, eastern USA, Africa, and Panama, then bankrupt themselves and agree to the Act of Union with England making Great Britain?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 52-6F-62 on Monday February 10, 2025 @03:51PM (#43004998)
Lol. If you call a segment of the merchant class (kind of like silicon valley) the entirety of the country and ethnic group.

But that would be a major misunderstanding. So no.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by m4rtink on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:20PM (#42975100)
The textile industry in Brno here in Czech Republic (sometimes called "Moravian Manchester") was hugely helped by a local noble posing as a worker in England & the smuggling detailed self-drawn plans of industrial machinery back:

"Brno’s fortunes were changed forever when a young freemason called Franz Hugo Salma set out for England in 1801. He intended to steal the plans for the most modern textile machinery in the world. His crime, the first recorded act of industrial espionage, boosted the competitiveness of Moravian textiles. Soon after smuggling the plans out disguised as a worker, and handing them over to Brno’s fledgling textile industry, Brno became the most important textile centre in the Habsburg empire."

You can even go see some of the original plans in a museum:

"Eleven designs are still preserved in the library of the Rájec chateau. They form a unique set of documents demonstrating both the level of wool processing technology at the turn of the late 18th and early 19th centuries, as well as the aims and means of the relatively rare business of industrial espionage at that time."

https://www.gotobrno.cz/en/brno-phenomenon/this-is-brno-kate... https://www.gotobrno.cz/en/place/salm-reifferscheidt-palace/

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by dcchambers on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:47AM (#42971980)
I guess the solution is to create a shell company for your illegal activities?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Cumpiler69 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:24AM (#42972238)
You must be new to billionaire business practices: break the rules first, ask for forgiveness later.

By the time the cheque comes, your illicit venture either went bust or you built a bilion dollar empire capable of buying the best lawyers and lobbying to walk away clean.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by georgemcbay on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:27AM (#42972264)
The modern solution has been to grow so fast that by the time anyone can go after you legally you've already amassed so much money/power that you can have the laws rewritten (or at least enforced) around your existence.

IMO part of the reason the SV tech bros are embracing right wing grift culture so publicly now is that this method, which had been serving them well for decades, doesn't really work without the infinite free money lending spigot being wide open.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cduzz on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:40AM (#42973082)
That's why you should go straight to the treasury's RSS feeds.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gnfargbl on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:37AM (#42971881)
I think if Google attempted to download the entirety of JSTOR with the express intent of making the full dataset freely available, then Google would also face legal consequences.

It's true, and relevant, that Google would feel those consequences much less sharply than Swartz did.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by vintermann on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:18AM (#42972182)
Don't buy into the rhetoric and call it "consequences". It's always a choice to sue, a choice to prosecute, and this would be true even if these choices were made consistently and impartially (which they certainly aren't).
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gnfargbl on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:02AM (#42972604)
I wasn't meaning to attach a pejorative to "consequences", but the word does typically have that meaning so you're right to call me out. Perhaps "resulting legal issues" would be a better way to put it.

For the record, I think the consequence was grossly disproportionate to the action.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by josefx on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:47AM (#42972446)
Google book search was declared fair use and copyright holders ended up having to explicitly request removal of their works.

Apparently he would have gotten away with downloading the JSTOR database if he made it clear that he intended to only publish half of each paper.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by dekhn on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:09PM (#42974993)
Google Scholar explicitly made direct deals with publishers to scrape their content, with the constraint that while they can use the content to serve search results in Scholar, but cannot show the content of the papers on the site- just titles and short fragments that match. the deals were tenuous and I had to step carefully around my plan to use that database to implement large-scale scientific search over the literature (this was a long time before anybody was seriously considering using LLMs on research data).

I've spoken to several very wealthy/powerful people and tried to get them to negotiate a large-scale content license with the various publishers that would allow researchers and individuals to access more research in lower-friction ways. None of them (NIH, Schmidt, etc) were really interested.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by pbh101 on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:21AM (#42971770)
> Google itself got big by indexing other people's data without compensation

Weird framing given how much value was and is still placed on Google driving traffic to you

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mrkeen on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:27AM (#42971820)
For Google's case the order was reversed.

Google used to send customers to your site. Now they try to show you the information on their site so that the customer doesn't need to go to your site.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by sitkack on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:23AM (#42972223)
Unless your site is an SEO cesspool serving THEIR ads, then you do end up there.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by joshstrange on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:26AM (#42971808)
Even before the LLM-craze Google was showing their Answers box or whatever it was called at the top of the results that told you the answer (sometimes) so that you didn’t have to visit any website.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by pbh101 on Monday February 10, 2025 @09:00PM (#43008114)
That was significantly after their market dominance was firmly established entirely through sending traffic to external locations.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cess11 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:06AM (#42972095)
It's roughly the Spotify story too. They had an extremely impressive catalog very early, way before they were bought by the entertainment cartel. The founders had background in torrenting and the initial product was quite similar to The Pirate Bay but with clearly capitalist ambitions and branding, in contrast to the anarchist leanings of the Pirate Bureau and rather anarchic attitude of The Pirate Bay.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by newsclues on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:17AM (#42971749)
Comprehensive intellectual property needs to happen for the modern (digital) era.

Basically the entire legal system needs to be retooled and rethought for computers.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by actionfromafar on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:32AM (#42971837)
Looks like the entire legal system is being retooled at the moment.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by threeseed on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:36AM (#42971870)
No we just need to enforce the existing laws.

And the legal system is for humans not computers.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by newsclues on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:42AM (#42971937)
The existing laws are a problem, and are not enforced in a fair and just manner.

Yes, the legal system is for humans, but we can use technology to improve the system for humans, so it's faster, better and more fair, because humans aren't perfect, and now we have technology to be better than the system create a long time ago. You don't think the legal system should run on pens and paper right? Adapting to typewriters, was a benifit to the system?

Well, video on demand, live streaming, and things like LLMs can also make the system better for humans.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nottorp on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:57AM (#42972025)
Aren't all LLMs based on models published by the big two or three, so built on IP theft and if you're using them you are guilty of handling stolen goods?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by newsclues on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:08AM (#42972115)
that's the point.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Qwertious on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:57AM (#42972543)
Plenty of the existing laws are insane and indefensible. Copyright duration of life of the author plus 70 years? Patents on videogame mechanics?

We need to both reform the laws and enforce them. Otherwise...

>The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tastyfreeze on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:24PM (#42975148)
Pantents on video game mechanics... oh how I wish this weren't true. I would love a first person adventure game with the best mechanics and controls taken from genres that did that mechanics very well.

The one that always comes to mind for me is the boxing controls from Fight Night games. It pains me a little every time I play a game where pugilistic battles come down to smash 1 or 2 buttons.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by threeseed on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:33AM (#42971846)
> Google itself got big by indexing other people's data without compensation

Wrong.

a) Robots.txt which defines what content you wish to make available to third parties predates every search engine including Google. Web site owners chose to make it available to Google and search engines have respected their wishes despite it not being in their best interest.

b) The difference here is that OpenAI, Meta etc have not even tried to honour the wishes of copyright holders. They just considered everything as theirs.

c) Google grew big because it had no ads, fast interface and PageRank was significantly better. It wasn't because it had the most comprehensive index.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by karamanolev on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:35AM (#42971867)
> Web site owners chose to make it available to Google.

Strong disagree. Since robots.txt is optional and the default is "crawl me as you please", website owners don't "choose to make it available", they just don't choose to make it non-available.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by XorNot on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:53AM (#42972005)
That's a functionally meaningless distinction. If you setup a web server that responds to requests, then you're choosing to make content available because your server can choose to not respond to requests. The entire protocol includes mechanisms to negotiate access.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by eviks on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:16AM (#42972167)
This is a meaningless simplification. In this framework "robots.txt" has no role, because your server "can choose" not to respond. Heck, even DDOS is fine, because "protocol"
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jokethrowaway on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:16AM (#42972157)
Granting access and granting right to redistribute (even just title + snippet) and use your content commercially are two completely different things.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by XorNot on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:29PM (#42977111)
And yet it is legal to produce and redistribute summaries as sufficiently transformative derivative works, and this has been court tested[1]. Of course in Australia we passed rather specific laws to the contrary, because lo and behold Rupert Murdoch wanted money and gosh darn it our government was going to give it to him[2].

[1] https://www.practicalecommerce.com/Search-Engines-Indexing-a...

[2] https://www.alrc.gov.au/publication/copyright-and-the-digita...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tobyhinloopen on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:52AM (#42971998)
a) If you don't have a robots.txt, you're indexed by default. It's opt-out, not opt-in. If you do nothing, you're being indexed.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by antiframe on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:50PM (#42975418)
It's an opt-out of an opt-in. If you run a webserver hosting your files, you already opted-in to people accessing that data. If you then don't go ahead an configure it properly, that's not exactly "opt-out" anymore. By default your files are not accessible to the network, you have to first opt-in to serving them.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tobyhinloopen on Saturday February 08, 2025 @03:44AM (#42981510)
Google makes a copy of your data and serves that data to users before they visit your site.

Also google cache allows users to get a copy of your site without visiting your site.

Why can they republish your data while we cannot? Why do we have to opt-out?

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by RALaBarge on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:35AM (#42971861)
To your first point, the op said without compensation, not without permission.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by boesboes on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:36AM (#42971869)
Wrong. Google ignores robots.txt entirely
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by threeseed on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:41AM (#42971925)
I wasn't aware. Can you please update Wikipedia then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robots.txt

Maybe also get Google to update their docs: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by phit_ on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:08AM (#42972111)
their own docs also specify that the robots.txt does not stop indexing or showing up in search, they even bolded it "it is not a mechanism for keeping a web page out of Google"

https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by alphan0n on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:48AM (#42972454)
The only way for links to appear in a Google search would be to host a public resource, that is linked from another public resource.

If you have specified in your robots.txt that you do not want the page(s) or directories ingested then only the url is indexed (if it is linked from another page). It does prevent the public display of the content of a page and creation description/summary.

https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/7489871?hl=en

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by threeseed on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:55PM (#42977373)
From the docs:

“While Google won't crawl or index the content blocked by a robots.txt file”

They will show the URL if someone else has linked to it. But the content itself is not indexed.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nottorp on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:50AM (#42971988)
It must be nice to believe everything people say by default... ;)
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by fredgrott on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:35AM (#42971866)
point c is wrong...they had ads since the original yahoo contract....
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by threeseed on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:38AM (#42971901)
Yahoo contract was 2 years after it launched.

I remember using Google the day it went public and it had no ads which made it unique compared to Altavista.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by veggieroll on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:26AM (#42972258)
Robots.txt is irrelevant after hiQ Labs v. LinkedIn (2019)
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by immibis on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:25AM (#42972252)
Something to understand about capitalist competition (also in politics) is that it's a war. Not one with guns and bombs, but more like a cold war, with espionage and hacking and just generally doing anything you can to gain an advantage without bringing negative consequences on yourself.

The limit is what you can actually get away with, not what the rules say you can get away with, and the system aggressively selects players who recognize this. It's amoral - there is no "ought", only "is". An actor gets punished or not, with absolutely no regard to whether it "should" get punished. One thing is consistent: following the rules as written means you lose.

You can see it in Y Combinator (and other) startups. The biggest ex-startups are things like AirBNB (hotels but we don't follow the rules but we don't get punished for not following them) and Uber (taxis but we don't follow the rules but we don't get punished for not following them).

One way to not get punished for not following the rules is to invent a variation of the game where the rules haven't been written yet. I again refer you to AirBNB and Uber; Omegle also comes to mind, although they didn't monetize.

Viewed in this light, Aaron Swartz's mistake was not the part where he downloaded journal articles, but the part where he got caught downloading journal articles. Shadow library sites are doing the same thing, minus the getting caught. So are Meta and Google and OpenAI. sci-hub is only involved in a lawsuit because it got caught and is now in the stage where it finds out whether it gets punished or not.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by oblio on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:35AM (#42972348)
> Something to understand about capitalist competition (also in politics) is that it's a war.

Turns out there are 2 simultaneous wars there. One where companies and individuals compete ruthlessly.

And another one where if non profit associations of individuals form, guns come out.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by bko on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:32AM (#42972314)
The thing is Google, meta and YouTube weren't giant entities when they did this stuff. I think it's good no one cracked down on them for copyright stuff. Now they're developing an LLM that will generate potentially trillions in value to humanity and looks like they're not exactly playing by the rules. But I prefer looser intellectual property rights anyway so Im ok with it
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ziddoap on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:02AM (#42972603)
>But I prefer looser intellectual property rights anyway so Im ok with it

I think more people, potentially anyways, would feel similar to to this if it applied even somewhat equally.

Instead, companies can seemingly do whatever they please whereas lawyers will send letters to your home for downloading a single episode of game of thrones.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ndriscoll on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:36AM (#42973841)
From the article, they took steps to avoid using their IP addresses. Individuals doing the same using a VPN are pretty much immune from any legal issues.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ziddoap on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:42AM (#42973934)
This is one small blip in an incredibly long history of companies being able to not care about copyright while individuals must.

Workarounds with a VPN are great and all, but they are a band-aid on a systemic problem.

(You are not immune, by the way, if your VPN company is subject to a subpoena and isn't one of very few actually no-log services)

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ndriscoll on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:48AM (#42974749)
IME companies take copyright way more seriously than individuals. e.g. my last 2 jobs have had scanners to ensure we're not accidentally pulling in GPL code to our products, and one of those was a startup. I'd be surprised if corporate security software weren't looking for torrent clients and if you wouldn't get fired for torrenting on corporate machines or networks at most companies. Meanwhile the same people setting those security policies have a 100TB array at home with fully automated pirating setups. They very much don't care personally, but it's a huge business risk.

In high school/university in the 00s, everyone casually pirated things. In college people passed around a USB drive with all of the books needed for our degree program. People in the dorms traded music collections with 10s of thousands of songs. Tellingly, Apple advertised that iPods could store 10,000 songs, which approximately zero people could afford to buy legitimately. If anything, the consequences for piracy have gone down since then, but streaming is convenient enough and phone storage/UX is hobbled enough that people pay.

In any case, I think the other poster is right that companies flouting copyright law is a good thing. It stops us from pretending that it's helpful for the little guy, making it easier to argue for abolition or vastly reducing the length. That they did it to build an open model is even better: it shows directly the kinds of benefits copyright is taking from us. We should be looking to scan every book out there to build better training sets, but copyright law restricts use of works dating back to a time before electrification was widespread. Obviously they're an evil company in general, but llama was an actual good deed from them.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by bko on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:40PM (#42975309)
> Instead, companies can seemingly do whatever they please whereas lawyers will send letters to your home for downloading a single episode of game of thrones.

I don't get it. All these companies took copyrighted data when they were tiny grew to be large, they still do that now. Google and OpenAI don't send these letters. They're not the copyright holders.

I have no idea what argument you're trying to make. Corporations bad?

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ziddoap on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:50PM (#42975417)
>Google and OpenAI don't send these letters.

Right. I'm not saying they do?

>I have no idea what argument you're trying to make.

I thought my point (not really an argument) was pretty clear, sorry.

"Rules for thee, but not for me" is the point. Where "thee" is individuals and "me" is corporations. (My comment was general commentary, not specific to Meta, Google, OpenAI, LLMs, or the article)

Right now "loose restrictions" seems to apply to corporations only. More people might be in favor of looser restrictions if it also applied to individuals, not just corporations.

I'm not sure how else to reword my comment more than that. It wasn't really meant to be too deep, and it wasn't intended to be argumentative.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by asjir on Saturday February 08, 2025 @07:49AM (#42982604)
His argument is that it's effectively a legal moat now that protects monopoly. Like we shouldn't accept that you need to break the law to have a chance to compete with them.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ok123456 on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:07AM (#42972657)
DRM for thee not for me.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by lofaszvanitt on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:43AM (#42973113)
Well, we'll see how will it generate value and for whom.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by marcosdumay on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:42AM (#42972406)
> If you plug a laptop into a closet at MIT to download some scientific papers you forfeit your life.

Just to point, but the material in question was public domain, so nobody had even a copyrights claim over it.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by scottbez1 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:44AM (#42973952)
Do you have a citation for that claim? I've not seen a claim that none of the material had copyright before.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by marcosdumay on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:24AM (#42974467)
It's a library of historical scientific work. You will find the famous Einstein's 3 1905 papers there, for example.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by warkdarrior on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:23PM (#42975801)
Every scientific paper in the last 90 years or so is still under copyright, owned by the authors, the published, or the universities.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by marcosdumay on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:06PM (#42976865)
JSTOR was explicitly a library of public domain works, consolidated in a single place so that academic libraries could access those papers that nobody had an interest in distributing anymore.

It recently added a bunch of copyrighted journals. It didn't have any of those at the time.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by dekhn on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:44PM (#42979560)
I re-read the MIT report by Abelson and it looks like JSTOR was an archive of old scientific articles from many journals, most of them still under copyright by the journal. I'd need to see more evidence that it was public domain.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by lolinder on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:50AM (#42972469)
Yes. And the problem here isn't that companies get away with doing things like this, the problem is that individuals don't. Attempting to lock information behind a nightmarish legal system is the problem.

I'm pretty much at the point now where I don't buy the "copyright incentivizes creation" argument any more. Copyright, like advertising, incentivizes creation by enormous corporations, but also like advertising it incentivizes creations that overwhelmingly have little value.

Creative individuals don't need copyright to be incentivized to create—they need a safety net that gives them the freedom to spend time on the creativity that naturally wants to bubble out. If the goal is to encourage creativity, copyright is a lousy and enormously expensive substitute for Universal Basic Income.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by post-it on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:59AM (#42972566)
Also, in Canada, it's basically impossible to protect your IP as an individual due to the astronomical cost and lack of options to recover that cost. So copyright will never incentivize my creations, or those of any small creator.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by derektank on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:57AM (#42974132)
Sure creative people will always create but the scope of that creativity will be limited if we do away with intellectual property. Steve Spielberg would probably always have created movies, but he wouldn't have been able to make Jurassic Park, Saving Private Ryan,or Indiana Jones without capital from the studio system, and the studio system wouldn't have provided him with that capital of they couldn't extract economic rents from the copyright for those films.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:28AM (#42974518)
I think a limited, short copyright can do good that the current many-year copyright does not. Imagine a 1 year copyright in the context of film. Companies would prioritize box office sales no doubt, but that’s how it used to be and it was generally positive. It’s really the extremity of modern copyright that I think causes these issues.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by zelphirkalt on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:59PM (#42976795)
They could have started a crowdfunded project and might still have made a great movie. If people truly like the created movie, why noch fund another one? Only no one would be paid millions for acting most likely, and that would be fine.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:55PM (#42978472)
Do we need to always have big-budget films and productions? Perhaps we should live smaller, and enjoy local art and low-budget films. Do I really care that Jurassic Park was made? I could read the book and it's more detailed and imaginative anyways, and any lessons to be learned are definitely better when read than when watching a blockbuster CGI film with more effects than message.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wk_end on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:08PM (#42978563)
"Let's create a world where all TV and movies have the production values of Public Access" is a poor pitch. Even if you don't mind that, you have to understand that, politically, it's a non-starter.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ok_dad on Saturday February 08, 2025 @07:11AM (#42982399)
Yea sounds dumb like that I agree.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by startupsfail on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:07PM (#42974971)
Nothing stops you from downloading Ann’s archive and training a model on it, right? The likelihood that you, as an individual, get sued over is is virtually zero.

This is what Meta tried to do, quietly download and use the data, to do research and advance their LLMs, without trying to establish any legal precedents or pick up fights.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by immibis on Saturday February 08, 2025 @05:07AM (#42981895)
In Germany people are sued for illegal movie downloading all the time. It's hard to imagine the companies behind that operation aren't aware that you can also download books.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ipaddr on Saturday February 08, 2025 @09:17AM (#42983089)
People are also sued over books
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by teaearlgraycold on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:52PM (#42977352)
Individuals do get away with it all of the time.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by modzu on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:55AM (#42972512)
i know of a company that poisoned an entire town! thats terrorism if done by an individual. the company still exists, just paid a settlement and carried on...
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by JKCalhoun on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:17AM (#42972772)
I agree with your point, but will split hairs on using the word "terrorism". I think that should be reserved for people that commit atrocities for some political aim. I'm fairly sure the company in question (I assume Union Carbide) did not poison the town to advance a political agenda.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by winthrowe on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:50AM (#42973214)
Profit at all costs is a political agenda.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mrweasel on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:36AM (#42973846)
Kinda terrifying that you can get away with shit if you just argue that it's not politically motivated, you did it because you really wanted a yacht.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AuryGlenz on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:12AM (#42974306)
You also get a lesser offense killing someone accidentally as opposed to a premeditated murder.

There’s a difference between an intentional act, an accident, and an accident due to extreme neglect and our laws reflect that.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cute_boi on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:14PM (#42978600)
how is it not intentional? Union Carbide higher up ppl knew there was safety issue, but because of profit they didn't give a damn.

The lesson here is do criminal activities through company, so that there are chances that you can escape from it.

https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/dec/08/bhopals-trage...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by drawkward on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:59AM (#42974149)
Money is the ultimate political agenda.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by dahart on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:02AM (#42974188)
Are you talking about Bhopal in 1984? If so it would be an understatement to refer to half a million people as a “town”, and an overstatement to imply it was terrorism. Willful negligence, yes, but terrorism, no.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jodrellblank on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:48PM (#42980200)
Russia has a town called Asbest which has an open-pit asbestos mine half the size of Manhattan where they mine with explosives.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asbest

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cy3piCUPIkc - VICE documentary and visit video. I think it contains an interview with an American woman who suffered from WR Grace and Company's asbestos mining and manufacturing in the USA, she says "they knew, they knew". WRG faced 129,000 personal injury claims and set asude $3 Bn for settling asbestos related lawsuits.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by pockmarked19 on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:56AM (#42972523)
> Spotify's music library was also pirated in the early days.

I want to know more, please enlighten me (anyone who knows). I read the book "The Spotify Play" and it made it seem like the pirated music was an internal-only thing and not something available to customers. Is that true?

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mzl on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:24AM (#42972863)
Before the launch, Spotify had a deal with the music rights holders association in Sweden (STIM) that they could use a merged collection of friends and families music libraries. All this was removed before Spotify went out of beta.

So while it was using pirated media, it was sanctioned by the rights holders for the experiment of building Spotify.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by arwineap on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:18AM (#42972776)
Users would upload their copies of the music and spotify would replay them. This was obvious to early users, even if they were only consumers, because of the pirate-shout-out-overlays that were in a lot of the poorer quality releases.

Another interesting note, in the early days of spotify, the app would saturate your upload bandwidth while using it. Given their close ties to utorrent, I always assumed that's how they were affording the bandwidth as well.

Pretty brilliant way to bootstrap I guess; they didn't have to pay for bandwidth or content until they already had contracts in place

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by lysace on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:51AM (#42974056)
Afaik, the trick was to stream (via http, I assume) the first few hundred kilobytes or so from fast/expensive servers and then try to p2p the rest in some clever order. I guess seeking also triggered the fast/expensive path for a while.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by billdybas on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:24PM (#42977061)
"Mood Machine: The Rise of Spotify and the Costs of the Perfect Playlist" by Liz Pelly goes into more detail about their origins and the culture around piracy in Sweden at the time.

https://lizpelly.info/book

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by larodi on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:59AM (#42972564)
The most outrageous thing about the whole story is that smart people (like here and not only) knew this all since day one. They been uncovering this the whole time.

And in their face, with all the fierce ignorance, broligarchs deny, evade and totally pretend this never happened. The most non open company of all even went to lengths to accuse others of stealing their IP - not theirs to begin with.

Just think of it - why did all major content platforms closed their APIs the day after GPT-2 got the word going…? Cause they knew all this very well - the content is precious and needed. They been doing it all along. Distilling the essence of world’s writing and digital imagery they had no right to.

We have a saying where I come from - no mercy for the chicken, no laws for the millions. I thought it was a local thing at first, it turned is how the world goes. Nothing new under the sun, indeed.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by qup on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:56AM (#42973295)
Speaking of GPT2, I remember that nobody gave a shit what it was trained on, because it sucked then.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Cthulhu_ on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:20AM (#42972817)
Crunchyroll started off as a straight up piracy site, it now has millions of paying subscribers and was sold to Sony for over a billion a few years ago.
[dead]
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by kendalf89 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:07AM (#42973448)
I don't think it's right to downplay the disproportionate response the FBI had to Aaron's actions. He was initially being threatened with 50 years in prison and a $1 million fine, the stress from which sent his mental health spiraling and in no small way contributed to his suicide. I think the original point of the person you are responding to still stands.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tiahura on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:07PM (#42974977)
You are correct. Prosecutors don’t consider whether charging a perp will upset them and stress them out. Nor should they.

Don’t do the crime if you can’t do the time.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wing-_-nuts on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:02PM (#42976205)
Every time I wonder how authoritarian regimes gain power, I remind myself there are people who seem to delight in the suffering of others.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wing-_-nuts on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:30AM (#42973772)
For downloading papers, paid for with government funding and gatekept by greedy rent seekers charging ~ $30 a pop. The lengths people will go to defend things that should not exist astounds.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tiahura on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:08PM (#42974986)
What about his family and friends? Do you blame them as well?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wing-_-nuts on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:59PM (#42976172)
Why would I?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tiahura on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:31PM (#42977143)
As a general rule, I'm not a fan of prosecutors. However, blaming a prosecutor for the suicide of a defendant, because they filed charges in a clear cut case, is just as unfair as blaming friends and family.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wing-_-nuts on Tuesday February 11, 2025 @03:43PM (#43018119)
I mean yes, the prosecutor had discretion to offer a light plea deal, and instead chose to try and ruin someone's life over papers. I absolutely blame the prosecutor.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by HeatrayEnjoyer on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:15PM (#42976339)
What does that even mean?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by impossiblefork on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:32AM (#42973805)
Everyone is responsible for the full effects of his actions. One is literally responsible for all consequences, everything no matter how indirect.

This absolute responsibility is physics, while the limited 'only direct consequences' type thing is a choice made in some human legal systems.

People are smart. They know what stress they put on people and from interacting with them they get a good feel of much they can take. If they ignore that, or decide not to talk to people they're putting stress or choose to ignore things, that's only intentional negligence.

I don't think the prosecutors cared. I don't think we should judge unless there double standards or hypocrisy, but let's not imagine they aren't responsible for things that resulted from their action and inaction. You cause what you case.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by StefanBatory on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:47AM (#42973175)
Shame though that corpos aren't responsible for their actions too :|
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by HeatrayEnjoyer on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:50AM (#42974035)
What a repulsive comment.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by belter on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:30AM (#42972940)
"Zuckerberg was at White House for meetings on Thursday" - https://www.reuters.com/world/us/zuckerberg-was-white-house-...
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by coliveira on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:50AM (#42973219)
Yes, these companies are based on massive IP and copyright theft. And they still want to lecture others about their "property rights".
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by throwawaygmbno on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:53AM (#42973255)
Everyone on here is smart enough. Just do not participate and save your money. Do not pay for digital goods. If Netflix raises their prices, it doesn't matter because there is a torrent of all of their shows. If Spotify raises their prices, it doesn't matter because your favorite artist has their entire library in a torrent. If some game company ask you to pay real life prices for a digital costume, find the crack online and play on a private server. If YouTube wants to interrupt your video with an ad in the middle of the sentence, download one of the many options that blocks all ads. Billion dollar companies have shown they do not care about you. The people who complain about losing their salary, should just get replies thanking them for paying.

All the sad poor people who might be hurt were already paid. The caterer on your favorite show is not getting residuals. NBC also isn't going to stop making TV shows because that is all they can do. Content creators also existed on the internet long before that was a job. They just did it because they cared about it not for ad money. If you really want to support the artist directly go to a concert or just mail them a check. If you can't actually identify a person who might be hurt, then do not care.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ericyd on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:12AM (#42973528)
I just can't get behind the sentiment that the unethical behavior by big companies means I get to access all the content I want for free.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:21AM (#42974419)
Imo it’s not about you accessing things you want for free. If your family purchased a disc copy of the goonies before you were born and you watched it as a kid, your accessing of that content you wanted for free has no moral bearing. The core question is what impact does your consumption have, and I don’t think that participating in the streaming landscape is making things any better for anyone but their ceos.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ericyd on Saturday February 08, 2025 @06:13PM (#42987032)
The comment I was responding to certainly seemed to be advocating uninhibited free access via torrents, but your point is reasonable. I don't think streaming is a great way to support artists either, though I do think it's better than nothing.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Sunday February 09, 2025 @12:15PM (#42991953)
I just don’t think streaming is really working for anybody. Artists are being given less and less creative control as time goes on as each streaming company attempts to optimize itself in a largely fixed market. It’s working the same way cable used to work. I think a disruption is in order, but last time disruption started with people moving to nascent torrent sites.

I guess the way I’d put it is that if you can only get some particular show through one company, that company gets to treat you shitty, cause where else are you gonna go. Torrenting, even just widespread knowledge of torrenting, gives the customer more leverage.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ericyd on Monday February 10, 2025 @08:30AM (#43000010)
But is torrenting better than buying music e.g. through bandcamp or directly from the artist's label? I do a combination of streaming for exploratory listening and buying to support artists. And live shows when I can. I'm not trying to suggest I'm holier than thou, but I really don't think torrents are the answer to this equation. However I strongly agree that the current system isn't working for artists and needs disruption.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Tuesday February 11, 2025 @01:27PM (#43016313)
I know music can be bought from the artist, but is that true for shows or movies?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ericyd on Tuesday February 11, 2025 @06:30PM (#43019726)
Fair point, I tend to think more about music artists than film/TV.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Tuesday February 11, 2025 @09:37PM (#43021190)
Yeah for torrenting I tend to think more about video media.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tdb7893 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:33AM (#42973812)
Also if you pirate everything you're not incentivizing people to make things in a more ethical manner. I've mostly cancelled my streaming services (I'll get different ones for a month at a time for specific shows) but I still pay for Dropout.tv (when they turned a profit they paid out a dividend to actors) and Patreon for YouTube creators that have high quality content.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by throwawaygmbno on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:13AM (#42973543)
Thank you for your service
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by jamespo on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:36AM (#42973851)
At least your human right of watching a netflix show is unaffected
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by drawkward on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:55AM (#42974104)
They have no morals, therefore I shouldn't either! That'll teach 'em!
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by chefandy on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:15AM (#42974337)
A whole lot of people in the tech scene got really mad when Huawei was using obviously stolen Cisco designs and code for their switches. Didn’t humanity benefit from having cheaper access to switches because they didn’t have to pay for Cisco’s sunk costs? A whole lot of people got mad when Microsoft reportedly ganked open source code for things like DNS. Didn’t humanity benefit from one of the world’s most popular server OSs having more reliable name resolution?

Oh, but corporations were the primary beneficiaries, right?

Well, corporations are the primary beneficiaries of this too from a financial perspective. A vanishingly small percentage of people will run, let alone train these models themselves— it’s almost exclusively used to make commercial services that directly compete against the people that made the initial ” data“. But, the vanishingly small percentage of people that directly utilize this stuff for non-commercial use frequent echo chambers like this that make them think more regular people benefit directly. And the companies that are competing directly with creatives and intellectuals using their stolen work employ a whole lot of people here, directly or not.

The distinction between a reason and a justification gets pretty difficult to distinguish the closer you are to the group benefiting from injustice.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 486sx33 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @12:53PM (#42984683)
I’d completely disagree, because China was the beneficiary and it destroyed North American jobs.

China needs to respect the American trademark system!

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by chefandy on Saturday February 08, 2025 @03:53PM (#42986105)
> I’d completely disagree, because China was the beneficiary and it destroyed North American jobs.

a) The whole point of commercial NN services is to replace human labor, and jobs are paid labor. Literally the entire point of LLMs is to destroy jobs; this isn't hypothetical-- US companies have openly talked about having fired people and not filled roles because they either have increased or hope to increase efficiency with LLMs. And that's in tech where there's a chance more jobs will be created as a result-- the situation is far worse in creative fields. I personally know quite a few north American creative workers that have lost their jobs because the studios they work for have replaced almost the entire department with image generators that the remaining workers use to spray-and-pray concept art and game assets. Comparatively, the argument that they will create more jobs-- even as many jobs-- as they destroy is pure speculation.

b) Considering you're willing to have in-group protectionism in the form of nationalism, I'm guessing you're willing to extend that to industry, so creative workers don't count? Is it only American tech jobs that count or are you against American LLMs that replace any American workers, also?

> China needs to respect the American trademark system!

Trademarks? I assume you're talking about the patent system rather than logos... and legally they don't, actually. The US doesn't respect Chinese patents, either. How many times have you heard of a US company stopping doing something because a Chinese company patented it first? Do you really think we just invent everything first over here?

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:23AM (#42974451)
The observation being made here is that copyright law serves to protect the interests of large companies, not the public, so violating copyright law is, in and of itself, not unethical.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by xigoi on Saturday February 08, 2025 @04:42AM (#42981789)
If buying is not owning, piracy is not stealing.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by drawkward on Saturday February 08, 2025 @08:57AM (#42982974)
Whereas i agree that the current regime of "licensing" is not good, I simultaneously find it incredibly selfish to believe that one has the right to any content one likes.

"Own nothing" is bad, but so is "access and share anything." Both positions are too extreme.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by abustamam on Saturday February 08, 2025 @01:35PM (#42985049)
I try to buy/rent/legitimately stream all the media I consume. But I've run into issues where I would "buy" a license to a movie, and suddenly I don't have access to a movie. I'm sure it was for some publishing licensing legal reason, but the fact remains that they kept my money I paid for the movie and I don't have what I paid for.

I wouldn't say I have a fundamental right to any content, but certainly I have a right to content I paid for.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by drawkward on Sunday February 09, 2025 @10:47AM (#42991364)
I think your position is reasonable!
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by doctorpangloss on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:16PM (#42975702)
Well yeah, because it’s dumb.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by timcobb on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:15PM (#42976332)
“There is no ethical consumption under capitalism”
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Nasrudith on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:23PM (#42978203)
Who even thinks that ethical consumption exists under any system? Any of your consumption denies it to others. Some consumption is a necessity of course. We wouldn't speak of something absurd like "ethical breathing".
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by stevage on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:53PM (#42978447)
I think the point is, using Spotify is already essentially listening to your artists without supporting them. You might as well do that without supporting a company that is harming them.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by hnpolicestate on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:58AM (#42973329)
I'm not paying for Led Zeppelin IV after having probably bought 3 copies in my lifetime. I agree with you.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by dingnuts on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:57AM (#42973317)
if you want to support an artist go to the show and BUY MERCH at the table! almost all of their income comes from that. the importance of buying a T-shirt at the show cannot be overstated and sometimes you get to say hi to your idol, too
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:12AM (#42973538)
It's a stupid situation, though. There are many creators I'm happy to support - but for 99% of them, I don't want their stupid merch. It's mostly low-quality garbage with high markup, that nevertheless cost something to design and produce, thus wasting both precious resources and labor - an useless tax on contributions to artists that doesn't even help anything. I really wish this wasn't necessary.

(Even the okay-quality merch is a waste, since for most artists I'd want to support, I don't identify with them enough to display that stuff, so it's again just buying to put away and eventually throw away.)

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BrandonM on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:37AM (#42973857)
I don’t think I’ve ever seen a band selling merch that didn’t also have a tip jar.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:51AM (#42974047)
I've never seen a band that had. I usually end up buying CDs that then end up on the shelf or in a drawer, never opened.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by throwawaygmbno on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:37AM (#42973862)
What is the point of this comment? Just a stream of consciousness for a future LLM sweep? Nobody thinks that the actual creator should get nothing. Are you asking for better T shirts? Do you want more direct ways of just giving cash?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nosioptar on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:32AM (#42974564)
I agree mostly with their comment.

What I want more than anything is for bands to just sell me a damned CD. I've lost track of how many times an artist I want to support doesn't release their music on CD. I'd even settle for DRM-free flacs, if it costs less than a CD.

High quality sheet music would be cool. Lindsey Stirling is the only artist I can think of that does that though. Rasputina used to at one point.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by TeMPOraL on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:49AM (#42974022)
The latter, yes.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gpvos on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:52PM (#42978441)
Let them ask a tenner for an album download code.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nullfield on Tuesday February 11, 2025 @01:04AM (#43009486)
Well, and like the venue will take 50% of merch sales or some , which makes Apple look kinda generous.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by macromagnon on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:52AM (#42974800)
A lot of artists are under a 360 deal and they take a cut of everything, so that might not always be true.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by dopidopHN on Sunday February 09, 2025 @09:50AM (#42991008)
By a lot you mean a minority and by artist you mean professional musician in contract with large label, correct ?

I live in New Orleans, that one of the few place where is see artists in the street living from their art. Paying rent by playing music.

None of them have a 360 deal. And their is hundred of them just in New Orleans.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by swozey on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:02PM (#42975556)
lol I absolutely do not want non digital goods nor pirating. Ever. It's 2025. I don't have a cdplayer, a tape player, a blue ray player, I don't even know what the most modern "blue ray" disc would be. I have $2k worth of vinyls that are just unique copies I display as art I'll never put in my record player, that's also never been used. I don't want to constantly worry about 60gb of mp3 files.

Oh no, that TV show I'll forget about in a year cost me $15/mo instead of $60 of blurays.

I jump in my cars and hit a button and music plays. Almost any music I want. That's amazing.

I'm also not pirating games. I'm not 12 without a job. I have a job. I pay developers for their work. I want more games, like Kingdom Come 3, to come out.

Weird ass comment. You seriously think we're going to put our lives on hold to.. what, fight "digital media"? You think I care about netflix? Or societies use of it? I haven't used netflix in years. I don't know anybody under 40 with a netflix account. Everyone on your end of the pirate spectrum uses debrid nowadays, anyway.

Next you're going to tell people to install the "Black XP Windows" edition to not support Microsoft and they all get malware and their credit cards stolen because they installed some pirated and modified cracked windows. Genius.

MSNBC just cancelled Andrea Mitchells TV show, today, because she brought in no younger audiences. So yes, shows do get cancelled by not being watched.

This comment was upvoted? Hn needs a break. This is some I'm 14 and edgy bullshit that sounds like it belongs on an eastern european piracy forum.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Larrikin on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:31PM (#42975888)
>MSNBC just cancelled Andrea Mitchells TV show, today, because she brought in no younger audiences. So yes, shows do get cancelled by not being watched.

Did anyone, young or old, want to watch an 80 year old stumble over her words, lose her train of thought, and speak so painfully slow? She had built up connections over her long career but was basically unwatchable. The worst part of a Kamala presidency would have been her on the news and not in retirement.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by swozey on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:49PM (#42976081)
I'm celebrating it today. No idea who is replacing her but I am ecstatic.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by hnpolicestate on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:15PM (#42976955)
You're arguing for media as a service. I think many people are tired of the SASS everything model. It's generally user hostile, you need multiple different services, there are dark patterns and you still have to endure ads. Privacy issues too. Piracy is definitely superior.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tumsfestival on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:14PM (#42976312)
I don't know how you went from "don't pay for overpriced digital goods, just pirate them instead" to "hurr durr start using blurays and vinyls".

Reading comprehension is a lost art nowadays.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by asacrowflies on Saturday February 08, 2025 @10:48AM (#42983709)
He just wantrd to express how superior to the young kids he is .. while all the points about ethics, freedom, and privacy went over his head.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by MourYother on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:51PM (#42976735)
I sometimes think my adblocker should very much lie to the page that "yeah, watched that, totally" in an undetectable way.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ffpip on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:58PM (#42976782)
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by amarcheschi on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:39PM (#42977235)
Goat
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by genewitch on Saturday February 08, 2025 @04:11PM (#42986243)
It takes like a quarter hour to process the entire ad blob on my old machine, and it's over $70k in ads clicked.

Between that and pihole I see very few ads. Being out and watching a yt video is shocking with how many ads there are - and what type.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Cub3 on Monday February 10, 2025 @09:18PM (#43008219)
If buying isn't owning, piracy isn't stealing
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by earthnail on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:53AM (#42973264)
In Spotify’s defense, they used the pirated data only to show a proof of concept to the copyright holders, and that use was sanctioned by the local rights holders organization STIM.

The copyright holders then approved their concept, and subsequently Spotify got the rights to offer their service to customers. Everybody won.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by tanjtanjtanj on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:09AM (#42973486)
That’s not entirely true, in Spotify’s early days you could upload files to the service and listen to songs uploaded by other people. I think the majority of any song I wanted to listen to before they went Europe-only for a time was “pirated”.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by kqr on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:05PM (#42974954)
Indeed. I remember there was one song that used a pirated variant and you could tell because it had an obvious artifact that was accidentally introduced in a pirated copy of the song!
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by earthnail on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:13AM (#42973544)
Fair. I stand corrected.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by electriclove on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:03AM (#42973388)
Some can pirate on a large scale and see no repercussions.

Some can steal from stores and see no repercussions.

Some can steal from others and see no repercussions.

Some can violently harm others and see no repercussions.

Some can damage property and see no repercussions.

Some can’t. This world is not right.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ls612 on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:28PM (#42975855)
The strong do what they wish and the weak suffer what they must. Any morality beyond that is a fairy tale that the weak tell themselves.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by vel0city on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:07AM (#42973453)
> once people started uploading copyrighted TV shows to it

End users, not YouTube employees, right? And they would take things down following DMCA requests and what not, right? So, pretty much following the law?

> Google itself got big by indexing other people's data without compensation

Scraping public websites to build a search index isn't the same as making LLMs that can recreate the source verbatim devoid of even attribution. I do agree there's an argument to be had about the LLM's transformative nature in the end though.

> Spotify's music library was also pirated in the early days

Not any version generally available to the public, and with the copyright holder's permission to do so.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cma on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:47PM (#42979906)
I think he's thinking of Grooveshark
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by sylario on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:07AM (#42973454)
And Hollywood was created on the west coast because for intellectual property it was still the far west and it allowed them to ignore patents on movie technologies.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by bayindirh on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:11PM (#42975017)
They became the thing they lamented.

This is the inevitable.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by smugma on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:09AM (#42973488)
Spotify was born as a response to piracy. Why do you say their catalog was pirated?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by chanux on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:10AM (#42973508)
Corporations are people. Just a notch above the regular kind.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Lucasoato on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:30AM (#42973774)
> If you plug a laptop into a closet at MIT to download some scientific papers you forfeit your life.

In case anybody here doesn't know, that's a reference to Aaron Swartz, an activist (and Reddit co-founder) that was risking 35 years in prison and a $1 million fine just for downloading a lot of academic papers from JSTOR. He eventually took his life because of the pressure. May his soul rest in peace.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by gruez on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:35AM (#42974597)
Except he was offered 6 months in a plea bargain, which he declined because he wanted a trial. Whether 6 months was reasonable punishment for "plug a laptop into a closet at MIT to download some scientific papers" is another matter, but "you forfeit your life" or "35 years in prison and a $1 million fine " is massively misleading.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:17PM (#42975076)
Swartz wasn't the kind of person to accept a plea bargain from an overzealous prosecutor who was indicting him on 13 felony charges with a possible sentence up to 35 years along with a $1 million fine. I assume he wanted a trial because he wanted to continue his fight for open access. And maybe he thought he might lose, but wouldn't lose on all counts, and would make the prosecution look unreasonable in the public eye. Was that decision rational from a self-interest point of view? Maybe not.

And then you might ask, if he wanted a trial, why did he kill himself? Obviously no one knows what was going through his head when he did it. He left no note. But the prospect of being locked in a cell until he was an old man probably had something to do with it.

You can certainly argue it was his own fault for not pleading down, but even if that's your view, that doesn't absolve the prosecutor. Ortiz has a lot of blame in this too, and the fact she still hasn't acknowledged it over a decade later speaks volumes to the kind of person she is.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ianhawes on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:34PM (#42976550)
His criminality is one matter, but the full weight of the Federal Government on him was an entirely separate matter. A federal prosecutor's job is to jail you regardless of whether it is for downloading a file from a server or for trafficking in humans, and they will come at you with the same vigor regardless of the crime. And nothing has changed about that.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:28PM (#42977096)
Treating a human trafficker and someone who downloaded some files from a server the same is not in the job description of a prosecutor. What an absurd statement. It's very much the job of a prosecutor to make judgements about the severity of the crime and how to respond. And in this case, the prosecutor showed incredibly poor judgement. There wasn't even a particular reason why the case should go federal in the first place. The state prosecutor saw things very differently.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by chasd00 on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:41PM (#42978345)
The job of a prosecutor is to get a guilty verdict, the judge decides the sentence. At least that's how i understand it.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by internetter on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:30PM (#42979489)
The prosecutor can tack on stupid charges, e.g. Luigi Mangione getting a terrorism charge, and pursue punishments
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by barnabyjones on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:01PM (#42979664)
Isn't that what this whole thread is about? They're surely not going to come after Meta with the same vigor.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by asacrowflies on Saturday February 08, 2025 @10:55AM (#42983767)
That is complete bullshit as evidenced by the federal criminal sitting president.... The ONLY time I ever see this argument is to try and paint over blatant police and state injustice and tyranny.

"A federal prosecutor's job is to jail you regardless of whether it is for downloading a file from a server or for trafficking in humans, and they will come at you with the same vigor regardless of the crime."

You have to be malicious to put forward this statement in the current environment. Or you are so propagandized you think it's true? Either one is very frightening

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wavemode on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:05PM (#42977467)
I agree there's more nuance here than was initially stated, but I also think there's more nuance than simply "he was offered 6 months". Even if he was offered 6 days, the ways in which someone's life and livelihood changes by having ever been convicted of a crime and gone to prison, is dramatic. This is especially true in white collar work and/or knowledge work.

Schwartz was a research fellow at Harvard. Really think he would've been able to continue?

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by AndyKelley on Saturday February 08, 2025 @03:19AM (#42981396)
Wild to see the concept of the plea bargain being defended. It's a blatant retraction of the due process clause from the bill of rights, and here you are defending it.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ThaDood on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:46AM (#42973977)
Thanks for sharing this. Reading his story is kind of insane honestly. He created the CC licenses which I did not know. What an icon, truly.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by CuriousSkeptic on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:19PM (#42977599)
On that note, Lawrence Lessigs talks on copyright from that period are worth a watch https://youtu.be/9xbRE_H5hoU
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by bobbob1921 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:50AM (#42974768)
Thanks, I thought it was a sarcastic reference to torrents. So this cleared that up
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by sneak on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:12AM (#42974292)
> If you plug a laptop into a closet at MIT to download some scientific papers you forfeit your life.

I’m opposed to copyright and pro-aaronsw, but the state did not kill him.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by roguecoder on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:30PM (#42978257)
Absolutely.

1.8 million people are in United States jails today. It isn't a death sentence, and it is a foreseeable consequence of some ethically-appropriate actions.

Supporting folks spending time in jail is a valuable role in any social movement.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by yurlungur on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:12AM (#42974303)
I think the difference may be LLMs may not be laundered clean of copyright data anytime soon. Even if chatgpt got big and profitable, it's not so clear that it won't contain copyrighted data as that may simply be necessary to train the best models.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cma on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:52PM (#42979936)
Most of the web is copyrighted
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by yowzadave on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:14AM (#42974320)
> Youtube was initially a ghost town (it started as a dating site) and it only got traction once people started uploading copyrighted TV shows to it

To this day, there are a huge number of videos that show copyrighted content on YouTube; they are usually crappy clips, reversed and with different music playing in the background to avoid automated detection.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by soheil on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:14AM (#42974323)
So be a company? Last I checked it costs a couple of hundred dollars to form an LLC, what am I missing?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wcfrobert on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:16AM (#42974348)
VC and startups are fundamentally about disruption. You can't make an omelette without breaking a few eggs (laws). The incumbent players are not going to sit still and let things be "disrupted". A common response is to make sure the public knows about the broken eggs. I would say youtube, Google, Spotify, Uber, doordash, etc. all have made my life much better.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by soheil on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:27AM (#42974511)
You don't know a world without them so you actually have no idea if they have made your life compared to that world much better or much worse. How your life was at the time is irrelevant.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by theatomheart on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:32PM (#42975229)
100%
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by warkdarrior on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:25PM (#42975829)
This is a vacuous statement. You can say the same thing about electricity, or antibiotics, or any other modern advancement.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by soheil on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:28PM (#42979480)
That's kinda the point. That type of reasoning is vacuous.

There are millions of great arguments why antibiotics made the world a better place, I'm yet to hear one of YT.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by wcfrobert on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:56PM (#42976138)
Why would I say something is better without a point of comparison?

I was born in the 90s. So definitely alive before YouTube and Spotify albeit as a teenager rather than an adult. I guess you're right I'm not familiar with the world of Sony Walkman, Blockbuster, and IBM PC. But I definitely remember dial-up modems, CDs, Windows 95 and XP. Technology has improved most aspect of my life better since then. (maybe minus all the ads + dopamine slot machines part...)

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by soheil on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:19AM (#42974396)
Aaron committed suicide and FBI going after him was meant more as a lesson to the other kids at MIT than anything.

MegaUpload did the same, kim dotcom got raided in his sleep by FBI in New Zealand! So no I don't buy your reductionist argument, there are forces at play that allow companies with founders with the likes of Google to get away with it but not others.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by whatever1 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:23AM (#42974448)
How does that prosecutor sleep at night?
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by observationist on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:33AM (#42974581)
This frames Google's indexing of the web in a totally, abjectly wrong fashion. It wasn't "other people's data", it was data people published to the public internet, implicitly and explicitly granting permission to download through the act of serving that data without restriction to whoever navigated to a particular URL.

That's how the internet works. If you want private content, you need to put up a gate mechanism of some sort with authentication or other methods of restricting access. Without that, you are literally having your server "serve" the content to whoever asks for it, without restriction or exception, without ToS or meaningful contract or agreements.

You can't have it both ways. "But they didn't know" or other post-hoc claims of innocent people publishing content to the web being misled or confused or abused is infantilizing nonsense.

The web wouldn't have been as amazing and revolutionary and liberating if the fundamental public and open nature of its systems was private and walled off by default.

Your take on YouTube going viral initially over copyrighted content isn't correct, either - it was ease of use and access. It was fairly popular by the time Google bought it, and once it was reachable and advertised by google itself, it exploded, because by that time, everyone had defaulted to using google for search.

Other people corrected your Spotify take.

The reason they pirated is because it is functionally impossible to gain access to the data in any other way. For consumers, there are lots of old shows, music, and other content that aren't accessible, so they turn to piracy. A vast majority of the time, if content is accessible, people will pay and do the technically legal and "right" thing.

Publishers exploit authors and content creators in the name of "platforming" and "marketing" , effectively doing as little as possible to take 90%+ of the value of a product and providing as little as possible to the producer of content or books or music. They get by on technicalities and have captured the legal arena entirely, with any attempt at reform or revolution meeting a messy death at the hands of lawyers and big money publishers.

Screw those people. They lie, cheat, and steal, and somehow have gotten away with fooling the world into thinking they're the good guys.

Copying bits and bytes is not stealing, and the ones trying to shill that narrative are trying to fool as many people as possible into giving them more money without any return of value in kind. I'd download the hell out of a car. Pirate everything.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by mrtesthah on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:29PM (#42975192)
Don’t forget the original developers of Skype also created Kazaa first.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by sandeepkd on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:36PM (#42975932)
Reminds me of recent discussions about similar topic, what may clearly look like a crime can be treated differently depending on if you do it as an individual or as a company. Somewhere down the line its all about understanding the limits and boundaries of the system, its a skill in itself.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by cyanydeez on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:42PM (#42976008)
Mmm, the broader point is: laws are are as real as the cash you can pay a lawyer to fight.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by plasticbugs on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:07PM (#42976873)
I briefly worked for Crunchyroll, which began life as an anime pirating service with subtitles. The contracts with the Japanese anime publishers came later. Now they vigorously protect their content from "pirates".
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:15PM (#42976954)
"Spotify's music library was also pirated in the early days."

"Ek, who had been the CEO of the piracy platform uTorrent, founded Spotify with his friend, another entrepreneur named Martin Lorentzon. Both-Ek at 23 and Lorentzon 37-were already millionaires from the sales of previous businesses. The name Spotify had no particular meaning, and was not associated with music. According to Spotify Teardown, the company developed a software for improved peer-to-peer network sharing, and the founders spoke of it as a general "media distribution platform." The initial choice to focus on music, the founders said at the time, was because audio files are smaller than video files, not because of a dream of saving music.

In 2007, when Spotify first publicly tested its software, it allowed users to stream songs downloaded from The Pirate Bay, a service for unlicensed downloads. By late 2008, Spotify would convince music labels in Sweden to license music to the site, and unlicensed music was removed. From there, Spotify would take off across Europe and then the world."

https://qz.com/1683609/how-the-music-industry-shifted-from-n...

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BrenBarn on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:28PM (#42977099)
Exactly. We need leaders with the political will to apply a "financial death penalty" to companies that engage in this kind of brazen behavior. That means all assets seized, the company dissolved, personal assets of executives seized, executives jailed. People running companies should live in mortal fear of ever doing the things that they routinely do today.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Nasrudith on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:33PM (#42978277)
Do people even take civics classes anymore? That isn't how any of this works. Political will doesn't allow arbitrary punishments. You would need legislation at very least and that could face issues with the Eighth Amendment. (Which could not be post-facto of course.)

At least you're not calling for jailing all the shareholders....

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BrenBarn on Saturday February 08, 2025 @12:52AM (#42980724)
Political will can be used to pass legislation and ultimately to change the Eighth Amendment.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by immibis on Saturday February 08, 2025 @05:17AM (#42981930)
Punishment wouldn't be arbitrary, it would be based on the crimes you committed.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by ctrlp on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:16PM (#42978613)
The sooner people learn this lesson, the sooner it might change.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by nostrademons on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:32PM (#42978716)
A bigger lesson might be "don't get caught until you're big enough to destroy the people suing you."

Napster got shut down for widespread enabling of copyright infringement. So did numerous other filesharing startups, including Travis Kalanick's first startup, Scour. Lots of small startups get put out of business all the time for being sued and not having the money to defend themselves.

Likewise, individuals like Donald Trump or Elon Musk get away with all sorts of illegal shit, because they are big enough to shut down the court systems prosecuting them.

Google's genius was in staying under the radar and aligning their incentives with everyone that might dislike them, until they were big enough that they could simply crush anyone that might dislike them.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by vkou on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:48PM (#42978844)
> Google itself got big by indexing other people's data without compensation.

So in other words, it got big by providing free user traffic to people's websites without asking for compensation?

You generally don't charge the phone book money to include you in it. It's actually the other way around.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by Izikiel43 on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:31PM (#42979134)
So, might makes right, a tale as old as humanity
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by yard2010 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @04:09AM (#42981611)
RIP Aaron Swartz
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by djmips on Saturday February 08, 2025 @05:39AM (#42982009)
Doesn't Google have their own internal scanning of books?