News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by roenxi on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:29AM (#42972288)
But the crime is creating something new. If laws are enforced that criminalise creation, then the world will be rather static.

It seems to be a consistent direction of history's arc that the people who make it easy to create and innovate get ahead.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by miltonlost on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:40AM (#42972382)
We don’t allow indiscriminate human experimentation in medicine. We have crimes against this, and yet we still have new medicines. Sure, it won’t be as quick if we could just use humans as test subjects from the start, but that’s an unethical line. Innovation done immorally is progress that shouldn’t have been made. The ends don’t justify the means, but I’m not an ethical nihilist.

The crime is downloading and copying and distributing copyrighted materials! Not creating the LLM! Get the crime right

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by roenxi on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:08AM (#42972673)
Those medical policies have condemned thousands, possibly millions, to lives of unnecessary pain and suffering. They're more damaging than copyright.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:36AM (#42974607)
You actually don’t know that. The question would be, what proportion of human experiments are successful, and you don’t know the answer to that question, so the victims of experiments could dwarf the beneficiaries of successful research. That’s always the hard thing with basic utilitarianism.
Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by roenxi on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:08PM (#42979358)
1) It is an experiment. The point is to test something that nobody is sure about. Whether the result is expected or unexpected there isn't really such a thing as "unsuccessful"; even duplication of work is considered useful.

2) If you think the cost-benefits are bad, my advice is don't sign up to be experimented on. Nobody has to be experimented on if they don't want to be.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:01PM (#42979662)
1) Experiments, by their nature, must spend resources in order to produce tangible results. In this case the relevant results are saved lives, and the expenditure is often going to be lives. You framed your comment in these terms, I’m arguing the costs very well may not be justifiable by the benefits. You’d need to make a case for that.

2) What if the families of experimentees receive payment? Allowing that would be a short way down the slippery slope from allowing the experimentation, and would make the matter of consent more difficult to assess.

Re:Meta torrented & seeded 81.7 TB dataset containing copyri... by miltonlost on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:15AM (#42972746)
Ok, I’ll go tell the Nazis that their medical experiments using live humans were A-OK!!!