News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google changes its search box by simonw on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:45PM (#48197528)
Nilay Patel has been talking about "Google Zero" - the moment when Google effectively stops sending any traffic to other sites - for a few years now: https://www.theverge.com/24167865/google-zero-search-crash-h...
Re:Google changes its search box by ekidd on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:00PM (#48197769)
Which as some running a website raises a fascinating question. If Google is just going to crawl my sites and present information as an AI summary on their site, then what exactly do I gain by allowing Googlebot to crawl my sites?
Re:Google changes its search box by pflenker on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:11PM (#48197951)
A couple of years back I worked with a company which maintained specific data which was the main traffic driver on that page. Google approached them and wanted to pay for the rights to get the data and display it on top of the search results, a feature which was fairly new back then.

This was an interesting dilemma because it was very clear that the money was way less than the loss in ad revenue due to traffic drop, but it was also clear that if we wouldn’t take the deal, a more desperate competitor would, which would result in the same traffic loss but without the extra google money. So the company took the deal.

History repeats itself here, with the difference that instead of paying for the data, the ai crawlers simply take it for free.

Re:Google changes its search box by iamtedd on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:19PM (#48198068)
Real-world Prisoner's Dilemma.
Re:Google changes its search box by jonshariat on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:31PM (#48198258)
It always comes back to game theory haha
Re:Google changes its search box by drcongo on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:11PM (#48198799)
"Nice data you got there, it'd be a shame if something were to happen to it"
Re:Google changes its search box by vb-8448 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:44PM (#48199352)
The fact is that internet is already "tech giants own realm": the power is way beyond public imagination and affects all of us in real life on daily bases, but there are still people thinking they are not the "evil one" here.
Re:Google changes its search box by thelastgallon on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:45PM (#48199356)
This reminds me of Walmarts squeezing strategy with all the manufacturers. Business with us at the price we say or out of business.
Re:Google changes its search box by burnte on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:53PM (#48199488)
Yep, this is exactly why some companies simply don't work with Walmart.
Re:Google changes its search box by augzodia on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:05PM (#48200312)
it's because both google and walmart have too much market power
Re:Google changes its search box by johnny_canuck on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @08:59PM (#48201728)
But ultimately that strategy is good for the consumer right?

In this context, if Google is going to give me the recipe without having to scroll through the story, that seems like a win to me.

The ad-revenue driven Internet of web 2.0 is finally dead and I'm not sure I'm all that sad.

Re:Google changes its search box by redsparrow on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:41PM (#48202038)
Without some way to generate revenue, people aren't going to publish recipes (for Google to scrape into their AI.) Maybe we could live without more recipes being fed into the machine, but there are many other types of content that will suffer the same fate.

It would be nice to find something better than an ad-revenue driven web, but I'm not sure this is it. We'll find out I guess...

Re:Google changes its search box by bbondo on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:53PM (#48202132)
> people aren't going to publish recipes

Sure they are. I can attest that musicians will gladly publish their music even when no recompense is offered. Surely culinary artists are the same.

Re:Google changes its search box by gwbas1c on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:32PM (#48202790)
We just won't get countless recipe websites where you have to scroll, scroll, scroll through slop about someone's day to read a scraped recipe that every other website has.

This is just disruption.

Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:00AM (#48203662)
Does the current Google search results indicate that they will be any different?

It’s also not disruption if your product relies on the output of the industry it kills. What will AI train on when it destroys the economics of sharing information with others?

Re:Google changes its search box by gwbas1c on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:10AM (#48207096)
> your product relies on the output of the industry it kills

I disagree, Google doesn't rely on a massive amount of recipe websites; they rely on Google and exploit it.

More importantly: These recipes exist from many sources, not just the website that exploited Google to be first in their rankings.

Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:48PM (#48213118)
From the HN guidelines: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."

In this instance, the internet is more than top-ranking recipe websites.

Re:Google changes its search box by gwbas1c on Thursday May 21, 2026 @02:27PM (#48227037)
"Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes."
Re:Google changes its search box by grantj on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:54AM (#48203617)
Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:57AM (#48203640)
Some people will. The vast majority won’t. You are not playing for an audience, only for crawlers, so what is the point?
Re:Google changes its search box by mrighele on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:23AM (#48203802)
Those who won’t were doing it for the money. Those who continue are those who do it for passion, or those whose recipe is just a way to attract people to their business (e.g. kitchenware company). I don’t think it is necessarily bad, the quantity will decrease but the quality may even improve
Re:Google changes its search box by RyanHamilton on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:27AM (#48204306)
I built a passion reference site. A large part of that passion came from knowing and talking to the people I was helping. One person emailing or saying thanks would later help power me through to create more useful articles. Enriching openai/claude/ms/google and no thanks from an individual, has disincentivized me from writing more.
Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:11AM (#48205039)
Same here. People knew the website and it was immensely flattering to meet users in the wild. It motivated me to really sweat the small stuff, because people noticed. Now I'm just feeding the slop machine, and it feels pointless.
Re:Google changes its search box by the_af on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:22AM (#48207287)
> Those who continue are those who do it for passion

Nothing kills passion faster than your only audience being an AI crawler.

Re:Google changes its search box by mcphage on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:12PM (#48202673)
> But ultimately that strategy is good for the consumer right?

No. Temporarily it’s good for the consumer. Ultimately it is bad for the consumer, because as prices drop, so to does quality.

Re:Google changes its search box by itsmek on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:56PM (#48202912)
It's not uncommon for free things to be higher quality than cheap things, especially when we're not talking about physical goods. Think hobbyist vs hack. Selective pro bono vs quantity over quality. The former describes old internet while the latter describes much ad-supported internet. I'm not saying cheap is better than expensive, and I'm not saying everything works this way, but I do think many things do, especially for pure information that doesn't have a major capital cost associated.
Re:Google changes its search box by Ar-Curunir on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:28PM (#48202378)
No, because now Google controls entirely what you see. They could decide to show you the recipe after all.

Also, at some point even the ad-laden websites will die, and then Googles sources will be extinguished.

Re:Google changes its search box by goosejuice on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @12:56AM (#48203275)
You can find many ad free recipes in the cookbooks at your local library. They're likely of higher quality as well.
Re:Google changes its search box by Ey7NFZ3P0nzAe on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:23AM (#48203424)
> But ultimately that strategy is good for the consumer right?

No because it's killing competition and becoming an even more obvious monopoly. Then at any occasion they have to choose between consumers and profits, they'll do what shareholders want and increase profits.

Re:Google changes its search box by jasonkester on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:30AM (#48203465)
But google won’t give you the recipe. It’ll give you a pretty piece of text that resembles a recipe. You’ll only find out it’s not a recipe when it fails to produce a cake.

But then, the sites it's training on are starting to do the same thing, so maybe it won’t matter. Just last night, I pulled up four sites with “gluten free almond cake” recipes. One specified less than 1/4 the flour it would have needed, and another didn’t have any butter in the ingredients list. I had to eyeball the median and tweak from experience to actually get a bakable cake out.

Re:Google changes its search box by emayljames on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:04AM (#48203685)
You don't need butter to make cake, it ends up lighter and softer without it
Re:Google changes its search box by jasonkester on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:06AM (#48203694)
You need to compensate for not adding it though. The recipe without was literally the same ingredient list as the site it copied, just missing a line.

And almond flour does its thing by carmelizing in combination with butter and sugar, turning your whole cake into a sort of giant macaron. You can’t pull it off without any one of those things.

Re:Google changes its search box by subscribed on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:28AM (#48206043)
LOL, that's some confident pan-cake misinformation.
Re:Google changes its search box by tardedmeme on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:56AM (#48203632)
You can buy recipe books at brick and mortar stores, and they're mostly not AI slop yet.
Re:Google changes its search box by acron0 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:08AM (#48203704)
My partner recently bought a receipe book that was probably 100% slop, from the recipes themselvea to the images for each dish.
Re:Google changes its search box by soco on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:28AM (#48204320)
Completely unrelated to AI, I buy and always bought recipe books in second hand bookstores. It has this vintage vibe, and not everything has to be kale. Downside is that some ingredients aren't easily reachable, but it doesn't happen that often.
Re:Google changes its search box by specproc on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:37AM (#48205226)
Totally related to AI. You're gonna be able to spot slop whilst browsing.

Local bookshops are great, use them or lose them.

Re:Google changes its search box by ethbr1 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @06:24AM (#48205555)
My favorite are 50s and 60s recipe books. They use modern ingredients where appropriate, but mostly basic ingredients.

Later and you start seeing "Use this new processed wunderfood ingredient substitute!" (70s-00s)

Re:Google changes its search box by scrame on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:39PM (#48212119)
I kinda think everyone should have an old school "joy of cooking", where they have instructions on skinning rabbits and squirrels, just as a reference that things weren't always like this not even that long ago.
Re:Google changes its search box by yoz-y on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:54AM (#48205348)
Online grocery shopping service I use has added recipes to their website. Not obvious slop at first reading but then you see stuff like add 600g of carrots and 100ml of water to make a quite watery soup according to the picture.
Re:Google changes its search box by ethbr1 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @06:14AM (#48205475)
We're already post dead info.

The only solution is to find recipe books that were printed in previous decades.

Which is ironic, given that Google's entire value proposition (to users) was extracting signal from noise...

... and now it's come full A/B-advertising-optimization to being useless at that, when the need is greater than ever.

Imho, Google's greatest failing was missing how its own incentives warped creation of new web content, and failing to account for that strategically -- it turned the web into something it can't itself usefully parse.

Re:Google changes its search box by bsenftner on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:20AM (#48206524)
We have a distinct poverty when it comes to secondary considerations and long term ramifications - which used to be manageable when progress was slower. Now, we're on a very steep acceleration/progress curve, and any shortsighted mistakes cause extremely large ramifications. Which are then compounded by both more short sighted non-fixes and our rapid acceleration/progress curve layering in additional confusion, misunderstandings, omissions of critical information.
Re:Google changes its search box by taude on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:01AM (#48206985)
What kind of insanity are you all talking about? Plenty of cook book authors out there with good recipes, tested, big-personal brand, etc. no need to go to prior decades for good books.
Re:Google changes its search box by tardedmeme on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:12PM (#48211754)
How do you know which ones are good?
Re:Google changes its search box by subscribed on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:21AM (#48205983)
I'm not going to drive to the bookstore only to find out the recipe I need twice a year is not there because the local cousine doesn't even know the ingredients.

Oh, maybe I should drive to the major city and check several bigger bookstores?

Or order it online? But that would be from the third country because this one is weirdly blind to variety. That will be €20 for a book and some €10 postage.

You're sure I can just get my recipe from the store?

Re:Google changes its search box by steveBK123 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:12AM (#48205913)
Not really good for consumers in the long term. Creates a monopsony (monopoly on the buyer side instead of seller side) in the supply chain, with all the same negative externalities to competition.

Same reason its not good to have a "company town" where 1 company is the major employer to 50% of the workers.

Re:Google changes its search box by tremon on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:37AM (#48206122)
> But ultimately that strategy is good for the consumer right?

No. It may be good for the consumer right now, but not ultimately (and on top of that, I would argue that reducing everyone to a consumer is already the wrong framing -- you need to ask what's good for the citizens). Having ten competing supermarkets with various interweaving supply lines is ultimately much better than having one giant supermarket, because that one monopolist is able to squeeze both consumers and suppliers to the detriment of both.

Re:Google changes its search box by brookst on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:12AM (#48207132)
Do you think Walmart’s prices are higher than you’d pay if there were just ten competing stores with the same product mix, each of which did not have the leverage to squeeze suppliers?
Re:Google changes its search box by tremon on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:04AM (#48208008)
It doesn't matter what Walmart's prices would be -- because there'd be nine alternatives offering their products at different price points. Also, you seem to be implying that suppliers are inhuman and deserve to be squeezed (but Walmart somehow deserves all the wealth it extracts as a middle-man, go figure), which is exactly why I said that focusing on consumers only is a myopic view of the world.
Re:Google changes its search box by miltonlost on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:31AM (#48207456)
Please please please learn the basics of monopolies.
Re:Google changes its search box by brookst on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:18AM (#48218189)
While I appreciate the condescension, tell me how Walmart is a monopoly?
Re:Google changes its search box by gosub100 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:40AM (#48206730)
Not even the summary of the recipe, I think a lot of the "value" AI provides is decluttering the interface. All these perverse incentives conspire to make it undesirable for web publishers to simply show you a cake recipe. They need to meet SEO metrics for being higher on googles index, they need to monetize with ad and chum boxes. They need to distract and dazzle your senses. In the end, AI strips all these anti patterns out and shows you the meat. Or the "summary" of what should have been there all along. The "AI" isn't learning about what the words mean, it's stripping out cruft and filler that was deliberately added!

I'm not saying LLMs are worthless, but I'm saying if you had a magic browser add-on that simply stripped the BS out and showed you the relevant content, it would meet the use cases of the majority of people using AI (regarding search).

Said differently, Google are bringing you a solution to a problem they (largely) created.

Re:Google changes its search box by byzantinegene on Monday May 25, 2026 @02:11AM (#48263919)
except this isn't a solution. taking away sources just creates another problem down the road. there's no information to crawl from if no one is building websites to crawl from.
Re:Google changes its search box by BurningFrog on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:08PM (#48201808)
This is tough for the manufacturer, but great for the consumer.

I think it's a good tradeoff.

Re:Google changes its search box by CGamesPlay on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @08:48PM (#48201648)
That doesn't feel like a repetition at all? You said that the first time there was "traffic loss but without the extra google money", but that this time there's no extra google money either way.
Re:Google changes its search box by pflenker on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @12:38AM (#48203162)
The part where data providers lose traffic because their own data is displayed directly on the google premises is what repeats.
Re:Google changes its search box by rikschennink on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:00AM (#48203661)
A similar dilemma presents itself when blocking AI spiders.

You’re free to block them, but the websites cloning your content won’t. So either way they’ll get the content they’re after.

Worse, when/if the time comes that LLMs source their claims they’ll refer you to the websites that cloned your content.

Re:Google changes its search box by yard2010 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:36AM (#48203904)
That's the problem with the current monopolistic system, the money won't go down the stream, it's like a dam. One big dam owned by a few people is worse than many small dams
Re:Google changes its search box by Gareth321 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @06:40AM (#48205658)
I agree. For what it's worth, I think Google's business model is in trouble. They're putting in heroic effort to stay relevant during this shift to AI search, but how does their advertising model work when people expect summarised and accurate information instead of scrolling pages of ads?

The search space is actually not that unhealthy. There are competitors. They just lack the reach of Google. These competitor will become increasingly useful when our personal AIs plug into them to search for the right info.

That said, I think the old internet business model is dying. Why will people write articles and pay for hosting if they can't receive any advertising revenue? I think I'm okay with this. Before advertising decimated the free internet, people ran sites for fun. Maybe we return to that.

Re:Google changes its search box by bookofjoe on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:06AM (#48206386)
>... I think Google's business model is in trouble.

>Google parent Alphabet profit jumps 81% in Big Tech earnings roundup

https://www.euronews.com/business/2026/04/30/google-parent-a...

Re:Google changes its search box by jfil on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:08AM (#48208088)
Both could be true. I think Google is milking their main asset and tanking it, before the party ends.
Re:Google changes its search box by keeda on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:25PM (#48211076)
This comment thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47954579 is relevant.

TL;DR: Google is heavily stuffing more and more ads into every monetizable SERP, which explains the ever-increasing revenue.

But my theory (expanded in more detail here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47957708) is that its cash cow is heavily optimized towards its current anti-competitive, multi-sided chokehold of the online ad market -- look up the AdTech Antitrust findings around manipulating ad auctions, e.g. Project Bernanke -- which relies on ad volume.

With agents however, I suspect that volume will shrink drastically even if they stuff ads at each step of the conversation. Because it's only the final click that will matter, and those ads will be meaningless.

It's not clear that Google can charge enough for that final click to compensate for the loss of both, the value of all the ads that lead to it, as well as their ad auction manipulation premium.

Re:Google changes its search box by sandworm101 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @06:48AM (#48205707)
>> but how does their advertising model work when people expect summarised and accurate information instead of scrolling pages of ads?

1) because that fancy summarised results page will effectively be the ad. The results will push you towards google's partner sites or promote behavior benificial to them.

2) because partners may soon be able to pay to change the results of searches. Who won an election 20 years ago? That "fact" from the AI could depend on which answer has been sponsored by which political interest. What happened in china in 1989 ... how much money do you have?

3) the user becomes the product. No ads in search results, but our searches and online behavior tracked by them will be sold to whoever is most interested in what we do online.

Re:Google changes its search box by b112 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:20AM (#48205975)
Hanging my comment here, not blaming the parent poster, it's just relevant...

All the "AI search" I've tried is far less relevant than a proper search, using search engines without it seems much faster and more relevant.

Whenever I get AI search results, its summaries lack substance, are often just plain wrong, and so on. When I check, it's often usong the wrong aggregate data to return results.

Search engines these days, traditional ones, have been hobbled by targeting the lowest common denominator. They drop search terms, alias them (eg, Joe=Joseph,Josephene, Jodiene), and thus return endless bad results.

Using "web" search on Google, for example, putting all search terms in quotes, helps enormously. If searching for Joe Baker, you don't want aliased responses.

My point is, AI is yet another abstracted layer. It not only aliases things, it halucinates, and further, it doesn't even show the context it simply summarizes.

It's the next layer of crappiness.

As a side note, there os a product in my home country called the Swiffer. It is like a broom, but uses disposable sticky paper instead of broom bristles and a scoop.

Point is, it isn't very environmentally friendly. I weirdly see environmentalists using it, instead of just a good old broom.

And now I see environmentalists using AI for search. What? Why! The sheer additional power and cost, all the new datacenters, hardware, just for what??

Even of one believes it is mildly better (which it isn't, if you use traditional search properly), are you now replacing your broom with a swiffer?!

The amount of environmentalism that goes out the window, for convenience, astonishes me.

Re:Google changes its search box by bookofjoe on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:12AM (#48206427)
>All the "AI search" I've tried is far less relevant than a proper search, using search engines without it seems much faster and more relevant.

I've had the opposite experience with Perplexity Pro. Yesterday it took just under nine minutes to deliver a detailed and accurate answer as to the nearest locations where I can buy Meta Ray-Ban Display glasses (at least 3 hours drive away FWIW) that day.

In the past several months I've spent countless hours using search engines with dismal results that weren't close to that.

Re:Google changes its search box by sandworm101 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:20AM (#48206526)
It is totally dependant on context. Ask about product purchases/prices and it will give you great results. Ask for basic data and it will quote wikipedia or government websites all day. Ask for a coding solution and it will spit out answers ripped from the corners of github. But i asked google about hydrogen-3 recently and got back a result saying that we were mining it on the moon. An entire space economy was invented because AI cannot tell scifi from reality.

The real test: dont test AI by asking it questions you already know. Ask it a proper question and then go out and find the answer yourself. That is where AI really falls down, the non-trivial stuff.

Re:Google changes its search box by gosub100 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:30AM (#48206636)
Regarding a swiffer: it's a zero sum game. Where did the materials come from? The earth. Where did they return after use? The earth. The only thing changed was the energy used to create and transport them.

If conserving energy was important, none of these AI datacenters would be built, none of our items would be shipped across the planet from Asia. They would conserve energy and import raw materials only.

Re:Google changes its search box by taude on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:57AM (#48206932)
I’ve experienced the opposite. I get good summaries with links for original sources when something seeems off, which it almost never does. I also like that I can glance to see where the data came from.

Several months ago, I was getting hallucinations and silly answers, like Jaco Pastoreous being the bass player for Metallica.

but lately it’s been great. Especially for technical syntax stuff, like asking for syntax on a jq command, or sal syntax, or something trivial like movie casts members….

Edit: I also assume there’s now some pre-processing filter to retrieve answers from a cache or something, because I’m getting pretty long answers very quickly….

Re:Google changes its search box by mannanj on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:51AM (#48207796)
I've noticed something of a hybrid of what you posted and what one of your responders below posted.

For average results, that can have an acceptable answer that tends to the mean or societal mainstream views along some subject, the google answer works for me. For others, which are well unfortunately most of my queries these days, the google answer is brainwashing and propaganda. It feels little more than a continuation of the SARS-COV-2 era fact checkers which were actually failed attempts at propaganda machines for enforcing certain views as true while others were cited as "evidence does not suggest" (hand selecting the evidence of course means this is nothing more than confirmation bias).

I think the AI technology used in most LLM models is an acceleration of this- it will tout mainstream views or hand-picked views as truth while calling others false. And without an ability to search any more for opposing views, you get left with a really warped view of reality that might work for most. Though not for everyone.

Re:Google changes its search box by dormento on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:01PM (#48212442)
While I agree in principle, I think it was inevitable. People been gaming SEO for so long that even with judicious use of search operators, it was getting harder to find the things I wanted (probably drowned in a sea of spam in such a way as to fall outside of the optimized search index). It _looks like_ the AI overview does not have this problem (yet...).
Re:Google changes its search box by eitally on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:59PM (#48211592)
Anecdotally, I find Google's AI Search results to be genuinely helpful much of the time, and the box isn't so intrusive that it prevents me from digging into literal search results if I am not satisfied with the AI summary.
Re:Google changes its search box by simulator5g on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:37PM (#48217155)
The new business model is misinformation sold by the highest bidder. Ask it what's the most reliable kind of computer, it answers with whoever paid the most this week.
Re:Google changes its search box by wmeredith on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:12AM (#48208167)
That's a pretty sinister system when the dam builders are suing the work of those downstream to build their damn. What happens when everyone downstream has been starved to death?
Re:Google changes its search box by theptip on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @11:04AM (#48209028)
Obviously the pitchforks come out before then.

But! Does Musk have his robot army or not at this time? That will determine how the pitchfork mob turns out.

Re:Google changes its search box by soraminazuki on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:49AM (#48208806)
The very people calling the shots have so far been the most removed from the consequences of their actions. They have no incentive to be responsible or considerate of others.
Re:Google changes its search box by zackmorris on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @11:22AM (#48209264)
That's why if trickle-down economics were real, its proponents would also support antitrust enforcement
Re:Google changes its search box by ozim on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:48AM (#48203987)
Then we go and pay to Cloudeflare or other cloud providers you host sites with to prevent Google from scraping.

Let the big guys fight it out.

There is money in protecting the websites. If you host with OVH they are interested in you making money so you can pay them.

Re:Google changes its search box by arisAlexis on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:13AM (#48204211)
Ok but how would people find your website then
Re:Google changes its search box by esseph on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:34AM (#48204360)
You put it in your hn bio /s
Re:Google changes its search box by ozim on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:32AM (#48206075)
How are people finding your website now?

You are on top of Google search results or something? I think I am on some last page that no one will click like 2nd page of results.

Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:27AM (#48206602)
This won't work because Google just pays Cloudflare to enable scraping.
Re:Google changes its search box by brookst on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:19AM (#48207253)
Any evidence for this claim?
Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:56AM (#48207875)
Re:Google changes its search box by brookst on Thursday May 21, 2026 @08:43AM (#48221746)
I don’t see where they charge for it.
Re:Google changes its search box by altmanaltman on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:27AM (#48207380)
But like why would anyone make original content or websites anymore if google actively works to ensure you make no money
Re:Google changes its search box by lexlambda on Thursday May 21, 2026 @01:59PM (#48226632)
Why? To sell you something. If the traditional web incentives were to disappear, the internet will become just ads, selling things & work.

The web won't die. It will just become even more commercialized than it already is. You might recognize most of the things listed.

Selling things: Restaurants, hotels, local businesses; Ads: more of the same

Work: a) Projects people collaborate on and need to share information b) Writing articles to boost a resume

And maybe sharing what people do, they do it for free, see social media.

Re:Google changes its search box by Yizahi on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:49AM (#48207771)
Oh the joys of the free market. At least Google didn't have to suffer any red tape or taxes, and we all should deeply care about Google's suffering.
Re:Google changes its search box by ABCLAW on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @11:02AM (#48208999)
>History repeats itself here, with the difference that instead of paying for the data, the ai crawlers simply take it for free.

This discussion was broached originally when discussing whether or not search engines and aggregators had any compensation obligation in respect of news articles. This was a hot topic in the IP and policy circles for a few years.

When the Canadian government attempted to create a mechanism to compensate content creators for the scraped content, there was widespread outrage from tech circles, despite the same community agreeing, across extensive policy discussions, that action had to be taken to prevent this universal man-in-the-middle value capture by search engines.

I've had fairly extensive discussion with the individuals involved in the academic, policy and internal industry analysis of the issue. Watching industry agree to address the issue, then aggressively spend to shape public narratives in public was eye opening.

The recent shift into "AI is obviously going to hoover up all your data and there's nothing you can do now that the theft is laundered through an LLM" is just the latest example of the same trend of short sighted capital-over-everything decision making we've become used to in jurisdictions that have dysfunctional legislatures.

Re:Google changes its search box by pokot0 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:57PM (#48198623)
Internet is more and more becoming a commercialization platform. If you are selling something on your website, you still want Google (or ChatGPT for that matters) to expose customers to your product. The gate is the actual delivery of the product is behind a purchase/signup. Google and others want to control the entire customer journey, to the point the your website is simply a way to pass metadata to them. They are actually achieving this!

this kills the entire internet vibe of the 90s, early 2k

Re:Google changes its search box by nine_k on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:04PM (#48199623)
> is more and more becoming a commercialization platform

FTFY: "couple of decades since has become". The vibes of passion-driven 1990s started to be overwhelmed by the din of money right when the Internet has become a major commerce venue, some time in early 2000s.

Re:Google changes its search box by 1718627440 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:42AM (#48205256)
The content has long been commercialized, it's the platform itself, that it is now undergoing that change.
Re:Google changes its search box by soco on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:30AM (#48204346)
Maybe it's time to think about alternative ways to market your products, if search engine ranking and SEO got broken. I have no idea how, I don't need or do that, but it seems we're past breaking point.
Re:Google changes its search box by wvenable on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:37PM (#48198329)
It's a catch-22. Without google crawling your site, you don't get any new traffic. But with google crawling your site, you also might not get any traffic.

AI summarization has already causes issues for sites like rtings where people are no longer visiting the site but still making use of the data presented there. Leading to rtings not getting enough traffic to continue to post their data.

It is an existential crisis for websites and when they go away it'll be an existential crisis for AI.

Re:Google changes its search box by kxrm on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:55PM (#48198596)
> Without google crawling your site, you don't get any new traffic. But with google crawling your site, you also might not get any traffic.

I may be strange and unusual, but I just have never cared about my Google ranking. I know this makes me out of the ordinary among site owners but I have been humming along fine.

This certainly will disrupt traffic but for some of my sites I honestly think this is a good thing. I want you to want to be there, not just stumble upon my site because you happen to hit the right search keyword. Plus if it gets bad, this does create a new opportunity for others with cross linking and search.

Re:Google changes its search box by prinny_ on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:27PM (#48199066)
Only issue is what happens when the company that owns the search and has a dominant share of the browser market flags your site with the good old "warning: potential risk ahead" when people try to reach it directly? And buries the "I know the risk let me through" deep in the browser settings. Advocate for different browsers? Google is pushing web attestation in one form or the other. I wish the future would look bleak, because right now it's looking blue, red, yellow and green and it's worse.
Re:Google changes its search box by kxrm on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:02PM (#48199597)
> Only issue is what happens when the company that owns the search and has a dominant share of the browser market flags your site with the good old "warning: potential risk ahead" when people try to reach it directly?

My target market is more technical then that so likely, nothing would change for me. Again, I recognize the impact of Google's dominance for some, but if the "attestation" isn't helpful and only hinders using services that people have come to rely on, there will be push back.

I also have been advocating for years for everyone in my circle to avoid using Chrome. A homogenized browser market is a risk, and Chrome is the new IE. I hope you are also a part of the effort to advocate for browser diversity.

Re:Google changes its search box by tardedmeme on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:59AM (#48203655)
You could lose your domain name: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47151233
Re:Google changes its search box by 1718627440 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:41AM (#48205249)
> flags your site with the good old "warning: potential risk ahead"

They are already training people to click these away.

Re:Google changes its search box by account42 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:45AM (#48206193)
Don't forget that other browsers also just use googles web good boy list and if you report false positives point you towards google and cover their ears.
Re:Google changes its search box by carlosjobim on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:30PM (#48199107)
> I have been humming along fine.

Do you depend on site visitors for making a living? That's what this is about.

Re:Google changes its search box by kxrm on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:55PM (#48199507)
Yes! However most of my users were established through my network, not search.

I know that sites relying on ad income will and are being hurt tremendously by this effort on Google's part. However, if you are in the startup space and make money on services you offer, search should be one of several strategies you are deploying for user growth.

Re:Google changes its search box by vasco on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:00AM (#48203659)
This is like saying people should just win the lottery or something. Your conditions are extremely niche
Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:29AM (#48206628)
> I may be strange and unusual, but I just have never cared about my Google ranking.

But that's why you're a nobody instead of a million dollar startup founder. You didn't play the game, so, you lost. I lost too.

Re:Google changes its search box by elevation on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:43PM (#48198403)
> Without google crawling your site, you don't get any new traffic

What about the stories of marketing managers who learned months after the fact that their credit card had expired and their google ad spend had ceased with no affect on traffic? Google isn't always an effective promotional vehicle.

Re:Google changes its search box by loloquwowndueo on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:01PM (#48198662)
Sounds like a pretty ineffective manager: wasn’t buying the correct ad placement in the first place, used a personal card to sign up for an ostensibly corporate service, didn’t keep track of expiration dates for the card, and was also ignoring email notifications from Google about the expired card. Let me know if I’m missing any other reasons why this manager should be fired instantly.
Re:Google changes its search box by elictronic on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:09PM (#48198784)
Most large corporations have company credit cards. The user is likely referring to his card being the company card.
Re:Google changes its search box by loloquwowndueo on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:21PM (#48200998)
Nah. Pretty sure he was using a personal card - corporate finance dept would likely better track where each card is being used and their expiration dates to avoid this happening. Also this better tracks with the rest of his sloppy behavior.
Re:Google changes its search box by esseph on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:37AM (#48204382)
> corporate finance dept would likely better track where each card is being used and their expiration dates to avoid this happening

I have seen this happen first hand at a Fortune 100. They didn't track shit.

Re:Google changes its search box by vntok on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:39PM (#48199260)
Well in addition to what you wrote, the marketing manager ALSO wasn't tracking any ad-related marketing performance indicator (CTR, CR, etc.) in any measurable way for very long periods of time... or they would have caught it almost immediately ("wow ad spend, CTR and CR have all suddenly gone down to 0/0% and have been staying there for days on all our campaigns! What's up with that?").
Re:Google changes its search box by seb1204 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:35AM (#48206100)
Could be a smaller company.
Re:Google changes its search box by maccard on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:50PM (#48198513)
What stories are they?
Re:Google changes its search box by elevation on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:12AM (#48208157)
There were a couple similar stories in a previous HN article/discussion that I would have bookmarked had I anticipated this discussion.
Re:Google changes its search box by monooso on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:50PM (#48198512)
That's some catch, that catch-22.
Re:Google changes its search box by BubbleRings on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:25PM (#48200508)
I see everything twice!
Re:Google changes its search box by Boxxed on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:04PM (#48201779)
It's the best there is.
Re:Google changes its search box by WarmWash on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:03PM (#48201764)
> Leading to rtings not getting enough traffic to continue to post their data.

And here I thought denying ad revenue to websites was the morally superior way to navigate the web...

Re:Google changes its search box by monkpit on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @12:59AM (#48203294)
Step 1, Google serves info directly and consumers rejoice

Step 2, Google extinguishes the web and nobody has a reason to publish content, consumers lament but are trapped, Google has created a platform to serve content instead of links

Step 3 (or maybe 2a), Google is now monetizing their content machine

Step 4, Google offers people a way to contribute to the content machine, make some $$ per N views, whatever. People create content within the ecosystem

Step 5, Google is now the internet, more content is created overall, quality is lower overall perhaps, algorithmic echo chambers flourish even more than today, old heads on HN lament, everyone else just goes on living

Re:Google changes its search box by jcattle on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:09AM (#48204174)
I mean this is already (kind of) the case for video.

There's no real mainstream way outside of youtube to make meaningful money with free video content.

But yes, interesting thought which does kind of make sense. The marketplace-ification of the textual web.

Re:Google changes its search box by eithed on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @04:35AM (#48204753)
With google search you don't get money for creating content as people rely on summary provided by the search.

Imagine people would go to youtube and watch previews of your videos solely; or the preview is your video, but condensed and given preferential treatment.

Re:Google changes its search box by jcattle on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:01AM (#48207961)
> With google search you don't get money for creating content as people rely on summary provided by the search.

I'm aware. And I'm curious how that will play out. Because same as with Youtube, historically Google Search gave the means and the discoverability to monetize producing valuable free content.

Youtube is directly dependent on people producing free content. If Youtube wouldn't pay its creators as well as it does, it would simply die.

Same with Google Search. Good content and good SEO gives the means for websites with free content to survive. Google usually takes a cut on ad placement on those pages with AdSense.

If Google Search now doesn't pay content creators as well as it used to, what will happen to free content on the web? It's bad for Google and it's bad for the creators.

We will see.

Re:Google changes its search box by larodi on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:28AM (#48206041)
how about Tiktok - seems quite meaningfully getting money to people. Of course with short-format video, but still video, right?
Re:Google changes its search box by jcattle on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:04AM (#48208011)
As far as I know, Tiktok pays significantly less than Youtube. But yes, TikTok is a thing, as well as Twitch.

Still, it's all very centralized platforms, which historically isn't the case for all the monetized free content you usually get from google search (reviews, recipes, travel guides, converter sites etc. etc.)

Re:Google changes its search box by account42 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:50AM (#48206237)
Since "making money with free content" essentially means manipulating your users into spending more money elsewhere from which you then get some indirect kickbacks, I don't think we need to lament there being fewer opportunities for that particular business model. That's not to say that video centralization doesn't have other actually bad effects.
Re:Google changes its search box by camillomiller on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:49AM (#48205305)
If so, I can only see a silent Laotian Buddhist monastery in my future. Until Larry Page buys it out, of course.
Re:Google changes its search box by pferde on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:52AM (#48206249)
Haven't they tried doing Step 4 already? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knol
Re:Google changes its search box by pelasaco on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:54AM (#48203619)
> AI summarization has already causes issues for sites like rtings

Isn't Stack Exchange the emblematic case?

Re:Google changes its search box by tardedmeme on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:58AM (#48203646)
Stack Exchange committed suicide by closing all the questions. It was already in a steep decline before LLMs, after it got bought by private equity and did things like firing the moderators.
Re:Google changes its search box by kid_cubi on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @04:41PM (#48213814)
Related but not related: I wonder if, on a YT video, clicking on "Ask AI" and generate a summary of the video counts as seeing the video in its entirety.
Re:Google changes its search box by deaton on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:42PM (#48198391)
What you gain? Nothing, but they and other AI companies have decided not to respect your robots.txt
Re:Google changes its search box by loloquwowndueo on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:02PM (#48198677)
There are other ways to block robots from crawling our sites. I have a robots.txt but place no faith in it, it’s just there because it’s cheap and does stop some of the crawlers.
Re:Google changes its search box by franze on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:13PM (#48198847)
well its already happening and people are fighting over traffic crumbs already, they call it GEO
Re:Google changes its search box by coldpie on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:28PM (#48198212)
> allowing Googlebot to crawl my sites

As far as I know, you don't have a choice. They have no obligation to respect your wishes, and LLMs are legally allowed to scrape & republish your content.

Re:Google changes its search box by oh_no on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:15PM (#48198864)
except google does respect robots.txt so you do have a choice?
Re:Google changes its search box by PunchyHamster on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:21PM (#48198975)
still respects robots.txt
Re:Google changes its search box by margalabargala on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:41PM (#48198388)
> They have no obligation to respect your wishes

I have no obligation to not send all scraper-looking traffic to a black hole full of zip bombs.

Re:Google changes its search box by charcircuit on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:29PM (#48199094)
You do have an obligation because what you are describing is illegal, at least in the US under the CFAA.
Re:Google changes its search box by margalabargala on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:28PM (#48200542)
Okay, nix the zip bombs. What's my obligation to treat bot-shaped traffic as something I should reply to?
Re:Google changes its search box by charcircuit on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:34AM (#48203891)
Your obligation is not to cause harm to the requester.
Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:36AM (#48206697)
Sending them a zip bomb didn't cause harm. It was their choice to unzip it. Is jwz liable if a child sees his testicle eggcup macro when visiting via HN?
Re:Google changes its search box by charcircuit on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:48PM (#48213116)
Why send a zip bomb if your goal is not to cause some amount of a denial of service attack to the crawler.

Showing porn to a minor is not legal either.

Re:Google changes its search box by tardedmeme on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:49AM (#48205312)
Everything worth doing is illegal. Advice for startups is don't worry about it. Worry about not being caught instead.
Re:Google changes its search box by vntok on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:43PM (#48199334)
Spreading malware to your website's visitors is wild and illegal in most jurisdictions. I certainly wouldn't confess about it online.
Re:Google changes its search box by margalabargala on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:50PM (#48200735)
Malware? It's just a large file. A very, very large file.

But fine. How about I just...don't respond to those requests at all. I have no obligation to send them data period.

Re:Google changes its search box by ChoGGi on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:37PM (#48200022)
Is AI a visitor or malware? It certainly steals paid resources (bandwidth).

Disclaimer: his website is for hosting malware for "testing" purposes. Testing how well AI can't deal with it.

Re:Google changes its search box by xmcp123 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:58PM (#48200795)
There's always poison fountain - deliberately wrong source code.
Re:Google changes its search box by Andrex on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:10PM (#48197946)
Free speculation: I could see a future where Google populates a footer on results with the website logos of the sources. Presumably, the new web will require users to memorize websites/brands and go directly to those sites if they see a lot of their results are being provided by one source.

Websites may go back to being simply labors of love.

Re:Google changes its search box by runako on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:09PM (#48198786)
> Websites may go back to being simply labors of love.

The situation may be even worse. Back in the labor of love era, at least webmasters could get feedback from readers. In the LLM era, readers may not even know that the site exists. Without feedback/community, the overall quality of those sites will decrease over time.

Re:Google changes its search box by Andrex on Sunday May 24, 2026 @04:42PM (#48260829)
I've been mulling over your comment for a few days now.

On the old internet, "know one knows that you're a dog."

On the new internet, "know one knows (for sure) that you're an AI."

In a mixed discussion consisting of both AI and human participants, AI could generate interesting discussions and recite novel-sounding statements for ongoing ones. It doesn't sound plausible to me that an avalanche of profit-driven LLMs would even post -- I would think they'd be the lurkers. My take would be that LLMs actively participating, depending on the content they post, are also labors of love by some nerd out there trying to make the best LLM.

Drain all the profit motives and rent-seeking from the web, and even something like AI joining discussions doesn't sound scary.

Re:Google changes its search box by victor106 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:49PM (#48198502)
>I could see a future where Google populates a footer on results with the website logos of the sources.

ChatGPT/Claude does this today. I barely click or care for the source when they already have me the info I wanted.

My speculation is all information worth anything is going to be behind some kind of wall.

Re:Google changes its search box by nozzlegear on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:18PM (#48198910)
> ChatGPT/Claude does this today. I barely click or care for the source when they already have me the info I wanted.

Maybe I'm just #builtdifferent, but I click these a lot. Especially if I'm trying to research or make a decision on something, I want the actual source and not the potentially-fudged summary.

Re:Google changes its search box by victorbjorklund on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:44PM (#48199348)
I click those all the time if it is something that matters and I wanna verify that the AI got it correctly.
Re:Google changes its search box by microtherion on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:17AM (#48205082)
Absolutely! And I also click them to get an idea how good the source is.
Re:Google changes its search box by dbetteridge on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:00PM (#48201734)
Seems like a great way to end up knowing no real information and with no ability to analyse literature or think for yourself?

Not to mention the hallucinations

Re:Google changes its search box by al_borland on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:34PM (#48199196)
It seems like they should have a model similar to YouTube. If I watch a video on YouTube made by someone, they get a little cash, and it ads up.

Similarly, if I use Gemini uses a website for an answer, it should pay something to those sites for the information it gathered. Sites would need to sign up to earn via Google, and I'd imagine there would be a certain threshold to cross to make it worth cutting checks... but that would make all these AI search tools feel much less scummy while providing site owners an incentive to keep sharing information on the internet.

Where a model like this would get messy is with sites like reddit. It's a very popular source for AI search, but the value comes from the users, not the platform itself.

Re:Google changes its search box by vb-8448 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:56PM (#48199525)
Actually it cannot work this way, content creators make far more money from ads in the video itself compared to the one yt gives them. If it were for yt money alone basically we will still be in the 2010 yt: folks that doing it just for fun.

The problem with all this AI/llm stuff is that end users doesn't even know your tiny site with a lot of useful information exists at all.

Re:Google changes its search box by al_borland on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:59PM (#48200247)
> The problem with all this AI/llm stuff is that end users doesn't even know your tiny site with a lot of useful information exists at all.

This depends on implementation. I primarily use Kagi for any LLM stuff. I cites pretty much everything and links out to the source. I regularly use this for search. The normal search results may not have what I need, but a line in the AI results sounds better and I click through to the source to get more context.

I find clicking through to the source is important, as I've often seen the AI get it wrong. The page has what I need on it, but the AI grabbed the wrong thing and got it backward. I'm probably in the minority, I'm guessing most people don't use LLMs like this.

Re:Google changes its search box by vb-8448 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @04:00AM (#48204538)
Maybe there are some exceptions, but my[0] behaviour changed a lot in the last 3 years:

- in the past Google was the entry point for everything, I was opening every single site at the top of my search and navigate through it. E.g.: if the site was a Reddit or HN post I was reading comments, following links, ecc

- today I'm using google 1 in 3 times and I mostly read the "AI Overview" section. The other 2 out of 3 I go directly into chatgtp, claude or gemini and rarely follow any links.

[0] But I see the same pattern basically in all of my colleagues, friends and relatives.

Re:Google changes its search box by Manuel_D on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:58PM (#48199548)
Google's AI summaries already do this. I occasionally click through to see the underlying source the AI summary leaned on to generate the response, but probably only ~20% of the time.
Re:Google changes its search box by sleepycat801 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:46PM (#48200134)
I rely far more on bookmarks and memorised URLs now.
Re:Google changes its search box by Andrex on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:08AM (#48204160)
This is the future I see happening. And, I don't think it will be a total apocalypse. The web will endure.
Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:35AM (#48206693)
It's kind of like any extinction scenario though: Yeah, there will still be a big ball of rock after the nuclear apocalypse, there will still be life on the rock, and probably even still humans, but that only makes it slightly less tragic.
Re:Google changes its search box by Andrex on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:02PM (#48210746)
I have to focus on the silver linings or things are too sad. :(
Re:Google changes its search box by Unai on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @06:21AM (#48205533)
> Websites may go back to being simply labors of love.

If I'm gonna lose my job, at least give me that in return

Re:Google changes its search box by tedd4u on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:29PM (#48198224)
Vastly less but still more traffic than if you didn’t participate. I’m sure they will calibrate it just so.
Re:Google changes its search box by whazor on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:04PM (#48197848)
Websites tend to be updated and considered to be the source as well.
Re:Google changes its search box by thedelanyo on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:16PM (#48198038)
> then what exactly do I gain by allowing Googlebot to crawl my sites?

Mention

Re:Google changes its search box by lacewing on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:16PM (#48198880)
It's worse than that. They train their models preferentially on what they consider to be high-quality data. But if you look at the usual "references" on search queries, they're often just a post-hoc BS justification that links to spam blogs or Tiktok videos.
Re:Google changes its search box by swarnie on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:20PM (#48198089)
Allow? Deep down, do you think you have a choice?

Mechanisms might exist to make you think you have one, the same way copywrite should prevent millions of books being gobbled up by TheZuck but ultimately do you really have a choice?

Rules and laws don't exists for you.

Re:Google changes its search box by alt227 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:26PM (#48198172)
Yes, Google advertises its crawler IP ranges and it is quite easy to keep track of this and block them. But only if you control the infrastructure that your site runs on of course.
Re:Google changes its search box by rolph on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:43PM (#48198411)
stego your site, google sees the red herring version, intended users see the payload.

this has been done before, quite often, but toward ends morally askew.

Re:Google changes its search box by account42 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:37AM (#48206707)
You think they'll stick to those IPs any more than robots.txt when it comes to that?
Re:Google changes its search box by alt227 on Thursday May 21, 2026 @09:29AM (#48222293)
Yes I do, I also think they will continue identifying themselves in the user-agent header.

https://developers.google.com/crawling/docs/crawlers-fetcher...

Re:Google changes its search box by UltraSane on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:20PM (#48198955)
Can you actually prevent Google from crawling your site?
Re:Google changes its search box by prinny_ on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:21PM (#48198976)
You're allowed to exist on the web. The alternative is you are pushed out, your site is not indexed and google / chrome labels it as a security risk when people are trying to reach it directly. The mandate is clear: give up the data or give up the spot.
Re:Google changes its search box by jefftk on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:39PM (#48199263)
I write things on the internet because I want to share ideas. If someone reads my post and tells a friend, that's great. If an AI crawls my posts and passes along the ideas that's great too.

(It doesn't work for ad-funded writing, but while I have substantial sympathy there this has historically been an unpopular argument on HN)

Re:Google changes its search box by mrtksn on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:46PM (#48201198)
Sure but this means that you’re no longer eligible to make living from your ideas, which can be fine by you but it eliminates entire class of people who used to make living from intellectual work.

This also could have been fine, it can bring back authenticity however for this to happen no one should be making money from it. Instead, only megacorps make money and they can just ignore your ideas and generate theirs. They control the distribution and the supply now.

Re:Google changes its search box by satvikpendem on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:03PM (#48202615)
Not making a living from ads specifically, sure, but many have things like Substack which actually directly incentivizes them to make good content rather than serving ads.
Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:04AM (#48203678)
Substack is not all websites. There are more than one kind of website out there.
Re:Google changes its search box by kennywinker on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:43PM (#48199329)
Setting aside ad-driven revenue - the ideas, when spat out by an llm, are disconnected from the author. If people like your ideas, they aren’t becoming fans/followers/long-term-readers. That means good luck leveraging some interesting writing into a book, a speaking tour, a podcast, or even any kind of consistent readership. The llm slurps up your content and monetizes it while you get nothing.
Re:Google changes its search box by jefftk on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:50PM (#48199438)
I'm not interested in a book, speaking tour, or podcast. I've never had consistent readership because I write about too many unrelated things. I blog because I have ideas I want to share; I don't feel at all ripped off.
Re:Google changes its search box by arcatech on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:27PM (#48199917)
And do you think that’s how everyone should feel? If not, how is it relevant to people not liking what Google is doing?
Re:Google changes its search box by jefftk on Saturday May 23, 2026 @03:26PM (#48250547)
People are certainly welcome to feel a lot of different ways, not trying to be prescriptive here. My parent asked: "what exactly do I gain by allowing Googlebot to crawl my sites?" and I was describing what I get out of it, in the hope that others might feel similarly.
Re:Google changes its search box by kennywinker on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:27PM (#48199924)
Fair enough, sounds like you won’t be impacted. But the vast majority of people i read online are able to write the content i enjoy because there are paths to earn a living off it. I expect the future of llm search will leave only hobbyists and slop producers standing.
Re:Google changes its search box by gbear605 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:47AM (#48205294)
Speaking as someone who is a bit more familiar with your site, the variety of content you post is really valuable. I know multiple people, myself included, who have either gone from EA to Contra or Contra to EA thanks to both being on your blog.

More broadly, I love it when an author I trust in one area writes about other topics.

Re:Google changes its search box by pera on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:26AM (#48203828)
Sharing ideas with people is nice, the actual problem is your ideas in this case are just a vehicle for generative AI companies to monopolize access to information and control our own cognitive processes, which is not entirely something new but it feels like we are now moving backwards: from free access back to ministry of truth days
Re:Google changes its search box by RyanHamilton on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:29AM (#48204338)
AI crawls your post, corrupts your idea or alters it to advertise a product and then passes that along. Still happy?
Re:Google changes its search box by victorbjorklund on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:42PM (#48199324)
Maybe you want your ideas to spread? If your sites purpose is getting ad impressions then yea no point. But if your purpose is to spread ideas then it is still useful.
Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:10AM (#48203719)
I have spent nine years putting out free information. Surely you realise that I have to pay rent and buy food while I do it?

My income isn’t ads, just getting a cut of the sale on the complex products I help you buy. Even that sort of curation takes time and effort.

Even for all the things I do for free without any revenue whatsoever - most of it, really - I do want to feel some recognition. I don’t want the interaction to be mediated by an advertising company.

Re:Google changes its search box by account42 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:31AM (#48206642)
Google is not going to be spreading ideas that they don't approve of.
Re:Google changes its search box by nine_k on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:58PM (#48199552)
If your site is all about disseminating information (like Wikipedia), then Google would provide a free mirror of sorts.

If your site is about your product, Google won't be able to serve the sign-up page from AI; the traffic would come your way. Same for a site that sell something: the traffic you're interested in would arrive at your checkout page.

Paid-content sites and ad-supported sites are screwed though, on top of their being screwed by archive.is and ad blockers.

Re:Google changes its search box by afavour on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:13PM (#48199738)
The really confusing part about the ad-supported sites is that most of them are supported by Google's ad products. So Google is eating their own lunch here.
Re:Google changes its search box by rchaud on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:21PM (#48200999)
Search Engine Result Page (SERP) ads shown on Google itself are far more valuable than display ads that get shown on random websites. Google has been slashing payouts to those sites for over a decade. More recentlt, they've been slashing search impressions to those sites as well. With search engine ads + Youtube ads + Play Store ads, they can probably cut out the third - party site ads business altogether and not miss a beat.
Re:Google changes its search box by watwut on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:56PM (#48212359)
> Google would provide a free mirror of sorts.

That is not what "free mirror" is. Like, that is not the same thing at all.

Re:Google changes its search box by esseph on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:11PM (#48199708)
> what exactly do I gain by allowing Googlebot to crawl my sites?

Site traffic

Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:12AM (#48203730)
That’s the thing, they have altered the deal. You still feed the machine but you get no traffic. Keep writing that helpful stuff though!
Re:Google changes its search box by rdedev on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:15PM (#48200413)
Sites pay good money to appear on top search results. Looks like the future is going to be sponsored AI sources. It's going to be even more difficult to figure out if google is presenting you with actual information instead of just an ad
Re:Google changes its search box by try-working on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:33PM (#48200598)
That's Google making way for its disruptor. We'll see who that is. Imagine a search engine that just presents search results. Groundbreaking.
Re:Google changes its search box by daemin on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:10PM (#48202254)
More likely you're going to get a search engine which returns results as short 5 second AI generated video clips with an infinite scroll.

(Torment Nexus rules apply here)

Re:Google changes its search box by duskdozer on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:02AM (#48205826)
As it turns out I found out some people use tiktok as a search engine. How exactly, I am not sure.
Re:Google changes its search box by jazzypants on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:17AM (#48207212)
You search for a term and then you watch videos until you're satisfied. I don't think it's a very good way to learn about a topic, but millions of people seem to disagree with me. It makes more sense when you remember that 21% of the American population is functionally illiterate.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy_in_the_United_States

Re:Google changes its search box by hansmayer on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:32AM (#48205184)
It was exactly my opinion after thinking about this for a while. This is essentially Google making their search engine into yet another website. Sure, there is certain inertia - people used to using Google - but it will fade out with new generations. They've shot themselves in the foot, they just don't see it yet, and it will take some time for it to become obvious.
Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:32AM (#48206652)
Thanks for the optimistic view. We could use more of that. I can only hope it comes about...
Re:Google changes its search box by gerdesj on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:39PM (#48201139)
(You misspelled someone as some)

Google has always crawled your site and been an arse! Now you get to decide whether they are hallucinating!

You can drop pointers on Masto and other socials to your sites - that has not changed.

Do we need something else? ie you drop a link to somewhere else.

Re:Google changes its search box by lifis on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:51PM (#48202543)
The expected purpose of websites is to spread information, so whether users get it by making a request to your website or to Google is irrelevant. In fact, if they get it from Google it's better because it reduces website load.

If instead the purpose of your website is to manipulate users for financial gain (for instance by showing media attempting to manipulate their purchasing decisions, after receiving a bribe from a vendor), and the information is just a way to lure users, then maybe this malicious business model will finally be no longer possible.

Re:Google changes its search box by AlexandrB on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:38PM (#48211253)
On the one hand, this is an interesting observation. The internet as it exists today is filled with product placement slop and real information is a rare commodity. The loss of these kinds of sites is a blessing.

On the other hand, Google played a big role in creating this problem in the first place. The search results have trended downwards towards this kind of SEO slop for the last 10 years and Google has been unable (or unwilling) to fix it. Plus, the AI results Google shows are not free from commercial influence and will probably only get worse in this regard. Except now this money will flow to Google instead of $random_internet_spammer. I don't know if that's any better.

The idea that Google won't eventually "manipulate users for financial gain" with Gemini is comically naive. That's how they're going to make money from this thing.

Re:Google changes its search box by ymolodtsov on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @04:30AM (#48204725)
Depends on what you're trying to do. Sell ads over your content? Probably not great. Sell goods? Still good for you. Become influential and spread ideas? Good for you.

It's the news media that will suffer the most.

Re:Google changes its search box by saddist0 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @04:36AM (#48204763)
Honestly, a majority of news media are just AI generated content (echo chambers). I personally feel Dead Internet Theory is true and has arrived already.
Re:Google changes its search box by ymolodtsov on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @04:50AM (#48204849)
It's like saying that most YouTube videos are bad. Sure, but there's a power law and most people consume the top content.
Re:Google changes its search box by conradfr on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @04:59AM (#48204945)
Who can lobby the EU for the right to abstain a website from being used for training data?
Re:Google changes its search box by duskdozer on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:01AM (#48205818)
It should have been a clear extension of the intent of existing copyright/licensing that training would be disallowed without consent, but "move fast and break things"/"possession is nine-tenths of the law" win out
Re:Google changes its search box by 1718627440 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:44AM (#48205274)
Copyright already exists, the issue is that these companies are doing it legally anyway. For me it is the same issue as with privacy: I'm deeply uncomfortable with the current situation, but there is no political fight for me to fight, because the law is already how I want it to be, it's the public perception, that needs to change, but that is hard to influence, without being rich.
Re:Google changes its search box by gblargg on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:18AM (#48205095)
> then what exactly do I gain by allowing Googlebot to crawl my sites?

Making the information available that you put up your site for?

Re:Google changes its search box by larodi on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:25AM (#48206020)
Exactly nothing, nada, zero. And given it does not only crawl, it trains on it, so that never ever should people come back to search for it again.
Re:Google changes its search box by vdelpuerto on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:27AM (#48206036)
honest question here, why there are lot of comments about SEO is dead?
Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:33AM (#48206659)
Search engines are dead. The industry has moved to GEO.
Re:Google changes its search box by vdelpuerto on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:58PM (#48212395)
Thanks. I'll take it a look
Re:Google changes its search box by le-mark on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:56AM (#48206301)
> then what exactly do I gain by allowing Googlebot to crawl my sites?

The counter argument is that sites are becoming more AI slop or may intentionally provide poison they don’t want to train on. There may be a cut off date after which training must be carefully curated; and the main body of data has already been collected.

Sites may still get traffic from agents searching for current information. Maybe even the resurgence of RSS? One can dream.

Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:23AM (#48206561)
The opportunity to feed it false information?
Re:Google changes its search box by gsky on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:16AM (#48207196)
I asked the exact question back in 2011 when they were showing images directly leaving me pay for bandwidth out of my pocket
Re:Google changes its search box by Minor49er on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @10:46AM (#48208776)
It's the Google AMP controversy all over again
Re:Google changes its search box by watwut on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:51PM (#48212280)
Nothing, but idea is that you wont be able to prevent it from happening.

In that case, the consequence will be that people will stop having webs. It is already happening with personal and niche sites.

Re:Google changes its search box by CSMastermind on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:13PM (#48198844)
This was the promise of Bing that never materialized.
Re:Google changes its search box by SoftTalker on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:23PM (#48198141)
The web as we know it is over.

Websites will die on the vine if LLMs intermediate all the content.

The "website" of the future will be an API optimized for LLM crawlers, serving plain-text content that no end-user will ever view directly. The SEO game will change to LLMAO.

Re:Google changes its search box by thisisit on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:19PM (#48198931)
Or more likely move towards substack or newsletters where the pitch is - Don’t let the LLM chose the output for you, go directly to our Substack/newsletter instead.

This will happen especially with things like conspiracy theories because the choice might be to pollute the output or share the general consensus. Like searches for Apollo landing conspiracy theories can either chose to present “alternate facts” so that people can “do their own research” and conclude it is fake or LLM auto corrects to “Apollo landing happened”.

Re:Google changes its search box by rchaud on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:33PM (#48201098)
Newsletters have a webview fallback with a public URL that makes them just as susceptible to scraping. If that ever gets fixed, Google will just scrape the full-text content in Gmail instead.

Newsletters have been around forever and never taken off like the open web and free blogging have. Slapping a Stripe integration on the backend hasn't led to Substack becoming a sustainable business not propped up by VC cash.

Re:Google changes its search box by SoftTalker on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:34PM (#48199992)
The truth is out there!
Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:17AM (#48203762)
Not every website is a blog. Substack is not suited to guides and evergreen information.
Re:Google changes its search box by BrunoBernardino on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:42PM (#48198394)
Alternatively, we can collectively "fight back" by not using Google and teaching others around us to do so as well. There are plenty of decent [1] and great (better) alternatives, where you're not the product [2]!

[1]: https://alternativeto.net/software/google-search/?license=fr...

[2]: https://alternativeto.net/software/google-search/?license=co...

Re:Google changes its search box by lyu07282 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:17PM (#48198900)
There is actually another way that was just hinted at a few days ago demonstrated by the EU courts reaffirming a law from 2019 against Meta, just force google et al to compensate publishers:

https://www.epceurope.eu/post/epc-welcomes-landmark-cjeu-rul...

Re:Google changes its search box by carlosjobim on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:38PM (#48199256)
That translates to "Force Google to give money to these specific organizations and newspapers which EU leaders wish to benefit". It won't help any individuals who has made great websites with important and popular information.
Re:Google changes its search box by lyu07282 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:17PM (#48202302)
Well that's just an example, You could mandate an API to allow bots pay their fair share; could ban google from using content it stole without compensation; could shatter google into a thousand pieces.. There are music rights organizations with small time artists to huge celebrities, they are strong organizations that collect revenue from big platforms and redistribute it to all artists as well. Lots and lots of ways to address this problem.

My appeal is just to realize that our implicit assumption that we can't do anything ever at all besides appealing to completely ineffectual individual action is in and of itself a strongly ideological and politically radical position to take.

Re:Google changes its search box by carlosjobim on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:08AM (#48205876)
It's possible to do that easily: By putting your content behind a paywall. Google can't access that legally. That's how book authors have won in court against both Google and the AI giants.

That also requires new ways to think about how you sell content online. Mass syndication has been very successful for music and video content, and much more.

Re:Google changes its search box by account42 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:43AM (#48206767)
That's a horrible solution:

- It assumes google should be the arbiter who gets paid.

- It assumes the only damage here is financial.

We have more than enough of these misguided schemes that just enrich small interest groups while inconveniencing everyone.

Re:Google changes its search box by buo on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:57PM (#48200780)
I can recommend https://noai.duckduckgo.com. It works pretty well.
Re:Google changes its search box by dyauspitr on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:08PM (#48202650)
Fighting back is stupid, these things are inevitable, and honestly probably for the best over the long-term.
Re:Google changes its search box by krige on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:05AM (#48203325)
Nothing is inevitable, and long-term effects of google's move are unknowable.
Re:Google changes its search box by dyauspitr on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:48AM (#48204466)
Well I’d like it to be inevitable.
Re:Google changes its search box by chadgpt3 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:38AM (#48206718)
We can fight back better by falsifying information when the crawler is detected to be Google.
Re:Google changes its search box by MSFT_Edging on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:29AM (#48207406)
You can make this particularly juicy by targeting information that could cause legal/financial trouble for companies.

Incorrect legal advice, incorrect critical statistics or incorrect compliance information.

Make it a genuine liability to rely on the AI summaries.

Re:Google changes its search box by ben_w on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:38PM (#48198345)
> Websites will die on the vine if LLMs intermediate all the content.

The current zeitgeist of them will, but I think not all.

My first website (GeoCities) was either before Google existed or very close to it. Connected to people via WebRings and directory listings. More recently, RSS feeds.

Re:Google changes its search box by SoftTalker on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:43PM (#48198417)
Yeah their will likely continue be a small underground of old-style websites I guess. But you'll have to be in the loop on how to find them, and very few people will pay to advertise on them.
Re:Google changes its search box by mrec on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:49PM (#48198501)
> very few people will pay to advertize on them

That sounds like an unalloyed plus. The perverse incentives caused by advertising have been the biggest driver of the web's decline, IMO.

Re:Google changes its search box by abirch on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:49PM (#48198496)
Here is what I think the future web may look like:

   1) Sites will have mcp / APIs for LLMs. So that when I ask my AI Agent du jour. It can call any of the sites where I have subscriptions for information. 
   2) Sites that are passion projects will be harvested by our LLM overlords.
   3) Sites that people don't type into their web browser and need ad revenue will die.
   4) SEO will finally die.
Re:Google changes its search box by latexr on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:08PM (#48199669)
> SEO will finally die.

On the contrary, it will flourish. It’s just that it’ll shift to whatever can trick LLMs into recommending your product.

https://www.anthropic.com/research/small-samples-poison

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20260218-i-hacked-chatgpt...

Re:Google changes its search box by Rp8yXmdmr on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:02AM (#48204970)
> 4) SEO will finally die.

I recently search for some generic home appliance term and google's AI Overview blurb ended with "For more information about repairing home devices check samsung.com" (non clickable)

I am sure SEO companies will claim they can make that happen on purpose, and people will pay them for that.

Re:Google changes its search box by jve on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:04AM (#48206366)
Well I recently also repaired home appliance (washing machine with fault code).

Opened ChatGPT, photographed the machine because I didn't know concrete model, he saw the error code. I told that it also leaked prior to today and it just said: clean the filter.

Did it, and now it continues to work :)

Another bullet point: Father has older Audi, Battery drains fast. Some mechanic said him to check comfort control module - usually does that for those older cars.

While I was measuring how much Amps battery draws and let ChatGPT know what I'm doing, he also tells me the same stuff mechanic did. I hope that mechanic wasn't using ChatGPT :) Anyways, there was no current leak after ripping out comfort control module.

Re:Google changes its search box by LetsGetTechnicl on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:29PM (#48198231)
That sounds like absolute hell
Re:Google changes its search box by stck on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:24AM (#48203809)
LLM agent is the new browser.

We had internet before we had browsers, then the browser took over as the main method of consuming the internet. It has a lot of problems and e.g. mobile apps are trying to fill the void, but they have their own problems. Next stage is the personal assistant agent, which will be the single entry point to the internet.

Re:Google changes its search box by jcattle on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:34AM (#48204365)
So when will you stop visiting HN?
Re:Google changes its search box by stck on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:25AM (#48205139)
Probably after the Algorithm adds its own custom tailored preference weighing to the HN submissions and meaningfully summarizes the discussion.
Re:Google changes its search box by Mordisquitos on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @06:51AM (#48205727)
That's an insightful prediction! Agentic LLMs won't only replace the browser, they will also optimize and enhance the content that you should consume. Would you like us to go deeper into how human comments and conversations on HN submissions will also become obsolete thanks to AI?
Re:Google changes its search box by jcattle on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:36AM (#48207523)
And then you will dictate your predictions on the future of the internet which your agent will flesh out into a comment?

But I would guess that the agents would already know their handlers well enough to answer for them.

Which will then get summarized for others by their agents.

Re:Google changes its search box by le-mark on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:07AM (#48206393)
HN blocks AI or otherwise alters the data. I tried summarizing a thread last week and Claude reported it only got a handful of entries. I saved the page as a pdf and Claude was able to process it.

Real human discussions will be gold going forward. HN should be paying us actually.

Re:Google changes its search box by einpoklum on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @08:22AM (#48206551)
No, they will not. And that's because:

* A large fraction of people are realizing that some search engines are soft-censoring, already; * Another fraction of people will not accept AI agent slop as a replacement for website search; * Another fraction of users will get annoyed/tired with not getting directed anywhere; * Another fraction of users does not rely on AI-focused/AI-exclusive search engine.

Between the lot of those, the non-Google-covered Internet has, and will, live on. Yes, with _less_ traffic - nto _no_ traffic.

Re:Google changes its search box by apitman on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @09:44AM (#48207678)
Or maybe we'll go back to creating websites for fun/passion instead of money.
Re:Google changes its search box by winterschon on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:14PM (#48199747)
He also spins a lot of trash talk about an industry he's never personally worked in as any kind of engineer at all. He's a "Journalist Covering Tech" without a degree in journalism, so he's not even a "Tech Journalist"; might as well be the blogger character from Silicon Valley.

> Bachelor of Arts degree in political science from the University of Chicago.

His hot takes are best ignored, is just convenient click bait for their entire negativity angle.

Re:Google changes its search box by jreed91 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:20PM (#48199812)
Brendan Carr is that you?
Re:Google changes its search box by nicbou on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:57PM (#48200227)
It has reduced traffic to my website by around 65%. I live from that website. My income is a function of the traffic it gets.

I spent 9 years of my life putting hard-earned information on the internet, and now big tech uses it to enrich themselves while putting me out of work. Even my backup plan - software development - is being devalued to hell. It's so damn depressing. We'll get the internet that we deserve.

Re:Google changes its search box by salomonk_mur on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @08:41PM (#48201608)
To be fair, the traffic you had was mostly routed by them as well. Google giveth, Google taketh away.
Re:Google changes its search box by ryanisnan on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @12:53AM (#48203255)
Callous take. You make it seem like only Google was giving here. If Google was routing users to OP's site, surely OP had something beneficial to give.
Re:Google changes its search box by atoav on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:08AM (#48203340)
No. OP made the content Google copied with AI to their landing page, which reduced the traffic.

But I forgot that they convinced you to accept AI as a magic "make copyright disappear"-technology.

Re:Google changes its search box by CalRobert on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:11AM (#48204190)
Had they been correctly punished for anticompetitive practices there would be other search engines with meaningful market share.
Re:Google changes its search box by jmusall on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:49AM (#48205307)
In my humble opinion it was balanced when Google gave traffic to sites and these sites gave good results for Google to show
Re:Google changes its search box by intended on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @07:02AM (#48205827)
Google giveth jack shit here.

Google users wanted to find that info. Google served its users.

Re:Google changes its search box by andsoitis on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:29PM (#48200551)
Isn’t Google’s ads flywheel depend on them sending traffic to websites?
Re:Google changes its search box by jcattle on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:27AM (#48204308)
Yes, but this just shows how google is not repeating mistakes of the Kodaks and Blockbusters of the world.

They keep innovating even if it means cannabilizing their main revenue stream. Which increases the chances that you will not still be stuck producing film emulsions while everyone else is slowly making bank doing digital.

Re:Google changes its search box by snowwrestler on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:05PM (#48201788)
Over the past year to 1.5 years, in the sites I run, I have seen a drop in traffic from Google, which leveled off, and is now slightly rising.

I think if you look through this thread you’ll see a lot of skepticism of the AI results, and I think that is a fairly broadly held opinion. The obvious way to check the AI answer is to click through to some sources.

I think for Google to stop sending me traffic, it would have to be essentially perfect at AI answers. It will never get there, especially as so many searches are opinion-based like “what is the best mobile phone right now.”

Re:Google changes its search box by dyauspitr on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:07PM (#48202641)
They will not do that because their cash cow ad revenue depends on it
Re:Google changes its search box by ex-aws-dude on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:44AM (#48203539)
Take it one step further, the ultimate endgame is everyone consuming things through their own LLM assistant

In the future I don't even use Google but my bot does

Re:Google changes its search box by spencerflem on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:46AM (#48203558)
I think the idea is the google is the bot
Re:Google changes its search box by ex-aws-dude on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:49AM (#48203584)
Yeah but google will inject ads, my future LLM bot will filter them out

Why would I want to be restricted to google’s “view” of the info

Re:Google changes its search box by popcorncowboy on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:23AM (#48204274)
Assumes you'll be able to parse out, or even discern the ads. "May contain product placement". The content is the ad.
Re:Google changes its search box by tardedmeme on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:51AM (#48205323)
(this bot exists and is called Kagi)
Re:Google changes its search box by voidUpdate on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @03:42AM (#48204417)
How does google get the information to create an LLM-generated response without sending traffic to any other sites?
Re:Google changes its search box by dust-jacket on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:15AM (#48205070)
By scraping them, same as always.

The difference is where once they scraped, wrote a summary and invited users to go to the site, now they just provide the summary.

Re:Google changes its search box by illiac786 on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:35PM (#48212063)
That article is not even two years old… “for a few years” make it sound like he saw it coming long before it started. He’s just describing a trend and its ineluctable destination.

But I do agree it will be or already is a paradigm shift. And a painful one.

Re:Google changes its search box by simonw on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @05:36PM (#48214479)
> That article is not even two years old"

From that article:

> There’s a theory I’ve had for a long time that I’ve been calling “Google Zero” [...] Regular Decoder listeners have heard me talk a lot about Google Zero in the last year or two.

But the point here is not that he predicted it first, it's that he coined a term for it and has been extensively covering it.