News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by andersa on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:50AM (#39023765)
It's incredible that there are actually people in this thread arguing in favor of Apple. You don't need to defend the trillion dollar company. They are not your friend, they do not care about you, your work or your life. All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes than make a few people who already have everything even richer.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by xanderlewis on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:42AM (#39025559)
I haven't done any defending, but I reject the idea that it's a ridiculous idea to do so. I choose (almost always) to defend people on the basis of whether they are right or wrong (by some measure), emphatically not due to some expectation of return on investment because they 'care about me'. Also, no one is defending Apple because they think 'the trillion dollar company needs defending' -- they're doing it, presumably, because they just so happen to have an opinion on the matter that aligns with Apple's.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by remus on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:59AM (#39023813)
I also think apple's 30% cut is excessive, but I don't think this line of argument helps. We should discuss the points on their merits, not based on who's making them and how much money they have.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nevir on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:25AM (#39024416)
Here's a little story / timeline from 2009-2010 (from my perspective as a dev on Kindle for iOS):

* we submit the Kindle app ...including an in-app bookstore... to Apple for initial app review

(Note: multiple ebook readers with in-app bookstores are already on the app store at this point)

* several weeks pass with no response

* Apple announces in-app purchasing (to be released several months later)

* Apple rejects our app: we have to give them a 30% cut of all sales through the app, or remove the store and all references / external links to it. We chose option 2.

* Apple forces the other ereader apps to remove their stores or go with IAP. Several (most?) just gave up and pulled their apps entirely

* Apple negotiates agreements with most of the major book publishers that if they want to sell books on iBooks, ebooks must be listed at the same price on ALL stores, and have a 30% margin

* Apple launches in-app purchasing and the iBooks store (with the iPad announcement, IIRC)

...aka even if we (or any other ereader app) wanted to sell books via our app, the terms Apple set forth effectively meant that ALL profit from those sales must go to them (and we would have to eat the bandwidth / service costs on top of that)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by slimsag on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:51AM (#39025104)
This may be the funniest and saddest thing I've read all year.

So $MEGACORP abuses their absolute monopolistic position in the market to underhandedly negotiate with book publishers and force their hand into working the way $MEGACORP wants: in order to gain access to $MEGACORPs completely dominated (but technically not a monopoly*) audience who wishes to buy books in a convenient way online, book publishers must bow down to $MEGACORP and pay the tax. Meanwhile, everyone else who sells books through alternative avenues is decimated because the audience only wants to buy books through $MEGACORP.

And you can replace $MEGACORP with both 'Apple' and 'Amazon', and it is 100% factually accurate. Beautiful. It's fucking turtles eating turtles all the way down.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:31AM (#39025464)
> This may be the funniest and saddest thing I've read all year.

‘Funniest thing in a fortnight’ sounds less impressive.

You’re comment is actually funny, the OPs just makes one sad and frustrated.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dsign on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:25AM (#39026757)
This must be f*cking really hard with our culture. I for once can say that I have been reading less because Amazon's recommendation algorithm keeps throwing at me books with trendy covers that make me cringe. And same with the blurbs. Sometimes, if I manage to go over my cringe reaction to those two things, the book under it is actually good. Therefore, I get a feeling authors and publishers feel they need to imitate the crowd and make the book look childish from the outside, in order to mollify The Algorithm.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by SamoyedFurFluff on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:27AM (#39026789)
Have you tried storygraph?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fallingknife on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:30AM (#39026808)
It's not really comparable because Amazon never did anything to try to stop anyone from buying books through any other channel. The platform they do own, AWS, unlike the iphone, is perfectly open to competitors to Amazon's retail business.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by stetrain on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:05AM (#39027817)
Unless you count selling books at a loss to hurt their competition.

It's a less direct form of market manipulation and one that doesn't usually meet the US's legal standards for antitrust, but it's a strategy Amazon loves to use.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fallingknife on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:20AM (#39028009)
A quick google search doesn't turn up many good sources on that allegation. The best I could find says that they do make a small profit but at a much lower margin than bookstores, which makes sense given Amazon's business model. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2015/07/13...
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rickdeckard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:52AM (#39029357)
It's mentioned in the lawsuit which described how Apple orchestrated the publishing industry to raise its prices for Apple to have room to mandate a 30% share [1]

Amazon was selling eBooks at $9.99, for Apple it was an issue because they couldn't ask a 30% share from publishers AND compete at $9.99 because Amazon achieved that price due to wholesale volume-deals, and likely not with a 30%+ margin.

Publishers wanted Amazon to increase sales-prices from $9.99, but due to their wholesale model they couldn't dictate that. Even when they increased wholesale prices, Amazon kept their sales-price of many NYT bestsellers at $9.99 making a loss (probably to drive eReader growth).

Quote: "Amazon continued to sell books at $9.99, losing money, even when publishers increased the wholesale price of books they were giving the online giant."

[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/how-steve-jobs-and-apple-fix...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by stetrain on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:41AM (#39028321)
That article lists one example which "likely still turns a small profit", and contains allegations from other groups that Amazon is selling some books below cost.

That small margin above wholesale in the article's example is probably still effectively selling at a loss when you account for overhead of running the store, shipping, etc. It certainly would be for a smaller competitor.

Either of those represents a price that a competitor whose only business is selling books cannot compete with. Amazon can offer these prices as a loss leader because of their position in other markets, not because it has found a more optimal way to run the business of selling books.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fallingknife on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:05AM (#39028671)
News articles are for clicks. If they could find an example of selling at a loss, they would have used that because it would get more clicks. The fact that they couldn't find one tells me that the allegations are likely to be false. The fact that googling "Amazon selling books at a loss" didn't turn up massive amounts of articles from anti-tech media companies also tells me that. The fact that selling books at a loss to drive out competition (which is, in fact, illegal) is not even mentioned in the anti-trust complaint against Amazon tells me that the allegations are false.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by macspoofing on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:31AM (#39028176)
>It's not really comparable because Amazon never did anything to try to stop anyone from buying books through any other channel.

Neither does Apple. Amazon prevents all of their sellers from selling their goods at any sort of discount anywhere else (including through direct-to-consumer channels).

>The platform they do own, AWS, unlike the iphone, is perfectly open to competitors to Amazon's retail business.

It's not apples-to-apples comparison. Here's a better one ... Amazon will gather competitive metrics from sellers on their marketplace (i.e. their 'partners' and 'costumers') and then launch a competing product, undercut them on price, rig their search (to prioritize their product) and ultimately drive them out of business.

Apple is bad, but their terribleness is limited to the Mac-iOS ecosystem ... Amazon is way worse.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:47AM (#39028418)
Nobody in the digital-marketplace business is a Good Guy. Unfortunately, sometimes we need two sets of scumbags to fight it out to find some decent compromise for society as a whole. See also: Miranda rights, VHS vs Betamax, etc.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fallingknife on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:07PM (#39032739)
> Amazon will gather competitive metrics from sellers on their marketplace (i.e. their 'partners' and 'costumers') and then launch a competing product, undercut them on price, and rig their search

Brick and mortar retailers do the exact same thing and make generics that are exactly the same as best selling brand names, put them in favorable shelf position, and even put "compare to <brand>!" on their labels. This practice has probably saved me multiple thousands of dollars over my lifetime, so it is definitely to the benefit of the consumer and I am 100% in favor of it continuing. If you, as a company, add nothing that can't be replicated to your product other than a brand label, then you deserve to be replicated and undercut. That is a perfect example of the market working towards the public good.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by macspoofing on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:15AM (#39027930)
Indeed - the irony was not lost on me of someone from Amazon complaining about Apple's anti-competitive behaviour. The difference is that what Amazon does is not limited to the book publishing space and a particular device. Amazon forces ALL of their sellers to normalize prices for all customers an all platforms.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fennecfoxy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:47AM (#39030165)
And the losers at the end of the day, are the consumers. Amazon & Apple are still making money hand over fist.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rustcleaner on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:13PM (#39031317)
Piracy: it's the only sure way out!
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ruddct on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:33AM (#39024947)
Don’t forget the kicker, that IAP at the time was unable to support more than a few thousand SKUs! And (iirc) that pricing, naming, etc for everything would’ve needed to be done through their atrocious web app.

Not exactly doable for the ‘everything store’.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nevir on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:34AM (#39024952)
Oh, lol, I totally forgot about those technical limitations! We couldn't even have done it if we wanted to.

Also hi :) long time!

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by torginus on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:27AM (#39024908)
Weird, this sounds super illegal, and anti-competitive, considering Apple has its own competing bookstore that's not subject to these fees.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hammyhavoc on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:37AM (#39024978)
In retrospect, yes, the consequences of what happened are now very obvious, but at the time, whilst there were a fair number of people sounding the alarm across the blogosphere, most people didn't care because the iPad was a hit, and the Apple reality distortion field was at its peak of effectiveness.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:36AM (#39025507)
The situation is farcical and feeling sad for Apple or Amazon shouldn’t happen. Consumers lost whatever the outcome.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hammyhavoc on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:35AM (#39025958)
Completely agreed.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nevir on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:29AM (#39024920)
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:37AM (#39025519)
So Amazon won (and consumers lost), where we could have had Apple win (and consumers lose).

There was little to cheer about whatever happened.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fallingknife on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:34AM (#39026849)
That fine of 0.016% of their market cap will really show them!
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by bsjaux628 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:09AM (#39024773)
That sounds a lot like price fixing and the same thing that Amazon is being grilled on with FBA
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by issafram on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:50AM (#39024612)
I did my first iOS development about a couple of years ago. Question, how in the world do you tolerate the storyboard XML files? One small change in XCode results in so many line changes. PRs are impossible to review with any confidence.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:28AM (#39025433)
That's a big argument for SwiftUI, which replaces storyboards.

But if you must use them, keep each storyboard small enough it's only going to be used by one dev at a time to avoid conflicts, and then combine trusting the GUI won't make stupid XML plus some automated UI tests to make sure functionality isn't damaged by e.g. a button being deleted.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by roopepal on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:20AM (#39025849)
SwiftUI does not replace storyboards. It replaces UIKit(/AppKit).

You can build UIs without storyboards/Interface Builder in UIKit just fine. And writing your UI in code indeed easily solves the whole versioning conflicts issue that storyboards have.

So no, not a big argument for SwiftUI, but instead for writing UIs in code.

SwiftUI vs. UIKit and IB vs. code are two entirely separate discussions.

But yes, I totally agree, if you must use storyboards, keep them as small as possible.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:24AM (#39025881)
> SwiftUI does not replace storyboards. It replaces UIKit(/AppKit).

Unless I've missed something, by doing the latter it automatically also does the former?

> You can build UIs without storyboards/Interface Builder in UIKit just fine.

Eh, perhaps the examples I've worked with of that were especially egregious (it's certainly possible given some of the other things very very wrong with that code), but my experience of such a codebase was very much not fine.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by watchblob on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:22AM (#39026739)
I have worked with lots of codebases using UIKit constraints in code. These were non-trivial apps (200k lines of code). You can create wrappers of your own to simplify things or use libraries like Snapkit. It works and there's no need to use Storyboards.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:36AM (#39026870)
The bad codebase I'm thinking of was 120 kloc. But I'll take your word for it being possible to do better than that example, one example is merely an anecdote.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by plagiarist on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:43AM (#39028368)
I think they want to make the distinction that SwiftUI is not necessarily to replace Storyboards, although it will replace them.

UIKit works okay in code. But unless you have experienced people actively laying groundwork, it's IMO more likely to be a mess than SwiftUI. Even the explicitly declarative part, Autolayout, will only be understood by like 10% of the team and the rest are kinda winging it. Using Autolayout outside of Storyboards makes it less declarative, so it is then more conducive to programmer error (like non-idempotent updates).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by 0x0 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:22AM (#39024869)
Answer: Don't use storyboards.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by plagiarist on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:20AM (#39027996)
Do everything programmatically. Especially because the XML is not (last I checked) compile-time validated against the symbols it is using.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jacquesm on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:07AM (#39024753)
Sorry but I can't find much sympathy for anything Amazon related when comparing with Apple. In my book they're both predatory.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:22AM (#39024873)
Well all the same things would apply to any independent ebook store, it would just hurt them massively more than it does Amazon..
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hammyhavoc on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:39AM (#39024987)
Perhaps the stance to take is that it was bad for consumers in the long-term, because monopolies aren't a good thing.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by elcomet on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:23AM (#39024877)
This doesn't affect only Amazon, it affects also all smaller online book stores
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jimbokun on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:15AM (#39027931)
They are not sports teams.

We should be rooting for better outcomes for consumers. Not picking between which megacorp is less bad.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by macspoofing on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:20AM (#39028011)
>We should be rooting for better outcomes for consumers. Not picking between which megacorp is less bad.

I will argue that pointing out the hypocrisy of a megacorp complaining about the anti-competitive behaviour of another magacorp, when it engages in the same type of behaviour but at a much bigger scale, is a pro-consumer move.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rickdeckard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:54AM (#39025664)
The missing part is that Apple's maneuver was to effectively destroy the wholesale model in favor of an agency-model, and orchestrate all major publishers to charge more for ebooks just so they can earn their 30% commission from it.

Apple actively engaged as facilitator to help publishers raise prices on the whole market, for a 30% cut.

The result was that books previously available for $9.99 were suddenly sold for $12.99

[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/how-steve-jobs-and-apple-fix...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Fluorescence on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:15AM (#39026262)
To highlight the untold level of harm Apple caused, I now realise this event stopped me reading for years.

I loved ebooks and my reading went way up. They were cheaper than paperbacks and cheap enough that I was making curiosity and impulse purchases. The problem with digital sales is that unlike a bookshop, I could not browse and take a book from the shelf and start reading and get hooked.

Once ebooks suddenly jumped in price and absurdly became more expensive than paperbacks, I was done, and didn't buy a book for years. You might try and argue this was irrational, but when I feel I am being scammed, my wallet stays in my pocket. I will indeed cut off my nose to spite an asshole.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by marcus0x62 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:43AM (#39026924)
Jobs was deeply cynical about ebooks, claiming early on that Kindle would fail because “people don’t read anymore”[0].

There’s some level of irony in the fact that the most successful product from the guy who wanted to build a “bicycle of the mind”[1] ended up being something more like the floating chairs in Wall E.

0 - https://www.wired.com/2008/01/steve-jobs-peop/

1 - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KmuP8gsgWb8

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by clankyclanker on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:39AM (#39026895)
Agreed, I only picked up reading again after finding Libby.

(A short story about how cheating the user with exorbitant prices results in the exit of your audience.)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by tekkk on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:10AM (#39026649)
I just looked and the last Song of Ice and Fire audiobook is 41€ in Apple Books. That is hilariously insane. I could perhaps pay that for all of them but for 1 — the others are basically the same price. That's 200€ for the set.

There are weirdly other audiobook versions that cost only 29€ so I wonder what's the story here.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by yourusername on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:40AM (#39027486)
Audiobooks are just expensive in general. A song of Ice and Fire is $39 in Audible on android (well it's on sale now for $27). Sadly $20-40 is a fairly normal price for a audiobook.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by tekkk on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:44PM (#39033944)
Yeah I think they are though artificially inflated by Amazon and co since why on earth can Audible sell them 8$ every month. Luckily there are a lot of old public domain books that you can listen to. Reading what Brandon Sanderson has to say about Audible to me was really revealing.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cheschire on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:19AM (#39026713)
And many other folks will keep wondering what the story is for 41€!

My bad puns aside, thank god for libraries. Otherwise these stories would be truly lost to the rich.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by troupo on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:48AM (#39027601)
What do you think it would cost?

It's a professional reading/acting out a full book in a professional studio, with at least an editor, a production team, a corrector. And the market for audiobooks is still very minuscule.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:09AM (#39028717)
If a band of professional musicians can put out an album with original music and multi-track mixing for $10, a pre-written book with a single voice performer and minimal production crew shouldn't cost multiples of that.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by TuringNYC on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:40PM (#39031645)
> If a band of professional musicians can put out an album with original music and multi-track mixing for $10, a pre-written book with a single voice performer and minimal production crew shouldn't cost multiples of that.

Not saying this is fair, but musicians often do economically sub-optimal things for the love of creation and because it is a passion. Hopefully, the musician also gets added revenue from concerts.

The voice performance doesnt get the fame nor after-performance revenue -- so naturally they are charging market rates for their time reading. Further, most of the credit/glory goes to the author, not the voice performer. I doubt most people know who the voice performer is on audiobooks.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lsaferite on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:09AM (#39028723)
> the market for audiobooks is still very minuscule

> A song of Ice and Fire is $39 in Audible

Is this really surprising? Production costs for a single audiobook are _significantly_ less than something like a movie, but the audiobook is more than double the cost of seeing a movie?!? I straight up refuse to buy audiobooks based on the price alone. Ebook prices are bad enough, but audiobook prices are ludicrous.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:22AM (#39028928)
Movies amortize their cost over a much, much larger audience than books do. A book that sells a 100,000 copies is a fairly successful book. A movie that sold 100,000 tickets is a complete flop.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rickdeckard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:41AM (#39030077)
Then add on top that Audiobook sales-volume in total is still smaller than book-sales, that Audible controls the majority of the US Audiobook sales, while the majority of consumption is actually their monthly subscription tier (which probably doesn't pay much at all). Then Audible takes a revenue-share of 30~50% depending on content, publisher and author also want to earn money,...

Then the audiobook of "A song of fire and ice" is apparently 33 hours and 46 minutes, which is more than 3 times the average length [1], so just the narration production-cost is 3 times higher than the average audiobook.

So overall there's not so much left to make a profit, leave alone break-even.

[1] https://wordsrated.com/audiobook-statistics/

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lsaferite on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:31PM (#39032285)
The statistics on that page are interesting.

> Younger people are more likely to consume audio format, as 57% of Americans younger than 50 listened to audiobooks in 2021.

I know I only have anecdata (I'm in that cohort), but that seems off based on my personal experiences and the people I know. Perhaps 2021 was an outlier?

> Over 23% of Americans listened to at least one audiobook in 2021, 15% more than in 2020.

This also seems off. Almost 1 in 4 Americans listened to an audiobook in 2021? That seems... high.

I couldn't find a link to the source data used to generate those statistics.

Based on your link, you'd be looking at something in the range of $24,000 for ASOIAF. Even if you double that you're looking at $48,000. If we factor in 50% (WTF?) rev share with Audible, that's ~2400 units to break even. And then they are clearing ~$20/unit after that. Yeah, I know I hand-waved a bunch of minutia, but my point is that the volume of sales needed to start making a profit, even considering a large rev share, isn't _that_ high.

I can't stack that against sales numbers, but I'll say this, even if it's a legit price based on costs and volume that it doesn't _feel_ legit to _me_. As a result, I won't buy audiobooks. I don't think I'm totally alone. I can't say much past that.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by troupo on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:30PM (#39033019)
> Almost 1 in 4 Americans listened to an audiobook in 2021? That seems... high.

Yes. A book. That's one single book. As with anything, the majority will listen to a few popular titles like self-help books and Harry Potter.

No idea how you arrived at $24000 for ASOIAF and then decided to randomly double it

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lsaferite on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:15PM (#39033575)
Given the lack of source data I can't tell if they talking X listens across Y population, or are they saying that Z individuals listened to at least one audiobook. Do you have some insight from another data source? If not, I stand by my claim that 1 in 4 Americans listening to an audiobook is hard to believe.

From the article in the post I was replying to[1]:

   Audiobook production is a multi-step process that requires equipment, software, a studio, and a narrator. Depending on the cost and availability of each of these aspects, the price of producing an audiobook can vary.

   * Generally, around 9,300 words of text equate to one hour of audiobook length.
   * The average audiobook is around 10 hours long, containing close to 100,000 words.
   * The average narrator charges around $200 per finished hour, meaning that the expenses on the narrator will amount to $2,000 for recording an audiobook.
   * On top of that, it is necessary to either rent a studio where the recording will take place or invest in the equipment and sound production yourself.
   * In either case, producing an audiobook will take between $4,000 and $8,000.
   * Some companies offer a complete production service for a fixed price, usually at the $6,000 range.

They are saying it's something on the order of $8,000 to produce a 10 hour audiobook. I tripled that to get to $24k since ASOIAF is a little over 33 hours, then doubled it just to account for things like more expensive voice actors or more expensive production. Keep in mind this was just napkin math to get a general range for what it would cost and I'd rather inflate it a bit just to be safe.

[1] https://wordsrated.com/audiobook-statistics/

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lsaferite on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:03PM (#39035480)
For anyone interested, I think I tracked back to the original study.

Edison Research’s Share of Ear is a quarterly survey of Americans who are asked to keep a detailed one-day diary of their audio usage. Share of Ear utilizes a nationally representative sample of those age 13+. The sample for this study was 4,118

https://www.edisonresearch.com/the-spoken-word-audio-report-... or https://www.edisonresearch.com/solutions/the-infinite-dial/

https://publishingperspectives.com/2023/06/apa-report-audio-...

https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/a...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rickdeckard on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:27AM (#39039364)
> Based on your link, you'd be looking at something in the range of $24,000 for ASOIAF. Even if you double that you're looking at $48,000. If we factor in 50% (WTF?) rev share with Audible, that's ~2400 units to break even.

That's ONLY production-cost, it doesn't take into account the royalty/license for the actual content-author and the cut the book-publisher takes for "publishing" it. I doubt that the author takes a smaller share just because the book was recorded instead of printed.

If you assume that production cost should make up max. 10% of that revenue (like the actual cost to design a cover and print a book), then the break-even shifts ALOT farther away...

> Yeah, I know I hand-waved a bunch of minutia, but my point is that the volume of sales needed to start making a profit, even considering a large rev share, isn't _that_ high.

Yeah, the scale is indeed hard to estimate, and I can't find ANY statistics on the actual volume-size of the market (actual amount a bestseller Audiobook has sold)

But the stat from the same source stating that "Audiobook revenue accounted for around 3.8% of the book publishing" is an indication that despite glorious growth-figures of the Audiobook industry, the actual market-size is still VERY small even in comparison to the book-publishing market.

AND at the same time, Audible controls ~50% of that market, and drives consumption with Spotify-like flatrate offers.

Making big upfront investments for Audiobook production seems to be a risky call for a publisher then. Unless you have a title like ASOIAF and set the price at 36 USD I guess ;)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by endemic on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:57AM (#39029445)
I can watch the whole (insanely expensive to produce) TV series for $16/month.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by troupo on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:25PM (#39032963)
No, you can't. What you can is have a million or so people pay $16/month which pays for these insanely expensive series.

So, let's assume Netflix. It has 247 million subscribers. You do the math.

An audiobook (and audiobooks in general) don't have that.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by amelius on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:12AM (#39025782)
Again, if you're against government regulation, then you haven't seen a company regulate a market.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fenomas on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:23AM (#39025879)
Another random app store anecdote: way back when (2010?) Adobe made a feature where you could publish flash content as an iOS app. Like you build a flash game, hit publish, and an .ipa file comes out. So the feature goes into open beta, and a bunch of flash devs make iPhone apps, they work fine, they get accepted into the app store, users are using them, everybody's happy.

Then a few days before the feature was scheduled to leave beta and be formally supported, Apple changed the app store terms to disallow it, by requiring that apps be "originally written" in certain languages like objective-C or C++. Nothing to do with what the app did or how it worked, and no definition for what "originally written" specifically meant. And there were lots of other technologies for building apps by then, so of course they all freaked (though AFAIK Apple never actually enforced the new terms for anything besides flash).

Anyway shortly afterward Adobe reverted the app-publishing feature, and then a few months later Apple quietly reverted the terms to what they were before.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:42AM (#39026431)
Apple is very much a subscriber to the Darth Vader School of Business: "I'm altering the deal; pray that I don't alter it any further."
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:31AM (#39026820)
You would think that as the web platform is starting to pick up things like WASM and many new capabilities that there are an extremely large set of apps all of a sudden where you would be insane to think about

- writing it in a different language that only really runs on one operating system

- pay $99/yr for the privilege

- at any point and for any reason you can be cut off from reaching your audience

- you have to pay them 30% of your revenue (not profit) for any money your application makes

- you can’t make updates in a timely manner

- you have close to zero avenues of recourse if you disagree with any of this

- the deal can change at any time and you don’t get a say in it.

Why the fuck would anyone choose that option in 2024 if they didn’t have to? It’s no wonder Apple went out of their way to try and cripple the web for over a decade now, it was only legal action from the EU that forced them to staff Safari properly about two years ago.

And even now, they still take any opportunity they can to make it look unattractive such as hiding the ability to install a PWA deep in a series of unrelated menus.

That’s a hostage taking business. Get out of that ecosystem if you can

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:15AM (#39027203)
> And even now, they still take any opportunity they can to make it look unattractive such as hiding the ability to install a PWA deep in a series of unrelated menus.

That isn’t true. It takes two taps. You tap the share button, then you tap Add to Home Screen. That’s it. That’s not “hidden deep in a series of unrelated menus”. It’s a top-level option.

And don’t complain about the “share” button – that’s just a bad name for what iOS users understand as the “Send/Put/Open this somewhere else” button. It makes total sense if you are an iOS user, don’t be misled by what people call it. People tap it when they want to “do something” with what they are looking at. It’s exactly the button you’d tap if you wanted to add a PWA to your home screen.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:19AM (#39027232)
Go and find a random person on the street and ask them to install a website on an iOS device and watch what happens.

It is absolutely set up in such a way that normal people not only can not do it but don’t even know it’s possible.

I should be able to trigger an install prompt as a developer at a minimum.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:00AM (#39027749)
> It is absolutely set up in such a way that normal people not only can not do it but don’t even know it’s possible.

Would you say that Apple are deliberately hiding how to bookmark a website and that people are unable to do that? Because you do that the same way too.

How about printing? Does Apple have a secret motive to stop people from printing? Because you do that the same way too.

The share button is the “Send/Put/Open this somewhere else” button. That’s just how iOS works. It’s not a devious plan. It’s a standard platform convention.

> I should be able to trigger an install prompt as a developer at a minimum.

This is not currently part of any web standard. It was implemented unilaterally by Chromium and hasn’t been accepted by any other rendering engine yet. It’s explicitly not on a web standards track:

> Status of This Document

> This specification was published by the Web Platform Incubator Community Group. It is not a W3C Standard nor is it on the W3C Standards Track.

https://wicg.github.io/manifest-incubations/

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:13AM (#39027909)
I don’t understand why you’re acting purposely obtuse here.

They have a multi billion dollar incentive here along with a long history of actions all clearly focused on protecting that revenue stream at the expense of the web platform.

I’m making an argument that like any other application delivery platform I should have a clear and standard way for my users to install my software.

The reason we don’t currently have that is largely tied up in Apple yet again with the exact same incentive structure as every other time they pulled shit like this.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:30AM (#39028165)
> I don’t understand why you’re acting purposely obtuse here.

Do you want to try that reply again in a less insulting way? Perhaps consider the possibility that people can have a legitimate difference of opinion with you without it being a stupid act?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:38AM (#39028270)
Im not trying to be insulting but this also isn’t a legitimate difference of opinion scenario.

You tried to do a weird gotcha by claiming that the ability to install a web app is no different to print a webpage and implied that I was seeing conspiracies where there were none to be found.

I’m saying that the thing I’m talking about has a very clear difference when it comes to incentive structures and I know you’re aware of it because we are in the middle of a discussion about it.

So I don’t know what other conclusion to draw here other than you’re pretending to not understand the difference.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:49AM (#39028465)
> Im not trying to be insulting but this also isn’t a legitimate difference of opinion scenario.

You are claiming that it’s literally impossible to honestly disagree with you; that the only possibility is that I’m deliberately acting the fool? Do you really believe that?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:08AM (#39028708)
I feel like you’re getting more worked up here than the situation requires.

If you took offence at the original comment where I said you appeared to be playing games by ignoring something I’m sorry.

I am however asking that you present some kind of rebuttal rather than trying to make this a thing about polite discourse on the internet.

I made specific points, you came in talking about unrelated points, I pointed out that your reasoning had a major hole in it and now we are in a conversation nobody wants to be a part of.

Let’s just say we both understand why an install prompt and printing a web page aren’t the same thing because I think we covered that ground already.

To get it back on track, I’m saying that they don’t belong together and that when you listed all that other random set of actions people could do that appear in the same screen that this illustrates the point I’ve been trying to make from the start.

If the argument is “oh that’s just iOS, it’s totally innocent and how could you ever seen anything nefarious there” then make that argument but as discussed, it has major holes.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:05AM (#39029559)
> I feel like you’re getting more worked up here than the situation requires.

I’m not getting worked up, I’m refusing to accept direct insults. It’s possible to do that without getting worked up. This place is supposed to be better than this and you’re falling short. If people don’t push back on behaviour like yours this place will be dragged down into the muck. Insults should not be tolerated here.

And telling people they are getting worked up when they complain about you insulting them, in itself, additionally insulting and inflammatory. Don’t do that.

> If you took offence at the original comment where I said you appeared to be playing games by ignoring something I’m sorry.

You didn’t accuse me of playing games, you accused me of “acting purposely obtuse”. You’re saying that I’m pretending to be a moron because my argument is far too stupid for anybody to really believe. You don’t get to put me in the catch-22 of either taking your insults without complaint or getting accused of being worked up. It’s entirely reasonable to reject your replies calmly until you stop being insulting.

> I am however asking that you present some kind of rebuttal

I already did that. You called it a “weird gotcha” and ignored it. I suspect you missed the point because you were so sure I was pretending to be an idiot. You are free to go back and read it again. If you still don’t understand it a second time, ask for clarification instead of throwing insults around.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:37AM (#39030023)
Just to be clear… your argument is or isn’t “That’s just iOS and there’s clearly nothing nefarious about it”?

That’s my good faith understanding of the point you’re making at the moment so I will try one final time…

Do you care to address the incredibly specific point I’ve made repeatedly that that line of reasoning has a huge hole in it which you seem to be ignoring no matter how often I ask you to acknowledge it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:46PM (#39030944)
> which you seem to be ignoring no matter how often I ask you to acknowledge it.

I wasn’t ignoring it. I was refusing to respond to replies with insults. I have been very clear about that.

> Just to be clear… your argument is or isn’t “That’s just iOS and there’s clearly nothing nefarious about it”?

No.

Your argument is:

> they still take any opportunity they can to make it look unattractive such as hiding the ability to install a PWA deep in a series of unrelated menus.

Let’s deconstruct that to three assertions:

- It’s deep in a series of menus

- It’s in an unrelated menu

- It’s being purposefully hidden by Apple.

I have pointed out several things:

- It’s a top-level item in a very commonly used menu.

- It belongs in that menu.

- Other items in that menu are also there for the same purpose.

- Apple has no incentive to hide those other items.

So right away, we can get rid of the first assertion. It’s not deep in a series of menus. That’s just plainly false, as anybody who has an iPhone near them can verify. It’s a top-level item in a primary menu. It’s a single tap away.

Next we move on to whether it belongs there or not. As I repeatedly point out, the “share” button actually exposes a whole lot more than just sharing. I’m not even certain “share button” is its official name, I think it might be called “action button” or something. You can consider it the “put this somewhere else button” because that’s what it actually means, even if the name doesn’t roll off the tongue. That’s the platform convention. That’s how iOS users perceive it.

Want to send it to somebody? Tap the button. Want to open it in a different app? Tap the button. Want to save it somewhere? Tap the button. That’s what the button is for. You are looking at something and you want to put it somewhere.

What else is in that menu? You can save a document to files. You can print it. You can bookmark it. You get a list of other apps you can open it with. You can add it to a note. You can copy it to the pasteboard. These all fit the same theme. You are looking at something and you want to put it somewhere.

Does “I want to put this PWA on my Home Screen” fit there? It absolutely does. That’s exactly where I’d locate the feature. You are looking at a PWA, and you want to put it somewhere. So tap the put it somewhere button.

So no, it’s not in an unrelated menu. So the second assertion goes.

Finally, is Apple purposefully hiding it there? Well, showing that it belongs there should be enough to disprove that, but there’s also more. What else is in that menu? Let’s skip over sharing to eliminate quibbling over “but those belong there”.

Saving a file isn’t sharing. Printing isn’t sharing. Bookmarking isn’t sharing. Opening in another app isn’t sharing. Adding it to a note isn’t sharing. Copying it to the pasteboard isn’t sharing.

Are all of those purposefully being hidden by Apple where users won’t look for them? How does hiding “Add to bookmarks” have a “multi billion dollar incentive” behind it? How does hiding “Copy to pasteboard” “protect Apple’s revenue stream”? Why would Apple even implement these features in the first place only to hide them?

They aren’t being purposefully hidden. They are all there because they all do the same sort of thing – the same thing that Add to Home Screen does. They take what the user is looking at and put it somewhere.

And users use this menu all the time. It’s not some obscure part of Safari you’ve got to dig to find. The average user has probably scrolled past Add to Home Screen thousands and thousands of times.

If Apple were trying to hide this functionality, this is the very last place they’d put it. They’ve put it somewhere that a) is accessible with a single tap, b) makes sense conceptually, and c) will be seen by users all the time. So the final assertion is no good either.

And like cpuguy83 pointed out elsewhere in the thread - this has been how you add a site to your home screen since day one, when Steve Jobs was telling everybody that web apps were the only way to build apps for the iPhone. At that point PWAs didn’t even exist. And that’s the spot they chose for it back then – before native apps were even allowed by Apple, when Apple wanted everybody to build web apps and add them to their home screens. It completely contradicts the idea that this is a hiding place where they don’t want people to see it. That’s where they chose to put it when it’s incontrovertible fact that they wanted people to use it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:13PM (#39032807)
So why is it that after this existing for so many years that nobody seems to even know it’s an option or how to do it.

Just to give a bit of context on my own background because it’s relevant here but I spent most of the last ten years running A/B tests for companies and then analysing the results.

One of the core truths in my particular line of work is that default options matter a lot more than people tend to realise.

So when you take an idea such as “I would like to install this app” and you then:

1. Don’t provide a way to ask users if they would like to do that.

2. Put it in a menu that’s cluttered with many other unrelated things.

3. Call it something entirely different “add to home”.

It’s not a mystery what is going to happen here. We are talking the overwhelming MAJORITY of people will have no idea and it won’t get used.

I’m just a random person on the internet so I’m not asking you to take my word for it.

It’s specifically why I mentioned the test before of go and talk to any person with an iPhone and ask them how they can install an app without the App Store. You can prove this to yourself tomorrow by asking ten people.

You can even incentivise them with money. They absolutely can not do it and will look at you like you have two heads.

They have no idea it’s even possible.

So the next logical question that comes to mind is why do you suppose that is?

There’s a few potential options:

1. They somehow have no idea that this is a problem their users struggle with.

2. They are bad a UI design

3. It’s an intentional choice to try and keep people in the dark while still avoiding any legal action for anti competitive behaviour.

I can only find evidence for one of those options but I have a LOT of it. It’s not a coincidence that it happens to align perfectly consistently with all of their other actions towards treating the web as a competitive application platform.

That’s just who they are and how they do business.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by TimPC on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:48AM (#39029320)
I think they gave you a clear answer to the difference:

The Web Standards Committee has decided the correct way for the web to work is that there is an expectation that a user understands how to bookmark something and can elect to do so if they choose. They don't make a part of any web standard a developer being able to ask a user to add a bookmark. So not just Apple, but on the standard web, developers don't have the install rights you are saying they should have. It's hard to argue it's a conspiracy by Apple when a standards body outside Apple has defined how it works.

Maybe enough users don't know how to bookmark on iOS. Could Apple do more to make sure they know how? Yes. But I don't think we should change the web to allow websites to ask to create bookmarks because Google Chrome thinks its a good idea.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:52AM (#39030242)
Based on your comment I think there might be some misunderstandings here.

That committee you are talking about isn’t actually independent of Apple. They are a part of it.

Historically Apple have repeatedly used those exact committee bodies as a way to shut down a whole range of things that would bring the web platform closer to iOS in terms of capabilities.

The point about the bookmarking is also a bit hard to follow. I don’t know if this is getting a bit abstract or something so I’ll just restate my main argument.

Apple have repeatedly tried to make sure the web wasn’t able to compete with iOS and actively worked to get as much lock in on their platforms as possible. They have a terrible track record in terms of interoperability and as I stated numerous times in this thread they have an obvious reason for doing so.

The only point I saw them concede any ground towards a more consumer friendly and away from an overtly anti-competitive approach was specifically when serious talk of antitrust litigation emerged from the EU.

At that point they had a miraculously coincidental change of heart and began a hiring spree for Safari so they could try and close some of the more nefarious gaps with interoperability so they could point to it as evidence that they shouldn’t be fined billons of dollars and have new restrictions placed on them.

I am claiming that that looks like the text book definition of a conspiracy and you need to understand the arguments about installability in that wider context and the point you’re making about bookmarks is in no way relevant to what I’m talking about.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:14PM (#39031325)
> That committee you are talking about isn’t actually independent of Apple. They are a part of it.

> Historically Apple have repeatedly used those exact committee bodies as a way to shut down a whole range of things that would bring the web platform closer to iOS in terms of capabilities.

That’s not what’s happening, neither for this specific case nor in general.

There are three major rendering engines: Blink by Google, WebKit by Apple, and Gecko by Mozilla.

It’s an ongoing theme that Google will write a spec. and implement it in Blink, then Apple and Mozilla will either reject it outright or not express interest, and then people come along and accuse Apple of “holding back the web”. This has happened with Web Bluetooth, with Web USB, and more.

In this particular case, the ability to trigger installation prompts from a PWA was originally part of the manifest spec. But it got removed because nobody was keen on implementing it as-is except for Google. That’s how it ended up in the non-standard manifest-incubations instead.

Now there’s a chance that further work will be done on it in manifest-incubations to the point where Mozilla and Apple think it’s worth implementing. If consensus is reached it could become a web standard in future. But just because Google implemented something by themselves does not mean that “Apple are holding back the web”. Google are not the sole arbiter of what constitutes the web platform and Apple and Mozilla aren’t obligated to implement whatever Google wants. This is a case of Google promoting something by themselves, not Apple holding something back. Mozilla and Apple are in agreement; Google are the ones acting unilaterally.

> Apple have repeatedly tried to make sure the web wasn’t able to compete with iOS and actively worked to get as much lock in on their platforms as possible.

There is no single organisation that has done more to push the mobile web forward than Apple.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:20PM (#39032897)
That last sentence is truly one of the most deranged things I’ve heard all year.

You’re literally talking to an audience of largely web developers and trying to claim with a straight face something that they all know full well not to be true because they spent the last decade having to deal with Safari’s bullshit and lack of interoperability.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:04AM (#39038103)
> That last sentence is truly one of the most deranged things I’ve heard all year.

You’ve really got to figure out how to disagree with somebody without being insulting.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by philistine on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:58PM (#39032638)
Any web developer seriously asking for yet another web prompt is delusional. The web in general has suffered because prompts enrage and discourage users. We, collectively, need to rein in the ability of websites to bother us. It's what's needed to protect our privacy, and save our sanity.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kemotep on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:07PM (#39031241)
Honestly, the average person probably couldn’t find an app in app store without direction.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cpuguy83 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:17AM (#39027951)
iOS has "app clips" which websites can (and absolutely do) prompt you to use.

As for how to save a webpage to your Home Screen, that literally hasn't changed except maybe to have it together with other on-device interactions. It has been there since before there was even an App Store. It's not hidden in any way and never has been. It was demoed on stage by Steve Jobs.

The App Store is a scam, for sure. But Apple has not been crippling the web... at least not in the way you claim here (only one browser on the platform is sucky, but that's a different discussion).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:43AM (#39028367)
> But Apple has not been crippling the web

Well, they definitely drag their feet on keeping Safari up to date, not unlike what Microsoft did with Internet Explorer 20 years ago.

IIRC, there are also some limitations in what web apps launched from the home screen can actually do, which are not in regular Safari - but I've not looked at this in a long time so I could be wrong.

What I do remember very clearly is that the common consensus, as reflected in data from app developers, is that people just don't know (or don't want to use) the "pin to home screen" feature. One could argue that Apple should, maybe, sprinkle on that feature a bit of the effort they lavishly pour on emojis, so that more people could be enticed to use PWAs. That would go some way towards reassuring developers that they are not slaves to the AppStore.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:56AM (#39028543)
> Well, they definitely drag their feet on keeping Safari up to date, not unlike what Microsoft did with Internet Explorer 20 years ago.

It’s entirely different. After Microsoft killed the competition and gained >90% market share, they disbanded the Internet Explorer developer team for five entire years.

Apple releases a new major version of Safari every year like clockwork and pushes people hard to update.

> What I do remember very clearly is that the common consensus, as reflected in data from app developers, is that people just don't know (or don't want to use) the "pin to home screen" feature.

What data? The internal data I’ve seen across ~500 community apps is that when given a choice, two thirds of people use the iOS app, a quarter of people use the Android app, and about 10% use the PWA. And that’s across all users, including desktop.

“Don’t know” and “don’t want to use” are two entirely different things.

If people preferred PWAs and it was just down to Apple holding them back, there wouldn’t be any such thing as an Android app; people would just use PWAs on that platform instead. People don’t install PWAs because they don’t want to.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:52AM (#39029370)
> Apple releases a new major version of Safari every year like clockwork and pushes people hard to update.

That's largely a byproduct of their attempt to keep support costs low by forcing yearly upgrades of the entire OS. Other browser makers release 10 times more often (literally!). When you're 10 times slower than everyone else (while being 10 times wealthier...), I think it's legitimate to say you're dragging your feet. The fact that they're not as atrociously bad as Microsoft was at its worst, doesn't mean they are not bad.

> “Don’t know” and “don’t want to use” are two entirely different things.

Come on now - discoverability and education are things. If Apple wanted to, they would make that feature so easy and promote it so heavily, that everyone would do it or at least know how to do it.

> If people preferred PWAs and it was just down to Apple holding them back

Don't strawman me, I never said that. I said that Apple is not making any effort to change a status quo where consumers are not keen on the feature, which tallies with your experience. There is nothing stopping them from aiming their reality distortion field at the feature, as a service to developers.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:14AM (#39029686)
> Other browser makers release 10 times more often (literally!). When you're 10 times slower than everyone else

They aren’t ten times slower than everybody else. You can’t measure progress by counting releases.

> I think it's legitimate to say you're dragging your feet.

They aren’t though. Take a look at the Interop 2023 dashboard:

https://wpt.fyi/interop-2023?stable

Or just read through the WebKit blog:

https://webkit.org/blog/

They are getting loads done.

> The fact that they're not as atrociously bad as Microsoft was at its worst, doesn't mean they are not bad.

Your exact words were: “they definitely drag their feet on keeping Safari up to date, not unlike what Microsoft did with Internet Explorer 20 years ago” and my point is that it’s very unlike that.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:44AM (#39030120)
They picked up the slack only after they were shamed multiple times, including by websites like https://issafarithenewie.com/ (which now reflects their progress, very honestly). A brief look at items from the last several years will return lots of pretty bad press.

> They aren’t ten times slower than everybody else.

Just to mention one, WebRTC took 7 years to go from the first Firefox implementation to Safari. Chrome had it less than 2 years after FF, so I guess not 10x but 3x-4x - still a very significant lag, which is definitely not explainable by lack of resources.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:34PM (#39031566)
But that’s just it – you are just mentioning one. No mention of the many, many improvements that were made. Safari has been advancing steadily every single year since it was first released. Which makes it an entirely different situation to Internet Explorer, which held the web at an absolute standstill for five straight years.

Sorry, no, not an absolute standstill. Windows XP Service Pack 2 tweaked how an HTTP header was handled. That was the most significant movement in the front-end development world in a five year period. Because of Internet Explorer.

Compare Safari 12 to Safari 17. Now imagine we were still stuck with Safari 12. That’s what it would be like if Safari “dragged their feet” like Microsoft did with Internet Explorer. They aren’t the same thing, not even remotely close. Anybody saying that “Safari is the new IE” clearly does not remember what Internet Explorer did to the industry, especially if they are saying it because of things like Safari won’t let websites vibrate your phone.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Thursday January 18, 2024 @07:03PM (#39049816)
The difference is simply a function of smarter leadership and experience.

Of course nobody, today, would act exactly like MS did - that would make it trivial for people to see their game. Instead, Apple gives you something to show they're trying, "honest, guv" - but in ebbs and flows, only when pushed, and slower than everyone else despite being the most profitable company on the block.

To be honest, nobody would really care how many releases they push or how many features they push, if only they let other browsers compete on iOS. But they don't; so they carry a responsibility to be at the forefront of standards and look absolutely beyond reproach - which, at the moment, is not the case.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Saturday January 20, 2024 @02:12AM (#39065404)
> The difference is simply a function of smarter leadership and experience.

Look, the difference is glaringly obvious: Microsoft brought front-end development to a standstill for five long years. Apple has not. Apple has continued to add features, standards support, and interoperability bug fixes year after year like clockwork.

This isn’t a matter of nuance. This isn’t Apple being “smarter”. Apple fundamentally has not done what Microsoft did in any way, shape, or form. The two situations are extremely dissimilar.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:30AM (#39028170)
You’re replying to me here suggesting that they don’t cripple the web by providing an example of another proprietary thing that they control and has zero interoperability with any other devices.

I don’t know what to do with that argument other than to use that exact same set of facts to support my own point.

Also, that’s a nice historical fact that Steve Jobs once did a demo on stage years ago but my point was that nobody knows how to do it in real life or that it’s possible.

I’m explicitly making the argument that this isn’t a coincidence but is very much on purpose.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cpuguy83 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:54AM (#39028518)
So you are saying they are crippling the web because they don't allow websites to add themselves to your home screen through a button on the page. OK. I'll cede this is to drive people to the App Store where they can get their cut.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:19AM (#39028893)
I just want to be clear here that when I made that claim it was in no way just because of that but was a decade of actions (or largely inaction) where they made sure that the web platform would be missing lots of functionality that app developers would require to consider the web as a viable option for their software business.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by troupo on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:45AM (#39027569)
> Go and find a random person on the street and ask them to install a website on an iOS device and watch what happens.

Go and ask a random person to install a website on any OS, and watch what happens

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:00AM (#39027744)
You do understand that the main thrust of my argument here is that it doesn’t have to be like that correct?

I should be able to prompt the user to install and it would just work.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by plagiarist on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:12AM (#39027891)
I'm not receptive to allowing websites to prompt me for any reason whatever after observing everyone's behavior for the last two decades.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:16AM (#39027937)
That’s very interesting but we aren’t designing the web around your personal set of preferences so I don’t know if it’s particularly relevant to the conversation.

I’m sure when it arrives like other APIs that require certain permissions you will be able to disable it and live in peace.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by troupo on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:20AM (#39028904)
> That’s very interesting but we aren’t designing the web around your personal set of preferences

Indeed. The (collective) you are designing the web around maximum profit to stakeholders. People's interests and preferences don't come in to it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:30AM (#39029058)
Respectfully what are you even talking about…

How did we get from “I think app install prompts should be a thing so the web is on a level playing field with operating systems” to me somehow being responsible for the ills of capitalism?

I literally said you should have an option to opt out and your response was an impassioned speech about “the will of the people”.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by troupo on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:25PM (#39032968)
I think this answers all the questions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39029042
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by plagiarist on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:30AM (#39029042)
It's not just my preference. People would want a nice and easy button to install a webapp to their homescreen. People would not want alert boxes from every website they visit. The latter will happen along with the former.

I cannot disable these things when Apple has a profit incentive. I haven't been able to make the dumb Game Center thing permanently quit appearing. I guess they don't have a profit incentive, here, huh? So the result is that people who understand how to turn it off, will turn it off. Most everyone else will be trained to hit no instantly. A few people will have hundreds of webapps on their home screens like the browser bars of yore.

For the record; I completely agree that side loading should be possible with minimal barrier and it would be nice if web apps were more discoverable and integrated. But preventing websites from nagging people with a system-level iOS prompt is a feature.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by troupo on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:19AM (#39028885)
> You do understand that the main thrust of my argument here is that it doesn’t have to be like that correct?

No, I don't

> I should be able to prompt the user to install and it would just work.

No, you shouldn't. Not until you prove that you can actually make proper prompts and not turn the web into what it is today: a collection of in your face modals, calls to action, popups etc.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mdhb on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:37AM (#39029168)
I don’t even understand the “no I don’t understand the thing that you just said” response here.

I’m not sure where to go here if I’m supposed to be responsible for your sense of reading comprehension.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:07AM (#39027113)
> So the feature goes into open beta, and a bunch of flash devs make iPhone apps, they work fine

We tried this at work at the time. They absolutely did not work fine. The best I can say about them is that they ran, mostly.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rchaud on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:40AM (#39029216)
This was the topic of Steve Jobs' infamous "Thoughts on Flash" memo, which was essentially a blueorint for the coming iOS App Store walled garden strategy.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by d4rti on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:49AM (#39026966)
KDP from Amazon will always take a 30% or greater cut.

https://kdp.amazon.com/en_US/help/topic/G200644210

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by honeybadger1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:14AM (#39027186)
Honestly this is the only thread of comments that really get to the meat and potatoes of why Apple can be evil although while making good product. Their evil must be curbed as they go out of their way with certain actions to completely punish their customers and partners.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by macspoofing on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:10AM (#39027867)
>Apple negotiates agreements with most of the major book publishers that if they want to sell books on iBooks, ebooks must be listed at the same price on ALL stores, and have a 30% margin

That's also what Amazon does, except with everything.

It's terrible what Apple is doing, but is peanuts compared to what Amazon does.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nvarsj on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:31AM (#39029941)
Apples behaviour vis a vis the App Store is the textbook definition of monopolistic practices. It’s beyond the pale these stories. The only reason I can think it continues is because there are a lot of AAPL holders in Congress.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by gigatexal on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:24AM (#39025398)
People also need to remember how it was before in the CompUSA or telco provided phones. The retailer or marketplace would take > 30% margins closer to 50% and to get on a pseudo-smart phone before the current smart phone era one had to ask the AT&T's and Verizon's very nicely. But now one can build apps now and publish and just pay the 30% comission or 15% on subscriptions after the second year and look at the explosion in the app marketplace.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by muro on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:51AM (#39026064)
We don't need to remember that, good riddance and great that they were disrupted. How do you disrupt this market though?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by gigatexal on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:27AM (#39026341)
I honestly think Apple will need to be compelled by law verdict or congress to open up the appstore or allow other appstores and have some sort of cap on fees charged -- I dunno.

The ideal would probably be what Steve envisioned before the AppStore was a thing and that's basically PWAs. But I think it's been alleged that Apple is arbitrarily nerfing Safari to prevent PWAs on iOS running as well as native applications -- though I've no source.

How to effectively "disrupt" the appstore model is a billion dollar question I'm not sure of. What I do know is that the Tim Sweeny's et al of the world are hypocrites in that they just want to create their own rent-seeking AppStores and charge their own commissions and skirt around paying the platform anything for being on the platform. This is akin to wanting to be in a supermarket and put your kiosk inside and sell your product to the supermarket's customers without some sort of financial agreement between you and the supermarket.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Workaccount2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:27AM (#39029872)
It's just imessage. If imessage falls, so will the iPhone.

The courts don't take stuff like "social compliance" into account when evaluating something like the iPhone, so it all looks rosy. In reality, it's incredibly difficult to be a social young person in the US without an iPhone. Which naturally spreads to families becoming "iPhone families".

All of it just comes down to messaging though.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pompino on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:08AM (#39023853)
> We should discuss the points on their merits, not based on who's making them and how much money they have.

Its not based on how much money they have. Its how they've managed to accumulate the money - by gouging devs.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:18AM (#39023922)
To be fair, roughly half of Apple's money is made from hardware. The app store is extremely lucrative and apparently 70%+ of their revenue from the App store is just leeching off of mobile games, but Apple can definitely survive without the app store if push came to shove.

BUT, I will also mention that part of its market capture comes from all the charges on devs even before the rev share. You need apple equipment to develop, and they (apparently) don't sell server racks anymore for businesses to scale off of, nor any legitimate form of emulation. You have a small cost per year to have a developer account, and a cost to submit your app for review. Then if you care about visibilty they have their own ad discovery program you can pay into.

So I did disagree with a brief judge statement about how "It's possible to skirt around Apple's innnovation for free...". Apple controls and charges for the entire pipeline, even before you launch the app.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jb1991 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:53AM (#39024165)
> a cost to submit your app for review

They charge you to submit an app? Is this new? When I worked as an iOS developer this was not a thing but that was many years ago.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by __m on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:09AM (#39024282)
No they don’t
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by wouldbecouldbe on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:24AM (#39024405)
You pay 99 per year. But this definitely doesn’t cover their cost. The review process is very labor intensive on their side
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by munk-a on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:36AM (#39024502)
As someone who has developed a commercial app and spent time on the app store - their review process is a joke... there are non-compliances all over the store and I suspect a lot of their review process is highly automated.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by wouldbecouldbe on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:48AM (#39025072)
Yeah just because it's labor intensive doesn't mean it's good.

Im sure both App stores have lot of automated tests. But I've submitted a lot of apps and the feedback from Apple is much more specific and from humans.

I agree it's very annoying, often complaining about things that are explained in submission notes.

But if I submit and do around 5-10 updates per year that seems highly unlikely it covers their salary cost.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Fluorescence on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:23AM (#39026309)
Most of their review is for their own interests so they should foot the bill.

Their priority is to ensure every dollar gets taxed and to block features they want to monopolise. The idea that it is a service to developers that they should pay for is insulting.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by throwaway346434 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:36AM (#39024967)
Would you pay a drunk rich person $99/year, so that you can publish a community newsletter to your local town or sell custom decals to your state's car enthusiasts club? Who then randomly decrees your newsletter is not allowed, forgets why, then slurs THIS CONVERSATION IS OVER and bans you yelling "I'm everybody safe, keeping!"

In this case, who exactly are they protecting, the townsfolk or car enthusiasts that you have an independent relationship with?

Would this scenario seem like a good idea to agree to? If no, why is the app store/walled garden model an appropriate use case at all/how is it substantially different?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jacquesm on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:09AM (#39024768)
The review process is only there to give Apple a fig-leaf to remove apps at will without recourse.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by akmarinov on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:31AM (#39024933)
Not really, I put in a feature to record the screen and all they did was launch the app, click a button and then auto approve
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:24AM (#39024888)
However it’s so inconsistent and arbitrary that it hardly ever mattered.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by la_oveja on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:53AM (#39024635)
you are trippin
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by wkat4242 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:54AM (#39025659)
It depends how often you submit. Also they do it mostly in cheap labour countries.

And it doesn't have to conver the cost really. It's not a service to developers like developer support would be. It's more an impediment due to its randomness.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jacquesm on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:08AM (#39024765)
Oh no, those devs would have certainly passed the difference on to the consumer.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by camillomiller on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:34AM (#39024025)
This is a biased view that disregards basic available metrics. Apple is a hardware company. Developers are instrumental to its devices success and a point can be made that 30% might be too high of a fee. On the other hand many of those developers wouldn’t have a job in the first place if it wasn’t for Apple creating the App Store.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:47AM (#39024118)
I find it interesting seeing the arguments here on how Apple should keep its large cut for years after it's become sustainable, but when mentioning the idea of giving copyrighted artists any sort of royalty (it'd be far, far, far from 30%) for training LLMs that the argument shifts back to "well they got paid already".

So, how long does Apple get to reap the rewards of their old accomplishments from 18 years ago? how long should such works be benefited from before we shift the dynamics back to being "a public commons"?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pompino on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:23AM (#39024403)
Agreed, While there may be people who think they're defending Apple "on principle", I hope those folks also realize that there is no "principle" that is ingrained in nature. We're all just making up rules, laws, taxes, as we go along. Just because a law or article of constitution is old, doesn't make it any more 'natural' than others.

There is no "right" of any student for their debt to be forgiven, but we want to do it anyway. Apple has taken advantage (as have others) of a ridiculously broken tax code, availed of the strong US legal system, property rights, etc. How about we shift the balance back?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kergonath on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:32AM (#39024475)
> I find it interesting seeing the arguments here on how Apple should keep its large cut for years after it's become sustainable, but when mentioning the idea of giving copyrighted artists any sort of royalty (it'd be far, far, far from 30%) for training LLMs that the argument shifts back to "well they got paid already".

Do you account for the fact that it might not be the same people making both arguments? Most websites’ readerships are not monoliths and even on HN there are plenty of people with different perspectives, and who are not necessarily vocal in the same threads.

> So, how long does Apple get to reap the rewards of their old accomplishments from 18 years ago? how long should such works be benefited from before we shift the dynamics back to being "a public commons"?

That’s an interesting argument, but it’s usually not discussed with any nuance. Basically there are several layers:

- are we entitled to Apple opening their platforms? (AFAICT the opposite would be a first though the EU seems to be going that way)

- is Apple entitled to profit from the App Store in principle? (Some people are arguing that they are not, but they are a fringe; Epic lost their argument about that)

- is 30% too much? (But then, where is the line? It’s more or less the standard for closed platforms

Where would you put your “public commons”? Did this ever happen?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:31AM (#39027385)
>Do you account for the fact that it might not be the same people making both arguments?

I don't. It's possible to (dis)prove this with comments but that would be a bit invasive (ironically enough) without doing a lot of work to anonymize the dataset I gather and prove sufficient random sampling. It's possible for admins to (dis)prove this through voting habits, but not for me to bring about such evidence.

All I can say from here is that so far, there's a local sample of one reply to me that seems to indeed think this way.

>Where would you put your “public commons”? Did this ever happen?

The "commons" in this case would be the OS. I don't think we've ever historically had another OS as locked down as hard IOS. Game consoles come the closest to this, but are ultimately ephemeral; no gaming OS store has lasted (i.e. been officially supported. I cannot submit a PS3 game today even if I wanted to) as long as IOS, and I don't see IOS closing anytime soon.

On top of that, there is the argument on IOS being a general OS compared to games being specialized; no one de facto seems to desire doing much more than consuming media on consoles (consoles don't even have proper web browsers these days). So that's another factor to consider when determining what is a "major OS" and if/when it should be opened up if closed down.

These seem to be questions that are slowly being asked in formal channels. So I suppose these are all TBD. But if you want my sample of 1 answers:

- At some point I do think a "major OS" should become a commons for those who seek to publish through it. Microsoft was dinged 30 years ago for much less and Apple has way more control and restrictions now than MS ever did.

- Apple is entitled to profit from the App Store, but isn't entitled to be the only store able to distribute apps on its platform. Again, MS was considering this with Windows 8 and 10 and it was an absolute disaster. Another aspect of an "existing commons" trying to close up in a way that MS in theory feels entitled to but in a way that would hurt consumers and developers.

- the 30% is definitely a question to ask and not one I have a particularly strong answer on. I feel this is where the invisible hand should take charge, so it comes down more to "would the audience take a lower cut if they were able to find an alternative (which may or may not include themselves)?". So my concern here is with providing alternative options and seeing if the market shifts rather than throttling existing rates.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pompino on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:53PM (#39031030)
What someone is "entitled" to is an opinion. AFAIK, Courts do not adjudicate opinions, they decide if a law was broken in the context of the existing legal framework. These are arbitrary systems we set up to help us flourish as a society. If it is no longer doing that, we should change it.

50,60,80% cut would still be legal, but there is no way Apple can get away with that. What Apple is entitled to is going to be based on peoples feelings and opinions, and the amount of pushback generated. Its good to generate push-back on things you don't agree with.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:26AM (#39025409)
> I find it interesting seeing the arguments here on how Apple should keep its large cut for years after it's become sustainable, but when mentioning the idea of giving copyrighted artists any sort of royalty (it'd be far, far, far from 30%) for training LLMs that the argument shifts back to "well they got paid already".

There are multiple people on here, who say different things.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fallingknife on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:39AM (#39026898)
Those artists learned the same way generative AI did, by ingesting copyrighted art. I couldn't care less about that unless the AI companies are somehow preventing people from purchasing from those artists or taking a cut out of their sales like Apple does with the app store.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by camillomiller on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:15AM (#39027932)
I definitely do not hold that belief, and you are saying that about the only company that values and pays artists decently among the FAAMG
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by throwaway346434 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:40AM (#39024998)
They are a hardware company. By the same token, can you imagine a car company controlling the fuel you put in your car, the tires you buy, the repair shops you use, the radio stations you can listen to?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by culturestate on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:45AM (#39025053)
> can you imagine a car company controlling the fuel you put in your car, the tires you buy, the repair shops you use

Assuming a slightly generous definition of "the fuel you put in your car," you've just described a lease.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lostlogin on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:42AM (#39025563)
> you've just described a lease.

Or the purchase of a German car.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jfk13 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:02AM (#39025203)
Or a printer company controlling the ink you put in your printer? Unthinkable! Oh, wait...
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by plagiarist on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:49AM (#39028456)
Yes, and that's why printers are nearly universally reviled as exploitative. Even people who aren't keyed in on why open source is important all understand the ink costs more than it should.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pompino on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:11AM (#39024294)
That may be, but IMHO its impossible to be completely neutral on this issue. All analysis is somewhat compromised and biased based on subjective weightage to historical facts, etc.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kridsdale1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:10AM (#39023869)
Ok. Write your app with zero use of the non-posix system calls or any of the platform SDK. Because they wrote that. Why do you get to run a business off it for free?

They spend hundreds of millions on SWE salaries to make a nice SDK for you to use. They’re also operating all the servers. Your $100 does not cover it. It’s a symbiotic relationship. At least see it and acknowledge it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jzl on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:17AM (#39023919)
It’s a symbiotic relationship

Yes, exactly. It's symbiotic because Apple needs apps to sell iPhones in the first place. Apple is already getting their cut of the symbiotic relationship by selling their massively profitable iPhone hardware, full stop. Any chance you remember the first year of the iPhone when there were no third party apps? Other than being a good phone, it was basically just a technological novelty, and that was about it. Third party apps are literally what give value to the iPhone (and other iOS devices).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by aspenmayer on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:29AM (#39023989)
Cydia was live on iOS before Apple's App Store.

Which is to say, I agree.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ankit219 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:48AM (#39024126)
I have never fully agreed with this premise. On the face of it, yes apps help people stay on the store. But at the same time, Apple does come up with many good apps.

Comparing it to the first iPhone is probably valid. They saw the writing on the wall and opened the gates, but could have easily chosen the other way of doing it themselves. No one wins in this scenario - nor the devs, nor the users, nor Apple. But it's not as clear as "Apple needs apps to sell iPhones in the first place".

Idly wondering, say you don't download any third party app and neither does anyone. You can still surf the internet for the most part. You can still connect with others via FaceTime/iMessage. You can still check mails etc. Things you won't be able to do is play games, go on dates, browse tiktok, book a cab (though all that is possible through safari but not a great experience).

A caveat here: The original 30% was on infinitely reproducible digital goods only. Which is 80-90% gaming skins and artifacts and digital subscriptions. Don't know if that is still the case.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jrowen on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:07AM (#39024257)
It's symbiotic because Apple needs apps to sell iPhones in the first place.

And developers need a solid platform with users willing to pay money. I feel like you have the wrong answer to the chicken and egg problem. The first iPhone was a marvel to pretty much everyone, and blew everything else at the time out of the water. I don't recall much sentiment of people being disappointed about the lack of apps, because there was no reason to expect that at that point. Just being able to use a lot of the web like you would on a computer was a massive leap from a RAZR or whatever.

This is not to defend the 30% tax or anything, but I don't think it does any good to downplay the value they've built. The elephant in the room with your argument is that, if it were true, app developers would simply flock to Android and Apple would be forced to course-correct.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pentae on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:34AM (#39024494)
People seem to think that the customer exists because of the iPhone app store, when it's often usually the other way around. Other than a small handful of apps being promoted for free in the app store, the majority of businesses have to spend very real, very expensive advertising dollars or offer a unique product to attract customers. If you have your own product your customers want but they just happen to have an iPhone, you're now forced to pay the maker of their device 30% off the top of your gross revenues like some kind of Mafia. This same Mafia does everything they can to make sure that web/Safari experience is as poor of an experience as possible so that users prefer native apps delivered through the app store.

Imagine if you sold expensive CAD software through your own sales team and advertising efforts completely offline but because some of those users were on Windows they have to get it through the Windows store and 30% of your topline revenue went to Microsoft?

Because of the way online marketing/advertising works with competitive bidding in a lot of cases I would bet that Apple is making more margin than the developers of the apps are. Your competitor who doesn't have to pay a 30% Mafia shakedown fee for their product will be able to outcompete you on clicks every time.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jrowen on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:18AM (#39024844)
This same Mafia does everything they can to make sure that web/Safari experience is as poor of an experience as possible so that users prefer native apps delivered through the app store.

Can you expand on this? I prefer to use the web when I can, and every time I've begrudgingly downloaded an app, it's the service itself that was actively pushing me away from their poor/hamstrung web client. I'm still left with the impression that users are staying there and developers jump through the hoops because it's just that good. That doesn't mean it's right, but - that's Capitalism, baby!

Also, the MS of yore would have absolutely done that if they thought they could get away with it, and definitely engaged in more than their fair share of unsavory tactics.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:39AM (#39024988)
> The first iPhone was a marvel to pretty much everyone

IIRC its sales figures weren’t that great though. Of course from Apple’s perspective it was more of a prototype than the actual final product.

> Just being able to use a lot of the web like you would on a computer was a massive leap from a RAZR

IMHO not having 3G basically turned it into a toy.. also comparing it to a consumer flip-phones isn’t that fair. You you had touschscreen/stylus “smartphones” from SonyEricsson, Nokia etc. which weren’t that awful at the time (of course the UX was inferior after it actually became possible to the internet on your iPhone when the 3G was released).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:49AM (#39026968)
You seem to be doing some history revisionism, at least from the point of view of someone in France. At the time of iPhone release (that I imported in France) there were very few phones of what you could consider smartphones. I actually had one of those, on windows mobile 6.5, complete with the stylus and it just sucked. You could get one of the early 3G contracts, but it wasn't really worth it unless you really needed that for business use. Because outside of receiving mails there was not real application that would benefit a lot from the connectivity (that only existed inside the big city, and only at certain spots since it was just the start of 3G rollout).

The iPhone made it so there were at least 3 use cases that were worthwhile getting that : full internet browsing with decent experience and speedy enough ; real-time map download for navigation and emails. Of course the first iPhone was limited by its connectivity speed, but it didn't matter because at this point 3G was not even really there for the vas majority of peoples. Then the next year we got the 3G iPhone that actually made sense to buy with a 3G contract because it became viable in the big cities.

The other "smartphones" who had 3G before that were largely irrelevant because even if you had the connectivity, using them wasn't worth your time and that's just ignoring the fact that outise of city centers you were out of luck (I know, been there, done that...).

There is a reason before the iPhone, Blackberrys were so popular, that's because they were the only decent option for the only use case that made sense before iPhone : email/messaging.

I really don't like the recent developments at Apple, but pretending that they didn't completely changed the game at the time is bonkers...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by matwood on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:30AM (#39028167)
I had the first iPhone. Sales were low in part because it was locked to Cingular (then ATT when they bought Cingular). It was very much a beta device, but you could see and feel the future as soon as you used it. It certainly was more than a toy. I remember walking into my office the day after I got it and told everyone 'this changes everything'. It's not often those types of moments happen with such clarity (the one I remember prior was when I got my first 3dfx Voodoo gaming card, but I digress).

The 3g version and when it went multi-carrier is when it started to really take off sales wise. Then the iPhone 4 (first retina phone) was the next big bump, followed by the first 'big' iPhone.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kelnos on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:11AM (#39024295)
Apple was just fine building all those platform SDKs for macOS without charging people to write apps for it. Why should iOS be any different?

The servers do not cost 30% of all sales on the platform. Not even close.

But none of that matters. Very few businesses set their prices based on how much it costs them to provide their goods or services. They charge what the market will bear. The problem is that there is no "iOS app distribution market"; Apple controls it, 100%, so they can set prices wherever they want, without regard to competition.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by bryans on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:37AM (#39024979)
> The servers do not cost 30% of all sales on the platform. Not even close.

Specifically, the transfer cost to download a 50MB app is approximately $0.0005. That's 200,000 downloads per $100. Even assuming a low average revenue of $1 per download, that's a $60,000 take for Apple for maybe $105 worth of hosting.

That's not to say there aren't other costs involved in running the store. But we definitely shouldn't be pretending that hosting is even relevant to the conversation. Hosting costs haven't been relevant for over a decade.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by flumpcakes on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:52AM (#39025109)
> 50MB app is approximately $0.0005

It's probably orders of magnitude smaller than that, like 2e-7 dollars per MB.

People have gotten use to AWS/Azure/GCP pricing when bandwidth is essentially free at scale. You can rent a few 100Gb/s ports for ~$500 to ~$5000 per month depending on location.

But I guess this is best case scenario and not everyone will have the capital/clout to colocate at POPs.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Sebb767 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:30AM (#39027368)
This disregards side costs like storage, global distribution, retries, re-downloads, updates, backups and the likes. It's probably still cheaper than AWS outbound pricing in the end, but hosting apps is more than just the bandwidth used exactly once.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by flumpcakes on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:18PM (#39031380)
The original comment only listed bandwidth cost. Storage is also equally cheap, global distribution is equally cheap if you have your boxes at POPs. Someone that is at Apple's scale could very easily manage this.

We're looking at cents per app per user in lifetime costs.

The "Cloud" is disgustingly expensive at nearly any scale. It does require some capital investment and competent people to host your own however. Although there really is no alternative to the cloud if you are small scale but need presence globally.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by bryans on Friday January 19, 2024 @10:06PM (#39064265)
Late on the reply, but I don't think your argument matches reality.

1. Storage for 50MB is less than $0.001 per month. So, even if you're storing and backing up every every version of an app, and they update a very high 50 times per year, and they're storing on 12 different locales, that's less than $1 per year for the typical app.

2. "Global distribution" is a one time cost per app update at approximately $0.006 per 50MB per server. For 12 updates per year spread across 12 servers, that's less than $1 per year total. Over 75% of apps are updated less than once per month.

3. Retries, re-downloads and updates are already insignificant transfer costs, per my original comment. Even if you want to attribute 90% of those downloads to being updates from the same set of users, and keep the lifetime revenue per user at a very low estimate of $1, Apple is still taking $6,000 for approximately $105 of hosting costs.

All in all, that matches my original estimate of $100 per 200k downloads for transfer and $5 for server fees. So, as I said, hosting isn't relevant to the conversation, at all.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by TerrifiedMouse on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:05AM (#39024735)
I feel the App Store is one thing differentiating Apple from Android phone manufacturers.

Money from the App Store gets reinvested in the entire iPhone supply chain. Whereas in the case of Android, App Store money goes to Google only.

It also encourages Apple to support their phones long term as its preferred that you stay on your aging iPhone and keep spending at the App Store then risking you leaving the Apple ecosystem because Apple allows their older phones to become obsolete. Android manufacturers on the other hand have every incentive to obsolete your phone ASAP because you buying a new phone is the only way they make money.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by sally_glance on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:21AM (#39025365)
Doesn't Google sell hardware as well? Would it be better if Android was only available on Pixel phones?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by albert180 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:25AM (#39024890)
Do you seriously believe this? It's Apple that's blocking you from installing any apps or updates when you don't receive iOS Versions Updates anymore, while Google Play doesn't care about it, as long as the app itself is still developed for that version. Also they make more than enough money from the Hardware itself, they just take the profits off the software purchases.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:35AM (#39024961)
> that's blocking you from installing any apps or updates

Technically that’s the app developers who do that.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by albert180 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:40AM (#39025000)
Isn't it XCode that blocks you from developing for older versions at some point?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Daedren on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:17AM (#39025331)
No, Xcode requires you to have an up-to-date MacOS to develop, not iOS.

However, developers are strongly encouraged to raise their apps' minimum iOS versions since Apple does not backport any APIs to older versions, any new thing presented at WWDC is only for the new iOS version. This also applies to bugfixes in some cases (SwiftUI).

So as a developer you either stagnate your knowledge or keep moving forward. Google does backport many APIs, so the issue isn't as problematic on that end.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by AYBABTME on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:08AM (#39024271)
There's a point where the phone becomes similar to infrastructure, and allowing a single market actor to charge 30% tax on anyone using the roads, for any business conducted where someone took a road to get there, is ridiculous.

I'm not saying the App Store is infrastructure-like. But the market share of Apple is so large, and it's quasi-impossible to conduct consumer business without being required to have a native app... that it's starting to be infrastructure-like.

Can a viable B2C online business exist without being present via a native app? It seems untenable due to consumer expectations. Consumers also expect to be able to drive to coffeeshops, yet road providers don't charge 30% taxes on coffeeshop revenues.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by MilaM on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:36AM (#39024968)
> I'm not saying the App Store is infrastructure-like.

It is infrastructure-like. Try to live in modern society without a phone. It will be very difficult. Not impossible, but much less convenient.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by AYBABTME on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:56AM (#39025148)
I meant I'm not ready to say that it is, I have not solidified this as a fact in my own mind. I'm contemplating.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seer on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:28AM (#39025917)
It’s no surprise countries like india are indeed treating phones as infra, with their whole government stack centered around smartphones. You’re forced to have and use one, but in return you get free transactions, strong identity and various other perks. It _is_ a monopoly, but the monopoly is the government so everyone has a say on how its run and audited. It’s still strange to me how the states allows private companies to do things the at should be public goods/services.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by thayne on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:28AM (#39023980)
And if no one wrote apps for iOS how many people would buy iPhones and iPads? Yes, it is a symbiotic relationship. But Apple has better position to negotiate, because it is as single entity, and have a lot more resources than the the other side. If all the app developers were able to organize and boycott apple, they might be able to force Apple to negotiate better terms. But that would probably result in many of the smaller companies going out of business, unless the boycott was very short lived.

> Your $100 does not cover it.

There are almost 2 million apps on the app store. Assuming there is roughly 1 developer license per app, (some developers will create multiple apps with a single license, but others will have multiple licenses to develop a single app), that is at least in the ballpark of "hundreds of millions on SWE". And that doesn't include revenue from selling the devices themselves.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by camillomiller on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:36AM (#39024044)
You just proved your point wrong. Hundreds of million is peanuts, and it’s very improbable that it covers anything near the HR costs of Apple’s App Store infrastructure and department.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dvdkon on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:29AM (#39024454)
If Apple can't run the App Store just on developer fees, then I'm sure somebody else could. But that's conveniently not allowed.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ikiris on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:48AM (#39024128)
Where do you think those app developers / apps originally came from.

Huge amounts of people bought those iphones first man.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kelnos on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:15AM (#39024340)
So what? Shut down the App Store tomorrow, and forcibly delete all non-Apple-authored apps off of everyone's iPhones. Watch everyone flock to Android, no matter how much they claim to hate it. Watch Apple's stock drop into the toilet.

Apple needs all their third-party developers just as much as those developers need Apple -- more than at least some of those developers need Apple.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by yazaddaruvala on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:01AM (#39025191)
If the AppStore was shut down tomorrow, and all my apps forcibly removed: I'd keep using my iPhone with Safari. Might even become a better experience.

I'd need to save some short cuts for things like Google Maps, my banks, etc but that seems like all of the hassle.

I might miss the notifications (exclusively for the messaging apps - for all other apps I don't want them to have notifications) but otherwise, the biggest annoyance would be on the airplane I wouldn't have some pre-downloaded streaming content from apps like Netflix and Youtube.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Detrytus on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:50AM (#39025618)
I guess you do not really use your iPhone that much :)

For me removing non-Apple apps would render my phone useless: losing contact with my friends on WhatsApp and Signal, no way to call an Uber/taxi, no mobile authorization for my bank accounts, no MFA apps that I use for work...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by wwtrv on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:20AM (#39025848)
People wouldn't have bought them if there were no apps available though.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by coldtea on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:39AM (#39027472)
People bought the iPhone when there were no apps available.

And devs complained that there's no SDK, and Apple told them they can make web-based apps, and they didn't like that.

Now the have an SDK, and they complain they can't create nice enough web-based apps.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pompino on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:15AM (#39023904)
>Why do you get to run a business off it for free?

There isn't a divine commandment as to what rights we "should" have. We vote, fight, protest and get to make up our own rights.

>They spend hundreds of millions on SWE salaries to make a nice SDK for you to use. They’re also operating all the servers. Your $100 does not cover it. It’s a symbiotic relationship. At least see it and acknowledge it.

I don't feel like paying for an Apple executives BMW car payment. But you do you.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:29AM (#39025448)
This isn't about rights. You already have all the rights you need here.

You would like others to work for nothing, or for what you care to give them, instead of the price they offer their services at, and you'd like to vote, fight and protest until they work for your price.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by qwytw on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:23AM (#39025874)
> You would like others to work for nothing,

So like developers working on macOS or Windows? It's so horrible that Apple has allowed third party developers to exploit them for for free for over 40 years now...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:05AM (#39026609)
It's not horrible, because they chose it. The price Apple offered there was $0. No one forced them.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by qwytw on Sunday January 21, 2024 @06:06AM (#39077419)
Well yeah, obviously. Because Apple benefited a lot more from developers making apps/etc. for their platform than the other way around. Now that the balances has shifted (of course only on mobile) Apple became a lot more exploitative.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Ma8ee on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:50AM (#39024613)
> There isn't a divine commandment as to what rights we "should" have. We vote, fight, protest and get to make up our own rights.

Not in America. The only venue to change you have is to spend, or not spend money somewhere. Since people think they profit more from developing apps for iOS than not developing apps for iOS, Apple’s profit is “right”.

And a century or so of indoctrination has made most Americans believe that this is just the natural order of things.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:34AM (#39024951)
> Why do you get to run a business off it for free?

So Microsoft did all of this on Windows (or Apple itself for that matter for macOS) due to entirely altruistic reasons?

Also platforms need developers a whole lot more than developers need specific platforms. You can always go and works at a bank or something. Apple would be skewed with no 3-rd party developers they always knew it.

> They’re also operating all the servers. Your $100 does not cover it. It’s a symbiotic relationship.

Maybe the ads on the app store would more than cover it? Not only do you need to pay 30% you also have to pay extra for placement so that Apple wouldn’t put your competitors apps at the top of the results when users search for your app?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by blasphemers on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:42AM (#39029240)
It's like people don't remember windows phone failed because of a lack of third-party apps.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by NineStarPoint on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:49AM (#39024132)
Would Apple even approve something going on the app store that tried to do things in ways that were that non-standard? More generally it’s not like you can choose to host your own servers or, in forgoing all of Apple’s work, not have to pay that 30%. When Apple isn’t going to let you do things another way, they don’t get to argue that all of the benefits they do provide are what people are paying for. People have to pay the price to be allowed on the ecosystem at all.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by guax on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:06AM (#39024255)
Apple wrote their kernel from zero?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kridsdale1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:02AM (#39024712)
No, that’s why I excluded posix parts of the operating system. That’s from Berkeley.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by 6510 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:02AM (#39024235)
I look at it like this. If someone is doing it you have to do it too, you cant run a competitive business if your competitor is taking 30%. It is not something you chose to do but you have to.

The most important angle is what this grows into. Apple doesn't have to make hardware. They can simply stop doing that and live on rent alone. Hardware is hard work. It might just be that they have to stop doing it.

How much they put the squeeze on who and who makes how much money isn't even important. This is not beneficial to the industry or to society.

After the age of working your ass off while starving comes the age of contributing and thriving, this period ends with the age of entitlement. You do the work, I enjoy the benefits. we can only afford so much of that before our civilization turns into a hell hole. You will be working day and night to make ends meet while I have all the time and resources in the world to figure out how I'm going to take just a little bit more from you.

It's not about wealth, people should be able to EARN whatever they EARN.

It isn't even about mortality, we can go back to the age of working your ass off while starving, we know how to do that. The bigger issue is to have people in control who cant tie their own shoes. It sets us up for total failure. It takes one small incident to end humanity.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kridsdale1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:06AM (#39024740)
> Apple doesn't have to make hardware. They can simply stop doing that and live on rent alone.

This is what Valve discovered.

Nobody in 2004 would have thought the best developer in the world would stop making games.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:13AM (#39027170)
To be honest it seems like what it is for the younger generation in life generally. A nice legacy from the boomers and unsurprisingly Apple is a very big boomer company.

I think many here do not see this since they earn enough that those considerations are kind of irrelevant, but I believe current Apple problems reveal a systemic problem across society. Apple acts like an old entitled asshole who just want to capture value for not doing much because one day they did something good and I feel in general this is exactly what the current governing generation is doing...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:41AM (#39024073)
>They’re also operating all the servers. Your $100 does not cover it.

I mean, let's be real here. Most people even if Apple fully allowed other payment processors would still opt into Apple's payment. Easiest to setup, most visible and familiar interface for consumers, and lets them push liability back to Apple. So they'd still get 30% from many consumers.

This angle only applies in a situation where you think 1) the pareto principle applies and 2) all of that 20% decided to roll their own payment processing, which isn't trivial nor a risk many want to take onto themselves. It'd take a lot more than a dozen megacorps doing this to make Apple sweat.

And if this does happen, it sounds like a service issue a that point. If you can offer all that convenience but people don't view it as worth 30%, then maybe the rate should be re-negotiated.

>They spend hundreds of millions on SWE salaries to make a nice SDK for you to use

they spend hundreds of millions to get other businesses to do business with them, and still charge many upfront costs along the way. Back then, we simply called that the cost to do business.

Adtech also spends hundreds of millions each on salaries to make a nice SDK for you to use. I don't exactly feel I owe those companies for their labor since I'm (the dev) not the primary point of revenue.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by greysphere on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:14AM (#39024317)
You just described most games.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kridsdale1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:05AM (#39024731)
I am aware.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Hamuko on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:22AM (#39023950)
>They’re also operating all the servers. Your $100 does not cover it.

You can get about 1.1 terabytes of data transfer out from Amazon S3 to Internet for $100.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ryanbrunner on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:48AM (#39025074)
And anyone on Apple's scale is paying orders of magnitude less than that, even through Amazon.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Hamuko on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:50AM (#39025087)
I mean, if you were self-distributing your iOS app right now instead of having Apple do it, and you had to look up how much transferring data in the terabytes costs, you'd just use Cloudflare R2 instead.

I'd be willing to bet that, all things being equal, most apps would save money if the developers were self-distributing them instead of using the App Store.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by qwytw on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:26AM (#39025902)
> most apps would save money if the developers were self-distributing them instead of using the App Store

There must be a reason why almost all games are still published on Steam despite the 30% though. The increased customer reach almost always outweighs the additional revenue (and this also applies to major companies like EA, Ubisoft etc. who have tried building their own storefronts).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:28AM (#39027347)
The thing is that you can't really talk about Steam like other platforms. They are already competing with themselves on price somehow. Games that are launched on Steam do not cost more than they do elsewhere in the first place, and secondly people very often buy on sales at prices low enough that it doesn't make sense to look elsewhere for the convenience of having it all in one place.

There are also plenty of big games with publishers big enough that they have their own platform (EA, Ubisoft, Epic, Microsoft) and depending on many things their games may or may not be on Steam also.

Steam also accepts keys purchased from elsewhere so in principle even if most of your sales are somewhere else, it is better to have it on Steam. I also think you Steam is offering some valuable community/platforms tools.

Not much of this applies to the Apple app store. The truth is the reason people use it is because that's the only thing allowed. If peoples could install apps from anywhere with its own self-update mechanism (like sparkle or something more modern like a hybrid web-app) I doubt it would be used as much appart from free stuff from developers that do not want to figure out distribution. If there was a large price difference, most people wouldn't use it, just like most people do not go to the more expensive supermarket unless they absolutely have to.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by qwytw on Saturday January 20, 2024 @04:24PM (#39072501)
> If there was a large price difference, most people wouldn't use it, just like most people do not go to the more expensive supermarket unless they absolutely have to.

Yet developers still use Steam and most people prefer buying games on there than on any other platform or direct? How is this particularly different?

Of course the App Store UX is atrocious garbage (and I won't even mention the paid ads...) so maybe competition might force Apple to do something about it. However I would bet most consumers and developers will still primarily use it rather than any other platform (just like Play Store is still dominant on Android) because of discoverability, trust and other rational reasons. Of course you do have a point about IAP (Apple would likely have to cut prices to 10-15% or risk a significant proportion of apps switching to something else).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:13PM (#39123300)
Yes, people use Steam because they can make pricing competitive enough (low) that they will find users that will pay for the game instead of just pirating it or trying to buy it somewhere else cheaper. Steam also has built-in market arbitration, since they do not charge the same in all countries and you can buy keys that are still valid worldwide, people who find some games still too expensive will go and buy a key from a third-party seller and still play the game on Steam.

From the point of view of devs it is very worth it, because even though steam might take as big of a cut as Apple (at first, and debatable) this is on what wouldn't be sales otherwise so it ends up being better in the long run. On top of that, Steam actually lowers the cut they take if your game is successful, which makes a lot more sense than what Apple does (if you make more than a 1m you are back to 30% which makes zero sense, because the more your product is successful the less relevancy Apple has in your success...).

And it seems pretty clear that those are just what is publicly available information, considering the number of latitudes/tools and options Steam give to developers it is obvious that most even moderately successful developers get to negotiate their terms. Unlike Apple they are willing to work on a case-by-case basis, instead of going the route of a giant soulless corp that will treat everyone the same, because the rules are the rules or whatever (all the while working out deals with actually powerful corporations in the back, still maintaining that extremely wrong do-gooder better than you attitude they have).

Another reason Steam is very different is that they are not exclusive, you can very well distribute both on Steam or somewhere else cheaper, including your own solution with no issue at all (many games do this). And it means that sales on Steam maybe wouldn't have happened somewhere else, which makes the cut feel a lot fairer.

So here you have it, Steam is very different in many ways, first and foremost because it is not your only option for the platform and they cannot have monopolistic behavior. But also, even though I think it is still a big corp with many issues, they are less of a pain in the ass to work with than Apple.

I agree that most people would still primarily use Apple's App Store, but this is exactly the point and the whole reason their arguments are irrelevant and anti-competitive. If people were to start using some other solution in large numbers, it would mean that Apple is indeed doing something very wrong. And I do believe that they are way too greedy, on top of being way too controlling of the devices/systems they do not have ownership anymore. All their arguments about privacy and security are horseshit because if we accept them, it means private property is a rather vague concept and there would be no reason they get to keep their intellectual property at this point.

As for what you said about Android, I find it funny because just a few days ago I helped a friend install an ad-blocker from F-Droid to play a Tetris game (that has an insane 3euros/months subscription if you want to get rid of ads). So yeah, the majority of people use Google Play, but also the majority of people mostly use popular social media, a few utilities (cheap or free mostly) and some games. The Apple tax doesn't even apply to most cases because an app making a lot of revenue can figure out a way to make users pay in-app with no Google tax and the solution of their choosing.

And you are talking about Apple lowering rates to 10-15% and I think it seems acceptable because payments seem to be weirdly expensive in the US (because of credit card and cashback programs I have been told). But in the EU, it still seems like an absurdly high tax / cut for what is a payment solution. If you are dealing with micro-transaction (in the cents amounts) it could make sense, but with the app pricing inflation, it is largely not the case and you are talking about multiple euros amount most of the time. Payment solutions for this kind of transaction would work out to about 7% in the worst-case scenario, and mostly depending on the profile of customers, many devs could get rates as low as 3-4% if they have large volume. If you think about the market as a whole, it is a huge amount of money, which is exactly the reason Apple is making so much of it.

Since I know, some are going to argue about Apple making their dev tools available and their distribution infrastructure, I will cover this very easily. They need their dev tools for their own apps and the reason you have to use them is because they make it almost impossible to use anything else; on top of that without this their platform would be extremely uninteresting and completely irrelevant compared to Android, because who would buy a smartphone (that is just a small computer) that can only run apps from its manufacturer (they were called feature phones before...). Before Apple launched the App Store, people figured out how to make and publish apps without them just fine, without much need of Apple tooling. So, if the system was accessible as any computer system should be, the value of their tools would be almost non-existent in fact or a very low amount compared to what they take. Anyone that isn't a complete hypocrite knows they make those tools to make it easier and desirable to develop for their platform, they have a big interest in it, and every developer already paid for it when they bought their extremely expensive hardware (but modern Apple has no issues double-dipping everywhere).

As for the distribution, I actually think they should charge for it, even the "free" apps (I would say ESPECIALLY). There is no reason a small dev would have to give Apple at least 15% of all of his revenue for distribution when Facebook can distribute their app for free even though it must use an extremely large amount of bandwidth. This would have many side effects: first the apps would become slimmer (since peoples start caring when they have to pay, even more for corporations, you can be certain they would they find ways to reduce the bandwidth bill), second there would be less updates (and that in itself would be an achievement) and third it would automatically cleanup the store since devs wouldn't publish trashy/scummy apps if they had to pay for the waste of ressource they cause (can't give back the time stolen from users anyway).

In any case, I believe that those "app stores" are a modern problem created by network effect inherent to technology, and it just isn't right to let companies run a very large tax rate on economics activities happening on their platforms. Apple is being targeted more because they are by far the worst of the bunch and also the richest target. There is often a lot of talk about market value, but it is irrelevant since it can be wiped pretty fast. The fact is Apple has a mountain of cash, and they got there by stealing more than their fair share from society.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by psychoslave on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:00AM (#39024687)
If merit was a highly pondering factor of income, coal miners would be extremely rich and no annuitant would exist out there.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pratnala on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:16AM (#39024344)
I agree that Apple should take some cut but 30% is predatory and excessive.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:20AM (#39024380)
They can get 99% provided they allow the users the freedom to download and install apps from wherever they want.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by merlindru on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:56PM (#39031081)
This

I don't care about the fee for using their services, I care about the fact that I'm forced to use their services

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:45AM (#39027570)
Apple charges 15%. The only developers who pay 30% are the ones earning over a million dollars a year through the App Store. Even then, they get charged 15% if it’s a long-term subscription.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by yMEyUyNE1 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:51AM (#39024620)
I view such companies as Trolls under the Bridge (i.e. appstores) that connect the app developers and the users.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nkrisc on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:14AM (#39026249)
No, we can factor in who’s making them and how much money they have.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:39AM (#39026891)
The merits are centered around the outcomes, which in this case are the consolidation of wealth by a few who don’t need it from the many who do. What other merits are more meaningful than the observable outcomes of the practice?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by SOLAR_FIELDS on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:17AM (#39027217)
Here’s a very simple example. Search ChatGPT in the App Store. The top result is an ad that’s not ChatGPT but looks extremely similar. The top 10 results are basically intended to look as much like the ChatGPT in name and logo as possible.

Ostensibly this 30% cut is supposed to prevent things like this from happening, as Apple argues it uses that money to keep the App Store clean from fraudulent or misrepresenting apps, among other things. There is a much touted “review” process that is supposed to be partially funded by the 30% cut.

So if that isn’t really happening, what, pray tell, is that 30% going towards? It isn’t making the App Store a better experience

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by taylorius on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:26AM (#39027324)
Why shouldn't who's making a claim and their money be relevant? Monopolies (and near monopolies) are a bad thing for free markets.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by sharemywin on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:27AM (#39028118)
I think it's kind of the same argument. if you can justify an excessive marketplace tax for a company that "wins" in a wins a winner take all market dynamic then you get a $Trillion company. not sure how you get one without the other.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by gunapologist99 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:24AM (#39028959)
That's often true, but it's not a hard-and-fast rule, because we also have to look at the capabilities of the two combatants. It's why you would probably/hopefully assist the underdog who was being bullied.

We're talking about the wealthiest company in the world who can obviously afford to run out the clock on the court system and bury an opponent with legal fees. There's a monster difference of offensive capabilities, even if we realize that Epic is a sizeable company; in this case, Epic is really standing in for every other tiny company or one-man shop in the App Store, and we should thank them for doing that.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:22AM (#39025375)
> You don't need to defend the trillion dollar company. They are not your friend, they do not care about you, your work or your life.

True.

> All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes than make a few people who already have everything even richer.

I'm old enough to have developed software before the App Store existed, and remember that everyone was very excited both buy it finally being introduced to iOS, and by the relatively low fees of only 30%.

You're free to argue that 30% is too high, or even that the 15% for small developers is too high, that this is rent-seeking by Apple and only made sense when they were also a small company… but I think this is also true for the businesses trying to convince everyone that it matters, and I think they would like to charge the same sticker price while collecting the difference for themselves.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nolok on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:08AM (#39025747)
The problem is not that 30% is too high or too low, the problem is that it shouldn't be a % but a flat fee structure, like every other services ever.

If you have an app tomorrow that sells for $10 to 10k people you owe Apple $30k, now you manage to up your price to $30, same work same size same everything, but suddenly you now owe Apple $90k ? That's called a tax, not a fee.

Doing so wouldn't stop apple from having a separate, "pay 30% all inclusive" fee, and it wouldn't stop them from "if your app is free you have no fee" (beside the xcode sub fee).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by HatchedLake721 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:14AM (#39025793)
> like every other services ever

Apple didn’t invent a marketplace.

Please have a look how other online and offline marketplaces work and how they monetize access.

You can look at anything from Salesforce, Shopify, to Microsoft, Epic Store, PlayStation and your local Target store.

Hint - it’s not a flat fee structure.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nolok on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:16AM (#39025806)
What makes you think I agree any more with any of these ?

But as a user I'm able to buy my pc games, my groceries or my music from another store. Apple prohibits me from doing that.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by qwytw on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:29AM (#39025928)
Yeah but technically nobody is forcing anyone to use Steam. Yet pretty much all the games are published there and the market has decided that the 30% fee is "fair" (AFAIK they can get away charging even more than Apple on average because there is no 15% tier?)
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by criley2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:09AM (#39026641)
There is competition for Steam and stores like Epic offer at 12% tier. Developers make substantially more money per sale on Epic than Steam.

And the thing is, 30% cut is pointless for Steam. They have more money than they could ever spend. There is no budget at Valve. They just spend whatever they want and do what they want.

They rob hardworking small developers of real money that they need to support themselves all so billionaire Gabe N can enjoy the extreme excess of his valve palace

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by HatchedLake721 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:51AM (#39026987)
And Epic admitted that 12% is unsustainable.

The rest of your comment is baffling to me.

I assume you're neither a shareholder or employee of Steam.

But you count their money, you decide for them that their own money is pointless to them, you somehow know how much money they earn, and based on that make assumption it's more than they could ever spend (even though you admit yourself there is no budget at Valve).

And how long is "ever" in "than they could ever spend"? 1 year? 5 years? 20 years? 100 years?

I very much dislike people who count other people's money, I don't know if it's their own jealousy or greediness. But you on top of that also somehow came to the conclusion that their own money is pointless to them, and then accuse them of robbing people.

And this is about marketplace for PC games, a wild west of side-loading and land of free for all.

But somehow Steam is robbing developers.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by criley2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:08AM (#39027120)
Epic has not admitted that 12% is unsustainable, and the suggestion that it has is so detached from reality that it colors the rest of your comment as being extremely unreliable.

You should double check your sources because you fell for low-effort low-intelligence fake journalism. What Sweeney said was that 12% was not viable in developing countries due to high finance costs. https://twitter.com/TimSweeneyEpic/status/109102593910919987...

You dislike people who count private profit margins?

I dislike low-information consumers who simp for corporations based on literal fake news.

Be better, shame on you.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by HatchedLake721 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:43AM (#39027526)
It's ironic for you to call me "low-information consumer" and "shame me" when you don't even look further than the first Google result to Tim Sweeney's tweet.

Epic Game Store is unprofitable and losing money. There were financial documents released in Epic vs Apple about Epic Game Store becoming possibly profitable in a few years and accumulating 1 billion loss before the end of this decade.

> You dislike people who count private profit margins?

I like how you honestly believe that saying "% cut is pointless for Steam", "they have more money than they could ever spend", "they just spend whatever they want and do what they want", "they rob ... so billionaire Gabe N can enjoy the extreme excess of his valve palace" is counting profit margins.

To bring you back to reality, you're not counting profit margins, because you have no access to their financials. You're making stuff up and talking emotional nonsense like you have a personal grudge and accuse other people and companies of robbing people.

edit: can't reply to your comment below. wishing you all the best with your future trap laying for incompetent repliers

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by AlexandrB on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:58AM (#39030315)
> They rob hardworking small developers of real money that they need to support themselves all so billionaire Gabe N can enjoy the extreme excess of his valve palace

Steam's 30% is still a huge improvement on the overhead involved in brick and mortar physical sales. But if a developer doesn't want to pay the 30% they can always sell their game from their own website - and some do[1]. Most developers seem to think that the 30% is worth it though.

[1] https://fractalsoftworks.com/preorder/

Edit: Something I neglected to make explicit is that the PC is an open platform. If you don't want to sell through Steam you have tons of other options, including self-publishing. If you want to get your game on a PS5 or an iPhone, you have to go through Sony or Apple and they take a similar cut of your revenue.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:25AM (#39025899)
While true, I think these examples are sufficient to dispute calling it a "tax".

"Excessive" or "monopolistic", if you like, but not really a tax.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by HatchedLake721 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:13AM (#39026234)
It doesn't matter if you personally agree or not how marketplaces monetize.

It's up to the people who created these marketplaces to charge what they feel is fair and/or financially sustainable for the value they provide.

If it wasn't worth it for the sellers, these marketplaces wouldn't exist today.

But they do, and they thrive.

If you have a secret sauce how to build a sustainable billion people marketplace after spending billions on it without charging sellers access to your customers, please do it and show the world how it should be done.

> Apple prohibits me from doing that

Yes, because that's their product, their philosophy and the experience they want their customers to have.

And they do that for 15 years already.

You knew that and still bought the iPhone. As have hundreds of millions of others.

And it still is one of the most popular, highest rated consumer devices in the world for over a decade.

So it's not a deal breaker for consumers, is it?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by carlosjobim on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:51AM (#39026989)
Flat fee services are starting to seriously attack percentage based services in the marketplace right now. Sirvoy for hotel bookings, Ticket Tailor for event ticketing, not to mention buy-and-sell marketplaces everywhere. I expect percentage based services to be murdered during this economic recession, as businesses do what they can to survive – including cutting completely useless costs.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by flutas on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:10AM (#39028748)
> Shopify

Is a flat fee structure?

Basic: $39/mo

Shopify: $105/mo

Advanced: $399/mo

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by HatchedLake721 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:39AM (#39029201)
I mean the sellers side of the marketplace, not buyers.

https://shopify.dev/docs/apps/store/revenue-share

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fennecfoxy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:50AM (#39030200)
B-b-but-

We can take them all down. We should. Doesn't matter if it's Valve or Steam or Google or whoever. It's only better for consumers and clearly we've let it slide to the point where even us usually cynical HN peeps are apparently willing to defend this predatory and anti-consumer behaviour.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dnissley on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:24PM (#39031446)
Apple can do what they want. I want them to be able to do what they want because I'm from America dammit and companies in non-critical segments of the economy like video games and phones should be able to do what works for them. Ain't called the land of the free for nothing.

Personally I don't like these practices -- it's all cuz of the walled garden, locked down aspect of it all. But luckily I'm also free to continue avoiding the heck out of Apple devices. They make nice hardware so that sucks that I miss out on that, but I'll take the trade off that I get to install whatever apps I want on this here Android phone of mine.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by amelius on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:54AM (#39026077)
> The problem is not that 30% is too high or too low, the problem is that it shouldn't be a % but a flat fee structure, like every other services ever.

I hate Apple like the next enlightened guy, but then banks and credit card companies should also charge a flat fee for their services. This isn't the case and probably never will be, however. But their fee is much more reasonable than Apple's fee.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by klabb3 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:46AM (#39027577)
There is a lot wrong with banks. In many cases people try to dip in a % when it should be flat. However, with credit the risk is proportional to the loan.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by sofixa on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:28AM (#39025427)
> and by the relatively low fees of only 30%.

30% is low compared to what? Mafia extortion rates?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:11AM (#39025776)
When the App Store was new, the web hosting for my indie shareware games was about 30% of their net revenue after the payment processor and marketplace fees.

The payment processor (cheapest PayPal (U.S. Accounts), most expensive American Express/Optima International[0]) and marketplace (Kagi[0]) fees were on top of that hosting fee, and cost anywhere from (1.9 to 5.0)% + $0.30 (payment provider) plus 2.5% + $1 (market place for ≤$25), which makes those two items combined also more than 30% for any item sold for less than $5.08-5.77.

Hosting fees are of course cheaper today, more so when bulk bought (I think more than enough to compensate for games today getting into the 100GB range when my shareware was 10s of MB).

I'd hope that payment providers are also.

But at the time, it looked amazing.

[0] https://web.archive.org/web/20090903044400/http://www.kagi.c...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by zzbzq on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:04AM (#39027086)
I don't understand what hosting fees have to do with apps. The app store seemed to be more or less a ripoff of Facebook's (now long defunct) app store, back when Facebook was a web-based app-of-apps, and AFAIK Facebook apps were free plugins.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:38AM (#39028287)
> I don't understand what hosting fees have to do with apps.

Apple hosts the apps, doesn't charge devs or customers anything for bandwidth used when downloading them. At the time the store launched, this was a big part of my overall costs, which Apple covered in full from their take.

> The app store seemed to be more or less a ripoff of Facebook's (now long defunct) app store, back when Facebook was a web-based app-of-apps, and AFAIK Facebook apps were free plugins.

I forgot that ever existed, so I searched for it. Looks like FB's was announced about 4 years after Apple's App Store?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by xigoi on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:59PM (#39031136)
> Apple hosts the apps, doesn't charge devs or customers anything for bandwidth used when downloading them.

But it doesn’t allow developers to host the apps themselves, so they are being forced to pay for a service they don’t need.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Thursday January 18, 2024 @09:07AM (#39041807)
Need is the wrong word there, developers absolutely need it. They may well be able to do better value for money with their own choices, and I appreciate the argument that everything bundled together isn't great, but unlike e.g. the CloudKid data sync Apple also provides at no extra cost, app download bandwidth is mandatory and unavoidable.

I could also go the other way and say that being tax-like is good for the same reason actual taxes are good: that it gets spent on building up an economic environment from which others can profit (at this point one would then want to retort something about democratic values).

But as I'm not hugely interested in defending a trillion dollar company (just giving a historical perspective that 30% was, when it was first announced, an improvement over the status quo), I say that if anyone feels the world has changed enough this is no longer good, it is good to call for change — companies may not be democracies, but the nations they operate in generally are.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by xigoi on Thursday January 18, 2024 @10:31AM (#39042942)
Most developers are already using a platform like GitHub, which allows them to publish releases for free. There is no point in paying for that service other that being forced to.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:31AM (#39043809)
"""Usage limits

GitHub Pages sites are subject to the following usage limits:

* GitHub Pages source repositories have a recommended limit of 1 GB. For more information, see "About large files on GitHub"

* Published GitHub Pages sites may be no larger than 1 GB.

* GitHub Pages deployments will timeout if they take longer than 10 minutes.

* GitHub Pages sites have a soft bandwidth limit of 100 GB per month.

* GitHub Pages sites have a soft limit of 10 builds per hour. This limit does not apply if you build and publish your site with a custom GitHub Actions workflow

In order to provide consistent quality of service for all GitHub Pages sites, rate limits may apply. These rate limits are not intended to interfere with legitimate uses of GitHub Pages. If your request triggers rate limiting, you will receive an appropriate response with an HTTP status code of 429, along with an informative HTML body.

If your site exceeds these usage quotas, we may not be able to serve your site, or you may receive a polite email from GitHub Support suggesting strategies for reducing your site's impact on our servers, including putting a third-party content distribution network (CDN) in front of your site, making use of other GitHub features such as releases, or moving to a different hosting service that might better fit your needs."""

- https://docs.github.com/en/pages/getting-started-with-github...

I managed to use 25 GB in a month for games that were less than 5 MB(!) each (shareware model, so more downloads than sales), and that was for something generating mere hobby-level income, not full time job replacement income.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by xigoi on Thursday January 18, 2024 @01:24PM (#39045486)
I was talking about the “Releases” feature of GitHub (which the document you quoted recommends using for large downloads), not GitHub Pages. And specifically for games, there is Itch.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ben_w on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:34PM (#39046489)
A quick look at the App Store games section suggests about half of the "top" games exceed the default file size limits for both of those.

(But this is rather beside the point, I've been trying to repeatedly make it clear that I was defending the initial value proposition when the App Store was new and shiny and Apple were mere upstarts, not the ongoing one where the corporation's market cap is approximately the same as the net value of the entire country I was born in).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by matwood on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:06AM (#39029572)
At the time it was low compared to any retail software distribution. If (a big if) a developer could get on a carrier App Store (they existed) it was much more than 30%.

Go back and watch the keynote. Developers cheered because 30% was so much lower than any other stores available at the time.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pjc50 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:53AM (#39025648)
It's a small amount compared to retail; it's a large amount compared to a download; and it's infinitely larger than the 0% platform royalty required by IBM-compatible PCs.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by merrywhether on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:27AM (#39027333)
That 0% platform royalty was on top of the $300 flat fee for the Windows operating system (or however much, I never ran Windows myself), whereas iOS is technically free (no fee for major updates). You’re paying for the OS/platform one way or another.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:42AM (#39030093)
Very few people bought Windows separately, its price was bundled with the hardware sale just like it is with iOS. This is a completely moot point.

You could try to argue that Apple give more value by supporting longer, but then again you would be completely wrong (some hardware manufacturer are not super good at supporting their stuff for the very long term, but windows in itself has a support timeline way beyond anything Apple ever did...)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Halvedat on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:23AM (#39024400)
It's very likely that people posting on Hacker News may hold equity in a company like Apple, may have their primary form of income derived from that company or may be able to attribute their sizeable wealth to its growth.

It is no surprise that people will come to the defense of this giant when you stop to consider this. Apple doesn't have to care about them, it already has.

I am of the opinion that there should be some sort of disclosure of financial interest.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:51AM (#39024622)
Pretty much everyone that invests in the public equity markets holds equity in Apple. In fact, Apple would be most public market investor’s biggest holding (or 2nd biggest due to Microsoft’s recent increases) via index funds.

Even if you are not invested in public equity markets, you can be exposed to them via local and state government’s pension fund investments, because if those do not perform as projected, then your taxes have to make up for it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by darkwater on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:23AM (#39024879)
With the caveat that if you just invest in indexed funds, if Apple does worse than before, probably some competitor does better than before, and it might compensate. If you just own AAPL stocks on the other hand...
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fauigerzigerk on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:28AM (#39025428)
Maybe so, but I never found this line of argument particularly convincing.

The investments people have in Apple are often insignificant compared to the rest of their income or wealth.

Also, buying shares in the public market is like a bet. Instead of changing your opinion to agree with the bet you could simply bet the other way. Or you could bet that your own political activism will fail. Betting on an outcome doesn't mean you prefer that outcome. It can also be hedging.

The people who really do have something riding on Apple's success are employees getting stock options. And yes, I would also like to know whether someone is an Apple employee when they are commenting on these subjects.

Developers are affected by Apple's policies and success in very complex ways and can legitimately take either side on these questions.

Disclosure: I have an app in the App Store that made me ~£100 in the previous fiscal year. I also have £3000 in a NASDAQ 100 ETF. Apple's share of that is ~£270.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by carlosjobim on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:36AM (#39029149)
Not everybody who has a different opinion than you is a paid corporate shill or spy from Russia or China. If you seriously harbour these thoughts, you should be careful with where they can lead you. Group schizophrenia has become the most common issue among the population in industrialised countries, it seems everybody is suspecting everybody nowadays. And not only suspecting, but outright accusing, just on a hunch and without any evidence.

Please note that I was not paid by Apple to write the comment above.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by highwaylights on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:20AM (#39024858)
Keeping the tax at more or less the same rate on outbound links is incredibly brazen, even by Apple standards.

If the EU DMA does eventually force them to open the platform to competing stores it’s going to be very hard to defend the different policies in different markets, especially as I assume Epic will push aggressively to have Fortnite and the Epic Games store on iOS in those markets as early as possible to force the conversation.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lijok on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:02AM (#39024708)
You need to learn the difference between defending an entity and defending an argument.

The line of thinking you're expressing here is what leads to questioning free speech and privacy absolutism.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dragonelite on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:42AM (#39025018)
The lords and churches of the past wouldn't even dare to ask as much as 30% of revenues in our feudal past.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:08AM (#39025255)
It’s 15% for the commoners (<$1M) and I’d believe that in feudal times.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by qwytw on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:42AM (#39026010)
IIRC the standard for serfs was 2-3 days of labor per week (in some cases during harvest even up to 5), for a 6 day workweek. Add various random fees and rents and that's way more than 50-60%.

Of course everything improved massively after the plague. So it depends on which part of the middle ages we're talking about.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:18AM (#39024361)
>They are not your friend, they do not care about you

Of course they care about you. They hope you are healthy and in a good shape so you can work more to earn more money and give them their share.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by danieldk on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:03AM (#39023832)
It's almost religious zeal. In a thread on another website about the EU's requirements to allow side-loading, etc. People were wishing that Europe is dragged into a third world war, to teach them a lesson about after regulating Apple. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:28AM (#39024440)
Apple has few talents:

-putting disparate things together to form a whole and polishing it

-design

-marketing which includes cult building

All these talents are put at work together in harmony.

I own devices from Apple (which have both advantages and disadvantages) and other companies, but at no point I fell myself better because I own Apple devices, nor do I consider their devices better than anything else out there.

For some people, brands are a part of who they are. Apple, Gucci, Christian Dior, Tesla are not longer manufacturers of goods to be used. They are symbols that are used to craft ones identity, together with whatever ideology of the day.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lozenge on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:54AM (#39024651)
When a UK court made Apple merely put a notice on their website for two weeks (due to stealing Samsung's design elements) they similarly found the worst possible way to "comply". So much so that the court issued another order to do it properly.

The comments on the above Apple news website were all "why should Apple comply with a UK decision anyway".

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by droopyEyelids on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:25AM (#39023970)
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by zer0zzz on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:57AM (#39025161)
I can understand some perspectives of the Apple-defending crowd. Apple being the popular yet closed-end-to-end platform experience does kind of provide a level of balance in the industry that wouldn’t exist otherwise. I personally think it’s silly to look at Amazon or Google as an example of openness.

I think it’s also kinda weird to label Apple as a monopoly unless you mean a monopoly on revenues. They seem to actively swerve away from getting over 50% share of anything.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:36AM (#39026392)
They realized that getting over 50% marketshare paints a target on their back, whereas what you want is 50% of profitable money in the market.

If BMW sell 10 cars with $1 margin, Jaguar sell 5 cars with $2 margin, and Ferrari sell 2 cars with $40 margin, the latter took home 80% of profits with 11% marketshare. Then Ferrari just work their hardest to make sure that their customers cannot change car without a lot of effort, effectively coopting (or rather enslaving) them forever.

That keeps antitrust law at bay in practice, while egregiously breaking it in spirit.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by gonzon on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:41AM (#39024071)
the ironic thing is that the way you describe apple is the way 99% of people outside of hackernews would describe the people of hackernews (or tech ppl in general).
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lynx23 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:12AM (#39024793)
"They are not your friend, they do not care about you"

I beg to differ. As a blind user relying on accessibility, Apple was actually the first company that decided that accessibility should be an inherent part of the OS, not just an expensive add-on. Since the iPhone, blind users can just buy the product and turn speech output on, without having to install expensive extra software as was the case with Windows, for instance.

So keep your generic accusations for yourself, they are far from correct.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cryptonym on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:31AM (#39025942)
This is a great result. That being said, I wouldn't bet they did that just because they cared about you in a friendly way.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by tuyiown on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:41AM (#39027508)
If it's not driven by ROI, it can only be empathy and «do the right thing»
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cryptonym on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:09AM (#39027856)
Who said there is no ROI? Apple is no charity, they probably found another way to generate profit out of it (brand reputation, more sales, you name it). It might be better than previous situation, profit was generated in a terrible way. Still doesn't mean you owe them something nor they are being particularly "nice" with you.

If cutting it was a way to generate high profit, finance and shareholders would probably ask for this to be removed quickly. For instance, in the last vote they refused assessments on social and environmental issues.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lynx23 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:33AM (#39038294)
You are so full of activism and the resulting hatered, it hurts to read. I hope you have something in your life that makes you feel cozy.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cryptonym on Thursday January 18, 2024 @02:52AM (#39039143)
I'm really sorry if I hurt your feelings, that was not my intent. I don't think activism means what you think, I'm not involved in any of this and I'm not hating anyone.

I'm not hating Apple for this, they play the game the way it's supposed to be. Let's not be delusional about their intents, that could hurt you.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by tuyiown on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:36AM (#39039417)
> Who said there is no ROI?

I did not because I don't know.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dingaling on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:14PM (#39032056)
"...in 1988, the company added the first accessibility support program for Windows by incorporating work developed at the TRACE Center, a research and development center on accessible technology at the University of Wisconsin.

Known then as Access Utility for Windows 2.0, the program improved the accessibility of Windows for people who are deaf, hard of hearing, or who have limited dexterity"

https://www.afb.org/aw/1/4/16165

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lynx23 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:30AM (#39038269)
I wasn't implying Windows never had an Accessibility API. However, it took Microsoft until around 2010 until they actually added their own built-in screen reader, Narrator. Before that, the API was there, but if you wanted a capable screen reader, chances were high that you would pay a relatively high price for it. These days, Narrator is even almost useable, although I dont know any blind users who actually use it on a daily basis.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Zetobal on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:57AM (#39024195)
This guy also hates taxes.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by atoav on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:09AM (#39024283)
So where can I vote out apple if I am unhappy with the 30%?

Not everything you pay money for is comparable to taxes.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:33AM (#39024939)
Don’t develop for iOS.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by atoav on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:49AM (#39025614)
That is not voting.

That is the equivalent of telling someone who doesn't like the current dictator to "go live in the desert".

Remember: I did not bring up the bad analogy. Someone abusing their quasi-monopolistic position to charge high fees is not the same as a tax. This was the point of my post. And sure we can pretend it is the same and bend reality till it fits, but that seems to me more like an idological expedition, than an insightful exploration.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:18AM (#39025824)
That is voting in a modern democracy. You put your eggs into Android, iOS, and/or one of the less popular candidates. Or you don’t get into the mobile space at all.

Just because you don’t like the options doesn’t mean it’s not voting.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rickdeckard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:31AM (#39026826)
It's not democratic voting because in a democracy a vote is made to decide the direction for the entire voting-audience. The path the majority considers to be for the greater good, in which everyone will participate then.

Here the voting audience will be split in different paths which will all continue to exist, and a person changing his mind will have to leave behind things HE/SHE accumulated and contributed on this path.

If that would be like democratic voting, it would mean that if you decide to change your vote from one election to the other, you have to return your entire income and acquisitions you made during the ruling of this party, to start building your life again on the other path (--> "if you don't like it, go live in the desert")

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by vdaea on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:59AM (#39026118)
>Someone abusing their quasi-monopolistic position to charge high fees is not the same as a tax.

Actually it is. How do I stop paying taxes, if not by living in the desert?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by smoldesu on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:31PM (#39032287)
You think you're funny until the IRS back-charges you for 15 years of Arizona property tax.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by thebruce87m on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:24AM (#39024408)
You vote with your wallet.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by danieldk on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:27AM (#39024913)
I agree when it's a healthy market. But when the choice is between relinquish most control over your own device or relinquish most of your privacy, maybe it's time to regulate the market?

In the EU this is happening on both fronts:

- The GDPR has Android phone manufacturers to ask consent for different ways of using your data and being able to remove data. This is starting to work, on a Samsung phone Samsung/Google will ask you separate consent for using your data for diagnostics, ad targeting, etc. It's not perfect yet, but regulatory pressure is giving people privacy back.

- The DMA will force Apple to allow side-loading and alternative payment methods without taking a cut.

Once this has all played out, we'll still have a duopoly, but at least users and third-party developers are better protected.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by azemetre on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:39AM (#39027478)
Voting with your wallet just means that those who have the most money are “most correct.”

Sorry but that’s not a society I want to continue living in.

There needs to be strict regulations and maybe apple needs to be broken up. Owning the hardware and App Store has already shown have abusive they can be. They need to divest or spin off one of them into a new company or we can pressure politicians to do this for us.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by sekai on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:40AM (#39026417)
That 30% doesn't fund the schools or the roads, it's just a fee. Completely different.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by charcircuit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:20AM (#39023934)
>All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes

This is how all businesses work. If there was no way to make profit then businesses would not exist. Apple spent billions of dollars creating an app platform with a clear monetization model that did not get in the way of them accumulating a lot of valuable apps and users. Developers are not forced to make apps for the platform nor are users forced to use the app platform. Other app platforms can impose lower fees and developers are free to release exclusively on those platforms if they wish. Apple hopes that the developers willing to tolerate the 15/30% fee for what the developer gets in return will be good enough to make their app platform competitive to users compared to others.

It's not just defending a trillion dollar company, it is defending the right to set your own prices.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by flanked-evergl on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:26AM (#39024424)
Something is not moral just because it makes a profit or because it is legal, and revenue is also not profit. And I think if a company operates outside societal norms, which I think Apple with regards to European societal norms, it should expect to get regulated to fit those norms again. Maybe the US is too dysfunctional to do this any more, but the purpose of government should be to align the laws and regulations with the morals of the people being governed.

My bank generates revenue by offering me a service in return for my money, not by monopolizing access to my money and then charging people who want to sell to me for the honour of allowing me to buy their goods and services.

Very few companies that I deal with as a consumer have similar business practices, and the ones that do, like Visa and Mastercard, is also something I think should be cracked down upon.

There are many things the EU messes up in my opinion, but cracking down on this clearly immoral business practices is not one of those as it aligns 100% with my morals even though I'm incredibly pro "free" market (i.e. pro minimally regulated market, as every person who has ever been pro "free market" is).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:35AM (#39024495)
>My bank generates revenue by offering me a service in return for my money, not by monopolizing access to my money and then charging people who want to sell to me for the honour of allowing me to buy their goods and services.

Well, maybe Apple should open a bank. You just gave them ideas. :)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by flanked-evergl on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:23AM (#39024874)
If that is the only way they can make profits while aligning with the norms of the societies they operate in then sure, more power to them.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rickdeckard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:01AM (#39026581)
They already operate as a bank, they just offload the legal/annoying part of it to others and focus on selling the sum of its customers' purchasing power
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:33AM (#39024480)
>Apple spent billions of dollars creating an app platform with a clear monetization model

I don't want their platform forced down my throat. On my PC I can download and install software from wherever I see fit. Had I not being a MacBook Pro user for the time being, I would have a chance to upgrade RAM and SSD without paying twice on the damn device.

If anything, I consider Apple being an anti consumer company. What is good for them, is not good for the end user.

That being said, their devices do have some advantages.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by lijok on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:00AM (#39024688)
Why did you buy a Mac then? You clearly knew the drawbacks, so I'm interested to hear, in this competitive market where both Windows and even Linux machines are now available, what made you decide to buy a Mac?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:12AM (#39024796)
>what made you decide to buy a Mac

Battery life.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by yazaddaruvala on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:14AM (#39025302)
> I don't want their platform forced down my throat.

> I would have a chance to upgrade RAM and SSD without paying twice on the damn device.

>> what made you decide to buy a Mac

> Battery life.

When you made the choice to buy your MacBook because of the better battery life were you at any point lied to about the disadvantages?

Additionally, if you're not aware the RAM on SOC is a fundamental tradeoff because of physics. Hardwiring it into the SOC is a BIG part of the battery life improvements that you have stated you prefer.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by charcircuit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:24AM (#39025396)
>I don't want their platform forced down my throat.

As a consumer the whole point of buying a computer is to get access to its app platform. It's not forced down your throat it just inherently is a part of the device's identity.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dimask on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:55AM (#39026088)
Ummm no? This is a weird take. I want a device to run software, I do not care about their app platforms per se. I have a macbook and barely use the apple store. If they prevent me from running any software apart from through their platform, that is a problem for me.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by charcircuit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:29PM (#39030715)
>I want a device to run software

Without an app platform there would exist no software.

>I have a macbook and barely use the apple store.

The app platform is more than just the store. If you can install an app without the apple store, that app has to be able to run and actually do stuff somehow. The way it is able to run is the app platform.

>If they prevent me from running any software apart from through their platform

If you do not want to run software using Apple's hardware and Apple's software then Apple is effectively out of the picture. Apple won't prevent you from running apps on a different app platform like Android.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by smoldesu on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:06PM (#39032725)
Apple should charge separately for their App Platform then, instead of bundling it with arbitrary features. The US government threatened to break up Microsoft as a result of the IE case, Apple would be wise to skate to away from where the laser-breathing regulatory dragon is headed.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by totaa on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:15AM (#39024333)
> nor are users forced to use the app platform is side loading or alternative stores like f droid available on IOS?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by charcircuit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:17AM (#39025335)
Yes, but it is for supporting developers and enterprises.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kriops on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:30AM (#39024925)
That’s a strawman if I ever saw one. Apple is morally entitled to licence their products however they’d like, because property rights. If you don’t like it, then nobody is forcing you to give them your business.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:03AM (#39023833)
I've yet to see an HN hate thread about the trillion dollar company Google and its Play Store, with the same fees, stealing 30% from an even broader part of society.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kelnos on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:19AM (#39024376)
While most people do install apps through the Play Store, Google doesn't lock down their platform to make it the only option. I have one alternative store (F-Droid) installed, and also have a couple apps side-loaded.

Google's 30% isn't the only option on Android. Apple's 30% is the only option on iOS.

Regardless, Google gets plenty of flak here for a variety of things, including how they run the Play Store.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:39AM (#39024529)
I really don’t think it’s about side-loading, principles of freedom, the spirit of hacking, etc. HN’s full of indie app developers trying to make money. They know iOS users more often pay for things so it’s their target audience.

I doubt existence of F-Droid is even a drop in the bucket of fee savings for those developers on Android. Otherwise, Google would do something about it to get their cut.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by tonoto on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:24AM (#39025889)
Also, Google doesn't have a developer fee. How's that Apple both have 30% commission and a "membership" fee - https://developer.apple.com/support/enrollment/

Unfortunately, many corporations only leave the choice of Windows or Macos. Open source operating systems are treated like 3rd class passengers..

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by JimDabell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:04AM (#39027804)
Google does have a developer fee. It’s a one-off fee rather than a yearly fee, but they do have it.

https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answ...

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by tonoto on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:22AM (#39028930)
Developer fee for the Play Store yes, but no developer fee for using the open stores (although I'm well aware that in certain environments it is disallowed to use other than the Play Store) or developing local apps.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by account-5 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:06AM (#39023845)
You clearly not been looking hard enough; Google, rightly, gets hated on way more than Apple. My experience tends to be that on HN apple can do no wrong.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:38AM (#39024059)
Google gets mild-mannered, disappointed commenters sighing about how they've messed up search, the web, and has no product/customer support. When Apple comes up, people get on their soap boxes with expletives about how society and the world is fundamentally being ruined. The tone just isn't comparable at all.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by account-5 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:54AM (#39024180)
You're definitely not looking in the right places then. I've seen Microsoft, Google, twitter, Mozilla, you name the company; coming under fire and everyone piling on. When apple gets criticised in the same way (few and far between that it is), you get an army of apologists out in force ready to die to defend all that apple does.

I've never come across a company that instills that sort of blind faith in its users.

My personal stance is I don't trust any of these companies and will come to threads to be informed about whatever privacy/security/monopoly practices these companies are trying to bypass/do this week for their own profit. I have no allegiance, they're all as bad as each other. In my experience apple is able to do more and gets criticised less.

A recent example was Google implementing something in chrome apple had implemented ages ago in safari. You actually had people saying is was ok for Apple to do it but not Google.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:46AM (#39024582)
>you get an army of apologists out in force ready to die to defend all that apple does.

They defend their choices. But do that in an almost religious way.

And is not something that is particular to Apple. Try to criticize Under Armour or New Balance in front of someone wearing it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by prmoustache on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:59AM (#39024209)
I don't think so.

The main difference is that most people use one of the google products directly or indirectly, regardless of their attitude towards the company.

In comparison it is easier to not use Apple products if you don't like the company.

And thus people like you who own an Apple device feel targeted for their choice of using Apple and thus see it as more aggressive and powerful. It is as simple as that. You can find this pattern in every kind of domain, I see people replying with anger and/or passion to any criticism on their car, motorbike or bicycle brands. They naturally feel compelled to defend their brand of choice because they actually feel targeted as owner of it, because it feels like their own discernment is targeted indirectly.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:40AM (#39024532)
>They naturally feel compelled to defend their brand of choice because they actually feel targeted as owner of it, because it feels like their own discernment is targeted indirectly.

True. But regardless if the commenter is right or wrong, anger is not the proper answer. If the commenter is right, you have some thinking to do. If he's not, you shouldn't care.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kelnos on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:21AM (#39024386)
Well I guess we need some people at the other extreme to balance out all the Apple-is-the-messiah types.

I'm being glib, here, but I think that's a fairly normal effect. If people's opinions about something are generally pretty boring, average, and uncontroversial, few people will feel the need to stir the pot and adopt extreme views.

But seeing others unquestioningly, unapologetically drooling over something, without allowing any sort of criticism, just eats at some people so much that they need to adopt the completely opposite position and find any reason to brutally criticize.

Human nature is weird.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:42AM (#39024553)
Why do we need to balance that? If people do believe Apple is Messiah, they do that at their own loss. Why should I care?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:53AM (#39024167)
you must have missed the soapboxes on how google cannot properly support products anymore (The "google graveyard") and especially any topic touching on Youtube.

But sure, for Android topics they get off lighter because devs do technically have F-Droid as an option, or simply hosting an APK on version control for user s to find. There are ways to get around Google's barriers even if they have a steep financial penalty. Apple gives no official way without voiding your warranty (I don't even think rooting your Android these days void you).

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:50AM (#39024606)
You can install only some types of apps from third party stores or sideload them. Many apps like banking apps require using Google Play Services and if you use a third party ROM like LuneageOS or Huawei HarmonyOS, good luck with installing certain apps.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:01AM (#39027066)
well yes. That's more on the dev than google though. No one is forcing Chase to stay on Google Play and go so far to not work if you sideload it. Or maybe Google is and that will be rounded into all the other stuff happening in courts.

They are important apps, but they are relatively few that go that far.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by paulddraper on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:10AM (#39023874)
The iOS vs Android flamewar has a clear winner on hn
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hackernewds on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:06AM (#39023844)
Au contraire I believe Google is the most hated company on HN by a mile and half. We see this play out IRL even with their anticompetitive lawsuit outcomes
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:53AM (#39024638)
Both Apple and Google do nasty things. Other companies, too.

This thread is dedicated to Apple's own wrongdoings. If Google does nasty things, that doesn't mean Apple should get a pass.

Most people here care about consumers, not about companies, especially about monopolistic companies.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:25AM (#39024889)
Apple allowing alternate payment methods with a fee discount in the US, as Google does in other countries, is a wrongdoing?

Consumers don’t care about the fees developers pay.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jsnell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:59AM (#39027039)
It's not a fee that the developers pay. It's a fee that the customers pay.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by conradfr on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:00AM (#39024218)
The only difference is that you don't need to own an expensive Google device and pay $100 per year to develop for the Play Store, the 30% criticism applies as well though.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hyperhopper on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:15AM (#39024338)
Google doesn't force you to use Google Play and Google doesn't force devs to pay them. (Also they are still hated as well)
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by throwaway20222 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:34AM (#39024027)
First visit? Welcome!
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dotnet00 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:16AM (#39023913)
There are threads pretty much daily about how evil Google is.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jve on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:54AM (#39024168)
Stealing? I see it as fee for an exchange to access to a huge market of wealthy people (one that can afford an iPhone probably can afford your app). Where entry barrier is extremely low. If you make 100 sales, you don't have to pay much, if you make huge profits off the platform you make huge payments to the platform owner.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hyperhopper on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:14AM (#39024325)
They shouldn't have the right to be the gatekeeper in that relationship.

The wealthy people own the hardware, the devs own the app. Why does apple get the legal right to demand money in that transaction when it would be better for everyone if they weren't involved

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by yazaddaruvala on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:18AM (#39025339)
So what about people like me? I buy an iPhone because Apple gatekeeps the apps.

I grew up in the age of torrents and Kazzaa and am tired of spam, malware, bloat, anti virus, etc. I want my phone to be an unbreakable toy, not a computing device.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ric2b on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:35AM (#39025498)
So you use exclusively the Apple store, problem solves?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by yazaddaruvala on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:26PM (#39035700)
I mean.. maybe. Lets see. My biggest worry is the dark patterns on the messaging apps I need to use.

Actually, I'll try out using then through the browser and see what happens.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by LoganDark on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:28AM (#39024445)
When you buy an Apple device you don't control the hardware or the software on it. Apple does.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hyperhopper on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:48AM (#39026038)
That should be illegal.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by LoganDark on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:18PM (#39030565)
I agree.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by DeathArrow on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:55AM (#39024663)
>one that can afford an iPhone probably can afford your app

If I afford something doesn't mean I should buy. I grew up being poor and I earn my living working hard. Throwing money is not a good option for me.

Also, in what world affording a damn phone does make you rich?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ric2b on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:34AM (#39025493)
iPhones are not expensive enough to signal you are rich, most people are able to buy one, the question is if it makes financial sense to do so.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by puszczyk on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:41AM (#39024540)
I don’t care about trillion dollar company. I care about my experience. App Store purchases and subscriptions are a good experience for a user. I’ve never had problems canceling subscriptions, or getting refunds.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ric2b on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:40AM (#39025538)
Ok, but the argument is that people should have options, not that you should stop using the Apple store.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by thealistra on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:45AM (#39025583)
I am afraid that some developers will drop Apple payments all together and I will have to type my credit card info inside of low-quality apps. Currently I just press ok after a Face ID.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by asadotzler on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:36AM (#39029153)
Why do you install low quality apps?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:54AM (#39024643)
I have difficulty following this argument, especially the "stealing" part. App Store does not just randomly take money from the devs. App Store also provides a service. They do world-wide payment and VAT processing, refund processing, discovery, distribution, user login management, APIs, distributed cloud storage, etc. It costs money to run these things. As a small-time developer, I think this is a great deal for 15%. At the price levels of most small apps it would cost more to use a payment processor + hiring an accountant, not to mention the extra work involved in setting up and maintaining these things. For behemoth like Epic — sure, the "Apple tax" hurts, they'd rather gouge their customers without Apple's involvement. But frankly, I don't see any reason to punish one multi-billion corporation just so other multi-billion corporation can make more money. I care primarily about the interest of the small-time developers.

And this is the point that should be made more often IMO — App Stores (and Apple bing one of the first ones) have democratized software development by making the barrier of entry extremely low. Anyone with some talent or idea can go and write an app, without any additional financial risk. App Store is based around sharing your success. The relatively few successful devs carry the costs to keep that barrier of entry low to everyone. And I really don't want that to change.

On a serious notes, what are the alternatives? What exactly is your argument? That Apple should be charging nothing? Ok, then they also shouldn't be providing any services. You want to do distribution or payment processing? Take care of it yourself. Epic would love this of course, Joe the indie developer instead is dead in the water. Or are you arguing that Apple is charging too much? Well, there are solutions to that as well. They could charge for services individually for example, but that again hurts the small developer, because trying out things starts costing them money.

Frankly, my idea would be to split the App Store into a separate commercial entity and make it nonprofit. I am sympathetic to the argument that the Store itself is not a product but is used to support and create value for Apple's ecosystem. I do think that the devs should pay for running the store, and I like the current success-based model and it's low barrier of entry for new devs, so basing the fees on actual operating costs seems like a good compromise. Of course, similar considerations should apply to other stores as well.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jdkoeck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:02AM (#39024709)
Again, it’s crazy people defend Apple on this. Apple is not just providing a payment platform, it’s forcing you to use it. As a developer, you should be free to use any payment platform you want in your app, like on the web. Let the user decide. End of story.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:56AM (#39025147)
> Let the user decide. End of story.

The value proposition of iOS is that the app store is the place to go, and that my experience will be seamless. I want a centralised place to manage my subscriptions. Here's an example:

I subscribed to NYT Cooking in the web a few years back. I went to cancel only to find out that I have to phone them. If I subscribed on an app store it would have been one click and done. I'm actually still subscribed to it.

Why is your choice more important than my choice?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ric2b on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:28AM (#39025442)
Right, so you'd use the app store by choice, so why should Apple force you to?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:23AM (#39025878)
The first move that will come out of this will be a Meta store for "all your meta products". You won't have the choice of Instagram on the App store or Instagram on the Meta store, you'll have Instagram on the Meta store.

This won't be a choice for users, this will be a choice for large developers.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dotnet00 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:08AM (#39029590)
So just follow your own supposed ethos and don't use Meta products?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ric2b on Sunday January 21, 2024 @08:47AM (#39078375)
That never happened on Android, why would it be different on iPhone?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nprateem on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:16AM (#39025324)
Yeah that's perfectly reasonable. Of course it makes everything easier. It's also practically impossible to compete against which is what gives apple this unfair advantage, making their 30% cut obscene. They're making it due to being first, technical issues aside.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jdkoeck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:14AM (#39025791)
Your point is moot because Apple forces you to use its own app store, where using their payment platform is mandatory. If there were alternative app stores, I would have no qualm with this restriction. Let Apple's store compete with others, it will come out on top if it's really the best.

The larger point is this: in a free market, if you have a bad experience with a product (like NYT Cooking in your example), you can bring your business elsewhere. That's how it works, and that's what Apple is interfering with.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:34AM (#39025957)
Why does the free market arugment apply on apple's ecosystem but not the mobile ecosystem? There are alternative app stores with alternative ecosystems - if you have a bad experience with your iPhone, replace it with an Android and use the open ecosystem there.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:28AM (#39026347)
Because the entire mobile market is a duopoly and asking someone to switch platforms that they might have invested 15 years of their life into isn't reasonable. Think of all the data, hardware (smart watches, tablets, trackers, speakers, smart home gadgets), app & in-app purchases that one would have to forfeit to switch platforms.

They explicitly carved out their own market by making it a tightly integrated walled garden that's closed to outside integration, it seems hypocritical to now claim that users are free to leave at any time. They're not and that's by design.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:53AM (#39027659)
How come it's reasonable to force someone who _doesnt_ want the app store to be opened to competition to change?

I don't want the Meta store where Meta decide what level of API access their apps get). I explicitly choose the iOS ecosystem _because_ of this. If you want the alternative, you have a choice right now with Android. If this changes, then I _dont_ get a choice. Your choice removes my only option of a curated app marketplace in favour of a marketplace that will allow for billion dollar companies to set their own rules on how I interact with their apps, rather than me delegating that to one trusted gatekeeper.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:29AM (#39029030)
> How come it's reasonable to force someone who _doesnt_ want the app store to be opened to competition to change?

Are you asking why we have antitrust laws?

> I don't want the Meta store where Meta decide what level of API access their apps get

And they shouldn't! Users should have full control over what data their apps can access, how often, with optional spoofing where it makes sense to stop apps from gating functionality behind invasive data collection. This should be an OS-level feature, not (poorly) enforced by the app store.

Apple's superficial review process isn't going to spot malicious abuses of your data unless it's plainly obvious.

> Your choice removes my only option of a curated app marketplace in favour of a marketplace that will allow for billion dollar companies to set their own rules on how I interact with their apps, rather than me delegating that to one trusted gatekeeper.

How so? You can continue using whichever marketplace you trust. Meanwhile your privacy and security should be technological, OS-level guarantees. You don't need Apple's app store to stop apps from stealing your banking information. You need a secure operating system (which iOS advertises itself to be) which employs sandboxing and that offers fine-grained permissions which users can freely grant, deny, or spoof.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:17AM (#39029724)
> Are you asking why we have antitrust laws?

you're putting words in my mouth here.

> How so? You can continue using whichever marketplace you trust.

No. I get to use whichever marketplace the publisher decides to use. Epic aren't going to publish on the App Store (see Fortnite on PC), Meta are going to publish on their own store. 37signals are going to use their own store. I currently can use a marketplace I trust. If iOS opens to allow other stores, then those stores either need to be curated by Apple or the store apps are sideloaded and have wider permissions. I don't want Meta's store with those permissions, I'm fine with using WhatsApp and not giving them my location.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:14PM (#39034963)
There's no technical reason why sideloaded apps would or should have wider access to permissions. That's a false dichotomy.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jdkoeck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:32AM (#39029077)
You hit the nail on the head. The market of mobile platforms is in a state of "market failure": no real competition, because mobile platforms are not "homogeneous" (that is, it's hard for a buyer to change platforms). The market of mobile platforms being thus "monopolised", you need regulation to enforce proper competition.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:17AM (#39025334)
Apple provides the OS and SDKs developers need to make their app function at all.

Users do not care how much it costs a developer. They want it to be easy to see and cancel subscriptions all in one place. The web’s myriad of payment systems is the opposite of a good user experience, meant to only fatten the pockets of developers by making it difficult to cancel.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by CogitoCogito on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:54AM (#39025662)
> Users do not care how much it costs a developer.

This is a ludicrous statement. The users are the ones paying for it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:12AM (#39025783)
That 15-30% going to Apple isn’t going to go back to app users. Don’t pretend this is all about developers wanting to give users a discount.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jdkoeck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:15AM (#39025801)
It actually is, there are plenty of services where you can pay 30% less if you go through their site instead of Apple's app store.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by CogitoCogito on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:26AM (#39025906)
Do you believe businesses don’t take their margins into account when pricing their products?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:19AM (#39026291)
I'm all for letting the user decide. But what you are proposing is not letting the user decide.

If Melinda wants to use the Facebook app, but the Facebook app is only available on the Meta store, then Melina is forced to use the Meta store. This is not giving users choice. This is replacing one corp-backed store by multiple corp-backed stores. The user loses.

The only way how this would be a choice is if the same app, with the same basic functionality was available on all stores. Then the user would really have the choice which store to use. Or if there were alternative apps on different stores. Good luck with that given the current monopoly markets.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Fluorescence on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:46AM (#39026476)
Melinda should be able to choose to have a business relationship with Meta. The Meta store, aka a trivial hosting/payment service, would be part of that Meta offering. She should not however only be allowed to have an Apple(Meta) relationship where Apple gets to tax and restrict Meta for it's own commercial benefit.

An "App Store", when it is not used as a rent-seeking choke-point, is a nothing-burger, it's a simple website to buy and download an app, yet you are trying to claim some great horror if this website was run by Meta not Apple. Please. It's nonsensical.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:50AM (#39027628)
Right. So you are saying that Meta has the right to implement their services and platforms in any way they see fit, and the user has the right to choose between using those services under Meta's conditions or not using them at all. But Apple has no similar right to their own services, platforms, or SDKs, and is forced to let Meta harness their platform and user base while expecting no compensation? And this apparently makes sense to you? What you are proposing is the dictatorship of the developer. This completely throws the idea of proprietary platforms and SDKs out of the window.

By the way, I couldn't care less if Meta has their own shop or not, and I don't see any horror in that, they decide how to best run their business, not me. But I take an issue with claims that Meta running their own exclusive show somehow creates more user choice (which is the direction the commenter I was replying to was heading towards)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Fluorescence on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:21AM (#39028021)
I can barely parse what you say it's so unhinged.

It's such a bizarre belief that a product sold by Apple remains "their platform" once in the hands of a consumer. The only thing they still "own" is copyright IP. They sold a product. They don't get to legislate user actions. Their power over the device post sale, that they use to extract rent, is entirely artificial.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:08AM (#39028701)
This is quite funny, because I feel the same about what you are saying. The way I understand you is that a seller of the product should grant any third party extensive access to that product, so that the third party can modify and implement their own services in any way they see fit. Frankly, this is completely shattering the idea of business relations as we know it. By your logic no proprietary store or platform SDK should ever exist (e.g. console SDKs should be free for all developers). What's more, extending this argument software itself should be moldable at will (I bought the app, I have the right for it to be modified in any way I please).

I mean, it's not that I would oppose this ideology in particular, it just sounds a bit radical. We'd have to change quit a lot of things for it to be feasible.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pcnix on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:02AM (#39024713)
The problem is that we place a responsibility on competition in the market to favor consumers by reducing prices and preventing companies from having excessive margins. Allowing a single marketplace means there's no competition, and we're not sure if 15% is a fair rate at all.

I could make the assertion that I'd be able to provide everything that Apple does, but with a much lower cut, but this can't be put to the test because there's no way for me to start another app store that iPhone users can access. I suspect a lot of the arguments for the 15% cut will change once we have alternate app stores offering the same things Apple does, but with a much lower cut. You'll then see app developers with skin in the game, and we'll know if everyone actually really thinks Apple does this better or if they'd rather have the extra money from other app stores.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:43AM (#39025029)
Do you really think that there will be more competition? I fear what will happen is that the big corps will set their own stores to distribute their own apps, and that's pretty much it. The user won't see any difference in pricing. The small dev will be hurt because each store will make less money and will likely implement price increases to compensate.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ryanbrunner on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:54AM (#39025131)
We don't have to speculate - the desktop OS world has exactly this structure - an open ecosystem with a first party app store that ships with the OS, but the ability for other app stores to exist or even for developers to ship their products independently.

In practice you still see a decent amount of activity on the official app store, along with some other major app stores, and a relatively small amount of independent distribution. There's still a good amount of small independent developers shipping apps (both on the stores and independently), and there's not a ton of evidence of price increases - in fact there's a very large amount of free software being distributed.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:20AM (#39025843)
Desktop marker and smartphone software markets are very different. There are many more small utility apps for the smartphones for example, while desktop is more open. Discoverability in particular is a huge issue for a small desktop app developer. I don't think comparing to desktop is a good example. On the other hand, desktop app market does illustrate the point I am making — big corporations running their own "stores" to the user disadvantage. And don't let me start about horrible installers that companies like Adobe or Microsoft ship which will change your system configuration and litter your filesystem with random crap.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by wouldbecouldbe on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:52AM (#39025112)
It's actually annoying that the refunds and VAT are handled.

For small international developers, under 500K per year spread out over several states & countries, often they don't have to pay VAT in most international places, so they lose an extra 20-22%. For instance most US states won't require you to pay VAT under 100K revenue if you are from another country.

Same for refunds & subscription management, often clients will ask you, but you have zero control with Apple. Let alone 60 days before being paid, where stripe does it in a few days.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:06AM (#39025224)
This is a great point and I think it illustrates the drawbacks of centralized store. I think an argument can be made that App Store is an important part of the developer experience and as such they are entitled to have a voice in what features it should prioritize.

The thing is, I fully agree that the model has to change and adapt. There has to be more transparency, more accountability, and these stores have to improve in a way that best fits the interests of the developers and the users. I just don't think that third-party stores or unrestricted side loading will do anything like that — in fact, I fear that they will make things considerably worse.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jim180 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:10AM (#39027145)
The threshold is 10k€ in the EU. So, way less than 500k
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by wouldbecouldbe on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:05PM (#39030405)
Yeah EU is stricter, but for lot of my clients US is a large market, without they themselves being in the US. If you are EU based then it's cheaper to pay EU tax and not US tax.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:39AM (#39024993)
> You want to do distribution or payment processing? Take care of it yourself.

Yes! That's exactly what everyone wants.

> Joe the indie developer instead is dead in the water.

No, Joe the indie developer will happily use one of the most popular alternative app stores that fits their needs and doesn't rip them off with fees.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:58AM (#39025164)
> No, Joe the indie developer will happily use one of the most popular alternative app stores that fits their needs and doesn't rip them off with fees.

What would these be? Last time I checked, the "champion of the people" Epyc charges 12% and pushes the charges for some payment methods onto the buyer. And it seems like they still haven't turned profitable, even with their bare-bones store model.

Stripe (one of the most popular payment processors) will take 9% from a 5$ purchase just for payment processing. This doesn't include tax processing or any other stuff, all that you have to pay extra. A customer wants a refund? You are eating the cost.

I just don't understand how any of this stuff people are talking about is realistic. I am not aware of a single commercial payment processing solution that will end up under 12-15% for small charges, while offering much less value to both the developer and the user compared to App Store. And I don't understand why people expect that this solution will suddenly magically pop up if Apple allows alternative stores.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:23AM (#39025872)
The lack of competition and alternative options is the core issue here. Free market competition will figure it out, that's the simple answer.

One developer might be operating on effectively infinite margins and opt to stay in the Apple app store for visibility and most familiar experience.

Another might participate in an alternative app store that charges a review fee, a distribution fee but doesn't charge anything for in-app purchases except baseline payment processing fees.

Yet another might be operating on razor-thin margins and/or doesn't need to participate in an app store for visibility, they might sell their app directly through their website and roll their own payments and distribution.

> Stripe (one of the most popular payment processors) will take 9% from a 5$ purchase just for payment processing.

We might as well treat this as 0 when discussing alternative options since it's an inescapable fact of selling things anywhere (cash and crypto aside)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:01AM (#39027760)
> The lack of competition and alternative options is the core issue here. Free market competition will figure it out, that's the simple answer.

You know what? I actually agree with this! If alternative stores would really offer competition, then it's indeed something worth investigating. The problem is that I doubt that we will see alternative stores much. We will have a Meta store that sells FB-relevant services, an Epic store that sells Fortnite, an MS store that sells MS Office experience, an Adobe store that sells Adobe subscriptions, etc. Basically big corps making their own bubbles to improve margins.

If all these stores are regulated instead (transparent rules for all, no corp-only stores, strict privacy regulations), sure, I'm all for it! But that's not where the suggestions are going, so far most of the comments are along the lines "Apple should not be allowed to do this, everyone else should be allowed to do everything". Unfortunately, many "fairness initiatives" end up with some other big corp creating a soft monopoly (just look at google who de facto control the web standards just because their engine has 90% of the market share)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:04PM (#39031197)
Where do you get this number for Stripe ?

Right now, in the EU, the standard fee (before negotiation and volume consideration) is 0.25ct + 1.5% which will work out to about 26.5% cut for a 1-euro payment that is the worst-case scenario currently possible in the App Store as far as I am concerned.

They sell added services but there is no obligation for them and I figure most developers wouldn't care for them. The most expensive it can get is for international payment with currency conversion: 0.25ct + 3.25% + 2%. I don't know exactly how they do the fee calculation, but for a payment of 1, you would get a cut of about 30% max. Apple definitely does NOT provide the same service, since they do not allow international payment in their different localized app stores and they don't do currency conversion (they will let the bank charge you for that, which will get MUCH more expensive).

And the stripe number becomes much better with bigger price because of the fixed transaction fee. If you sell an app for 5$, the minimum you would have to give Apple would be 75 cents (the 15% they will allow under certain conditions) when the maximum you would pay to stripe would be 51 cents, or about 10.25%. Realistically most developers that do not have the scale to operate a fully custom system will address one or 2 big regional markets (with mostly shared language, culture and currency) and they would be just fine with the standard offering of stripe that would bring the cost to around 6.5%. While setting up everything would be a bigger hassle, for most developers that make enough money to live off it, that's a no brainer. Even if we argue that Apple provides more value than the base stripe and push to 10% cost everything included, for a dev making 100K in sales, it's already "free" 5K coming their way.

Many seem to mistakenly think that Apple allows dev to sell their app worldwide with very little hassle. Not only this is not true since many apps are actually region locked for whatever reason and cannot be purchased in a different market (it happens to me all the time, especially with apps from the US or from Germany) but Apple does not realy simplify the process of localisation, marketing, and proper tax declaration in each relevant market. Apples gives you pretty sales statement with everything you need, but any decent system will do that, you still need to do the actual work of compliance if you are big enough or care enough to follow the laws.

There are some argument to be made about the benefits of Apple integrated solution but it is only relevant for cheap software that are impulse buys precisely because they were cheap enough. The higher the price of the software the less relevant Apple solution is. Especially considering the inflexibility and dumb "categories" they push everything into. And if you have to push subscription or in-app purchase nonsense like they currently do, the economics are even better for external solution.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:23PM (#39032931)
> Where do you get this number for Stripe ?

That's Stripe's US fee. CC processing fees are much higher in the US so that card issuers can run all of those "cashback" programs.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:25AM (#39039341)
I checked and it is indeed higher at 30cts + 2.9% but the international cards and currency conversion fee are much lower (1.5%, 1%).

Your base case is a bit worse and it will work out over 30% for a payment of 1 (0.329) but if you sell a 5$ app, it would be 0.445 or about 8.9% like you said. You are still 6% lower than the minimum Apple would charge you.

It's not clear cut depending on what you need, but at the same time if you are small enough to qualify for the 15%, you probably don't need much or have time to figure it out.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by commandersaki on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:03AM (#39024718)
The alternative is Apple allows side loading so that you can buy software independently of the App Store , and sellers can distribute independently of the App Store.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:44AM (#39025040)
I am ok with side loading. Of course, side loaded apps would need to be sandboxes for security reasons and should not be allowed to access basic services like calendar, contacts or iCloud.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by CogitoCogito on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:03AM (#39024720)
> On a serious notes, what are the alternatives? What exactly is your argument? That Apple should be charging nothing?

The alternative is “competition”.

In any case, I don’t see how any of this affects you since you’re happy paying Apple the fees. You can keep doing so as others pursue other options once they’re available.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Aerbil313 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:02AM (#39024703)
Well written. It can be argued that Apple also develops the OS and UI libraries which the apps run on/with, which is also providing something.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:00AM (#39025185)
> It's incredible that there are actually people in this thread arguing in favor of Apple

It's incredible to me that people arguing against apple here don't realise that they're arguing to allow another billion dollar company to do what they want, and that their own opinion is the only one that could possibly be valid

If you want an open ecosystem with alternative app stores, head on over to Android. The value of iOS to me is the app store and related ecosystem.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mihaaly on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:07AM (#39025241)
Regardless, it is a phenomenon here that negative words on Apple - justified or not alike - here attract numerious downvotes without comments, just for the sake of it.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:35AM (#39025965)
Honestly, I've found nuanced discussion on this topic in any direction attracts downvotes, and reddit-tier comments like the one I replied to float to the top. It's a pity as the quality of the discussion here is usually above this.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nprateem on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:11AM (#39025280)
> head on over to Android

I'll just tell all my potential customers to buy a new phone before buying my app. That'll work.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by todd3834 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:37AM (#39024514)
They probably do care a lot about developers staying on their platform. The 30% is only from companies making more than $1 million. Otherwise you can qualify for 15% small business program.

I don’t need them to be my friend or to care about me but as a share holder I want them to succeed. So far their R&D has proven valuable to me as both a consumer and share holder.

I don’t care if a few people who already have everything get richer. Since I believe the company is doing great things and I think it still has a bright future ahead I get to share in that upside too. And so can you if you want to.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by eptcyka on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:40AM (#39024534)
Do they care though? As a developer, I either play by the rules and get access to their massive, lucrative market or I just don't. Its not like the investment developers and Dev companies make into their ecosystem can be just moved elsewhere - its all a sunken cost.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by todd3834 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:45AM (#39024572)
Do you really think they wouldn’t care if developers left their platform? They care because it’s beneficial to them. I don’t expect anything else from any corporation including the ones who’ve employed me.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by eptcyka on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:15AM (#39027194)
They don't need to care about developers - they cannot leave.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by the_other on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:47AM (#39025601)
I often defend Apple. I don't want to defend Apple on this current topic: I think taking a cut of out-of-app physical purchases/subscriptions is ridiculous and should be legally challenged.

However...

> All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes than make a few people who already have everything even richer.

If you're gonna argue that, you have to inspect the edges of this position. Are you willing to let go of your own shares? Or the interest on your pension (or equivalent), which comes via the roughly the same route you're arguing against. If you own your own company, do you share most/all profits with your staff (rather than pay a wage), or your shareholders? This is all wrapped up together.

IMO, To make such a claim, you need really to argue against the system these "rich people" operate in as much, if not more than, the individual cases.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by quonn on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:57AM (#39025691)
> If you own your own company, do you share most/all profits with your staff

This is not the same, there a degrees of unethical behavior. We should collectively try to give more meaning to these degrees instead of jumping to first principles.

Taking your example, there is a difference between taking a cut or underpaying your staff or severely underpaying them or perhaps not paying them at all or perhaps forced labor or perhaps outright slavery.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by yard2010 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:50AM (#39025616)
Ikr. That's a big incentive to be evil! Special snowflakes will vouch for you no matter what
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by norman784 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:08AM (#39025752)
As a user I don't care for the 30% cut, what I care is to have a centralised payment method and subscription system, I don't have energy/time to keep with different subscriptions in each service/app and knowing that there are bad actors, they will do whatever possible to make hard to unsubscribe (like a few years ago the NYT, where you could only unsubscribe by phone and was very hard even so). But if even when using third party payment systems they need to integrate with Apple subscription API and you can cancel/track in one place then I'm fine with that.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rezonant on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:14AM (#39026241)
The inability to unsubscribe should be fixed in the law, not by granting a payments monopoly for all users of a specific operating system or phone model.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by xoa on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:32AM (#39027395)
>The inability to unsubscribe should be fixed in the law

Even taking your second part as given without addressing the actual complexity here: then how about you accomplish that FIRST? Because I've heard a lot of "we'll break this hack that makes things work suboptimally but better than nothing and then fix it properly in law later" over the decades and 99% of the time it breaks the hack and then surprise surprise never ever gets the "fixed in law" part, leaving us worse off without the gain. I'm all in favor of passing some laws in this area that'd accomplish stuff more efficient with fewer perverse incentives on all sides. I'd like to see users have the option by law to control their root key stores, to require standard secure APIs for subscriptions so that multiple 3rd parties can offer central management and users can cancel without any interaction with what they're subscribing to, for long basic price linked warranties required by law, local use and ad free data control options by law, but also for manufacturers/devs to be protected by default from liability etc. It'd be great to fix a whole lot of stuff.

But until that happy day happens I'm less inclined to just mindlessly bash down what we have and a lot of people are pretty happy with and seems to have struck an ok if far from ideal compromise. I mean, killing upgrades alone makes me hate the app store, but still fix first.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by merrywhether on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:31AM (#39027378)
It should be, but I’m not holding my breathe for the US to suddenly start ancting like a functional government (and there are probably other countries where a legal fix is less likely as well). Until then companies are free to offer private alternatives to users who find that to be a valuable service.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by smoldesu on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:59AM (#39030333)
> Until then companies are free to offer private alternatives to users who find that to be a valuable service.

The question with the App Store is, are customers allowed to choose?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cryptonym on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:22AM (#39025867)
That's a fair statement, you may like Apple payment even if it adds 30% to whatever you are buying. What is not fair is forcing everyone into this.

If I'm selling content, why couldn't I give customer the choice between:

- Paying the 30% Apple cut and benefiting from everything you like about this

- Buying directly, cheaper, without Apple cut (or maybe with a tiny cut if that make any sense, removing only 3pt is a joke)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by HatchedLake721 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:27AM (#39026342)
Because it's Apple's marketplace and Apple's customers.

They spent billions on hardware, software, R&D, marketing and operations.

Why would they give another business a free access to a billion of their customers?

You want to earn money of Apple's customers? Then pay Apple a revenue share of the money you get from their customers.

That's how pretty much any marketplace works in the world.

From your local Target to Salesforce/Shopify/PlayStation/Epic Store/Steam/etc.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seandoe on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:20AM (#39027247)
I don't think that's equivalent. If you buy a Ford car, you aren't forced to buy tires from the Ford dealership. You're not a "Ford Customer" beholden to the Ford Motor Company when it comes to everything related to the car. If you buy a Dell desktop you aren't forced to buy all software through a Dell marketplace. I'm sure if these companies could, they would, and apple can and so they do. But is that the world we want? Sure, in a totally "free" market apple should be able to do want ever they want. But are we more interested in freedom for corporations or freedom for people? Would things be better for everyone if we used the power of government to prevent these anticompetitive practices? Why can't apple offer good reason for iPhone users to buy software through their marketplace and take the 30%, all the while allowing users to choose to download software outside of the marketplace?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by robertjpayne on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:35AM (#39027433)
This is rapidly changing with Tesla first. Outside the tires not much you're going to get after-market except from Tesla.

You always have the option to not buy a ford, or not buy an iPhone.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cryptonym on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:14AM (#39027925)
That's true and is not something most people are happy with. This model is being pushed on us by billionaires.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by smoldesu on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:10AM (#39029629)
And you're convinced that this is good for us?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rustcleaner on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:33PM (#39031549)
We have the option to make the laws such that this cute little rent-extracting business model you defend gets companies who follow it shut down for being criminal enterprises.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rustcleaner on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:31PM (#39031516)
Apple does not create that kind of value; it hoodwinks buyers with a pretty interface and its cultish marketing. Like any hazing ritual or circumcision, the new apple user feels he put in a heavy cost to join what appears to him to be an elite class (but really a marketing trick). The new user is now complete and ready to defend his newly acquired identity in internet forum posts critical of it.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by klabb3 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:56AM (#39027694)
Nobody is complaining about that. Apple can freely put whatever price they want for their payment/subscription services. It’s a good product even, albeit with an outrageous price.

People are upset that developers are forced to use that product, and now with this news: pay an extortion fee on a 3p transaction that doesn’t concern Apple.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by cptskippy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:33PM (#39030791)
I'm not advocating for PayPal, but PayPal does all the stuff that Apple does and they don't charge a 30% cut. I've been contributing to a freeDNS Service managed by PayPal for the last 10-15 years. I noticed the annual renewal was coming up and thought it was time I bump up my contribution, so I went into PayPal and did it.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by poszlem on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:14AM (#39025795)
What a wild take. Epic doesn't care about me either. What difference does it make? Are we supposed to judge if something's right or wrong based on who's doing it, rather than what they're actually doing?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by remon on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:13AM (#39026233)
This is exactly the wrong argument to make and a perfect example of why internet discussion is becoming harder.

None of what you said matters. It does not matter how much money a company makes or if you personally think they're charging too much for a service. They're allowed to. The open question is if they're in a position where there's no reasonable alternative for developers and/or consumers which you can make a strong case for. That line of argument would not be affected at all by how much money Apple makes, their cut or if they're spending their money in a socially productive way.

The fact that this is the second highest upvoted comment is a rather sad datapoint on issues related to internet based conversation where opinions consistently trump fact or reason.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:21AM (#39026302)
> It does not matter how much money a company makes or if you personally think they're charging too much for a service. They're allowed to.

Ah yes, loan sharks are perfectly legitimate businessmen too, then.

> The fact that this is the second highest upvoted comment is a rather sad datapoint

I personally find sadder that there are people who just rationalize away the utter lack of morality in modern capitalism. "Why screw others? Because we can! Woot!" is even worse than "greed is good".

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by remon on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:31AM (#39026827)
Are you being intentionally obtuse? Those two things are, again, completely unrelated. As a person I do feel capitalism in its current form results in demonstrably unethical practices, and I do think Apple overcharges for the value they bring to the table in the specific case of their 30% cut. That's a subjective ethical and moral assessment of Apple as a company.

But that's not the topic at hand, and strawmanning one problem by pulling in another is just lazy. Ruling on this will not just affect Apple but any company with a similar modus operandi in the future, including smaller more ethical companies. Why people have trouble keeping legislative challenges (what you can do) and moral challenges (what you should do) apart is beyond me. You can have more than one opinion in your head at the same time.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:36AM (#39028244)
> Are you being intentionally obtuse?

For someone lamenting the state of discourse on the internet, you seem to have a problem with avoiding ad-hominems. You also seem to rabidly post multiple items at speed. Please calm down and refrain.

> Ruling on this will not just affect Apple but any company with a similar modus operandi in the future,

Absolutely - and absolutely, anyone creating a digital platform should be forced to follow better rules than what we have at the moment. The market alone will produce exploitative monopolies, and this is what we're seeing with Apple. If the letter of current antitrust laws doesn't touch them, the spirit definitely does.

> Why people have trouble keeping legislative challenges (what you can do) and moral challenges (what you should do) apart

Because it's in the cracks between those concepts that Bad Things for society tend to happen; which is why we have laws to reconcile them where the market fails to do so on its own. In this case, we have large companies effectively establishing exploitative and feudal relationships with smaller businesses and consumers, extracting parasitical rents. This is a Bad Thing and should be fixed.

Including your other comment:

> And yes, loan sharks are legitimate businessmen in the US.

No, they are not. You need licenses to lend money in the US, and to get those you have to follow extensive rules and regulations put in place precisely to make it illegal to be a loan shark. Some businesses get close to the limits of such rules (payday loans etc), and that is a political item - precisely because they get very close to be something that is Bad for society.

> if you want to change it vote for people that can turn that into law

Absolutely, and people do. EU representatives are running with this, and Apple is slowly being subject to more and more scrutiny (together with Google, Amazon, and anyone else with a digital marketplace). People understand that what these businesses are doing is Bad for society in the long run, so if they can't reign themselves in on their own, they will have to be reigned in by the law.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by inemesitaffia on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:04AM (#39026602)
Why do companies charge extra to businesses for the same product? Should they? See the SSO tax
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by remon on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:41AM (#39026917)
There's plenty of good reasons to charge different amounts for the same services. There's nothing immoral about that. People can simply say no to making the purchase for the price offered to them. Again, this is completely besides the point of the Apple case.

In Apple's case there are no reasonable alternatives and no practical way to say "no" to the service if you want any business at all. That and that alone should be the issue at hand. What Apple is doing should not be legal on that ground. Either they allow third party stores, or they adjust their cut to a level that can reasonably argued is aligned with the value they're adding to the publisher of that app or service. Now they're in "we can charge whatever because we're the only route to getting your product on Apple products" land, and that's just not where we want to be.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:19AM (#39026711)
Companies should be free to compete on various variables, which include price for their services. But there is no competition for the Apple AppStore on Apple devices, it's a captive market. At that point, it's not competition but exploitation; and exploitation surely is a Bad Thing.

We used to be taught that one of the Bad Elements of feudal life was that the local lord could impose arbitrary taxes to use a road or a bridge, with no recourse for people and tradesmen. Now we are at the same point in the digital world.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by matwood on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:12AM (#39029656)
> But there is no competition for the Apple AppStore on Apple devices, it's a captive market

Apples argument, which has legally worked so far, is the competition is at the ecosystem level. The iPhone and App Store are all parts of the whole. If someone doesn't like they can go to a competing ecosystem. Think game console, not computer.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by toyg on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:21PM (#39032138)
I know very well, and I think that's the sticky point that needs untangling to take antitrust legislation into the XXI digital century. Ecosystem competition is not enough.

Imagine buying a house, and having to ask to the original builder for permission to buy wardrobes, or a fridge, a table and chairs. The builder can tell you what he does or does not allow, and takes a cut of every purchase you make. It's a ludicrous proposition, but that's very much how our digital life currently is.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by remon on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:33AM (#39026843)
And yes, loan sharks are legitimate businessmen in the US. Not most other places mind you because *there's legislation preventing it*. You're conflating "can" and "should" consistently, much like most other people in this thread. It's just not a moral business. Much like gambling isn't, selling addictive unhealthy products isn't, and so on. It's legal though, and if you want to change it vote for people that can turn that into law. Welcome to democracy.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by criley2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:04AM (#39026605)
> All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes than make a few people who already have everything even richer

Apple stock is the most widely held stock by American 401k's and forms the basis of retirement investments for middle class Americans more than any other stock

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hortense on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:57AM (#39027021)
Wouldn't that be Microsoft? It's worth 2.9T, vs Apple's 2.84T.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ants_everywhere on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:26AM (#39026771)
Apple is a lifestyle brand and some people act pretty threatened when that brand is criticized.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by namdnay on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:27AM (#39026788)
> make a few people who already have everything even richer.

"a few people" being everyone with a retirement plan, 401k or any equivalent around the world, i.e. the vast majority of people in developed countries

if anything, taking from smaller companies to give to megacorps is a net benefit for "the common man", since the former will generally belong to founders/VCs/private equity in which they have no stake, and the latter are owned by everyone with exposure to the MSCI World :)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hospitalJail on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:55AM (#39027013)
Its completely obvious Apple has some sort of mind control going on. Its insane to see society is okay with this.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Darthy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:27AM (#39027334)
Apple Vision Pro is coming out soon, with the same terrible rules for app developers.

We should put out an open letter to Apple that we will collectively ignore that product until it contains more favourable terms.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by spdif899 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:29AM (#39027360)
Great idea, I was totally planning to spend $3500 on a first gen gadget but now you've convinced me not to
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by thinkerswell on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:39AM (#39027477)
It's amazing to me that people in this thread still don't understand free markets. You are free to use Android, or Amazon phone. Or Graphene. Or one of the many others.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by webstrand on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:20AM (#39028006)
Apple preventing 3rd party software not paying the apple tax from running on their phones is not "free market". The only reason they can get away with this is because of laws that protect their market from 3rd parties.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by systoll on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:00AM (#39028594)
…what laws?

Apple restricts third parties almost entirely through technical measures.

Jailbreaking to bypass the technical measures is legal.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by webstrand on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:54AM (#39030265)
It may have finally been settled now as legal? I know in the past it was considered a violation of DMCA, circumventing technical countermeasures.

Looks like the lawsuit was settled not decided, and Apple is free to sue it's next victim.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kasajian on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:50AM (#39027627)
I'm going to use this post as a reference for what I believe to be one of the least logical arguments I've ever seen on a technical forum. Congratulations.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by concordDance on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:57AM (#39027708)
People can defend Apple purely for "Someone is wrong on the Internet!" reasons. We're mostly not Homo Economicus Machiavelli who only do things for considered reasons.

(I agree that the 30% is probably bad for society though)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kspacewalk2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:16AM (#39027940)
What's incredible is the idea that an argument or a point of view is somehow invalidated purely because it happens to side with the trillion dollar company. This is in the same vein as "this cause is supported by teh evil Amerika, hence it must be evil" line of thinking, typically espoused by self-declared anti-imperialists (who are often mere anti-US-imperialists).

>make a few people who already have everything even richer.

I do wonder what percentage of Apple stock is owned by pension funds and the like, i.e. The Regular Person, once you unwind the levels of indirection (mutual funds, index funds, ETFs, etc). It is surely a double digit percentage, but high, low? No idea.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by eaglelamp on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:51AM (#39030216)
It's not incredible it is just a different view point. In your second paragraph you take a utilitarian point of view in which case the size of an organization is irrelevant so long as it produces a net gain for society.

An alternative view values human freedom and autonomy. From this perspective the size of an organization is relevant - a large enough organization can impose its will on individuals who don't wish to associate with it.

Neither viewpoint is wrong, but acting as if the one you prefer is somehow more correct or objective is.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by itsoktocry on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:23PM (#39031428)
>It's not incredible it is just a different view point...Neither viewpoint is wrong

Claiming that Apple is "stealing" their cut of commission is definitely wrong.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by SllX on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:47PM (#39031728)
> An alternative view values human freedom and autonomy.

That is some choice rhetoric with a particular bias, but not a distinct point of view from people arguing for freedom and autonomy for Apple’s business practices.

The corporation is a legal fiction, but it’s still human owned, operated, and staffed, and reflects the millions (billions?) of choices that get made by individuals working together to accomplish whatever it is the corporation does. In Apple’s case, that gestalt includes running the App Store at a price to developers that they see fit who choose to do business with them.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by eaglelamp on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:05PM (#39034192)
I didn't mean it as rhetoric, it's a simplified statement of a viewpoint.

I think rhetorically "..who choose to do business with them" is doing a lot more work than anything I wrote. Once an organization reaches a certain size individuals start losing meaningful choice in how they interact with it. You can say that the "gestalt" will of the organization is more important, but you can't make other people concede that their point of view is merely a rhetorical stance.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by SllX on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:26PM (#39035690)
In attempting to split the difference between two points of view, you validated one side as the one that values freedom and human autonomy over the other. That is subtle, and because it is subtle it can be effective rhetoric, but it is also disingenuous, but if you tell me you didn’t mean it that way, I’ll believe you full stop.

> I think rhetorically "..who choose to do business with them" is doing a lot more work than anything I wrote.

Dude, we’re talking about iPhone apps at the end of the day. When you’re at the level where you write iPhone apps for a living, you and your employer made your choices. If you’re only writing iPhone software in a way that generates income for you because somebody has a gun to your head, then first, I’m sorry, that’s really messed up and hang in there, but at that point in your life, your first concern probably isn’t Apple’s cut.

> Once an organization reaches a certain size individuals start losing meaningful choice in how they interact with it.

If you were talking about a sovereign nation with a standing army or maybe even a corporation with a standing army, or just a City’s police department, you might have a point here. In this discussion, we’re talking about Apple, and not all of Apple mind you, but specifically about Apple’s developer program and App Store policies.

> but you can't make other people concede that their point of view is merely a rhetorical stance.

Pointing out rhetoric isn’t for the benefit of the practitioner, it’s for the benefit of anyone else who comes across it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rurp on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:45AM (#39030130)
93% of stock wealth is held by 10% of Americans; the amount of Apple held by The Regular Person is relatively miniscule.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38958534

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:15PM (#39031338)
I suspect the number of app Developers is quite smaller than that 10%.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by tivert on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:10AM (#39029620)
> What's incredible is the idea that an argument or a point of view is somehow invalidated purely because it happens to side with the trillion dollar company.

What's incredible is how people waste their tiny amount of personal energy defending their exploitation by a corporation that has vastly more resources than them and objectively does not need their help.

Apple is probably the poster child for effectively using marketing to brainwash their customers into identifying with them in a cult-like manner. That cult was close to the only thing sustaining them through the 90s.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nailer on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:39AM (#39030050)
It's because people are defending the principle, not Apple.

I think Apple is wrong, but I don't think they're wrong because they're successful - in fact I think saying Apple is wrong because they're successful is against the concept of objective reality and not appropriate for HN.

The idea that Apple are wrong because they're successful is the same awful thinking that advocates for violence or systemic discrimination against people based on their skin color (because they're considered 'successful') and is abhorrent.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by idopmstuff on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:30PM (#39030738)
> What's incredible is how people waste their tiny amount of personal energy defending their exploitation by a corporation that has vastly more resources than them and objectively does not need their help.

Nobody here is trying to help Apple by posting on HN. They're just discussing their viewpoints on how Apple operates and its policies around taking commission on purchases. That's what this entire message board is about - talking about tech and the like.

If they're wasting their time by posting in defense of Apple, you're doing the exact same thing with your response - neither is going to have any actual impact on the world, so either posting is a waste of energy or it's not. There's no valid argument that posting in defense of Apple is a waste of energy but posting attacks on Apple is a useful and productive thing to do.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kspacewalk2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:42PM (#39030889)
None of this matters. Only the substance of the defence matters. It either makes sense, or it does not.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Me1000 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:49AM (#39028453)
Who said "purely"? The arguments in favor of Apple here are invalid for a number of reasons. OP is just saying you don't need to bend over backwards to defend them, they're not an underdog anymore and haven't been for over a decade.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by docmars on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:00AM (#39028599)
Not to mention, Apple has been known to be too controlling and take it too far, to levels that are unfair enough to garner major public disapproval.

Their anti-developer/consumer moves are worthy of backlash, especially since Apple isn't likely going to change their positions without enough of it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rchaud on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:37AM (#39029162)
It's invalidated because a real-world alternative already exists (Android sideloading) and hasn't required Google to hold everyone's hand or to use their toll roads to distribute the product.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by zamalek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:06AM (#39029574)
And the Play/Android store is still wildly successful.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by timtom39 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:28AM (#39028126)
> I do wonder what percentage of Apple stock is owned by pension funds and the like, i.e. The Regular Person, once you unwind the levels of indirection (mutual funds, etc). It is surely a double digit percentage, but high, low? No idea.

Pretty high. The S&P 500 has ~7% apple stock which means many peoples retirement accounts have several percentage points of apple stock.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Podgajski on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:52AM (#39029359)
So Apple takes 30% of your money from one hand and gives you back 3% with the other?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by crazygringo on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:40AM (#39030065)
More like the opposite.

If you had $1,000 invested in Apple around ten years ago (a reasonable amount in a retirement fund), you'd have made around another $8,500 by now.

While if you'd spent $1,000 on apps and subscriptions over 10 years, Apple would have taken $300.

So Apple would take $300 of your money from one hand and give you back $8500 with the other.

That's a difference almost 3x larger than the difference you suggested... but in the opposite direction!

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kspacewalk2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:58AM (#39029465)
"Apple" takes and gives nothing. "Apple" is a collective figment of imagination of its shareholders, which people typically picture as dastardly moneybags living in mansions, but often forget to also picture, like, themselves, in retirement.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fennecfoxy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:46AM (#39030145)
So we should let every company charge 10000% what they currently do, because some of the shareholders might be relying on extra dividends for retirement. Hmmm.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kspacewalk2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:44PM (#39030914)
Indeed, we absolutely should "let" them. We should let them charge whatever they wish, we should let them sink or swim, and we should apply our laws to them fairly and equally, including antitrust legislation.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by amplex1337 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:58AM (#39028581)
Does this make them a better company? You are allowed to not like the way a company does business but still own an ETF that profits from their success. I still would never own an Apple item out of principal. Their marketing, hype and fanboyism are their prime success factors it feels like.

It's funny but since the rise of the iPhone I feel like society has gone straight downhill, not that they have been the only player in the smartphone game, but they sure have profited well, are the biggest drain in the industry to the home developers that contribute to their ecosystem. They pay 0 tax and aren't contributing to the better of society through computing while convincing half the population they are protecting them, etc. It's a scam.

Like many large corporations, they aren't ANY better and will plead that it is due to 'competition' while being ahead of the food chain and able to lead in any way they choose.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by kspacewalk2 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:08AM (#39029592)
No, they aren't better, nor are they worse, they just are. Evaluate their behaviour on the merits of their behaviour, not based on their size or what kind of image their PR efforts have successfully projected into our brains (they're all about amazing design! and the other guys motto is don't be evil! and these guys over here have "open" in their name and they're basically like a non-profit with lofty, humanity-altering goals!).

You're welcome to project general failings of society onto the emergence of the iPhone (but not Android because Google maybe isn't nearly as evil I mean it's in their motto). And there's tons of hype and fanboyism associated with their products. But they are good products. After ditching Windows back in 2008, I've haven't yet had a compelling reason to switch OSes again in my career as a software engineer. Their higher-end devices are absurdly priced but my employer buys them for me, maybe that's why.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by mattmaroon on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:13PM (#39031309)
Big minds think about systems. Small minds think about individuals within the system, like corporations or people, because they can't comprehend the bigger picture or even that one exists.

The people who think Apple is evil because of their size are simply not systems thinkers. They have an illogical view of the world in which the little guy is always right simply because they are the little guy, and thus the big guy must be wrong. It's very similar to the Amerika thing you said. If you don't think about the system Apple or America operates in, it's really easy to hate them.

Which is not to say one can't be a systems thinker and still think this was a bad decision or that Apple is given too much power or does things that are unethical or bad for consumers or whatever else. I totally concur that the government should require Apple and Google to allow sideloading, payments they're not involved in, etc BECAUSE I am thinking about the system and how having two corporations own the device our world runs on is a bad one. And how there's essentially no way for governments to mandate a third viable mobile OS into existence.

But the people who say "I can't believe you'd side with Apple" phrase it that way because they are not thinking of the system. They're thinking small. They think making ad-hoc decisions about individuals within the system is appropriate because they can't think any bigger. If they could, they'd lay out the argument as I just did (and, as many, many people in here did too) or something that was less about the individual.

There's been a lot of this on display (not so much here) in what people say about the whole Israel/Hamas situation too. It's not so much what they say (systems thinkers don't agree anymore than anyone else) but how they say it that tips it off.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by throw__away7391 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:19AM (#39027983)
Who is definitely not my friend is third party app developers who want to side load their trash spamware on to my phone.

Every single platform out there is a dumpster fire of fraudulent and abusive software and products aggressively pushed by deception with every trick or vulnerability they can find exploited.

The App Store works just fine for me as a user as is. I don’t care at all what software you want to install on my phone or what access you feel entitled to.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Someone on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:52AM (#39029360)
I think you can be unhappy with the 15/30% price cut, yet objectively see little wrong with it, given current capitalistic economies and legislation. There are many other large companies with huge margins that, in your words “steal from society”. Alphabet’s is over 20%, for example, and it’s very hard to avoid them when advertising online. Microsoft likely makes money on Xbox game sales, too.

In capitalism 101, Apple created a market and a shop, so they can set the rules. If they demanded too much, developers would move away, their venture would collapse, iPhones would become less popular, etc.

I think you’ll find that selling ice cream at Disney theme parks similarly is expensive for ice cream vendors. They’ll either demand a cut on revenues or charge a lot for the right to sell stuff, and be picky about who can sell what at their venues.

Large retail companies such as Walmart won’t technically take a cut if you want them to sell your product, but they’ll negotiate lower prices from you, require you to take back any unsold inventory, etc.

In summary: ‘we’ currently allow all kinds of huge companies to play by different rules than small companies and individuals.

For me, the main issue is whether iOS needs special handling because of its success, and if so, what special handling.

The first, for me, is “yes”; smartphones are different enough from theme parks, Xbox and Walmart to handle them differently. The second I’m less sure about.

For example, yes, I’d like to have the option to side-load stuff, but also think Apple should have control over what their iPhone product stands for.

They currently ban apps selling drugs, for example. Requiring them to support third party stores that may have such apps might harm the image of their iPhone product. Because of that, I think we should allow them (but not necessarily be happy with) to put up a firm warning whenever you try to install a third party app store, even though that would put them on unequal footing with Apple’s store.

Maybe, the best solution would be to make Apple’s App Store a non-profit with a monopoly on selling iOS apps, with Apple keeping the right to specify what can and cannot be sold there (keeping that a true non-profit would be hard, though. Some non-profits manage to hoard lots of money over time, their CEO’s ‘deserve’ large salaries, etc)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Friedduck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:57AM (#39029447)
Oh grow up. It’s so naive to think there’s no time, effort or money in building what they have. That there’s no ongoing costs. That it doesn’t take thought.

They should build it and you should just get it for free.

Is 30% reasonable? Should there be some taper once your app is in maintenance mode? No, and yes.

I don’t see any reason from either side of this argument frankly. They’ve built a wonderful think that provides immense value, and we all benefit.

They should be more flexible in their pricing model, and you should understand that actual people spent hundreds of thousands of hours of their lives to deliver it to you, and charging for that isn’t stealing.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by savanaly on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:31AM (#39029944)
What about their customers? Am I allowed to speak up for their freedom to engage in consensual commerce? Or is that craven of me as well?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by fennecfoxy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:44AM (#39030113)
"B-b-but Google and others do it, too!"

I'd like to quote a passage from Reamde by Neal Stephenson: "So what are you going to do?" Yuxia asked. "Maybe tag along. Like escorting a drunk president home after a long night in the bar." "Didn't you say you had to make a phone call?" "I have been trained by the United States government," Seamus said, "to do more than one thing at a time."

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:57AM (#39030296)
I wouldnt defend 30% specifically but surely they should get some cut or share. What is the right number? 1%? 50%? I don't know.

> All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes than make a few people who already have everything even richer.

Kind of an odd take. They take a cut because they provide a service. They are not stealing. I guess lump me in with the defending apple crowd if you want to but to think they would or should charge nothing for their service feels... silly.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by barbariangrunge on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:09PM (#39030469)
Does windows deserve 30%? what about your isp? Or your motherboard manufacturer? What about nvidia? Should every single company providing you software or hardware take a cut, or only apple?

We should own our own computers

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jwagenet on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:24PM (#39030644)
Pretty much every middleman or service provider in every industry takes a cut, whether by charging you more than they paid or a fee for their service. For some reason people think software is uniquely exempt from this transaction. Nvidia and your motherboard manufacturer already charged you for the product they provided and you also paid for the fee Dell or Newegg charged on top. Your isp is charging you a fee for uninterrupted service. Apple is charging developers for hosting apps and developing tooling.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by noapologies on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:53PM (#39031800)
Sure, but the cut is a fixed amount based upon the value of the services the middleman is providing. And most importantly, it is not a percentage of the revenue the customer is able to generate by using these services - these two models are polar opposites.

A great example that highlights this absurdity is vehicle ownership - imagine if Tesla announced tomorrow that they are actually a "transportation platform" and started charging Uber drivers a percentage of their revenue, or Mazda found out about the weekend race you did in a Miata and is demanding a cut of the winnings.

Businesses would love perfect price discrimination in every context (because profits!), but is not clear to me how that is a desirable state for humanity.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:59AM (#39044219)
> A great example that highlights this absurdity is vehicle ownership - imagine if Tesla announced tomorrow that they are actually a "transportation platform" and started charging Uber drivers a percentage of their revenue, or Mazda found out about the weekend race you did in a Miata and is demanding a cut of the winnings.

They could do this. It would just result in people being upset and likely no longer using their products.

I don't think it makes a ton of sense to compare a store or marketplace to hardware though? Every marketplace I know of takes a cut of items purchased through their store. Or they buy their items upfront and then take all the revenue of the sale.

The issue really shouldnt be that a cut is taken, it should be the amount or letting developers create alternative ways to download apps. Having an issue with someone taking a cut of revenue generated for products purchased on their platform just doesnt make a lot of sense.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:41AM (#39043964)
I pay windows a fee to use their OS. I'm guessing they take a cut of anything sold via microsoft store as well. My ISP gets a fee for its service. My motherboard was paid for. Nvidia card was paid for.

I don't know exactly how every store works but doesnt every digital store, and non digital store, take a cut of what they sell?

I agree with the fact that we should own our own computers but you do own your iphone. You can jailbreak it and do whatever you want with it. You can even sideload apps, like altstore, through an incredible tedious process.

It sucks that Apple doesnt make this easier to do but that is another topic... Right?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by linuxhansl on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:26PM (#39030676)
Seems to me the range of what a credit card charges would seem sensible. I.e. 3-7%.

Alternatively charge 30% but be forced to allow side-installing Apps. That way developers can decide if they want the convenience and reach of the AppStore or not.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by merlindru on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:55PM (#39031063)
> Alternatively charge 30% but be forced to allow side-installing Apps.

Yes this exactly

I don't care whether they charge 10%, 30%, or 100%

I do care that there's no alternative to NOT using their services & paying their fee

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:01PM (#39044258)
Sure. I think side loading is the best options or allowing another way to pay where apple takes a lower cut makes sense. I'd argue that credit card companies are doing a lot less than a marketplace? But again... How do you come up with a number that really makes sense? Apple is just going to charge whatever they can until they are told they have to change.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by thefounder on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:27PM (#39030688)
They should as much as Mozilla gets for the online transactions carried out on its browser.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:03PM (#39030377)
only in tech...

can you imagine if selling a replacement bulb for a ford headlight required you to pay 30% to ford.

only in tech can this be considered fair.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hnaccount_rng on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:15PM (#39030530)
I’ve got very bad news for you.. what do you think happens when Ford solicits bids for headlamps? Sure “you” don’t pay something to Ford. But Ford absolutely gets its cut
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:29PM (#39030723)
that's not nearly the same thing, stop it.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hnaccount_rng on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:39PM (#39031626)
How is it not? Giant company vs tiny company. With basically all the profit being allocated to the giant company.

Yes it’s not software and yes the tiny company is not single-person company. But that really doesn’t change the situation (well except for you being seemingly personally affected). You can call this situation unfair and say that it _should_ not exist. But reality just disagrees with your assessment that it _does_ not exist. At least as far as I can see. Feel free to explain the difference that I’m missing.

And just for completeness sake: this isn’t even unique in software. Distribution commissions were usually in that order of magnitude. Even for less service and reach

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:18PM (#39032866)
I can buy a 3rd party bulb that I can put directly into a vehicle I own, how Ford sources the bulbs they put into the vehicles they sell or repair has nothing to do with that.

Steam deck recommends you purchase the official steam dock but they don't prevent you, nor do they take a cut of, 3rd party docks that interface with the steam deck.

only in tech would someone argue they should be entitled to a cut of that transaction because they _sold_ the original hardware to the user.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:55AM (#39044160)
You can buy third party hardware to use with your apple products.

You can even install apps like altstore on iphones.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:42PM (#39047405)
jailbreaking your iphone voids the warranty, replacing the the bulb with a 3rd party brand does not.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:43AM (#39043990)
I pay ford, or some other distributor, 100% of the cost of the replacement bulb plus whatever their markup is when I purchase it.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by m_0x on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:08PM (#39030442)
> All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes than make a few people who already have everything even richer.

Steal? What you want the App store to be free and become the Android Play Store which is utter garbage and hostile against small and mid developers?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by gustavus on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:15PM (#39030533)
You know I hear this argument a lot, but had a revelation recently. Everything people are saying about apps and the app store could apply equally well to web browsers and webpages. After all there are plenty of malicious webpages out there that can do bad things, but we decided that it is fine, that's a risk we as society are willing to take. The alternative is to allow large organizations like the state and corporations to tell us what we can and can't do with devices we own and what we can or can't look at.

In conclusion "Information wants to be free."

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by xigoi on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:00PM (#39031155)
I prefer F-Droid. It would be nice if iOS could have something like that too.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by drdeca on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:08PM (#39030443)
> You don't need to defend the trillion dollar company. They are not your friend, they do not care about you, your work or your life.

I don’t like what apple is doing here, and am not inclined to defend it.

However, I am inclined to complain about this type of rhetoric. If invalid criticism are being made, it is appropriate to correct those criticisms, even if the criticisms being made are criticisms of some vile person or organization.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dnissley on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:10PM (#39031274)
It's super easy to avoid all of this drama: Do not buy an iPhone. Almost any other phone will allow you to download and install arbitrary programs from any source that offers them. It's quite wonderful.

It amazes me that people would rather force apple to open up through dubious court cases than simply buy a different device.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by rustcleaner on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:44PM (#39031688)
Nothing in current smartphone-land beats a Google Pixel running GrapheneOS.

Put GrapheneOS on your phone(s) and Qubes OS on PC(s), and you have the world's two most secure and owner-respecting operating systems in existence today!!!! :^)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by thegrimmest on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:16PM (#39031349)
I support Apple not because they need my support, but because the supporting argument aligns with my principles. I believe that the entire App Store ecosystem belongs to Apple, and that none of us have any right to dictate what Apple does with it. It's theirs in the same way my organs are mine. Just because it happens to be massively successful doesn't change this. I'm not a negative utilitarian.