News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:54AM (#39024643)
I have difficulty following this argument, especially the "stealing" part. App Store does not just randomly take money from the devs. App Store also provides a service. They do world-wide payment and VAT processing, refund processing, discovery, distribution, user login management, APIs, distributed cloud storage, etc. It costs money to run these things. As a small-time developer, I think this is a great deal for 15%. At the price levels of most small apps it would cost more to use a payment processor + hiring an accountant, not to mention the extra work involved in setting up and maintaining these things. For behemoth like Epic — sure, the "Apple tax" hurts, they'd rather gouge their customers without Apple's involvement. But frankly, I don't see any reason to punish one multi-billion corporation just so other multi-billion corporation can make more money. I care primarily about the interest of the small-time developers.

And this is the point that should be made more often IMO — App Stores (and Apple bing one of the first ones) have democratized software development by making the barrier of entry extremely low. Anyone with some talent or idea can go and write an app, without any additional financial risk. App Store is based around sharing your success. The relatively few successful devs carry the costs to keep that barrier of entry low to everyone. And I really don't want that to change.

On a serious notes, what are the alternatives? What exactly is your argument? That Apple should be charging nothing? Ok, then they also shouldn't be providing any services. You want to do distribution or payment processing? Take care of it yourself. Epic would love this of course, Joe the indie developer instead is dead in the water. Or are you arguing that Apple is charging too much? Well, there are solutions to that as well. They could charge for services individually for example, but that again hurts the small developer, because trying out things starts costing them money.

Frankly, my idea would be to split the App Store into a separate commercial entity and make it nonprofit. I am sympathetic to the argument that the Store itself is not a product but is used to support and create value for Apple's ecosystem. I do think that the devs should pay for running the store, and I like the current success-based model and it's low barrier of entry for new devs, so basing the fees on actual operating costs seems like a good compromise. Of course, similar considerations should apply to other stores as well.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jdkoeck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:02AM (#39024709)
Again, it’s crazy people defend Apple on this. Apple is not just providing a payment platform, it’s forcing you to use it. As a developer, you should be free to use any payment platform you want in your app, like on the web. Let the user decide. End of story.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:56AM (#39025147)
> Let the user decide. End of story.

The value proposition of iOS is that the app store is the place to go, and that my experience will be seamless. I want a centralised place to manage my subscriptions. Here's an example:

I subscribed to NYT Cooking in the web a few years back. I went to cancel only to find out that I have to phone them. If I subscribed on an app store it would have been one click and done. I'm actually still subscribed to it.

Why is your choice more important than my choice?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ric2b on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:28AM (#39025442)
Right, so you'd use the app store by choice, so why should Apple force you to?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:23AM (#39025878)
The first move that will come out of this will be a Meta store for "all your meta products". You won't have the choice of Instagram on the App store or Instagram on the Meta store, you'll have Instagram on the Meta store.

This won't be a choice for users, this will be a choice for large developers.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dotnet00 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:08AM (#39029590)
So just follow your own supposed ethos and don't use Meta products?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ric2b on Sunday January 21, 2024 @08:47AM (#39078375)
That never happened on Android, why would it be different on iPhone?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by nprateem on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:16AM (#39025324)
Yeah that's perfectly reasonable. Of course it makes everything easier. It's also practically impossible to compete against which is what gives apple this unfair advantage, making their 30% cut obscene. They're making it due to being first, technical issues aside.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jdkoeck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:14AM (#39025791)
Your point is moot because Apple forces you to use its own app store, where using their payment platform is mandatory. If there were alternative app stores, I would have no qualm with this restriction. Let Apple's store compete with others, it will come out on top if it's really the best.

The larger point is this: in a free market, if you have a bad experience with a product (like NYT Cooking in your example), you can bring your business elsewhere. That's how it works, and that's what Apple is interfering with.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:34AM (#39025957)
Why does the free market arugment apply on apple's ecosystem but not the mobile ecosystem? There are alternative app stores with alternative ecosystems - if you have a bad experience with your iPhone, replace it with an Android and use the open ecosystem there.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:28AM (#39026347)
Because the entire mobile market is a duopoly and asking someone to switch platforms that they might have invested 15 years of their life into isn't reasonable. Think of all the data, hardware (smart watches, tablets, trackers, speakers, smart home gadgets), app & in-app purchases that one would have to forfeit to switch platforms.

They explicitly carved out their own market by making it a tightly integrated walled garden that's closed to outside integration, it seems hypocritical to now claim that users are free to leave at any time. They're not and that's by design.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:53AM (#39027659)
How come it's reasonable to force someone who _doesnt_ want the app store to be opened to competition to change?

I don't want the Meta store where Meta decide what level of API access their apps get). I explicitly choose the iOS ecosystem _because_ of this. If you want the alternative, you have a choice right now with Android. If this changes, then I _dont_ get a choice. Your choice removes my only option of a curated app marketplace in favour of a marketplace that will allow for billion dollar companies to set their own rules on how I interact with their apps, rather than me delegating that to one trusted gatekeeper.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:29AM (#39029030)
> How come it's reasonable to force someone who _doesnt_ want the app store to be opened to competition to change?

Are you asking why we have antitrust laws?

> I don't want the Meta store where Meta decide what level of API access their apps get

And they shouldn't! Users should have full control over what data their apps can access, how often, with optional spoofing where it makes sense to stop apps from gating functionality behind invasive data collection. This should be an OS-level feature, not (poorly) enforced by the app store.

Apple's superficial review process isn't going to spot malicious abuses of your data unless it's plainly obvious.

> Your choice removes my only option of a curated app marketplace in favour of a marketplace that will allow for billion dollar companies to set their own rules on how I interact with their apps, rather than me delegating that to one trusted gatekeeper.

How so? You can continue using whichever marketplace you trust. Meanwhile your privacy and security should be technological, OS-level guarantees. You don't need Apple's app store to stop apps from stealing your banking information. You need a secure operating system (which iOS advertises itself to be) which employs sandboxing and that offers fine-grained permissions which users can freely grant, deny, or spoof.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by maccard on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:17AM (#39029724)
> Are you asking why we have antitrust laws?

you're putting words in my mouth here.

> How so? You can continue using whichever marketplace you trust.

No. I get to use whichever marketplace the publisher decides to use. Epic aren't going to publish on the App Store (see Fortnite on PC), Meta are going to publish on their own store. 37signals are going to use their own store. I currently can use a marketplace I trust. If iOS opens to allow other stores, then those stores either need to be curated by Apple or the store apps are sideloaded and have wider permissions. I don't want Meta's store with those permissions, I'm fine with using WhatsApp and not giving them my location.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:14PM (#39034963)
There's no technical reason why sideloaded apps would or should have wider access to permissions. That's a false dichotomy.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jdkoeck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:32AM (#39029077)
You hit the nail on the head. The market of mobile platforms is in a state of "market failure": no real competition, because mobile platforms are not "homogeneous" (that is, it's hard for a buyer to change platforms). The market of mobile platforms being thus "monopolised", you need regulation to enforce proper competition.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:17AM (#39025334)
Apple provides the OS and SDKs developers need to make their app function at all.

Users do not care how much it costs a developer. They want it to be easy to see and cancel subscriptions all in one place. The web’s myriad of payment systems is the opposite of a good user experience, meant to only fatten the pockets of developers by making it difficult to cancel.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by CogitoCogito on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:54AM (#39025662)
> Users do not care how much it costs a developer.

This is a ludicrous statement. The users are the ones paying for it.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by riscy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:12AM (#39025783)
That 15-30% going to Apple isn’t going to go back to app users. Don’t pretend this is all about developers wanting to give users a discount.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jdkoeck on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:15AM (#39025801)
It actually is, there are plenty of services where you can pay 30% less if you go through their site instead of Apple's app store.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by CogitoCogito on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:26AM (#39025906)
Do you believe businesses don’t take their margins into account when pricing their products?
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:19AM (#39026291)
I'm all for letting the user decide. But what you are proposing is not letting the user decide.

If Melinda wants to use the Facebook app, but the Facebook app is only available on the Meta store, then Melina is forced to use the Meta store. This is not giving users choice. This is replacing one corp-backed store by multiple corp-backed stores. The user loses.

The only way how this would be a choice is if the same app, with the same basic functionality was available on all stores. Then the user would really have the choice which store to use. Or if there were alternative apps on different stores. Good luck with that given the current monopoly markets.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Fluorescence on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @06:46AM (#39026476)
Melinda should be able to choose to have a business relationship with Meta. The Meta store, aka a trivial hosting/payment service, would be part of that Meta offering. She should not however only be allowed to have an Apple(Meta) relationship where Apple gets to tax and restrict Meta for it's own commercial benefit.

An "App Store", when it is not used as a rent-seeking choke-point, is a nothing-burger, it's a simple website to buy and download an app, yet you are trying to claim some great horror if this website was run by Meta not Apple. Please. It's nonsensical.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:50AM (#39027628)
Right. So you are saying that Meta has the right to implement their services and platforms in any way they see fit, and the user has the right to choose between using those services under Meta's conditions or not using them at all. But Apple has no similar right to their own services, platforms, or SDKs, and is forced to let Meta harness their platform and user base while expecting no compensation? And this apparently makes sense to you? What you are proposing is the dictatorship of the developer. This completely throws the idea of proprietary platforms and SDKs out of the window.

By the way, I couldn't care less if Meta has their own shop or not, and I don't see any horror in that, they decide how to best run their business, not me. But I take an issue with claims that Meta running their own exclusive show somehow creates more user choice (which is the direction the commenter I was replying to was heading towards)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Fluorescence on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:21AM (#39028021)
I can barely parse what you say it's so unhinged.

It's such a bizarre belief that a product sold by Apple remains "their platform" once in the hands of a consumer. The only thing they still "own" is copyright IP. They sold a product. They don't get to legislate user actions. Their power over the device post sale, that they use to extract rent, is entirely artificial.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:08AM (#39028701)
This is quite funny, because I feel the same about what you are saying. The way I understand you is that a seller of the product should grant any third party extensive access to that product, so that the third party can modify and implement their own services in any way they see fit. Frankly, this is completely shattering the idea of business relations as we know it. By your logic no proprietary store or platform SDK should ever exist (e.g. console SDKs should be free for all developers). What's more, extending this argument software itself should be moldable at will (I bought the app, I have the right for it to be modified in any way I please).

I mean, it's not that I would oppose this ideology in particular, it just sounds a bit radical. We'd have to change quit a lot of things for it to be feasible.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by pcnix on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:02AM (#39024713)
The problem is that we place a responsibility on competition in the market to favor consumers by reducing prices and preventing companies from having excessive margins. Allowing a single marketplace means there's no competition, and we're not sure if 15% is a fair rate at all.

I could make the assertion that I'd be able to provide everything that Apple does, but with a much lower cut, but this can't be put to the test because there's no way for me to start another app store that iPhone users can access. I suspect a lot of the arguments for the 15% cut will change once we have alternate app stores offering the same things Apple does, but with a much lower cut. You'll then see app developers with skin in the game, and we'll know if everyone actually really thinks Apple does this better or if they'd rather have the extra money from other app stores.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:43AM (#39025029)
Do you really think that there will be more competition? I fear what will happen is that the big corps will set their own stores to distribute their own apps, and that's pretty much it. The user won't see any difference in pricing. The small dev will be hurt because each store will make less money and will likely implement price increases to compensate.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ryanbrunner on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:54AM (#39025131)
We don't have to speculate - the desktop OS world has exactly this structure - an open ecosystem with a first party app store that ships with the OS, but the ability for other app stores to exist or even for developers to ship their products independently.

In practice you still see a decent amount of activity on the official app store, along with some other major app stores, and a relatively small amount of independent distribution. There's still a good amount of small independent developers shipping apps (both on the stores and independently), and there's not a ton of evidence of price increases - in fact there's a very large amount of free software being distributed.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:20AM (#39025843)
Desktop marker and smartphone software markets are very different. There are many more small utility apps for the smartphones for example, while desktop is more open. Discoverability in particular is a huge issue for a small desktop app developer. I don't think comparing to desktop is a good example. On the other hand, desktop app market does illustrate the point I am making — big corporations running their own "stores" to the user disadvantage. And don't let me start about horrible installers that companies like Adobe or Microsoft ship which will change your system configuration and litter your filesystem with random crap.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by wouldbecouldbe on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:52AM (#39025112)
It's actually annoying that the refunds and VAT are handled.

For small international developers, under 500K per year spread out over several states & countries, often they don't have to pay VAT in most international places, so they lose an extra 20-22%. For instance most US states won't require you to pay VAT under 100K revenue if you are from another country.

Same for refunds & subscription management, often clients will ask you, but you have zero control with Apple. Let alone 60 days before being paid, where stripe does it in a few days.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @04:06AM (#39025224)
This is a great point and I think it illustrates the drawbacks of centralized store. I think an argument can be made that App Store is an important part of the developer experience and as such they are entitled to have a voice in what features it should prioritize.

The thing is, I fully agree that the model has to change and adapt. There has to be more transparency, more accountability, and these stores have to improve in a way that best fits the interests of the developers and the users. I just don't think that third-party stores or unrestricted side loading will do anything like that — in fact, I fear that they will make things considerably worse.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jim180 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:10AM (#39027145)
The threshold is 10k€ in the EU. So, way less than 500k
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by wouldbecouldbe on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:05PM (#39030405)
Yeah EU is stricter, but for lot of my clients US is a large market, without they themselves being in the US. If you are EU based then it's cheaper to pay EU tax and not US tax.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:39AM (#39024993)
> You want to do distribution or payment processing? Take care of it yourself.

Yes! That's exactly what everyone wants.

> Joe the indie developer instead is dead in the water.

No, Joe the indie developer will happily use one of the most popular alternative app stores that fits their needs and doesn't rip them off with fees.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:58AM (#39025164)
> No, Joe the indie developer will happily use one of the most popular alternative app stores that fits their needs and doesn't rip them off with fees.

What would these be? Last time I checked, the "champion of the people" Epyc charges 12% and pushes the charges for some payment methods onto the buyer. And it seems like they still haven't turned profitable, even with their bare-bones store model.

Stripe (one of the most popular payment processors) will take 9% from a 5$ purchase just for payment processing. This doesn't include tax processing or any other stuff, all that you have to pay extra. A customer wants a refund? You are eating the cost.

I just don't understand how any of this stuff people are talking about is realistic. I am not aware of a single commercial payment processing solution that will end up under 12-15% for small charges, while offering much less value to both the developer and the user compared to App Store. And I don't understand why people expect that this solution will suddenly magically pop up if Apple allows alternative stores.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @05:23AM (#39025872)
The lack of competition and alternative options is the core issue here. Free market competition will figure it out, that's the simple answer.

One developer might be operating on effectively infinite margins and opt to stay in the Apple app store for visibility and most familiar experience.

Another might participate in an alternative app store that charges a review fee, a distribution fee but doesn't charge anything for in-app purchases except baseline payment processing fees.

Yet another might be operating on razor-thin margins and/or doesn't need to participate in an app store for visibility, they might sell their app directly through their website and roll their own payments and distribution.

> Stripe (one of the most popular payment processors) will take 9% from a 5$ purchase just for payment processing.

We might as well treat this as 0 when discussing alternative options since it's an inescapable fact of selling things anywhere (cash and crypto aside)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @09:01AM (#39027760)
> The lack of competition and alternative options is the core issue here. Free market competition will figure it out, that's the simple answer.

You know what? I actually agree with this! If alternative stores would really offer competition, then it's indeed something worth investigating. The problem is that I doubt that we will see alternative stores much. We will have a Meta store that sells FB-relevant services, an Epic store that sells Fortnite, an MS store that sells MS Office experience, an Adobe store that sells Adobe subscriptions, etc. Basically big corps making their own bubbles to improve margins.

If all these stores are regulated instead (transparent rules for all, no corp-only stores, strict privacy regulations), sure, I'm all for it! But that's not where the suggestions are going, so far most of the comments are along the lines "Apple should not be allowed to do this, everyone else should be allowed to do everything". Unfortunately, many "fairness initiatives" end up with some other big corp creating a soft monopoly (just look at google who de facto control the web standards just because their engine has 90% of the market share)

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:04PM (#39031197)
Where do you get this number for Stripe ?

Right now, in the EU, the standard fee (before negotiation and volume consideration) is 0.25ct + 1.5% which will work out to about 26.5% cut for a 1-euro payment that is the worst-case scenario currently possible in the App Store as far as I am concerned.

They sell added services but there is no obligation for them and I figure most developers wouldn't care for them. The most expensive it can get is for international payment with currency conversion: 0.25ct + 3.25% + 2%. I don't know exactly how they do the fee calculation, but for a payment of 1, you would get a cut of about 30% max. Apple definitely does NOT provide the same service, since they do not allow international payment in their different localized app stores and they don't do currency conversion (they will let the bank charge you for that, which will get MUCH more expensive).

And the stripe number becomes much better with bigger price because of the fixed transaction fee. If you sell an app for 5$, the minimum you would have to give Apple would be 75 cents (the 15% they will allow under certain conditions) when the maximum you would pay to stripe would be 51 cents, or about 10.25%. Realistically most developers that do not have the scale to operate a fully custom system will address one or 2 big regional markets (with mostly shared language, culture and currency) and they would be just fine with the standard offering of stripe that would bring the cost to around 6.5%. While setting up everything would be a bigger hassle, for most developers that make enough money to live off it, that's a no brainer. Even if we argue that Apple provides more value than the base stripe and push to 10% cost everything included, for a dev making 100K in sales, it's already "free" 5K coming their way.

Many seem to mistakenly think that Apple allows dev to sell their app worldwide with very little hassle. Not only this is not true since many apps are actually region locked for whatever reason and cannot be purchased in a different market (it happens to me all the time, especially with apps from the US or from Germany) but Apple does not realy simplify the process of localisation, marketing, and proper tax declaration in each relevant market. Apples gives you pretty sales statement with everything you need, but any decent system will do that, you still need to do the actual work of compliance if you are big enough or care enough to follow the laws.

There are some argument to be made about the benefits of Apple integrated solution but it is only relevant for cheap software that are impulse buys precisely because they were cheap enough. The higher the price of the software the less relevant Apple solution is. Especially considering the inflexibility and dumb "categories" they push everything into. And if you have to push subscription or in-app purchase nonsense like they currently do, the economics are even better for external solution.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by dns_snek on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:23PM (#39032931)
> Where do you get this number for Stripe ?

That's Stripe's US fee. CC processing fees are much higher in the US so that card issuers can run all of those "cashback" programs.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by seec on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:25AM (#39039341)
I checked and it is indeed higher at 30cts + 2.9% but the international cards and currency conversion fee are much lower (1.5%, 1%).

Your base case is a bit worse and it will work out over 30% for a payment of 1 (0.329) but if you sell a 5$ app, it would be 0.445 or about 8.9% like you said. You are still 6% lower than the minimum Apple would charge you.

It's not clear cut depending on what you need, but at the same time if you are small enough to qualify for the 15%, you probably don't need much or have time to figure it out.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by commandersaki on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:03AM (#39024718)
The alternative is Apple allows side loading so that you can buy software independently of the App Store , and sellers can distribute independently of the App Store.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by ribit on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:44AM (#39025040)
I am ok with side loading. Of course, side loaded apps would need to be sandboxes for security reasons and should not be allowed to access basic services like calendar, contacts or iCloud.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by CogitoCogito on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:03AM (#39024720)
> On a serious notes, what are the alternatives? What exactly is your argument? That Apple should be charging nothing?

The alternative is “competition”.

In any case, I don’t see how any of this affects you since you’re happy paying Apple the fees. You can keep doing so as others pursue other options once they’re available.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Aerbil313 on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:02AM (#39024703)
Well written. It can be argued that Apple also develops the OS and UI libraries which the apps run on/with, which is also providing something.