News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @11:57AM (#39030296)
I wouldnt defend 30% specifically but surely they should get some cut or share. What is the right number? 1%? 50%? I don't know.

> All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes than make a few people who already have everything even richer.

Kind of an odd take. They take a cut because they provide a service. They are not stealing. I guess lump me in with the defending apple crowd if you want to but to think they would or should charge nothing for their service feels... silly.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by barbariangrunge on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:09PM (#39030469)
Does windows deserve 30%? what about your isp? Or your motherboard manufacturer? What about nvidia? Should every single company providing you software or hardware take a cut, or only apple?

We should own our own computers

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by jwagenet on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:24PM (#39030644)
Pretty much every middleman or service provider in every industry takes a cut, whether by charging you more than they paid or a fee for their service. For some reason people think software is uniquely exempt from this transaction. Nvidia and your motherboard manufacturer already charged you for the product they provided and you also paid for the fee Dell or Newegg charged on top. Your isp is charging you a fee for uninterrupted service. Apple is charging developers for hosting apps and developing tooling.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by noapologies on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:53PM (#39031800)
Sure, but the cut is a fixed amount based upon the value of the services the middleman is providing. And most importantly, it is not a percentage of the revenue the customer is able to generate by using these services - these two models are polar opposites.

A great example that highlights this absurdity is vehicle ownership - imagine if Tesla announced tomorrow that they are actually a "transportation platform" and started charging Uber drivers a percentage of their revenue, or Mazda found out about the weekend race you did in a Miata and is demanding a cut of the winnings.

Businesses would love perfect price discrimination in every context (because profits!), but is not clear to me how that is a desirable state for humanity.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:59AM (#39044219)
> A great example that highlights this absurdity is vehicle ownership - imagine if Tesla announced tomorrow that they are actually a "transportation platform" and started charging Uber drivers a percentage of their revenue, or Mazda found out about the weekend race you did in a Miata and is demanding a cut of the winnings.

They could do this. It would just result in people being upset and likely no longer using their products.

I don't think it makes a ton of sense to compare a store or marketplace to hardware though? Every marketplace I know of takes a cut of items purchased through their store. Or they buy their items upfront and then take all the revenue of the sale.

The issue really shouldnt be that a cut is taken, it should be the amount or letting developers create alternative ways to download apps. Having an issue with someone taking a cut of revenue generated for products purchased on their platform just doesnt make a lot of sense.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:41AM (#39043964)
I pay windows a fee to use their OS. I'm guessing they take a cut of anything sold via microsoft store as well. My ISP gets a fee for its service. My motherboard was paid for. Nvidia card was paid for.

I don't know exactly how every store works but doesnt every digital store, and non digital store, take a cut of what they sell?

I agree with the fact that we should own our own computers but you do own your iphone. You can jailbreak it and do whatever you want with it. You can even sideload apps, like altstore, through an incredible tedious process.

It sucks that Apple doesnt make this easier to do but that is another topic... Right?

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by linuxhansl on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:26PM (#39030676)
Seems to me the range of what a credit card charges would seem sensible. I.e. 3-7%.

Alternatively charge 30% but be forced to allow side-installing Apps. That way developers can decide if they want the convenience and reach of the AppStore or not.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by merlindru on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:55PM (#39031063)
> Alternatively charge 30% but be forced to allow side-installing Apps.

Yes this exactly

I don't care whether they charge 10%, 30%, or 100%

I do care that there's no alternative to NOT using their services & paying their fee

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @12:01PM (#39044258)
Sure. I think side loading is the best options or allowing another way to pay where apple takes a lower cut makes sense. I'd argue that credit card companies are doing a lot less than a marketplace? But again... How do you come up with a number that really makes sense? Apple is just going to charge whatever they can until they are told they have to change.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by thefounder on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:27PM (#39030688)
They should as much as Mozilla gets for the online transactions carried out on its browser.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:03PM (#39030377)
only in tech...

can you imagine if selling a replacement bulb for a ford headlight required you to pay 30% to ford.

only in tech can this be considered fair.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hnaccount_rng on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:15PM (#39030530)
I’ve got very bad news for you.. what do you think happens when Ford solicits bids for headlamps? Sure “you” don’t pay something to Ford. But Ford absolutely gets its cut
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:29PM (#39030723)
that's not nearly the same thing, stop it.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by hnaccount_rng on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @01:39PM (#39031626)
How is it not? Giant company vs tiny company. With basically all the profit being allocated to the giant company.

Yes it’s not software and yes the tiny company is not single-person company. But that really doesn’t change the situation (well except for you being seemingly personally affected). You can call this situation unfair and say that it _should_ not exist. But reality just disagrees with your assessment that it _does_ not exist. At least as far as I can see. Feel free to explain the difference that I’m missing.

And just for completeness sake: this isn’t even unique in software. Distribution commissions were usually in that order of magnitude. Even for less service and reach

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @03:18PM (#39032866)
I can buy a 3rd party bulb that I can put directly into a vehicle I own, how Ford sources the bulbs they put into the vehicles they sell or repair has nothing to do with that.

Steam deck recommends you purchase the official steam dock but they don't prevent you, nor do they take a cut of, 3rd party docks that interface with the steam deck.

only in tech would someone argue they should be entitled to a cut of that transaction because they _sold_ the original hardware to the user.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:55AM (#39044160)
You can buy third party hardware to use with your apple products.

You can even install apps like altstore on iphones.

Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday January 18, 2024 @03:42PM (#39047405)
jailbreaking your iphone voids the warranty, replacing the the bulb with a 3rd party brand does not.
Re:US developers can offer non-app store purchasing, Apple s... by Taylor_OD on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:43AM (#39043990)
I pay ford, or some other distributor, 100% of the cost of the replacement bulb plus whatever their markup is when I purchase it.