I agree that a wealth tax is not the way to go. But there are other ways to skin this cat. The big takeaway I got from the article missing in your summary is that the wealthy take loans secured by unrealized gains in order to finance their lifestyle.
So what if we found a way to make a rule that using unrealized gains as collateral for a loan was, for tax purposes, the same as realizing the gains? (You might need to tweak the rule for fairness but the basic point remains.)
I think aggressively closing loopholes in the current code could go a long way (you mentioned a couple, like charitable donations and tax havens).
I may be missing your point though.
Maybe they're kicking the can down the road, but that's their choice.
The real issue here is that super rich are, at the end of that road, donating shares to their non-profits, tax free. ...and that their children then have access to that non-profit and all of its assets, again without income or estate tax.
The big hole here isn't the unrealized gains - it's the "charitable Foundations" that are a complete scam.
Unless they pay back said loan with another loan. Given the massive amount of wealth accumulated, you can rinse and repeat indefinitely. Basically you have a free cash flow machine, without ever having to convert that income as proceeds (unless you want to convert between asset types).
Having said I agree with your main point: we need to close the loopholes, and the charitable foundations is the biggest of all, and sadly the article missed the point entirely.
That shouldn't matter as long as they don't start to enjoy the benefit of those assets.
This means tax rules should separate the estate as a business/investment from the personal use of the funds/wealth.
Sure, at some point it becomes neigh impossible, like let's say Bill and Melinda went to Africa on their marriage anniversary, was that business or personal? (And yes, at that level of wealth, influence, income it's always both.)
When an owner (or close relative or friend of an owner) of a family trusts/foundations/estates/NGOs/church/non-profit conducts business through said entity, that entity should pay some tax corresponding to said expense as if some part of that expense were income to the owner/relative/friend.
I can't just say "Oh, I'm investing 30% of my income, tax that part when I sell later", I don't have that choice of kicking the can down the road.
The problem is you're not kicking the can down the road, you are delaying it forever. Your entire 'Lifestyle' can be funded tax free. Instead of things being your assets, that you spent money on you could have a company plane, car, boat, house. Lavish dinners can be put on the company card as 'business meetings' and travel as 'Business Travel'. This is all taken out of your business profits and the best tax structure for a business is at a loss or barly profitable. Add that to the point OP made about taxing collateral loans is it would semi-eliminate the 'loophole' of never having to pay taxs.
Edit: One more point. Should a $1m donation to scientology be considered a tax writeoff?
We can argue about whether or not it's good, but its not unthinkable. Property taxes in most places (in the USA, the subject of the article) are linked to the current market value of real estate. Sometimes property values rise, taxes follow, and people have to move.
That would only affect home refinancing, which will still be a considerable number of people.
For all intents and purposes, it is income and should be taxed as such.
This isn't a new thing. Property taxes are the wealth tax that already exists, at large.
That is... You're point on a tax reassessment is exactly what is being discussed. And if the tax on your wealth is increased as a form of capital wealth, expect the rates to be higher that most property taxes.
Edit: I see I missed that this was a hypothetical on touching collateral. Not sure how I feel on that one. In large because I know so many folks are essentially tricked by marketing to refinance all the time.
Taxing non-income wealth increases by any means incentivizes the government to manipulate the prices of those assets -- and more than any other entity, the government possesses the power to do so through regulation and legislation.
It also makes the government the eventual largest capital owner, which could create all sorts of unintended consequences. It could sit on those assets indefinitely (like it does its liabilities) instead of selling and using the money to fund itself. There's a special kind of poverty that exists when the government owns almost everything.
Also, there's a big difference between legal worth at a given time and fungible value at that time. The difference (or lack thereof) between the two could itself create all sorts of opportunities for gaming the system when fungible value becomes a basis for being taxed.
Unless you mean a series of leins incurred once a year based on price increases. But then an asset with high YoY volatility but no long-term gain would cause the lein sum to approach the value of the asset over many years, despite no material increase in price at exit. That makes no sense - the government profiting off of volatility alone.
If that's not what you mean, how is what you mean different from standard capital gains tax?
So: Exemptions specifically covering residency already exist in finance law. If you go bankrupt, you can still live in your house (only if you owned it, mind).
The government, as soon as practical, can auction the stock it receives. Thus identifying its value and releasing the funds.
I'm not advocating anything in particular. I'm only pointing out some potentially serious issues with the proposed system.
Sure, primary residence could be excluded. But that doesn't change anything about what I said, except perhaps blunt the initial impact on the middle class.
> The government, as soon as practical, can auction the stock it receives. Thus identifying its value and releasing the funds.
Perhaps that could be part of the tax law. I doubt it would stay that way... once the government can own stocks and portions of real estate, I'm sure it will seek to incrementally increase its benefit from doing so. I shudder to imagine politician-beaurocrats as the most powerful hedge fund managers of tomorrow.
There's nothing stopping the government from owning these things already (governments own plenty of real estate, in particular), so this seems like undue cynicism.
In fact there's almost no comparison to be made between the two.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/bisnow/2017/04/11/solving-the-m...
This is now really a bad faith argument.
You've moved the goalposts (again), and declared that your new goal wasn't met (when, in fact, you just ignored that part).
It's OK to admit you were wrong <3
If the government purchases real estate with its own money and later sells it--fine by me. They have business to take care of and need places to do it.
What bothers me specifically would be a growing federal or state government stake in assets owned by others by virtue of a tax law that grants them such ownership.
I imagine whole swaths of businesses, apartments, and other buildings in cities across the US that are >50% owned by the government 40 years from now.
It would push us a lot closer to a world where people don't own anything anymore besides their own houses (maybe not even that) and the government owns everything.
I'm really struggling to understand this point of view, given the article that you couldn't be bothered to read says the US government owns 15% of all real estate already.
In my country, the reason that a lot of people own their houses is because the government sold its housing stock to residents in the 1980s and 1990s. That created a majority of homeowners, for the first time.
The fact that the government didn't replace this housing stock has been the cause of a massive generational rift, with a reduction in owner-occupancy from that peak, down to the point that a plurality of people (the vast majority of people under 45 - almost all young families) are now private renters in insecure housing situations.
While that same housing stock - originally built by the people, for the people - is increasingly dominated by exploitative for-profit landlords.
Either pay %x in cash value or give %x percent of the item to the government.
Of course likely the government would just want to liquidate immediately but you could perhaps set it up as a "lien" on the stock/bond/property that gets satisfied at final sale.
It’s supposed to work out in the end as you have a higher basis at that point but you still have a liquidity issue.
Do they also get to leverage these shares to have a vote as to the business decisions, like any other share holder does? (assuming they have enough shares in this hypothetical share tax)
For simple income tax, where you're paid in dollars and hand the government a percentage, that's fine.
But what if you're paying a tax on, say, some equity you were given in a startup?
This can cause huge trouble for people who have illiquid assets, like equity in a private company. You have to pay tax in dollars based on a guess of the value of that equity, even though you can't trade the equity for dollars (it's not liquid). When you eventually can sell the asset, like at an IPO, its assessed value could have decreased and it might be worth even less than the taxes you already had to pay on it.
That's the kind of gift you don't want to receive.
I'm suggesting that, for those who are worried about that risk, the government allow you the option of handing over a percentage of the asset instead. If it ends up being worthless paper, then the government gets nothing, but on the other hand that's also the correct amount for them to get because the tax on $0 should also be $0.
Most likely, the government would choose to (or perhaps by legislation could be compelled to) sell the asset at an IPO, but that's a detail. Perhaps they could also have an agency for managing and directing such assets in the public interest.
No doubt they would be loads of ways to scam this though, setting up supposedly valuable companies to 'pay' a big tax bill, then rinse the company or allow it to fail while diverting profit elsewhere.
It would be an interesting idea to explore and could potentially be a massive boon to risky startups by allowing them to hand out equity more freely as incentives without worrying about the accompanying tax burden.
I cannot think of a more complicated mess as the government being part-owner of half the small businesses in America.
In this case, the value is not well defined. If you don't have a market, you cannot determine the value. You may think it's extremely valuable, but if you have no one else willing to recognize that value, then it doesn't really exist.
You can handle your hypo the same way the tax system handles mine. You can deduct the capital loss from future gains.
It could work in some cases but I don't see how it's the same as selling stock A and buying stock B.
Why would we want a system that taxes people on an unrealized gain and then (maybe) gives it back to them over coming years?
C'est la vie. That's how Capital Loss deductions, Electric Vehicle credits and other non-refundable tax credits currently work: individuals may not have enough upside to maximize their benefits, That's just how the system works as it is impossible to balance everyone's competing scenarios. If you are eligible for a $7500 EV credit but only paid $3000 in taxes, you'll only get that $3000 back, and not the full $7500.
1. When they do realize gains, the tax brackets are severely broken such that someone realizing $2Billion in capital gains pays a lower effective rate than someone with 1/10000th that number in income.
2. We live in a financial environment in which the Fed will rescue the stock market no matter what, creating asset inflation and making this a relatively reliable strategy, whereas there should be more theoretical risk in doing this. Bear markets, albeit painful, are the only times in recent history where wealth inequality decreases as the economy corrects and reallocates capital [0]. Staving them off at all costs for the last few decades via easy monetary policy is arguably one of the greatest contributors to the rise in wealth inequality, alongside poorly graduated income tax brackets and (to a lesser degree) automation.
I do completely agree that treating capital gains more favorably than earned income is just crazy (even though I personally benefit from it).
There would be some risk that you couldn't get another loan, but if you're only borrowing 10% of your net worth, it's probably an extremely small risk.
No they don't. The article even describes how they use income to pay for that, and then use the interest paid to avoid write off paying any income tax:
>Borrowing offers multiple benefits to Icahn: He gets huge tranches of cash to turbocharge his investment returns. Then he gets to deduct the interest from his taxes. In an interview, Icahn explained that he reports the profits and losses of his business empire on his personal taxes.
The whole article is full of logical fallacies and focusing on the wrong thing to drum up outrage. E.g. I do not care that Bezos didn't pay any taxes in some year where he sold no assets and received no income. What matters is what the tax brackets levy on wealthy people when they do liquidate, which are currently a complete joke and cap out at a number thousands of times lower than the highest earners.
The exact rules could be tweaked to keep it from being a burden on families taking a second mortgage, e.g. if you borrow less than a certain amount in the tax year perhaps the rule doesn't apply. Use your imagination.
This is pretty much the situation that the tax is designed to combat - people using their assets to increase their wealth without paying taxes. So yes, if you did that, you would need to pay taxes on the new money in the refinance. I don't see an issue if that makes this business model unprofitable or untenable.
> If we do this to homes, and the wealthy move their money to a new place, such as venture capital, do we try and re-price those illiquid assets each year?
There's no need to price anything. You value the assets put up as collateral as the amount of the loan they are securing.
> If one IPO’s and they take a loan against the stock to buy a home, do you give them their previous year’s mark-to-market payment back to them if the stock goes down the following year and they get a margin call?
Nope. It's just like selling and immediately re-purchasing.
> Imagine trying to grow a startup and being worth X on paper with no actual gains or money in the bank.
Ok, but nothing happens unless you borrow against it. I'm not sure what scenario you are imagining here.
People take out loans for much more or less than the value of the collateral. Do we ban that, or do we open up another tax/laundering loophole by letting the official value of a property diverge arbitrarily from a hypothetical sale value?
Which they have to pay back with post tax money. I don't see a problem here. At best this is tax deferral until capital gains are realized, something we allow for good reason - paying real money to cover tax on paper gains (which could vanish) is a problem, and could even force you into giving away an illiquid asset because you can't afford the tax on it.
They're gambling their stock will perform better than the interest rate on the loan. That's a reasonable gamble.
Taxing a loan seems silly.
Unless they die first. If heirs hold on to inherited property for a while (2 years?) they can sell it at the cost basis reset to the value at the time they inherited. They pay back the loan with the before-death gains untaxed. The original buyer got to effectively realize their gains via loans, untaxed.
https://smartasset.com/taxes/how-to-avoid-paying-capital-gai...
We bought a house last year and I was forced by QuickenLoans to liquidate my Tesla positions, that appreciated 5x and incurred short term capital gains. Were I richer, I could have avoided liquidating my long positions and pay proportionally less in taxes.
The most annoying part is that in the end they didn't even need all of my stock portfolio liquidated, only about 30% to cover closing costs. Yet I got hit by a 5 figure tax bill because of it.
In short - the system literally setup to extract as much as possible out of everyone, other than the wealthiest/most powerful. And that includes banks, government and lenders.
Eventually they have to sell stock to pay back the loan?
Aren't they just delaying the taxation?
https://www.thebalance.com/how-the-stepped-up-basis-loophole...
It's even worse than that. The interest on those loans is tax deductible, according to the New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/08/us/politics/income-taxes-...
If people really understood how this all essentially boils down to the rich not having to pay taxes, purely by being wealthy and being given loans on it, they'd riot tomorrow.
It would be interesting to see what happened if a sufficient amount of that debt was bought up and forced to be repaid.
Why not? A tax on wealth, even a small one, is the only mechanism to avoid a long-term drift towards a feudal-like state of society.
We also don’t need to make perfect the enemy of the good. We don’t need to account for absolutely every piece of wealth if we cover the big ones. We can also continue to revise these tax policies as new loopholes are discovered and exploited.
Major components of the economy are not valued regularly, e.g. private businesses. Sure, if a buyer paid $10MM last week for a private business, we might say it's worth $10MM today. But what about a business that was started from scratch by the founder? Or one that was last sold 30 years ago? Or one in a very niche industry?
Put simply, valuation is not only a science, but an art... and it's an expensive art. The cost and difficulty of administration alone would be reason enough to steer clear of a wealth tax.
Lastly, although I'm not a fan of higher taxes on anyone, even simply a more progressive income tax would make more sense than a wealth tax.
I'm not a fan of taxes on most stocks (eg wealth) rather than flows (eg income). But if you held a gun to my head and said "design a wealth tax!", I'd set the minimum wealth far above the $32MM proposed by Bernie Sanders or $50MM proposed by Elizabeth Warren.
And keep in mind, even if there are actually only 1,200 billionaires in the US, a number of people slightly below the threshold will still have to be analyzed; I might not know if I'm worth $800MM and owe no wealth tax or $1.2B and owe tax on $200B of wealth.
Oh bless your heart.
If there is no form of weath + inheritance tax, a feudal society is unavoidable.
Even if difficult, we'd better try.
What exactly do you mean by this? Holding wealth in bars of gold doesnt need to employee anyone (if you have enough of them, you might want security personnel, but you could also just own a Gold ETF or something).
Seems roughly fair
One might suspect the wealthy are just dropping turds in the punchbowl.
One thing I want to point out, the reason why 'wealth taxes have always failed' is because it's against the interests of the wealthy, and the wealthy are powerful. Look how scared republicans are of grover norquist and the billionaires that back him. It's hard not to argue the same thing is happening in the EU as well.
I especially love how the Koch brothers effectively funded an astroturf campaign that hijacked the republican party, to get blue collar folks to argue against taxes on the 1%. That is some rich irony.
Make the owner declare its value, tax it at the value. But anyone can buy it at that price. If they want to keep it, they'll need to value it correctly, and thus it will get taxed correctly.
I have to choose a price for all of my assets and then anyone could just be like 'yeah, I'll buy at that price' and take it from me? What if I bought the assets for the hope of it maybe being worth something in 5-10 years? Do I prematurely announce 'yeah, it's worth the price in 5-10 years that I hope it will be', and pay an enormous tax on something that's not a guarantee it will ever go to that price, just to keep other people from buying it from me if I announced what the market value is now? (And also I'm not allowed to keep any assets at market value unless I announce it's worth more to me?)
Ugh. Never get in a position where you could feasibly propose this in government, please.
I wasn't proposing that this become policy for all assets. Would it allow you to accurately assess the price of rare high valued art for the purposes of a wealth tax -- yes. It would also allow you to value other assets as well, but there are drawbacks.
I don't think your example of speculation is particularly good example of a drawback though. If you need to set the price at X so that someone doesn't buy it from you now, then that means its value is indeed just below X (assuming you've set X correctly).
If you're the only person in the world you thinks that the value of your asset will be 10X in 10 years, then you can safely set the value at X now and nobody will buy it from you. If you aren't the only person in the world who thinks this and someone is willing to buy it from you now for 2X, then I guess the value of the asset right now is 2X.
But I'm willing to read more about the idea, if you have an article or two that makes a good case for your proposal, please post and I'll give it a look.
I saw in another comment someone called it the Harberger tax, and linked to a 66 page paper that I'm just not going to read for the sake of an internet post.
I could have been less antagonistic in my reply, I apologize for that.
I do think you're overestimating how well people can judge, individually, what something is worth accurately on declaration, both now and in the future, especially if it's an asset they don't ever want to part with.
But again, I'd be happy to read articles from experts that make a case for this.
Also a video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uj186urDU8c
Neither of these is particularly short and still don't address all (or even many) of the practical issues. As with most real policy and law, I don't think something can be both short and cover all the real world cases. There's unfortunately a reason most laws are really long.
I believe the chapter of the book addresses the issue of how will people know what values to set. In addition to the solution proposed in the book, another alternative (of mine), is to allow people to pay some amount of retroactive tax. Let's say someone tries to buy the asset from you for your set price, but you don't want to sell. You can raise the price to some amount the buyer no longer wants to pay, but since you were underpaying taxes on the asset, you need to make them up.
Would such a proposal probably mean people set lower prices than are correct -- yes; would it still make sense for things like homes -- yes.
Also specifically for houses, at what point are you expected to make such a declaration? You don't really own the house until you've completely paid off the mortgage on it. Until then it really belongs to the bank or mortgage lender. So does that mean you're free to not make such a declaration until your 30 year mortgage is up? And what if you take out a second mortgage on the property during that time?
In a case where you have a collateralized loan to purchase the asset, I imagine the lender could require the value you set to be at least the value left on the loan. (But the lender probably shouldn't be allowed to set the value beyond that stipulation.)
I also want to say that I definitely do not have all the answers for all the possible policy issues that might or will come up. I enjoy trying to think them through, so the first attempt might have problems and the cycle of finding those problems and fixing them will eventually lead to something that hopefully works well.
My fridge? My dog? My shoes? My car? My bike? My boat? My model railroad set? My grandmothers ashes? My underwear? Oops I accidentally undervalued my gaming computer on my taxes and now people are knocking on my door.
You'd end up with a document 3 million pages long and vengeful neighbors and exes buying each others items to fuck with each other. You're calling it a strawman argument, but these are actual things that would have to be addressed.
No amount of "delving into 150 years of research" gets around all the massive, massive holes in your ridiculous idea.
For example, you could easily say that only assets that would be declared as having a value over X amount need to be declared in this way. Choose X to be somewhere in the neighborhood of a house, and you would get almost all the value of such a policy without any of the drawbacks you just listed.
Does my collection of rare coins count as one asset as a whole, or individual assets that are each under X amount? Who decides what my random painting is worth so I know if I have to declare it? What happens when my asset depreciates?
Also, once you go to X being "somewhere in the neighborhood of a house" you lose a TON of taxable income with this policy to the point where it's probably not worth it. You're not going to gain much money taxing a few mega-yachts and rare paintings, especially when you have to include the money spent dealing with more complicated taxes and audits.
We can just raise income and capital gains taxes instead and it's a whole lot easier. Wealth taxes that include assets are so fragile and complicated.
I also think you're making a poor estimate of what the distribution of wealth looks like. Yes, there are lots of small items, but the vast majority of wealth is stored in items/things/land/etc. of significant value. Perhaps more than anything it is stored as equity in companies. For income taxes the top 1 percent paid a greater share of individual income taxes (38.5 percent) than the bottom 90 percent combined (29.9 percent). For wealth the distribution is even more skewed.
I agree there are a lot of things to figure out. That was and is true of our current system too. At one point the rules for all its loop-holes didn't exist and they had to be created and that didn't happen overnight.
If your asset depreciates, then you say its worth less next year. You decide what your random painting is worth. If you don't report an asset that should be reported, I can see multiple mechanisms:
(1) You sell it for more than X. At this point it becomes clear it should have been reported and back taxes are owed. (2) You bought it for X. If you don't report, questions would be asked. (3) There is no record of purchase and you never sell it. You might avoid paying taxes. I'm not sure what assets of significant value (over $500K) would fall into this category.
I don't have a great answer completely off the cuff about how to deal with things like a collection of rare coins. Perhaps the best answer is the easiest answer: they are just treated separately.
Sorry, what? Taxes should always be about raising money for various projects that benefit the country. If we can't see eye-to-eye on that I don't think we'll find common ground here. I'm not looking to punish rich people for being too rich. I'm looking to fund public projects like healthcare, infrastructure, and education.
I think raising money through the tax is important, but I think a more important long-term function of a wealth tax is to ensure that large fortunes eventually revert to the mean rather than sustaining in perpetuity for generations. (Unless they continue to be invested with above average returns for generations.)
Also - there are many taxes that exist not for the purpose of raising revenue, but for the purpose of a policy goal. To deny this would be to deny how a great deal of how modern public policy works.
I don't think anyone would have much of a problem with the simplistic scheme applied to rare art though.
One can imagine that public charities or government assets for example are exempt from such a scheme (since they don't pay tax anyway usually).
How long until some rich art collector starts a charity to hold their art and protect it from being auctioned?
I'm not a lawyer - but it seems like one obvious factor would take into account where the artwork purchased by the charity resides. Is it in a private residence? A freeport? Probably not really a charity.
Is it hanging on the wall in the Art Institute of Chicago? Might be fine.
Then the question is what happens if the charity tries to sell it back to a private collector at some future point. Might be allowed as long as back taxes are paid assuming some appreciation schedule.
I think the more general point is that policy is _hard_, and to assume that something doesn't work because you've thought about it for 2.5 seconds is probably a bad assumption to make. Most of our existing laws/policies would be similarly easy to attack if distilled to one sentence. There's a reason actual policy and laws are really long.
You however, seem to think that because you can find a corner case in a two line proposal, the whole thing has no merit.
Maybe someone knocks on your door and says "I just bought your house. Get out." That would be pretty unpleasant.
Or, more on topic for this site: maybe they do that with your startup.
Do you have a source for this? People keep repeating this over and over, but I have never seen a shred of evidence for it. It seems some people have just decided that they hate inheritance and thats just it, no evidence required.
I would encourage you to look at the most unequal countries in the world by wealth. You may find it surprising that none of them are "feudal".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_in...
Edit: I don't mean to be snarky, apologies if it comes off that way. Unfounded ideas just bother me, and I would love to gain new perspective forming info.
Take a look at the current housing market craze where wealthy/institutional buyers are taking advantage of low interest rates to buy properties with all-cash, inspection-waived offers above asking price, in some cases whole neighborhoods at a time, so as to rent them out. This is a privilege unavailable even to the upper middle class, and could very well turn into a sort of neo-feudalism if left unchecked.
It's also not unprecedented for companies to own entire towns and pay employees in company "scrip" that was only redeemable at company stores, a practice which lasted well into the 1950s and (after some googling) apparently was tried by the Mexican subsidiary of Walmart as recently as 2008.
Looking at the broader state of the economy, wages have been stagnant for decades; property, healthcare & childcare (at least in the US) and education are more expensive than ever. With the exception of food, everything that matters in life is more unattainable for the average person, and everything that doesn't matter is super-cheap, with no signs of those trends reversing. How does that not turn into a form of neo-feudalism if left unchecked?
The last time we "checked" it (in the US) it took decades of labor protests/riots that often turned bloody and the effects of a couple of world wars. Historically plagues (that actually kill a lot of people indiscriminately) and wars are just about the only re-distributive methods that have proven successful in the long term. Unless we want a repeat of some real nasty history, we need a historically unprecedented way to redistribute wealth.
The Netherlands topping the list has average house prices at EUR 400k(massive spike in prices in the last year), while average annual income(pre tax) is EUR 60k.
Feudal economies were actually powered by wealth taxes. So putting in a wealth tax won't do anything to avoid it becoming a feudal society. Further, confiscatory taxes[0] (of which wealth taxes are but one type) are favored by dictatorial regimes throughout history. I don't think we want to go down that road.
Wikipedia has a great summary on feudal taxes[1], and they are based on wealth (usually land and hides). It's actually a pretty good summary of a long period of time, and a complex topic to begin with.
[0] - https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/confiscate [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_medieval_England
So please let’s not hot-take it to the extreme
In the mid-term we’re looking at some sort of weird hybrid plutocrat/government hybrid with an American flavor and a Chinese flavor. Everyone else is in the middle with the scraps.
Lenders will quickly adapt to give loans without requiring collateral
1. drop the corporate tax rate to 0%. Most notably, these corporations would follow the REIT tax policy that requires them to distribute > 90% of taxable income to shareholders.
2. Move Social Security and Medicare into the Progressive Income Tax (it being flat on income is regressive)
3. Offset #1 and #2 with a higher income tax (especially for capital gains)
> A more interesting question is how did ProPublica get a copy of Jeff Bezos' tax returns. Seems like a leak at the IRS?
Yes the actual tax records are what make the story interesting, even if the data only confirms what “everyone knows” — at least there’s actual data and empirical analysis of the scope.
According to this accompanying explainer, the leak is anonymous:
https://www.propublica.org/article/why-we-are-publishing-the...
> A second question certain to arise is the motives and identity of the source who has provided this data to ProPublica. We live in an age in which people with access to information can copy it with the click of a mouse and transmit it in a variety of ways to news organizations. Many years ago, ProPublica and other news organizations set up secure systems that allow whistleblowers to transmit information to us without revealing their identity.
> We do not know the identity of our source. We did not solicit the information they sent us. The source says they were motivated by our previous coverage of issues surrounding the IRS and tax enforcement, but we do not know for certain that is true. We have considered the possibility that information we have received could have come from a state actor hostile to American interests. In particular, a number of government agencies were compromised last year by what the U.S. has said were Russian hackers who exploited vulnerabilities in software sold by SolarWinds, a Texas-based information technology company. We do note, however, that the Treasury Department’s inspector general for tax administration wrote in December that, “At this time, there is no evidence that any taxpayer information was exposed” in the SolarWinds hack.
Just because the person is not a sympathetic figure doesn’t mean it gives people the right to leak this kind of info, be they Bezos, Clinton, Soros, Koch, Gates, etc. get them on actual evasion if they have.
Otherwise what’s the purpose, rich people use tools to minimize their taxes? Ok, publish what the tools are and promote change in the tax code.
This is the obvious consequence of a system that feels unfair and unresponsive via normal channels.
The rules outlined in the article apply to everyone, not just the rich, and they should be fixed for everyone, not just the rich.
In this case leaking Jeff Bezos' tax returns targeted one individual and provided no new useful information. It's exactly what we already expected about his taxes.
...and frankly, the "rich are evil - look how they don't pay taxes on unrealized gains" is a huge distraction from fixing the actual problems with the tax system.
We need to eliminate foreign tax havens, and severely limit non-profit "Foundations".
Assuming people find this information objectionable that’s a reasonable justification to publish. In much the same way that leaking classified documents about questionable activities is morally justified, though illegal. Otherwise stamping secret on any evidence of say torture would work.
So this is more about shaming the witch rather than showing the witch did witchery.
the Watergate leaks?
Snowden's leaks?
the Pentagon Papers?
and a lot of less famous leaks of restricted information that have led to exposure and sometimes even justice for people who otherwise would have hid behind "legal" defenses for immoral or flat out illegal acts of their own?
I served in the Navy - I had a prety high clearance just to do the job I did. I know the value of classifying or otherwise restricting information. And I know the value of breaking those rules to expose those who would hide their crimes.
I consider the current tax code a recipe/playbook/script for stealing from the American public.
It’s simple some vigilante having a vendetta against someone they don’t like and using illegal mans to skewer them.
The case they have is known. We know the loopholes. Let's as close them. Don’t go out on personal or vendettas of virtue when it aids nothing. There is nothing new here. Jeff, as much as I dislike his company, didn’t commit a crime.
If the leak's target did nothing illegal or unethical with their taxes, then how are they being skewered? Their taxes would just show them to be an upstanding, law-abiding citizen, right?
So sure, you can claim all you like that we already knew about these holes, but abstract arguments and aggregate data are far less persuasive and motivating than specific examples that clearly show the stark reality.
Or are you forgetting how the George Floyd video galvanized a world-wide movement despite everyone already "knowing" that racism is bad, that it exists, that police training is subpar and that bad cops kill people of colour?
As if Twitter and all other social media media weren't about taking things and reframing them to make targets into bad people.
Like it or not, they created it.
Should we extract more taxes from them, yes, arguably. But we don't have to resort to blackmail or other underworld tactics since it really accomplishes nothing other than momentary outrage by the mob.
Get congress to enact laws that close loopholes.
Either by inheriting it or some business arrangement where you keep value created by other people. Bill Gates for example didn’t code Windows 7 himself. JK Rawlings didn’t print millions of Harry Potter books or even produce the movies etc. Sorts superstars don’t build stadiums or collect ticket sales etc.
This is most obvious with investments dividends. As such thinking of capital gains as the fruit of their effort is really kind of a silly idea.
And we do that by exposing the problems of the existing system and galvanizing people to demand change. Which is what these articles are doing.
I myself would like Jeff to pay more in taxes. I think the super wealthy pay too little in terms of parentage, but I should be upset with the Congress/IRS not the wealthy.
Really, it’s not a question of laws but one of obligations to society as a whole. Because society and the government are different entities but society depends on it’s government.
Wait. What who already knows?
I'm willing to bet that a lot of people who read this article did not already know the information contained within.
As such the article serves to educate a lot of people, which is a positive development.
That something is legally within the bounds of the US tax code is public knowledge.
That ultra-wealthy utilize something to an extent is not public knowledge.
Which cuts to one of the central issues with viewing the US tax code as democratic: there's almost no transparency of use.
The public might feel very different about a particular tax rule if they knew small businesses primarily used it, vs if they knew major corporations used it to shield 90% of their profits.
The IRS should do a better job of anonymizing actual tax reports, and reporting out on patterns in aggregate.
The problem with that argument is who get to make that decision? Would you still be saying that if someone leaked you tax records to the general public?
I completely agree with your overall point, but this statement is not true. Solid concrete evidence of what we "already expected" _is_ new information. (also, as other commenters have pointed out - what _you_ already expected is not necessarily what the average person already expected)
I think when he owns the Washington post, it becomes of the public interest.
Hell, in Norway literally everyone's salary is public information. Hasn't seemed to do them any harm either.
or more succinctly:
“We need to condemn the families and businesses in places like those tiny island nations in the Caribbean to more poverty”
Those tax havens exist because they realize that a very real thing they can offer as a service is a place to domicile a business and capital. Not everyone wants to go to Ireland for its nice beaches you know.
Google's only presence in Bermuda was a P.O. box.
Similarly, when Caribbean nations sell citizenship to foreigners seeking easier travel or tax optimization (another avenue they have explored into order to diversify their economies), the foreigner typically pays a fee in the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars for the passport, and that goes into the national budget.
Plus all the other things on top that are associated to flying in to Bermuda for the week of business to setup your PO BOX.
Oh and then there’s the airport, staff to maintain the airport.
All that plus more for a simple PO box
They are taking it upon themselves outside the law to settle disagreements, but they want to leverage new laws to make taxes more aligned with their policy (but obviously they are okay with ignoring other parts of the law —that’s a disconnect).
Would it be a disconnect to illegally oppose an immoral law - like, say, the legal protection of slaves as property - while simultaneously wanting to pass laws that you expect people to follow - like, say, making slavery illegal? Probably not.
It's inaccurate to treat obedience to the law as a moral act. It can only be moral because the law itself reflects moral attitudes. Wherever there is a disconnect between the law and morality, it is the law that bends - which is exactly why laws can be rewritten in the first place.
If you want these things to stop, you need to change the incentives that people operate on. Anything else will be like trying to plug holes in a dam with your finger; locally effective at best.
The total harm of stealing billions from the public dwarfs any concern for the thieves' privacy.
They are following the law, sure... the unfair law they pay for to their advantage.
If you earn $100 a week and tax withholding let you have $80 to yourself. That $20 didn’t belong to the government. It belonged to you. You however, having entered into an implicit agreement with society agree you will part with your money and give it to the government (which is different from its being theirs). Now, if you donated some of the $100 to charity or whatever and reduce your tax liability, that’s not “theft”. That’s part of the initial implicit agreement.
What proportion of Americans have a federal income tax liability of zero or less? (Yes, some Americans get paid to file taxes, via "refundable" tax credits)
I believe it is around 42%.
What proportion of the top income earners pay 80% of Federal income taxes?
Our system is overall quite progressive. To complain that the five or so people mentioned in the article "only" paid billions in taxes over a five year period is a bit nonsensical.
I hate paying taxes.
But I'm honest about what I'm buying for my money -- the broader community I live in and happen to like and care about.
Yes, it is, overall: https://theintercept.com/2019/04/13/tax-day-taxes-statistics...
> Once you factor in the regressive nature of social security taxes
Social security is effectively a mandatory pension scheme where you get benefits at retirement based on what you paid in, so calling it a regressive tax seems inaccurate.
> and average sales taxes
Many states have exemptions for essential goods to limit the regressive nature of sales taxes, but yes they are regressive overall.
> you quickly see that the rate of taxes paid on all income remains fairly consistent
I'm not sure what your definition of fairly consistent is, but your first sentence is incorrect above, so it's probably not accurate here either.
> up until you get to people with a net worth in tens of millions plus who pay a much lower percent rate.
This is absolutely true, and is something that should be addressed in my opinion. Just taxing capital gains as income would be a great start, and might be enough.
It was millions over the period of 2014 to 2018. Not that I disagree with your overall point.
Bezos did almost pay $1b himself though. In total the people in the article paid under $2b.
Also, another 13% of Americans make less than $12/hour, with many of them working under 30 hours a week. Roughly how many of those people, in your opinion, should have a federal tax liability?
Yelling at people for properly taking legal deductions, when you yourself take deductions on your taxes, reeks of hypocrisy and being mad because Joey got a cookie and you didn't.
You mean because Joey took his allowance and bought the supplies for a lemonade stand, took the money made from that to buy the ingredients to make cookies, then took the time to bake himself cookies.
It's strange that people find a person who creates & grows a company and who pays hundreds of millions of dollars in legally required taxes detestable. Yet a person who fails to gain the basic education that is free to them, who has no ambition, who is literally a drain on society, cannot be criticized. It's astonishing to me that society accepts and allows people to not have a least a high school education.
I wonder what the response would be to an article about how trillions in taxes are not paid because there are millions and millions of people who simply don't develop their personal capital and make decent choices that would result in them earning more and paying more in taxes.
There are guys in Hyderabad right now in conditions worse than US homelessness learning Python, devops, cloud, virtualization, you name it because that's how they can survive.
I know people in fairly poor countries with terrible crime rates and bad job prospects, and I have never heard them complain about how hard life is. They figure out how to get out of their situation and improve their life.
The idea that someone else has to fix your situation because life is hard has to be one of the most crippling mentalities you could have. The sheer amount of opportunity we have in the west is unprecedented in human history; instead of crying about the fact that your stable job of 20 years is ending, yes: I'm going to say that it is fundamentally you that has to pivot (even if it would be nice if the government helped).
This story is about how the very few extremely high earners use sophisticated personal finance strategies to minimize their tax burden. On the other hand huge numbers of people use the unsophisticated strategy of not developing any significant skills or education and not earning much money resulting in not paying any net taxes. Not talking about the super poor who earn nothing, but people who earn $30,000-$60,000/year. At the end of the day, they are not net tax payers.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/angr4k/what_i...
My entire thesis is that vigilante leaks like this are a product of the perceived unwillingness of the legislature to deal with the abuse of tax loopholes or to tax the rich at anywhere close to the rate that the overwhelming majority of voters want. If my theory is correct, then saying “talk to your legislator instead” is almost hilariously tone deaf, given that these leakers are probably taking actions into their own hands in response to a belief that their legislator is lazy or corrupt.
More broadly, my point is that singling out individual actors is an ineffective way to stop stochastic law breaking. Decry and punish individual law breakers all you want, but don’t expect it to stop until you at least triage the underlying causes.
The bureaucrats are functionally accountable to nobody. This leak was instigated by a bureaucrat.
Fuck the bureaucrats.
That’s the theory, yes. I do not believe this to be true in practice however.
Bothered by "internet mobs?" Look at the underlying issues.
I mean one is about basic rights the government owes us, the other is about us wanting the government to take more from particular people.
The civil course is slower but the alternative is typically bloody revolutions or Hongweibings, both of which set back societies.
How do you think most of the rich stay on the good side of the law? They have much more direct access to legislators via mechanisms that should be illegal, but are not because they pay to protect them.
Laws take political capital to pass, and without public outrage, you have zero political capital to take the first step towards reform. Any attempt to pass laws that increase transparency will be quashed, because you have no political capital to do so, and people taking advantage of this have a huge interest in squashing them, so they can keep operating in secrecy.
I'm not shilling some weird conspiracy, here. This is exactly the purpose behind ag-gag laws. [1] Thanks to them, the public can't make an informed decision on whether or not illegal activity should be prosecuted or investigated, or whether or not currently legal activity should be made illegal.
This is a similar situation, except that the financial stakes - and the incentives for secrecy - are about a thousand times greater.
Publishing an actual example of how these tools are used is a perfect way to explain what they are and how they're exploited. Bezos is rich enough to be untouchable, so what's really the concern here?
It's clear at this point that extremely wealthy figures should expect reduced privacy rights when it come to their wealth because it serves the public interest.
You're basically arguing that the public shouldn't be aware whether a person owns a nuclear weapon because they bought it fair and square and "privacy".
For example, knowing that the richest man in the world avoided paying $x billion in taxes using a loophole could insight change better than a theoretical story about how somebody could use these loopholes.
That being said, I'm still not sure if leaks like this are a good idea or bad idea. Just playing devil's advocate a bit.
I'm not saying we should not close loopholes. I'm all for that, but I'm not for willy nilly leaking illicitly obtained private documents that do not describe illegal behavior nor anything we didn't already know.
If you only condone taking legal courses of action, how would you go about opposing those billions and the leverage over the legislative process that brings?
It's all well and good to take a moral high ground and say no one should ever break laws, but when the laws are exploitative and the legislators are beyond real influence, what other recourse is there?
It gets substantially murkier, too, when you consider that much of the nominal valuation gains on their assets might be attributable to the dollar being essentially devalued vs hard assets.
What are they doing with the rest of the info?
That would work if people were purely logical. But people are not. Therefore the average person needs an anecdote, not data, to start caring.
I also think leaks about billionaire's finances are completely fair game. It's not that they are unsympathetic, it's that their finances are that important to the average person.
I’m sure some people donate their own money to Uncle Sam, but most people don’t and they are not required to.
The thing is that such leaks should help you realize that some things aren't crimes but should be.
Keep in mind that 200 years ago owning/buying/selling slaves was not a crime in the US. Yet nowadays we all agree that slavery exploitation is a crime.
Chances are actual downvotes are still from people who not only disagree with style but also with content, but when those are a minority a magic thing happens: people who agree with content but are at best neutral about the style see it in deeply faded grey and vote "it's not that bad", but only as long as it's deeply faded. The result of a most agree but don't wand to encourage surgeon reliably ends up a slap on the wrist "ca -1", no matter how many people voted. The mechanism works great.
(and it's also quite successful at keeping meta talk like this from escalating, I only feel that it's somewhat acceptable to write this now that the story has left the front page more than half a day)
The other issue I have is that not only is the provenance of this data unknown, so also is it's veracity. They don't know who gave it to them or why and thus they can't confirm it wasn't made up out of whole cloth.
We'd need some small adjustments to make them not useful for identity theft (remove SSNs, stop using specific values from them as authenticators for the IRS, etc.) but with that done, I think it would be a great improvement in transparency.
My public sector salary is already a matter of public record, and that has worked fine.
I'm for more aggregate data being made available as long as it couldn't be used to find one individual, and I'm okay with the IRS adding a checkbox for "make my data publicly available" as long as you could always uncheck it. But then I take privacy more seriously than many others do, not sure why.
I'd be happier if we greatly simplified the tax laws so that this extra data was not necessary. Not going to complain if they reduce the tax burden as well.
Edit: grammar
Some nice charts midway through this page: https://www.pgpf.org/analysis/cbo-warns-fiscal-path-is-unsus...
He has been straying into politics in DC very very heavily, and it looks like he's making enemies. I suspect that is also the reason we see near-daily anti-Amazon posts on social media.
I don't think ProPublica describes in exact specificity the scope of the data, other than it contains "the tax returns of thousands of the nation's wealthiest people, covering more than 15 years". And it includes Warren Buffett, Rupert Murdoch, Mark Zuckerberg, Larry Ellison, Mike Bloomberg, Carl Icahn, and Elon Musk — a group of guys who, along with Bezos, are not considered to be politically aligned.
If we were to guess and not be able to prove it, maybe it would be Bezos or regents, oligarchs, gangsters, opaque family trusts
Quite certain it is regents, oligarchs, gangsters, opaque family trusts.
The tax returns need some relative value to compare against to show effective tax rates. If most of that wealth is illegal and well hidden, it's going to be pretty difficult to compare a tax return against and get anything meaningful from. At least in these cases, the wealth is more glaringly obvious in the open and can be more reasonably compared to tax records.
https://www.voanews.com/usa/us-politics/terrible-crimes-made...
The ”human banking” method is very popular in transnational organised crime. Just look at how Putin has hidden his assets.
BT has a lot a negative press about its sports investments but Murdoch's sky doesn't
Not so, because of the step up basis at death. That provision allows the capital gains tax to be not just postponed, but eliminated.
Even a quick Google search yields articles describing a (very incomplete) list of loopholes one can use to make the estate tax not something one has to "worry about": https://smartasset.com/taxes/5-ways-the-rich-can-avoid-the-e...
The estate tax rate itself is fine - the issue is the exemptions.
That aside, I’m not arguing for a lower estate tax threshold. I’m arguing for an elimination of the state up basis at death, at least for assets which the estate tax has not been paid.
If Joe Farmer’s kids keep his $10 million farm, they won’t pay any taxes. But if they sell it, they ought to have the same basis as Joe would were he still alive.
In the U.S., a pettings zoos or a county fair might have pigs, cows, and others like goats, horses, etc. Working animals or ones that kids/families raise for contests/shows, say the 4H society or FFA.
The step up basis will probably be limited or eliminated this year with Biden's tax plan.
I know the intent of your comment is to support family farms, but now these tax incentives have become perverse and really only benefit rich people, not family farmers.
In reality it would be pretty easy to setup the tax code to avoid such issues, but instead we’ve whittled the estates tax down to nothing to benefit heirs of the ultra wealthy.
Suppose I own $1 million worth of Bitcoin I mined back in the day. If I sell the day before I die I’ll owe $200,000 in long term capital gains taxes. But if I die, leave those coins to you, and you sell them the day you inherit them for the same $1 million, you owe no capital gains taxes.
Edit: if this is surprising, it should be. The step up basis is insane.
If you inherent cash, that cash has already had taxes paid for that. It shouldn't be taxed again like some "death taxes" propose to do. If you inherit stock, then sell it, the basis date for that stock should be the date it was bought, not the date you received it.
It only gets complicated with capital assets. And your proposal works for simple stock holdings.
Consider, if you are the beneficiary of a retirement account, you already have to withdraw percentages every year. So that is covered? Or not?
Right and I don't think gifts should be taxed either. It's already been taxed.
At some level, most (all?) money has already been taxed. Some entities can write off expenditures as a deduction. Most of us can't.
Consider, my income had already been taxed. Why do I have to pay sales tax on purchasing something?
Edit: and in case you fix on sale's tax being different from income. Payroll for businesses comes out of profit. Which comes from that same transaction. So, somebody's income is ultimately funded from a sales made with money that had been taxed.
So I'll give you $200k as a gift and you gift me your house "as a gift" ;)
Basis step up is extremely pragmatic, because it can be extremely difficult to establish the cost basis of a dead persons assets.
It's offset by the estate tax -- change your figures to $20 million and the situation is substantially equalized.
E.g. if I win a car in a contest or get paid in stock for working, I have to pay income tax on the current value when I receive it.
- eliminate the step up basis at death entirely
- index the capital gains basis to chained CPI
- give a credit to heirs for estate taxes paid which can only be used to offset the capital gains on inherited assets up to the basis at death
Step up basis might get eliminated in any case, as the Biden Administration is proposing to remove it.
It is true that if estate taxes are paid on the gains then the step up loophole hasn’t completely eliminated taxes on capital gains. However, the estate tax is even more full of loopholes than the capital gains tax. See for example the Grantor Retained Annuity Trust.
Finally, the Biden administration is not proposing to eliminate the step up basis entirely, unfortunately, but merely rein it in some.
Now how do we change the system? Put it in front of the entire public how much higher a percentage of their wealth they give up compared to these few, and get the entire public to fight for equity.
In practice huge amounts of capital gains are not taxed by either the capital gains tax or the estate tax.
The facts are:
“By the end of 2018, the 25 [wealthiest Americans] were worth $1.1 trillion.
For comparison, it would take 14.3 million ordinary American wage earners put together to equal that same amount of wealth.
The personal federal tax bill for the top 25 in 2018: $1.9 billion.
The bill for the wage earners: $143 billion.”
And that's normal.
If I make $1k per year, taxing me is almost criminal, since I can barely afford to feed myself.
If I make $100k per year, taxing me $20k year is kind of annoying, but manageable. I'll probably have to avoid some bigger expenses I would have made if I were not taxed at all.
If I make $100m+ per year, taxing me $40m per year doesn't even change my lifestyle. It just gives me topics to bitch about at dinner time, but it doesn't change my life in any material way.
The more I have, the more I can afford to give away without it impacting me or my family in any realistic way. Except for losing ego points.
Avoidance is a more or less a fixed cost. It's the price of tax attorneys and Congressman. To the degree you go over that fixed cost it's going to be harder and harder to get the amount. The biggest surprise to me is always just how much the rich pay not how little.
I have no economic concept for this but I strongly suspect it's true.
How about this? If you go rooting around underneath my couch cushions you'll find quarters. If you do the same for Bill Gates' couch you'll find ... Not $100 bills. Even if in respect to his entire wealth a $100 is less then nothing to Bill Gates he can still see the utility that money has in the world at large and that changes how he views it - maybe he doesn't see it the same way I do now or I did when I was 15 but he'd value it more then would be expected in relation to his over all wealth.
The distinction between capital gains and wage income is heavily coded into law, but that doesn't make it a distinction that SHOULD be treated in the way that it is.
In light of this, I don't think we can so easily dismiss delayed taxation of capital gains as unimportant and irrelevant. Maybe it is, but I think we need more information to solidly come to that conclusion. Even one of the things you (rightly, I think) identify as a problem seems to have some serious synergy with such a delay. What happens if one of these charitable foundations ends up with stock? How long of a delay might that taxation have then? And is there any way for them to get some liquidity out of that stock without actually selling it? Can they take out loans with it as collateral, for example?
I'm not actively making claims here, but rather trying to show the situation is complex enough that we can't write off seemingly innocuous mechanics simply because they appear innocuous. It's complex, and weird, and needs deeper information and data to really understand.
Like let's say I'm some regular guy, but I put my only $1000 in some asset that appreciated 100x, and it's now "worth" $100,000. These people that want to tax unrealized gains swoop in and go "hey, you're 'worth' $100k on Dec 31, you should pay us $30k in taxes this year". And so I don't have that money and have to sell my stock to pay it, but two days before I do the stock market tanks before I get a chance to sell and it's dropped 70% in price, so now I'm 'worth' 30k. And now I've sold it all just to pay the unrealized gains tax.
Now this is an extreme example and unlikely to happen exactly in the stock world, although not terribly extreme if this weren't stocks we're talking about, but some cryptocurrency.
This is why taxing unrealized gains never made much sense to me. The gains aren't actually real until you've converted them into something else or you purchase goods or services with. Until then it's just some number on a scoreboard.
And then once you pay it back you still have to eventually cash out and pay capital gains tax anyway.
Like if I had done that with bitcoin a couple of months ago (and it's possible to do, there's DeFi now), I would have been in some deep shit with the 50% drop recently.
It does seem like a bit of a sidestep though, and I'm sure rich people are probably taking advantage of it, so I wouldn't be opposed to some sort of small tax on money gained from loans made against your assets assuming you owned enough of them (like I don't want to hurt small business loans or anyone in the middle class from it), to discourage this practice a bit.
> we need to ... severely limit tax exemptions for charitable donations
Why do we need to do this? Wouldn’t the natural incentive-based result of this be a huge reduction in charitable donations? It’s essentially an asset transfer from charitable causes to the government. I’m not sure I understand why that’s default good.
This distinction is so hard to make, that I think it simply makes more sense to limit donations to a much smaller percent of AGI.
The current limit of 60% is so high, that most donations at that level are providing some sort of unspoken utility to the benefactor.
It’s like a conservation agreement. The land (wealth) remains in control of the owner, but the state gets some say in its use and the public benefits. Abuse of the the system is a case for stricter enforcement; sanctioned but objectionable uses are a case for stricter regulations
It's almost never investigated, and there is, in the normal course, so much overlap between expenses that benefit ME as a person, and ME as the owner of the charity.
Travel is a big one, for example.
More pedestrian stuff (eg expensing a conference in Seychelles) definitely slips through, but we could make the same principal-agent complaint about business expenses or other settings where one person gets to spend money from different buckets that are taxed differently.
I’d challenge the notion that the rules are unenforced though - someone will have questions if you’re living in a house your foundation purchased or somesuch. At the very least several people with an obligation to know better and much less to lose we’re going to be very nervous.
Conversely, even a charitable organization not run by the donor may be heavily influenced by a disproportionate donor such that it is de facto controlled by them.
Our former president would beg to differ
[0]:https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2019/donald-j-trump-pays-cou...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howard_Hughes_Medical_Institut...
It seem like a good loophole for the rich to have control on where their charitable money goes to and do what. you can argue the Gates foundation is the same but Bill Gates actually doing some goods with his charitable organization like someone else said, if the charity is being use like a little piggy bank for the rich then its a crime.
Are you saying we should reconsider the ban on felons buying firearms because the law isn’t enforced?
As for the specific example, yes, I think felons that served their sentence should have their full rights restored.
For instance, I'm fairly certain that using the money in a way that provides you a tangible benefit is verboten, as is taking a deduction for a "donation" to said charity that results in a tangible benefit.
Whether these things are enforced or violated is another question; but it does not seem reasonable to assume that every such organization operates by fraud, nor that getting rid of all of them would be no loss.
You can't make a charitable donation to an organization created after you were born, or created by an ancestor. It's not perfect, but it's a sharp line in the sand, and prevents bullshit like the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.
Why not instead have people donate their own money to causes they believe in, and have no matching grants?
But could be distributional issues as well depending on where the rich choose to donate — lots of that money is probably implicit transfers from government revenues to the Met
My point is only that the elasticity is above 1, since if it were below 1 then there would be literally no justification for deductions. In that case, 1% reduction in tax revenue from deductions would lead to a less than 1% increase in giving, so the government could increase aggregate funding for charities by killing deductions and issuing grants. Elasticity >1 opens the door for deductions being sensible depending on objectives and use of funds by gvt vs. charities.
Note this is not a spending multiplier, so the comparison with government spending multipliers is irrelevant. The relevant comparison there would be, for example, GDP (or ideally the "social") impact of each dollar in charitable spending. I don't know what that is and it probably varies by charity.
It's complicated and corrupt, basically.
Haven for Hope (transformational campus to combat homelessness) https://www.havenforhope.org/
San Antonio Food Bank (part of a national network of food banks) https://safoodbank.org/
Catholic Charities, Archdiocese of San Antonio (I'm the Board Chair, we run ~40 programs meeting people where they are and helping them on a path to self sufficiency) https://ccaosa.org/
The issue is more with the ones that actively promote the interests of their founders.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koch_family_foundations
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cato_Institute
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Heritage_Foundation
Are just a few examples of far right think tanks that are tax exempted.
If the problem is that you think some interests should be promoted and other not - well, I'm all in favor of that. The two of us just need to sort out which will be favored. My plan is for me to decide and you to agree with me. Sound good?
In some cases, evidence is fairly clear that the charities are used to actively undermine our society even further, e.g. Kochtopus.
Who's with me on this?
Check out:
- Firearms Policy Coalition
- Second Amendment Foundation
- Gun Owners of America
Scenario A: Your taxable income is $1,000,000. Your tax liability is $200,000. You pay your taxes, you net $800,000.
Scenario B: Your taxable income is $1,000,000. Your tax liability is $200,000. You donate $200,00 to charity. Now your taxable income is $800,000 and your tax liability is $160,000. Your net income is $640,000.
The only scenario where a charitable contribution doesn’t lower your overall income is
Scenario C: you commit fraud.
Notoriously more difficult as the amount of financial leverage increases.
“I want to give a million pounds to charity.”
“That’s nice of you. You still need to pay tax first on that sum, though.”
“OK I want to give £600,000 to charity.”
You could think about if the owner of a business generously decides to give all his employees a pay rise - the government now receives less money because the employees pay a lower marginal tax rate than what the owner would have paid if he kept the money for his own higher salary. Should the government get involved here and claw back that lost tax?
If, for example, you were in the 30% tax bracket and gave a $100 deductible donation, you'd only reduce your tax liability by $30 (ignoring edge cases) - ie you're still $70 out of pocket.
I see some arguments along these lines here:
https://theconversation.com/explainer-why-are-donations-to-s...
Excerpts:
* The main argument for tax-deductibility of donations is that it is a form of government assistance or subsidy for what are considered publicly beneficial causes.
* A third argument is that indirect support mechanisms, such as tax-deductibility of donations, facilitates choice. So, taxpayers can direct a certain proportion of their tax to causes they choose, rather than the government determining how it should be spent.
Directing money to a charity, to avoid the money going to the government, is explicitly a way of directing your money away from the common good of the public (which is after all theoretically what the government would spend it on) and towards the specific spending goals which the donor supports. The idea that a wealthy person has a 'better' idea of how to spend their money than the collective will of the people expressed through government is fundamentally antidemocratic.
A billionaire spending money through a charity that promotes a particular kind of schooling, rather than paying the money as taxes into the general fund where it would be used to fund education as directed by a democratically elected government, is basically a way of using their wealth to obtain a bigger-than-one-vote say in how education spending works, and to bypass democratic decisionmaking about how to spend money for the common good.
Of course, democracies are imperfect decisionmakers and they may not always reflect the spending priorities that will maximise collective good - but at least as institutions they are intended to balance interests, and provide a measure of fairness and equality in how decisions are made. And why would we believe that individual wealthy charity donors will make better decisions on how to direct spending?
An individual billionaire deciding that all schools should work the way they would prefer might be a positive way to end-run around institutional inertia and advance the state of schooling for everyone; or they might just pay to have every school library stocked with books about how humans coexisted with dinosaurs. They're one person, unconstrained by how the rest of society would like to improve schools.
>> The idea that a wealthy person has a 'better' idea of how to spend their money ...
The word 'wealthy' can be taken out here. The said choice is being given to others too if we let go of the nitty-gritties.
I agree also that I have no reason to believe that donations should be entirely tax free. The optimal point may be at giving say 10% of the donation amount as rebates while the remaining 90% still is subject to taxes. May be that optimum is at 0% rebate also.
>> and provide a measure of fairness and equality in how decisions are made
Overall, I do agree to your point. Fairness in decision making is more important.
Equality however is different from fairness though. Equality and efficiency bear tradeoffs. See here: https://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/10_Principles_of_Economics
Also, I do not see how high earners being subjected to higher taxes is fair (to them). In my opinion, the very premise of taxes being proportional to income has flaws. See my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27433973
>> is basically a way of using their wealth to obtain a bigger-than-one-vote say in how education spending works
If my viewpoint in the linked comment above of constant income tax is accepted, then the rich may not even have a bigger-than-one-vote to begin with. Overall, I agree to you though.
The fundamental model behind progressive taxation is that the pain of paying taxes should be roughly the same regardless of income level. The notion of "pain" in this context is closely tied into the concept of marginal utility of income: how much value does a given person get from receiving an extra $X in income (or conversely, how much do they lose by not having $X in income). Give an extra $1000 to person who only earns $12k/yr, and it's a pretty big impact. Given an extra $1000 to a person who earn $12M/yr and its just noise. Taxes follow the same principle, but in reverse. When we tax those with very high incomes, we want them to feel the same "pain" of taxes as those with lower incomes. Because of marginal utility, that requires different marginal tax rates.
> the very premise of taxes being proportional to income has flaws.
Taxes are not proportional to income. We have marginal tax rates, not all-income tax rates. Someone who earns $40k/yr pays the same taxes on the first (and only) $40k (likely close to zero) as someone who earns $4M/yr. Someone who earns $200k/yr pays the same taxes on that $200k as the person who earns $200M/yr.
Good point. I'll think more on this.
One thing though which makes this non-obvious: We are in an equibrium system where demand and supply rebalancing change things. Economic utility and purchasing power of $1000 is the same whether someone earns $10K or $10MM per month. For somplicity sake, if all are made to pay $30,000 per year in income taxes, those who earn less would stop working, however, the demand-supply rebalance would either raise their income levels or the industry would have a higher drive for innovating and inventing to automate those jobs. In a similar fashion, with lesser taxes for the super-riches, more people would incline towards doing startups, etc. When that rebalancing is considered, the point of equalizing pain does not remain obvious to me anymore, as of now. :-)
>> Taxes are not proportional to income. We have marginal tax rates, not all-income tax rates.
Yes, I had made an approximation when writing "proportional". Marginal tax rates makes the income taxes grow faster than proportional with the income, whereas I am arguing for a constant income tax. :-)
Marginal utility of the $1k is not independent of income, even if purchasing power (almost irrelevant in this context) is. This is just basic economics.
> more people would incline towards doing startups, etc.
This seems naive. The rich do not, in general, do startups. The super-rich in particular do not do startups. Maybe you mean "invest in startups", which is an entirely different thing, since it presupposes the existence of startups to invest in. There is zero evidence from anywhere in the world that reducing taxation on the super rich results in any notable increase in investment activity.
I have no idea what this "rebalancing" that you're referring to is. I see no evidence that economies in the real world are in equilibrium states, nor any reason to suppose that they would be.
> For somplicity sake, if all are made to pay $30,000 per year in income taxes, those who earn less would stop working,
This thought experiment seems fairly pointless. This isn't going to happen. And if it did happen, people would not stop working. People need to eat, etc. Depending on the enforcement of the tax, they would have to find more or less ingenious evasion methods.
I'll think some more.
If there are some mathematical works showing what you have explained, I would like to read. :-)
And what about when it is the government who wants to place these books?
All things you can do to affect government action that are unavailable to you to affect private philanthropy.
Yes, and donors should be whipped proportionally to the size of their donation – then we'll see who really, really cares about their cause.
> People should be giving to charities out of the good of their heart [...]
It's not up to you to decide people's motivation for being charitable.
In one sense yes, but if they're living happily on a tiny fraction of their wealth then they can hang on to the rest until an opportune time to cash out. Governments come and go, taxes are imposed and abolished, loopholes open and close. If they can afford to play the long game then "eventually" may be very different to what would happen if they cashed out today.
And it's not as if the current system is fair. You regularly see cases like that kid who won a trip to the ISS and had to give it up because it was valued at $X million dollars and to accept it he'd have to somehow pay hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxes. There's also the issues with stock options that come up here from time to time, where someone is owed millions in options that they can't actually use because they'd have to first pay a percentage of the value in taxes.
The Netherlands manages to do exactly that.
> There's no way to (fairly) tax capital gains
The fair part is that it's taxed - otherwise, it's unfair on people who are unable to exploit this tax avoidance.
We are talking about people with meaningful wealth. They can afford to be taxed without waiting for it to be perfectly 'fair'. Letting them pay $0 until its fair doesn't make sense.
It makes more sense to pay the expected amount, at least until you have the receipts.
Indeed, that's how my own labour income is already taxed. I first pay income tax for 2021 based on my income in 2020 - whenever it turns out to be too much, I can declare it later and will get a refund. But, I can't pay $0.
But....shares are useless until sold. Even if you have 1BN worth of shares it means nothing until you actually sell them/trade them? In fact, they could be worth nothing next week, how can you be taxing someone on a hypothetical sale value?
>>Indeed, that's how my own labour income is already taxed. I first pay income tax for 2021 based on my income in 2020 - whenever it turns out to be too much, I can declare it later and will get a refund. But, I can't pay $0.
That's literally insane. So you're basically giving your government a loan a year in advance? Why? Why not pay your income tax when you know - you get your income, like the rest of Europe does?
Yeah, I have no idea why gambiting is not doing that.
The rules in the US is that your estimated tax payments have to cover the smaller of 90% of your current-year ongoing (quarterly) tax liability or 90% (sometimes 110% for high incomes, an there are other special rules for farmers/fishermen) of the previous-year tax liability.
So yes, you can make them based on last year's income as as safe harbor if you have no clue what's going on with your income this year for some reason. Or you can just make them based on this year's income as you go.
The idea that someone should pay taxes on potential money is not a good one, IMO. I think there would be a lot of legitimate pushback, and if a plan was adopted anyway there would be serious political consequences.
You might be misunderstanding - this is literally how tax withholding works. You pay estimated taxes as you go through the year, and then file a return at the end of the year and settle up with the government to what your actual tax liability should be.
That's how most income taxes work in most countries.
I'm not super rich but if the government wanted to tax my shares, I'd pay the tax out of my income instead of buying more shares. I could probably pay a decent chunk of it out of dividends too, if I wasn't reinventing them.
Property tax here in Australia is based on hypothetical value, the sky doesn't fall.
Even if people have to sell some shares, I just don't care, it's not a big deal. Sell em.
The problem with the oft-cited options example is that tax is levied on gain of an asset that in fact cannot be legally sold at the time the tax is levied and is often enough worthless (or worth a lot less than at tax time) by the time it _can_ be legally sold.
Asset-based taxation on liquid assets with deep markets and clear prices is indeed probably fine in various ways. But if you tax other sorts of assets there are various problems, and if you only tax the easily-taxable ones people will turn to the other ones to avoid taxation...
To avoid a massive tax payment at the end of the year, you could elect how much tax would be deducted from your salary each month. The usual way to calculate it was based on last year's income. It wouldn't factor in all tax deductions so, at the end of the tax year, and after you'd filed the tedious and complicated tax return, you'd find that you'd overpaid. Better that than underpaying.
In the UK, usually your employer collects tax monthly. They calculate the amount to collect based on your current monthly salary projected forward and how much tax you've already paid. If there's a mismatch at the end of the year, the tax office uses a 'tax code' to adjust the amount to collect over the next 12 months.
I think you're misunderstanding. The tax rate they are paying is estimated based on the previous year income (we'll actually it's a combination of present income and previous years) because the tax office can't know your exact income (and deductions) until the end of the year. So when you do your tax return at the end of the year you either get a refund or need to pay some more. I'm pretty sure that's how it works in most of Europe (at least in most of the countries I'm aware of). So there is no loan to the government, they still pay the tax as a rate on when the income comes in.
"Indeed, that's how my own labour income is already taxed. I first pay income tax for 2021 based on my income in 2020"
It sounds like they pre-pay tax for 2021 based on what they paid in 2020. If that's not how it works then I retract my statement.
Germany does something similar: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wegzugsbesteuerung (unfortunately only in German).
Basically your tax advisor agrees with the government on a "fair" valuation and you are taxed on a 'fictions sale' when you cease to be a German tax resident and hold more than 1% shares in a company.
This is clearly untrue. At least they have use in the ongoing option to sell. I can use them as collateral to borrow at least as much as, and probably a multiple of, their value.
If you genuinely think they are useless, please give me some. I will use them.
> how can you be taxing someone on a hypothetical sale value?
Since shares are fungible, the government could just apply the tax as a number of shares. Then nobody has to worry about defining a hypothetical value.
I think there are high profile cases of founders getting low interest loans with the shares as collateral. This allows spending of the money without losing control or paying taxes now.
So, no they are useful before they are sold.
You can borrow cash against them, and live entirely on that cash for decades.
And I mean, if I borrow money to help me out until I get my paycheck, I don't pay the income tax on the borrowed money - I pay it when I get the paycheck.
I don’t see that holding up in court.
What is being proposed is to change the law. A court will absolutely uphold that law, once it is written. What it would do under current laws is irrelevant.
Of course, the assessor can't exactly predict the value of a commodity like a home with complete accuracy. Some people get undercharged and some get overcharged, this might even be a systemic thing. But as long as it's "good enough", then the tax works more or less how it should.
Even the SWP is cool with employee shares now
Being asked to pay tax on your wealth is not a judgement about your moral character.
We ask people to pay tax to benefit society, not because we hate them.
Given that shares are fungible, you could just give a percentage of your shares to the government as the tax/the government could or should accept this as your tax payment.
> You do realise that many employees on average wages do this.
I'd like to say almost none but I understand the median person the US holds a small amount of wealth. If there was a progressive wealth tax, you could take people with average wealth out of the requirement to pay.
And some countries think and I agree that people having a stake in your employer and in the economy through share ownership is a good thing.
I agree that you and me, and even my paper-millionaire neighbors and friends cannot afford to be taxed on their assets, but a billionaire can, even a paper billionaire can drum up the cash or debt when needed to pay taxes. They do it every day for their large purchases.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_governm...
> Except the uber wealthy who can afford to lose money to pay taxes for the infrastructure that has enabled their explosive asset growth.
Federal income tax almost never gets used for infrastructure. Infrastructure is mostly built by state and local governments, which receive most of their income from sales tax and property tax, and other taxes, which are already almost entirely paid by businesses. So, they are already paying for the infrastructure that enabled their growth.
1. Maintaining a navy that reduces piracy enough to have global JIT delivery networks that reduce costs for corps
2. Protects corp interests abroad allowing a larger market and higher profits
3. Enforces regulations that attract a larger than otherwise likely share of people to put their money in the stock market, increasing the value of your equities.
The entire budget of #1 is about 3% of that, and #2 and #3 around 1%.
What a terrible deal.
So much of the wealth on this planet relies on Governments for it to exist and to persist.
The fact that a lot of unrelated money transits through Government to pay for social services is completely irrelevant to the point.
Nevertheless I totally agree some part of that 11% will benefit business and commerce. But it is still a terrible deal. In any other context no one would ever buy something with a 90% "commission".
So I did look up actual numbers and the numbers I saw were different to yours. In 2020 the percentage was 15% (721.5 billion for military of 4.79 trillion budget).
But the exact percentage isn't that important. I still don't get the 'not a great deal' part. It's not some good you could either buy from retailer X or brand Y. If no money is spent on military than the country is ripe for invasion, so it's either secure or it isn't. And it's not like we want the percent to be higher. Like we don't want to spend MORE than the Department of Defense thinks we need to secure the country. That's an even worse deal.
Even if you choose to move your assets/business to a country that spends a lot less on military, you're likely benefitting indirectly from how much the US spends on military (assuming it's an ally and the world is stable, that might not stay true in the next couple of decades).
Unless you're arguing to pay for a private security firm to secure your assets, then maybe you can pray we get to a Mad Max style future where it makes sense to do that.
Or you're suggesting it can be bypassed by buying cryptocurrency, which is secured by other means than government might. If that's the case then I'm on board with that thinking.
If your main argument is 'I want all of the money I spend in taxes to solely be spent on securing my assets, so reduce my taxes!' then that's ignoring the other government services those taxes provide.
Yet property taxes are very common throughout the US. Would you make the same arguments to eliminate property taxes? If not, why are capital gains any different?
I suppose because property values are considered to be more stable than, say, GameStock puts. But you raise a good point, that what we're talking about (really) is a "how we should tax _wealth_" vs "how should we tax _capital gains_".
Capital gains clearly represent a change in your wealth, and are somewhat "income-like". But they also are a persistent thing that you are in control of until the time of sale, and are somewhat "property-like".
It seems plausible that we could come up with a reasonable-scheme for capital gains taxes that manages to accommodate both properties, but I think it'd take a fair amount of consideration to make sure that there aren't nasty edge cases, and the benefits outweigh the additional accounting.
You may have just solidified my opinion against property taxes :)
Seriously, evaluating and setting values for property takes a lot of resources at the city/county level... it would take a massive increase to properly evaluate wealth for taxation, because so much of it is completely intangible and abstract.
Unless you are a large corporation / billionaire yourself, in which case I apologize, yes it works for you.
However, when discussing the various symptoms of this fundamental malady, as we are ITT, it's often useful to take the marketing at its word. It would be nice if our IRS were created and operated in the interests of justice for the vast majority of Americans. Let's imagine how that might be, and see how far the actual falls short of the ideal. The quicker we see USA as it is rather than how it has been sold to us from birth, the quicker we'll figure out something else marginally less awful.
There are any number of principled reasons to oppose paying taxes to USA government, but "I'm rich and I can afford the lobbyists and tax attorneys to make the system work for me" is not among those.
For liquid investments that have a well-agreed-upon market value, that wouldn't be a problem above a moderate wealth threshold. In particular, it should be easy to obtain credit against these securities (if necessary/desired) to pay the tax bill.
The loans would be very secure, since by definition they would have appreciated more than the taxes owing. And if the current offsetting-loss notions are retained (e.g. losses can be carried back to offset prior gains), if the securities fall in value then the taxes paid would be refunded, providing another way to repay the loan.
In the meantime, you'd avoid a current inefficiency of the tax system that encourages people to hold on to subpar or undesirable investments to avoid realizing taxable gains. The entire cottage industry of deciding which investments are "tax efficient" and should be held in taxable versus tax-sheltered accounts should go away.
I’m not sure how you’d write a matching tax provision but there should be something. Maybe the answer is to rely more heavily on VATs as Europe does.
2. Isnt this unfairly in favor knowledge businesses where there is tremendous value but no real MtM? So a private accounting firm with lots of clients gets no real MtM while a farm with physical assets gets a high MtM that is taxed.
For example, let's say you own a car with an appraised value of $25,000—meaning that you could buy one similar to your for that price (more or less). So you declare the taxable value to be $25,000 and pay the corresponding tax, and then right before you leave for an extended road trip someone decides that they would rather have your vehicle than one from a dealer and makes you an offer for $25,000 which you cannot legally refuse. Now you're without a car and scrambling to buy a replacement and get it registered, insured, packed, and ready to leave on short notice. Your plans are disrupted and the new vehicle, while "equivalent" to the one you had before in terms of factory specs and general condition, just isn't the same as the one you had carefully maintained and customized to your liking.
In practice people would need to over-declare the value of any property they didn't want to sell, which effectively makes this a tax on how attached people are to specific items and not a tax on their "fair" market value. The situation becomes even worse if the owner has enemies willing to over-pay for the item purely out of spite.
One of the fundamental rights of ownership is the right to choose not to sell, no matter how much someone offers.
If we think that "everyone" will have to "overdeclare" in such fashion, then obviously the government is collecting more revenue than it intended and will lower the tax rates to compensate, so in the end, you'll pay the same dollar amount in tax on your $26,000 car as you would have on your $25,000 car.
So, such a system would work fine. Particularly for property taxes, which are currently the subject of much scamming (apartment buildings in NYC being valued at a few percent of their actual market value, for example).
If everyone over-declares by the same amount, sure. But not everyone will. It depends on how much attachment one has to a specific item, how much risk there is that someone will attempt to take it, and how painful or inconvenient it would be to lose it. And you're ignoring the point about being vulnerable to motivated individuals willing to pay above-market rates purely to cause trouble.
You get to declare a reasonable value, and if someone wants to buy, but you're not willing to sell at that time, the insurance company negotiates a substitute payment, and works that cost into your retention rider rate going forward.
Piss someone off? Maybe they'll just come in and buy your house. Cherished one of a kind item? Jeff Bezos likes it, so it's his now. Property developer wants to build something on your land? Get ready to move, no questions asked.
Any item must be purchased at a +30% premium over the recorded value with that extra 30% going to the state if a sale occurs. So if you did want to hold onto something, you would declare a higher value and get paid extra.
Inflation seems like a pretty efficient wealth tax… and if the money is distributed fairly as a UBI that would cancel out the benefits that the wealthy have vs regular people to protect against inflation.
If we eliminated the charitable "Foundation" dodges that the super-rich are using, then I think we'd see many fewer people playing this game.
Opinions may differ, but one major point is that our tax system is a joke.
If we can put a movie about flying humans to the moon on Netflix, why can't we implement a tax system that isn't a Byzantine train wreck?
Because the people with power (money) like it this way. They aren't interested in what is fair for everyone, they are only interested in what they can get away with.
The rich can afford to hire a team of lawyers and accountants to navigate the tax system, and pay almost nothing. But they have to keep the fiction up that they are paying tax by having their "on the books" tax rate be non-zero.
The Hong Kong tax code is about 250 pages.
because of lacking political incentives?
It's not exactly the same with non-business tax rates but it's not that far off either - see the deduction for SALT.
I used to think this too until my wife inherited some stocks from her grandmother. Turns out the strike price is reset when you inherit and you dodge all of the capital gains tax.
This turned out to be a major win for us because her grandmother had acquired the stocks when she worked for AT&T back in the Ma Bell days and had not paid attention to them for 50 years. The paperwork was a complete mess and we had zero idea what the strike price would have been on stock she got as part of her normal income some time in the 50s and had been split up and recombined so many times in the mean time.
However, a lot of people:
1) never plan to cash out.
2) know that tax rates are fickle and plan for a day when there will be extremely low tax rates - just like for companies to "repatriate" their profits - and hope that they can in the future realize with little-to-no profits (although, I doubt capital gains tax rates will go much lower, and might actually go MUCH higher).
Anyway - the difference before you realize is >13% over 10 years (and the higher the rate of return is, the bigger the difference - it's >17% with a 10% per year return, which is historically average for the extremely wealthy according to Piketty).
Here's the sheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dZ6h0s2lZBp0fM6Z2w1K...
This strategy isn't really popular unless you have a networth of greater >$20M. It's particularly attractive, because you get $40k in untaxed capital gains per year - which is roughly what you need to pay the interest on your "borrowed" / "pretend unrealized" capital gains. And, the added benefit is, the interest IS TAX DEDUCTIBLE!
I'm totally supportive of "taxing the uber wealthy"... But govt needs to take the long approach on this. Eventually, people die and inheritance kicks in. That's where these generational mega wealth transfers that don't do much good for society can be mitigated.
The document leak probably has a banal explanation. Some insider with access to the documents...
Luckily US cannot police other countries (not that it didn't try) to prevent people from taking advantage of more competitive tax regions outside of US.
US obsession with taxing people and businesses to the ground is a strong contributor for so much capital escaping US.
It seems like ProPublica is trying to continue to lay the groundwork for a wealthtax campaign by fomenting further rage around the inequalities of US tax system.
Aside from that I have deep concerns about the source of this information and why it was used. Seems like IRS taxes have been weaponized and are readily available. Everyone should be deeply concerned about how ProPublica got this information.
That depends on what you mean. The US government (and a lot of US citizens) think that the tax on money Apple earns on selling iPhones in Europe belongs to the US, not France. But I feel if an iPhone is sold in a French building by a French person to another French person, with money transfered between two French bank accounts, all of that in French society, that that tax money belongs to the French and the US needs to keep its grubby paws off of it. No bullshit 'if you bring it back in the US we will forgo half of the tax on it and protect you internationally from the fallout'.
If anything, he's sort of a curator of the wealth for everyone in the Amazon world. Yes, he's able to live very well, but the simple value of his unsold shares doesn't capture his true ability to buy things.
But this article is all about hating on the rich and imagining that it's all perfect for them. They don't want to talk about the times when the stock falls and the once rich turn into very poor.
Remind me when that's ever been allowed to happen in the past 10 years. At the first sign of any market trouble, the default Fed response is OMO and cutting interest rates to shore up the markets. Stock prices can never fall even if the actual economy is in the shitter.
There is no way to predict somebody’s net worth and all the lists are wrong. There are only a few public things and they are all snapshots in time that assume it’s still true forever. An actor on a big movie? The list will say “we estimate they made 20 million, lets list them as a net worth of 20 million forever”, a non obfuscated real estate property record either in someones name or linked to them? Okay we are counting that. Aside from that they are just counting shares of public companies that large % holders are required to disclose. Outside of those slivers you’ll still never know if they were a savvy and passive investor in other public equities just like you are trying to be. You’ll never know if they made 1,000% more on tech stocks. You’ll never know if they assigned shares and cash to a charitable organization they control. You’ll definitely never know what subsequent trades the charitable organization made.
But even without pointing at charities: Hedge Funds, VC and Private Equity firms are not reported nor are any business interest. These things can pay out arbitrarily and also have large amounts of funds in any limited partners name.
I would be incredibly surprised if anyone who had that kind of access to IRS returns (ie searchable database for everyone) would leak the 25 top earners. It does add up for the career risk to take that risk on especially as its not leaking anything illegal just shining a light on the injustices of the system.
From their other article, https://www.propublica.org/article/why-we-are-publishing-the...
“We do not know the identity of our source. We did not solicit the information they sent us. The source says they were motivated by our previous coverage of issues surrounding the IRS and tax enforcement, but we do not know for certain that is true. We have considered the possibility that information we have received could have come from a state actor hostile to American interests. In particular, a number of government agencies were compromised last year by what the U.S. has said were Russian hackers who exploited vulnerabilities in software sold by SolarWinds, a Texas-based information technology company. We do note, however, that the Treasury Department’s inspector general for tax administration wrote in December that, “At this time, there is no evidence that any taxpayer information was exposed” in the SolarWinds hack.“
i would trust the gates foundation to use money 1 million more wisely than the government just wasting it
Probably familiar to many of you, but I have my coke and mentos moment while I read it, in 2021. Here is a link to archived pdf, for others like me
https://web.archive.org/web/20210112042733/https://www.lopp....
By far, the greatest increase in wealth (and inequality) is due to capital gains.
> [...] capital gains are eventually taxed
Normally, one might sell assets before a decline, and at that point gains (and therefore taxes) may be realised.
This is avoided by HODL stock in holding companies (such as Berkshire Hathaway) which can rotate assets without ever incurring capital gains (or indeed income).
I don't get how do they pay the loan off though, without paying taxes on the money used to pay off the loan. How does that work? Any loan I take out, I'd have to get income and then use my income to pay off the loan.
As long as the asset value doesn’t drop, you never have to actually repay the loan with your own cash (at least, not until you die or you sell the asset).
Politicians have them as well. Their foundations rarely if not ever cater to their stated mission. Instead, politicians use them as legal bribery vehicles.
One little trick here is to take out huge loans using things like stock holdings as collateral.
You're not paying tax on the money, and you can pay it back a bunch of difference ways that can limit how much you pay.
There are nuances to this, it's not as straight forward as I mentioned, but that's the general idea.
Isn't it the point that wealth creates more wealth? and the more you have the more you can make? thus not paying taxes leaves you with more to play with?
Maybe in different parts of the US this varies, but should the taxing authorities get more money because the real estate market is hot and do they take less when real estate values are down?
Especially fun for old people living off their pension in their family home with large, attractive gardens in areas which were way outside town but now, some 50-60 years later, has become highly attractive...
https://www.oslo.kommune.no/skatt-og-naring/skatt-og-avgift/...
They can only talk about minimum Corporation Tax...
What a joke.
The author(s) explicitly do NOT conflate these and point that out several times.
"The results are stark. According to Forbes, those 25 people saw their worth rise a collective $401 billion from 2014 to 2018. They paid a total of $13.6 billion in federal income taxes in those five years, the IRS data shows. That’s a staggering sum, but it amounts to a true tax rate of only 3.4%."
Income taxes paid divided by increase in net worth, how is this NOT conflating?
No one's definition of 'true tax rate' is calculated this way.
its part of the far rights end around democratic decline.
4. Divorces are being initiated to show expenses and "reduce" wealth ;)
It's the dumbest thing I've ever heard of when I first looked into taxes when thinking about getting married. We seriously thought about not getting married on paper because of it.
I imagine it's not a super common problem in the general population. But for the HN demographics, two high earning bay area tech people getting married is pretty common, and they'll often be hit with the penalty.
how do American financial statements show "wealth"? i read the article but i don't understand. if my personal balance sheet was $ 1 at the start of the year and by the closing, i say my capital balance is now $2, that means i got the balance through some earning so that is what is taxed. why the half assed approach to delay till final sale? accrual is an accounting word. isn't it?
Delaying until final sale encourages people to keep money in the market. Money in the market is, ostensibly, providing a value to society as good; probably better, than anything government has ever done.
The distinction is "wealth as personal consumption" versus "wealth as resource allocation."
The former is something that only benefits the wealthy person. The latter is something that already benefits society.
Wanted to post exactly the same comment.
We are yet to develop an appropriate terms, that are _widely_ understood that describe the problem in details.
Personally, I don't see the problem with "rich getting richer". I see the problem with poor getting poorer. It seems it is waaaay more complicated then the simple tax the rich
Even a rich person's consumption "benefits society"* by stimulating the economy. Their spending is someone else's salary or profit margin.
*Leaving aside that most consumption is a negative for the environment.
Capital gains taxes in India appear to work the same way as capital gains taxes in the United States[0]:
> Simply put, any profit or gain that arises from the sale of a ‘capital asset’ is a capital gain.
The tax is only incurred at the time of sale. If you don't sell anything then your accountant will report $0 in capital gains, even if the value of your assets (on paper) has increased.
If you are invested in a mutual fund then (at least by US rules) you may have reportable short-term or long-term gains despite not actually selling any shares due to trading activity in the fund; the taxes are passed through to the fund's investors. However, this is unrelated to any change in the value of the fund's shares.
If I sold it before 1 year of holding, I'd pay $1 in taxes (the gain) at my top tax rate based on my other income. If I sell it after 1 year I pay tax at a reduced rate on the total gain.
That's the point though. This is a tax on income, not wealth. And, until you sell the asset, it's not income.
The market value of an asset goes up and down all the time. There is only an actual gain or an actual loss when that asset is sold. That's the appropriate time to tax (and that's also when the person is sure to have the cash to pay any tax since they have just sold the asset!)
Imagine someone poor, having bought a small house in a sketchy neighborhood for not much. Imagine this neighborhood now becoming really fancy with hipsters moving in. With your system, the person would have to basically sell his house just to pay taxes on gains that didn’t translate into anything in his real life.
The way that property taxes work in California is more similar to Capital Gains in the US where your taxes are based on the sale price (although imposed continually, not just when a transaction occurs). The net effect of this is that you have neighbors with effectively identical homes who pay a full order of magnitude difference in property taxes every year (i.e. 2k vs 20k). [1]
Also, that scheme of taxation just further advantages the very wealthy and discourages investment anyway.
https://cleartax.in/s/capital-gains-income
https://home.kpmg/xx/en/home/insights/2011/12/india-income-t...
Not if you never sell. At death the "basis" is reset to the current market price. All those capital gains accumulated during a lifetime are never subject to capital-gains tax.
There is currently a proposal to eliminate this loophole which was originally intended to deal with the difficulty of determining the history of a dead person's assets. Obviously this doesn't apply to the extremely rich with accountants, lawyers and financial advisors.
1. Capital Gain taxes are delayed until you actually sell the stock.
2. Corporate taxes are being reduced because companies are moving profits to foreign jurisdictions.
3. Estate taxes & income taxes are being avoided by the creation of charitable foundations.
The 2nd and 3rd points are very valid, and I wish the author had spent more time on them. Unfortunately instead, the author spends much more time on point 1, conflating wealth with income, and avoiding the obvious argument that capital gains are eventually taxed - the rich are not escaping that.
...unless point 3 (foundation) occurs. And that should be the main story.
Squabbling over a wealth tax is not useful. The real issue is that the super rich create these personal "foundations" that act as never-taxed income holes, and then use them as personal and political tools.
In total, there's nothing very revealing about this article. It's everything we've already known. IMO, we need to curb foreign tax havens, and severely limit tax exemptions for charitable donations.
A more interesting question is how did ProPublica get a copy of Jeff Bezos' tax returns. Seems like a leak at the IRS?