Just because the person is not a sympathetic figure doesn’t mean it gives people the right to leak this kind of info, be they Bezos, Clinton, Soros, Koch, Gates, etc. get them on actual evasion if they have.
Otherwise what’s the purpose, rich people use tools to minimize their taxes? Ok, publish what the tools are and promote change in the tax code.
This is the obvious consequence of a system that feels unfair and unresponsive via normal channels.
The rules outlined in the article apply to everyone, not just the rich, and they should be fixed for everyone, not just the rich.
In this case leaking Jeff Bezos' tax returns targeted one individual and provided no new useful information. It's exactly what we already expected about his taxes.
...and frankly, the "rich are evil - look how they don't pay taxes on unrealized gains" is a huge distraction from fixing the actual problems with the tax system.
We need to eliminate foreign tax havens, and severely limit non-profit "Foundations".
Assuming people find this information objectionable that’s a reasonable justification to publish. In much the same way that leaking classified documents about questionable activities is morally justified, though illegal. Otherwise stamping secret on any evidence of say torture would work.
So this is more about shaming the witch rather than showing the witch did witchery.
the Watergate leaks?
Snowden's leaks?
the Pentagon Papers?
and a lot of less famous leaks of restricted information that have led to exposure and sometimes even justice for people who otherwise would have hid behind "legal" defenses for immoral or flat out illegal acts of their own?
I served in the Navy - I had a prety high clearance just to do the job I did. I know the value of classifying or otherwise restricting information. And I know the value of breaking those rules to expose those who would hide their crimes.
I consider the current tax code a recipe/playbook/script for stealing from the American public.
It’s simple some vigilante having a vendetta against someone they don’t like and using illegal mans to skewer them.
The case they have is known. We know the loopholes. Let's as close them. Don’t go out on personal or vendettas of virtue when it aids nothing. There is nothing new here. Jeff, as much as I dislike his company, didn’t commit a crime.
If the leak's target did nothing illegal or unethical with their taxes, then how are they being skewered? Their taxes would just show them to be an upstanding, law-abiding citizen, right?
So sure, you can claim all you like that we already knew about these holes, but abstract arguments and aggregate data are far less persuasive and motivating than specific examples that clearly show the stark reality.
Or are you forgetting how the George Floyd video galvanized a world-wide movement despite everyone already "knowing" that racism is bad, that it exists, that police training is subpar and that bad cops kill people of colour?
As if Twitter and all other social media media weren't about taking things and reframing them to make targets into bad people.
Like it or not, they created it.
Should we extract more taxes from them, yes, arguably. But we don't have to resort to blackmail or other underworld tactics since it really accomplishes nothing other than momentary outrage by the mob.
Get congress to enact laws that close loopholes.
Either by inheriting it or some business arrangement where you keep value created by other people. Bill Gates for example didn’t code Windows 7 himself. JK Rawlings didn’t print millions of Harry Potter books or even produce the movies etc. Sorts superstars don’t build stadiums or collect ticket sales etc.
This is most obvious with investments dividends. As such thinking of capital gains as the fruit of their effort is really kind of a silly idea.
And we do that by exposing the problems of the existing system and galvanizing people to demand change. Which is what these articles are doing.
I myself would like Jeff to pay more in taxes. I think the super wealthy pay too little in terms of parentage, but I should be upset with the Congress/IRS not the wealthy.
Really, it’s not a question of laws but one of obligations to society as a whole. Because society and the government are different entities but society depends on it’s government.
Wait. What who already knows?
I'm willing to bet that a lot of people who read this article did not already know the information contained within.
As such the article serves to educate a lot of people, which is a positive development.
That something is legally within the bounds of the US tax code is public knowledge.
That ultra-wealthy utilize something to an extent is not public knowledge.
Which cuts to one of the central issues with viewing the US tax code as democratic: there's almost no transparency of use.
The public might feel very different about a particular tax rule if they knew small businesses primarily used it, vs if they knew major corporations used it to shield 90% of their profits.
The IRS should do a better job of anonymizing actual tax reports, and reporting out on patterns in aggregate.
The problem with that argument is who get to make that decision? Would you still be saying that if someone leaked you tax records to the general public?
I completely agree with your overall point, but this statement is not true. Solid concrete evidence of what we "already expected" _is_ new information. (also, as other commenters have pointed out - what _you_ already expected is not necessarily what the average person already expected)
I think when he owns the Washington post, it becomes of the public interest.
Hell, in Norway literally everyone's salary is public information. Hasn't seemed to do them any harm either.
or more succinctly:
“We need to condemn the families and businesses in places like those tiny island nations in the Caribbean to more poverty”
Those tax havens exist because they realize that a very real thing they can offer as a service is a place to domicile a business and capital. Not everyone wants to go to Ireland for its nice beaches you know.
Google's only presence in Bermuda was a P.O. box.
Similarly, when Caribbean nations sell citizenship to foreigners seeking easier travel or tax optimization (another avenue they have explored into order to diversify their economies), the foreigner typically pays a fee in the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars for the passport, and that goes into the national budget.
Plus all the other things on top that are associated to flying in to Bermuda for the week of business to setup your PO BOX.
Oh and then there’s the airport, staff to maintain the airport.
All that plus more for a simple PO box
They are taking it upon themselves outside the law to settle disagreements, but they want to leverage new laws to make taxes more aligned with their policy (but obviously they are okay with ignoring other parts of the law —that’s a disconnect).
Would it be a disconnect to illegally oppose an immoral law - like, say, the legal protection of slaves as property - while simultaneously wanting to pass laws that you expect people to follow - like, say, making slavery illegal? Probably not.
It's inaccurate to treat obedience to the law as a moral act. It can only be moral because the law itself reflects moral attitudes. Wherever there is a disconnect between the law and morality, it is the law that bends - which is exactly why laws can be rewritten in the first place.
If you want these things to stop, you need to change the incentives that people operate on. Anything else will be like trying to plug holes in a dam with your finger; locally effective at best.
The total harm of stealing billions from the public dwarfs any concern for the thieves' privacy.
They are following the law, sure... the unfair law they pay for to their advantage.
If you earn $100 a week and tax withholding let you have $80 to yourself. That $20 didn’t belong to the government. It belonged to you. You however, having entered into an implicit agreement with society agree you will part with your money and give it to the government (which is different from its being theirs). Now, if you donated some of the $100 to charity or whatever and reduce your tax liability, that’s not “theft”. That’s part of the initial implicit agreement.
What proportion of Americans have a federal income tax liability of zero or less? (Yes, some Americans get paid to file taxes, via "refundable" tax credits)
I believe it is around 42%.
What proportion of the top income earners pay 80% of Federal income taxes?
Our system is overall quite progressive. To complain that the five or so people mentioned in the article "only" paid billions in taxes over a five year period is a bit nonsensical.
I hate paying taxes.
But I'm honest about what I'm buying for my money -- the broader community I live in and happen to like and care about.
Yes, it is, overall: https://theintercept.com/2019/04/13/tax-day-taxes-statistics...
> Once you factor in the regressive nature of social security taxes
Social security is effectively a mandatory pension scheme where you get benefits at retirement based on what you paid in, so calling it a regressive tax seems inaccurate.
> and average sales taxes
Many states have exemptions for essential goods to limit the regressive nature of sales taxes, but yes they are regressive overall.
> you quickly see that the rate of taxes paid on all income remains fairly consistent
I'm not sure what your definition of fairly consistent is, but your first sentence is incorrect above, so it's probably not accurate here either.
> up until you get to people with a net worth in tens of millions plus who pay a much lower percent rate.
This is absolutely true, and is something that should be addressed in my opinion. Just taxing capital gains as income would be a great start, and might be enough.
It was millions over the period of 2014 to 2018. Not that I disagree with your overall point.
Bezos did almost pay $1b himself though. In total the people in the article paid under $2b.
Also, another 13% of Americans make less than $12/hour, with many of them working under 30 hours a week. Roughly how many of those people, in your opinion, should have a federal tax liability?
Yelling at people for properly taking legal deductions, when you yourself take deductions on your taxes, reeks of hypocrisy and being mad because Joey got a cookie and you didn't.
You mean because Joey took his allowance and bought the supplies for a lemonade stand, took the money made from that to buy the ingredients to make cookies, then took the time to bake himself cookies.
It's strange that people find a person who creates & grows a company and who pays hundreds of millions of dollars in legally required taxes detestable. Yet a person who fails to gain the basic education that is free to them, who has no ambition, who is literally a drain on society, cannot be criticized. It's astonishing to me that society accepts and allows people to not have a least a high school education.
I wonder what the response would be to an article about how trillions in taxes are not paid because there are millions and millions of people who simply don't develop their personal capital and make decent choices that would result in them earning more and paying more in taxes.
There are guys in Hyderabad right now in conditions worse than US homelessness learning Python, devops, cloud, virtualization, you name it because that's how they can survive.
I know people in fairly poor countries with terrible crime rates and bad job prospects, and I have never heard them complain about how hard life is. They figure out how to get out of their situation and improve their life.
The idea that someone else has to fix your situation because life is hard has to be one of the most crippling mentalities you could have. The sheer amount of opportunity we have in the west is unprecedented in human history; instead of crying about the fact that your stable job of 20 years is ending, yes: I'm going to say that it is fundamentally you that has to pivot (even if it would be nice if the government helped).
This story is about how the very few extremely high earners use sophisticated personal finance strategies to minimize their tax burden. On the other hand huge numbers of people use the unsophisticated strategy of not developing any significant skills or education and not earning much money resulting in not paying any net taxes. Not talking about the super poor who earn nothing, but people who earn $30,000-$60,000/year. At the end of the day, they are not net tax payers.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/angr4k/what_i...
My entire thesis is that vigilante leaks like this are a product of the perceived unwillingness of the legislature to deal with the abuse of tax loopholes or to tax the rich at anywhere close to the rate that the overwhelming majority of voters want. If my theory is correct, then saying “talk to your legislator instead” is almost hilariously tone deaf, given that these leakers are probably taking actions into their own hands in response to a belief that their legislator is lazy or corrupt.
More broadly, my point is that singling out individual actors is an ineffective way to stop stochastic law breaking. Decry and punish individual law breakers all you want, but don’t expect it to stop until you at least triage the underlying causes.
The bureaucrats are functionally accountable to nobody. This leak was instigated by a bureaucrat.
Fuck the bureaucrats.
That’s the theory, yes. I do not believe this to be true in practice however.
Bothered by "internet mobs?" Look at the underlying issues.
I mean one is about basic rights the government owes us, the other is about us wanting the government to take more from particular people.
The civil course is slower but the alternative is typically bloody revolutions or Hongweibings, both of which set back societies.
How do you think most of the rich stay on the good side of the law? They have much more direct access to legislators via mechanisms that should be illegal, but are not because they pay to protect them.
Laws take political capital to pass, and without public outrage, you have zero political capital to take the first step towards reform. Any attempt to pass laws that increase transparency will be quashed, because you have no political capital to do so, and people taking advantage of this have a huge interest in squashing them, so they can keep operating in secrecy.
I'm not shilling some weird conspiracy, here. This is exactly the purpose behind ag-gag laws. [1] Thanks to them, the public can't make an informed decision on whether or not illegal activity should be prosecuted or investigated, or whether or not currently legal activity should be made illegal.
This is a similar situation, except that the financial stakes - and the incentives for secrecy - are about a thousand times greater.
Publishing an actual example of how these tools are used is a perfect way to explain what they are and how they're exploited. Bezos is rich enough to be untouchable, so what's really the concern here?
It's clear at this point that extremely wealthy figures should expect reduced privacy rights when it come to their wealth because it serves the public interest.
You're basically arguing that the public shouldn't be aware whether a person owns a nuclear weapon because they bought it fair and square and "privacy".
For example, knowing that the richest man in the world avoided paying $x billion in taxes using a loophole could insight change better than a theoretical story about how somebody could use these loopholes.
That being said, I'm still not sure if leaks like this are a good idea or bad idea. Just playing devil's advocate a bit.
I'm not saying we should not close loopholes. I'm all for that, but I'm not for willy nilly leaking illicitly obtained private documents that do not describe illegal behavior nor anything we didn't already know.
If you only condone taking legal courses of action, how would you go about opposing those billions and the leverage over the legislative process that brings?
It's all well and good to take a moral high ground and say no one should ever break laws, but when the laws are exploitative and the legislators are beyond real influence, what other recourse is there?
It gets substantially murkier, too, when you consider that much of the nominal valuation gains on their assets might be attributable to the dollar being essentially devalued vs hard assets.
What are they doing with the rest of the info?
That would work if people were purely logical. But people are not. Therefore the average person needs an anecdote, not data, to start caring.
I also think leaks about billionaire's finances are completely fair game. It's not that they are unsympathetic, it's that their finances are that important to the average person.
I’m sure some people donate their own money to Uncle Sam, but most people don’t and they are not required to.
The thing is that such leaks should help you realize that some things aren't crimes but should be.
Keep in mind that 200 years ago owning/buying/selling slaves was not a crime in the US. Yet nowadays we all agree that slavery exploitation is a crime.
Chances are actual downvotes are still from people who not only disagree with style but also with content, but when those are a minority a magic thing happens: people who agree with content but are at best neutral about the style see it in deeply faded grey and vote "it's not that bad", but only as long as it's deeply faded. The result of a most agree but don't wand to encourage surgeon reliably ends up a slap on the wrist "ca -1", no matter how many people voted. The mechanism works great.
(and it's also quite successful at keeping meta talk like this from escalating, I only feel that it's somewhat acceptable to write this now that the story has left the front page more than half a day)
The other issue I have is that not only is the provenance of this data unknown, so also is it's veracity. They don't know who gave it to them or why and thus they can't confirm it wasn't made up out of whole cloth.
We'd need some small adjustments to make them not useful for identity theft (remove SSNs, stop using specific values from them as authenticators for the IRS, etc.) but with that done, I think it would be a great improvement in transparency.
My public sector salary is already a matter of public record, and that has worked fine.
I'm for more aggregate data being made available as long as it couldn't be used to find one individual, and I'm okay with the IRS adding a checkbox for "make my data publicly available" as long as you could always uncheck it. But then I take privacy more seriously than many others do, not sure why.
I'd be happier if we greatly simplified the tax laws so that this extra data was not necessary. Not going to complain if they reduce the tax burden as well.
Edit: grammar
Some nice charts midway through this page: https://www.pgpf.org/analysis/cbo-warns-fiscal-path-is-unsus...
He has been straying into politics in DC very very heavily, and it looks like he's making enemies. I suspect that is also the reason we see near-daily anti-Amazon posts on social media.
I don't think ProPublica describes in exact specificity the scope of the data, other than it contains "the tax returns of thousands of the nation's wealthiest people, covering more than 15 years". And it includes Warren Buffett, Rupert Murdoch, Mark Zuckerberg, Larry Ellison, Mike Bloomberg, Carl Icahn, and Elon Musk — a group of guys who, along with Bezos, are not considered to be politically aligned.
If we were to guess and not be able to prove it, maybe it would be Bezos or regents, oligarchs, gangsters, opaque family trusts
Quite certain it is regents, oligarchs, gangsters, opaque family trusts.
The tax returns need some relative value to compare against to show effective tax rates. If most of that wealth is illegal and well hidden, it's going to be pretty difficult to compare a tax return against and get anything meaningful from. At least in these cases, the wealth is more glaringly obvious in the open and can be more reasonably compared to tax records.
https://www.voanews.com/usa/us-politics/terrible-crimes-made...
The ”human banking” method is very popular in transnational organised crime. Just look at how Putin has hidden his assets.
BT has a lot a negative press about its sports investments but Murdoch's sky doesn't
> A more interesting question is how did ProPublica get a copy of Jeff Bezos' tax returns. Seems like a leak at the IRS?
Yes the actual tax records are what make the story interesting, even if the data only confirms what “everyone knows” — at least there’s actual data and empirical analysis of the scope.
According to this accompanying explainer, the leak is anonymous:
https://www.propublica.org/article/why-we-are-publishing-the...
> A second question certain to arise is the motives and identity of the source who has provided this data to ProPublica. We live in an age in which people with access to information can copy it with the click of a mouse and transmit it in a variety of ways to news organizations. Many years ago, ProPublica and other news organizations set up secure systems that allow whistleblowers to transmit information to us without revealing their identity.
> We do not know the identity of our source. We did not solicit the information they sent us. The source says they were motivated by our previous coverage of issues surrounding the IRS and tax enforcement, but we do not know for certain that is true. We have considered the possibility that information we have received could have come from a state actor hostile to American interests. In particular, a number of government agencies were compromised last year by what the U.S. has said were Russian hackers who exploited vulnerabilities in software sold by SolarWinds, a Texas-based information technology company. We do note, however, that the Treasury Department’s inspector general for tax administration wrote in December that, “At this time, there is no evidence that any taxpayer information was exposed” in the SolarWinds hack.