News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by sokoloff on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:07AM (#27436174)
Can you imagine the day that you declare a value on your house and the following week someone much richer than you comes along and tells you to "beat it; I just bought this place!"
Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by ekelsen on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:23PM (#27438121)
One can imagine reasonable policies around things like housing, my original two line reply was not meant to detail all the ways this would for all types of assets.

I don't think anyone would have much of a problem with the simplistic scheme applied to rare art though.

Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by sokoloff on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:28PM (#27438186)
I do have a problem with that. I would prefer the Mona Lisa to remain in the hands of the Louvre than be regularly auctioned off. I would prefer American Gothic to remain in the hands of the Art Institute of Chicago, etc.
Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by ekelsen on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:48PM (#27438479)
Try to imagine a reasonable policy rather than assume the worst possible policy and then the outcomes that follow.

One can imagine that public charities or government assets for example are exempt from such a scheme (since they don't pay tax anyway usually).

Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by sokoloff on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:54PM (#27438564)
I’m trying to imagine the reasonably predictable response to the policy that you sketched out. Removing private property rights is not a casual undertaking I agree and would require substantial thought and care, perhaps too much to be practically workable.
Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by ekelsen on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:01PM (#27438645)
Your replies so far don't seem to indicate you gave much thought to how such a system would reasonably work -- as evidenced by the assumption that art owned by charities or governments (institutions which don't pay tax) would also be up for auction.
Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by sokoloff on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:02PM (#27438667)
You likewise don’t appear to have given a ton of thought to the logical responses that would likely occur from your proposal.

How long until some rich art collector starts a charity to hold their art and protect it from being auctioned?

Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by ekelsen on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:49PM (#27439253)
There are already laws that would make such abuse illegal. Abuse of charities is not a new problem.

I'm not a lawyer - but it seems like one obvious factor would take into account where the artwork purchased by the charity resides. Is it in a private residence? A freeport? Probably not really a charity.

Is it hanging on the wall in the Art Institute of Chicago? Might be fine.

Then the question is what happens if the charity tries to sell it back to a private collector at some future point. Might be allowed as long as back taxes are paid assuming some appreciation schedule.

I think the more general point is that policy is _hard_, and to assume that something doesn't work because you've thought about it for 2.5 seconds is probably a bad assumption to make. Most of our existing laws/policies would be similarly easy to attack if distilled to one sentence. There's a reason actual policy and laws are really long.

Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by sokoloff on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @07:46AM (#27446787)
Yes, policy is hard. That’s the exact same reason that when you think “it’s not that hard to find a price for a rare…”, you probably still have a lot more thinking ahead of you than behind you.
Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by ekelsen on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @01:30PM (#27450668)
That comment was meant to be taken in theoretical sense not that I had the text of a law ready to go into effect tomorrow. I'm well aware there's plenty more thinking to be done.

You however, seem to think that because you can find a corner case in a two line proposal, the whole thing has no merit.

Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by lovecg on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:03PM (#27436943)
Would do wonders for the Bay Area housing market! On a serious note, this proposal was originally coupled with a pretty radical (from our point of view) approach to land ownership. Land is closer to zero-sum than many other things (ignoring artificial islands etc.), so this forces a more efficient pricing/land use at the expense of doing away with private property rights for land.
Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by sokoloff on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:13PM (#27437962)
Worried that a competitor is catching up or threatening your market? Use your cash reserves to buy their factory out from under them. Don’t bother competing with Tesla, just make sure they can’t keep going once they get a little traction.
Re:IRS records reveal how the wealthiest avoid income tax by ekelsen on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:52PM (#27438525)
Imagine a reasonable policy rather than simplistic worst possible policy strawman. There are already many many laws that prevent abusive transactions in the current system, there's no reason that there wouldn't need to be similar laws to prevent abuse here either.