Delaying until final sale encourages people to keep money in the market. Money in the market is, ostensibly, providing a value to society as good; probably better, than anything government has ever done.
The distinction is "wealth as personal consumption" versus "wealth as resource allocation."
The former is something that only benefits the wealthy person. The latter is something that already benefits society.
Wanted to post exactly the same comment.
We are yet to develop an appropriate terms, that are _widely_ understood that describe the problem in details.
Personally, I don't see the problem with "rich getting richer". I see the problem with poor getting poorer. It seems it is waaaay more complicated then the simple tax the rich
Even a rich person's consumption "benefits society"* by stimulating the economy. Their spending is someone else's salary or profit margin.
*Leaving aside that most consumption is a negative for the environment.
Capital gains taxes in India appear to work the same way as capital gains taxes in the United States[0]:
> Simply put, any profit or gain that arises from the sale of a ‘capital asset’ is a capital gain.
The tax is only incurred at the time of sale. If you don't sell anything then your accountant will report $0 in capital gains, even if the value of your assets (on paper) has increased.
If you are invested in a mutual fund then (at least by US rules) you may have reportable short-term or long-term gains despite not actually selling any shares due to trading activity in the fund; the taxes are passed through to the fund's investors. However, this is unrelated to any change in the value of the fund's shares.
If I sold it before 1 year of holding, I'd pay $1 in taxes (the gain) at my top tax rate based on my other income. If I sell it after 1 year I pay tax at a reduced rate on the total gain.
That's the point though. This is a tax on income, not wealth. And, until you sell the asset, it's not income.
The market value of an asset goes up and down all the time. There is only an actual gain or an actual loss when that asset is sold. That's the appropriate time to tax (and that's also when the person is sure to have the cash to pay any tax since they have just sold the asset!)
Imagine someone poor, having bought a small house in a sketchy neighborhood for not much. Imagine this neighborhood now becoming really fancy with hipsters moving in. With your system, the person would have to basically sell his house just to pay taxes on gains that didn’t translate into anything in his real life.
The way that property taxes work in California is more similar to Capital Gains in the US where your taxes are based on the sale price (although imposed continually, not just when a transaction occurs). The net effect of this is that you have neighbors with effectively identical homes who pay a full order of magnitude difference in property taxes every year (i.e. 2k vs 20k). [1]
Also, that scheme of taxation just further advantages the very wealthy and discourages investment anyway.
https://cleartax.in/s/capital-gains-income
https://home.kpmg/xx/en/home/insights/2011/12/india-income-t...
how do American financial statements show "wealth"? i read the article but i don't understand. if my personal balance sheet was $ 1 at the start of the year and by the closing, i say my capital balance is now $2, that means i got the balance through some earning so that is what is taxed. why the half assed approach to delay till final sale? accrual is an accounting word. isn't it?