This here is about google, abusing their monopoly. So clearly not a good effect on society, but maybe a wake up call for some. And AI in general will replace jobs, can be good, can be bad, depending if those replaced find something more meaningful.
It feeds families, it gives people luxurious lifestyles. It provides incredible opportunities.
But it also ruins everything for everyone.
I could use any example where a beneficiary of literally any kind of service causes some real or perceived harm to some real or perceived group of people and equate it with corruption.
AI is a tool. It's massively useful and people pay for that. It's our economy that's broken.
No useful information is conveyed beyond "AI is bad for society" so I'd rather just mention that instead of bringing the loaded word "corruption" into it.
It degrades truth, quality, trust, and reliability. It feeds off the work of people who do things the correct way. People know there are big problems, but constantly point to short term benefit. People deride people who take a principled stand and say, "you think things were good before? Nothing's perfect, relax and enjoy it. Adapt or die." They laugh at people who try to do things correctly and say it's "impossible in this day and age."
But that does not automatically mean that those parallels stem from the nature of the AI technology. Corruption is related to moral or aesthetic or other values: someone does something for their own gain but which makes things worse in general (in moral, aesthetic, or some other sense). But AI is just a technology, and it is not clear that all its uses must lead to corruption. In fact, I believe that it is a technology that could cause a lot of good. If handled correctly.
Its corruptive effects are results of how our societies work; I don't think AI is to blame, we are.
Are you sure? Like, we learn most stuff just by doing it. If you delegate doing it to the LLM, how do you learn?
They help tremendously. Can explain concepts in your language, at your skill level. Can help you explore codebases, that might be outside of your deptph. Can visualize complex topics in seconds. Can create interactive tutorials on the fly. And I could go on and on.
For me, they help me with the unknown unknowns. There's so many technologies one can use for all sorts of things nowadays, just asking an LLM "what should I consider for the DB for this app" etc. opens my eyes on various things.
They can't, of course, teach you things the same way Neo was thought Kung Fu :)
What are you on? If you worked you presumably got a salary.
You and me both! I think though, it helps to separate out LLMs as a technology in themselves, and the prospect of increased technological dominance from a few small tech companies, as a result of that technology.
I'm a lot more enthusiastic about the first than the second, I suspect a lot or people are similar.
It results in a far more involved development process, which helps keep me in the loop but also has a big speed impact.
Not handing it all off to agents can trigger some FOMO. I'm not sure how long I can keep it up and still compete.
Also minor bit of feedback, on your webpage you use the term PKMS. I'm guessing it means Personal Knowledge Management System, but it could be helpful to define it in parentheses or explicitly.
Otherwise, the app looks interesting. I'm probably not the target segment as nowadays I'm building out a lot of my own custom systems that I find myself using day to day to have granular control of the system to make it super customized, but I could see it being interesting to people who currently use miro/obsidian/notion/etc.
Isn't it the goal of every player within a capitalistic game ? TBH I use to eat what bigFood teach me to at school, take the pills bigFarma lobbied my doctor with and consume whatever bigOil extracted. Sure, thinking is another field but it's not like we're not already sinking in energy, health and food distopia.
McCoy, Star Trek, 1968
But the centipede is LLMs training on LLMs regurgitations.
Of course it does. It the info in their archive is not up to date, then the AI output is first less reliable, then outdated, finally entirely wrong. With policies, rules, laws, processes etc. changing all the time, that won't take long. Then users will have to ignore the AI summary again, and look for human-input posts on reddit and other pages, like this one. But, this page, and reddit, too, it seems, are seeing less and less visitors lowering the probability of them being kept up to date.
Replace "Berlin" with anything else define: how can AI itself be a truly trustworthy source of such information?
LLMs excel at outputting answer-shaped feelgood.
That's a huge shift of power away from ordinary people.
But if people no longer have income and the AI promises come about in full, then who pays for the AI companies?
If your AI can give you the benefit without having to trade, you no longer need money. But even if your AI can do everything a human can, unless it can create something out of nothing, you still need land. Both to grow food and to extract resources. And you still need to defend your land.
But it's here now, and that's not going to change. There is too much to gain, and the wider public doesn't care. Or even understand.
But that's exploitative capitalism in general. Internalise the profits, externalise the damages to society. It was that way with environmental pollution and it's that way with AI. Governments aren't going to put a halt to it now. They're too afraid of 'losing the race' and the other guy is not going to play fair.
Again, engage politically and push for politicians that do care.
I don't think anything will be done until the lack of content will cause AI itself to become unstable due to lack of sources of information.
You phrase this as "absolutely" like it was this easy thing that people just need to realize it's within arms reach, but don't provide anything tangible to act on. In my opinion this is insurmountable task for a regular person.
Pay who? HN doesn't pay me for this comment. SO didn't pay the people who answered questions there. Reddit AFAIK doesn't pay commenters, and so on. People have been having their 'work' monetized by others for ages and were willing to accept fake internet points for that work. It feels a bit late to suddenly now say it's a problem.
Personally, I think it would be healthy for society go backwards and stop using social media. I just don't see that happening because people love the affirmation of others.
Nothing man-made is inevitable, but those in power love it when you think it is and just give up. A better world is possible, but they benefit when you believe it’s not.
I find this line if argument hilarious given how much time was spent arguing copyright infringement isn't stealing and "information wants to be free!" and intellectual property rights were corporate capture... when everyone wanted to pirate movies and games.
Sure came to bite these people back in the butt, didn't it.
1) to prevent programmers getting money from billionaires, we declare AI models "natural persons": https://www.courthousenews.com/coders-lose-appeal-in-copyrig...
(note: the "rights" the models would get from being considered natural persons, even from the same law, are denied to the models. For example, if any natural person, here including AI models, makes a work, it is now a crime for anyone else to claim authorship. So the obvious consequence of this decision, even just the one from the exact same law, that it is now a crime to claim AI produced work is your work, which would be a problem for billionaire companies, did not apply)
2) if it would mean billionaires getting money from authors, hundreds of millions of copyright violations are just forgiven, even illegal downloads. In fact congress itself violates the law making that OK: https://www.wiley.law/alert-Copyright-Office-Issues-Key-Guid...
(congress violated the law here by retroactively changing the law, because of course all the AI labs violated copyright law hundreds of millions of times (that's books only) before the law was changed. Congress cannot retroactively make that OK)
Note (Capitol Records v. Thomas-Rasset) when a kid violates copyrights "owned" by a billionnaire, the punishment is $222,323 per instance. The exact same punishment, what most people would call "justice", applied to AI models, would have bankrupted, OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, Meta, Microsoft, all of them. Because of the sheer amount of copyright violations they committed.
2addendum) if any other country doesn't agree with point 2, the US government will threaten them militarily AND the EU commission will threaten them economically. (A German court decided the opposite, and ...)
3) if it means billionaires want to keep "their" works out of online library lending, courts have judged that they get to do that EVEN IF THE LICENSE ALLOWED IT and IT OTHERWISE WOULD BE FAIR USE. It was judged fair use is NOT allowed if, after the fact, billionaire copyright owners decide it might harm their economic interests
4) The piratebay trial: Merely pointing people at copyrighted material, listing what is in a particular copyrighted work, got 2 years jail time and 6.4 million in damages
Can I just ask the question: how do you get courts to judge like this? Because when it comes to billion dollar company ideas ... if I can commit hundreds of millions of crimes to make them, I easily have 10 billion dollar company ideas. And of course Scam Allman, "all your jobs will now pay me instead" Amodei, and Google and Facebook, just risked it. How do I know which idea I can just risk?
When it comes to copyright crimes, what about making a Netflix, the one everybody wants, with AI versions that are near duplicates of existing works. Of EVERY existing work. From Casablanca to Snowwhite (after all both are public domain stories, so just change them slightly, and make a movie in the same style). That's a billion dollar idea. But of course, as soon as courts find Disney (who are a billionaire) suing someone like me, they will find some stupid law to misinterpret, some absurd excuse, to side with Disney. So how do I prevent that, and more importantly how do I know NOW that they'll do that for me, so I can get some investment?
I mean, all I'm asking is for courts to stand behind the "pro-AI" (but obviously really pro-billionaire) absurd judgements they've made before ... that's all.
Oh: in case it's not obvious, I'm not a billionaire.
If your work wasn't publicly available on the internet, that could not have happened. Why did you publish anything, if you didn't want it to be used by third parties?
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money
Feel? What do feeling have to do with it? It is a service being offered. Relatively fast T/s without having to own the hardware and pay for the cooling. How good the deal is is another question. But feeling? Have people grown so used to free services that we're talking feeling when it comes to paying a provider now?
It's not the paying, it's the fact that the "provider" stole the work without attribution.
The way I see it LLMs scrape websites (not prohibited by copryright or any other law) and are setup to regurgitate knowledge, not verbatim extracts.
Let's put aside for a momemt the reliability of this and potential hallucinations.
a way it is the same as writing a wikipedia article getting knowledge first from various publications, most of them being protected under copyright. The main difference being wikipedia encouraging sourcing while LLMs do not always cite sources but that isn't a requirement under any law anyway.
No theft or copyright infringement has been commited in the process.
Do we need new laws or taxes to retribute people being scraped and encourage people for providing knowkedge? Maybe.
Had creators known years ago that some company will take your content and sell it at a premium they would (probably) not have shared as much publicly for free. Another comment nicely said the social contract is broken, I agree.
And about Wikipedia, they don't charge for their service, it's a free encyclopedia that also requires attributions (maybe it's not enforced in all cases? but it is a requirement AFAIK).
Because 3 years ago, everyone had a reasonable expectation that any publicly available work would be appropriately credited and/or compensated for, in accordance with both copyright law and open source software licenses.
You realize that even very permissive software licenses, like MIT or Apache-2.0, still require attribution? Now a few companies are making big bucks selling your ideas (and sometimes verbatim code) without adhering to the terms of that license.
The social contract is utterly broken. The legal situation is utterly questionable. The only reason they get away with it is that the inmates are in charge of the asylum in the US.
Wait, because a party you don't like got elected, the whole judical system is also broken? I find that hard to believe.
If we are talking about application, ethical concerns then I think it fucking sucks.
The way I see it. This is the inevitable end goal of social media. The way social media grants instant gratification is the same way LLM's do just on a much larger scale. To me both of these things are connected.
We've been exploited by tech companies using fast feedback and this to me is another level of that.
But at the same time it hurts me more and more thinking about the massive data collection the AI providers have at this point. People are completely unaware of the gold in form of data we are sharing to these companies. And its what keeps their wheel spinning.
We can’t escape it. They are too powerful and because there is positive side effects as well, and they know it, there will always be a debate.
I feel that, the common mindset in software that you rarely see elsewhere, like in big pharma, is to open and give knowledge. But OpenAI, Anthropic absorbed everything and are not playing along. They should have continued giving free knowledge of everything as well. That’s only fair, but that’s just one way to see it.
It's really a tale as old as, well, western liberal democracy I suppose! We had a commons, then the commons were fenced in, and finally we were charged rent to access the thing we built, cultivated, sustained.
The digital era makes for some interesting new ways to fight back. Distilling models into open weights is one, liberating software through reverse engineering is another.
Who steals the goose from off the common
But leaves the greater villain loose
Who steals the common from off the goose
The law demands that we atone
When we take things we do not own
But leaves the lords and ladies fine
Who take things that are yours and mine
The poor and wretched don't escape
If they conspire the law to break
This must be so but they endure
Those who conspire to make the law
The law locks up the man or woman
Who steals the goose from off the common
And geese will still a common lack
Till they go and steal it back
(Seventeenth century protest song)
I mean, it's not even a long term "capitalist leaders" like you describe.
These companies have figured how to be at the edge, and how to stay at the edge a bit ahead of the others. What they have not figured out yet, is how to make a positive amount of money at the end of the quarter.
So, yes you now have the "we should impose a moratorium" (so we can stop paying so much to progress without risk of being overtaken), "we should stop open models or chinese models" (because if people realize deepseek flash can do 99% of their actual AI need how can we charge them triple), ...
But also, we're about to face the biggest rugpull ever, the MOMENT they think they have the conditions in place. Hell, they've has already tried several time, exclude the top model, make it way way more expensive, etc ...
In my expectation, governments who embrace AI and regulate on misuse rather than on protecting old structures will unlock access to the new value chains earlier on and get first-mover advantage. I hope Europe sees this instead of regulating us into pre-AI protectioninsm in an AI world.
There are so many opportunities to make the world better in line with the right-to-repair movement and their open data incentives. They were on the right track, I just hope they don't fall for the old money corruption, because that will cost way more to lower class people along the way than AI on its own ever would.
So many of the things that can be automated away don't really have higher-level value chains to move to. The value was other people reducing friction for you or presenting you with novelty. The AI-maximalist/old-money goals here are identical: don't have to pay a person for that.
It's obviously bullshit, because the American standard of living is based on extraction and exploitation elsewhere. If you make everyone rich, there's no gradient to exploit. If everyone everywhere does office jobs, who will work in the mines?
The AI trend is the pigeons coming home to roost. Oligarchs have extracted value from overseas, but now they also need to extract value from the underclass at home more aggressively than ever. The number has to go up.
I dont know what you mean here. AI is pushed by some of the most corrupt people on the planet. They are not "old money" either, they are new tech CEO, entirely comfortable with both corruption and tech feudal fascism.
And the last thing they care about are "lower class" people. They are in the process of getting as much power for themselves as possible and of pushing as many people as possible into lower class.
AI doesn't have to replace people, and it doesn't have to dumb us down. We need to do some economic re-modelling, otherwise capitalism will crumble and society will with it. I just don't see any other way, but I'm also terrified we will enter some dystopian Sam Altman Worldcoin reality where everyone has to scan their iris' to cryptographically sign anything uploaded onto the internet.
Either way, we have to get the balance right which will be very difficult... The alternative is terrifying.
I think you yourself are an example of this. The ideas that all regulation is harmful and that plucky upstart tech firms will save us were overly optimistic years ago, and now we know they aren't correct.
The danger is not old money corruption and protectionism; it's the new money robber barons of the tech industry.
How could you possibly know?
A government is supposed to represent its people. There is quite a wave of AI criticism, so governments should apply incentives to the good results and oppose/mitigate the bad results.
The problem is when governments are in bed with the big corps and stop representing their people.
Now go to https://xkcd.com/652/ lt used to be extremely accurate. Now I feel old.
Source : https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/652:_More_Accurat...
The people can, on increasingly rare occasions, make such a stink that they get something they wanted and the super rich have to make a concession. For a while at least, but then it always moves back.
I predict any new AI laws that come out of government (regardless of party in power) will have a spin about being good for people, but under the hood will be designed very carefully to further entrench the power of the existing players.
I wonder why we don't see other sob stories about businesses that go under every day.
I'm awaiting the blog post about Dominique Ansel Bakery that invented the Cronut, lamenting it's decline in sales due to other people selling Cronuts. Or all the casualties of the chicken sandwich wars.
Why do developers feel so entitled to have their work be able to fund their lifestyle indefinitely?
I personally don't care about any one website, I want to get information. This is obvious when you consider something like recipe websites that have long abused their users with long personal stories to just get a recipe and sleazy SSO abuses. Now I ask AI. We're all better for it.
If you want to add value and provide a better experience, do so. You still have your website. Get people to like your website enough that they bookmark it. But if you're providing simple info and just making users click into your website, you're not gonna make it.
This is 100% the "glory" days of AI. The price is subsidized by investors, thats going to ramp up and the product quality will dilute. Its the same long lived strategy of every great tech company that has VC returns to feed.
Cost of AI will get subsidized for 3-4 years while corporate america gets addicted, then pricing will ramp up and corporate ameria will be dependent. This has been said millions of times over.
It's hard to feel bad for them.
Scam sites flooding the internet with review listicles and now LLM slop and putting adverts in whatever channel will take them will do fine in this new world, and they will be your main source of information (mediated by AI). Are you sure you’re happy with that?
Small sites like this which provided local information with a human voice will simply cease, as nobody will visit them anymore. There is zero incentive to feed content to Google now.
There was a lot of arrogance. "Learn to code". "Things change". "Adapt".
To be honest, I never saw that as arrogance but rather as an answer to the utilitarian question of how to make more money.
I would never tell a skilled professional to learn to code if they can make a living wage and like what they do.
I do understand how that might come across as arrogance, I just think it is an unfair characterization.
Many of them are complaining about the fact that AI labs aren't playing fair ("stealing" content and code for training) and cutting costs to the potential detriment of service quality and security, but they didn't express the same level of concern about tech companies that "asked for forgiveness, not permission" when they exploited legal gray areas to build their businesses (the Ubers and Airbnbs of the world), used massive amounts of venture capital to engage in predatory business practices designed to undercut and drive out established companies, etc.
Also, there are businesses other than the ones you mention that would not be properly characterized by software-first. They don’t pay as much but you can make a pretty good living off them.
I really wonder what the marketing of Anthropic is doing and how they were not fired after the first “AI will take your job, and youre gonna be fucked!” claims to pump AI.
Any insider know how they can simultaneously make sweeping claims about the future of society and unbelievably tonedeath about actual society?
What does this comment even mean?
And therefore that a certain social group is finding out that the "it doesn't affect me" escape doesn't apply to them anymore.
Everything will be worse, except for the stockholders of the gatekeepers (and their owners).
And before anyone asks, I’m using AI heavily every day.
That site's business model is similar to the many paper magazines you'd get for free in tourist welcome centers, hotels and on the street. Companies (usually very small) who published those guides got replaced by the website. Some small publisher likely felt the same a few years ago.
A family member used to own a magazine about arts and crafts that went bankrupt because of Youtube channels and Internet articles - well before AI. It was a small magazine and profits were just enough to maintain a middle-class lifestyle. Random creators destroyed his livelihood.
You can try using laws and spreading the word against progress, but it's certain you'll lose in the end. I'm not saying it's not worth it because you may delay it long enough to give you time to settle elsewhere, but change will come against our will.
There is no progress here, only greed and destruction
For decades people fought against the media industry with some really good arguments about how music/film/software piracy doesn't deprive the original owner of their material so it's 'copyright infringement' and absolutely not theft. Now the same people will happily argue that since it's their work being copied and used, and they're losing out on the rewards and their jobs are at risk, now it's a heinous act of theft.
It doesn't work that way. People in the tech industry made some very clear statements about how copying is not theft, and we don't get to just take them back because we're all the victims now.
Copyright infringement is not theft, and copying some software to use for other purposes (e.g training AI) is very specifically allowed under some open licenses.
(I appreciate that this is a semantic argument that doesn't really matter very much.)
AI companies are the powerful taking from (and re-selling to) the weak. It's already dystopian and it's likely to get tremendously worse once they have become indispensable - they are not yet, at least outside of the SV bubble.
That's a fair argument while things remain stable but it falls down if things change.
AI companies have only really become powerful in the last few years, and they were taking the content a decade ago. The argument would only work if we either apply it retrospectively ("you took the content when you were weak, but now you're powerful so it's bad") or if we stopped anyone taking the content if they have the potential to become powerful ("you might invent AI in 10 years, so no content for you.") I don't see how that would work.
The only reasons LLMs are allowed is because big business thinks they will be able to get rid of much of their labour force AND because LLMs make it really hard to figure out whos copyright you are breaking.
So we are effectively in middle where copyright is more and more only for big companies and individual work is not gonna be protected.
Fine lets go all the way and kill copyright. Of course that won't happen.
It's interesting that we as workers apparently have to act inside the bounds of the law AND inside the bounds of our preferred legal structure (even though this was never turned into a law), while the rich and powerful are bound by neither.
Efficiency is one aspect of it. What we see is, one factor being made as the ultimate goal, pushing the human condition out of balance. The example of industrial revolution is great, as it resulted in the same out of control greed as we have today.
Why do you think those are mutually exclusive? History is full of greedy kings at the top of corrupt regimes. Is Putin’s Russia your role model?
Community is good and bad. You live in a low karen culture, cherish it, you won't like a high karen culture.
This gets repeated like a mantra, along with “survival of the fittest”, when we want sciencey-soudning justification for our bad impulses. No, efficiency is not survival, and natural process do not optimise for efficiency. They optimise for good enough.
Even human systems do not optimise for efficiency. Disproportionate wealth concentration and monopolies is not an efficient economic system in the abstract. It is efficient at wealth extraction. So, when we want to wax lyrical about efficiency, we should at least be honest: we’re saying that greed is good.
YouTube isn't a charity for creators. It's one of the biggest businesses in the world that takes enormous profits. While you can argue that certain large business models are better for society than others, it's still tech "destroying jobs".
Your analogies / examples do not cover this.
The core concern is that you are punished for creating useful information and putting it on the internet. Because if you do, it will be stolen by way of excessive AI traffic that makes you no money, while simultaneously suppressing human traffic that does.
So unless you are doing it entirely out of the goodness of your heart, and are also willing to effectively pay for Google and other AI overlords using your bandwidth, this information will disappear.
This is bad for everyone, but a confident AI will just slap together some random half truth from official sources that are required to be there, and that will be the new quality ceiling of information on the internet.
Having a page whose business model is talking about Berlin or restaurants might go away, but talking about Berlin or restaurants will not.
Think HN, we have plenty interesting discussions here out of the "goodness of our hearts", and I for one don't expect to profit from any contribution I might make when I post here.
What these changes are doing is killing the middle ground between purely hobbyist blogs and large companies websites. Blogs will remain because they were not making much money in the first place. Major newspaper will remain because they will find a way between subscriptions, sponsoring, and advertising. Everything in between is being overgrown by slop factories (this predates AI, but it is now completely unbearable) in a race to the bottom as they are displaced by Google’s AI (as if the bar was high in the first place). We are all losing.
There was a world before free information on the Internet, you know? Aside from the personal hardship of the site's owner, I won't shed tears for the ad-supported Internet. Not a droplet.
The only kind of free information ever available on the web was from small self-motivated authors and that will remain. They've don't feel "punished" if others, including AI, reads it. I have stuff online and I don't care if AI uses it.
If Google needs information for its AI, it better start paying for it. And perhaps a world of paid information providers will emerge.
If not, I'll be happy to keep the web hobbyists, forums like this one and paper books. Isn't that the old Internet we miss?
the "Theft" argument is just a bunch of people who'd otherwise hate copyright laws seething that they didn't get money from info that people'd otherwise never pay for.
When the internet displaced print media, that was done by individual creative people, not a large corporation (at least initially, today's YouTube is a different place). The person who used to write articles for a print magazine could learn the new skillset associated with online publishing, and apply their old skills and pivot to the new normal. It wasn't easy, but it was possible to survive.
But now, what options do we have? I'm not about to buy a data centre...
It’s so inevitable that Capital is pricing out personal computers and every IT-adjacent business is stuffing AI into their offerings in order to KPI-max to their managers. The top-down inevitability.
The OP claims:
> It will get worse. Last week, Google has made two announcements: AI-generated answers will replace search results entirely, and they have ads in them.
Yet more inevitability: Google will replace search results, that’s that. This is just progress.
On the other hand, people might like to get direct search results and be able to connect a person to their recommendations. It is possible. But it won’t, apparently, even be an option with Google soon enough. Because how to guerilla ads into other people’s websites? Much easier to guerilla them into AI “content”.
Also: Kagi (which has a good reputation here it seems) is a good search engine. How? By using Google’s services without the enshittification. More progress: the profit-maxing Google search engine is worse for the user, on purpose.
And all of this for what? No more original sources, no more authorship, no more talking to other people? This is progress?
Sadly it's very hard to build a search index in this era. You can't just run a recursive wget like it's 1994.
As someone once said: there is no alternative.
(Except that, of course, there are alternatives, they just really want you to shut up and stop trying to improve things for normal people).
It’s actually not. Tech progress is not happening in a vacuum. It’s accompanied by unprecedented inequity, corruption, monopolistic mega corporations, etc. Remove (or reduce) the cancer feeding on the technology progress and you may find it beneficial to us all.
When technology companies choose to take others information without compensation, what do you call it?
> Some small publisher likely felt the same a few years ago
Your analogy has no relationship to this situation. Unless you’re alleging small publishers, Work was stolen by websites and copied.
It's about the Google search page. Without Google, the website wouldn't have gotten any traffic in the first place.
Let's not go with wild speculation that have "your are a small fish and nothing without us" connotations.
If your livelihood depends on a thing, guard it.
Instead of attracting/relocating the talent, now their knowledge is copied and it benefits the entity copying (again overwhelmingly from one region) but no payments so the source that spent the resources doesn't even benefit in the form of few remittances. Atleast the recent post about Japanese hometown tax was one solution for the brain drain problem within a country.
Yes the knowledge resource is still there but due to the search monopoly, os monopoly, mobile duopoly and other reasons it is hard to compete for visibility or free packaging of the same.
I don't know what it is, but it feels like some implied social and/or political contract has been broken.
Isn't most work built on top of existing work? Regarding the example in the article, do you think OP opened an account at every German bank to compare them, or also relied on information from other people?
They keep reassuring us that alignment is a very important topic. Attribution and citation were the canaries in the coal mine, as one would expect an intelligence aligned with human expectations would deem those to be indispensable. They don’t give a damn about alignment, it is not a problem they are trying to solve.
Or will AI be the collapse of the corporation? Giving rise to millions of tiny companies providing incredible products and services through the use of AI? Or will it be the collapse of small businesses?
Or will AI be the end of digital content? Making it all meaningless as we drown in a sea of AI slop? Or will AI give rise to a new era of digital content never before imagined.
I have no idea. I have little hopes in the institutions in charge of all of this. I hope for the best, prepare for the worst.
Now that it impacts the bread and butter of smaller companies or individuals it becomes not ok.
I'd say that people have probably been delusionnal to expect making a living without charging money for goods or service.
Sure, there's some technical hurdles, like identifying who's actually using the info they read, but impressions are a thing in ad networks, then there's broader questions about evaluating what training data was useful and used to ultimately produce what token, I'm still just taking about the kind of ai summaries in search related to the article, seems doable with the same system we use for ad networks.
When it comes to coding and more generalized knowledge there's already been interpretations about copyright laws and fair use that seem to allow what oai and ant are doing and how they are capitalizing on it, doesn't mean we should rethink them.
I'm sure there are technical solutions that can be translated to this sort of issues as well that could be derived from ad networks, I mean, imagine a world where your code and your blog post get a score on their usefulness to train LLMs and you get a share of the revenue, wouldn't this be better for all players? they get good training data, we get paid for it.
https://x402.org can facilitate that, we just need forcing the Big AI to pay out.
The actual problem here is so weird that this doesn't actually work.
Consider something like Stack Overflow or Reddit. The people answering questions weren't getting paid to begin with, so you're solving the wrong problem.
And weirdly, the thing the AI summaries are doing is the thing sites like that have long been trying to do themselves. If someone has a common question that has already been answered, the AI summary answers it for them and then they don't show up to post the 5000th duplicate of the same question. It even lowers the operating costs of the site since then 5000 people don't have to load the same page.
Whereas if they have a question that hasn't been answered, there is nothing for the AI summary to summarize, so then the user isn't satisfied with it and proceeds to actually visit the site and post the novel question that hasn't been answered yet. In some kind of theoretical sense that should work. The site only gets used for new questions.
But it actually doesn't work, because it breaks an important part of how sites like that function, which is that the users vote on the answers. When you have the common question, you don't need to post anything new, but you upvote the correct answer, which gives the person answering the question a sense of accomplishment and lets them know that people value the thing they spent the time to write. And if you try someone's answer and it doesn't work then it gets downvoted and the low score lets other users know to be skeptical of it.
But if the AI summary shows the answer without the feedback mechanism then it breaks the site. The people who post good answers then can't see anyone interacting with them and feel like they're wasting their time, and if that happens the site is dead.
The question is, how do you fix that when "just show me the answer immediately" is actually the thing the user of the search engine wants?
Maybe there's technical solutions?
For sites like the one in the article the feedback loop and payment it's there with revenue sharing.
For web 2.0 (remember this term? Haven't used it in a while) you're right, the community building part is hampered by the LLM middle layer, but as you said if you're going past "just show me the answer immediately" and actually click on the site you may start to participate and this could actually improve the quality of contributors?
I kinda hate it but the "marketing funnel" is a valid model to apply here, and I'm sure there is an equilibrium to be found which benefits everyone, regardless of size and the kind of platform involved, history is not on my side here, but I need to be optimistic to keep being sane.
Yes I do have this feeling. I combat this by not paying a dime to the largest culprits (all frontier AI producers) and by recommending others to do the same.
If using AI on a large scale remains unprofitable then I hope the situation improves for everyone. The hardest part would be convincing large businesses not to use frontier AI either. Due to the large costs for businesses some have figured this out on their own already.
This capitalist machine's only concern is profit. People all around me have lost their purpose to do the job. Nobody really cares anymore and we can see the effects on that. For example the recent FAA disruption or bank outages are likely a result of this exact thing on a macro scale.
Personally I'm dealing with this by detaching. I no longer use big tech products (beside apple's). No youtube, no social media, no algorithmic feeds. I try to be very mindful of my LLM usage and to use it to learn (somehow). I decided to start my own product so that nobody can have any expectations of me.
I also pulled my money away from the AI bubble. I put everything in a global ETF (part of which is AI but I couldn't find one with less AI in it). I'm voting by not paying for this. I will ABUSE all these services like openai & anthropic and the moment they raise prices I'm gone. They can kindly have fun with the aftermath of the collapse.
The single most important thing they should be spending time on is UBI. If they are so sure they are building SI how come they do not understand that people are afraid? All these geniuses with the EQ of Zuckerberg can go to some other planet.
This industry did it onto themselves with "free and open source". Do hedge funds open source their proprietary software algorithms because "free software"?
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
They don't care and it is self inflicted.
> Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Software engineers slowly realizing that they are the new starving artists.
Free Software is actually remarkably similar to LLMs regarding its economic consequences for software, with a few important differences. It does make software cheaper to produce and it does redistribute economic value from the little guy to everyone. Two huge differences are that FOSS authors keep some control and recognition for their work, and that there is no third party jamming itself between FOSS producer and consumer, controlling everything. Maybe not for lack of trying on the part of GitHub...
Hm, not even close. If you only did relatively easy tasks that are well defined and don't have big change "radius", then maybe (never worked in such big companies and industries). But at my job I see coding part of the job that gained some speed, but all other aspects are more or less unchanged. Meeting with client, analyzing and planning, meeting with other members of the team, analyzing, planning again, and some more important parts of the software are still coded by hand. So maybe 20% of my job has gained a lot of speed (not 100% sure about that long term, because now making a decision about part of the app that was not coded by hand is not intimately known like it was before takes a lot longer or at least cannot be made on the spot but must be made by spending tokens). So yeah not even close.
P.S. Not to mention that there are cases where coding by hand is MUCH faster then using LLM
Then, it was the PC again, new "incredible" 4GL database software arrives, replacing the million-dollar database server with a small box that sat on the side of my desk.
Then, it was compilers. The incredible onslaught of devtools meant there were tons of new things to learn again. So, I did that. "No more command line C compiler for me!", I exclaimed, and launched Turbo Pascal and Turbo C and Delphi and .. yeah.
Then, Linux arrived, just when we all thought Unix was going to die and we need not keep learning new Unix things, except we do. Linux made the SBOM costs go way, way down, so .. some new things to learn, some old things to re-learn. So, I did that. (Oh, what a relief to go back to command line C compilers and things)
Then, the Internet revolution arrived, and nobody wanted fancy local native things any more - everything had to be done in this new technology, even if it wasn't quite ready yet, the world was moving in that direction and we had to learn it. So, I did that. And boy, did I ship a lot of things and many profits were made.
What came next .. oh yeah, mobile! iPhone this and Android that, and all the knowledge about how to write great user interfaces was thrown out the window to be replaced with Hot New Stuff™ that the kids were using, grandad! Catch up already, sheesh! So, I did that.
And now, the AI revolution is well and truly happening. So, so many new things to learn. So, I'm doing that.
I think the difference is, I've been in this game all along mostly because I love learning things, and computers have always been a mysterious box from which one can learn a great, great deal many things. I used to say "there is nothing mysterious about computers, only unknown - if its working and in front of you, its because someone, somewhere out there, knows it - so that means I can too", and that was a good maxim because it means I know assembly and multiple languages and can navigate all the layers of OSI with ease, and can invent things that others will have to catch up and learn, so .. they do that.
If you were in this for the paycheck, you're hurting. But if you're in it because you love making technology for your fellow human begins, then .. just do that. Embrace the things you don't know. Find your inner hacker spirit, and let it run world.
Get a DGX Spark, learn to use it. Learn to train models. Learn to SHIP those models to customers who will profit from using them. The data that all these other companies are using is out there for you to use, too! Don't forget that!
>Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
No, I do not. I didn't feel good about renting slots on a timeshare system, either, which is why I embraced the PC when it arrived. All the C compiling I could want, none of the bills!
It is the same as it ever was: Go local, or gtfo. Get that DGX Spark and get on with it. Next year is going to be fun! (Unless you're only in it for profit, in which case you're not gonna have a good time unless you can actually have fun, doing that which you need to do, to profit...)
And I will get that GPU (perhaps not a DGX spark but who knows) someday. It's important to me as well.
AI is just software. Learn how to use it to improve the lives of other humans, and you'll do fine.
I certainly do.
> How do you combat it?
I handed my notice in last Friday. The new CEO wants "AI at the heart of everything we do" and so it is at the heart of my departure. Actually I've been unhappy in tech since 2020, full time remote work is bad for my mental health and even though I go into the office I'm still remote because most of the people I work with are elsewhere, AI is just the final bale of hay.
This is professional suicide, of course. I'm not qualified for anything that isn't also going to be remote, fully AI infused, or both, so I'll most likely end up stacking shelves or waiting tables for a third of what I have been earning. I have the luxury of a paid mortgage (it is a small flat, but it is all mine), no debts, some savings, and no dependents other than the cats - others are not so lucky so couldn't make this choice even if they wanted to.
Right now my priorities are:
• getting out
• taking a sabbatical (some weeks, maybe two months) to deal with some of the immediate burn-out effects (fixing everything is a much more long term matter)
• then doing anything to pay the bills, so I'm not eating too much into savings for a long time.
There are quite a few people around me feeling exactly the same way, but they can't afford to take the risk of what I'm doing for various reasons (still paying mortgage/rent, partners and children to think about, etc.).
Not sure what to do next.
I can cope short-medium term on minimum spending etc, medium-long if I do something basic - I was thinking of doing something more physical like you mentioned, network installing (cabling etc) which I quite like doing but don't do it often. I know I couldn't get enough work to compete against what I get now, but maybe its enough.
The problem with "cloud computing" it doesn't break enough for people to care, so contracting work has been killed off by this. Probably costs more long term as well for the small business, small long term hidden costs etc.
Imagine knowing that there's a product that could bring in $500k/year but would take 2 people 3 years to make it, well, it was always going to be a chicken-and-egg problem. Now it might be possible for 1 person and several GPUs / high subscriptions to build that business in 6mo.
It's scary for sure to try and make something from scratch. But I think actually owning some kind of small business is going to be the best defense against getting laid off from a big company. People in tech for sure have challenges as they're really good at doing the thing vs seeing how the thing is used, but it's absolutely possible to learn the more product-management-ey and business-ey skills.
Sounds like a good time to start a new venture of your own? If you're captain of your own ship, you can make sure that it's not AI infused. And coworking spaces can feel a lot like offices, if you take care to go every day.
I think that a lot of people feel the same way you do, so there might be an opportunity in that.
While my company was paying for it, it was fine, I could go there whenever I felt like having some people around. When my company stopped paying for it (the company stopped existing), I switched to another (cheaper) coworking space, but the experience remained the same. Actually worse because now I was at a coworking space, looking for a job, while others where working on their product/company with their colleagues and teams, and I was shelling out money just for the privilege to have people around me.
I, for one, hate it.
Classic example of enshittification. In hindsight (not blaming the content creator!), relying on ads revenue from big players only worked for a while.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification
It's sad, and sadly solutions to the problem are non-trivial. Cory Doctorow discusses some solutions in his book. TL;DR from memory: increased regulation, in particular anti-trust and consumer rights.
The book is definitely worth reading. It discusses the central problem of today's Internet. It's a bit wordy/repetitive on the problem description side, but still ...
There was a game and you played it well, but the game has changed, what do you want me to do? Should we also bring back the horses?
I do really feel bad from another angle, I feel bad about not owning my means of production, and can't wait for the time when I can host my own, as I have always done. But I can see that that is going to happen, it will just take a while. I hate that a third party can take stuff away from me, and I need to be online for it to work.
I mean just the fact that Muses and Dots are just free VMs with (depending on reports) 12 GB of RAM, for free gets my blood boiling a bit, they borrowed the money, took everyone's RAM supply and put it in a machine to get us hooked before squeezing value back out or me. I did not and will not sign up for this. I want to host my own.
The work? The information? Meh, I'll adapt, but don't touch my agency.
You cannot publicly discuss the few options that might work for legal and moral reasons, but imho it'll end up like it always does when people get more and more alienated.
I should be able to read “all about berlin” and tell other people about Berlin without paying a separate license.
I should be able to share statistical results of analysis on copyright material.
And somehow the merging and scaling of those two don’t sit quite right with me.
They have about as much “cognitive dissonance” about their fecklessness as I have about eating meat. (the dilemma: on the one hand it is murder; on the other hand it is delicious.)
That depends on what you mean by "us".
Companies are paying taxes. Should they be paying more taxes? I really have no clue. Probably, as labor share of income decreases.
Should companies instead pay "us" (as in: creators) directly? I think here the issue is mostly that we are in unprecedented territory.
What needs to be paid for? What is okay to do with content that other people produced under a different regime? The rules so far have been pretty lax and in fact we are happy to share the knowledge, because it benefits all of us.
All of a sudden we have this machine that eats it all up systematically and creates outsized effects that are hard to compete with. This seems super messy. LLMs should exist, it's just good to have them. Again, taxing the corps seems like the simple solution, but idk.
What is curious is that we had the dry run: Google got rich and made people rich by linking to other peoples information. This to me is the same thing from a different angle. Who allowed Google to systematically index all this information? Well, nobody, but also nobody explicitly disallowed it, because nobody thought of it being a thing.
Then there is a separate question: What happens with those taxes in the future? Should it be used to fund UBIsh things? Again, crystal ball says: Probably, because what else? Also: Why not?
Random collection of thoughts and open questions.
It seems all the discussion revolve around the short/medium term issues, but the longer one I see that might bring back some balance is the creation of new content. Short/medium term yes the issues are what you list, the AI companies steal content, creators go bankrupt. But then how a new "All About Berlin" for a new subject emerges? As I see it the problem then will not be a new one emerges and is stolen, it's that there will be no new one altogether.
So to answer your question on how we'll combat this, I think "old" content / the web is lost, that new quality free content, be it websites, posts or Youtube videos, will dry up and move behind paywalls. Now is a difficult transition period for creators because the incentive for consumers are not yet there.
On the optimistic side, the mainstream web was already sick, it didn't wait for Google AI overview. So it might just finishes it off that dying model for creators with most of the ad and SEO industry.
Frustrated Fellow Americans put obligations on me but provide no assurance.
Same with environment; pearl clutching but stop driving. Flying. Psh. No.
When we don't know how to solve a problem we ignore it. So we're fucked. But then there was no beating physics anyway; life is the leading cause of death.
Downside to knowledge work has been the loss of all the manual skills that workers could fall back on, effectively look away from the digital virtual economy and just do the plumbing and roofing etc etc
(Yes yes hard on body but large enough labor pool (everyone that can) distributing load on a schedule).
I highly doubt they become profitable; Apple m7 and beyond or some other local device chip will come along that handles local inference on my own data just fine -or- society collapses seems most likely right now
Have seen it written we are in a cold world war 3, how this period is the Hitler's troops marches unobstructed across Europe" phase.
I don’t like it. I personally try to limit AI overviews as much as possible, and use Kagi for search. I’ll then follow the links.
I will say though, LLMs have made the deluge of AI generated websites with information even worse. I’m not even sure I can confidently find human made content anymore.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
No.
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
No.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
No. It’s conflicting. The tools are useful, but I don’t use them for content creation in the way of words to read, art to look at, etc. It doesn’t feel good though. On one hand I feel bad, on the other I have personal projects that would never have gotten done before.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Net positive? No. There will definitely be some positives. I don’t think they’ll outweigh the negatives.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
I have it every day. I don’t combat it, not well at least. But to quote Jango Fett: “I’m just a simple man, trying to make my way in the universe.”
I'm not sure what you're talking about. Yes I put some things on GitHub with permissive licenses. If it makes the clankers a little better, yay.
But I have no delusions that the LLM revolution is somehow dependent on my stuff. It's dependent on the collective effort.
There is good and bad things. Sure, nobody thought the first thing AI replaces would be the creative work.
Currently the frontier models are leading here and people become dependent on them. I don't think their moat will last too long, even if they try to make hardware scarce, at some point open models will replace them as well.
I don't think you can combat it much. But we can leverage the positive sides, even if they seem smaller right now.
Largest problem for developers right now is that the pipeline for new talent is broken. Well, in regards to anything to do with software, Germany hated building knowledge in several disciplines. A former engineering culture was replaced by lazy consumers and that was before AI in the picture.
perhaps if All About Berlin can pivot into consulting about UX design, they can share/sell the source of their compelling way of presenting the data
zeitgeist will never be in reach of AI, just by virtue of it always taking time to train / being reactionary (people catch on to trends instantly, and spontaneously generate them too)
You do not need to worry about that
What we really need is to spread the existing work load out amongst people _evenly_.
Hence 4 day weeks, but really this has to come with the 4 day pay.
And of course all the savings will mean we can afford this......
There will be no savings, continuous growth is the metric to the money makers and if that growth is actually more than the population, who cares?!
Like crap, but like with everything else in life you can't control: go with the flow and make the best of it. If I could re-wind to the pre-AI era and give Geoffrey Hinton something else that's interesting to do I would.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Most definitely not. But what to do about it?
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work?
Most definitely not.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
I don't and I never will.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
No, I think it will lead to worse than ever seen before wealth concentration and probably the end of the societies we have come to know.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
I don't combat it other than by writing (for instance: https://jacquesmattheij.com/the-ai-contradiction/ ), by trying as hard as I can to get local AI systems working for me that are not beholden to the scammers and by comforting myself that no matter which way this goes I'm too old for it to make a huge difference on my life. But at the same time: I worry for my kids and the world they will have to make their way in.
Companies are going to be deceitful either way; we have only discovered the extent to which they are able to be deceitful given advanced technology was far higher than ever imagined.
The un-unionized labour were the target of horrific shaming, intimidation, and abuse by the unionized labour. Of course "scabs" as they were known to the strikers were just trying to adapt to the situation they found themselves and take care of their families so even though my sympathies lie (then and now) with the strikers (or anti-AI crowd), I feel a great deal of empathy for them. Just as I feel empathy for anyone who finds themselves in a position now (as I do) of needing to use AI to stay relevant in their jobs. But I do feel like it makes me a bit like a "scab" of the current era.
I'm sure I can't be the first to have made this connection.
People also need to stop using clankers entirely. The blog post's message is severely undermined by the fact that the blog is Claude slop, so it also steals from other people.
I googled "best german bank account for foreigners" and compared his site to the Google AI response. They aren't even the same! Google recommends "C24 Bank" as its #2 choice whereas All About Berlin classifies it as "not expat-friendly." Google is not simply regurgitating information from his site.
Nowhere in this article does he question whether the experience is better for the users. Ulitimately, this is plain old creative destruction. I understand it sucks when it comes for you, but "I can't earn a living doing X anymore" isn't a good justification for stopping it.
Every single website had a symbiotic relationship with Google that had become increasingly strained and now is entirely one way and has become parasitic.
The web, and thus Google, cannot exist if that continues. No the world doesn’t owe this one guy visits to his website, but the way Google operates now the only people getting visits are people paying for ads.
The redirection is no longer necessary because an AI model, likely trained on their work, gives them the answer without having to go onto their site.
It’s a departure from old search engines made it easy to find the “right” site and showed a couple of ads before the user clicked onto the site, then seeing the site’s ads so they could make money too.
No. There are less visits to his site from Google because they’re directly displaying information from his website on their page.
That is not an accurate statement.
There are two things I tell myself to keep my head:
1. There are really two possible outcomes. Either “AGI/SI/RSI” is achieved, or it’s not. The former will change everything so drastically, there is literally no way to prepare for it or imagine the reprocusions. Nothing about that path is in my control, so I don’t spend any time thinking about it or worrying it. Doing so would be the equivalent of us practicing hiding under our desks for when the nuclear alarms go off. It helps that I don’t find it likely, but that “1% chance” lingered in the back of my brain until I embraced this mentality.
2. The amount of investor capital and debt involved in these businesses give me very little hope for their ability to innovate. The squeeze/enshittification will come faster than with any other technology. Those business that can outlast it will come back in demand. Private drivers were almost wiped out by uber, now I know several private drivers making a killing because people are tired of Ubers. AirBNBs were posed to take out hotels or BnBs or alternative lodging; nearly everyone I know now has sworn off airbnbs, and there are tons of cool alternative options.
It sucks that these companies can steal and get away with it. They’re destroying large swathes of society and ruining millions of people’s lives to make a few rich people even richer.
But eventually the check will come due and the music will end. Forest fires burn away hundred year old trees, but in doing so allow a new generation of seeds to take root. I refuse to believe the money inferno will burn up all human desire for uniqueness, creativity, and artisanry.
Keep doing what you’re doing, follow your passions, hone a craft, use AI as little as possible, refuse AI when you don’t want it, don’t get doomtrolled, and wait for the fire to burn out.
I feel like it's a good thing.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
We've been stealing each others work since the beginning of time. Nothing new. Let's take open source as an example. Who are the biggest contributors to open source? Typically, employees of big tech companies who have enough free time to build side projects and too much money to bother charging for it. Without big tech companies, open source wouldn't be as popular and AI wouldn't have enough data to train on. By using open source projects, we're stealing from big tech companies, so it's only natural for them to have the right to steal our jobs.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
Yes because unless I'm able to train my own models, I'm happy about paying some megacorp to get access to a trained one.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Any company that becomes profitable has a positive effect on society. People die from eating MacDonalds and KFC every year, but there are plenty of people who's happiness levels are increasing because of these companies. I guess AI should be seen as fast food. There are some weirdos who will talk to it about everything, but normal people will understand its limits.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
There's nothing to combat. Just accept reality. Worse case scenario I can become a construction worker or plumber. There are always houses to build and pipes to fix.
Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?