There is no progress here, only greed and destruction
For decades people fought against the media industry with some really good arguments about how music/film/software piracy doesn't deprive the original owner of their material so it's 'copyright infringement' and absolutely not theft. Now the same people will happily argue that since it's their work being copied and used, and they're losing out on the rewards and their jobs are at risk, now it's a heinous act of theft.
It doesn't work that way. People in the tech industry made some very clear statements about how copying is not theft, and we don't get to just take them back because we're all the victims now.
Copyright infringement is not theft, and copying some software to use for other purposes (e.g training AI) is very specifically allowed under some open licenses.
(I appreciate that this is a semantic argument that doesn't really matter very much.)
AI companies are the powerful taking from (and re-selling to) the weak. It's already dystopian and it's likely to get tremendously worse once they have become indispensable - they are not yet, at least outside of the SV bubble.
That's a fair argument while things remain stable but it falls down if things change.
AI companies have only really become powerful in the last few years, and they were taking the content a decade ago. The argument would only work if we either apply it retrospectively ("you took the content when you were weak, but now you're powerful so it's bad") or if we stopped anyone taking the content if they have the potential to become powerful ("you might invent AI in 10 years, so no content for you.") I don't see how that would work.
The only reasons LLMs are allowed is because big business thinks they will be able to get rid of much of their labour force AND because LLMs make it really hard to figure out whos copyright you are breaking.
So we are effectively in middle where copyright is more and more only for big companies and individual work is not gonna be protected.
Fine lets go all the way and kill copyright. Of course that won't happen.
It's interesting that we as workers apparently have to act inside the bounds of the law AND inside the bounds of our preferred legal structure (even though this was never turned into a law), while the rich and powerful are bound by neither.
Efficiency is one aspect of it. What we see is, one factor being made as the ultimate goal, pushing the human condition out of balance. The example of industrial revolution is great, as it resulted in the same out of control greed as we have today.
Why do you think those are mutually exclusive? History is full of greedy kings at the top of corrupt regimes. Is Putin’s Russia your role model?
Community is good and bad. You live in a low karen culture, cherish it, you won't like a high karen culture.
This gets repeated like a mantra, along with “survival of the fittest”, when we want sciencey-soudning justification for our bad impulses. No, efficiency is not survival, and natural process do not optimise for efficiency. They optimise for good enough.
Even human systems do not optimise for efficiency. Disproportionate wealth concentration and monopolies is not an efficient economic system in the abstract. It is efficient at wealth extraction. So, when we want to wax lyrical about efficiency, we should at least be honest: we’re saying that greed is good.
YouTube isn't a charity for creators. It's one of the biggest businesses in the world that takes enormous profits. While you can argue that certain large business models are better for society than others, it's still tech "destroying jobs".
Your analogies / examples do not cover this.
The core concern is that you are punished for creating useful information and putting it on the internet. Because if you do, it will be stolen by way of excessive AI traffic that makes you no money, while simultaneously suppressing human traffic that does.
So unless you are doing it entirely out of the goodness of your heart, and are also willing to effectively pay for Google and other AI overlords using your bandwidth, this information will disappear.
This is bad for everyone, but a confident AI will just slap together some random half truth from official sources that are required to be there, and that will be the new quality ceiling of information on the internet.
Having a page whose business model is talking about Berlin or restaurants might go away, but talking about Berlin or restaurants will not.
Think HN, we have plenty interesting discussions here out of the "goodness of our hearts", and I for one don't expect to profit from any contribution I might make when I post here.
What these changes are doing is killing the middle ground between purely hobbyist blogs and large companies websites. Blogs will remain because they were not making much money in the first place. Major newspaper will remain because they will find a way between subscriptions, sponsoring, and advertising. Everything in between is being overgrown by slop factories (this predates AI, but it is now completely unbearable) in a race to the bottom as they are displaced by Google’s AI (as if the bar was high in the first place). We are all losing.
There was a world before free information on the Internet, you know? Aside from the personal hardship of the site's owner, I won't shed tears for the ad-supported Internet. Not a droplet.
The only kind of free information ever available on the web was from small self-motivated authors and that will remain. They've don't feel "punished" if others, including AI, reads it. I have stuff online and I don't care if AI uses it.
If Google needs information for its AI, it better start paying for it. And perhaps a world of paid information providers will emerge.
If not, I'll be happy to keep the web hobbyists, forums like this one and paper books. Isn't that the old Internet we miss?
the "Theft" argument is just a bunch of people who'd otherwise hate copyright laws seething that they didn't get money from info that people'd otherwise never pay for.
this is not to detract from the overall problem. some people have provided value which is replaced by AI which can not be automatically replicated in their absence, yet the impact of AI on their finances might make it unfeasible for them to continue doing that work.
purely from a systemic point of view, it shouldnt matter though. if all about berlin cant operate on 1/4th the traffic, maybe someone else will (perhaps, using AI) create an equivalent service for 4 different subjects that each have 1/4th of the traffic and be profitable that way. if such a thing cant be profitable, society has deemed that it has no value in the first place.
this is a different argument from AIs effects on individuals of course.
When the internet displaced print media, that was done by individual creative people, not a large corporation (at least initially, today's YouTube is a different place). The person who used to write articles for a print magazine could learn the new skillset associated with online publishing, and apply their old skills and pivot to the new normal. It wasn't easy, but it was possible to survive.
But now, what options do we have? I'm not about to buy a data centre...
It’s so inevitable that Capital is pricing out personal computers and every IT-adjacent business is stuffing AI into their offerings in order to KPI-max to their managers. The top-down inevitability.
The OP claims:
> It will get worse. Last week, Google has made two announcements: AI-generated answers will replace search results entirely, and they have ads in them.
Yet more inevitability: Google will replace search results, that’s that. This is just progress.
On the other hand, people might like to get direct search results and be able to connect a person to their recommendations. It is possible. But it won’t, apparently, even be an option with Google soon enough. Because how to guerilla ads into other people’s websites? Much easier to guerilla them into AI “content”.
Also: Kagi (which has a good reputation here it seems) is a good search engine. How? By using Google’s services without the enshittification. More progress: the profit-maxing Google search engine is worse for the user, on purpose.
And all of this for what? No more original sources, no more authorship, no more talking to other people? This is progress?
Sadly it's very hard to build a search index in this era. You can't just run a recursive wget like it's 1994.
As someone once said: there is no alternative.
(Except that, of course, there are alternatives, they just really want you to shut up and stop trying to improve things for normal people).
It’s actually not. Tech progress is not happening in a vacuum. It’s accompanied by unprecedented inequity, corruption, monopolistic mega corporations, etc. Remove (or reduce) the cancer feeding on the technology progress and you may find it beneficial to us all.
When technology companies choose to take others information without compensation, what do you call it?
> Some small publisher likely felt the same a few years ago
Your analogy has no relationship to this situation. Unless you’re alleging small publishers, Work was stolen by websites and copied.
That site's business model is similar to the many paper magazines you'd get for free in tourist welcome centers, hotels and on the street. Companies (usually very small) who published those guides got replaced by the website. Some small publisher likely felt the same a few years ago.
A family member used to own a magazine about arts and crafts that went bankrupt because of Youtube channels and Internet articles - well before AI. It was a small magazine and profits were just enough to maintain a middle-class lifestyle. Random creators destroyed his livelihood.
You can try using laws and spreading the word against progress, but it's certain you'll lose in the end. I'm not saying it's not worth it because you may delay it long enough to give you time to settle elsewhere, but change will come against our will.