News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:24AM (#50401898)
The ancient sources were highly irresponsible in promoting mass migration theories, which play into the hands of Nazis and other ethnonationalists. Even if they didn't know any better, modern historians and archeologists certainly do. Let's not allow DNA analysis and historical linguistics to privilege reality over justice.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:50AM (#50402013)
Of all the mythic origin stories about the globe, Goths originating in Scandinavia is one of the less exciting ones to be proven correct.

DNA from unearthed car sized scales proving a giant snake carved the rivers and shape of the land would be something ...

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:03AM (#50402072)
I'm not so sure this study proves anything new, too. We always knew some Goths came from Scandinavia, that they mixed extensively with less mobile people in the regions they passed through during the age of migration, and that Gothic identity was (at least eventually) more tied to Arianism than to ancestry, so that when they became Catholic they stopped identifying as Gothic.

The real wild Gothic origin story is that the island of Gotland got overpopulated and they decided by lottery which 1/3 of them should leave.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by genxy on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:21AM (#50402706)
So it was quite literally a flood of people.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:10AM (#50403196)
If you believe the origin story from over 1000 years later (by a guy who had read Jordanes' story written merely 500 years later), sure.

What seems more accurate is that there were people near the Vistula River around year 1 who had cultural, linguistic, trade and - yes - genetic connection to people on the other side of the Baltic sea, and in the age of migration those people got moving, got into Arian Christianity and called themselves Goths. They did comparatively well in a time when most of Europe didn't, so they have plenty of descendants, many of them carrying ancestry we can trace back to people who lived in Scandinavia before year 1.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by qwytw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:38AM (#50403060)
> they decided by lottery which 1/3 of them should leave.

That's a thing in some ancient Greek sources on how they picked people who had to leave when the city was establishing a new colony. So it's possible that the writers reused the same trope (assuming the Goths were significantly less centralized and couldn't organize a lottery like the Ancient Greek city states).

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by andai on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:51AM (#50403740)
What is Arianism?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:35AM (#50404018)
A non-trinitarian Christian doctrine, considered heresy by all Christians following the Nicene creed and vice versa. No relation to Aryans.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by EdwardDiego on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:51AM (#50402265)
Giant wiggly snake is a great explanation of the obvious evidence glaciation/erosion, ngl.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by taneq on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:30AM (#50402447)
It’s a water snake too, so the explanation is literally correct with a bit of poetic license.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by EdwardDiego on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:14AM (#50402940)
I love a myth that kinda makes sense with a bit of poetic licence.

E.g., the North Island of New Zealand is called "Te Ika A Māui" in Māori, that is "the fish of Māui", and if you look at it from above, it definitely resembles a stingray.

What blows my mind is how Māori knew that before cartography or aerial mapping or satellites.

I understand how they likely did, Polynesians didn't spread across the Pacific by being clueless about geography and coastlines.

But still, a pre-literate society that was able to say "huh, this island looks like a giant stingray" is pretty bloody cool.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by eesmith on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:32AM (#50404862)
I don't see stingray. I maybe see a bat.

The summary from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Island is:

> According to Māori mythology, the North and South Islands of New Zealand arose through the actions of the demigod Māui. Māui and his brothers were fishing from their canoe (the South Island) when he caught a great fish and pulled it right up from the sea. While he was not looking, his brothers fought over the fish and chopped it up. This great fish became the North Island, and thus a Māori name for the North Island is Te Ika-a-Māui ("The Fish of Māui").

Does your perception of the stingray match the head location in local use?

> Names of certain tribes like Muaūpoko (mua upoko "front of the head") and Muriwhenua (muri whenua, "backland")

Muaūpoko is in the south of Te Ika A Māui.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by EdwardDiego on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:22AM (#50412647)
Northland is the tail, Wellington harbour is the mouth, and Lake Taupō is the heart.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by joegibbs on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:59AM (#50402059)
Why did people doubt this? It doesn’t sound so ridiculous that a Germanic-speaking people would come from Scandinavia, which has a island called Gothland, a province East Gothland and West Gothland, a city called Gothenburg and people called Geats (probably related to Goths).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by dmix on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:18AM (#50402127)
The article explains

> The findings challenge decades of scholarship that played down the importance of migration and emphasized the spread of language and culture between settled populations.“

> “What the genotyping is showing is what the ancient sources report, and what late–20th century historiography has been working very hard to deny,” says Yale University historian Noel Lenski, who was not involved in the work. “We have to … admit the sources knew more than we thought they did.”

If I'm reading that right they are implying academics were pushing the idea of cultural exchange being the most valuable thing, a vague menagerie of local and foreign cultures coming together, rather than a specific set of people arriving from a far off land to dominant an existing empire and influencing the entire region in the process.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by jimnotgym on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:36AM (#50402193)
The cultural exchange part was more a post punk thing. The Cure, Bauhaus, Siouxsie and the Banshees.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:53AM (#50402272)
It was the post-WW2 hangover of "pots aren't people" (reaction to Kossinna and other racist archeologists favored by the Nazis). There was a lot of resistance from archeologists and anthropologists to ancient DNA findings in the 2010s vindicating mass migration but they ultimately had to fold (and admit that the historical linguists were right all along). Now we have a more balanced perspective and can see that language and material culture can be transmitted via either cultural diffusion or mass migration, and we have to look at the actual evidence in each case to identify the transmission mechanism. An interesting example of how both transmission mechanisms can be involved in one cultural-linguistic phenomenon is the Bell Beaker culture (associated with the spread of an Indo-European language family possibly ancestral to Italo-Celtic), which spread east from Iberia to Central Europe via cultural transmission, and then back west to the Atlantic via mass migration (reaching all the way to Britain, where they appropriated Stonehenge from its Neolithic builders, who went virtually extinct within a century).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by inglor_cz on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:07AM (#50402334)
Politicization of science is never good.

The "pots aren't people" wave wouldn't be problematic per se (e.g. obviously a lot of non-Latin ethnicities adapted Roman way of life), rather because it sought to be the dominant theory.

We have a very similar "intelligence and nature-vs-nurture" situation in biology, caused by the very same thing - defeat of the Nazis, which made some ideas extremely dirty and other ideas very attractive.

This has an interesting consequence in that we do not know much about natural human intelligence today, which is coming back to bite us in the age of emerging artificial intelligence. The topic of human intelligence has been a political minefield for nearly a century now. It is probably safer and easier to study intelligence of octopuses and crows than that of humans. You're definitely freer from political repercussions there.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by siva7 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:15AM (#50402378)
> We have a very similar "intelligence and nature-vs-nurture" situation in biology, caused by the very same thing

no we don't. intelligence isn't racial..

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by card_zero on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:36AM (#50402483)
I say intelligence is ideas, so it isn't physiological* and doesn't have a quotient.

* except in that being beaten around the head can make a person stupid.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by adrianN on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:44AM (#50402518)
Suggesting that intelligence might be (partially) inheritable always causes backlash.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by card_zero on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:52AM (#50402559)
I just got a downvote for an opposing opinion, so at least one person feels keenly that intelligence is genetic and is unable to say why.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by Viliam1234 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:58PM (#50407983)
Probably because it correlates with some genes. It is not so implausible that the functionality of some body parts is regulated by genes. Neither it is implausible that brain is a body part. Only when you put those two facts together, people on the internet start freaking out.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by logicchains on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:27AM (#50403011)
It causes backlash because there are huge fields of modern academia built around the implicit assumption that everyone has the same IQ and hence the worse outcomes encountered by black and brown people are due to a big societal conspiracy against them, when in reality their outcomes are almost identical to white people who score the same on IQ tests as those groups do.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by Roark66 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:37AM (#50403654)
It is true any discussion of the subject marks you as a racist so how can we have an honest conversation in such environment? Just look at your own down votes?

Having said that, even if the academic outcomes of people with darker skin color were worse (no idea if that is true, or in which country) just knowing that is no proof. It may as well be cultural or even income based (pregnant mothers eating worse quality food for example, or same thing with young children).

Is the question even answerable? What kind of intelligence do we measure with "academic outcomes"? How do we adjust for income and quality of life as a child, things like having both parents, or grandparents? It's an absolute minefield of possible manipulation. Same data can probably be spun to "proove" any hypothesis you have.

Then imagine writing a proposal for such research. What benefits can you predict? If you find there is absolutely no correlation between skin color and academic outcomes after adjusting for all external factors will it convince people that are racist as part of their identity? I doubt it.

Lets say you do prove there is some correlation. What the result of that would be? Open discrimination and vindication of racist views. But even if the principle was true the average doesn't apply to individuals so you can't apply it to any particular person.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by bluGill on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:33AM (#50404878)
In the ideal world, assuming this is true, we could then ask for the question of, well, what can we do about these people with different intelligence levels?

Intelligence is not just a single thing. We can assign a number by an intelligence test, of course, but there are lots of ways to look at it that are more nuanced. Generally, you're not going to say someone is better than everything you're going to find that someone is better at some things. And so can we direct people to the things you're better at for the better of everyone? Division of labor is a good thing.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:21PM (#50416170)
It would be wonderful if we understood what biological process determines the size of the brain. There are thousands of genes that each affect IQ ever so slightly but if we zoom out and look "macro" biology, then the size of the brain does correlate reasonably well with IQ and it is likely to be influenced by relatively few genes.

This is probably the first route we will find towards increasing the intelligence of children.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:51AM (#50404130)
What plausible mechanism is there to even approach the idea that skin color influences intelligence? Why not study the effects on intelligence of eye color, or blood type?

This is especially clearly just a racist concept once you realize that none of the studies of IQ vs race actually do any genetic testing, they only rely on phenotype. Which is absurd given the fact that the child of a black-skinned person born in sub-Saharan Africa and a white-skinned person born in a village in Ireland is extremely likely to be black-skinned, but is genetically just as much part of both populations. It's only the history of racism that assigns this child as black more so than white.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by adrianN on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:03AM (#50404221)
We know that people with red hair tend to metabolize anesthesia differently. It is not completely implausible that there is also a correlation between looks and other traits, also it seems almost impossible to me to untangle cultural, environmental and genetic effects.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:09AM (#50404268)
Of course, any two traits can correlated. But unless there is an obvious causal mechanism ("whiter skinned people get sun burns more easily", "darker skinned people tend to have vitamin D deficiencies at higher latitudes"), there's no reason to assume it and start studying it. It's a priori just as likely that there is a genetic link between toe shape and intelligence as skin color and intelligence. Yet no one is doing the science of measuring toe length correlation to intelligence, just skin color ("race").
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by adrianN on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:14AM (#50404296)
As far as I know phrenology measured all kinds of things and claimed correlations. But they used highly dubious data and the field is now too unpopular to try again with better methodology.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tacitusarc on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:42PM (#50406415)
Wouldn’t the racist claim be that because some group has a lower average IQ, they deserve fewer rights and freedom and less dignity?

The implication that if one group was shown to have a measurably lower intellect they are less “human” somehow is really worrying.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by adrianN on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:11PM (#50406664)
It is my understanding that it's only racist if the group somehow aligns with a race, but I don't know a good term for that belief when it doesn't align with races.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:06AM (#50411313)
No, that would be ableist, or maybe eugenics.

And the way IQ is used in modern racist discourse is not this. Instead, the claims are "black people are not less well off on average because of racism in society, either old or current, they are less well off because they are dumber (have lower IQ) on average, so it's only a consequence of that, as dumber white people also tend to fail to get as much success". This is the argument being made, at least publicly, by most modern day scientific racists.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by OroPla on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:10AM (#50412249)
Is it racist, that we put gorillas in a zoo instead of a school because gorillas as a group have lower average IQ? Would we treat Gorillas this way if they had similar or higher average IQ?

What does it mean to be human?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by carlosjobim on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:40PM (#50406407)
"Skin color"? There's never been anybody with functional intelligence who thinks that skin color alone determines race.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:02AM (#50411297)
Well, skin color, hair color, hair texture, certain bone structure features. But black skin color alone is 100% enough to be racially profiled in the USA, especially historically. Or do you think people in the deep South 1900s would have accepted a black-skinned blonde blue eyed neighbor?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by carlosjobim on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @06:17AM (#50438723)
Skin color never manifests alone, with the exception of albinos. It's just been a short hand for talking about different races of people, but nobody thinks that any racial property of a person comes from the skin color. These properties you mention are the outwardly visible properties of race. They are determined by race, race is not determined by them.

So if we for example say that a certain man has a deep voice because he is black, we don't mean that his skin gives him the deep voice.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @05:19PM (#50459517)
My point is this: the people who run these studies looking for correlations between race and IQ invariably use skin color (and a few other physical traits) as the indicator by which they split people by "race". The concept of "race" is anyway merely a socio-cultural convention and is itself very distant from any genetic notions - and also tied mostly to skin color, at least when talking about "white people" and "black people".

That is, no one would point at a man with dark brown skin and say "that's a white man" even if both of his parents were white and he had just inherited his dark skin color from a grandparent (which can occasionally happen). And more commonly, the child of a "black" person and a "white" person is invariably considered to be a "black" person in the USA *, despite being exactly 50-50 part of both populations from a genetic standpoint. And this can extend for a ridiculous number of generations, since the child of this person with another "white" person would also be considered "black", despite being only 25% part of their dark skinned grandparent's population from a genetic perspective.

This is also the root of one of the biggest fears of white supremacists, the danger of "white genocide" by "race mixing" - as you can't get "white" children when a "non white" person has children with a "white" person.

* I'm saying "in the USA" because other places have their own rules, since race is a socio-cultural construct. In South Africa, at least during apartheid, for example, the children of "whites" and "blacks" were considered a separate "race", "colored".

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:28PM (#50416252)
Skin colour almost certainly doesn't affect intelligence (much). There are plenty of dark skinned upper caste Indians who are intelligent, for example.

We can predict skin colour reasonably well on the basis of very few genes. We need many more to predict intelligence (and we can't predict it nearly as well).

On the other hand, however...

...there are a lot of people who happen to have whatever genes cause dark skin who also happen to have lot of other genes that do other things...

Some of those others things include a genetic protection against malaria. Others confer a genetic protection against a nasty parasitic worm that prefers to live in the kidneys. The downside is that that protection itself is a bit unhealthy for the kidneys.

And some of them do a might good job of seeming like they cause lower intelligence. If we use our genetic prediction models, then they do in fact predict a lower intelligence.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by gsich on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:28AM (#50403019)
Intelligence is inheritable.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:45AM (#50403092)
Intelligence isn't even well defined.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by gsich on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:09AM (#50403842)
That doesn't matter.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:26AM (#50403959)
Apparently not.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by wolfi1 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:31AM (#50403292)
for the sake of DJT's offspring I hope not
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:12PM (#50407134)
Probably because people the idea and run it right off a cliff like Wil-E-Coyote, because very few commenters on message boards know what "heritability" actually means.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by paganel on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:50AM (#50402544)
> intelligence isn't racial..

The same way as South-Koreans are by now taller than North-Koreans (because of material reasons) we could posit that "intelligence", i.e. the "workings" of our brain, can be distributed in a non-uniform manner across humankind, depending on the "local" material conditions.

And this is not about "race", because according to those that do believe in the "race" stuff both North-Koreans and South-Koreans are part of the same "race", it is about those material conditions that I've mentioned and which, in the end, by necessity end up modifying things in our (very material) brains, and hence in our "intelligence". Believing otherwise, meaning believing that are our brains are not affected by the material conditions under which we live our day-to-day lives, would be preposterous.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by card_zero on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:58AM (#50402583)
Right, but the equation of workings of the brain to intelligence is the tricky bit. That's like equating the workings of my bicycle to my decision to ride to a particular place.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by paganel on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:04AM (#50402612)
> workings of the brain to intelligence is the tricky bit

I don't find it that tricky, intelligence does come from the brain.

> That's like equating the workings of my bicycle to my decision to ride to a particular place

Both one's brain and one's "intelligence" belong to the same person, like, physically and materially, which is not true when it comes to your bicycle example. More to the point, I find the comparison itself kind of self-describing, it's like deciding to "outsource" intelligence to some other external, non-ethereal entity (like a bicicle that is physically separate from a human being) in order to avoid those hard questions the OP was alluding to (hard questions that oftentimes also involve the political side of things).

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by card_zero on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:13AM (#50402659)
Now I want to say that your ideas don't come from your brain. But of course they do, as a result of interaction with other people's ideas, some of which were written down. (Don't worry, I'm not a dualist.)
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:17AM (#50402683)
You, as a dualist, is the least of the fears we hold.

There are other notions about the transfer of ideas: https://www.apa.org/monitor/2010/06/memory-transfer

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by card_zero on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:19AM (#50402695)
I'm not a dualist! Fumes
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:23AM (#50402711)
I for one thank our AI overlords that weight training avoided that path not taken :/
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by jstanley on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:04AM (#50402902)
If you think any brain can be just as intelligent no matter how it works then why not extend that to things that aren't brains? If everyone's brain is equally good then isn't a rock just as good as well?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:58AM (#50403141)
A lot of HN is currently about rocks that we've made very smart, in case you haven't noticed. I don't want archeology polluted by generic academic culture war stuff, so can we please leave "intelligence" out of it?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by jstanley on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:14PM (#50406182)
Well this just proves the point I'm making.

It takes an enormous amount of engineering work to make an intelligent rock, and not all intelligent rocks are equally intelligent. This is very obvious.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by card_zero on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:42AM (#50403347)
Sure, if the rock has good ideas.

(Rocks don't have ideas.)

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by pingou on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:18AM (#50402690)
I don't think many people dispute the fact that the environment plays a role in intelligence. Not even many people dispute that there is some heritability to intelligence. What is in dispute is if that heritability means that some races are on average genetically more intelligent than other (and another problem is how to define intelligence).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by thin_carapace on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:21AM (#50402704)
I don't understand how the precedents could lead to any question regarding the disputed conclusion
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by logicchains on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:19AM (#50402968)
If we define intelligence as IQ then the evidence is overwhelming that the average differs among races. Even in Singapore, which has a very high standard of living, nutrition etc., we still see Chinese Singaporeans perform significantly better than Malay Singaporeans on various measures of intelligence, with Indian Singaporeans somewhere in the middle. The same pattern is seen among Chinese, Indians and native Malaysians in Malaysia, and globally when we compare the mean IQ scores of China, India and Malaysia.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by pingou on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:37AM (#50403053)
That could also be explained by cultural differences, I don't think the evidence is overwhelming.

Or it could be discrimination. There are studies that show that black and white mixed races children did not score any higher than children with two Black parents, which may point to some discrimination impacting IQ.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by JuniperMesos on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:26AM (#50403267)
Discrimination against whites in favor of blacks doesn't lower white IQ.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by autoexec on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:01AM (#50411555)
We know that discrimination, even between whites, has a negative impact on test scores. It seems like discrimination can hurt people's performance, but the type of discrimination, how impactful it is on the people being discriminated against, and the extent to which it happens over the population probably matters.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by graemep on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:01AM (#50403456)
There are significant cultural and economic differences between those communities. These will be similar between Singapore and Malaysia. The Chinese and Indians are sufficiently recent immigrants for their culture to still have a lot in common (they speak the same language, follow the same religions, have inherited attitudes) with the places their ancestors came from.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by carlosjobim on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:01AM (#50412903)
> There are significant cultural and economic differences between those communities.

And where does culture and/or economy come from if they don't come from races of people? Do hackers argue that human culture existed before humans?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:33PM (#50416313)
If the difference is due to culture (and not genes), then the conclusion would be that Malay culture is bad and should be oppressed, right?

If the difference is genetic then Malay culture gets a free pass.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:13PM (#50407143)
No, you mean to say "if we define intelligence as the output of IQ testing", which clarifies that you're projecting from statistical surveys (with all sorts of potential confounders) rather than some directly queryable and innate attribute of people.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by graemep on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:55AM (#50403422)
How do you define races? As I said in another comment definitions shift and they are different in different countries. I have an encyclopedia from the 1950s that defines South Asians as "Caucasoid". Some East Africans were also defined as "Caucasoid" historically.If we define races on the basis of genetic similarity then almost everyone whose ancestry is from Eurasia is the same "race", but people whose ancestry is African belong to multiple races.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by pigpop on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:26AM (#50404830)
Race was only ever a stand in before we had an accurate understanding of genetics.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by doodlebugging on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:03AM (#50405662)
It's a bit like the old adage that we should not judge a book by its cover. The outside often does not provide any clues into the content or worse, it could bias an observer's opinions about what they would find inside if they chose to engage with the material.

Its akin to judging a man by the color of his skin instead of by the content of his character.

Thanks for your comment that clarifies how genetics provides a much more granular window into an individual than any physical characteristic taken by itself can provide.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by graemep on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:02PM (#50406076)
Yes, but people seem very reluctant to accept that. They keep trying to pretend that genetics backs their culture's definitions.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ffsm8 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:13AM (#50402934)
If genetics had no impact whatsoever then great apes would have the same intelligence potential as humans, as human races are more diverse then you give them credit for.

The impact of it's culture and behavioral like inbreeding being acceptable probably plays a bigger role though, but denying genetic impact is just putting your head in the sand because you cannot face reality not being equal. Which it ain't.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by simonh on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:55AM (#50403126)
Race is a combination of genetic, and cultural factors such as nutrition, early childhood care practices, social values, etc.

Cultural practices can have a big effect on intellectual development, so disentangling any possible genetic factors from cultural ones can be very difficult, but there is very little evidence for genetic factors related to race also being related to intelligence at the population level. Obviously certain genetic disorders can have a significant effect.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by logicchains on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:16AM (#50402953)
All the evidence we have shows that there's a significant difference in mean IQ across races. Suggesting otherwise is anti-science, putting ideology over reality.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by kshri24 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:27AM (#50403276)
Most studies of Indians done in famous IQ tests were of those Indians who lived in villages and suffered from diseases. Its been debunked so many times.

Those who immigrate to America are not smarter. They just had the where with all to pay for immigration. Even those who go on scholarship have to prove they have atleast land/housing back in India to even get a chance to immigrate.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by kelipso on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:49AM (#50404512)
I remember looking up the source of the IQ data from Nepal a few years ago. It was a taken from an IQ survey of a school for mentally disabled children..
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:15PM (#50407160)
You're giving away the game here by building an argument around national IQ statistics, because there is no such thing. There are serious surveys of IQ test results in places like the United States, with some statistical validity. There is no equivalent global country-by-country survey that would enable you to compare the United States to India or any other country. The reason people believe there are is because there are multiple fraudulent studies that claim to provide those numbers, and people cite them without reading the underlying papers and seeing what they did to generate those numbers.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fliglr on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:54AM (#50403124)
IQ differences between the racial groups is one of the most, if not the most, replicated findings in psychology.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by graemep on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:51AM (#50403400)
Are they consistent across time and cultures? Are they corrected for differences in health, education, culture, wealth, etc?

How do you define racial groups? its something that constantly shifts. I have an encyclopedia for the 1950s that defines South Asians as "Caucasoid" which is not how most people now think.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by DC-3 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:08AM (#50403492)
You can do a dimensionality reduction on genetic variants and certain recognisable groups fall pretty clearly out of the data.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by graemep on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:31AM (#50403618)
Do those groups relate closely to what people generally mean by race? Race as defined in which culture? I know from personal experience that its not the same definitions across cultures. How big are those differences compared to differences within racial groups?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by DC-3 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:43AM (#50404071)
Take a look yourself.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f9/Principa...

Obviously some racial groups which are heavily socially constructed are not borne out by the data. There's no cluster for 'Latinos'. But in general I think there is quite a high correspondence with race as it is constructed in society and culture.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ComposedPattern on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:39AM (#50404940)
So on that graph, the distance between East and West Africans is about as great as the distance between Indians and Europeans. Somalis are closer to East Asians than they are to Southern African Khoisan people. Bedouin Arabs and Southern Europeans are closer to each other than either are to North Africans or Northern Europeans.

There's certainly some cases where the genetic data matches conventional thinking about race, but also many where they flatly contradict. It also suggests that saying something like "white people are genetically smarter on average than black people" is highly suspect. The group of people that we call "black" has a greater range of genetic profiles than the rest of the world put together, and the group we call "white" is kind of confused—to be genetically meaningful it would probably need to either include North Africans and Arabs or exclude Southern Europeans.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mjanx123 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:30AM (#50410672)
The social "white race" (declared superior to other "races" to rationalize and justify the UK empire parasitation on a half of the world) corresponds with the northwestern european genetic cluster (with the exclusion of the Irish who were conquered by the UK and not considered white despite being the least pigmented population in the world). The intra european clusters are an ultra fine genetic resolution analysis. The genes that in todays population correlate with high IQ spread from ~2000bc likely with the Iran-neolithic genetic component.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by jcranmer on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:49AM (#50405964)
There is more genetic diversity among Africans than among all of the non-African groups. And yet I haven't seen a racial typology that didn't lump all of the Africans into one race, very often while they're trying to declare differences between people in the same European cluster.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:08PM (#50416050)
Most of the differences are between the big majority groups (Bantus etc) and the small aboriginal groups (those who were mostly overrun by Bantus etc).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by graemep on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:57AM (#50406039)
Where are South and SE Asians on that?

Looking at this

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_genetic_variation#/media...

It looks as though there are two rough clusters, Africans and everyone else, with Europeans and Middle Easterners in the intersection. Pretty much reflecting geography.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:02PM (#50410319)
> Take a look yourself.

> https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f9/Principa...

Is there a reason you're sharing a random uploaded file instead of a "vetted" actual Wikipedia article?

Is there any reason to think this is from a real or valid scientific study?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mf2hd on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:55AM (#50411815)
Dimension1 and Dimension2? What is this thing?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fliglr on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:50PM (#50410269)
Well, one way of looking at it is, asking: to what extent does biological population correlate with self-identified race. The answer is, very much so.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:57AM (#50404168)
Based almost entirely on racist studies, including some famous ones that were comparing white and black school children in apartheid South Africa. I wonder if there may be have been some confounding variables there, but surely this is just my bias.

Plus, none of these studies actually spend the money to do any genetic testing, they simply assign people to "white" or "black" race based almost always on skin color (which, since the gene for dark skin is dominant, is a very poor marker of actual genetic similarity - the great grandchild of a dark-skinned person with otherwise only white-skinned relatives can still be dark-skinned).

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by sjducb on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:53AM (#50405057)
We care about racial differences in outcomes that are correlated to IQ, such as employment and imprisonment.

What if some of the observed racial differences were caused by a lack of vitimin D, due to darker skin photosynthesising less of it? Then we could fix the prison crisis with a pill!

If we block all research into a problem then we can’t solve it.

If you actually care about fixing a problem then we should bring all available tools to fix and solve it.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ogogmad on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:46AM (#50405505)
> correlated to

Correlation measures whether Y=mX+c holds with small error. I sometimes think that too many people think that all dependencies are somehow straight-line ones. This is distinct from "linear approximation" in physics and engineering, which is more justifiable.

I also suspect that correlations of 0.5 or lower are just statistical noise.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by sjducb on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:31AM (#50405845)
I don’t see how your reply relates to my comment. At no point do I say that any correlations are linear, nor does my argument depend on linear correlations.

Fundamentally my argument is maybe science can solve a problem, let’s at least try.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:28AM (#50405822)
It's a good tool if you want to rank people, it's a bad tool if you want to help people. IQ tests couldn't (and can't) even detect dyslexia, a specific disability which you can get help with, which was known even in Terman's time. IQ tests by design throw out all information which could complicate ranking people. If your goal is to help, why would you measure people with a tool which can't tell the difference between dyslexia and concussion?

IQ tests have been revised several times to address things like that, like that they "unfairly" penalize dyslexia, or that they had lots of questions which were easier for people of specific social backgrounds. Every time they were, they naturally became less "predictive", since both dyslexia and not belonging to the California white upper middle class give you pretty obvious disadvantages in life outcomes.

So don't waste time on IQ, and don't waste time on other academic culture war BS either.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by sjducb on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:39AM (#50405894)
If you can’t study IQ how do you demonstrate that lead poisoning causes reduced intelligence?

The research to ban lead in fuel relied on measuring IQ and measuring lead exposure, then showing a correlation between the two.

At the population level IQ is a very useful tool.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by jcranmer on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:58AM (#50406049)
IQ is a very bad tool for measuring populations. That's because IQ is definitionally designed to force a population to adhere a particular metric: a bell curve distribution, with the median at 100 and the standard deviation of 10. Whatever the thing you're measuring is--and there's good reason to think it's not "intelligence"--you're crunching and distorting that measurement to get the number at the end of it to force the population to adhere to a standard distribution.

We don't have a good model of what intelligence is. But since IQ studies are fairly common, there's a lot of data collected that uses IQ, and since it IQ looks vaguely like "intelligence," a lot of researchers who are motivated to find reasons to declare particular people intelligent or unintelligent are more than happy to use that data to support their claims.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by sjducb on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:05PM (#50406098)
Did you even read my comment?

Answer this question:

> If you can’t study IQ how do you demonstrate that lead poisoning causes reduced intelligence?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by jcranmer on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:19PM (#50407188)
The answer to that question should be blindingly obvious: you don't.

It should be clearly evident that trying to use IQ to establish that "<insert ethnic group here> are stupid" is bad science. It's the same sort of science to establish that "<insert environmental factor here> causes stupidity," so we also need to reject it even if the environmental factor is clearly something problematic. The problem isn't the conclusion, it's the methodology.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by sjducb on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:33PM (#50407798)
So do you reject that lead poisoning causes stupidity because it is unethical to measure intelligence?

It’s a good thing that measuring IQ enabled us to discover that trace amounts of lead in the environment causes reduced intelligence. That was a key piece of data for banning lead in fuel. The loss of IQ points happens to all kids living in cities, rich and poor. Rich powerful people didn’t want their kids made stupid by lead in the air.

I think that removing lead from paint and fuel has greatly improved the lives of billions of people.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:10PM (#50408098)
No, we knew lead was bad. We knew what heavy metal poisoning looked like, we knew lead caused heavy metal poisoning. We knew of a hell of a lot more concrete effects than average lower scores on IQ tests.

> The loss of IQ points happens to all kids living in cities

No, it didn't. The reduced test scores happened _on average_.

I won't rule out that what you said is correct, in that it may well be the fear that "my child may lose 1-5 IQ points!" helped get lead banned, but if so, that's an indictment of society.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:45PM (#50407878)
I agree with half of this argument but think you're taking it too far when you reject IQ testing as an epidemiological tool. It's not dispositive. It's statistically ill fitted as a ranking tool, for the reasons you stated, and the fact that it's not reliable across its whole range, and test-test reliability issues, &c. But like, "you can use it as an indicator for environmental causes of cognitive harm" is actually a valid argument, I think?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:11PM (#50407130)
Wait, this is the opposite of reality. IQ is in fact a useful tool (in a battery of other tools) for helping diagnose cognitive deficits and learning disabilities. That's what it's good for: as a clinical tool. It's in fact terrible for ranking people.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:18PM (#50408160)
Well that's what it was used for! Do your history homework, mr. clinician!

Tell me then, if someone scored low on a text-based IQ test and that's all you know, how do you tell if it was caused by dyslexia or concussion? I guess you break out that "battery of other tools"? What does IQ tests give you that those other tools don't give better?

Oh, I know one. An excuse to write someone off as simply stupid. An excuse to _stop looking_ for the things which might have helped them. Which is what it was historically used for.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mjanx123 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:49AM (#50410761)
The US never truly abolished slavery, it turned it into a punishment, and started sending black people into prison en masse. There is no prison crisis, in fact the prison industry is flourishing like never before!
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:13PM (#50416090)
The US punishes blacks too leniently relative to their crime rate.

Punishing shoplifting is considered racist in many places.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Monday November 09, 2026 @04:01AM (#50422969)
> What if some of the observed racial differences were caused by a lack of vitimin D, due to darker skin photosynthesising less of it? Vitamin D is essential for brain development. Black people in northern climates get less of it than evolution intended. This lack of vitamin D might be causing reduced brain development in black populations. If that is true, we could fix the prison crisis and racial IQ differences with a pill!

Well, that would be knowable from a study of Vitamin D levels in the incarcerated population vs non-incarcerated among those with the same skin tones. I don't see any reason to bring IQ into this, nor race (vitamin D absorption is tied to skin tone, so a dark skinned person of Indian descent is as likely to have vitamin D deficiency as one of sub-Saharan African descent).

> If we block all research into a problem then we can’t solve it.

Establishing or refuting IQ differences among "races" is simply not a problem. It is sought after, at best, as a scapegoat, to deny any responsibility of racism in the measurably worse outcomes of people with certain heritage than others. Refuting race-IQ genetic correlation would simply eliminate this scapegpat, that most scientists don't actually believe in; while confirming it would just mean the problem is hopeless and nothing can be done to improve the situation.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fliglr on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:53PM (#50410289)
You are hilariously wrong. There is a mountain of evidence of racial differences in IQ scores, why don't you familiarize yourself with the literature before spouting off nonsense about it?

Question: is there any kind of evidence, that hypothetically did show a racial difference, that you would not label as racist?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:11AM (#50411337)
All of the studies I have ever seen discussed are hopelessly terrible. People like Murray cite apartheid-era South Africa IQ studies, for example, where some of the black children being tested didn't even speak the test language natively. Others look at country differences and claim to extract racial differences from that, as if education and culture play no role in IQ scores. Virtually none of these studies actually look at the genetics of the populations they are testing, they just go by outward aspect, thus making most of their genetic claims laughable. And, of course, many of them are either small samples, p-hacking, or outright fabricated - like many papers in psychology.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:16PM (#50416132)
What about data we have from many countries today? PISA tests!

Why do people of X-extraction who were born in Y-country score about as well (or typically badly) as people back home in X-country? They do this in Western countries with sufficient nutrition and free education. They do this even when their parents immigrated as children. They even do this when their grandparents were the immigrants.

And the sample sizes are huge...

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tsimionescu on Monday November 09, 2026 @04:05AM (#50423014)
PISA tests are not IQ tests.

Cultural and socio-economic factors are just as good an explanation for the effects you mention than genetic ones tied to race.

I also very much doubt that the effects you mention are studied in the data on PISA test takers - there is simply not that level of demographic information being collected when a PISA test is administered. No one asks each child in the classroom where their parents or grand-parents were born, nor is their race or skin color noted down. So until you cite some papers, I'm going to be extremely skeptical of your claim.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by peterfirefly on Friday November 13, 2026 @07:43AM (#50482706)
I'm extremely sceptical of your willingness to familiarize yourself with the existing published data. You clearly don't know much about PISA, for example. Those reports exist. Read them. I can't chew your food for you.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by snowwrestler on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:38AM (#50405884)
Of course it is, creating that difference was the basis for IQ testing in the first place.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by red75prime on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:24AM (#50411659)
IQ tests were created to quantify a hypothesized g factor that underlies positive correlation between results of various intelligence-related tests (AKA positive manifold).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:09PM (#50407109)
Difference in IQ test scores between racial groups is established and replicated. Differences in innate intelligence are not. It's not hard to intuit the difference.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mike_hearn on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:44PM (#50408325)
It replicates worldwide, it's not a US thing.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:53PM (#50408808)
What do you mean "it replicates worldwide"? What replication are you referring to?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fliglr on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:48PM (#50410256)
IQ differences between ethnic/population groups/racial groups. It's not only a US phenomenon
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:53PM (#50410288)
I don't think it's a US phenomenon in particular; I'm saying we have data about the US, and not about the rest of the world.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fliglr on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:22PM (#50410393)
Then you haven't looked
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:26PM (#50410405)
People tend to say this before citing "IQ and the Wealth of Nations" or something derived from it.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:52PM (#50429832)
I'm really asking, by the way! If you meant to say "group differences in intelligence have replicated in other countries, like in Europe", that's noncontroversial. But if you mean to suggest that we have actual global data about IQ --- forget inter-group intra-country, just data for most of the world at all --- I think the story there is we do not.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mjanx123 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:21PM (#50410389)
The US racial groups are US specific. The bundling of different ethnicities into a race (like grouping high pigmented out of Africa with Africans instead of with low pigmented out of Africa) is silly.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by Roark66 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:23AM (#50403569)
>intelligence isn't racial

And how do we know that? Any very controversial stuff like this will have people on both sides doing all in their power to convince everyone to their point of view. The truth gets lost.

To discuss this objectively we have to first agree on some basics. First I think the concept of race is a bit outdated. People have phenotypes and these phenotypes have various features (one may be skin color).

Also where did the idea there exists one feature responsible for "intelligence" came from? It seems to be accepted apriori, but I think the truth is closer to humans (and animals and AI) having various types of intelligence. Social, emotional, linguistical, math like, spatial (ability to imagine shapes etc) and probably few more.

And those intelligence types may very well have a genetic component and be present in one phenotype in a different mix than another.

But saying it is likely vs having actual proof are two different things so my view is that we simply don't know.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:09PM (#50407101)
This is a message board trope. In reality there are multiple fields of study, all of which feature active and frequent publication in major journals, that address this question. Also: intelligence is not racial.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ordu on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:12AM (#50411609)
I question all these findings, because there is no chance for them to publish results that point the other way. There is a selection bias at work: you can publish research article saying "intelligence is not racial", and you cant publish an article saying otherwise.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:33AM (#50414130)
Results in both directions are published all the time.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ordu on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:32PM (#50431622)
Maybe, but I don't see results that point to some races to be inferior to other in any sense. (TBH, I've read about genetic diversity in Africa, but it is it). I'm not looking for those reasons, because it is a stupid thing that doesn't matter really, but the point is: I don't see them. Therefore I don't believe to the field at large.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Monday November 09, 2026 @04:43PM (#50432669)
There continue to be published studies suggesting group differences in intelligence, but the weight of studies over the last 10 years or so seems to be in the other direction.

The explanation for that is probably the "missing heritability problem"; twin studies in the 1980s and 1990s set extraordinarily high heritability statistics for intelligence that have been undercut by molecular genetics results. Put differently: there was an unreasonably high correlation established in the literature at the turn of this century, and it's had nowhere to go but down.

(In case it matters for the thread: I'm not an expert, but I do follow this area of research, and I've been pretty convinced for many years now that supposed race/IQ correlations are basically bullshit, and that science is really beating the crap out of the old Murray and Lynn numbers.)

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ordu on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @10:39AM (#50454694)
> supposed race/IQ correlations

I have one more issue with that: IQ is a bullshit. Psychology can't answer what intelligence is. It came to a point when someone proposed to treat IQ tests as a definition of intelligence. Even as IQ tests are correlated with intelligence, they grab as well a lot of cultural and educational confounders. Twin studies tend to have not so many participants, but controlling for culture and education means the need to multiplying the sample size by 10 or more if we want to get a statistically significant result.

Just think about how many factors can contribute to development of an intelligence (as a practical problem solving skill). Was a kid praised when he solved some problem, or maybe his parents didn't even notice that the kid solved a difficult (for him) problem? How about the teachers and their relationships with the kid? May some specific situation influence how a person develops their attitude to hard thinking? I mean do they like to think, or treat it as a hard work that should be avoided at all costs? Do they suffer from learned helplessness when it comes to thinking? There are a _lot_ of factors, though probably you can model them all as a motivation to think as a function of age: it would catch such things like how much time the person spent practicing thinking, and at what development stages. Then one can develop a predictive model of IQ-tests results, and then try twin-studies to explain what cannot be explained by the model.

But that age->motivation functions is not known, it is substituted with inadequate controls (in the best studies), and therefore those twin studies in the 1980s and 1990s are crystallized bullshit. Their results should be ignored by every sensible person. I wonder how did they manage to get any statistically significant results. I'd expect such studies to show just a noise around zero, or maybe around political views of the researchers.

> There continue to be published studies suggesting group differences in intelligence

I think, you just don't get it. I can believe some physics research results without understanding the research. I mean without digging into the paper figuring what the authors did, why they did this and not that, why this experimental setup, why these statistical methods, how it proves what they claim and so on. I can believe physics, because physics is (mostly) not interesting for politicians and their fans.

I can't believe social sciences because they are a battlefield for politicians. I need to dig into each research paper before I start believing. Or even worse, the research papers itself, I believe are useless, meta-research papers trying to reason on basis of many papers are better, and them I'd need to study under the microscope, to see what the authors did, and then better read what guys with PhD in the field think about the research. Keeping in mind that not everything can be said aloud.

It doesn't help that social sciences still struggling from the replication crisis.

All this leads to one conclusion: I can't believe into any social sciences results because you've said me that some kind of results is published.

But I'm not going to dive into social sciences papers, because I do not believe that their results are useful. Not yet, our society is not ready for that. If they found that blacks are learning things in different way, and the best outcome for all is to create separate schools for blacks and whites, that would respect racial differences, how our society would react? So even if they find something, it wouldn't lead to any meaningful changes.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by tptacek on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @11:35AM (#50455353)
Sorry, I don't follow really any of this, but it's becoming clear that you think I'm someone you can productively argue at about race/IQ differences, and I'm not.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ordu on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @06:54PM (#50460777)
My point is, that no one is.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:36PM (#50410448)
>> intelligence isn't racial

> And how do we know that? Any very controversial stuff like this will have people on both sides doing all in their power to convince everyone to their point of view. The truth gets lost.

> But saying it is likely vs having actual proof are two different things so my view is that we simply don't know.

The scientific consensus is that race is a social construct and does not have a genetic basis [1], and intelligence is not linked to "race" [2], and attempts to link those are rooted in racism [3].

Science is moving towards recognizing non-human-intelligence, and substantial NHI too - among all different levels of the animal kingdom, with cetaceans and corvids ranking rather high; and here we have folks claiming "the truth gets lost" and "we simply don't know". Sir, we do know.

Since this science information is easily googled, or spat out by frontier AI when queried, what must one think about a lack of willingness and basic due diligence before espousing the statements above?

No need to answer, we all know it is [3].

[1] https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.60.1.71

[2] https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0001228

[3] https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.24150

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by red75prime on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:12AM (#50411608)
There are four components to this. In no particular order: intelligence measurement, validity of racial division, genetic components of intelligence, genetic variation between groups. Your articles address the second point.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:09AM (#50412569)
[2] above already shows there is no scientific basis to genetics explaining intelligence variations in human groups. Other studies [3] back this up, and there are studies clearly tying intelligence variations between human groups to environmental factors [4] [5].

Based on the easily googled wide availability of this information and given the environmental causes of IQ differences, I wonder if an easy scientific corollary is that racists must have had environmental factors behind their inability to comprehend the established science in this matter. LoL

[3] https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2322874121

[4] https://doi.org/10.1037/a0026699

[5] https://doi.org/10.1037/a0029772

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by red75prime on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:24PM (#50418062)
Regarding [1], [2], [3]. GWAS uses additive linear no-interaction model, while we know that there are many regulatory sequences. This limits its power. Environmental variability clearly can't describe 100% of intelligence variability. Twin studies show that.

And, please, be mindful of the difference between arguing discriminatory policies (racism) and finding the facts about the world we live in (science).

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:50PM (#50418354)
> GWAS uses additive linear no-interaction model, while we know that there are many regulatory sequences.

Are you suggesting the listed papers are incorrect? Do you have any published science to support your argument?

> Environmental variability clearly can't describe 100% of intelligence variability. Twin studies show that.

Sauce?

> And, please, be mindful of the difference between arguing discriminatory policies (racism) and finding the facts about the world we live in (science).

The papers I listed are about the science not supporting the racism, literally.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by OroPla on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:53AM (#50412133)
> scientific consensus

“Consensus is the business of politics. Science, on the contrary, requires only one investigator who happens to be right, which means that he or she has results that are verifiable by reference to the real world. In science consensus is irrelevant. What are relevant are reproducible results. The greatest scientists in history are great precisely because they broke with the consensus. There is no such thing as consensus science. If it’s consensus, it isn’t science. If it's science, it isn't consensus. Period.” - Michael Chrichton

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:31AM (#50412354)
> If it’s consensus, it isn’t science. If it's science, it isn't consensus. Period.” - Michael Chrichton*

*not a scientist

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by OroPla on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:57AM (#50414329)
If the message is a truth you don't like, attacking the messenger changes nothing.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:41AM (#50414782)
> If the message is a truth

Do you have any evidence to support this so-called "truth"?

There is strong evidence that IQ differences between human groups are environmental and not genetic [1][2][3].

Based on the easily googled wide availability of this information and given the environmental causes of IQ differences, I wonder if an easy scientific corollary is that racists must have environmental factors behind their inability to comprehend the established science in this matter. LoL

[1] https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2322874121

[2] https://doi.org/10.1037/a0026699

[3] https://doi.org/10.1037/a0029772

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by OroPla on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:32PM (#50415274)
I am talking about the truth that consensus and science are different.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:07PM (#50415566)
> I am talking about the truth that consensus and science are different.

Yes, same. Do you have any evidence for this so-called "truth" that scientific consensus is not science?

It's like claiming that the scientific consensus that 1+1 equals 2 is not science. Or that the scientific consensus that the Earth goes around the Sun is not science. Oh wait, that latter bit is probably triggering for a bunch of people... but probably not for real scientists, though.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by Lum2 on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:56PM (#50429910)
« IQ differences between human groups are environmental and not genetic »

What about running? Down to race? Some races better at (bipedal) racing than others? Or down to environmental factors (availability of open land or whatnot)?

Note I don't care about so-called "IQ" (the very concept seems moronic to me); running performance, on the other hand, can be measured accurately.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Monday November 09, 2026 @09:04PM (#50435175)
> What about running? Down to race?

> running performance, on the other hand, can be measured accurately.

So do you have any science to back up your hypothesis? That certain human groups are better than others at running? And that the better performance isn't tied to geography or other environmental factors?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by Lum2 on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @03:04AM (#50437408)
« any science » — What? Is that supposed to be a joke? Ever heard of the olympics? Ever seen any world-class competition, in sprint or marathon? The former is dominated by West Africans (or the descendants of the negro slaves shipped to America), and the latter by East Africans. It is clear as day.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ninjagoo on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @11:02PM (#50449620)
>> And that the better performance isn't tied to geography or other environmental factors?

> It is clear as day

And yet no science sources, no scientific evidence. All hat, no cattle.

> Ever heard of the olympics? Ever seen any world-class competition, in sprint or marathon? The former is dominated by West Africans (or the descendants of the negro slaves shipped to America), and the latter by East Africans.

But it didn't used to be; it used to be all caucasians winning in the olympics and other world-class events. There's a whole award-winning movie about the olympic sprinters with nary an african amongst the athletes [1]. So your own claim is proof against your argument. Impressive self-goal.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chariots_of_Fire

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by Lum2 on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @11:42AM (#50455434)
Okay, I wasn't thinking about the first Olympics before Berlin 1936 (where Jesse Owens won the 100 meters), and never studied historical statistics. I'd say that back then there were likely socio-environmental factors at work that put Afros at a disadvantage… :) But once those factors were eliminated and a level playing-field established, they were able to play out their superior genetics, and ever since Witty Whitie has been unable to make a comeback!
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ordu on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:07AM (#50411583)
> intelligence isn't racial..

How do you know it?

You see, the issue is one can't just research the topic and then publish an article claiming that intelligence is racial. If someone tried it it would be a shitstorm of accusations in racism.

I personally sure that there are individual differences that work like a limit for an intelligence that a person can develop, and I doubt it highly that these individual differences do not correlate with ancestry in any way. It is very interesting topic, but it is ideologically forbidden, because a) "all men are created equal"; b) the history of racial abuses in Europe and USA.

You see, it is like researching victims of pedophiles seeking any positive personal changes stemming from the abuse. If any1 tried it and had found anything, the Public would burn them alive for their findings.

The public had never learned to tolerate challenges (however remote) to its ideology. There are reasons for that, and I'd say pretty good reasons, but what I want to say: it leads to a situation where some truths are hidden for us and we can't reach them. All we can do is to guess and to believe.

You claim that intelligence isn't racial? I don't believe that you can _know_ it, because the attempt to prove it with a research would be a challenge to Ideology, it is one of unreachable truths.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by avadodin on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:27AM (#50402735)
To be honest, I'm more interested on what ideology/religion lead to the Yamnaya Y line taking over a continent in a timespan of over thousands of years to almost utter replacement despite of the fact that, in the end, the "invaders" were almost identical to the "invaded" than I am in elucidating whether Llama 3 being less performant than Gemma 4 in benchmarks is due to the training corpus or the architecture.

I don't feel like being racist either way.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by qwytw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:28AM (#50403013)
Based on the evidence we have it seems that they simply killed most (in some places almost all) of the local men they could find?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by avadodin on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:13AM (#50403204)
Who is they? The Yamnaya never made it out of the Ukraine.

We know people often kill people. That doesn't even need explanation.

My argument is that it is thousands of years and dozens of mixed generations.

Why do you decide to participate in a thousand-years-long campaign to kill the neighbor who is also your second cousin?

There is no reason they couldn't have turned the other way and attacked their other second cousin.

My best guess is religion but it could also have also been a different kind of fanatic ideology.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by qwytw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:44AM (#50404976)
The immigrants from the steppes and their descendants. It's hard to interpret the fact that the majority and often 90% or more pre Indo European male lineages were replaced in Western and Northern Europe in any other way.

Sure it took many generations but it's hard to imagine that the violence wasn't culturally and racially motivated. Based on genetic evidence it's speculated that that there were more than 10 male migrants to every female coming from the steppe.

> The Yamnaya never made it out of the Ukraine.

I'm not sure what that means? Their descendants clearly did reach Iberia and Britain.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:20PM (#50417412)
Are you referring to the R1a/R1b problem? We do know that non-Corded Ware-derived Indo-European speakers like the Greeks, Armenians, Albanians (the latter perhaps derived from ancient Illyrians) all carry significant amounts of R1b, like the Yamnaya. Why Corded Ware carried R1a instead is still an open problem but not fatal to the hypothesis that Corded Ware originated in a Yamnaya migration (e.g. there might have been different elite paternal lineages involved that weren't dominant enough to be represented in steppe kurgan burials).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by avadodin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:09PM (#50418584)
Haplogroups aside, the replacement over thousands of years is the most interesting detail to me.

In Iberia, you have northern Iberian groups which maybe spoke a bit of an Indo-European language at first, and they are invading Southern Iberians and leaving almost no trace of other haplogroups.

Britain is less interesting because basically it was a regular colonization/invasion of the kind we know by Britons; although there is a genetic trace left of the megalithic people, they were swamped.

As a contrast to the Iberian case, we have several steppe invasions in the historical record but most of them look nothing like it.

The Khans did expand rapidly and engage in some wild oat seeding but there is barely any evidence that they ever were in most of the places they conquered. The Huns were basically new management for Germanic tribes. Again, no trace of their existence.

The only one that looks a bit like the Indo-European expansion is the Turkish invasion of Anatolia where by the end you have a bunch of South-Eastern Europeans with minor Asiatic ancestry effectively larping as Islamic Asians and even becoming the center of the Islamic world for centuries.

But, even in the Turks, you don't see full Y-DNA replacement, not even with the power of Islam.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by JuniperMesos on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:28AM (#50403278)
Regardless of how you feel about being racist, some people will accuse you of being uncomfortably close to a Nazi for talking about the Yamnaya Y line taking over a continent, because 19th and early 20th century anthropologists that the Nazis liked and amplified the ideas of really did think that the Yamnaya Y line took over a continent, they just called them "Aryans" instead of "the Yamnaya Y line".
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:04PM (#50431129)
It is indeed a bit uncomfortable that the Corded Ware-derived cultures that expanded across Central Asia into South Asia ("Indo-Aryans") originated in Central Europe, even if the proto-Indo-Iranians who originated the "Aryan" eponym had no descent relationship to the "Germanic" Corded Ware branch (being essentially siblings). But obviously anyone who thinks the word "Aryan" has any relevance to Germanic peoples is a hateful ignoramus.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by JuniperMesos on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @04:28AM (#50437940)
If "Aryan" ever referred to a specific ethno-cultural group, the best candidate is the Sintashta culture (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sintashta_culture ), who almost certainly were the population who spoke Proto-Indo-Iranian, and who flourished in the southern Urals c. 2200-1900 BC. And we know from among other sources paleogenetic evidence that the Sintashta culture had influence from a 3rd-millennium-BC steppe back-migration of various Corded Ware people, who were cultural descendants of the nuclear-Indo-European-speaking Yamnaya peoples who expanded westward into Europe c. 3500 BC.

Yamnaya/Corded Ware DNA basically persists to this day everywhere in Europe, including Germany. The modern white European genome is a mix of DNA from the Yamnaya, the pre-Yamnaya Anatolian farmer population, and European hunter-gatherers who predated the Anatolian farmers, in varying quantities depending on exactly where in Europe you are looking. Corded Ware populations really do form part of the ancestry of modern Germans, although hardly only them.

An etymology of arya beyond Proto-Indo-Iranian and into common Indo-European is shaky - h₂eryós, probably meaning some kind of social status like "noble" or "freeman", has been posited, which would have a Proto-Germanic reflex *arjaz, which may be attested in some Germanic personal names. It's hard to be certain about details of words reconstructed from a time well before the invention of literacy. Still, I think it's hard to avoid concluding that this is a way that the word "Aryan" does have some relevance to Germanic people, whether other people judge you to be a hateful ignoramus for considering it or not.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @07:34PM (#50461216)
Yeah, this is really about the once-common claim that Germanics were the true Proto-Indo-Europeans, which they were certainly not (the ethnogenesis of anything recognizably "Germanic" was pretty late, definitely in the Iron Age).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by throwthrowuknow on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:15AM (#50403534)
There’s really only one way you totally replace male lineage.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by seri4l on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:02AM (#50403458)
Lysenkoism predates the defeat of the nazis and it's pretty much the same pseudoscientific dismissal of nature for ideological reasons.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by cucumber3732842 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:33AM (#50404417)
>(e.g. obviously a lot of non-Latin ethnicities adapted Roman way of life),

If you wanna tell the romans to GFY you're gonna have to adopt a lot of the structures that make them competitive in order to resist them. There's a fairly large "you wrestle the pig you get shit on you" factor going on.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by inglor_cz on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:23PM (#50407207)
Most of the ethnicities/nations that adapted Roman way of life did not attempt to secede from Roman rule for centuries after that, if ever.

While it is true that learning from Rome was very useful for its later challengers, this usually was not the primary motivation for adoption of Roman culture, especially before ~ 400 AD. It was more about the higher standard of living plus legal stability, as long as Rome could enforce its Pax.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by skew-aberration on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:26AM (#50403000)
Do you know of any good books or sources about this viewpoint?

When I read about history of Europe/Old World in Roman and post Roman times, it's clear that large scale movements of whole groups of people is very common in the historical record.

I wonder why such views were ever resisted in prehistory, a time when such movements were simpler and their motivations more likely to arise?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:49PM (#50407447)
_Who We Are and How We Got Here_ by David Reich (the dean of ancient DNA studies).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ChrisMarshallNY on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:59AM (#50404590)
Language etymology is a fascinating study. This is very far from my own expertise, but I have family that have made it more of a vocation.

Languages can spread by utility, rather than culture.

For example, "Low German" was a common trade tongue, and shows up in parts of the world, where Germans never set foot.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mmooss on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:07AM (#50405686)
The Nazis did do a lot of damage - far more than any benefits from the science would balance - and the 'science' contributed to it. The Nazis and many other racists have long argued that they are just being objective and the other side is biased.

How will you prevent that harm from recurring? Ignoring it hasn't worked, and doesn't distinguish the program you propose from a long line of racist programs and propaganda - that is, nobody can tell whether it's sincere or just another cover story.

But people can tell that it's not responsible, which is a clue about the thought behind it. We can't wash our hands of the consequences of our actions. If you don't prevent the next racist catastrophe, who will? Will you just do it and leave the consequences for others to clean up (and suffer from)?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by abecedarius on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:54AM (#50406007)
"Hitler was a vegetarian. You aren't like Hitler, are you?" is a fair reason to run a garbage-collection pass over your beliefs if you're vegetarian, checking your reasons for it -- but invalid argument against claims that vegetarian diets are healthy. It sounds like mid-century historians collectively made the latter mistake.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mmooss on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:05PM (#50407555)
That's an attempt at dismissing a priori the issues outlined in the GP, completely avoiding addressing them. These are very serious issues with very serious consequences; dismissing them won't change the outcomes.

Assuming you also don't want these horrible outcomes, it doesn't make sense to dismiss the risk. The people who advocate dismissing it are the ones who don't care about or seek those outcomes and are trying to remove obstacles.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by abecedarius on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:24AM (#50413628)
Who's dismissing? The healthy reaction in scholarship is the GC pass of checking, invalidating, and retracing inferences. How else do you approach truth?

Intimating that caring about truth implies "seeking those outcomes" is a great way, to the extent it works in your field, of disconnecting it from reality.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mmooss on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:39PM (#50416375)
Still nothing on the merits. Have a good day!
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by abecedarius on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:49PM (#50416462)
I'm confused about what merits you mean, then. If it's about something other than truth, why should it conflict? Best to you too.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:54AM (#50403120)
And what's the difference exactly? We knew that e.g. the Visigoths had Scandinavian ancestry, but we also know that by then they had lots of other ancestry, too.

To me this reads like Lenski (not affiliated with the authors!) trying a little too hard to make it into an academic culture war issue.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by bazoom42 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:54AM (#50403125)
If I understand the article correctly, there is DNA evidence of mass migration from Scandinavia to Northern Poland, but going further south, the evidence points to migration of a smaller elite rather than mass migration.

> In the beginning, there was a big migration, but later they started mingling, and the transmission of Gothic was more of a cultural nature.

In this comment section it seems people really want it to be one or the other, evidence be damned.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by throwthrowuknow on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:56AM (#50403427)
“mingling”
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by cucumber3732842 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:27AM (#50404383)
>If I understand the article correctly, there is DNA evidence of mass migration from Scandinavia to Northern Poland, but going further south, the evidence points to migration of a smaller elite rather than mass migration.

I.e it wasn't fashionable, didn't make for good career advancement for anyone to look into it let alone say it.

>In this comment section it seems people really want it to be one or the other, evidence be damned.

I'm just here to remind everyone that the "professionals" are fallible and subject to industry circle jerks.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:14AM (#50404712)
Archaeogenetics is a new field in archaeology and linguistics, it only started to really make an impact in the last 15 years. No one was "looking into it let alone saying it" before that simply because DNA from dated archaeological sites hadn't yet been extracted, sequenced, and made available to researchers.

You rushed here to slander people working in the field without familiarizing yourself with the first things about it. Is this really what HN needs?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by shakow on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:26AM (#50404831)
I mean, the academic community deliberately went against historical sources without much evidence-based arguments to do so. Turns out that denying DNA data is not doable, and now they have to do a 180.

I personally wouldn't put the “shame” onto GP.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:32AM (#50404863)
Again, anyone actually familiar with Gothic studies would know that people didn't outright "go against Jordanes", but rather the Gothic Urheimat was always discussed as a matter of controversy, with Jordanes' claims one version but external evidence lacking. Now there is some external evidence.

Historians hold out on claims made in historical sources (especially when written centuries after the fact) all the time, it is a standard scientific practice to seek external evidence.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by shakow on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:55AM (#50405080)
And for having worked in a similarly behaving field, there is a big difference between “yeah we're not sure yet” and “no the ancients are most certainly wrong because our Modern Thinking is necessarily better (wink wink)”.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:14AM (#50405249)
In the specific field of the linked article, I never heard the latter. Not sure why your experience in an unrelated field is relevant here.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by brabel on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:45AM (#50405496)
I suspect the academic community had a bias towards nationalistic interpretation of history. We see this both from Russian and Polish/Ukrainians, whose history is totally interlinked, making it plausible for both sides to make claims favoring what their national identity would prefer, rather than the truth.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:51AM (#50405562)
Again, why "suspect" something about a field of scholarship? You can refer straight to the scholarship on the Gothic Urheimat from the last seventy years and see that this is a field blessedly free from nationalist squabbles compared to others. The Goths left no descendants identifying as such, their entire branch of the Germanic language family went extinct, and no scholar working today is emotionally invested in them for nationalist reasons, nor would they resist particular interpretations because anyone else was.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by themgt on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:10AM (#50405705)
> You can refer straight to the scholarship on the Gothic Urheimat from the last seventy years and see that this is a field blessedly free from nationalist squabbles compared to others.

I am no expert, but here's Michael Kulikowski's argument quoted from the wiki page on the debate:

[Heather] is right to try to deduce governing apparatus from the actions that kings and chieftains were able to compel their followers to take. This approach, more than anything, goes some way toward justifying his assertion that a broad class of nonaristocratic "freemen" warriors must have existed in many of the barbarian cultures of the first half of the millennium. Yet to claim the point proved and build further hypotheses upon it is not legitimate; he comes perilously close to recreating the old, volkisch notion of an inherent “Germanic” belief in freedom. Throughout, in fact, Heather makes the tacit assumption that evidence from any “Germanic,” “Celtic,” or “Slavic” group can be used to analyze any other “Germanic,” “Celtic,” or “Slavic” group—in other words, that linguistic identity and socioinstitutional behaviors go inevitably together. [...] a great many historical comparanda would support a model that he ignores — that the Goths were formed from a large number of indigenes and a small number of migrants under the pressure of Roman imperialism, and in the shadow of the Empire.[31]

And more:

Kulikowski charges that old German nationalist and even Nazi influences continue to influence scholarship on the Goths up to the present day, particularly through the theories of Gustav Kossinna.[19] He considers much of what is written about Goths to be "Germanist fantasy" derived from this legacy.

This isn't exactly what I would describe as a debate "blessedly free from nationalist squabbles"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origin_of_the_Goths

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:29AM (#50405830)
> old German nationalist and even Nazi influences

Notice how the key word there is "old". Scholars may respond to earlier schools of thought in the field, from a now long-vanished time when anyone was invested in it for nationalist reasons, but that doesn't mean anyone today is invested in it. Major work today on Gothic linguistics, one componentin the Urheimat debate, happens in places like Leiden and UCLA who no one has any nationalist dog in the fight.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by brabel on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:00AM (#50411285)
The new evidence points to a population replacement having occurred to a greater extent than academics had anticipated. That is alway a topic that involves nationalist rhetoric because people would rather believe they had been always there, not that they descend from the invaders, or even the next wave of maigrants.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:26AM (#50411674)
Can you point to any nationalist rhetoric from people currently working in the field? Among the handful of current scholars in Poland, Ukraine, and Russia -- i.e. the countries relevant to the article -- I doubt anyone feels anxiety about having the Goths among their ancestors. That happened so long ago (nearly two millennia ago), and there are obviously more recent conflicts that weigh more heavily on people's minds and national consciousness.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by brabel on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:34AM (#50414144)
Well, I was thinking of Kyiv Rus, which appeared almost a thousand years later and were arguably Slavic people with a Scandinavian elite... but if you read the history in different languages around the region they once inhabited, you'll get quite a different picture. I don't know if there's something similar about the Goths, but I am just saying that the academy apparent preference for the Goths having been just a moving culture for the most part, with little population displacement, seems quite biased towards the very common "our people were here for eons" narrative, from the outside.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:35AM (#50414733)
If you don't actually know much about a field of inquiry yourself, maybe it is best to refrain from assuming (and based on a totally different branch of history/archaeology/linguistics) what interpersonal dynamics are at play within it and what it is biased towards. As someone who has been in the field, these posts are just dripping with uninformedness.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by brabel on Monday November 09, 2026 @02:41AM (#50422360)
I will post what I think here, I don’t care how you feel about it.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by a34729t on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:13AM (#50405719)
Sadly very par for the course. You wont get very far if you challenge the consensus nor get funding. I know of this true in at least a major area of neuroscience reliable 2ndhand.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by bazoom42 on Monday November 09, 2026 @09:28AM (#50426132)
> didn't make for good career advancement for anyone to look into it let alone say it.

Say what? You comment is rather vague but seem to suggest you have some knowledge which have been suppressed by academia.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ekidd on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:10PM (#50407125)
> If I'm reading that right they are implying academics were pushing the idea of cultural exchange being the most valuable thing, a vague menagerie of local and foreign cultures coming together, rather than a specific set of people arriving from a far off land to dominant an existing empire and influencing the entire region in the process.

From what I understand, the prevailing academic belief was based on cases where "elite replacement" was what did happen. For example, the Norman conquest of England contributed massively to modern English (all those French load words), and affected the culture in a lot of ways. But for the most part, the actual population movements were smaller. And DNA evidence suggested that several other big cultural and linguistic shifts worked the same way. Mostly the ordinary folk kept doing their thing, while the ruling class suffered upheaval.

The linked article is interesting because it confirms an actual population displacement. Which breaks the recent pattern of studies! But even here later stages were often more cultural shifts than population ones.

We don't know any of this until someone does the DNA studies.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by thaumasiotes on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:11AM (#50411904)
> If I'm reading that right they are implying academics were pushing the idea of [...]

Academics were captured by ideological concerns. There's nothing really veiled about this. One slogan for the movement was "pots not people".

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by InfiniteRand on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:26AM (#50412681)
Honestly, this is one of those things where historiography swings back and forth and the truth is somewhat in the middle. The swinging back and forth is usually because confidence builds around a certain assumption but time is long and eventually evidence is discovered challenging that, then other assumptions get undermined, the new revelation gets focused on to the expense of all the past evidence and it becomes the new central assumption
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by barrenko on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:11AM (#50402354)
Or that Russia commenced as a Viking startup.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fsckboy on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:47AM (#50402530)
I think the Russia case is the case of some Viking leaders of Slavs
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by madspindel on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:08AM (#50404662)
Vikings took slavs as slaves. In Swedish "slav" means "slave". Vikings was rowers from Roslagen. In Finland they use the name Ruotsi for Sweden and Venäjä for Russia.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by stasomatic on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:26PM (#50406284)
I rewatched the Vikings recently (highly recommended, perhaps not historically accurate, but no horned helmets). It was a bit ... don't know, eye opening or strange or hard to believe to learn that the Vikings played a crucial role in that part of the continent and Constantinople. I know that the term "Viking" is not an ethnic identification, more like a profession/warrior, but I don't have another word in my vocabulary.

Ivar the Boneless, Varangians. When I was growing up in Ukraine, this was never ever mentioned in any literature, school, college. That the names like Oleg or Igor were not native threw a twist too, but they are very common names over there in UA/RU, on par with Ivan and Dmitry.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by bergie on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:49PM (#50409508)
Estonian "Venemaa" for Russia sort of points at a common origin there ("venemaa" would be "boat land" in Finnish). So rowing land, boat land.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by griffzhowl on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:18AM (#50404750)
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by somenameforme on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:15AM (#50405260)
Wiki has a pretty interesting history on that [1]:

During its existence, Kievan Rus was known as rusĭskaja zemlja, translated as the "land of Rus" or the "Rus land" (Old East Slavic: роу́сьскаꙗ землꙗ́), with Rus being derived from the ethnonym Роусь. ... The first known use of the term Kievan Rus comes from the 1582 chronicle by Polish historian Maciej Stryjkowski, where it was used to describe the region of Rus state immediately adjacent to Kyiv.

In 1837 it was adopted by Kyiv University rector Mykhailo Maksymovych in relation to the Principality of Kiev; known for his Ukrainophile political orientation, Maksymovych later spread that definition to the whole realm, seeing Kyiv as the original point where Rus statehood emerged, establishing the base for the future Russian Empire.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kievan_Rus%27#Names

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by barrenko on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:16PM (#50406695)
Funny how our slavic etymologies's mythologies are similar -

Ukranian picture - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kievan_Rus%27#/media/File:%D0%...

Croatian picture - https://hr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolazak_Hrvata#/media/Datoteka...

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by contingencies on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:36AM (#50402479)
If you sail south (toward the sun) it's pretty hard to miss Poland, and you'd know it's there long earlier due to observing migratory seabirds.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mjw1007 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:39AM (#50402774)
When you're reading a popular-science story about a new discovery, there are two things to be careful about:

- are the claims it's making about the discovery right, or exaggerated?

- are the claims it's making about what people previously believed right, or exaggerated?

When I'm reading about areas that I happen to know something about, I find that there's a smallish tendency to exaggerate the first and a large one to exaggerate the second.

I think it's likely that's true in other areas. I get the impression it's particularly common for archaeological discoveries for some reason.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by vintermann on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:50AM (#50403108)
Same here. This study is mostly kicking in open doors - or at least the people quoted not affiliated with the study for some reason, are kicking in open doors. I got into this as a tangent from genealogy, and that the Goths were for a good part actually from Scandinavia is not a particularly bold assertion.

Now that the Wielbark culture simply is the Goths, that would be a sightly bolder assertion - and one which is probably good they're not making since it would probably be oversimplifying things.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by OroPla on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:19AM (#50412293)
Probably because you need to exaggerate both for people to care. Everyone thought X was true and now we have evidence for X to be true isn't a particularly interesting thing to read about. Either you insert some drama or you don't even bother reporting it to the larger public.

News are entertainment, after all.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by bazoom42 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:44AM (#50403088)
Science is not just believing what sounds plausible. It is about gathering evidence. Having historical, archeological and DNA evidence is a lot stronger that just historical evidence alone.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by INTPenis on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:04AM (#50403169)
Yeah but I'm a Swede and even I thought those regions were named long after Rome, in tribute to Roman history. Claiming the origins of the infamous Goths just because of their accomplishments in the south.

Because Swedish history before 1000AD is very murky.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ChrisGreenHeur on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:23AM (#50403252)
You did not find it weird that Beowulf identified as a geat?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by INTPenis on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:48AM (#50405526)
Never read it, but also, wasn't it written like hundreds of years after? I thought the oldest written stories we had were Snorres and the Icelandic sagas.

So the 5th and 6th centuries are still very much guesswork when it comes to scandinavian history.

I just always assumed that the legend of Rome was powerful enough for swedes to claim the Goths. But it makes sense that it's based on fact.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ChrisGreenHeur on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:26PM (#50501626)
the edda is about the viking age ca 800, beowulf is about the great migratory age ca 500. Dating is hard, but beowulf should be a couple hundred years younger
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by oh_my_goodness on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:29AM (#50404850)
>Why did people doubt this?

Because the spread of a language doesn't necessarily imply that the DNA also took over. The article makes that point.

I hesitate to suggest this. But maybe the HN commenter standard of proof ("it seems obvious to me") is less exacting than the scholarly standard "what does all the evidence say?"

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by georgeburdell on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:12AM (#50405714)
The article says why. The fall of the Roman empire being increasingly attributed to the migration of foreigners is both problematic and topical
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by arjie on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:11PM (#50407127)
Yeah, but these false-relationships exist a lot. Tamil onnu and English one are not related but Sanskrit’s eka is related to English one.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:01PM (#50408457)
Western arrogance that anything not scientifically proven must not be true. Those myths and oral traditions are backward and uncivilized.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by pvaldes on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:20AM (#50412301)
[delayed]
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by __rito__ on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:54PM (#50415463)
> Why did people doubt this?

Because the university departments are held by a certain type of individuals who want to play down and dismiss anything held sacred and holy by tribes, old cultures, religions, etc., explaining them away with "totems", "magic rituals", etc.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:22PM (#50416188)
This article is ultimately about support for Jordanes' claim that the Goths originated in Scandinavia and then some new findings that the Goths spread by demic diffusion, not just cultural assimilation. Jordanes was a Christian writing among a Gothic community that had converted to Christianity, and they had no attachment to whatever was "sacred and holy" to their ancestors centuries before. Consequently, historians expressing scepticism about Jordanes claim were not doing it out of any bone with "sacredness and holiness".

Perhaps before trying to depict an ultimately rather minor controversy among historians as some axe ground against the sacred and the holy, it might be worth actually learning about the topic first?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by __rito__ on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @01:14AM (#50436701)
My comment was not limited to the particular topic at hand.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by pmontra on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:36AM (#50402196)
> the Spanish for “bandit,” “helmet,” and “truce.”

If they are bandido, casco, tregua they are identical to the Italian bandito, casco, tregua. The only difference is a d/t. Actually in Italy a cyclist and a worker wear a casco, but a soldier wears an elmetto.

I googled the etymology of casco and it comes from Latin but it came to Italy from Spain a few centuries ago. So I wonder what other word for helmet they use in Spain, that originated in the Goth language.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by card_zero on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:22AM (#50402412)
"On the peninsula" ... I found elmo, does Galician count? https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/elmo#Galician
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fcatalan on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:35AM (#50402476)
We have yelmo and almete, but looking up both of them, they seem to be considered later medieval loans. Espuela (spur), dardo (dart) and a few other warlike items are often mentioned. And of course guerra (war) itself.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fcatalan on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:42AM (#50402506)
And tangentially, to this day Canary islanders'slur for peninsulars is "godos", in the sense of "arrogant and haughty"
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by madduci on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:02AM (#50402882)
And in German the word is "Helm" as well
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by shakow on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:34AM (#50404881)
And French has both casque (from latin) and heaume (from germanic languages).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by nachexnachex on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:40AM (#50403672)
Yelmo for helmet
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by anon84873628 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:16AM (#50405270)
I always found this fact about the common Spanish surname Rodríguez to be interesting:

>The "ez" signifies "son of". The name Rodrigo is the Spanish form of the German name Roderich, meaning "rich in fame", from the Gothic elements "hrod" (fame or glory) and "ric" (rich). It was the name of Roderic, the last Visigothic King before the Muslim conquest, and the subject of many legends. The surname Rodríguez could have originated in the 9th century when patronymic names originated.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rodr%C3%ADguez_(surname)

The Visigoths directly ruled in Iberia so that's an example of the "elite influence" spreading culture and language.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by jdw64 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:58AM (#50402298)
Then why did those people move? Was it because of climate change? First of all, it seems less like a movement of a warrior group and more like a group migration that included women and children—so why on earth did they have to move that way? I’m curious: is there research on this?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by dsign on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:57AM (#50402863)
I was visiting the northern city of Umeå in Sweden, in the middle of the winter. It's a bit dark, and in a good year you get a mantle of snow that reaches waist-high, and that was a good year. So I'm sitting in this super-cozy fika room with nice warm lighting having some coffee. Out of the blue, this sweet middle aged lady who had been born there a good half a century before and who loves skiing, says: "I can't bear the darkness any longer. I'm going to Spain this year."
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by gorgmah on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:09AM (#50402922)
I was wondering the same things : I often heard that the relative civilizational collapse that happened in europe during the middle ages was correlated with lower overall temperatures, e.g. what you see here [1] or there [2]. In the second one, the most recent projections (in red), show that there were a lot of very cold years (down to -0.6 degrees relative to normal) during those times. Later on, starting in the 1200s, there was the Little ice age, where temperatures fell to -0.9 relative to normal (I don't know how they defined normal). The peak, when almost all years were at -0.6 or below on that scale, caused the "General Crisis of the seventeenth century" where people from the Goth/scandinavian regions also had huge famines [3].

So my guess would be that there were several very cold years in a row, which caused famines, and the populations understood that their best survival chance was to migrate south, where they had to compete with the roman empire for land.

[1] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fichier:2000_Year_Temperature_... [2] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fichier:2000_Year_Temperature_... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_of_1695%E2%80%931...

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:59AM (#50403144)
For many decades, climate events have been viewed as one driver of cultural events during the Age of Migrations: somewhere on the Asian steppe, decline in quality pasturage successively causes one people to pressure another people to their west, and eventually the avalanche rolls into Europe.

It has saddened me to see this viewpoint associated in the American cultural wars with one party's "enemy camp", where discussion of climate as a problem is automatically associated with all kinds of unrelated policy positions. People are unaware this explanation was posited by hoary old (and largely long-dead)/twentieth-century men who had no dog in the contemporary political divide.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ChrisGreenHeur on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:28AM (#50403281)
Overpopulation, Scandinavia did not have very fertile soil.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by namenotrequired on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:39AM (#50403666)
This is often said (also about the Viking age) and it seems such an incomplete explanation to me. Normally if more people are born than the land can feed, then vulnerable people (eg babies and kids and elderly) die at higher rates until the balance is restored. Why would Scandinavia be different?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mr_toad on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:27AM (#50403969)
They didn’t just have the motivation to leave, they also had the opportunity.

Their longboats made them amphibious. Their ships were durable enough for the open ocean, but still able to land on any beach, or sail fair upriver.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by jltsiren on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:02PM (#50408461)
There are often cultural elements in that balance. Many societies had cultural adaptations that lowered fertility under normal circumstances but enabled faster repopulation after a crisis. But if there was an outlet for excess people, the base reproduction rate could be higher.

For example, the Roman Republic had adapted to constant warfare and the steady stream of casualties caused by it. And then the Late Republic got into trouble, because Rome had become too good at war, and the required casualties didn't happen.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:49PM (#50416469)
The Irish solution was mass emigration and blaming the English.

They had too many births before the potato famine -- it's the reason why it was such a disaster in Ireland compared to the rest of Europe -- and they continued up until a few decades ago. This happened during a time when it was unusually easy to move to "empty" land and colonize it.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by LarsDu88 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:31AM (#50405382)
It had to do with inheritance. Younger sons in the viking era did not inherit the farmstead and had to seek their fortunes elsewhere.

Anytime they had a population explosion, younger sons would have to go A Viking.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by cma256 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:29AM (#50403981)
The Huns drove them out of their lands. The Goths needed to find better lands to support their population. The Roman Empire was weak. The Romans had better land. The Romans couldn't defend their land against the Goths and the Goths couldn't defend their lands against the Huns.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:17AM (#50404320)
The Huns arrived centuries after the Gothic expansion, which reached as far as the Volga river. I assumed the OP's question is (like the linked article) about that expansion from Scandinavia south and east, not the later one west into the Roman Empire.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by hypfer on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:59AM (#50402590)
Not contributing anything intellectually, but this article is a lot of fun to read when one mentally envisions the modern style, looks and meaning of the word Goths.

> In 251 C.E., Roman Emperor Decius, his son, and most of his army were killed fighting Goths in what is today Romania, in one of the empire’s greatest defeats.

Envision the black Eyeliner

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by danparsonson on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:03AM (#50402890)
Sarcasm and irony were their greatest weapons
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by goodmythical on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:24PM (#50409380)
The feared eye-rolls, scathing side-eyes, and deadly scoffs.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by RobotToaster on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:56AM (#50403133)
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by grehbies on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:16PM (#50407647)
The biggest guy I ever saw at an anime convention was a goth. Fishnet shirt, raver pants, arm socks, eyeliner, painted fingernails, lipstick, jet-black hair down to his back, and he had to be around six-foot-five, approaching four hundred pounds of builtfat. In particular, I remember him having a massive chest/arms and a solid belly. Like an NFL lineman deeply in touch with the darkness of his soul.

All this to say that I am envisioning quite easily.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by Terr_ on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:24AM (#50410901)
[delayed]
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by clauderoux on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:00AM (#50403151)
Actually, the most ancient recorded instance of the Goth language is a Bible that was written in what is now Bulgaria around 350: The so-called Bible of Wulfila. So, there is nothing new under the sun about the presence of Goths in the area, bringing their language and culture around.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:11AM (#50403508)
Your "Well acktually..." is misplaced, because no one anywhere in the article ever cast doubt on that, but rather the debate was about the Gothic Urheimat and the degree of gene spread versus cultural diffusion.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ricksunny on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:29AM (#50403287)
barbarian = ?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:44AM (#50403357)
That depends a great deal on who is talking or typing, in what era, and where. Here's a brief list of some of the OED options for meaning:

* A foreigner, one whose language and customs differ from the speaker's.

* One not a Greek.

* One living outside the pale of the Roman empire and its civilization, applied especially to the northern nations that overthrew them.

* One outside the pale of Christian civilization.

* (With the Italians of the Renascence) One of a nation outside of Italy.

* A rude, wild, uncivilized person.

* (in mid 1800s) Applied by the Chinese contemptuously to foreigners.

* An uncultured person, or one who has no sympathy with literary culture.

* A native of Barbary.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by bazoom42 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:08AM (#50403490)
In this context it means they invaded the Roman empire.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by mr_toad on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:07AM (#50403832)
Anyone who talks like a barbarian. In some tales the ancient Greeks thought that anyone who lived outside their city states sounded like bleating sheep. True or not, the word did mean someone who talks like a foreigner.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by singpolyma3 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:22AM (#50403933)
No kidding. That's not an ok word to be putting in a headline
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by ricksunny on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:37AM (#50404037)
I’ve come to have low expectations of Science Magazine under EIC Holden Thorp.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by bortimus on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:20PM (#50407687)
Not Roman.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by alexpotato on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:20AM (#50404343)
This reminds me of Herodotus [0].

For those that don't know about him:

- he was an ancient historian

- he made a lot of "wild claims" e.g. there was a tribe that made clothes out of human skin

- historians assumed these were myths or exaggerated

- recent research has shown that many of his wild claims were true (even the one above) [1]

0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herodotus

1 - https://www.livescience.com/archaeology/ancient-scythians-us...

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by science4sail on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:44AM (#50405930)
[delayed]
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by adammarples on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:46PM (#50406448)
Regardless, he reported a lot of made up stuff like dog headed men and so forth
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by npc99 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:14PM (#50407146)
well if a bunch of other stuff he said that ppl thought was false turned out to be true, why not that too lol
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by alephnerd on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:05PM (#50408055)
How much of that is just literary flourish.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by nemo on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:05PM (#50408906)
[delayed]
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by QuantumNomad_ on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:19PM (#50409357)
A human body with a canine head. My guy Herodotus wasn’t telling tall tales at all, he was merely giving accounts of some of the very first furry conventions. These “dog-headed” men were wearing fursuits!
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by wannabe44 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:12AM (#50412584)
So there are myths about wolf men which are now considered to be evidence of some sort of wolf ritual.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by kromem on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:20PM (#50408603)
Part of the issue was that Herodotus reported what his sources said. So rather than it being 'Herodotus' as a single reliable or unreliable source, it was more like a collection of unvetted sources.

As a result, you got stories about dog sized ants that were nonsense but then also stories that were legit.

People tend to be rather binary with how they process information, so when there's things that are wrong they group everything in the 'wrong' category.

Definitely a lot of false negatives with how Herodotus was regarded. Much like how the prevailing consensus was that Troy was a fictional city until it was discovered.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by skoll43 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:36PM (#50409741)
The dog ants with gold were the Marmota caudata aurea

Which if described by others and you never have seen them, they sound like mythological creatures

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by echoangle on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:59AM (#50412890)
What’s the connection between Marmota and Ants? They look pretty different, no?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by abecedarius on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:30AM (#50413677)
There may've been a translation issue behind "ants". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold-digging_ant
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by pseudohadamard on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:33AM (#50410684)
> So rather than it being 'Herodotus' as a single reliable or unreliable source, it was more like a collection of unvetted sources.

So a sort of one-man Greek Facebook then?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by monocasa on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:07PM (#50409605)
To be fair, Herodotus also didn't believe everything he wrote down. Both implicitly such as recording blatantly mutually exclusive accounts, as well just just explicitly stating that he didn't believe everything on several occasions such as "it is my business to record what people say, but I am by no means obliged to believe it."

He was pretty open about the fact that he basically wrote down any interesting stories, and was not attempting to find some historical truth, but instead transition as much as possible from oral tradition to written.

He mostly gets called the father of history for this semi-novel take. That you can (and in most cases, should) strive for recorder and interpreter to be separate tasks.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by LarsDu88 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:29AM (#50405370)
Swedish Gotlander's have been referring to this mythic origin story for centuries. I believe Gustavus Adophus referenced this history to justify blatant Swedish militarism in the 17th century.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by actionfromafar on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:40PM (#50408304)
Ah, the "stay at home goths" :)
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by w0de0 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:32AM (#50405393)
This of course means that Spaniards are Swedes on extended vacation. They mentioned this to the latter at the 1545 Council of Trent.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by fierycatnet on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:11PM (#50407606)
I thought it was known already? Hardcore History covered it in Thor's Angels episode.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by anthk on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:33PM (#50408674)
> including some connected to conflict and conquest, like the Spanish for “bandit,” “helmet,” and “truce.”

And, totally weird words such as "casa" (home, house) or "sofá".

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by nyeah on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:13PM (#50408954)
[delayed]
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by toppa33 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:49PM (#50409792)
Turns out Jordanes got the Scandinavian boat trip right. A few centuries later, though, most "Goths" were locals who'd signed up.