Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ...
by bluGill on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:33AM
(#50404878)
In the ideal world, assuming this is true, we could then ask for the question of, well, what can we do about these people with different intelligence levels?
Intelligence is not just a single thing. We can assign a number by an intelligence test, of course, but there are lots of ways to look at it that are more nuanced. Generally, you're not going to say someone is better than everything you're going to find that someone is better at some things. And so can we direct people to the things you're better at for the better of everyone? Division of labor is a good thing.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ...
by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:21PM
(#50416170)
It would be wonderful if we understood what biological process determines the size of the brain. There are thousands of genes that each affect IQ ever so slightly but if we zoom out and look "macro" biology, then the size of the brain does correlate reasonably well with IQ and it is likely to be influenced by relatively few genes.
This is probably the first route we will find towards increasing the intelligence of children.
Having said that, even if the academic outcomes of people with darker skin color were worse (no idea if that is true, or in which country) just knowing that is no proof. It may as well be cultural or even income based (pregnant mothers eating worse quality food for example, or same thing with young children).
Is the question even answerable? What kind of intelligence do we measure with "academic outcomes"? How do we adjust for income and quality of life as a child, things like having both parents, or grandparents? It's an absolute minefield of possible manipulation. Same data can probably be spun to "proove" any hypothesis you have.
Then imagine writing a proposal for such research. What benefits can you predict? If you find there is absolutely no correlation between skin color and academic outcomes after adjusting for all external factors will it convince people that are racist as part of their identity? I doubt it.
Lets say you do prove there is some correlation. What the result of that would be? Open discrimination and vindication of racist views. But even if the principle was true the average doesn't apply to individuals so you can't apply it to any particular person.