News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by cucumber3732842 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:27AM (#50404383)
>If I understand the article correctly, there is DNA evidence of mass migration from Scandinavia to Northern Poland, but going further south, the evidence points to migration of a smaller elite rather than mass migration.

I.e it wasn't fashionable, didn't make for good career advancement for anyone to look into it let alone say it.

>In this comment section it seems people really want it to be one or the other, evidence be damned.

I'm just here to remind everyone that the "professionals" are fallible and subject to industry circle jerks.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:14AM (#50404712)
Archaeogenetics is a new field in archaeology and linguistics, it only started to really make an impact in the last 15 years. No one was "looking into it let alone saying it" before that simply because DNA from dated archaeological sites hadn't yet been extracted, sequenced, and made available to researchers.

You rushed here to slander people working in the field without familiarizing yourself with the first things about it. Is this really what HN needs?

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by shakow on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:26AM (#50404831)
I mean, the academic community deliberately went against historical sources without much evidence-based arguments to do so. Turns out that denying DNA data is not doable, and now they have to do a 180.

I personally wouldn't put the “shame” onto GP.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:32AM (#50404863)
Again, anyone actually familiar with Gothic studies would know that people didn't outright "go against Jordanes", but rather the Gothic Urheimat was always discussed as a matter of controversy, with Jordanes' claims one version but external evidence lacking. Now there is some external evidence.

Historians hold out on claims made in historical sources (especially when written centuries after the fact) all the time, it is a standard scientific practice to seek external evidence.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by shakow on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:55AM (#50405080)
And for having worked in a similarly behaving field, there is a big difference between “yeah we're not sure yet” and “no the ancients are most certainly wrong because our Modern Thinking is necessarily better (wink wink)”.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:14AM (#50405249)
In the specific field of the linked article, I never heard the latter. Not sure why your experience in an unrelated field is relevant here.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by brabel on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:45AM (#50405496)
I suspect the academic community had a bias towards nationalistic interpretation of history. We see this both from Russian and Polish/Ukrainians, whose history is totally interlinked, making it plausible for both sides to make claims favoring what their national identity would prefer, rather than the truth.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:51AM (#50405562)
Again, why "suspect" something about a field of scholarship? You can refer straight to the scholarship on the Gothic Urheimat from the last seventy years and see that this is a field blessedly free from nationalist squabbles compared to others. The Goths left no descendants identifying as such, their entire branch of the Germanic language family went extinct, and no scholar working today is emotionally invested in them for nationalist reasons, nor would they resist particular interpretations because anyone else was.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by themgt on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:10AM (#50405705)
> You can refer straight to the scholarship on the Gothic Urheimat from the last seventy years and see that this is a field blessedly free from nationalist squabbles compared to others.

I am no expert, but here's Michael Kulikowski's argument quoted from the wiki page on the debate:

[Heather] is right to try to deduce governing apparatus from the actions that kings and chieftains were able to compel their followers to take. This approach, more than anything, goes some way toward justifying his assertion that a broad class of nonaristocratic "freemen" warriors must have existed in many of the barbarian cultures of the first half of the millennium. Yet to claim the point proved and build further hypotheses upon it is not legitimate; he comes perilously close to recreating the old, volkisch notion of an inherent “Germanic” belief in freedom. Throughout, in fact, Heather makes the tacit assumption that evidence from any “Germanic,” “Celtic,” or “Slavic” group can be used to analyze any other “Germanic,” “Celtic,” or “Slavic” group—in other words, that linguistic identity and socioinstitutional behaviors go inevitably together. [...] a great many historical comparanda would support a model that he ignores — that the Goths were formed from a large number of indigenes and a small number of migrants under the pressure of Roman imperialism, and in the shadow of the Empire.[31]

And more:

Kulikowski charges that old German nationalist and even Nazi influences continue to influence scholarship on the Goths up to the present day, particularly through the theories of Gustav Kossinna.[19] He considers much of what is written about Goths to be "Germanist fantasy" derived from this legacy.

This isn't exactly what I would describe as a debate "blessedly free from nationalist squabbles"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origin_of_the_Goths

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:29AM (#50405830)
> old German nationalist and even Nazi influences

Notice how the key word there is "old". Scholars may respond to earlier schools of thought in the field, from a now long-vanished time when anyone was invested in it for nationalist reasons, but that doesn't mean anyone today is invested in it. Major work today on Gothic linguistics, one componentin the Urheimat debate, happens in places like Leiden and UCLA who no one has any nationalist dog in the fight.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by brabel on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:00AM (#50411285)
The new evidence points to a population replacement having occurred to a greater extent than academics had anticipated. That is alway a topic that involves nationalist rhetoric because people would rather believe they had been always there, not that they descend from the invaders, or even the next wave of maigrants.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:26AM (#50411674)
Can you point to any nationalist rhetoric from people currently working in the field? Among the handful of current scholars in Poland, Ukraine, and Russia -- i.e. the countries relevant to the article -- I doubt anyone feels anxiety about having the Goths among their ancestors. That happened so long ago (nearly two millennia ago), and there are obviously more recent conflicts that weigh more heavily on people's minds and national consciousness.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by brabel on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:34AM (#50414144)
Well, I was thinking of Kyiv Rus, which appeared almost a thousand years later and were arguably Slavic people with a Scandinavian elite... but if you read the history in different languages around the region they once inhabited, you'll get quite a different picture. I don't know if there's something similar about the Goths, but I am just saying that the academy apparent preference for the Goths having been just a moving culture for the most part, with little population displacement, seems quite biased towards the very common "our people were here for eons" narrative, from the outside.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by TFNA on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:35AM (#50414733)
If you don't actually know much about a field of inquiry yourself, maybe it is best to refrain from assuming (and based on a totally different branch of history/archaeology/linguistics) what interpersonal dynamics are at play within it and what it is biased towards. As someone who has been in the field, these posts are just dripping with uninformedness.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by brabel on Monday November 09, 2026 @02:41AM (#50422360)
I will post what I think here, I don’t care how you feel about it.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by a34729t on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:13AM (#50405719)
Sadly very par for the course. You wont get very far if you challenge the consensus nor get funding. I know of this true in at least a major area of neuroscience reliable 2ndhand.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by bazoom42 on Monday November 09, 2026 @09:28AM (#50426132)
> didn't make for good career advancement for anyone to look into it let alone say it.

Say what? You comment is rather vague but seem to suggest you have some knowledge which have been suppressed by academia.