Lum2
I'll add that the entire vocabulary used today is totally misleading. The standard term is "Überfall auf Polen". Well, that sounds like "surprise attack", which is impossible anyway. Poland had fully mobilized their army, and done so first, and repeatedly in the weeks and months leading up to the war. There had been several border incidents with dozens of casualties on both sides. So there was a dangerous smeltering crisis with both sides up in arms, and not the least bit of surprise.
This is how they frame things, they use BS terms such as "Überall" or "Global War on Terror", and they repeat them a million times systematically (Sprachregelung, in education, media and politics), it's all meant to deceive and indoctrinate the public.
« Hitler's invasion into Poland … Humanitarian »
There's no such thing as a "humanitarian military invasion". There were pogroms against Germans in Poland, and thousands of refugees seeking shelter in the Reich, so there were humanitarian issues, and there were reasons to do something about it urgently. But military action never makes anything better. What was going on was somebody provoking Hitler into war. There were of course contingency plans. Hitler wanted to solve the issues involving Poland (Danzig, corridor, and human rights), if possible peacefully (and he made very reasonable proposals: referendum etc) but if not militarily. To then go to war is of course Hitler's hence Germany's responsibility, just like making it into a World War is Britain's.
« Lebensraum » — Completely irrelevant for the war, misleading, ex post projection.
« Poland had no right to exist as a nation » — Where did you get that from? Hitler wanted an alliance with Poland to protect against Bolshevism. But that was before the anti-German riots.
« fundamental text of Nazism » — Completely irrelevant for the war, written in 1924, likely conceived by Hanfstaengl anyway (who was sort of Hitler's mentor). Consider the educational background of Hitler, his biography, his social status. He was a nobody. Not dumb, but a nobody.
« fundamental driver was ideological » — It never is. But that's almost always the pretext. "Our values" etc, all that BS. It's always power politics.
« just a random Senator » — Not sure there is such a thing. It's not a lottery. You need to be loyal to and affiliated with the power basis. And that is not the people, but the rich families who own the country.
« that the invasion was a spontaneous reaction to something that was happening in Poland then? »
There's no such thing as a spontaneous invasion. It has to be prepared, and it had been prepared as "plan B", because Hitler wanted to solve the issues fast, and by force if need be. But he tried to solve them by perfectly peaceful and democratic means (referendum etc) so there could be peaceful coexistence and Poland would obtain a port on the Baltic, whatever the outcome.
A peaceful settlement was not in Britain's interest, so they torpedoed that solution, bolstering up Poland. And incredible as it sounds today, leading Polish politicians such as Beck thought that if push came to shove there would a putsch or revolution against Hitler in Germany and the Polish army would march in unter den Linden. They truely thought that.
So no, the invasion was not spontaneous. It had been plan B all along, i.e. contingent on the failure of plan A, the peaceful settlement.
Here's some of the glaring WTFs about 9/11:
• no plane at the Shanksville site
• no plane at the Pentagone
• aluminium planes ("eggshells") shown on TV going cookie-cutter style through steel girders
• WTC building 7 "pulled" (Silverstein), which takes months of preparation
• unprecedented and ridiculous "pancake collapse" (which of course was demolition)
Even if there was only a single one of these severe plausibility issues ("showstoppers") for the "terrorist attack" narrative, the entire story should be met with the utmost scepticism, if not straightforward refusal to accept.
9/11 is a fraud from A to Z and it started with the construction of the WTC some 30 years earlier.
« 80% confidence JFK »
LHO was set up as a patsy. There was a conspiracy for LBJ to take over, who had been forced upon JFK as a VP (via blackmail: if you don't accept then SHTF wrt to your "extramarital activities" which will destroy your candidacy). Many people were involved in the conspiracy, including part of the Secret Service (his bodyguards). There were a lot of shooters from various angles and places. They hit governor Connally and possibly an SS agent and also JFK but only at the neck.
You can see that in the Zapruder film, which clearly shows the lethal shot coming from the front. But even so, the Zapruder film has been altered to hide a most damning fact: Seeing as the shooters hadn't managed to kill the president in the slow-moving limousine, the driver (SS) brought it to a complete halt (multiple witnesses) to offer JFK as a sitting duck. And that worked, the final shot blew his brains out.
They then altered the evidence (the body) to make sure it didn't flatly contradict the LHO story they were going to tell. But there is proof for this manipulation taking place.
Find the Youtube channel "David Lifton on JFK" (595 subscribers) if interested. The JFK topic is rife with disinformation and all sorts of elaborate theories meant to mislead you and waste your time. But Lifton is the real deal. In "Best Evidence" (1981) he explained how the body was altered to fit the LHO story. Unfortunately, he passed away in 2022 so could't publish his second book "Final Charade" (which may still get published one day, perhaps).
There is also JFK to 9/11 | Everything is a Rich Man's Trick (https://youtu.be/niTwvtokYf0), and while it's great entertainment, it does contain some highly dubious claims ("pink marines" and "homosexual Wehrmacht" IIRC), so I'd take that with a grain of salt.
JFK matters because he wanted to be a true president and not just the general secretary of the ruling criminal plutocracy (which is what are all the others). Well, they didn't allow him to be that president.
Major impacts on Earth on a regular basis would indeed upset the applecart of planetary taxonomy.
« lol, lmao at the idea Hitler was invading for any reason related to humanitarianism » You're laughing because you don't know about the August crisis etc† and the immediate reasons Hitler had to attack Poland (and that were not just his personal reasons). Britain would not have waited so long before attacking in such a case.
Your attitude is no surprise but precisely what propaganda is tailored to accomplish. Inconvenient facts are never taught in school and never broadcast in media. Ideology rules, facts don't matter.
† www vor kriegs geschichte .de
See? You put ideology first. "Soviets = bad", so quoting them is bad, too. Ideology first, hence facts don't matter any more. And this is not an insult, it's an observation.
Btw, I was quoting Truman, not the Soviets, and the NYT link only so no one can say, "ah, that Truman quote is fake." It isn't. But you chose not to focus on facts.
« Why make peace when you're going to win? » — Because most people prefer peace? Because you don't want to be at war?
Such an approach would of course be completely misguided. OTOH, the official narrative does contain lies and omits a lot of facts in many ideologically important cases, such as JFK or 9/11, where I think the assumption of fraudulence and "sth foul about it" has become the mainstream view.
« Most people just look at the surface level of what is presented to them and don't really think about anything (unless forced by circumstances). In spite of the fact that we know everything is Propaganda and Deception (of one sort or another) managed by vested interests (not always to one's detriment though) people want to believe they are "free to act as they please". Given what we know today about the world, human psychology and the power of technology, this belief is so naive that i find it hard to understand how one can maintain it. People are consciously maneuvered into a "mental box" and they seem to be unaware of it. »
He then also recommends books by Ellul and one Edward Jay Epstein (a Usanian journalist who apparently doubted the "lone gunmen LHO killed JFK" claim, hence must be labeled a "conspiracy theorist" by the honest and righteous adherents of bienpensance).
Factually wrong (not even a mainstream history claim), and flawed thinking: British action is British responsibility, not some automatism or law of nature.
Seeing as there were no attempts from the Western side to solve the humanitarian issues in Poland all through the summer, Hitler decided to go to war. That is his, or Germany's, responsibility. A regional war in the Baltics that lasted four weeks. Britain made it into a World War. And that's Britain's responsibility. Their total hypocrisy in the matter is proven by the fact they didn't declare war on the Soviet Union after Sep 17, 1939. They had very specific ideas, strategically. Hitler, OTOH, didn't have a strategy.
« no idea … random novel » — It's the source of the quote.
« You seem to be a person … views … beliefs. » — You got it all wrong because you're driven by ideology. For me, it's about the truth of the history they've dumped us in. And I know they are liars and hypocrites. Hence the need for revision.
Perhaps because you don't want to? Some people put ideology first. Many more use ideological vocabulary as the baseline of their reasoning, which is how people are educated in Western societies. So do you. And most people prefer never to leave the propaganda matrix because they sense it could be uncomfortable. Maybe that is your case? I don't know.
I mean, you demanded, you obtained, then you dismissed. It is impossible to get acquainted with the circumstances within just a few hours. There's so much people aren't taught (as a matter of systematic disinformation), and so many lies they are taught instead.
The mere informational volume precludes any "understanding" within so short a timeframe. Then, there's the deeper obstacle of fear to overcome. Fear to leave the herd. Most people simply don't. That's how propaganda, conformism and compliance work. You can read about it in the classics of mass psychology (Gustave Le Bon, Jacques Ellul, Edward Bernays). This is how "free" societies are herded.
As for "money flow", the books by Antony Sutton are quite well known (but I haven't read them yet).
« You take very great care to claim that it saved lives … »
Really? I wrote one sentence about it, a dozen words. (Hope you didn't use AI to assist in writing.)
« … without making any mention of the fact that lengthening the war by years caused far more suffering in the long run. »
So why didn't Britain make peace if that's what they were interested in? Because they weren't. Germany made many peace offerings, Britain wasn't interested, only feigned interest in order to deceive, successfully so to the point that Hitler even sent Hess for direct negotiation, in a heroic one-man mission (see Martin Allen, The Hitler/Heß Deception, dt Churchills Friedensfalle, author was maligned and accused of forgery, b/c he's right on the money, of course).
Hitler was so foolishly anglophile he let them escape at Dunkirk. It's almost as if he was a British agent.
Hitler had made reasonable proposals to solve the contentious issues of the millions of Germans who had been shoved under Polish rule, like referendums and transit corridors, but Britain wasn't interested. Same for the US, of course, but they stayed in the background at first. Because Britain (like the US) were interested in war (their second "World War" against Germany), and they knew they would be in a position to instrumentalize the Soviets.
If we see that Germany is winning we ought to
help Russia and if Russia is winning we ought to
help Germany, and that way let them kill as many
as possible, although I don't want to see Hitler
victorious under any circumstances. Neither of
them thinks anything of their pledged word.
— Harry S. Truman about "Barbarossa"
Apparently (haven't checked) quoted in: The New York Times (24 June 1941) and in: TIME magazine (2 July 1951), also:https://www.nytimes.com/1951/02/03/archives/wests-treachery-...
Main difference between Brits and Amis, the latter like to boast and brag in public while the former are too smart to do so.
To counter (and then replace) your ideology-driven approach, you could do some FACTUAL background reading on how the war was actually set up, Schultze-Rhonhof wrote a great book about it (Der Krieg, der viele Väter hatte).
That is only because you haven't left the propaganda matrix yet… The role of Ernst Hanfstaengl is quite well known, he worked for US intelligence, basically conceived the second part of "Mein Kampf" (part I is the history of "the Movement", part II is kind of a "geopolitical and ideological outlook" – if you haven't read it).
There's a book I haven't read whose authors (Macgregor and O'Dowd) claim that the British had an agent called Bill de Rupp in Hitler's entourage (never heard of him). Frederick William Winterbotham himself is also said to have been in close contact with Hitler (I'll have to read their book first).
https://covertactionmagazine.com/2025/09/20/anglo-american-i...
Jim Macgregor has written books with Gerry Docherty about WW1, they're very good, and radically revisionist (blame Britain for WW1, i.e. a "secret elite", following the prosopograhpic approach by renowned US historian Carroll Quigley, basically tracking people/power networks).
But apart from Hanfstaengl & Co, if you observe British/US behaviour towards Germany, and the way they twist and frame history (now as then), and get a sense for the sophistication of their lies, then it's pretty obvious what they wanted Germany to accomplish:
• go to war against the Soviet Union
• make life uncomfortable for the Jews so they'd emigrate (to Palestine, and with their money of course) – rather then serving as soldiers to fight and die in the East like their non-Jewish compatriotes
I could write more but I'll leave it at that because in my experience (from a previous account) so many substantive comments here on HN get "flagged" (and thus censored) by bigots (who effectively control what can be discussed here), so it's not worth while investing too much effort.
Just one thing, France wasn't "smashed", France was outmaneuvered, sparing them (and us) the horrible bloodbath of WW1. And I'll add that France, together with Britain, had declared war on Germany on 3 Sep '39 – just because so many people are never taught these things and still don't know them when they retire (perhaps because they're not supposed to know).
What about running? Down to race? Some races better at (bipedal) racing than others? Or down to environmental factors (availability of open land or whatnot)?
Note I don't care about so-called "IQ" (the very concept seems moronic to me); running performance, on the other hand, can be measured accurately.
I haven't read the transcripts, but I remember reading about Weizsäcker stating that they went outside whenever they didn't want the British to listen in on their conversations, simply because they suspected they were being eavesdropped on:
Erst nach fast fünfzig Jahren wurden die Mithörprotokolle
freigegeben und veröffentlicht.[23] […]
Allzu weitreichende Schlüsse sollten aus den Farm-Hall-Protokollen
jedoch nicht gezogen werden. Zum einen blieb nur ein Bruchteil der
Gesprächsmitschnitte, ungefähr zehn Prozent, erhalten. Zum anderen,
und dies ist weitaus wichtiger, ahnten die Deutschen, dass sie
abgehört wurden. Daher besprachen sie die sensibelsten Themen
nicht im Haus, sondern im Rosengarten. »Es war der geeignete Ort für
ernste Gespräche zu zweit«, wie Heisenberg später feststellte.[24]
Weizsäcker erklärte: »Wenn es etwas gibt, was die Engländer besser
nicht hören, gehen wir in den Garten.«[25]
Rainer Karlsch, Hitlers Bombe, 2005I haven't read the entire book yet, which argues that there was a German project to build an "atomic bomb", a proposition that would probably have met with ridicule were it not for the fact that the author is an established researcher and very well respected on account of his prior work.
I'm certain he's serious and in good faith and not writing for hype or propaganda. Maybe there was such a project, who knows. But I'm convinced the entire "atomic bomb" thing as it has been publicized is a scam and there's never been such a weapon because nuclear fission, while a great source of heat (and hence power) given the right conditions (moderation), does not lead to explosion.
If interested, see my comments 50411911 or 50412194, flagged to death by bigots, who censor facts and opinions they dislike and prevent interesting discussions on HN (because such apparently aren't the site's purpose). Palmer's book, while free, is serious work, apparently too serious for HN, hence the URL in 50411911 is blacklisted and entails instant death of the containing comment (at least when I post it – YMMV).
Excellent point about how "a rigorous quantitative approach based on official documents" can lead to wrong results and flawed conclusions… :)
Hitler lacked prudence, and his rise was facilitated by the US and Britain precisely for that reason, to make Germany into an ideological antagonist to the Soviet Union, and lead into a clash.
In practice, ideology mattered little, and it was classic geopolitical reasons that led into war in 1941, viz Germany's vulnerability wrt the oil (Ploesti threatened by the Red Army), key to almost everything in the industrial age, still true today.
I disagree with the logic that sth or somebody is "a scam" because of defeat. By that logic, the victims of rape and murder would be "scams". That is not to say that everything about NS was good.
“You must understand that this war is not against Hitler or National Socialism, but against the strength of the German people, which is to be smashed once and for all, regardless of whether it is in the hands of Hitler or a Jesuit priest.” — Winston Churchill (allegedly)
I don't know whether Churchill actually said that, but that is the truth of the matter. The motives were not noble: envy and greed, and nothing more.
Funny thing is that Germans back then didn't realize that at all. On the contrary, they were – by and large – really happy with Hitler, and that was precisely because of the economy. "The Nazis" had brought back employment. And not just "because of armament", simply not true. There were creative things like MeFo-Wechsel and barter agreements with Latin America, thus bypassing the bloodsuckers in London and New York. So what was wrong with that?
But of course there's that particular kind of know-it-all Azi American who knows everything about all other countries, while also slurring them as a matter of routine, from his superior vantage point in the City on the Hill. I guess it's not his fault because because that's the way the system has educated him.
You said the scientists thought that: « Enough talented, high-ego people could not work together on project that large and demanding. » However, this is flatly and totally contradicted by the successful A4/V2 project, within the Wehrmacht, which did end up producing a working product (and not just a fictional narrative), despite the career ambitions of SS and industry people who showed up as soon as "success was in the air" (as described in the book on Peenemünde by executive Walter Dornberger).
Why would they have done that? Hadn't they themselves been "working on an atomic bomb"?
Wernher von Braun wasn't hanged either although he'd been working on a "device" that actually ended up working. He was even "invited" to continue his work in the USA, bringing along his entire team.
Here's Yozo Kudo, general secretary of the Japanese National Association for the Assessment of Air Raids and War Damage:
————————
INTERVIEW: Why U.S. air raids continued until day of Japan’s surrender — THE ASAHI SHIMBUN² — August 14, 2023 — Yozo Kudo, 73, secretary-general of the national association of groups recording air raids and war damage
The United States carried out air raids from Aug. 14 to early Aug. 15. More than 1,000 aircraft, including 825 B-29 bombers, attacked targets nationwide. It is believed to be the largest number of aircraft deployed for (a string of) air raids during the Pacific War.
Q: Which cities were attacked?
A: Targets included Osaka, where Osaka Arsenal and Kyobashi Station were bombed, Akita’s Tsuchizaki district, Isesaki in Gunma Prefecture, Kumagaya in Saitama Prefecture, and Iwakuni and Hikari in Yamaguchi Prefecture.
When small-scale bombings are included, about 30 locations were attacked. Many people were killed. But casualty counts vary, and the exact number is unknown.
Q: Why were air raids conducted on the day of the surrender or the day before?
A: Japan’s delay in accepting the Potsdam Declaration was in the background.
The government informed the Allied powers on Aug. 10 that it would accept the declaration on condition that the emperor’s rights of sovereignty would not be changed. But arguments within the government and military became tangled over a response from the Allied powers. Some said the emperor’s status was not guaranteed, and an agreement was not reached for some time.
The United States on Aug. 10 stopped air raids on urban areas by B-29 bombers to prevent an adverse impact on peace negotiations. The following day, air raids by B-29 bombers were suspended altogether.
The United States once waited for an end of peace negotiations, although it continued some air raids by other bombers. But Japan did not produce its conclusion for some time, and the United States decided to carry out large-scale air raids on Aug. 14-15 to urge Japan to accept the Potsdam Declaration.
Henry Arnold, commander of the U.S. Army Air Forces, had wanted the grandest possible finale, according to a history of warfare by B-29 bombers.
The U.S. military initially considered an air raid on Tokyo, which would have a strong psychological impact on the Japanese government, but eventually decided to target several areas outside Tokyo.
Japan decided to accept the Potsdam Declaration at a meeting in the presence of the emperor on Aug. 14. But it took time before U.S. military officials on the ground were informed of Japan’s decision, and air raids continued until the early hours of Aug. 15.
————————
That doesn't give a clear answer as to the motivation of these anewed US terror bombing raids against civilians. There is no military reason, as with all previous attacks on civilians. Just sadism? Or maybe the raids on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were not impressive enough?
Do you think what they reveal is the truth? Was the diary meant to be published and become "a source"? Was Truman informed about everything important going on in the US? About the reality (the truth) of the Manhattan Project? Did he even need to know? Wasn't it preferable for him to simply believe in order to play his role?
Just some questions to ponder as to the quality of this source and what can be deduced from it.
« This is alternative history, not real history. »
Okay, but "real history" is full of lies, so that per se cannot be an argument against "alternative history". Which is not to say that "alternative history" is truthful, it can be just as full of lies, or even, in certain cases, be the flip side of the very same lie.
Your fighter pilot anecdote sounds like Hollywood: Good US boy scared to death by insane fanatical Japanese cranks up a lie that is then believed by the highest state leadership, alright… We can smell the propaganda here, can't we.
What defrost said wrt Alperovitz sounds very reasonable:
• Japan already defeated – FACT
• Japan had been sueing for peace (since around May, I think) – FACT
• real reason for "The Bomb" was to impress Soviet Union (and the world at large, I think) – FACT
• "The Bomb" only an excuse for emperor, real reason was Manchuria – arguable/doubtful, but not important; key is points 1 and 2
Now, in his book "Hiroshima revisited" (free PDF available), Michael Palmer takes a scientific look at the Hiroshima and Nagasaki evidence and concludes that it does not support the notion conveyed by US propaganda that a novel "atomic bomb" was used.†
Rather, it appears these cities were democratically firebombed like dozens of other Japanese cities, using napalm, which is clear as day from the medical evidence. Palmer, who is an MD, also notes that there is a conspicuous absence in the medical literature about napalm injuries.
In fact, the forensic evidence (medical, physical and other) totally and absolutely contradicts the notion that any extraordinary weapon such as the "atomic bomb" was used.
But there was more than napalm (a heinous weapon) that was dumped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki (like on dozens of other cities before). Various "special effects" were used, and notably mustard gas, apparently to fake radiation effects.
† [URL deleted in this repost (in an attempt to avoid automatic censorship) but you can easily google it yourself]
This is the key to understand WW2. The oil, and the iron ore (Sweden, hence Norway). But mostly the oil. All the rest about ideology etc in Western/Anglo historiography is distraction at best (but actually rather deliberately misleading). Like "Hitler sought world domination" and similar junk, this is just ludicrous, we can simply take a look at the map and take note of who had already secured world domination.
The lack of oil had already been painful for Germany during Britain's first "World War", having to rely on horses to a much larger extent than the enemy, and the importance of oil had only risen with motorization.