News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by avadodin on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:27AM (#50402735)
To be honest, I'm more interested on what ideology/religion lead to the Yamnaya Y line taking over a continent in a timespan of over thousands of years to almost utter replacement despite of the fact that, in the end, the "invaders" were almost identical to the "invaded" than I am in elucidating whether Llama 3 being less performant than Gemma 4 in benchmarks is due to the training corpus or the architecture.

I don't feel like being racist either way.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by qwytw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:28AM (#50403013)
Based on the evidence we have it seems that they simply killed most (in some places almost all) of the local men they could find?
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by avadodin on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:13AM (#50403204)
Who is they? The Yamnaya never made it out of the Ukraine.

We know people often kill people. That doesn't even need explanation.

My argument is that it is thousands of years and dozens of mixed generations.

Why do you decide to participate in a thousand-years-long campaign to kill the neighbor who is also your second cousin?

There is no reason they couldn't have turned the other way and attacked their other second cousin.

My best guess is religion but it could also have also been a different kind of fanatic ideology.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by qwytw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:44AM (#50404976)
The immigrants from the steppes and their descendants. It's hard to interpret the fact that the majority and often 90% or more pre Indo European male lineages were replaced in Western and Northern Europe in any other way.

Sure it took many generations but it's hard to imagine that the violence wasn't culturally and racially motivated. Based on genetic evidence it's speculated that that there were more than 10 male migrants to every female coming from the steppe.

> The Yamnaya never made it out of the Ukraine.

I'm not sure what that means? Their descendants clearly did reach Iberia and Britain.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:20PM (#50417412)
Are you referring to the R1a/R1b problem? We do know that non-Corded Ware-derived Indo-European speakers like the Greeks, Armenians, Albanians (the latter perhaps derived from ancient Illyrians) all carry significant amounts of R1b, like the Yamnaya. Why Corded Ware carried R1a instead is still an open problem but not fatal to the hypothesis that Corded Ware originated in a Yamnaya migration (e.g. there might have been different elite paternal lineages involved that weren't dominant enough to be represented in steppe kurgan burials).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by avadodin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:09PM (#50418584)
Haplogroups aside, the replacement over thousands of years is the most interesting detail to me.

In Iberia, you have northern Iberian groups which maybe spoke a bit of an Indo-European language at first, and they are invading Southern Iberians and leaving almost no trace of other haplogroups.

Britain is less interesting because basically it was a regular colonization/invasion of the kind we know by Britons; although there is a genetic trace left of the megalithic people, they were swamped.

As a contrast to the Iberian case, we have several steppe invasions in the historical record but most of them look nothing like it.

The Khans did expand rapidly and engage in some wild oat seeding but there is barely any evidence that they ever were in most of the places they conquered. The Huns were basically new management for Germanic tribes. Again, no trace of their existence.

The only one that looks a bit like the Indo-European expansion is the Turkish invasion of Anatolia where by the end you have a bunch of South-Eastern Europeans with minor Asiatic ancestry effectively larping as Islamic Asians and even becoming the center of the Islamic world for centuries.

But, even in the Turks, you don't see full Y-DNA replacement, not even with the power of Islam.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by JuniperMesos on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:28AM (#50403278)
Regardless of how you feel about being racist, some people will accuse you of being uncomfortably close to a Nazi for talking about the Yamnaya Y line taking over a continent, because 19th and early 20th century anthropologists that the Nazis liked and amplified the ideas of really did think that the Yamnaya Y line took over a continent, they just called them "Aryans" instead of "the Yamnaya Y line".
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:04PM (#50431129)
It is indeed a bit uncomfortable that the Corded Ware-derived cultures that expanded across Central Asia into South Asia ("Indo-Aryans") originated in Central Europe, even if the proto-Indo-Iranians who originated the "Aryan" eponym had no descent relationship to the "Germanic" Corded Ware branch (being essentially siblings). But obviously anyone who thinks the word "Aryan" has any relevance to Germanic peoples is a hateful ignoramus.
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by JuniperMesos on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @04:28AM (#50437940)
If "Aryan" ever referred to a specific ethno-cultural group, the best candidate is the Sintashta culture (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sintashta_culture ), who almost certainly were the population who spoke Proto-Indo-Iranian, and who flourished in the southern Urals c. 2200-1900 BC. And we know from among other sources paleogenetic evidence that the Sintashta culture had influence from a 3rd-millennium-BC steppe back-migration of various Corded Ware people, who were cultural descendants of the nuclear-Indo-European-speaking Yamnaya peoples who expanded westward into Europe c. 3500 BC.

Yamnaya/Corded Ware DNA basically persists to this day everywhere in Europe, including Germany. The modern white European genome is a mix of DNA from the Yamnaya, the pre-Yamnaya Anatolian farmer population, and European hunter-gatherers who predated the Anatolian farmers, in varying quantities depending on exactly where in Europe you are looking. Corded Ware populations really do form part of the ancestry of modern Germans, although hardly only them.

An etymology of arya beyond Proto-Indo-Iranian and into common Indo-European is shaky - h₂eryós, probably meaning some kind of social status like "noble" or "freeman", has been posited, which would have a Proto-Germanic reflex *arjaz, which may be attested in some Germanic personal names. It's hard to be certain about details of words reconstructed from a time well before the invention of literacy. Still, I think it's hard to avoid concluding that this is a way that the word "Aryan" does have some relevance to Germanic people, whether other people judge you to be a hateful ignoramus for considering it or not.

Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by senderista on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @07:34PM (#50461216)
Yeah, this is really about the once-common claim that Germanics were the true Proto-Indo-Europeans, which they were certainly not (the ethnogenesis of anything recognizably "Germanic" was pretty late, definitely in the Iron Age).
Re:A barbarian tribe's mythic origin story is true, ancient ... by throwthrowuknow on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:15AM (#50403534)
There’s really only one way you totally replace male lineage.