no we don't. intelligence isn't racial..
* except in that being beaten around the head can make a person stupid.
Having said that, even if the academic outcomes of people with darker skin color were worse (no idea if that is true, or in which country) just knowing that is no proof. It may as well be cultural or even income based (pregnant mothers eating worse quality food for example, or same thing with young children).
Is the question even answerable? What kind of intelligence do we measure with "academic outcomes"? How do we adjust for income and quality of life as a child, things like having both parents, or grandparents? It's an absolute minefield of possible manipulation. Same data can probably be spun to "proove" any hypothesis you have.
Then imagine writing a proposal for such research. What benefits can you predict? If you find there is absolutely no correlation between skin color and academic outcomes after adjusting for all external factors will it convince people that are racist as part of their identity? I doubt it.
Lets say you do prove there is some correlation. What the result of that would be? Open discrimination and vindication of racist views. But even if the principle was true the average doesn't apply to individuals so you can't apply it to any particular person.
Intelligence is not just a single thing. We can assign a number by an intelligence test, of course, but there are lots of ways to look at it that are more nuanced. Generally, you're not going to say someone is better than everything you're going to find that someone is better at some things. And so can we direct people to the things you're better at for the better of everyone? Division of labor is a good thing.
This is probably the first route we will find towards increasing the intelligence of children.
This is especially clearly just a racist concept once you realize that none of the studies of IQ vs race actually do any genetic testing, they only rely on phenotype. Which is absurd given the fact that the child of a black-skinned person born in sub-Saharan Africa and a white-skinned person born in a village in Ireland is extremely likely to be black-skinned, but is genetically just as much part of both populations. It's only the history of racism that assigns this child as black more so than white.
The implication that if one group was shown to have a measurably lower intellect they are less “human” somehow is really worrying.
And the way IQ is used in modern racist discourse is not this. Instead, the claims are "black people are not less well off on average because of racism in society, either old or current, they are less well off because they are dumber (have lower IQ) on average, so it's only a consequence of that, as dumber white people also tend to fail to get as much success". This is the argument being made, at least publicly, by most modern day scientific racists.
What does it mean to be human?
So if we for example say that a certain man has a deep voice because he is black, we don't mean that his skin gives him the deep voice.
That is, no one would point at a man with dark brown skin and say "that's a white man" even if both of his parents were white and he had just inherited his dark skin color from a grandparent (which can occasionally happen). And more commonly, the child of a "black" person and a "white" person is invariably considered to be a "black" person in the USA *, despite being exactly 50-50 part of both populations from a genetic standpoint. And this can extend for a ridiculous number of generations, since the child of this person with another "white" person would also be considered "black", despite being only 25% part of their dark skinned grandparent's population from a genetic perspective.
This is also the root of one of the biggest fears of white supremacists, the danger of "white genocide" by "race mixing" - as you can't get "white" children when a "non white" person has children with a "white" person.
* I'm saying "in the USA" because other places have their own rules, since race is a socio-cultural construct. In South Africa, at least during apartheid, for example, the children of "whites" and "blacks" were considered a separate "race", "colored".
We can predict skin colour reasonably well on the basis of very few genes. We need many more to predict intelligence (and we can't predict it nearly as well).
On the other hand, however...
...there are a lot of people who happen to have whatever genes cause dark skin who also happen to have lot of other genes that do other things...
Some of those others things include a genetic protection against malaria. Others confer a genetic protection against a nasty parasitic worm that prefers to live in the kidneys. The downside is that that protection itself is a bit unhealthy for the kidneys.
And some of them do a might good job of seeming like they cause lower intelligence. If we use our genetic prediction models, then they do in fact predict a lower intelligence.
The same way as South-Koreans are by now taller than North-Koreans (because of material reasons) we could posit that "intelligence", i.e. the "workings" of our brain, can be distributed in a non-uniform manner across humankind, depending on the "local" material conditions.
And this is not about "race", because according to those that do believe in the "race" stuff both North-Koreans and South-Koreans are part of the same "race", it is about those material conditions that I've mentioned and which, in the end, by necessity end up modifying things in our (very material) brains, and hence in our "intelligence". Believing otherwise, meaning believing that are our brains are not affected by the material conditions under which we live our day-to-day lives, would be preposterous.
I don't find it that tricky, intelligence does come from the brain.
> That's like equating the workings of my bicycle to my decision to ride to a particular place
Both one's brain and one's "intelligence" belong to the same person, like, physically and materially, which is not true when it comes to your bicycle example. More to the point, I find the comparison itself kind of self-describing, it's like deciding to "outsource" intelligence to some other external, non-ethereal entity (like a bicicle that is physically separate from a human being) in order to avoid those hard questions the OP was alluding to (hard questions that oftentimes also involve the political side of things).
There are other notions about the transfer of ideas: https://www.apa.org/monitor/2010/06/memory-transfer
It takes an enormous amount of engineering work to make an intelligent rock, and not all intelligent rocks are equally intelligent. This is very obvious.
(Rocks don't have ideas.)
Or it could be discrimination. There are studies that show that black and white mixed races children did not score any higher than children with two Black parents, which may point to some discrimination impacting IQ.
And where does culture and/or economy come from if they don't come from races of people? Do hackers argue that human culture existed before humans?
If the difference is genetic then Malay culture gets a free pass.
Its akin to judging a man by the color of his skin instead of by the content of his character.
Thanks for your comment that clarifies how genetics provides a much more granular window into an individual than any physical characteristic taken by itself can provide.
The impact of it's culture and behavioral like inbreeding being acceptable probably plays a bigger role though, but denying genetic impact is just putting your head in the sand because you cannot face reality not being equal. Which it ain't.
Cultural practices can have a big effect on intellectual development, so disentangling any possible genetic factors from cultural ones can be very difficult, but there is very little evidence for genetic factors related to race also being related to intelligence at the population level. Obviously certain genetic disorders can have a significant effect.
Those who immigrate to America are not smarter. They just had the where with all to pay for immigration. Even those who go on scholarship have to prove they have atleast land/housing back in India to even get a chance to immigrate.
How do you define racial groups? its something that constantly shifts. I have an encyclopedia for the 1950s that defines South Asians as "Caucasoid" which is not how most people now think.
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f9/Principa...
Obviously some racial groups which are heavily socially constructed are not borne out by the data. There's no cluster for 'Latinos'. But in general I think there is quite a high correspondence with race as it is constructed in society and culture.
There's certainly some cases where the genetic data matches conventional thinking about race, but also many where they flatly contradict. It also suggests that saying something like "white people are genetically smarter on average than black people" is highly suspect. The group of people that we call "black" has a greater range of genetic profiles than the rest of the world put together, and the group we call "white" is kind of confused—to be genetically meaningful it would probably need to either include North Africans and Arabs or exclude Southern Europeans.
Looking at this
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_genetic_variation#/media...
It looks as though there are two rough clusters, Africans and everyone else, with Europeans and Middle Easterners in the intersection. Pretty much reflecting geography.
> https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f9/Principa...
Is there a reason you're sharing a random uploaded file instead of a "vetted" actual Wikipedia article?
Is there any reason to think this is from a real or valid scientific study?
Plus, none of these studies actually spend the money to do any genetic testing, they simply assign people to "white" or "black" race based almost always on skin color (which, since the gene for dark skin is dominant, is a very poor marker of actual genetic similarity - the great grandchild of a dark-skinned person with otherwise only white-skinned relatives can still be dark-skinned).
What if some of the observed racial differences were caused by a lack of vitimin D, due to darker skin photosynthesising less of it? Then we could fix the prison crisis with a pill!
If we block all research into a problem then we can’t solve it.
If you actually care about fixing a problem then we should bring all available tools to fix and solve it.
Correlation measures whether Y=mX+c holds with small error. I sometimes think that too many people think that all dependencies are somehow straight-line ones. This is distinct from "linear approximation" in physics and engineering, which is more justifiable.
I also suspect that correlations of 0.5 or lower are just statistical noise.
Fundamentally my argument is maybe science can solve a problem, let’s at least try.
IQ tests have been revised several times to address things like that, like that they "unfairly" penalize dyslexia, or that they had lots of questions which were easier for people of specific social backgrounds. Every time they were, they naturally became less "predictive", since both dyslexia and not belonging to the California white upper middle class give you pretty obvious disadvantages in life outcomes.
So don't waste time on IQ, and don't waste time on other academic culture war BS either.
The research to ban lead in fuel relied on measuring IQ and measuring lead exposure, then showing a correlation between the two.
At the population level IQ is a very useful tool.
We don't have a good model of what intelligence is. But since IQ studies are fairly common, there's a lot of data collected that uses IQ, and since it IQ looks vaguely like "intelligence," a lot of researchers who are motivated to find reasons to declare particular people intelligent or unintelligent are more than happy to use that data to support their claims.
Answer this question:
> If you can’t study IQ how do you demonstrate that lead poisoning causes reduced intelligence?
It should be clearly evident that trying to use IQ to establish that "<insert ethnic group here> are stupid" is bad science. It's the same sort of science to establish that "<insert environmental factor here> causes stupidity," so we also need to reject it even if the environmental factor is clearly something problematic. The problem isn't the conclusion, it's the methodology.
It’s a good thing that measuring IQ enabled us to discover that trace amounts of lead in the environment causes reduced intelligence. That was a key piece of data for banning lead in fuel. The loss of IQ points happens to all kids living in cities, rich and poor. Rich powerful people didn’t want their kids made stupid by lead in the air.
I think that removing lead from paint and fuel has greatly improved the lives of billions of people.
> The loss of IQ points happens to all kids living in cities
No, it didn't. The reduced test scores happened _on average_.
I won't rule out that what you said is correct, in that it may well be the fear that "my child may lose 1-5 IQ points!" helped get lead banned, but if so, that's an indictment of society.
Tell me then, if someone scored low on a text-based IQ test and that's all you know, how do you tell if it was caused by dyslexia or concussion? I guess you break out that "battery of other tools"? What does IQ tests give you that those other tools don't give better?
Oh, I know one. An excuse to write someone off as simply stupid. An excuse to _stop looking_ for the things which might have helped them. Which is what it was historically used for.
Punishing shoplifting is considered racist in many places.
Well, that would be knowable from a study of Vitamin D levels in the incarcerated population vs non-incarcerated among those with the same skin tones. I don't see any reason to bring IQ into this, nor race (vitamin D absorption is tied to skin tone, so a dark skinned person of Indian descent is as likely to have vitamin D deficiency as one of sub-Saharan African descent).
> If we block all research into a problem then we can’t solve it.
Establishing or refuting IQ differences among "races" is simply not a problem. It is sought after, at best, as a scapegoat, to deny any responsibility of racism in the measurably worse outcomes of people with certain heritage than others. Refuting race-IQ genetic correlation would simply eliminate this scapegpat, that most scientists don't actually believe in; while confirming it would just mean the problem is hopeless and nothing can be done to improve the situation.
Question: is there any kind of evidence, that hypothetically did show a racial difference, that you would not label as racist?
Why do people of X-extraction who were born in Y-country score about as well (or typically badly) as people back home in X-country? They do this in Western countries with sufficient nutrition and free education. They do this even when their parents immigrated as children. They even do this when their grandparents were the immigrants.
And the sample sizes are huge...
Cultural and socio-economic factors are just as good an explanation for the effects you mention than genetic ones tied to race.
I also very much doubt that the effects you mention are studied in the data on PISA test takers - there is simply not that level of demographic information being collected when a PISA test is administered. No one asks each child in the classroom where their parents or grand-parents were born, nor is their race or skin color noted down. So until you cite some papers, I'm going to be extremely skeptical of your claim.
And how do we know that? Any very controversial stuff like this will have people on both sides doing all in their power to convince everyone to their point of view. The truth gets lost.
To discuss this objectively we have to first agree on some basics. First I think the concept of race is a bit outdated. People have phenotypes and these phenotypes have various features (one may be skin color).
Also where did the idea there exists one feature responsible for "intelligence" came from? It seems to be accepted apriori, but I think the truth is closer to humans (and animals and AI) having various types of intelligence. Social, emotional, linguistical, math like, spatial (ability to imagine shapes etc) and probably few more.
And those intelligence types may very well have a genetic component and be present in one phenotype in a different mix than another.
But saying it is likely vs having actual proof are two different things so my view is that we simply don't know.
The explanation for that is probably the "missing heritability problem"; twin studies in the 1980s and 1990s set extraordinarily high heritability statistics for intelligence that have been undercut by molecular genetics results. Put differently: there was an unreasonably high correlation established in the literature at the turn of this century, and it's had nowhere to go but down.
(In case it matters for the thread: I'm not an expert, but I do follow this area of research, and I've been pretty convinced for many years now that supposed race/IQ correlations are basically bullshit, and that science is really beating the crap out of the old Murray and Lynn numbers.)
I have one more issue with that: IQ is a bullshit. Psychology can't answer what intelligence is. It came to a point when someone proposed to treat IQ tests as a definition of intelligence. Even as IQ tests are correlated with intelligence, they grab as well a lot of cultural and educational confounders. Twin studies tend to have not so many participants, but controlling for culture and education means the need to multiplying the sample size by 10 or more if we want to get a statistically significant result.
Just think about how many factors can contribute to development of an intelligence (as a practical problem solving skill). Was a kid praised when he solved some problem, or maybe his parents didn't even notice that the kid solved a difficult (for him) problem? How about the teachers and their relationships with the kid? May some specific situation influence how a person develops their attitude to hard thinking? I mean do they like to think, or treat it as a hard work that should be avoided at all costs? Do they suffer from learned helplessness when it comes to thinking? There are a _lot_ of factors, though probably you can model them all as a motivation to think as a function of age: it would catch such things like how much time the person spent practicing thinking, and at what development stages. Then one can develop a predictive model of IQ-tests results, and then try twin-studies to explain what cannot be explained by the model.
But that age->motivation functions is not known, it is substituted with inadequate controls (in the best studies), and therefore those twin studies in the 1980s and 1990s are crystallized bullshit. Their results should be ignored by every sensible person. I wonder how did they manage to get any statistically significant results. I'd expect such studies to show just a noise around zero, or maybe around political views of the researchers.
> There continue to be published studies suggesting group differences in intelligence
I think, you just don't get it. I can believe some physics research results without understanding the research. I mean without digging into the paper figuring what the authors did, why they did this and not that, why this experimental setup, why these statistical methods, how it proves what they claim and so on. I can believe physics, because physics is (mostly) not interesting for politicians and their fans.
I can't believe social sciences because they are a battlefield for politicians. I need to dig into each research paper before I start believing. Or even worse, the research papers itself, I believe are useless, meta-research papers trying to reason on basis of many papers are better, and them I'd need to study under the microscope, to see what the authors did, and then better read what guys with PhD in the field think about the research. Keeping in mind that not everything can be said aloud.
It doesn't help that social sciences still struggling from the replication crisis.
All this leads to one conclusion: I can't believe into any social sciences results because you've said me that some kind of results is published.
But I'm not going to dive into social sciences papers, because I do not believe that their results are useful. Not yet, our society is not ready for that. If they found that blacks are learning things in different way, and the best outcome for all is to create separate schools for blacks and whites, that would respect racial differences, how our society would react? So even if they find something, it wouldn't lead to any meaningful changes.
> And how do we know that? Any very controversial stuff like this will have people on both sides doing all in their power to convince everyone to their point of view. The truth gets lost.
> But saying it is likely vs having actual proof are two different things so my view is that we simply don't know.
The scientific consensus is that race is a social construct and does not have a genetic basis [1], and intelligence is not linked to "race" [2], and attempts to link those are rooted in racism [3].
Science is moving towards recognizing non-human-intelligence, and substantial NHI too - among all different levels of the animal kingdom, with cetaceans and corvids ranking rather high; and here we have folks claiming "the truth gets lost" and "we simply don't know". Sir, we do know.
Since this science information is easily googled, or spat out by frontier AI when queried, what must one think about a lack of willingness and basic due diligence before espousing the statements above?
No need to answer, we all know it is [3].
[1] https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.60.1.71
Based on the easily googled wide availability of this information and given the environmental causes of IQ differences, I wonder if an easy scientific corollary is that racists must have had environmental factors behind their inability to comprehend the established science in this matter. LoL
[3] https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2322874121
And, please, be mindful of the difference between arguing discriminatory policies (racism) and finding the facts about the world we live in (science).
Are you suggesting the listed papers are incorrect? Do you have any published science to support your argument?
> Environmental variability clearly can't describe 100% of intelligence variability. Twin studies show that.
Sauce?
> And, please, be mindful of the difference between arguing discriminatory policies (racism) and finding the facts about the world we live in (science).
The papers I listed are about the science not supporting the racism, literally.
“Consensus is the business of politics. Science, on the contrary, requires only one investigator who happens to be right, which means that he or she has results that are verifiable by reference to the real world. In science consensus is irrelevant. What are relevant are reproducible results. The greatest scientists in history are great precisely because they broke with the consensus. There is no such thing as consensus science. If it’s consensus, it isn’t science. If it's science, it isn't consensus. Period.” - Michael Chrichton
*not a scientist
Do you have any evidence to support this so-called "truth"?
There is strong evidence that IQ differences between human groups are environmental and not genetic [1][2][3].
Based on the easily googled wide availability of this information and given the environmental causes of IQ differences, I wonder if an easy scientific corollary is that racists must have environmental factors behind their inability to comprehend the established science in this matter. LoL
[1] https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2322874121
Yes, same. Do you have any evidence for this so-called "truth" that scientific consensus is not science?
It's like claiming that the scientific consensus that 1+1 equals 2 is not science. Or that the scientific consensus that the Earth goes around the Sun is not science. Oh wait, that latter bit is probably triggering for a bunch of people... but probably not for real scientists, though.
What about running? Down to race? Some races better at (bipedal) racing than others? Or down to environmental factors (availability of open land or whatnot)?
Note I don't care about so-called "IQ" (the very concept seems moronic to me); running performance, on the other hand, can be measured accurately.
> running performance, on the other hand, can be measured accurately.
So do you have any science to back up your hypothesis? That certain human groups are better than others at running? And that the better performance isn't tied to geography or other environmental factors?
> It is clear as day
And yet no science sources, no scientific evidence. All hat, no cattle.
> Ever heard of the olympics? Ever seen any world-class competition, in sprint or marathon? The former is dominated by West Africans (or the descendants of the negro slaves shipped to America), and the latter by East Africans.
But it didn't used to be; it used to be all caucasians winning in the olympics and other world-class events. There's a whole award-winning movie about the olympic sprinters with nary an african amongst the athletes [1]. So your own claim is proof against your argument. Impressive self-goal.
How do you know it?
You see, the issue is one can't just research the topic and then publish an article claiming that intelligence is racial. If someone tried it it would be a shitstorm of accusations in racism.
I personally sure that there are individual differences that work like a limit for an intelligence that a person can develop, and I doubt it highly that these individual differences do not correlate with ancestry in any way. It is very interesting topic, but it is ideologically forbidden, because a) "all men are created equal"; b) the history of racial abuses in Europe and USA.
You see, it is like researching victims of pedophiles seeking any positive personal changes stemming from the abuse. If any1 tried it and had found anything, the Public would burn them alive for their findings.
The public had never learned to tolerate challenges (however remote) to its ideology. There are reasons for that, and I'd say pretty good reasons, but what I want to say: it leads to a situation where some truths are hidden for us and we can't reach them. All we can do is to guess and to believe.
You claim that intelligence isn't racial? I don't believe that you can _know_ it, because the attempt to prove it with a research would be a challenge to Ideology, it is one of unreachable truths.
I don't feel like being racist either way.
We know people often kill people. That doesn't even need explanation.
My argument is that it is thousands of years and dozens of mixed generations.
Why do you decide to participate in a thousand-years-long campaign to kill the neighbor who is also your second cousin?
There is no reason they couldn't have turned the other way and attacked their other second cousin.
My best guess is religion but it could also have also been a different kind of fanatic ideology.
Sure it took many generations but it's hard to imagine that the violence wasn't culturally and racially motivated. Based on genetic evidence it's speculated that that there were more than 10 male migrants to every female coming from the steppe.
> The Yamnaya never made it out of the Ukraine.
I'm not sure what that means? Their descendants clearly did reach Iberia and Britain.
In Iberia, you have northern Iberian groups which maybe spoke a bit of an Indo-European language at first, and they are invading Southern Iberians and leaving almost no trace of other haplogroups.
Britain is less interesting because basically it was a regular colonization/invasion of the kind we know by Britons; although there is a genetic trace left of the megalithic people, they were swamped.
As a contrast to the Iberian case, we have several steppe invasions in the historical record but most of them look nothing like it.
The Khans did expand rapidly and engage in some wild oat seeding but there is barely any evidence that they ever were in most of the places they conquered. The Huns were basically new management for Germanic tribes. Again, no trace of their existence.
The only one that looks a bit like the Indo-European expansion is the Turkish invasion of Anatolia where by the end you have a bunch of South-Eastern Europeans with minor Asiatic ancestry effectively larping as Islamic Asians and even becoming the center of the Islamic world for centuries.
But, even in the Turks, you don't see full Y-DNA replacement, not even with the power of Islam.
Yamnaya/Corded Ware DNA basically persists to this day everywhere in Europe, including Germany. The modern white European genome is a mix of DNA from the Yamnaya, the pre-Yamnaya Anatolian farmer population, and European hunter-gatherers who predated the Anatolian farmers, in varying quantities depending on exactly where in Europe you are looking. Corded Ware populations really do form part of the ancestry of modern Germans, although hardly only them.
An etymology of arya beyond Proto-Indo-Iranian and into common Indo-European is shaky - h₂eryós, probably meaning some kind of social status like "noble" or "freeman", has been posited, which would have a Proto-Germanic reflex *arjaz, which may be attested in some Germanic personal names. It's hard to be certain about details of words reconstructed from a time well before the invention of literacy. Still, I think it's hard to avoid concluding that this is a way that the word "Aryan" does have some relevance to Germanic people, whether other people judge you to be a hateful ignoramus for considering it or not.
If you wanna tell the romans to GFY you're gonna have to adopt a lot of the structures that make them competitive in order to resist them. There's a fairly large "you wrestle the pig you get shit on you" factor going on.
While it is true that learning from Rome was very useful for its later challengers, this usually was not the primary motivation for adoption of Roman culture, especially before ~ 400 AD. It was more about the higher standard of living plus legal stability, as long as Rome could enforce its Pax.
The "pots aren't people" wave wouldn't be problematic per se (e.g. obviously a lot of non-Latin ethnicities adapted Roman way of life), rather because it sought to be the dominant theory.
We have a very similar "intelligence and nature-vs-nurture" situation in biology, caused by the very same thing - defeat of the Nazis, which made some ideas extremely dirty and other ideas very attractive.
This has an interesting consequence in that we do not know much about natural human intelligence today, which is coming back to bite us in the age of emerging artificial intelligence. The topic of human intelligence has been a political minefield for nearly a century now. It is probably safer and easier to study intelligence of octopuses and crows than that of humans. You're definitely freer from political repercussions there.