Correlation measures whether Y=mX+c holds with small error. I sometimes think that too many people think that all dependencies are somehow straight-line ones. This is distinct from "linear approximation" in physics and engineering, which is more justifiable.
I also suspect that correlations of 0.5 or lower are just statistical noise.
Fundamentally my argument is maybe science can solve a problem, let’s at least try.
IQ tests have been revised several times to address things like that, like that they "unfairly" penalize dyslexia, or that they had lots of questions which were easier for people of specific social backgrounds. Every time they were, they naturally became less "predictive", since both dyslexia and not belonging to the California white upper middle class give you pretty obvious disadvantages in life outcomes.
So don't waste time on IQ, and don't waste time on other academic culture war BS either.
The research to ban lead in fuel relied on measuring IQ and measuring lead exposure, then showing a correlation between the two.
At the population level IQ is a very useful tool.
We don't have a good model of what intelligence is. But since IQ studies are fairly common, there's a lot of data collected that uses IQ, and since it IQ looks vaguely like "intelligence," a lot of researchers who are motivated to find reasons to declare particular people intelligent or unintelligent are more than happy to use that data to support their claims.
Answer this question:
> If you can’t study IQ how do you demonstrate that lead poisoning causes reduced intelligence?
It should be clearly evident that trying to use IQ to establish that "<insert ethnic group here> are stupid" is bad science. It's the same sort of science to establish that "<insert environmental factor here> causes stupidity," so we also need to reject it even if the environmental factor is clearly something problematic. The problem isn't the conclusion, it's the methodology.
It’s a good thing that measuring IQ enabled us to discover that trace amounts of lead in the environment causes reduced intelligence. That was a key piece of data for banning lead in fuel. The loss of IQ points happens to all kids living in cities, rich and poor. Rich powerful people didn’t want their kids made stupid by lead in the air.
I think that removing lead from paint and fuel has greatly improved the lives of billions of people.
> The loss of IQ points happens to all kids living in cities
No, it didn't. The reduced test scores happened _on average_.
I won't rule out that what you said is correct, in that it may well be the fear that "my child may lose 1-5 IQ points!" helped get lead banned, but if so, that's an indictment of society.
Tell me then, if someone scored low on a text-based IQ test and that's all you know, how do you tell if it was caused by dyslexia or concussion? I guess you break out that "battery of other tools"? What does IQ tests give you that those other tools don't give better?
Oh, I know one. An excuse to write someone off as simply stupid. An excuse to _stop looking_ for the things which might have helped them. Which is what it was historically used for.
Punishing shoplifting is considered racist in many places.
Well, that would be knowable from a study of Vitamin D levels in the incarcerated population vs non-incarcerated among those with the same skin tones. I don't see any reason to bring IQ into this, nor race (vitamin D absorption is tied to skin tone, so a dark skinned person of Indian descent is as likely to have vitamin D deficiency as one of sub-Saharan African descent).
> If we block all research into a problem then we can’t solve it.
Establishing or refuting IQ differences among "races" is simply not a problem. It is sought after, at best, as a scapegoat, to deny any responsibility of racism in the measurably worse outcomes of people with certain heritage than others. Refuting race-IQ genetic correlation would simply eliminate this scapegpat, that most scientists don't actually believe in; while confirming it would just mean the problem is hopeless and nothing can be done to improve the situation.
What if some of the observed racial differences were caused by a lack of vitimin D, due to darker skin photosynthesising less of it? Then we could fix the prison crisis with a pill!
If we block all research into a problem then we can’t solve it.
If you actually care about fixing a problem then we should bring all available tools to fix and solve it.