News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:23PM (#50499400)
The only place where a space data center makes sense is in Mars orbit to reduce the amount of mass that needs to be landed. Every thing else is a smoke and mirrors game to justify rolling a bunch of failed businesses into SpaceX.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by TheBlight on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:30PM (#50499474)
By what % is your portfolio beating the market?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by eldenring on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:30PM (#50499477)
What specifically do you disagree with from the article to say its Smoke and Mirrors? I think their analysis is reasonable and that it will reduce to a launch cost problem.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by jasonwatkinspdx on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:38PM (#50499551)
Giving it a quick look they're doing the same thing as everyone else and handwaving away really difficult engineering problems with some back of the envelope math that only looks at one or two aspects.

Like their section on collision avoidance isn't any more sophisticated than "Starlink has a great record so far" when we're talking about a very different scale of how much mass and surface area has to be moved around in a coordinated way.

This is in effect an editorial from two postgrads, not an actual detailed workup. I don't feel like spending time going into any more effort based on that.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by maxerickson on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:52PM (#50499683)
Saying it is equivalent to launch costs is hand waving. Their "median" scenario would involve Starship working at the lower bound of their operational goal for it.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ben_w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:36PM (#50499527)
Even then. If you're building a million satellites, they only need to be about 42 meters long for you to make them into a contiguous ring in LEO. Smaller (22.5m) or fewer (537,000) for the same in a 200 km orbit around Mars.

Do that, and you can quickly bootstrap an orbital ring and make rockets obsolete from surface to orbit of either body.

In the case of Mars, the planet-wide dust storms make it a good idea to locate your PV off-planet, and an orbital ring is also very convenient for that.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Y_Y on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:51PM (#50499672)
What would you like to make this orbital ring out of?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ben_w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:04PM (#50499784)
Structually, it barely matters. The physics works even if each element isn't joined contiguously to the next, it's just that if you do you can also use it for power delivery.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_ring

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by dvh on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:20PM (#50499920)
Pangolin scales?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ben_w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:29PM (#50499994)
Goodness no, all subspecies are listed on Wikipedia as having various kinds of "Threatened" conservation statuses.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by lefra on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:04PM (#50499785)
Maybe I missed something obvious, but how does an orbital ring make rockets obsolete for surface to orbit trips?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ben_w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:10PM (#50499842)
Because it's held up by being in orbit (strictly: a bit faster than that), you can by the same process as a maglev hang a stationary-with-respect-to-ground cable off it; and because the cable is only as long as your orbit is high (~200 km or whatever) rather than the 36,000 km you'd need for a full space elevator, we don't need to invent any supermaterials for it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_ring

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by howunfortunate on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:04PM (#50499790)
"Failed businesses" is some insane cope.

The impulse to discredit someone's "art" because of their politics has always stuck me as incredibly juvenile.

It's as if people can't imagine competence - even in some narrow way - in someone who doesn't share all their exact beliefs.

It seems especially silly because literally every great man and woman of history shares only a tiny fraction of our modern beliefs.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by bar8uyr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:33PM (#50501694)
Just so you know, this is what cope looks like.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by howunfortunate on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:58PM (#50501909)
Sure bud. The richest man alive is a huge business failure and I'm just coping about it.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:10AM (#50505294)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by exe34 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:24PM (#50499407)
No.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by FerretFred on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:24PM (#50499408)
Definitely need to see a Microsoft data centre in Uranus.

Sorry. Not sorry.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by baxtr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:25PM (#50499425)
From the article:

Conclusions

Orbital data centers look more viable than we expected going in and the case rests primarily on launch cost. The engineering challenges seem significant but none appear intractable. Commercial off-the-shelf solar, passive radiators, and standard error-correcting codes seem sufficient for a baseline architecture. We expect limited demos and shipments of compute to orbit in the coming years but our best estimate is that orbital data centers are unlikely to represent a meaningful share of compute before 2030. They might scale quickly thereafter however, and are more likely to be bottlenecked by chip production rates rather than by launch cadence. A generally important dynamic is that terrestrial data centers likely face headwinds that worsen as compute scales up while orbital data centers face constraints that relax with scale.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by marcosdumay on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:48PM (#50499636)
And all those conclusions take is cost to space to reduce 15 times; new cooling tech that isn't used anywhere to work at scale but only in space (if ground datacenters can use it too, their cost decrease); that ops cost line to not do anything useful so it can be just dropped; those 10mm radiation shields to not weight anything, because they didn't enter the costs; and that ground datacenters to use more expensive tech than they use today (just not improving is not enough).

We will have space datacenters some day. But I'm not holding my breath.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:01PM (#50500766)
We can just repurpose Deep Space 9, the Cardassians aren’t using it and nobody really cares about Bajor.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:56PM (#50500725)
This is complete bullshit.

Anyone who thinks we’ll have data centres in space before we have a civilisation changing step up in surface to orbit space drives and materials science is an idiot.

How the hell does anyone think a rocket is ever going to compete with a prime mover towing two trailers, or an ocean going vessel.

We’re not exactly short of land.

And no, space is not cold.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by carabiner on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:59PM (#50500752)
All of this sounds a lot like how ULA, ESA thought reusable rockets were a pipe dream. These are engineering challenges, not physical laws that need to be broken.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rf15 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:32PM (#50501092)
yeah, but: Data centers, fundamentally, are a solved problem. The rest is just cost balancing - and space looks like complete rubbish when it comes to all kinds of costs, including and especially when it comes to maintenance.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by brainwad on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:30PM (#50510386)
Maintenance is impossible, but maintenance isn't necessary either. You can just cope with the decay by a) over-provisioning and b) writing off your satellites after the planned life.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by EA-3167 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:44PM (#50501782)
This sounds like someone who concludes that FTL is possible because “once people thought that flight was impossible!”

But we have and had ample evidence of flight in nature, we just didn’t understand how it worked. A similar search across the observable universe reveals no sign of FTL behavior.

Sometimes when you understand the science a comparison to some time when people didn’t isn’t as moving or compelling as you seem to imagine.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ordu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:31PM (#50502638)
> space is not cold.

Yes, it is. There is such a phenomenon as infrared radiation. You feel it on your skin right now. It is hard normally to separate them from other ways you exchange heat with your environment, but in some conditions it is easy. Like when there is a hot object you can feel it to be hot even if you don't touch it or the air heated by the object. Likewise you can feel that a cold object is cold thing without touching it or cold air around it.

These experiments would be hard to run in space, because it is highly polluted by vacuum and it is not a good idea to expose human limbs to vacuum. But artificial sensors could be used for that.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:30AM (#50515012)
Sure.

Now put freshly boiled water in a Thermos, or your preferred brand of vacuum insulated flask.

Notice how the water stays hot for, what, I don’t know, 24hrs or so.

That’s how ”cold” space is.

Incidentally, did you now it is estimated that the Sun, or star Sol, is anticipated to take trillions of years to cool via radiative dissipation after nuclear fusion stops in the core.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ordu on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @03:15PM (#50537544)
Thermos has two mechanisms blocking heat transfer. A vacuum to stop conduction/convection and a mirror to reflect IR. If you look into your thermos you'd see its inner reflective surface. Space is not a mirror, it is pitch black, it just absorbs all IR that you emit.

Had you thought that your face probably could feel the heat of the Earth being in space? Suppose your skin is resistant to vaccum, suppose you are on some low orbit (so the Earth would have really big angular size), and suppose that you look at the Earth and then turn to look into a deep space so you have no "nearby" objects in your field of view. I believe, that you can feel the difference with your skin's thermal receptors. Even if you are about the night side of the Earth.

I'm not entirely sure about it, maybe I missed something when doing math, but I'm still pretty sure. How can you talk about space not being cold with all this?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by thehappypm on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:51PM (#50502801)
The 24/7 energy is a plus.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Tadpole9181 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:11PM (#50502937)
You know what else has 24//7 energy? The bog standard power grid, some solar panels, and some batteries. I can even have redundancy and regular maintenance cycles on the ground.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by postalrat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:51PM (#50503832)
And how much does that all cost to have built and provide power for 5+ years?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by luipugs on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:56AM (#50504653)
Much cheaper than doing the same thing in space.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:04AM (#50505256)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:14AM (#50514926)
24/7 power in space only works if you believe the Earth doesn’t cast a shadow.

Or you’ve prepared to use some form of power source other than solar.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ls612 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:30PM (#50503401)
Scott Manley did a video on this and basically concluded that technologically this is totally possible, but the economics may never work. It would depend on how much free power buys you compared to launch costs etc.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:06AM (#50505985)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ls612 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:58AM (#50508461)
The radiators necessary for say a 20KW rack are not extreme compared to existing tech. And the free power 24/7 is a big benefit. As I said, the tradeoff comes down to cost of launch vs cost of power (and to a lesser degree reliability of hardware up there, but GPUs depreciate rapidly on Earth too)
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:25PM (#50510943)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ls612 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:34PM (#50512966)
I’m not denying any of that, I’m saying it’s a question of relative prices not capability, and Starship moves the needle on prices far more than anything else.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:58AM (#50515173)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:17AM (#50514948)
One does not need to be Scott Manley to have figured this out.

The overwhelming majority of his content is of very little intellectual value, if one already has a high school education.

He’s not even particularly entertaining, although I guess his accent does help a lot there.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ranger_danger on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:25PM (#50499426)
We kinda already have IMO.

Starcloud-1 is already in orbit, and many other plans by them and other firms are already well into development.

And Lonestar has a backup server on the moon. Seriously.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by groos on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:33PM (#50499497)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by drum55 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:38PM (#50499546)
It's difficult to imagine any sort of compute in space given the state of the art rad hardened processor is about as fast as a computer Apple sold in 1998.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by emtel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:31PM (#50500521)
You don’t have to imagine. The starlink constellation is a working and profitable massive deployment of orbital compute. (It doesn’t use rad hardened hardware as far as I can tell)
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by za_creature on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:01PM (#50501398)
Starlink is impressive but calling it compute is a stretch.

It's not that far off from a residential router with a bigger antenna.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by kibwen on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:23PM (#50502134)
Starlink satellites have such a low orbit that they experience non-negligible atmospheric drag, which is why they have to be replaced at such a rapid rate. All proposals for orbital datacenters propose placing them in sun-synchronous orbits for maximum solar exposure, which puts them right at the edge of the Van Allen Belt at best, meaning they'd be exposed to dramatically more radiation than a Starlink satellite.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by FireBeyond on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:40PM (#50499576)
Musk's "genius idea" there was to (pardon the pun) derail high speed rail and other similar investments so he could sell more cars.

What are Hyperloop/Boring actually doing now? It doesn't take that much investment to human-drive a 10-20 Teslas up and down the Vegas Strip in a straight tunnel at normal speeds.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:50PM (#50499655)
The problem is that experiments into this by Google have concluded that radiation hardening is unnecessary. HBM memory far surpassed their expectations for survival, exceeding 5 years in their simulated proton beam on earth. Localized shielding for consumer equipment is more than enough, especially combined with ECC.

Solar power and power dissipation are similarly solvable. The only bottleneck currently is launch costs which is why it’s expected around 2030 is when these DCs will explode

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:09PM (#50502016)
> Solar power and power dissipation are similarly solvable

So it is not outright stupid, just has a few extra costs.

So again, what's the economical benefit? Because you surely have no power and dissipation problem down on Earth, so why add a whole rocket launch into the equation? Because big fire goes brr?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:59PM (#50503251)
Because data centers take a long time to get through local regulations. By comparison launching a bunch of satellites into orbit is much simpler and you don’t get local political opposition you have to spend a lot of resources trying to overcome (not to mention secondary cost effects). Any political opposition to space DCs is going to be more diffuse and disparate since any problems are non local.

So what’s the economic benefit? As Suncatcher has predicted, the economic cost benefit flips to space DCs at a certain launch price/kg which is expected to be reached commercially by early to mid 2030s (spacex will be ahead because they don’t need profitable launches and can get ahead).

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:40AM (#50505817)
We surely don't expect the same total computation throughput from one data center and a couple of satellites, right?

Like even if a single satellite launch is cheaper than.. building a whole building, I have a really hard time believing that putting that many satellites up would still be cheaper.

And even that hypothetical depends on that we need some very quickly growing need for compute, which somehow can't be managed by.. simply replacing the existing compute hardware every 5 years in data centers, and the relative slow build of new ones?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:14AM (#50508057)
Space is big. We’re not talking about a couple of satellites eithers. It’s probably many tens of satellites in close proximity. Enough to host a single LLM model for example. Then you put up enough of these micro DCs. There’s simply no need for a single constellation with thousands of racks like a terrestrial warehouse. The only reason you do it that way today is purely because that’s how permitting and construction makes sense on earth, not because there’s some inherent advantage.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:31PM (#50508819)
You can surely just put a single rack into every 10th office building in a city of your choice for faster connections, significantly larger compute per rack, and significantly cheaper price.

What's the point of going to space besides a scammer wanting his share price up?

And before you say "politics" and "legal", space is just not that regulated because there was no need for it. Why do you think it will not get regulated once "per kg transport" becomes cheap enough? How is the politics and legal all that bad for the data center case? Like maybe don't build it into stupid places harming the environment, but it's not that bad of a thing all together, no reason why they couldn't be built under normal circumstances.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:29PM (#50509354)
I imagine the cooling and power challenges of that is what inhibits this idea. But if it were economical, why don’t you try building a startup around it and find out? It’s easy to argue from the couch, much harder to actually validate your ideas against reality
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by K3UL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:27PM (#50501026)
The bet that they are making is that, in the near-future, energy on Earth will be such an issue (especially if you want to scale) that DCs on Earth will cost more than components + launch costs
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:11PM (#50502026)
Why would energy be an issue? The Sun is shining, wind is blowing, the ocean has waves, nuclear is nuclear. All of these will just get more efficient in using the same constant resource.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by K3UL on Monday November 16, 2026 @07:13PM (#50525537)
It's not the energy per-se, it's the access to it. You mention solar, solar in orbit is constant, on Earth it's not. You mention wind, it's not pilotable. You mention ocean, it means you need to build close to an ocean. Nuclear yes, but it's expensive. And then there is the grid, and there is the cooling.

Finally you can sprinkle all of that with political things like putting datacenters in residential areas and forests.

But these might also get solved, hence why a "bet".

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:43PM (#50501219)
The PV at least can potentially be much less robust than on Earth, since it doesn't have to contend with wind and weather. CdTe thin films, for example, can be just 1 micron thick (the absorption length of solar photons in that material is ~0.1 microns). So potentially the material cost of space PV can be much less than the same peak power PV on Earth.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by postalrat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:58PM (#50503873)
I'd imagine sometime in the future we will build processing wafers similar to monocrystalline solar panels. Data processed sequentially over a couple dozen feet. AI models hard coded into the silicon itself. The entire data center maybe a milimeter thick sheet.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by InsideOutSanta on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:33PM (#50499500)
I thought this was one of these joke websites that just say "No."

I mean, Elon will probably shoot some GPUs up there and call it a success, but I'm not sure that should could at "data centers in space."

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ben_w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:45PM (#50499618)
I wouldn't put it past him to launch 20,000 of them before moving on to the next thing.

Or two. It's a broad range, but with his personality and prior history both are possible before he announces whatever the next pivot is.

Just, not a million. There's better things to do with the capacity to put a million up there, and better places to put a million (last I checked) 120 kW compute racks and associated PV systems.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by zelphirkalt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:35PM (#50499514)
No we will not. The reason is simple: Space is not in the cloud, it is above. Anything that's not in the cloud is bad.

Silliness aside, has anyone come up with a cooling system that would work well for a friggin data center in space? Or is it still all just a wishful thinking game, ignoring physics?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ben_w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:42PM (#50499590)
> Silliness aside, has anyone come up with a cooling system that would work well for a friggin data center in space? Or is it still all just a wishful thinking game, ignoring physics

That's perfectly viable.

However at the temperatures chips operate at, because stuff on the ground is getting convective cooling as well as radiative, a radiator designed for LEO will reject slightly more heat on the ground than it would in orbit.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by exogeny on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:43PM (#50499603)
It is absolutely a wishful thinking game, ignoring physics. It's a bet made by investors who don't know or care about the science, and are looking for a modal outcome of a failed company purchased by SpaceX or by an even dumber company looking to compete with SpaceX.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:55PM (#50499711)
I recommend reading up on the results of Google’s project suncatcher. IMHO the results have provided a roadmap to space DCs with the only blocker being launch cost which are targeted to become economically viable in 2030s; sooner for spacex because they can lower their margins to zero or even negative for the launch itself.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:47PM (#50501256)
Whenever I asked someone to dig down into "against the laws of physics" arguments, they turned out to instead rest on a pile of tacit and pessimistic technological assumptions.

Perhaps you could explain in detail why you think the laws of physics have to be violated for space data centers to work.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:53PM (#50499688)
The plan as I understand it is to pack it tightly with TPUs with liquid cooling out to radiators and flying a tight cluster of these next to each other using high bandwidth laser links. That lets you balance the amount of thermal radiation you need to emit vs the amount of TPUs in a single satellite. Thus it’s not a DC in a single satellite but more like a rack and then a bundle of racks flying beside each other.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:14PM (#50502062)
Or you know, just have tpus with liquid cooling in huge racks, with optical cables or whatever. We can put a shitton of them into a warehouse sized space, and we have basically infinite energy to power and cool it, with physical connection to the internet for ultra fast speeds!

(Sorry, the snark is not directed at you)

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:42PM (#50502273)
The problem is that building the physical DCs is a cost problem not just in terms of energy availability (it’s not infinite) but also politics and legal regulations. Ignoring that is why it makes the space idea seem silly but it’s a real one
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by zelphirkalt on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:43AM (#50505839)
Well, how does that liquid cooling agent get cooled down? Do we have a way of producing sufficient surface area, to be able to cool it down in space, where cooling is difficult exactly due to not interacting with much matter.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:10AM (#50508026)
You probably replied to the wrong commenter as they were talking how a warehouse is easier.

To answer your question, what project suncatcher results show is the cooling radiator needed to dissipate the rack is a insignificant fraction of the mass of the satellite rack. It bounds the absolute size of a rack you can launch maybe but that’s why you build a close flying constellation of many many such satellites interlinked by high speed laser links to handle the inter-rack communication.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by freecodeio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:38PM (#50501168)
it's the equivalent of PMs asking "can we just make our own llm to save costs"
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rdtsc on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:38PM (#50499547)
> and becomes cheaper than any current terrestrial energy source at around $50/kg

Heck for $50/kg I could see it, too. Now with Falcon 9 or Heavy it's on the order of thousands, isn't it? Just need a measly two orders of magnitude improvement and then we can start talking.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by topspin on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:47PM (#50500660)
Does gauging this based on Falcon 9 launch costs make sense now? SpaceX has already deployed two payloads of satellites using Starship. Falcon 9 is a deprecated system because SpaceX intends to use Starship for future payload missions.

We can't yet know the ultimate cost of Starship payloads. All we have is SpaceX projections of $10-100/kg. Maybe that is realized, maybe not. Given the scale of the LA launch site they're building, they'll certainly have the launch cadence to deliver lower launch costs than anything achieved with Falcon 9 or any other launch system ever created.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by asciimike on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:42PM (#50499598)
The viability of space DCs seem to depend entirely on the existence of higher latency, lower throughput, single card to single server workloads, which IMO isn't the primary class of workload today (and if one holds the belief that frontier will maintain their dominant position, this will remain rack/row/facility level, which isn't viable for orbital facilities to handle).

If that workload does expand in usage, and the economics of orbital DCs make sense (with high launch costs, zero ability to do maintenance, and weight penalties for shielding and radiators), then surely ocean based data centers (e.g. Panthalassa) make more sense (lower 'launch' costs, high latency on maintenance, no weight penalties), and if those make sense then surely the distributed land based facilities (e.g. Rune Energy) or home based facilities (e.g. Span XFRA) make even more sense (easier maintenance, low/no permitting overhead because they're covered by existing permits, reasonable quality terrestrial fiber internet).

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by dboreham on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:27PM (#50500488)
I don't think we need that many words. It's an obviously preposterously stupid idea that has been promoted only to defraud investors.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:49PM (#50500674)
Correct.

And putting things in the ocean is only marginally less idiotic due primarily to sea water being corrosive, wet, and full of creatures that tend to want to grow all over anything.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by NortySpock on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:09PM (#50500851)
Microsoft did attempt ocean racks in a sealed container , and it sounded like the 3 year test ended successfully but was not renewed.

I presume the cost of setup, teardown, lead-time, low power density when scaled up, and lack of convenient access for mid-life repairs made it not worth the trouble

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/project/natick/

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by cogman10 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:24PM (#50500988)
This is the sort of thing that highlights why space is such a dumb place to put a DC.

Everything about storing a DC underwater is easier than it is in space (except corrosion).

It's easier to access, cheaper, easier to cool, easier to get enough power, easier to update.

Heck, doing a second story data-center resolves a ton of issues with today's data-centers (while being a bit more expensive due to additional structural support requirements).

There are so many options for terrestrial DCs to overcome whatever problem space might supposedly solve, and they are all cheaper than the space solution.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by dgoldstein0 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:42PM (#50501207)
how is power easier? solar power in orbit seems like a no-brainer - no losses due to the atmosphere / weather, and with the right orbit you can get sun all the time. Was the ocean DC tide-powered or something? how does that compare?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by munchbunny on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:46PM (#50501251)
In Microsoft’s case, they ran a cable, which is much simpler to do than putting solar panels in orbit.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by cogman10 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:57PM (#50501361)
In space, you have to deploy all the power production you want to consume in the same package that's consuming that power.

On earth, you can build a power plant miles from the DC. And you can use all sorts of different sources of power, tidal, wind, nuclear, solar, fossil fuels. All options. And like the DC, if there's a problem with any of those sources, you can go fix it or replace it with different power sources. If there's a problem with the solar panels in space, your DC is dead.

That's both easier and a lot more flexible.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by DoctorOetker on Monday November 16, 2026 @05:05AM (#50515904)
In a computational race, and restricting to earthly computation, we'd quickly heat the globe by prompt heating, no CO2 needed. Of course, long before that actually happens Average Joe is priced out of energy or climate control.

We should be thankful to those who propose to "let's step outside" instead of starting a bar fight down here on Earth.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by bayindirh on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:51PM (#50501839)
It looks like ISS can generate 240KW peak from 2500m2 of solar panels, and runs at half of that nominally [0].

A single B200 can consume up to 1200W. A single GB300 system needs 14.5kW. So, you can only have ~15 (incl. satellite's energy needs) GB300 with ISS' solar panels, which is absurd. See [1] for the size of the panels we're talking about.

People dream about Starlink-style close flying systems to aggregate them to a single data center. With these power requirements, it's more like an AI hallucination. If we can build way more efficient chips or run smaller models on modest hardware, etc. We may go there, but needing ISS sized solar panels to run frontier models in space?

Also, don't forget the radiators. You also need those to pump that heat out of these systems.

The outlook doesn't look good at this point.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_panels_on_spacecraft#Spa...

[1]: https://www.sgmk.edu.pl/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/iss.png

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by chmod775 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:52PM (#50501311)
> except corrosion

Spacecraft in LEO deal with corrosion due to metal oxidation from atomic oxygen atoms up there. The rate of this can be greater than on Earth's surface, though I'm not sure how oceans compare.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corrosion_in_space

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by DoctorOetker on Monday November 16, 2026 @04:15AM (#50515594)
> Everything about storing a DC underwater is easier than it is in space (except corrosion).

LEO does have corrosion (mono-atomic oxygen) as a matter of fact

When power blocks enter escalating computational races (searching for number theoretic breaks in cryptography) thermodynamics heavily favors space, the one who can launch datacenters at the highest rate will tend to be ahead of the competition.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by horsawlarway on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:52PM (#50501309)
Yes, but that apparently proves the point of the poster above you.

The moderate improvements in cooling we're not worth the extra complexity.

So it just didn't make sense to do outside of a single media stunt project.

Data centers in space don't even get the cooling benefit.

The whole idea just doesn't survive modest consideration. Data centers aren't particularly dangerous. There's no forcing function to put them away from where people live. The best location for a data center is going to be a decent sized urban center with existing utilities (power and network) and acceptable land costs.

There are nearly forty of them in Atlanta, people walk by them every day with no idea what they are.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by bayindirh on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:32AM (#50506814)
> Data centers aren't particularly dangerous.

Unless you burn them during reentry. When this idea started to be discussed for the first time, somebody ran the numbers, and burning defunct ones during reentry created a massive fallout of hazardous materials, threatening the health of everyone on the planet.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Danox on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:27PM (#50503048)
Microsoft can’t catch a break. Their Surface mashup with Nvidia probably is probably dead within a year. Copilot and the gaming empire appear to be falling apart, other than massive Capex being lit on fire what does Microsoft/Nadella have to show for it right now aside from a plan to off 60,000 people.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by cactusplant7374 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:09PM (#50502018)
How is Panthalassa doing? Anyone know?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by bliteben on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:20PM (#50500947)
I think if we manufactured most of the infrastructure and maybe the chips or solar panels in space it might actually make sense. Nobody is talking about that though, I guess Elon is saving the we will make the solar panels in space for a down quarter.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by skort on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:26PM (#50501009)
How would it make sense? Have you seen how things are manufactured? Why would you want to make something harder and more expensive than it has to be? It's delusional to think that these things will work better in space/on mars than on earth.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rbanffy on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:58PM (#50501366)
Some metallurgy on the Moon might be easier - at least the atmosphere doesn’t want to react with the materials. For other processes, you actually want some of the atmosphere to do exactly that.

We’ll need to develop base industries from scratch for these environments, but, eventually, we’ll get there. The downside is that it’ll take at least multiple decades, if not more than a century.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by bliteben on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:08AM (#50506335)
We are going to have to figure it out just to even deal with all the trash we are sending up.

Long term any colonies on the moon or mars will have to manufacture at least fuel.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rbanffy on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:55PM (#50501338)
I would not expect that to happen any sooner than 50 years from now. If a flight to the Moon on a Starship really requires a dozen refuelling flights, then we need an even bigger rocket (because the larger a rocket is, the more efficient it gets). Then we need to develop and build automated and teleoperated lunar factories, maybe ship the electronics from Earth for final assembly on the Moon, establish lunar mining and metalworking to build the structures, motors, actuators, solar panels, radiators, find raw materials and process them into heat exchanger fluids and propellants, and launch the satellites at least to Lunar orbit so they can self propel to their destination orbit where latency is not two seconds.

Even with an intelligence explosion guiding the development of all these technologies, it’d take many decades.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by blensor on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:36PM (#50501145)
That being said. If I were an AI, I would lobby for datacenters in space as hard as I can to put the off switch comfortably out of reach of humans.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by haglin on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:08PM (#50501476)
The benefit is that they will fall down in 5-10 years.

That's an automatic off switch.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by tartoran on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:25PM (#50501624)
That's an eternity for an exponentially growing intelligence.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by AnimalMuppet on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:31PM (#50501671)
Exponentially growing on the same hardware? That's... optimistic. Not, IMO, realistic.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by MadnessASAP on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:48PM (#50502775)
Anti satellite weaponry exists. The off switch would be in the hands of anyone with suborbital launch capability.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by EA-3167 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:41PM (#50501755)
Unfortunately most people even here don’t have a working knowledge of the relevant tech, and seem to lack a similar grasp of the thermodynamics.

A non-trivial number still think that the hard part of colonizing Mars is the rocket to get there. What can you do?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by redwood on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:22AM (#50518554)
I started from your perspective but after I understanding the plan of vertical radiative fins I actually think there's something here
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by svara on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:38PM (#50501159)
I don't think it's quite as crazy as you make it sound.

Per unit area, the radiators dissipate a similar amount of energy as the solar panels do, so they'll be a similar size. That's doable.

The upside is there's no land and power generation or grid connection issue; you get solar power 24/7 and the latency to earth is just a few ms.

It would also be possible to fly the individual satellites close together so that you can do high bandwidth optical links between them, i.e. you're not limited to single rack workloads.

A single GB200 rack costs about $3M, transporting its 1.4 tons on a Falcon 9 would cost a similar amount, around $4-5M.

That's got to be too expensive for now, but it's also not in a range that's totally off.

The idea is essentially a bet on land and power continuing to be a big issue and launch costs getting a lot cheaper, which they very well might with Starship. The rest is engineering challenges that are probably solvable.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by treyd on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:42PM (#50501213)
>you get solar power 24/7 and the latency to earth is just a few ms.

Not at the same time. To have few-ms latency you need to be in/below LEO, but then earth blocks the sun half the time.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by svara on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:49PM (#50501281)
It can be done in a dawn-dusk, sun synchronous orbit, less than 1000 km up.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by echoangle on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:08PM (#50501475)
That’s at least 20 ms of round trip time, realistically much more. Especially since it’s not geostationary so the distance to the closest ground station will in most cases be much longer than straight down. I would be surprised if the average ping is below 100 ms.

Probably still fine for most applications though.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by asciimike on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:12PM (#50501505)
Latency isn't really the issue here (lots of inference serving happening across oceans, which is probably 100-150ms RT), but bandwidth ends up becoming an issue for large scale transfers (mostly model weights, not the actual inference tokens/queries).
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by echoangle on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:23PM (#50501598)
With laser terminals you’ll get a few gigabits per second. That’s possible both between sats and to the ground station. Probably not cheap though.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by jltsiren on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:26PM (#50501625)
Low Earth orbit is 90 to 120 minutes, depending on altitude. Even if the satellite is currently close to you, it will soon be on the other side of the world.

Assuming that orbital data centers make sense, it will be an interesting challenge to figure out how to best mitigate that. Short tasks that require little data will be easy, but everything else needs rethinking. Can you tolerate variable latency? Should you duplicate the data across many satellites? Or should the data constantly migrate from satellite to satellite?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by asciimike on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:00PM (#50501388)
Finding land/power/space to do a _single_ rack is not hard as ~every office building in America has 200kW of extra power and HVAC water at ~25C. Plus it only costs $4-5k to stick that $5M rack in the back of a truck to drive it there. No permits, easy maintenance, stable network connectivity.

Why use a satellite to do what your IT closet can already do?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by semiquaver on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:21PM (#50501576)
People are fudging orders of magnitude because it sounds cool and they are stupid.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:54PM (#50501869)
Put it in the ocean with a wave generator for trivial cooling and effectively infinite energy.

It's just so much easier, the other looks like a Rube Goldberg machine next to it.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Guvante on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:07PM (#50501993)
Why are you ignoring all of the costs of actually being in orbit here?

A normal satellite runs something similar to 1U worth of computer and costs roughly what you quoted in total...

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by cortesoft on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:40PM (#50502262)
Why are you guys rehashing the exact calculations that were made in the article? The article is all about these calculations, and they give ranges of values for each cost to see the the possible price points for everything in order to make it worthwhile.

They take all of the bits you guys are talking about into account in the article. You might disagree with some of the numbers, I guess, but that doesn't seem to be what you guys are talking about.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by blurker on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:29PM (#50502629)
> The upside is there's no land

Orbital space is becoming increasingly congested and hazardous. I think this is actually one of the worst arguments in support of space data centers.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Choad_20261104 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:42AM (#50507763)
I know you probably weren't meaning to solve a business model here, but there are differences between the space-borne rack and the earthbound rack that will require cost consideration. Likewise the space-bound system will have no maintenance and will thus either require planning to manufacture for higher reliability or plan for greater risk of failure in MTTR/replacement cost modeling.

Whomever decides to fund the venture will necessarily ask investors/CFO to rationalize the expected return.

In our modern hurry up, returns only pencil out in the very far future and yet investors seem to care little.

I am not certain that reflects good capitalist values or discipline.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by wmf on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:59PM (#50502380)
Starmind is already one rack.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by hermitShell on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:59PM (#50503551)
I think the kinds of workloads that will be profitable to run in space are not complex workloads, but rather ones that benefit from being outside of any country. Power (control authority) that is running on space infrastructure is literally above the law. It doesn't take a whole lot of compute to do a lot of things.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Balooga on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:09AM (#50504724)
The uplinks that talk to the satellite are in a country. The company that owns the uplinks and the satellite is in a country. The people that work for that company live on the ground and in a country. Having a GPU in space won't let anyone operate "above" the law.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by hermitShell on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:48AM (#50519674)
So... you don't think that some members of the top 1% wealthiest people in the world consciously skirt (or outright violate and abuse) the law, today?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ggm-at-algebras on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:51PM (#50499670)
Do we need to? Do we want to? Who is "we" here?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by omgwtfbyobbq on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:53PM (#50499692)
Even if their aren't financially viable, I think they're attractive because companies want to keep certain kinds of data/processing on everyone/everything someplace where there's a lower chance of government regulation (gdpr/etc).

If this is the case, I wouldn't be surprised to see them support these kinds of regulations because it would enhance their moat (now earth orbit in addition to large capex for equipment and a sufficiently large user base).

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by jeltz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:35PM (#50500553)
GDPR does not care about where your servers are located.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by omgwtfbyobbq on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:26PM (#50501004)
It seems to be in certain cases. For example Meta is subject to GDPR because they have EU headquarters, and were subject to fines because they transferred EU data to US servers.

If they have headquarters outside the EU, and only use data they've already acquired/processed to make money off of EU consumers from outside the EU, GDPR shouldn't be an issue for them.

And GDPR makes it harder for their competitors to catch up because it's harder to get data.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Eezee on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:53PM (#50501319)
Aren't they subject to GDPR because they do business in the EU with EU citizens? I don't see how that would change.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by omgwtfbyobbq on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:26PM (#50501632)
Probably, but not in the same way. I'm guessing they wouldn't have been fined for external data transfers if their servers were located outside the EU.

It could be that the EU would block them if they wanted to host fb/etc... including ads, and didn't have a presence in the EU, but I'm not sure if that's the case.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Buttons840 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:42PM (#50500626)
The satellites would be no different than a ground datacenter located near the satellite's human operators.

Maybe the government can't easily access your satellite, but you can, and the government has their $5 wrenches.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:24PM (#50500987)
There are only three ways to deal with regulations you don’t like: political, legal, and force.

Where you put something is completely irrelevant.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by omgwtfbyobbq on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:31PM (#50501076)
That's not accurate. You can build/do/etc things in some places and not in others because of differences in local law/regulation.

Where you put something, like a data center, can be relevant. If Meta didn't have a business presence in the EU, and operated their data centers outside of the EU, they wouldn't have been subject to GDPR in the same way they were.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:35PM (#50511048)
True true, good point.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by berkes on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:06PM (#50501458)
In that case, international water is far easier. There already are server farms on old oil rigs.

But, as these things go, regulation isn't that much about where you put the computers, but about where you register your company, and where your customers are living.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by omgwtfbyobbq on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:28PM (#50501644)
It's easier, but it's riskier too. Someone can come along a take your stuff a lot easier at sea than they can in orbit. And weather is always tricky, although launches aren't easy either.

In terms of regulation, it depends on the specifics. Sometimes it depends on where the customer lives, but even if it does, when a platform has no business operations in a region and there aren't international treaties to resolve that sort of thing, the most the regulation country can do is block them.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pu_pe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:55PM (#50499714)
The article makes several big assumptions that are questionable (experimental cooling can scale, permit issues on land will only become worse, etc). But more importantly, their analysis of the risks of placing a data center in orbit is completely off. They mention that it costs tens of millions to launch a missile to destroy a satellite, and it might be cheaper to simply replace it (based on launch costs). But one strike can hit many targets, those targets may contain hardware costing multiple times the value of their launch, and you will be out of compute while you scramble to launch a replacement. We can also assume that placing big fat valuable targets in space would have many actors wondering how to make it cheaper to destroy them.

For those reasons alone, and because compute will become more and more strategic for defense, I find it very hard to believe that data centers in space will represent even 5% of all compute in the next 10 years. I think a higher proportion will rather be underground or in bunkers than in space.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by hkpack on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:09PM (#50499829)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by FranOntanaya on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:09PM (#50499834)
Space is like the deep ocean, you never really know what's lurking in the shadows. A well placed pebble, a pellet of paint or a beam of microwaves could ruin a fragile satellite without being none the wiser.

If you want a safer datacenter you put it underground and you can safely assume that if it's hit by a bunker buster you have much much bigger problems.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by red-iron-pine on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:30PM (#50501073)
you just need one missile, maybe 2-3.

space debris will ruin the rest.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by simonebrunozzi on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:11PM (#50502025)
> We can also assume that placing big fat valuable targets in space would have many actors wondering how to make it cheaper to destroy them.

Yup. See True Anomaly, among others.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by UltraSane on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:57PM (#50499729)
Only if launch costs fall to 10% of current costs.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by lefra on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:08PM (#50499822)
IMO, they need to fall below the land cost for the same computing power somewhere in a desert.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by kaonwarb on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:59PM (#50499745)
Remarkably few comments are engaging with the actual assumptions, arguments, and calculations in the article. Beware vibes, in both directions!
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by runarberg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:17PM (#50500915)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by red-iron-pine on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:31PM (#50501083)
i heard someone say the same thing about thranos even after it was looking clear that they were shady
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by elnatro on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:59PM (#50499746)
If we don’t put data centers in the North Pole or in Antarctica, I really doubt that we put data centers in space.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by erulastiel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:03PM (#50499781)
Bro the North Pole doesn’t have land FYI
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by JRandomHacker42 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:06PM (#50499811)
neither does space
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Marsymars on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:57PM (#50501898)
Hey the geomagnetic pole is probably currently somewhere over Ellesmere Island, though has been drifting away.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:41PM (#50501203)
In space solar energy is available all the time. That is not the case in those locations, and the storage needs to get around that are the worst on Earth.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:19PM (#50502103)
Wind, waves, nuclear.

You don't have to pack your energy generator into the same package where your compute would go, for laughably little energy. You can have a single cable go between a huge power plant and the data center.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:47PM (#50502308)
A huge cable to the North Pole or to Antarctica would be way too expensive.

Also... nuclear? Please don't be silly.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:34AM (#50505788)
Ever heard of a nuclear submarine? Is it also plugged in?

And obviously you wouldn't bring the energy from a different continent. You think the wind is not blowing at these places? My point was that you have all the space you need, don't have to create a compact thing for everything.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:03AM (#50506646)
I want you to consider the difficulty of building anything at those places. It's going to cost at least as much to transport material there as it does to put stuff into space with a mature Starship-like launcher.

Nuclear submarine reactors are not sources of cheap power. Such power plants aren't even economical for most naval vessels vs. burning petroleum-derived fuels.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:29PM (#50508785)
Then.. do that? The point is, literally everything is orderS of magnitude cheaper here down on Earth, and there is zero problem scaling up stuff when you have the space for it.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by flossly on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:06PM (#50499810)
It's really hard to get electronic "space grade" there is a lot more radiation there.

Also I wonder how long the ODC needs to operate to offset the energy spend on getting it in orbit.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pokstad on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:12PM (#50500869)
Isn’t “space grade” a result of high space launch costs? If it becomes cheap enough to launch hardware into space, it doesn’t need to last as long to meet ROI.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:56AM (#50505219)
[delayed]
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by WillPostForFood on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:17PM (#50499893)
I have a few qualms with this:

As a Linux user, I can already build such a system quite trivially by installing Debian on a Raspberry Pi, attaching it to a weather balloon, and setting up a cron job to maintain orbit. The cooling is handled by opening a window. From Windows or Mac, the balloon could be accessed through built-in software.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Goodliff on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:35PM (#50500034)
One cool possibility is superconductance with a number of materials.

The catches:

o Shielding from the sun's light and radiant heat.

o And efficiently radiating the system heat into space (since there is no air to convect or conduct the heat away).

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by tonnydourado on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:52PM (#50500182)
There's a lot of long shot assumptions here, but I feel the biggest is $250/kg launch costs (let alone $100 or $50).
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by boelboel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:20PM (#50500417)
The long shot assumptions are only really applied in one direction as well, never really in favour of earth DCs.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by jpgvm on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:35PM (#50500555)
Earth has massive amounts of mostly unused land that is comparatively close enough by speed of light in fibre.

vs Space:

* Can drive a truck out there

* No limit on weight or dimensions (within reason)

* No giant explodey thing transporting it to into where it needs to be

* No constant falling towards the earth that needs to be averted with thrusters

* If building in the middle of nowhere there is also lots of space for solar panels

* Heat can be rejected into the atmosphere/earth/nearby bodies of water etc instead of radiation into the vacuum of space

* De-comissioning it doesn't also involve slamming a DC worth of mass into the atmosphere and burning up otherwise recyclable materials.

* You don't look like a doofus for doing bad math.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pokstad on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:15PM (#50500889)
Drive through Nevada outside of Vegas and you’ll see land everywhere. Yet, solar plants still build out slowly. It’s more than just land availability.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by flowerlad on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:48PM (#50500669)
Wouldn't it be cheaper to build a nuclear plant to power data centers than to launch the data centers into space? Nuclear is expensive, but rockets, orbital infrastructure, and giant cooling radiators aren't exactly budget options.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by sroussey on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:58PM (#50500740)
Aalo Atomic is working with datacenter maker Crusoe.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:03PM (#50500778)
There isn’t really any other option than nuclear.

Solar & wind can’t power industry.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by jiggawatts on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:06PM (#50500819)
That’s just not true. For the same cost as a nuclear plant of some rated power, you can build far more solar, wind, and batteries.

The pro-nuclear propaganda is suspiciously associated with people with a history of also wanting to build nuclear weapons. The Liberal Party of Australia is an example — they seem very interested in overpriced nuclear power and obtaining nuclear powered subs capable of launching nuclear tipped missiles.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by anenefan on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:46PM (#50503171)
The uranium based nuclear power generation's short comings in Australia has been pointed out to RNWJ at least once already [1] There's a lot of near desert regions here that could use some shading ... but it might be time to start looking at directing that power in something other than transmission lines or batteries, perhaps ammonia production which has multiple uses including powering large fuel cells.

I would say the motivation for nuclear by certain political parties in Australia ... aka Fat Cat's Mates ... is more out of the huge .. humongous ... ludicrous amount of money that would be generated via established think tanks, design committees ... and or kick backs to the relevant parties allowing Australia to go down the nuclear path. I would expect that if a firm monetary cap was placed on any think tank, survey, decision meetings and other design type areas (generally these are specialists firms based in countries that have a number of older style power plants) to that of 50 to 100 million per plant, most of the pro nuclear harping would go away immediately - though there are interests to have Australia be part of the nuclear problem as it wouldn't be long [2] the hard word would be placed and soon enough Australia would be a convenient dump for much of the nuclear global waste given the idea that the country is vast.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49532704

[2] Even with the nuclear sub program ... one of the politicians eventually had to rule that out publicly via media ... but what politicians say and what happens are two different things at times, sometimes there are things beyond their control.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:09AM (#50514895)
You’re good with Australia exporting uranium for nuclear power in other countries? It’s good for India and the other 40 or so countries we export uranium to?

But not Australia?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by anenefan on Monday November 16, 2026 @07:07AM (#50516695)
I am not ideologically opposed to the safe mining and export of Uranium to various countries which still require uranium for their existing power plants - basically if they have issues it falls into NIMBY territory. I would if I had the power urge any new nuclear build to be Thorium based as it's much safer for the planet.

I am opposed to new Uranium mines esp including ore processing, as some opportunists would certainly like to capitalise on what could only be seen as short term gains ... In Queensland iirc mid 10's when the mining ban was lifted, there was a stupid idea floated to mine Uranium west of Townsville (Qld.) with a new rail corridor built to the coast that would cut right though the city to the port. I wouldn't find any old data on that proposal only [1] and mention of an old mining operation in the same region that had problems. [2]

Reasons why Australia should not go Uranium nuclear are simple, apart from having a vast amount of land that is dry and near desert that would do well with large solar installations [3] ... much of the nuclear pathway here is bluntly an obvious gravy train for those (individuals and companies) who love money in return for going to meetings and making proposals, some plans ... and in the end we all know that in Australia, the hard question will be where to store the uranium waste - and that even before they start to tackle the new reality that the waste will require ongoing security.

[1] https://industryqld.com.au/mines/oasis-uranium-project/

[2] https://www.nqcc.org.au/uranium_mining_in_townsville_would_s...

[3] The US state of Texas which is smaller than NSW, (approx 7/8th the size) generates enough solar power to meet all of Queensland and NSW current daily electricity usage.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:37PM (#50501153)
Well named account. I assume it's a parody account.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rightnutwingjob on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:10AM (#50514903)
I’m just a person. I live in Melbourne.

My previous account, now 15 years old and with 10,000 karma got banned, primarily because I don’t mind tell people like you: try not to be a cunt. ;)

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Monday November 16, 2026 @03:09PM (#50522463)
You should be familiar with how advocating nuclear went over in Australia. It makes no economic sense there and those advocating it got clobbered in a recent election.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rgmerk on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:57PM (#50500731)
Underlying this seems to be the assumption that those pesky governments, pushed around by public opinion, will keep on blocking or delaying terrestrial data centres, but space-based ones will be fine.

The idea that launch rates could increase to the rates required to launch gigawatts of computing into space, without attracting a huge backlash, is fantasy. And such a backlash would be entirely justified - the only reason why the environmental effects of space launch aren't a focus of environmentalists is because there aren't many of them.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by sroussey on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:02PM (#50500777)
The only use case for datacenter in space is to have high communication speed with satellites that have low compute. Though that does beg the question of why not just add more compute to those satellites going forward.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by caidan on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:03PM (#50500791)
The real main purpose of putting data centers in space is not economic, and it’s not to guard against threats from major powers who could easily destroy them. It’s so that the ultra rich can have data centers that the rest of us cannot destroy. I make no argument about whether we should be thinking of doing so or not, but it is interesting to think of the implications is it not? And it certainly fits the personalities involved and their public statements.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pokstad on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:10PM (#50500858)
Since when have the public destroyed data centers?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by etchalon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:29PM (#50501654)
Hopefully soon.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by drayfield on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:09PM (#50500846)
This premise always struck me as a solution in search of a problem, which when implemented introduces even more problems.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by doctorpangloss on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:42PM (#50501212)
another POV is that outer space is a very prescient place to put infrastructure since it seems municipalities basically say no to everything
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Tadpole9181 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:14PM (#50502962)
I wouldn't even be that generous. It's not a solution in search of a problem: it's a scam by Elon Musk in an ever-continuing campaign of market manipulation and SEC violations.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by matteoraso on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:13PM (#50500876)
Even if data centres in space become cost-effective, what's the point? The only non-contrived answer that I can think of is to avoid NIMBYism, but pushback against data centres can't be that bad.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rgmerk on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:15PM (#50503643)
It is noticeably bad, but the idea that space-based data centres are immune to NIMBYism is extraordinarily naive as well. You have to get permission to launch rockets, and you're going to max out existing launch facilities pretty quickly if you increase the launch rate.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by perilunar on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:26AM (#50506101)
That's why SpaceX is building new ones: https://www.spacex.com/sites/starbase-la
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by alcomatt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:15PM (#50500895)
What happens to all the rare earth materials once the space DC have been decommissioned? Isn't it a horrible waste of the already hard to come-by resources to send it to a disposable trash heap in space, all in the name of forever chasing profits?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:40PM (#50501187)
What rare earth materials? Are you referring to Shellenberger's BS that PV uses rare earths?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by quantum_state on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:16PM (#50500901)
Solar wind and magnetic storm will fry the data center into space junk …
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Ekaros on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:23PM (#50500983)
Outside cost of launch I have understood that scaling it to sufficient power envelope with needed cooling is biggest step which most likely makes it unreasonable at scale. That is being able to use enough power to get reasonable amount of compute. Scale it small and low power enough and it is pretty simple. But at that point you might not be talking about amount of compute you expect.

Especially fun when you consider how often gigawatts are talked about with AI. And what that would mean just for cooling as in area... Or then dividing that to sufficient number of individual satellites...

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by lordnacho on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:26PM (#50501001)
You can put computers in space, but can you really call it a data centre at the scale that it can be done at?

Surely a single AWS/GCP/Azure/etc DC on earth is so big we won't be getting close to a similar amount of compute in space for the foreseeable?

The economic case also needs to be explained. What are people going to do with a DC in space?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ryanmcbride on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:28PM (#50501043)
We barely even have functioning trains or planes.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by K3UL on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:30PM (#50501060)
Google's paper on their Suncatcher project (where they recently put their TPU in orbit and received a response from a prompt) is pretty interesting to read:

https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(26)00362-4

Their blogpost is more "marketing-ish" but the videos are worth a watch too:

https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/models-and-research/go...

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by jp0001 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:45PM (#50501231)
Underground or in skyscrapers make more sense
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by siliconc0w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:49PM (#50501287)
Even put launch cost aside and assuming the best case for starship, most of the whitepapers I've seen seem to hand-wave the weight, cost, and complexity of cooling. You need large panels with special coating, pumps, and pipes - and that will get hit with micro-meteors so you need redundancy.

Land based or even sea wave-based datacenters are all much more feasible.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by fierycatnet on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:52PM (#50501314)
How feasible would that be? Don't we have to bring down some satellites from the orbit at some point? How would that work if space datacenter has a limited time use?
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by berkes on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:04PM (#50501441)
Wouldn't it be far cheaper to put DCs in offshore windmill parks? You have the power, cooling water abundant, fewer "NIMBY" than onshore DCs?

Is this already done?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by joe_the_user on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:23PM (#50501595)
All these wild plans are pretty funny given hyperscalers won't even "in the middle of nowhere" in the US but rather they put their sites in the edge of exist industrial areas with the aim to repurpose every bit of industrial infrastructure plus aiming to get all the incentives these small town (corruptly imo) offer industries for relocation.

I mean, the US could have a rational process of building new energy infrastructure (which should be only solar, wind and nuclear imo) but the actual process is opportunistic and haphazard. So it's not strange to see the NIMBYs biting them. It's like "well if you hadn't a d*k, this might not be happening to you..."

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by octoberfranklin on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:07PM (#50501461)
For people selling the anti-sabotage / anti-datacenter-terrorism angle: the math doesn't work.

The energy needed to achieve orbital altitude is vastly less than the energy needed to reach orbit. About 1kg of rocket fuel will carry a small explosive and some tiny steel spheres to LEO altitude. The projectile will not be in orbit; it won't have escape velocity -- in fact it will briefly hit zero velocity (wrt the earth) at orbital altitude and then fall back to earth.

The very large cloud of shrapnel created will encompass LEO orbital height for several seconds. If an orbiting datacenter passes through the cloud during those seconds, the shrapnel will be moving at orbital velocity wrt the datacenter. In other words, just one piece will take it out.

With relatively simple rocketry (and, these days, an abliterated LLM to aid you) a dedicated luddite would have several opportunities per day to hit one of a constellation of satellites. If they wanted one very specific satellite they'd have one or two chances a year. The targeting and steering is not hard -- the orbital paths are publicly known and easily observable; you can use RF time-of-flight to implement exceptionally precise position/altitude/velocity measurements from the rocket (no need for GPS -- use your own transmitters on the ground). This is not hard. And it will only get easier as AI advances.

*I strongly discourage anybody reading this from doing the above.*

I'm posting it in order to show people that anti-sabotage is absolutely not a selling point for orbital datacenters. If anything, they are far more vulnerable to luddite attacks. The people channelling billions into this tech know this too. So their motive is something else. I don't know what, but it isn't this. The math doesn't work.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by LostInTheWoods on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:13PM (#50501518)
Perhaps companies should consider putting their data centers underground (out of sight and out of mind). Space seems incredibly expensive and risky in comparison.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by MisterMunchkin on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:17PM (#50501549)
Oh I'm sorry, are you not even thinking of the lesser American ground worm? We're going to need a 15 year weevil analysis just to even think about digging a one metre borehole to test whether the worms will be affected.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by thepryz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:24PM (#50501608)
I’m thinking semi-mobile datacenters near active volcanos powered by the heat of the lava/magna flows would be “cool”
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by wry_xy on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:34PM (#50501703)
Or maybe we should just stop trying to centralize compute in the first place...
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by beloch on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:16PM (#50501537)
The discussion of cooling in this piece is more convincing than I would have expected, but there remains a glaring social problem:

Should we consider orbit to be outside of terrestrial tax jurisdiction?

The majority of the cost of putting these data centres into orbit would be borne by terrestrial jurisdictions. The places that built institutions, funded education, provide medical care, etc. for the people who built these things. The environmental impact of building these data centres and launching them will be paid by those living on Earth's surface.

On Earth, we often fail to recoup many of these costs because of out-sourcing, but at least some other jurisdiction benefits. If a poor country is lifted up by the benefits of out-sourcing, at least some good has been done. If we let billionaires simply blast off and evade taxes, that's a net loss to the societies that made this possible with no benefit to anyone but the billionaires. That's fundamentally wrong.

Space may belong to no one nation, but neither is it true that space belongs to no one at all. The space around Earth belongs to all of humanity. Orbital data centres should pay terrestrial taxes. It's not clear where those taxes should go, but we need to hammer out the laws to make sure they are paid.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Marsymars on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:49PM (#50501833)
You can tax the owners on the profits.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by newsclues on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:17PM (#50501548)
Yes, for military reasons.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by thepryz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:22PM (#50501592)
Outside of the physical, technical, and maintenance challenges of putting data centers in space, I simply don’t want more trash littering the night sky.

https://youtu.be/yZpbJJLk1ug

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by semiquaver on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:25PM (#50501621)
No
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by etchalon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:28PM (#50501647)
So if launch costs drop 15x and radiator technology improves 12 to 30x and chip lose is improved 2x and there are absolutely no innovations that make terrestrial deployment cheaper, it's totally slightly cheaper!
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by stillpointlab on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:33PM (#50501690)
The more I read HN the more I realize that I am more of an empiricist than a rationalist.

So many people here are opining as if they are correct. I have a large amount of doubt and I like the fact that the world is structured so that people can try things out and see if it works.

If the world was run by the naysayers in this thread, almost nothing would ever get done.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Joker_vD on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:58PM (#50501908)
Oh my god, it'd be way easier to, I don't know, build datacenters near Tashkent, Uzbekistan, where [0] is located. Here's your almost unlimited solar power, cheap land, and still better latency and easier cooling.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_furnace_of_Uzbekistan

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ordu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:08PM (#50502456)
> it'd be way easier to, I don't know, build datacenters near Tashkent, Uzbekistan, where [0] is located.

To build? Yes, it would be easy. But to not get those datacenters annexed by Russia would be pretty hard. Russia experiences shortages of hardware right now, I'm sure Putin would be happy if we placed some ready-made datacenters nearby so he could grab them.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Joker_vD on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:50PM (#50502793)
Uzbekistan doesn't even have a common border with Russia; it borders Kazakhstan instead. And even Putin can't teleport over a country, grab the datacenters, and teleport back to Kremlin.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ordu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:12PM (#50502952)
> Uzbekistan doesn't even have a common border with Russia; it borders Kazakhstan instead.

I don't think that it matters. Uzbekistan is highly dependent on Russia, Putin probably wouldn't even need to cross the border, he would need to ask Uzbekistan to nationalize a datacenter, and then some Putin's relative would buy it from Uzbekistan.

Are you ready to invest in a datacenter to see would it work in practice?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Danox on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:47PM (#50503176)
Putin is dead within 10 years, he doesn’t matter (unless he uses a nuke). Time is running out not just for him but for Russia if they don’t get their act together. Within the next 20 years in the same, may apply to the United States in certain respects the turnaround across the board needs to happen fast after the present clown show in the White House. right now, what are the odds thru the end of this century? China, Russia, United States, Western Europe.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ordu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:30PM (#50503400)
> Putin is dead within 10 years, he doesn’t matter (unless he uses a nuke).

The question still stands: are you ready to bet your money on Putin's death? Do you think that Putin's death would change Russia's behavior enough so your datacenter in Uzbekistan wouldn't be in danger?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Joker_vD on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:17PM (#50510274)
> Uzbekistan is highly dependent on Russia,

Not really, no. It exports more to the UK and Switzerland than to Russia; it imports more from China than from Russia. Sure, Russia is Uzbekistan's major trade partner, but Ukraine had Russia as an even bigger trade partner — and it didn't make Ukraine cave in to any of Putin's demands, if you haven't noticed. So neither would the Uzbeks.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by bob1029 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:07PM (#50502452)
I have doubt but I don't believe in the idea of something like this being strictly impossible.

This is turning out just like everything else. We establish a certain conclusion that is preferred and then walk backward into whatever evidence supports that conclusion.

In this case, AI needs to fail for certain groups. It is an apparent loss of identity. The notion of it going to space where it's a lot harder to get at (protest/regulate/etc) must really bother these people. I don't need datacenters in orbit to succeed. Whether they do or do not doesn't bother me very much. The concept is interesting but not essential. The inverse is clearly not true with the counterparties. I really don't understand why you would go on the internet and be a total shitlord regarding how orbital datacenters are impossible and fuck you for even suggesting they might be.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by louprado on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:23PM (#50503361)
Sadly this world is being run by masters of hype that appeal to the scientifically illiterate. Their super power is getting politicians and fund managers to support techno-religious non-sense with other people's money.

What's the goal or even the story at this point ? More compute will cure cancer and make those humanoid robots finally do something useful ? Then why are we letting millions of consumers use compute to create slop? Why is a significant part of the training data pornographic materials ? If compute is such a precious resource and we are so desperate for more that it needs to in outer-space then why use it to remake the Odyssey ?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Jamesbeam on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:58PM (#50501907)
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Grombobulous on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:00PM (#50501929)
Just skipping to the Conclusions section, I find this article to be wildly biased toward space data centers. Some of this reasoning is ridiculous, insane.

For one thing, I think there's a huge assumption that we just can't make energy cheap on earth (Cost per GW). Solar/battery costs are plummeting, nuclear energy is still a great option (see: the quantity of in-progress Chinese nuclear power plant builds in progress, I think around 30 projects under construction right now), and we might just figure out fusion reactors one day soon.

"Favors: Earth today; Space later" - seems way too confident.

Land Use: Does this article just not realize how large the earth is? The earth will never run out of space for data centers. You can even put them in skyscrapers if you want.

Long-run scaling: How does this row make a lick of sense? This is a lot like saying that if I build my house in space then I could have 100 parking spots in my driveway. The problem is, I don't need 100 parking spaces in my driveway. Like, yeah, we know that there's infinite room to put stuff in space.

Carbon / local environmental burden: Another insane take on this subject. Are we really going to hand-wave over burning a shitload of rocket fuel to put stuff in space? "Favorable vs gas-backed terrestrial buildout" why are we comparing against a gas-backed buildout?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by andxor on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:28PM (#50502179)
It will definitely happen and when it happens, HN will deny it happened, just like self-driving cars.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Rapzid on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:50PM (#50502325)
I couldn't find a single instance of "upgrade", "recover", or "recycle" in there.

What happens if a major advancement renders all the GPUs obsolete? How can they upgrade the hardware and resell the old hardware?

Are they just going to vaporize all the gear and precious metals?

IDK, the whole thing seems silly at the current state of space logistics.. For these and many more reasons.

It's popular mechanics/science levels of practical fantasy, but somehow now those stories end up swirling around the Internet and never flush. Would have been like having 5 newspaper articles about space elevators every month for years.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Luke2642 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:01PM (#50502398)
For this article, they put their thumb on the scale. It's just nonsense. Bad assumptions.

A 100kW Earth based solar array and a 500kWh grid scale battery that will last ~20 years is already a tiny fraction of the cost of even one Starlink satellite. It doesn't matter even if it was free to put in orbit, as only lasts five years once it's up there.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by wewewedxfgdf on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:15PM (#50502509)
Its so self-evidently a bad idea I'm surprised anyone gives it any thought at all.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by fwlr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:43PM (#50502733)
I will repeat my comments from earlier discussions of data centers in space: yes, the physics are bad, and yes, the economics are bad, but space has the critical advantage of being outside the Molotov throwing range of Joe Public (recently unemployed). I guess now you can also add that it would be out of the reach of their ballot casting range, too.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by rgmerk on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:12PM (#50503629)
They can throw Molotov cocktails at: the chip factory, the rocket factory, the launch pad, the ground stations, or more to the point the people who own the the data centres immiserating them.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Danox on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:16PM (#50502975)
No, one Chinese honey has ruined the party.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ungovernableCat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:38PM (#50503116)
The idea sounds really expensive. Wouldn’t it be easier and cheaper to just build in the third biggest country in the world? Lots of land out there.

If people object maybe you could propose some revenue sharing deal or tax funding for useful infrastructure or you know things that’ll make their lives easier instead of bribing corrupt local officials and make them sign NDAs or however they completely fumbled their PR with this so far.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by germoney on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:05AM (#50504700)
Economics are not there, technology is not there.

Some problems I can think of which make it economical infeasible right now: - Radiation hardening - Cooling ( look at the enormous difficulties cooling small objects e.g ISS) - Transport/Maintenance - Latency

And thanks to the Iran war: how to protect them?

It reeks of greenwashing like: „Endure massive DCs on earth just a bit longer and then they are in space“ everyone loves space, right?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by taegee on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:09AM (#50506688)
Betteridge's law of headlines: "Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no."
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Choad_20261104 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:52AM (#50507840)
What would be the point in serving terrestrial customers?

If you have a foundation model with sensors on board that has physics and the human unknowns about the universe loaded, you have a unique opportunity.

You have all that potential incoming data about the big universe and about the teeny marble below, why not just set Albion loose to just start crunching that?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by thewileyone on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:40AM (#50514420)
Aren't solar flares and UV radiation the huge risks to the servers? Time and catastrophic failure are just waiting to happen.