News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by stillpointlab on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:33PM (#50501690)
The more I read HN the more I realize that I am more of an empiricist than a rationalist.

So many people here are opining as if they are correct. I have a large amount of doubt and I like the fact that the world is structured so that people can try things out and see if it works.

If the world was run by the naysayers in this thread, almost nothing would ever get done.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Joker_vD on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:58PM (#50501908)
Oh my god, it'd be way easier to, I don't know, build datacenters near Tashkent, Uzbekistan, where [0] is located. Here's your almost unlimited solar power, cheap land, and still better latency and easier cooling.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_furnace_of_Uzbekistan

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ordu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:08PM (#50502456)
> it'd be way easier to, I don't know, build datacenters near Tashkent, Uzbekistan, where [0] is located.

To build? Yes, it would be easy. But to not get those datacenters annexed by Russia would be pretty hard. Russia experiences shortages of hardware right now, I'm sure Putin would be happy if we placed some ready-made datacenters nearby so he could grab them.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Joker_vD on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:50PM (#50502793)
Uzbekistan doesn't even have a common border with Russia; it borders Kazakhstan instead. And even Putin can't teleport over a country, grab the datacenters, and teleport back to Kremlin.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ordu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:12PM (#50502952)
> Uzbekistan doesn't even have a common border with Russia; it borders Kazakhstan instead.

I don't think that it matters. Uzbekistan is highly dependent on Russia, Putin probably wouldn't even need to cross the border, he would need to ask Uzbekistan to nationalize a datacenter, and then some Putin's relative would buy it from Uzbekistan.

Are you ready to invest in a datacenter to see would it work in practice?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Danox on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:47PM (#50503176)
Putin is dead within 10 years, he doesn’t matter (unless he uses a nuke). Time is running out not just for him but for Russia if they don’t get their act together. Within the next 20 years in the same, may apply to the United States in certain respects the turnaround across the board needs to happen fast after the present clown show in the White House. right now, what are the odds thru the end of this century? China, Russia, United States, Western Europe.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ordu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:30PM (#50503400)
> Putin is dead within 10 years, he doesn’t matter (unless he uses a nuke).

The question still stands: are you ready to bet your money on Putin's death? Do you think that Putin's death would change Russia's behavior enough so your datacenter in Uzbekistan wouldn't be in danger?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by Joker_vD on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:17PM (#50510274)
> Uzbekistan is highly dependent on Russia,

Not really, no. It exports more to the UK and Switzerland than to Russia; it imports more from China than from Russia. Sure, Russia is Uzbekistan's major trade partner, but Ukraine had Russia as an even bigger trade partner — and it didn't make Ukraine cave in to any of Putin's demands, if you haven't noticed. So neither would the Uzbeks.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by bob1029 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:07PM (#50502452)
I have doubt but I don't believe in the idea of something like this being strictly impossible.

This is turning out just like everything else. We establish a certain conclusion that is preferred and then walk backward into whatever evidence supports that conclusion.

In this case, AI needs to fail for certain groups. It is an apparent loss of identity. The notion of it going to space where it's a lot harder to get at (protest/regulate/etc) must really bother these people. I don't need datacenters in orbit to succeed. Whether they do or do not doesn't bother me very much. The concept is interesting but not essential. The inverse is clearly not true with the counterparties. I really don't understand why you would go on the internet and be a total shitlord regarding how orbital datacenters are impossible and fuck you for even suggesting they might be.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by louprado on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:23PM (#50503361)
Sadly this world is being run by masters of hype that appeal to the scientifically illiterate. Their super power is getting politicians and fund managers to support techno-religious non-sense with other people's money.

What's the goal or even the story at this point ? More compute will cure cancer and make those humanoid robots finally do something useful ? Then why are we letting millions of consumers use compute to create slop? Why is a significant part of the training data pornographic materials ? If compute is such a precious resource and we are so desperate for more that it needs to in outer-space then why use it to remake the Odyssey ?