News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by zelphirkalt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:35PM (#50499514)
No we will not. The reason is simple: Space is not in the cloud, it is above. Anything that's not in the cloud is bad.

Silliness aside, has anyone come up with a cooling system that would work well for a friggin data center in space? Or is it still all just a wishful thinking game, ignoring physics?

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by ben_w on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:42PM (#50499590)
> Silliness aside, has anyone come up with a cooling system that would work well for a friggin data center in space? Or is it still all just a wishful thinking game, ignoring physics

That's perfectly viable.

However at the temperatures chips operate at, because stuff on the ground is getting convective cooling as well as radiative, a radiator designed for LEO will reject slightly more heat on the ground than it would in orbit.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by exogeny on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:43PM (#50499603)
It is absolutely a wishful thinking game, ignoring physics. It's a bet made by investors who don't know or care about the science, and are looking for a modal outcome of a failed company purchased by SpaceX or by an even dumber company looking to compete with SpaceX.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:55PM (#50499711)
I recommend reading up on the results of Google’s project suncatcher. IMHO the results have provided a roadmap to space DCs with the only blocker being launch cost which are targeted to become economically viable in 2030s; sooner for spacex because they can lower their margins to zero or even negative for the launch itself.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:47PM (#50501256)
Whenever I asked someone to dig down into "against the laws of physics" arguments, they turned out to instead rest on a pile of tacit and pessimistic technological assumptions.

Perhaps you could explain in detail why you think the laws of physics have to be violated for space data centers to work.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:53PM (#50499688)
The plan as I understand it is to pack it tightly with TPUs with liquid cooling out to radiators and flying a tight cluster of these next to each other using high bandwidth laser links. That lets you balance the amount of thermal radiation you need to emit vs the amount of TPUs in a single satellite. Thus it’s not a DC in a single satellite but more like a rack and then a bundle of racks flying beside each other.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by gf000 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:14PM (#50502062)
Or you know, just have tpus with liquid cooling in huge racks, with optical cables or whatever. We can put a shitton of them into a warehouse sized space, and we have basically infinite energy to power and cool it, with physical connection to the internet for ultra fast speeds!

(Sorry, the snark is not directed at you)

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:42PM (#50502273)
The problem is that building the physical DCs is a cost problem not just in terms of energy availability (it’s not infinite) but also politics and legal regulations. Ignoring that is why it makes the space idea seem silly but it’s a real one
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by zelphirkalt on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:43AM (#50505839)
Well, how does that liquid cooling agent get cooled down? Do we have a way of producing sufficient surface area, to be able to cool it down in space, where cooling is difficult exactly due to not interacting with much matter.
Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by vlovich123 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:10AM (#50508026)
You probably replied to the wrong commenter as they were talking how a warehouse is easier.

To answer your question, what project suncatcher results show is the cooling radiator needed to dissipate the rack is a insignificant fraction of the mass of the satellite rack. It bounds the absolute size of a rack you can launch maybe but that’s why you build a close flying constellation of many many such satellites interlinked by high speed laser links to handle the inter-rack communication.

Re:Will We Put Data Centers in Space? by freecodeio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:38PM (#50501168)
it's the equivalent of PMs asking "can we just make our own llm to save costs"