Utterly appalling. Seriously. So sad and pathetic that there are human beings out there with dirtiness on their minds and power to impose their interpretation of reality in something universal as art. Seriously, my blood boiled after reading that.
Also, the West interferes with the rest of the world quite enough - I'd suggest we try to stop exploiting the rest of the world before we 'save them from their backwards religions' or whatever.
After ISIS took over parts of Iraq, they did what many have done before them through the millennia of destroying art and beauty because they disagreed.
A modern take is the climate activists destroying art because they fear the end of the world.
Fear manifests in interesting ways.
ISIS on the other had specifically wants the art destroyed because their particular brand of brainworms is opposed to anything that isn't worm-shaped. The goal wasn't to shock people, it was to cause deliberate damage to human culture.
It’s all power games. Trying to pretend your morals are correct is hypocritical.
Takes that destroying art is worse than defacing some unremarkable plexiglass?
I mean... yeah, it is.
It was easier to terrify people into surrendering their mind than to defeat them physically (and have them surrender their SUV in the art example).
ISIS wanted to recreate the Caliphate, and shocking, violent videos were one of the most effective methods of recruiting young, belligerent, impressionable males. Martyrdom, beheadings, and violent Jihad were things long before ISIS, and they simply put on the mantle.
to put it another way, you only saw the violent propaganda, since it was in the interest of the US Gov, Israel, Turkey, et al, to make sure the world saw how brutal they were. You didn't watch the hundreds of hours of non-violent propaganda or theology, such as the recruiting videos aimed at young Islamic women.
I hope there isn't a time in the future when people see the current wave of anti-racism, anti-slavery, and anti-misogyny as just a silly fad we had in the early 21st century. Although, I guess the people would have said the same about nudity in the mid-1800s...
You see that in a way they are perfectly fine with old sensitivity. As long as censorship and exclusion are done the way they have been done in past, they support it.
Plenty of the things which are pushed unconditionally in the US right now should be debatable and debated. Some concepts like cultural appropriation look clearly dubious to my French self. The issue is that having a debate has become impossible. In some circles, you will be quartered for daring to express that there exists differences between men and women which might not be socially constructed.
That's a problem. Why have people become so afraid to speak their minds? We live in a democracy or not?
Always was, IMO what you're experiencing with this is just the Overton window shifting around you.
Goes both ways: People hardly ever discussed trans topics when I was a teenager and I don't know if that was a taboo or merely lack of awareness, but I do know that lesbian gay and bisexual topics were tabooed.
A sufficiently large group of people have realized that they can function legally as a social lynch mob.
A person can stand by their ideals all they want, but if their livelihood and/or social standing have been taken from them, then expressing those ideals doesn’t serve them very well.
Many people just find it easier not to engage.
History will not reflect kindly on these groups — they will be mocked (“crazy things people actually believed in the 2020s!”).
> We live in a democracy or not?
Regarding democracy, the most vocal zealots on both extremes of the political spectrum support decidedly undemocratic positions.
Many/most of the folks I know who speak out loudest about “freedom” are also the most willing to restrict it… for others.
What’s the saying… freedom for me but not for thee?
Before I come across as overly cynical, let me just add that most Americans I’m around have a very laissez faire attitude about most things. They are just very quiet about it, living their lives peacefully.
I’m a believer in the very moderate silent majority in the US. It’s just hard to notice that it exists when pretty much all mainstream media and social media are designed to favor the promotion of extremist stances.
My experience in the US is the opposite. It's only at the extremes that you'll find people concerned about our civil liberties slipping away, wanting to give everyone a voice, and accepting that there are opinions unlike their own and that's ok.
Probably because people on both ends are threatened by the middle party duopoly. The middle only allows conversation about wedge issues and nothing different or more substantive. The middle both decide for whom we can vote because they're corporations, not democratic entities. They collaborate only to make sure viable 3rd parties cannot exist and to ensure their donors' demands are met. Otherwise, they return to squabbling over wedge issues that neither party actually ever solves because the wedges are too useful to be solved. Our two middle parties are fundamentally anti-democratic - maybe that's why most Americans are independent.
And doing that while you created that topic in the first place.
Not really, no.
Setting aside pedantry about the US being a republic and not a pure democracy, the fact is that wealthy elites decide election outcomes now. You ended up with Trump because elites in Russia wanted him elected more than elites in the US wanted Clinton. You got rid of him because elites in the US had woken up to the fact that they weren't the only player in that game anymore.
Culture wars are a proxy battlefield in much the same way that Ukraine is.
Sadly, we can't wait for the train to stop at next station and get out, because it's the only train we have.
This is so detached from reality, that is not even trying to understand why trump happened and why it may happens again.
On a similar note, you can absolutely point to America for using the international monetary system in its favor, and that wouldn't be the same a blaming regular americans.
Some of them, like Israel and China, push pretty hard, albeit with different goals.
Also worth noting that in many cases they're just co-opting the system set up by US powerbrokers, e.g. Tucker Carlson of Fox News talking about how great Putin is.
Actually political scientists routinely refer to the US as a democracy. You're splitting a hair that experts do not. The word "democracy" does not only mean direct democracy. Mentioning this non-issue at all is a signal, but maybe not the one you hoped for.
In day-to-day life it certainly doesn't matter - but when you are attempting to discuss the nature of that political system itself, I don't think it is at all unreasonable to call out the distinction and decide whether to discuss it further. No need for snide jabs.
Arguing these is pointless, because they are violate dogmas that underpin our modern ideology. They are not up for argument. If another ideology suggests that racism is actually a-ok, then we consider it clearly flawed, because dogmatically, ideologies that come to that conclusion must be flawed. And not just flawed, because these fundamental dogmas are what shapes our notions of "good" and "evil". Not adhering to these dogmas makes you evil.
I must add, this is not a fallacy of some sort. If I were thrown into another society where everyone approves of racism, I am still attached to my personal dogmas. I would consider such a society unjust and warped. As a matter of fact, there's plenty of personal dogmas our current society violates, and I consider our current society and its ideology unjust and flawed.
Which raises another point, which is that our society does not have a monolithical ideology. It has an emergent ideology that arises from common agreement, but there's plenty of people in our society these days who disagree with several of the dogmas. And that's what makes them "bad" or "evil".
The only way to argue someone out of a personal dogma is to convince them that whatever your dogmas are is reflective of absolute good, evil, and/or truth. This is the subject of what is likely one of the oldest philosophical debates and has spawned several religions.
This is not a two sided discussion where each camps agree in block with a set list of propositions. It's also not manichean with things being either completely true or false, right or wrong or, good or evil. You are not either for or against. If you believe that, you are the problem.
We should be able to explore these subjects in their full complexity with the disagreement that entails. It's not even possible anymore in academia.
We almost universally agree that racism is not ok but what's racism? Some think affirmative action is racist.
The society is far greater than you. Different people have (and have the right to have) different opinions.
I mean it is a fad just a centuries old one.
My opinion is that morality is essentially a tips and trick of how to survive passed in a game of generational telephone.
E.g. ancient Greek hated cannibalism but practiced pederasty. Cannibalism can lead to catching prions and going crazy. For them it was god's punishment. Pederasty probably didn't have as many negative side effects at that time.
Proclaiming superiority over our predecessors is short lived. Imagine if there were two races of butterflies, one gray one white. The white blend better on trees and thus survive more, so white butterflies start arguing they are morally superior (favorite of God, etc.) to the gray ones, but that quickly changes once pollution grays the trees making now white butterflies the more visible prey.
So killing, cannibalism and pederasty are obviously imoral.
Die-off from lack of breeding? Sexually transmissible diseases? In both cases you could also construct homosexuality as immoral
Actually cannibalism is just eating of people, there is no requirement that said people get butchered for it. Someone might ritualistically eat an elder in their community to gain part of their wisdom for example, but there is not a requirement that they slay that elder first - they may just wait for them to die
Maybe this is an unpopular opinion, but I put the blame on those afraid to speak their minds.
I try always to speak my mind — whether it flies in the face of popular opinion or no. I take the downvotes — I sort of like that they have me pause and reconsider my opinion. But if in the end I feel I am still justified the downvotes just become a kind of war-wound or something that I take some small amount of pride in.
I'm not sure why everyone doesn't do the same.
But denying me the possibility to provide food for my two kids, my wife and me, is another thing. And there are just two possible responses: either I won't talk anything meaningful to strangers, or, having calculated my chances, I would aggressively defend my right and my children's rights to speak our minds. And by aggressively I mean very, as in revolutionary very. You threaten my very existence, and then all bets are loose and anything that will let me and my people win over you is permitted.
I hope you're wrong, but...
It would be lovely to see some actual historical perspective on America's periodic obsessions. Post-9/11 anti-terrorism and airport security theater are still here. The Vietnam-era obsession of the left with being anti-war (while the right was still pro-war and anti-communist) has almost reversed. We had McCarthyism in the 1950's. Etc.
The Great Awakenings ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Awakening ) should probably be thrown into the list. And the Salem Witch Trials ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salem_witch_trials#Political_c... ). And...
Can you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules? We'd appreciate it.
where [view] exists at any point on the political spectrum.
> that there exists differences between men and women which might not be socially constructed
It depends on the context for me. If you're stating that point to make an interesting and insightful comment, all well and good. If you're just using it to bash trans people, it's less valuable IMO.
> If you're stating that point to [say something I agree with], all well and good. If you're just using it to [say something I disagree with], it's less valuable IMO
That's the point. Create a chilling effect to stifle discussion. Make it easy to draw sides and rally a demographic. Force opposition to take increasingly wild, extreme positions, then use those as a way to force your side to get even more extreme. Now you have 20-305 of the population who are rabid about issue X, and any real discussion about it is dead.
Makes it real easy to sidestep other discussions, like how broken housing or minimum wages are.
Nor is this a new thing, by a long shot; was an explicit tactic of the Soviet Union, and has been adopted by plenty of others, notably the US Right-wing.
Reducing racism is great, but censoring existing works because they contain the n-word just seems stupid.
It can also lead to further problems. Is it still racist to point out the [race/gender/religion/etc.] [students/employees/etc.] on average aren't as good now they actually aren't due to [employment/selection] bias?
Or good racism.
> Spielberg was also asked about the controversial re-editing of Roald Dahl’s work which has included changing words like “fat” to “enormous” and “ugly and beastly” to just “beastly”.
> Initially he joked that “Nobody should ever attempt to take the chocolate out of Willy Wonka! Ever!” before adding “For me, it is sacrosanct. It’s our history, it’s our cultural heritage. I do not believe in censorship in that way.”
Roald Rahdl books were a big part of what I remember reading as a child. The words "fat" and "ugly" are absolutely grotesque, but also part of the palette he used to draw his worlds as he wanted people to see them. I think parents have the responsibility to have a proper conversation about the questions their children might have about the some of stuff those books bring up, or make the decision to not read them until the child is of a certain age. At least from my point of view, the central question would be that what is the proper age that a child is old enough to know about the existence of the words "fat" and "ugly".
Give it a generation of children growing up with the new euphemisms as standard terminology. Then they will be equivalent.
But even if we erased every single word for fatness from the minds of everybody in existence all in an instant, new words for fatness would be invented the very next instant when people around the world see fatness, can't find a word for it, and invent a new one. Words are tools for conveying understanding. Humans are tool-creating apes; when we need a tool, we make a tool. Remove a slur from people's vocabulary and people will invent a new one.
When I was young, my school had a program for retarded kids, the kids with profound mental disabilities. We also called each other retarded as a mild insult to impugn our friends' intelligence. The teachers and parents hated this, they banned the word retarded and renamed the class for the retarded kids to "Special Education". Anybody caught saying "retarded" would be scolded very severely and denied recess/etc. So what did we do? We started using "special", "special education" and "sped" as insults equivalent to retarded. You can't erase concepts by erasing words, least of all concepts that are so readily observable and self-evidently negative as the state of being mentally retarded or fat. Need a tool, make a tool.
inb4 "it's not real censorship unless the government does it"
Anyway, you're wrong and I think you know it because you said "government-mandated censorship." The first two words clarify the third. This wouldn't be necessary if the third truly implied the first two.
Have you ever heard of the Hay's Code? It's quite infamous, you probably have; it was a system of self-imposed censorship from Hollywood to ban scandalous content from movies, such as people kissing or husbands and wives only having a single bed in their bedroom (oh the implications!) But the point is this censorship was self-imposed, there was no act of congress requiring it. The claim that true censorship must come from the government is simply wrong.
It hasn't even been 5 years, and already the 2020 "fight racism by renaming your master branch to main" movement feels like a tone-deaf embarrassment.
I can see how these would be considered a silly part of the current anti-racist movement.
Thank god they weren't in place when I went to school. My kids wouldn't be here.
Not sure if it is at all obvious.
https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditEng/comments/11xx5o0/you_brok...
> The nodeSelector and peerSelector for the route reflectors target the label `node-role.kubernetes.io/master`. In the 1.20 series, Kubernetes changed its terminology from “master” to “control-plane.” And in 1.24, they removed references to “master,” even from running clusters. This is the cause of our outage. Kubernetes node labels.
Main is a better name IMHO (increased clarity and brevity) but it is far from "zero downside."
It's not obvious at all. The music industry has been using the term "master" for ages: master bus, master copy, mastering engineer. (It's worth noting this is the exact etymology of the git term, too, as opposed to master in the context of master and slave.) The Black community has overall had zero problem with this, and it hasn't stopped many Black musicians and artists from being successful. The music industry also had none of the "we have to rename the master bus" nonsense that came from the tech industry, despite, or more likely because, a significantly larger proportion of BIPOC and LGBT minorities being involved in music.
I don't care about the master vs main name in the abstract. Either branch name is a fine choice. It just completely doesn't matter and pretending that it has any positive impact or meaningful change on the racism and discrimination faced by Black people in America is insulting. It's purely driven by self-indulgent white people who don't want to make material changes to their own extremely comfortable lives while pretending they're fighting the good fight.
Exactly, and I agree with this completely as a Slavic person (from which the word slave is derived). I frankly consider this insulting as well as having a great grandparent used for forced labour in the Ukrainian Canadian interment camps during WWI, and a grandparent in the German forced labour camps during WWII.
One day we will realize all over again that hyper-focus on race only produces more division and more racism. But I'm lost as to whether or not those on the left doing it care. Maybe they want division and feel that minorities will come out on top and all white men will get their chance to "suffer". Not sure. I have been told as much in person by some who hold this philosophy.
“It appeared that there had even been demonstrations to thank Big Brother for raising the chocolate ration to twenty grams a week. And only yesterday […] it had been announced that the ration was to be reduced to twenty grams a week. Was it possible that they could swallow that, after only twenty-four hours?"
Maybe not, but there'll definitely be a time in the future when the current puritanical wave will be seen as a fad, an embarrassment in human history.
"You mean people actually self-censored in case they were punished for thoughtcrime?"
"Yes, grandson."
Proceeds to destroy hundreds of paintings by adding poorly drawn fig leaves and to censor masterpieces over tiny penises.
It is a fad; people will come to their senses and recognise the value of the original work; while accepting the fact that they were produced in a time where these behaviours were considered as acceptable but it's no longer the case.
So... I certainly hope that being genuinely anti those things doesn't turn out to be a fad, those things are all bad things and should be opposed. Having said that I do hope that some of the ways people are choosing to be "anti" these things goes the way of the dodo because I believe they are ineffective and dumb.
As an example trying to get rid of the word "master" in tech... it's use in tech is in no way an endorsement of slavery. The suggestion it is racist to use this term is especially silly to me, because slavery has been practiced by all sorts of cultures for human history and because slavery is still a thing that is going on in the world (just look at that new stadium in the UAE).
Being anti slavery is fantastic. We can do that by boycotting companies that turn a blind eye to forced labour and by pressuring our governments to sanction countries that ignore it within their borders.
The same applies to being anti-racist or anti-misogynist or whatever. There are concrete actions that can be taken that will make a difference, but going back through old art and censoring certain words for fear that they get uttered as if this were Harry Potter and these words were Voldemort is just fucking silly.
Best to capture art as a moment through books, sculptures and film and to interpret that moment later on.
You could choose however to not display certain things in your library if it doesn’t match your (current) standards, that’s perfectly fine.
I think it’s important how you deal with the things that don’t match your standards.
That said, at this point, the painted on underwear is part of the history, and at least one example of overwrought censorship should be preserved as an artefact of its era.
For movies it's as easy as obtaining DRM-free copies of the movies you care about, saving them to an SSD, and installing a copy of Plex.
Do that with the movies, music and books you love. They are a part of our cultural history. It's almost a guarantee that any copy you don't own and control will at some point in the future be revised. I want the real history not what the powers that be tell me it was.
It's virtually guaranteed that Amazon, Netflix et. al. will not store this stuff for you with integrity, it is built into the nature of the system.
No need to even go to censorship, you have people like George Lucas who go out of their way to destroy their previous productions.
I'm really doubtful that it's as simple as Lucas one day having a left-wing/progressivism epiphany or some other grand artistic change, sell Lucasfilm to Disney, then participate in the destruction of their IP.
Wasn't he promised "treatments" and general involvement in the latest trilogy, then Disney back-stabbed him last-minute? I vaguely remember some drama about that.
Anyway, long story short, I think that there is more to the story, such as him being promised one thing and another thing happening, etc.
It's difficult to see this as a political event, where he was outplayed.
He's worked with and against the big cats in Hollywood his whole career, he specifically made career decisions to 'get away' from Hollywood meddling in his work.
He knew what he was doing and this mythical George Lucas character, who is victim and hero in one man, is getting a bit long in the tooth.
But like many story-spinners, he needs an equally phenomenal editor to sit on him. And it happens time and time again that a story-spinner gets so famous/rich/whatever that they can sit on the editor instead, and then the quality drops.
It's a very rare breed of story-spinner who can sit on themselves, offhand I can think of Tolkien perhaps.
George Lucas just saw making sci-fi movies as an effort to get reality as close as possible as the images he had in his mind. That meant seeing FX as an approximation, a constant compromise to reach the limits of what is possible to film. Lucasfilm were pioneers in digital FX and 3D for that very reason.
However, that also meant that each new work looked different from the previous, as real and digital FX diverged more and more with each passing year. He tried to rectify this by updating old works with new scenes and new effects. Had he stopped there, I reckon most people would have just plauded the novelty and moved on.
Unfortunately, while doing that, he also took the chance to modify what he saw as plot problems in the original movies - particularly the first, which was shot in isolation as a one-off, since there was no indication it would be as successful as it did (most actors thought it would be a one-and-done piece of trash, just to make a quick buck, particularly Sir Alex McGuinness). He made some dubious choices and the fandom never forgave him for that.
s/McGuinness/Guinness/
var objRef=document.querySelector("#\\33 5725793 > td > table > tbody > tr > td.default > div.comment > span > p:nth-child(3)");
objRef.textContent=objRef.textContent.replace('Alex','Alec').replace('McGuinn','Guinn');My take is that he became complacent with the money after the first Star Wars, and never had much to show for afterwards or cared for movies that much. Contrast with his pal Spielberg who churned out film and film, and mastering his craft.
Ah, wait. He did found a great passion in the early 80s: merchandise.
I think what comes across in the prequels as this sort of ‘first take’ feel to the performances is a manifestation of his impatience - he wants to get the footage, edit it, get the effects, and see the thing in his head. And the ‘remastering’ he has done is similarly a bit of psychological desire to always feel like he can fix it later.
Waiting five days for Phil Tippett to stop motion ten seconds of tauntaun walking must have driven him crazy.
Underneath, it’s an engineer’s kind of laziness - the sort that drives innovation. I honestly felt after watching that documentary that I am slightly less annoyed by the clunkiness of Attack of the Clones because I actually now can see underneath it the excitement of Lucas to use all the toys he has spent a fortune investing in ILM to build and just make the damn movie.
Yes, but he overemphasized those technical aspects (where his care went) over the movie aspects.
It's like the guy who builds an expensive studio, with a huge mixer console, high end microphones, state of the art Pro Tools rig, and then proceeds to record his farts.
And we all get to benefit from the innovation he drove.
As much as you and I might knock Star Wars, it's wildly successful and is still seeing plenty of success in other mediums, so obviously it appeals to someone.
If the best you can say about a director is that "without him we wouldn't have as many franchize videogames" then I can rest my case :)
"I'll defend Lucas til I die. His expanded universe is why I read so many books as a kid, and the huge number of star wars videogames in the 90s/2000s allowed game designers to tinker with different gameplay ideas with the star wars fans as a safety net. The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?"
Want me to highlight your argument? Here it is...
"The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?"
That's the neat thing about art, I can choose not to think the post-Disney acquisition cash-cow milking is canon, especially when none of the original storytellers are involved, and it is thus not their vision.
Call it what it is: they retconned to milk the cash cow they bought dry.
Lucas contributions were iconic, but not enough to get the movie to the level it is. From some dialogues I've seen between the whole team about the films [1], Lucas was more into throwing high level ideas, not about any core script work. So, the main concept, parts of the character design, and a high level plot summary. The rest had to make a full story, screenplay, and movie out of it.
[1] http://maddogmovies.com/almost/scripts/raidersstoryconferenc...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changes_in_Star_Wars_re-releas...
Count me among the purists who think he ruined his good work ;-)
You can tell all the inserted scenes because the colors are off, the animations are not blended well, and it feels off uncanny valley style.
Sometimes directors have to give into the limitations of their medium -- time, money, meddling producers, etc. If they want to revise it later to meet their original vision, more power to them.
Also entirely possible it was a cash grab; Skywalker Ranch needed a new wing or something.
Agh, I know the series is still raking in millions. But I can't enjoy the edits because my brain cries 'blasphmeny!'
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/c206f2/do_laser...
The best you are likely to find is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmy%27s_Despecialized_Editio... – I don't think the unaltered editions were ever released on DVD or BluRay at all, just VHS and LaserDisc.
No they were released in the 2006 DVD set, quality is very poor though.
Digitally remastered but otherwise the cinema release
At the time the excuse was that there were no longer any masters for the original trilogy to rescan for rerelease, so the LaserDisc version was the best that could be done.
https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_changes_in_Star_War...
Their video quality is also terrible, even for DVD, being derived from a scan made for a Laserdisc release.
Edit: With the exception of getting LaserDisc releases of various vintages, the DVD release is the best, most accessible (excluding rarity) home video release of the original, unedited trilogy. They are not the highest quality, no doubt, but they are the best that was released. It could be argued that the despecialized editions are better for this reason or that, I personally consider them an incredible novelty, rather than a reference release.
It spoils the twist, but:
> And everybody knows that Greedo never even fired
> when Han shoots first it sets up his entire moral journey
> Plus it's cool
Also don't start me on that 'thing' they have singing in Jabba's palace.
0 - https://www.amazon.com/Tales-Eisley-Cantina-Star-Wars/dp/055...
The Greedo scene has been tweaked multiple times. In the most recent version available on Disney+ (confirmed to be Lucas’ work), Greedo exclaims “macklunkey!” just before the shooting starts, which I find hilariously absurd.
I have no problem with people making new versions of existing works; the problem I have is destroying the originals; even if destroyed by the author. The existence of copyright itself is a "deal" between society and an individual, we give the individual certain rights and privileges in exchange for certain benefits to society.
Only now has the ability to go back and change things resulted in large-scale destruction of personal copies of that original thing.
I don't know the reason it was removed but it was like a I was pinched and realised how little control I have over my favourite music.
The album is still on YouTube but I don't know for how long.
I bought the vinyl, even though i currently don't have a record player but plan to get one
I have to start preserving DRM free or physical copies of media I like. I always knew there was a risk of stuff being removed but always put off thinking about it for convenience, but not anymore
I'm not aware of this happening for explicitly censorious reasons, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if it did.
If The Internet Archive can do it for websites, we can find a similar solution for films, too.
There used to be one called what.cd [0] that, to me, was like the Library of Alexandria, but for music. It was burned down in the name of commercial interest.
It might not be legal, but that's because the industry's interest is diametrically opposed to ours.
If it's moral and worthy of support, I'll leave for you to decide.
[0] https://www.vice.com/en/article/3de7vj/remembering-whatcd-th...
Which may happen for awhile, even a century. But it won't last thousands of years, unless storage space becomes infinitely big and cheap.
I liked DC++ approach on file sharing more. If someone in the network has the file, you can get it, no matter how rare. It can be an obscure film made in 1930 or an mp3 only few people know or care about.
20 and 25 years ago, before torrents, it was king and it provided what us, poor kids, didn't have the money to pay for.
I guess today it isn't used that much as it used to be. It requires a client for discovery.
1. A unique computer key identity is created on startup.
2. It announces every network adapter you have to the dHT, including localhost, docker virtual network adapters, everything.
3. If someone is sharing a specific hash content, you can query the network for their machine key and all their network interfaces, and everything else they're sharing.
4. I have early IRC communications that the ipfs.io gateway also quietly watches for 'bad hashes' and reports them to authorities. This was initially the decision they made to hunt down child porn predators, but this can be easily pivoted to copyright violators.
5. I also caught early on (in the 0.34 version) that google was already crawling computers, and all their shared hashes'. I had a few files I created that were very unique, and a curious search showed them to me, along with my machine's key.
For completely legal bulk data, IPFS is a terrific solution. But for anything that is illegal or might be illegal in the future, well, I have to question that usage for those aforementioned reasons.
> 2. It announces every network adapter you have to the dHT, including localhost, docker virtual network adapters, everything.
This is totally insane, is there any client that don't enable those misfeatures? (like, generate a new key identity on startup, and don't publish any network adapter)
#2 does seem silly.
On a semi-related note, it's not that hard to set up a private IPFS. You just need a publicly-reachable "lighthouse" node (and it's extremely low-resource, the cheapest hosted VM you can find can likely handle the task without trouble) and some light config edits. IPFS isn't (and isn't trying to be) anonymous, but you can avoid sharing with the entire IPFS network and share only with trusted peers instead. The ordinary IPFS network won't even know you're there, because you won't be connecting to it.
The justification for a computer key (which is a base56 sha) was to make every machine a unique node on the network. Note that IPFS also purports to be a multi-network system that can be on top of ip4/6/tor/etc, so they wanted a backwards compat ID.
Now if my computer asks the dHT for hash X, I get a response back from all the computers with that hash. And it's similar to BitTorrent in that fashion. And the content hash is like Git.
There's also IPNS, which makes a connection from DNS to IPFS. You need unique machine identifiers for this.
With the sharing of every network interface, prior to 0.3 the idea was that ALL content loaded with IPFS could be shared. And 'nearness' ala STP could be used to provide local data to local machines. However, due to garbage copyright law, was not turned on by default.
The root problem is that basic security was never considered, as in the 'bad things someone can do with these identifiers'. Ideas like "one person loads a viral video and every device on the local network gets it from them" are amazing ideas, but preclude the bad side like 'who to DoS and doxx' and all these bad side of internet issues.
It sucks, cause I really think IPFS should have absolutely taken off. I could see this as solar system worthy networking for satellite to satellite. But there's inherent problems that I think would be better in the crucible of the IETF and not a commercial entity.
Just three questions I have:
-is performance an issue?
-can the source code and architecture be easily be modified so it becomes more safe where anonimity is concerned?
-if I run IPFS from a virtual machine and route the connections through socks proxy chains / ssh tunnels / VPNs / TOR it would still be able to spill info about me?
There's also significant bandwidth costs from a distributed hash table. That's a design implementation that really can't be avoided as the nature of dHT's. Running this on phones will blow through your monthly quota pretty quickly just on announce traffic.
I'm not well versed in GO, so I can't! However there's a LOT of customizations and settings you can turn off/on. For example, you can create a private IPFS network of just your machines. Or you can create piracy networks of friends. That sort of thing.
Just my complaints about the defaults are what I would classify as unsafe.
As for running through Tor or I2p, well yeah. I worked with another user who ended up figuring out a way to do it through Tor that only shared an internal 192.168.0.0/24 address. Basically they firewalled all internet comms other than Tor and forced through it. Also had to do MAC randomization because IPFS also shares that.
The IPFS folks initially said they were going to first-class Tor support. But when it got hard, they backed out. My guess was that would have turned IPFS into the biggest unstoppable piracy net. And Benet and gang were busy with filecoin. Tor doesn't make money, and has the smell of unsavoriness.
My recommendation is to get 2 machines, and bring them both up with a trivial 'hello.txt' file and prove all the details you can about the other. I don't think the protocol changed much... But I could be wrong.
I left using it because of massive resource usage, high network bandwidth, and user-hostile hosting environment due to insecure and everything-shared environment.
I don't understand, what is not turned on by default? Do you know which setting can be used to turn it on?
On IPFS, the provenance of a file is its content hash, not some server you downloaded it from.
On IPFS, if I join in on hosting and sharing a hash of a file, I could be a malware spewer, but that doesn't change the hash.
Where this conflicts with copyright is, say you are on a IPFS enabled Movie server from CBS. By definition, only they are approved to transmit their files. But IPFS uses Git and BitTorrent to swarm download content. And default copyright, that's a civil tort matter.
The original idea for IPFS was that for the local network, that it did support BitTorrent like operations from browser cache. So if something went viral, it was 1 download from the internet connection, and then on-lical-network the rest of the way.
That feature was disabled EARLY on because it strictly violates copyright.
It's also why your computer published all the network interfaces to the dHT, so that you could find local nodes. But they didn't remove that; they only removed the dynamic sharing part.
I think there are settings to turn that back on, but I'm not 100% sure.
Some data hoarder must have saved all this stuff, right? So why isn't it in a torrent?
I think archive.org might be that data hoarder :). They might release stuff slowly as the copyright expires.
It also looks like https://redacted.ch/ might be the spiritual successor - https://interviewfor.red/en/prepare.html this process sounds very familiar ;)
If you have a copy of HarryPotter and want to make sure it stays as is, then you have to back it up.
Luckily the number of people obsessed with emulating old systems saves the day for now. But at some point things like Video CDs and the Compact Disc-Interactive systems may fully fade into history.
There just isn't that much demand for large-scale storage, since everyone just keeps their data "in the cloud" or has subscriptions to online services now. 20 years ago, HD sizes were doubling every year.
This reminds me of the apple 'service' that automatically replaced your MP3s with its own 'sanctioned' digital files. It turned several of my tracks into unlistenable, censored versions and I've been incredibly wary of digital-only content ever since.
https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/news/bil...
Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia.
This:
> "See, there are only two possibilities: XX, a girl, or XY, a boy. The chance of becoming either a boy or a girl is always 1 in 2, a 50-50 chance either way. It’s like flipping a coin: X you’re a girl, Y you’re a boy.”
is out by a few percent .. numbers wise it's more inaccurate than claiming there's no gold in the earths crust. ( see [1] )
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex
I imagine Nye himself authorised the change to his own work as I assume he later corrected himself (as appears to be implied in your link).
Why does it have a "Sex specificity" column? Why does it contain the words male and female?
The reason for that is the actual verifiable existance of people who were born here clearly, scientifically, medically as neither M NOR F.
They are valid exceptions to the above quote from the Nye program and there are enough people born this way to number in the thousands in a country of some ~ 23 milllion or so.
The passport system was changed as a citizen of this country fronted and objected to having enter M or F when they were born clearly neither.
As someone with a science background who measures and models reality I approve of systems that track the world and its elements as it is and as they are .. rather than models that force a world view that doesn't match reality.
As Richard Dawkins recently clarified, "As a biologist, there are 2 sexes. And that's all there is to it." It's binary and there is no exception. People that claim otherwise are confused.
If one wants to make a simple statement that encompasses the largest group of people they might say, "There are 2 sexes." If they want to make a more complex statement that encompasses all humans they might add a qualifier such that they instead say, "There are 2 typical sexes." That "typical" adds a whole lot of complexity in order to generalize the statement.
Comparing to different sex determination systems in other species can help with conceptualizing this distinction, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temperature-dependent_sex_dete... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZW_sex-determination_system.
This is an opinion. Clearly there are at least some in Australia who have the opinion that they are indeed additional sexes or their passports wouldn't have more than 2 options. That's not "anti-science"; it is an opinionated interpretation of science.
Certainly the statement, "There are 2 sexes," simplifies the biological understanding we have of sex. To then add, "And that's all there is to it," makes the statement plainly wrong.
How some jurisdictions choose to legally define sex is a separate issue. For instance, in some countries, the law is such that people who desire to be the opposite sex can have the sex in their passport changed to reflect this desire. So a male, with penis and testicles, who wants to be female, can legally obtain a passport with an 'F' marker in the sex field. This does not mean he is actually female - from a material biological perspective he is and will always be male.
It's taken as binary because the biological difference doesn't result in a meaningful physiological difference. That doesn't mean it's "anti-science" to have an alternative take. Consider that "The biological understanding of sex" as used in your comment should logically be understood as "A common interpretation of the biological understanding of sex". It might suddenly become clear that "it is a binary of male and female" as used in your comment is actually an opinion.
Anyway, I'm not deluding myself that this particular legal definition in Australia was not made in response to recent gender politics. It's more likely there for trans people than for a person who is biologically XXY and physiologically male. However, to say that it's "anti-science" to claim there are more than 2 sexes is mistaken. It is, as I said, an opinionated interpretation of a certain understanding of biology. You disagree with this opinion and you are mistaken when you say it is factually incorrect.
This form of reproduction is a biological phenomenon that shared by almost all complex life, and this understanding is uncontroversial amongst biologists. Stating that's it's an opinion is like saying that evolution is an opinion, or that the earth being a spherical mass orbiting around the sun is an opinion.
The semantic sparring over sex and gender has a pretty simple compromise, that people who want to say it is a spectrum and people who want to say it is binary should be able to agree on and be happy with:
it is a bimodal distribution
of course the problem is that is a nuanced idea and humans can't handle nuance. Maybe you can, and I can, but WE as a human group can't. We prefer to drive ourselves literally insane over the semantic argument. oh well.
this isn't something that most people are familiar with, especially people who tend to see things in binaries (not because they're stupid, but because they're trained to see the world in binaries, because it's the simplest classification system which makes it easy to manipulate by politicians and media).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex
I thought you were going to mention how there are more male embryos than female embryos created since males have a higher death rate. Why is sex the only category in which we have to constantly qualify ourselves with regard to birth defects? Someone who's talking about how the three types of cones work to create color vision doesn't have to constantly harken back to how some people are color-blind, despite that population being an order of magnitude larger than intersex individuals. Not mentioning people with phocomelia does not mean your lesson on the anatomy of the arms and legs is wrong or inadequate.
Exempting them from bans on genital surgery for infants/children certainly is a political choice.
That's very interesting, I didn't know that. Personally I believe in a blanket ban of all unnecessary surgical procedures/body mods on newborns and infants, including "genital correction", circumcision, and piercing.
Exempting them from bans on genital surgery for infants/children certainly is a political choice.
> have nothing to do with the biology of sex
is not true. The motivation for dehumanizing trans people is largely based on the (completely erroneous) twin ideas that "gender is sex" and "there are two sexes". Both of those things being false really takes the wind out of the argument.
In all seriousness, changing language to fit some weird political philosophy and then berating others for not going along is as dangerous as it is outrageous.
Constructs in your head are not real. When you die, they are gone forever. Yet, when they dig up your body 1,000 years from now as some sort of archeological dig, they will study your skeleton and determine your biological sex with certainty.
You (or anyone) is free to think whatever you want about yourself or others - but you are not free to force others to think like you, particularly when your thoughts are irrational and not grounded in reality or scientific fact.
And people make fun of the flat-earthers for denying reality and objective facts...
I am going to agree (?) that gender is a construct. I assert that it is a social construct. It does not exist inside our cells, only in our minds (individually and collectively).
I am going to disagree that sex is determined by our skeletons. I assert that skeletal structure and other phenotypical features are symptoms of sex, which is determined by genes. This is a scientific consensus as far as I can tell.
I believe I am disagreeing with you when I say that there are more than two possible outcomes of genetic sex determination. This is obvious, because there are multiple sex-determination systems in animals, not just XY. There is X0, there is ZW, and there are others.
Even within XY, there are variations. An individual can be born with XXY chromosomes. Or they can be born male with XX chromosomes, or female with XY chromosomes.
Or, a human can be born female with XX chromosomes, no outward differences from typical female phenotype, and feel they are a man. This is because, as stated above, gender is a social construct. Not actually sure if we agree or disagree on that.
There is no berating happening here or anything else that should make a person feel victimized. Just science. A little more advanced than grade school science, but still science.
"He who controls the language controls the masses." - Saul Alinsky
> Even within XY, there are variations. An individual can be born with XXY chromosomes. Or they can be born male with XX chromosomes, or female with XY chromosomes
We are not discussing extremely rare genetic defects. We're discussing people who slander biological genders by dressing as offensive caricatures and then demand everyone else participate in their mental illness.
Which is why there is no substantive conversation around this subject. As soon as we don't agree, it's suddenly hate speech.
I don't call it hate speech because you aren't on my side. I call it hate speech because it treats transgender people as uniformly ill and invalidates their identity. (You'll find that if we stop doing that, their mental health tends to be pretty good.) And because the rigidness of the gender binary in modern western society is not universal across time and space within human cultures and it exists in opposition to scientific understanding.
You are saying right now that you want a genuine engagement. I'm a sucker for debate obviously. This is your chance to genuinely engage, lay out your scientific reasoning why a biologically female person with XX chromosomes should be forced by their peers into accepting the gender roles that other people say they must have regardless of what makes them feel good or happy.
The honest solution to this, that is grounded in material reality, is for her to reject these gender roles, and be a woman who accepts herself as she is, regardless of any such attempted impositions.
If she pretends to be a man instead, she isn't challenging gender roles, but is implicitly agreeing with the harmful idea that women must adhere to some roles, men must adhere to other roles, and anyone who doesn't do this is defective and must change themselves to fit this mould.
Even worse is how such non-conformance to gender roles has been medicalized, so she may end up taking opposite-sex hormones, having her breasts removed and other cosmetic surgeries to appear as some odd facsimile of a man. Rather than accepting herself for who she is.
I appreciate your rational input. And to be honest, I don't completely disagree with this part. Trans people are not unaware of it either. However, [I must explain that] I was using "gender roles" in a very broad way, including pronouns like "she". This person doesn't need anyone to use specific words to describe their sexual phenotype if they don't want it. We don't have different a different form of "he" for children vs adults, nor for black people vs white people. It is a societal construct and they're allowed to opt out.
> Even worse is how such non-conformance to gender roles has been medicalized, so she may end up taking opposite-sex hormones, having her breasts removed and other cosmetic surgeries to appear as some odd facsimile of a man. Rather than rejecting this malignant, cultish ideology that advocates physical destruction of the self in lieu of bodily acceptance.
This is an extremely disgusting and transphobic thing to say though. I hope you didn't realize how hateful it sounded. Gender-affirming care is widely supported in the medical community as a life-saving intervention. As for whether or not you think it's appropriate for another person to have their body surgically altered, what do you think about tattoos? About facial reconstruction for burn victims? About a mastectomy for cancer? And why do you even care what other people do with their bodies?
Most people undergo some period of time where they are unsure of their self, their future, their purpose, and perhaps even question their existence and the meaning of it all.
Now we teach people being uncomfortable and uncertain is unacceptable and that it obviously means you are the problem and must change. In doing so, we doom these people to a lifetime of hardship and uncertainty.
Imagine a world where having blue eyes was viewed as bad and had to be surgically and permanently altered to look more brown. Would these people feel any more confident after the operation? Why do celebrities continuously get plastic surgery over and over? They are never comfortable with themselves, and the further they go down the path of altering who they are, the more uncomfortable they become - ignoring whatever actual problems they may be experiencing in favor of cosmetic and superficial changes.
For instance, here's a NIH article studying extremely high suicide rates among transgendered people[1]. It cites many, many possible reasons for this, but the facts remain. Your assertion appears to have no supporting evidence.
The article even acknowledges the paucity of data: "However, the exact prevalence of completed suicide among transgender persons remain undocumented".
Let's allow them to "doom" themselves to increased happiness and just stop filling their lives with hardship.
> Imagine a world where having blue eyes was viewed as bad and had to be surgically and permanently altered to look more brown. Would these people feel any more confident after the operation?
Probably.
> Why do celebrities continuously get plastic surgery over and over? They are never comfortable with themselves, and the further they go down the path of altering who they are, the more uncomfortable they become
Is this what all your celebrity friends say? My celebrity friend circle mostly disagrees. Let's take a poll of all the celebrities we personally know and try to get some more data on what's going on inside the minds of "celebrities". Even though we already both know so much about the internal experiences of all celebrities.
No one cares what anyone else thinks. The only thing that matters is behavior. If your behavior is harmful to others, then we certainly are free to try and change that behavior.
If gender is not real, then why do you care what gender people are assigned.
> Yet, when they dig up your body 1,000 years from now as some sort of archeological dig, they will study your skeleton and determine your biological sex with certainty.
I mean, its thousands of years in the future, so maybe, but if we do it today, that’s not how it works; there’s a scale for skeletons of “Female, Probable Female, Intermediate, Probable Male, Male” and even the extremes are subject to caveats. But who cares? Why would what archeologists will think about your sex from your bones in some distant future constrain your gender expression in life?
The notion you can be whatever you want - that is not real, that exists solely in your head.
As an adult, you are free to do whatever you want - so long as it does not impact me and my life. Which is the problem isn't it... people forcefully impacting my life to please themselves.
Forcing me to guess whatever pronouns you happen to what to use today is not a game I am going to play. If I demanded you refer to me as "King Alupis" in every one of your responses, you would probably not play that game either, despite the obvious happiness it would bring me.
"if someone says 2+2=5, the correct response is, ‘What are your definitions and axioms?’ not a rant about the decline of Western civilization".
From Wikipedia because math is hard, let's go right wing.
Use a wiki or something. Because when even I know that 2 + 2 = 5 can be true in some cases then you might want to reconsider your arguments.
BTW.
A + B != B + A also can be true.
> Constructs in your head are not real. When you die, they are gone forever.
Almost all of you is a construct, there are few things directly wired into the brain(but they aren't irrelevant) but most of it is learned. And when you die everything you had in your brain is gone forever. And then by your definition things that make us us are fiction. And they are as fictional as gender(btw. gender is not sex, and sex is more complex).
Who is trying to do that? Gender-affirming genital surgery is not commonly, if ever, practiced on minors and no one is advocating for that except maybe a few people on the lunatic fringe.
The whole idea that doctors are going around performing genital surgery on trans-kids is a baseless political attack by people trying to ban reversible gender-affirming treatment like social transitioning and puberty blockers under the guise of banning more extreme treatments that aren't actually performed on minors.
There's increasing scepticism as to whether social transitioning is reversible in practice (see the interim report of the Cass Review for more detail on this), and the long-term adverse effects of puberty blockers are currently unclear.
This is part of the reason why the health authorities in many countries are starting to halt or restrict the gender-affirming approach, as it may be causing more harm than good to gender non-conforming children.
Even the simple dumbing down of gay rights to talk in schools about people who love others of the same gender, just let them love whoever they want! You have been free to love whoever you want for centuries. Im a male that loves my father, and would help a few of my friends fight to the death if they were being attacked. I love them. That has nothing to do with being gay. Why do we even need to have a flag raised at school that talks mainly about the right to stick sexual organs into other people? Because that's the only distinction I see between me loving my male friends and me being gay.
Um, no. It was a criminal act to be gay in the US earlier this century.
> Im a male that loves my father
Oh, I see. You're either practicing illegal love, or you're being purposely obtuse by conflating two different meanings of love.
> Because that's the only distinction I see between me loving my male friends and me being gay.
You hold hands with them? In public? You kiss and cuddle with them? In front of children? Because gay people have been murdered for that in living memory. I guess they just should have avoided touching sexual organs (in private) and everything would have been fine.
This isn't scientifically accurate either. Some people have 4 types of cones.
https://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/from-sex-to-gender-mode...
These identity folks have no ability to laugh at themselves.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Hz3zZlsS7c
We can joke. The thing is, we have more than two, and they're actually funny.
${X} joke about ${Y} -- if ${X} is only funny so long as ${Y} doesn't violate cultural taboos to make fun of, then we have an issue with the permanence of the joke. If a bad joke about ${Y} can be fixed by changing ${Y} to Republican (or whatever else is culturally acceptable to make fun of in time ${Z}, then the problem is not ${X} joke, it's our sensitivity to ${Y}.
What the hell Netflix??
It's insane how freaked people STILL get over black bars! Look, we get it, some aspect ratios don't work when on other aspect ratios! Just leave the content alone!
Mark Twain was making a point about judging people by labels or how they look on the surface, instead of judging them by their character and actions. Of course now we're back to square one to judging people by labels and how they look on the surface, but this time it'll be different.
We as a species seem doomed to repeat history on loop, like some sort of real life Ground Hog Day.
[0]: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/32325/32325-h/32325-h.htm
Yet, we keep trying to build rules, societal norms, APIs (and now AIs) to try and achieve this at scale. And it always fails.
But the rest I agree with.
And to your point, I just found a trove of rare 'banned' cartoons. Naturally, they're banned primarily for depictions of Japanese (WWII), and of black people in various degrading roles.
I do not take enjoyment in watching them. However, due to censorship, these could be lost. And that would be a bigger loss compared to their inherent lack of compassion.
- PlexAmp is a much, much better tool for consuming music than the Jellyfin UI
- Prologue[0] is an app that hooks into your local Plex library to play audiobooks; Jellyfin has no equivalent that I'm aware of
- There's a general dearth of iOS and Android apps that support downloads/offline play that sync play progress back to the server
Why do you feel this is worth preserving? It's designed to evoke positive emotion (laughter) and outrage/hatred about something we don't condone anymore. In addition to being propaganda, outside the context of warmongering, it's toxic.
We don't insist on archiving artifacts from smear campaigns between white politicians every election season. But we need to forever archive demeaning racist cartoons?
You'd have more of a case defending "Song of the South," which at least has artistic merit. We lose a musical experience with that one.
It's the "vampire" problem...immortality is not a good thing. Outdated/bad ideas are supposed to fade with the flow of time, not spread forever for later "research."
I think it's worse in institutionally 'forgetting' via censorship, than to having that media.
I also think it would be improper to sell that content, as it'd be profiting on racism and sexism.
To the point, this set of files also included Fantasia, Songs of the South, WWII propaganda by Disney and Looney Tunes, and more.
Just because parts of history are horrific, does not mean we should self-censor and remove the uncomfortable parts from our collective memories. Frankly, these videos belong in a museum, or archive.org .
It turns out that much of the music featured in the original airing of the show wasn’t licensed in a way it could be used long term, and over the years it has been replaced with terrible stock songs or jarringly anachronistic choices that sound totally out of place.
Entire scenes and episodes have been cut from the seasons distributed on streaming platforms, because they featured live concerts that couldn’t be edited. The original had performances by the Flaming Lips, among many others, that simply can’t be watched now, except if by chance someone copied an old VHS to YouTube.
Music was a big part of the original show–in addition to the live shows it featured all sorts of great pop songs from the time, which was part of why it was such a hit with teenagers when it aired. It’s such a bummer they stripped it all out!
There are some places online with copies of early DVD releases that have more music, but still not all of it. The original is locked away in a vault somewhere and almost certainly won’t ever be enjoyed in a complete state.
The most egregious example is from the classic "Turkeys Away" episode, there was a whole joke about Pink Floyd's "Dogs" which Johnny Fever was playing at the time. In the edited version Mr. Carlson just walks out mid-conversation.
Is there a list of the differences somewhere? I remember that show having a very good soundtrack.
Or, often, because the original production bought licenses imagining more limited uses than later distribution opportunities presented, and chose not to spend extra money for things they didn’t expect to need.
And everyone knows that answer will be: "nothing stops potential distributors from licensing music now and releasing originals, the fact they are not willing to pay is not copyright holders problem". And there's some truth to it, licensing costs back then were lower because they were time constrained. No one would pay more for broadly licensed music in throwaway series. No one knew they would have lasting impact on popculture.
From what I understand, TV broadcasts (at least in the US/UK) have a general/blanket exemption for copyrights w.r.t to things like music (RIAA). So no restriction when airing episodes, you can pick what music you like.
When looking to distribute DVDs however you have to get permission to use the music/pay for it. So it often gets changed.
I hate how the IP owners just can't resist messing up the culture.
The decision to mutilate Friends was made by a software engineer (working for the License) who couldn't be bothered to add black bars or convert ratios because "reasons."
For the streaming platforms, they chose to crop it the other way:
https://i.imgur.io/sbdIoxd_d.webp?maxwidth=640&shape=thumb&f...
IMO they should just split the difference and stream the full original 1.33:1 with (smaller) black bars.
In the 90s, film directors would often consider both the cinema and TV ratios, but TV directors? I kind of doubt it; changing the framing might be interesting, but it's not a good way to show it, IHMO. Debates over overscan are fine, but if it wasn't part of the original broadcast, and wasn't part of the directors' intent to be shown, it shouldn't be part of any distribution.
It was filmed at 1.37:1. 1.33:1 would be almost indistinguishable from 4:3 (its 3.99:3)
>Poker Night at the Inventory was delisted from Steam on May 23rd, 2019. Although Telltale did not offer the same kind of explanation that they did regarding Poker Night 2, the game was likely delisted due to expired licensing of one or more of the properties featured in the game.
Songs were ganked from GTA3: San Andreas, as well as GTA4 and its expansions.
I think in the latter case there might have been a couple replacements, but still.
For these the loss of the original music was such an issue they eventually did (or attempted) to re-release with everything as it was. But don't trust things to always be like that. It holds for almost everything: if you want to keep something as-is the best thing is to store your own copy, second best is to rely on an archivist to store a copy but even that's risky.
Once TV shows started to release on DVD in a big way, and then digitally a few years later, it became immediately obvious that shows would need longer music licenses, and so the issue has been solved for newer works.
I would love to see an elaboration. I think you're saying this because it's in their interest for wide appeal and so will adjust their "products" as necessary to please.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J2H_7LY5LqM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YOAz4nPNvLI
Funnily they had musical guests so that they could sell the show as a variety show, and get the funding to do something so silly.
It's a good sign that he has publicly acknowledged that the edits were a mistake and the original theatrical version of E.T. is available.
Fortunately, with the rise of Z-Library, I was able to recover her books (she already paid for them, so I'm ok with downloading it from such a shady source).
I guess we have to fall back to piracy if we want to stay in control.
So I guess HN, or most Americans ( East or West End ) can now finally agree this is a serious problem?
I still remember in 2019 and even in 2021, HN's majority position was that people were too focused on culture war and this is only the minority of people who cares about it.
The thing with movies though is you can have multiple versions just fine. So while I have no interest in ‘updated’ versions it’s not necessarily as visceral an issue. The problem is more with the social pressure and lack of availability of original cuts.
This also reminds of something the comedian Ricky Gervais often says (I'm paraphrasing): You can joke about everything. The problem is people mistaking the target of the joke with the subject.
yeah that's bullshit. as someone on the receiving end of these types of totally-not-a-joke-jokes, it's completely transparent and only a fool would believe in this miniscule level of plausible deniability. it's actually pretty insulting that anyone is expected to believe this. just call it what it is - a social loophole to be as racist as you want to be.
which is fine, because people tell these jokes in private non-stop. i think this kind of comedy should be preserved and nothing should be censored, because in 10 or 20 years or whatever they're going to be seen as blatantly racist.
people know when they're being laughed at, no matter how much 'comedy' you dress it up with.
Statements like this make me afraid of the future of culture.
I am a member of a minority, and I do enjoy jokes about my minority if they're well done and/or hit a nail on the head. Your statement effectively says you dont believe I am a member of "everyone", which is quite condescending.
The complete sociological ban on the utterance of any words that even sound like "the actual N word" is so bizarre to me. As a kid in the early 80s it was very clear and unambiguous to me that actually calling someone the N-word was extremely taboo and racist. But it wasn't like using the phrase in a sentence such as "Calling someone the <N word> is extremely taboo and racist" was considered offensive. When I first heard about a story where a college professor was suspended for giving a lesson in Chinese where the Chinese word just happened to sound like the N word [1], I was convinced it was either an Onion article, or an example of the right trying to make a caricature of anything that smelled of "wokeness". But alas, it was actually real, and just as absurd as I originally thought.
1. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/09/fight-agai...
The joke: Turk and JD go to a college party dressed as each other, in whiteface and blackface respectively. Turk gets distracted and leaves just as JD opens the door to an all-black frat. The frat beats the shit out of JD for his blackface.
It wasn't the blackface that made the joke racist, in my opinion. It was the tired stereotype of violent black men without deeper emotions. It was the assumption that racism is transactional in this way; you do a racism and you get your ass beat if you get caught.
Would keeping slaves as a reminder of the evils of slavery make sense?
Also, for the most part none of this is being done due to law, but rather because the owner of the content wants to sell more of it and thinks this is the way to do it. Looked at like that, it's hard to see how you can stop it occurring.
The main reason I don’t think it’s profit motivated is that you see the exact same sort of culturally imperialist neo-Victorianism in entities without a profit motive like the ACLU or state govt.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cover-up-at-justice-department/
Thankfully his successor fixed this. This latest fad is just the next generation of the same puritanism.
> Photographers have gone to great lengths in the past to capture the scantily-clad female statue in the background as the Justice Department's top brass addressed the world's press.
…
> Hired drapes have previously hung in front of both statues for formal events, such as President George W Bush's visit to name the building after assassinated former attorney-general, Robert Kennedy.
…
> The drapes are reported to have been hanging since Monday, drawing to a close the sport of photographers who infamously sprawled on the floor to snap the former Attorney General Edwin Meese holding aloft his report on pornography in front of the female statue.
The awkward composition of the lead photo in the linked article is a decent example in itself.
Disney, for example, decided to forbid the reprint of Eisner Award winning
"Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck"'s last chapter...
because it "do not align with their values"
(source: https://www.cbr.com/disney-bans-don-rosa-uncle-scrooge-mcduc... )
how stupid is that?!
1. Clothes badly painted onto nudes could be seen as itself an interesting/funny cultural artifact, and since it's at a library, you could have signs explaining the history.
2. I have no problem with Confederate statues being torn down or destroyed, since any perceived cultural/historical value is outweighed by other considerations. They are giant public symbols; little signs explaining "these statues were actually erected during Jim Crow and these guys were bad" are too...abstract.
3. Silently revising works of fiction seems especially wrong because we don't even know where the titties are getting painted over. The Roald Dahl edits weren't just removing "ugly" and "fat", they were also removing all reference to Conrad and at one point removing a reference to the color black applied to an inanimate object, a tractor I think.
That about it?
Or would you argue that their beliefs are wrong, and yours are right, so it's ok then?
Pretty sure they'd make a similar argument.
Or we could, you know, not destroy things.
[1] https://www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/history-and-civilisatio...
So like a Nazi furry Funko pop, we can't get rid of that.
Cool strawman! Here, I can do it too:
Why do you feel the need to be the ministry of truth and right-think, destroying and silencing anything that violates your "modern" sensibilities, regardless of it's historical significance?
In other words, they are not art, they are spam. They have more in common with hustlebros spamming T-shirt and poster sites with AI-generated images than they do with art.
I see, you get to decide what's art then?
How could that possibly go awry...
These Roman artifacts were mass produced by a slave owning nation too [1], probably ought to be destroyed along with the statues too, I guess.
[1] https://ancientimes.blogspot.com/2009/05/ct-scans-reveal-rom...
The obvious middle ground is to move the art somewhere else.
The problem with replacing words with nicer sounding ones is eventually the replacement words start to sound equally negative. This is of course because fatness / ugliness are real things and cannot be eliminated by creating new words.
bowd·ler·ize
tr.v. bowd·ler·ized, bowd·ler·iz·ing, bowd·ler·iz·es
To remove material that is considered offensive or objectionable from (a book, for example); expurgate. [After Thomas Bowdler (1754-1825), who published an expurgated edition of Shakespeare in 1818.]
The idea I'm arguing for isn't to endorse irreversible erasure of the past, but addition of versions that are updated / edited.
And once we start with these edits, say for blatant racism, do we also have to appease groups who are deeply offended by sexism/misogyny, profanity, blasphemy, nudity, drugs, gambling, alcohol, meat-eating, fossil fuels, and probably more?
Better off to leave the work intact, and when necessary just add a content warning up front, to remind people that a creative work was the product of a specific time period and in no way an endorsement of language/behavior that is seen as completely unacceptable today.
People complained about the very mild language policing of 'political correctness' way back in the 90s, and look where we are now, rewriting Roald Dahl to purge words like 'fat', and discussing whether we should actively edit the unpleasantness out of more of our cultural history, wondering whether a favourite book will even still tell the same story if I re-read it on Kindle in a few years time.
Having a state-ish approved nomenclature that is way off their everyday one has to be phsycois inducing.
As you've rightly observed, censoring the paintings was destructive.
Now, this is apart from the moral argument about whether we want to allow rightsholders to offer "modernized" versions of classic works. But it's still notable that the classic work does not cease to exist in this case, which makes it fundamentally different from the one you describe.
Not unless it's out of copyright.
Ideally the rightsholders would still offer the original editions for sale for those interested, but regardless:
The original work is just as available as it would be if it had gone out of print, which is a thing that happens to many genre classics.
Er, what about our cultural heritage? Historical accuracy? Creative intent? The possibility for abuse?
Was 1984 just about a guy with a nice job "keeping things in print?" I mean, sure the guy made a lot of edits, with the express intent of manipulating people - but the originals were all around somewhere, so it's fine?
"you think this guy/God was so great you made a stature of him? Here's what I think <chop>"
Deliberate breakage of the nose seems to be an Egyptian thing.
Then in the later 1800s the townsfolk decided the paintings and statues were scandalous because they had nudes, so they painted over the breasts and genitals, and covered over the statues with togas / cloths.
Luckily in modern times it was easy to remove the cloths, but unfortunately the paintings are ruined. The cover-job was done poorly and the paintings have an off-color paint on it that looks wrong. There have been talks to fix it but I don’t think anything has been done.
My point is that, the desire to censor prior art that disagrees with fad-interpretations of what is taboo and scandalous, will certainly be looked at in a few decades as a very weird and Victorian era. Definitely should not re-cut movies to be “safe” or whatever.