yeah that's bullshit. as someone on the receiving end of these types of totally-not-a-joke-jokes, it's completely transparent and only a fool would believe in this miniscule level of plausible deniability. it's actually pretty insulting that anyone is expected to believe this. just call it what it is - a social loophole to be as racist as you want to be.
which is fine, because people tell these jokes in private non-stop. i think this kind of comedy should be preserved and nothing should be censored, because in 10 or 20 years or whatever they're going to be seen as blatantly racist.
people know when they're being laughed at, no matter how much 'comedy' you dress it up with.
Statements like this make me afraid of the future of culture.
I am a member of a minority, and I do enjoy jokes about my minority if they're well done and/or hit a nail on the head. Your statement effectively says you dont believe I am a member of "everyone", which is quite condescending.
The complete sociological ban on the utterance of any words that even sound like "the actual N word" is so bizarre to me. As a kid in the early 80s it was very clear and unambiguous to me that actually calling someone the N-word was extremely taboo and racist. But it wasn't like using the phrase in a sentence such as "Calling someone the <N word> is extremely taboo and racist" was considered offensive. When I first heard about a story where a college professor was suspended for giving a lesson in Chinese where the Chinese word just happened to sound like the N word [1], I was convinced it was either an Onion article, or an example of the right trying to make a caricature of anything that smelled of "wokeness". But alas, it was actually real, and just as absurd as I originally thought.
1. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/09/fight-agai...
The joke: Turk and JD go to a college party dressed as each other, in whiteface and blackface respectively. Turk gets distracted and leaves just as JD opens the door to an all-black frat. The frat beats the shit out of JD for his blackface.
It wasn't the blackface that made the joke racist, in my opinion. It was the tired stereotype of violent black men without deeper emotions. It was the assumption that racism is transactional in this way; you do a racism and you get your ass beat if you get caught.
This also reminds of something the comedian Ricky Gervais often says (I'm paraphrasing): You can joke about everything. The problem is people mistaking the target of the joke with the subject.