Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by zx8080 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:15AM
(#35725338)
What did Lucas do?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by Pinegulf on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:19AM
(#35725386)
Did Han shoot first? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Han_shot_first
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by yreg on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:18AM
(#35725375)
He remastered Star Wars several times and some people are apparently convinced that he 'destroyed' the work by doing that.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changes_in_Star_Wars_re-releas...
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by Findecanor on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:17AM
(#35725869)
George Lucas has claimed that he cut and spliced the original negative when editing the Special Edition of the original trilogy, so that the master copies of the original films don't physically exist.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by danparsonson on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:27AM
(#35725946)
He didn't just remaster, he repeatedly altered the films, even changing the sense of some scenes, perhaps most notably and notoriously the stand-off between Han and Greedo. Most of his revisions have been questionable at best, ham-fisted and cringeworthy at worst.
Count me among the purists who think he ruined his good work ;-)
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by caseysoftware on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:43PM
(#35730801)
While Han vs Greedo is the most egregious, the style is the most jarring.
You can tell all the inserted scenes because the colors are off, the animations are not blended well, and it feels off uncanny valley style.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by philwelch on Friday April 28, 2023 @07:57AM
(#35740199)
I think the Jabba scene is arguably worse because it simply repeats the same lines we already had in the Greedo scene for no real gain. It also undermines the dramatic reveal of the much-discussed but never-seen Jabba in ROTJ. Plus the unnecessary fan service of Boba Fett literally turning and staring at the camera at the end.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by red-iron-pine on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:59AM
(#35730040)
I'll make an exception for authors who want to tweak or improve their work.
Sometimes directors have to give into the limitations of their medium -- time, money, meddling producers, etc. If they want to revise it later to meet their original vision, more power to them.
Also entirely possible it was a cash grab; Skywalker Ranch needed a new wing or something.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo...
by OkayPhysicist on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:59PM
(#35732095)
For a positive example, Ridley Scott has a bunch of edits of Blade Runner. The huge improvement over the narration-riddled theatrical release was huge, and the pathological edits around hints towards Decker's replicant-ness are just kind of fun, in that different people are likely to have different views on the subject depending on which cut they watched.