News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ekianjo on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:04AM (#35725245)
> The fact that even guys as influential as Spielberg and Tarantino are worried about having their past work censored is the most convincing reason I've seen to own your own data.

No need to even go to censorship, you have people like George Lucas who go out of their way to destroy their previous productions.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by samhuk on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:22AM (#35725425)
I didn't follow the Lucasfilm acquisition too closely when it was all going down, but something that has confused me is that Lucas seems like a fairly talented guy with a passion for what he does, so how does it make sense that he actively wants to destroy his legacy?

I'm really doubtful that it's as simple as Lucas one day having a left-wing/progressivism epiphany or some other grand artistic change, sell Lucasfilm to Disney, then participate in the destruction of their IP.

Wasn't he promised "treatments" and general involvement in the latest trilogy, then Disney back-stabbed him last-minute? I vaguely remember some drama about that.

Anyway, long story short, I think that there is more to the story, such as him being promised one thing and another thing happening, etc.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by joshjdr on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:41AM (#35725586)
I think they’re referring to the remastering of the original trilogy, long before Disney got involved.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by barrysteve on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:41AM (#35725578)
He knew his style of films were over, so he sold the franchise and let Disney take the burn for it.

It's difficult to see this as a political event, where he was outplayed.

He's worked with and against the big cats in Hollywood his whole career, he specifically made career decisions to 'get away' from Hollywood meddling in his work.

He knew what he was doing and this mythical George Lucas character, who is victim and hero in one man, is getting a bit long in the tooth.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Technotroll on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:59AM (#35725726)
I, for one, would love to see another George Lucas movie.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by drewcoo on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:44AM (#35725607)
When I consider this, I don't think there's any legacy there to ruin. The only thing that made the first movies watchable was gone long before Disney bought it up.

https://collider.com/star-wars-george-lucas-wife-marcia

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bombcar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:22AM (#35728552)
Lucas is a phenomenal story-spinner.

But like many story-spinners, he needs an equally phenomenal editor to sit on him. And it happens time and time again that a story-spinner gets so famous/rich/whatever that they can sit on the editor instead, and then the quality drops.

It's a very rare breed of story-spinner who can sit on themselves, offhand I can think of Tolkien perhaps.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by midoridensha on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:53PM (#35737001)
He can spin stories and build worlds very well indeed, but he can't write dialog or direct actors worth a damn. He needs someone else to handle this stuff. His best work was when he came up with the grand vision for something, but someone else handled dialog, scriptwriting, and directing. Basically, the guy was a technical genius but had no eye for the human element.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by toyg on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:07AM (#35725793)
This has nothing to do with "wokeism" or Disney.

George Lucas just saw making sci-fi movies as an effort to get reality as close as possible as the images he had in his mind. That meant seeing FX as an approximation, a constant compromise to reach the limits of what is possible to film. Lucasfilm were pioneers in digital FX and 3D for that very reason.

However, that also meant that each new work looked different from the previous, as real and digital FX diverged more and more with each passing year. He tried to rectify this by updating old works with new scenes and new effects. Had he stopped there, I reckon most people would have just plauded the novelty and moved on.

Unfortunately, while doing that, he also took the chance to modify what he saw as plot problems in the original movies - particularly the first, which was shot in isolation as a one-off, since there was no indication it would be as successful as it did (most actors thought it would be a one-and-done piece of trash, just to make a quick buck, particularly Sir Alex McGuinness). He made some dubious choices and the fandom never forgave him for that.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by denton-scratch on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:21AM (#35726956)
> particularly Sir Alex McGuinness

s/McGuinness/Guinness/

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jameshart on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:14AM (#35727580)
s/Alex/Alec/
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by adolph on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:28AM (#35728660)

  var objRef=document.querySelector("#\\33 5725793 > td > table > tbody > tr > td.default > div.comment > span > p:nth-child(3)");
 
 objRef.textContent=objRef.textContent.replace('Alex','Alec').replace('McGuinn','Guinn');
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by toyg on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:50PM (#35731956)
Thank you, what a brainfart I had :(
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:12AM (#35725837)
Lucas hasn't shown any real passion or talent since Star Wars IV. Except perhaps for pitching ideas for the Indy films. He thankfully relegated the V and VI to other directors and screenwriters (even for IV, a lot of his contributions were cringe, and rightfully resisted by the rest of the crew). And let's not talk about the prequels (Jar Jar and midichlorians anyone? Not to mention the acting of the protagonist).

My take is that he became complacent with the money after the first Star Wars, and never had much to show for afterwards or cared for movies that much. Contrast with his pal Spielberg who churned out film and film, and mastering his craft.

Ah, wait. He did found a great passion in the early 80s: merchandise.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jameshart on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:14AM (#35727568)
Watching the ILM documentary (Light & Magic) the thing that stood out about Lucas is that he hated having his moviemaking decisions set in stone, and it being expensive and hard to change stuff. He pushed to adopt digital compositing technology, digital audio, then digital cameras, and digital sets, because he was so frustrated by the slowness and friction of optical and location work.

I think what comes across in the prequels as this sort of ‘first take’ feel to the performances is a manifestation of his impatience - he wants to get the footage, edit it, get the effects, and see the thing in his head. And the ‘remastering’ he has done is similarly a bit of psychological desire to always feel like he can fix it later.

Waiting five days for Phil Tippett to stop motion ten seconds of tauntaun walking must have driven him crazy.

Underneath, it’s an engineer’s kind of laziness - the sort that drives innovation. I honestly felt after watching that documentary that I am slightly less annoyed by the clunkiness of Attack of the Clones because I actually now can see underneath it the excitement of Lucas to use all the toys he has spent a fortune investing in ILM to build and just make the damn movie.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:34AM (#35727875)
>He pushed to adopt digital compositing technology, digital audio, then digital cameras, and digital sets, because he was so frustrated by the slowness and friction of optical and location work.

Yes, but he overemphasized those technical aspects (where his care went) over the movie aspects.

It's like the guy who builds an expensive studio, with a huge mixer console, high end microphones, state of the art Pro Tools rig, and then proceeds to record his farts.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jameshart on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:40AM (#35728870)
Right, but Lucas didn’t buy that stuff off the shelf. He poured money into ILM and made them invent all that stuff so he could record his farts.

And we all get to benefit from the innovation he drove.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by hammyhavoc on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:13PM (#35733923)
I'm not a Star Wars fan, but that's pretty unfair to liken someone recording their farts to a whole movie with a huge crew and cast that each added their own speciality skills to the movie.

As much as you and I might knock Star Wars, it's wildly successful and is still seeing plenty of success in other mediums, so obviously it appeals to someone.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lazystar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:21AM (#35727690)
I'll defend Lucas til I die. His expanded universe is why I read so many books as a kid, and the huge number of star wars videogames in the 90s/2000s allowed game designers to tinker with different gameplay ideas with the star wars fans as a safety net. The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:36AM (#35727900)
>The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?

If the best you can say about a director is that "without him we wouldn't have as many franchize videogames" then I can rest my case :)

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lazystar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:02AM (#35728241)
If youre going to twist my words and ignore my point, why are you on hackernews? This isnt reddit, mate.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:28PM (#35736192)
Sorry, you don't get to invoke the "reddit, mate" as if your point was twisted. These are your literal quoted words, in their entirety:

"I'll defend Lucas til I die. His expanded universe is why I read so many books as a kid, and the huge number of star wars videogames in the 90s/2000s allowed game designers to tinker with different gameplay ideas with the star wars fans as a safety net. The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?"

Want me to highlight your argument? Here it is...

"The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?"

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by selimthegrim on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:53AM (#35728126)
And Disney proceeded to nuke said expanded universe canon upon acquiring Lucasfilm
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by hammyhavoc on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:16PM (#35733941)
What's your point? It still exists. It's only "not canon" if you view it through the angle of the sequel trilogy being canon. People are still free to enjoy the EU within the context of what came before the sequel trilogy, and it still tells the same story it did on release.

That's the neat thing about art, I can choose not to think the post-Disney acquisition cash-cow milking is canon, especially when none of the original storytellers are involved, and it is thus not their vision.

Call it what it is: they retconned to milk the cash cow they bought dry.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:11PM (#35730275)
I think the argument is that the universe he created is amazing and rightly beloved, but his movie-making skills were troublesome. I also love the SW universe, but mostly for things that did not come directly from Lucas...
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by vehemenz on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:01AM (#35729176)
Lucas was an EP and writer for all three Indiana Jones films. I think these films hold up better than Star Wars, so I wouldn't say he has any passion or talent since Star Wars. With respect to the three Star Wars films though (and all the garbage that came later), I agree.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Friday April 28, 2023 @08:46AM (#35740632)
They do hold up better, but it's because of Spielberg who did the directing (I can't even imagine the cringe mess Lucas would have made - I'd rather we had a Tom Shelleck Indiana Jones movie, as was considered at one time, than a Lucas-directed one), Phillip Kaufman (who fleshed the story plot) and Lawrence Kasdan (who wrote the screenplay) rather than Lucas.

Lucas contributions were iconic, but not enough to get the movie to the level it is. From some dialogues I've seen between the whole team about the films [1], Lucas was more into throwing high level ideas, not about any core script work. So, the main concept, parts of the character design, and a high level plot summary. The rest had to make a full story, screenplay, and movie out of it.

[1] http://maddogmovies.com/almost/scripts/raidersstoryconferenc...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Tangurena2 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:07AM (#35729284)
My understanding is that most of what made Episode 4 work were the results of his then-wife editing the script. She did not get a credit in the movie.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Friday April 28, 2023 @08:36AM (#35740542)
This explains things!
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by zx8080 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:15AM (#35725338)
What did Lucas do?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Pinegulf on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:19AM (#35725386)
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by yreg on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:18AM (#35725375)
He remastered Star Wars several times and some people are apparently convinced that he 'destroyed' the work by doing that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changes_in_Star_Wars_re-releas...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Findecanor on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:17AM (#35725869)
George Lucas has claimed that he cut and spliced the original negative when editing the Special Edition of the original trilogy, so that the master copies of the original films don't physically exist.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by danparsonson on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:27AM (#35725946)
He didn't just remaster, he repeatedly altered the films, even changing the sense of some scenes, perhaps most notably and notoriously the stand-off between Han and Greedo. Most of his revisions have been questionable at best, ham-fisted and cringeworthy at worst.

Count me among the purists who think he ruined his good work ;-)

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by caseysoftware on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:43PM (#35730801)
While Han vs Greedo is the most egregious, the style is the most jarring.

You can tell all the inserted scenes because the colors are off, the animations are not blended well, and it feels off uncanny valley style.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by philwelch on Friday April 28, 2023 @07:57AM (#35740199)
I think the Jabba scene is arguably worse because it simply repeats the same lines we already had in the Greedo scene for no real gain. It also undermines the dramatic reveal of the much-discussed but never-seen Jabba in ROTJ. Plus the unnecessary fan service of Boba Fett literally turning and staring at the camera at the end.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by red-iron-pine on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:59AM (#35730040)
I'll make an exception for authors who want to tweak or improve their work.

Sometimes directors have to give into the limitations of their medium -- time, money, meddling producers, etc. If they want to revise it later to meet their original vision, more power to them.

Also entirely possible it was a cash grab; Skywalker Ranch needed a new wing or something.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by OkayPhysicist on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:59PM (#35732095)
For a positive example, Ridley Scott has a bunch of edits of Blade Runner. The huge improvement over the narration-riddled theatrical release was huge, and the pathological edits around hints towards Decker's replicant-ness are just kind of fun, in that different people are likely to have different views on the subject depending on which cut they watched.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by HeckFeck on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:48AM (#35725649)
I've deliberately sought the DVD edition of the unaltered original trilogy. The editing that makes Greedo shoot first looks cheap. It also doesn't make sense; someone pointing a gun at you is a clear sign of intent, and Han was simply defending himself. Han's decision to shoot first was also in line with his character as the rogue for hire.

Agh, I know the series is still raking in millions. But I can't enjoy the edits because my brain cries 'blasphmeny!'

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ReptileMan on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:31AM (#35725980)
The whole point is that Han Solo is badass. So he doesn't need high bar to shoot. Luke is the crybaby. The original trilogy Han will totally opportunity shoot Grido in the back if he knew he was sent for him and Grido was walking the street. And the only thing he will feel is recoil. And I know blasters don't have any recoil.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by hirundo on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:42AM (#35728000)
Even flashlights have recoil. Not that Han would feel it.

https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/c206f2/do_laser...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by dspillett on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:45AM (#35726095)
> I've deliberately sought the DVD edition of the unaltered original trilogy

The best you are likely to find is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmy%27s_Despecialized_Editio... – I don't think the unaltered editions were ever released on DVD or BluRay at all, just VHS and LaserDisc.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by gsich on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:11AM (#35726295)
4k77 also exists.

No they were released in the 2006 DVD set, quality is very poor though.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by dspillett on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:05AM (#35728271)
When I tried those I found the brightness and colour balance odd in places. I'm told this is because they are optimised to look as close as possible to how they would in a cinema in 1977 (hence the name) so are optimised for viewing via a projector not an LCD TV.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by benj111 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:38AM (#35727943)
I've got them (well my brother stole them) sold along with the rerelease so 6 discs total.

Digitally remastered but otherwise the cinema release

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jonhohle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:55AM (#35728153)
They are (unfortunately) not remastered. They are 480i letterboxed scans of an earlier LaserDisc release.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ycombobreaker on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:42AM (#35727983)
There's a DVD "limited edition" of the trilogy that is 2 discs each, and the "extras" disc has either the original or laserdisc edit. This is good. The downside is that the black levels and audio are obviously dated/untouched. There's just no market for "remastering" without the content changes.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jonhohle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:52AM (#35728120)
There was a single run that included the THX LaserDisc version of the original Trilogy on DVD. I own it specifically because it included the original release and it’s the version I shown my kids. https://comic-cons.xyz/star-wars-original-trilogy-unaltered-...

At the time the excuse was that there were no longer any masters for the original trilogy to rescan for rerelease, so the LaserDisc version was the best that could be done.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by philistine on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:02AM (#35729186)
No! For purists, those DVD releases don't cut it because they messed with the sound mix and the releases are not in the original frame format.

https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_changes_in_Star_War...

Their video quality is also terrible, even for DVD, being derived from a scan made for a Laserdisc release.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jonhohle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:34AM (#35729674)
When TVs were 4:3 and media playback was sending signals to control a photon gun, letterboxing was how you presented a 2.39:1 panavision feature. You’re screwed on resolution, but the framing is correct. HandBrake and other tools recognize and crop the matte giving you back a video in the correct aspect ratio (albeit still interlaced).

Edit: With the exception of getting LaserDisc releases of various vintages, the DVD release is the best, most accessible (excluding rarity) home video release of the original, unedited trilogy. They are not the highest quality, no doubt, but they are the best that was released. It could be argued that the despecialized editions are better for this reason or that, I personally consider them an incredible novelty, rather than a reference release.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by vehemenz on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:58AM (#35729125)
There are DVD rips of each LaserDisc, not sure if that torrent is still in circulation, but the video quality isn't as good as Harmy's.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by sd9 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:52AM (#35726152)
https://youtu.be/qb6UGbRlsgE "Thanksgiving" - Paul and Storm

It spoils the twist, but:

> And everybody knows that Greedo never even fired

> when Han shoots first it sets up his entire moral journey

> Plus it's cool

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by flippinburgers on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:23AM (#35727708)
Am I the only one who finds the end of Return of the Jedi to be the most horrible edit among all of the edits? I mean... I just want the song from my childhood not the garbage found in the blurays...
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by HeckFeck on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:00AM (#35728217)
That and the insertion of Hayden Christensen. I know they wanted continuity, but it just throws me off every time I see him. It is as if the ghost represents the worst excesses of the prequels seeping through time.

Also don't start me on that 'thing' they have singing in Jabba's palace.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Tangurena2 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:06AM (#35729264)
In the book Tales from The Mos Eisley Cantina, the other two Rodians in the Cantina at the time of that scene were present to execute Greedo (for a clan rivalry). Solo shooting Greedo let them claim the bounty. Every story in that book centers around the scenes from the film that took place inside the cantina.

0 - https://www.amazon.com/Tales-Eisley-Cantina-Star-Wars/dp/055...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by philwelch on Friday April 28, 2023 @07:54AM (#35740165)
Entertainment media seem to have significantly different use-of-force standards than any real life legal or moral statutes. Maybe because the drama of protracted Mexican standoffs would be undercut if people reacted realistically to having guns pointed at them.

The Greedo scene has been tweaked multiple times. In the most recent version available on Disney+ (confirmed to be Lucas’ work), Greedo exclaims “macklunkey!” just before the shooting starts, which I find hilariously absurd.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by sundvor on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:24AM (#35726401)
You could say he drew first.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bookofjoe on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:13AM (#35726872)
>A work of art is never finished, only abandoned.—Paul Valéry
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by zczc on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:35AM (#35727086)
Well, Spielberg himself replaced guns with walkies-talkies in E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E.T._the_Extra-Terrestrial#/me...
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by iconjack on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:47AM (#35727214)
Literally the subhed of the article: "Director has criticised the practice of re-editing older films while expressing remorse over removing guns in a later edition of ET"
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ycombobreaker on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:48AM (#35728068)
That was my first thought upon reading the title. However, people learn, grow, and change. I believe his argument will carry more weight with the acknowledgment and duscussion of his own prior decision. It's not hypocrisy; it's a lesson learned.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bombcar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:20AM (#35728487)
And he's a director! His job is to experiment and use new tools as they come available, and he's realized he made a mistake.

I have no problem with people making new versions of existing works; the problem I have is destroying the originals; even if destroyed by the author. The existence of copyright itself is a "deal" between society and an individual, we give the individual certain rights and privileges in exchange for certain benefits to society.

Only now has the ability to go back and change things resulted in large-scale destruction of personal copies of that original thing.