News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by safety1st on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:52AM (#35725146)
The fact that even guys as influential as Spielberg and Tarantino are worried about having their past work censored is the most convincing reason I've seen to own your own data.

For movies it's as easy as obtaining DRM-free copies of the movies you care about, saving them to an SSD, and installing a copy of Plex.

Do that with the movies, music and books you love. They are a part of our cultural history. It's almost a guarantee that any copy you don't own and control will at some point in the future be revised. I want the real history not what the powers that be tell me it was.

It's virtually guaranteed that Amazon, Netflix et. al. will not store this stuff for you with integrity, it is built into the nature of the system.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ekianjo on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:04AM (#35725245)
> The fact that even guys as influential as Spielberg and Tarantino are worried about having their past work censored is the most convincing reason I've seen to own your own data.

No need to even go to censorship, you have people like George Lucas who go out of their way to destroy their previous productions.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by samhuk on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:22AM (#35725425)
I didn't follow the Lucasfilm acquisition too closely when it was all going down, but something that has confused me is that Lucas seems like a fairly talented guy with a passion for what he does, so how does it make sense that he actively wants to destroy his legacy?

I'm really doubtful that it's as simple as Lucas one day having a left-wing/progressivism epiphany or some other grand artistic change, sell Lucasfilm to Disney, then participate in the destruction of their IP.

Wasn't he promised "treatments" and general involvement in the latest trilogy, then Disney back-stabbed him last-minute? I vaguely remember some drama about that.

Anyway, long story short, I think that there is more to the story, such as him being promised one thing and another thing happening, etc.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by joshjdr on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:41AM (#35725586)
I think they’re referring to the remastering of the original trilogy, long before Disney got involved.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by barrysteve on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:41AM (#35725578)
He knew his style of films were over, so he sold the franchise and let Disney take the burn for it.

It's difficult to see this as a political event, where he was outplayed.

He's worked with and against the big cats in Hollywood his whole career, he specifically made career decisions to 'get away' from Hollywood meddling in his work.

He knew what he was doing and this mythical George Lucas character, who is victim and hero in one man, is getting a bit long in the tooth.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Technotroll on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:59AM (#35725726)
I, for one, would love to see another George Lucas movie.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by drewcoo on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:44AM (#35725607)
When I consider this, I don't think there's any legacy there to ruin. The only thing that made the first movies watchable was gone long before Disney bought it up.

https://collider.com/star-wars-george-lucas-wife-marcia

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bombcar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:22AM (#35728552)
Lucas is a phenomenal story-spinner.

But like many story-spinners, he needs an equally phenomenal editor to sit on him. And it happens time and time again that a story-spinner gets so famous/rich/whatever that they can sit on the editor instead, and then the quality drops.

It's a very rare breed of story-spinner who can sit on themselves, offhand I can think of Tolkien perhaps.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by midoridensha on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:53PM (#35737001)
He can spin stories and build worlds very well indeed, but he can't write dialog or direct actors worth a damn. He needs someone else to handle this stuff. His best work was when he came up with the grand vision for something, but someone else handled dialog, scriptwriting, and directing. Basically, the guy was a technical genius but had no eye for the human element.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by toyg on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:07AM (#35725793)
This has nothing to do with "wokeism" or Disney.

George Lucas just saw making sci-fi movies as an effort to get reality as close as possible as the images he had in his mind. That meant seeing FX as an approximation, a constant compromise to reach the limits of what is possible to film. Lucasfilm were pioneers in digital FX and 3D for that very reason.

However, that also meant that each new work looked different from the previous, as real and digital FX diverged more and more with each passing year. He tried to rectify this by updating old works with new scenes and new effects. Had he stopped there, I reckon most people would have just plauded the novelty and moved on.

Unfortunately, while doing that, he also took the chance to modify what he saw as plot problems in the original movies - particularly the first, which was shot in isolation as a one-off, since there was no indication it would be as successful as it did (most actors thought it would be a one-and-done piece of trash, just to make a quick buck, particularly Sir Alex McGuinness). He made some dubious choices and the fandom never forgave him for that.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by denton-scratch on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:21AM (#35726956)
> particularly Sir Alex McGuinness

s/McGuinness/Guinness/

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jameshart on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:14AM (#35727580)
s/Alex/Alec/
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by adolph on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:28AM (#35728660)

  var objRef=document.querySelector("#\\33 5725793 > td > table > tbody > tr > td.default > div.comment > span > p:nth-child(3)");
 
 objRef.textContent=objRef.textContent.replace('Alex','Alec').replace('McGuinn','Guinn');
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by toyg on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:50PM (#35731956)
Thank you, what a brainfart I had :(
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:12AM (#35725837)
Lucas hasn't shown any real passion or talent since Star Wars IV. Except perhaps for pitching ideas for the Indy films. He thankfully relegated the V and VI to other directors and screenwriters (even for IV, a lot of his contributions were cringe, and rightfully resisted by the rest of the crew). And let's not talk about the prequels (Jar Jar and midichlorians anyone? Not to mention the acting of the protagonist).

My take is that he became complacent with the money after the first Star Wars, and never had much to show for afterwards or cared for movies that much. Contrast with his pal Spielberg who churned out film and film, and mastering his craft.

Ah, wait. He did found a great passion in the early 80s: merchandise.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jameshart on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:14AM (#35727568)
Watching the ILM documentary (Light & Magic) the thing that stood out about Lucas is that he hated having his moviemaking decisions set in stone, and it being expensive and hard to change stuff. He pushed to adopt digital compositing technology, digital audio, then digital cameras, and digital sets, because he was so frustrated by the slowness and friction of optical and location work.

I think what comes across in the prequels as this sort of ‘first take’ feel to the performances is a manifestation of his impatience - he wants to get the footage, edit it, get the effects, and see the thing in his head. And the ‘remastering’ he has done is similarly a bit of psychological desire to always feel like he can fix it later.

Waiting five days for Phil Tippett to stop motion ten seconds of tauntaun walking must have driven him crazy.

Underneath, it’s an engineer’s kind of laziness - the sort that drives innovation. I honestly felt after watching that documentary that I am slightly less annoyed by the clunkiness of Attack of the Clones because I actually now can see underneath it the excitement of Lucas to use all the toys he has spent a fortune investing in ILM to build and just make the damn movie.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:34AM (#35727875)
>He pushed to adopt digital compositing technology, digital audio, then digital cameras, and digital sets, because he was so frustrated by the slowness and friction of optical and location work.

Yes, but he overemphasized those technical aspects (where his care went) over the movie aspects.

It's like the guy who builds an expensive studio, with a huge mixer console, high end microphones, state of the art Pro Tools rig, and then proceeds to record his farts.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jameshart on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:40AM (#35728870)
Right, but Lucas didn’t buy that stuff off the shelf. He poured money into ILM and made them invent all that stuff so he could record his farts.

And we all get to benefit from the innovation he drove.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by hammyhavoc on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:13PM (#35733923)
I'm not a Star Wars fan, but that's pretty unfair to liken someone recording their farts to a whole movie with a huge crew and cast that each added their own speciality skills to the movie.

As much as you and I might knock Star Wars, it's wildly successful and is still seeing plenty of success in other mediums, so obviously it appeals to someone.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lazystar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:21AM (#35727690)
I'll defend Lucas til I die. His expanded universe is why I read so many books as a kid, and the huge number of star wars videogames in the 90s/2000s allowed game designers to tinker with different gameplay ideas with the star wars fans as a safety net. The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:36AM (#35727900)
>The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?

If the best you can say about a director is that "without him we wouldn't have as many franchize videogames" then I can rest my case :)

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lazystar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:02AM (#35728241)
If youre going to twist my words and ignore my point, why are you on hackernews? This isnt reddit, mate.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:28PM (#35736192)
Sorry, you don't get to invoke the "reddit, mate" as if your point was twisted. These are your literal quoted words, in their entirety:

"I'll defend Lucas til I die. His expanded universe is why I read so many books as a kid, and the huge number of star wars videogames in the 90s/2000s allowed game designers to tinker with different gameplay ideas with the star wars fans as a safety net. The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?"

Want me to highlight your argument? Here it is...

"The phantom menace movie had a lot of flaws, yes, but without it we wouldnt have the podracing videogames. disney, comparitively, has released... what, two star wars videogames in 7 years?"

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by selimthegrim on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:53AM (#35728126)
And Disney proceeded to nuke said expanded universe canon upon acquiring Lucasfilm
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by hammyhavoc on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:16PM (#35733941)
What's your point? It still exists. It's only "not canon" if you view it through the angle of the sequel trilogy being canon. People are still free to enjoy the EU within the context of what came before the sequel trilogy, and it still tells the same story it did on release.

That's the neat thing about art, I can choose not to think the post-Disney acquisition cash-cow milking is canon, especially when none of the original storytellers are involved, and it is thus not their vision.

Call it what it is: they retconned to milk the cash cow they bought dry.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:11PM (#35730275)
I think the argument is that the universe he created is amazing and rightly beloved, but his movie-making skills were troublesome. I also love the SW universe, but mostly for things that did not come directly from Lucas...
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by vehemenz on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:01AM (#35729176)
Lucas was an EP and writer for all three Indiana Jones films. I think these films hold up better than Star Wars, so I wouldn't say he has any passion or talent since Star Wars. With respect to the three Star Wars films though (and all the garbage that came later), I agree.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Friday April 28, 2023 @08:46AM (#35740632)
They do hold up better, but it's because of Spielberg who did the directing (I can't even imagine the cringe mess Lucas would have made - I'd rather we had a Tom Shelleck Indiana Jones movie, as was considered at one time, than a Lucas-directed one), Phillip Kaufman (who fleshed the story plot) and Lawrence Kasdan (who wrote the screenplay) rather than Lucas.

Lucas contributions were iconic, but not enough to get the movie to the level it is. From some dialogues I've seen between the whole team about the films [1], Lucas was more into throwing high level ideas, not about any core script work. So, the main concept, parts of the character design, and a high level plot summary. The rest had to make a full story, screenplay, and movie out of it.

[1] http://maddogmovies.com/almost/scripts/raidersstoryconferenc...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Tangurena2 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:07AM (#35729284)
My understanding is that most of what made Episode 4 work were the results of his then-wife editing the script. She did not get a credit in the movie.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by coldtea on Friday April 28, 2023 @08:36AM (#35740542)
This explains things!
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by zx8080 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:15AM (#35725338)
What did Lucas do?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Pinegulf on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:19AM (#35725386)
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by yreg on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:18AM (#35725375)
He remastered Star Wars several times and some people are apparently convinced that he 'destroyed' the work by doing that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changes_in_Star_Wars_re-releas...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Findecanor on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:17AM (#35725869)
George Lucas has claimed that he cut and spliced the original negative when editing the Special Edition of the original trilogy, so that the master copies of the original films don't physically exist.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by danparsonson on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:27AM (#35725946)
He didn't just remaster, he repeatedly altered the films, even changing the sense of some scenes, perhaps most notably and notoriously the stand-off between Han and Greedo. Most of his revisions have been questionable at best, ham-fisted and cringeworthy at worst.

Count me among the purists who think he ruined his good work ;-)

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by caseysoftware on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:43PM (#35730801)
While Han vs Greedo is the most egregious, the style is the most jarring.

You can tell all the inserted scenes because the colors are off, the animations are not blended well, and it feels off uncanny valley style.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by philwelch on Friday April 28, 2023 @07:57AM (#35740199)
I think the Jabba scene is arguably worse because it simply repeats the same lines we already had in the Greedo scene for no real gain. It also undermines the dramatic reveal of the much-discussed but never-seen Jabba in ROTJ. Plus the unnecessary fan service of Boba Fett literally turning and staring at the camera at the end.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by red-iron-pine on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:59AM (#35730040)
I'll make an exception for authors who want to tweak or improve their work.

Sometimes directors have to give into the limitations of their medium -- time, money, meddling producers, etc. If they want to revise it later to meet their original vision, more power to them.

Also entirely possible it was a cash grab; Skywalker Ranch needed a new wing or something.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by OkayPhysicist on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:59PM (#35732095)
For a positive example, Ridley Scott has a bunch of edits of Blade Runner. The huge improvement over the narration-riddled theatrical release was huge, and the pathological edits around hints towards Decker's replicant-ness are just kind of fun, in that different people are likely to have different views on the subject depending on which cut they watched.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by HeckFeck on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:48AM (#35725649)
I've deliberately sought the DVD edition of the unaltered original trilogy. The editing that makes Greedo shoot first looks cheap. It also doesn't make sense; someone pointing a gun at you is a clear sign of intent, and Han was simply defending himself. Han's decision to shoot first was also in line with his character as the rogue for hire.

Agh, I know the series is still raking in millions. But I can't enjoy the edits because my brain cries 'blasphmeny!'

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ReptileMan on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:31AM (#35725980)
The whole point is that Han Solo is badass. So he doesn't need high bar to shoot. Luke is the crybaby. The original trilogy Han will totally opportunity shoot Grido in the back if he knew he was sent for him and Grido was walking the street. And the only thing he will feel is recoil. And I know blasters don't have any recoil.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by hirundo on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:42AM (#35728000)
Even flashlights have recoil. Not that Han would feel it.

https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/c206f2/do_laser...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by dspillett on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:45AM (#35726095)
> I've deliberately sought the DVD edition of the unaltered original trilogy

The best you are likely to find is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmy%27s_Despecialized_Editio... – I don't think the unaltered editions were ever released on DVD or BluRay at all, just VHS and LaserDisc.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by gsich on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:11AM (#35726295)
4k77 also exists.

No they were released in the 2006 DVD set, quality is very poor though.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by dspillett on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:05AM (#35728271)
When I tried those I found the brightness and colour balance odd in places. I'm told this is because they are optimised to look as close as possible to how they would in a cinema in 1977 (hence the name) so are optimised for viewing via a projector not an LCD TV.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by benj111 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:38AM (#35727943)
I've got them (well my brother stole them) sold along with the rerelease so 6 discs total.

Digitally remastered but otherwise the cinema release

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jonhohle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:55AM (#35728153)
They are (unfortunately) not remastered. They are 480i letterboxed scans of an earlier LaserDisc release.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ycombobreaker on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:42AM (#35727983)
There's a DVD "limited edition" of the trilogy that is 2 discs each, and the "extras" disc has either the original or laserdisc edit. This is good. The downside is that the black levels and audio are obviously dated/untouched. There's just no market for "remastering" without the content changes.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jonhohle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:52AM (#35728120)
There was a single run that included the THX LaserDisc version of the original Trilogy on DVD. I own it specifically because it included the original release and it’s the version I shown my kids. https://comic-cons.xyz/star-wars-original-trilogy-unaltered-...

At the time the excuse was that there were no longer any masters for the original trilogy to rescan for rerelease, so the LaserDisc version was the best that could be done.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by philistine on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:02AM (#35729186)
No! For purists, those DVD releases don't cut it because they messed with the sound mix and the releases are not in the original frame format.

https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_changes_in_Star_War...

Their video quality is also terrible, even for DVD, being derived from a scan made for a Laserdisc release.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jonhohle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:34AM (#35729674)
When TVs were 4:3 and media playback was sending signals to control a photon gun, letterboxing was how you presented a 2.39:1 panavision feature. You’re screwed on resolution, but the framing is correct. HandBrake and other tools recognize and crop the matte giving you back a video in the correct aspect ratio (albeit still interlaced).

Edit: With the exception of getting LaserDisc releases of various vintages, the DVD release is the best, most accessible (excluding rarity) home video release of the original, unedited trilogy. They are not the highest quality, no doubt, but they are the best that was released. It could be argued that the despecialized editions are better for this reason or that, I personally consider them an incredible novelty, rather than a reference release.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by vehemenz on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:58AM (#35729125)
There are DVD rips of each LaserDisc, not sure if that torrent is still in circulation, but the video quality isn't as good as Harmy's.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by sd9 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:52AM (#35726152)
https://youtu.be/qb6UGbRlsgE "Thanksgiving" - Paul and Storm

It spoils the twist, but:

> And everybody knows that Greedo never even fired

> when Han shoots first it sets up his entire moral journey

> Plus it's cool

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by flippinburgers on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:23AM (#35727708)
Am I the only one who finds the end of Return of the Jedi to be the most horrible edit among all of the edits? I mean... I just want the song from my childhood not the garbage found in the blurays...
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by HeckFeck on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:00AM (#35728217)
That and the insertion of Hayden Christensen. I know they wanted continuity, but it just throws me off every time I see him. It is as if the ghost represents the worst excesses of the prequels seeping through time.

Also don't start me on that 'thing' they have singing in Jabba's palace.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Tangurena2 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:06AM (#35729264)
In the book Tales from The Mos Eisley Cantina, the other two Rodians in the Cantina at the time of that scene were present to execute Greedo (for a clan rivalry). Solo shooting Greedo let them claim the bounty. Every story in that book centers around the scenes from the film that took place inside the cantina.

0 - https://www.amazon.com/Tales-Eisley-Cantina-Star-Wars/dp/055...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by philwelch on Friday April 28, 2023 @07:54AM (#35740165)
Entertainment media seem to have significantly different use-of-force standards than any real life legal or moral statutes. Maybe because the drama of protracted Mexican standoffs would be undercut if people reacted realistically to having guns pointed at them.

The Greedo scene has been tweaked multiple times. In the most recent version available on Disney+ (confirmed to be Lucas’ work), Greedo exclaims “macklunkey!” just before the shooting starts, which I find hilariously absurd.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by sundvor on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:24AM (#35726401)
You could say he drew first.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bookofjoe on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:13AM (#35726872)
>A work of art is never finished, only abandoned.—Paul Valéry
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by zczc on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:35AM (#35727086)
Well, Spielberg himself replaced guns with walkies-talkies in E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E.T._the_Extra-Terrestrial#/me...
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by iconjack on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:47AM (#35727214)
Literally the subhed of the article: "Director has criticised the practice of re-editing older films while expressing remorse over removing guns in a later edition of ET"
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ycombobreaker on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:48AM (#35728068)
That was my first thought upon reading the title. However, people learn, grow, and change. I believe his argument will carry more weight with the acknowledgment and duscussion of his own prior decision. It's not hypocrisy; it's a lesson learned.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bombcar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:20AM (#35728487)
And he's a director! His job is to experiment and use new tools as they come available, and he's realized he made a mistake.

I have no problem with people making new versions of existing works; the problem I have is destroying the originals; even if destroyed by the author. The existence of copyright itself is a "deal" between society and an individual, we give the individual certain rights and privileges in exchange for certain benefits to society.

Only now has the ability to go back and change things resulted in large-scale destruction of personal copies of that original thing.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by friendlyHornet on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:17AM (#35725369)
One of my favourite albums of all time ("Witchcraft Destroys Minds and Reaps Souls" by Coven, released 1969) was very recently taken off of streaming platforms

I don't know the reason it was removed but it was like a I was pinched and realised how little control I have over my favourite music.

The album is still on YouTube but I don't know for how long.

I bought the vinyl, even though i currently don't have a record player but plan to get one

I have to start preserving DRM free or physical copies of media I like. I always knew there was a risk of stuff being removed but always put off thinking about it for convenience, but not anymore

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by AlexandrB on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:43AM (#35727179)
This has always been a pain about streaming services. The reason is almost always some licensing dispute or contract running out between the publisher, streaming company, and artist. Same kind of thing as when Netflix loses a movie or TV show. This is a good reason to still buy LPs, CDs, or DRM free mp3s since, for smaller artists, getting those rights back may not be worth bothering with for a giant like Spotify or Apple.

I'm not aware of this happening for explicitly censorious reasons, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if it did.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by wyre on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:12PM (#35730289)
I see the album on Apple Music listed as Witchcraft
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by friendlyHornet on Friday April 28, 2023 @06:43PM (#35748056)
Maybe it is geolocked? What country are you in? (You don't have to say if you're not comfortable)
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by DeathArrow on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:11AM (#35725301)
I would rather donate to a public effort to archive books, films, music and articles. I don't want to hoard the data myself and maintain backups.

If The Internet Archive can do it for websites, we can find a similar solution for films, too.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by malermeister on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:31AM (#35725498)
That already exists. It's called torrent trackers.

There used to be one called what.cd [0] that, to me, was like the Library of Alexandria, but for music. It was burned down in the name of commercial interest.

It might not be legal, but that's because the industry's interest is diametrically opposed to ours.

If it's moral and worthy of support, I'll leave for you to decide.

[0] https://www.vice.com/en/article/3de7vj/remembering-whatcd-th...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by DeathArrow on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:38AM (#35725545)
Torrent trackers are useless on long term because no one will seed for infinity.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by felixg3 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:47AM (#35725637)
Well, then you haven't witnessed the beauty of What.cd or PTP. A bunch of data hoarders with webseeds. Find that rare promo release from 1978 on Vinyl? Check. Get a lossless copy of a professionally digitized Laserdisc release of a film? Check.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by sam_lowry_ on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:53AM (#35726161)
rutracker is still good at archiving, albeit naturally biased towards Russian language. This is probably how it survives.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bombcar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:31AM (#35728707)
For now. But to survive generations you need a continual supply of new people interested in becoming data hoarders and seeding stuff they have absolutely never watched.

Which may happen for awhile, even a century. But it won't last thousands of years, unless storage space becomes infinitely big and cheap.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by malermeister on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:34AM (#35726491)
The beauty about it's distributed nature is that you don't need anyone seeding for infinity. You just need somebody seeding at all times and if you ever use a private tracker, you'll see that that's not an issue at all.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by DeathArrow on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:27AM (#35727782)
I saw many torrents with 0 seeders. Someone will be seeding only if the interest in that content is great. Rare content won't get any seeders. Old movies don't tempt many people.

I liked DC++ approach on file sharing more. If someone in the network has the file, you can get it, no matter how rare. It can be an obscure film made in 1930 or an mp3 only few people know or care about.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by malermeister on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:33AM (#35727862)
Was that on a private tracker? Those usually have strict rules around sharing ratios to prevent that scenario and in my experience, it works pretty well!
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by DeathArrow on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:32PM (#35734891)
DC++ is a client for DC/ADC protocol.

20 and 25 years ago, before torrents, it was king and it provided what us, poor kids, didn't have the money to pay for.

I guess today it isn't used that much as it used to be. It requires a client for discovery.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DC%2B%2B

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by yamtaddle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:09PM (#35730235)
I would—or, at least, I'd seed a whole lot longer—if there were a way to let me keep seeding after I normalize the file naming and structure. As it is, I have to render most downloads un-seedable in order to actually use them.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by malermeister on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:59PM (#35731117)
I use symlinks for that!
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by YurgenJurgensen on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:51AM (#35725664)
The current way torrents are designed is poor for archiving, because if you change the structure of the torrent even a little bit, the whole torrent has to effectively be recreated. Which is a problem if you didn't like the naming conventions used by the original seeder, or want to reorganise somehow. I believe there are already implementations that fix this, but they're not really being used.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Technotroll on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:03AM (#35725753)
I bid thee The Interplanetary File System (IPFS): https://ipfs.tech/
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by pierat on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:19AM (#35726937)
If you do use IPFS, then be aware that it has loads of traps you wouldn't expect.

1. A unique computer key identity is created on startup.

2. It announces every network adapter you have to the dHT, including localhost, docker virtual network adapters, everything.

3. If someone is sharing a specific hash content, you can query the network for their machine key and all their network interfaces, and everything else they're sharing.

4. I have early IRC communications that the ipfs.io gateway also quietly watches for 'bad hashes' and reports them to authorities. This was initially the decision they made to hunt down child porn predators, but this can be easily pivoted to copyright violators.

5. I also caught early on (in the 0.34 version) that google was already crawling computers, and all their shared hashes'. I had a few files I created that were very unique, and a curious search showed them to me, along with my machine's key.

For completely legal bulk data, IPFS is a terrific solution. But for anything that is illegal or might be illegal in the future, well, I have to question that usage for those aforementioned reasons.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by nextaccountic on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:34AM (#35728762)
> 1. A unique computer key identity is created on startup.

> 2. It announces every network adapter you have to the dHT, including localhost, docker virtual network adapters, everything.

This is totally insane, is there any client that don't enable those misfeatures? (like, generate a new key identity on startup, and don't publish any network adapter)

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by yamtaddle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:05PM (#35730171)
Guessing #1 has something to do with speeding up the notoriously-slow network. Probably allows more long-term route caching or something.

#2 does seem silly.

On a semi-related note, it's not that hard to set up a private IPFS. You just need a publicly-reachable "lighthouse" node (and it's extremely low-resource, the cheapest hosted VM you can find can likely handle the task without trouble) and some light config edits. IPFS isn't (and isn't trying to be) anonymous, but you can avoid sharing with the entire IPFS network and share only with trusted peers instead. The ordinary IPFS network won't even know you're there, because you won't be connecting to it.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by pierat on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:39PM (#35730728)
I was there doing early testing, way prior to the filecoin offering.

The justification for a computer key (which is a base56 sha) was to make every machine a unique node on the network. Note that IPFS also purports to be a multi-network system that can be on top of ip4/6/tor/etc, so they wanted a backwards compat ID.

Now if my computer asks the dHT for hash X, I get a response back from all the computers with that hash. And it's similar to BitTorrent in that fashion. And the content hash is like Git.

There's also IPNS, which makes a connection from DNS to IPFS. You need unique machine identifiers for this.

With the sharing of every network interface, prior to 0.3 the idea was that ALL content loaded with IPFS could be shared. And 'nearness' ala STP could be used to provide local data to local machines. However, due to garbage copyright law, was not turned on by default.

The root problem is that basic security was never considered, as in the 'bad things someone can do with these identifiers'. Ideas like "one person loads a viral video and every device on the local network gets it from them" are amazing ideas, but preclude the bad side like 'who to DoS and doxx' and all these bad side of internet issues.

It sucks, cause I really think IPFS should have absolutely taken off. I could see this as solar system worthy networking for satellite to satellite. But there's inherent problems that I think would be better in the crucible of the IETF and not a commercial entity.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by DeathArrow on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:24PM (#35734808)
You seem to have invested a great time in knowing IPFS.

Just three questions I have:

-is performance an issue?

-can the source code and architecture be easily be modified so it becomes more safe where anonimity is concerned?

-if I run IPFS from a virtual machine and route the connections through socks proxy chains / ssh tunnels / VPNs / TOR it would still be able to spill info about me?

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by pierat on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:11PM (#35735206)
Performance: ugh yes. The GO implementation is a CPU and RAM hog. Basically, you cannot run it on a cheap vps, where you could easily run apache or nginx.

There's also significant bandwidth costs from a distributed hash table. That's a design implementation that really can't be avoided as the nature of dHT's. Running this on phones will blow through your monthly quota pretty quickly just on announce traffic.

I'm not well versed in GO, so I can't! However there's a LOT of customizations and settings you can turn off/on. For example, you can create a private IPFS network of just your machines. Or you can create piracy networks of friends. That sort of thing.

Just my complaints about the defaults are what I would classify as unsafe.

As for running through Tor or I2p, well yeah. I worked with another user who ended up figuring out a way to do it through Tor that only shared an internal 192.168.0.0/24 address. Basically they firewalled all internet comms other than Tor and forced through it. Also had to do MAC randomization because IPFS also shares that.

The IPFS folks initially said they were going to first-class Tor support. But when it got hard, they backed out. My guess was that would have turned IPFS into the biggest unstoppable piracy net. And Benet and gang were busy with filecoin. Tor doesn't make money, and has the smell of unsavoriness.

My recommendation is to get 2 machines, and bring them both up with a trivial 'hello.txt' file and prove all the details you can about the other. I don't think the protocol changed much... But I could be wrong.

I left using it because of massive resource usage, high network bandwidth, and user-hostile hosting environment due to insecure and everything-shared environment.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by nextaccountic on Saturday April 29, 2023 @12:58AM (#35750168)
> However, due to garbage copyright law, was not turned on by default.

I don't understand, what is not turned on by default? Do you know which setting can be used to turn it on?

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by pierat on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:00PM (#35766088)
Right now, on the http(s) web, when you request a file, the provenance of that file is linked to the domain name and the HTTPS traffic.

On IPFS, the provenance of a file is its content hash, not some server you downloaded it from.

On IPFS, if I join in on hosting and sharing a hash of a file, I could be a malware spewer, but that doesn't change the hash.

Where this conflicts with copyright is, say you are on a IPFS enabled Movie server from CBS. By definition, only they are approved to transmit their files. But IPFS uses Git and BitTorrent to swarm download content. And default copyright, that's a civil tort matter.

The original idea for IPFS was that for the local network, that it did support BitTorrent like operations from browser cache. So if something went viral, it was 1 download from the internet connection, and then on-lical-network the rest of the way.

That feature was disabled EARLY on because it strictly violates copyright.

It's also why your computer published all the network interfaces to the dHT, so that you could find local nodes. But they didn't remove that; they only removed the dynamic sharing part.

I think there are settings to turn that back on, but I'm not 100% sure.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by anacrolix on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @09:50AM (#35802373)
IPFS did browser caching? Are you sure?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by nextaccountic on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:35AM (#35728779)
> There used to be one called what.cd [0] that, to me, was like the Library of Alexandria, but for music. It was burned down in the name of commercial interest.

Some data hoarder must have saved all this stuff, right? So why isn't it in a torrent?

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by malermeister on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:19PM (#35730402)
https://archive.org/details/whatcdcrawl&tab=about

I think archive.org might be that data hoarder :). They might release stuff slowly as the copyright expires.

It also looks like https://redacted.ch/ might be the spiritual successor - https://interviewfor.red/en/prepare.html this process sounds very familiar ;)

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by john_the_writer on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:19AM (#35725391)
the only issue with that, is you don't own the copy-right, so donating it isn't possible.

If you have a copy of HarryPotter and want to make sure it stays as is, then you have to back it up.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by DeathArrow on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:39AM (#35725564)
But that only works for me and my kids. And for physical books, I am kind of doing it. Bill kids won't have that copy of Harry Potter.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by pabs3 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:15AM (#35725855)
IA does archive books and magazines etc, including storing physical items and digitising them.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by mitchdoogle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:50PM (#35731957)
The Library of Congress collects films
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Technotroll on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:56AM (#35725700)
I’m sorry to say that this is a rather naïve approach to long term preservation of data. There are surprisingly few solutions to preserve consumer data for more than a decade or so. If you really want to preserve your data for, say, decades, much less hundreds of years, then you need to think beyond the storage media you’re currently using. Even CDs fade after merely a few years of safe storage, leading to errors and data loss in the long run. Thus there are a multitude of factors you need to take into account before storing data for longer than a decade or so.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by pacija on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:08AM (#35725810)
Well, over last two decades my mp3s, flacs, avis, mkvs, pdfs, epubs and others moved between CDs, DVDs, HDDs to land at a ZFS array replicated to another ZFS array at the moment. The way I use them has changed over the years (cloud streaming from navidrome, kodi for local playing, azuracast for radio broadcast etc.), but the media files themselves are the same.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by cm2187 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:01AM (#35726219)
As long as you don’t have real media files or other codecs that have disappeared (or will disappear - imagine if we move to a new cpu instruction set, I assume not every codec library will be recompiled).
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bombcar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:26AM (#35728605)
If you maintain lossless storage you can switch formats as necessary; the problem really becomes a major issue when you have various formats you don't use very often and you don't notice that something became unplayable.

Luckily the number of people obsessed with emulating old systems saves the day for now. But at some point things like Video CDs and the Compact Disc-Interactive systems may fully fade into history.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by beepbooptheory on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:04AM (#35725769)
Is tape the answer here?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by cm2187 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:17AM (#35726353)
To cover the genitals on the paintings?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by api on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:23AM (#35726394)
I just maintain my data hoard by copying it to ever newer media. As that happens the cost drops and the capacity increases.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by midoridensha on Friday April 28, 2023 @01:40AM (#35737825)
This isn't really happening much any more. Spinning-platter HDs are barely increasing in size any more (I got a 4TB portable drive 5 years ago that I still use; now, looking at what's available, 5TB is the max and 4TB is still at the high end). SSDs are growing, but still not cost-competitive with spinning platters, and not really reliable for long-term offline storage anyway like spinning platters.

There just isn't that much demand for large-scale storage, since everyone just keeps their data "in the cloud" or has subscriptions to online services now. 20 years ago, HD sizes were doubling every year.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by causi on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:53AM (#35726674)
You can burn them to M-Disc. Most modern DVD drives can burn them. Personally I just use a local and remote backup.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:24AM (#35726406)
> It's almost a guarantee that any copy you don't own and control will at some point in the future be revised.

This reminds me of the apple 'service' that automatically replaced your MP3s with its own 'sanctioned' digital files. It turned several of my tracks into unlistenable, censored versions and I've been incredibly wary of digital-only content ever since.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by causi on Thursday April 27, 2023 @07:50AM (#35726648)
It's already happened. Netflix and Hulu both removed the episode of Community where someone was cosplaying a dark elf because it looked too much like blackface. Never mind the fact the person doing it is insane, its resemblance to blackface is the joke, and his character dies and is removed from the show after less than a minute of screen time.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by willcipriano on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:26AM (#35727005)
They also edited out a Bill Nye segment where he said there are two genders.

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/news/bil...

Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by defrost on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:38AM (#35727122)
Is there an issue with the removal of an actual scientific inaccuracy from a science program?

This:

> "See, there are only two possibilities: XX, a girl, or XY, a boy. The chance of becoming either a boy or a girl is always 1 in 2, a 50-50 chance either way. It’s like flipping a coin: X you’re a girl, Y you’re a boy.”

is out by a few percent .. numbers wise it's more inaccurate than claiming there's no gold in the earths crust. ( see [1] )

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex

I imagine Nye himself authorised the change to his own work as I assume he later corrected himself (as appears to be implied in your link).

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by willcipriano on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:45AM (#35727201)
Take a look at the chart you provided "Prevalences of various conditions that have been called intersex"

Why does it have a "Sex specificity" column? Why does it contain the words male and female?

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by defrost on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:25AM (#35727742)
Australia, the country I live in, has an official passport that has for Sex: the valid responses M | F | X.

The reason for that is the actual verifiable existance of people who were born here clearly, scientifically, medically as neither M NOR F.

They are valid exceptions to the above quote from the Nye program and there are enough people born this way to number in the thousands in a country of some ~ 23 milllion or so.

The passport system was changed as a citizen of this country fronted and objected to having enter M or F when they were born clearly neither.

As someone with a science background who measures and models reality I approve of systems that track the world and its elements as it is and as they are .. rather than models that force a world view that doesn't match reality.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by houstonn on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:57AM (#35730005)
Sad to hear that a country is anti-science.

As Richard Dawkins recently clarified, "As a biologist, there are 2 sexes. And that's all there is to it." It's binary and there is no exception. People that claim otherwise are confused.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:36PM (#35732661)
I believe there are cases of people being born with a set of sex chromosomes that are different from XY and XX. This is what your parent commenter is referring to and I fail to see how it's a valid point ("anti-science"), on the particular topic of determining biological sex in people.

If one wants to make a simple statement that encompasses the largest group of people they might say, "There are 2 sexes." If they want to make a more complex statement that encompasses all humans they might add a qualifier such that they instead say, "There are 2 typical sexes." That "typical" adds a whole lot of complexity in order to generalize the statement.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by illiopq on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:46PM (#35732806)
These aren't additional sexes. For example, XXY will be male and XXX will be female, assuming no other genetic anomalies.

Comparing to different sex determination systems in other species can help with conceptualizing this distinction, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temperature-dependent_sex_dete... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZW_sex-determination_system.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:46PM (#35733571)
> These aren't additional sexes.

This is an opinion. Clearly there are at least some in Australia who have the opinion that they are indeed additional sexes or their passports wouldn't have more than 2 options. That's not "anti-science"; it is an opinionated interpretation of science.

Certainly the statement, "There are 2 sexes," simplifies the biological understanding we have of sex. To then add, "And that's all there is to it," makes the statement plainly wrong.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by illiopq on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:28PM (#35734072)
Sorry but you are mistaken. Sex chromosome aneuploidies are not additional sexes. The biological understanding of sex, as Dawkins points out, is that it is a binary of female and male.

How some jurisdictions choose to legally define sex is a separate issue. For instance, in some countries, the law is such that people who desire to be the opposite sex can have the sex in their passport changed to reflect this desire. So a male, with penis and testicles, who wants to be female, can legally obtain a passport with an 'F' marker in the sex field. This does not mean he is actually female - from a material biological perspective he is and will always be male.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:07PM (#35734610)
> The biological understanding of sex, as Dawkins points out, is that it is a binary of female and male.

It's taken as binary because the biological difference doesn't result in a meaningful physiological difference. That doesn't mean it's "anti-science" to have an alternative take. Consider that "The biological understanding of sex" as used in your comment should logically be understood as "A common interpretation of the biological understanding of sex". It might suddenly become clear that "it is a binary of male and female" as used in your comment is actually an opinion.

Anyway, I'm not deluding myself that this particular legal definition in Australia was not made in response to recent gender politics. It's more likely there for trans people than for a person who is biologically XXY and physiologically male. However, to say that it's "anti-science" to claim there are more than 2 sexes is mistaken. It is, as I said, an opinionated interpretation of a certain understanding of biology. You disagree with this opinion and you are mistaken when you say it is factually incorrect.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by illiopq on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:49PM (#35735054)
It's a binary because anisogamous sexual reproduction is organised as a paired system of male and female, defined with the former producing small gametes and the latter with large ones. There's no third sex, and disorders of sex development are not new, additional sexes.

This form of reproduction is a biological phenomenon that shared by almost all complex life, and this understanding is uncontroversial amongst biologists. Stating that's it's an opinion is like saying that evolution is an opinion, or that the earth being a spherical mass orbiting around the sun is an opinion.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jackmott42 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:01AM (#35727398)
that column also contains the word "none" in some cases. And in either case it is all just a judgement call people made for the conditions.

The semantic sparring over sex and gender has a pretty simple compromise, that people who want to say it is a spectrum and people who want to say it is binary should be able to agree on and be happy with:

it is a bimodal distribution

of course the problem is that is a nuanced idea and humans can't handle nuance. Maybe you can, and I can, but WE as a human group can't. We prefer to drive ourselves literally insane over the semantic argument. oh well.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by flippinburgers on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:21AM (#35727676)
The idea has always been that it is essentially binary with edge cases.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by yellowapple on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:45AM (#35728030)
"Always" to whom? There are countless cultures out there - both historical and contemporary - with non-binary interpretations of sex and/or gender.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by flippinburgers on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:30AM (#35753872)
First of all there are definitely a countable number of cultures... secondly ... well rolf.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by yellowapple on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:27AM (#35759689)
I mean, yes, the number of cultures is probably mathematically countable, but considering how quickly they split and merge and mix and such (and have been doing so for likely the entirety of human existence), do you really think it would be practical to do so? ;)
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:57AM (#35729998)
> it is a bimodal distribution

this isn't something that most people are familiar with, especially people who tend to see things in binaries (not because they're stupid, but because they're trained to see the world in binaries, because it's the simplest classification system which makes it easy to manipulate by politicians and media).

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by plob on Friday April 28, 2023 @11:50AM (#35742859)
If sex can be plotted as a bimodal distribution, then what do you believe is on the y-axis, and how do you measure this variable?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by rightbyte on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:55AM (#35728157)
There are more exotic three letter variants too.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by causi on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:13AM (#35728372)
is out by a few percent .. numbers wise it's more inaccurate than claiming there's no gold in the earths crust. ( see [1] )

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex

I thought you were going to mention how there are more male embryos than female embryos created since males have a higher death rate. Why is sex the only category in which we have to constantly qualify ourselves with regard to birth defects? Someone who's talking about how the three types of cones work to create color vision doesn't have to constantly harken back to how some people are color-blind, despite that population being an order of magnitude larger than intersex individuals. Not mentioning people with phocomelia does not mean your lesson on the anatomy of the arms and legs is wrong or inadequate.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by nextaccountic on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:31AM (#35728709)
There isn't a group of people that is constantly dehumanizing colorblind people, stripping their rights and sometimes criminalizing their own existence. Attacking colorblind people isn't a political platform anywhere. People don't murder and sexually assault people because of their colorblind status.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by causi on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:45AM (#35728942)
Is attacking intersex people a political platform? I believe you're referring to transgender people who, while subject to all those horrible things you mention, have nothing to do with the biology of sex.

Exempting them from bans on genital surgery for infants/children certainly is a political choice.

That's very interesting, I didn't know that. Personally I believe in a blanket ban of all unnecessary surgical procedures/body mods on newborns and infants, including "genital correction", circumcision, and piercing.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ryan-c on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:55AM (#35729088)
> Is attacking intersex people a political platform?

Exempting them from bans on genital surgery for infants/children certainly is a political choice.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:55AM (#35729976)
Trying to step lightly here, but

> have nothing to do with the biology of sex

is not true. The motivation for dehumanizing trans people is largely based on the (completely erroneous) twin ideas that "gender is sex" and "there are two sexes". Both of those things being false really takes the wind out of the argument.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Alupis on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:09PM (#35730241)
We understand it now, 2 + 2 = 5

In all seriousness, changing language to fit some weird political philosophy and then berating others for not going along is as dangerous as it is outrageous.

Constructs in your head are not real. When you die, they are gone forever. Yet, when they dig up your body 1,000 years from now as some sort of archeological dig, they will study your skeleton and determine your biological sex with certainty.

You (or anyone) is free to think whatever you want about yourself or others - but you are not free to force others to think like you, particularly when your thoughts are irrational and not grounded in reality or scientific fact.

And people make fun of the flat-earthers for denying reality and objective facts...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:39PM (#35730729)
Woof, I'm not going to engage fully with this post. It is too loaded. I am not sure I can fully parse this post, but I am going to state some assertions that I believe respond to the statements made.

I am going to agree (?) that gender is a construct. I assert that it is a social construct. It does not exist inside our cells, only in our minds (individually and collectively).

I am going to disagree that sex is determined by our skeletons. I assert that skeletal structure and other phenotypical features are symptoms of sex, which is determined by genes. This is a scientific consensus as far as I can tell.

I believe I am disagreeing with you when I say that there are more than two possible outcomes of genetic sex determination. This is obvious, because there are multiple sex-determination systems in animals, not just XY. There is X0, there is ZW, and there are others.

Even within XY, there are variations. An individual can be born with XXY chromosomes. Or they can be born male with XX chromosomes, or female with XY chromosomes.

Or, a human can be born female with XX chromosomes, no outward differences from typical female phenotype, and feel they are a man. This is because, as stated above, gender is a social construct. Not actually sure if we agree or disagree on that.

There is no berating happening here or anything else that should make a person feel victimized. Just science. A little more advanced than grade school science, but still science.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Alupis on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:53PM (#35730992)
> A little more advanced than grade school science, but still science.

"He who controls the language controls the masses." - Saul Alinsky

> Even within XY, there are variations. An individual can be born with XXY chromosomes. Or they can be born male with XX chromosomes, or female with XY chromosomes

We are not discussing extremely rare genetic defects. We're discussing people who slander biological genders by dressing as offensive caricatures and then demand everyone else participate in their mental illness.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:56PM (#35732929)
This is paranoia and hate speech and I'm not continuing.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Alupis on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:51PM (#35733634)
Everyone already knows what tribe you belong to; there's no reason to signal here.

Which is why there is no substantive conversation around this subject. As soon as we don't agree, it's suddenly hate speech.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:02PM (#35734535)
You brought out emotionally charged language in response to my post about biological sex determination, which was in response to a post filled with emotionally charged language. It has nothing to do with whether or not we disagree. It's that you haven't expressed your ideas in a way that doesn't denigrate trans people and make you sound like the victim of their existence.

I don't call it hate speech because you aren't on my side. I call it hate speech because it treats transgender people as uniformly ill and invalidates their identity. (You'll find that if we stop doing that, their mental health tends to be pretty good.) And because the rigidness of the gender binary in modern western society is not universal across time and space within human cultures and it exists in opposition to scientific understanding.

You are saying right now that you want a genuine engagement. I'm a sucker for debate obviously. This is your chance to genuinely engage, lay out your scientific reasoning why a biologically female person with XX chromosomes should be forced by their peers into accepting the gender roles that other people say they must have regardless of what makes them feel good or happy.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by beklinos on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:13PM (#35735229)
> reasoning why a biologically female person with XX chromosomes should be forced by their peers into accepting the gender roles that other people say they must have

The honest solution to this, that is grounded in material reality, is for her to reject these gender roles, and be a woman who accepts herself as she is, regardless of any such attempted impositions.

If she pretends to be a man instead, she isn't challenging gender roles, but is implicitly agreeing with the harmful idea that women must adhere to some roles, men must adhere to other roles, and anyone who doesn't do this is defective and must change themselves to fit this mould.

Even worse is how such non-conformance to gender roles has been medicalized, so she may end up taking opposite-sex hormones, having her breasts removed and other cosmetic surgeries to appear as some odd facsimile of a man. Rather than accepting herself for who she is.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:22PM (#35736847)
> If she pretends to be a man instead, she isn't challenging gender roles, but is implicitly agreeing with the harmful idea that women must adhere to some roles, men must adhere to other roles, and anyone who doesn't do this is defective and must change themselves to fit this mould.

I appreciate your rational input. And to be honest, I don't completely disagree with this part. Trans people are not unaware of it either. However, [I must explain that] I was using "gender roles" in a very broad way, including pronouns like "she". This person doesn't need anyone to use specific words to describe their sexual phenotype if they don't want it. We don't have different a different form of "he" for children vs adults, nor for black people vs white people. It is a societal construct and they're allowed to opt out.

> Even worse is how such non-conformance to gender roles has been medicalized, so she may end up taking opposite-sex hormones, having her breasts removed and other cosmetic surgeries to appear as some odd facsimile of a man. Rather than rejecting this malignant, cultish ideology that advocates physical destruction of the self in lieu of bodily acceptance.

This is an extremely disgusting and transphobic thing to say though. I hope you didn't realize how hateful it sounded. Gender-affirming care is widely supported in the medical community as a life-saving intervention. As for whether or not you think it's appropriate for another person to have their body surgically altered, what do you think about tattoos? About facial reconstruction for burn victims? About a mastectomy for cancer? And why do you even care what other people do with their bodies?

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by causi on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:01PM (#35731145)
I believe in treating people the way they ask to be treated so I always respect pronouns, bathroom choices, etc. What I've never been particularly clear on is why we've collectively agreed to cooperate with the social construct version of sex, i.e., gender but not anything else. If someone identifies as being tall, or older/younger than they are, or a different ethnicity, why doesn't anybody respect that identity as well? Is it just because there are a lot more people who don't feel like their assigned gender than there are people who don't feel like their assigned, say, eye color?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Alupis on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:15PM (#35731370)
We used to teach people to accept others, and ourselves for who we are - flaws and all. We used to guide people into being comfortable and accepting of themselves - we are always our own harshest critic.

Most people undergo some period of time where they are unsure of their self, their future, their purpose, and perhaps even question their existence and the meaning of it all.

Now we teach people being uncomfortable and uncertain is unacceptable and that it obviously means you are the problem and must change. In doing so, we doom these people to a lifetime of hardship and uncertainty.

Imagine a world where having blue eyes was viewed as bad and had to be surgically and permanently altered to look more brown. Would these people feel any more confident after the operation? Why do celebrities continuously get plastic surgery over and over? They are never comfortable with themselves, and the further they go down the path of altering who they are, the more uncomfortable they become - ignoring whatever actual problems they may be experiencing in favor of cosmetic and superficial changes.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by causi on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:22PM (#35731486)
Indeed. I find it highly disturbing that the (very high) suicide rate for trans people has not precariously fallen as the number of people identifying as trans has risen. That doesn't make statistical sense if suppressing your trans nature is worse than embracing it. Something is wrong here. I wonder if perhaps we're classifying multiple conditions as "being transgender" and only some of them psychologically benefit from transitioning. Considering the charged political climate I doubt we're going to see any rigorous research on the topic for decades.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by filichi on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:00PM (#35732110)
It's because this high suicide rate is a myth, it's a false claim invented to push an ideological agenda and guilt trip anyone who disagrees.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Alupis on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:29PM (#35732542)
You may want to cite some source when asserting things that are contrary to well understood facts.

For instance, here's a NIH article studying extremely high suicide rates among transgendered people[1]. It cites many, many possible reasons for this, but the facts remain. Your assertion appears to have no supporting evidence.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5178031/

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by filichi on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:53PM (#35732897)
Did you read the article you cited, or dig further into the data sources it cites? You may be surprised at how poorly these support your hypothesis.

The article even acknowledges the paucity of data: "However, the exact prevalence of completed suicide among transgender persons remain undocumented".

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:10PM (#35733116)
> In doing so, we doom these people to a lifetime of hardship and uncertainty.

Let's allow them to "doom" themselves to increased happiness and just stop filling their lives with hardship.

> Imagine a world where having blue eyes was viewed as bad and had to be surgically and permanently altered to look more brown. Would these people feel any more confident after the operation?

Probably.

> Why do celebrities continuously get plastic surgery over and over? They are never comfortable with themselves, and the further they go down the path of altering who they are, the more uncomfortable they become

Is this what all your celebrity friends say? My celebrity friend circle mostly disagrees. Let's take a poll of all the celebrities we personally know and try to get some more data on what's going on inside the minds of "celebrities". Even though we already both know so much about the internal experiences of all celebrities.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by mitchdoogle on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:28PM (#35731580)
"You (or anyone) is free to think whatever you want about yourself or others - but you are not free to force others to think like you"

No one cares what anyone else thinks. The only thing that matters is behavior. If your behavior is harmful to others, then we certainly are free to try and change that behavior.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by dragonwriter on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:23PM (#35735302)
> Constructs in your head are not real.

If gender is not real, then why do you care what gender people are assigned.

> Yet, when they dig up your body 1,000 years from now as some sort of archeological dig, they will study your skeleton and determine your biological sex with certainty.

I mean, its thousands of years in the future, so maybe, but if we do it today, that’s not how it works; there’s a scale for skeletons of “Female, Probable Female, Intermediate, Probable Male, Male” and even the extremes are subject to caveats. But who cares? Why would what archeologists will think about your sex from your bones in some distant future constrain your gender expression in life?

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Alupis on Friday April 28, 2023 @10:29AM (#35741687)
No one said gender is not real, you are asserting an argument I did not make.

The notion you can be whatever you want - that is not real, that exists solely in your head.

As an adult, you are free to do whatever you want - so long as it does not impact me and my life. Which is the problem isn't it... people forcefully impacting my life to please themselves.

Forcing me to guess whatever pronouns you happen to what to use today is not a game I am going to play. If I demanded you refer to me as "King Alupis" in every one of your responses, you would probably not play that game either, despite the obvious happiness it would bring me.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by sobkas on Friday April 28, 2023 @04:33PM (#35746750)
> We understand it now, 2 + 2 = 5

"if someone says 2+2=5, the correct response is, ‘What are your definitions and axioms?’ not a rant about the decline of Western civilization".

From Wikipedia because math is hard, let's go right wing.

Use a wiki or something. Because when even I know that 2 + 2 = 5 can be true in some cases then you might want to reconsider your arguments.

BTW.

A + B != B + A also can be true.

> Constructs in your head are not real. When you die, they are gone forever.

Almost all of you is a construct, there are few things directly wired into the brain(but they aren't irrelevant) but most of it is learned. And when you die everything you had in your brain is gone forever. And then by your definition things that make us us are fiction. And they are as fictional as gender(btw. gender is not sex, and sex is more complex).

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bloxxox on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:38PM (#35731749)
If there are more than two sexes, please describe what they are, and the additional types of gamete produced by these sexes. Your explanation should be applicable to all anisogamic species over the past billion years or so, including all that are hermaphroditic and all that are gonochoric.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:46PM (#35732796)
> Exempting them from bans on genital surgery for infants/children certainly is a political choice.

Who is trying to do that? Gender-affirming genital surgery is not commonly, if ever, practiced on minors and no one is advocating for that except maybe a few people on the lunatic fringe.

The whole idea that doctors are going around performing genital surgery on trans-kids is a baseless political attack by people trying to ban reversible gender-affirming treatment like social transitioning and puberty blockers under the guise of banning more extreme treatments that aren't actually performed on minors.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by antiteetyeet on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:04PM (#35733038)
Genital surgery typically isn't performed until the child is at least 16 years of age, usually older, but 'gender-affirming' breast removal is being done to female children as young as 12 years old.

There's increasing scepticism as to whether social transitioning is reversible in practice (see the interim report of the Cass Review for more detail on this), and the long-term adverse effects of puberty blockers are currently unclear.

This is part of the reason why the health authorities in many countries are starting to halt or restrict the gender-affirming approach, as it may be causing more harm than good to gender non-conforming children.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by nicenewtemp84 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:26PM (#35731550)
If colorblind people were trying to indoctrinate kids and make them feel like they too might be colorblind because those children sometimes ponder if they see colors correctly, I'd be pretty annoyed too.

Even the simple dumbing down of gay rights to talk in schools about people who love others of the same gender, just let them love whoever they want! You have been free to love whoever you want for centuries. Im a male that loves my father, and would help a few of my friends fight to the death if they were being attacked. I love them. That has nothing to do with being gay. Why do we even need to have a flag raised at school that talks mainly about the right to stick sexual organs into other people? Because that's the only distinction I see between me loving my male friends and me being gay.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:29PM (#35736889)
> You have been free to love whoever you want for centuries.

Um, no. It was a criminal act to be gay in the US earlier this century.

> Im a male that loves my father

Oh, I see. You're either practicing illegal love, or you're being purposely obtuse by conflating two different meanings of love.

> Because that's the only distinction I see between me loving my male friends and me being gay.

You hold hands with them? In public? You kiss and cuddle with them? In front of children? Because gay people have been murdered for that in living memory. I guess they just should have avoided touching sexual organs (in private) and everything would have been fine.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by nicenewtemp84 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:10AM (#35788706)
My entire point was that there are two different types of 'love', yet the left wants to talk to grade school children about LGB people 'loving' each other constantly. And since theyre not talking about family or platonic love, were talking about romantic/sexual 'love', I don't think that's an appropriate subject for school children.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by midoridensha on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:07PM (#35736769)
>Someone who's talking about how the three types of cones work to create color vision

This isn't scientifically accurate either. Some people have 4 types of cones.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetrachromacy

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by treeman79 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:19AM (#35727640)
Google also removed Easter. On Easter if you asked what day it was you got something like “Chicken little day”
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Kye on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:25AM (#35727740)
I have to wonder if that was by his request. His newer show had a segment on gender and sex that covers the tremendous human diversity in both. I don't mind old stuff being cut for being misleadingly simplistic.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by tdehnel on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:36AM (#35727908)
This is a textbook “not true but if so good” comment.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by aorth on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:29AM (#35728672)
Incidentally they did themselves a favor, as biological sex differentiation is determined by the sex cells (aka gametes) an individual produces, not by chromosomes. In humans these are eggs in women and sperm in men.

https://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/from-sex-to-gender-mode...

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by WeylandYutani on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:07AM (#35727486)
Maybe I'm just a cranky old man but woke people are humourless cunts.

These identity folks have no ability to laugh at themselves.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Kye on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:30AM (#35727827)
Ten minutes of Ashley Gavin will change your mind.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Hz3zZlsS7c

We can joke. The thing is, we have more than two, and they're actually funny.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by tdehnel on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:40AM (#35727959)
Classic woke retort of “here’s a single person who’s the exception”. Citing a single example does not back up your case here. In fact it probably hurts it…”we have one!”
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bmelton on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:09AM (#35728315)
Getting back to the thesis, and without commenting on woke/not-woke (because I'm neither qualified nor care,) I am not sure what makes this particular comedy different from comedy we might otherwise consider problematic.

${X} joke about ${Y} -- if ${X} is only funny so long as ${Y} doesn't violate cultural taboos to make fun of, then we have an issue with the permanence of the joke. If a bad joke about ${Y} can be fixed by changing ${Y} to Republican (or whatever else is culturally acceptable to make fun of in time ${Z}, then the problem is not ${X} joke, it's our sensitivity to ${Y}.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by kodisha on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:08AM (#35727513)
Don't even get me started about Netflix cropping Seinfeld from 4:3 to 16:9, and thus making the whole thing TOTALLY unwatchable for me.

What the hell Netflix??

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bombcar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:12AM (#35728365)
"This show has been modified to NOT fit your TV".

It's insane how freaked people STILL get over black bars! Look, we get it, some aspect ratios don't work when on other aspect ratios! Just leave the content alone!

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by commandlinefan on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:25AM (#35727735)
I was listening to the Dire Straits song "Money for Nothing" on Sirius last week and there's an entire verse that was just edited out of existence (if you're old enough to remember the song when it came out, you can probably guess which verse). Never mind that the verse itself was poking fun at people who talked like that.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bmelton on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:40AM (#35727963)
The entire song was (as I recall) poking fun at people who talked like that, and all of the lyrics in the song came were overheard by some working class patrons and their observations watching MTV.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by somenameforme on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:01AM (#35728231)
It's ironic because so many of these things being targeted for censorship not only are completely inoffensive, but completely mocking the stuff in question. I suppose humor and irony are always the first victims of authoritarianism. Another excellent example is the adventures of Huck Finn. That literally the only genuinely good person in the book was called "[racial pejorative that would probably get this post auto-flagged] Jim" was the entire point.

Mark Twain was making a point about judging people by labels or how they look on the surface, instead of judging them by their character and actions. Of course now we're back to square one to judging people by labels and how they look on the surface, but this time it'll be different.

We as a species seem doomed to repeat history on loop, like some sort of real life Ground Hog Day.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Chinjut on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:13AM (#35729366)
He's not called that in the book. People constantly say he is, with an air of authority, but go read it yourself. He's just called Jim. Not once is there any instance in the book where anyone takes his name to be anything other than Jim. I don't know where this popular misconception was invented.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by red-iron-pine on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:57AM (#35729994)
This is bait.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by digging on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:05PM (#35730168)
It's really disturbing to see people parroting this mistake, let alone calling your comment called "bait". His name is Jim.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lapetitejort on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:13PM (#35730302)
I checked here [0] and you are correct. There is one match for "n-- Jim", however the n-word is used as an adjective, not as part of a proper noun, similar to "your coworker Bob". Searching for just the n-word brings up over 200 usages, however.

[0]: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/32325/32325-h/32325-h.htm

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by disqard on Thursday April 27, 2023 @05:41PM (#35734982)
Nuance, discernment, and careful judgement don't scale.

Yet, we keep trying to build rules, societal norms, APIs (and now AIs) to try and achieve this at scale. And it always fails.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ThinkingGuy on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:45AM (#35728938)
I recall that verse being edited out on some radio stations even when it was new. The music video on MTV still had the full song.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by amalcon on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:23AM (#35729510)
That verse is also absent in two of their greatest hits albums, including the 1998 one.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by pierat on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:05AM (#35726802)
I would kindly recommend looking into Jellyfin. It's a FLOSS equivalent of Plex. (And unlike Plex, isn't closed source nagware on 'premium features')

But the rest I agree with.

And to your point, I just found a trove of rare 'banned' cartoons. Naturally, they're banned primarily for depictions of Japanese (WWII), and of black people in various degrading roles.

I do not take enjoyment in watching them. However, due to censorship, these could be lost. And that would be a bigger loss compared to their inherent lack of compassion.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ascagnel_ on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:03AM (#35728246)
I would love to move my Plex server to Jellyfin, but it's not yet at feature parity:

- PlexAmp is a much, much better tool for consuming music than the Jellyfin UI

- Prologue[0] is an app that hooks into your local Plex library to play audiobooks; Jellyfin has no equivalent that I'm aware of

- There's a general dearth of iOS and Android apps that support downloads/offline play that sync play progress back to the server

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ranbato on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:27AM (#35729562)
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jstarfish on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:47PM (#35732820)
> Naturally, they're banned primarily for depictions of Japanese (WWII), and of black people in various degrading roles. I do not take enjoyment in watching them. However, due to censorship, these could be lost. And that would be a bigger loss compared to their inherent lack of compassion.

Why do you feel this is worth preserving? It's designed to evoke positive emotion (laughter) and outrage/hatred about something we don't condone anymore. In addition to being propaganda, outside the context of warmongering, it's toxic.

We don't insist on archiving artifacts from smear campaigns between white politicians every election season. But we need to forever archive demeaning racist cartoons?

You'd have more of a case defending "Song of the South," which at least has artistic merit. We lose a musical experience with that one.

It's the "vampire" problem...immortality is not a good thing. Outdated/bad ideas are supposed to fade with the flow of time, not spread forever for later "research."

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by pierat on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:17PM (#35733201)
The counterexample is that some of us (including myself) are digital archivists.

I think it's worse in institutionally 'forgetting' via censorship, than to having that media.

I also think it would be improper to sell that content, as it'd be profiting on racism and sexism.

To the point, this set of files also included Fantasia, Songs of the South, WWII propaganda by Disney and Looney Tunes, and more.

Just because parts of history are horrific, does not mean we should self-censor and remove the uncomfortable parts from our collective memories. Frankly, these videos belong in a museum, or archive.org .

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by macNchz on Thursday April 27, 2023 @08:44AM (#35727194)
Sometimes these edits can be pretty subtle as well: a while ago my wife and I started watching the original early-90s Beverly Hills 90210 on one of the streaming platforms. It’s a kind of absurd and fun pop-cultural time capsule of a show. After a few episodes, though, I started to realize there was something not quite right.

It turns out that much of the music featured in the original airing of the show wasn’t licensed in a way it could be used long term, and over the years it has been replaced with terrible stock songs or jarringly anachronistic choices that sound totally out of place.

Entire scenes and episodes have been cut from the seasons distributed on streaming platforms, because they featured live concerts that couldn’t be edited. The original had performances by the Flaming Lips, among many others, that simply can’t be watched now, except if by chance someone copied an old VHS to YouTube.

Music was a big part of the original show–in addition to the live shows it featured all sorts of great pop songs from the time, which was part of why it was such a hit with teenagers when it aired. It’s such a bummer they stripped it all out!

There are some places online with copies of early DVD releases that have more music, but still not all of it. The original is locked away in a vault somewhere and almost certainly won’t ever be enjoyed in a complete state.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ryathal on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:14AM (#35727579)
So many shows are unavailable or different because of ridiculous licensing rules around music. Scrubs has several different versions of music, The Drew Carey Show is basically impossible to find because of music. If Congress wanted to ever do something pro-consumer, passing a law that ends all this nonsense around licensing and require all licensing to be delivery method agnostic. whether a show is premiering, a rerun, syndicated, streamed, or on DVD it should be the same show.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by cellularmitosis on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:11AM (#35729341)
“Adventures in good music” with Karl Hass is likely offline forever due to licensing issues, sadly.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by justinator on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:39AM (#35729728)
The State on MTV is one of these too. They had an interesting deal where they could use literally the entire MTV catalog of music for the show, but didn't have license to use any of it for distribution of the show afterwards. That made producing the show cheap, and up'd the quality since you'd have these hilariously scenes of mock teenage angst or whatever with REM's "Everybody Hurts" playing in the background. But in the long run, it sort of hurt a lot of careers of the comedians and much of the future work from them are themselves cult hits, but haven't really become part of the cultural fabric. Comedies like Wet Hot American Summer or Drop Dead Gorgeous or Super Troopers.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by kid64 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:18PM (#35730380)
I noticed lots of set decorations (posters, pictures, etc) are blurred out too. So incredibly sad.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by justinator on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:29PM (#35733353)
That's a bummer. Pirated episodes are as you would expect of very low quality, being taped from home almost 30 years ago.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ralphc on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:56PM (#35731046)
We can't forget WKRP in Cincinatti, which had so much good music of the time, and even referenced it in the show which made for some butchered edits.

The most egregious example is from the classic "Turkeys Away" episode, there was a whole joke about Pink Floyd's "Dogs" which Johnny Fever was playing at the time. In the edited version Mr. Carlson just walks out mid-conversation.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by tivert on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:30PM (#35732549)
> Scrubs has several different versions of music

Is there a list of the differences somewhere? I remember that show having a very good soundtrack.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by dragonwriter on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:37PM (#35732668)
> So many shows are unavailable or different because of ridiculous licensing rules around music.

Or, often, because the original production bought licenses imagining more limited uses than later distribution opportunities presented, and chose not to spend extra money for things they didn’t expect to need.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by sobkas on Friday April 28, 2023 @03:51PM (#35746255)
> So many shows are unavailable or different because of ridiculous licensing rules around music. Scrubs has several different versions of music, The Drew Carey Show is basically impossible to find because of music. If Congress wanted to ever do something pro-consumer, passing a law that ends all this nonsense around licensing and require all licensing to be delivery method agnostic. whether a show is premiering, a rerun, syndicated, streamed, or on DVD it should be the same show.

And everyone knows that answer will be: "nothing stops potential distributors from licensing music now and releasing originals, the fact they are not willing to pay is not copyright holders problem". And there's some truth to it, licensing costs back then were lower because they were time constrained. No one would pay more for broadly licensed music in throwaway series. No one knew they would have lasting impact on popculture.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by joncrocks on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:16AM (#35727605)
I think this is common in the move from TV to DVD.

From what I understand, TV broadcasts (at least in the US/UK) have a general/blanket exemption for copyrights w.r.t to things like music (RIAA). So no restriction when airing episodes, you can pick what music you like.

When looking to distribute DVDs however you have to get permission to use the music/pay for it. So it often gets changed.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by xdennis on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:26AM (#35727749)
Same for "Married... with Children". They replaced the iconic "Love and Marriage" theme song with elevator music.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by webXL on Friday April 28, 2023 @02:45PM (#35745416)
WTF? That's incredibly sad. Suddenly I'm interested in DVDs again.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by lazystar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:08AM (#35727505)
This same music licensing issue happened to Charmed as well. The opening credits theme is gone; the guest bands that played at the end of each episode are gone. A ton of late 90s early 2000s culture, just... gone. No one who watches that show today will ever understand why it was enjoyable to those who originally watched it.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by wink on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:32AM (#35728720)
Now I'm really wondering if they cut that from the German dubs, or if I didn't pay attention, or if I simply didn't watch enough episodes, or not in full.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by Kye on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:22AM (#35727699)
This happened with the original Queer As Folk as well. I never got to watch it in the original run, but I've heard the music at Babylon was carefully chosen, and nothing works the same without it.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by rightbyte on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:51AM (#35728102)
Try watching e.g. Friends without the top and bottom cut off, in a legal way.

I hate how the IP owners just can't resist messing up the culture.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by toast0 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:57AM (#35729114)
The DVDs are probably 4:3, right? Just gotta go to enough thrift stores...
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by rightbyte on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:15PM (#35730335)
Maybe. I haven't looked too hard. Just got pissed off by scenes being so much harder to follow.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by gamblor956 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:27AM (#35729563)
Part of my job involves reviewing IP licenses. We don't negotiate technical details like aspect ratios. (Some IP owners do, like Disney.)

The decision to mutilate Friends was made by a software engineer (working for the License) who couldn't be bothered to add black bars or convert ratios because "reasons."

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by rightbyte on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:16PM (#35730344)
Ok interesting. Ye I guess much of these thing happen at random really.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:26PM (#35730525)
The original was filmed in 1.33:1 then cropped down to 4:3.

For the streaming platforms, they chose to crop it the other way:

https://i.imgur.io/sbdIoxd_d.webp?maxwidth=640&shape=thumb&f...

IMO they should just split the difference and stream the full original 1.33:1 with (smaller) black bars.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by toast0 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:40PM (#35730750)
Showing the original film means showing things the director thought would be out of frame.

In the 90s, film directors would often consider both the cinema and TV ratios, but TV directors? I kind of doubt it; changing the framing might be interesting, but it's not a good way to show it, IHMO. Debates over overscan are fine, but if it wasn't part of the original broadcast, and wasn't part of the directors' intent to be shown, it shouldn't be part of any distribution.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by dragonwriter on Thursday April 27, 2023 @04:34PM (#35734156)
> The original was filmed in 1.33:1 then cropped down to 4:3.

It was filmed at 1.37:1. 1.33:1 would be almost indistinguishable from 4:3 (its 3.99:3)

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by bombcar on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:10AM (#35728332)
This happens to computer games as well.

>Poker Night at the Inventory was delisted from Steam on May 23rd, 2019. Although Telltale did not offer the same kind of explanation that they did regarding Poker Night 2, the game was likely delisted due to expired licensing of one or more of the properties featured in the game.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by jstarfish on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:04PM (#35732181)
And Grand Theft Auto.

Songs were ganked from GTA3: San Andreas, as well as GTA4 and its expansions.

I think in the latter case there might have been a couple replacements, but still.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by user3939382 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:23AM (#35728567)
This also happened to Northern Exposure. I have one of the only full copies in the world with the original music.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:53PM (#35732008)
Now I'm even more pissed at whoever stole my box set. I learned of a bunch of great music from that show.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by user3939382 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:52PM (#35732882)
Yeah that's what was so tragic, the music was an integral, unique part of the show. They replaced it with this bizarre elevator music.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by zcal on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:21PM (#35766732)
As a big fan of the show I'm curious how you know this. Do you have more information on the edition you own?
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by aimor on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:39AM (#35728853)
Also see: WKRC in Cincinnati, The Wonder Years, Beavis and Butthead

For these the loss of the original music was such an issue they eventually did (or attempted) to re-release with everything as it was. But don't trust things to always be like that. It holds for almost everything: if you want to keep something as-is the best thing is to store your own copy, second best is to rely on an archivist to store a copy but even that's risky.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ikiris on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:19AM (#35729442)
I understand this basically ruined a lot of the feel of Supernatural if you never saw it on air.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by freedomben on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:54AM (#35729965)
Same thing with Supernatural. Season one especially was a Classic Rock masterpiece, but when the show hit Netflix they had to replace all the music due to licensing. :-C
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by nyarlathotep_ on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:05PM (#35730167)
This is a disturbing form of digital gaslighting.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by seanalltogether on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:08AM (#35727503)
The music in Scrubs is pretty integral to the character of the show, but they had to change many of the songs for streaming, so the only way to watch the show as it was meant to be is from the dvds which will slowly disappear as demand for physical media dries up.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ascagnel_ on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:57AM (#35728182)
It's because, before TV on DVD became a major thing in the mid-00s, TV shows would get limited licenses rather than perpetual licenses as a way to keep costs down. Most episodes would air once or twice (its premiere, and a summer re-run), and if a show hit its 100th episode (at which point it became feasible to license it for syndication), the studio would renegotiate music licenses (and some popular shows never entered syndication because of a failure to renegotiate these licenses, while others, like The Wonder Years, entered syndication with radically altered soundtracks).

Once TV shows started to release on DVD in a big way, and then digitally a few years later, it became immediately obvious that shows would need longer music licenses, and so the issue has been solved for newer works.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by fallat on Thursday April 27, 2023 @10:26AM (#35728612)
> it is built into the nature of the system

I would love to see an elaboration. I think you're saying this because it's in their interest for wide appeal and so will adjust their "products" as necessary to please.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by justinator on Thursday April 27, 2023 @11:42AM (#35729775)
One place this didn't happen was on The Young Ones. Where would we be without The Damned playing Video Nasty, or Motörhead playing Ace of Spades?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J2H_7LY5LqM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YOAz4nPNvLI

Funnily they had musical guests so that they could sell the show as a variety show, and get the funding to do something so silly.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by listenallyall on Thursday April 27, 2023 @12:29PM (#35730572)
Spielberg is "worried" about it, in part, because he did it himself. In later releases of E.T.: The Exta-Terrestrial, Spielberg edited a crucial scene so that it no longer showed police officers pointing guns at a group of children (among other changes).

It's a good sign that he has publicly acknowledged that the edits were a mistake and the original theatrical version of E.T. is available.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by nicenewtemp84 on Thursday April 27, 2023 @01:21PM (#35731462)
It's honestly amazing how many of my saved favorites list on YouTube goes missing years later. I know make sure to download any video I want to be able to watch again. Because between creators changing style, getting worried, going away, or getting stricken down by YouTube bots, it seems like anything worth watching won't actually be available to watch 3 years later.
Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by KETpXDDzR on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:11PM (#35733128)
A friend of mine recently made that experience. Her Amazon account got stolen, Amazon didn't care, and now she lost access to all movies and books she "owned".

Fortunately, with the rise of Z-Library, I was able to recover her books (she already paid for them, so I'm ok with downloading it from such a shady source).

I guess we have to fall back to piracy if we want to stay in control.

Re:Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on mo... by ksec on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:47AM (#35753378)
>The fact that even guys as influential as Spielberg and Tarantino are worried about having their past work censored

So I guess HN, or most Americans ( East or West End ) can now finally agree this is a serious problem?

I still remember in 2019 and even in 2021, HN's majority position was that people were too focused on culture war and this is only the minority of people who cares about it.