Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by rich_sasha on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:47AM
(#50363253)
This one is allegedly/hopefully a bug but just waiting for it to become a revenue stream / paywall. Uh oh, you want to run locally your dangerous illegal foreign open models, not licensed by Nvidia? Can’t work with you paying for a special security feature unlock on your GPU.
Or maybe just not at all - shell out for OAI tokens and send us all your data - your privacy is very valuable to us and we will make sure to be the only ones to monetize it.
You could say, Nvidia is selling pickaxes and has no business gatekeeping what rocks you hit with it, but I guess it depends on their relationships with major mining companies, and ultimately what pays more.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by hypfer on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:50AM
(#50363277)
Why does the title say DGX spark when the link is the RTX Spark laptop?
Those are very different things as far as I understand, and the whole "doesn't work well with linux" really only makes sense on the RTX Spark laptop I think?
Isn't the DGX spark linux by default?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by teiferer on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:06AM
(#50363897)
Enumerating 3 things really ..sparks a comment nowadays? Doing that as a rhetorical device has been a thing for generations and of course LLMs mimic it because it is everywhere in their training data.
I just heard a quick J. Talarico speech at some country concert. In the 10 or so sentences he spoke, he had 3 or 4 instances of doing this "Claudism" enumeration. Are you saying Texas just elected Claude for Senate?
Maybe we should stop with such superficial judgements. It's the modern equivalent of not liking the speaker's tie. (Doesn't mean the speaker's speech is good, but it doesn't mean it's bad either.)
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by fxwin on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:35AM
(#50364193)
There are more Claude-isms in there than just rule of three (Hence -isms and not -ism), and while I'd generally agree that we generally shouldn't be superficial with our judgements, this particular heuristic has served me pretty well so far.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by geoffhill on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:54AM
(#50364878)
Please be aware that you have been the target of foreign anti-AI influence campaigns. Your comment history makes it clear they have had a strong negative effect on you.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by officeplant on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:18PM
(#50369443)
Please be aware that you have been the target of national AI influence campaigns. Your comment history makes it clear they have had a strong negative effect on you.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by K0balt on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:09AM
(#50363457)
The attack on reverse engineering of games is a precursor to universal computing lockdown. When you need AI to keep up with programming, the entity controlling the AI controls what software is possible to create. It’s a bid for centralised control and thought censorship at a scale and depth much more ambitious than anything we have ever seen before.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by solyin on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:17AM
(#50363505)
Not everyone grew up in a situation where home was a stable dependable place. Not everyone has a home to go to. If you have it with you, they can't mess with it when you're not there. If you grew up in a broken home, you would understand.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by c7b on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:58AM
(#50364931)
Local AI is an expensive hobby. You're paying big money for small performance (so mainly for the feeling of "owning it", which is a great motivator). It can't match cloud services, not absolutely nor bang-for-buck, especially if you look a bit for cheaper and freebie options. As someone who loves and promotes local AI, in the situation you described my plea would be to use that money to improve your situation more directly (move out, get support,...). The cost of a laptop that can run somewhat decent models should buy you at least several months of therapy (@1 session/week).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by c7b on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:52AM
(#50365518)
If you want local AI, which I absolutely encourage you to, I agree with the OP. Get a (mini)-PC and set up a VPN. It's going to save you money compared to a laptop, short- (usually cheaper) and long-term (usually better upgradeability). You'll have more money for therapy, which I would also encourage you to consider if you come from a broken home, as the GP mentioned.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by c7b on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:00AM
(#50366496)
Maybe you're responding to the wrong thread. The discussion was about laptop vs PC for local AI, which should be pretty equivalent from the perspective of Anthropic, in the context of a broken home. Read the previous chain and calm down.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Gigachad on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:32PM
(#50371861)
The situation we are talking about here is someone with no fixed home or insecure housing. That kind of person likely isn’t even paying for cloud AI, let alone buying massively overpriced hardware to run it locally.
The market for someone who wants local AI in a laptop for $10k has to be tiny.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by barrkel on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:24AM
(#50365212)
If the security of your home possessions is an issue, it should be addressed first before you spend thousands on a very stealable laptop that you need to carry everywhere.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by pixelpoet on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:18AM
(#50363509)
I have been saying this for years, and the answer hits a nerve that gets you downvoted into oblivion: people prefer the aesthetics of laptops, simple as that. They will absolutely go to the grave arguing that they need the mobility etc, then just leave it plugged in. They simply prefer how laptops look, and they absolutely hate it when someone dares say it.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by monegator on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:43AM
(#50363716)
I have a laptop for work. 95% of the time i'd prefer a tower or at least a mini PC with proper cooling, but that remaining 5% i have to be around with the laptop is enough. I don't like the idea of having to remember to sync the projects every time (especially while i'm in the middle of testing something new so it's not like i can just pull the latest commit or sync the latest good version of something)
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by DaSHacka on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:08PM
(#50370810)
A laptop that is so beefy it can even run GLM 5.3 locally (while sounding like a jet engine, being as bulky as an old-school travelling briefcase, and having a 1.5 hour battery life) though?
GGP's point is just: keep the bulk of your compute at home, where airflow and energy is cheaper (in an opportunity-cost sense). Keep the laptop portable, cool, and light, with long battery life by offloading your own computing tasks to your own hardware.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by pixelpoet on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:57AM
(#50365574)
100% agreed, and people saying they need a laptop are missing the point; I wasn't saying don't use laptops, either.
The simple point I'm always trying to make is that area vs volume is a fundamental physical difference regarding cooling, which is critical for high performance applications (that's why they're considering an RTX Spark in the first place, right?).
There's so much more I could say about my Strix Halo machine, which fits in the palm of my hand and I have a wonderful portable screen and keyboard+touchpad (and only cost me 2k with 128 GB fast memory, idles at 4w, amazing 32 thread Zen 5 CPU with AVX-512, ...), but it's either preaching to the choir or pissing against the wind.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by close04 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:59AM
(#50363836)
> why anyone would want to do inference on a laptop
Because reviewers tell them this is is a good use case, and people want to take advantage of the HW they buy [0]. Unfortunately those reviewers didn't take any extra step to validate anything beyond the default config, out of the box.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by barrkel on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:18AM
(#50365148)
Exactly. Get yourself a DGX spark and plug it in at home.
I meanwhile, run my ridiculously OP workstation class hardware as a server - 9995wx, 768GiB, rtx pro 6000 w/ 96GiB vram - at home, and my Asus ZenBook is light, cool, and long-lived.
Runs GLM 5.3 flash at 35 tok/sec while consuming only 15 GiB VRAM, and I can run a lot more stuff on there alongside.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by jacquesm on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:30AM
(#50367002)
That's slower than I would have expected for the RTX 6000, do you have figures for say Qwen 3.8 27B? That model fits completely on the card, that should push it a lot further.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by barrkel on Thursday November 05, 2026 @08:47AM
(#50379014)
I'm pretty certain I can get it to go faster by caching experts and whatnot (with experimental llama.cpp branches), but that would consume a lot more VRAM and it's fast enough as it is for playing around with, and I can leave it always loaded. It's like 50% CPU inference, with a few layers + router + kv cache on the GPU.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by entrope on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:39AM
(#50365363)
Your prompts and whatever data they collect from your dev environment go to the inference provider, and typically the customer has neither control nor assurance over what the inference provider (re-)uses that data for.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by anonym29 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:46AM
(#50365445)
GP isn't proposing using closed proprietary models over an API, they're proposing having local hardware serving open weight models at your house/apartment being remotely accessible through an overlay network like Tailscale. The idea being that local inference is very hungry for power and thermal budget, so you run the inference somewhere that power and thermal headroom is abundant (your house/apartment, on a tower, or dedicated unified memory boxes like DGX Spark, Strix Halo, Mac Studio, etc) and then remotely utilize that inference from a regular laptop. You still get all of the benefits of local, private AI inference, without having to expend a laptop's limited power and thermal budget on doing the inference on the laptop itself.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by spaceywilly on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:51AM
(#50366322)
On the contrary I think in a few years most inference will be done locally. The smaller models have been slowly catching up to frontier for many tasks, and chips are being developed to run large models on phones and laptops (according to Qualcomm CEO they want to run 10T weights on a mobile chip).
To me the simple answer to why is control. If I run a model locally I get to control the model params, the system prompt, all of it. And of course there is no quota. But probably most importantly I am not tied to paying some company a monthly subscription forever.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by K0balt on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:05AM
(#50363422)
Wtf. Are we actually seeing a push towards being 100percent dependent on the cloud?
Sovereign AI has never been more important.
Controlling AI is so much more powerful and impactful than controlling search or social algorithms.
Centralized AI a 10x on social control over everything we have seen before, and there is no way that a free and open society survives contact with centralised, high capability AI if the system is manipulated towards guiding outcomes. It’s essentially mind control, as people will offload an even greater share of their cognition to AI than they do with search and social.
Build and maintain sovereign AI while you still can.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by InsidiousWombat on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:08AM
(#50363445)
NVIDIA probably already figured out that local will be massive part and are preparing to do DRM for AI.
Pay up for license to unlock full capacity, pay up for license to use encrypted models from AI moguls, paid per billion tokens processed or just operations in GPU
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by bayindirh on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:49AM
(#50365481)
That's older than current AI/LLM/NVIDIA wave. Many application specific DSPs probably carry their model weights in an encrypted manner. If not, we would have seen the extremely performant face recognition and tracking models extracted from professional cameras already.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by AlAjem on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:38AM
(#50363669)
I don't see the case for DRM protected local models on either side.
The consumer has access to free and open models for local use.
The supplier has better control and wider market to serve running the models in data centers.
Only way I can see encrypted models being widespread is if they are bundled as part of a software package (OS/Browser/etc) and not sold as the product.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by bri3d on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:51AM
(#50368289)
There are plenty of both transformer and non-LLM "edge" models that aren't free and open - think anything that ships in consumer electronics. Vendors usually want this IP protected.
And, the same GPUs are run in datacenter, where there's a big insider risk that vendors want to mitigate with encrypted models (if you're Anthropic and you want AWS to host your models, you don't want 5000 or even 500 or even 50 AWS employees with access to your highly valuable/desirable model weights).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by bayindirh on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:54AM
(#50365553)
It's not their first rodeo. Their cards already need to authenticate with the driver to be enable the card completely. When I last checked, Nouveau driver has received a key which only enabled the hardware, allowing enough features to see a desktop and install closed NVIDIA drivers, nothing more.
NVIDIA is holding to its pearls like a sloth holding to its branch, because their all business model and livelihood is dependent on that control. I still commend AMD's decision to allow full card enablement with any driver which talks the correct language.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by motbus3 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:00AM
(#50363845)
Years ago I would think I was being paranoid to think they would patch hardware retroactively to make it slower so you need to pay more to use your own hardware.
In 2026, I think this is what all car companies are doing after you pay the full car price.
I don't see a reason why they wouldn't do it with so little competition
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by somat on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:22AM
(#50364067)
It smells like something IBM would do. Coming from small computers where you own it, I was flabbergasted to learn that IBM would ship additional processors and ram with their mainframes but you were not allowed to use them until you paid the additional license fee.
So it is something that has been done for a long time now. Still feels like unethical rent-seeking that should not be tolerated by the customer.
See Also: car companies that charge additional fees for hardware already on the car. Additional services, I sort of understand(remote start via cell network), but stuff like heated seats, that is just wrong.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by mschuster91 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:36AM
(#50364727)
> See Also: car companies that charge additional fees for hardware already on the car. Additional services, I sort of understand(remote start via cell network), but stuff like heated seats, that is just wrong.
It saves the car manufacturer on logistics cost. The per-unit cost of a seat heater is (much) smaller than the cost related to keeping two variants of seat in stock and to provide spare parts. Say the heating mat costs 100€ per seat including materials and installation, and can be sold to the customer for 400€ permanent, that means as long as 1 in 4 customers buys the seat heating option, the books are balanced, and all money you save on logistics is pure profit.
Adding subscription on top of that is financially even better, if there is one thing companies LOVE thanks to stonk market incentives it is monthly recurring revenue.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by somat on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:17PM
(#50370909)
It's slimy as hell, A person buys a thing, they now own it. However there is a locked box, with no key. The manufacture sells the key to this box for an additional fee. To unlock a thing they already own.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by podocarp on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:29AM
(#50365255)
Databases licencing per core is the most ridiculous thing I've heard for me. In this case they have zero marginal cost and still charge you for it. Hilarious.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by graemep on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:25AM
(#50365955)
> In this case they have zero marginal cost and still charge you for it.
A license has zero marginal cost in the first place. Software distribution over networks have a negligible marginal cost. An ebook as zero margin cost. We are constantly paying lots of things with zero or negligible marginal cost.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by xhkkffbf on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:36AM
(#50368073)
These deals aren't as slimy as they look. Yes, there's no marginal cost, but the goal is to spread out the costs as evenly as possible with the companies using the software. Setting the price per core just means that the companies that might do more processing shoulder more of the software cost. (And, yes, it's another way to gouge companies. But it's gouging based on use.)
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by graemep on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:13PM
(#50368571)
Not necessarily slimy. The problem is that there is no clear right pricing where there is no marginal cost - makes it hard to decide whether the pricing if fair or not.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by duskdozer on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:13AM
(#50363960)
Yes? How is this at all surprising given....everything we've seen tech companies push for for years and years? People are fully embedding themselves and their workflows in the services of big, closed companies, and are going to be surprised when they finally feel able to clamp down? There has been warning sign after warning sign, but people are only increasing their dependence.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by boltzmann64 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:16AM
(#50363996)
The reason why open source couldn't win search and social was because they need network effects which is not possible for open source maintainers.
AI is a software just like operating systems and executables where open source absolutely dominates the industry. Remember when the compiler engineers optimized the shit out of llama.cpp.
Right now the bottleneck for AI software is compute and data. Moore's law is give us compute, StackOverflow, arXiv (and it's children like bioRxiv), gutenberg and others (3lib, anna, internet.org) will give us data.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by torben-friis on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:29AM
(#50364151)
>Right now the bottleneck for AI software is compute and data. Moore's law is give us compute, StackOverflow, arXiv (and it's children like bioRxiv), gutenberg and others (3lib, anna, internet.org) will give us data.
Tons of stuff happenning behind closed doors today though. No more stackoverflow for the next decade, that could create a problem if all new context only exists in chatgpt conversations only openAI has access to (or whoever).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Helmut10001 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:57AM
(#50364369)
Wait until the archives are compromised and millions of people's conversation and uploaded data are published. Such context was never before accessible in that scale, but it will become accessible soon, I am pretty sure.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by oblio on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:50AM
(#50368282)
> It's a waiting game. Open source always wins.
Based on... what? Thoughts and prayers? Feelings? Vibes?
I don't know if you looked around but open source is basically unusable for the largest platform in the world, mobile.
The next platform, whatever that is, will also be closed source (maybe VR, once it finally matures...).
LLMs are closed source, is there even 1 (ONE) LLM which is both open source and open weights and publishes its training data and methodology and is also remotely competitive with the frontier lab LLMs?
Consoles are closed source. Appliances are closed source. Embedded devices are closed source.
Even the web is basically closed source. Blobs of encrypted, obfuscated JS used to serve news pages (!).
Maybe I'm looking in the wrong places, but closed source has won.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by oblio on Thursday November 05, 2026 @01:58AM
(#50376019)
If you think I've been on HN for more than a decade and I don't know what Android is, you're sorely mistaken. And if you think you somehow managed to reply to my comment with a "gotcha", you go digging into what Android really is made of and get back to me.
And regarding servers, who cares? The platforms users interact with are their clients and the actual server software on top of the Linux OS is closed source 99% of the time.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by GuB-42 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:18AM
(#50364018)
No, we are just seeing a push towards Nvidia wanting to make money.
Nothing stops you from giving Nvidia half a million for their latest and greatest AI GPUs, unless you are in China I guess, but China does very well despite the export control.
It is just classic market segmentation, the thing Nvidia and just about every company that can benefit from it has done for decades. Cloud providers are ready to pay a lot of money, consumers wanting local AI have a lower budget, and gamers even lower. But a low budget is greater than zero, and there is still money to be made on these markets. But they also don't want to compete against themselves, so they are going to find ways of crippling enterprise-class workloads on consumer hardware.
It used to be that they crippled high precision arithmetic on consumer hardware, because it was a differentiating factor, but AI doesn't care about high precision, so now, it is something else.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by sidewndr46 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:45AM
(#50364283)
Given the history of prohibition in the past few centuries, it wouldn't surprise me if it is much easier to buy Nvidia products in China than in the US. The price is much higher most likely, but the actual transaction is likely easier.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by embedding-shape on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:15AM
(#50364534)
Unless the US somehow differs from the EU in some major ways, can't you just walk into a store and buy a NVIDIA GPU? Not sure how much easier it can get. And yes, it's as easy in China to, walk into store, point at GPU, fork over the money, you get your GPU. Like everywhere else, except the US I suppose?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by CamperBob2 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:12PM
(#50370166)
Yes and no. Yes, you can still buy high-end prosumer Blackwell hardware at retail in the US, but not without going through a KYC process that didn't exist a couple of months ago. The writing is on the proverbial wall.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Schlagbohrer on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:05AM
(#50365013)
I can't wait until we have real competition against NVIDIA, whether it is from a Chinese chip maker or someone else. Hopefully then these kinds of intentional crippling of hardware/firmware will be avoidable by buying an equivalent product from another firm.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by podocarp on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:25AM
(#50365221)
Even for things like the huawei ascend, what makes them crap for price to perf I think is still dram. They actually cost more than nvidia clusters last I checked. Just like how regular laptops and phones are now being squeezed upwards to become closer (and uncompetitive with) apple devices.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by FuriouslyAdrift on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:51AM
(#50366316)
AMD has been #1 for HPC and #2 in AI for a very long while. The currently shipping Helios systems go toe to toe with nVidia's next gen that aren't even shipping, yet (by nVidias own numbers).
These are multi-million dollar datacenter systems, not consumer. If you mean the consumer market, it's coming but it's going to be 2028-29 most likely (if the bubbled hasn't popped by then).
Strix Point is quite good but not the same thing as a DGX, though. Same idea, different methodology.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by smallmancontrov on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:42AM
(#50368174)
AMD's "datacenter HPC without consumer HPC" strategy was one of the biggest corporate whiffs in history. If AMD had taken consumer GPGPU seriously at any point in the decade leading up to LLM takeoff, they wouldn't have had to stand on the sidelines for years as NVDA charged 80% margin on matrix multiplication. They could have had 1/2 or even 1/1 market cap compared to NVDA. Instead, they have a tenth, and even that's largely grace in the forward looking estimations.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Fr0styMatt88 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:16PM
(#50370219)
Haha that’s been the AMD story when it comes to graphics in general.
I miss the old days when they released enthusiast products like the R9 295X2. Though that’s just the gaming enthusiast market in general declining (not that this happened organically though, it feels like a deliberate choice).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by FuriouslyAdrift on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:07PM
(#50370797)
It's less AMD not doing commercial GPGPU than nVidia completely staying out of the PC and server market. Remember AMD competes with both of them (nVidia and Intel) and is smaller than both.
AMDs revenue this quarter just passed Intels for the first time in history and they still are dominating in the HPC market which is fairly immune to the AI bubble (while also selling everything they can build at a high premium to AI datacenters).
AMDs margins on their Instinct datacenter GPUs is nearly as good as nVidia's. They just can't get contract volume at TSMC to make more because nVidia buys all of it.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by giwook on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:51AM
(#50366326)
> but China does very well despite the export control
They're still getting plenty of Nvidia GPUs. Someone in Jensen Huang's inner circle apparently runs a number of companies in Singapore that have been found to source GPUs at scale. The catch is that she has close ties to Beijing and is suspected of working closely with their government, potentially even spying for them.
This was reported just a week or two ago and is just one example of how China is still getting their hands on resources they're supposedly unable to get.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by zelphirkalt on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:05PM
(#50371517)
There are so many ways trade goes in and out of China, and so many trading partners, I think it is next to impossible to prevent them from getting what they want, if they are willing to spend the money.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by K0balt on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:16AM
(#50413028)
You are surely correct in the base motivation. There is a problem though, and I’m not sure what the name for it is, or if there is even a mature conceptual framework for it: opportunistic enclosure.
Social processes that pull towards freedom tend to be low investment, chaotic, individualistic processes; usually just working within the voids between enclosed spaces. There are projects of significant complexity working in these spaces, but they tend to be focused on their individual goals rather than the preservation of those voids.
Social processes that pull towards structural control, in contrast, tend to be well organised, funded, and focused mostly on exerting that control as a means to further some other goal.
With a high diversity of strategic actors and their highly divergent goals, almost any movement in a space of technological change can be seen as an opportunity to implement a ratchet that encloses more ground in the service of commercial or political vision. The end result is creeping enclosure of every active commons, while the expansion of opportunities occurs only at the frontiers of technology or in the abandoned areas with minimal commercial value (until they become revitalised, at least)
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by hsuduebc2 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:49AM
(#50364315)
This is classical move from Nvidia. They are doing similiar bullshits on their GPUs for decades. I'm very much looking forwars for their competition to rise.
I do not understand this play. This means that only hyperscalers or someone who purchased a licence can use Spark?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by FartyMcFarter on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:09AM
(#50364485)
> Are we actually seeing a push towards being 100percent dependent on the cloud?
[Hanlon's Razor] This is such a contrived performance drop scenario that I find it hard to believe it was done with the purpose you're inferring.
If anything I'd be more inclined to interpret this as Nvidia not caring that much about Linux once again, rather than anything to do with local vs cloud.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by keybrd-intrrpt on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:16PM
(#50372281)
> I'd interpret this as Nvidia not caring that much about Linux desktops/laptops once again
Even that argument is weak - the DGX Spark is Linux, and the RTX Spark is practically the same exact chip.
Sorry to remind people of HN, but most of the consumer market still runs Windows. This was a joint project to have a consumer-level Windows-on-ARM machine, likely requiring lots of development efforts from both NVIDIA and Microsoft.
So, for these specific laptops, they put 100% of their attention for it to be on Windows for launch to capture as much market mindshare as they can. Local AI, Graphics and creative work, and some gaming.
I doubt Microsoft would have been happy about NVIDIA having Linux on their laptop right at launch.
Market Share by OS for consumer laptops & desktops:
• Windows: 76.65%
• OS X / macOS (Combined): ~15.67% (OS X at 9.86% + macOS at 5.81% due to user-agent reporting quirks)
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by embedding-shape on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:16AM
(#50364540)
No, when people talk about building software they tend to mean building software. Just like "putting together my own training hardware" doesn't imply you're creating your own wafers from sand.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by f6v on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:47AM
(#50364826)
But the original post was about a hardware vendor getting in the way. It's pointless to talk about "sovereign AI" when all you do is run GLM on Nvidia.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by lcampbell on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:30AM
(#50367000)
To make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe.
Sovereign AI is less about being able to build it from first principles and more about being able to tinker and modify what already exists. I can’t train a 30B model, but I can modify the weights of one. I can’t fab my own chips, but I can putter with the software that interfaces with them.
Sovereignty is lost when encryption hides your toys and attestation tells you “you may not”.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by embedding-shape on Thursday November 05, 2026 @10:15AM
(#50380138)
> Look, China has sovereign AI because they can train on Huawei GPUs.
But those servers most likely use CPUs not made in China, if I were to hazard a guess, doesn't that mean that that AI isn't "truly sovereign" in your mind then?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by rkozik1989 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:32AM
(#50365292)
Yes, we are, the amount of data centers being built doesn't make sense for long-term model improvements. They are definitely planning on licensing us terminals to use instead of our own PCs at the very least as a backup plan if the frontier companies fail and have assets liquidated.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by itsmeduncan on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:20AM
(#50366839)
This isn't as hyperbolic as people think. This is a continuation of the centralized control of data + products. Not having sovereign AI is just enabling the enshiftification of the next innovation. We let ads win, we let data mining/centralization win... can we not let 3p AI win?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by nonethewiser on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:51AM
(#50367331)
>Wtf. Are we actually seeing a push towards being 100percent dependent on the cloud?
This is a linux driver proble. On laptops designed for windows.
Read the article and stop sensationalizing.
This is a problem on the MSI Prestige laptop using the RTX Spark platform. Lets assume it also applies to the Asus and Dell machines using RTX spark. It isn't an issue with RTX spark desktops.
RTX Spark is a new platform and all of these laptops ship with Windows. You cant get Linux on any of these machines from the factory. There is also precedent for NVIDIA shipping linux support well after Windows (2 years in the case of Dynamic Boost, a similar power sharing feature).
Kindly remove this from your list of "Evidence that NVIDIA is Colluding to Centralize Inference" and everyone else take note of this confirmation bias in action.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by advael on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:24PM
(#50369535)
I dunno about colluding to centralize inference, but "we encrypted the power firmware and only gave microsoft the keys" certainly reads as colluding to keep people on windows artificially
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by advael on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:48PM
(#50371288)
Yes, it seems a lot of companies can make a lot of money from fuckery like controlling what their customers can do with the devices they sell and deliberately sabotaging those devices for some customers via this control. What's your point? Am I supposed to support any practice a company can find a way to make money off of?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by nomel on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:21PM
(#50371726)
> What's your point?
That them trying to protect IP around something very profitable isn't crazy. That not being fully supported in Linux, when the product was literally designed around Windows, also isn't crazy or really evidence of anything, including evil (see the whole fucking history of Linux compatibility of made-for-Windows hardware).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by advael on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:49PM
(#50372033)
In general, the history of linux compatibility for nvidia specifically has been the research and open-source communities dragging them kicking and screaming into compliance while they do significant work to prevent compatibility via fuckery
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by rcxdude on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:25PM
(#50373367)
This kind of thing is far better at locking down the average user than preventing competitors from reverse engineering what they're doing. (much like DRM is pretty good at stopping your average consumer from doing what they want with their media but pretty bad at stopping the pirates getting access to the same content).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Peaches4Rent on Thursday November 05, 2026 @03:15AM
(#50376534)
Boo hoo. The biggest, most leather jacketest company in the world decides it can't maintain a Linux firmware. The same thing it's entire server system depends on. Omg why would that be??
It obviously can't be because of ulterior motives!
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Matl on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:25PM
(#50369545)
> This is a linux driver problem. On laptops designed for windows.
No. It's 'the NVidia way or the highway' problem. NVidia is so full of themselves they refuse to work under anyone's rules (i.e. the Linux kernel where they're constantly trying to work around them).
They're egomaniacs who are so full of themselves, riding high on the AI bubble, they think they're above everyone else in the ecosystem, while utilising all kinds of other people's work for their own benefit.
Look at the way they develop their 'open' Linux drivers where it's just a shim that loads a huge binary blob off the GPU rather than a proper driver like amdgpu has.
Meanwhile they wouldn't be a $5T company without Linux and the wider FLOSS ecosystem.
It's kind of like when Secure Boot debuted and the plan was to allow only Windows with it enabled, then no doubt someone would claim the fact that only Windows can boot with it enabled as a 'Linux driver problem'.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by shevy-java on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:23PM
(#50370308)
Where do you see "sensationalizing"? His analysis is very right: these companies prioritize windows over linux. That's a factual statement. Same with the collusion. This is a de-facto cartel.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by user01237123674 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:01PM
(#50370731)
To be honest, your comment is a perfect demonstration of how big corporations control public opinion by instrumentalizing people like you. Unless, of course, you work for NVIDIA.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by saidnooneever on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:54PM
(#50371376)
not being able to read something which is encrypted is not a driver problem. do u expect the driver to crack the encryption? or guess the key?
nvidia has always been crap like this. Look at amd and intel, they let u write proper drivers (even if its real difficult to do so). No encrypted blobs or voodoo needed.
the nvidia drivers u need to use a card on Linux are unintelligible binary blobs. thats sad as it is.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by ErroneousBosh on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:20PM
(#50371707)
> This is a problem on the MSI Prestige laptop using the RTX Spark platform and Linux. Lets assume it also applies to the Asus and Dell machines using RTX spark and Linux.
Is the problem one that could be easily countered by assuming that laptops are generally better when they're not on fire?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by lp92 on Thursday November 05, 2026 @09:17AM
(#50379344)
This is like any other driver compatibility problem with Linux. There's tons of laptops that don't have WiFi support out of the box on Linux for example.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by jleask on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:19AM
(#50363520)
Nvidia doing what Nvidia has always done; proprietary closed drivers. Weird choice to cryptographically protect the power settings. Key problem is that we've allowed a company that's always been this way to form a monopoly. Other brands exist, perhaps it is now worth the effort to migrate and rebuild elsewhere.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by jack_pp on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:01AM
(#50364401)
they could make money that way right now but they figured out they can make even more money by doing this. but jokes on them, people will figure it out, unlock / jailbreak and they just lose good will long term
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by bigyabai on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:34PM
(#50369666)
And people keep coming back. Myself included; there's no similar GPU products from AMD, Apple or Intel.
Nvidia won because their architecture is better. If you do a significant amount of work that can be CUDA-accelerated, you're kinda wasting your time not owning a CUDA-capable card. It's like being a video editor that software-encodes their projects because they don't want to get an accelerator card. It's your choice, but software-acceleration is a nightmare compared to how quick and efficient hardware-acceleration is. Competitors will all use the accelerator card and ship faster than you can.
Apple, AMD and Intel have all earned their current position by abandoning Khronos and refusing to build their own GPGPU architecture. If the entire industry refuses to invest in complex technology just because it's expensive, then they don't deserve to make money.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by kllrnohj on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:35AM
(#50366092)
that seems really hard to believe? If you wanted this running Linux in a data center you'd have just been buying the cheaper and yet also more powerful DGX Sparks.
The only value proposition of RTX Spark at all is the laptop form factor
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by kllrnohj on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:57AM
(#50366430)
Nvidia's MSRP is full of shit and has been for a long time. You see it with desktop GPUs all the time, even before the AI boom, where Nvidia would make up an MSRP but not offer a card at that price themselves, and none of the AIBs would, either, except for some token amount that rapidly sold out and were never restoked.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by jasomill on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:09AM
(#50366651)
The minimum configuration appears to be 24GB / 18 core, which at least one vendor, Microsoft, is selling for $2,599.99, which is at least closer to $2,399 than $3,000+.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by jasomill on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:05AM
(#50366599)
If datacenters aren't lining up to buy 64GB DGX Sparks for $5,000, what makes you think they'd be interested in 24GB RTX Sparks with fewer cores and less attractive form factors for almost half that?
And if there's a market for a DGX Spark configuration with a higher compute-to-RAM ratio, why isn't Nvidia offering it?
My best guess is that the entry-level Sparks are mostly intended for people who would otherwise be in the market for a traditional high-end laptop, who might be enticed to spend a few hundred more for at least the promise of local AI, while the higher-end models are intended for more serious AI development.
With that said, it's not hard to imagine there isn't nearly as large a built-in market for high-end SFF Linux PCs as there is for high-end Windows laptops.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Roark66 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:49AM
(#50366304)
No sane perse would buy dgx spark for datacenter. If you need Blackwell for the native nvfp4 you'd be better buying pallets of rtx5060 ti 16GB. Or if you don't, pallets of used rtx3090s.
In fact I'm pretty sure it's happening. Why? Because of constantly growing prices of those things.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by kllrnohj on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:53AM
(#50366345)
Sure, but if you think it's insane to buy a DGX Spark for a datacenter, then it's equally insane to buy an RTX Spark (which is the exact same SoC just with less networking and a screen) for the datacenter.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Roark66 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:36AM
(#50366102)
Not those laptops.
I was genuinely excited about this device until I heard the specs. Still under 300GB/s memory bandwidth when a gpu like rtx3090 from 6 years ago had 900+
This is really bread crumbing local inference users.
We should be measuring our memory bandwidth in TB by now. The only company that seems to be serious about this is Apple. (the m5 ultra studio etc).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by jasomill on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:54AM
(#50366368)
If this were cost-effective, why wouldn't they just buy DGX Sparks, with similar performance at similar price points and a more convenient form factor?
Or RTX Spark and run their workloads under WSL, which as the article notes, has minimal overhead relative to running Linux directly?
This sounds more like a bug than a feature, especially given that Linux on battery runs at full clock speed and downclocks when plugged in, and Windows does the opposite, suggesting they could at least mitigate the problem with no changes to their software stack by inverting a conditional in the firmware and adding a Linux kernel parameter to control memory allocation as apparently already exists for Windows.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by afarah1 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:55AM
(#50364358)
New generations such as Blackwell have open source kernel modules, there is not even a proprietary option. I thought there was a move in this direction?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by NekkoDroid on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:49AM
(#50364837)
The total linux-firmware-nvidia package uncompressed (outer, the firmware blobs are also compressed on top of that) is ~160MB (Mb would be Megabit), with the biggest individual compressed blob being ~50MB.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by kllrnohj on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:32AM
(#50366056)
Nvidia enabled that by offloading stuff that used to be in the proprietary driver onto the still proprietary GPU firmware. Making it, if anything, less open source as it's now harder to inspect what it's doing at runtime since it's now out of reach of even the kernel
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by tancop on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:36AM
(#50367092)
It's "we" as a society. Not pushing our governments to pass laws that could make Nvidia open up its hardware. Of course it's not your fault or mine, the problem is money in politics and uneducated voters.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by ion_trapper on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:19PM
(#50371704)
As we speak, there are numerous projects being worked on that you have no idea will be immensely useful to you in 10 years, and the people who are working on these projects are more likely than not motivated by the potential of future profit. 10 years from now, when you have recognized the value of these projects, you will take them for granted and demand you get them for free. CUDA was one of those projects 10 years ago. “We” can choose to start the precedent of scavanging CUDA today, but the price will be that those projects 10 years down the road won’t materialize.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by r3trohack3r on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:45AM
(#50365437)
> Key problem is that we've allowed a company that's always been this way to form a monopoly.
I don’t think anyone “allowed” them - quite the opposite. They’ve made generational bets that ended up being right, bets that IIRC the industry did not agree with for a long time. Them pursuing CUDA resulted in a draw down of something crazy like 75% of their valuation. They bet the farm multiple times to get to the point they are - and it’s only “obvious” in hindsight.
If you want folks to make generational bets as a matter of course (which I think most folks do), centralizing the downside of those bets and socializing the upside of those bets is not a great strategy. Almost as bad as socializing the downside.
Competition will eventually close that gap. We’re only a few years into this thing.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by krapht on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:31PM
(#50368799)
I know NVIDIA is dominating the market, but it's not like AMD/Intel/Google don't have credible alternatives. Hipify/OneAPI/MLIR(Jax etc) can be used today, it's just not as ergonomic as CUDA.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by totetsu on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:15AM
(#50363986)
I'm starting to feel empathy with those people who think bus lanes are coming form their freedom as part of some conspiracy to take away their cars.. I would like private enjoyment of my own RAM to use as I wish please.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by impossiblefork on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:30AM
(#50363614)
Unrelated to this slowdown, I could imagine this sort of thing being the right application for things like Taalas, although I'm not quite sure whether it can actually offer what I imagine that it can (i.e. ability to make a cheap, physically small card that can run a large model).
A laptop can't run the latest big models, because memory is too expensive. This thing probably can't run models larger than Mistral Small 4. But it'd be a completely different thing to have a hardcoded Mistral Large 4, than a choice of tiny models.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by RealityVoid on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:43AM
(#50363718)
You probably won't be able to run a sota model on a single Talaas card. You probably need a set. It should theoretically be cheaper, faster, more power efficient than Nvidia at running that model. But then you are stuck with a chip that can run only that model. And I understand that context size will also be a problem.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by impossiblefork on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:54AM
(#50363796)
Yeah, that was why I felt that, while Taalas might not be the right thing in general, it could be really appealing in a laptop, that would otherwise not be able to run any big model at all.
I think I misunderstood what the technology could do a little bit, because I imagined these fixed matrix multiplies encoded into hardware as small-ish, as using routing space etc., not just fast.
I think what I really imagined was useful would be more easily achieved by having a big ROM with model weights connected to an ordinary GPU.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by viraptor on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:43AM
(#50363714)
Fortunately that's just a matter of weeks until someone revengs and publishes the fix... even if we need to wait a while for a proper upstreamed solution.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by OsrsNeedsf2P on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:08AM
(#50363911)
As someone who went down the rabbit hole of local AI, there is so much exhausting debugging already. Even if this is "just" another step you have to find, it's toxic.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by adrian_b on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:27AM
(#50364645)
Not really, because for more than 2 decades the closed-source NVIDIA Linux drivers were at parity of features and performance with the Windows drivers, unlike the AMD drivers before they were open-sourced, which was much more recently.
This is a new thing with the firmware that can be used only by Windows. If this NVIDIA policy continues, then NVIDIA will indeed become a bad choice for Linux, but until now for graphics and AI applications NVIDIA has been the best choice for Linux, by providing the best performance and reliability.
For pure computational applications, especially for those requiring good FP64 throughput, there are many years since NVIDIA has become a worse choice than AMD and more recently also than Intel, but that is due to poor hardware support, not to bad software support.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by lcampbell on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:41AM
(#50367181)
> closed-source NVIDIA Linux drivers were at parity of features and performance with the Windows drivers
Hell, their old closed-source NVIDIA _FreeBSD_ drivers were at parity with Windows. CUDA included (though the CUDA toolkit required Linuxulator syscall emulation to run the Linux bins).
Imagine my surprise when my new Blackwell card didn’t work, and that the newly required open source drivers were Linux-only.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by laughing_man on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:57PM
(#50369988)
Based on the numbers I looked at when I installed Ubuntu last year, while AMD cards match or even exceed Windows performance, on Nvidia a whole lot of popular games run at just over half speed compared to the Windows version, and none of them run faster.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by adrian_b on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:14PM
(#50370880)
What kind of games were those, Windows games?
If they were using DirectX through Wine, perhaps the DirectX emulation is not optimized for NVIDIA, but only for AMD.
I do not play games, but I have used professional graphics or computational programs using OpenGL/Vulkan/CUDA/OpenCL natively on Linux with the NVIDIA driver, and those have always been as fast or faster than on Windows.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by petercooper on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:40AM
(#50364239)
Assume I'm naive on this matter, but why wouldn't Nvidia allow its own DGX OS to be a first party OS on these devices? Some sort of MS subsidy? Ecosystem-wise, wouldn't it make sense for Nvidia to keep pushing its own OS on all the devices containing its hardware?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by khgihpipihkjdsg on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:03AM
(#50364421)
I am starting to wonder whether CEOs everywhere ( but especially in US ) are simply unable to read the room. I shrugged off nvidia when they did it to gaming and mining ( it annoyed me, but ultimately there were options to deal with it ), but here it is touching a much wider populace with repercussion well beyond crypto and gaming.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by ilaksh on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:43AM
(#50364786)
So weird that everyone gives Microsoft a complete pass. They probably paid Nvidia to give them a head start so people would be forced into Windows and WSL for awhile.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Zigurd on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:06AM
(#50365711)
Elsewhere on this thread someone mentioned a Microsoft patent that appears to be related to this topic. I think you've found the thread that needs to be pulled here. With their background in the game industry I wouldn't be surprised if Nvidia is comfortable with this kind of fuckery.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by nibbula on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:54AM
(#50364877)
You will never stop me. As I and everyone like me, before and after me, have shown, time and time again. And by me, I mean nature. And by nature I mean math and logic unchangeable in any possible universe. You cannot give me a thing without me having it. If a thing exists, I can copy it, know it, and bring it's equivalent into existence. Nothing can be created that is not indelibly written into the the intricate cause and effect chain of history. A perfectly encrypted thing is indistinguishable from the noise of the cosmos, but if I want I thing, it shall soon emerge, free from any control from that noise, which is the weight of all that has happened, just as surely as I can count to a number.
If you want to prosper with the current of nature, provide a thing easily for mutual benefit. The more you try to block a thing, the sooner your demise into uselessness.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by nubinetwork on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:32PM
(#50370418)
The GPUs start up with the lowest speeds, and only the binary driver has the bits needed to "reclock" the card. That's partially why the oss driver sucks these days.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by quaffcode on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:16AM
(#50365129)
We have antitrust laws on the books. They have barely been enforced since Reagan. But that good change if there was political will. How is Nvidia not a monopoly?
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by 999900000999 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:30AM
(#50365264)
>Oddly, the direction of the problem flips depending on power source. Unplugged, Linux hit around 61 to 67 tokens per second on LM Studio, comparable to Windows. Plugged in, that same test dropped to about 15 tokens per second.
Absolutely hilarious.
This is just incompetence. No reason Nvidia with its TRILLIONS of market cap couldn't of tested and fixed this on Linux before shipping.
Or a day one patch.
I have no doubt that'll it'll work right eventually. Long after RTX Spark laptops flop and can be purchased for half off.
Last night I pulled out my 5070TI laptop and installed CachyOS. I was running various models within about 20 minutes.
That 12GB of VRAM is a hard limitation, Unsloth can't split jobs between vram and system memory.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by juujian on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:54AM
(#50365552)
This is unfortunately the normal release cycle for Linux, especially with Nvidia. If you buy the latest and greatest, some features just aren't available. Eventually, manufacturers work with Ubuntu to unlock some of those features and other distributions then adopt those drivers. Takes a few months though. If you're lucky, the drivers become part of the Kernel, and that process takes even more time. Some features never land at all (looking at you, AMD XDNA gen 1).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by TkTech on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:49PM
(#50370598)
Most nvidia consumer/desktop GPUs are crippled intentionally in various subtle ways - tensor cores for example are capped at half speed on all GeForce cards, which is why https://github.com/Zagitta/gpu-unlock exists. The intent is to force you to spend significantly more for the exact same silicon under commercial packaging if you want to do inference tasks.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by nonethewiser on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:55AM
(#50367396)
How is everyone wildly misunderstanding this article?
It's lack of linux driver support for firmware designed for windows only laptops.
What is going on here? Commenters here are clearly extremely paranoid about NVIDIA centralizing inference. This is not reflected in the facts nor narrative of the article - it's completely fabricated out of left field her in the comments.
This is a problem on the MSI Prestige laptop using the RTX Spark platform. Lets assume it also applies to the Asus and Dell machines using RTX spark.
RTX Spark is a new platform and all of these laptops ship with Windows. You cant get Linux on any of these machines from the factory. There is also precedent for NVIDIA shipping linux support well after Windows (2 years in the case of Dynanmic Boost, a similar power sharing feature).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by topspin on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:53PM
(#50369914)
"You cant get Linux on any of these machines from the factory"
That's the part that mystifies me. These are not mundane business laptops. There is a high probability that anyone paying $4000-6000+ for a high performance LLM hosting laptop will want to run bare metal Linux, because the software stacks involved are Linux native. Yet somehow this is apparently not even tested properly, never mind available as a product.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by nonethewiser on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:57AM
(#50367446)
Please read the article. Comments here are wildly misinformed.
This is a lack of linux driver support for firmware designed for windows laptops.
This is a problem on the MSI Prestige laptop using the RTX Spark platform. Lets assume it also applies to the Asus and Dell machines using RTX spark.
RTX Spark is a new platform and all of these laptops ship with Windows. You cant get Linux on any of these machines from the factory. There is also precedent for NVIDIA shipping linux support well after Windows (2 years in the case of Dynanmic Boost, a similar power sharing feature).
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by m3kw9 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:47AM
(#50368238)
This is the same reason misinformation works so well on these people they have to stuff and they don’t critically think if there are other reasons. They’d write more headlines and others will act the same, like wild fire.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by qwerpy on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:37PM
(#50369703)
Unfortunately HN commenters as a group are not any more intelligent or resilient to emotionally-appealing misinformation than the general public, contrary to what we'd like to believe. We see a headline that confirms our biases, we turn off our brains, and then we make in-group noises to show that we belong. Pretty much the same as religious groups and rituals that we turn our noses up at.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by callamdelaney on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:48PM
(#50369850)
Is it misinformation that the driver is slower on linux? There’s no such thing in my book as ‘windows’ hardware. It should work as well everywhere on day one, or we should have the ability to make it do so.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by ThrowawayB7 on Thursday November 05, 2026 @01:00AM
(#50375736)
> "There’s no such thing in my book as ‘windows’ hardware."
Good luck with that. A PC is more or less defined by specifications laid out in Microsoft's Windows Hardware Compatibility program and tested by their Windows Hardware Lab Kit. Before that, it was defined by IBM.
I've heard that ARM has had a standard for ARM-based servers, their Server Base System Architecture, but I've never seen any compliant hardware in the wild.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by alex43578 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:54PM
(#50371364)
Do they also need to support MacOS, Chrome OS, and FreeBSD? They made these laptops to work with Windows. It’s not on them to ensure compatibility with anything more than they were marketed for.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by bigyabai on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:13PM
(#50372255)
> Do they also need to support MacOS, Chrome OS, and FreeBSD?
They basically do. ChromeOS runs a Linux kernel, so the userland has everything it needs to run CUDA. FreeBSD is a first-class target for Nvidia drivers, and macOS used to be supported too but stopped signing Nvidia code. Nevertheless, AArch64 is still supported.
It is up to Nvidia to support whatever platforms they want users to be on. In their case, it means supporting many OSes.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by alex43578 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:22PM
(#50372832)
The article says "A real fix depends on Nvidia, specifically on porting the platform controller’s power management logic into its Linux driver, which would effectively turn the laptop into a portable version of the DGX Spark."
My point is that's not Nvidia's responsibility. The article itself admits the laptop "ships with Windows on ARM", so support for another OS shouldn't be expected, even if NVIDIA supports other platforms and other product lines differently.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by bigyabai on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @07:06PM
(#50373204)
These aren't "other product lines" though. They are RTX and Spark SOC products that do support Linux as a first-class citizen with all of their hardware. The RTX Spark is the outlier, and the breakage is not on the GPU product, but the SOC devicetree drivers. This is only a problem because Nvidia avoided standard Windows power management a-la ACPI/UEFI, and has to port the remainder to Linux by hand.
There are OEMs that refuse this responsibility. If that's the vindication you wanted, there you go. This specific issue is not a radical blocker that Nvidia will deliberately avoid.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by unethical_ban on Friday November 06, 2026 @11:27AM
(#50394506)
They can do whatever they want, of course. But why wouldn't they support Linux? It's a weak argument to compare Ubuntu and Fedora, modern freely available operating systems in wide use by the tech community, to Windows XP.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by yunnpp on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:06PM
(#50370082)
You are asking to read the article in a vacuum and ignore the context in which the driver support is missing. That doesn't make for very good reading comprehension.
> There is also precedent for NVIDIA shipping linux support well after Windows
There is also a precedent for NVIDIA nerfing drivers on Linux and pulling anti-competitive shenanigans against competition, so it's only reasonable that people look at the "missing" driver support with suspicion.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by keybrd-intrrpt on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:26PM
(#50372362)
And the DGX Spark and DGX Station both are Ubuntu based linux.
How does your conspiracy theory hold up to that?
GB10 and N1X are both Blackwell cousins. So they've had consumer-level Linux machines for a while now.
This was simply a partnership with Microsoft, so of course development of drivers and firmware focused heavily on Windows. Especially since I'm sure Windows required a LOT of updating to run nicely on ARM as well as the N1X unified memory model.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by yunnpp on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:45PM
(#50372542)
They have data centers to sell, and it's not out of this world for Microsoft to have requested a nerf as part of their "partnership".
You may as well be right, I am speculating and this theory might be baseless (I don't think it is.) But GP's comment is wrong to ask people to simply read the article at face value. That is bad reading.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by wtallis on Friday November 06, 2026 @12:35AM
(#50388591)
> GB10 and N1X are both Blackwell cousins.
GB10 and N1X are the same thing. It's the same silicon.
> Especially since I'm sure Windows required a LOT of updating to run nicely on ARM as well as the N1X unified memory model.
Windows has been shipping with ARM64 support for 8 years; Microsoft and Qualcomm already took care of those hurdles, which was almost certainly a key factor in NVIDIA's decision to build a laptop SoC in the first place.
They have not figured out how to make Windows work nicely on a unified memory model: https://forums.developer.nvidia.com/t/rtx-spark-on-windows-c... Either you deal with those problems and having to reboot to change how much memory is reserved for the GPU, or you run with minimal reserved memory and most of your GPU memory accesses take a ~4x latency hit. Most RTX Spark systems seem to be shipping with a 50/50 split out of the box.
NVIDIA has had a full year since shipping DGX Spark (which was already clearly quite late to marker) to finish polishing the Windows support and power management. For them to ship in this state and regress the quality of Linux support on the same silicon is quite convincing evidence that they're half-assing this and really don't care about this platform the way they care about their datacenter cash cows.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by bayindirh on Thursday November 05, 2026 @05:01AM
(#50377325)
> This is a lack of linux driver support for firmware designed for windows laptops.
Personally, I don't care. If you don't support open drivers, you have to provide first class drivers on Linux on day 1, because NVIDIA's majority of business is running on Linux already.
On top of that, they claim to have the best Linux support, and claim to have best drivers in their class.
So, it's better to act like that and provide support. If any other company has done that, they have been incinerated with the flame of internet's hate thrice already.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by Zak on Thursday November 05, 2026 @10:51AM
(#50380650)
This isn't just a matter of lack of a good driver because they didn't bother making one for an OS they didn't intend to support. Encrypting the firmware's power table serves no purpose other than frustrating any third-party effort to develop a good driver.
It is not obvious to me why they would want to do that.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by BalistaCRATZ on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:45PM
(#50369008)
Unclear to me why the first attempt was to boot Omarchy, a brand new, vibecoded distro, as opposed to one of the much more reliable ones that have been around for decades
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by ctolsen on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @04:49PM
(#50372043)
Bit more than a reskin now. They do enough that Omarchy distributed a configuration by default that allowed for root escalation and some UI scripts that let desktop notifications run arbitrary code. That was a month or two ago and seemed pretty vibey.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by dagmx on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:48PM
(#50369846)
As an aside, I made the mistake of buying the Surface Laptop Ultra and it’s such a dud.
NVIDIA and Microsoft tried so hard to make a Mac clone with this and it’s just missing the mark everywhere.
It doesn’t do the dynamic memory split that a Mac does so out of the box it reserves 32GB (half) for the GPU and windows limits CPU processes to that. Getting more memory requires a reboot.
And because I want Unix tools (without Cygwin), WSL2 splits that even further in half.
Performance is way behind a similarly specced Mac. The GPU is thermally throttled near a 5060 laptop. The CPU out of the box came in a lower power state but windows power management makes it stuttery unless you change that, at which point it’s cooling is a hurricane compared to the Mac which outperforms it while being quieter.
The new MagSafe like connector is stupidly designed too. You can’t generically use it in any USB-C port, it’s super chonky and disconnects only on the horizontal axis. Worse, because it’s a right angle connector it can only be used in one orientation without blocking the other ports.
Windows input handling sucks too. There’s a lag before the trackpad responds based on moved distance. Some terrible take on palm rejection I’m sure. But even their display is mediocre because it gets very bright but they messed up local dimming. So if you select a bunch of text in the terminal it blinds you.
Idk I got this specifically to do windows dev with CUDA on arm. So I knew it was niche but anyone else buying this is making a mistake. It’s an unfinished product trying to be a competitor that nobody in Microsoft even understands.
This Linux support issue is just the icing because everyone keeps asking me why I don’t just put Linux on it and workaround my issues, but you can’t.
I’ve spoken to friends at NVIDIA who say it’s rushed out. So maybe software will get better but I urge folks to not buy this unless you’re into the same niche needs as me.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by shevy-java on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @02:22PM
(#50370293)
Or alternatively it is time to help support companies that support
Linux. As Nvidia keeps on being a problem, let's look for alternatives.
We can see with this evil cartel currently driving up the RAM prices
how greedy they all are. Our money should go into fairness. The US
court system has given up on that. Even on capitalism. Capitalism used
to claim that a free market with competition leads to lower prices.
Well - we have several de-facto cartels here. And nobody is breaking
any of these up.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by porphyra on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:12PM
(#50372244)
honestly the fact that right at release it works with
> laptop ran a full desktop at 4K and 120Hz, with working audio, touchpad, keyboard, and CUDA acceleration
is amazing. It seems that this person's MSI version had some quirks with firmware but Omarchy already supports the Asus and Dell versions of the RTX Spark out of the box. I'm surprised that everyone is focusing on the negative when, prior to RTX Spark's release, it wasn't clear if Linux would work on the RTX Spark at all in the first place.
This is way better support than Qualcomm's Snapdragon X1 and X2 laptops, which are still struggling to get Linux support years after release.
Presumably, once this one power management driver issue gets sorted out (surely an accidental bug rather than what some of y'all cynics are suggesting), it will be great. Now if only it could be cheaper...
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by lolive on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:38PM
(#50374431)
Isn’t this RTX product targeted at the corporate market, proposing privacy and local AI for laptops, targeting an audience that is wealthy, massively uses Windows [and may be WSL], and is in dire need of that feature, so willing to pay.
Re:Nvidia DGX Spark encrypted firmware slows inference speed...
by prima-facie on Thursday November 05, 2026 @06:45PM
(#50386225)
This reminds me of the BDProcHot throttling issue on some Intel laptops from a while ago.
I remember having a similar issue with an HP laptop running the first generation of Intel Alder Lake.
The CPU would throttle heavily to something like 800Mhz on battery on Linux.
Or maybe just not at all - shell out for OAI tokens and send us all your data - your privacy is very valuable to us and we will make sure to be the only ones to monetize it.
You could say, Nvidia is selling pickaxes and has no business gatekeeping what rocks you hit with it, but I guess it depends on their relationships with major mining companies, and ultimately what pays more.
Those are very different things as far as I understand, and the whole "doesn't work well with linux" really only makes sense on the RTX Spark laptop I think? Isn't the DGX spark linux by default?
Man it really is exhausting to read a title that sparks my interest, just to be greeted with the most basic Claude-isms in the subheading.
I see what you did there. ;)
I just heard a quick J. Talarico speech at some country concert. In the 10 or so sentences he spoke, he had 3 or 4 instances of doing this "Claudism" enumeration. Are you saying Texas just elected Claude for Senate?
Maybe we should stop with such superficial judgements. It's the modern equivalent of not liking the speaker's tie. (Doesn't mean the speaker's speech is good, but it doesn't mean it's bad either.)
But, on the other hand, having my DGX Spark stack at hand, I know the solution:
"AI views proprietary components as damage and routes around them."Sovereign AI has never been more important.
But yeah, we do need to make sure the REA cat stays out of the bag.
I, for one, welcome our reverse-engineer-anything overlords.
TIL. Nice word.
If you really want to do DIY inference, plug it in at home and set up tailscale so you can access it on the go.
No huge battery drain or toasty hot laptop required. Lower cost laptop. Lighter laptop. Longer battery life laptop. Win win win win.
Maybe you need a therapy. FOMO can be treated, too. Or you're just upset about Trump falling into irrelevance.
The market for someone who wants local AI in a laptop for $10k has to be tiny.
GGP's point is just: keep the bulk of your compute at home, where airflow and energy is cheaper (in an opportunity-cost sense). Keep the laptop portable, cool, and light, with long battery life by offloading your own computing tasks to your own hardware.
I am not saying don't use a laptop.
I am not saying you have to use cloud inference.
I am saying using a laptop for inference is dumb. If you want private inference:
- use a dgx spark or similar plugged in at home
- set up tailscale so you can connect from anywhere
- use your phone as a hotspot on the go
- work on your laptop, using tailscale to connect to your home inference server if you're on the go
This gets you everything except for the few hours you might be on an airplane.
The simple point I'm always trying to make is that area vs volume is a fundamental physical difference regarding cooling, which is critical for high performance applications (that's why they're considering an RTX Spark in the first place, right?).
There's so much more I could say about my Strix Halo machine, which fits in the palm of my hand and I have a wonderful portable screen and keyboard+touchpad (and only cost me 2k with 128 GB fast memory, idles at 4w, amazing 32 thread Zen 5 CPU with AVX-512, ...), but it's either preaching to the choir or pissing against the wind.
unique local data and know how not shared with cloud.
Because reviewers tell them this is is a good use case, and people want to take advantage of the HW they buy [0]. Unfortunately those reviewers didn't take any extra step to validate anything beyond the default config, out of the box.
[0] https://arstechnica.com/reviews/2026/10/the-surface-laptop-u...
I meanwhile, run my ridiculously OP workstation class hardware as a server - 9995wx, 768GiB, rtx pro 6000 w/ 96GiB vram - at home, and my Asus ZenBook is light, cool, and long-lived.
Runs GLM 5.3 flash at 35 tok/sec while consuming only 15 GiB VRAM, and I can run a lot more stuff on there alongside.
To me the simple answer to why is control. If I run a model locally I get to control the model params, the system prompt, all of it. And of course there is no quota. But probably most importantly I am not tied to paying some company a monthly subscription forever.
Sovereign AI has never been more important.
Controlling AI is so much more powerful and impactful than controlling search or social algorithms.
Centralized AI a 10x on social control over everything we have seen before, and there is no way that a free and open society survives contact with centralised, high capability AI if the system is manipulated towards guiding outcomes. It’s essentially mind control, as people will offload an even greater share of their cognition to AI than they do with search and social.
Build and maintain sovereign AI while you still can.
Pay up for license to unlock full capacity, pay up for license to use encrypted models from AI moguls, paid per billion tokens processed or just operations in GPU
I wonder if this space is explored fully enough at the moment.
Aside from some implementation details, it's conceptually much easier than doing it for a SQL database.
The consumer has access to free and open models for local use.
The supplier has better control and wider market to serve running the models in data centers.
Only way I can see encrypted models being widespread is if they are bundled as part of a software package (OS/Browser/etc) and not sold as the product.
And, the same GPUs are run in datacenter, where there's a big insider risk that vendors want to mitigate with encrypted models (if you're Anthropic and you want AWS to host your models, you don't want 5000 or even 500 or even 50 AWS employees with access to your highly valuable/desirable model weights).
NVIDIA is holding to its pearls like a sloth holding to its branch, because their all business model and livelihood is dependent on that control. I still commend AMD's decision to allow full card enablement with any driver which talks the correct language.
There will be ways for them to segment the market and make their money. Maybe not 100x stock in 5 years but money all the same.
So it is something that has been done for a long time now. Still feels like unethical rent-seeking that should not be tolerated by the customer.
See Also: car companies that charge additional fees for hardware already on the car. Additional services, I sort of understand(remote start via cell network), but stuff like heated seats, that is just wrong.
It saves the car manufacturer on logistics cost. The per-unit cost of a seat heater is (much) smaller than the cost related to keeping two variants of seat in stock and to provide spare parts. Say the heating mat costs 100€ per seat including materials and installation, and can be sold to the customer for 400€ permanent, that means as long as 1 in 4 customers buys the seat heating option, the books are balanced, and all money you save on logistics is pure profit.
Adding subscription on top of that is financially even better, if there is one thing companies LOVE thanks to stonk market incentives it is monthly recurring revenue.
I think more than that, it is probably a lie they tell us that you are not paying for the hardware/equipment.
Yeah, Nothing morally wrong there.
A license has zero marginal cost in the first place. Software distribution over networks have a negligible marginal cost. An ebook as zero margin cost. We are constantly paying lots of things with zero or negligible marginal cost.
AI is a software just like operating systems and executables where open source absolutely dominates the industry. Remember when the compiler engineers optimized the shit out of llama.cpp.
Right now the bottleneck for AI software is compute and data. Moore's law is give us compute, StackOverflow, arXiv (and it's children like bioRxiv), gutenberg and others (3lib, anna, internet.org) will give us data.
It's a waiting game. Open source always wins.
Tons of stuff happenning behind closed doors today though. No more stackoverflow for the next decade, that could create a problem if all new context only exists in chatgpt conversations only openAI has access to (or whoever).
Based on... what? Thoughts and prayers? Feelings? Vibes?
I don't know if you looked around but open source is basically unusable for the largest platform in the world, mobile.
The next platform, whatever that is, will also be closed source (maybe VR, once it finally matures...).
LLMs are closed source, is there even 1 (ONE) LLM which is both open source and open weights and publishes its training data and methodology and is also remotely competitive with the frontier lab LLMs?
Consoles are closed source. Appliances are closed source. Embedded devices are closed source.
Even the web is basically closed source. Blobs of encrypted, obfuscated JS used to serve news pages (!).
Maybe I'm looking in the wrong places, but closed source has won.
And regarding servers, who cares? The platforms users interact with are their clients and the actual server software on top of the Linux OS is closed source 99% of the time.
Don't post lazy comments.
Nothing stops you from giving Nvidia half a million for their latest and greatest AI GPUs, unless you are in China I guess, but China does very well despite the export control.
It is just classic market segmentation, the thing Nvidia and just about every company that can benefit from it has done for decades. Cloud providers are ready to pay a lot of money, consumers wanting local AI have a lower budget, and gamers even lower. But a low budget is greater than zero, and there is still money to be made on these markets. But they also don't want to compete against themselves, so they are going to find ways of crippling enterprise-class workloads on consumer hardware.
It used to be that they crippled high precision arithmetic on consumer hardware, because it was a differentiating factor, but AI doesn't care about high precision, so now, it is something else.
These are multi-million dollar datacenter systems, not consumer. If you mean the consumer market, it's coming but it's going to be 2028-29 most likely (if the bubbled hasn't popped by then).
Strix Point is quite good but not the same thing as a DGX, though. Same idea, different methodology.
I miss the old days when they released enthusiast products like the R9 295X2. Though that’s just the gaming enthusiast market in general declining (not that this happened organically though, it feels like a deliberate choice).
I have many pleasant memories of keeping myself warm just by opening Witcher 3 on my R9 390.
AMDs revenue this quarter just passed Intels for the first time in history and they still are dominating in the HPC market which is fairly immune to the AI bubble (while also selling everything they can build at a high premium to AI datacenters).
AMDs margins on their Instinct datacenter GPUs is nearly as good as nVidia's. They just can't get contract volume at TSMC to make more because nVidia buys all of it.
https://youtu.be/Bteba8KLeGc
https://d1.awsstatic.com/onedam/marketing-channels/website/a...
https://youtu.be/5SgZ3zRJFAY
They're still getting plenty of Nvidia GPUs. Someone in Jensen Huang's inner circle apparently runs a number of companies in Singapore that have been found to source GPUs at scale. The catch is that she has close ties to Beijing and is suspected of working closely with their government, potentially even spying for them.
This was reported just a week or two ago and is just one example of how China is still getting their hands on resources they're supposedly unable to get.
Social processes that pull towards freedom tend to be low investment, chaotic, individualistic processes; usually just working within the voids between enclosed spaces. There are projects of significant complexity working in these spaces, but they tend to be focused on their individual goals rather than the preservation of those voids.
Social processes that pull towards structural control, in contrast, tend to be well organised, funded, and focused mostly on exerting that control as a means to further some other goal.
With a high diversity of strategic actors and their highly divergent goals, almost any movement in a space of technological change can be seen as an opportunity to implement a ratchet that encloses more ground in the service of commercial or political vision. The end result is creeping enclosure of every active commons, while the expansion of opportunities occurs only at the frontiers of technology or in the abandoned areas with minimal commercial value (until they become revitalised, at least)
I do not understand this play. This means that only hyperscalers or someone who purchased a licence can use Spark?
I stopped using my laptop for dev and switched to talking to claude code on my phone and as you can imagine I am faster at producing code.
100% cloud with a single entry point device to manage dedicated servers + agents
[Hanlon's Razor] This is such a contrived performance drop scenario that I find it hard to believe it was done with the purpose you're inferring.
If anything I'd be more inclined to interpret this as Nvidia not caring that much about Linux once again, rather than anything to do with local vs cloud.
Even that argument is weak - the DGX Spark is Linux, and the RTX Spark is practically the same exact chip.
Sorry to remind people of HN, but most of the consumer market still runs Windows. This was a joint project to have a consumer-level Windows-on-ARM machine, likely requiring lots of development efforts from both NVIDIA and Microsoft.
So, for these specific laptops, they put 100% of their attention for it to be on Windows for launch to capture as much market mindshare as they can. Local AI, Graphics and creative work, and some gaming.
I doubt Microsoft would have been happy about NVIDIA having Linux on their laptop right at launch.
Market Share by OS for consumer laptops & desktops:
• Windows: 76.65%
• OS X / macOS (Combined): ~15.67% (OS X at 9.86% + macOS at 5.81% due to user-agent reporting quirks)
• Linux: 5.63%
• Chrome OS: 2.04%
As in, make your own inference and training hardware?
Sovereign AI is less about being able to build it from first principles and more about being able to tinker and modify what already exists. I can’t train a 30B model, but I can modify the weights of one. I can’t fab my own chips, but I can putter with the software that interfaces with them.
Sovereignty is lost when encryption hides your toys and attestation tells you “you may not”.
Estonian only has sovereign AI as long as they’re allowed to buy from Nvidia. Oh wait, they’re already restricted in what they can get.
But those servers most likely use CPUs not made in China, if I were to hazard a guess, doesn't that mean that that AI isn't "truly sovereign" in your mind then?
Who exactly?
Beyond him, I would bet most of his bilderberg group friends agree. E.g. Peter Thiel, the owner of JD Vance.
This is a linux driver proble. On laptops designed for windows.
Read the article and stop sensationalizing.
This is a problem on the MSI Prestige laptop using the RTX Spark platform. Lets assume it also applies to the Asus and Dell machines using RTX spark. It isn't an issue with RTX spark desktops.
RTX Spark is a new platform and all of these laptops ship with Windows. You cant get Linux on any of these machines from the factory. There is also precedent for NVIDIA shipping linux support well after Windows (2 years in the case of Dynamic Boost, a similar power sharing feature).
Kindly remove this from your list of "Evidence that NVIDIA is Colluding to Centralize Inference" and everyone else take note of this confirmation bias in action.
That them trying to protect IP around something very profitable isn't crazy. That not being fully supported in Linux, when the product was literally designed around Windows, also isn't crazy or really evidence of anything, including evil (see the whole fucking history of Linux compatibility of made-for-Windows hardware).
Maybe let them cook.
It obviously can't be because of ulterior motives!
No. It's 'the NVidia way or the highway' problem. NVidia is so full of themselves they refuse to work under anyone's rules (i.e. the Linux kernel where they're constantly trying to work around them).
They're egomaniacs who are so full of themselves, riding high on the AI bubble, they think they're above everyone else in the ecosystem, while utilising all kinds of other people's work for their own benefit.
Look at the way they develop their 'open' Linux drivers where it's just a shim that loads a huge binary blob off the GPU rather than a proper driver like amdgpu has.
Meanwhile they wouldn't be a $5T company without Linux and the wider FLOSS ecosystem.
It's kind of like when Secure Boot debuted and the plan was to allow only Windows with it enabled, then no doubt someone would claim the fact that only Windows can boot with it enabled as a 'Linux driver problem'.
Claude, make a driver that runs at full capacity on my laptop. (make no mistakes).
nvidia has always been crap like this. Look at amd and intel, they let u write proper drivers (even if its real difficult to do so). No encrypted blobs or voodoo needed.
the nvidia drivers u need to use a card on Linux are unintelligible binary blobs. thats sad as it is.
Is the problem one that could be easily countered by assuming that laptops are generally better when they're not on fire?
Nvidia won because their architecture is better. If you do a significant amount of work that can be CUDA-accelerated, you're kinda wasting your time not owning a CUDA-capable card. It's like being a video editor that software-encodes their projects because they don't want to get an accelerator card. It's your choice, but software-acceleration is a nightmare compared to how quick and efficient hardware-acceleration is. Competitors will all use the accelerator card and ship faster than you can.
Apple, AMD and Intel have all earned their current position by abandoning Khronos and refusing to build their own GPGPU architecture. If the entire industry refuses to invest in complex technology just because it's expensive, then they don't deserve to make money.
Nvidia does something to prevent abuse so that regular people who want the laptops can buy one. Nvidia gets knocked on.
This is all but certainly a bug in their linux driver and nothing else. It sure as hell isn't some "anti abuse" to enable "regular people" to buy one.
The only value proposition of RTX Spark at all is the laptop form factor
> NVIDIA has now confirmed an official starting price of $2,399 for RTX Spark laptops
https://shattered.io/nvidia-rtx-spark-mediatek-oems-price-20...
https://www.servethehome.com/nvidia-dgx-spark-64gb-launched-...
If we look at what you can actually buy the 64GB RTX Spark is $4,500 and the 128GB one is $7,000: https://eshop.asus.com/us/31150-us-cnf-auto.html & https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/laptop-computers/spd/xps16dx...
And if there's a market for a DGX Spark configuration with a higher compute-to-RAM ratio, why isn't Nvidia offering it?
My best guess is that the entry-level Sparks are mostly intended for people who would otherwise be in the market for a traditional high-end laptop, who might be enticed to spend a few hundred more for at least the promise of local AI, while the higher-end models are intended for more serious AI development.
With that said, it's not hard to imagine there isn't nearly as large a built-in market for high-end SFF Linux PCs as there is for high-end Windows laptops.
In fact I'm pretty sure it's happening. Why? Because of constantly growing prices of those things.
I was genuinely excited about this device until I heard the specs. Still under 300GB/s memory bandwidth when a gpu like rtx3090 from 6 years ago had 900+
This is really bread crumbing local inference users.
We should be measuring our memory bandwidth in TB by now. The only company that seems to be serious about this is Apple. (the m5 ultra studio etc).
Or RTX Spark and run their workloads under WSL, which as the article notes, has minimal overhead relative to running Linux directly?
This sounds more like a bug than a feature, especially given that Linux on battery runs at full clock speed and downclocks when plugged in, and Windows does the opposite, suggesting they could at least mitigate the problem with no changes to their software stack by inverting a conditional in the firmware and adding a Linux kernel parameter to control memory allocation as apparently already exists for Windows.
https://developer.nvidia.com/blog/nvidia-transitions-fully-t...
Point was about the kernel drivers being open-source enabling hackability - they don't, the card hardware is just as closed as before.
When did "we" have a say in this? I don't get these types of comments from the "open-source as a community."
Nvidia has been doing this for decades, and there are two possible arguments:
1. They are successful despite it.
2. They are successful because of it.
There is no mythical collective "we" representing the open-source community in Nvidia's supply chain of success. It's Nvidia and its consumers.
I don’t think anyone “allowed” them - quite the opposite. They’ve made generational bets that ended up being right, bets that IIRC the industry did not agree with for a long time. Them pursuing CUDA resulted in a draw down of something crazy like 75% of their valuation. They bet the farm multiple times to get to the point they are - and it’s only “obvious” in hindsight.
If you want folks to make generational bets as a matter of course (which I think most folks do), centralizing the downside of those bets and socializing the upside of those bets is not a great strategy. Almost as bad as socializing the downside.
Competition will eventually close that gap. We’re only a few years into this thing.
Have you ever heard of U.S. Steel, IBM, Kodak, and Western Union?
A laptop can't run the latest big models, because memory is too expensive. This thing probably can't run models larger than Mistral Small 4. But it'd be a completely different thing to have a hardcoded Mistral Large 4, than a choice of tiny models.
I think I misunderstood what the technology could do a little bit, because I imagined these fixed matrix multiplies encoded into hardware as small-ish, as using routing space etc., not just fast.
I think what I really imagined was useful would be more easily achieved by having a big ROM with model weights connected to an ordinary GPU.
But with Nvidia people just expect they nerf all the features.
This is a new thing with the firmware that can be used only by Windows. If this NVIDIA policy continues, then NVIDIA will indeed become a bad choice for Linux, but until now for graphics and AI applications NVIDIA has been the best choice for Linux, by providing the best performance and reliability.
For pure computational applications, especially for those requiring good FP64 throughput, there are many years since NVIDIA has become a worse choice than AMD and more recently also than Intel, but that is due to poor hardware support, not to bad software support.
Hell, their old closed-source NVIDIA _FreeBSD_ drivers were at parity with Windows. CUDA included (though the CUDA toolkit required Linuxulator syscall emulation to run the Linux bins).
Imagine my surprise when my new Blackwell card didn’t work, and that the newly required open source drivers were Linux-only.
If they were using DirectX through Wine, perhaps the DirectX emulation is not optimized for NVIDIA, but only for AMD.
I do not play games, but I have used professional graphics or computational programs using OpenGL/Vulkan/CUDA/OpenCL natively on Linux with the NVIDIA driver, and those have always been as fast or faster than on Windows.
Also very curious if the NPU is visible in Linux, too.
https://www.xda-developers.com/nvidia-rtx-spark-laptops-same...
Still miles ahead compared to Apple, where linux does not even boot on newer macs!
If you want to prosper with the current of nature, provide a thing easily for mutual benefit. The more you try to block a thing, the sooner your demise into uselessness.
This has been an issue on Linux since 2014, and the gtx980.
Even if this is an intentional nerf by Nvidia, which I doubt, then then nerf is buggy.
Absolutely hilarious.
This is just incompetence. No reason Nvidia with its TRILLIONS of market cap couldn't of tested and fixed this on Linux before shipping.
Or a day one patch.
I have no doubt that'll it'll work right eventually. Long after RTX Spark laptops flop and can be purchased for half off.
Last night I pulled out my 5070TI laptop and installed CachyOS. I was running various models within about 20 minutes.
That 12GB of VRAM is a hard limitation, Unsloth can't split jobs between vram and system memory.
Could have tested.
Even from the article I'm guessing you could write a script to automatically extract the encryption keys while on Windows and the load those in Linux.
This is only mildly inconvenient for anyone who'd use this in a data center cluster.
They've always played these sorts of games. Now, people are seeing the substandard solutions for what it is, and are angry.
I understand that their "secret sauce" might be exposed with open drivers, so I somewhat respect their right to intellectual property in this respect.
It's lack of linux driver support for firmware designed for windows only laptops.
What is going on here? Commenters here are clearly extremely paranoid about NVIDIA centralizing inference. This is not reflected in the facts nor narrative of the article - it's completely fabricated out of left field her in the comments.
This is a problem on the MSI Prestige laptop using the RTX Spark platform. Lets assume it also applies to the Asus and Dell machines using RTX spark.
RTX Spark is a new platform and all of these laptops ship with Windows. You cant get Linux on any of these machines from the factory. There is also precedent for NVIDIA shipping linux support well after Windows (2 years in the case of Dynanmic Boost, a similar power sharing feature).
That's the part that mystifies me. These are not mundane business laptops. There is a high probability that anyone paying $4000-6000+ for a high performance LLM hosting laptop will want to run bare metal Linux, because the software stacks involved are Linux native. Yet somehow this is apparently not even tested properly, never mind available as a product.
Why the fuck is the power table encrypted?
This is a lack of linux driver support for firmware designed for windows laptops.
This is a problem on the MSI Prestige laptop using the RTX Spark platform. Lets assume it also applies to the Asus and Dell machines using RTX spark.
RTX Spark is a new platform and all of these laptops ship with Windows. You cant get Linux on any of these machines from the factory. There is also precedent for NVIDIA shipping linux support well after Windows (2 years in the case of Dynanmic Boost, a similar power sharing feature).
Then you misunderstand how hardware, software, firmware, drivers, and operating systems have worked for the last few decades.
Good luck with that. A PC is more or less defined by specifications laid out in Microsoft's Windows Hardware Compatibility program and tested by their Windows Hardware Lab Kit. Before that, it was defined by IBM.
I've heard that ARM has had a standard for ARM-based servers, their Server Base System Architecture, but I've never seen any compliant hardware in the wild.
They basically do. ChromeOS runs a Linux kernel, so the userland has everything it needs to run CUDA. FreeBSD is a first-class target for Nvidia drivers, and macOS used to be supported too but stopped signing Nvidia code. Nevertheless, AArch64 is still supported.
It is up to Nvidia to support whatever platforms they want users to be on. In their case, it means supporting many OSes.
My point is that's not Nvidia's responsibility. The article itself admits the laptop "ships with Windows on ARM", so support for another OS shouldn't be expected, even if NVIDIA supports other platforms and other product lines differently.
There are OEMs that refuse this responsibility. If that's the vindication you wanted, there you go. This specific issue is not a radical blocker that Nvidia will deliberately avoid.
> There is also precedent for NVIDIA shipping linux support well after Windows
There is also a precedent for NVIDIA nerfing drivers on Linux and pulling anti-competitive shenanigans against competition, so it's only reasonable that people look at the "missing" driver support with suspicion.
How does your conspiracy theory hold up to that?
GB10 and N1X are both Blackwell cousins. So they've had consumer-level Linux machines for a while now.
This was simply a partnership with Microsoft, so of course development of drivers and firmware focused heavily on Windows. Especially since I'm sure Windows required a LOT of updating to run nicely on ARM as well as the N1X unified memory model.
You may as well be right, I am speculating and this theory might be baseless (I don't think it is.) But GP's comment is wrong to ask people to simply read the article at face value. That is bad reading.
GB10 and N1X are the same thing. It's the same silicon.
> Especially since I'm sure Windows required a LOT of updating to run nicely on ARM as well as the N1X unified memory model.
Windows has been shipping with ARM64 support for 8 years; Microsoft and Qualcomm already took care of those hurdles, which was almost certainly a key factor in NVIDIA's decision to build a laptop SoC in the first place.
They have not figured out how to make Windows work nicely on a unified memory model: https://forums.developer.nvidia.com/t/rtx-spark-on-windows-c... Either you deal with those problems and having to reboot to change how much memory is reserved for the GPU, or you run with minimal reserved memory and most of your GPU memory accesses take a ~4x latency hit. Most RTX Spark systems seem to be shipping with a 50/50 split out of the box.
NVIDIA has had a full year since shipping DGX Spark (which was already clearly quite late to marker) to finish polishing the Windows support and power management. For them to ship in this state and regress the quality of Linux support on the same silicon is quite convincing evidence that they're half-assing this and really don't care about this platform the way they care about their datacenter cash cows.
Personally, I don't care. If you don't support open drivers, you have to provide first class drivers on Linux on day 1, because NVIDIA's majority of business is running on Linux already.
On top of that, they claim to have the best Linux support, and claim to have best drivers in their class.
So, it's better to act like that and provide support. If any other company has done that, they have been incinerated with the flame of internet's hate thrice already.
It is not obvious to me why they would want to do that.
NVIDIA and Microsoft tried so hard to make a Mac clone with this and it’s just missing the mark everywhere.
It doesn’t do the dynamic memory split that a Mac does so out of the box it reserves 32GB (half) for the GPU and windows limits CPU processes to that. Getting more memory requires a reboot.
And because I want Unix tools (without Cygwin), WSL2 splits that even further in half.
Performance is way behind a similarly specced Mac. The GPU is thermally throttled near a 5060 laptop. The CPU out of the box came in a lower power state but windows power management makes it stuttery unless you change that, at which point it’s cooling is a hurricane compared to the Mac which outperforms it while being quieter.
The new MagSafe like connector is stupidly designed too. You can’t generically use it in any USB-C port, it’s super chonky and disconnects only on the horizontal axis. Worse, because it’s a right angle connector it can only be used in one orientation without blocking the other ports.
Windows input handling sucks too. There’s a lag before the trackpad responds based on moved distance. Some terrible take on palm rejection I’m sure. But even their display is mediocre because it gets very bright but they messed up local dimming. So if you select a bunch of text in the terminal it blinds you.
Idk I got this specifically to do windows dev with CUDA on arm. So I knew it was niche but anyone else buying this is making a mistake. It’s an unfinished product trying to be a competitor that nobody in Microsoft even understands.
This Linux support issue is just the icing because everyone keeps asking me why I don’t just put Linux on it and workaround my issues, but you can’t.
I’ve spoken to friends at NVIDIA who say it’s rushed out. So maybe software will get better but I urge folks to not buy this unless you’re into the same niche needs as me.
Odd because Tegra/Jetson platforms have been doing this for years.
I suspect it’s a limitation of them focusing on Windows driver and windows being far behind the curve.
We can see with this evil cartel currently driving up the RAM prices how greedy they all are. Our money should go into fairness. The US court system has given up on that. Even on capitalism. Capitalism used to claim that a free market with competition leads to lower prices. Well - we have several de-facto cartels here. And nobody is breaking any of these up.
Vote with Your wallet.
Its that simple.
Every.
Single.
Time.
> laptop ran a full desktop at 4K and 120Hz, with working audio, touchpad, keyboard, and CUDA acceleration
is amazing. It seems that this person's MSI version had some quirks with firmware but Omarchy already supports the Asus and Dell versions of the RTX Spark out of the box. I'm surprised that everyone is focusing on the negative when, prior to RTX Spark's release, it wasn't clear if Linux would work on the RTX Spark at all in the first place.
This is way better support than Qualcomm's Snapdragon X1 and X2 laptops, which are still struggling to get Linux support years after release.
Presumably, once this one power management driver issue gets sorted out (surely an accidental bug rather than what some of y'all cynics are suggesting), it will be great. Now if only it could be cheaper...
I remember having a similar issue with an HP laptop running the first generation of Intel Alder Lake. The CPU would throttle heavily to something like 800Mhz on battery on Linux.
https://github.com/yyearth/turnoff-BD-PROCHOT