A good indicator though is the finances of the company. If you are going to be another cog contributing marginal value, for whatever reason that is, then it's going to be difficult to argue for better salary (thought they MIGHT give a higher salary, to everyone, like e.g. Google). If you can however have a big impact and they have good revenue or funding, then it's a lot easier to argue for higher salaries: "so you are making $300k MRR or just raised $5M of VC money with 4 employees? And you have more tickets and bug fixes to improve growth and reduce churn that you can feasibly do? Great, let's talk how I can effectively help to slash those tickets and then we can discuss my compensation".
Classic: https://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/01/23/salary-negotiation/
Cities definitely don’t have the resources to track you down and I’m not sure employers especially larger ones have any mechanisms in place to keep track. I’m not advocating for this just surprised it’s not more well known. Though I suspect it’s common and just not talked about much for obvious reasons. Certainly there are also jobs that require you to physically work from a given state as well for example.
How do so called digital nomads handle it from a tax perspective? Do they maintain a residence for tax purposes? Is that any different?
You can, for example, get employed at 10 companies and then outsource all the work (someone got caught doing it and it was in the news).
If you want to cheat, you can, but you probably should not be discussing it on hacker news.
What makes it more problematic is that it's not just tax offices that would be interested in finding out. The company you work at may also get in trouble with the tax office as they pay employment taxes too, so they are probably interested in the fact that you're deceiving them. If your manager suspects you're not being truthful and follows up with HR this could easily get you in trouble. As remote work becomes more popular, it becomes more likely that companies will pay attention to this.
Knowing all of that, I'd find it quite hard to justify playing these games. It just seems like asking for trouble, with a pretty good chance of getting it.
For example, it's de facto not illegal to drive 5mph over the speed limit on the highway. No police officer will pull you over for that unless they have some other prior reason. So in that sense, lack of enforcement has made the practice legal.
They probably have a "permanent address" at a friend's house or through some service. And it's probably technically fraud. That said, the US is not really setup for citizens not to have a permanent address in one state--even if just for things like driver's licenses. You can do things by the books for tax purposes but I suspect a lot of people moving around don't.
https://www.annuity.org/personal-finance/taxes/residency-req...
Ultimately it comes down laws, regulations and taxes. Company wants to make it easy for itself to deal with that.
You can just say plans changed and you moved in the case of an audit. You could tell your employer the same thing. Much harder to dock someone's salary once they've started working.
California FTB very much cares if you are collecting SV salary but are not paying CA taxes by living in LCOL areas. Unless you are a CPA, please do not spread lies.
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/business_law/publications...
In the city where I currently live, lots of small businesses try to claim that their employees are contractors. Those businesses depend on the ignorance of their workers.
In France, companies also like to contract out a lot, either to "freelance" or regular outsourcing shops.
The reason I put freelance in quotes is that there's no such thing here, legally. You have to have some form of company, through which you invoice the client.
But then, whenever you want to get the money out of the company to pay rent and eat, you'll be hit by, more or less, the same taxes the employer would pay. For a given unit of work, it's not cheaper to contract out, there's no real tax loophole.
As far as I know, the state doesn't really care. It may even prefer it, since contractor rates are usually higher than salaries, so they get to get more tax.
The only situation where it would crack down on this is if the would-be employee complained. Since this is considered a "precarious" arrangement, if the contractor can prove that they're basically an outsourced employee, they can ask to be converted to an actual employee and the state will back them up.
However, depending on what you do, people can end up paying less in taxes overall as a contractor because you have more flexibility for deductions. There are very little options for an employee to deduct any expenses in the US, whereas, a contractor could potentially deduct the cost to commute to an office, their cellphone and home internet (if used for work) and even a portion of their rent/mortgage for a home office.
which means you're a contractor, rather than an employee. I do think this is a better way tbh, as you can potentially own all of your healthcare costs, and optimize your taxes properly. And you can probably charge a lot more as a contractor, to make up for the lack of job security etc.
It is a poor reflection of our tax system that running your own entity that you then pay yourself out of can have lower taxes than simply earning money as an employee.
If the reason is bullshit, there's no need to bullshit back.
If the reason isn't bullshit (e.g. coz they want you in their Manhattan office on a moment's notice) then having a virtual address won't help.
WA has no state income tax, but a beefier payroll tax, so it's cheaper for me but more expensive for the company.
You know the old saying, noting is certain except death, and the will of the department of taxation for the state of (California|New York).
.. where are those tax exempt? In the UK they're treated as income at the time of vesting, which is not unreasonable https://frazerjames.co.uk/rsus-a-tech-employees-guide/
So yeah, you do need to learn about the different examples. It's something people just talk about in the valley and ultimately/generally is where the "high compensation" from tech comes from. In other countries/cities people don't even know what any of these things are.
[1] https://zajacgrp.com/insights/what-you-need-to-know-about-do...
Play the game as fits your needs. For example, adjust your work output and use the freed time to look for a better employer.
It's mostly about what you can negotiate to be fair. Refusing to pay you more is their way of telling you they don't believe you can get something better than what they offer where you are which is legitimate. They will reassess if you show them a better offer from a competitor if they really want you. A big part of negotiation rests on your best alternative to what's being negotiated.
> It's different, and you need to adjust your processes
So you actually agree it's complicated from a company point of view.
Except when they collude to drive down wages or pay for laws to make it harder for workers to organize keeping them weak. Also "where you are" has been made irrelevant for many workers because they can get employment anywhere without going anywhere. That means what's really being said is that they don't believe you can get something better than what they offer anywhere.
Except that employees would do the same thing that employers do all the time and walk across the line as soon as someone offers them a compelling deal, even if it isn't at the "collusion" price.
That's like saying the price of goods and services should be about the cost of producing them. No no no: the price is about what buyers will bear. In the same way, salaries are about what the worker will bear.
If there is an arbitrage lever to maximize profit, any business will use it.
I just don't think this is true for the overwhelming majority of employees, including developers.
Corporations have enough staff that they can lay off hundreds or thousands of workers without a single worry. They can hold out not paying you the rate you want for much longer than you can afford not paying your bills and eating. Eventually, you will accept a lower salary and if you don't there are plenty of others who will. The vast majority of all employed people have next to no leverage compared to the companies that hire them and companies know it.
The large problem with the collusion before was that the 3-4 that already paid top of the market salaries colluded to keep them the same. It doesn’t mean they weren’t still top of the market for someone with a given level of experience.
But a professional in a small team, usually witha bus factor of 1? This means a hard time finding a new employee + months of training, while the old worker probably found a new job before they even quit at the first one.
There are plenty of blogposts from the other side, about "never give a raise to a flight-risk, because their loyalty is already shot". The business strategy is to quietly hire a (typically cheaper) replacement, then fire the uppity employee.
This depends on how happy/able the employee is to leave to find an alternative.
A while ago I was at a trade fair in Germany and happened to see an advert from a jobs website, it read (roughly translated): "Hate your job ... ? It's your own fault!" (ie that you've not yet left the job you claim to hate...)
Must be nice being wealthy. Most people can barely go a single month without a paycheck.
> severance pay or unemployment insurance
Lol. In the UK, severance pay is one week per year of service, i.e. nothing. Unemployment insurance typically covers only specific costs, like mortgages, and can be significantly expensive.
And this is quite good compared to what happens almost anywhere outside of Europe.
> Transaction costs for employer depends
For any well-established business with significant redundancy, these costs are minimal. Only small companies suffer significantly when losing an employee.
Not necessary wealthy. For people with median pay, it is more about financial responsibility. According to EU-SILC data more than half EU population has financial reserves for at lest three months.
> Lol. In the UK, severance pay is one week per year of service, i.e. nothing. Unemployment insurance typically covers only specific costs, like mortgages, and can be significantly expensive.
Here in Czechia it is 2 months notice period, then severance pay is 3 months (for > 2 years of employment), and then 5 months of government unemployment benefits on ~half pay. So 10 months to find a new job.
> For any well-established business with significant redundancy, these costs are minimal
Even in large businesses you can have small teams with domain experts, losing them can be costly.
Most corporate cultures are inherently authoritarian, with money being used as a proxy for power.
Empirically there is plenty of evidence that given a choice, many businesses would rather maintain the power differential and complain about "lack of applicants" than increase pay and suffer a corresponding diminution of authority.
Stock is an even more specific proxy for power, which is why stock options that have real value are usually reserved for those at the top of the hierarchy.
This is also why remote working is unpalatable. Even if it increases productivity it also enhances worker autonomy and reduces the power differential. That's not acceptable in an authoritarian culture.
Attitudes to remote work can be a useful indicator of how central hierarchy is in the culture.
Why does any company every pay more than the legally required minimum, then?
If you have 10 employees and you want to hire 3 more but to do that you have to increase their pay by 25% in relation to others then you might decide not to because this decreases power for everyone (should they find out what you're paying these others)
Oh come on. This is a cynical or Marxist take, but it's pretty obviously untrue. A flea market, farmers market, FB marketplace doesn't have a substantial power imbalance. A market may have a power imbalance, but it is not required. People can exchange goods/services at equal power, and routinely do so. And if I understand economics correctly, that's the purpose of a "free" market: no artificial power imbalances.
It's only later laissez-faire and neoliberal capitalists that turned "free market" synonymous with a lack of regulation and a playground for the biggest and most powerful companies.
Nobody credible disputes the validity of Marx's critiques of capitalism and 'free markets' by the way - they dispute his fantasy called communism.
Thus it can't simultaneously be a Marxist take and be obviously untrue. One of those has to give :)
I'd encourage anyone to read the first chapter of the Communist Manifesto [0] that summarizes his issues with capitalism. It'll take less than 30 minutes and is a great read, unlike the rest of his writings (in my opinion).
[0] https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/61/pg61-images.html
It's like asking "why shouldn't workers work for subsistence income instead of asking for more money?": the obvious answer is "because the only reason they would consider doing so when they don't have a choice"
Being a shareholder requires capital, which the vast majority of people don't have.
Arguments against will be that value "is" what people are willing to pay for them, which is some combination of supply and demand, but I find this just too simple. Technically it's true that the "value" of something is the price someone last paid for it, but then we get situations where we say a Bitcoin is worth 40k usd or whatever tf the price is right now. And then suddenly its value is 20k, and if you ask why you'll get thirty answers, all wrong. Maybe the price was 40k to someone and 20k to someone else, but the value? Nah. And the price alone tells us basically nothing.
The interesting thing for me is the third person. Me, in this case, to whom Bitcoin is worth 0, or less than 0 because I would consider it a labor cost to own a Bitcoin (figuring out a wallet or whatever). How does someone to whom a Bitcoin is worth 40k then then around and say "Bitcoin is worth 40k" to someone like me?
To capitalists trying to nod their heads and say ah the price is high, supply must be down or demand must be up, I say, good luck predicting human behavior, that usually goes great.
For me though I agree with you, the value of goods is some combination of their production costs, in any meaning of the word "value" that matters.
"But what if someone spends an entire lifetime of labor producing a single widget nobody wants? Clearly demand plays a part in value!" I don't know, go away. Why would that happen? Sure, ok, also include in value calculus that hopefully people only make things that people actually want. (the capitalist argument here is, the profit is to be found in the margin between cost to create and the price set by desirability - to which I say exactly, profit should be eliminated)
Edit: someone else had a comment they deleted talking about how profit is necessary so as to have surplus to save in case of equipment failure, I'll paste my response here cause my thumbs put in the labor so by golly I'll get the Payout
Traditionally, are profits sequestered to be used as savings like that? In my experience the equipment breaks and both companies go bankrupt because the executives in the c corp spent the profit on themselves already and are happy to just go find a new investment.
Actually in my experience the other company, the co-op, doesn't go bankrupt, because the workers are smart enough to safeguard their well being with rainy day funds. This might be one of the reasons coops are repeatedly shown to be far more resilient than traditional companies.
While I am not an expert, I remember reading about it on "The Classical School: The Turbulent Birth of Economics in Twenty Extraordinary Lives", by Callum Williams. It made sense to me.
https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/49374783
While linking to the sources is useful, I would appreciate any argument correcting the above since, as I said, I am not an expert and it makes perfect sense to me.
This is not true; Marx's model of exploitation (known to modern economists as the Profit-Exploitation Correspondence Model (PECP)) does not concern itself with what demand and offer agree on within a labor negotiation. Marx says that workers do not sell their labor, they sell their labor-time (e.g. X units of time/goods) during which they exercise their labor-power. The discrepancy between the value of the time and the value produced during that time is where this 'exploitation' comes in.
The idea that exploitation is a matter of opinion or agreement adds a moral or justicial spin to what Marx considered to be a fact of the capitalist economy. Whether the people involved are happy with the situation or agree to it does not change this discrepancy of value or its representation in money.
Marxism is explicitly amoral, it does not concern itself with that is morally right. It is a social science that analyses the contradictions within the material world and their consequences.
> The discrepancy between the value of the time and the value produced
I am thinking how can one value this time. If it is valued by the market (how much someone is willing to pay for it) we would end up with the same problem, no?
It must be intrinsically valued, I am assuming.
The capitalist wants to pay as little as possible per hour, but will on average long term not be able to pay less than the cost of living. Capitalists pay just enough so that workers as a class reproduce themselves (so there are more workers), but less than the value the workers produce.
What is the "value"? Well, the prices cannot be explained only in terms of offer and demand (a society with an offer of 100 pens and demand for 100 pens and offer of 100 planes and demand for 100 planes still would not sell pens and planes for the same price) nor entirely because of the price of raw materials (because this only postpones the explanation: from where came the price of the raw materials?). It also cannot be explained only based on subjectivity, because there exists a number, which is a very objective measure, representing the price if you balance offer, demand, assume competition and discard several perturbations. The "value" tries to explain this basis value that later will became the price and show objectively and numerically how the wealth is produced and distributed.
This "value" is measured by Marx as the quantity of labor socially necessary to produce the product. Given a car, the value represented by a car can be measured by the mean time necessary for the workers to produce that car in the industry plus the value transferred by the machines and tools used by those workers (whose value came from the workers that produced these machines and tools). Both manual and intellectual work need to be taken into account and you can also assume that some complex tasks or more intense work can produce more value than simple tasks in the same time.
Given this, you can compare the value produced by a worker with the value of the things that the worker can buy with its salary. This is how Marx measures these things and shows the exploitation in the society.
There is bid price, ask price, and last sale price.
Do they indicate "value" to the specific people making those transactions, bids and asks? Sure. Does it have to be the same for everybody? No, and that's why trade happens.
But that tendency comes with a lot of asterisks.
Not sure why you are getting downvoted though.
Seems like a dangerous analytical framework.
This is literally why one function of the state is to act as a non-market-participant so it can provide a safety net. There are some things markets can't and shouldn't try to do.
The market has been taking care of it for too long, we're getting too fat, we need a few decades of food controlled by the police to get back into shape.
I don’t know if you’ve seen the average American waistline, but yes, this part is absolutely true. Unhealthily so.
You're not helping your argument with this example imo.
If I am a CEO of a remote-first company and it truly doesn't matter for me where the employees are located it makes no sense to overpay for labor in high cost of living area.
So if there's a company A that pays $X in high COL area, and $X/3 in a low COL area. And then there's a company B that pays $X/2 everywhere. Then people from the low COL area would go to the company B, and people from the high COL area would go to the company A. As a result, company B gets the same results 2 times cheaper.
Repeat this process enough times and the salaries will be equalized. Of course it's not immediate, there are companies rigidly set in their ways; there are people who won't move no matter what; there is limited supply of both companies and workers; etc, etc. But eventually the market forces will do their thing.
The assumption dorwi's asking you to make is that moving to Silicon Valley somehow makes you work twice as fast, or that only engineers who work twice as fast live there.
Basically, lunarhustler is making the assumption that humans who can program end up at roughly the same quality no matter where they live or how much you pay them, while dorwi is making the assumption that how much you are paid is directly related to your productive output.
Beyond that, highest paid people I know aren't paid well because they're 5x as productive, they're paid well because they solve really hard problems - the types of problems you don't run into at most companies.
To use an analogy: neurosurgeons aren't expensive because they're really good at "doctoring". Even if you had all the $$$ in the world you wouldn't consult one for a sprained ankle.
After you're necessity for that market equalization is long gone.
We're in a situation where the wealth class can literally wait it out for more than a generation for market conditions they prefer to normalize. The Market is manipulated and owned, and not by us. The tipping point is past, and the majority of society has yet to realize, our only hope at this point probably requires violence and capital destruction, sadly.
And who is 'us' in that comment?
Seems to be all going pretty well.
"Normal people in the western world are better off than they were at any/nearly any given time in the past."
and
"There is a staggering amount of wealth inequality in the western world right now, and there are very concerning signs about what it is doing to our politics, economy, and culture."
Not sure what you mean 'what it is doing to our politics, economy, and culture.'? All those are doing ok as far as I can tell. At least not worse than in the past.
I'm talking about inequality within the developed nations—specifically, the US (I believe it also affects the UK; I don't feel qualified to talk about such effects beyond that, due to lack of information).
As for what's happening with our politics...if you can't see that the current situation is wildly different than it was 40, 20, or even 10 years ago, then I'm sorry, but you have not been paying close attention. We have people proclaiming themselves as actual literal neo-Nazis storming the Capitol building in an attempted coup, in open collaboration with certain members of Congress and the wife of a sitting Supreme Court judge. And while some of the people involved in the Jan 6 coup attempt are, indeed, being convicted as they should be, to my knowledge, none of the politicians who are complicit have been publicly investigated. This is not normal, it is not healthy, and while it is not entirely due to the increasing wealth inequality, to claim that that has no part in the level of polarization today and the rise of extremism...well, it would be an extraordinary claim, and thus require extraordinary evidence to support it.
This is a case where, at least in certain respects, times are provably getting worse than they were before.
If politics are too fuzzy and nebulous for you, look at generational economics: I don't recall the precise figures off the top of my head, but the baby boomers are still holding wealth vastly disproportionate to their share of the demographics, and younger generations have vastly less income and wealth than they did at the same time in their lives, while over the same period, prices of many important things—like homes, health care, and higher education—have all risen much faster than the rate of inflation. The kind of house that someone working minimum wage could have afforded in 1960, they'd now need a white-collar job (probably requiring a college degree) and several years of savings to buy.
You can't just handwave all of that away as "eh, people have complained about times getting worse since the Ancient Greeks".
Can't afford to buy a house or start a family at anything like the rate 50 years ago that's for sure.
You can always afford to start a family. The question is what trade-offs you want to make.
People used to do with less.
It might be there are people who are able and willing to burn money for a long time. Sure as hell it doesn't stop me the startup founder to set whatever salary ranges I believe are efficient.
We don't give people different offers based on where they say they live.
Rather, we have a salary range for a job, and we look for people who are attracted by that salary range. This usually means people in SF, NYC, and other high COL cities disqualify themselves, so we end up hiring many people outside of tech hubs.
In other words, if you simply stop hiring in the top 20% COL cities, you can hire talent at significantly less salary ranges simply because we're not competing with Google, Amazon, etc in Silicon Valley or NYC.
Which allows us to hire a greater quantity of people. E.g. 2 engineers at $150k instead of 1 engineer at $300k.
But the key to this is not making a salary decision based on location. Instead, just set a salary range and you'll find what parts of the country people are willing to work at that range.
I have my home address, but I actually only spend maybe 4-6 months of the year physically located there. This kind of pisses off most employers due to the tax situation as well as them treating it as if I'm gaming the system by being physically located for much of the year in lower cost of living areas (though sometimes I've even gone to higher cost of living areas for months at a tiem).
A situation like this where the salary doesn't really depend on location so it wouldn't be treated like I'm actively trying to game anything would actually be preferred in my situation, and to many others I know as well.
Exactly. We've had multiple employees move to different cities/states during their tenure. That wasn't a problem with us (from an employer perspective) and there was also no expectation that salary would be adjusted in response to a move, since location wasn't factored into the original offer in the first place.
For run of the mill junior-ish employees who are treated as disposable cogs by my company, your strategy worked effectively. So we ended up with junior employees in LCOL or foreign countries (mostly Canada and Mexico) and senior levels in SFBA / NYC.
There is no real equilibrium in markets, only forces that push constantly in one direction (maximizing profits, lowering costs, increasing capital efficiency).
In fact, if you think about it, the upper limit to profit margin is
profit_margin = (price_sell - price_buy) / price_sell
Look familiar?There are perfectly valid reasons why that's not the case, see here:
https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/total-rewards/compensation...
https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2019/02/28/why-we-pay-local-ra...
For example, moving to a low cost of living area is something I did as a choice so that I could save more, and this came with a cost: my friends live further away now. They’re saying I should be penalised for this by not being able to save more compared to their employees who stayed in the high cost of living area.
What a bunch of hypocrites. The perfectly know that what a person is currently making does not come "organically" into the conversation. The employer does whatever is in its power to have this information from the candidate.
Does it have challenges? Yes. Am I a valued employee? Yes, I am potentially one of the most valuable employees after my first year in my team. Easily top 20%.
I visit my team every few months for a week. Mostly the point is so we can go out for dinner and I get to have some drinks with them. The workday itself is changed very little by being in person.
Imagine haggling with a supplier like this. Crazy we put up with it.
But they are not hiring you for "value", you are just a body in a seat filling a "role".
Real game to play is: you ask for X money, they propose Y money, agree and do Y amount of work and not the X amount of work. It's entirely reasonable to "quite-quit" even at non-minimum-salary compensation levels.
Perhaps the company doesn't see it worthwhile to argue over peanuts.
Btw, it's getting bigger in the US as well over the least few decades.
Singapore is a place with a smaller gap, and less regulation. That's part of the reason they went from third world to first world.
Where you put your developers shouldn't make much of a difference to how much business you have?
However you are up to something: big cities tend to be more productive. That's the reason people and businesses put up with the higher rents and other inconveniences. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration
What, no! It should be about what offers you can get from other places. If your offer is close to your local salaries, then that mean the company thinks you would have a hard time getting a better offer from somewhere else.
For example, I can get x$ from Google, but that doesn't mean SAP or ASML should also pay me x$: I don't know anything about their respective ecosystems, so I wouldn't be able to contribute much of value.
It's complicated because a large number of managers haven't figured out how to manage a remote team.
Remote work does an exposé on the usefulness of these roles. And of course, those holding them, would be eager for everyone to return to the office work theater.
> duct tapers, who temporarily fix problems that could be fixed permanently, e.g., programmers repairing shoddy code...
To think that code can be “fixed permanently” shows a complete lack of understanding and insight into programming, and brings to mind the Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect - if Graeber is so wildly wrong about a subject I know well, why do I trust him on those I don’t?
More so than ever with the push for MVP and agile ticket stat chasing.
I imagine that the only bug that gets fixed "permanently" is in a product that nobody uses enough for it to need change. Like some failed MVPs.
And it looks great at the start, the project is making great progress until people start to leave and the tech debt starts to kick in. By that stage all the "high performance" agile rock stars have pissed off to another company and left behind their legacy.
And then its death by 1000 cuts, things aren't logged correctly, no proper exception handling rather just do a print(e) and falling over, any integrations with 3rd parties aren't documented when they break and its just a mess.
(I know that in eg France is basically impossible to fire people, so I can see why they might have lots of bullshit jobs.)
There's always the human factor in capitalism. And with the human factor comes ego.
IIRC, Graeber roughly compares CEOs to feudal kings. You want more people under your rule as a metric of success. Also, the "king" often seeks to have a big "court" (top-level managers) to reflect their prestige.
The effect is cascading. The "king's court" members want their own smaller courts (second-level managers) and compete with their peers for power, as measured by the headcount. As we go down, unecessary hires will start to occur, only to justify a title.
And everyone involved in the theater has an incentive to turn a blind eye on the situtation.
See also how share prices often increase when layoffs are announced.
Whether we hire a dedicated manager or have the responsibility rotate among teammates really depends on a bunch of factors both internal and external to the team / company.
Most people who get a job in America (can't speak for other places) are not interested in managing. It's too messy. If more doers took on management work - we'd be able to push out shitty managers. Until that happens though, my recommendation is to immediately move to a different team or company as soon as a shitty manager is installed.
In salary per value to the company you are extremely overpaid, assuming you live in the west.
I don't think you want to open that can of worms.
Edit to add:
All those people moving from India to the US for the money could then stay in India.
You're not competing with the remote work crowd. You are competing with local cost of labor. If the market switches to just value added, unrelated to location, then you're screwed.
The big problem is that labour in India isn't all that productive. Offshoring isn't some magic bullet. Companies have tried that and are still trying.
Google, Microsoft etc have offices in India. They also keep their offices in the US and Europe not just out of imaginary obligation to westerners, but because it makes economic sense.
See also how Apple still does lots of the design work in the US, but manufactures in China. They would off-shore more off the design work as well, if they could. (And if Apple could but would not, someone else would do it and eat their lunch.)
There are great people in India. It's just more conducive for them to get better pay if they manage to get an H1B and move to the US.
If they could just "work remote", then you (as an American, or at least someone who can and does work in the US? Well, applies to any western country) are no longer competing with "people from India who manage to get an H1B and have a family situation compatible with moving countries", but suddenly with ALL qualified workers in India.
Big tech in the west employs HUGE numbers of expats from lower paid countries. A very large portion of which Big tech paid for the H1B (or equiv) and relocation costs.
If you are remote, then you're only valued on your output. And I'm not saying you're in a poor position against a random engineer from India (nor presumably from a random engineer in the US), but you'll be in a poor position against the equivalent of your amazing local coworker who moved from India (or hell, any European country with less pay) because that's where the job was.
If the job is "anywhere, because it's remote", then I'm saying that you may not be on the winning side of this change.
Opening up "work from anywhere" is not like offshoring to save costs. More like given two equally valuable people, why should an employer pay a premium to one, just because they chose to live in a higher cost of living country?
> Opening up "work from anywhere" is not like offshoring to save costs. More like given two equally valuable people, why should an employer pay a premium to one, just because they chose to live in a higher cost of living country?
Yes, and that's progress! That's good!
Most just think they're clever and exploiting the system, and the thought that they'd get paid lowly Texas (or Ohio) salaries never occurred to them.
Though I do think 'off-shoring' from California to the Ohio vs off-shoring from California to India have important aspects in common.
For better or worse, agglomeration effects are real, and for some ineffable reasons software people are more productive when located in Silicon Valley, rather than Ohio. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration
However the pandemic forced an investment in making remote-work work. That's not even so much an investment in technology (hardware or software), but more taking the time and effort to figure out what works and doesn't work. It's full of soft factors.
Why pay to get H1B and shipping for someone from India when you can just hire that same person in place and not only save on that, but also salary?
Offshoring in my experience does not usually work on an individual basis.
Unfortunately it's not that simple. It usually turns out that these lower paid employees are significantly worse, and Indian nationals who are highly competent demand salaries similar to Americans.
But it's literally the exact same people, in this case. Big tech currently pays to move them to the US, and then pays them higher salary.
That is very different from spinning up a department in India.
All else being equal, the only reason to hire a distant programmer is to pay them less. From the firms perspective they can't easily tell if a distant programmer is more effective than a local programmer so it is a struggle (market-for-lemons style) to justify paying the same amount. If the costs are equal, may as well hire local.
It starts to make sense when you realise salaries are driven by the cost to replace an employee (including the risk of a bad hire), not the value they provide. Companies can't measure the value individual programmers provide anyway.
You could reframe these points so that they look like advantages of global businesses... you'll have someone to vouch for and evaluate people across multiple talent pools (increasing talent supply), the majority of your team will never be sanctioned simultaneously (diversifying that risk), and as for cultural norms, don't we all know that diversity is strength.
Saying there are no advantages to global remote first besides cost is underselling it; there are important advantages, for one
> It starts to make sense when you realise salaries are driven by the cost to replace an employee
asynchronous remote makes documentation and written communication central, which at the end of the day makes it easier to replace employees.
Cost is important too, if you can literally hire 50% more workforce that's one hell of a deal.
> All else being equal, the only reason to hire a distant programmer is to pay them less.
Yes. To give some example where not everything else is equal:
There can be benefits from covering more timezones, or benefits from covering different jurisdictions (and tax regimes).
Tell that to the kid getting paid 14 cents an hour on the other side of the planet to make your $1,500 iPhone.
Most people will be envious of the transaction relationship be it employee/employer or consumer/seller and feel that they were cheated, regardless.
The wage was too low, the product was priced to high from one side and the wage was too high and the product priced too cheap from the other.
There is actual cheating but it seems like people are never(rarely) actually satisfied, and social media has made it worse.
Making remote work and pay for productivity more common and accepted, would help that kid. That's good!
Employment rules, customs, and laws vary by at least state and country (and minimum wages vary by city). How would I know what laws applied to the employment relationship?
Do you report and pay federal taxes and state taxes separately? Or do you just deal with IRS and they forward the docs and the money to the state you live in?
Yes. They are separate sets of forms that you pay (or get refunded) independently. They're basically unrelated exxcept to the degree that deductions/refunds may come into play.
The employer is making various deductions and payments, e.g. into unemployment, based on the state you live in. So your employer really does need to know your state of residence.
NH has sovereignty to set their minimum wage (subject to the limit of the federal minimum wage). They might do that to attract business there. Massachusetts has the same sovereignty to set their minimum wage. Which state should give up their sovereignty so that an employer [possibly out of state] could practically hire people without knowing where they live?
You suggest how much you are willing to pay me to the government. And I get information how much I'll be earning after taxes and required social security fees.
If I don't agree or the amount you proposed is illegally low then I can't work for you until you decide to bump up the salary.
If I agree I start working. You pay to the government the full amount. Government taxes it and transfers the rest to me as a salary.
If you pay too little or too late you are on the hook with the government. But you don't need to know where I live or what the taxes are.
With electronic system the whole procedure of hiring could probably take an afternoon or less and zero knowledge.
It's a balancing act. If companies pay based on value added to the company, they will wind up paying more than average in low COL areas, and less than average in high COL areas; so they won't be able to hire people in high COL areas at all. If they scale pay based on COL, they'll be able to hire people in both areas. So yes, it's not "fair" to people in lower COL areas, but it's not arbitrary either.
You say it like it's a bad thing. If they can hire people for relatively cheap purely from low COL areas, and make the company work, they should totally go for that. That's the whole reason behind having offices in even cheaper areas like Vietnam, instead of just the American Midwest.
Of course, if you can't actually run your business purely on people from low COL areas, that means there must be something the people from the high COL areas bring to the table that's worth it for your business. And that's proves the original commenter's point that the company should pay you according what value you bring to the company.
It's called the "job market" for a reason. Both sides (employers and employees) are trying to maximize their returns. It's never going to be solely about the value we as developers (or any other occupation) bring to the company.
Keep in mind that not all companies are competing for talent globally. [1]
This shift in the labor market will eventually settle. The real question is whether companies that compete in a local or regional market locally will be able to retain anyone with specialized skills who can go remote at local salaries, or if they’ll just give up and find some other solution.
[1] https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/software-engineering-sala...
Sounds like your interview at companies who employ the former, not later.
https://www.zenefits.com/workest/cost-of-living-vs-cost-of-l...
They all want to sell nationally or internationally whilst paying based on what they think the local market value for labour should be.
I’ve worked remote and managed remote teams for a long time. I would say it is indeed more complicated.
You may not struggle with remote work and may do fine interacting remotely, but that’s not true for a lot of people. It’s very common to hire good engineers into remote positions and discover that they can’t focus at home, they misinterpret digital communications, or that they just wanted a remote job because they read somewhere that they could work 2 hours per day and nobody would be able to tell.
The obvious retort is that you just need to hire “right”, but that’s not an easy thing to do.
"You may not struggle with office work and may do fine interacting in person, but that’s not true for a lot of people."
I have people who do far better at home than in the office, and some on the other end of the spectrum. People come in all sorts of shapes and sizes and finding the right people is the same challenge regardless.
What is hard is tooling and setting up processes that work for remote people. The world is at the start of figuring that out at scale and there is lots to learn. But hiring is always going to be the same game, finding the right people for the role and its requirements.
If I were hiring for an oil rigger it would not be more complex than hiring for a great developer. It will definitely be different, but all recruitment is different and sees different challenges. But it's always going to be about knowing what to ask, knowing your industry, and doing your very best to find a process that selects fairly and efficiently. Remote work hiring is just a different challenge that we are all just getting used to. People are hard problems to solve.
Are you claiming that the complexity of managing in-office is usually, roughly the same as managing remote teams? I'm asking towards magnitude/degree, not if both are sometimes true.
If not, you are stating the obvious: "People come in all sorts of shapes and sizes"
In my experience, more people struggle with remote than in-office. I've found a lot of satisfaction in returning to a primarily in-person team for this reason. But that's just my experience, an anecdote. Not everyone should be like me, and I'm not saying everyone should return to the office or that WFH is bad. What I am frustrated about is that it seems like many people take dogmatic pro-WFH positions and do not acknowledge the nuance of these issues.
Case in point, you struggle with WFH, others thrive. I just don't see any problems with employees not enjoying WFH as being significantly more complex than, say, an issue with someone struggling to get into the office on time. Or being stressed out by a stupidly long commute, or having no time with their children. And so on. There are pros and cons abundant that pretty much level it all out.
You really need a team of like-minded people w/r to remork work. They started working as a company with people from different company locations forming "a team". And after Covid started, they realized it's perfectly fine to add people to the team that do not sit in offices.
Thinking back, at my past employer, we had a subsidiary in another city, and failed to work with them. It would have been so much easier if we'd been able to do that. But management didn't like it, so it didn't work.
How could a statement about recruitment be contorted into one about management
An employer, especially one that isn't just a Human being but a company, will only pay you enough to make you sign and incentivize you to work. They don't care at all how you make your living.
And there are tons of just dumb things in remote work policy today. My company does cost of living adjustment based on the state you’re in. So if you were to move to a high cost city in a low cost state (Bozeman, MT), it’s a brutal effective pay cut. But if you move to low cost city in an expensive state (Yreka, CA), it’s a huge effective pay raise. Despite, theoretically, the employer getting the same value.
I think these will sort themselves out over time, but it’s annoying in the short term.
They refused to even talk about it, even as I protested they'd wasted so much of my time and I was about to sign. I walked away and found a much better paying job elsewhere.
Your salary has never been even related to the value you bring the company. That is just the absolute maximum they're willing to pay. Your salary is the lowest your company thinks they can pay to get a suitable employee. They pay remote workers less because there are remote workers willing to work for less, simple as that.
There is some correlation, don't get me wrong, but it looks like people are generally undervalued at the low end of the compensation spectrum and overvalued at the high end.
no shortage of threads here or reddit or elsewhere: "new guy got hired and they;re making 10k more than me and I've been here 5 years" and the like.
there is a reason jumping every 2-3 years gives a better raise than sitting in the same job.
Your mistake is to assume that you (being there 5 year) is doing your work well and over the expectations, becoming an important piece to your team. Important enough that your manager wants to secure you as part of the team. Maybe you are just average. Regardless of being 2, 5 or 10 years there.
I guess that can happen. I suspect in the majority of cases, you keep your shitpay even if you become a supremely efficient pillar.
Employers are not friends, they're businesses who thinks like psychopaths, so manage your expectations and get as much money as you can from them. You need them but they need you, so get the juice and move on when it gets hairy.
It was identified as a stupid idea from the start but I was curious what kind of concessions it involves. Like you cant just call a useful method anymore, it has to be known what it costs precisely given the exact work load.
It didn't take long for my mind to be blown by the completely insane overhead. Counting consumption of system resources is consumption too! While exact calculation is not very complicated every step of the way I felt tempted to just estimate it. Sorting out micro transactions in a secure way???...
Eventually I got distracted by the parallels with our society. Job agencies here charge 95% of the salary earned but the administrative overhead hardly ends there! The real cost is hidden in the estimated stuff. After all the taxes and subsidies are calculated someone at the tax office has to repeat the calculations. In some almost fixed percentage of cases mistakes are made and it takes judges, lawyers, law makers, lobby groups. Tons of expensive transactions along the way.
Before you can even get to work there are licenses, permissions, diplomas, certifications, health and sanity checks.
If your job is to dig holes one would think it involves little more than a pair of good boots and a shovel. End of the day you want a shower, a good meal, a roof over your head and some guarantee you don't have to dig holes the entire year round. (We are mistaken to think people in poorly paid grunt work are interested in trying to make ends meet.)
If you have just 20 people digging holes their performance becomes extremely measurable. They know exactly how good they are at their job. Rewarding them involves such an enormous clusterfuck of fuzzy params which may accumulate to 10 fold their salary (or more!) that their performance becomes irrelevant to their reward. The cost of accounting for it would be much larger than the cost of poor performance.
What we can do is reward their boss or their supervisor. We do that to maintain the illusion that every bit of overhead needs to be there. It is all there for a reason ofc, it is a legacy system slowly migrating from manual paperwork to automation.
You could have a very simple government app like Uber so that those who dig holes may dig holes. Customers and hole diggers can review the quality of the holes themselves. Contractors can use the API to have expensive fast holes, cheaper slow ones, an all you can eat rate or a hybrid between the 3.
But that is not going to happen, in stead we build machines to dig the holes, deploy even more administration, engineers, designers, repair shops etc lots of complicated skills required and the hole diggers can get social support while looking for other work which involves even more circus of estimates portrayed as measurement.
Some sub set of the bean counting is incredibly important and their work makes modern society what it is. Don't ask me to measure it tho.
Simplicity has its appeal. We could build monasteries where each monk maintains 1 module. If it worked for kung fu why not for array sort?
You're willing to go the extent of accusing people you never met nor have any idea who and how they are of being incompetent at a job you don't even know just to preserve your cognitive dissonance.
> Important enough that your manager wants to secure you as part of the team.
Straight out of college I worked at a place where they handed me a 1 year contract where I was paid below market rate. When I was reaching the end of my contract I asked for a meeting to review my salary. I had a meeting but it's outcome was a firm "we want you here but we will only offer you the same pay". I sat on that and on the day before my auto renewal would kick in I handed my resignation. I was immediately pulled into a meeting with my manager where they promply offered me over 20% pay hike.
Do you honestly believe I only gained importance the moment I resigned? They were the same people who said a few days earlier in no unclear terms I was not getting a raise.
The most ridiculous aspect of your unfounded personal belief is this idea there's this universal performance evaluation law where every manager and every boss is binded to hand over rigorous pay adjustments reflecting anyone's performance, and that there is no such thing as being exploited. Back in the real world, the whole economy revolves around people trying to get more value while paying less, and there's a almost universal pressure to not only eliminate any kind of leverage from employees but also make them perfectly replaceable cogs in their machine. You are pressured to not discuss salary with your peers, let alone other employees. You get what you are paid, and you should feel happy for it. If you work hard that just means your boss is getting more returns over his low investment.
For sure I assume that everyone did their homework and found a great company to work. That's the step 1! The step 2 is do the best version of you. That's the most important factor on your salary, assuming the step 1!
Good luck
Edit: we've asked you more than once before not to post like this. If you don't want to be banned on HN, we need you to heed these warnings.
Never happens. I have no idea where you got this from, but someone fooled you really hard.
Looks like you know all companies and every relationship between employee and employeer to come up to a bold conclusion. Or maybe you are just a fool.
Alright, Mr Gilbert, cloud engineer, microservices architect, UX person, whichever. What is your value to the company?
Well, I help to design a.....
No, your VALUE. As in, money. How much money do you make the company?
Errrr......
Why is this surprising? People like to pay less for things.
But then again, I'm grateful that we are in the position to get support from the government.
In person jobs have a smaller market. Everyone is subject to the same COL, so the min salary the employer must pay has a certain floor to it.
Remote jobs have a larger market. If you're remote, your employer may as well hire someone from Ohio that is willing to work for half your salary. You have to compete on cost with those cheaper employees.
They had a main office in South Carolina in an area with very low cost of living and salaries that matched. They had an office in Phoenix and an office in Seattle.
Ended up standardizing pay based on Phoenix since it was in the middle. This was actually a really big deal because the majority of the company was in South Carolina while only about 40 people were split between Seattle and Phoenix.
Why limit yourself to the CoL due to geographical location? How about the CoL of someone who is single and someone who has 2 kids in college? How about the CoL of someone who needs expensive drugs as opposed to someone healthy?
Oh you adjust to CoL? Well, then I expect my salary to be indexed on the inflation. Oh no? You only do the standard 3%? But what about CoL?
As a side note, a salary is not about the value you bring to the company either. It's just how much they have to pay to find someone with your skills.
I got interviewed a few times, and some stated that they cannot pay the salary I was asking, because i don't live in a high-density, high-cost-for-living area, while others argued that they have to respect their local salaries, which are below what I would expect in my area. I'm yet to meet the employer that can truthfully deduct the cost-for-living from the compensation they are offering. It should be about the value I bring to the company, not where I live.
Also, from my personal point of view, it's the time I'm saving for myself, not the money. Electricity is quite expensive nowadays, and my standing desk and audio/video equipment also wasn't payed by my employer.
What annoys me the most is that there are still companies out there stating that remote is "complicated". It's different, and you need to adjust your processes, but it's not "complicated".
//edit: fixed typos and added a/v equipment to my ramblings