You could reframe these points so that they look like advantages of global businesses... you'll have someone to vouch for and evaluate people across multiple talent pools (increasing talent supply), the majority of your team will never be sanctioned simultaneously (diversifying that risk), and as for cultural norms, don't we all know that diversity is strength.
Saying there are no advantages to global remote first besides cost is underselling it; there are important advantages, for one
> It starts to make sense when you realise salaries are driven by the cost to replace an employee
asynchronous remote makes documentation and written communication central, which at the end of the day makes it easier to replace employees.
Cost is important too, if you can literally hire 50% more workforce that's one hell of a deal.
> All else being equal, the only reason to hire a distant programmer is to pay them less.
Yes. To give some example where not everything else is equal:
There can be benefits from covering more timezones, or benefits from covering different jurisdictions (and tax regimes).
All else being equal, the only reason to hire a distant programmer is to pay them less. From the firms perspective they can't easily tell if a distant programmer is more effective than a local programmer so it is a struggle (market-for-lemons style) to justify paying the same amount. If the costs are equal, may as well hire local.
It starts to make sense when you realise salaries are driven by the cost to replace an employee (including the risk of a bad hire), not the value they provide. Companies can't measure the value individual programmers provide anyway.