News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by curt15 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:36AM (#50496926)
If the OG Google Glass got so much backlash 10 years ago, why should the current crop of recording products get any less hostility when they all pose the same privacy problem?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by benoau on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:54AM (#50497053)
There is already a big backlash with these glasses, they've become colloquially known as "perv glasses" and it's been proposed to make them illegal to use in some places!
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by ghm2180 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:01AM (#50498078)
Yeah I don't think I like the idea of someone wearing them and looking at me. They can just paint or tape over the privacy light.

There is a path forward though. If they can strip out pictures of people and PII by default from video feed and enforce explicit consent(digitally). People might be open to adopting it. I think only apple kind of has any where near that level of trust.

I think a biggest belief that tech people have in pilled circles at Meta and Google is that " this is amazing why would people not use it?" is dead.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SoftTalker on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:22AM (#50498242)
> strip out pictures of people and PII by default

You trust Meta to do this unfailingly, without making an exception for themselves which you will consent to somwhere in a 30 page user agreement?

That goes against the very core of their being as demonstrated by everything they've done to date.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by ghm2180 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:08PM (#50499262)
If meta actually wanted to sell consumer electronics to people. They have no choice but to actually compete with apple and apple will beat them every time on trust, at least today in 2026.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SoftTalker on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:47PM (#50503796)
Maybe. Today I would trust Apple more than Meta. There's no way to be assured that will not change however, so I don't want either one tracking me.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by timschmidt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:22AM (#50498244)
> I think only apple kind of has any where near that level of trust.

I'll trust them when I can inspect their source code and chip schematics.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by ghm2180 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:07PM (#50499252)
It does not matter if you trust them as long as non technical people do. Because HN crowd is less than 1% or people. People trust apple way more than meta.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by benoau on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:20PM (#50499375)
> People trust apple way more than meta.

I think it's more a case of the HN crowd trusts Apple way more than Meta.

Meta has ~3.5 billion users while Apple has ~2.5 billion users and Meta is one of their top app developers, which suggests people trust both of these companies way more than they should.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by ZnerflBerp on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:32PM (#50500011)
"Trust" and "use the services of" are very different things
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by LoganDark on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:46PM (#50501797)
Agreed, dozens of countries rely on Facebook for even government. Plenty of EU countries for example assume WhatsApp to a point where it's practically non-negotiable if you want to participate in the economy at all.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by microtonal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:42PM (#50500085)
If they can strip out pictures of people and PII by default from video feed and enforce explicit consent(digitally).

Seriously, trust Meta to do anything privacy preserving? Besides that, they also record audio.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by OptionX on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:05AM (#50497129)
Because the frog as been continuously boiling for a while now, so even if it generates a negative reaction it will be smaller than before.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by plastic-enjoyer on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:13AM (#50497184)
It is a generational thing. Gen Z grew up with an internet where it was normalized to share your complete life online, create posts under your real identity, and so on. Give it 1 - 2 generations, and perv glasses will be seen as not intrusive.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Loughla on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:58AM (#50497542)
Gen Z (and Alpha for that matter) very carefully curate their online lives. There is a distinct and appreciable difference between how they act when there are visible cameras and when there are not.

The kids are savvy.

In other words, I disagree with you. I think they'll be more likely to use them, but only under very particular circumstances.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by retwakm4 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:30AM (#50497800)
Gen Z is very opposed to perv glasses tbh and we are not generally speaking the same kind of "tech optimists" that prior generations often were. I think you've got your generational stereotypes a little off.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by sznio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:27AM (#50498290)
>Gen Z grew up with an internet where it was normalized to share your complete life online

I don't see that. Social media seems to be a Millenial phenomenon. Gen Z hates the internet despite using it. Gen Z uses nicknames rather than real names. Gen Z prefers private chatrooms to the exhibitionism of Facebook

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by mrdependable on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:58AM (#50498046)
For some reason in the last ten years, people have gone from being critical of corporations to favoring them. I think these companies have become so huge, and they have gotten away with so much, that people have resigned themselves to being at their mercy.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by skybrian on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:14AM (#50498174)
[delayed]
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by ToValueFunfetti on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:14AM (#50498179)
This doesn't seem to be the case- https://news.gallup.com/poll/5248/big-business.aspx
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by mannanj on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:42AM (#50498400)
I think there has been a growing failure in identifying fake opinions and accounts from real ones. Who's checking that the people you are engaging with are real, aren't AI or LLMs hired by some 3rd party agency to manufacture opinion about some company or cause?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by JDups on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:02PM (#50499219)
People are nearly universally critical of Meta, the only place I see people defending or talk positively about it is here.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by rolph on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:27PM (#50499445)
[delayed]
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by aprilthird2021 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:00AM (#50498071)
At the time there were two camps: tech-optimists who saw the value in a device that brought the power of the internet on top of your view of the world, and the other camp who worried about privacy or the "creep factor" and believed that outweighed any potential benefit.

When Google Glass came out that latter group had more sway culturally and more political power to ban such things. They don't have that as much anymore but that could swing back in their favor again

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Planktonne on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:41AM (#50498391)
"Tech optimists" is an extremely kind term here. The other group was 'worried about the creep factor' because their opposition were the creeps. This is still the case today.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by tdeck on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:27AM (#50498289)
"We will launch during a dynamic political environment where many civil society groups that we would expect to attack us would have their resources focused on other concerns,"

This is a quote from an internal Meta memo about how they would plan the launch of these creepy glasses. There are too many crises that seem more pressing to a lot of people.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by yasnu5 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:28PM (#50498848)
This is a domestic enemy. Send the military in against them. Drag them from their homes and throw them in Gitmo.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by richwater on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:10PM (#50500859)
unhinged
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by yasnu5 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:26PM (#50501006)
Don't you have some Adderall to snort, fag?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by account42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:22AM (#50516352)
Not at all. The original statement from Meta is unhinged behavior and well beyond what society should accept.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by progval on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:04PM (#50500285)
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by soundworlds on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:14PM (#50502961)
And Zuck endorses Trump to create this volatile political environment. Create social chaos so you can sneak your product in.

I very rarely think this about anyone, but I actually now think Zuckerberg is evil.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by jayd16 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:41PM (#50500084)
With the rise of cellphone video posted online I don't think it has the same visceral reaction it once did around the Google Glass era.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by eddythompson80 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:45PM (#50500121)
I think there are many reasons some but not all imo:

- The price difference. Calling a person who dropped $1,500 on a "tech glasses" in 2013 a glasshole made sense. It felt like someone with more money than sense. Meta glasses are $299 today that's just small gadget money so there is no "too much money, little sense" aspect

- Tech went 100% mainstream. It wasn't exactly an exclusively nerdy or geeky thing in 2013 anymore like the 90s or early 2000s, but there was still certain "Too much tech means you are a socially incompetent neckbeard". Today the biggest socialites online often do a tech haul style videos about the latest tech gadgets they got.

- Cameras exploded everywhere. Everyone has watched footage from Ring, GoPro, traffic lights, security cams, court cams, dashcams, police body cams, etc. Plenty of regular people got home cameras too and find it very useful to keep an eye on pets, backyards, etc. Plenty of very regular people have stories about how their cameras saved their ass in one occasion or another. There has been plenty of high-profile news stories about how a Tesla or a Ring camera helped solve a crime or catch a horrific murder or criminal.

- The proliferation of prank YouTubers in the 2010s. Even though most of them were paid actors, going out and acting as a douch and recording it became a mainstream. Kids love it, and despite the "backlash" they were getting millions regardless

- It doesn't matter how you feel about meta glasses or google glasses, you will have reports online of people who tell you how those products changed their life for the better because it helped them overcome some adversity, or protected them in a victim situation or literally saved their life in some situation

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pocksuppet on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:16PM (#50500384)
Don't forget prices have doubled since 2013, so it was $3000 equivalent in today's money.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by account42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:21AM (#50516344)
You never heard about boiling the frog? They'll keep trying both smaller and larger jumps. Some will get past the outrage and stick. Eventually only "nutters" object to what most of us today consider insane privacy invasions.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by deodorel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:40AM (#50496950)
These devices are illegal and make you face jail time ok most European countries.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by lifestyleguru on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:58AM (#50497077)
People in Europe install surveillance cameras all over and threaten you with the police when you tell them you don't consent being recorded. When you go to the police, the police tells you to get a lawyer and open a civil case.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by jareklupinski on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:19AM (#50497219)
you cant go to the lawyer either, because their brother sells the cameras XD
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by lifestyleguru on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:33AM (#50497320)
the brother is also retired policeman, recording intensifies after your visit at the police station
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by kakacik on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:57AM (#50497527)
Depends which Europe, I know its popular US view to treat us as 1 monolithic country but we are anything but that. In Switzerland for example its strictly forbidden to record people privately without their consent, and good luck dealing with Swiss police on spot, they are not that kind to such assholism.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Danox on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:31AM (#50497300)
Give it time. I am sure the Israelis, the Ukrainians, and the Russians will be world leaders in this type of jamming technology I have a feeling infrared light jamming cameras and sound frequencies beyond human hearing are going to be key components of this new technology. I’m ready, and so is my checkbook.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by lifestyleguru on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:37AM (#50497351)
Shut up and take my money.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by bigyabai on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:20AM (#50497722)
As a passive sensor, cameras are essentially undetectable at-range and requires an insane, highly illegal amount of directed energy to disable.

The proliferation of battlefield EOTS has made this sort of system a real priority, but we have no anti-radiation defenses against passive sensors. It's likely that a civilian system in that vein will never exist.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by sorokod on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:34AM (#50497835)
Given the overall trend, jamming may become illegal. Give it time.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by analog31 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:45PM (#50499039)
Jamming is illegal already.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by semiquaver on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:45AM (#50497431)
I’m not disputing the legality point but I don’t believe you can point to even one person who was jailed for using such a device.

So perhaps “face jail time” is not accurate.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by voakbasda on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:35AM (#50497838)
Has anyone tried? I had the opportunity but did not pursue it, but someone must be trying to fight it.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by semiquaver on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:16PM (#50499339)
Tried what? Putting someone in jail?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by probably_wrong on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:06AM (#50497601)
Sadly that's not the case, or at least not in Germany. A judge actually refused to block the sale of the glasses because it was considered that the LED were sufficient warning. Sure, you can still use them covertly and releasing material often requires a waiver, but that's true of smartphones too.

There's a case right now (brought forward by the HateAid organization) arguing that these types of glasses should be forbidden, but I'm not optimistic that they'll succeed.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by rolph on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:40PM (#50499575)
[delayed]
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by lithos on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:36AM (#50498358)
Expected an anti nuisance streamer app by now. Just playing ad reels and copyrighted music above and below human hearing levels. Since algo bots will usually scan that high/low and bury videos for whatever is considered an infraction.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by amelius on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:57AM (#50497067)
I feel like we need to have privacy laws enshrined in the constitution before bigtech stops their bullshitting.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pvab3 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:01PM (#50498574)
the constitution is about what the government is allowed to do, and we do have those
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by amelius on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:10PM (#50499839)
I don't see the problem. What prevents us from making the constitution force the government to never accept anti-privacy laws, etc.?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by apples_oranges on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:04AM (#50497122)
Someone should invest some serious money for a big ad campaign that explains the state of privacy of 2026 to people. From online tracking and fingerprinting to cars and street cameras etc.

Governments could do it. Or tv stations.. (“the more you know..”)

Tell it like it is and perhaps fewer will elect to consume crazy conspiracy theories. And instead make better life choices.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by zx8080 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:08AM (#50497150)
What? Govts wants everyone (except politicians) to have no privacy.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by duskdozer on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:29AM (#50497794)
The response I tend to see is "why should I care? I'm boring. I'm not doing anything wrong."
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by voakbasda on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:36AM (#50497851)
There is no profit in privacy, but there is in exploiting people’s secrets.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SamInTheShell on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:20AM (#50497226)
A decade ago, I would have said that's an individual person problem. Though these companies don't understand the word "No" and have already pushed the boundaries to the point that they're all in collusion with each other, resulting in broken privacy.

At least US-side, nothing will change until people start holding their representatives accountable and start voting for people that will actually do something about it.

This wont happen anytime soon, we have a much bigger problem we're dealing with for the next two years.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by bradleyankrom on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:44AM (#50497412)
"No" has been replaced with "Maybe Later".
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Oarch on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:06AM (#50497610)
Big Tech despises the idea of consent.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by voakbasda on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:32AM (#50497818)
That’s not just Big Tech. All corporations fight the rules that bind them.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by classified on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:46AM (#50497939)
And what they despise even more, and don't give you the choice of if they can avoid it, is dissent.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SamInTheShell on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:52AM (#50498494)
I've been collecting flagged posts for months now. It's very interesting to see the upvote counts vs it's visibility through the main pages.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by hobo123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:37PM (#50498965)
Salami tactics.

See also: "We decide on something, leave it lying around, and wait and see what happens. If no one kicks up a fuss, because most people don't understand what has been decided, we continue step by step until there is no turning back." - Jean Claude Juncker

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by 9rx on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:07AM (#50498123)
> nothing will change until people start holding their representatives accountable

Which itself won't change. The term for holding representatives accountable is "lobbying", which the public believes is an abhorrent act!

> and start voting for people that will actually do something about it.

There are always exceptions, but most representatives seem to be there in good faith. However, they are not mind readers. They can't do anything until the people start lobbying, but they won't do that because it is seen as being abhorrent.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SamInTheShell on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:51AM (#50498478)
I could be wrong. Like when you're dumb enough to eliminate large swaths of the workforce, especially technologically skilled workers, you're risking these people using these same technologies to vote you out.

People know how to game the algorithms presented to them, so it's not as simple as having ad-bucks anymore.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pocksuppet on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:17PM (#50500400)
Do they? I don't.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by antonvs on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:12PM (#50498670)
> The term for holding representatives accountable is "lobbying", which the public believes is an abhorrent act!

That’s a misrepresentation. You see plenty of exhortations to “call your representative”, which technically could be called lobbying, but that’s not what people find problematic. The issue is professional lobbying, which involves people paid to lobby, and often involves money or other incentives for the representative being lobbied. This kind of lobbying is not actually focused on holding representatives accountable, but rather on changing their positions.

As such, the above quote really doesn’t have much bearing on how much the public holds, or wants to hold, representatives accountable.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by win311fwg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:33PM (#50498916)
> That’s a misrepresentation.

No matter how much you try to apologize it away the reality remains that the public abhors talking to their representatives. According to the 2016 US census on behaviour, only 10% of the public do. Which, conveniently, is exactly the same proportion of the population whose livelihood comes from ownership of a business. You're right to point out that business lobbying doesn't have the same stigma, but I think the earlier commenter already recognized that.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by antonvs on Monday November 16, 2026 @04:01AM (#50515523)
I'm not apologizing away anything. I corrected an incorrect description.

That said, your characterization about "the public abhors..." doesn't follow from the 10% number you mentioned. It's common for representatives to give minimal feedback to public requests, such as a form email response, with no other discernible action resulting. As such, members of the public may often see it as a pointless exercise to try to "hold representatives accountable" themselves, which is what was being discussed.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by tehjoker on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:43PM (#50503779)
The issue with lobbying is that the companies buy people with real preexisting relationships like former congresspeople or staffers, this is very influential. Furthermore, I would argue it’s less about quid pro quo and more about how there is a stratum of “real people” and a large mass of ants. When you deal with the real people you are doing big things, being also considered a real person. When you deal with the ants you get shut out and you’re one of the ants.

Since the real people are all very rich and connected, over time if you please them, you will likewise become rich and connected. The ants continue to suffer what they will.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by kursus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:24AM (#50497251)
Is some sort of "personal" jammer hardware plausible?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by duskdozer on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:28AM (#50497784)
Well, cell signal jammers are illegal. I could see the possibility of something like a Meta-produced device that could be set to disable recording by Meta glasses in the vicinity. That seems different in scope. But lol on that.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by jareklupinski on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:51AM (#50497983)
it would be interesting to see if the "camera light has been tampered with" 'privacy mechanism' could be remotely triggered by some carefully timed application of electromagnetic energy pulses ;)
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SamInTheShell on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:30PM (#50498884)
No. The only solve is to start voting and voting for people that actually fix these problems instead of bowing to corporate interests over people interests.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Danox on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:27AM (#50497273)
I didn’t read the post. I didn’t have to. They wanna shift it to you have no privacy anywhere at any time correct?

The tech companies leading the charge are mainly the ad companies in short, the companies that have a cost of acquisition because most people do not and will not buy anything from them and in most cases never will ie.. Facebook, Google and soon the AI model makers.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by fwn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:55AM (#50497510)
If you are about to comment on it, why not read the article? Why leave it to chance whether your contribution will be signal or noise?

In the article, EEF discusses the currently emerging issue of not being able to consent to other people's always-on wearable technology in the context of the broader problem of our diminishing ability to speak openly. It ends with a clear message on how to oppose such systems in a constructive, meaningful way.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by drfloyd51 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:57AM (#50498040)
Dear Internet, please summarize this article for me. Make no mistakes.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by acd on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:56AM (#50497524)
UN Human right article 12

"Article 12

No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and reputation. Everyone has the right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks." https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma...

"arbitrary interference with his privacy"

That is tech companies does not have right to private data through data fusion. We humans collectivly have the right to privacy.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Lucasoato on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:38AM (#50497871)
Lately, a German colleague shared with me why they are so focused on privacy. For the dark events that happened in Germany from 1933 to the end of WW2, they used data from a variety of sources that were available at that time. There’s a serious fear (now more than ever in the past) that if an authoritarian regime rose again it would have access to so much data to persecute minorities or even people with different opinions that it would seriously be a nightmare. This puts often overlooked initiatives like GDPR in a completely different light to me.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by benoau on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:43AM (#50497914)
You don't have to look to the past to see that in action, ICE and the DOJ have used social media and every government database they can to do this.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SV_BubbleTime on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:12AM (#50498165)
Used social media to do what? What is <this>? What country does not enforce its border laws?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SoftTalker on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:15AM (#50498195)
I don't object to enforcing borders but at what cost? That's the point here. A another example, the public objections to Flock cameras are not because we don't want to catch thieves, kidnappers, and other criminals, they are that we don't want to do that at the cost of having our movements tracked everywhere we go, and because when that tracking data exists, it is invariably, eventually abused.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by porkshoe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:29PM (#50498862)
Agreed, nobody’s arguing against enforcing border laws. That's a dishonest right-wing canard.

ICE is doing things that have nothing to do with them. DHS has subpoenaed tech companies to unmask people who criticize ICE online, and a federal judge ruled ICE likely violated the First Amendment by sending agents to warn a man over an email.

Hundreds of US citizens have been detained by immigration agents, and most were never charged with anything. Federal judges, including Trump appointees, have found illegal detentions THOUSANDS of times.

Enforcing the law is the OPPOSITE of violating the Constitution.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by JuniperMesos on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:21PM (#50500433)
> Agreed, nobody’s arguing against enforcing border laws. That's a dishonest right-wing canard.

This is dishonest. Claiming that it is bad for " ICE and the DOJ have used social media and every government database they can" to detect illegal immigrants, especially in the context of talking about Nazi Germany, with the implication that ICE is morally equivalent to the Nazis using bureaucratic records to find and persecute their enemies, is in fact an argument against enforcing border laws.

It's completely reasonable for the government to have records of which people are citizens and of what the specific legal status is of non-citizens present in the country. It's completely reasonable for the police agencies in charge of enforcing border laws to use those records to find people in violation of those laws and arrest and deport them. It's completely reasonable for the same police agencies to look at social media posts of people talking, sometimes even bragging, about their undocumented status and use that as a basis to arrest and deport them for violating immigration law.

The only reason not to think this is if you think it's inherently wrong to enforce immigration laws at all, which many people do, and often lie about because it sounds extreme to say it that bluntly.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by porkshoe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:48PM (#50500663)
> The only reason not to think this

Bullshit.

There are a HUGE number of reasons to think that there should be meaningful controls over what data the government aggregates and accesses, and how that's handled.

Fuck off with your authoritarian horseshit, and your dreams of unlimited government power.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by JuniperMesos on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:47PM (#50501259)
> There are a HUGE number of reasons to think that there should be meaningful controls over what data the government aggregates and accesses, and how that's handled.

This is reasonable in principle. I think that those meaningful data controls should make citizenship and legal immigration status completely public and completely transparent to all parts of the government, as well as to the general public, at all times. So not only should ICE and every single other government agency be able to instantly tell if someone they are interacting with is a citizen, a legal immigrant, or an illegal immigrant - I personally as an ordinary citizen should be able to do the same thing; in the same way that right now I can look up who gave donations to political candidates or parties by name, or look at someone's ID and figure out if it's legal or illegal for me to sell them alcohol.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by folkrav on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:16AM (#50498197)
Still pretending like ICE was just used to enforce your country’s border laws is, at best, willful ignorance.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by sznio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:21AM (#50498238)
genocide.

The parent comment is obviously speaking about what happened in Hitler's Germany

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by jrajav on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:06PM (#50498625)
> What is <this>?

Targeting specific minorities and political opponents, and detaining and deporting US citizens without access to legal representation or their families. I'm not sure how you missed these events which have been widely reported, and are unprecedented and illegal (but with a cowardly lack of any pushback / checks+balances).

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by what on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:16PM (#50498713)
These incidents are not unprecedented though. You can finds cases of citizens being mistakenly deported long before orange man ever set foot in the White House.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by warkdarrior on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:38PM (#50500063)
Yes, and? We must expect that mistakes and abuses of the past are not repeated.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by frankest on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:44AM (#50497925)
The desire to do that by people in power is always there. It's just latent until new tech comes along that can achieve it.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by 1718627440 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:46AM (#50497940)
Sorry for being ignorant from the other side. What else did you thought GDPR and privacy in general is about, if not to prevent powerful entities from (automatically) messing with your life?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by nalekberov on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:57AM (#50498044)
GDPR is a great initiative. However it doesn’t prevent big tech from buying politicians, manipulating people or collecting massive data from individuals.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Ylpertnodi on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:18AM (#50498222)
Look up 'list of gdpr fines in eu country'. For some reason, where I am, a lot of Mayors are fined (as individuals), and also their municipalities as 'entities'. Also, the national elecricity company has been fined, in various areas, various amounts from 1k up (guess who pays the entity fine?)
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by uptrails on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:01AM (#50498075)
Interesting that this is the example they've used, as they have a more recent one which was much closer to an oppressive techno-surveillance state (Stasi).

However, I'm not sure how the abuses perpetrated by totalitarian regimes map to regulation such as GDPR, which constraints private entities. Compared to their US counterparts, European governments are not all that more hesitant to use spyware, tap phones, etc.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by mockerell on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:15AM (#50498191)
Good observation and I agree that the German situation is more nuanced, even if it’s not perceived as such.

GP’s argument applies to the design of German state bureaucracy. E.g there exist no unified German identification number but several for different purposes (tax, pension etc.). This is directly motivated from the Nazi regime as GP told us. That’s also why the Stasi is not often cited as an argument because the GDR developed in parallel with the West German state.

I would say that these precautions are not enough to prevent a 21st century authoritarian regime from rising and using data. Most of the interesting data is in the hand of privatized public places (social media). We can see these issues already happening with ICE in the US

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by fooqux on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:56AM (#50498522)
I view it as another facet of policy.

If corporations (public or private) have data the government wants, then the government gets it. This can even be used as a way to circumvent tighter regulations on the government; see Flock for an example.

Secondly, it's the corporations that are paving the way here. Yeah, governments are obviously capable of designing and producing their own tech, but if the corporations have already made it? Than it's so much easier for the government to use it.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by hobo123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:32PM (#50498910)
Even today different German agencies or public institutions are not linked. If you marry, or get driver's license, you have to fill all kinds of forms, maybe get a birth certificate etc, because they can't just ask a different office to give it to them.

As you said, this is so nobody in government can collect all kinds of data about citizens, to do bad things to them.

Some people would like to have, say, a public wealth register today, and the above is exactly why others heavily oppose those ideas.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pessimizer on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:30PM (#50500510)
> they have a more recent one which was much closer to an oppressive techno-surveillance state (Stasi).

The Stasi were low-tech card catalogs and blackmail.

The Nazis used IBM, and digitized census data that had already been collected and was just there to be used.* Places without extensive census data are where Jews survived. Plenty of people didn't even know they were "Jewish" until the Nazis told them.

It absolutely maps to GDPR. I bet that if you pulled a few good sources of private data, you could map every single e.g. homosexual in the US, with few false positives or negatives. This could still happen if we passed a privacy law tomorrow, and only used data collected until today.

The odds are very much non-zero that this will happen. It should be illegal to collect and trade in massive collections of dossiers on US citizens. The government can just buy them. Weird how we could see it as bad when it was anti-Chinese propaganda about "social credit," but Americans don't know that it's illegal in just about every country in the world to collect and make decisions based on dragnet "credit ratings" like we do here.

The problem with GDPR is that Europeans don't control anything; and they don't really make rights, they make guidelines that they call "rights" but that they can break whenever they want or whenever they want to buy American. GDPR is just a restraint on Europeans, nobody else has to care, and European companies and governments can just buy the info they want about their own populations from Americans who will be happy to sell it to them.

[*] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by tchalla on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:01PM (#50498573)
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pocksuppet on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:13PM (#50500355)
Germany still has this btw. For everyone.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by fxde on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:51PM (#50513065)
This is completely false, as seen in the link you were replying to.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by makingstuffs on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:37PM (#50498964)
When you consider this fact consider the impact COVID and the vaccine registers had on privacy.

Whatever your belief about COVID or it’s origins there is one thing which no one can dispute: as a result of the pandemic and the ‘no vaccine no flight/bar/restaurant/public event’ mandate, governments around the world acquired a comprehensive list of every citizen most likely to disobey sweeping orders within their respective jurisdictions.

That sounds harmless on the face of it but consider it in the context of what your German colleague is (rightfully) fearful of and you realise there is now a list of people to go after should such an atrocity ever prevail again.

I know it sounds very tinfoil hat on the surface but here we are.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:19PM (#50499907)
> This puts often overlooked initiatives like GDPR in a completely different light to me.

The problem with initiatives like GDPR is that they don't actually solve the problem. If you're worried about the SS then a law that tries to tell companies what they can do with some data is totally useless, because the thing you need is for the companies to not have the data.

If Apple can run code as root on every iPhone then when the SS comes, the SS can run code as root on every iPhone. They go to Apple and put a gun to their head, or infiltrate the company with operatives, and then do what they please with the central control the company already holds.

To prevent that you need to change the architecture of the systems in popular use to remove central chokepoints that authoritarians could use for censorship and surveillance. But none of those initiatives have accomplished that, even though that's the thing you'd need them to do.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by sojourning on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:57PM (#50500729)
.. in what sense is the GRPR overlooked?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by adolph on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:56AM (#50498039)
This UN declaration doesn’t seem to establish an enduring definition of privacy.

Hayek offers a significant observation that things that work among small orders, like a family, don’t work when applied to a whole city. It speaks to the gap between a single police officer seeing something and a city-wide camera crime detection network.

  Part of our present difficulty is that we must constantly adjust our lives, our thoughts and our emotions, in order to live simultaneously within different kinds of orders according to different rules. If we were to apply the unmodified, uncurbed rules of the micro-cosmos (i.e., of the small band or troop, or say our families) to the macro-cosmos (our wider civilization), as our instincts and sentimental yearnings often make us wish to do, we would destroy it. Yet if we were always to apply rules of the extended order to our more intimate groupings, we would crush them. [Friedrich Hayek, The Fatal Conceit]
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by j45 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:07AM (#50498122)
Is this binding on and inside every member country?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by laweijfmvo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:09AM (#50498138)
the real UN has no more power than the model UN high schoolers role play
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by j45 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:20AM (#50498230)
It would be good then to see the laws in each country.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by andai on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:40AM (#50498386)
A right is like a trademark. It must be defended, or it loses its power.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by irishcoffee on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:24PM (#50498807)
The UN, a global entity that isn’t worth the paper its existence it’s written on. Probably the best ever example of the term “paper tiger”
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pocksuppet on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:14PM (#50500368)
Many people believe the UN is supposed to be one world government, and is failing at that purpose. It is certainly not achieving that purpose. However, that is not its purpose.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by graemep on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:03PM (#50499221)
A right to privacy the European Convention on Human Rights which every European country other than Belarus is a signatory to. It is directly incorporated into UK law and in all signatory countries appeals can be made to the European Court of Human Rights.

Some governments ignore it, pretty much all governments have tried to find ways to limit the right to privacy. It has not been terribly effective. As far as I can tell constitutional protections in a few countries (like Germany) have been far more effective.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pocksuppet on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:10PM (#50500334)
Germany has also lost its right to privacy, with widespread surveillance conducted by police, such as 24/7 in the area surrounding Hamburg main station, and every single protest, and with the police knowing everyone's home address (Anmeldung register), every cellphone being connected with an ID, and every website publicising the home address of the person who wrote it (Impressum). It's not yet total surveillance, more like 80%.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by graemep on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:49AM (#50506578)
Sad to hear that, but its still better than most of Europe.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by intended on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:48PM (#50499632)
If you are in a country which has some decent legal system and institutions.

And even then it’s a crap shoot

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Illniyar on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:32AM (#50497812)
The one moving the goal post is the eff. There is no expectation of privacy in public spaces.

It is legal and moral for me to take a video of someone in public. If I can do it with a phone I can do it with glasses.

A shop having a camera pointed outside is not breaking the law, even if it's hidden from view.

There has never been a requirement for devices to indicate anything to those they are recording. It at most a curtsy.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by simoncion on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:43AM (#50497913)
> There is no expectation of privacy in public spaces.

As always, scale matters, as does the purpose of the surveillance and the affiliation of the surveilling party. This comment of mine from last month (and the document linked in the footnote) will be good reading for you. [0] Also keep in mind that private entities can be legally considered to be agents of the State... depending on how they and the State are conducting themselves.

[0] <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50027322>

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pdonis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:34PM (#50502224)
> There is no expectation of privacy in public spaces.

These devices don't stop recording when you exit a "public space". They record everywhere.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by thadt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:37AM (#50497856)
Tech companies respond to incentives. If the technology exists to create and sell devices that are useful to people and legal, then they'll do it, and people will buy and use them. And that is fantastic - I'm great with tech companies making tools that makes my life easier. I absolutely plan on using the heck out of the next wave of AR glasses for digitizing historical documents so I can have both hands free instad of holding a phone in one. Better audio recording devices? Yes, please.

Simultaneously - I own my words, either written or spoken. This isn't really all that different from copyright, and I'm rather surprised we don't more regularly bring that reasoning to bear on this issue. If I give them to you in a private conversation, then those words are for you to hear. If you record them without my consent, then you're violating my (copy)right. If a company takes those words without my consent, then that company is violating my copyright.

I don't know exactly what should happen to people and companies violating my copyright, but I do remember when it was the other way around a few years back and the RIAA was getting people fined thousands to tens of thousands of dollars per incident. That seems about right.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by drfloyd51 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:56AM (#50498029)
The AI tech companies already violated perhaps millions of copyrights.

They should have quite a hefty fine to pay.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by tzs on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:40PM (#50502265)
> Simultaneously - I own my words, either written or spoken. This isn't really all that different from copyright, and I'm rather surprised we don't more regularly bring that reasoning to bear on this issue. If I give them to you in a private conversation, then those words are for you to hear. If you record them without my consent, then you're violating my (copy)right. If a company takes those words without my consent, then that company is violating my copyright.

The copyright situation is interesting, at least under US law, because is most cases where someone on the street records you speaking you will not copyright. That's because of a loophole in the way the copyright statute works.

People commonly believe that when the US changed from copyright coming into existence when you register your work they switched to it coming into existence as soon as your create the work, but that is not correct. 17 USC 102(a) tells us that copyright subsists in works that are

>> [...] fixed in any tangible medium of expression, now known or later developed, from which they can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or device.

But what does it mean to be "fixed" in a tangible medium of expression? For that we must turn to 17 USC 101:

>> A work is “fixed” in a tangible medium of expression when its embodiment in a copy or phonorecord, by or under the authority of the author, is sufficiently permanent or stable to permit it to be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated for a period of more than transitory duration.

Their recording of you is not "by or under the authority of the author" so is not a fixation, so your work is not copyrighted yet.

Congress recognized this loophole and partly closed it in 1994, with 17 USC 1101, which is titled "Unauthorized fixation and trafficking in sound recordings and music videos". This closes it in the case where you are, say, a street musician and someone records your song which is not yet copyrighted because you have not yet recorded it or written down the sheet music or tab. It gives such a musician essentially the same rights and remedies they would have if they had copyright.

But that is explicitly for music. Unless you start singing everything you say in public it won't help you. Even if you do that, those devices that just immediately transcribe what they hear probably would not be covered, because no matter how creative a melody you come up with to sing "I'll have a medium Big Mac meal with a coke please" to, they will just be recording your lyrics. US requires a certain level of creativity in a work for it to be copyrightable and "I'll have a medium Big Mac meal with a coke please" is probably not going to make the cut.

You best defense, if you want to have a chance of federal copyright applying, is to wear something of your own that records you. Then your words are fixed under the authority of the author (you) as soon as you speak them, and so if they do meet the bar for being copyrightable they will be copyrighted.

There is also state common-law copyright law to consider. Federal copyright law preempts state copyright law, and with it so easy to get federal copyright you don't really tend to hear much about state copyright law.

However, that loophole that makes federal copyright law not attach also makes it so state copyright law is not preempted for works that fall into the federal loophole. State common law copyright tends to be more generous or expansive than federal copyright, so this is probably your best copyright bet.

This suggests that you may want to actually avoid recording yourself, to avoid any chance of getting federal copyright and thus having state common law copyright law preempted.

I did a little searching, and apparently whether you should record yourself or not has been debated and analyzed in other contexts like stand-up comedy performances and public lectures.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by thadt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:47PM (#50502757)
That makes sense. I don't expect copyright law to apply out of the box - but more that it could be used as a reference point in thinking about privacy issues. For example if it's illegal to record a movie at a theater, then it should similarly be illegal to record and transmit someone where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy.

It's not black and white, and there's an entire spectrum of issues to consider, but preserving someone's right to privacy seems conceptually close to preserving someone's right to control how their work is copied.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by classified on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:41AM (#50497894)
> ...while they also expect the owners of these devices to use them responsibly and to notify those around them of their capabilities to act within whatever laws their states may have.

Hell, no. They expect you to act as uninformed and oblivious about it as possible so they can scrape the maximum amount of data while the liability is all yours.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by halsafar on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:58AM (#50498047)
Exactly this. Anyone who wears these smart glasses are just selling themselves for a negative return. Like meta should be giving these glasses away given how much data they harvest. Instead they convince rubes and pervs to actually pay for it.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by nalekberov on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:52AM (#50498000)
> *Apple is an EFF donor. EFF donors do not influence our agenda or our positions.

Oh sure, otherwise why would you emphasize over and over again that Apple makes it harder for law enforcement to extract private data of an individual?

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by talkingtab on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:03AM (#50498090)
The issues around privacy are inherent in an internet that is paid for by targeted advertising. If there is privacy there is no way to pay the small amounts for email for example.

If we want privacy, we need an alternative business model.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Silhouette on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:03PM (#50498587)
The Internet was in many ways a better place before data capitalism came along so the likes of Google and Facebook could monetise.

We had email and it worked just fine. You got an account via your ISP or paid a small amount for a separate service and perhaps a custom domain that you controlled yourself. Centralising this with the likes of Google is not progress.

We had more content than anyone could ever consume in a lifetime on the Web even back then. It was mostly created by people interested in sharing for personal satisfaction and perhaps the enjoyment of a good discussion that followed or by organisations that benefitted from sharing that information freely. It wasn't done with a direct profit motive based on metrics like page views. We didn't have endless AI spam designed to host endless auctioned ad spots diluting the good stuff.

So here's my proposed privacy-friendly alternative business model: You don't get to harvest personal data for reasons unrelated to whatever products or services you're providing to willing consumers and if you do then we throw you in jail. I'm pretty sure the Internet would find a way to continue providing the functionality that is actually useful. I'm pretty sure the signal/noise ratio online would be much better too.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by analog31 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:43PM (#50499019)
Possession of the data has to be illegal, enforced through statutory civil damages.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Silhouette on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:51PM (#50500171)
Civil damages can become merely a "cost of doing business".

Jail time for the responsible executives makes it personal for the decision makers. Obviously there still needs to be due process. It would be sensible to have stages where there are clear warnings given by the relevant regulators with indications of the specific remediation actions required and then a reasonable amount of time to actually implement that remediation before anyone is getting carted off in handcuffs for non-compliance.

I am not generally in favour of piercing the corporate veil but in cases of flagrant and deliberate disregard for the law I think there is a point where it becomes justified and perhaps even necessary.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by analog31 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:47PM (#50501819)
I see the point. My misgiving is that jail time means the government can just refrain from enforcing it because the leaders have found favor with one another.

A data breach of 10 million records, times $10k per offense, might not deter Google, but it would raise the eyebrows of smaller violators. An industry of class action lawyers might emerge to specialize in those claims.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by account42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:50AM (#50516557)
Jail time would be great but even monetary damages can become beyond the cost of doing business if they increase with continued non-compliance.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by account42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:48AM (#50516543)
No, what we need to to accept that some things should not have any business model. That is, we ween to seriously update our selection of what we consider public infrastructure to the 21st century. It's insane that in cyberspace all roads, the postal service and even the courts and law enforcement are self-imposed private entities.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by hollow-moe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:14AM (#50498185)
The goal is so obviously to push the last sane people to isolate themselves from the other humans to not have to cope with all the bullshit.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Havoc on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:51AM (#50498485)
More & more tech is starting to look like a pretty sketchy industry
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by elephanlemon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:25PM (#50498820)
Seems like this is flatly illegal in two party consent states, but I see no mention of this in the article or comments. Am I missing something?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by toddmorey on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:37PM (#50498958)
Here’s a question I have: every professional meeting I now attend is being recorded & uploaded by seen and unseen AI guests. Even 1:1 conversations between direct managers and colleagues.

That’s a world I don’t want to endorse, but it’s seemingly impossible to opt out and stay employed. Is there anything that I can do to minimize my exposure? Has anyone made it a norm to say “transcription isn’t needed for this meeting so I would like everyone to turn off AI notetaker before we proceed?”

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by andsoitis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:58PM (#50499185)
> Even 1:1 conversations between direct managers and colleagues.

You can ask someone to turn it off.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by MichaelZuo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:14PM (#50499321)
Yeah, if they refuse then that is also a signal about how much they truly value you (and not an insignificant one either).
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by andsoitis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:17PM (#50499350)
If someone refuses, then you can frame that it limits candor and vulnerability. If they still prefer to have it on, then you can simply be less open with them.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by maxrmk on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:43PM (#50499607)
Yes I do this constantly? It has never been an issue.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by boredatoms on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:50PM (#50499656)
Its often seen as an imposition to do so, so it depends on how the power structure runs if someone is comfortable asking
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by andsoitis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:50PM (#50500157)
You can still ask. If you're too afraid to even do that, then the alternative is to be guarded during the conversation. But you can choose which path to take.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by NaiveBayesian on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:45PM (#50501232)
Really? In my everyday people always ask "Is it okay for my/our notetaker to join the meeting?"

Might be a German/European thing though...

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by socksy on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:28AM (#50506112)
How acceptable do you think it would be, socially speaking, to say no? I always regard people asking that as more of a rhetorical question, kinda like asking if you might use the WC. Like, technically I could say no, but it would be seen to be very strange...
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Symbiote on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:56AM (#50506275)
[delayed]
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SOLAR_FIELDS on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:44PM (#50501781)
Not enough. Many people are running Superwhisper and the like on their machines that capture the audio stream directly out of the OS and applications. Even if all the cloud recorders are removed, you must assume that unless you have the entire security provenance chain of the other person's device verified, that your words are being recorded.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by matheusmoreira on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:14PM (#50502061)
The world is becoming dystopian at a rapid pace... These capabilities will be weaponized against people in ways we can't even dream of yet.

We already have products that provide active countermeasures against recording devices, an audio jammer of sorts that renders microphones unable to pick up anything. I wonder how effective they are.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by voxic11 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:06AM (#50505013)
Well thats a crime in my state so they are taking a big risk talking to me if they are secretly recording. I guess I don't know many people who are willing to risk jail for some meeting notes.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by SOLAR_FIELDS on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:16PM (#50508656)
I think you would probably be very surprised how many people are illegally surreptitiously recording you without taking this into consideration.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by whatshisface on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:27PM (#50499447)
It's fine, a leak of your meeting to a potential competitor could result in as much as another meeting. ;-(
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by rolph on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:07PM (#50499816)
[delayed]
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by willis936 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:35PM (#50500033)
I am part of the problem and recently started turning them on after realizing they were proving to be very useful inputs when using chatbots with connectors to tools that can see the transcripts. It's made scribing notes mostly a ritual and not a practical benefit.

Before I turned it on I asked my team if they had any objections. Silence for eight seconds before saying if anyone was uncomfortable objecting in the group they could reach out to me individually. No one ever did. The only request was that everyone internal get copied on the notes so they could correct them if needed.

These are company decisions to have these connectors and privacy choices. It's their data and their risk. There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company. At home I partake in none of this.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by b112 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:32PM (#50500529)
I'm surprised lawyers aren't jumping all over this, not with you specifically, just generically everywhere.

Casual meetings can have misconstrued words.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by barney54 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:02PM (#50500771)
What’s the legal theory here?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by b112 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:13PM (#50502050)
Someone sues, and stuff comes out in discovery.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by caminante on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:03PM (#50503572)
What specific to AI notetaker, though?

You think they could find something with a neutered transcript and there's precedent that someone can infer the LLM reasoning for a proprietary frontier model?

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by b112 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:57AM (#50505934)
Look upthread. The context is additional note taking being done.

AI enables it, but isn't relevant to the concerns.

If not for cost, we could have done the same thing with a tape recorder, and a human transcriber. Lawyers would dislike that too.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by caminante on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:32AM (#50507212)
I read the thread.

>Additional note taking

a. This seems hand wavy. I assume people are already taking discoverable notes on company assets even for "casual" calls.

b. What's your experience with enterprise AI meeting note takers? My experience is that they're setup to summarize and won't give verbatim accounts.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by b112 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:04AM (#50507972)
Hand wavy? Upthread is talking about transcripts of meetings, not summaries, and my simple, uncomplex response was clear. What are you even talking about?

Apparently you disagree. OK, thanks, see you later?!

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by caminante on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:02PM (#50508515)
> Upthread is talking about transcripts of meetings

And AI notetakers. You didn't distinguish.

It's a core premise of the article:

> These tools still often use a microphone to capture raw audio from conversations and convert it into summaries or transcripts before discarding the audio.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by overfeed on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:01PM (#50500768)
> Before I turned it on I asked my team if they had any objections.

Did you check with internal counsel?

> There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company

The entire industry is one court case away from banning transcription. Not many companies want every word of every meeting legally discoverable - the implications haven't percolated yet

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by willis936 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:17PM (#50500909)
This is all of course sanctioned by leadership and the teams who have standing (legal, IT, cybersecurity). Just because something is allowed doesn't mean I'll opt to do it. If I worked somewhere that hasn't been using corporate spyware on all employee laptops and face recognition around the building since long before auto transcription came in vogue I might feel differently about the decision to embrace the surveillance for productivity.

I don't have the authority to make the meaningful decisions, just to do my job efficiently.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by caminante on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:08PM (#50503600)
This is where I've seen it land.

Leadership sanctions, and sub teams make their own rules (out of convenience).

If you have the AI notetaker button to mass employees, and don't want it used, then your GC is not protecting you or they're expecting you to ask for forgiveness.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:43AM (#50506191)
> This is all of course sanctioned by leadership and the teams who have standing

I’m right now in a minor dispute with AIG and added to my record-preservation demand any AI notes and recordings from internal meetings. It set off a minor firestorm. I suspect a lot of folks are going to be doing the same over coming years.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by ksec on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:46AM (#50505864)
Without someone openly object to it, and without the trust that I can tell you I am objecting to it without the fear of being asked why and what am I hiding from. The Norm would be no one speaks up, and knowing it is recorded it means there can't be a honest and candid conversation behind close doors. And the tone of the meeting on long term will shift.

>done at work is private from the company.

That is why we have phone call, face to face meetings and email. Things are black and white for a reason because I want it to be recorded. If everything I said is going to be on record I will now be very careful of what comes out of my month.

In an already toxic work environment, this will likely make things even worst.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by AbstractH24 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:14AM (#50507493)
> I am part of the problem

The next problem is going to be having to opt into the headless ones to reduce friction around adding your notetaker

I don’t particularly want to, for both ethics reasons and the fact my headed one (Fathom) is good enough. But it’s getting annoying to have inconsistent notes

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by account42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @05:59AM (#50516227)
> There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company.

There has also never been an illusion that anything said in public is private from the government yet I hope you can see that technologies that allow mass surveillance make for a very different society.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by blfr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:03PM (#50500275)
Automatic transcripts of online meetings are amazing: it means that you can just shoot the shit for half an hour and then have Claude bang out a deck and MVP for review. And no one has to waste time and attention on making notes.

Even better if it's a feedback session or people have notes and comments. You can have them all mock-implemented before you even send out the summary.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by 1over137 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:42PM (#50500629)
Taking notes works your brain, helps your memory, and strengthens understanding.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by plandis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:39PM (#50501738)
I learned very quickly in my undergraduate days that the act of physically writing down information was the best way for me personally to retain knowledge.

I’ve got over a decade of work experience now and I have like 100 notebooks filled with notes from nearly every day. I routinely find that my own notes differ from auto written transcripts of meetings. Mostly it’s minor things but ever once in a while the automatic transcription gets something critically wrong.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Tanjreeve on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:45PM (#50501792)
I always used to take notes and casually read minutes out of habit after meetings and pick up on stuff that sounded weird and more and more recently that's been feeling like a superpower to just read things and think through the implications and raise them because people are not picking up on them.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by VBprogrammer on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:58AM (#50505580)
I'd asked a close work friend what his new girlfriends name was two or three times. Last time I took out my Obsidian notes on my phone and typed it in there. Weirdly, I've never gone back to look at the note but it's now committed to memory. So just typing it out on a phone works. Though it's obviously suboptimal for more graphic heavy text (drawing chemical compounds for example would be a pain but is easy with pen and paper).
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by cruelacid on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:46AM (#50508363)
Excalidraw for obsidian lets you draw notes!
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by itake on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:48PM (#50501267)
I am horrified of the idea that HR can listen/review every single ~private conversation, that may include frustrations with leadership, family problems, or personal health information that is shared with a trusted manager or coworker, not some HR person.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by willis936 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:27PM (#50502173)
Then these changes are actually a good thing because you get the opportunity to learn that they've had that power for years.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by itake on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:52PM (#50503210)
Since when?

If I go on a private walk with a manager around San Francisco, how would leadership or HR learn about this, assuming both parties do not defect.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by willis936 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:36AM (#50505800)
They have cameras and badge access records. They know you went on the walk. They didn't know what you talked about and very likely don't know now unless for some reason they are wearing spy devices. The smartglasses and always on listeners are a problem, but I haven't heard of a company along employees to wear those and start signed into company accounts outside of work.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by rexpop on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:06PM (#50502901)
Then you had better organize and consolidate your bargaining power.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by adamddev1 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:16PM (#50501539)
Except that the summaries can be totally inaccurate. And then people think they have proof that so-and-so said something, when maybe they never said that.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by n_plus_1_acc on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:50AM (#50507831)
Why even have a meeting then? Just let the other person(s) dictate their stuff into their computer and send you the transscript.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by micromacrofoot on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:07PM (#50500307)
Get your coworkers together and form a union.

I'm not even kidding. An individual has no protection, if it's workplace policy you can be fired for not following it.

If employees collectively challenge the policy an employer can not legally retaliate against collective action.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by JuniperMesos on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:13PM (#50500364)
One problem with this is that it's very easy to think of ways that having a recording of what was said in a meeting might benefit one or more of the participants, by letting them provide evidence later that another participant is lying about what was said in that meeting. An AI recording of a meeting might well protect your interests in court later.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by b00ty4breakfast on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:39PM (#50500604)
This is not a problem that needs an "AI" solution; small, cheap digital audio recorders have existed for decades and every consumer computer, from smartphones to laptops, has more than adequate udio recording capabilities.

I'm not even talking about a "we didn't computers in my day and we did just fine" old-man-yells-at-cloud objection here; there is no real benefit, wrt recording a meeting, that "AI" brings to the table.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by JuniperMesos on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:41PM (#50501197)
You might reasonably want a text transcript of spoken-language audio from a meeting and any computer technology that can do that is effectively some type of AI. In any case, I don't think there's a principled reason to be okay with every meeting at work being audio-recorded but to suddenly become not okay with it if there's a modern LLM involved doing speech-to-text; unless your actual objection is to LLMs as a technology or to the companies that are currently in the news for selling LLM-based software products.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by knollimar on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:10PM (#50503609)
I’m a bit worried about meeting recordings being neutered by poor transcription and the audio being thrown away. And that mistranscribed meeting showing up in court
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by dayvid on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:41PM (#50500615)
I've been in meeting where people turn off AI notes when real stuff gets discussed and turn it back on after. Seems like a good compromise as long as you trust that it's not going to get logged
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by boringg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:53PM (#50500700)
Its obviously getting logged
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by morkalork on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:41PM (#50501754)
Hilariously enough the answer is return to the office. I coordinate with my manager to do our 1:1s on days we're both in the office and I know we're not alone.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by anal_reactor on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:46PM (#50502754)
Unfortunately, there's no way to opt out because even though people like to say "muh privacy and freedom of speech", in practice they usually vote for tighter control. This is one of the reasons why I desire to become financially independent.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by xg15 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:21AM (#50505711)
It's not just transcription, it's also working on the code itself. I find it remarkable that everyone just seems to be ok with sending all of their internal company data straight to the AI labs...
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by account42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:09AM (#50516275)
Yeah, I find it really weird as well. Especially when that code isn't even available to other deparments (due to ISO cert requirements I guess) but somehow YOLO startups to whom your company isn't even an afterthought are trustworthy?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by bagacrap on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:18AM (#50507522)
For me, if it's a professional interaction, I have no expectation of privacy, or even desire for it.

There have been too many times when an adversarial colleague untruthfully claimed or inferred I said or did something -- not that it happens frequently, but a handful of times over decades is enough to burn you. And the worst is when they keep meeting notes by hand, because those are somehow given more credibility even when they're just as likely to contain fabrications. (In fact I have grown suspicious of people who take meeting notes by hand, compulsively, in every meeting, although some of them mean well.)

Hence an objective, indelible record of what was said sounds ideal to me.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by lickonographic on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:27AM (#50507632)
Privacy and documenting adversarial interactions are entirely orthogonal

There is zero need to stream video and audio to third party APIs to document a meeting.

In fact, an automatically inferred transcript is arguably riskier than no documentation at all.

Recording meetings has been a thing for literal decades and it can be done in very privacy safe ways. A binary view of privacy is defeatist. Data governance is not an all-or-nothing proposition.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by bagacrap on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:27PM (#50509346)
Makes zero difference if it is on site or in a cloud. Amazon and my employer are both equally unlikely to have my interests at heart. But if it's in the cloud it's probably less likely to get hacked.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by lickonographic on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:37AM (#50516446)
Again, the choices are not "let employer or Amazon record everything"

And you're equating passing the video and audio stream to some inference API for automatic transcription with merely storing video on premise or in cloud which is a gross misrepresentation of my objections.

Again, because you are intentionally misinterpreting my point: there is a lot of space in between hearsay and passing a stream for third party auto transcript APIs and somewhere in there is proper, reliable, and controllable documentation.

Also, like everything else ever to be framed as a technical only problem, it has social and political dimensions. From you to the corporate overlords "employer" and "cloud provider" there are a lot of layers and ignoring that is part of the defeatist attitude I denounce.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Buttons840 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:41AM (#50507757)
I can't believe I'm about to say this--I hate myself for saying this, but you've heard it before...

If you have nothing to hide you wont be bothered by having your conversations recorded.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go brush my teeth.

I fully reject that idea--well, I 99% reject that idea--but there is is a case when it comes to the communications of government officials or the executives of trillion dollar publicly traded companies where, yeah, I start to feel that maybe all their interactions should be recorded.

Just because something is recorded doesn't mean it needs to be made public. People often muddy the water for things like police video--"whell, police can't have their cameras on at all times because they might go into a private domicile"--that's a Red Herring. Just because something is recorded doesn't mean it needs to be public. Police cameras should just be on 100% of the time, but certain parts of it should not be made available to the public.

This will quietly become true more and more. We get close and closer to having every single interaction of normal people recorded forever, and yet, I expect that those in power will still somehow NOT have their conversations recorded.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by bagacrap on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:13PM (#50508620)
At work. I want the conversations recorded at work. We expect this of police with body cams. How is my job different and special?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Buttons840 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:10PM (#50510218)
Sure, and the higher up the more important it is that the conversations be recorded.

I mean, if we're going to enter a world of little or not privacy, let's at least make sure the people actually running things are recorded.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by throwaway5752 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:48PM (#50499088)
EFF is onto something HN is not generally on the right side of this. The hacker community, to my observation, is deeply divided. Cynically, I think half of hackers have become dissociative and mildly sociopathic in terms of their views of technology.

Tech should benefit people and be open, and trillionaire are not a healthy long term indicator in a stable society.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by Papazsazsa on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:10PM (#50499279)
There is no other solution here if you want to both participate in the modern economy and preserve some semblance of privacy, and even then some idiot somewhere will leak your medical records or family photos.

1. A public profile that is your real self.

2. Throwaway identities.

3. Air gaps

4. EFF[1], IJ, or EPIC membership

[1]EFF is a serious organization, but I would happily pay their $1k or even $5k membership tiers if they ran a larger, more concentrated pipeline of affirmative lawsuits like FIRE and ACLU do. Hire liberty-minded sharks to find bad laws, find plaintiffs, file challenges across jurisdictions, and keep a large docket moving continuously.

For what it's worth IJ and EPIC do this well, but EFF has a bigger profile and the technical bench to make this approach highly effective.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by specialist on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:50PM (#50499657)
US Constituion understands privacy as self-sovereignty. As in I am the boss of me.

My prior folk understanding was that privacy is me deciding what is publicly known about me.

Since I am my personal data and that data is me, I own every single bit of my data.

The fix to surveillance capitalists abusing all our data (and by extension ourselves) is to recognize and enforce our property rights.

Any private entity storing, using, or both, any of my data owes me. Pay up.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pessimizer on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:49PM (#50500671)
> US Constituion understands privacy as self-sovereignty. As in I am the boss of me.

It doesn't. The Bill of Rights does, and it was pushed by the anti-federalists. It is also constantly eroded, and the entire package put together in the context of slavery, a group of people born with no rights. It certainly doesn't have an opinion about whether you have an intellectual property right over facts about yourself.

The Constitution isn't a metaphysical document that can be confused by this sort of psychedelic reasoning about some sort of natural property rights. It is a document that is enforced by Congress and the Judiciary. If they both agree that you shouldn't have any privacy, you won't have any privacy. Neither have been restraining the Executive since 9/11; and they've only barely restraining the states and local municipalities, and not always in a good way.

Your privacy rights come from the psychedelic reasoning of the Judiciary, and can be taken away if they switch drug preferences. It has been decided that privacy rights are written in shadows* cast by the constitution. Really. And only since 1965 - you might be older than your constitutional privacy rights.

[*] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penumbra_(law)

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by specialist on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:22PM (#50500970)
Thanks, that's important history.

I've read that article before. I've worked on both voter and patient privacy, so have thought about privacy well enough for a layperson. IANAL, obviously.

I'll concede that, with a few exception, SCOTUS has been actively hostile to individual rights. That will have to change.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by LoganDark on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:43PM (#50501767)
I'm a little disappointed that this article makes no distinction between Apple implementing hard technical barriers between them and your data, plus very detailed technical white papers describing many of the barriers they implement, and Facebook offering some virtual settings that let you feel slightly differently while they use your data either way. Are these really the same thing?
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by milderworkacc on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:18PM (#50502524)
In my view, this is precisely the kind of water-carrying that has led to the incremental erosion of our privacy in the first place. It happened little by little, enabled by opinions like this, who say "well at least foo is doing it in a more privacy-preserving way than bar", and each additional little erosion, each pebble on the beach newly washed away, is built on top of this new expectation, rather than the old status quo.

Go back ten years, and compare to today, and tell me whether we as a society would be happy with that difference occurring overnight. We wouldn't. But we let it happen over 500 odd weeks, with a new intrusion each week built on top of the last.

I reject the premise. They are functionally the same over a longer time span, but only Apple wins plaudits for it. They are as guilty as the rest of them.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by LoganDark on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:34PM (#50502669)
Has Apple done this yet, or is this prediction based on what others have done? I don't really see a difference between the Apple Watch recording locally for the benefit of its user and someone running an app that does the same thing. If they're both entirely local and not accessible to Apple, what's the difference? Is the difference just that the functionality is preloaded by Apple as opposed to being installed by the user? Is there a reason to be uncomfortable with Apple doing this instead of uncomfortable with users that take advantage of it? People can be creeps by recording without permission, so why is the company the creep when it's still the user who's doing it?

Meanwhile, other companies are unquestionably the creeps when they collect and analyze this data for themselves rather than leaving it local to the device and to the user.

Probably the creepiest thing I've encountered from Apple lately is that Siri AI actually has access to a screenshot when you ask it a question, even if you didn't explicitly upload one. That's extremely surprising behavior to me, especially since there's dedicated functionality for explicitly uploading a screenshot, so I have no idea why it would happen implicitly as well, but I don't worry about it nearly as much as if literally anyone else did it.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by abecedarius on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:26PM (#50502609)
I haven't tried live-transcribing glasses, but done well they ought to be transformative for people like me: the deaf and nearly deaf.

No reason they can't use a local model not saving or exporting anything, but still, once you have this system you're one if-statement away from retention. If you want these devices banned, are you going to ban open-source prosthetics?

Say we develop Neuralink-style brain prostheses to the point everyone wants one. Will we ban memory assists then? The copyright lobby will smile at that one.

Yes, let's fight for privacy, just... watch where you're swinging.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by drdaeman on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:22PM (#50503015)
I hate that first-party data processing gets the collateral backlash, while the whole issue is third-party processing.

It’s one thing when a megacorp siphons in all private conversations they can. It’s a whole different thing if someone has a machine that they fully own, that processes data entirely locally. In the latter case, no party that wasn’t privy to the conversation gets any data about it.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by conception on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:48PM (#50503507)
Privacy concerns can be solved pretty easily. It’s just we rather not put limit on making money.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pptr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:16PM (#50502977)
Once we have robots walking in public spaces, they will have a 24/7 video and audio feed ... As do humans. It would be ridiculous if we built robots to be blind and deaf.

I believe the `privacy == no video/audio sensor` definition won't hold for long. Maybe we could require sensor data to only go into the multimodal model, without being stored raw.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by pnt12 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:10AM (#50506691)
Well, that's up for debate if that's desirable or not.

But assuming yes: it's reasonable to have laws, eg don't store the video, don't use for training, etc

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by riponretards on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:22PM (#50503016)
the privacy larp is designed to shut the door behind giants like amazon and google who sit on giant lakes of data, and they dont want you to have that data unless you lease it from them. people that want privacy take it, you all use privacy tools and even plebs use privacy tools. in the end you are raising the costs of startup service providers and exposing yourself as a schizo retard.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by teeray on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:02PM (#50503896)
[delayed]
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by justauserid on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:46AM (#50504909)
The trick this time around, that has worked for these companies, is that the face of this new technology (AI; or anything riding on it) has been as a needed tool, a needed productiity boost - and it has been so, of course. So the adoption skyrocketed even before the opposition could even begin to catch up.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by aaabbbccccc on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:18AM (#50505688)
Ironic as the articles site doesn't support TLS 1.3 ..
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by neop1x on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:17AM (#50506392)
Meanwhile, Mercedes cars in EU can't automatically start recording with built-in dash cam due to "privacy" concerns.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by stuaxo on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:30AM (#50506799)
Can they just stop.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by newmean-ai on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:40PM (#50513004)
On-device AI seems to be solution. But long way to go