You can ask someone to turn it off.
Might be a German/European thing though...
We already have products that provide active countermeasures against recording devices, an audio jammer of sorts that renders microphones unable to pick up anything. I wonder how effective they are.
Before I turned it on I asked my team if they had any objections. Silence for eight seconds before saying if anyone was uncomfortable objecting in the group they could reach out to me individually. No one ever did. The only request was that everyone internal get copied on the notes so they could correct them if needed.
These are company decisions to have these connectors and privacy choices. It's their data and their risk. There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company. At home I partake in none of this.
Casual meetings can have misconstrued words.
You think they could find something with a neutered transcript and there's precedent that someone can infer the LLM reasoning for a proprietary frontier model?
AI enables it, but isn't relevant to the concerns.
If not for cost, we could have done the same thing with a tape recorder, and a human transcriber. Lawyers would dislike that too.
>Additional note taking
a. This seems hand wavy. I assume people are already taking discoverable notes on company assets even for "casual" calls.
b. What's your experience with enterprise AI meeting note takers? My experience is that they're setup to summarize and won't give verbatim accounts.
Apparently you disagree. OK, thanks, see you later?!
And AI notetakers. You didn't distinguish.
It's a core premise of the article:
> These tools still often use a microphone to capture raw audio from conversations and convert it into summaries or transcripts before discarding the audio.
Did you check with internal counsel?
> There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company
The entire industry is one court case away from banning transcription. Not many companies want every word of every meeting legally discoverable - the implications haven't percolated yet
I don't have the authority to make the meaningful decisions, just to do my job efficiently.
Leadership sanctions, and sub teams make their own rules (out of convenience).
If you have the AI notetaker button to mass employees, and don't want it used, then your GC is not protecting you or they're expecting you to ask for forgiveness.
I’m right now in a minor dispute with AIG and added to my record-preservation demand any AI notes and recordings from internal meetings. It set off a minor firestorm. I suspect a lot of folks are going to be doing the same over coming years.
>done at work is private from the company.
That is why we have phone call, face to face meetings and email. Things are black and white for a reason because I want it to be recorded. If everything I said is going to be on record I will now be very careful of what comes out of my month.
In an already toxic work environment, this will likely make things even worst.
The next problem is going to be having to opt into the headless ones to reduce friction around adding your notetaker
I don’t particularly want to, for both ethics reasons and the fact my headed one (Fathom) is good enough. But it’s getting annoying to have inconsistent notes
There has also never been an illusion that anything said in public is private from the government yet I hope you can see that technologies that allow mass surveillance make for a very different society.
Even better if it's a feedback session or people have notes and comments. You can have them all mock-implemented before you even send out the summary.
I’ve got over a decade of work experience now and I have like 100 notebooks filled with notes from nearly every day. I routinely find that my own notes differ from auto written transcripts of meetings. Mostly it’s minor things but ever once in a while the automatic transcription gets something critically wrong.
If I go on a private walk with a manager around San Francisco, how would leadership or HR learn about this, assuming both parties do not defect.
I'm not even kidding. An individual has no protection, if it's workplace policy you can be fired for not following it.
If employees collectively challenge the policy an employer can not legally retaliate against collective action.
I'm not even talking about a "we didn't computers in my day and we did just fine" old-man-yells-at-cloud objection here; there is no real benefit, wrt recording a meeting, that "AI" brings to the table.
There have been too many times when an adversarial colleague untruthfully claimed or inferred I said or did something -- not that it happens frequently, but a handful of times over decades is enough to burn you. And the worst is when they keep meeting notes by hand, because those are somehow given more credibility even when they're just as likely to contain fabrications. (In fact I have grown suspicious of people who take meeting notes by hand, compulsively, in every meeting, although some of them mean well.)
Hence an objective, indelible record of what was said sounds ideal to me.
There is zero need to stream video and audio to third party APIs to document a meeting.
In fact, an automatically inferred transcript is arguably riskier than no documentation at all.
Recording meetings has been a thing for literal decades and it can be done in very privacy safe ways. A binary view of privacy is defeatist. Data governance is not an all-or-nothing proposition.
And you're equating passing the video and audio stream to some inference API for automatic transcription with merely storing video on premise or in cloud which is a gross misrepresentation of my objections.
Again, because you are intentionally misinterpreting my point: there is a lot of space in between hearsay and passing a stream for third party auto transcript APIs and somewhere in there is proper, reliable, and controllable documentation.
Also, like everything else ever to be framed as a technical only problem, it has social and political dimensions. From you to the corporate overlords "employer" and "cloud provider" there are a lot of layers and ignoring that is part of the defeatist attitude I denounce.
If you have nothing to hide you wont be bothered by having your conversations recorded.
Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go brush my teeth.
I fully reject that idea--well, I 99% reject that idea--but there is is a case when it comes to the communications of government officials or the executives of trillion dollar publicly traded companies where, yeah, I start to feel that maybe all their interactions should be recorded.
Just because something is recorded doesn't mean it needs to be made public. People often muddy the water for things like police video--"whell, police can't have their cameras on at all times because they might go into a private domicile"--that's a Red Herring. Just because something is recorded doesn't mean it needs to be public. Police cameras should just be on 100% of the time, but certain parts of it should not be made available to the public.
This will quietly become true more and more. We get close and closer to having every single interaction of normal people recorded forever, and yet, I expect that those in power will still somehow NOT have their conversations recorded.
I mean, if we're going to enter a world of little or not privacy, let's at least make sure the people actually running things are recorded.
That’s a world I don’t want to endorse, but it’s seemingly impossible to opt out and stay employed. Is there anything that I can do to minimize my exposure? Has anyone made it a norm to say “transcription isn’t needed for this meeting so I would like everyone to turn off AI notetaker before we proceed?”