News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by milderworkacc on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:18PM (#50502524)
In my view, this is precisely the kind of water-carrying that has led to the incremental erosion of our privacy in the first place. It happened little by little, enabled by opinions like this, who say "well at least foo is doing it in a more privacy-preserving way than bar", and each additional little erosion, each pebble on the beach newly washed away, is built on top of this new expectation, rather than the old status quo.

Go back ten years, and compare to today, and tell me whether we as a society would be happy with that difference occurring overnight. We wouldn't. But we let it happen over 500 odd weeks, with a new intrusion each week built on top of the last.

I reject the premise. They are functionally the same over a longer time span, but only Apple wins plaudits for it. They are as guilty as the rest of them.

Re:Tech Companies Are Trying to Shift the Concept of Privacy... by LoganDark on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:34PM (#50502669)
Has Apple done this yet, or is this prediction based on what others have done? I don't really see a difference between the Apple Watch recording locally for the benefit of its user and someone running an app that does the same thing. If they're both entirely local and not accessible to Apple, what's the difference? Is the difference just that the functionality is preloaded by Apple as opposed to being installed by the user? Is there a reason to be uncomfortable with Apple doing this instead of uncomfortable with users that take advantage of it? People can be creeps by recording without permission, so why is the company the creep when it's still the user who's doing it?

Meanwhile, other companies are unquestionably the creeps when they collect and analyze this data for themselves rather than leaving it local to the device and to the user.

Probably the creepiest thing I've encountered from Apple lately is that Siri AI actually has access to a screenshot when you ask it a question, even if you didn't explicitly upload one. That's extremely surprising behavior to me, especially since there's dedicated functionality for explicitly uploading a screenshot, so I have no idea why it would happen implicitly as well, but I don't worry about it nearly as much as if literally anyone else did it.