News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by krisroadruck on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:20PM (#34765239)
Just built a new rig last week. This isn't at all surprising. Prices are so out of whack right now. $1000 used to be the ceiling for the highest end video cards (like a 1080 Ti), now $1000 is the floor. There are no good current gen (or even previous gen) cards available for under $1000. The 4080 is a horrible value and still regularly listed at $1200-$1400. The 4090 is overkill and sits around $1700-$2200. Even 2 year old tech 3080's are regularly selling for near a grand. AM5 motherboards are insanely priced. Want a 10Gb onboard NIC? Be prepared to shell out $1000 just for the motherboard. Add to all of that, this latest batch of CPUs are just stupid power hungry - like 240w+ under load (except for the non-x variants of AMD 7000 series, just released last month).

It used to be you could buy a lot of computer for $2-3K, now that figure is closer to $5K. These prices, combined with the folks that just went through this pain 2 years ago during the pandemic and yeah you aren't going to see stuff flying off the shelves any time soon.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by gruez on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:38PM (#34765464)
>Add to all of that, this latest batch of CPUs are just stupid power hungry - like 240w+ under load (except for the non-x variants of AMD 7000 series, just released last month).

That's because in the race to get the highest benchmark scores, both companies have set the stock clocks to a level that's way beyond what's optimal (eg. adding 100W of power consumption to get 5% higher benchmark scores). The CPUs themselves are fine, you just have to adjust the power/clock limit lower.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by chx on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:26PM (#34766525)
^^^^ this

Someone on reddit did a power analysis of the 13900K and I reposted it here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34404683 https://www.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/10bna5r/13900k_po... and it shows the CPU at 100W has 75% of the performance at 40% of the power consumption...

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by oblak on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:48PM (#34766777)
It's still pretty bad compared to Ryzen 7000. The non-x models are just the regular guys at 65W, like my good ol 3700x.

That said, Intel sure has magic dust given how far behind their node disadvantage. Serves them right, though. What a horrible company.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by reisse on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:11PM (#34767004)
Their node disadvantage is mostly good marketing from TSMC though. Intel 10 (10nm, but that's not the real nanometers) is ~100M transistors per mm2, while TSMC 5 (5nm, but again, that's not the real nanometers) is ~130M transistors per mm2.

Sure, 30% better, but not a 2x improvement as marketing suggests.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by megous on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:53PM (#34768493)
10nm to 5nm feature size should be [naively thinking] 4x improvement in density, so it's even worse. :)
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by paulmd on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:39PM (#34781012)
Actual feature size stopped shrinking a long time ago, though. First they flipped the transistors on their side (FinFET) and now they're embedding them inside a block of gate (GAAFET) to get more out of the same size. But the transistors have not just diverged from their actual names (which happened a long time ago) but have not even really shrunk since like 28nm, there is no dimension of a 5nm chip that is actually 5nm. ;)

I know you're poking fun at it, but, node names are completely made up and the points don't matter these days. It is a "5nm-class node", if nodes had continued to shrink according to the original plans in 2000 or whatever.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Dylan16807 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:57PM (#34769296)
I will nitpick because the naming is a giant mess: There is no "Intel 10".

Intel's old naming scheme had "nm" after every number, and the one you're describing is "10nm".

Then they renamed everything to use smaller numbers, and no "nm". Newer versions of "10nm" became "Intel 7", still at ~100M transistors per mm².

Similarly "7nm" became "Intel 4", with an expected density of ~160M. And so on.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by 7speter on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:17AM (#34770398)
A bit of an efficiency advantage though, as seen when you max out zen4 vs alderlake/raptorlake cpus.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by paulmd on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:10PM (#34780554)
> It's still pretty bad compared to Ryzen 7000. The non-x models are just the regular guys at 65W, like my good ol 3700x.

* 65W TDP, 88W PPT

This little bit of sleight-of-hand from AMD was really really effective, boost TDP used to be called boost TDP, and Intel expected their TDPs to cover full load when boosting or under AVX. Then AMD made up this new number but it's not TDP it's uh, PPT, and marketed all their chips under a 30% lower number.

It's obviously worked because people do this "my CPU is only 65W!" thing all the time and no, it's not, it's 88W, unless you've turned off boost.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Gigachad on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:07PM (#34768580)
In a desktop, hardly anyone cares. Everyone is using AIO coolers that can handle these insane temps. So the 15% improvement is usually worth it, considering the CPU will not even use these powers unless it's actually being used to the fullest.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by chx on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:17PM (#34769035)
> Everyone is using AIO coolers

[citation needed]

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by mastax on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:25PM (#34769088)
In the summer, at least, I appreciate not having my room heat up so much.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by greggyb on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:50PM (#34799032)
AIOs do not significantly outperform tower coolers. Their benefit is flexibility of placement. Tower coolers require room for ... a tower. And that placement is both inflexible and in need of airflow through most of the case.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by BoorishBears on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:42PM (#34766707)
Honestly you don't have to adjust the limit: the "power under load" angle just gets completely overblown because people go based on a reviewer's definition of load

They might be 240W under extreme load, but I can play AAA titles on my i9 at 240hz barely cracking 50% CPU load. And that's with a 3090, so not exactly a mismatched CPU/GPU situation.

At those types of loads the CPU doesn't even try to hit boost clocks most of the time, so you're nowhere near the figures you often see touted based on benchmarks.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by 015a on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:10PM (#34766999)
Yeah; games to this day are still pretty bad at utilizing multiple cores. Any idiot can do the math; the i7 13700k has 16 cores, and an advertised max TDP of 250W. That's a ton of power; but if you're only really stressing 2 or 3 cores the real power draw isn't that high. These chips are so powerful that your bottleneck is almost always GPU, unless you're playing CS:GO at 1080p and aiming for 800fps, so realistically its common to see 25-60% utilization on 1 or 2 P-cores, and the rest just running Windows background shit.

This is proven by any outlet which takes the time to measure Performance Per Watt (e.g. https://www.hwcooling.net/en/intel-core-i7-13700k-efficient-...). Intel has consistently driven higher PPW with every generation, when you're comparing like-for-like binned chips. AMD, on the other hand, has been a bigger victim of what the OP is describing; while their raw PPW is generally higher than Intel, so they have room to fall, their Ryzen 7x chips aren't consistently posting higher PPW numbers over Ryzen 5x.

In other words; both Intel and AMD are doing well here. If you're stressing every core on the CPU at 100%, you're going to draw a lot of power, but you're also going to be completing workloads much faster than on 12th or 11th gen, so your aggregate power draw will be lower. The low-tier media outlets that post "OMG 250W" aren't doing research, and also don't care to, because they get clicks from tons of people like the OP who eat outrage at face value.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by BoorishBears on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:42PM (#34767355)
It's not just low-tier media outlets (at least in terms of reach), this is largely driven by large names like LTT and Gamer's Nexus

People don't realize that mid range mobile chips from both Intel and AMD out perform top of the range desktop SKUs from a few years ago because they're constantly bombarded by hot takes based on things like CPU rendering and unzipping files...

At this point I'm convinced it's just an informal cycle, where if they actually reported in a realistic manner, no release would be exciting. If they didn't pair bottom of the line CPUs with top end GPUs and odd settings configurations under the guise of "not wanting to reflect a GPU bottleneck", it'd be a lot clearer how badly needs have stagnated vs the speed of these new SKUs

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by gruez on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:53PM (#34767460)
>At this point I'm convinced it's just an informal cycle, where if they actually reported in a realistic manner, no release would be exciting. If they didn't pair bottom of the line CPUs with top end GPUs and odd settings configurations under the guise of "not wanting to reflect a GPU bottleneck", it'd be a lot clearer how badly needs have stagnated vs the speed of these new SKUs

Hardware unboxed did a video explaining why reviews do that: https://youtu.be/Zy3w-VZyoiM

tl;dw: you're not caring about the performance today, you're caring about the performance a few years from now when you bought a faster GPU.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by BoorishBears on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:23PM (#34768673)
Wow that's the most blatantly misleading chart I've seen out of these types of outfits in a long time!

I'm sorry this is kind of long, but I really had to make sure I wasn't missing something with how obvious there were about it.

The complaint people have is that they're not matching up hardware realistically... so they take a ~$350 Intel CPU and pit it against a ~$250 AMD CPU, instead of the ~$350 AMD sibling it launched alongside of to artificially induce a larger gap!

How much do you want to bet the same graph with a 2700x would have given a much less convincing gap?

-

Now you might be thinking I'm just being uncharitable... but they actually tested the correct SKUs specifically for future proofing, twice over the last few years! Talk about a smoking gun: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=11GvlWamF2E

And no surprise, it took using a $1000 GPU at 1080p to shake out half the gap shown for a similarly priced GPU in the video!

And even worse, if you actually go and look at the individual titles, unlike the graphs shown here, at no point was the difference enough to affect your ability to hit a playable refresh rate! The largest differences were in games where they were both getting over 300 FPS since again, they're using a $1000 GPU for 1080p!

-

And if you're still not convinced it's an intentional attempt to push a misleading point, I mentioned they've done this comparison twice... the last time the entire point of the video was to not base your choice on future proofing! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZkJ_-vfQa8

They actually concluded by saying there was no meaningful difference, gaming is largely GPU limited, and specifically replied to people claiming that you can just wait for the difference to appear:

I wouldn't hold your breath, I expect you'll upgrade your [CPU] platform once or twice before those extra cores for gaming matter

I don't know how much more blatant you can get than that...

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by gruez on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:40PM (#34768796)
>Wow that's the most blatantly misleading chart I've seen out of these types of outfits in a long time!

>I'm sorry this is kind of long, but I really had to make sure I wasn't missing something with how obvious there were about it.

>The complaint people have is that they're not matching up hardware realistically... so they take a ~$350 Intel CPU and pit it against a ~$250 AMD CPU, instead of the ~$350 AMD sibling it launched alongside of to artificially induce a larger gap!

I'm assuming the "chart" in question is the one shown at https://youtu.be/Zy3w-VZyoiM?t=278. The point of comparing the $250 amd cpu against the $350 intel cpu isn't to claim that they're in the same market segment, it's to point out that if benchmarked CPUs using "reasonable" GPU parings, you'll see little to no difference between high end and mid end CPUs. Now, you might argue that benchmarking this way is misleading because in reality, you'll never see the performance differential and therefore would waste money by buying the high end CPU. However, the CPUs are actually faster. Benchmarking them in such a way that their actual performance doesn't show because they're limited by some external factor would also be misleading. It'd be like putting out a benchmark between a sports car and an econobox and concluding that they're within 5% (or whatever) of each other in terms of performance because the speed limit is 60mph, so they both get you to your destination in around the same amount of time.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by BoorishBears on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:59PM (#34769318)
You're missing that the video is making a claim with two parts:

a) you need to use unrealistic pairings to get the true margin of the parts under review...

b) we prioritize exposing the margin to allow future-proofing your CPU choice

I'm totally agreeing that they need to use mismatched GPU to make the first point.

-

But I'm strongly refuting the second: they expose the "hidden" margin because again, the real world gains for most owners wouldn't be there and the content would be a lot less exciting.

And they're claiming that it's not about today, but it will be once future GPUs at the same price point are faster... but they concluded the exact opposite before: stating that you should not bank on GPU futureproofing changing the math on which CPU is a better choice.

And what's so damning is that when they wanted to prove that opposite take about the exact same topic they used direct competitors twice.

As soon as they benefited from the gap they decided to downgrade the CPU.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by gruez on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:27PM (#34769487)
>And they're claiming that it's not about today, but it will be once future GPUs at the same price point are faster... but they concluded the exact opposite before: stating that you should not bank on GPU futureproofing changing the math on which CPU is a better choice.

Going back to your previous comment

>And if you're still not convinced it's an intentional attempt to push a misleading point, I mentioned they've done this comparison twice... the last time the entire point of the video was to not base your choice on future proofing! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZkJ_-vfQa8

>They actually concluded by saying there was no meaningful difference, gaming is largely GPU limited, and specifically replied to people claiming that you can just wait for the difference to appear:

>I wouldn't hold your breath, I expect you'll upgrade your [CPU] platform once or twice before those extra cores for gaming matter

>I don't know how much more blatant you can get than that...

I don't see the contradiction here. The specific advice he was arguing against in the video is "you should get ryzen CPUs because they have more cores and therefore they futureproof better". His argument against that is that games are still single threaded and will be in the near future, so any theoretical benefits you get from more cores will take forever to materialize. He's not making a blanket statement arguing against any sort of futureproofing.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by BoorishBears on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:42AM (#34770818)
If you can't see the multiple layers of contradiction at this point, I'm not sure how much more plain it can be...

In video 1 in the series he makes a side mention about viewers previously complaining "why are you comparing these at low resolutions, the differences you're exposing won't matter".

But the point of that video is to compare two CPUs for gaming, so he goes at length about the margin exposed in a way that would imply the 8700k "won"... despite briefly mentioning "under most conditions there is no actual difference" right afterwards.

3 years after that he says does that again, going at length about the 8700k winning, but then walking it back to "but really they're about the same"

-

Fast forward to now, and this time he's making a video that directly addresses the complaints about low resolution testing.

So this time he chooses a slower CPU, even faster GPUs, ends up with slightly bigger gaps than the ones he previously wrote off (which are more than accounted for by both the even faster GPU this time, and slower competitor). Honesty would dictate a similar "they're essentially the same", but this time he goes on to beat his chest with "well this is why we call out the margin!"

I wonder if maybe you're missing that the dishonesty doesn't stem from having falsified anything, it's about the obvious conflict of interest where they intentionally set up each case to show as much as a gap as possible regardless of bearing on reality because that's the flashiest content that lets them make the hottest possible takes.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by karamanolev on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:46PM (#34767398)
By "CPU load", loading the CPU is implied. The fact that your AAA titles don't load the CPU, because they're GPU-bottlenecked is irrelevant. Load the CPU properly, e.g. compiling, and you'll see large power consumptions.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by BoorishBears on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:36PM (#34768380)
> By "CPU load", loading the CPU is implied

Didn't think I needed to explain load is not a binary concept. Understanding that is just table stakes for making a meaningful contribution the conversation.

The point is that the CPUs are massively capable at less than 100% utilization.

These reviewers are covering more use cases than "24/7 Linux Kernel compiles", yet they're selling conclusions that only apply in that sort of use case as much more relevant than they actually are.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by arecurrence on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:27PM (#34765328)
Reading this really points out to me how killer of a deal that GeforceNow is. I truly don't understand why more publishers don't allow their games on the platform.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by eric__cartman on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:35PM (#34765433)
It's not a killer deal for the consumer. That's just Nvidia fucking you over either way and still profiting off it. The market is not only bad in the high end, but there aren't any ~$200 value oriented graphics cards that provide significant upgrades over past generations. Just now the GTX 1060 has stepped down from being the most popular card in Steam's hardware survey just to be replaced by the GTX 1650, a much newer card that costs about the same and performs about the same. And with less VRAM!
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by pdntspa on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:38PM (#34765463)
I am so glad this notion of renting your games is dying. People need to own their bits.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by geraldhh on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:37PM (#34765452)
i would suspect that they either fear a loss of profit (b/c platform cut) or reputation (because latency/jitter from bad connection will be wrongly blamed on the game rather than the platform)
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by dfghjjbhvg on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:36PM (#34765441)
because they all learned from stadia and know how crappy and useless remote streaming of input/graphics is for most games.

this tech is bad. awful. only worth for casual games which are already well served by comon hardware localy.

its all a ruse to try to sell idle capacity for their gpu farms because AI model training hype never materialized

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by 0-_-0 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:18PM (#34767095)
I tried geforce now, it's amazing, lag is almost imperceptible with the 8ms ping I had.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Gigachad on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:16PM (#34768631)
I also tried it on a gigabit network and it was essentially unusable. Constant frame drops and audio stuttering.

Even for casual gaming it was horrible. Can't imagine something multi player.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by nottorp on Monday February 13, 2023 @06:45AM (#34772416)
You talking about your local network or your internet connection?

It works just fine(tm) on the two fiber connections i've tried, one 500 mbps only, not 1 gbps. It only uses like 10 mbps for 1080.

It's the latency and packet loss that kills you, it's unusable on wifi going though the same fiber for example.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by arecurrence on Monday February 13, 2023 @09:20AM (#34773676)
There’s a lot of bad networks out there. I won a number of Fortnite battle royals testing this and it was rock solid 120 fps, barely any detectable latency at the 10 ms ping I was getting.

The lack of noise actually made me prefer it over my gaming box. It’s a real home run for people fortunate enough to have excellent network connections to nvidia’s data centres.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by 0-_-0 on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:03AM (#34775252)
Did you have a gigabit wired connection to the server?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by wonnage on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:42PM (#34766117)
Having what feels like 100ms of input delay at a minimum is pretty awful. Idk if there's some magic way to speculatively render extra frames so that input is resolved locally
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by vitaflo on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:27PM (#34765326)
Let’s also remember when the 1080 first launched it was a massive upgrade and the retail price was $600.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ricardobayes on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:33PM (#34765396)
And was considered really expensive, at the time
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by qayxc on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:53PM (#34768497)
Ah, those youngsters have no idea what expensive means :) Back in the early 90s a half decent SVGA card could set you back $900 easily (e.g. ATI's 1MB Graphics Ultra from 1991). And that's 1992 dollars, mind you. So about $1,900 adjusted for inflation.

Heck, a SoundBlaster Pro sound card was $300 back then (~$670 adjusted for inflation) - the base model for $170 was considered a steal at that price :D And that thing couldn't do half as much as even the cheapo ALC897 sound chip in a basic motherboard.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by pjmlp on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:41AM (#34771417)
Hence why I was big into flight simulators up to when they started asking for 486/ 4MB as baseline, it was over for me, as I had other things in life more relevant to spend the money.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by checkyoursudo on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:52PM (#34767444)
I bought a 1080 quite a while after they launched. I still have it. I have thought about building a new PC lately, and it seems to me that newer cards are ... not as much as an upgrade as I might have been led to believe? Especially given the cost. If I did build a new PC today, I am not entirely sure I would buy a new video card. The performance/value ratio doesn't seem as appealing as jumping to the 1080 did at the time back then.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by tomnipotent on Sunday February 12, 2023 @10:03PM (#34769685)
The 3080 to 4080 gain is the same as the 980 to 1080 jump (~27%).
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by checkyoursudo on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @05:14AM (#34879176)
Well that's not too bad maybe. I probably will upgrade sometime relatively soon. It just hasn't seemed as compelling, but that could also be my enthusiasm has waned since I was younger. Hard to know, I guess.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by jb1991 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:26PM (#34765315)
The Mac Studio is quite a powerful machine at a relatively reasonable price.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:31PM (#34765382)
How many games run on it?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by davely on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:36PM (#34765442)
Quite a lot, at least based on my experience using Steam and playing various games I’ve bought for my actual gaming PC, but have builds available for multiple platforms.

As long as they’re 64 bit builds, MacOS’s Rosetta translation layer does a great job of running then without a hitch.

Apple Silicon is a beast. I wish more developers would take advantage of it.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by krisroadruck on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:43PM (#34765526)
This is only true if your primary game preference is casual games. The mac studio lacks a discrete graphics card. Ignoring the OS, the whole ARM vs x86, and Rosetta, wine, whatever stumbling blocks - just lack of a discrete GPU is enough to make it a no-go as a serious gaming rig. This isn't just me talking out of my neck either. I have 3 rigs I keep around my desk, and one of them is a mac studio. Great for dev and video editing, but for gaming not so much.

Edit: "Why do you need 3 computers?" - I regularly switch between Windows, Ubuntu & MacOS, and I don't like dinking with switching my monitor inputs, dual booting or remoting in. Rather just swivel my chair. Yes I fully realize how ridiculous this is. Some people like nice cars. I like wasting money on computers apparently. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by bitL on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:08PM (#34766358)
No worries, I have 12 computers around my desk...
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by amelius on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:50PM (#34767423)
> Apple Silicon is a beast. I wish more developers would take advantage of it.

It's consumer electronics. Not very useful for people who want to build things containing a CPU/GPU.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by jb1991 on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:09AM (#34771541)
It’s a lot more than “consumer electronics”. When I upgraded my i7 last year for a base model M1 chip, I found that all of my c++ code ran vastly more quickly on a machine that cost about half as much as what it replaced. What is strange is that if you look at the raw specs, it should not have been near half in execution time —- there’s definitely some fascinating things going on in that chip.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by robertoandred on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:36PM (#34769175)
Computers are more than just dumb toys.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ChuckNorris89 on Monday February 13, 2023 @09:49AM (#34774030)
Are you talking about Macs?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by robertoandred on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @02:12PM (#34794404)
Talking about computers.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by jb1991 on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:54AM (#34770869)
I have no idea, in my long career I’ve never installed a computer game on anything. It might be surprising, but some people use computers for other things.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ChuckNorris89 on Monday February 13, 2023 @07:42AM (#34772769)
Good for you mate, but games were a main driver of hardware innovations both for CPUs and GPUs and were responsible for the adoption in the household of the PC and many people today still prefer them to the locked down console ecosystems because once your gaming session is over you can use that computing power for other things, like coding, rendering, etc.

The fact you never installed a game is largely irrelevant.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by jb1991 on Monday February 13, 2023 @07:50AM (#34772829)
Hi Chuck, you mention hardware innovations but it's largely well-recognized that the deprecation of cross-platform GPU APIs is the main reason the mac is not known for gaming, and has nothing to do with whether or not it has a powerful hardware. It has, in fact, some of the most impressive innovations in recent memory, including unified memory and more.

The Mac Studio is one of the most powerful desktops currently on the market, and its integrated GPU competes quite well against many discrete GPUs. It's your comment and subsequent argument about gaming that is ultimately irrelevant on the topic of whether or not it is "powerful".

btw big fan of walker, texas ranger. Please do more like that one.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ChuckNorris89 on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:06PM (#34776376)
And yet despite their powerful GPUs, Mac is still irrelevant in the GPU space due to their locked down nature to a niche API that's Apple exclusive.

Everyone targets Nvidia or AMD GPUs for both gaming and compute like ML.

Mac GPUs are mostly used by YouTubers to accelerate video editing.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by jb1991 on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:39PM (#34777031)
Many of the most important ML toolchains run natively on Apple Silicon, including PyTorch [0] and TensorFlow. For example the PyTorch folks have this to say about it [0]:

> Every Apple silicon Mac has a unified memory architecture, providing the GPU with direct access to the full memory store. This makes Mac a great platform for machine learning, enabling users to train larger networks or batch sizes locally. This reduces costs associated with cloud-based development or the need for additional local GPUs. The Unified Memory architecture also reduces data retrieval latency, improving end-to-end performance.

Plenty of other reports out there [1]:

>We ran a sweep of 8 different configurations of our training script and show that the Apple M1 offers impressive performance within reach of much more expensive and less energy efficient accelerators such as the Nvidia V100 for smaller architectures and datasets.

If one is looking for a great bang for the buck and a big savings in energy use, the GPUs in Apple Silicon are a compelling option. Plenty of Apple haters (presumably yourself) like to ignore what has been achieved with this technology, but that doesn't make it any less real.

[0] https://pytorch.org/blog/introducing-accelerated-pytorch-tra...

[1] https://wandb.ai/vanpelt/m1-benchmark/reports/Can-Apple-s-M1...

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ChuckNorris89 on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:21PM (#34777773)
And yet it won't run most games and apps because Apple won't support Vulkan like ... every single other computing platform in existence.

You're ignoring mainstream apps and focusing on niche things off GitHub.

What's Apple's market share again in the GPU compute space? Oh yeah, it's almost zero.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by jb1991 on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:59PM (#34778399)
PyTorch and TensorFlow are not niche, they are key tools in the ML field, which is what you brought up and I responded too.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by geraldhh on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:45PM (#34765557)
> Want a 10Gb onboard NIC? Be prepared to shell out $1000 just for the motherboard.

quick search turns up options for around 500euros

but don't be fooled, 10GbE copper is a power hungry mess. go with lower n-baseT speeds if just want some progression for the last twenty years of networking innovation or invest in optical and get a real upgrade (20/40/100 Gbps)

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by krisroadruck on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:51PM (#34765610)
AM5 w/ PCIE 5, DDR5 support and 10GBe? I've already eaten the cost, but I would love a link to the board you found. I saw a lot in that price range with 2.5 or 5GB but didn't run into any with 10GBe. That said I may have missed one. If nothing else it may be useful for when the wifes gaming rig gets an upgrade in a few months.

As to why I'm sticking with 10Gbe - I have a 24 port 10GBe switch for the house so going with the kit that matches the network I already have.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by flangola7 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:06PM (#34766347)
What is the use case of 10Gb Ethernet for the regular PC user? Or even the enthusiast?

I have a sprawling homelab and home theater and scarcely need regular 1G. Last summer I transferred a media archive of ~10TB to new hardware, which completed overnight across Cat5. Is there some hot new hobby that generates multi gigabit bursts that I don't know about?

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by lazide on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:08PM (#34766968)
Uh, at maximum speed on a gigabit network, it takes 22 hours, 13 minutes to transfer 10 TB.

That’s not overnight unless you’re a hell of a sleeper.

On a 10Gig network, assuming no other bottlenecks (harder to do), it’s 2 and a quarter hours.

Personally, I use 10 gig because 100MB/s is really slow. Even 2.5Gb is much, much better and makes it a lot more likely something besides the network is the bottleneck.

I personally move around enough data, it bothers me enough to be worth it.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by fragmede on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:10PM (#34768182)
But what is that data? What super cool hobby do you have where you're regularly transferring 10TiB of data around?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by kaetemi on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:20PM (#34768653)
Downloading Linux ISOs.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by lazide on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:36PM (#34769176)
For me? I move around a lot more than 10TB.

Just my NVR archive is 70TB+, and that is with only a 3 month retention.

Throw in Photogrammetry data sets, decades of photos and videos, hundreds of thousands of PDF scans, and a ton more stuff, and, well. It’s a lot of data.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by sokoloff on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:09PM (#34766985)
Editing video files. My kids are both into making videos and even though most of them are crap, I still want to get them into good habits of "store important files on the storage server" and we don't have any redundancy on local file storage. The difference between 1 and 10Gbps ethernet is noticeable there. (They only have 2.5Gbps to the desktop switch which has 10Gbps link to downstairs, so they only get ~250MB/s transfer, but they each have it simultaneously if they want.)
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by progman32 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:10PM (#34766998)
My only 10g link is between my main workstation and my nas. Between the SSD on my workstation and the 2 ssd array in the nas, I easily saturate 1g. Makes a big difference for video work and certain dev tasks (i.e. generating disk images). Granted I spent less than $100 for this capability using older solarflare cards and optics.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by geraldhh on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:24AM (#34771321)
> spent less than $100 for this capability using older solarflare cards and optics

this is the way

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by formerly_proven on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:44PM (#34768434)
Without 10 GbE (or at least 2.5 GbE) using any kind of NAS is a pretty significant performance downgrade over directly connecting hard drives (even using USB 3). GbE has been too slow for even a single hard drive for at least 15 years.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by eertami on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:45PM (#34768439)
Perhaps having a 10Gbit internet connection and it is faster to download/upload things than 1Gbit? I'll never max it out, but it's $54/month instead of $44 for 1Gbit so why not. Why 1Gbit instead of 100Mbit?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by cptnapalm on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:01PM (#34767556)
I got an older Supermicro off eBay with 6 10Gb ports for $89.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Whinner on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:47PM (#34765572)
$1000 as the floor? Maybe if you’re talking 4K gaming but that’s the very high end.

Intel arc a750 are under $300 and are decent cards for 1080 and do well in 1440. Dx9 support has greatly increased since release.

Going up a little in price, amds 6650 amd 6750 are 3-400.

6800xt are under $600.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by krisroadruck on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:54PM (#34765634)
I haven't bought a non-4K monitor in over 6 years. I honestly don't know anyone who is still using 1080p monitors as daily drivers if they are also using the machine for productivity or media work. But your point is not invalid.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by pprotas on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:18PM (#34765875)
https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/Steam-Hardware-Softw...

> 60% of Steam users have a 1080p monitor as their primary display

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by interstice on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:10PM (#34766380)
How recently have they upgraded
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Nullabillity on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:48PM (#34767980)
What motivation is there to upgrade? Even if you're replacing the PC itself completely there's not much of a reason to not just reuse the old screen.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by thfuran on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:47PM (#34768840)
How about not wanting to be able to see the pixels anymore?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by alyandon on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:53PM (#34766830)
Apparently, I'm a real oddball with my dual 2408WFP setup:

  1920 x 1200  0.70%   +0.01%
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ClumsyPilot on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:54PM (#34768879)
I was rocking that for many years.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by alyandon on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:08AM (#34770348)
I'm really going to be unhappy when one of them finally gives out and I have to replace them - amazing S-PVA panels. :(
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by cma on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:26PM (#34769097)
Users on cheap internet cafe PCs get counted per user instead of per computer.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by krisroadruck on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:01PM (#34765703)
@ChuckNorris89 man... why do they hate their devs? That's just mean =/ Hopefully they don't have you all on a bunch of $400 dell optiplexes too. Pouring one out for you brother.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:58PM (#34765678)
At my job we all got 1080p monitors for dev work.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by qayxc on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:20PM (#34768253)
You poor souls. I couldn't imagine going back to 1080p for dev work.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ChuckNorris89 on Monday February 13, 2023 @06:14AM (#34772231)
That's how cheap European tech companies are.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by IntelMiner on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:42PM (#34766116)
Hi, I use a pair of 1080p monitors on my primary machine. Both for work, leisure and my hobby of video editing for youtube videos
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by bryanlarsen on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:46PM (#34766155)
Modern games let you set separate rendering and display resolutions so you can get most of the benefit of a 4k display without requiring a video card that can render every pixel. The new upscaling techs address really good.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by dvngnt_ on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:46PM (#34766156)
1440p gang
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by tbrownaw on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:46PM (#34766157)
On in-office days I'm stuck with a pair of 1080p (at home, yes it's a pair of 4k). It's kind of annoying.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ClumsyPilot on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:59PM (#34766278)
I understand when people sont want to spend their own money on displays, but as a business you wre literally loosing money by using substandard equipment, research shows its around 10% of salary, much more than a monitor costs
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by lazide on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:03PM (#34766917)
Different budget line items. Silly huh?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by goosedragons on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:01PM (#34766305)
1440p monitors aren't that expensive either and for a lot of people 4K at 100% scaling is too small to be comfortable at a typical 27" size. For PC gaming a high refresh rate 1080p or 1440p display is a better buy than a 60Hz 4K one at roughly the same price.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ClumsyPilot on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:58PM (#34768913)
High refresh rate displays are very pleasant to use even if you are just doing non-gaming. They are legitimate conoetition to 4K
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by TaylorAlexander on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:14PM (#34766411)
Still using my old Dell 1440p 27" monitor to edit my 4k youtube videos. I briefly considered buying a 4k monitor this year but I spent my money on a NAS instead. I use three monitors on my desktop, the other two being 1080p. I use the 27" for my main monitor and the others are for docs and videos. I haven't bought a monitor in like 10 years because these things just keep on going. I do have a 4k monitor and work and its nice but does not feel significantly different from my old 1440p monitor. If I had more money I probably wouldn't think much about an upgrade but I work for a tech non profit and live in the Bay Area so I am not out buying new stuff that often. The NAS was a long needed upgrade to serve as a backup for my important media!
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by anthomtb on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:14PM (#34766412)
I am on a pair of 1080p’s. I stare at text all day. What is the benefit of upgrading to 4K?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by acdha on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:47PM (#34766764)
The text isn’t fuzzy? I have a work-provided 1080p display and it’s really noticeable switching between that and a Retina display unless I’m across the room, even without my glasses.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by anthomtb on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:50PM (#34766803)
Nope, not at all.

Maybe it is one of those things where, once you switch to 4K, you can’t got back.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by acdha on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:53PM (#34766825)
Quite possibly. I do this multiple times a week and it’s quite noticeable but that’s definitely after training my baseline expectations.

I have found it seems to be better for eye strain but that’s a single anecdote, not science.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by E39M5S62 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:59PM (#34767532)
I was on ~100dpi monitors for years. I just picked up a 26" 4k Dell for a steal - it's noticably more crisp than my 1440p screens. I'm not getting rid of my 1200p and 1440p screens on my workstation, but ... 4k is nice.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by giantrobot on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:50PM (#34766797)
Your text can be much sharper and easier on the eyes. Newer displays also can have much better dynamic range which also improves text readability.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by FpUser on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:53PM (#34766832)
I run single 30" 4K monitor at 100% scaling. Main reason for 4K is - I usually have 2-3 editing windows arranged side by side when coding. It fits a lot of text vertically and I like that.

As an extra benefit: I am a sucker for good photos and viewing those on large 4K is way better in my opinion. 4K Youtube and Netflix also looks better.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by tbrownaw on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:58PM (#34769309)
I tend to have most of my things half-maximized, so the same width as a 1080 but twice the vertical space. Generally three half-screens like that with vs code or a browser or whatever, and then the last half has a bunch of smaller overlapping utilities (terminal, notes, chat, etc).

I don't generally maximize windows across a whole screen except for word (~8 document pages on-screen at once) and visio.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by cammikebrown on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:25PM (#34766520)
144Hz is way more important to me than resolution. I have a 4K TV I can hook my computer up to if I really want.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Gigachad on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:10PM (#34768598)
These days 4k 144hz screens are pretty affordable and good. I picked one up recently because I couldn't stand less than 4k to use while programming. But I agree in games it's not the biggest difference.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by scarface74 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:50PM (#34766804)
This is so out of touch with reality it might as well be “do people still watch TV? I haven’t owned a TV in 10 years”
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by elabajaba on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:20PM (#34766461)
The cheapest 3050 in Canada is $389. It is ~10% slower than a 1070ti.

4 years ago you could get a 1070ti in Canada for $400 new.

The exchange rate is about the same as well.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by qball on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:44PM (#34766731)
>The cheapest 3050 in Canada is $389. It is ~10% slower than a 1070ti.

Fortunately, used 1070s and RX580s are 150CAD (100USD).

The combination of board prices being completely out of whack, and the performance delta of the 3080 over the 3070/2080Ti (made worse by the fact that the 4090 is that leap again over the 3080) being as large as it is, means the value proposition in the middle has disappeared.

It's not that the 3080 isn't worth 700USD or that the current 4000 series cards don't have a similar price/performance ratio- because they very much are priced appropriately; it's that the cheaper new cards (especially the 3070) have a far worse ratio than the expensive ones do. This is also partially why the most popular gaming GPU on Steam is the GTX1650.

And with current-generation console games targeting the equivalent of that 1070/2060, buying anything less than a 3080 is an objectively bad decision, unless you're someone who plays a lot of competitive shooters and thus can benefit from an intermediate for high framerate reasons. (The fact that most of those games aren't particularly fun to play also hurts the hardware industry.)

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by sokoloff on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:06PM (#34766947)
I've got a couple of machines here (mine and the kids') with RX480/580s in them.

At this point, I think a buyer might as well get a new 6650XT (~US$260 plus tax) rather than trying to chase a 5-year old, used, half-as-powerful 580.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by paulmd on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:16PM (#34780668)
Grandparent seems to have forgotten about 4070 Ti (only $800, what a bargain!) but yeah, $800 is currently the floor for current-gen hardware in the sense that nothing has launched below $800 despite being almost 6 months into this product cycle. AMD's cheapest is a $900 MSRP (but starting to fall below that) and NVIDIA's cheapest is an $800 MSRP.

That space is currently filled by older, slower, less efficient, less-featured last-gen products. Both companies have some significant amounts of inventory they want to burn through after the mining thing and it's going slow because of the general declines in shipments.

Generally though I think people are remembering the past with rose-colored glasses... not saying OP said this in particular, but a lot of people have latched onto the idea of the "$300 x70 tier", and the x70 tier has literally never been $300 MSRP for the entire time it's existed. It's bounced back and forth between $350 and $400 even 10 years ago, $329 was the lowest price it's ever launched at and people have latched onto that one as being the price x70 has to match forever, plus a little extra. GTX 680 (full-die GK104) was $499 10 years ago, for a 300mm^2 chip, GTX 670 was a GK104 cutdown for $399 for example, and GTX Titan was where you got the full GK110 at a mere $999 (in 2012 dollars).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nvidia_graphics_proces...

Ampere was somewhat below the baseline, using Samsung was an attempt to make cheaper cards and push down the cost, so by $499 being a "bargain" price (for 3070) before pandemic cost spirals got too bad, and factoring in the more expensive TSMC 5nm node, I think the realistic price for a 4070 (GA104 cutdown, whatever you call it) is probably $600-700 at this point.

So there's definitely some gouging taking place, but, a lot of people are fixated on that $300 number and that's just not going to happen. Costs have just spiraled a lot more than people realize, Pascal was not cheap either and that was 7 years ago (!) this june, and everything since then has been on older, cheaper nodes to help keep the costs down... until now. Throw in the pandemic generally blowing a lot of costs up, and yeah things are expensive now.

And yes, 4850/4870 were good cheap cards, but AMD could do that because they got onto 55nm ahead of NVIDIA, and that was back in the days when shrinking first was a real advantage, you could match a high-end card with a cheap midrange card if you got to a newer node first. That's not how it works anymore, higher wafer costs and R&D costs mean newer nodes are better but they're not really cheaper even considering you get more chips per wafer. Costs are growing fast enough to eat up the increases in density.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Tuna-Fish on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:53PM (#34765626)
There are complex reasons related to patent licensing why it makes no sense to put 10Gbe on a motherboard right now. If you want 10Gbe, don't get a $1000 motherboard for it, get a motherboard with a free pcie 4.0 slot and get an adapter. That'll cost an extra ~$100 today, and an extra ~$20 in August.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by robin_reala on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:41PM (#34766095)
Why $20 in August?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Tuna-Fish on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:56PM (#34766250)
Patents expire.

The cost of actually making a 10gbase-t network card is really not much anymore. All of the cost is licensing.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by krisroadruck on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:56PM (#34765649)
Fair enough - I'm clearly paying a premium to keep a cleaner interior on the build. I tend to run exactly one card - the video card, and aim to get everything else onboard, but as you pointed out that's definitely not the only way to go, and certainly not the most cost efficient way.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by willis936 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:38PM (#34766084)
Vanity can cost as much as a market is willing to pay.

From a function standpoint: I'm happy that multiple PCIe slots is still the standard. If I didn't have functional wants such as "more accelerators and more I/O" then I'd go with a cute ITX build.

I did get a compact case recently because 5.25", 3.5", and 2.5" bays are no longer an interesting use case for my daily driver, but now I find that even if I did want to shell out for a new high-end GPU the only model that would fit in my case is a perpetually sold out AIO model.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by myself248 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:40PM (#34767331)
Aye. I keep two desktops around for this reason.

One is my new Ryzen APU in a small (sub-7-liter) case, which sits half empty because I haven't even dropped a GPU into it. All my games and CAD run just fine on the APU. All the included peripherals are more than I've ever needed.

The other is my old Athlon64x2 4850e in a bigass M3N78 Pro board, with drives and I/O out the wazoo. It's old enough to have floppy and PATA ports, but new enough to have SATA and USB too (and even a PCIe slot), so it's my media mule. I power it up whenever I need to do CD ripping, floppy archiving, that sort of stuff. I actually picked up the fastest chip that would fit the board (a Phenom II X4 945), just for giggles because they're $30 on eBay now, but promptly swapped back to the 4850e because 125 watts in a CPU is unconscionable when 45 does the job just fine.

The latter, of course, is chock-full of cables like they're goin' out of style. I made a few long floppy and PATA ribbons for working with external disks so they sit crammed up in the bottom when not in use, etc. And the non-modular PSU has like a dozen cables all splattered everywhere. It's the opposite of vanity, and I love it.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Flockster on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:42PM (#34766114)
Are there substantial patents running out in this year or why the huge expected priceloss?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by chx on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:30PM (#34766566)
US7164692B2 and US6944163B2 at least. There might be even more. The former expires 2023-07-18 the latter on 2023-08-08.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by FpUser on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:45PM (#34766742)
Lovely. Might actually switch to 10Gb network after prices fall.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Tuna-Fish on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:55PM (#34766240)
Yes.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by bauruine on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:41PM (#34767344)
You can get dual port 10 Gbit cards from ebay for less than 20$ right now.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Tuna-Fish on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:21PM (#34767743)
The only ones I see are sfp+ cards, those also require transceivers (at ~$50 per) to work. The cheapest 10gbase-t cards I can see are refurbished PCIe 16x cards with active cooling for ~$40, you probably don't want those either. Really, as a consumer you want either a PCIe x4 or ideally a PCIe 4.0x1 card, with a modern much more power-efficient chip.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by bauruine on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:56PM (#34768038)
SFP+ uses less power, has less latency and DAC / Twinax cables cost less then 30$ for 6 meters. The only downside is that DAC is limited to 6 meters I think.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by allenrb on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:04PM (#34768112)
I run sfp+ 10 gig at home. You can get SR transceivers for maybe $6ea last I made a purchase. Appropriate LC fiber patch cords are similarly dirt cheap.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by greggyb on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @08:59PM (#34799086)
If you are already buying a used NIC, why would you not buy a used transceiver as well? I see SFP+ transceivers for $6-$15 with a quick search.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by chasd00 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:41PM (#34767345)
Posted the basic question in another post but I’ll ask here too. What are you using to saturate a 10gbe nic? Inet??? I find a true 10gbe inet connection unusual but I’ve been out of that game for a while.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by 14u2c on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:53PM (#34768018)
What's happening in August?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by shmerl on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:10PM (#34765783)
> Add to all of that, this latest batch of CPUs are just stupid power hungry - like 240w+ under load

Eco mode is a thing for AMD CPUs. There is no point really in not using it by default - benefits are very marginal with power cost being disproportionally huge. And AMD are doing it more for marketing reasons to gain some single digit percentages in benchmarks.

So just enable it and enjoy way more reasonable and efficient power usage with basically almost the same performance.

See some details here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6aKQ-eBFk0

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by dotnet00 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:46PM (#34766150)
Agreed, I don't mind spending extra money on GPUs (I have 2 3090s sitting next to me) because the improvement are still worthwhile for my use case, but the CPU prices have been unjustifiable, especially on the AMD side. Increasing CPU price, absurd motherboard price AND needing to buy new RAM, all for an improvement that isn't really too meaningful unless in very specific tasks, is not really worth it. I instead just got a 5900x for my computer and moved its 3900x into a server, retiring its 1600x (which was also sufficient for its work, although at least the 1600x was noticeably slower for transcoding, the 3900x is proving more than sufficient).
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by bluedino on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:48PM (#34766169)
I don't keep up with PC component prices but I thought crypto crashing flooded the market with cheap cards? (Then again I guess BTC is back into the $20k's)
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by thomastjeffery on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:54PM (#34766227)
You can only food desert for a moment.

BTC hasn't been viable on GPUs for a while, either. It's the Ethereum Proof-of-Stake change that was the most exciting, but it doesn't seem to have had a significant effect, especially with newer (3-4yr old) cards.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by svnt on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:59PM (#34766283)
They are good heaters. Wait til summer.

Or maybe they just sell them to generative AI farms.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by thomastjeffery on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:06PM (#34766945)
It's a generally global market, and it's always summer somewhere.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by incrudible on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:15PM (#34768213)
Summer yes, but winter not so much.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by maerF0x0 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:59PM (#34766285)
If you care about price, the 3060, RX 6700 XT, or Intel Arc A770 16GB are your best bets.

xx80 and xx90s are in the class "If you need to ask the price you cant afford it."

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by docfort on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:12PM (#34766394)
There’s been a lot of ink spilled about the decline of Moore’s Law and how it hasn’t yet exactly fallen for all aspects of computer engineering. I think it’s fallen for customers, though. The economics of exponential speed improvement in traditional CPU design have gone away, and the capability/complexity ratio of software collapsed with the fall of Dennard scaling. No fundamentally new applications have come out (save ML, which is not particularly suited to CPUs or even GPUs), so consumers are happy to keep chugging along with their current setup or move more load to their phones.

Even if the increase in hardware cost stays at parity with inflation, it’s tremendously more expensive than it used to be, when waiting six months could get you more machines for your budget.

Gaming, a previous driver of high-end consumer growth, has split into truly mobile, consoles, and very high end PCs. But complex games take more capital and time to develop, so recouping costs is important (except if the studio is part of a conglomerate like Microsoft that can weather temporary market forces). I’d imagine that places pressure on game developers to aim for maximum compatibility and a scalable core. So too bad for the Mac, great for phones, and great for consoles (especially with monetizing the back catalog). And new PCs will have to fight against good-enough, and lower demand funding new hardware and software.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by jmyeet on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:17PM (#34766437)
> There are no good current gen (or even previous gen) cards available for under $1000

The 4070 Ti is <$1000.

> Want a 10Gb onboard NIC? Be prepared to shell out $1000 just for the motherboard.

Why not just a PCI-e 10GbE NIC on a regular motherboard?

> now that figure is closer to $5K.

I see plenty of prebuilt PCs (eg CyberpowerPC) with 3070 Tis for $2k. 4070 Tis for $2.5k.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by AussieWog93 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:31PM (#34766578)
I wonder how much of this increase is due to social media.

10-15 years ago, people would buy graphics cards to play the latest games on. Epeen was a thing, but limited to just some text in your forum signature.

Now, it seems like half the reason people buy any sort of "status" item is for the clout on Insta. It was eactly the same thing with the PS5 2 years ago - people clamouring for a useless object just to show other people they have it.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Clubber on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:42PM (#34766715)
I believe bitcoin mining contributed a lot to the demand side as well.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by tedivm on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:47PM (#34766763)
10-15 years ago people were posting their rigs, adding liquid cooling, ridiculous lighting, massive overclocking. It was definitely more than a forum signature.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Spooky23 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:34PM (#34766620)
Enterprise drives shipments and the PC industry is fucked because: the surge of Windows 7 migration is over, they’ve become appliances, and everyone bought thousands of laptops in 2020/1.

The only reasons to replace business desktops are swollen batteries and Microsoft. My teams are responsible for 250k devices globally. Failure rates are <3%, and 75% of failures are batteries and power supplies. With the transition away from spinning rust complete, we have more keyboard failures than desktop PC failure. I’m taking the PC refresh savings and buying Macs, iPads and meeting room hardware.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by slowmovintarget on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:54PM (#34766837)
Yep, tech work, and especially remote software work, is all done with laptops and docks.

I'm writing this from my home gaming rig, which is an old, not-cool-enough-for-Win-11 (thank god), desktop. I don't know what I'll be replacing it with when it keels over and dies. Maybe a Mac tower? Maybe a Linux rig. But it'll be my PC, not Microsoft's if I can help it.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by downrightmike on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:41PM (#34767347)
mac mini is probably enough these days
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by paulmd on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:04PM (#34780452)
especially with the M2 Pro refresh... it's practically a studio at that point.

Apple is conspiciously maintaining some differentiation like larger RAM sizes to force some people to the studio but the distinction really is slim at this point. Better cooling I guess? But M2 is not a hot chip. Maybe a few more thunderbolt ports?

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by downrightmike on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @09:35PM (#34799312)
cooling will matter if you're using it for larger workloads and renders.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by layoric on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:44PM (#34767943)
I think is largely correct, I’ve been working remotely for the better part of 10 years. I used laptops for around 6. The portability is great when I was split between multiple jobs.

Changed to a desktop about 3 years ago and wouldn’t go back unless I really needed that portability again. I had forgotten how much faster a well spec’d desktop machine actually is. And upgrading parts I find a lot better than replacing the whole laptop every 2-3 years.

Currently on a Ryzen 5950x, 64gb ram, multiple gen 4 ssds, and a workstation GPU. The only laptops to beat such a setup in most tasks weigh a lot, cost more than double the desktop, and are 2 years newer.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by howaboutnope on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:39PM (#34768790)
And then you can still use SyncThing[0] to share things. Depending on what you're doing of course, and how friendly the applications you use for it are to being used that way.. but if it's all in the browser and email profiles and a bunch of data files, you're golden. Getting used to that "lifestyle" has been the biggest leap in joy of using computers since SSD, for me personally.

[0] And/or FreeFileSync or similar for manual operation: I don't want e.g. browser profile data to be synced while the browser is in use, and running the sync manually is no biggie at all.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by binkHN on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:40PM (#34769198)
So what do you use when you're not WFH?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Baeocystin on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:28PM (#34767187)
Speaking from the smaller scale side of IT, in the past ~6 months or so, I've deployed more BeeLinks ( https://smile.amazon.com/Beelink-Graphics-Desktop-Computers-... ) or even smaller, Atom-powered boxes ( https://www.amazon.com/GMKtec-Nucbox5-Desktop-Computer-Windo... ) than Lenovos or Dells. And my clients are really happy with them, too. These are, of course, still technically PC shipments, but the amount of money involved for the manufacturers is absolutely minimal. And most office workers don't need more.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by mistrial9 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:00PM (#34768084)
agree except for the spinning rust part.. BackBlaze stats and I agree, spinning disks can be reliable.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Spooky23 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @11:00PM (#34769964)
In the datacenter - absolutely. In a PC, different story. Poor thermals, rough handling and dust are brutal to mechanical parts. Solid state stuff will survive even outside of its typical operating temperature range.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by stefan_ on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:18PM (#34769042)
I wonder if anyone has done some large scale testing on just restricting laptop charging to 80% or around that mark. I swear the large PC vendors charge these things to "full 100%" for the extra 30 minutes on some shitty video endurance benchmark and it ends up causing bloating batteries at alarming rates.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by AnthonyMouse on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:02PM (#34769343)
> The only reasons to replace business desktops are swollen batteries and Microsoft.

Windows 11 requires TPM 2.0. Windows 11 is the garbage one everyone is going to skip, but will Windows 12 require the same?

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by briHass on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:37PM (#34769534)
TPM 2.0 is old table stakes, circa 2014-2015. The processor requirement (8th gen Intel) is probably more of a concern, but even that is almost 6 years old at this point. I'd wager most business laptops/desktops are Win 11 ready, though that doesn't mean anyone wants it.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by AnthonyMouse on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:40AM (#34771087)
TPM 2.0 existed in 2015. That doesn't mean every PC purchased then has it.

But the general point is that they keep coming up with things like this.

Compare modern CPUs to ones from ten years ago and they're maybe twice as fast per thread, and have more cores which applications the majority of people use don't support. For most people the ten year old machine is perfectly adequate.

But it doesn't have TPM 2.0 or whatever, and the copy of Windows 7 it came with is no longer supported, so you eventually have to buy a new one (or stop using any supported version of Windows).

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by paulmd on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:06PM (#34780492)
hardware TPM is only required if your CPU doesn't support it as an onboard thing... almost all Ryzens have TPM 2.0 support via fTPM for example.

And the hard requirement for a TPM is only for OEM procurement anyway. You as a company can probably put Win11 on anything you want, just build your image and deploy it same as ever.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by AnthonyMouse on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:43PM (#34781078)
Even if you can technically do it, many people won't know that when making purchasing decisions, or won't want to run hardware that isn't officially supported.

Meanwhile the requirement means third party software can soon start relying on all recent hardware having that feature and you may soon run into trouble if your hardware doesn't have it.

"Nobody got fired for buying IBM" was a thing for a reason. If you spend the same amount you did last year on new PCs, nobody asks questions. If you put the money somewhere else and then after three years Enterprise Vault Thing 4.0 comes out and requires TPM 2.0, the CEO is mad because you need three years worth of budget in one year to replace all the old PCs.

Smarter companies will find better ways to avoid this, but 50% of companies are below average.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by paulmd on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @02:57PM (#34795049)
Updooted yesterday but didn't have time to respond, but yup, fair.

Again though I think the fact that soft-TPM has existed for a long time softens that blow. If you have Intel 8000 series or higher or Ryzen 2000 series or higher (iirc) then you have TPM 2.0. Do you need a standalone TPM for a specific reason? Or maybe calling it "soft" is even a misnomer, it's hardware, it's iTPM vs dTPM I guess.

And sure at an enterprise scale going forward why not, it's ten bucks at scale. But it just seems like a lot of todo about nothing... your legacy machines can be imaged up if you want, everything purchased in the last 5 years has hardware support already, and yeah you can toss a whole second module in going forward if you want. But I don't see a hard barrier here to keep enterprise from moving to Win11.

Especially given how much hardware was purchased during COVID WFH... all of that stuff already has support, it's really only stuff that is 2+ years pre-covid that is even an issue.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by scotty79 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:05PM (#34769355)
> I’m taking the PC refresh savings and buying Macs, iPads and meeting room hardware.

What's the failure rate of Macs?

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Spooky23 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @10:43PM (#34769879)
We measure them differently because of lower volume and a self service model - they are more like phones to us. Anecdotally, M1s so far are like iPads.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by AtlasBarfed on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:26AM (#34770453)
If desktop OSes stopped being garbage maybe they'd attract users back. Win still has the ti lol r crap, Linux is suffering under snaps and usual deck chair reshuffling and osx is apple imprisoned, and neglected regardless.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by chx on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:39PM (#34766680)
I am sorry but the "rule of thumb" website, https://www.logicalincrements.com/ disagrees with you, heavily so. You can still buy an awful lot of computer for $2k, it's right there how. The prices are real, they link -- yes, with affiliate links -- to real sales on Amazon/Newegg/etc. To quote what you can expect from their "outstanding" tier at 1628 USD:

> This expensive tier has the highest possible cards that still maintain a reasonable performance/price. Sure it is pricey, but it is luxurious!

> Expect high performance at 1440p, and solid performance at 4K even in the most demanding games.

For 1865 USD:

> Max most titles at 1440p@144Hz, and solid framerates in 4K, even with max settings.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by bialpio on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:08PM (#34766971)
> For 1865 USD:

You can also save up on the case (cheaper options should be available), and grab a Ryzen 7900 which should have similar perf & comparable price point to Intels they used, and comes with stock cooler, shaving off additional ~$100. I'd also probably skip the HDD and grab 32GB RAM.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by lastLinkedList on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:46PM (#34767396)
That's what I'm thinking of doing when I build PCs for my partner and I later this year. I've been looking at benchmarks and I'm not as worried about the top end of performance as much as I am Intel being about ready to release a new socket design next refresh.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by waboremo on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:51PM (#34767438)
This is misleading. For nearly $2000, you better be getting 4K with ray tracing (max settings), AKA, a top of the line device. 1440p/144 is midrange now.

Which that $1865 one does not provide. Even before ray tracing, most games struggle to hit the 144 rate you're aiming for, so with ray tracing that drops down to like ~40 (Cyberpunk 2077 for example in that 6900XT card). You have to enable workarounds like DLSS/FSR to make those games playable.

The only way you're getting good framerate at 4k is without ray tracing, but you're paying $2000 to have to worry about still disabling settings? Ridiculous!

So yes, they are overpriced. For $2000 you should not be worried about having to enable FSR.

The usual excuse when this is brought up is "well just don't play those games, they seem unoptimized" to which again, the question is, why are you spending two thousand dollars to avoid playing certain games? How absurd.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by mosquitobiten on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:28PM (#34767817)
Well the website is called logical increments, it's really hard to call ray tracing a logical increment. You are sacrificing too much to gain so little, at least for now.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by breckenedge on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:42PM (#34767922)
This is how I see it now too. The manufacturers are capitalizing on people needing to have the best by making even more expensive top tier components. You don’t need 4K or ray tracing to enjoy a triple-A game. Last year, I got a 3070-equipped system, force feedback driving wheel, and a 4k TV as a monitor for under $2k. The games are still quite gorgeous, and I have no idea what I’m missing by not having something more expensive.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by arvinsim on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:06PM (#34769358)
The best way to save money is not to target 4k
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by waboremo on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:05PM (#34768955)
Ray tracing IS the logical increment the industry has decided on though. So again, you're spending $2000 to miss out on what the industry has decided on is the next logical step, only to have to spend another ~$500 for whatever upgrade to actually play those games.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by hotstickyballs on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:08PM (#34769375)
Afaik the industry is only the supply side of the equation. If the market doesn’t think ray tracing isn’t worth it then it won’t happen.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by otikik on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:43AM (#34771103)
Not worth it
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by mosquitobiten on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:17AM (#34771582)
>Ray tracing IS the logical increment the industry has decided on though.

I disagree. Nvidia decided it didn't had enough exclusivity, if the industry decided it was a logical increment then it would've had to come as a request from video games and video games engine developers towards hardware companies. It would've been a more natural progression, we wouldn't have it now and also it wouldn't feel like it's in a perpetual beta phase.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by operatingthetan on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:57PM (#34768054)
>This is misleading. For nearly $2000, you better be getting 4K with ray tracing (max settings), AKA, a top of the line device. 1440p/144 is midrange now.

You're both just setting an arbitrary baseline of performance at $2k. Arbitrary comparisons cannot be misleading.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Sebguer on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:09PM (#34768170)
Yes, I don't know where this person is getting the idea that you shouldn't have to worry about settings at $2k? Fifteen years ago you could spend $10k and still have to worry about settings!
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by waboremo on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:03PM (#34768948)
That's not even remotely true. Actually quite absurd.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by johnwalkr on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:48PM (#34769240)
It was famously true for Crysis but not generally true.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Sebguer on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @07:56PM (#34798567)
Yeah, this was the point. I was intentionally hyperbolic.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by mistrial9 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:59PM (#34768068)
4k displays are like giant televisions right? do coders really buy 4k displays ..
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by BHSPitMonkey on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:22PM (#34768269)
I've been "coding" on dual 27" 4K@60 displays for years. Can't go back to lo-dpi displays after getting used to having truly legible/beautiful text rendering.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by 7speter on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:30PM (#34769506)
This is why when presented the chance to buy a 4k60 monitor or a 2k144 monitor this christmas, I decided to get the high refresh 1440p monitor…
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by operatingthetan on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:04PM (#34768118)
There are lots of 30-32" 4k displays out there.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Sebguer on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:10PM (#34768175)
A common resolution for modern 27" monitors is 4k, even. For several years now.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by lkramer on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:22PM (#34768671)
I use a 4k 28inch as my primary monitor for code at home (laptop screen has email and slack). I run i3wm and typically code with 4 terminals windows next splitting the monitor into 4 equal sub windows, each having 1080p and running vim. It's very nice and whenever I have to visit the office and is stuck with their 1080p monitors I find my self severely limited because I'm so used to my home setup.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by wkat4242 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:06PM (#34768960)
I use a 24" 4K at 200% scaling for the razor-sharp text. It helps a lot for text heavy stuff like coding.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by arvinsim on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @12:59PM (#34793224)
I would love that specs but they are rare
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Dylan16807 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:40PM (#34769193)
Inches don't matter. Pixels per degree matter. And my desktop screen takes up a wider angle than a TV would.

Even just being close in angle would suggest 4k is good.

Text on monitors has traditionally never been able to have crisp curves. High pixel densities help a lot with that.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by gpm on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:48PM (#34769242)
I love my pair of 32" 4k monitors for coding. Screen real-estate let's me have everything I want open, open. I don't have to go digging for windows. I don't have to worry about arranging windows carefully. I get to see a lot of code, and a lot of terminal history.

Gaming and TV on the other hand, I'm perfectly happy with a smaller 1080p monitor. There just isn't much to be gained by a few more pixels.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by arvinsim on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:09PM (#34769381)
I use one and pixel double the display to 1080p.

Mac displays have spoiled me...

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by tbihl on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:11PM (#34768603)
Sounds like you would like to use a console for gaming.

When I built my last desktop, in 2015, you would've blown way more than 2k just on the over-the-top monitor that you're mad can't be cheaply populated with high-speed, high-complexity output in 2023. Now you can get a decent quality 4k monitor plus a desktop that will drive it for years of normal tasks, all for less than 1k.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by crote on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:35PM (#34768749)
2015 is eight years ago. In PC terms, that's forever.

I got my 4k 60Hz monitor in 2017 for $400 or so. You can get them for $250 these days, so I agree that is pretty mid-range by now - or even the lower part of it. That leaves $750 for the computer.

According to the logicalincrements linked above, that gets you a RX 6600 - which they rate for 40 FPS @ 4k in The Witcher 3 - a game which came it out 2015.

So no, you cannot get a decent 4k monitor and a PC able to drive it for less than 1k. That's the entire problem: there is no midrange anymore.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by thfuran on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:44PM (#34768822)
>2015 is eight years ago. In PC terms, that's forever.

In the '90s, eight years was forever, but less so now.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by brnaftr361 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:57PM (#34768899)
Steam Survey says you're wrong. Unless something changed recently most people are 1080p and with midranges (GTX*60 & *70). I was running a 970 and 1080p until 2021. I play mainstream stuff, FotM, and competitive.

The way the market is structured just doesn't offer a whole lot of reward. Forknife, LoL, CSGO, CoD, etc... Are all built to accommodate toasters. The big titles are are built for consoles and poorly optimized, there isn't a whole lot to be had aside from higher framrates - and many times these are locked.

I upgraded for compute power.

As for resolution I'm not convinced it's worth the upgrade. Maybe in a few years.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by red-iron-pine on Monday February 13, 2023 @09:05AM (#34773489)
Is that most people in the US, or most people?

But am generally in agreement, I did a big upgrade a while ago and while it's great for a few things, the extra hardware and resolution don't mean much while playing Stellaris.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by SECProto on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:50PM (#34769255)
8 years is no longer forever in PC terms. It used to be you could only go a couple years before your computer could no longer run anything but that's no longer the case.

For an example, I usually build a PC once the older one is horribly outdated. So that was 1999, 2002, 2006, 2011, and ... Well that one has turned into the PC of Theseus. I upgraded to an SSD and $300 video card in 2018, and in 2022 I bought a new cpu/mobo/ram. Still plays games at 1440p at acceptable frame rates.

If I wanted to game at 4k 240Hz, yeah I'd probably have to spend $3500 (and it still wouldn't run that great) which just tells me that 4k gaming isn't ready for prime time

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by landemva on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:18AM (#34770987)
> in 2022 I bought a new cpu/mobo/ram

That's basically a new computer in your previous case.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by SECProto on Monday February 13, 2023 @08:35AM (#34773161)
Generally I agree. However, I saw negligible performance improvement from getting a ten year newer mobo/cpu/ram, so the previous trend didn't apply. I only upgraded because thrre were some system stability issues (probably ram caused, but buying new ddr3 ram in an attempt to fix it seemed a waste). From a performance point of view, the new GPU and SSD in 2018 were the new computer experience.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by 7speter on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:24PM (#34769476)
1440p should be midrange but the gpu makers refuse to make that a reality. How is it that decent framerate 1080p was entry level SEVEN years ago, and cards that double the speed of the rx480 are still going for 300-500 dollars?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by jjav on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:23AM (#34770439)
> 2015 is eight years ago. In PC terms, that's forever.

I think the point is that this isn't true anymore.

In the 80s or 90s eight years was huge in terms of computer hardware advances. In the last eight years though? Meh. Aside from one of my laptops, all of my computers are older than 2015 and they are all perfectly fine for current use. Hardware doesn't advance very quickly anymore, which is great, but bad for sales.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by waboremo on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:16PM (#34769021)
Consoles are great devices, sure.

If you spent over 2k on an over the top monitor in 2015, then you were being silly because even top of the line GPUs weren't hitting 1440 at a stable rate.

We're not talking about normal tasks, if you want normal tasks even a chromebook would be fine. We're talking about intensive tasks, like gaming, which push boundaries and justify the high cost... except for components like GPUs which are dramatically overpriced still. These components make it misleading when people then claim that you can get a top of the line system for under $2k - which is not possible (a top of the line GPU costs more than $2k alone).

You can make tradeoffs, but when paying that much who wants to deal with tradeoffs?

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ryanisnan on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:26PM (#34768297)
Beware of any site that makes bold claims like “Max most titles” - this type of comment ages like milk.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by chx on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:08PM (#34768586)
Last updated 08 February 2023
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ryanisnan on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:06PM (#34779546)
I mean that as the landscape of titles available changes, and what the author takes into consideration, the quality of the statement decreases.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by chx on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @11:25AM (#34791692)
The site is quick to adapt, it's what I am saying. The site has been around for a very long time.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ryanisnan on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:17PM (#34812380)
Interesting. I'll take a closer look, thank you for sharing!
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by adrian_b on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:41PM (#34766705)
The current prices are indeed high, but if I would upgrade right now my desktop with the best components that I can find, that would cost only $1500.

The $1500 would pay for an AMD 7950X, an ASUS MB with ECC support and a decent configuration of the expansion slots, a Noctua cooler suitable for 7950X (e.g. NH-U12A) and 64 GB of ECC DDR5-4800 memory (which costs $50 more than the non-ECC variant).

For the rest, I would continue to use the case, the SSDs, the 10 Gb/s NIC and the GPU that I am currently using.

If I would want to also upgrade the GPU, I would buy a RTX 4070 Ti, for 3 reasons. It provides enough extra performance to make an upgrade worthwhile, it has the best performance per $ among all recent GPUs (at MSRP, a 7900 XTX would have better performance per $, but it can be found only at much higher prices), and lastly, 4070 Ti is the only recent GPU for which the vendor specifies the idle power consumption and the power consumption during light use (e.g. video decoding) and the specified values are small enough to be acceptable in a desktop that is not intended for gaming.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by sylens on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:44PM (#34766737)
Not only are the prices out of whack, but the newest games coming out all seem to have some sort of technical issue on the PC. Shader stutter is nearly a universal thing in most new releases, or the developer doesn't optimize for the platform at all (Callisto Protocol and to a lesser extent, Hogwarts Legacy). So not only are you paying more money than ever, you're experiencing certain issues that just aren't there on consoles.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by slowmovintarget on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:48PM (#34766767)
I recall Jonathan Blow talking about how it's basically impossible to eliminate stutter on Windows now due to a number of design decisions in the OS driver system itself.

I'm wondering if this is the moment for Linux gaming. Valve has certainly taken it a long ways from where it was.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by incrudible on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:11PM (#34768184)
Linux has the same issue in principle, the problem is that shaders must be compiled anew for each driver version, at runtime. It is impractical for the developer, but a distributor like Steam can actually track and redistribute caches for most combinations of drivers and GPUs in active use. Also, warming up the cache (not just precompiling) is possible.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Aardwolf on Sunday February 12, 2023 @07:04PM (#34768566)
Steam is always compiling shaders before starting a game.

What is this needed for actually, can't these come precompiled with the game, just like the game's executable?

There are 3 brands of GPU so max 3 precompiled versions needed? Is that naive to assume this? CPU's need only one version mostly between AMD and Intel (or at most a few for different SIMD instructions)

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by ThatPlayer on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:18PM (#34769436)
Unlike low level SIMD instructions, GPUs work on higher level APIs: Vulkan, DirectX, OpenGL. How that gets interpreted by the GPU changes with driver updates. That's how Intel Arc GPU performance started off in a somewhat bad state yet are steadily improving. Changes in interpretation also mean changes in shaders, so you can't just take shaders on one version of a driver and use it on another.

Internal pipelines can vary between GPU architecture too. Currently AMD ships a different branch of their own Windows drivers for the new RDNA3 architecture GPUs (RX 7000 series). So precompiled shaders probably work won't between architectures.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Aardwolf on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:18AM (#34771930)
But why do they change this per driver update? That sounds horrible to do!

CPU's are not changing their instructions based on driver updates either.

IMHO, time for CPU's to offer thousands-of-floats-wide SIMD instruction sets instead of the measily 512 bits, that can do the same as GPU's but are way more stable, and get rid of those annoying, version-of-driver-dependent, install-100-python-libraries-to-use-them GPU's.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by incrudible on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:41PM (#34778082)
Performance. Vendors will literally go in and hack the shaders for major titles. Also, drivers have bugs.

GPUs will never be outperformed by a CPU with wider SIMD. Intel learned that the hard way with Larrabee. They are on a different place on the pareto front.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Aardwolf on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:45PM (#34778153)
Performance at the cost of stutter. So not really performance...

When did compiling of shaders become a thing? Nvidia GeForce had shaders in the year 2001 but I don't remember ever seeing this then. The first time I saw compiling of shaders happen was in 2017 in a console emulator I think.

So how did it work before then, and what exactly has this compiling now improved compared to before?

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by incrudible on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @05:38AM (#34802116)
It only stutters the first time the shader is used, but modern games use a lot of shaders and they are more complex. In modern APIs it is not just shaders but a combination of shaders and state.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by incrudible on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:34PM (#34777978)
They can be precompiled, but not to the point where there is no stutter, because some optimizations only happen at the point where the shader is executed. That is why you need a warmup. You need to actually execute the shader. Theoretically with Vk/D3D12 you can cache and ship the entire state, but again, it is a combinatorial explosion of drivers and devices.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by formerly_proven on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:41PM (#34768421)
Linux has noticeably worse framepacing than Windows ime
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by sylens on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:42PM (#34768429)
I think it’s not the moment for Linux gaming in general, but more so the moment for certain devices like the Steam Deck. Fixed hardware platform is what you need to precompile shaders and eliminate stutter. I would love for Valve to put out a box that sits under your TV with an APU on par with the PS5
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by themulticaster on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:45PM (#34769584)
Mesa (the Linux OpenGL driver) supports caching shaders on any GPU. And Vulkan essentially has shader caching built in at the specification level. I know that Steam ships precompiled Vulkan shaders, and while there's no equivalent for Mesa's shader cache yet, it shouldn't be a huge issue since it would only cause a short delay the first time the shader is loaded.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Aardwolf on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:58PM (#34768525)
Playing Cyberpunk 2077 in Linux on Steam Proton currently. I've not seen any stutter whatsoever. I frame limit it to 60fps and it never dips below that, with most settings on the highest (though ray tracing is grayed out in settings despite supported Nvidia card so that's disabled).
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by scarface74 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:48PM (#34766778)
I doubt the decline of PC shipments is because of a statistically few people building gaming PCs
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by nickstinemates on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:32PM (#34767224)
> Want a 10Gb onboard NIC?

Just buy an Intel PCI-E 10g card. They're like $100. Slots on motherboards are meant to be used.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by Aardwolf on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:54PM (#34768498)
There are hardly any slots on motherboards too now these days. One network card may fit next to the GPU. All kinds of limitations to nvme SSD speeds and GPU bus width may start applying just for doing that.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by paulmd on Monday February 13, 2023 @05:37PM (#34781901)
Exactly, as long as GPUs keep swelling larger and larger, pcie cards just aren't going to be practical.

It's crazy that X670E literally has multiple chipsets daisychained together ostensibly to increase expansion capability and yet there's less and less expansion available to end-users. And what there is, is almost entirely blocked by the GPU these days.

The only real viable solution I see is thunderbolt, move as much as possible out of the case and break that expansion out as external ports. And tbh the PCIe add-in-card form factor needs to die, the GPU needs to become a standardized module that is connected separately (via riser if desired) and it probably needs a 48V rail. The GPU being 3-4x the TDP of the CPU but completely dimensionally unstandardized is not sustainable.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by nickstinemates on Monday February 13, 2023 @07:15PM (#34783075)
There are so many motherboards that fit exactly what your ideal state describes. They just start to get expensive.

As an example, I'm currently running 2 3090ti's on a MSI board in addition to 2 10GB PCI-Express cards, + 3x m.2 SSD's and I am not even close to fully utilizing the lanes OR other premium slots (like SATA)

If room is an issue, get a larger case or there are also offset/vertical mount options for things like GPU's.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by paulmd on Monday February 13, 2023 @08:05PM (#34783676)
Here's a list of all X670/X670E boards with 4 or more PCIe x16 slots.

https://pcpartpicker.com/products/motherboard/#h=4,8&s=41&c=...

The only boards in that category are actually B650E boards, and there's only 4.

https://pcpartpicker.com/products/motherboard/#h=4,8&s=41

Looks like the current max for any AM5 or LGA1700 board is 5 pcie x16 slots. And of course they won't all be full ones, they'll be some x4-in-x16 (which still is better than nothing, because slot width does affect electrical delivery capability of the slot). And using M.2 slots often eats up some of the pcie slots as well.

Looking at one example - Gigabyte B660 DS3H - you get 1 pcie 4.0x16 and the rest are PCIe 3.0x1-in-x16.

https://pcpartpicker.com/products/motherboard/#h=5,8&s=41,40

The promise of having these super-powerful chipsets has supposedly been that we can put more stuff on it. Same thing for pcie 5 - stuff doesn't really need it yet but you could put a bunch of slower stuff on switches and get a lot of the capability of HEDT out of a consumer board. That has not materialized, even a $700 consumer board is still pretty much intended for one gpu and maybe 2 nvme slots.

If you want a bunch of pcie expansion you still have to go to HEDT or server, but AMD killed HEDT and then lost interest and went outside to ride bikes. So now it's only server.

ROMED8-2T is the closest thing that exists to what I want, but, the promise of X670E and daisychained chipsets and superfast pcie is that I shouldn't have to buy an Epyc to get some decent number of real x16 slots, or at least x4-in-x16 or whatever.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by chasd00 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:34PM (#34767255)
Unless you your inet connection can sustain 10gb then what’s the point of a 10gb nic? I have gbit fiber that rarely gets above 6-700mbit. Is a full 10gb inet connection that common?

Even on LAN do you have I/O that can deliver 10gb/sec to the wire?

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by allenrb on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:10PM (#34768180)
It doesn't have to deliver 10gb/sec to be worthwhile. 3 gbps is easy and already more than a 2.5GbE link can handle. And the prices for those switches still exceed what's available used for 10gbps.

I've got an ICX7250-24p at home that cost about $200 from ebay. That's 24 ports of PoE gigabit, plus 8 SFP+ ports for 10gig. Noise and power are quite reasonable, though it doesn't belong on the desk next to you.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by supertrope on Sunday February 12, 2023 @09:31PM (#34769509)
Regular SATA SSDs are bottlenecked by gigabit and 2.5 gigabit. 116MB/sec is not slow per se. Usually only video editors are waiting on file loading bars frequently enough to make an upgrade worthwhile. That and moving around VM images.
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by neogodless on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:39PM (#34767314)
> There are no good current gen (or even previous gen) cards available for under $1000

Wait, what? Yes there are! An AMD Radeon RX 6800 will set you back $480.

What is your criteria for "good" here?

My computer would be, at today's prices, about $1400.

AMD Ryzen 9 5900X 12 core | 32GB DDR4-3600 | 2 x 1TB PCIe gen 4 | Radeon RX 6700 XT 12GB | (Corsair case, PSU and AIO)

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by guidoism on Sunday February 12, 2023 @06:56PM (#34768511)
This is almost exactly my gaming setup. I know people have different expectations but in my house this is the fastest gaming computer and can play the best games (like MSFS2020) perfectly.

My main computer is an M1 MacBook Air which is essentially a perfect computer. It never feels slow. It was a little over thousand bucks. In no world I can imagine could this not be considered an amazing performance value.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by teeray on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:55PM (#34767489)
I would have expected the crypto implosion to have a depressing effect on graphics card prices (certainly in the secondary market). Any theories why they remain elevated? Is it just supply chain stuff that everything is experiencing?
Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by neogodless on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:59PM (#34767530)
In comparison, they are much less expensive. (Though people who refuse to switch brands might have a harder time.)

For example, The Radeon 6700 XT 12GB was commonly $900+ during the crypto boom, but is regularly around $350 now. That's a pretty big drop.

"Current generation" - only very expensive high end models have been announced (and some aren't selling as low as MSRP yet.)

RTX 4070 Ti $800 | RX 7900 XT $900 | RX 7900 XTX $1000 | RTX 4080 $1200 | RTX 4090 $1600

You have to stick to last generation for excellent performance with less insane pricing.

Re:PC CPU Shipments See Steepest Decline in 30 Years by bennysonething on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:58AM (#34771815)
I remember buying a voodoo 3 for 130 GBP. That was pretty high end at the time. Who's the target market for 1k+ cards?!

At one point you could get a decent gaming pc for about 500 or 600 GBP. I doubt that's possible now. And madness compared to the hardware in a Xbox series X. Yes I know it's hardware is subsidized.