Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by bombcar on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:22AM
(#50483907)
I took a Vornado TRANSOM, a Broadlink RM4, and a Shelly Smart Plug, a Qingping Air Quality Monitor Gen 2 + claude and HASS, and now I have a fan that turns itself on when the CO2 level gets too high.
And I can override or change it from Apple Home.
The smart plug lets it verify that the fan is actually running, (because it measures usage) and we worked out that after a power cycle the Vornado goes back to a known state, and we can find the speed by forcing it all the way to 4 and then stepping back.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by reasonabl_human on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:20AM
(#50485748)
Nice! I have a similar setup. You might like the custom visualization or temperature and humidity offsets I’ve made for that air monitor. Its screen and battery cause excess heat to throw off readings and the calibration is rough from the factory, I used a cheap bluetooth govee thermo-hygrometer as reference to build a better cal curve.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by deadbabe on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:30AM
(#50484045)
I love how it has become a trend now to take some device that required a cloud subscription, reverse engineer it, then connect it to your own server you control.
Suddenly there are so many products to play with that would have previously been undesirable! This is one of the good things AI has enabled.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by jerf on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:42AM
(#50484219)
Enjoy it while you can. You can see the AI companies have already started the process of locking us out of this, with Opus 5.5.
God forbid our fans, our fans of all things, might be broken of their dependencies on the internet. The plebians can't be allowed to do that. Every relay must be cloud-connected so it can be monetized and disabled for whatever dumb ass reasons someone might want to disable it.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by Zopieux on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:44AM
(#50484259)
Just use abliterated/uncensored self-hosted models. This is why we need them and the hardware to run them. Yes, the API models which will further close the walled gardens will evolve faster than the open-weights ones, but I'm hopeful about the community as a hole rejecting this status quo.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by ed312 on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:42AM
(#50485153)
An RTX4090 or a 128gb macbook can generate a pretty reasonable number of tok/sec. Those are not cheap, but within the realm of serious hobbyist. I really hope the AI bubble deflates a bit so consumers can get more powerful hardware at the low thousand $ range.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by mschild on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:16AM
(#50485680)
> So this only works on products that was developed before ~now.
You're under the assumption that the companies producing these give a shit about security. It'll probably increase a bit but I doubt it will be by much. If they have shipped devices that leave the doors wide open for almost any intrusion, they won't invest engineering/AI time and money to make these better than before and certainly won't review the code that the model spit out beyond a quick check if the promised base functionality still works.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by mschild on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:12AM
(#50485633)
OpenAI and Anthropic models seem to be the most affected by these barriers, from my own experience.
Mistral, QWEN, and other models (read non-American) tend to have little to no restrictions. There were some tasks where I was actively trying to sabotage my own local network and Mistral had no issue helping. Anthropic and OpenAI refused outright or had to be "convinced" but would often hit further barricades along the way.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by drnick1 on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:57AM
(#50486296)
> I hear this a lot but I've never hit this.
Opus 5.5 will absolutely refuse to touch anti-cheat systems in video games, even when the end game isn't to cheat but to work on Linux compatibility or to bypass/spoof the checks to enable gameplay.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by orangecat on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:53PM
(#50487159)
The other problem is that the manufacturers can also use AI to improve their DRM and do red-teaming to fix "vulnerabilities" before release. Right now they're not because it actually takes some effort but eventually they'll be able to just tell their agents "make sure no unauthorized clients can connect". I expect that several years from now there will be a sizeable market for pre-2027 hackable devices.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by skrtskrt on Friday November 13, 2026 @02:33PM
(#50488577)
Coway sells tons of devices with no smart/connected features. Their best-reviewed ones for home air purification are not connected. Everyone will be better served by supporting such product lines or pressuring companies to create them more than they will be by reverse engineering "connected" features no one ever needed.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by ACCount39 on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:30AM
(#50484973)
Unironically a gift. On your own home network, the one most likely to MITM you is yourself. And eMudhra's fuckup allows for a nice attack on a few devices you'd otherwise have to disassemble to pwn.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by nijave on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:28PM
(#50490009)
Yeah, I have a couple cheap Tuya devices you can't necessarily re-assemble easily once disassembled (IoT light bulbs, outlets that are plastic welded/glued). Pretty sure they use mqtt over tls
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by noja on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:39AM
(#50484176)
I have a light with a controller on the cord: brightness up/down, power. I can't use a smart plug with it because it always defaults to off. Any ideas?
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by bluGill on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:47AM
(#50484301)
Cut the controller off and use the smart plug to control brightness. You might need to open it up and replace the power supply.
I'm going to guess that you will spend more money on this than just buying a light that has smart features compatible with your smart home ecosystem. You can't mix two smart systems on one cord - this has never worked. Where to put the smart is a tricky question as there are pros and cons to every answer, but in general the smarts need to be in exactly one place or things won't work.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by micromacrofoot on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:58AM
(#50484500)
Coway are some of the best, and there are many dumb models without internet access at all
If you don't mind the hum of fans, it's hard to beat a Corsi-Rosenthal box... there are kits from cleanairkits.com or cybernightmarket.com to build quiet PC fan based boxes that in my experience work excellent and can use off-the shelf filters and parts
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by microtonal on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:45AM
(#50484272)
I am a simple man. When I see people buy devices with Zigbee, Z-Wave, or other fully local protocols, I nod. When I see people reward vendors that lock in with their money, I shake.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by toomuchtodo on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:02AM
(#50484568)
How do you feel about Matter? Asking as someone all in on Home Assistant, open local protocols, and ready to reverse engineer and spend whatever is needed for digital sovereignty, for both myself and the community.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by amluto on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:08AM
(#50484655)
In my experience, Matter is okay except that it’s built over IP and manufacturers seem to be unable to resist using that juicy IP connection to talk to the Internet.
Thread should not have allowed Internet connectivity by default.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by NotOscarWilde on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:34AM
(#50485031)
(Not the OP, but want to spread awareness, sorry.) The Wikipedia page already lists the greatest disadvantage:
> (..) the ability to commission a finished product into a Matter network in the field mandates certification and membership fees, entailing both one-time, recurring, and per-product costs. This is enforced using a public key infrastructure (PKI) and so-called device attestation certificates.
Matter is designed to necessitate phoning into the internet for certification, which allows all manufacturers to just easily add-in phoning into the internet for telemetry. Furthermore, it does not define exactly which functionality must remain if a device is disconnected from the internet for a long time (assuming the user is trying to avoid sending out telemetry, not even bypassing certification).
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by BHSPitMonkey on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:04PM
(#50486397)
> The Matter devices (a smart bulb or a sensor) have no Internet access required by the spec, and no way to send telemetry to the Internet.
That's a little disingenuous... All Matter-over-WiFi devices inherently have Internet access unless you're blocking it through router policy, and most Matter-over-Thread border routers commercially available today give Thread devices Internet access by default if they want it (to avoid this you need to self-host your own OTBR instance).
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by huijzer on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:15AM
(#50484750)
What I don’t like about Zigbee though is that it is on the Wifi band so every device with wifi antenna can snoop on it. Even assuming the protocol is secure, anyone can infer patterns and devices based on traffic shape. For example, a motion sensor that sends data whenever someone walks by. In the end, nothing beats physical wires in terms of privacy and reliability if I understand correctly.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by amiga386 on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:25AM
(#50485816)
> Even assuming the protocol is secure
The other fun thing about them is because they talk Wi-Fi frequencies, if you break into them they can also be reprogrammed to act like a hotspot, or start commanding _other_ devices.
So if you send a drone up the side of an office building to the executives floor, and can break into one lightbulb wirelessly, you can then make that lightbulb break into all the other lightbulbs, until you reach the secluded inner rooms, and you can make that lightbulb listen for Wi-Fi traffic and can pretend to be a hotspot for the targetted executive's laptop. Like in the movies!
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by SecretDreams on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:24AM
(#50484905)
I am a simple man. I don't buy smart devices, mostly. Offline only is completely acceptable.
The connected home was an idealistic dream that has been made perverse by the Zucks and Elons of the world. It is not accessible for normal people and it might never be - at least, not without the blood sacrifice of your privacy.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by driverdan on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:52AM
(#50485293)
It's not always that simple. I have a bunch of devices in my home that have WiFi IoT: bedroom AC, dehumidifier, refrigerator, and washer/dryer. I bought all of them regardless because they work fine without WiFi and I've never connected them. I'd love it if I could connect them to Home Assistant without data leaving my network. Reverse engineering them is on my list of future projects.
In the meantime they continue to function as "dumb" devices just fine.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by ssl-3 on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:26PM
(#50486702)
I'm not sure that this ability to be firewalled is what keeps Homekit down. Inexpensive Matter devices abound that can also be firewalled from the internet, and never connected to it even once[1].
[1]: Yes, I know. There exists Matter-upgradeable widgets that must be connected to the Internet before becoming usable as Matter devices; send those back. I'm also aware that there's Matter devices that require Internet in order to be useful[2], but every instance I've seen of that is just something that was designed by a moron, imbecile, or idiot; send those back, too. Returns cost these companies money.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by roosterIllusi0n on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:31PM
(#50486766)
You want a router that will not let those wifi devices reach the internet or contact any other device on your network except allowed devices.
For any device that needs to connect to the internet, you want to be able to use dns and ip block lists at the very least.
These changes are on my todo list. Tvs especially need to be quarantined. They scan your network to datamine and try to report your conversations to the tv manufacturer.
The next step is root the tvs and clean off as much junk as possible.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by driverdan on Friday November 13, 2026 @08:24PM
(#50492552)
What I want to do is replace their firmware with one that never tries to leave my network. But that's getting a bit ahead of myself since I haven't looked into them at all yet.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by pluralmonad on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:20AM
(#50485744)
But what if the desire is not to harm some obnoxious company, but instead to reduce their influence in the market? But I agree generally, free any locked down device you happen to find yourself possessing.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by pluralmonad on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:53AM
(#50486226)
I was challenging the assertion that buying and freeing is better than not engaging at all. I think the better comment would have been to indicate there is not likely a general rule. Devils and details and all that.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by reaperducer on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:50AM
(#50486186)
I don't believe that they subsidize hardware anymore.
Years ago, this was true. But today, selling your personal information isn't a loss leader. It's additional profit on top of the profit from the product.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by rationalist on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:29AM
(#50485879)
Subsidizing products does not mean the consumer spends less.
Who pays for those ads/tracking/etc... companies that want to sell stuff to the consumer. Congratulations, subsidization just introduced more middlemen which extract more profit from the consumer.
The simpler things can be, the cheaper things can be.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by margalabargala on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:46AM
(#50486117)
The goal isn't to pay minimal money. If that was the goal, you strap an air filter to a box fan and use an esp32 to turn the power on and off. Or a solid state relay if you want to get fancy with different power levels.
The goal is to do harm to anti-consumer companies. Buying their (subsidized) hardware, and then breaking their lock-in so you and others aren't shown ads or forced to pay useless subscriptions, harms the company.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by drnick1 on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:43AM
(#50486072)
> Counterpoint: many vendors with lock-in use the price of the subscription and ads they show you to subsidize the device itself.
Vendors want to have their cake and eat it. They are no longer happy with a one-time sale, they want a continuous revenue stream. I have absolutely no qualms about buying "subsidized" devices and liberating them. I am not going to pay five times the price of a "smart TV" for a commercial display with worse specs when I can buy the consumer version and not connect it to the Internet or root it.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by dd8601fn on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:00PM
(#50486344)
I want everyone, everywhere, to do this to TV manufacturers. Root them. Destroy their “smart” software.
There is no competition in the space anymore. Not on that. You either get crudded-up devices or a panel that doesn’t have the fundamental AV capabilities required of a living room TV.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by devsda on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:14PM
(#50486548)
> Counterpoint: many vendors with lock-in use the price of the subscription and ads they show you to subsidize the device itself.
What exactly is the subsidy here?
Is it that they plan to meet a bulk of their profit target after the sale, instead of frontloading the profit. The subsidy can be considered a 1000 dollars on a 200 dollar device if their target is 1200 dollars.
It is only really subsidized if the device is actually sold below cost of BOM & essential software needed minus bloat.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by flanz_10 on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:54PM
(#50488040)
They're not giving away the hardware. They're giving away a couple points of margin and making up for that after.
And with Amazon and other online shopping, consumer price sensitivity, and the ability to act on it, pressure is at an all-time high. There's a huge race to the bottom for all sorts of consumer goods.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by natnatenathan on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:13PM
(#50487461)
This isn't quite true. They are nearly always using subscriptions and ads to increase their profit margin. Enabling them to go from a low-margin hardware business into a high margin software service business. Even high-end brands like Wolf/ Sub-zero are low margin compared to a software services company. That is why every company is shifting their portfolio to this subscription/ ad model and not leaving any "unconnected" device models available in their line ups.
I think this is bad for customers. If every vendor does this, and regulators don't set regulations that balance the interests of companies with the interests of customers, than the only option people have are things like this.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by darkwater on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:51PM
(#50487115)
Unfortunately some classes of devices have only those pesky proprietary and closed firmwares. I'm generally with you but nowadays with LLMs it's probably less effort to free up that specific IoT WiFi only device that finding a ZigBee version of it.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by criley2 on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:47AM
(#50485239)
I don't mind the app functionality of my air purifier. I get a push notification when air quality degrades, and I can see data and charts of air quality over time. I can change the settings remotely, which is nice because I have a small child and keep the "lock" function set for the actual controls.
It's easier to setup and maintain schedules, routines, or more complex functionality.
It's certainly not critical functionality, but it's nice. Same with my laundry machine and dryer sending a push notification when the cycle ends. Unnecessary, but nice.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by nonameiguess on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:00PM
(#50486333)
It's one of those things quite interesting to see the difference in response from one consumer to another. I can't stand the washer/dryer notifications and finally turned them off a few weeks ago. Especially when I'm on the road half the time, why should I care my wife did 8 loads of laundry in a day? When I'm home, the chime is enough to hear from the other room anyway and the notification on the phone usually just backlogs and gives me a load of red badges I need to clear at the end and beginning of every day for notifications I didn't even get because the phone wasn't with me and I changed the laundry anyway.
For an air purifier, I feel like I'd probably want to see outcome-level statistics convincing me it actually matters to lifespan, healthspan, quality of life, something, anything at all, to know and adjust minute-by-minute the exact air quality going through a purifier, or for that matter what the purifier is able to detect even reflects the quality of air elsewhere in a house with a whole lot of air volume not going through that purifier very regularly.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by wpm on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:25PM
(#50486690)
> It's easier to setup and maintain schedules, routines, or more complex functionality.
Complex like wanting to hit the "Good night" button in Apple Home and have it turn the purifier to full blast for white noise, the workflow in TFA that wasn't possible with the app experience?
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by toddmorey on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:52AM
(#50485321)
In the larger picture, it's because the tech industry started packaging every imaginable piece of hardware as a loss leader for subscription services. That's a big reason why it's really hard to get a high quality dumb TV.
Hopefully, hopefully this new trend can break the cycle of using software to turn things into subscription services that should never be subscription services. I'm terrified that manufactures will respond with hardware encryption and legal maneuvering, but perhaps by then there will be an even larger and thriving ecosystem of open hardware as the ease of setting it up and integrating it with AI accelerates its adoption.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by feirlane on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:58AM
(#50485431)
Sometimes manufacturers bake in the expected revenue from snooping into the price of the device. That can lead to better hardware at cheaper prices, that then you can liberate and use offline.
I used to have a small counter-top dishwasher that relied on proprietary soap cartridges. The dishwasher itself was fairly good and effective, and after hacking the cartridges to allow them to be refilled the overall price was quite acceptable!
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by qurren on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:35AM
(#50485960)
I really can't understand why the hell these manufacturers don't just provide open source firmware. Nobody is buying a Conway purifier for the software and there are no trade secrets there.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by ryandrake on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:30PM
(#50486747)
You love to see it!
I (with heavy LLM help) recently R.E. a golf cart motor controller which had a USB interface for programming, but only a crappy proprietary windows application, and it was super satisfying to see it hum attached to Linux.
What would be even more satisfying to see would be companies that were chill about this kind of work, instead of sending[1] legal threats[2] to people doing the work that they should be doing in the first place.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by Aurornis on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:46AM
(#50484284)
> The fan downloads its root CA cert over plain HTTP. It was always MitM-able.
The most fascinating part of this wave of LLM reverse engineering is seeing how many weird and poor choices we’re lying in plain sight.
Any number of people could have discovered and exploited this, but it’s tedious work. Most people who can do this are busy with their job and other things. Now LLMs enable people who understand these things to quickly get through the tedious parts, so they can do a lot more of this work in their free time than they could before.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by eddieroger on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:46AM
(#50485207)
Similarly, how easy things are for more people to do. I'm certainly not advocating for pulling in a root CA over HTTP, but before LLMs could make this knowledge trivial, how many people would even think to look at that angle. It's democratizing in an interesting way.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by ryandrake on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:25PM
(#50486688)
Hardware companies by and large don't get software. They just don't understand it. Their world is sourcing parts and assembly and packaging. They look at software like any other line item in the BOM: Like a screw or gasket. You source it from the cheapest supplier, and spoon it onto the product somewhere on the assembly line. These companies simply don't care about their software, and their requirements to their supplier amount to "make something work." The quality bar is literally "customer should not return the product."
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by Aurornis on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:34PM
(#50486834)
> Anyone care to guess why someone would make this choice?
My guess: At some point in the past, a firmware was developed without plans to include firmware update functionality. The team that did this was later burned when the client tried to use a new certificate that the hardcoded, unchangeable system didn't recognize.
Angry meetings occurred, developers were chastised, and someone realized they could avoid that problem by fetching an updated root CA on demand. They did it over HTTP to avoid a chicken and egg problem.
In hardware manufacturing, everything is about crossing items off the list of problems. A problem was raised, someone came up with an idea to solve that problem, and it was implemented. The practice might have spread to other products because it became institutional knowledge about how to avoid a problem that made a customer angry once.
This is from my experience in the consumer hardware industry. If you're not watching the outsourced development closely, they will take the easiest route to solve the problem in front of them and nobody will consider any other consequences.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by sippingabonedry on Friday November 13, 2026 @02:29PM
(#50488526)
Everyone (including the author) is as per usual focused on the wrong thing.
There is nothing wrong with downloading a certificate over HTTP. In fact, that's how PKI is designed and if you look at the AIA field of this very site you will see the certificate chain is meant to be served over HTTP.
What IS wrong is implicitly trusting an untrusted certificate. Whether it came over HTTPS or HTTP is irrelevant. But no one is talking about that.
I'm more puzzled why someone would buy a complicated IoT purifier for a drafty Bay Area house that probably has knob and tube wiring.
My most reliable air purifiers have a dumb, physical on/off switch. I bought them deliberately for that feature.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by teaearlgraycold on Friday November 13, 2026 @03:04PM
(#50488915)
People don’t understand things and act shocked when they learn apt and Steam packages are downloaded over HTTP. You only need encryption for private information. CA public keys are not that. But you do need verifiable signatures.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by sippingabonedry on Friday November 13, 2026 @03:08PM
(#50488957)
I partly blame Google and Mozilla for the HTTP hysteria.
You publicly demonize something long enough and otherwise intelligent people start believing HTTPS is an invisibility cloak or the Good Housekeeping seal of approval for the web.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by notaproton on Friday November 13, 2026 @03:30PM
(#50489208)
It kind of makes sense opsec wise when you are on a network with adversaries though.
1) Others knowing knowing exactly which package you are downloading could give them a very clear way to fingerprint and target services you are running
2) HTTPS could allow you to potentially reduce your risk surface in a case where there is a bug in Steam's signature checker itself and someone sends a crafted payload instead of game files. Server validation would have prevented that. This has actually happened with apt before: CVE-2019-3462.
Odds are small, but I believe in DiD. I could imagine an attacker with nothing better to do could get up to this on say, a Uni's network.
And before you come at me with I should be using a VPN to protect against these scenarios, I do that already. This is about HTTPS being a sane default when possible.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by notaproton on Friday November 13, 2026 @03:58PM
(#50489559)
I'm all for Air Filters using HTTP!
The default for package upgrades on PCs should be (and is on Ubnutu and Fedora) HTTPS as it reduces risk with minimal performance impact for most of the people.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by cyphar on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:49AM
(#50494666)
While that is true in principle, there are loads of examples of update protocols where staunchly using HTTP led to security issues. Since you mentioned APT, CVE-2026-109518 was discovered recently but similarly bad issues were discovered a decade ago with CVE-2014-6273 and CVE-2016-1252 (which caused a lot of people to switch to apt-transport-https). There are probably even more -- being able to modify HTTP response headers being parsed by a privileged process is a much more powerful tool than you might expect.
When building update systems, while you shouldn't root your trust in PKI you should still use HTTPS to make attacks harder because even if your updates are signed there is still a lot of parsing going on before you get to the update payload. (Even better, you should use TUF to avoid reinventing insecure designs.)
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by ozyschmozy on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:13PM
(#50499855)
> I'm more puzzled why someone would buy a complicated loT purifier
That's explained pretty early in the article, author wants to be able turn it up high to double as a noise machine from the same automation that turns off lights and such for nighttime
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by nijave on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:30PM
(#50490060)
3rd party SDK requires TLS and it's not easy to bypass. Development contract doesn't allow long-term support where they can push updates if/when proper CA bundle changes.
Solution: ignore security in 1st party code outside 3rd party library that tries to prevent ignoring security.
As far as I know, most of this cheap crap is basically supply chain management companies that contract a factory to manufacturer and contract a software development/IoT/chip company to write software. Everything is waterfall-style locked in with no ongoing support or funding after the production run is done. The software company doesn't care insomuch as it "works" and working to the SCM company is "powers on and functions", not "is secure".
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by sitzkrieg on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:59PM
(#50490525)
did firmware a long time. had two PIs try to force this on me for an IoT device. i pushed back and we missed a deadline. but it uses aws iot certs correctly in a secure element. the customer knew better and thanked me later, lead to 1099 work
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by tclancy on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:58PM
(#50487236)
It is an interesting thought experiment: what things happen once the inertia cost to seeing how something works collapses to 0 for even a small number of your user base. Smart companies might give in now and open up their app even if only as a read-only repo. Dumb ones won’t even know to consider it. And the huge middle will wind up getting new UX ideas for free.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by tclancy on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:03PM
(#50487309)
As a data point here, the people from Ting electrical monitors should really contact me. I used their app for a few days and then built something way cooler off of it and managed to run down what was causing our high electrical usage (the well pump serving an out of control ice maker). You can’t do this at any fine-grained level, but the well pump’s electrical draw was very recognizable by just having the data logged to SQLite in real time from the Ting api and then telling Claude when the pump went on and off.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by mmmlinux on Friday November 13, 2026 @02:09PM
(#50488282)
I remember when people were like LLMs write insecure code. Well, so does literally everyone apparently. I feel like that group has gotten a lot quieter lately.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by godelski on Friday November 13, 2026 @06:21PM
(#50491575)
> The most fascinating part of this wave of LLM reverse engineering is seeing how many weird and poor choices were lying in plain sight.
I think what's interesting is that for decades one group of devs has been pushing for higher quality and security while other groups have been pushing for "good enough" or "MVP"[0]. Clearly the group that rushed won.
But in some weird way we're coming to the day of reckoning. I'm sure we'll always have missed bugs but with a lot of what we're seeing it more seems like these were avoidable problems. Code issues I can easily imagine at least one person on the team said "this isn't acceptable, we need to correct it" and them getting overruled. I'm sure each and every one of you has seen, if not experienced, this.
It'll be interesting to see if that continues. I suspect companies will still rush but from my experience even the best models happily produce shoddy code. And there's a feedback loop, the model's performance is influenced by the code's quality. So it's easy to degrade and get into a bad feedback loop. But I think people still value speed over quality, even in this world where Microsoft shit the bed
[0] in quotes because the entire conversation is essentially about what is actually good enough and what actually is the minimum viable product.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by _blk on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:21PM
(#50493893)
I don't think it's fair to say that those who didn't push for more security pushed against it or just for good enough. They didn't care enough to push back, sure, they were coerced - maybe, they did wrong - probably. But there is a good enough in security too. If you want near-perfect security, keep if off the web.
Don't get me wrong, I wish all products had minimal care for good practices, but I won't expect it the random Chinese made product.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by godelski on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:35PM
(#50500557)
> people will frequently argue that approaches like the one in the article are "good enough" because they don't understand
The same goes for complexity. I've routinely seen people argue against a simpler system by saying "stop making it complex" simply because they don't understand.
Its true that complex means multiple things. But there's a strong push against elegance.
I'll give an example. In one job we had to deal with a bunch of different file types. We had a function for each, about 500 lines for each one. Mostly copy pasted. Recognizing that, I wrote one 500 line function that allowed us to write a new file type routine (a common occurrence) in 5 lines. So I removed thousands of lines of code, increased code speed by 10x, decreased developer time by 2x, and by boss (who only ever imported the code, never wrote it) overruled because it was "too complicated" since I was using a C++ abstraction he didn't understand (guy barely knew C++. Like didn't know what a template was).
The problem with both of these is that they slowly lower the bar. If the shortcut was "good enough" last time then another shortcut will be "good enough" this time. If X is "too complex" because I struggle to understand it, then Y is too. Which I find extra ironic since our field is quite egotistical and we seem to revel in the fact that we don't understand. But I guess Dijkstra was writing about that half a century ago. Which is plenty of time for things to go to shit
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by skydhash on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:55PM
(#50503230)
Had this kind of problems before in my last assignment. The code was full of antipatterns (imperative paradigm in a reactive architecture), lot of global state and an adhoc messaging system using persistent storage. The was was the misuse of the typechecker with type erasure to silence the compiler and linters were never enabled.
The good part is that I owned the project and never has been forced to lower a bar I raised back up. Bad code is just stress for no good reason.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by johndubchak on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:53PM
(#50494073)
> "Clearly the group that rushed won"
This is has been the case since I started developing software in the 90's. As far as I, and likely many others, are concerned it might as well be a Software Aphorism.
I think it will be very interesting as we continue to reverse engineer such things to find out just how poorly "glued together" the Paper Tigers really are....
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by godelski on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:39PM
(#50500602)
> This is has been the case since I started developing software in the 90's.
Dijkstra even wrote about it decades before that. But the issue is that this has a feedback loop. It doesn't take long for everything to be made of spaghetti and duct tape. Duct tape is a fine tool, but the real danger is a temporary fix that works is never temporary
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by mattlondon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:31AM
(#50495498)
I have experienced that quite a few people who are otherwise decent (if not amazing) engineers just have huge blindspots in their knowledge sometimes.
I am sure I am one of them. Known unknowns, and unknown unknowns etc.
You might be shit hot at low-level kernel programming but know nothing about networking for example. Or amazing distributed system design and architecture but missing fundamentals about POSIX process handling etc. And so on and so on. I've seen this even in BigCos where hiring bar is high and they try to recruit "generalists". Not everyone can know everything.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by godelski on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:23PM
(#50500448)
I think that's a different problem. Nobody is perfect. No code will ever be perfect (even if formalized). But I'm talking about the category of foreseeable issues. Known knowns. Not even known unknowns. This is a problem not even unique to software. There's many things we do that we know will create problems, or are very likely to, but are in the future so we put them off.
Yes, there are trade-offs but that's never how we have those conversations. It's never about weighing the options. We generally have these conversations by dismissing each other's concerns (arguably not a conversation). There's a strong pattern that we dismiss future costs (or future rewards). Why pay $5 now when I could pay $1 is what people hear even if it's "in 10 years you'll make 1000x what you put in" or "in 10 years it'll cost you 1/(10^x) of your net worth". Now matters but we have to remember that so does the future. You can't be penny wise and pound foolish, unless you're a monopoly or extravagantly rich.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by unrented7977 on Monday November 16, 2026 @05:17PM
(#50524195)
Agreed, it's fascinating to see where and how manufacturers drop the ball.
I used Claude to reverse a widget recently. Turns out that the microcontroller is a perfectly secure chip, unreadable keystore, encrypted firmware, the whole shebang. It would have been nearly impossible to dump.
Except they didn't use the secure key store and did OTA decryption on the fly in 'userspace' as it were. The keys were left in RAM where a debugger can read them and suddenly the device is pwned.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by simonsarris on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:07AM
(#50485569)
I have 2 Coway air purifiers, they have no cloud stuff. They work really well.
While this is impressive: Why not just get a not-cloud one in the first place? Why does an air purifier need to be controlled via wi-fi?
I'm against a lot of smart home things because its actually more maintenance, not less, to have to think about an object connecting to wifi, to have to decide whether or not to control it (what are you even doing to it?) And I suppose to have to write your own drivers or app. Why allow it to occupy this much mental space for you?
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by enraged_camel on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:13AM
(#50485643)
>> Why not just get a not-cloud one in the first place? Why does an air purifier need to be controlled via wi-fi?
It is convenient to be able to monitor air quality from your phone, sourced from a device that is designed to improve it. Because then you can see how much of an impact it is actually making, move it to a different location with better airflow, etc.
I have the non-wifi version, and have to use a separate device for it.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by simonsarris on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:16AM
(#50485691)
I just occasionally move them. I know it is working because the pre-filter needs cleaning often enough. Does it really need "monitoring"?
One of the nice things about air purifiers, unlike owning a boat or leaving a stove on, is that its never going to surprise you in a bad way. You don't need to really monitor anything, it will just purify some air. Do you really want to be bringing that under the umbrella of the stuff you monitor? Maybe this is an irreconcilable difference and we cannot see it the other person's way.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by HnUser12 on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:20AM
(#50485736)
It’s just a remote control. Why did the tv started coming with a remote control. It’s convenient.
Setting up almost never takes more than a few seconds for me. I have Apple home, it’s almost always scan a QR code, wait a few seconds for wifi and done.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by dcrazy on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:34PM
(#50486814)
The article explains why: the author’s wife cranks it up for white noise while they sleep, and the author wanted to tie that into their existing “go to sleep” home automation.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by palata on Friday November 13, 2026 @03:23PM
(#50489131)
> I'm against a lot of smart home things
What I like about IoT is the idea of hacking them :-). Of course I don't want connected devices running proprietary firmwares anywhere near my LAN.
Also one thing is that when a company sells an IoT device, maybe they mass produce it and it's cheap. Whereas if you wanted to build it yourself, it would be harder. Getting relatively good and cheap hardware and putting your own software on it is nice!
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by nijave on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:46PM
(#50490311)
Not sure about air purifier, but I have a Midea dehumidifier and it publishes runtime and setpoint info I pull into Home Assistant along with power draw from a smart plug. I can see how often it's running at different times of the year and how much it costs. Ended up saving some money tweaking it from 50 to 55 after seeing runtime and A/B testing both.
Also auto on/off. If you put Home Assistant app on your phone, you can wire up automations that turn things on and off depending on whether or not you're home. Could also have Home Assistant pull in air quality/pollution info for auto on/off. High pollen count today? Keep it running so I sleep well. Low pollen count? Turn it off.
Maintenance is minimal. I set the dehumidifer up 2 years ago and haven't touched it since or had a single issue. Main thing is a) get it working, b) get it isolated from internet, c) never touch or patch it.
Once the data is in Home Assistant, I can also look for correlation with wearable health info. Does purifier running improve sleep? Does changing thermostat set point improve sleep?
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by Cu3PO42 on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:28AM
(#50485856)
I wanted to do the same with Phillips air purifier that uses AWS IoT. Unfortunately, it seems the engineers did their job: an eMudhra-signed certificate was not accepted and the AWS endpoint also uses mTLS, so I wasn't able to MITM the connection.
Their ESP also uses Secure Boot... I don't know that there isn't a way to break in, but I wasn't able to find one short of hardware notification :/
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by Eric_WVGG on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:46AM
(#50486124)
Jeez. I've had a Coway for about eight years, such a good device that my whole perception was “good product == good company”. If I had known their IOT offering was such a POS I would think very differently.
That said, the non-wifi model works perfectly with a simple HomeKit compatible on/off plug, so all this work — despite being very, very cool — seems a little pointless?
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by eande on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:54AM
(#50486238)
It is great to see another cloud mandatory device set free. I noticed lately several such entries in HN and personally it is a good trend.
I am wondering how the big corporate will respond sooner or later. Because it is clear and they know that as well with the every rising capability of LLM more people will find ways to liberate their hardware from such unnecessary dependency and accept less the money drain.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by alnwlsn on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:56AM
(#50486260)
All that to control one of 3 fan speeds. An extra slap in the face when it seems the motor used (at least in a similar model) appears to be continuously variable.
Don't go hepa because it slows down the filtering too much. I use this technique in my house and it cuts down on pollen, smoke and mold. You'll feel a lot better than a tiny expensive hepa that has proprietary filters.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by dcrazy on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:30PM
(#50486756)
I’m not dedicating 1600 cubic inches of my living space to an ugly homemade piece of furniture that I have to rebuild whenever I change a HEPA filter. I suspect I am not alone in this.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by instaclay on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:32PM
(#50486781)
True, but the MacGyver looking thing in the middle (or side,whatever) of your living room doesn't sit right with everyone. People pay money for aesthetics and take the hit on efficiency.
I'm seeing some 3d printed projects popping up that look to be filling this gap though.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by wallst07 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:22AM
(#50494260)
I'm guessing there are a lot of single folks on this site and would wonder the opposite... if you've never been married you think of things WAY different.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by rcoveson on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:55AM
(#50494420)
All you need for aesthetics is to put the whole thing in any nice-looking piece of box-shaped furniture with some kind of breathable, obscuring fabric, grille, or louvre on two sides (or even just one side, if you're okay with an open back).
Find a free-standing cabinet at the thrift store or something. Will look way nicer than any minimalist-modern plastic thing from Temu (or anything 3D printed, not that I have anything against 3D printers in general).
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by snk on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:34PM
(#50487775)
In my bachelor days I put an air filter behind a box fan; women have higher aesthetic standards. mirv 8 works fine for me and I can pick them up grocery shopping, but my primary contaminant is a sheprador.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by vikramkr on Friday November 13, 2026 @02:01PM
(#50488148)
That rules! Looks like you can do it with like 3 filters so it's more triangle shaped which makes sense. That's so stupidly simple too. Also aesthetically pretty cool - would look great in a workshop where it's like function first/don't hide the mechanism. And I feel like there's gotta be clever ways to incorporate something as simple as "box fan but the box is made of air filter" into like a coffee table or stand or something else clever? Probably you'd want to hide the filters inside if they look grimy before you actually need to replace them so you don't feel obligated to waste money by replacing too soon but sounds like a fun time to figure out how to integrate that in a hidden way into whatever's your vibe without looking jank
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by schiffern on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:46AM
(#50494376)
Typical flow rates for HVAC systems are ~1 air change per hour, but to effectively filter the air faster than dirty air leaks in, you need about 5 air changes per hour (AHAM recommendation).
If you're using your HVAC, run the fan continuously, and use the 1" 3M 1900 filter. Other brands or models (including the supposedly 'better' 4" 3M 1900 filters) have fewer pleats, which calculates to smaller surface area and worse airflow resistance. Check BJs website, usually $10/filter in a 4-pack.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by rainbowzootsuit on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:22PM
(#50501582)
One issue beyond the flow rate others have noted is that if the fan doesn't cycle with the evaporator coil when in cooling conditions the wet coil will re-evaporate the water that is on it which will give higher humidity in the space. This is a climate and season dependent issue.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by gojomo on Friday November 13, 2026 @03:08PM
(#50488944)
I was wondering when one of the low-end 20" box fan vendors would add a slot for a 20"x20" filter... and it turns out Lasko finally did, creating an "AirFlex 2-in-1" product that's often knocked for price/noise but resolves the homemade look, for those that care.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by Diederich on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:38PM
(#50490176)
We've been doing the $9 Amazon Basics fan with a good filter since wildfire smoke started really getting bad in the bay area, quite a few years ago now. We had a couple of big, expensive filter tower things, and they helped, but just a couple of the boxfans with filters duct taped on quickly and consistently annihilated PM2.5 and PM10 in our apartments.
Most surprising thing: all but one of those original Amazon fans is still running. They've had years of run time, at quite a bit higher stress than normal.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by sushid on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:50PM
(#50490391)
I never get this take. Yes, you'd make this in a pinch but that thing is hideous to have around the house.
It's like telling someone they bought a car and pointing out that golf dimples with increase your mileage. No reasonable adult would have that thing in the middle of their living room!
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by AnthonBerg on Friday November 13, 2026 @05:14PM
(#50490751)
Filtering out the fines and ultrafines – the stuff that HEPA filters capture – makes a biiiiiiig difference in air quality.
A smaller supplementary unit made out of PC fans and N95s can do that. A 120mm Noctua fan's flow and pressure fits well for about three 3M Aura masks in parallel.
It's unhinged how good the air quality is in a room with a device like this.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by paper2d on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:07AM
(#50494164)
This is exactly what I have done, but with 12" fans instead. It works exceptionally well and you are not locked into any ecosystem. For aesthetics, as everyone is crying about it, maybe one can 3D print a case for it.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by deanc on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:29PM
(#50486738)
Has anyone managed to pull this off with the Levoit air purifiers. I've isolated mine on a seperate VLAN at home but it requires internet connection to control.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by Night_Thastus on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:49PM
(#50487081)
For anyone considering getting an air purifier, please do not get a Coway (or similar brands).
The air purifier market is full of garbage because consumers don't understand how these products work or what their tradeoffs are.
The root problem is that these products are designed the wrong way around. They almost all use custom-fit HEPA filters. That sounds great, HEPA is good, right? Except HEPA is really not good for household air filtering. HEPA is so fine that even air struggles to move through it. It's also far more fine than the common contaminants (dust and pollen) need. Because it's so fine, you need a VERY powerful fan to move any air through it, which means the purifier will be very loud.
Finer filters are not better. There are two things you want to optimize for:
1: CADR - clean air delivery rate. This is essentially how much air you can move through the filter per hour, multiplied by how much of the contaminant you can catch each time that air passes through the filter.
2: Volume - It doesn't matter how amazing your air purifier is if it sounds like a tornado. If you only run it for a few minutes before getting annoyed, the purifier is not doing its job. Every moment it is OFF it is not doing its job. Many purifiers try to use sensors to determine when to run the filter, but this fundamentally a flawed approach and just means you have low quality air 99% of the time.
The solution to these problem is a less-fine filter. For dust and pollen, something like MERV13/14 is absolutely fine. It will catch most of those on each pass, and because air moves through it so much easier - you can run the same air through it many times more in the same period of time. This results in an air purifier that is whisper quiet, keeps the air far cleaner, and can use off-the-shelf furnace air filters that are VERY cheap compared to custom-fit HEPAs which may stop being made the moment that purifier product line inevitably ceases to exist. (Note: This is mainly true in the US, said filters are harder to find elsewhere)
Combine MERV13/14 with off-the-shelf PC case fans (which have been optimized for decades to be as quiet and long-lasting as possible) and the result is an easily-maintainable, quiet, highly-effective purifier.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by tclancy on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:01PM
(#50487272)
Any resources you could share here? I bought a Rabbit air filter years ago and it seems like it does fine. But since I did something similar to the OP here and started tracking my Awair air quality monitor in real time, I’ve noticed we have wild VOC levels in our roomy house and I can’t sort out what causes spikes, especially overnight. Some of it is probably due to the insulating and weather stripping mania I went through a while back and I’ve looked into getting an exhaust fan (whatever those things are called) to alleviate it but would like to know the source(s).
It doesn't matter how amazing your air purifier is if it
sounds like a tornado. If you only run it for a few minutes
before getting annoyed, the purifier is not doing its job.
Top speed is about 53dB. The other speeds range from "barely noticeable" to "is this thing on?"
Combine MERV13/14 with off-the-shelf PC case fans (which
have been optimized for decades to be as quiet and long-lasting
as possible) and the result is an easily-maintainable, quiet,
highly-effective purifier.
More nonsense. My oldest Coways's been in service for ~10 years including ~5 years of services running 24/7/365 near my cat's litterbox.
For a given CFM, with all other things being equal, larger fans (like the ones in Coways) are going to be easier than a bunch of smaller fans. Though, if using an array of Noctuas or similar, I'm sure it could be done.
Many purifiers try to use sensors to determine when to
run the filter, but this fundamentally a flawed approach
and just means you have low quality air 99% of the time.
If you put the Coway on "Auto" and fart next to it, it will spin up to a higher speed for a few minutes. That seems like pretty good detection to me. You do get false positives though, sometimes it spins up for apparently no reason, so I usually just leave it on low.
The solution to these problem is a less-fine filter. For dust and
pollen, something like MERV13/14 is absolutely fine.
This is certainly true, though a lot of people buy these to help with pet allergies and want/need HEPA.
off-the-shelf furnace air filters that are VERY cheap compared to
custom-fit HEPAs which may stop being made the moment that purifier
product line inevitably ceases to exist.
Once again, it just shows that you're making this stuff up. Now, it's a good point in general -- nobody should buy a rando air purifier without looking into this aspect. But have you actually taken 30 seconds to look on Amazon and noticed the dozens of third-party filters made to fit the Coways, which have been popular models sold essentially unchanged for 10+ years?
Admittedly, standard furnace air filters do have the edge here of course. Corsi-Rosenthal style boxes are going to give you guaranteed filter availability from now until the collapse of civilization. And if you're filtering air in a large or dirty space, then yes, Corsi-Rosenthal boxes are the winners in CADR-per-dollar. I'm building one for my garage workshop before pollen season....
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by dgacmu on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:26PM
(#50487654)
HEPA is less important in most scenarios than "something that on a few passes will catch everything", which MERV-13 will do. Not all systems can handle the pressure drop of a MERV-13 but many can, and there are some pretty low-drop options out there if you search for them.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by flanz_10 on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:50PM
(#50487984)
merv-8 is a great drop in for most systems, and it makes a huge difference. my system runs the fan for an hour every evening, and that also has been an improvement.
i have to do a major upgrade next month (30 year old gas furnace!) and i will need to do some research, but i would like to even ascend to true HEPA if it's feasible
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by j45 on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:57PM
(#50488083)
Mismatched merv levels between some heating systems (ie., forced air) and what they were designed for can also create strain on the system and premature failures.
Also, in new homes, beware of undersized heating systems that will fail prematurely.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by zbrozek on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:31PM
(#50487732)
Annoyingly, both Ecobee and (at least historically) Nest make controlling the fan independent of the heating and cooling hard. You have to enable either heating or cooling before being allowed to enable the fan. And you can't specify how long you want to run it for, but have to select one of a few options.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by flanz_10 on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:47PM
(#50487945)
i have an ecobee and it was pretty simple to hit fan on even when system is off. this may be a limitation of your hvac system being exposed awkwardly through to ecobee. some systems have a "fan only" wire, which mine does. but my guest house is a much older system, and it is like yours.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by zbrozek on Friday November 13, 2026 @06:28PM
(#50491636)
It's able to run the fan without either a heating or cooling call, so I'm not sure what would prevent it from doing so without making me choose heating or cooling first in the UI.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by nijave on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:41PM
(#50490239)
Could just bypass with esp32 and relay. I think you just need to close a 24v AC switch/relay unless you have a newer/more expensive communicating system (although then I don't think you'd have an Ecobee)
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by hamdingers on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:46PM
(#50487938)
Based on personal experience, HEPA isn't even necessary when you're filtering that much air.
My house downwind of a freeway and a wilderness area, lots of nasty black tire dust mixed with allergens. It did not come with A/C. I had HEPA air purifiers around the house that I would leave in auto mode and they would run for a few hours a day based on the air quality.
Then I got central A/C installed with a standard 1" MERV 13 rated filter on the intake. Just running the blower for 10 minutes every hour is enough to keep the air quality in every room below the level where the air purifiers would kick on. I've given most of them away.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by j45 on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:56PM
(#50488071)
100%. Understanding your air quality is important, since it can vary greatly based on so many factors, some other ones can be location, home type (condo, house), occupant types (seniors, small humans), health conditions (allergies, etc), homes don't always share the same kind of air circulation.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by ashdksnndck on Friday November 13, 2026 @02:20PM
(#50488413)
This is not a good choice for everyone. Before greatly increasing the load on you HVAC blower motor, make sure you first understand where it is, how old it is, and how inconvenienced you would be if it burned out.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by nijave on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:40PM
(#50490213)
At least in summer/cooling mode, I think the fan blows some of the condensed water back in the air off the coil (instead of it dripping down the drain). I think it still dehumidifies, just not as efficiently. Not sure if that's what op meant
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by nijave on Friday November 13, 2026 @04:50PM
(#50490392)
Had Claude build a Home Assistant integration for my Rheem furnace which exposes commanded ECM CFM, actual CFM, fan RPM, static pressure (among other things) via Bluetooth Low Energy.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by tonymet on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:29PM
(#50487692)
We need an Orthodox Union for IOT devices. Basic Kosher would be unlocked bootloader. Advanced Kosher would be open source firmware . One level could be an escrow service for skittish companies, where escrow shares the firmware when the company terminates support.
It works in many other industries like UL for electronics, Intertek, NSF for foods etc.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by tda on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:47PM
(#50487944)
I just liberated my Haier AC units. The WIFI modules it came with but that I never used turned out to be ESP32's, with solder pads for rx/tx etc. I soldered on some wires, plugged into a USB ot UART dongle and Claude had ESPHome running in no time. I now can not only control the AC units, but I have a lot more visibility into wat it is doing: coil temps, gas temp, valve positions: all is available and all is logged now.
I also liberated my air purifier long ago by soldering a wire to the various buttons, so i can trigger a press the physical buttons from an esp32. And I soldered a wire to the PWM of the fan, so I can bypass whatever the onboard logic is doing. Liberating your own electronics is fun, and now with AI easier than ever. I also ditched the WIFI unit of my solar inverter and hooked up the tiniest ESP32 nanoC6 and now I get all the data at 1Hz. Still working on taking over the EcoFlow batteries and their charging/unloading logic.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by radicality on Friday November 13, 2026 @01:55PM
(#50488051)
I’m quite happy with my MedifyAir MA-125. Just mentioning it and the brand since I don’t see it often mentioned. I’ve had mine running for around 4 years continuously at this point. It feels good quality too and marked/sold as commercial, and since it’s quite large with a large fan, it’s quiet.
Re:Reverse Engineering My Coway Air Purifier to Ditch the Cloud
by smusamashah on Friday November 13, 2026 @05:40PM
(#50491108)
This also means that we have a short window where products d hardware can be reclaimed by users. After a while, these makers will also start using LLMs to lock the devices properly.
And I can override or change it from Apple Home.
The smart plug lets it verify that the fan is actually running, (because it measures usage) and we worked out that after a power cycle the Vornado goes back to a known state, and we can find the speed by forcing it all the way to 4 and then stepping back.
Need to try to get Sonoff bridge rigged up next but have been busy messing with Hatch alarm
Suddenly there are so many products to play with that would have previously been undesirable! This is one of the good things AI has enabled.
God forbid our fans, our fans of all things, might be broken of their dependencies on the internet. The plebians can't be allowed to do that. Every relay must be cloud-connected so it can be monetized and disabled for whatever dumb ass reasons someone might want to disable it.
I hear this a lot but I've never hit this.
For weeks now I've been working on a shared recompilation project of Switch 1 and 2 games, and Opus 5.5 has handled that with no issue.
Over 10 supported Switch 1 games, and 3 supported Switch 2 games, and never once has Opus 5.5 denied anything
So this only works on products that was developed before ~now.
The solution is to not buy crap regardless if you can make it work or not.
You're under the assumption that the companies producing these give a shit about security. It'll probably increase a bit but I doubt it will be by much. If they have shipped devices that leave the doors wide open for almost any intrusion, they won't invest engineering/AI time and money to make these better than before and certainly won't review the code that the model spit out beyond a quick check if the promised base functionality still works.
The Home Assistant hackers are some of the most persistent reverse engineers that I have seen. Almost as much as game crackers and cheat developers.
Mistral, QWEN, and other models (read non-American) tend to have little to no restrictions. There were some tasks where I was actively trying to sabotage my own local network and Mistral had no issue helping. Anthropic and OpenAI refused outright or had to be "convinced" but would often hit further barricades along the way.
Opus 5.5 will absolutely refuse to touch anti-cheat systems in video games, even when the end game isn't to cheat but to work on Linux compatibility or to bypass/spoof the checks to enable gameplay.
I'm going to guess that you will spend more money on this than just buying a light that has smart features compatible with your smart home ecosystem. You can't mix two smart systems on one cord - this has never worked. Where to put the smart is a tricky question as there are pros and cons to every answer, but in general the smarts need to be in exactly one place or things won't work.
The relay clicking is a feature so you can tell the brightness audibly :)
I am tired of having dust everywhere.
If you don't mind the hum of fans, it's hard to beat a Corsi-Rosenthal box... there are kits from cleanairkits.com or cybernightmarket.com to build quiet PC fan based boxes that in my experience work excellent and can use off-the shelf filters and parts
Thread should not have allowed Internet connectivity by default.
> (..) the ability to commission a finished product into a Matter network in the field mandates certification and membership fees, entailing both one-time, recurring, and per-product costs. This is enforced using a public key infrastructure (PKI) and so-called device attestation certificates.
Matter is designed to necessitate phoning into the internet for certification, which allows all manufacturers to just easily add-in phoning into the internet for telemetry. Furthermore, it does not define exactly which functionality must remain if a device is disconnected from the internet for a long time (assuming the user is trying to avoid sending out telemetry, not even bypassing certification).
That's a little disingenuous... All Matter-over-WiFi devices inherently have Internet access unless you're blocking it through router policy, and most Matter-over-Thread border routers commercially available today give Thread devices Internet access by default if they want it (to avoid this you need to self-host your own OTBR instance).
The other fun thing about them is because they talk Wi-Fi frequencies, if you break into them they can also be reprogrammed to act like a hotspot, or start commanding _other_ devices.
So if you send a drone up the side of an office building to the executives floor, and can break into one lightbulb wirelessly, you can then make that lightbulb break into all the other lightbulbs, until you reach the secluded inner rooms, and you can make that lightbulb listen for Wi-Fi traffic and can pretend to be a hotspot for the targetted executive's laptop. Like in the movies!
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322969640_IoT_Goes_...
https://sci-hub.reatk.com/10.1109/MSP.2018.1331033
The connected home was an idealistic dream that has been made perverse by the Zucks and Elons of the world. It is not accessible for normal people and it might never be - at least, not without the blood sacrifice of your privacy.
In the meantime they continue to function as "dumb" devices just fine.
Apple's HomeKit allows you to firewall your IoT devices, if you have a Wifi router that supports it.
Since that kind of privacy cuts into the profits of shady IoT companies, they don't support HomeKit.
I'm not interested in trading my privacy for the pithy convenience of moving the dishwasher start button from the machine to my phone.
[1]: Yes, I know. There exists Matter-upgradeable widgets that must be connected to the Internet before becoming usable as Matter devices; send those back. I'm also aware that there's Matter devices that require Internet in order to be useful[2], but every instance I've seen of that is just something that was designed by a moron, imbecile, or idiot; send those back, too. Returns cost these companies money.
[2]: https://www.reddit.com/r/TrySwitchBot/comments/1j8ogt8/matte...
For any device that needs to connect to the internet, you want to be able to use dns and ip block lists at the very least.
These changes are on my todo list. Tvs especially need to be quarantined. They scan your network to datamine and try to report your conversations to the tv manufacturer.
The next step is root the tvs and clean off as much junk as possible.
By buying the device and then breaking the lock-in, one does more harm to the anti-consumer device manufacturer than had they done nothing at all.
I don't see the difference. How would you reduce their influence without harming them?
Only if you can guarantee that the vendor is going to remain in business forever, and provide service and support for the product forever.
Neither of those things happen. Ever.
If the manufacturer subsidizes the hardware purchase, that loss is realized at hardware purchase time.
Years ago, this was true. But today, selling your personal information isn't a loss leader. It's additional profit on top of the profit from the product.
Who pays for those ads/tracking/etc... companies that want to sell stuff to the consumer. Congratulations, subsidization just introduced more middlemen which extract more profit from the consumer.
The simpler things can be, the cheaper things can be.
The goal is to do harm to anti-consumer companies. Buying their (subsidized) hardware, and then breaking their lock-in so you and others aren't shown ads or forced to pay useless subscriptions, harms the company.
Vendors want to have their cake and eat it. They are no longer happy with a one-time sale, they want a continuous revenue stream. I have absolutely no qualms about buying "subsidized" devices and liberating them. I am not going to pay five times the price of a "smart TV" for a commercial display with worse specs when I can buy the consumer version and not connect it to the Internet or root it.
There is no competition in the space anymore. Not on that. You either get crudded-up devices or a panel that doesn’t have the fundamental AV capabilities required of a living room TV.
What exactly is the subsidy here?
Is it that they plan to meet a bulk of their profit target after the sale, instead of frontloading the profit. The subsidy can be considered a 1000 dollars on a 200 dollar device if their target is 1200 dollars.
It is only really subsidized if the device is actually sold below cost of BOM & essential software needed minus bloat.
And with Amazon and other online shopping, consumer price sensitivity, and the ability to act on it, pressure is at an all-time high. There's a huge race to the bottom for all sorts of consumer goods.
I think this is bad for customers. If every vendor does this, and regulators don't set regulations that balance the interests of companies with the interests of customers, than the only option people have are things like this.
It's easier to setup and maintain schedules, routines, or more complex functionality.
It's certainly not critical functionality, but it's nice. Same with my laundry machine and dryer sending a push notification when the cycle ends. Unnecessary, but nice.
For an air purifier, I feel like I'd probably want to see outcome-level statistics convincing me it actually matters to lifespan, healthspan, quality of life, something, anything at all, to know and adjust minute-by-minute the exact air quality going through a purifier, or for that matter what the purifier is able to detect even reflects the quality of air elsewhere in a house with a whole lot of air volume not going through that purifier very regularly.
Complex like wanting to hit the "Good night" button in Apple Home and have it turn the purifier to full blast for white noise, the workflow in TFA that wasn't possible with the app experience?
Hopefully, hopefully this new trend can break the cycle of using software to turn things into subscription services that should never be subscription services. I'm terrified that manufactures will respond with hardware encryption and legal maneuvering, but perhaps by then there will be an even larger and thriving ecosystem of open hardware as the ease of setting it up and integrating it with AI accelerates its adoption.
It's also partially the reason that a high quality smart TV is so cheap nowadays
I used to have a small counter-top dishwasher that relied on proprietary soap cartridges. The dishwasher itself was fairly good and effective, and after hacking the cartridges to allow them to be refilled the overall price was quite acceptable!
My god, this is straight out of a Douglas Adams book.
I (with heavy LLM help) recently R.E. a golf cart motor controller which had a USB interface for programming, but only a crappy proprietary windows application, and it was super satisfying to see it hum attached to Linux.
What would be even more satisfying to see would be companies that were chill about this kind of work, instead of sending[1] legal threats[2] to people doing the work that they should be doing in the first place.
1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50443824
2: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50363968
Basically a git repo with instructions that would maybe pull in rea and set all this up.
The most fascinating part of this wave of LLM reverse engineering is seeing how many weird and poor choices we’re lying in plain sight.
Any number of people could have discovered and exploited this, but it’s tedious work. Most people who can do this are busy with their job and other things. Now LLMs enable people who understand these things to quickly get through the tedious parts, so they can do a lot more of this work in their free time than they could before.
My guess: At some point in the past, a firmware was developed without plans to include firmware update functionality. The team that did this was later burned when the client tried to use a new certificate that the hardcoded, unchangeable system didn't recognize.
Angry meetings occurred, developers were chastised, and someone realized they could avoid that problem by fetching an updated root CA on demand. They did it over HTTP to avoid a chicken and egg problem.
In hardware manufacturing, everything is about crossing items off the list of problems. A problem was raised, someone came up with an idea to solve that problem, and it was implemented. The practice might have spread to other products because it became institutional knowledge about how to avoid a problem that made a customer angry once.
This is from my experience in the consumer hardware industry. If you're not watching the outsourced development closely, they will take the easiest route to solve the problem in front of them and nobody will consider any other consequences.
There is nothing wrong with downloading a certificate over HTTP. In fact, that's how PKI is designed and if you look at the AIA field of this very site you will see the certificate chain is meant to be served over HTTP.
What IS wrong is implicitly trusting an untrusted certificate. Whether it came over HTTPS or HTTP is irrelevant. But no one is talking about that.
I'm more puzzled why someone would buy a complicated IoT purifier for a drafty Bay Area house that probably has knob and tube wiring.
My most reliable air purifiers have a dumb, physical on/off switch. I bought them deliberately for that feature.
You publicly demonize something long enough and otherwise intelligent people start believing HTTPS is an invisibility cloak or the Good Housekeeping seal of approval for the web.
1) Others knowing knowing exactly which package you are downloading could give them a very clear way to fingerprint and target services you are running
2) HTTPS could allow you to potentially reduce your risk surface in a case where there is a bug in Steam's signature checker itself and someone sends a crafted payload instead of game files. Server validation would have prevented that. This has actually happened with apt before: CVE-2019-3462.
Odds are small, but I believe in DiD. I could imagine an attacker with nothing better to do could get up to this on say, a Uni's network.
And before you come at me with I should be using a VPN to protect against these scenarios, I do that already. This is about HTTPS being a sane default when possible.
Or they could connect to the service.
> Server validation would have prevented that
No it wouldn't have. HTTPS does not ensure a server's contents are trustworthy.
> And before you come at me with I should be using a VPN to protect against these scenarios, I do that already
So you protect yourself from unlikely, irrelevant threats by... deliberately paying strangers to MiTM your traffic?
The default for package upgrades on PCs should be (and is on Ubnutu and Fedora) HTTPS as it reduces risk with minimal performance impact for most of the people.
When building update systems, while you shouldn't root your trust in PKI you should still use HTTPS to make attacks harder because even if your updates are signed there is still a lot of parsing going on before you get to the update payload. (Even better, you should use TUF to avoid reinventing insecure designs.)
That's explained pretty early in the article, author wants to be able turn it up high to double as a noise machine from the same automation that turns off lights and such for nighttime
Solution: ignore security in 1st party code outside 3rd party library that tries to prevent ignoring security.
As far as I know, most of this cheap crap is basically supply chain management companies that contract a factory to manufacturer and contract a software development/IoT/chip company to write software. Everything is waterfall-style locked in with no ongoing support or funding after the production run is done. The software company doesn't care insomuch as it "works" and working to the SCM company is "powers on and functions", not "is secure".
But I do see someone has a HA integration, it just hit the cloud.
But in some weird way we're coming to the day of reckoning. I'm sure we'll always have missed bugs but with a lot of what we're seeing it more seems like these were avoidable problems. Code issues I can easily imagine at least one person on the team said "this isn't acceptable, we need to correct it" and them getting overruled. I'm sure each and every one of you has seen, if not experienced, this.
It'll be interesting to see if that continues. I suspect companies will still rush but from my experience even the best models happily produce shoddy code. And there's a feedback loop, the model's performance is influenced by the code's quality. So it's easy to degrade and get into a bad feedback loop. But I think people still value speed over quality, even in this world where Microsoft shit the bed
[0] in quotes because the entire conversation is essentially about what is actually good enough and what actually is the minimum viable product.
Its true that complex means multiple things. But there's a strong push against elegance.
I'll give an example. In one job we had to deal with a bunch of different file types. We had a function for each, about 500 lines for each one. Mostly copy pasted. Recognizing that, I wrote one 500 line function that allowed us to write a new file type routine (a common occurrence) in 5 lines. So I removed thousands of lines of code, increased code speed by 10x, decreased developer time by 2x, and by boss (who only ever imported the code, never wrote it) overruled because it was "too complicated" since I was using a C++ abstraction he didn't understand (guy barely knew C++. Like didn't know what a template was).
The problem with both of these is that they slowly lower the bar. If the shortcut was "good enough" last time then another shortcut will be "good enough" this time. If X is "too complex" because I struggle to understand it, then Y is too. Which I find extra ironic since our field is quite egotistical and we seem to revel in the fact that we don't understand. But I guess Dijkstra was writing about that half a century ago. Which is plenty of time for things to go to shit
The good part is that I owned the project and never has been forced to lower a bar I raised back up. Bad code is just stress for no good reason.
This is has been the case since I started developing software in the 90's. As far as I, and likely many others, are concerned it might as well be a Software Aphorism.
I think it will be very interesting as we continue to reverse engineer such things to find out just how poorly "glued together" the Paper Tigers really are....
I am sure I am one of them. Known unknowns, and unknown unknowns etc.
You might be shit hot at low-level kernel programming but know nothing about networking for example. Or amazing distributed system design and architecture but missing fundamentals about POSIX process handling etc. And so on and so on. I've seen this even in BigCos where hiring bar is high and they try to recruit "generalists". Not everyone can know everything.
Yes, there are trade-offs but that's never how we have those conversations. It's never about weighing the options. We generally have these conversations by dismissing each other's concerns (arguably not a conversation). There's a strong pattern that we dismiss future costs (or future rewards). Why pay $5 now when I could pay $1 is what people hear even if it's "in 10 years you'll make 1000x what you put in" or "in 10 years it'll cost you 1/(10^x) of your net worth". Now matters but we have to remember that so does the future. You can't be penny wise and pound foolish, unless you're a monopoly or extravagantly rich.
"The S in IoT stands for security" has been a joke for 20 years now.
It's always been in plain sight. There's a whole search engine dedicated to it: https://www.shodan.io/ (since 2009)
I highly recommend this talk from 14 years ago: https://youtu.be/5cWck_xcH64?is=O4zCafVz-6eXRYES
Same with I think the lichess android app at the time, except on every sign on.
I used Claude to reverse a widget recently. Turns out that the microcontroller is a perfectly secure chip, unreadable keystore, encrypted firmware, the whole shebang. It would have been nearly impossible to dump.
Except they didn't use the secure key store and did OTA decryption on the fly in 'userspace' as it were. The keys were left in RAM where a debugger can read them and suddenly the device is pwned.
While this is impressive: Why not just get a not-cloud one in the first place? Why does an air purifier need to be controlled via wi-fi?
I'm against a lot of smart home things because its actually more maintenance, not less, to have to think about an object connecting to wifi, to have to decide whether or not to control it (what are you even doing to it?) And I suppose to have to write your own drivers or app. Why allow it to occupy this much mental space for you?
It is convenient to be able to monitor air quality from your phone, sourced from a device that is designed to improve it. Because then you can see how much of an impact it is actually making, move it to a different location with better airflow, etc.
I have the non-wifi version, and have to use a separate device for it.
One of the nice things about air purifiers, unlike owning a boat or leaving a stove on, is that its never going to surprise you in a bad way. You don't need to really monitor anything, it will just purify some air. Do you really want to be bringing that under the umbrella of the stuff you monitor? Maybe this is an irreconcilable difference and we cannot see it the other person's way.
Setting up almost never takes more than a few seconds for me. I have Apple home, it’s almost always scan a QR code, wait a few seconds for wifi and done.
Also it’s fun to mess with.
What I like about IoT is the idea of hacking them :-). Of course I don't want connected devices running proprietary firmwares anywhere near my LAN.
Also one thing is that when a company sells an IoT device, maybe they mass produce it and it's cheap. Whereas if you wanted to build it yourself, it would be harder. Getting relatively good and cheap hardware and putting your own software on it is nice!
Also auto on/off. If you put Home Assistant app on your phone, you can wire up automations that turn things on and off depending on whether or not you're home. Could also have Home Assistant pull in air quality/pollution info for auto on/off. High pollen count today? Keep it running so I sleep well. Low pollen count? Turn it off.
Maintenance is minimal. I set the dehumidifer up 2 years ago and haven't touched it since or had a single issue. Main thing is a) get it working, b) get it isolated from internet, c) never touch or patch it.
Once the data is in Home Assistant, I can also look for correlation with wearable health info. Does purifier running improve sleep? Does changing thermostat set point improve sleep?
Their ESP also uses Secure Boot... I don't know that there isn't a way to break in, but I wasn't able to find one short of hardware notification :/
That said, the non-wifi model works perfectly with a simple HomeKit compatible on/off plug, so all this work — despite being very, very cool — seems a little pointless?
I am wondering how the big corporate will respond sooner or later. Because it is clear and they know that as well with the every rising capability of LLM more people will find ways to liberate their hardware from such unnecessary dependency and accept less the money drain.
https://github.com/device-teardowns/coway-ap1512hh
1 20" box fan. 4 20" mirv 13 filters (cheapest is likely costco or lowes or home depot - buy in a 4 pack to save money).
This is still expensive but the amount of air processing per hour is incredible.
More info
https://filterbuy.com/resources/air-filter-basics/how-to-bui...
Don't go hepa because it slows down the filtering too much. I use this technique in my house and it cuts down on pollen, smoke and mold. You'll feel a lot better than a tiny expensive hepa that has proprietary filters.
I'm seeing some 3d printed projects popping up that look to be filling this gap though.
It's a cool hack, it doesn't pass the wife test.
Find a free-standing cabinet at the thrift store or something. Will look way nicer than any minimalist-modern plastic thing from Temu (or anything 3D printed, not that I have anything against 3D printers in general).
If you're using your HVAC, run the fan continuously, and use the 1" 3M 1900 filter. Other brands or models (including the supposedly 'better' 4" 3M 1900 filters) have fewer pleats, which calculates to smaller surface area and worse airflow resistance. Check BJs website, usually $10/filter in a 4-pack.
Most surprising thing: all but one of those original Amazon fans is still running. They've had years of run time, at quite a bit higher stress than normal.
It's like telling someone they bought a car and pointing out that golf dimples with increase your mileage. No reasonable adult would have that thing in the middle of their living room!
A smaller supplementary unit made out of PC fans and N95s can do that. A 120mm Noctua fan's flow and pressure fits well for about three 3M Aura masks in parallel.
It's unhinged how good the air quality is in a room with a device like this.
FilterBuy tested at MERV 7 (stick filter) not MERV 13: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FKAVEek1YaSQ
Filtrete 1900 filters perform best in these DIY boxes: https://www.bjs.com/product/filtrete-20-x-25-x-1-premium-all...
Also MIRV = Multiple Independently-targetable Reentry Vehicles, MERV = Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value. ;)
| only your basic assumptions that are |
\ wrong. /
--------------------------------------
It will unfortunately be a lot harder to free those devices
The air purifier market is full of garbage because consumers don't understand how these products work or what their tradeoffs are.
The root problem is that these products are designed the wrong way around. They almost all use custom-fit HEPA filters. That sounds great, HEPA is good, right? Except HEPA is really not good for household air filtering. HEPA is so fine that even air struggles to move through it. It's also far more fine than the common contaminants (dust and pollen) need. Because it's so fine, you need a VERY powerful fan to move any air through it, which means the purifier will be very loud.
Finer filters are not better. There are two things you want to optimize for:
1: CADR - clean air delivery rate. This is essentially how much air you can move through the filter per hour, multiplied by how much of the contaminant you can catch each time that air passes through the filter.
2: Volume - It doesn't matter how amazing your air purifier is if it sounds like a tornado. If you only run it for a few minutes before getting annoyed, the purifier is not doing its job. Every moment it is OFF it is not doing its job. Many purifiers try to use sensors to determine when to run the filter, but this fundamentally a flawed approach and just means you have low quality air 99% of the time.
The solution to these problem is a less-fine filter. For dust and pollen, something like MERV13/14 is absolutely fine. It will catch most of those on each pass, and because air moves through it so much easier - you can run the same air through it many times more in the same period of time. This results in an air purifier that is whisper quiet, keeps the air far cleaner, and can use off-the-shelf furnace air filters that are VERY cheap compared to custom-fit HEPAs which may stop being made the moment that purifier product line inevitably ceases to exist. (Note: This is mainly true in the US, said filters are harder to find elsewhere)
Combine MERV13/14 with off-the-shelf PC case fans (which have been optimized for decades to be as quiet and long-lasting as possible) and the result is an easily-maintainable, quiet, highly-effective purifier.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corsi%E2%80%93Rosenthal_Box
I'm confused by your dust and pollen comment. What about PM2.5, is this mostly dust or are you not that concerned about this vs dust?
"For a purifier of its capabilities, the Mighty is notably quiet" - https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-air-purifier...
Alternatively, just take a glance at the ~30K reviews on Amazon. - https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01728NLRG
Top speed is about 53dB. The other speeds range from "barely noticeable" to "is this thing on?" More nonsense. My oldest Coways's been in service for ~10 years including ~5 years of services running 24/7/365 near my cat's litterbox.For a given CFM, with all other things being equal, larger fans (like the ones in Coways) are going to be easier than a bunch of smaller fans. Though, if using an array of Noctuas or similar, I'm sure it could be done.
If you put the Coway on "Auto" and fart next to it, it will spin up to a higher speed for a few minutes. That seems like pretty good detection to me. You do get false positives though, sometimes it spins up for apparently no reason, so I usually just leave it on low. This is certainly true, though a lot of people buy these to help with pet allergies and want/need HEPA. Once again, it just shows that you're making this stuff up. Now, it's a good point in general -- nobody should buy a rando air purifier without looking into this aspect. But have you actually taken 30 seconds to look on Amazon and noticed the dozens of third-party filters made to fit the Coways, which have been popular models sold essentially unchanged for 10+ years?Admittedly, standard furnace air filters do have the edge here of course. Corsi-Rosenthal style boxes are going to give you guaranteed filter availability from now until the collapse of civilization. And if you're filtering air in a large or dirty space, then yes, Corsi-Rosenthal boxes are the winners in CADR-per-dollar. I'm building one for my garage workshop before pollen season....
i have to do a major upgrade next month (30 year old gas furnace!) and i will need to do some research, but i would like to even ascend to true HEPA if it's feasible
Also, in new homes, beware of undersized heating systems that will fail prematurely.
My house downwind of a freeway and a wilderness area, lots of nasty black tire dust mixed with allergens. It did not come with A/C. I had HEPA air purifiers around the house that I would leave in auto mode and they would run for a few hours a day based on the air quality.
Then I got central A/C installed with a standard 1" MERV 13 rated filter on the intake. Just running the blower for 10 minutes every hour is enough to keep the air quality in every room below the level where the air purifiers would kick on. I've given most of them away.
It works in many other industries like UL for electronics, Intertek, NSF for foods etc.
[1] https://xkcd.com/3109/
home devices must be homed