News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by thisisauserid on Thursday November 05, 2026 @06:00AM (#50377721)
This is central to the plot of D: Heavy Water, Neal Stephenson's second installment of the Bomb Light Trilogy.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by the__alchemist on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:29PM (#50409040)
Holy shit this is out?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mjmvisser on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:50PM (#50409513)
Enjoy, it’s riveting!
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by thedrexster on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:27AM (#50421814)
Aye, I ran across it at Powells last week. It's fantastic, enjoy!
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by abcd_f on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:33AM (#50411709)
Can it be read standalone or it needs the first book?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by arethuza on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:00AM (#50412173)
I'd recommend reading the first book before D.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by leonidasrup on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:33PM (#50408679)
Boron contamination of graphite also slowed the Manhattan Project:

" Fermi writes that "The results of this experiment was [sic] somewhat discouraging" presumably because of the absorption of neutrons by some unknown impurity. So, in December 1940 Fermi and Szilard met with Herbert G. MacPherson and V. C. Hamister at National Carbon to discuss the possible existence of impurities in graphite. During this conversation it became clear that minute quantities of boron impurities were the source of the problem. "

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_graphite

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by schiffern on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:46PM (#50409139)
Sounds like a good time travel story: the mission is to go back in time and plant a single uranium cube, to be found ~80 years hence, to convince people that the German bomb project was doomed so that– ahh, but let's not spoil it... :)
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by TomJansen on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:12PM (#50409310)
So that WW2 had to go on for an extra 2/3 years?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by xbmcuser on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:25PM (#50410173)
Germans had already surrendered and the Japanese were going to surrender as Russians now were able to move their force against Japan before the nuclear bombs were used. They were used to test the bombs and make sure no such war happens again specially the 2nd Bomb on Nagasaki that was used a few days after they bombed Hiroshima.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:32PM (#50410192)
> They were used to test the bombs and make sure no such war happens again

The two cities were already on a "to be bombed" list and were the 73rd and 74th Japanese cities to be utterly destroyed by bombing.

So, Yes - they were literally used to test the bombs.

The "and make sure no such war happens again" is more of a post WWII retcon of the Cold War era.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by rightnutwingjob on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:09PM (#50410336)
In all likelihood, the two nuclear bombs killed fewer people than the bombing that otherwise would have occurred.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:15PM (#50410367)
Really?

They certainly killed less people than the bombing that had already occurred - the destruction of Tokyo alone likely killed more people than either atomic bomb.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by hunterpayne on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:38PM (#50410456)
This is alternative history, not real history. Remember, there was an attempted coup even after the first bomb to prolong the war. The Japanese leadership at the time were very zealous verging on religious zeal. One of the things that got them to eventually give up was a captured US fighter pilot that (under threat of death) told the Japanese that the US had 100s of atomic bombs. This was a lie but he didn't know that and just was trying to get the insane intelligence agent to not cut his head off (literally). There were other factors too. The USSR invading Manchuria for example. Also the US was in the process of ringing the home islands with 50 fleet carriers (the big ones, 50kt displacement) which would have been able to bomb Japan at will. Even with all of this, there was a significant faction of Japanese leadership who wanted to fight on.

These claims are more about politics than anything. Its an attempt to retcon history to vilify the US. The Japanese had never been invaded and that was a huge point of pride. They were training the civilians for a guerrilla war. Just because you can find a person in the Japanese government who wanted to surrender at that point (and there were) doesn't mean that's the decision that would have been taken.

PS That 3rd point is especially specious...if it were true, no 2nd bomb would have been used. PPS Stuff like this is why historians don't like nor will engage with hypotheticals or the alternative history folks. Its clearly politically motivated, not a good faith attempt to understand history.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by fc417fc802 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:52PM (#50410501)
> Its an attempt to retcon history to vilify the US.

An attempt to vilify ... the side that eagerly deployed nuclear weapons on civilian targets? I'm from the US and I'm not someone who is blind to pragmatism but your argument here just seems completely absurd to me. We clearly committed an atrocity with somewhere between minimal to no legitimate justification.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by nickff on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:59PM (#50410526)
Where did you get the idea that the USA was “eager” to deploy the atomic bomb?

>Stimson wrote in his diary afterwards that after his briefing, Truman felt “the terrible responsibility that such destruction placed upon us here and himself.” [1]

[1] “Memorandum of Conference with the President, August 8, 1945 at 10:45am,” in Stimson diary (8 August 1945), Henry Lewis Stimson Papers (MS 465), Manuscripts and Archives, Yale University Library.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by fc417fc802 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:48AM (#50410754)
For starters, how many days did it take before we dropped the second one again? I don't think it matters what any of the participants wrote or said given the events that we know to have transpired. There were clearly many other paths available to take.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by brookst on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:02AM (#50413465)
Easy to say 80 years later, not having any of the personal experience, and handwaving away first person accounts.

You can certainly choose to believe that the decision makers were eager to use nukes and didn’t consider other paths, but you have to acknowledge that opinion is coming entirely from your own intuition and intentionally excludes all contrary evidence.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by somenameforme on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:44AM (#50414233)
It's literally in Truman's diary. [1] I mean I suppose he doesn't "literally" say 'I'm anxious to nuke the Japs', but he comes pretty close!

"Discussed Manhattan (it is a success). Decided to tell Stalin about it. Stalin had told P.M. of telegram from Jap Emperor [actually from the Foreign Secretary] asking for peace. Stalin also read his answer to me. It was satisfactory. Believe Japs will fold up before Russia comes in. I am sure they will when Manhattan [A-bomb] appears over their homeland. I shall inform Stalin about it at an opportune time."

And on top of this, the Japanese had been negotiating their surrender with the ostensibly neutral USSR hoping to get more favorable conditions with their assistance. And the US had been secretly intercepting these cables and knew all about it. [2] And on top of this the US had also already created another secret agreement with the USSR such that they would declare war on Japan on August 8th, which would be essentially the end of Japan. We nuked them on August 6th, and then again on the 9th.

It was completely unnecessary.

[1] - https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/28466-document-47-trumans...

[2] - https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/28458-document-39b-magic-...

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by InTheArena on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:42PM (#50416403)
Their conditions included remaining in sole possession of all of the land that they had taken in China, the Dutch East Indies, and Korea.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by somenameforme on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:14PM (#50419714)
Not quite. The main negotiator they were using in the Soviet Union was fully aware of the reality of what was happening, long before the nukes and Soviet declaration of war. He was suggesting unconditional surrender except with the promise of the continuity of the Emperor, which is exactly what they ended up going for.

The problem is that he did not, independently, have the authority to make such an offer. And in the mainland things were also confused. The Emperor was treated as a borderline divine figure, but that also meant he was mostly hands off except as a lost resort. He was pushing for surrender behind the scenes, but the war council was the one making the decisions of what would be offered, and they were completely divided. Half wanted to fight, and half wanted peace.

This division continued even after the nukes and Soviet invasion. What changed is they chose to allow the Emperor to make the final call, and he chose to surrender as he had been angling for for quite some time already. The nukes played little role in this decision. The pro-war Japanese correctly believed that we couldn't have many such weapons and were, in any case, prepared to fight to the last Japanese because they thought it'd be glorious.

The thing that did change their mind was the Soviets entering the war meaning they not only no longer had any intermediary with with which to hope for more favorable terms, but also were now facing a massive invasion from the north as well.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by somenameforme on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:17AM (#50411933)
Truman's own diary would be a pretty good source: https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/28466-document-47-trumans...

The diary is full of revealing quotes like "Discussed Manhattan (it is a success). Decided to tell Stalin about it. Stalin had told P.M. of telegram from Jap Emperor [actually from the Foreign Secretary] asking for peace. Stalin also read his answer to me. It was satisfactory. Believe Japs will fold up before Russia comes in. I am sure they will when Manhattan [A-bomb] appears over their homeland. I shall inform Stalin about it at an opportune time."

For some timeline the US had secretly arranged for Russia to declare war on Japan on August 8th. We nuked them first on August 6th, and then again on the 9th. The goal was to get them to surrender to the US before the Soviets made significant inroads in Japan.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:58AM (#50412503)
« The diary is full of revealing quotes »

Do you think what they reveal is the truth? Was the diary meant to be published and become "a source"? Was Truman informed about everything important going on in the US? About the reality (the truth) of the Manhattan Project? Did he even need to know? Wasn't it preferable for him to simply believe in order to play his role?

Just some questions to ponder as to the quality of this source and what can be deduced from it.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by philipallstar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:11AM (#50412254)
> the side that eagerly deployed nuclear weapons on civilian targets

No one was eager. This sort of lie destroys discussion. This site is only about discussion, so please don't keep trying to destroy the only thing the site is about.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by throw1234567891 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:17PM (#50415152)
I hate people like you with passion. The only person insisting on stopping the discussion here is you. Because the argument doesn't fit whatever narrative you're presenting. There exist historical resource which goes against what you're proclaiming. The most common trope is being able to compare results of a uranium vs plutonium nuclear weapon. So STFU.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:55AM (#50412485)
The bombs were an atrocity against a nation that had been committing atrocities of its own.

There are no moral winners in war.

But it remains true that if Japan or Germany had had the bomb, they'd have bombed civilians without compunction, discussion, or regret.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ufmace on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:56AM (#50414322)
This is so profoundly and comprehensively ignorant about pretty much everything about the pacific theater of WWII that it's hard to know where to even start. I would suggest you start reading about the conduct of the Imperial Japanese Army in China, Korea, Philippines, and pretty much everywhere else they invaded and occupied, much of it before the US even started to consider entering the war.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by wombatpm on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:55AM (#50410785)
The second bomb is the one whose use is questionable. If Truman were to be tried for war crimes it would be for that. A surrender was in play. Truman wanted no conditions. I think another week of people dying from radiation poisoning would have brought people around anyway.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by refurb on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:00AM (#50411543)
This theories all fall flat when Japan refused to surrender after the first bomb. As the other comment mentioned there was an attempted coup to keep the war going.

It took two bombs to get Japan to surrender. “A surrender is in play” means zilch.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by InTheArena on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:40PM (#50416390)
There was no surrender in play. We have the records of the Japanese councils at this point.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:02AM (#50412194)
[repost b/o deletion/suppression]

« This is alternative history, not real history. »

Okay, but "real history" is full of lies, so that per se cannot be an argument against "alternative history". Which is not to say that "alternative history" is truthful, it can be just as full of lies, or even, in certain cases, be the flip side of the very same lie.

Your fighter pilot anecdote sounds like Hollywood: Good US boy scared to death by insane fanatical Japanese cranks up a lie that is then believed by the highest state leadership, alright… We can smell the propaganda here, can't we.

What defrost said wrt Alperovitz sounds very reasonable:

• Japan already defeated – FACT

• Japan had been sueing for peace (since around May, I think) – FACT

• real reason for "The Bomb" was to impress Soviet Union (and the world at large, I think) – FACT

• "The Bomb" only an excuse for emperor, real reason was Manchuria – arguable/doubtful, but not important; key is points 1 and 2

Now, in his book "Hiroshima revisited" (free PDF available), Michael Palmer takes a scientific look at the Hiroshima and Nagasaki evidence and concludes that it does not support the notion conveyed by US propaganda that a novel "atomic bomb" was used.†

Rather, it appears these cities were democratically firebombed like dozens of other Japanese cities, using napalm, which is clear as day from the medical evidence. Palmer, who is an MD, also notes that there is a conspicuous absence in the medical literature about napalm injuries.

In fact, the forensic evidence (medical, physical and other) totally and absolutely contradicts the notion that any extraordinary weapon such as the "atomic bomb" was used.

But there was more than napalm (a heinous weapon) that was dumped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki (like on dozens of other cities before). Various "special effects" were used, and notably mustard gas, apparently to fake radiation effects.

† [URL deleted in this repost (in an attempt to avoid automatic censorship) but you can easily google it yourself]

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ufmace on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:04AM (#50414406)
This exactly. I don't know why people are posting "alternative history conjecture" as if it's fact.

We should remember further that after the second bomb was dropped AND the Soviet entry into the war AND the emperor specifically ordering them to surrender the militarists in the Japanese government still attempted to carry out a coup to stop the surrender and continue the war.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by worik on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:49PM (#50415880)
The West insisted on unconditional surrender (implies occupation)

The Japanese would not agree to that

They might have agreed to a cease fire and reduced overseas possessions. A defeat, but not surrender

Make up your own mind of continuing the war to enforce total surrender

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by kstenerud on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:49AM (#50410757)
Such a convenient narrative. "Yeah, a shit ton of people who weren't vaporized died slow, agonizing deaths from radiation exposure, but believe you me, it's more humane than the alternative! They should be thankful!"
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by CamperBob2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:08AM (#50410841)
It was more humane, whether you like it or not. What if we had waited to learn our lesson until the Korean war, when the yield of the first atomic bomb dropped on people would be measured in megatons?

Also, people who are ready to surrender don't need to be nuked twice.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:20AM (#50410890)
> people who are ready to surrender don't need to be nuked twice.

The question remains whether in fact Japan "needed" to be nuked even once - it's unknown whether the ongoing city by city destruction would have resolved WWII.

Further, did they "need" to be nuked a second time so quickly (within three days)? That second nuke was not to force a surrender (just as the first wasn't) - the two bombings were two live tests of two separate weapon designs untested in the field of war.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by CamperBob2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:11AM (#50411089)
Further, did they "need" to be nuked a second time so quickly (within three days)?

Apparently so. Most people will run up the white flag after being nuked once, you see.

It was important to make them think that we had a whole stockpile of them. Otherwise, twice might not have been enough.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by pfdietz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:11AM (#50414461)
Japan had already lost 272 out of 665 sq. km of built up urban areas, with no sign of collapse.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by kstenerud on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:36AM (#50410953)
“The question arose: what about the women and children? I decided to find a perfectly clear solution to this too. I did not consider myself justified in exterminating the men — that is, to kill them or have them killed — while letting avengers in the shape of their children grow up for our sons and grandchildren.”

- Heinrich Himmler

“I am persuaded that this is a righteous judgment of God upon these barbarous wretches, who have imbrued their hands in so much innocent blood; and that it will tend to prevent the effusion of blood for the future, which are the satisfactory grounds to such actions, which otherwise cannot but work remorse and regret.”

- Oliver Cromwell

“It was no longer a question of merely dispersing the crowd, but one of producing a sufficient moral effect, from a military point of view, not only on those who were present, but more especially throughout the Punjab.”

- Brigadier-General Reginald Dyer

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by CamperBob2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:11AM (#50411091)
"I wasn't there."

- kstenerud

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by rightnutwingjob on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @02:10AM (#50437043)
It’s important to note that Oliver Cromwell lived from 1599 to 1658.

And Colonel Reginald Edward Harry Dyer from 1864 to 1927.

They’re not exactly Himmler contemporaries.

How long do you intend on holding the West accountable for figures from its passed?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by leonidasrup on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:52AM (#50411014)
There is nothing humane in bombing with conventional explosives, or bombing with napalm, thermobaric weapons or nuclear bombing. Or biological or chemical weapons.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_nuclear_explosions

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_nuclear_explosions_...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermobaric_weapon

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by cucumber3732842 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:21AM (#50413066)
This is the kind of thing people say when they've never seen someone die over several days from burn injuries.

Plenty of the survivors of the nuclear bombings and the fire bombings writings went on to be published. You can read them yourselves but generally speaking the fire bombings were way, way, worse.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by pfdietz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:02AM (#50414376)
It's convenient, yes, but it's also true. The deaths in Japan had an invasion and ground conquest been necessary would have dwarfed anything they had yet seen. Just their deaths from starvation would have been horrific.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by rightnutwingjob on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:49AM (#50414852)
I didn’t actually say any of that.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazyasciiart on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:34AM (#50411164)
What, if Truman had accepted the telegram surrender instead of sending nukes in response?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by refurb on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:55AM (#50411531)
If Japan were going to surrender, why did they refuse to surrender after the first bomb? And took days to surrender after the second bomb?

The theory makes no sense

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by maratc on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:10AM (#50411896)
Japan were not going to surrender. Some things happened that made them reconsider.

The things that happened: (a) Hiroshima bombed on Aug 6th, (b) USSR declared war on Japan and invaded Manchuria on Aug 8th, and (c) as the Cabinet gathered on Aug 9th to discuss the terms of surrender, Nagasaki was bombed.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:16AM (#50412611)
And if "the Bomb" was so overpowering and decisive, as immediately claimed by US propaganda, then why did the US attack again on Aug 14/15, using pumpkin bombs¹, in a " Grand Finale" ?

Here's Yozo Kudo, general­ secretary of the Japanese National Association for the Assessment of Air Raids and War Damage:

————————

INTERVIEW: Why U.S. air raids continued until day of Japan’s surrender — THE ASAHI SHIMBUN² — August 14, 2023 — Yozo Kudo, 73, secretary-general of the national association of groups recording air raids and war damage

The United States carried out air raids from Aug. 14 to early Aug. 15. More than 1,000 aircraft, including 825 B-29 bombers, attacked targets nationwide. It is believed to be the largest number of aircraft deployed for (a string of) air raids during the Pacific War.

Q: Which cities were attacked?

A: Targets included Osaka, where Osaka Arsenal and Kyobashi Station were bombed, Akita’s Tsuchizaki district, Isesaki in Gunma Prefecture, Kumagaya in Saitama Prefecture, and Iwakuni and Hikari in Yamaguchi Prefecture.

When small-scale bombings are included, about 30 locations were attacked. Many people were killed. But casualty counts vary, and the exact number is unknown.

Q: Why were air raids conducted on the day of the surrender or the day before?

A: Japan’s delay in accepting the Potsdam Declaration was in the background.

The government informed the Allied powers on Aug. 10 that it would accept the declaration on condition that the emperor’s rights of sovereignty would not be changed. But arguments within the government and military became tangled over a response from the Allied powers. Some said the emperor’s status was not guaranteed, and an agreement was not reached for some time.

The United States on Aug. 10 stopped air raids on urban areas by B-29 bombers to prevent an adverse impact on peace negotiations. The following day, air raids by B-29 bombers were suspended altogether.

The United States once waited for an end of peace negotiations, although it continued some air raids by other bombers. But Japan did not produce its conclusion for some time, and the United States decided to carry out large-scale air raids on Aug. 14-15 to urge Japan to accept the Potsdam Declaration.

Henry Arnold, commander of the U.S. Army Air Forces, had wanted the grandest possible finale, according to a history of warfare by B-29 bombers.

The U.S. military initially considered an air raid on Tokyo, which would have a strong psychological impact on the Japanese government, but eventually decided to target several areas outside Tokyo.

Japan decided to accept the Potsdam Declaration at a meeting in the presence of the emperor on Aug. 14. But it took time before U.S. military officials on the ground were informed of Japan’s decision, and air raids continued until the early hours of Aug. 15.

————————

That doesn't give a clear answer as to the motivation of these anewed US terror bombing raids against civilians. There is no military reason, as with all previous attacks on civilians. Just sadism? Or maybe the raids on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were not impressive enough?

1 https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/509th_Composite_Group

2 https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14980968

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Detrytus on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:07PM (#50419185)
The theory that I read is this: Japanese emperor did not really realize what a "nuclear bomb" is. Today we obsess that Hiroshima was "nuked", but for the emperor, and the Japanese central command at the time, the report from Hiroshima (if they even bothered to read it) would not really stand out from dozens of similar reports of bombings they got on their desks every week.

USSR joining the war on US side, however - that is the kind of news that could tip the scales and make them surrender.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jjk166 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:30PM (#50420704)
The Japanese were aware of the US atomic bomb program and had correctly deduced that the US would be able to create a bomb by summer of 1945. They believed the US could only produce one such weapon every 3 months, and decided that getting nuked at that frequency was tolerable for some period, and they could still hold out for more favorable terms as the US would not want the war to drag on too much longer, and the Japanese had hope the still neutral Soviet Union would mediate that peace. It is worth noting that while the atomic bombs were extremely powerful compared to one bomb, they had spent years suffering strategic bombing that destroyed cities; from a tactical perspective the bomb didn't make much difference, losing 5 or 6 more cities wouldn't move the needle. What they were unaware of was that the US was also producing plutonium for nuclear weapons (the Japanese nuclear program was unaware of plutonium in general). When the second bomb came in 3 days instead of 3 months, they knew the situation was very different than what they had anticipated. In a way the US was sort of bluffing - it could make bombs faster than the Japanese thought, but it could not nearly keep up with the 3 day cadence. Combined with the Soviet Union's entry into the war a few hours earlier, the Japanese government realized they had to surrender, but still were not prepared to fully accept the Potsdam Declaration. Truman gave the order to drop a third bomb as soon as it was ready (which would have been August 19th). The decision to surrender unconditionally was only made after consulting with Filed Marshal Hata, whose headquarters had been in Hiroshima, who told the Big Six that he had no confidence in defeating an invasion. Japan communicated its intent to surrender on August 14th. In his surrender speech, Hirohito specifically cited the atomic bomb and more specifically the threat of its continued use as the reason for the surrender.

It's also worth noting that forcing Japan's rapid surrender also limited the amount of territory that the Soviet Union could conquer after their entry into the war. Despite the Soviet Union continuing to fight into September, they were not in a position to occupy Hokaido as they had intended. WW2 would have certainly come to an end at some point without the atomic bombings, but there may have been a North and South Japan at the end of it.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by somenameforme on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:32PM (#50410191)
The USSR declared war on Japan on August 8th, as part of a secret agreement with the West. The US knowing this, first nuked Japan on the 6th and then again on the 9th. It's hard not to see 'us' as trying to force a surrender before the USSR could get significantly involved. Why? Because territories in WW2 were split up in significant part based on who conquered which part. Hence East Germany going to the USSR and West Germany going the the West. Thanks to the US getting a quick surrender from Japan, the USSR was able to be completely excluded from the following occupation of Japan.

If any documents were ever created about this debate, they've probably been destroyed, and those involved have taken it to the grave with themselves. So I suppose technically we can never know for sure. But I think the cynical view is far more well supported. Or at least I think the cynical aspects were the majority of the logic behind it. And it was not only about control of Japan but also about sending a message to the USSR as the US undoubtedly saw the outlines of a new West-East world order emerging after WW2. And all the way up until the 80s [1] our dominant political philosophy was that we could win by intimidation and demonstrations of force, nuclear in particular.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proud_Prophet#Impact

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by rdtsc on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:47PM (#50410250)
> Why? Because territories in WW2 were split up in significant part based on who conquered which part. Hence East Germany going to the USSR and West Germany going the the West.

That was particularly painful for Churchill to accept at the end when he had to hand over Poland to Stalin. Poland was the reason Britain officially entered WW2 in 1939

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_betrayal

> We and France are to-day, in fulfillment of our obligations, going to the aid of Poland, who is so bravely resisting this wicked and unprovoked attack upon her people. We have a clear conscience. We have done all that any country could do to establish peace, but a situation in which no word given by Germany's ruler could be trusted and no people or country could feel themselves safe had become intolerable. And now that we have resolved to finish it, I know that you will all play your part with calmness and courage

(Chamberlain, Sep 3, 1939)

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Create on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:40AM (#50411471)
> shall inform Stalin about it at an opportune time

Stalin was fully aware well before Potsdam, Kurchatov was already working on it for years.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:11AM (#50411601)
Some of the key technical people recruited into the Manhattan Project were already long time Soviet sympathisers and feeding updates on their work (and of others) back to the USSR.

eg: (one of several) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klaus_Fuchs

  Post Cold War declassified information states that the Russians freely acknowledged that Fuchs gave them the fission bomb.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:46AM (#50413330)
Funny though that at "Operation Crossroads" in July 1946, the US was still trying to convince the Soviet Union, which they had invited to send a delegation, that the atomic thing was real. They apparently still didn't know that the Soviets had known all along.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by barrenko on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:29AM (#50412692)
Never ever do I read enough about the blame Europe had in all of this due to it's procrastinating to deal with Hitler / Germany on time.

Happening again with Russia.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by amanaplanacanal on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:11AM (#50413964)
Blaming the victims has gone out of style, for some reason.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by whycome on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:45AM (#50413325)
This is where AI kinda has a role. Built on all the sci fi tropes of years past. You can give it a seed and an ending and get it to write the evening’s entertainment.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by qnleigh on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:28PM (#50410180)
This is why the German's used heavy water instead of graphite as a neutron moderator, which made it much harder to build a reactor. Their early reactors consisted of concentric spheres of heavy water and uranium powder. This was an unfortunate combination, as uranium powder ignites on contact with water. Leaks caused explosions on two separate occasions [0].

In contrast, the first allied nuclear reactor was a literal pile of uranium and graphite on a squash court.

[0] The Bastard Brigade (great book on all of this)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_Pile-1

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:53AM (#50411018)
> uranium powder. This was an unfortunate combination, as uranium powder ignites on contact with water.

Why did they use metallic uranium instead of the stable oxide?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Kubuxu on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:14AM (#50411925)
Pure guess based on intuition: density making it easier to reach criticality.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by 44mkultra69 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:41AM (#50412405)
> This is why the German's used heavy water instead of graphite as a neutron moderator

Were there other approaches discussed or used in Germany around the time?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by pfdietz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:55AM (#50413411)
There was one proposal to use dry ice as the moderator, in a low power experiment.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by fortran77 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:05AM (#50413922)
> This was an unfortunate combination, as uranium powder ignites on contact with water. Leaks caused explosions on two separate occasions

This was a _fortunate_ combination, the way I see it.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by smallerize on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:15AM (#50414506)
TFA points out that their heavy water production would have been too low to make single working reactor during the whole course of the war.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by AndrewKemendo on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:47PM (#50408761)
Awesome article and interesting to see Heisenberg get it wrong. It really was a perfect situation for the US because we could get all the radioactive material with little issue.

A clean reminder that logistics is everything.

Also cool that the author is married to Sean Carroll.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by 1970-01-01 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:06PM (#50409599)
We always knew they weren't close because Moe Berg was going to shoot Heisenberg during his lectures in Zurich if he suspected they were.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by failbuffer on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:14PM (#50409634)
It mega-helped that Edgar Sengier saw the importance of uranium ore and shipped 1200 tons of it to New York before the U.S. government realized it would need it.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by thenthenthen on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:19PM (#50415164)
Wow that is wild.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Someone on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:34PM (#50416319)
[delayed]
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mmooss on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:07PM (#50408914)
Relatively recently, recordings were released of conversations between captured Nazi scientists held at a house in the UK (I think I saw it on HN). They were housed together and the house was bugged purposely to capture casual conversation for intelligence purposes.

IIRC one conclusion they/some of the scientists drew was that the culture of the Nazi regime - the paranoia, fear, and violence - made a project on that scale impossible. Enough talented, high-ego people could not work together on project that large and demanding.

Also, IIRC, when the Hiroshima bomb was announced, many couldn't believe it. They had been working on a power generation reactor as a first step - though I'm not sure the OP fits that story?

Also, maybe Heisenberg didn't want to succeed? Has that ever been resolved to some degree?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:57PM (#50409204)
The sheer economic costs of the manhattan project were prohibitive to a nation like Germany, even if they'd managed to build a functional project team.

(how many nations had 14,700 tons of silver lying around)

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by throwaway81523 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:16PM (#50409341)
The silver bus bars in the magnetic separators were kind of a stunt, if that's what you're thinking of.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by dboreham on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:48PM (#50409500)
I don't believe the silver was strictly necessary. Copper windings would have worked for the calutron. Silver was used because copper was not as easily available at the time. But the point is valid. The project was originally British, moved to the US for economic reasons.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by fooker on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:53PM (#50409532)
A nation like Germany on the cusp of losing a war sure. The opposite scenario of Germany controlling all the resources of Europe and Africa is a scary proposition.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jcranmer on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:18PM (#50409655)
> The opposite scenario of Germany controlling all the resources of Europe and Africa is a scary proposition.

It shouldn't be. In WW2, in 1942, Germany did essentially control all of Europe, save only the UK. And at the height of its power, Germany's vast industrial machine produced roughly on par with the UK. Not the entire British Empire, just UK.

It turns out that the Nazis were complete incompetent buffoons when it came to economic management. Their grand master plan for Europe was to overrun the east, not for some vast rich treasure trove of minerals to fuel an industrial juggernaut, but to plop down more homesteads to feed their inefficient agricultural economy. And even if the Nazis had a grand plan to become an industrial juggernaut, they still faced the prospect of the industrial juggernaut par excellence, the US.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:37PM (#50409983)
The US at the start of WW2 was primarily an inefficient agrarian economy.

The war machine is what changed that - that and not being reachable by enemy bombers, and hence not bombed to bits.

Germany started middling and ended destroyed.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jcranmer on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:05PM (#50410324)
No, that's categorically not true!

Germany required like 10 percentage points more of its labor force in agriculture in 1939 than the US did, and that still wasn't enough to make Germany self-sufficient in food; the US was of course one of the major food exporters in the world (in neither case were agriculture workers more than a third of the population, I should note). US agriculture also had largely mechanized in the 1910s, albeit many farms did switch back to draft animals during the 1920s and 1930s due to the collapse in agricultural prices, making animal feed grown on your own farm cheaper than buying fuel for the tractor. Europe agriculture largely didn't mechanize until the 1950s, after WW2.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:04AM (#50411065)
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by hunterpayne on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:22AM (#50410629)
Complete nonsense. The US became the largest economy in 1870 (70 years before the start of the war). And in 1875 it became the 1st country to start using crude oil. Even in 1940, the US exported 75% of the worlds oil. Most of the main directions of advance by Germany and Japan were trying to get access to the 15% of the worlds oil they could get to (Romania, Baku and Indonesia). The US economy was 3x the size of Germany's (#2 by GDP) and was the majority of the world's industrial and manufacturing.

Let's try this another way, during WWII the US built warship tonnage equivalent to all the rest of the world's navies combined...in just 1943. Then the US did that again in 1944. At one point, the US hit a Japanese fleet with 17 fleet carriers at once. Keep in mind the Japanese only built 9 fleet carriers total and that was considered the most powerful fleet in the world at the beginning of the war.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:06AM (#50411072)
not even close [https://www.statista.com/statistics/1076289/gdp-continent-18...]]

telling that your example of actual concrete economic output was many years into the war, eh?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:14AM (#50411615)
« Most of the main directions of advance by Germany and Japan were trying to get access to the 15% of the worlds oil they could get to (Romania, Baku and Indonesia). »

This is the key to understand WW2. The oil, and the iron ore (Sweden, hence Norway). But mostly the oil. All the rest about ideology etc in Western/Anglo historiography is distraction at best (but actually rather deliberately misleading). Like "Hitler sought world domination" and similar junk, this is just ludicrous, we can simply take a look at the map and take note of who had already secured world domination.

The lack of oil had already been painful for Germany during Britain's first "World War", having to rely on horses to a much larger extent than the enemy, and the importance of oil had only risen with motorization.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jameshart on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:13PM (#50415610)
Could an inefficient agrarian economy put 88,000 tons of steel into the Golden Gate Bridge between 1933 and 1937?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:27PM (#50415717)
Definitely. That isn’t much steel at all, relatively speaking.

A single WW2 aircraft carrier is about 2/3 of that amount, or a single WW2 battleship is about half.

In the 3 years after Midway, the US made 17 aircraft carriers, and 8 battleships in roughly that same amount of time.

Not to mention literally thousands of cargo ships, destroyers, etc.

Also, thousands of bombers and 10’s of thousands of smaller aircraft.

Plus tanks, heavy trucks, etc. in the hundreds of thousands.

The pre-war USA and post-war USA were entirely different beasts.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jcranmer on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:08PM (#50416051)
There's a categorical mistake you're making here. You're assuming that the US was an agrarian economy that suddenly became a massive industrial juggernaught because of WW2. You can't flip a switch and turn a million farmers into high-end industrial workers overnight (see, e.g., China, which did try exactly that).

The US was the world's most industrialized country by the early 1900's. In the 1920's and the 1930's, the world's highest-end, most advanced manufacturing facilities, would be located almost exclusively in the United States. Yes, the Great Depression hit the US hard--as it did the entire world--but it didn't cause the US to revert to an inefficient, agrarian society. Indeed, the agricultural recession was worse than the industrial recession, plagued with overcapacity brought about the recultivation of farmland in Europe post-WWI. So the Great Depression leaves the US with a massive amount of spare capacity that is fully eaten up by the turbocharged military buildup in 1940.

The deeper you dig into the economic policies of the various states, the more you realize just how bad the Nazis were at the economy. Even the Soviet's communist economy, for all of its problems, was more efficient than the fascist economies. The only economic advantage the Nazis had was starting their rearmament--and consequent Keynesian economic injection--a few years earlier. When the Allies warbucked their economies, the Nazis were totally screwed.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:08PM (#50416635)
The US was in the right place at the right time, yes.

It was still mostly agrarian pre-WW2. Post-WW2 it was orders of magnitude more industrialized.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jcranmer on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:53PM (#50417125)
> It was still mostly agrarian pre-WW2.

This is categorically false. About 20% of the US labor force was engaged in farm labor in the 1930s. Keep in mind that, given concomitant unemployment numbers, this means there is nearly as many unemployed US people as there are farmers.

Does that sound like a "mostly agrarian" economy to you?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:07PM (#50417263)
1 in 5 working adults literally in the fields? you bet. Guess what the ratio is now? 1.5%, or as the 70’s, about 1 to 22.

That number at the time (21.5%, btw) only counts folks directly working on the farm, not all the secondary folks - butchers, bakers, flour mill workers, etc.

Currently in the US, the 1.5% working directly on farms then leads to ~ 10.5% of additional economic activity going ‘farm to table’. Not counting restaurants and the like, but all the middle folks and value add folks.

[https://www.statista.com/statistics/1316855/us-farm-nonfarm-...]

Late 1800’s to pre-1930’s, direct farm labor was as high as 53% - but that was also because there wasn’t much value add. There was a lot of subsidence farming, and people often ate what was produced locally due to poor transportation infrastructure.

That started to change with automation and the railroads, with a very large multiple of the economy being about processing, transporting, etc. the food produced by farms. Think the milkman, butchers and meat processing plants, textile mills, etc. It’s what made Chicago the powerhouse it was, for instance.

that is still part of the agrarian economy.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jameshart on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:41PM (#50418245)
US might have been 20% agrarian prior to WWII; but Germany still had 30% of their workforce employed in agriculture.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:55PM (#50418415)
and that changes what I said how?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jameshart on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:04PM (#50418530)
By adding valuable global context for how much more industrialized the US was than its contemporaries prior to WWII.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:34PM (#50418892)
then you should include actual context. but it would refute your point eh?

the Nazi’s rose to power using agricultural jobs programs starting in the 30’s, because the financial collapse caused by reparations and hyperinflation (followed by the great depression!) mostly impacted the cities and industrial centers. unemployment in some years topped 26% or more during that time period.

This also encouraged rigging the numbers, and every analysis I’ve found for german labor force types/censuses points out the data is basically all hot garbage. one set of data even shows 76% (!!!) agricultural workforce participation during part of the period which is wild.

none of this has much to do with actual industrial production capability, as those factories largely sat idle while this all played out. post-WW1 treaties forbade most of the interesting heavy industrial stuff. building large capital equipment in a hyperinflationary environment is begging to go bankrupt. even building ships was heavily restricted by tonnage, arms were heavily restricted, etc.

the Nazi’s were so popular in Germany because they eventually just said ‘fuck it’, and started building them anyway - but then lied and hid they were doing so. again making the industrial numbers highly suspect.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:02PM (#50429078)
« rigging the numbers »

Excellent point about how "a rigorous quantitative approach based on official documents" can lead to wrong results and flawed conclusions… :)

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:37PM (#50419428)
« the more you realize just how bad the Nazis were at the economy »

Funny thing is that Germans back then didn't realize that at all. On the contrary, they were – by and large – really happy with Hitler, and that was precisely because of the economy. "The Nazis" had brought back employment. And not just "because of armament", simply not true. There were creative things like MeFo-Wechsel and barter agreements with Latin America, thus bypassing the bloodsuckers in London and New York. So what was wrong with that?

But of course there's that particular kind of know-it-all Azi American who knows everything about all other countries, while also slurring them as a matter of routine, from his superior vantage point in the City on the Hill. I guess it's not his fault because because that's the way the system has educated him.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:29PM (#50420255)
One could argue that the difference between a scam and an amazing deal, is the end result eh?

Germany lost the war and was in ruins, so Nazi-ism was clearly a scam.

If Germany has won, it would be talked about pretty differently eh?

Ghenghis Khan certainly gets a very different treatment than Hitler, and near as I can tell, was at least as bad, if not worse.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:35AM (#50422757)
History is written by the victors, and Hitler is for our day's historiography as Hannibal for Roman history. It's a cover story to justify insatiable greed and lust for control.

Hitler lacked prudence, and his rise was facilitated by the US and Britain precisely for that reason, to make Germany into an ideological antagonist to the Soviet Union, and lead into a clash.

In practice, ideology mattered little, and it was classic geopolitical reasons that led into war in 1941, viz Germany's vulnerability wrt the oil (Ploesti threatened by the Red Army), key to almost everything in the industrial age, still true today.

I disagree with the logic that sth or somebody is "a scam" because of defeat. By that logic, the victims of rape and murder would be "scams". That is not to say that everything about NS was good.

“You must understand that this war is not against Hitler or National Socialism, but against the strength of the German people, which is to be smashed once and for all, regardless of whether it is in the hands of Hitler or a Jesuit priest.” — Winston Churchill (allegedly)

I don't know whether Churchill actually said that, but that is the truth of the matter. The motives were not noble: envy and greed, and nothing more.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:58PM (#50432033)
Few points:

- Going to need to cite something if you want to claim UK and US aided the rise of the Nazis. Ignored to their detriment, sure. But aided? Outside of a few home grown nazis in each country? Never seen any information to that effect.

- You don't need the fact that they were defeated to call Nazism a scam. Have you ever heard of MEFO bills? The Nazi regieme literally scammed it's own banks and people in order to fund rearmament.

- Further to that, their economic model (with the rearmament) was not sustainable. They had to go to war, and the only reason they had to go to war was because they painted themselves into that corner. The reason they did that, of course knowingly, was ideological. They could have rearmed far less and still been a credible power player in europe capable of self defense. But Hitler wanted an aggressive war for Lebensraum.

- Even after smashing France, the fundamental cause of war with the USSR was ideological. Hitler didn't need that war, but he perceived the greatest advantage to be then and jumped at it.

- The quote, regardless of who it came from, would fit very well into the political milleux of the day. Remember WW1 was ascribed as germany's fault and WW2 was too. The average man in the street would want an assurance that there would never be a third tragedy of that nature. (even though that's actually pretty unrealistic as any reasonably powerful nation could cause a war, germany just happened to have an imperial legacy)

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @01:21PM (#50444104)
« Going to need to cite something … Never seen any information to that effect. »

That is only because you haven't left the propaganda matrix yet… The role of Ernst Hanfstaengl is quite well known, he worked for US intelligence, basically conceived the second part of "Mein Kampf" (part I is the history of "the Movement", part II is kind of a "geopolitical and ideological outlook" – if you haven't read it).

There's a book I haven't read whose authors (Macgregor and O'Dowd) claim that the British had an agent called Bill de Rupp in Hitler's entourage (never heard of him). Frederick William Winterbotham himself is also said to have been in close contact with Hitler (I'll have to read their book first).

https://covertactionmagazine.com/2025/09/20/anglo-american-i...

Jim Macgregor has written books with Gerry Docherty about WW1, they're very good, and radically revisionist (blame Britain for WW1, i.e. a "secret elite", following the prosopograhpic approach by renowned US historian Carroll Quigley, basically tracking people/power networks).

But apart from Hanfstaengl & Co, if you observe British/US behaviour towards Germany, and the way they twist and frame history (now as then), and get a sense for the sophistication of their lies, then it's pretty obvious what they wanted Germany to accomplish:

• go to war against the Soviet Union

• make life uncomfortable for the Jews so they'd emigrate (to Palestine, and with their money of course) – rather then serving as soldiers to fight and die in the East like their non-Jewish compatriotes

I could write more but I'll leave it at that because in my experience (from a previous account) so many substantive comments here on HN get "flagged" (and thus censored) by bigots (who effectively control what can be discussed here), so it's not worth while investing too much effort.

Just one thing, France wasn't "smashed", France was outmaneuvered, sparing them (and us) the horrible bloodbath of WW1. And I'll add that France, together with Britain, had declared war on Germany on 3 Sep '39 – just because so many people are never taught these things and still don't know them when they retire (perhaps because they're not supposed to know).

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @06:28PM (#50447782)
The work of a handful of individuals with fascist leanings who lived in a country, investing their own money does not constitute a government intervention in favour of the Nazis. It does not make policy. And I don't see any evidence that policy that you seem to suggest is self-evident exists. Even if they did have an agent close to the man in charge, that doesn't mean you're supporting them. It means you value influence.

You'd need to show me something they actually did, some policy action or some secret flow of money that favoured the rise of the Nazi party for me to believe that.

Also Hanfstaengl didn't join US intelligence until 5 full years after he'd fallen out with the Nazi party. That's not a timeline that makes sense.

France was smashed because they were outmaneuvered. You take very great care to claim that it saved lives without making any mention of the fact that lengthening the war by years caused far more suffering in the long run.

You seek to imply that the UK and france started the war because they declared it. Germany invaded Poland in violation of a defense guarantee. They may have believed it was not a credible guarantee, but they chose to roll those dice despite knowing the consequences.

I have no idea why you're quoting some random novel.

You seem to be a person with a lot of views that align very closely with actual nazi beliefs. And you seem to be apologizing an awful lot for them. I do not find your arguments credible.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @04:04AM (#50451170)
« I don't see »

Perhaps because you don't want to? Some people put ideology first. Many more use ideological vocabulary as the baseline of their reasoning, which is how people are educated in Western societies. So do you. And most people prefer never to leave the propaganda matrix because they sense it could be uncomfortable. Maybe that is your case? I don't know.

I mean, you demanded, you obtained, then you dismissed. It is impossible to get acquainted with the circumstances within just a few hours. There's so much people aren't taught (as a matter of systematic disinformation), and so many lies they are taught instead.

The mere informational volume precludes any "understanding" within so short a timeframe. Then, there's the deeper obstacle of fear to overcome. Fear to leave the herd. Most people simply don't. That's how propaganda, conformism and compliance work. You can read about it in the classics of mass psychology (Gustave Le Bon, Jacques Ellul, Edward Bernays). This is how "free" societies are herded.

As for "money flow", the books by Antony Sutton are quite well known (but I haven't read them yet).

« You take very great care to claim that it saved lives … »

Really? I wrote one sentence about it, a dozen words. (Hope you didn't use AI to assist in writing.)

« … without making any mention of the fact that lengthening the war by years caused far more suffering in the long run. »

So why didn't Britain make peace if that's what they were interested in? Because they weren't. Germany made many peace offerings, Britain wasn't interested, only feigned interest in order to deceive, successfully so to the point that Hitler even sent Hess for direct negotiation, in a heroic one-man mission (see Martin Allen, The Hitler/Heß Deception, dt Churchills Friedensfalle, author was maligned and accused of forgery, b/c he's right on the money, of course).

Hitler was so foolishly anglophile he let them escape at Dunkirk. It's almost as if he was a British agent.

Hitler had made reasonable proposals to solve the contentious issues of the millions of Germans who had been shoved under Polish rule, like referendums and transit corridors, but Britain wasn't interested. Same for the US, of course, but they stayed in the background at first. Because Britain (like the US) were interested in war (their second "World War" against Germany), and they knew they would be in a position to instrumentalize the Soviets.

  If we see that Germany is winning we ought to
  help Russia and if Russia is winning we ought to
  help Germany, and that way let them kill as many
  as possible, although I don't want to see Hitler
  victorious under any circumstances. Neither of
  them thinks anything of their pledged word.
  — Harry S. Truman about "Barbarossa"
Apparently (haven't checked) quoted in: The New York Times (24 June 1941) and in: TIME magazine (2 July 1951), also:

https://www.nytimes.com/1951/02/03/archives/wests-treachery-...

Main difference between Brits and Amis, the latter like to boast and brag in public while the former are too smart to do so.

To counter (and then replace) your ideology-driven approach, you could do some FACTUAL background reading on how the war was actually set up, Schultze-Rhonhof wrote a great book about it (Der Krieg, der viele Väter hatte).

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @01:21PM (#50456636)
You insist I'm ideologically driven. I would contend the reverse and that you're trying to hide your affiliation, but I don't think either of us is going to convince the other so you can leave off the random insults thanks.

"I mean, you demanded, you obtained, then you dismissed" Even if it were credible, which I don't believe it is, your evidence supplied doesn't back your case. You just kept insisting that because there were individual fascists in Countries that that somewow constituted government support

"Really? I wrote one sentence about it, a dozen words. (Hope you didn't use AI to assist in writing.)" You picked up on my description of Germany "smashing" france. Most people would not feel a need to pick up on an accurate statement and reframe it to make Germany sound as non violent as possible. That constitutes taking great care.

Why make peace when you're going to win? Germany's position was strategically unsound.

And you're quoting the cold war soviets talking about the US president to back your case, ok. That sounds credible to me! No agenda there!

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Thursday November 12, 2026 @02:55AM (#50464272)
« ideologically driven … quoting the cold war soviets … credible to me! »

See? You put ideology first. "Soviets = bad", so quoting them is bad, too. Ideology first, hence facts don't matter any more. And this is not an insult, it's an observation.

Btw, I was quoting Truman, not the Soviets, and the NYT link only so no one can say, "ah, that Truman quote is fake." It isn't. But you chose not to focus on facts.

« Why make peace when you're going to win? » — Because most people prefer peace? Because you don't want to be at war?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:56AM (#50486262)
So none of your claims are ideologically driven?

Let me just back up a bit. Your claim is that WW2 was started for strictly geopolitical reasons by the west. You also claim that Hitler's invasion into Poland is "Humanitarian, on account of the August Crisis". Therefore the invasion is not Ideologically driven.

So you are contending that Hitler's repeatedly stated, ideological belief that there was a need for lebensraum which should be taken from lesser races in the east and that Poland had no right to exist as a nation on account of being (re)created by the treaty of Versailles, denoted in the fundamental text of Nazism, repeatedly avowed publically, is according to you either not ideological or has nothing to do with the invasion?

You see, I think Ideology does matter for credibility. If I see the Soviets making a claim that Truman said something during the cold war, I'd like to see some evidence that it was backed up. I'd want much the same for quotes in Western newspapers regarding Soviet leaders, as they both have an agenda. However, I'd need quite a lot of evidence to consider changing my established read on the conflict between the two i.e. that the fundamental driver was ideological, but that both sides used extremely cynical geopolitics to try to pursue their aims.

I'll concede that that's a pretty cynical quote and I'm not surprised that the USSR used it later on for propaganda.

It is also at best circumstantial evidence. Bear in mind Truman was not the VP when he made that statement. This is just a random Senator, who did not have a role in the executive branch or formal influence on foreign policy.

So, on your august crisis/humanitarian response claim. Were you intending that to imply that the invasion was a spontaneous reaction to something that was happening in Poland then?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:28AM (#50496857)
Thanks for a thoughtful reply.

« Hitler's invasion into Poland … Humanitarian »

There's no such thing as a "humanitarian military invasion". There were pogroms against Germans in Poland, and thousands of refugees seeking shelter in the Reich, so there were humanitarian issues, and there were reasons to do something about it urgently. But military action never makes anything better. What was going on was somebody provoking Hitler into war. There were of course contingency plans. Hitler wanted to solve the issues involving Poland (Danzig, corridor, and human rights), if possible peacefully (and he made very reasonable proposals: referendum etc) but if not militarily. To then go to war is of course Hitler's hence Germany's responsibility, just like making it into a World War is Britain's.

« Lebensraum » — Completely irrelevant for the war, misleading, ex post projection.

« Poland had no right to exist as a nation » — Where did you get that from? Hitler wanted an alliance with Poland to protect against Bolshevism. But that was before the anti-German riots.

« fundamental text of Nazism » — Completely irrelevant for the war, written in 1924, likely conceived by Hanfstaengl anyway (who was sort of Hitler's mentor). Consider the educational background of Hitler, his biography, his social status. He was a nobody. Not dumb, but a nobody.

« fundamental driver was ideological » — It never is. But that's almost always the pretext. "Our values" etc, all that BS. It's always power politics.

« just a random Senator » — Not sure there is such a thing. It's not a lottery. You need to be loyal to and affiliated with the power basis. And that is not the people, but the rich families who own the country.

« that the invasion was a spontaneous reaction to something that was happening in Poland then? »

There's no such thing as a spontaneous invasion. It has to be prepared, and it had been prepared as "plan B", because Hitler wanted to solve the issues fast, and by force if need be. But he tried to solve them by perfectly peaceful and democratic means (referendum etc) so there could be peaceful coexistence and Poland would obtain a port on the Baltic, whatever the outcome.

A peaceful settlement was not in Britain's interest, so they torpedoed that solution, bolstering up Poland. And incredible as it sounds today, leading Polish politicians such as Beck thought that if push came to shove there would a putsch or revolution against Hitler in Germany and the Polish army would march in unter den Linden. They truely thought that.

So no, the invasion was not spontaneous. It had been plan B all along, i.e. contingent on the failure of plan A, the peaceful settlement.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:09PM (#50500849)
"Completely irrelevant for the war, misleading" It's literally in the OKW meeting minutes where they discussed Fall Weiss with Hitler that the true objective is "Living space", not Danzig. L79 from the nuremberg files if you want to check. Also note that the meeting took place in May with the conclusion to attack Poland at the first suitable opportunity. I.e. you have the order reversed, the intention was to look for an excuse to invade Poland without pulling in the UK/France, but they absolutely always wanted to invade. It was plan A, not plan B. See also that they acknowledge the possibility of war with France/England, even though they hope to avoid it.

"What was going on was somebody provoking Hitler into war" You think the UK wanted the war (Which wouldn't be a great move IMO given how their own rearmament was far behind Germany's but lets take it as read.)? If so, by what means did they do this? Just guaranteeing Poland is not sufficient to instigate war as Poland had its own interests to consider. If Poland had thought the deal would avoid war and had accepted it how would the UK have prevented that? It seems far more likely to me that Poland thought Germany's deal fundamentally untrustworthy and likely to result in another demand from a weaker position, in which case better to fight without giving up the city first. (Given the document I cited earlier, they'd have been right about Germany's intentions, too.)

"Where did you get that from?" He says it in multiple public speeches around the time of the invasion. He also said it in Mein Kampf earlier on, stating it was created to hold Germany down (Which is partially true, but it also served the goal of giving ethnic poles a homeland for which they had been lobbying for quite some time). There was a period during rearmament where he played nice, but he reneged on that.

"Completely irrelevant for the war, written in 1924" See earlier OKW doc, Lebensraum still very much on his mind. Hitler's approach to the peace and the war was completely consistent with his expressed views in Mein Kampf. The only aberration ironically is the invasion of France and that was definitely driven by military reality. Mein Kampf is not irrelevant. It is probably the most candid expression of Hitler's actual intent he ever produced as at the time he had no political goal beyond rallying sincere supporters to his cause.

"Not sure there is such a thing" There are orders of magnitude of difference between the influence exerted by a senator with no specific role in a government vs one who is directly delegated executive power by the president. One of them talks directly to ambassadors and spies and provides them with instructions, sits on meetings where the President outlines foreign policy. The other does not.

The war was fundamentally caused by Ideology. Power politics always plays into it, yes, and some wars are started for purely cynical reasons. But not Germany's involvement in WW2.Germany wanted to go to war due to Hitler's ideology. They then painted themselves into a corner where they financially had to go to war (See MEFO bills) by spending so much on rearmament. Which they did in order to be able to engage in a war of aggression - because that's what Hitler wanted to do because that's what Hitler believed Nazi, German supremacy ideology required. Some rearmament was definitely a sensible power politics move (Hence why Weimar Germany was already doing it). But Hitler went way overboard for any kind of pacifist narrative to hold up.

The plan B narrative you put forward does not hold up. Neither the intentions communicated in their internal documents, nor the dynamics between the nations align with it.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum3 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:25AM (#50506090)
« L79 from the nuremberg files if you want to check. »

This is known as the "Schmundt-Mitschrift" bzw "-Protokoll". Did you actually read that text?

https://www.ns-archiv.de/krieg/1939/schmundt/23-05-1939-schm...

This is wild, disjointed, incoherent rambling, chock-full of contradictions and WTFs. If you didn't burst in laughter a couple times while reading it I'd have to conclude you're "intellectually challenged".

This is one of their key documents, and it clearly is a freaky floppy fake, without even the slightest doubt about it. Lieutenant colonel Schmundt, allegedly the author, couldn't be asked, he fell in 1944. When Raeder attempted to attack the authenticity of the doc during the trial, the chairman cut him short (he was no fool so must have known the doc was fake).

You probably don't know that the victors seized the German documents and did all the INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE they thought fit. This is a proven fact, in some cases it "stands out" forensically because the paper quality is different from the surrounding pages hence over time "yellows" (vergilbt) differently.

« UK … armament far behind … by what means … ? »

Germany had had to disarm (Versailles), then Hitler rearmed after the other powers had refused to also disarm (as they had promised to do). It is untrue to say that "Britain was far behind", even if you only consider the British isles; but you have to factor in the dominions, geographic isolation, unlimited US support, and of course reliance on the Soviet Union (there were tripartite negotiations in Moscow during the summer of '39 for an attack on Germany which only failed b/c Stalin was unwilling to do the bulk of the figthing for F/UK).

They provoked Hitler via the anti-German riots (arson, murder, rape, refugees), I already wrote that in a prior post.

« If Poland had thought the deal would avoid war and had accepted it … »

Argumentum ad speculum. We know they harshly refused. Why speculate otherwise? I already wrote that Polish leaders thought that if push came to shove there'd be chaos in Germany and the Polish army would occupy Berlin. This seems strange today, but that's what they were thinking, not clear why. Maybe they'd been fed disinformation, perhaps by the Brits, who knows.

« He says it in multiple public speeches around the time of the invasion. »

Please provide time and place of the public speech where he said that "Poland has no right to exist as a nation". Chatty says there is no such speech, and that aligns with what I've heard and read. I remember in one speech he explicitly says that "we need to concede Poland a port on the Baltic sea, such a port is vital for Poland", and in another, when Poland annexed Teschen and Oderberg in Oct 1938, "ich kann nicht wegen jeder deutschen Stadt mit Polen streiten". And here's another true quote about Poland:

« Wir sehen ein, daß hier zwei Völker sind, die nebeneinander leben müssen und von denen keines das andere beseitigen kann. Ein Staat von 33 Millionen Menschen wird immer nach einem Zugang zum Meer streben. Es muß daher ein Weg der Verständigung gefunden werden. » — Adolf Hitler, 26 Sep 1938, Berlin/Sportpalast

Contrast that with the disjointed rambling from the ridiculous Schmundt IMT junk you referred to (a key document at the IMT).

« giving ethnic poles a homeland »

There's nothing wrong with that. But they gave them huge swathes of land that were not "Polish homeland" because they were in majority populated by Germans or, even more blatantly, by Ukrainians. They created a huge Frankenstein Poland where all minorities were suppressed by the Polish. And that was by (British & French) design, so as to create the germ of the next war (same for so-called Czechoslovakia, where there were more Germans than Slovaks).

TBH, my impression is that you're not looking at the facts (or not trying to learn any), but are grasping at the usual wrong claims and fake "documents", possibly without even reading them.

And I suspect you haven't read Mein Kampf either but are using it, in a round-about manner without specifics, as "evidence" because you've been taught it is somehow "important" or "relevant". Am I wrong?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:43AM (#50496974)
« spontaneous »

I'll add that the entire vocabulary used today is totally misleading. The standard term is "Überfall auf Polen". Well, that sounds like "surprise attack", which is impossible anyway. Poland had fully mobilized their army, and done so first, and repeatedly in the weeks and months leading up to the war. There had been several border incidents with dozens of casualties on both sides. So there was a dangerous smeltering crisis with both sides up in arms, and not the least bit of surprise.

This is how they frame things, they use BS terms such as "Überall" or "Global War on Terror", and they repeat them a million times systematically (Sprachregelung, in education, media and politics), it's all meant to deceive and indoctrinate the public.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @04:22AM (#50451267)
« Germany invaded Poland […] knowing the consequences. »

Factually wrong (not even a mainstream history claim), and flawed thinking: British action is British responsibility, not some automatism or law of nature.

Seeing as there were no attempts from the Western side to solve the humanitarian issues in Poland all through the summer, Hitler decided to go to war. That is his, or Germany's, responsibility. A regional war in the Baltics that lasted four weeks. Britain made it into a World War. And that's Britain's responsibility. Their total hypocrisy in the matter is proven by the fact they didn't declare war on the Soviet Union after Sep 17, 1939. They had very specific ideas, strategically. Hitler, OTOH, didn't have a strategy.

« no idea … random novel » — It's the source of the quote.

« You seem to be a person … views … beliefs. » — You got it all wrong because you're driven by ideology. For me, it's about the truth of the history they've dumped us in. And I know they are liars and hypocrites. Hence the need for revision.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @01:24PM (#50456695)
Factually wrong

So they should just let Germany take over another Country while losing credibility for their guarantee?

Also lol, lmao at the idea Hitler was invading for any reason related to humanitarianism.

"It's the source of the quote" You misunderstand, I understand you are quoting a novel, but the particular quote you chose has absolutely no relevance to what we are talking about.

"You got it all wrong because you're driven by ideology" Spiderman pointing at spiderman.jpg

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Thursday November 12, 2026 @03:15AM (#50464413)
[repost of 50464331 b/c comment was censored, probably b/o link]

« lol, lmao at the idea Hitler was invading for any reason related to humanitarianism » You're laughing because you don't know about the August crisis etc† and the immediate reasons Hitler had to attack Poland (and that were not just his personal reasons). Britain would not have waited so long before attacking in such a case.

Your attitude is no surprise but precisely what propaganda is tailored to accomplish. Inconvenient facts are never taught in school and never broadcast in media. Ideology rules, facts don't matter.

† www vor kriegs geschichte .de

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Friday November 13, 2026 @12:01PM (#50486357)
You seem to believe the west has far tighter control over it's own media landscape than seems possible. Even if you believe money ultimately controls what media is produced and the vast majority of media is controlled by people with an agenda - Different billionaires and governments have different agendas.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @08:18AM (#50453069)
HN user rramadass in 50451133 this morning:

« Most people just look at the surface level of what is presented to them and don't really think about anything (unless forced by circumstances). In spite of the fact that we know everything is Propaganda and Deception (of one sort or another) managed by vested interests (not always to one's detriment though) people want to believe they are "free to act as they please". Given what we know today about the world, human psychology and the power of technology, this belief is so naive that i find it hard to understand how one can maintain it. People are consciously maneuvered into a "mental box" and they seem to be unaware of it. »

He then also recommends books by Ellul and one Edward Jay Epstein (a Usanian journalist who apparently doubted the "lone gunmen LHO killed JFK" claim, hence must be labeled a "conspiracy theorist" by the honest and righteous adherents of bienpensance).

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @01:12PM (#50456523)
Most people look at the surface level. Some people decide that because they are not rubes, every fact which is part of the commonly narrative must ipso facto be false.

This, ironically, makes them more susceptible to propaganda.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Thursday November 12, 2026 @02:44AM (#50464197)
« every fact which is part of the commonly narrative must ipso facto be false »

Such an approach would of course be completely misguided. OTOH, the official narrative does contain lies and omits a lot of facts in many ideologically important cases, such as JFK or 9/11, where I think the assumption of fraudulence and "sth foul about it" has become the mainstream view.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:59AM (#50486321)
I disagree about the mainstream view on both counts. The majority (If they know anything at all about JFK) believe that the conventional narrative is the true one.

I also believe them in the sense of being the most likely answers. (I'd give you, say 80% confidence JFK is true nd 99% 9/11)

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:52AM (#50496635)
Concerning the JFK assassination, maybe in Germany there's a majority that is "okay" with the "LHO did it alone" claim. But only among people who are not interested in the case, of course. As for the USA, I'm sure (and have seen that claim made repeatedly) that the majority think there was a conspiracy of some sort, i.e. no "lone assassin".

« 80% confidence JFK »

LHO was set up as a patsy. There was a conspiracy for LBJ to take over, who had been forced upon JFK as a VP (via blackmail: if you don't accept then SHTF wrt to your "extramarital activities" which will destroy your candidacy). Many people were involved in the conspiracy, including part of the Secret Service (his bodyguards). There were a lot of shooters from various angles and places. They hit governor Connally and possibly an SS agent and also JFK but only at the neck.

You can see that in the Zapruder film, which clearly shows the lethal shot coming from the front. But even so, the Zapruder film has been altered to hide a most damning fact: Seeing as the shooters hadn't managed to kill the president in the slow-moving limousine, the driver (SS) brought it to a complete halt (multiple witnesses) to offer JFK as a sitting duck. And that worked, the final shot blew his brains out.

They then altered the evidence (the body) to make sure it didn't flatly contradict the LHO story they were going to tell. But there is proof for this manipulation taking place.

Find the Youtube channel "David Lifton on JFK" (595 subscribers) if interested. The JFK topic is rife with disinformation and all sorts of elaborate theories meant to mislead you and waste your time. But Lifton is the real deal. In "Best Evidence" (1981) he explained how the body was altered to fit the LHO story. Unfortunately, he passed away in 2022 so could't publish his second book "Final Charade" (which may still get published one day, perhaps).

There is also JFK to 9/11 | Everything is a Rich Man's Trick (https://youtu.be/niTwvtokYf0), and while it's great entertainment, it does contain some highly dubious claims ("pink marines" and "homosexual Wehrmacht" IIRC), so I'd take that with a grain of salt.

JFK matters because he wanted to be a true president and not just the general secretary of the ruling criminal plutocracy (which is what are all the others). Well, they didn't allow him to be that president.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:56AM (#50496660)
« 99% 9/11 »

Here's some of the glaring WTFs about 9/11:

• no plane at the Shanksville site

• no plane at the Pentagone

• aluminium planes ("eggshells") shown on TV going cookie-cutter style through steel girders

• WTC building 7 "pulled" (Silverstein), which takes months of preparation

• unprecedented and ridiculous "pancake collapse" (which of course was demolition)

Even if there was only a single one of these severe plausibility issues ("showstoppers") for the "terrorist attack" narrative, the entire story should be met with the utmost scepticism, if not straightforward refusal to accept.

9/11 is a fraud from A to Z and it started with the construction of the WTC some 30 years earlier.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jcranmer on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:51AM (#50497036)
Oh fuck the right off with trivially disproven conspiracy bullshit about 9/11.

> • no plane at the Shanksville site

All you have to do is read the Wikipedia article on flight 93 to find pictures of the plane debris.

> • no plane at the Pentagone

Plenty of eyewitnesses saw the plane. There are pictures of the plane's debris on the Wikipedia article. Do you think that all plane crashes need to have a Loony Tunes-style outline of a plane or something?

> • aluminium planes ("eggshells") shown on TV going cookie-cutter style through steel girders

Kinetic energy = ½mv², baby. Wait until you hear how battleship shells work.

> • WTC building 7 "pulled" (Silverstein), which takes months of preparation

The "pulling" refers to pulling the firefighters from trying to fight the fires in the building, not bring the building down itself.

> • unprecedented and ridiculous "pancake collapse" (which of course was demolition)

Unprecedented? Really? Pancake collapse is like the single most common cause of high rise collapses!

The ridiculous theory here is that it came down via controlled demolition. I happened to live across the street from a building that came down via controlled demolition, which means I got not only a front-row seat to a live demolition, but I also got to endure the months of really obvious preparation for the demolition. If it really was controlled demolition, why hasn't there been a shred of evidence in the past 25 years of any of this preparation work? The only "evidence" for it is the collapse mechanism itself--which, the only similarities is tall building turning into a pile of debris; actually analyzing how the collapse progresses shows many key differences, most notably the point of initiation of the collapse.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum3 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:32PM (#50500012)
I posted a reply to your first four objections (50499394), but it is sadly stillborn because of all the negative votes cast upon my posts (childishness? pettiness? bigotry? I really cannot relate to such behaviour), so here it is again from a fresh account (and I'll maybe answer the last point tomorrow):

————————

« Oh fuck the right off » — No need for that kind of language.

I saw aerial/drone and ground footage from the Shanksville "crash site" and there was nothing there in terms of airplane debris, just the crater. There should have been a lot because airplanes cannot disappear into the ground (even when it's just loosely packed farmland soil), but there was nothing. The Shanksville mayor is on camera stating he went to the alleged crash site and, emphatically and repeatedly, "there was no airplane." It is beyond me how anyone can claim there was.

I looked at the Wiki article you recommended. Yes, there are some photos of debris. But there is still no proper crash site, which means "lots of debris all over the place". So what conclusion are we to draw from these photos? I would say it's a very low effort attempt at pumping some faint reality into the story, possibly by planting some debris.

Someone said it was a ground-penetrating missile that produced the crater. Perhaps. But there's no airliner, that's clear as day.

The Pentagon was hit by a flying object, and there are eyewitnesses. Several rings of the building were pierced as a consequence, in what almost seemed like a tunnel (before the façade collapsed). That is clearly visible on photos in Thierry Meyssan's Pentagate book. While I do not vouch for TM, his book contains a damage assessment study by a French military officer and expert for explosives and damage, who also had repeatedly been to the Pentagone. That expert concludes the damage was caused by a jet-like explosion as produced by a shaped charge (charge creuse, or Hohlladung in German), likely delivered by a cruise missile.

Here, too, we have some token pieces of debris, but it doesn't add up to an airplane by a very long shot. It was claimed the airplane had "evaporated" due to the intense heat but the passengers had been "identified by their fingerprints." Which is obviously unashamed mockery of the public.

« Kinetic energy = ½mv², baby. Wait until you hear how battleship shells work. »

Kinetic energy is of course the main factor in the intensity of the collision, but it does not harden the energy-bearing body (which is mostly aluminium or fiber compounds in the case of an airliner). I know you're an authority on C++ so I find it hard to imagine that you would think otherwise.

My understanding was that battleship shells have tips made of hardened steel, and aluminium or other soft material are inappropriate. Chatty confirmed. So they penetrate and then explode. Again, I don't understand why you're bringing this up? There's no comparison to airliners.

The Silverstein quote is "pull it", not "pull them" (the firefighters). But regardless, the building must have been prepared (which takes months), so you cannot "pull it" spontaneously. This has remained unexplained.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum3 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:44AM (#50506545)
Now the pancakes.

« If it really was controlled demolition, why hasn't there been a shred of evidence in the past 25 years of any of this preparation work? »

Because the towers were basically empty. Otherwise it would have been impossible to prepare the towers for their demise.

The towers were not quite the bustling business centers they were made up to be. Never built to spec, never fully equipped with floors. My father and brother went to the South Tower platform in 1988 and reported that the tower swayed noticeably b/o wind. Maybe there were makeshift plasterboard solutions where you'd reasonably expect solid concrete. That would considerably facilitate preparation for demolition.

Rudy Giuliani, on 9/11, curiously answered a question that nobody had asked, viz why there was so little rubble left from the towers.

There's a video of a NYC landfill worker asked "what stands out" in the rubble, and his answer is a long list of things that are missing from the rubble, such as doorhandles, toilets, washbasins – "not a single one, that stands out!"

There is evidence of the operation of artificial smoke generators installed and working on 9/11. You can see that in some close-ups on the façade. There is a piping system installed on parts of the façade to distribute smoke. You can see it belching out smoke in a steady stream, then fading, dwindling to a halt… and then restarting anew at full throttle.

This is damning evidence.

This has massive implications wrt the scale of the operation, which is absolutely magnificent.

9/11 is also the largest insurance case in history, money flow in the order of many billions via the VCF – but the "victims" cannot quite be what they're made up to be, obviously… there was no "mass murder" as claimed by all the "truthers" (manufactured and controlled opposition). Won't develop this further for now b/o time.

Stockhausen said it was "the greatest piece of art of all times". Not sure what exactly he meant, but quite close to the mark.

Btw, none of what I know about 9/11 is my invention or to my credit. I read the posts of Phil Jayhan and Larry McWilliams on the old LetsRollForums, which can only be read in the Wayback Machine. All credit is to them. They discovered the truth about 9/11 around 2010/11 when lots of material was released due to FOIA requests. I only stumbled about it in 2015.

Here's one thing I observed with my own eyes:

I visited NYC in Sep 2000 for the first and only time, had only 48h unfortunately. It was a marvelous 25°C sunny workday afternoon, I had met with my brother's friend in his office in downtown Manhattan (at a company called Tiger) and then went out to take a walk till 5 o'clock. I wanted to go to the tip of the island, Battery Park, and suddenly, around the corner, there it was, the World Trade Center, whow!

Across an empty plaza I could see a queue, a few dozen people, maybe to get in or to use the elevator to the platform. As I didn't have much time I didn't want to spend any in a queue, so moved on.

But one thing was strange: There was no street life in that part of Manhattan. No cafés, no restaurants, no shops, nothing. Allegedly there were 40 or 50,000 people working in the towers, and yet … desolation! Elsewhere, like on Wall Street, there were a lot of people and coffee shops and busy whatnot as you'd expect. But at the WTC? Nothing! The streets were deserted.

« … many key differences, most notably the point of initiation of the collapse. »

Fully agree with you here. The towers exploded like a sparkler burns, top-down, not bottom-up as in your typical controlled demolition. But the point is that there were explosives, taking out one floor after the other, just in an unorthodox top-down sequence, and at nearly free-fall speed.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by fooker on Monday November 09, 2026 @04:11AM (#50423068)
For sure, history is written by the winners.

The British empire had committed pretty horrible atrocities with victims spanning several orders of magnitudes for about two hundred years prior to WW2, and we do not hear much about it.

Churchil's genocide killed about 3 million people - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bengal_famine_of_1943

There was so much that they had to hold document burning sessions to get rid of evidence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Legacy

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jameshart on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:38PM (#50418210)
“That isn’t much steel at all, relatively speaking.”

Really? you don’t think so? Because America was stamping out projects on that kind of scale pretty regularly through the 1920s and 30s (with a bit of a dip in productivity for the Great Depression). The George Washington bridge in New York was finished in 1931 and took over 120,000 tons of steel; same year the San Francisco Bay bridge was completed with over 160,000 tons of steel. No other country was constructing infrastructure on that scale at that time.

This steel wasn’t being grown in cornfields - it was coming out of places like the US Steel plant in Gary Indiana and the Bethlehem Steel Works which were by far the largest steel mills in the world. The Gary plant alone produced more steel than the entirety of German industry.

Before the Great Depression, global steel production was 110 million tons a year; almost half of that produced in the US.

That massive economic and production capacity which had already been built up prior to WWII was what enabled the US to pivot to churning out carriers and liberty ships and Sherman tanks.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:56PM (#50418424)
compared to WW2 and post-WW2? It was tiny. which was my point.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jcranmer on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:20PM (#50420178)
Consider this article: https://www.nytimes.com/1941/01/02/archives/record-steel-pro...

That's for 1940, which isn't the peak of US WW2 steelmaking (that's 1944). But if you run the numbers, 1944 is about 100% of US steel capacity as of January 1, 1940.

That suggests that the US industrial capacity at the end of WW2 is like 40-50% higher than at 1929, the cusp of the Great Depression. Which is a lot, but it's not "the US economy is completely different as a result of WW2" but "the US economy is continuing the fundamental change that has already occurred". In fact, if you plot the lines starting from 1900, the production levels of WW2 are pretty bang-on as if the Great Depression had never happened.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:30PM (#50420268)
I’m not sure you’re making the point you think you’re making. It’s coming across more like a ‘except for that, Mrs Lincoln, how was the play?’
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jjk166 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:41PM (#50420793)
The US was 50% of the world economy before WW2 broke out.

Ironically it was not getting bombed to bits that contributed heavily to US industrial decline in the post-war years. Countries which had their old infrastructure and manufacturing capacity destroyed replaced them with newer, more efficient versions.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:29AM (#50413160)
You're underestimating the latent capacity of the US in that period. Germany was basically in a state of war mobilisation before the war and beginning to burn their long term potential. US was anything but that.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:32PM (#50415739)
They spent more on V-2.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by kragen on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:58PM (#50409211)
> one conclusion they/some of the scientists drew was that the culture of the Nazi regime - the paranoia, fear, and violence - made a project on that scale impossible

This makes me think about the pervasive classification and paranoia in the "defense" contractors supporting the US Department of "Defense". Any information that's classified, even at the lowest "confidential" level, is only provided on a "need-to-know" basis. And unclassified projects are sort of looked down on, so there's a perverse incentive to classify more than necessary. This "secretive, isolationist approach" seems like it probably prevents a lot of groups from "sharing information or resources", in the article's words (though it concludes that wasn't the biggest problem facing the German effort).

When sharing classified information that someone might not need to know might be a crime, and might get your clearance pulled even if it's not, the incentives run strongly counter to sharing information. Consequently, I confidently claim that there are very, very few people in a position to serendipitously make significant discoveries that involve combining two or three different classified facts.

(I don't actually know this, because I don't know any classified facts.)

Maybe this is part of the sclerosis that causes the US defense-industrial complex to "basically produce useless junk", in the words of Les Earnest (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ych6pvLMKCU), and which prompts Sergey Tovkach to say, "There isn’t a single Western drone that’s proven itself effective in this conflict." (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RmfNUM2CbbM). Maybe that's why Russian propaganda in 02024 reported that Ukraine had to withdraw the USA-made M1A1 tanks far from the front (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aCIN-t3VxJ0).

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by brians on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:03PM (#50409579)
Or look at it the other way: having seen what assembled scientists can do, we separated them, gave them an Orwellian environment, and slept easy.

See Anathem for more on this.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by insom on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:33PM (#50409970)
A double Stephenson comments section :)
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mmooss on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:28PM (#50410182)
Not to take away from your comment, but to clarify: That's not the paranoia the Nazi scientists meant. They meant fear of the SS, being spied on, being stabbed in the back by a co-worker in a power struggle, fear for the families, etc.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by kragen on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:10AM (#50410565)
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to imply that the paranoia was similar in the two cases. I appreciate the clarification.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mmooss on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:58PM (#50415961)
I'm sorry - no apology needed. I didn't mean to imply there was anything wrong.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:03AM (#50413904)
Whatever the authenticity of these transcripts, in English only. And they didn't release any recordings. Plus, the German scientists knew or strongly suspected that the house was bugged, which (a) undermines the authenticity of anything they may have said, and (b) made them leave the house when they wanted to talk about any touchy subjects.

You said the scientists thought that: « Enough talented, high-ego people could not work together on project that large and demanding. » However, this is flatly and totally contradicted by the successful A4/V2 project, within the Wehrmacht, which did end up producing a working product (and not just a fictional narrative), despite the career ambitions of SS and industry people who showed up as soon as "success was in the air" (as described in the book on Peenemünde by executive Walter Dornberger).

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mmooss on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:57PM (#50415950)
> totally

Life and evidence aren't crystal clear or binary - all or nothing; to understand things, we need to handle nuance, multiple dimensions, and matters of degree. Obviously the Nazis could work together to a significant degree; they had functioning organizations. A project to invent nuclear weapons is on a different scale. And of course no evidence is perfect, including what's in your comment.

> made them leave the house when they wanted to talk about any touchy subjects.

They did talk about touchy, self-incriminating things in the house.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:18PM (#50429331)
« They did talk … »

I haven't read the transcripts, but I remember reading about Weizsäcker stating that they went outside whenever they didn't want the British to listen in on their conversations, simply because they suspected they were being eavesdropped on:

  Erst nach fast fünfzig Jahren wurden die Mithörprotokolle
  freigegeben und veröffentlicht.[23] […]
  Allzu weitreichende Schlüsse sollten aus den Farm-Hall-Protokollen
  jedoch nicht gezogen werden. Zum einen blieb nur ein Bruchteil der
  Gesprächsmitschnitte, ungefähr zehn Prozent, erhalten. Zum anderen,
  und dies ist weitaus wichtiger, ahnten die Deutschen, dass sie
  abgehört wurden. Daher besprachen sie die sensibelsten Themen
  nicht im Haus, sondern im Rosengarten. »Es war der geeignete Ort für
  ernste Gespräche zu zweit«, wie Heisenberg später feststellte.[24]
  Weizsäcker erklärte: »Wenn es etwas gibt, was die Engländer besser
  nicht hören, gehen wir in den Garten.«[25]
Rainer Karlsch, Hitlers Bombe, 2005

I haven't read the entire book yet, which argues that there was a German project to build an "atomic bomb", a proposition that would probably have met with ridicule were it not for the fact that the author is an established researcher and very well respected on account of his prior work.

I'm certain he's serious and in good faith and not writing for hype or propaganda. Maybe there was such a project, who knows. But I'm convinced the entire "atomic bomb" thing as it has been publicized is a scam and there's never been such a weapon because nuclear fission, while a great source of heat (and hence power) given the right conditions (moderation), does not lead to explosion.

If interested, see my comments 50411911 or 50412194, flagged to death by bigots, who censor facts and opinions they dislike and prevent interesting discussions on HN (because such apparently aren't the site's purpose). Palmer's book, while free, is serious work, apparently too serious for HN, hence the URL in 50411911 is blacklisted and entails instant death of the containing comment (at least when I post it – YMMV).

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by kragen on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @04:20AM (#50437892)
Thanks for the insight! It does seem like it could be difficult to build a practical device around D2O, other than as a power source.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jcranmer on Saturday November 07, 2026 @07:12PM (#50409311)
> Also, maybe Heisenberg didn't want to succeed? Has that ever been resolved to some degree?

From the Farm Hall transcripts, it seems that Heisenberg was "happy" to have been working on a reactor and not a bomb, but from context, this seems less like an objection to the principle of working on a weapon and more like gratitude that the Allies couldn't hang him for working on an atomic bomb. Recall that the conversations took place after Germany had been utterly defeated and the scientists were prisoners at the mercy of the British--prisoners in a gilded cage, but prisoners nonetheless.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:33AM (#50413700)
« more like gratitude that the Allies couldn't hang him for working on an atomic bomb »

Why would they have done that? Hadn't they themselves been "working on an atomic bomb"?

Wernher von Braun wasn't hanged either although he'd been working on a "device" that actually ended up working. He was even "invited" to continue his work in the USA, bringing along his entire team.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Steve44 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:27AM (#50411978)
The transcripts from that bugged house were turned into a play, we saw it in Richmond, London, a few years ago. It was really well done and seemed to by enjoyed by everyone, not just those interested in the science & its history.

https://www.whatsonstage.com/shows/outer-london-theatre/farm...

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by 1970-01-01 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:03PM (#50409580)
We always knew they weren't close because Moe Berg was told to shoot Heisenberg during his lectures in Zurich if he suspected they were.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mauvehaus on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:04PM (#50409585)
Since Norsk Hydro was mentioned in the article, I have to mention in turn one of my favorite books ever: The Winter Fortress by Neil Bascomb. It's the true story of the Norwegian commando sabotage of the heavy water plant. Short version: after a failed attempt by the English, some locals who'd fled to England and received training parachuted in, blew it up, and then skied to neutral Sweden. Legends, the lot of them: they froze their balls off and didn't have enough to eat, but they pulled it off.

Every time I re-read it, it makes me want to take up nordic skiing. It's is absolutely up there on my list of greatest true stories ever told with Touching the Void, The Emerald Mile, and a select few others.

https://www.abebooks.com/Winter-Fortress-Epic-Mission-Sabota...

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by testing22321 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:41PM (#50409761)
Nordic skiing is great.

As a snowboarder I was reluctant, but got into it a few years ago. We pull our young daughter in a chariot with skis about 10km into a little cabin by a river with a wood stove.

Cheese, salami and hot chocolate and we make the return loop. Three evenings a week all winter long is a great way to spend time outside.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by rjsw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:54PM (#50409818)
One of the Operation Gunnerside members was later part of the Kon-Tiki Expedition [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kon-Tiki_expedition

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by 1123581321 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:25PM (#50409936)
That looks good; thanks. Growing up, I loved the firsthand account published in the 80s. Probably mentioned as a source in this newer book. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/100634.Skis_Against_the_...
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mauvehaus on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:55PM (#50410044)
I am so excited to read this; thank you! I've reread The Winter Fortress every year or two since the first time.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by qnleigh on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:12PM (#50410110)
This story is also covered in The Bastard Brigade, which details many other Allied attempts to sabotage the Germany nuclear program. Fun fact: Heisenberg was close to being assassinated by a famous baseball player (Mo Berg). Very entertaining and interesting book.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by hunterpayne on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:52PM (#50410504)
There's a movie about that which focuses on Berg who was a pretty impressive person. He was a MLB player at a time when that was the biggest sport in the US but the players made next to nothing. He also spoke 10 languages fluently and spent most of the war translating intelligence intercepts. Supposedly he found Heisenberg but judged that he wasn't a threat and so didn't kill him. That's the story anyway, no idea how true that is.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mk_stjames on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:04AM (#50410540)
Little extra fun fact since Norsk Hydro was mentioned in the article and now you've mentioned it again-

Norsk Hydro was founded as a hydro power plant + nitrogen fertilizer production company (the nitrogen production needing lots of electricity, and the hydro plant to provide said energy...) but around WWII, pivoted to light metals, and build aluminum and magnesium factories with German company IG Farben in order to support them in the war as they were partially under Nazi occupation by then. That all went south but then after the war they kept on with the aluminum business.

The company went on to become experts in aluminum extrusions, and were then contracted not just to extrude but also to manufacture the first bonded aluminum chassis for the S1 Lotus Elise in 1995, which went on to be the basis for the Tesla Roadster.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mnw21cam on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:04AM (#50411572)
Also the 1965 film "The Heroes of Telemark", the documentary "The Real Heroes of Telemark" by Ray Mears, and his book of the same name.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by phatfish on Monday November 09, 2026 @08:09AM (#50425098)
Ah, I forgot Ray Mears made that documentary. All of his work is just great.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by peterfirefly on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:15PM (#50415624)
The follow up operation killed a bunch of civilians for no good reason at all.

There was a bunch of heavy water being transported on a ferry. They blew it up. People died. Even with that heavy water, Germany wouldn't have had the bomb.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by raldi on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:26PM (#50409697)
Clickbait antidote: The cubes revealed only that the uranium was a bit less dense than textbook values because of tiny internal voids.

That measurement fed a computer model, but if I'm reading the article right, most of the work was actually based on wartime records on heavy water and graphite. Anyway, the model showed they would have needed twice the uranium and heavy water they actually had.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Crunchified on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:59PM (#50409845)
IIRC, US Colonel Hogan got Luftwaffe Colonel Klink to drink a bunch of that heavy water as a cure for baldness as a truckful of it transited through Stalag 13.

Phew, that underground mission was more important than I thought!

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by pfdietz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:13AM (#50414479)
I know nothing, nothing...
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by GolfPopper on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:44PM (#50415375)
I thought Renee convinced Colonel von Strohm to let him use it fill a bunch of empty champagne bottles to bribe General von Klinkerhoffen, but the bottles were drunk by some downed British airmen who were being hidden by the French Resistance in the same attic?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by hunterpayne on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:58PM (#50410523)
It should be noted that they didn't have the supplies for the design they tried. There were designs that could have worked with what they had. And its unlikely that during the war anyone knew exactly which designs the Germans tried and even less chance that someone would have known if a specific novel design would have worked. Its an interesting detail but largely irrelevant.

Its also suspected Heisenberg didn't want the design to work (its the given reason why he wasn't killed by Berg). But it was still a reasonable possibility during the war that the Germans could have made it work.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by yubblegum on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:25PM (#50415215)
Heisenberg's humanity shines through in his written words in Reality and It's Order.

It is very upsetting that one of the most profound minds of 20th century and Germany, entirely in the tradition of Leibniz, Goethe, et al., is blackwashed because of the coincidence of existing during the Nazi regime.

(https://northtownbooks.com/book/9783030256951 << Recommended)

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Someone on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:01PM (#50416585)
[delayed]
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Beijinger on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:39PM (#50409754)
"As the German scientists were racing against time,"

The Germans tried to build a reactor, not a bomb, or am I wrong?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by rjsw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @08:59PM (#50409847)
The US built a reactor first too [1], followed by others [2] as part of the Manhattan Project.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_Pile-1 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanford_Site

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:11PM (#50409888)
In the context of the time, those US scientists that built a reactor were all in for nuclear energy and absolutely 100% did not think that a nuclear weapon was economically feasible.

"Economically feasible" meaning maybe, perhaps, theoretically possible but even if so astronomically expensive in time, money, and physical resources.

It took the UK/CA/AU Tube Alloys group to find ways to make a weapon more practical, and multiple letters, attempts, and a one on one press the flesh tour to convince the US nuclear types that a weapon was both possible and achievable.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by bluGill on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:23PM (#50409932)
If you go to the Los Alamos Science Museum you can see an original letter from Albert Einstein where he proposed that a nuclear bomb could be fit on a ship and sailed into harbor in 1938. A ship-sized nuclear bomb was not of interest to President Roosevelt at the time for a likely good reason. It's only when the UK realized that it wasn't a ship size. It was something that you could drop from a conventional airplane bomber of the day that the US became interested.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:29PM (#50409952)
Seen it, read it, and aware of why it was ignored at the time - the ability to make such a weapon, as relayed by Einstein, was a hearsay tale of speculation.

Some time later Mark Oliphant visited the US in person and walked key people through a circles and arrows on chalkboard breakdown of how such a thing would be actually possible.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:33PM (#50409968)
It was also a failure of imagination. A ship sized tsar bomba at the time would still be quite interesting - armor the ship like a Iowa class (or more), and give it an automated navigator (very doable at the time, plus or minus a mile or two), and it’s a war ender.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by gonzalohm on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:43PM (#50410004)
And sail the ship into Berlin?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:51PM (#50410032)
Wait until the wind is right, and you wouldn’t need to do so to poison all of Germany for at least a generation.

Also, Tokyo Bay.

For the Axis powers, it would be an even easier sell of course.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:05PM (#50410085)
Footage of the actual Tsar Bomba has no scale, detonating as it did high up in the atmosphere - for anyone watching it might have been a really big or really small explosion.

For the first bomb ever made to immediately jump to Tsar Bomba size, or for it to utilise an understanding of fallout and contaminants that didn't exist prior to the Castle Bravo tests seems ... unlikely.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:36PM (#50415771)
Like Castle Bravo, if the timescale is accurate the scale is obvious to anyone who has seen explosions/bombs before. That being, huge and destructive on a scale previously impossible.

I think you’re making my point though - literally no one could really comprehend or believe such a thing was even possible. Ever.

Until they saw it happening.

So of course it got dismissed until it was essentially inevitable.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:20PM (#50418721)
> Like Castle Bravo,

The Tsar Bombe footage* had warships in the frame for scale? That's certainly news to me.

> the scale is obvious to anyone who has seen explosions/bombs before.

Okay, fair point - so how big or small was this nuclear explosion then? (No banana for scale, but there is a human for reference): https://i0.wp.com/blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/wp-content/uploads...

Sure, there's no real challenge to lookup the test series via name in the URL for answers, but bear in mind, watching live IRL as the bubble expands the question for casual humans is how far away is that explosion? ( Fermi had distance, time, and shockwave force at distance to work with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_problem )

* 1961 Tsar Bomba hydrogen blast: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtCTzbh4mNQ

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by lazide on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:53PM (#50419067)
bigger than anything ever seen on the planet before, with the fireball going into the stratosphere. but then you know that.

what even is your point?

if Roosevelt had seen that footage, he’d be shitting his pants and funding anything and everything going in that direction. which is mine.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by chasil on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:27PM (#50409945)
The plutonium bomb was vastly more difficult to design than the uranium version.

Were both judged infeasible for different reasons? Perhaps uranium purification challenges and the implosion required for plutonium?

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:45PM (#50410011)
In general the take was that human created nuclear weapons were infeasible (regardless of design) because of what was thought to be the barrier to cross to achieve a chain reaction.

The Frisch–Peierls memorandum changed that understanding ... provided that reading of the FP-memorandum was convincingly conveyed to people that made things happen, what Einstein put to paper (and was ignored) and that Oliphant pushed through in person.

Little Boy on Hiroshima was a gun design, a grossly inefficient McGyver that used some 64 kilograms of enriched uranium to successfully convert less than half a gram to energy.

Fat Man on Nagasaki was an implosion device - a necessary design change due to simply not having enough uranium or an enrichment pipeline to sustain the needs of a gun design.

The first device detonated, at Trinity in the USofA, was an implosion device, created to test the more difficult design.

Further, there was an abandoned / discarded "Thin Man" device IIRC.

These were all alternative implementations that were pursued after the FP-memorandum was pushed about to make the case that weapons were apparently possible rather than not yet achievable - the prevailing belief in the US prior to Oliphant doing the rounds.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by rjsw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:56PM (#50410046)
Trinity and Fat Man were plutonium bombs, they needed to be implosion designs because it was realized that a gun wouldn't work using plutonium [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thin_Man_(nuclear_bomb)

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by defrost on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:01PM (#50410066)
As I said above - and perhaps you might like to try a primary source rather than wikipedia ?

  These weapons were, however, as different as their monikers imply. Little Boy was a uranium, gun-type weapon, whereas Fat Man was a plutonium, implosion-style weapon. Two types were needed because there was only enough uranium for one gun-type weapon, and the U.S. government knew it would need to make more than one weapon. 
~ Los Alamos Nuclear Lab https://www.lanl.gov/media/publications/the-vault/1023-a-tal...
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by beloch on Saturday November 07, 2026 @10:00PM (#50410062)
Building a reactor was a step on the way to building a bomb.

Two isotopes were used for fission bombs in WWII: Uranium 235 and Plutonium. More than 99% of naturally occurring Uranium is Uranium 238, which will not sustain a chain reaction necessary for a bomb. There are only trace amounts of Plutonium in nature, but it can be produced in reactors that use U238 for fuel. So, to make a fission bomb you need to either separate U235 from U238 or build a reactor to create Plutonium.

It's worth noting that the shortage of heavy water was no accident. The Allies sabotaged the heavy water production facility in Norway that Germany relied on[1].

________________________

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegian_heavy_water_sabotage

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by hunterpayne on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:00AM (#50410529)
Nitpick. You can't power a reactor with U-238. You breed U-238 into Pu-239 and that can power a reactor.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by alcover on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:53AM (#50411519)
RBMK used only 2% enriched though.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by dopa42365 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:34AM (#50413706)
CANDU even less today (similar drawbacks though, larger size, bigger and more expensive containment structures). Of course you could theoretically just skip the containment structure))
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by jojobas on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:25AM (#50411138)
It was the first step out of 1000 to make. It took both US and USSR more than 2 years from a working reactor to a working bomb, all away from bombing raids. Reactors used to make bomb plutonium were a lot larger and more powerful than these first research ones, and Germany was nowhere near the required scale.

Germans also didn't have anything resembling a workable bomb design.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by shagie on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:58AM (#50414343)
[delayed]
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by codedokode on Saturday November 07, 2026 @11:02PM (#50410320)
Why famous scientists supported Nazi regime? Aren't scientists supposed to be smart?
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by russdill on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:18AM (#50410880)
The Vintage Space has an excellent video that does talk a fair bit about individually scientists feelings toward the Nazi regime

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FGvS4T-r_fk

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by kakacik on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:01AM (#50411553)
Smart people still work for trump regime. Lets put it this way - it won't be viewed kindly by history neither. Yet it keeps happening, people have various priorities and high intelligence doesn't guarantee high morals. musk keeps doing nazi gestures and behavior and clearly his values are not far neither, yet he is supposedly smart and definitely doesn't have to behave that way, its a personal choice.

Also, a lot of people are trivial to manipulate and have emotional weaknesses that are easy to abuse by skilled manipulators, smart or not.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by 2b3a51 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:57AM (#50412498)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ettore_Majorana

Majorana basically disappeared in 1938. It has been suggested that he could see the feasibility of weapons using fission (Leonardo Sciascia wrote a play about this). Opinions vary and the issue is cloudy and ripe for fiction.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by kakacik on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:53AM (#50412841)
That was interesting read, thank you. I wonder what his stance would be after experiencing nazi extermination camps, people often flock to populists promising cleanup of some non-ideal situation but what it actually means down the line is far more sinister (or just empty words like mexican wall which could be completed for years if wanted).
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Aachen on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:43AM (#50412784)
Without agreeing with the stereotype that scientists are supposed to be smart¹, yeah this is something that worries me. Be it naziism, slavery, racism the way that it was considered normal and legal when my grandparents were alive: there are so many things about which I wonder how large groups (not just a few individuals that aren't right in the head) can be convinced to believe it.

How do I know what I'm doing in life is right? By what mechanism could I ensure that I believe someone who tells me that Jews aren't the cause of all evil if I lived in ~1940 Germany? What makes people increasingly vote for racist parties since covid? The average person hasn't gotten any smarter or dumber in many thousands of years; evolution is not that fast. At best, genes might be expressed differently based on environmental factors, but I'm not aware that this is a factor for the aforementioned inhumane beliefs

¹ we can all do amazing things when we have the right idea in the right situation with the means to execute it. Of course, good ideas occur to a smarter person more frequently, and they might be inclined to become scientists because it's an environment seemingly meant for working on new ideas, but that doesn't mean everyone there is per se smart. Lots of people who are topically smart (not to be confused with topical knowledge: I scored both top % and bottom % depending on which part of the iq test you looked at, so that's not about knowledge but about abilities. Many people think I'm smart, but I think they mainly notice the parts where I'm unusually good rather than the 'boring' parts where I perform normally or somewhat below average, or attribute it to laziness)

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mmooss on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:16PM (#50417976)
IMHO these are great, essential questions - the most essential. Here are some fundamental ideas that help me:

> How do I know what I'm doing in life is right?

Start with humility, as you already have: We don't know if we're doing the right thing. Notice that those doing bad things these days embrace brazen arrogance and power.

Wise, good people are hesitant to embrace power; not only do we lack the knowledge to know if we're right, power corrupts. The founders of the US purposely diffused power away from one individual; George Washington declined it, repeatedly. In the most popular fiction of the 20th century, the Lord of the Rings, what distinguished the good guys is they destroyed power and feared using it themselves.

That's one reason it's essential to sharpen our critical thinking and judgment, because doing good requires finding the best way in uncertainty.

(That doesn't mean doing nothing or never using power. We need to use our best judgment.)

> I wonder how large groups (not just a few outliers) can be convinced to believe it.

Humans are group creatures; we and our primate ancestors all live in sizeable groups and not alone (compare bears or sharks, for example). We are programmed to move with the herd.

The herd is guided by social norms. It's naturally very hard to resist them because we fear most being outcast - what feels worse than shame and ridicule? - in part because we cannot survive well or for long alone. You can't get far in life without social connections; it may ruin or even kill you when you need help - and you will - and have nobody to call.

It's very hard to be the only one at the meeting, when everyone agrees and is moving forward, to raise your hand alone and say 'stop, this is wrong'. For one thing, you may be ineffective and dismissed, lose reputation, and lose group standing. Outcast, to a degree. In the HN context, this happens to innovators: what is the first response to your innovation? 'First, they laugh at you' - ridicule. Being a true innovator requires violating social norms, which is hard even when it's just technology. Nobody wants to work for years being laughed at by family and friends (and you never know if you'll be successful after all, for reasons having nothing to do with your innovation).

Sophisticated communicators know this and manipulate groups and the public. Recently the Republican Party in the US as been much more sophisticated at communiation than the Democrats (IMHO), at least in this respect. You see them wield ridicule very effectively, making many left-wing ideas outcast even among centrists and relatively moderate Democrats - as a good example, climate change is factually very well-founded as the moderates and centrists know, but raising the issue is socially outre. Everyone will smirk and walk away from you.

An important part of doing the right thing is both not being moved by norms, by the herd, to do evil, while still being effective and not outcast. It's not always easy and takes courage - grace under pressure, not shrillness.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by codedokode on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:20PM (#50421035)
To be fair, it doesn't take a genius to understand that killing Jews for being Jews is not ok. It is even written in the Bible which is 2000 years old.

Also, regarding slavery: Americans understood that it was not ok. This is why they replaced the word "slaves" with "other persons" when writing a Constitution:

> Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons.

> What makes people increasingly vote for racist parties since covid?

You should not assume that majority of people are good people.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Aachen on Monday November 09, 2026 @05:50AM (#50423860)
If most people aren't good then humanity is, at least in its current form, not worth existing, so one might as well take it as an axiom that we are. It also doesn't seem true to me, not by a long shot. How many people go about their day scratching cars just because they can with no extra effort? What percentage of people would condemn someone who does that? How many people do volunteer work (be it structural and organised or randomly helping someone in the neighborhood) or donate to volunteer causes at some point in their lives? If even a tight majority (50.1%) were evil, even the good people should expect that, on average, the business they're donating to is run by crooks

Al Capone saw himself as a force of good. People want to be good, doing right by them and theirs. All this indeed makes it all the more perplexing what our minds are, as you evidence with fighting wars, capable of twisting into a good system or cause to fight for, but we (save for a small % of people that would not evolutionarily survive because they'd be outcast) are still aiming to be good

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by fred_is_fred on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:16PM (#50416700)
Wernher Von Braun knew of and saw the existence of slave labor for his V2 rockets and was brought to the US and then celebrated. In both his role in Germany and in the US it was considered "national security".
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mannyv on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:48AM (#50410753)
Anyone interested in the bomb should read 'And the Devil Reached Towards the Sky, an oral history of the atomic bomb.'

It's full of fun anecdotes and asides...like when they 'found' tuns of uranium ore in NY...or the aforementioned acquisition of silver from Treasury.

There are classic bureaucratic things...like when they issued a check for millions and specified 'no questions asked.' Then the guy called with questions. Or how Groves' people and Treasury tried to figure out how many ounces were in a ton.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by leonidasrup on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:15AM (#50410864)
Also cery good reading on this subject is "The Making of the Atomic Bomb", by "Richard Rhodes".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Making_of_the_Atomic_Bomb

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by gcanyon on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:32AM (#50413688)
The obvious question to me is whether Heisenberg got it wrong on purpose.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by pfdietz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:18AM (#50414534)
An intermediate possibility is he got a wrong answer and, for subconscious reasons, didn't press himself to confirm it was correct.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by HarHarVeryFunny on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:46PM (#50419510)
The Uranium cubes don't tell you anything - they just didn't have enough, or enough heavy water, to achieve criticality for a nuclear reactor.

The real goal was to build a nuclear bomb, not a reactor, and the main reason the Germans failed at that is different - Heisenberg incorrectly calculated the critical mass of U-235, thinking that tons would be necessary, which would be impossible to produce (unlike a heavy water reactor which doesn't need refined U-235).

Of course even if Heisenberg had calculated correctly, it's not clear that Germany had the resources or mindset for a Manhatten project scale effort to actually pursue it.

One interesting stat on the Manhatten project is that is was using 10-15% of all electricity generated in the US - just to refine the 64kg of U-325 needed for the Hiroshima bomb.