These claims are more about politics than anything. Its an attempt to retcon history to vilify the US. The Japanese had never been invaded and that was a huge point of pride. They were training the civilians for a guerrilla war. Just because you can find a person in the Japanese government who wanted to surrender at that point (and there were) doesn't mean that's the decision that would have been taken.
PS That 3rd point is especially specious...if it were true, no 2nd bomb would have been used. PPS Stuff like this is why historians don't like nor will engage with hypotheticals or the alternative history folks. Its clearly politically motivated, not a good faith attempt to understand history.
An attempt to vilify ... the side that eagerly deployed nuclear weapons on civilian targets? I'm from the US and I'm not someone who is blind to pragmatism but your argument here just seems completely absurd to me. We clearly committed an atrocity with somewhere between minimal to no legitimate justification.
>Stimson wrote in his diary afterwards that after his briefing, Truman felt “the terrible responsibility that such destruction placed upon us here and himself.” [1]
[1] “Memorandum of Conference with the President, August 8, 1945 at 10:45am,” in Stimson diary (8 August 1945), Henry Lewis Stimson Papers (MS 465), Manuscripts and Archives, Yale University Library.
You can certainly choose to believe that the decision makers were eager to use nukes and didn’t consider other paths, but you have to acknowledge that opinion is coming entirely from your own intuition and intentionally excludes all contrary evidence.
"Discussed Manhattan (it is a success). Decided to tell Stalin about it. Stalin had told P.M. of telegram from Jap Emperor [actually from the Foreign Secretary] asking for peace. Stalin also read his answer to me. It was satisfactory. Believe Japs will fold up before Russia comes in. I am sure they will when Manhattan [A-bomb] appears over their homeland. I shall inform Stalin about it at an opportune time."
And on top of this, the Japanese had been negotiating their surrender with the ostensibly neutral USSR hoping to get more favorable conditions with their assistance. And the US had been secretly intercepting these cables and knew all about it. [2] And on top of this the US had also already created another secret agreement with the USSR such that they would declare war on Japan on August 8th, which would be essentially the end of Japan. We nuked them on August 6th, and then again on the 9th.
It was completely unnecessary.
[1] - https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/28466-document-47-trumans...
[2] - https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/28458-document-39b-magic-...
The problem is that he did not, independently, have the authority to make such an offer. And in the mainland things were also confused. The Emperor was treated as a borderline divine figure, but that also meant he was mostly hands off except as a lost resort. He was pushing for surrender behind the scenes, but the war council was the one making the decisions of what would be offered, and they were completely divided. Half wanted to fight, and half wanted peace.
This division continued even after the nukes and Soviet invasion. What changed is they chose to allow the Emperor to make the final call, and he chose to surrender as he had been angling for for quite some time already. The nukes played little role in this decision. The pro-war Japanese correctly believed that we couldn't have many such weapons and were, in any case, prepared to fight to the last Japanese because they thought it'd be glorious.
The thing that did change their mind was the Soviets entering the war meaning they not only no longer had any intermediary with with which to hope for more favorable terms, but also were now facing a massive invasion from the north as well.
The diary is full of revealing quotes like "Discussed Manhattan (it is a success). Decided to tell Stalin about it. Stalin had told P.M. of telegram from Jap Emperor [actually from the Foreign Secretary] asking for peace. Stalin also read his answer to me. It was satisfactory. Believe Japs will fold up before Russia comes in. I am sure they will when Manhattan [A-bomb] appears over their homeland. I shall inform Stalin about it at an opportune time."
For some timeline the US had secretly arranged for Russia to declare war on Japan on August 8th. We nuked them first on August 6th, and then again on the 9th. The goal was to get them to surrender to the US before the Soviets made significant inroads in Japan.
Do you think what they reveal is the truth? Was the diary meant to be published and become "a source"? Was Truman informed about everything important going on in the US? About the reality (the truth) of the Manhattan Project? Did he even need to know? Wasn't it preferable for him to simply believe in order to play his role?
Just some questions to ponder as to the quality of this source and what can be deduced from it.
No one was eager. This sort of lie destroys discussion. This site is only about discussion, so please don't keep trying to destroy the only thing the site is about.
There are no moral winners in war.
But it remains true that if Japan or Germany had had the bomb, they'd have bombed civilians without compunction, discussion, or regret.
It took two bombs to get Japan to surrender. “A surrender is in play” means zilch.
« This is alternative history, not real history. »
Okay, but "real history" is full of lies, so that per se cannot be an argument against "alternative history". Which is not to say that "alternative history" is truthful, it can be just as full of lies, or even, in certain cases, be the flip side of the very same lie.
Your fighter pilot anecdote sounds like Hollywood: Good US boy scared to death by insane fanatical Japanese cranks up a lie that is then believed by the highest state leadership, alright… We can smell the propaganda here, can't we.
What defrost said wrt Alperovitz sounds very reasonable:
• Japan already defeated – FACT
• Japan had been sueing for peace (since around May, I think) – FACT
• real reason for "The Bomb" was to impress Soviet Union (and the world at large, I think) – FACT
• "The Bomb" only an excuse for emperor, real reason was Manchuria – arguable/doubtful, but not important; key is points 1 and 2
Now, in his book "Hiroshima revisited" (free PDF available), Michael Palmer takes a scientific look at the Hiroshima and Nagasaki evidence and concludes that it does not support the notion conveyed by US propaganda that a novel "atomic bomb" was used.†
Rather, it appears these cities were democratically firebombed like dozens of other Japanese cities, using napalm, which is clear as day from the medical evidence. Palmer, who is an MD, also notes that there is a conspicuous absence in the medical literature about napalm injuries.
In fact, the forensic evidence (medical, physical and other) totally and absolutely contradicts the notion that any extraordinary weapon such as the "atomic bomb" was used.
But there was more than napalm (a heinous weapon) that was dumped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki (like on dozens of other cities before). Various "special effects" were used, and notably mustard gas, apparently to fake radiation effects.
† [URL deleted in this repost (in an attempt to avoid automatic censorship) but you can easily google it yourself]
We should remember further that after the second bomb was dropped AND the Soviet entry into the war AND the emperor specifically ordering them to surrender the militarists in the Japanese government still attempted to carry out a coup to stop the surrender and continue the war.
The Japanese would not agree to that
They might have agreed to a cease fire and reduced overseas possessions. A defeat, but not surrender
Make up your own mind of continuing the war to enforce total surrender
They certainly killed less people than the bombing that had already occurred - the destruction of Tokyo alone likely killed more people than either atomic bomb.