Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed
by Lum2 on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:18PM
(#50429331)
« They did talk … »
I haven't read the transcripts, but I remember reading about Weizsäcker stating that they went outside whenever they didn't want the British to listen in on their conversations, simply because they suspected they were being eavesdropped on:
Erst nach fast fünfzig Jahren wurden die Mithörprotokolle
freigegeben und veröffentlicht.[23] […]
Allzu weitreichende Schlüsse sollten aus den Farm-Hall-Protokollen
jedoch nicht gezogen werden. Zum einen blieb nur ein Bruchteil der
Gesprächsmitschnitte, ungefähr zehn Prozent, erhalten. Zum anderen,
und dies ist weitaus wichtiger, ahnten die Deutschen, dass sie
abgehört wurden. Daher besprachen sie die sensibelsten Themen
nicht im Haus, sondern im Rosengarten. »Es war der geeignete Ort für
ernste Gespräche zu zweit«, wie Heisenberg später feststellte.[24]
Weizsäcker erklärte: »Wenn es etwas gibt, was die Engländer besser
nicht hören, gehen wir in den Garten.«[25]
Rainer Karlsch, Hitlers Bombe, 2005
I haven't read the entire book yet, which argues that there was a German project to build an "atomic bomb", a proposition that would probably have met with ridicule were it not for the fact that the author is an established researcher and very well respected on account of his prior work.
I'm certain he's serious and in good faith and not writing for hype or propaganda. Maybe there was such a project, who knows. But I'm convinced the entire "atomic bomb" thing as it has been publicized is a scam and there's never been such a weapon because nuclear fission, while a great source of heat (and hence power) given the right conditions (moderation), does not lead to explosion.
If interested, see my comments 50411911 or 50412194, flagged to death by bigots, who censor facts and opinions they dislike and prevent interesting discussions on HN (because such apparently aren't the site's purpose). Palmer's book, while free, is serious work, apparently too serious for HN, hence the URL in 50411911 is blacklisted and entails instant death of the containing comment (at least when I post it – YMMV).
I haven't read the transcripts, but I remember reading about Weizsäcker stating that they went outside whenever they didn't want the British to listen in on their conversations, simply because they suspected they were being eavesdropped on:
Rainer Karlsch, Hitlers Bombe, 2005I haven't read the entire book yet, which argues that there was a German project to build an "atomic bomb", a proposition that would probably have met with ridicule were it not for the fact that the author is an established researcher and very well respected on account of his prior work.
I'm certain he's serious and in good faith and not writing for hype or propaganda. Maybe there was such a project, who knows. But I'm convinced the entire "atomic bomb" thing as it has been publicized is a scam and there's never been such a weapon because nuclear fission, while a great source of heat (and hence power) given the right conditions (moderation), does not lead to explosion.
If interested, see my comments 50411911 or 50412194, flagged to death by bigots, who censor facts and opinions they dislike and prevent interesting discussions on HN (because such apparently aren't the site's purpose). Palmer's book, while free, is serious work, apparently too serious for HN, hence the URL in 50411911 is blacklisted and entails instant death of the containing comment (at least when I post it – YMMV).