News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum3 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:32PM (#50500012)
I posted a reply to your first four objections (50499394), but it is sadly stillborn because of all the negative votes cast upon my posts (childishness? pettiness? bigotry? I really cannot relate to such behaviour), so here it is again from a fresh account (and I'll maybe answer the last point tomorrow):

————————

« Oh fuck the right off » — No need for that kind of language.

I saw aerial/drone and ground footage from the Shanksville "crash site" and there was nothing there in terms of airplane debris, just the crater. There should have been a lot because airplanes cannot disappear into the ground (even when it's just loosely packed farmland soil), but there was nothing. The Shanksville mayor is on camera stating he went to the alleged crash site and, emphatically and repeatedly, "there was no airplane." It is beyond me how anyone can claim there was.

I looked at the Wiki article you recommended. Yes, there are some photos of debris. But there is still no proper crash site, which means "lots of debris all over the place". So what conclusion are we to draw from these photos? I would say it's a very low effort attempt at pumping some faint reality into the story, possibly by planting some debris.

Someone said it was a ground-penetrating missile that produced the crater. Perhaps. But there's no airliner, that's clear as day.

The Pentagon was hit by a flying object, and there are eyewitnesses. Several rings of the building were pierced as a consequence, in what almost seemed like a tunnel (before the façade collapsed). That is clearly visible on photos in Thierry Meyssan's Pentagate book. While I do not vouch for TM, his book contains a damage assessment study by a French military officer and expert for explosives and damage, who also had repeatedly been to the Pentagone. That expert concludes the damage was caused by a jet-like explosion as produced by a shaped charge (charge creuse, or Hohlladung in German), likely delivered by a cruise missile.

Here, too, we have some token pieces of debris, but it doesn't add up to an airplane by a very long shot. It was claimed the airplane had "evaporated" due to the intense heat but the passengers had been "identified by their fingerprints." Which is obviously unashamed mockery of the public.

« Kinetic energy = ½mv², baby. Wait until you hear how battleship shells work. »

Kinetic energy is of course the main factor in the intensity of the collision, but it does not harden the energy-bearing body (which is mostly aluminium or fiber compounds in the case of an airliner). I know you're an authority on C++ so I find it hard to imagine that you would think otherwise.

My understanding was that battleship shells have tips made of hardened steel, and aluminium or other soft material are inappropriate. Chatty confirmed. So they penetrate and then explode. Again, I don't understand why you're bringing this up? There's no comparison to airliners.

The Silverstein quote is "pull it", not "pull them" (the firefighters). But regardless, the building must have been prepared (which takes months), so you cannot "pull it" spontaneously. This has remained unexplained.

There are no comments on this comment yet.