News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:28AM (#50496857)
Thanks for a thoughtful reply.

« Hitler's invasion into Poland … Humanitarian »

There's no such thing as a "humanitarian military invasion". There were pogroms against Germans in Poland, and thousands of refugees seeking shelter in the Reich, so there were humanitarian issues, and there were reasons to do something about it urgently. But military action never makes anything better. What was going on was somebody provoking Hitler into war. There were of course contingency plans. Hitler wanted to solve the issues involving Poland (Danzig, corridor, and human rights), if possible peacefully (and he made very reasonable proposals: referendum etc) but if not militarily. To then go to war is of course Hitler's hence Germany's responsibility, just like making it into a World War is Britain's.

« Lebensraum » — Completely irrelevant for the war, misleading, ex post projection.

« Poland had no right to exist as a nation » — Where did you get that from? Hitler wanted an alliance with Poland to protect against Bolshevism. But that was before the anti-German riots.

« fundamental text of Nazism » — Completely irrelevant for the war, written in 1924, likely conceived by Hanfstaengl anyway (who was sort of Hitler's mentor). Consider the educational background of Hitler, his biography, his social status. He was a nobody. Not dumb, but a nobody.

« fundamental driver was ideological » — It never is. But that's almost always the pretext. "Our values" etc, all that BS. It's always power politics.

« just a random Senator » — Not sure there is such a thing. It's not a lottery. You need to be loyal to and affiliated with the power basis. And that is not the people, but the rich families who own the country.

« that the invasion was a spontaneous reaction to something that was happening in Poland then? »

There's no such thing as a spontaneous invasion. It has to be prepared, and it had been prepared as "plan B", because Hitler wanted to solve the issues fast, and by force if need be. But he tried to solve them by perfectly peaceful and democratic means (referendum etc) so there could be peaceful coexistence and Poland would obtain a port on the Baltic, whatever the outcome.

A peaceful settlement was not in Britain's interest, so they torpedoed that solution, bolstering up Poland. And incredible as it sounds today, leading Polish politicians such as Beck thought that if push came to shove there would a putsch or revolution against Hitler in Germany and the Polish army would march in unter den Linden. They truely thought that.

So no, the invasion was not spontaneous. It had been plan B all along, i.e. contingent on the failure of plan A, the peaceful settlement.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by ZnerflBerp on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:09PM (#50500849)
"Completely irrelevant for the war, misleading" It's literally in the OKW meeting minutes where they discussed Fall Weiss with Hitler that the true objective is "Living space", not Danzig. L79 from the nuremberg files if you want to check. Also note that the meeting took place in May with the conclusion to attack Poland at the first suitable opportunity. I.e. you have the order reversed, the intention was to look for an excuse to invade Poland without pulling in the UK/France, but they absolutely always wanted to invade. It was plan A, not plan B. See also that they acknowledge the possibility of war with France/England, even though they hope to avoid it.

"What was going on was somebody provoking Hitler into war" You think the UK wanted the war (Which wouldn't be a great move IMO given how their own rearmament was far behind Germany's but lets take it as read.)? If so, by what means did they do this? Just guaranteeing Poland is not sufficient to instigate war as Poland had its own interests to consider. If Poland had thought the deal would avoid war and had accepted it how would the UK have prevented that? It seems far more likely to me that Poland thought Germany's deal fundamentally untrustworthy and likely to result in another demand from a weaker position, in which case better to fight without giving up the city first. (Given the document I cited earlier, they'd have been right about Germany's intentions, too.)

"Where did you get that from?" He says it in multiple public speeches around the time of the invasion. He also said it in Mein Kampf earlier on, stating it was created to hold Germany down (Which is partially true, but it also served the goal of giving ethnic poles a homeland for which they had been lobbying for quite some time). There was a period during rearmament where he played nice, but he reneged on that.

"Completely irrelevant for the war, written in 1924" See earlier OKW doc, Lebensraum still very much on his mind. Hitler's approach to the peace and the war was completely consistent with his expressed views in Mein Kampf. The only aberration ironically is the invasion of France and that was definitely driven by military reality. Mein Kampf is not irrelevant. It is probably the most candid expression of Hitler's actual intent he ever produced as at the time he had no political goal beyond rallying sincere supporters to his cause.

"Not sure there is such a thing" There are orders of magnitude of difference between the influence exerted by a senator with no specific role in a government vs one who is directly delegated executive power by the president. One of them talks directly to ambassadors and spies and provides them with instructions, sits on meetings where the President outlines foreign policy. The other does not.

The war was fundamentally caused by Ideology. Power politics always plays into it, yes, and some wars are started for purely cynical reasons. But not Germany's involvement in WW2.Germany wanted to go to war due to Hitler's ideology. They then painted themselves into a corner where they financially had to go to war (See MEFO bills) by spending so much on rearmament. Which they did in order to be able to engage in a war of aggression - because that's what Hitler wanted to do because that's what Hitler believed Nazi, German supremacy ideology required. Some rearmament was definitely a sensible power politics move (Hence why Weimar Germany was already doing it). But Hitler went way overboard for any kind of pacifist narrative to hold up.

The plan B narrative you put forward does not hold up. Neither the intentions communicated in their internal documents, nor the dynamics between the nations align with it.

Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by Lum3 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:25AM (#50506090)
« L79 from the nuremberg files if you want to check. »

This is known as the "Schmundt-Mitschrift" bzw "-Protokoll". Did you actually read that text?

https://www.ns-archiv.de/krieg/1939/schmundt/23-05-1939-schm...

This is wild, disjointed, incoherent rambling, chock-full of contradictions and WTFs. If you didn't burst in laughter a couple times while reading it I'd have to conclude you're "intellectually challenged".

This is one of their key documents, and it clearly is a freaky floppy fake, without even the slightest doubt about it. Lieutenant colonel Schmundt, allegedly the author, couldn't be asked, he fell in 1944. When Raeder attempted to attack the authenticity of the doc during the trial, the chairman cut him short (he was no fool so must have known the doc was fake).

You probably don't know that the victors seized the German documents and did all the INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE they thought fit. This is a proven fact, in some cases it "stands out" forensically because the paper quality is different from the surrounding pages hence over time "yellows" (vergilbt) differently.

« UK … armament far behind … by what means … ? »

Germany had had to disarm (Versailles), then Hitler rearmed after the other powers had refused to also disarm (as they had promised to do). It is untrue to say that "Britain was far behind", even if you only consider the British isles; but you have to factor in the dominions, geographic isolation, unlimited US support, and of course reliance on the Soviet Union (there were tripartite negotiations in Moscow during the summer of '39 for an attack on Germany which only failed b/c Stalin was unwilling to do the bulk of the figthing for F/UK).

They provoked Hitler via the anti-German riots (arson, murder, rape, refugees), I already wrote that in a prior post.

« If Poland had thought the deal would avoid war and had accepted it … »

Argumentum ad speculum. We know they harshly refused. Why speculate otherwise? I already wrote that Polish leaders thought that if push came to shove there'd be chaos in Germany and the Polish army would occupy Berlin. This seems strange today, but that's what they were thinking, not clear why. Maybe they'd been fed disinformation, perhaps by the Brits, who knows.

« He says it in multiple public speeches around the time of the invasion. »

Please provide time and place of the public speech where he said that "Poland has no right to exist as a nation". Chatty says there is no such speech, and that aligns with what I've heard and read. I remember in one speech he explicitly says that "we need to concede Poland a port on the Baltic sea, such a port is vital for Poland", and in another, when Poland annexed Teschen and Oderberg in Oct 1938, "ich kann nicht wegen jeder deutschen Stadt mit Polen streiten". And here's another true quote about Poland:

« Wir sehen ein, daß hier zwei Völker sind, die nebeneinander leben müssen und von denen keines das andere beseitigen kann. Ein Staat von 33 Millionen Menschen wird immer nach einem Zugang zum Meer streben. Es muß daher ein Weg der Verständigung gefunden werden. » — Adolf Hitler, 26 Sep 1938, Berlin/Sportpalast

Contrast that with the disjointed rambling from the ridiculous Schmundt IMT junk you referred to (a key document at the IMT).

« giving ethnic poles a homeland »

There's nothing wrong with that. But they gave them huge swathes of land that were not "Polish homeland" because they were in majority populated by Germans or, even more blatantly, by Ukrainians. They created a huge Frankenstein Poland where all minorities were suppressed by the Polish. And that was by (British & French) design, so as to create the germ of the next war (same for so-called Czechoslovakia, where there were more Germans than Slovaks).

TBH, my impression is that you're not looking at the facts (or not trying to learn any), but are grasping at the usual wrong claims and fake "documents", possibly without even reading them.

And I suspect you haven't read Mein Kampf either but are using it, in a round-about manner without specifics, as "evidence" because you've been taught it is somehow "important" or "relevant". Am I wrong?