News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed by mmooss on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:16PM (#50417976)
IMHO these are great, essential questions - the most essential. Here are some fundamental ideas that help me:

> How do I know what I'm doing in life is right?

Start with humility, as you already have: We don't know if we're doing the right thing. Notice that those doing bad things these days embrace brazen arrogance and power.

Wise, good people are hesitant to embrace power; not only do we lack the knowledge to know if we're right, power corrupts. The founders of the US purposely diffused power away from one individual; George Washington declined it, repeatedly. In the most popular fiction of the 20th century, the Lord of the Rings, what distinguished the good guys is they destroyed power and feared using it themselves.

That's one reason it's essential to sharpen our critical thinking and judgment, because doing good requires finding the best way in uncertainty.

(That doesn't mean doing nothing or never using power. We need to use our best judgment.)

> I wonder how large groups (not just a few outliers) can be convinced to believe it.

Humans are group creatures; we and our primate ancestors all live in sizeable groups and not alone (compare bears or sharks, for example). We are programmed to move with the herd.

The herd is guided by social norms. It's naturally very hard to resist them because we fear most being outcast - what feels worse than shame and ridicule? - in part because we cannot survive well or for long alone. You can't get far in life without social connections; it may ruin or even kill you when you need help - and you will - and have nobody to call.

It's very hard to be the only one at the meeting, when everyone agrees and is moving forward, to raise your hand alone and say 'stop, this is wrong'. For one thing, you may be ineffective and dismissed, lose reputation, and lose group standing. Outcast, to a degree. In the HN context, this happens to innovators: what is the first response to your innovation? 'First, they laugh at you' - ridicule. Being a true innovator requires violating social norms, which is hard even when it's just technology. Nobody wants to work for years being laughed at by family and friends (and you never know if you'll be successful after all, for reasons having nothing to do with your innovation).

Sophisticated communicators know this and manipulate groups and the public. Recently the Republican Party in the US as been much more sophisticated at communiation than the Democrats (IMHO), at least in this respect. You see them wield ridicule very effectively, making many left-wing ideas outcast even among centrists and relatively moderate Democrats - as a good example, climate change is factually very well-founded as the moderates and centrists know, but raising the issue is socially outre. Everyone will smirk and walk away from you.

An important part of doing the right thing is both not being moved by norms, by the herd, to do evil, while still being effective and not outcast. It's not always easy and takes courage - grace under pressure, not shrillness.

There are no comments on this comment yet.