Re:Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed
by jjk166 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:30PM
(#50420704)
The Japanese were aware of the US atomic bomb program and had correctly deduced that the US would be able to create a bomb by summer of 1945. They believed the US could only produce one such weapon every 3 months, and decided that getting nuked at that frequency was tolerable for some period, and they could still hold out for more favorable terms as the US would not want the war to drag on too much longer, and the Japanese had hope the still neutral Soviet Union would mediate that peace. It is worth noting that while the atomic bombs were extremely powerful compared to one bomb, they had spent years suffering strategic bombing that destroyed cities; from a tactical perspective the bomb didn't make much difference, losing 5 or 6 more cities wouldn't move the needle. What they were unaware of was that the US was also producing plutonium for nuclear weapons (the Japanese nuclear program was unaware of plutonium in general). When the second bomb came in 3 days instead of 3 months, they knew the situation was very different than what they had anticipated. In a way the US was sort of bluffing - it could make bombs faster than the Japanese thought, but it could not nearly keep up with the 3 day cadence. Combined with the Soviet Union's entry into the war a few hours earlier, the Japanese government realized they had to surrender, but still were not prepared to fully accept the Potsdam Declaration. Truman gave the order to drop a third bomb as soon as it was ready (which would have been August 19th). The decision to surrender unconditionally was only made after consulting with Filed Marshal Hata, whose headquarters had been in Hiroshima, who told the Big Six that he had no confidence in defeating an invasion. Japan communicated its intent to surrender on August 14th. In his surrender speech, Hirohito specifically cited the atomic bomb and more specifically the threat of its continued use as the reason for the surrender.
It's also worth noting that forcing Japan's rapid surrender also limited the amount of territory that the Soviet Union could conquer after their entry into the war. Despite the Soviet Union continuing to fight into September, they were not in a position to occupy Hokaido as they had intended. WW2 would have certainly come to an end at some point without the atomic bombings, but there may have been a North and South Japan at the end of it.
It's also worth noting that forcing Japan's rapid surrender also limited the amount of territory that the Soviet Union could conquer after their entry into the war. Despite the Soviet Union continuing to fight into September, they were not in a position to occupy Hokaido as they had intended. WW2 would have certainly come to an end at some point without the atomic bombings, but there may have been a North and South Japan at the end of it.