News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by webhamster on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:08AM (#47647522)
German implementer here. We have to use some kind of attestation mechanism per the eIDAS implementing acts. That doesn't work without operating system support.

The initial limitation to Google/Android is not great, we know that, and we have support for other OSs on our list (like, e.g., GrapheneOS). It is simply a matter of where we focus our energy at the moment, not that we don't see the issues.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by makerofthings on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:23AM (#47647952)
Requiring people to use products from one of two private American companies with a bad track record of locking people out of their accounts is more than “not great”. Some things are better not done if they can’t be done well.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by spwa4 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:47AM (#47648401)
So what can be used as an attestation API? WHAT will make sure that when a phone says "you're paying 10 euro to $coffee_place" that it isn't a bitmap being shown over "you're paying 10.000 euro to $scammer", above the pay button. Note: needs to be a real guarantee that isn't a permission question away from going away.

Either governments can develop (and pay for) THAT technology, or they can use Apple/Google ...

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by xorcist on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:46AM (#47648860)
That seems like a weak argument to require attestation? What would attestation prevent that scenario, specifically?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by spwa4 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:14AM (#47650284)
Oh I see your confusion. It is not trying to prove it's not cheating with the UI (or remote control, or ...) to the owner of the phone. It's proving to the owner of the website (or app, or SIM, or ...) that it's really the user agreeing to the contract on the screen. Or, more to the point, it's proving it to courts after the fact so they'll convict the owner of the phone rather than the business or government.

The scenario it would prevent is that a government gets a filled in form with someone requesting unemployment benefits, or reimbursement for a medical procedure on account X ... and then government finds out after payment, later, in court, that the owner of the phone never agreed to it and it needs to pay it out again (because the claim, true or not, that a scammer initiated the payment agreement in some way rather than the owner). Same for business and agreeing to a loan and ...

It is NOT to protect you, the owner of the phone, against scammers (it does not really do that at all), it is to protect companies and especially governments AGAINST the owner of the phone. It is a way to fire most EU government employees by allowing automation that currently can't work because you can't legally trust phone and internet automation to be binding in court.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by GoblinSlayer on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:44AM (#47650554)
Do you imply that google can prove such a thing or it's just a security theater for (((compliance)))? AFAIK attestation attests hardware, not software, but hardware attestation is self contained and doesn't require any remote cartel permission, cf yubikey attestation.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by spwa4 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:43PM (#47651892)
The EU is trying to make a standard that courts will enforce because EU politicians (the commission, not parliament) really want that. But all EU countries are trying to save cash without touching what's causing the money problem (that would be pensions, there is no way in hell EU governments can spend what's required to keep pensions going as is even in 2026. In the past they spent all the pension money instead of investing and now they have to start paying it back, except they can't. And if they touch pensions ... well there's a French joke. It goes something like this "One of the greatest accomplishments of the 20th century is that you can see Paris from space. Look there it is, that flame right there ...")

So they're just going to use the Apple/Google standards and declare the job done. So it's theater from all sides. Politicians will pretend this is a good solution because they don't want to spend real money, and they really want to tempt EU kids to get loans on their smartphones because, you know, in the EU you're protected from companies exploiting you. Of course, that just means governments will have to do it instead.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by xorcist on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:17PM (#47653974)
The argument here is kind of hard to follow. Who is the "owner" of the phone, "the user" is also mentioned and it is not clear if these two are the same. Is the owner of the phone in the controlling-software sense, Google, or is it the end user? Both fits, and both are commonly used.

Because if it is the end user, the strong version of the argument would be as follows: The end user signs a document, baked in is an attestation that Google guarantees that this device is an approved Android device with a clean boot chain and a Chrome web browser. Then the end user contests the signature in court, either because they didn't understand what they signed, or they did not sign it at all, or did it under threat. How could the attestation help here?

I do not have experience with all EU countries, of course, but more than one, and nowhere is this an issue today. Countries use a wide variety of electronic identification, from soft certificates and mobile phones to smart cards. But as far as I know, all countries accept signatures made even with normal Windows PCs. You can contest a signed document in court for a multitude of reasons, but that's not specific to electronic signatures.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by spwa4 on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:15AM (#47659912)
> How could the attestation help here?

By proving that when the user clicked "Yes, I want this loan, $X deposited on amount Y" that is actually what was on the screen then the user clicked approve. In other words, that the agreement is actually what the REMOTE party believes it is, even if the owner installed "Free coins in the bunny casino v7.0.apk" from a website.

(meaning that is not currently very provable, and exploited by scammers quite a bit. Courts have a nasty irritating habit of holding the more powerful party (ie. the bank/government) responsible for the consequences of scammers' actions. Well, at least from the viewpoint of banks/governments that is a nasty habit)

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by xorcist on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @08:11AM (#47689110)
That is indeed the question: How does attestation help with proving that?

From my limited understanding, I can immediately think of a dozen ways to implement such an attack, and none would be helped by Google attesting that the device is indeed a legitimate Android(tm) device.

It is very hard to understand how this would make any difference juridically. The technical difficulties of avoiding phishing aside, contracts can be contested for a multitude of reasons, including contracts being signed involuntarily.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by miki123211 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:04AM (#47649004)
I'm not sure I want my government to develop that technology.

Government software is usually low-quality, expensive procurement crap, often riddled with security holes, and an exercise in checkbox checking. UX and user friction can't be expressed as a verifiable clause in a procurement contract, so they're ignored.

Besides, every time EU governments tried to force smartphone manufacturers to pre-install government apps, the population freaked out over (unwarranted) surveillance concerns. This isn't something you can do without pre-installing apps (you don't want these APIs opened up because then attestation loses all meaning).

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by GoblinSlayer on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:57AM (#47650722)
It's not that difficult, just `git pull lineage`.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:44AM (#47649374)
In case of Android - AOSP attestation.

Not necessarily the company that locks out entire family because one of the family member jacked off on the chat with Gemini model.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mytailorisrich on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:27AM (#47647980)
Yes but in the real world all smartphones are either Apple or Android. Europe has zero footprint in either software or hardware. It is not creating a requirement to use specific products, it is using the products people already have.

So one may argue that the implementers are only taking the pragmatic approach regarding something that is out of their hands.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jonathanstrange on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:43AM (#47648067)
We're talking about an essential government service, not just another weather app. You have to look at this through the lense of national security, the debate about EU digital sovereignty, and the requirements of the GDPR in light of the US CLOUD Act, as well as prior decisions of EU courts about these issues.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mytailorisrich on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:52AM (#47648116)
Yes all that you wrote is true. But that does not magically change anything to what I previously stated: in the real world all smartphones are either Apple or Android...

I don't know what the eIDAS 2.0 requires in term of security but it may make the choice the implementers made here unavoidable in practice, as hinted by @webhamster.

If so, it seems that a solution, if technically possible, might be to mandate that OSes provide the required security features without tie-in.

The outrage in the comments feels a bit like people yelling at clouds...

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by taotau on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:21AM (#47648624)
correction. in the real world all smartphones are either apple, android or none/other. in terms of legals, you really do have to cater to all three, which is why we don't have one world government.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mytailorisrich on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:10AM (#47650235)
This is about a digital wallet, so people who don't have a smartphone are out of scope.

Now, "other" than Apple/Android is so small as to be negligible and governments also have a duty not to waste taxpayers' money, which means not spending hundreds of thousands to cater for an ultra small number of people who have an easy access to an alternative.

To have government apps work only on iOS and Android is perfectly reasonable in the current state of the world where this covers 99% of smartphones.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by znort_ on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:12PM (#47650870)
> To have government apps work only on iOS and Android is perfectly reasonable in the current state of the world where this covers 99% of smartphones.

the fundamental flaw with that approach is that it is totally unreasonable to have government apps in anything other than open source and fully public systems. nothing else can really be trusted, and any private/closed source option should be disqualified from the get go.

the reason is simple: you can't trust private entities or opaque systems, and you can't trust government either, thus the solution has to be fully transparent or you're doing nothing.

the problem with that is that it is hard, expensive and/or inconvenient.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by limagnolia on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:31PM (#47651058)
Why should I have to have a smartphone to have a digital wallet? Smart watches, tablets, laptops, portable game consoles, etc, are all perfectly cromulent hardware for running a digital wallet.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Hackbraten on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:59AM (#47650113)
> in the real world all smartphones are either Apple or Android...

So you're claiming that Mobian doesn't exist? PureOS doesn't exist? PostmarketOS doesn't exist? Ubuntu Touch doesn't exist? SailfishOS doesn't exist?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mytailorisrich on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:00PM (#47653832)
Don't be disingenuous. All of what you mention are rounding errors in term of market share.

This discussion feels unreal, really.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by MrDrMcCoy on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:29PM (#47655471)
Right, because "you can't use an unpopular OS if you want your full rights as a citizen, and access to those rights must be additionally subject to a foreign corporation's opinion of you" is totally acceptable. I would go so far as to say that a government requiring any particular technology or private service to be a functioning member of society is hostile to all citizens. If your OS vendor / phone carrier / ISP all close your accounts despite no illegal activity, and your government has no alternatives you can use for essential services, then your government has sold your citizenship.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jonathanstrange on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:15AM (#47650288)
Essential EU government services cannot be devised on the hope that US companies will invent something that - contrary to current US legislation - will somehow provide the attestation services needed in a GDPR-compliant way without forcing EU citizens to provide personal data to US companies.

If it's not possible to create such a system for mobile phones because of legal issues (as you seem to acknowledge and judges have found in the past), then the focus would have to be on creating hardware devices in the EU, ideally with open source hardware and software. These can be made reasonably secure, have been used by banks for a long time, and would enhance digital sovereignty.

What I find unacceptable is the attitude "well, it will violate the law but as a matter of practicality it's the only choice we have right now so we'll just do it."

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mytailorisrich on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:44PM (#47652555)
> Essential EU government services cannot be devised on the hope that US companies...

I don't disagree. I am just pointing out that this is wishful thinking right now.

As said, Europe has zero footprint in hardware or software so the choice is either not to develop any digital services or to accept that they will run of foreign hardware/software because everything is either Android or Apple and runs on hardware that is from US/Taiwan/China.

Developping honegrown alternives is pie in the sky or a 20 year project if we are optimistic (which I am not)...

Frankly, many comments, and the reactions to mine, show how out of touch and idealistic or naive the HN crowd can be.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jonathanstrange on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:47AM (#47658041)
EU can build token-generation hardware and that's the solution to the perceived problem. Such approaches have been used by banks for decades. It's not a "20 years project" to issue similar hardware to what my German bank issued 10+ years ago. I've explicitly stated in my post that the EU should not build a software solution for smartphones with US operating systems since this approach violates the GDPR and other laws because of a fundamental incompatibility of EU law with the US CLOUD Act that has been recognized by judges already. The proposed solution you seem to favor is illegal.

If I'm right, you're the person ignoring reality and basing their judgment on wishful thinking, not me. I understand why you want to have a smartphone solution ("practicality") but AFAIK that's currently not a viable approach. I might be wrong about the legal situation but that's what I've claimed. Just repeating your talking point is not a reasonable reply to these legal concerns. In addition to this, there are also serious national security concerns, of course.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:47AM (#47649407)
It literały has created the dependency on google when thought Android offers the standard/generic AOSP attestation.

Also you weirdly forget all the Chinese phones. There's also some tiny European brand which will have absolutely no way to limit their users dependency on the famously hostile and unconctactable provider.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by FabHK on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:32AM (#47649859)
Most Chinese smartphones run Android (Huawei uses HarmonyOS).
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by qwertox on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:52AM (#47648118)
Maybe that will force the companies to not be allowed to just lock you out of the account.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by gmerc on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:59AM (#47648150)
Ya, sorry, no, maybe is not really a durable position here.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:44AM (#47649381)
You, your siblings, your parents, etc, etc.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:26AM (#47648667)
There are no alternatives.

I mean you could use Huawei and others, but the FUD campaigns against chinese manufacturers was pretty agressive in the EU.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by haagch on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:07AM (#47647844)
German citizen here. So why is an implementation going forward when you already know it will not serve all citizens? Why are we not refusing to implement this until we know we can make it work on all devices?

Personally I recently switched from an AOSP based android without Google Play to Ubuntu Touch. In the future with better hardware support I will probably switch to postmarketOS.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dark-star on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:23AM (#47647949)
because then it will never get done. There are still people using old Nokia phones, for those there will never be a solution.

The usual 80/20 rule applies here as well.

And if you really are a German citizen, you know how slow the wheels of government already turn in Germany, I assume next week you would be the one complaining that "Germany is so far behind" and that "other countries are so much faster at implementing stuff" :)

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by haagch on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:43AM (#47648060)
Nah, I'm that one idiot who uses alternative open software and just accepts when services aren't offered to me. The older I get, the easier it feels to not give a fuck anymore.

Can't buy any single fare public transport tickets online here in Stuttgart? Sure, I'll use the DeutschlandTicket NFC card. Can't view the EPA? Fine then I don't. Can't pay with Wero? Fine, I don't actually need to use shops that don't offer SEPA Vorkasse or Lastschrift (only without a dodgy "identity verification" fintech startup of course.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by futune on Thursday April 09, 2026 @08:26AM (#47702793)
You are not alone.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by abc123abc123 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:29AM (#47647985)
Yeah, let's burn the witches who care about privacy! Jokes aside, in a democracy, the systems must be designed so that everyone can participate. We manage to do it with voting, with income tax declaration, but for some strange reason, with ID we want to achieve 1984 nirvana, and crush the voices who tell us that the surveilance society we are building is just setting us up for the next Hitler.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by sippeangelo on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:43AM (#47648066)
Then maybe it shouldn't be done? What??
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jijijijij on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:19AM (#47650334)
> There are still people using old Nokia phones

No one wants support for toasters and washing machines. We're talking general purpose compute hardware. TCP is also supported on all these devices. Quite frankly, it's probably easier to implement, if you are not fighting a locked-down OS like iOS.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by microtonal on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:42PM (#47653675)
We are not talking about old Nokia phones, but perfectly modern phones like those with GrapheneOS, that can be run on cutting-edge hardware, with a secure enclave, does not use Google Play Services by default, and has a high probability of being more secure than iPhone or any Android phone.

It is exactly the kind of alternative that European countries should embrace to become less dependent on US tech.

I am not sure if you are European, but why people are still supporting the GMS Android/iOS duopoly after the US revoked the Google accounts, Office 365 accounts, credit cards, Amazon accounts, etc. of ICC judges is beyond me. Supporting only iOS/Google GMS Android in a government app basically gives the US all the means to blackmail you and/or disrupt your digital infrastructure.

It seems there are still people working for European governments (including developers) who seem to have missed 2025 and the first few months 2026?

We are repeating the same mistakes as depending on Russian oil/gas again.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by p2detar on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:42AM (#47648057)
Do we have stats how many germans use something else than Google Android, Samsung Knox or Apple? I recon it should be less than 1% which quite honestly is in fact „all“ citizens.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by elric on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:04AM (#47648175)
Sure, let's just arbitrarily exclude ~1million people because they're not running the government's preferred American spyware.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by p2detar on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:24AM (#47649771)
This is an unfair and a straw man argument, is it not? Are you also unhappy that in a democracy the 51% choose how the other 49% are going to be governed?

Why device attestation is required is quite well explained by this github comment [0]. I am in the industry and I agree fully with it, because it is a fact a problem for most smart phone users in terms of security.

0 - https://github.com/eu-digital-identity-wallet/eudi-app-andro...

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Hackbraten on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:11AM (#47650249)
I think your analogy is flawed. I can be part of the losing 49% and still be entitled to receive the same services as the 51%, whereas people who chose a privacy-oriented OS are essentially going to be excluded from essential governmental services. That's a whole different kind of thing.

I'm not going to replace my 1200 EUR smartphone with a device that forces me to have an account with Apple or Google. I've been issued a German identity card, which is its own computer that includes a digital identity already. I also own an expensive card reader, which together forms a system that is completely capable of supporting any attestation anyone would need. They should just stop excluding me already.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by p2detar on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:34PM (#47651087)
> privacy-oriented OS

Well, in all seriousness what examples could you give me here in terms of device hardware attestation? Even GrapheneOS does use Google root certificates to attest your device. There is indeed an option for EUDI to keep a list of keys and I bet this is probably the way they are going to go for Android in the future. We shouldn't forget this is still in the planing phase.

> to have an account with Apple or Google.

True for Google, not true for Apple. Device attestation on iOS does not require you to have an iCloud account or sign into some Apple services. It works entirely using device hardware ids.

> I also own an expensive card reader, which together forms a system that is completely capable of supporting any attestation anyone would need.

Nope. This is eID and verifies your identity, it does not attest the security of your hardware. These are two different problems we talk about here.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Hackbraten on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:17PM (#47652263)
> Nope. This is eID and verifies your identity, it does not attest the security of your hardware.

The reader and its firmware is already certified by the federal IT security agency BSI for use with eID and banking. Why shouldn’t I be allowed to use that for whatever digital identity wallet thing the EU is cooking up?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by p2detar on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:49PM (#47652598)
Correct me if I’m wrong please, but this is a mobile Wallet app, an enclave, for government issued documents: Ausweis, Diploma, etc. How does a card reader come into the workflow here? I don’t quite get your point.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Hackbraten on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:23PM (#47652921)
Currently, the card reader is the only thing that allows me to do banking and use government services on Linux. If at some point, governmental services decide to drop support for the physical-card-plus-reader systems and move everything to mobile wallets instead (like many banks already did), then I can’t do shit anymore without Apple or Google.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:32PM (#47651753)
> in all seriousness what examples could you give me here in terms of device hardware attestation?

My Librem 5 runs an FSF-endorsed OS and has a smartcard.

> True for Google, not true for Apple. Device attestation on iOS does not require you to have an iCloud account or sign into some Apple services.

This is extremely misleading. Even if true, you must have an account in order to install any app on an iPhone.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by p2detar on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:38PM (#47652499)
> My Librem 5 runs an FSF-endorsed OS and has a smartcard.

Ok, so how does that help with device attestation? If I am an app developer how does it tell me that your OS has not been tempered with or actually that my app has not been tempered with? Are there any cryptographic keys stored in a secure place on the device that the Librem vendor can verify?

> This is extremely misleading.

But it's not. It's an architectural difference between how Google and Apple implemented attestation. Apple stores the generated keys in a secure part on your device and certifies them. The rest is your job as an app developer. And as a user, you do not have your iCloud or iTunes account used for device attestation. In contrast Google and its Play services are an integral part of the attestation workflow.

For Apple it's evident from their docs. As a side note: I do try to learn more about this, because of an incoming project concerning it.

> You can’t rely on your app’s logic to perform security checks on itself because a compromised app can falsify the results. Instead, you use the shared instance of the DCAppAttestService class in your app to create a hardware-based, cryptographic key that uses Apple servers to certify that the key belongs to a valid instance of your app. Then you use the service to cryptographically sign server requests using the certified key. Your app uses these measures to assert its legitimacy with any server requests for sensitive or premium content.

Source: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/devicecheck/establ...

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:09PM (#47652804)
> If I am an app developer how does it tell me that your OS has not been tempered with or actually that my app has not been tempered with?

This is not your business to verify and control what can run on my phone. I can do it with my smart card, which securely stores cryptographic keys.

> And as a user, you do not have your iCloud or iTunes account used for device attestation.

It does not matter. An account is necessary to make the phone usable at all. The attestation is useless on a phone that can't install apps.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by well_ackshually on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:43PM (#47653095)
>I' ve been issued a German identity card, which is its own computer that includes a digital identity already.

Then keep using it, instead of the not-mandatory app?

> I also own an expensive card reader, which together forms a system that is completely capable of supporting any attestation anyone would need.

Sure. In the mean time, do we tell the other few dozen millions that don't have an expensive card reader to go fuck themselves, or can we get to work on a solution that, even if not ideal, makes their lives easier?

> They should just stop excluding me already.

They aren't. You said it yourself, your ID is in your pocket.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Hackbraten on Monday April 06, 2026 @12:23AM (#47656972)
Government services are going to drop support for the old scheme the minute they start supporting the new one.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by well_ackshually on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:54AM (#47661734)
Sure, that's why they stopped receiving paper letters for tax declarations once they setup Elster.

Oh, wait, they didn't, my bad. You can still declare your taxes with good old paper. The only people that can't are self employed, and that's because they have a different set of obligations with higher demands

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Hackbraten on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:57PM (#47666143)
Telecoms shut down 3G once 4G had rolled out. TV networks killed DVB-T after DVB-T2 went live. Banks have abandoned FinTS for app-based 2FA.

Your comment compares a paper-based, non-digital process with a digital one. My criticism, however, is about abandoning an old digital (but vendor-neutral and inclusionary) process in favor of a new (and discriminatory) one.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by shakna on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:22PM (#47651653)
If it requires a Google or Apple account, then it also requires those companies never cease an account, either. Or vulnerable people will be harmed.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by nothinkjustai on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:02PM (#47652732)
> Are you also unhappy that in a democracy the 51% choose how the other 49% are going to be governed

Yes of course. That is one of it’s fundamental issues.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by elric on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:08AM (#47658176)
That's a silly argument, not only because many important changes require a 2/3 majority.

My point was that the government and its services (German or otherwise) should be available to all citizens/residents, regardless of their choice (or lack) mobile device.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ryandrake on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:05PM (#47651428)
This is a very, VERY stereotypical Tech Product Manager viewpoint: "N% of users are hard to support edge cases, so we should exclude them." You see this justification everywhere in business. "We'll drop support for [old OS] once it gets to 1% of our user base." "Only 1% of our users have non-Latin characters in their usernames so it's OK to not support that." "1% of our users are on 3G or slower Internet connections, so we don't have to consider them in our performance metrics."

It's a pragmatic, profit-oriented point of view, but not one that makes sense when your mission is to be inclusive of everyone.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by type0 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:21AM (#47648272)
In fact „all“ citizens who are willing to be surveilled by Google and Apple, unless German government provides each citizen with similar eID hardware there won't be any digital equality any time soon. Maybe they should pay to some subsidiary company of IBM (like RedHat) to do this, they already have such a good track record of storing nationality on their machines /s

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehomag#Holocaust

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by class4behavior on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:41PM (#47652520)
There's a big difference between having to run a particular company's OS and being forced to share private data (whether that's merely your DNS requests or your ID documents and full financial history). with said organization.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by account42 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:35AM (#47675168)
And backup software should also remove the "restore" option because hardly anyone needs that, right?

Same here, the government shouldn't build a system where two American mega-corporations have the keys to everyone's lives.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:28AM (#47648680)
> Why are we not refusing to implement this until we know we can make it work on all devices?

Simply put: this will never happen. Way too many devices implementations to make this a reality.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:29PM (#47651730)
It's just a matter of creating a web app.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by well_ackshually on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:39PM (#47653064)
And what attestation services does your web app use? Do we lock that web app behind having Secure boot enabled, along with a Java applet for the fun of it?

If your answer is "none", you missed the point.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:46PM (#47653126)
Attestation of what? It's none of your business how I secure and configure my phone. I use a smart card on my Librem 5 btw. See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47647047
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by well_ackshually on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:03PM (#47653309)
My business, no. Your government however, has a few reasons to want to ensure that the ID you're going to use to vote, to prove your identity to any service, etc, etc, does not get passed from device to device.

Configure your phone however you want, then use your physical ID because your phone isn't supported. They're not taking it away. In the same way that you can file your taxes. Having an online filing service doesn't mean you're being "excluded" because your i386 running BeOS isn't part of the supported hardware. Send a letter. It'll still work.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by haagch on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:45PM (#47653689)
I second the question, attestation of what? I have a Solo key that I use with webauthn for several services already. Is that not good enough and even if not, there surely are sufficient alternatives, least of all the actual electronic id on the national id card via nfc?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by miki123211 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:06AM (#47649025)
Do all German hospitals serve vegan food?

If you were averse to carrots (without any health restrictions on eating them), would every government institution in Germany be required to serve you carrot-free food?

If not, why should they be forced to accommodate every smartphone brand in existence, even if there's only 3 people in Germany using it? THe list has to end somewhere.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by RobotToaster on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:53AM (#47649474)
> Do all German hospitals serve vegan food?

Can't speak for Germany, but they do in the UK. It would be illegal discrimination against a belief for them not to.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by vovavili on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:08AM (#47649622)
Subsidizing expensive tastes doesn't strike me as discriminatory.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by RobotToaster on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:54AM (#47650067)
Would you say the same if they refused to serve kosher/halal meals for Muslim/Jewish patients?

UK law protects some philosophical beliefs equally to religions. (what qualifies is a bit of a mess as it's all case law)

(On a practical note, I imagine it's easier for hospitals to just serve vegan food for anyone who is vegetarian/Muslim/Jewish rather than have specific kosher/halal meals)

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by raw_anon_1111 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:19PM (#47652286)
Actual yes since I think all religions are illogical…
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by vovavili on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:07PM (#47653889)
Religion tends to be more constitutive to a person's self-identity than purity signalling dietary trends.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by tga_d on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:01PM (#47654353)
Setting aside the fact that there are multiple very old, very large religions that are nearly or actually vegan (e.g., Jainism), or that people raised vegan can't easily digest meat or animal products, why on earth do you feel that you or a hospital worker are qualified to determine the beliefs making up someone's identity, when you know absolutely nothing about them?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by vovavili on Monday April 06, 2026 @11:36AM (#47662300)
It took Western government institutions hundreds of years of violent conflict to embrace religious tolerance. I don't recall any major intense violent conflict being fought over dietary preferences.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by sotix on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:46AM (#47649990)
Vegetables, legumes, nuts, and grains are not expensive, and veganism is a protected class in the UK.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by plagiarist on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:26PM (#47651008)
Yeah but when you're mad at a nation not force-feeding meat to vegans you have to come up with some reason why the vegans are bad.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by account42 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:32AM (#47675132)
Having a separate option is however not free.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by aziaziazi on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:50AM (#47650030)
Actually the subsidies mostly go to diary farming. Vegan food is cheap to produce but mostly not subsidised. This, plus the (no) economy of scale makes the shelf prices sometimes slightly higher, eg soy milk vs defatted milk.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by conception on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:22PM (#47650971)
Lol at eating just plants as being expensive. You do know where animals that are eaten get their food right?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by account42 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @08:49AM (#47674517)
Mostly from plants that humans can't or at least wouldn't want to eat.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by b112 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:35PM (#47651109)
While the example your provide is reasonable fair, the comparison is not.

For it to be fair comparison, the carrots would have to be grown by a foreign company, known for using unsafe growing practices, causing contamination. Eg, poison carrots. This same company would have to be under the control of a very hostile, very actively aggressive and threatening nation.

Such as one currently threatening to annex allies, among other things.

With the US literally tapping and spying on heads of foreign states:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Parliamentary_Committee...

and there being lots of ways to spy, such as push notifications:

https://www.reuters.com/technology/cybersecurity/governments...

Only insane people would objectively decide to use Google or Apple anything for any form of ID. Those platforms should literally be outlawed. Any use of push notifications or identity attention should be looked at as utter fantasy.

Here's a secret for you. There really isn't any urgent requirement to have an electronic identification method. It can wait. Supporting legislation can be passed first. There are lots of ways to do so.

For example, the entire EU could pass legislation stating that all cell phones have open source code available, including all binary blobs for drivers. And that all phones are unlockable, and that (for example) the phone has a version of the rom you can download without any Google services.

(If Apple isn't able to compete here, well... too bad)

The phones would not be legal to sell, unless the open source firmware was compiled in front of regulators. The point of this is another pet-peeve of mine, it would allow people to support their own phones, for that source code would be released the day that phone was no longer supported.

And yes, it's trivial to have open source firmware blobs. There just isn't a market for it. Pass a law, and sellers of SoC and other ICs will capitulate, or maybe more punitive laws will be passed against them. As someone once said, yes companies can have a lot of sway.

But governments have police, courts, and armies.

Right now, Android and Apple devices are a literal arm of the US government's spying apparatus, even if those two companies actively work against it.

Do not trust Google Play. Do not trust Firebase. Do not trust Google. At all.

Are Germans just too trusting? I remember 15 years ago, when nuclear power plants were closing, concerns were raised about the reliance on Russian natural gas. These were waved away. Russia? What's wrong with Russia! They're almost allies, they're capitalists now!

Don't do this again.

Do NOT trust Google. Don't. Don't make it a core part of any identity management.

Imagine, needing an active Google account to even bank! Or to file your taxes, or even to prove who you are!? Google cancels accounts with no recourse, no reason why, won't help anyone, and this is to be the core of identity management for Germany?

The average person won't even be able to install any German Government designed apps, unless they are on the Play store! Are you going to teach Grandma how to use ADB to install an app? Without an active Google Account, will you even be able to use push notifications?

Why would a government even allow ID to be blocked by the requirement that a company with terrible, horrible, inane customer service, which just kills accounts without recourse, be a gatekeeper?

No Google account, no ID! Wha!?

It's literally not sane.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by LexGray on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:42PM (#47651887)
I think it falls under the article yesterday about male German citizens having restrictions on their travel. Electronic ID is a step toward “papers please”.

Germany at least seems to feel international war is only a few steps away and from how militant the Chinese and Russians have been treating their “territory” I am not sure it is a bad call.

America has likewise turned bad preferring violence over dialogue and loves tracking “hostile influences on the American way of life”. Those influences being anyone who would call out the toxic culprits making America into a cesspit.

Tying to Apple and Google? It is a terrible idea. Both are prone to freeze devices for financial or social issues.

However, a fix I would accept is to force the device makers to support multiple accounts out of box on every device to keep separate what the corporations have proven time and again they cannot be trusted to combine. Also for those companies to be forced to make a cheap credit card sized device which must be held to power on for the few that truly hate the ecosystems.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dudefeliciano on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:25PM (#47652352)
> cheap credit card sized device

I don't understand why this is not the default to be honest, and why people are not advocating for that

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by b112 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:09PM (#47652799)
The first thing to go in every major war, will be the reliably of electronic anything.

What's wrong with ID cards and cash?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by faust201 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:59PM (#47652695)
They do.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by haagch on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:26PM (#47652951)
Lots of hospitals don't even serve healthy food in any sense, so expecting a good coverage of dietary options is optimistic...

But to answer the question in a real way: Veganism is often regarded as just a dietary choice like any other, when in reality courts in several countries have more or less agreed to classify it as a matter of conscience, which would give adherents some right to it. Though it seems German courts have been reluctant to draw much legal consequence from it - so far at least.

So in that sense, I don't think people have been talking about digital sovereignty and abstaining from proprietary software under another country's jurisdiction much as a matter of conscience yet. We can thank Trump that it might actually become a thing though.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by preisschild on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:31PM (#47652985)
You are forgetting that by not allowing more open platforms they effectively force you to accept Apple/Google EULA's essentially forcing you to give your private data to Google/Apple.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dgellow on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:46PM (#47653127)
The ones I’m aware of do, yes
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dabber21 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:17PM (#47650920)
also German here, we have to get rid of the 100% perfection at launch expectation its crippling this country
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ramblerman on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:22PM (#47650973)
Taxpayer money project being tied to a dependency on Apple google is 100% counter what that money should be used for.

You are copy pasting a “correct” argument against eu bureaucracy in the absolute wrong space

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by conception on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:21PM (#47650956)
But things not in the launch can easily be deprioritized as budget issues indefinitely. “Oh why spend the money adding support for just a few people??” will be the line moving forward.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by charcircuit on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:12PM (#47651517)
It would be cheaper to just buy all of the outliers a bottom of the barrel Android phone for them to use with the tax money.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by raw_anon_1111 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:18PM (#47652274)
Yes just like it’s cheaper to just provide people who can’t afford a phone in the US a phone by taxing other cell phone users - and I don’t have a problem with that.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:28PM (#47651712)
And force them into the Google surveillance, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26639261
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by charcircuit on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:47PM (#47651945)
Collecting telemetry is not the same thing as surveillance. Using such vocabulary to describe what a phone does is both misleading and manipulating, playing into the angle of scaremongering people who do not want to be survived.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by haagch on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:49PM (#47652594)
It really doesn't matter. When you power on an android smartphone with google play installed for the first time you are presented with a gate screen that asks you to consent to google's privacy policy. You can't use the phone without accepting. (for example https://forum.fairphone.com/t/finalising-the-setup-wizard-wi...)

Using smartphones with such a setup should not become required by a European government on a fundamental level.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by illiac786 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:49PM (#47656783)
It really does. Just calling everything racism makes racism acceptable to a lot of people.

Telemetry/tracking feels a more appropriate wording than “surveillance”. Exaggeration (in case it was one, not sure) also does not make an argument more compelling – quite the apposite with me at least.

And I use AdGuardHome, uBlock, VPNs, etc. I HATE tracking. But it’s not what the Chinese government does to their citizens for example, it’s not comparable.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:53PM (#47652008)
So please tell us what the difference is.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by charcircuit on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:06PM (#47652142)
With surveillance a person gets surveilled with telemetry a person doesn't. Telemetry is collecting information about the operation of the device. The goal of telemetry is to understand how the device is operating where with surveillance it is about seeing what a person is doing.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by tavavex on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:23PM (#47652326)
The types of data that's collected for these two purposes have a significant overlap.

Sufficiently detailed telemetry is indistinguishable from surveillance because even if the goal isn't to target you right now, they will still have the secondary option of going back and inspecting all that data you sent them if they ever are interested in you. Another secondary use of telemetry is selling it to someone else to squeeze out a bit more money. There's no downside to doing this, so any business that collects a lot of varied telemetry and likes making money might as well do it. And once the data is in the hands of adtech businesses, it becomes a whole lot more like tracking you personally than just collecting some data for development. In Google's case, you don't even need to hand it over to anyone else, everything stays in-house.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dmantis on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:00PM (#47653278)
Do you imply that it's not possible for the US intelligence agencies to request this data from google per person of interest and deliver some information from the metadata?

I heavily doubt that.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by preisschild on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:28PM (#47652962)
What does it matter in practice? Do you seriously think Google, the targeted advertisement company, does not use that Telemetry for targeted advertisements?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by charcircuit on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:57PM (#47653793)
Yes, I do seriously think that Google does not use anonymous telemetry for ad targeting.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:49AM (#47661666)
Do you have any reason to think this? Why would Google refuse to earn more money?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by AJ007 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:13PM (#47652226)
Are you a lobbyist for Google, Apple, Meta, or the adtech industry? Because if you aren't, you are parroting their bullshit.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dns_snek on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:14PM (#47653432)
[delayed]
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by charcircuit on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:58PM (#47653801)
The pro consumer standpoint is overly represented on this platform so often I can simply upvote points I agree with.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by charcircuit on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:56PM (#47653786)
I am not a lobbyist, but I do recognize the great value the adtech industry provides to society and I am familiar with the common arguments and strategies people try and use to undermine it and sow distrust.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by allarm on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:09PM (#47656187)
> I do recognize the great value the adtech industry provides to society

good one, very funny.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:05AM (#47657778)
Any articles highlighting the great value?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by newdee on Monday April 06, 2026 @05:24AM (#47658638)
Genuinely curious to hear what great value you think is being delivered to society by adtech.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jamesnorden on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:52AM (#47659717)
>but I do recognize the great value the adtech industry provides to society

Ok, so you're trolling then.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by tremon on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:00PM (#47653279)
This is not about 100% perfection at launch, this is about civil equality. Launching without broad support for use cases creates a two-tier society.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fsflover on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:15PM (#47652853)
Refusing to send all your private data to the US to benefit their megacorps, using the tax payers' money, is not "perfection". It is the only reasonable and legal choice.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by josefx on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:22PM (#47650975)
A 10% goal would be a good first step. Now excuse me while I read some tea leaves to find out if my trains will be on time tomorrow ( spoiler: they wont).
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dudefeliciano on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:23PM (#47652328)
surely 10% of DB digital offerings work as expected, just not the 10% that is essential for train travel.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by josefx on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:50AM (#47658060)
I love how just ordering a ticket is already a minefield for anyone not aware of how crappy german services are integrated. Pick one route, you will get a list of fully customized tickets that cover everything you need, pick another and you will get a list of tickets that will get you fined unless you carefully read through each and pick both a ticket that comes close to what you need and buy more tickets to cover any additional options.

The only thing near 100% perfection when it comes to german services is the full assery with which they are implemented.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dudefeliciano on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:03AM (#47658142)
So much hate.

Some time ago my "25% DB Card" ran out and was not active anymore, but the app did not display a warning. Even when buying a ticket from the app, it still had the "25% off" option activated by default.

Result: huge fine (something like 200 euros) on the train + I had to buy a completely new ticket (another 100+ euros) because the ticket I had bought ( which was 75% of original price) was considered completely invalid. I tried in all possible ways to get this fine reduced, as it was an honest mistake and arguably caused by their UX, but they did not budge.

I hate hate hate Deutsche Bahn with a passion, yet I still use it cause I'm an idiot who doesn't want to fly for short routes.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by like_any_other on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:55PM (#47651321)
> it will not serve all citizens

This is an understatement. Better phrasing would be "when it allows two unaccountable foreign companies to lock citizens out of the digital market".

There are plenty of horror stories of tech giants frivolously banning people. We shouldn't be adding state support to that. I don't want to lose access to digital banking because of some deliberately vague "community guidelines" violation, or because I got mass-reported to some "e-safety" provider that both Apple and Google outsource to.

Sibling comments see this as a good solution, just not a perfect one. I see it as making a bad problem worse.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by gmueckl on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:36PM (#47651815)
You have the totally wrong expectations here. Some service that requires citizens to buy and bring their own devices in order to use a service will by definition always be exclusive. Whining about lacking compatibility with some niche sbowflake devices is just inappropriate in this context. The only solutiin is to require an actually convenient fallback for those otherwise excluded from that service.

The limited selection of attestation providers can be criticized for many other reasons, though.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by class4behavior on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:32PM (#47652428)
Your disdain isn't helpinh you here either as you're just as wrong as parent.

Such public utilities ought to always prioritize privacy, platform-independence, and empowering market competion long- and short-term. And to achieve that you need to start at the design level.

In this case, clearly, you either have to avoid relying on app attestation or lay the foundation for an unrestricted number of independent chain of trust frameworks.

The latter, of course, is a policy-level issue, but the ones responsible for the design and development are the ones who need to pass such concerns up the chain.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by gmueckl on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:06PM (#47653333)
You have the right starting point, but the wrong conclusion. Government services need to be inclusive of everybody. But you simply cannot build technical solutions that put technical requirements on devices owned by the users in a way that the service is sufficiently inclusive. That is just a fact.

If you want to be critical of the outcome on compatibility grounds, forcing a grind to increase technical compatibility is the wrong thing to ask for. That must necessarily always leave some people behind. The only honest alternative positions on that front are (a) the government issues the tech to everybody itself or (b) the government doesn't build advanced systems at all.

The German government offices rely on a lot of quaint-looking paper based processes, but they have one thing going for them: working through them can be done with pen and paper - tools that are available for cheap and broadly compatible. It's probably not such a bad thing after all?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by class4behavior on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:06PM (#47653877)
Inclusivity is secondary here. Moreover, it's just fallacious to argue the nation has to give up on its own rights and principles and be content with whatever the market provides.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by raw_anon_1111 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:16PM (#47652253)
Because you can’t please all of the people. And before someone likens it to the ADA. Even with accommodations you have to make, car makers aren’t for instance required to make cars that blind people can drive.

You chose to use a non mainstream platform. Thats on you.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by haagch on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:14PM (#47664700)
Sure.

Something I forgot to mention is that the UBPorts foundation whose mobile operating system I currently use is a German organization.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by illiac786 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:53PM (#47656801)
You are assuming it will not be possible to add support to other OS. Why?

What would be “knowing it can work on grapheneOS” for example, in your view?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:41AM (#47659624)
It will be possible but simply won't be done.

And as of now it won't work on GrapheneOS, it doesn't pass anything except MEETS_BASIC_INTEGRITY

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by illiac786 on Monday April 06, 2026 @03:19PM (#47665571)
That’s not what the parent wrote though.

And why is it so bad that they start with a smaller subset of feature and target the 99% of the population using either google or apple?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Thursday April 09, 2026 @11:00AM (#47704659)
This is a misleading way to put it.

Re: Android.

Goggle can supports AOSP attestation like any other vendor who wants to support it. They invented it.

So instead of immediately locking down everyone using android to ONLY Google-dependent method, I'd developers could go the vendor agnostic way, but consciously decided not to.

It's untrue to claim that supporting AOSP attestation only serves GrapheneOS and leaves out everyone using Google-surveiled handset.

Nb, mixing it up with Apple is a conscious way to further the false claim, and I believe it's not accidental since these ecosystems are naturally completely separate.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by illiac786 on Thursday April 09, 2026 @11:22AM (#47704934)
You are misleading in fact, you use terms such as:

“it won’t work on GrapheneOS” “locking down everyone using android to ONLY Google-dependent method”

which make it sound like it’s a permanent and definitive limitation.

It is not, they can add support later, as they stated already.

> It's untrue to claim that supporting AOSP attestation only serves GrapheneOS and leaves out everyone using Google-surveiled handset.

hmmm, what do you have in mind? Publish it to F-Droid but not to the google app store?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Saturday April 11, 2026 @08:41AM (#47730092)
I indeed said "locking down everyone (...) to only Google-depended method"

It is a permanent limitation until it's resolved by the vendor, isn't?

You are phrasing it like it was untrue that on non-Google Androids it will work.

It's false - it will not, until it's fixed (changed).

They CAN add the alternative methods later but until they added they're not there.

So it's a permanent failure until (not unless) until it's resolved by either removing the hard dependency on Google Play Integrity or adding alternative attestation methods.

And your last comment about FDroid is a little bizarre to be honest - if it's meant to be available it must be on the Google Play too.

I was just objecting the suggestion that ADDING alternative methods of attestation somehow precludes devs from using Google play integrity as well.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by illiac786 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @10:00AM (#47730685)
What’s a temporary failure then for you, I’m curious? Everything is permanent, following your definition.

You didn’t answer my question. I don’t understand what you are suggesting. You want them to do AOSP at the same time rather than afterward? You simply disagree with they prioritisation? They stop using words like lockdown, it’s misleading. Say “I wish they had included AOSP support in the initial release” then everyone understand what you want.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by nip on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:43AM (#47648063)
In light of all of these shortcomings with platform attestation, why go with the eIDAS 2 wallet approach at all? eIDAS 1 already solved this with Mobile-ID (SIM-based, no Google/Apple dependency) and Smart-ID (server-side key management with minimal platform reliance). What does the wallet model give you that justifies this level of dependency on two American corporations’ proprietary backends?

Especially considering that mobile-ID has been around since 2007.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Avamander on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:48AM (#47648403)
SIM-based solutions are on their way out because phones are starting to lose SIM slots. Certifying eSIM implementations is way too difficult. At least for one country doing it alone.

Smart-ID sucks. It's not truly hardware-backed, it's proprietary and has fundamental flaws like not having a direct link between the site being authenticated to and the authenticating device (auth can be proxied, just like if it were just plain TOTP).

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by nip on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:33AM (#47648719)
Agree on Smart-ID but the answer is to fix those flaws, not to replace the entire approach with one that depends on Google Play Integrity verdicts that even the German architects admit they can’t fully trust.

SIM-based solutions on their way out is a non-issue. For eSIM to support that use case, political will only is needed: the EU got Apple to abandon the lightning cable, this is not any different.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Avamander on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:39AM (#47648776)
> Agree on Smart-ID but the answer is to fix those flaws

Fundamentally can't be, it'd be a whole new solution.

> For eSIM to support that use case, political will only is needed: the EU got Apple to abandon the lightning cable, this is not any different.

Mandate every phone vendor to EAL4(+) certify their eSIMs? I'd love to see that, but I'm not sure that's a viable approach to take.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by nip on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:51AM (#47648110)
I’m sorry to lash out at you but I keep getting disappointed in European countries (more precisely the ever disappointing EU commission) all suffering of the NIH syndrome instead of collaborating and learning from each other
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:39AM (#47648780)
There is mothing to be gained politically by doing this. You think you look good if you say “hey, the Poles had this really good idea, how about we do the same”?

Plus, the process is something like:

- we want to do $something

- hire consultants to help us define $something and produce a document

- hire other consultants to write the specs for the project

- launch an RFP

- select a winner

- wait for the implementation to finish

All the proposed solutions will be something paid, ideally made by a really large company to lend it credibility, and with maintenance costs that justify hiring dedicated people for it.

In the end no one gets what they want.

You think if there was any will wouldn’t the whole EU use whatever the Estonians are doing very well?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jen20 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:56AM (#47648941)
> You think you look good if you say “hey, the Poles had this really good idea, how about we do the same”?

Yes.

> You think if there was any will wouldn’t the whole EU use whatever the Estonians are doing very well?

Using the Estonian system would be vastly preferable.

If politics doesn’t allow that, the political environment is broken.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by grundrausch3n on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:35PM (#47651108)
How is the Estonian system now? I remember when I visited around 2010 our host just had a quite simple smart card reader and could just use it to sign in to government services with their ID and as far as I remember even sign mails and documents. Germany of course could not use normal smart cards but had to use NFC cards with special readers and made the signing feature and additional service you had to pay for on a yearly basis. Of course the Germans system did not went anywhere for years. I do have a reader now and can use it for some governmental services and have very limited appetite to bind the ID to my phone.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by pas on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:54PM (#47654754)
Ukraine also seems to have solved this pretty well. NFC in the plastic card, selfie video confirmation, etc.

Hungary is also rolling out a "digital citizenship" app. (Also can be bootstrapped via newer plastic cards, so no need to visit the government office.)

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mytailorisrich on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:24AM (#47648290)
Isn't the eIDAS 2 wallet approach a legal requirement of eIDAS 2 (which is an EU regulation, i.e. the law).
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by nip on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:31AM (#47648320)
It is, mandated by the EU commission.

Instead they could have mandated the use of eIDAS 1 to all countries + extend it with attribute/credential support, and let countries choose their implementation (cards, SIM, server-side).

Instead we’re back to the drawing board with the big shortcomings highlighted in this thread.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mytailorisrich on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:45AM (#47648389)
Oh OK, I understand your point now.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by pwlb on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:42PM (#47652533)
EIDAS 2 motivation is implicitly that eID failed in eIDAS 1. It simply either didn't take off or didn't work at all
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by EmbarrassedHelp on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:34PM (#47656340)
They are also trying to shoehorn in age verification with it.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by isodev on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:16AM (#47648243)
> The initial limitation to Google/Android is not great

It’s also illegal on both accessibility grounds as well as violating the eIDAS spirit of no dependency on specific providers.

By shrugging it off as “not great”, you’re also dooming every citizen to have to comply with whatever whimsical terms of service Google and Apple have.

Have you ever tried to unban your Apple/Google account? So in effect, everyone’s access to eID services will depend on some crappy automation some intern in California setup to detect “abuse” or whatever.

There are technical solutions to avoid this dependency and you’re probably getting paid to find, research and adopt them. So … do your job?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by verbalize2224 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:21AM (#47647591)
You should think about how easy it is to permanently lose access to your Google account for very trivial issues and Google doesn't offer any form of recovery. That in addition to the current geopolitical situation should be reason enough not to rely on that for any justification.

And personally as a software developer myself i know that nothing is more permanent than a temporary solution. No one will prioritize or give budget to change it later "because it works"

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by trklausss on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:03AM (#47647826)
What? They should freaking think of sanctions, not about "how easy is to lose Google account". Both Google and Apple are American companies. If someone lands on a sanctions list, they close your account without further notice [1].

Let me get this straight: you can be a defender of human rights, aligned with the country you live in, but if you fall in disgrace with the American government, _you can't even do transactions with your own country_.

So this is fundamentally flawed, and violates the fundamental rights of German citizens in Germany.

[1] https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/british-icc-chief-prosecutor-l...

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by extraduder_ire on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:21AM (#47647935)
His wife and kids are sanctioned too. Sometimes it isn't even anything you did.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by applfanboysbgon on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:12AM (#47647877)
Sanctions are a bonus point argument, but shouldn't be a factor either. No citizen should be subjected to this, whether the company running it is American or German. Can you imagine if the Nazis had this level of control in the 1930s? Imagine having your ID digitally revoked, effectively cutting you out of society completely, without so much as an attic to hide in before it can happen. This is a completely dystopian legislation from start to finish. There is no possible way this can ever provide a benefit to the German people, it exists only to control them.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by GoblinSlayer on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:58AM (#47648142)
Can't you just make a new google account then?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:40AM (#47650516)
That's crazy.

Imagine cheering for the company that will block the criminal prosecutors investigating war crimes and genocide from having the ID at all(1) once the supporter of the investigated sanctions the law-abiding persons: https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/02/impo...

But anyway - why the requirement in the first place?

(1) because sanctioned person must not be allowed to create another account.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by GoblinSlayer on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:32PM (#47651066)
It's puzzling how such sanctions are enforceable in the first place. If the person published their phone number then maybe, but if not then little can be done to identify them.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by KellyCriterion on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:07PM (#47652788)
....with a new phone number....
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ghighi7878 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:41AM (#47647714)
Tbh, I feel this is stupid.

Banks are giving out QR Tan. Optical TAN devices which work with credit cards and it has been going pretty well. Why can eiDAS not have something similar. Distribute hardware tokens. Get rid of dependency on any OS.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by pwlb on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:20AM (#47647924)
Banks actually have high fraud rates today because of weak security mechanisms. If attackers steal your money, the bank will reimburse you. If attackers steal your identity, you are really screwed. Security requirements for banking and identity are simply different.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ulrikrasmussen on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:31AM (#47648322)
Please give some evidence that this is due to hardware tokens failing where a smartphone based solution would have prevented it
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ghighi7878 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:58AM (#47648143)
Mobile Google account based is even weaker than hardware tokens used by banks. Make of that what you will.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by GoblinSlayer on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:21AM (#47648274)
If they use SSN as a password, it doesn't mean you can't have something slightly more reasonable without going full cyberpunk dystopia.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mariusor on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:04AM (#47647829)
I'm pretty sure electronic IDs are a good starting point for exactly this. Hopefully they get wider use inside the EU.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dudefeliciano on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:50PM (#47652614)
why do you hope that?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mariusor on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:23AM (#47658247)
Because there are many interesting uses for having a personal electronic token that's also recognized by your own government. My own interest is in using it as a base for establishing an identity for electronic ballots.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dudefeliciano on Monday April 06, 2026 @04:27AM (#47658269)
sure but I don't understand how electronic IDs are a good starting point for having QR TAN or some other hardwarde device. I think OS-agnostic hardware should be the default starting point, not the other way around.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mariusor on Monday April 06, 2026 @06:09AM (#47658955)
The electronic ID hosts a cryptographic key that can be used through some sort of hardware device in order to generate QR codes, or whatever that are linked to the user's official identity...

The public part of the identity (which in our example it was enrolled at bank account opening) can be used by the server that checks the QR code to see if it actually belongs to the correct account owner.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Avamander on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:29AM (#47648691)
Plenty of EU countries have rolled out SmartCards for this exact purpose, some are now adding NFC functionality. Nothing really stops Germany from continuing like that either.

The issue then becomes the UI/UX. If the legal mandate is not strong enough the solution will not gain enough ground. You can see this if you start comparing those countries with an eID rolled out.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by omnibrain on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:21PM (#47651636)
The German ID card (Personalausweis) supports certificates and communication via NFC. I really don’t understand what’s all this about?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ghighi7878 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:19PM (#47654944)
This is about what device you use to verify this. Currently, the ausweisapp on android allows you to authenticate to your authorities. However, this can also be done with a TAN generator and a user name and password like banks do.and them you dont need to depend on a trusted mobile phone.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by notpushkin on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:57AM (#47647786)
Just a quick question, and sorry if it might have been answered already... why preventing duplication is so important? I know it’s in the spec probably [1], but I can’t figure out the reason.

And a suggestion: add external HSM support at least? (e.g. things like NitroKey/YubiKey)

[1]: https://eudi.dev/latest/architecture-and-reference-framework... I suppose?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by pwlb on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:17AM (#47647905)
Preventing credential duplication is a requirement to achieve high level of assurance. One of its purpose is to limit the potential damage that can be done by attacks. If credentials are bound to hardware-bound keys, attackers will always need access to this key store to make any miss-use. If you don't prevent duplication, attackers may extract credentials and miss-use them at a 1000 places simultaneously.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:55AM (#47649505)
Okay, but Google certifies phones which are not updates for the last several years.

They can be trivially rooted, then they spoof the signature and get a pass in Integrity while being wide open for malware (or cooying the ID, ID presume).

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by pwlb on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:48PM (#47652585)
The documentation clearly outlines that there are multiple signals being analysed. Relying on play integrity alone is definitely not sufficient as you state.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:46AM (#47659676)
Okay, I meant that Google issuing a "pass" is worthless, yet it's being used as a mandatory signal.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by notpushkin on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:08AM (#47647851)
I’ve just had another, completely stupid but not implausible, idea:

> a local internal WSCD, which is a component within the User device, such as a SIM, e-SIM, or embedded Secure Element,

So you could issue SIM-cards / eSIM profiles that only do signatures and nothing else. The app then connects to such eSIM (and you keep your main SIM/eSIM in another slot).

The less stupid variant is, of course, to get mobile operators to issue SIM cards with e-sign capabilities. Estonia has that, for example: https://www.id.ee/en/mobile-id/

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Avamander on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:34AM (#47648741)
> The less stupid variant is, of course, to get mobile operators to issue SIM cards with e-sign capabilities. Estonia has that, for example: https://www.id.ee/en/mobile-id/

It works great. Just keep in mind that newer phones are starting to deprecate physical SIM slots. At the same time certifying eSIM implementations to the same EAL level is an absolutely crazy task.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by notpushkin on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:00AM (#47659289)
> At the same time certifying eSIM implementations to the same EAL level is an absolutely crazy task.

It probably is, but it does make sense. eSIM standards were built to solve pretty much the same problem (make cloning eSIM profiles impossible), so it should be a good anchor of trust for that.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Archelaos on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:56AM (#47647782)
German citizen here. I find this attitude horrible and threatening. You are working on sacrificing yet another part of our digital sovereignty to a US company. There are trillions of better things to do with your life.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by sam_lowry_ on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:37AM (#47648029)
European Citizen here, and indeed lots of people in IT turn a blind eye onto the collateral damage their work may create.

I know someone who happily codes "verifiable credentials" in Elixir, disregarding all externalities.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by oytis on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:54PM (#47652017)
What's wrong with verifiable credentials? It's an important thing to have it seems? Your passport or a bank card are verifiable credentials, or at least are designed to be.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by sam_lowry_ on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:03PM (#47653851)
It's an EU thing, overcomplicated an not sovereign:

https://ec.europa.eu/digital-building-blocks/sites/spaces/EB...

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by oytis on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:40PM (#47654687)
Oh dear, web 3.0, blockchain. Do we get our sovereign monkey NFT too?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by esbranson on Monday April 06, 2026 @05:15PM (#47667225)
Verifiable credentials (VCs) are W3C standards and do not involve blockchains. Nor does Web 3.0.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by sam_lowry_ on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:02AM (#47672472)
Tell this your parlamenentarian.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by NanoCoaster on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:32AM (#47647997)
Will eIDAS be the only way to identify yourself in cases where it's needed, or will we be able to user other mechanisms like the german ID card stuff or an entirely separate alternative?

Or to put it another way, is a smartphone required? If not, that would already clear up a lot of issues, I think.

EDIT: Whoops, just saw the answer to another comment asking precisely this. So it's not a requirement. Good. Is there a legal framework that ensures that this remains the case? Otherwise, I fear it will become a de facto requirement over time.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jech on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:26AM (#47648661)
One datapoint: at least in practice, it used to be impossible to delete an entry in the French INPI database (trademarks and company names) without eIDAS. It forced me to unearth an old unmodified Android phone (I run LineageOS on my main phone).

If you read French:

* https://www.plus.transformation.gouv.fr/experiences/4531155_...

* https://linuxfr.org/users/jch-2/journaux/l-identite-numeriqu...

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by NanoCoaster on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:21PM (#47650959)
Oof, that's disappointing to hear. Thanks though, that's actually quite interesting.

I'm also thinking of keeping an android phone purely for auth purposes, separate from my main one. The world's most overengineered (and probably also less safe) Yubikey.

> If you read French

Let's see how far my five years of French at school will get me. I'm not getting my hopes up ;)

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Aachen on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:23PM (#47650985)
Also if you are legally required to be able to use some backup mechanism, it can become the de facto requirement
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by codethief on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:52AM (#47648425)
> The initial limitation to Google/Android is not great, we know that, and we have support for other OSs on our list (like, e.g., GrapheneOS).

GrapheneOS uses standard Android APIs for hardware attestation (as opposed to Google-specific ones), so why don't you just use those from the get-go?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by izacus on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:35PM (#47655075)
They did. This is why Graphene works.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by codethief on Monday April 06, 2026 @06:20AM (#47659023)
Call me confused. The comment I was responding to is saying something different:

> The initial limitation to Google/Android is not great, we know that, and we have support for other OSs on our list (like, e.g., GrapheneOS).

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by izacus on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @02:43PM (#47694465)
Yes, they still need to audit and whitelist the builds of GrapheneOS. That's what "standard APIs" are - they identify a build of OS, but someone still needs to make sure it's secure.

If you don't want Google to do that for you, then the app developer has to.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:59AM (#47659778)
They said they have GOS support in the roadmap, meaning they know it doesn't work but pinky promise to work on it in some undisclosed future.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ibbtown on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:22AM (#47647598)
Why is a trusted device chain needed? It will put more trust in the potential Chinese device maker and American software companies than the user who's id is shown?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by pwlb on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:38AM (#47648032)
This is necessary because the wallets contain an identity proofing functionality called PID(Person Identification Data). Showing these credentials basically approves you are you. There are high requirements for identity proofing that even pre-date wallets and that makes sense, because the potentially blast radius of identity theft is huge. Historically, these have been secured in smartcards, like eID cards or passports and are not shifting to the smartphone. Verifying the security posture of your device and app is therefore crucial.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:28AM (#47650410)
OK, but Google will happily confirm android device running Oreo is safe.

While it's dramatically worse than devices Google refuses to certify (ie these not running their spyware as privileged services).

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by oytis on Sunday April 05, 2026 @01:05PM (#47651425)
What do you mean "shifting to smartphone"? It's not a natural process - it's a technical decision to shift them to the smartphone, and a really bad one. We already have smart cards, they work and do not depend on any corporations, even less foreign corporations.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by zb3 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:40PM (#47654157)
We even have smartcards with e-ink displays and I'd personally want them to succeed here instead of moving security-critical apps to smartphones..

Because Google then abuses its position to inject unremovable spyware with elevated privileges into the phone which the user then can't defent against without making the phone "unsecure" and thus unsuitable for these apps.

If these apps really need a smartphone, I'd at least want it to be free of ad-related garbage in the system. I'm fine with not being able to flash a custom ROM on the smartcard as it doesn't contain hostile software.

Now if even Apple starts showing ads, there's no other choice but to restist this..

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by kodebach on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:32AM (#47647667)
Simply because the law was written that way. But also the whole idea of identity verification becomes pretty useless, if there is no chain of trust. You could run a modified client that lets you assume any identity you choose, exactly the opposite of what eIDAS is trying to achieve.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by notpushkin on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:38AM (#47647689)
> You could run a modified client that lets you assume any identity you choose

Provided you know the secret key to a government-issued certificate. Making it impossible to copy said certificate is not really a requirement for identity verification.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:33AM (#47650462)
Some countries fixed it already, see Estonian ir Polish IDs with digital layer (performing signing, authentication, etc), and the devices only acting as untrusted interfaces to these.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by notpushkin on Monday April 06, 2026 @06:31AM (#47659101)
It’s still impossible to extract an Estonian certificate from the smart card (or Mobiil-ID/Smart-ID), no?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:19AM (#47659437)
I believe do, I didn't see a successful attack yet.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by kro on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:10AM (#47647866)
It will likely display something like a QR Code with signature anyways, otherwise it's just a glorified passport picture?

Authorities/anyone could verify that it's not counterfeit. And photo should be checked anyways to match the person.

So I also don't see the need for attestation. For ID check it should be ok without. For signing stuff ofc it is not resistant to copying. But EID smartcard function already exists.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by sam_lowry_ on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:10AM (#47647864)
Who wrote that law and why, this is the question.

I think we need some fingerpointing that EU officials strive to avoid.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:31AM (#47650450)
But you can run modified client already.

Rooted, wildly insecure devices can pass the attestation easily: https://magisk.dev/modules/play-integrity-fix-inject/

Safe, updated devices cannot unless they permit Google to run their surveillance services in the privileged, unconstrained mode.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by pwlb on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:53PM (#47652631)
The documentation actually reveals why this will most likely not work, given you are on expert on mobile security
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Monday April 06, 2026 @07:24AM (#47659478)
Oh, you don't say. The above was a link to the source module, but ad with magisk there are many ways to peel the potato.

I've see countless users confirming it works for them, for example by using this workflow: https://magiskzip.com/how-to-pass-integrity-with-strong-chec...

But as an expert on the mobile security you can assure us its not possible to spoof Google play integrity pass with Magisk - am I right?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by vaylian on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:57AM (#47647785)
Thank you for chiming in.

> We have to use some kind of attestation mechanism per the eIDAS implementing acts.

What does this attestation need to prove? Is this only about ensuring that private keys are managed by a secure enclave or a TPM?

> we have support for other OSs on our list (like, e.g., GrapheneOS)

I appreciate that, even though I am really not enthusiastic of eIDAS. But time will tell. Thank you.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:25AM (#47650384)
They won't implement alternatives later, they'll be no point if "most of out customers is using either of the major providers".

Concerning secure enclave - what other device except iphones and Pixels have it actually safe?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Aachen on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:25PM (#47651006)
The nfc chips in identity documents
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by vaylian on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:10PM (#47652195)
> They won't implement alternatives later, they'll be no point if "most of out customers is using either of the major providers".

It's hard for me to assess the effort needed here, but I guess that the GrapheneOS implementation will be 99% like the regular Android implementation. Supporting both systems does not seem to be that unrealistic.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:09AM (#47659855)
But the "regular android implementation" they decided to choose now is not the regular android implementation (AOSP), they're relying on the signal from Google running play store integrity checks.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by longdidi on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:53AM (#47647766)
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:25AM (#47650389)
They don't really want to.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by tadfisher on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:52PM (#47654749)
That "guide" is kinda shit, there is massive work to do for an actual attestation implementation that replaces Play Integrity and supports the various backend frameworks.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by tannhaeuser on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:22AM (#47647941)
You must go back to the drawing board and rely on highly-regulated Telecom standards (that's why they were mandated in the first place!) not monopolistic defacto "best practices" you have no influence over because they're more convenient for you.

This is simply unconstitutional and should be escalated ASAP if you don't want to end it before the appropriate court in Leipzig, Karlsruhe, or maybe Luxembourg.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by gorgoiler on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:23AM (#47647945)
I know it’s not quite the same thing as an OS vendor, but culturally, if you’re having trouble empathizing with the ick in this thread then imagine if the initial implementation was available only for account holders with Facebook, Yahoo! Mail, or MySpace.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by eMPee584 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:37AM (#47648026)
There's a new initiative by some non-google non-apple phone vendors called *UnifiedAttestation* which I hope you will support at some point in the future:

https://www.heise.de/en/news/Paying-without-Google-New-conso...

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by oytis on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:27AM (#47647981)
I don't get it. Are mechanisms in our ID cards not strong enough so that we have to rely on the security of the operating system?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by chaz6 on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:45AM (#47648388)
Have you considered Unified Attestation [1] which is an alternative to Google's?

[1] https://uattest.net/

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by tadfisher on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:54PM (#47654762)
Oh dang, this is exactly what I've been looking for. Thank you.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by EmbarrassedHelp on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:36PM (#47656352)
That just puts the power to allow/ban rooting and operating systems in the hands of a different set of companies. Its still unacceptable.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by zajio1am on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:01AM (#47648476)
Why not just use U2F or certificates on crypto-tokens?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by zajio1am on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:02AM (#47648490)
Note that for eIDAS 1, a Czechia e-identity provider uses U2F tokens.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by oakpond on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:11AM (#47648211)
Shouldn't the energy instead be focused on creating a standardized eIDAS driver API that OS vendors are required to implement?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by regnerd on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:33AM (#47648005)
that‘s not correct. Article 5 eIDAS2 explicitly states, that europeans exercise full control over their data. Therefore EUDI wallet must not be a walled garden. Especially if the wallet shall be used for authenticating and signing, it must be available to all europeans, even those sanctioned by the US.

If this is your plan, please go back to the drawing board.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by khalic on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:06AM (#47647837)
It's insane to make yourselves US dependent from the very beginning, at least provide something like a crypto-key that you can get from an official, banks can do it, so can you.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by utopiah on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:12AM (#47648216)
> The initial limitation to Google/Android [...] is simply a matter of where we focus our energy at the moment

Nice... so the rush is to delegate power to the large American platform?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ulrikrasmussen on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:30AM (#47648313)
This is simply unacceptable. You are not making an innocent pragmatic compromise here, you are launching digital infrastructure which initially will tie everyone to Google/Apple and give alternatives a huge disadvantage for an unknown amount of time. Nobody knows when, or even if ever, support for open platforms will arrive.

You should be ashamed of being involved in this monopoly handover to American big tech.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by aenis on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:47AM (#47649403)
Fingers crossed for the judiciary - if the implementers ignore the intention of the law, then lawyers will have to help them understand the limits of corner cutting - and block this.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:01AM (#47649565)
I bet £50 that the alternative (eg GrapheneOS attestation (based on the standard AOSP attestation)) will be delayed, then delayed, then scrapped since almost everyone is using Google Plag integrity anyway.

Yes, I assume malicious intent, sorry, seen this happen enough tines recently.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by tadfisher on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:51PM (#47654742)
I'm in the US, not facing a mandate, but I want an open-source alternative to Play Integrity to use in the financial sector. There should be no excuse for anyone not supporting GrapheneOS. I've asked on Google's issue tracker and they are not interested in opening the program to non-OHA ("Google Play Approved") participants.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:06AM (#47659826)
Indeed. Goggle is very hostile to anyone not wanting Google deep in their OS, running undisclosed code with the superuser privileges.

I think we all collectively should try the compliance / regulatory ways to force enough companies to have to adkit they know Google lies about security when talking about attestation, then force them into supporting alternative attestation methods.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by anonzzzies on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:57AM (#47647789)
I think it should be possible IMHO, like it is for many banks (still), to get a hardware token and then use whatever hardware/browser. Even a nice EU hardware token which allows banks , govs etc to add their keys/seeds in the enclave would be nicer so I don't have the lug 1000 tokens around, but it's still better than having to trust non sovereign companies for anything without backup; like multiple here said; Google/Apple getting the command from the Dep of War to shut down EU phone attestation, you losing your account etc, or, you know, me simply not wanting to use their stuff.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:36AM (#47649304)
The hardware tokens ate being phased out by banks and replaced with SMS OTP codes + passwords.

Cost saving measures.

Its funny to see that I can access the bank account through FaceID but to actually make a payment I need to use an SMS code.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by gmerc on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:59AM (#47648147)
“Not Great” is the understatement of the century. It fails to protect sovereign identity by handing the default to companies not only under foreign sanctions control but who also lock people from their accounts without recourse.

The device chain is a classic misdirection, it seems everyone here is just following Meta’s lobbying to put this into the OS.

Even the carrier layer would be better than the mobile device layer.

Or, you know, just look at Singapore’s or Swiss National SSO - it functions on an app that layer just fine, no issues.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jonathanstrange on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:23AM (#47647944)
Another German citizen here. I think what you're doing is illegal and will be blocked by German courts.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by 0x3f on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:52AM (#47648115)
It's funny because this is also the exact German response for when your neighbour has an unsanctioned BBQ.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by retired on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:15AM (#47647893)
Perhaps look at the Spanish Cl@ve, it works with Linux. It's just a simple digital certificate that allows you to identify yourself.

You can even run it on OpenBSD or TempleOS if you want to.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by egorfine on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:05AM (#47647831)
> That doesn't work without operating system support

Do you realize where this path is going?

Certain European governments would have greatly benefited from KYC/attestation in the late 1930s had it existed.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by elric on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:06AM (#47648184)
Yup. But apparently the EU is refusing to take lessons from history.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by gambiting on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:23AM (#47648637)
Germany is just part of EU - as many other people pointed out, there is no requirement from the EU to implement it this way. Same as California or New York making extremely Draconian laws around 3D printing doesn't represent all of US.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by bakugo on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:16AM (#47648242)
> We have to use some kind of attestation mechanism per the eIDAS implementing acts.

Sounds like these "eIDAS implementing acts" are the problem, and were influenced by ulterior motives.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by reconnecting on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:31AM (#47647659)
Humiliating disregard for sovereignty.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by brador on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:24AM (#47647612)
Google has banned many accounts of genuine users.

What is your fallback for such an important vital service?

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by notpushkin on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:34AM (#47647675)
To play the devil’s advocate here: MEETS_STRONG_INTEGRITY on Android doesn’t require a Google account AFAIK. But it might change, of course.

Edit: but as pointed out elsewhere in the thread, Play Integrity is not the only way to do hardware attestation on Android. GrapheneOS devs have a guide: https://grapheneos.org/articles/attestation-compatibility-gu...

So avoiding proprietary Google stuff altogether is possible and we should encourage it.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Monday April 06, 2026 @08:47AM (#47660228)
How do you propose running Google play checks on the phone without working Google play? :)

I don't think it's possible. And indeed, avoiding is possible and better, but the companies choose lie of play store "integrity".

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by notpushkin on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:58AM (#47685924)
For Play Integrity, you do have to have the Play Services installed, but that doesn’t mean you need to sign into Google :-)

(By the way, microG, an open source Google Play Services reimplementation, can achieve BASIC_INTEGRITY now, too. Which unfortunately doesn’t help much as most applications that do use Play Integrity want DEVICE_INTEGRITY at least.)

> but the companies choose lie of play store "integrity"

Agreed, very unfortunate. Most apps don’t even need it, but the security theatre is easier to do than actual security.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by archerx on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:15AM (#47647553)
What if I don’t have a smartphone?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by anileated on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:30AM (#47647653)
No one is required to use EUDI: https://ec.europa.eu/digital-building-blocks/sites/spaces/EU...

Companies and providers (like banks) have to support it, but use is voluntary.

Check out the spec and legal framework, it actually makes sense and is open to different implementations, though you might need to certify it.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by pastage on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:13AM (#47648565)
You are not required to accept anything other than digital ids. So from experience, whatever demands euid has will be what is required to identify you.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by bschwarz on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:02AM (#47647821)
If they have to support something that most everybody has they will soon stop supporting alternatives that are not required by law. What then?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dudefeliciano on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:06PM (#47652782)
My prediction is that eventually services for people NOT using the digital ID will be so degraded to be almost useless or seriously disadvantageous.

Kinda like the discrimination DB does for people using paper tickets vs those using the DB Navigator app.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by EmbarrassedHelp on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:37PM (#47656363)
There are attempts make it almost mandatory through mandatory age verification. Which would mean that you'd have to submit to privacy violations or be cut off from a sizeable portion of the internet.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by jahnu on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:21AM (#47647590)
I wonder if there will be a big enough market for a very compact smartphone equivalent device that can be used just for credentials? A device that is offline on standby except when you need it. Perhaps the size of a car key.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by Matumio on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:29AM (#47647988)
If it can go online, I'd prefer to use an android work (or user) profile with only auth apps in it, and nothing else.

As a separate device, it should be offline always IMO, and perhaps the size of a passkey. Or one of those banking devices with a display that show an authenticated text saying what you are confirming.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by archerx on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:41AM (#47648049)
What if it was the size of a credit card and it had stuff like your name, date of birth and even a picture of your face. I want to name this invention an ID card…
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:26PM (#47651017)
And if you added a cryptographic layer to it, with your own private key baked into it, you could both sign the documents, confirm your identity and the government could confirm it's actually you....

....wow, that would be reinventing the existing model of the leading ID cards....

Crazy if you think about it :)

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by AndyMcConachie on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:24AM (#47647619)
You're screwed. This has been the way for a while now. You cannot exist in society without a smart phone and it's only going to get worse.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by maccard on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:43AM (#47647718)
If you can't exist in society without a smart phone already, how is it going to get worse?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by 0x3f on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:54AM (#47648124)
Perhaps you won't be able to exist in private without a smart phone. Or there will be some technology beyond a smartphone that you can't exist without.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by HighGoldstein on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:33AM (#47647669)
Essential services (banks, government services, public transport) generally still support SMS as an alternative to their mobile apps when there's no completely offline process.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by subscribed on Sunday April 05, 2026 @11:51AM (#47650659)
...without a smartphone that is surveilling you 24/7.

Private smartphones are excluded already.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by fredgrott on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:22AM (#47647937)
so I have to buy a Yubikey hardware thingie to keep my Google account just to use eIDAS??

For those that do not know, that is the only way to get the Google account back is to use a hardware 2FA in the first place....

AND yubikeys are $60 per yubikey...and generally you want 2 including a backup

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by ksjfjsmb on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:34AM (#47647676)
Sich bei staatlichen Dienstleistungen auf Google oder Apple zu verlassen, kommt schon fast einem Verrat gleich. Trump hasst uns.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by crest on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:33AM (#47648724)
This is on the stupid side of lazy (again). You'll still be sovereign only at the pleasure of Apple and Google if you submit to their platform as a service crap.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by inexcf on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:49AM (#47648887)
Side question. How come it is always the most incompetent people who get put in charge of implementing things like that. Over and over apps and services are developed in Germany and completely fail at what they are supposed to achieve. Where are these people recruited from?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by matheusmoreira on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:47AM (#47649994)
> and we have support for other OSs on our list (like, e.g., GrapheneOS)

Excellent. Massive respect to you for doing this. This attestation business is an existential threat to "other" operating systems. I'm glad to see people are putting effort into supporting them.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by morpheuskafka on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:06PM (#47650802)
What happens if someone is banned from both companies (even for a very legitimate reason such as hosting illegal content -- they still need to access government services)?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dudefeliciano on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:59PM (#47652702)
What about people hosting content that is illegal in the US but not Germany (not sure what that may be now, but with the direction the US is taking maybe in a couple years even the fat Vance meme could become some kind of illegal subversive content). Anger the big daddy and your identitiy is gone.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by mrsssnake on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:26PM (#47651016)
> We have to use some kind of attestation mechanism per the eIDAS implementing acts.

Translates to:

"We have to make sure citized accessing the public service have not control over the device per the eIDAS implementing acts"

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by dudefeliciano on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:28PM (#47652383)
glad that the "move fast break things" mentality has finally arrived to Germany, just didn't expect the public sector to be the first to implement it
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by amaccuish on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:07PM (#47652791)
Why the need for a Cloud HSM?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by whizzter on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:22PM (#47653501)
Is this implementation related to the AusweissApp I've seen mentioned before (that reads the cert via NFC from a physical card) or another implementation?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by nforgerit on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:54PM (#47653768)
Congrats, this is the stupidest thing I’ve been reading all day. And that includes the orange man’s post.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by hans_castorp on Sunday April 05, 2026 @05:13PM (#47653944)
German citizen as well.

So with a Jolla phone and Linux laptop, I am left in the cold.

Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by tadfisher on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:43PM (#47654704)
Are you interested in a community-maintained alternative to Play Integrity? I work in the finance sector and it's increasingly likely I'll have to implement attestation at some point. Graphene's examples are adaptable, but we need a DB of open Android distribution keys and effective admin to support adding and revoking, possibly something like the LVFS system for Linux firmware.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by greatgib on Sunday April 05, 2026 @08:16PM (#47655382)
You know that it is how Germany got its darker period when people were just "doing their job" despite being against the good of the population. Without good conscious!
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by EmbarrassedHelp on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:32PM (#47656332)
Why not explicitly forbid the German version of the eDIAS from being used for things like age verification then? That'd solve a ton of privacy issues with the implementation.
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by frm88 on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:56AM (#47657733)
With a view on current geopolitics I find it absolutely irresponsible to use two US companies for attestation. The sanctions on ICC judges/prosecutors at the latest should have shown that it is a matter of national security to avoid a possibility of being completely shut down by an unstable US government. How do you propose to deal with people who get sanctioned or banned by Google/Apple for whatever reason? What measures do you have in place so these people can still access their ID?
Re:German implementation of eIDAS will require an Apple/Goog... by account42 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @08:29AM (#47674267)
The proper response to requirements ruling out an ethical implementation is to not implement them, not to provide an unethical implementation.