News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by nickdothutton on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:15AM (#44983582)
Step 1, pass law.

Step 2, demand compliance.

Step 3, upon not hearing of compliance, levy fines.

Step 4, upon non payment of fines, declare in breach of (2).

Step 5, block site from UK using DNS, in the same manner as torrent sites etc.

5 was always the goal, 2 to 4 are largely just performative.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by fruitworks on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:33AM (#44983768)
Step 6: Someome buys (or steals) a new domain to mirror the site. Or piggybacks a subdomain.

Step 7: Rinse and repeat, fueling the domain-bureaucracy complex. Oceania has always been at war with the pirate bay!

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by username332211 on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:34AM (#44983781)
How does step 5 work? Switching DNS servers is trivial.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by supriyo-biswas on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:29AM (#44985122)
DNS poisoning and rejection of TLS handshakes based on SNI.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by LexiMax on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:50AM (#44985356)
That's one domain down. Only 3,524 domains that just cropped up yesterday to go.

Never mind the fact that doing a Google search will surface pages on various wikis, git repositories, and other sites that conveniently list all of the mirrors.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by HDThoreaun on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:35PM (#44986585)
Big enough barrier to stop most users
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by LexiMax on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:06PM (#44988536)
Most users default to search engines instead of typing in a URL. I searched for "pirate bay" just now and all of the top results are mirrors or lists of mirrors.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by aaomidi on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:45AM (#44985299)
This is why I’m really pissed off at how long ECH has taken.

And it’s all because of corporate interests at IETF.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by worewood on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:16PM (#44987100)
Encrypted Client Hello and DNS over HTTPS.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by supriyo-biswas on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:17PM (#44987829)
Drop all ECH TLS connections, as China does.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by themafia on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:23PM (#44989375)
Creating the "Great Firewall of the UK" without actually calling it that: Priceless.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by postexitus on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:35AM (#44983797)
For you - not for 99% of the public.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by jdietrich on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:38AM (#44985898)
Millions of British people are already engaged in a cat-and-mouse game against online censorship, for one main reason - football (soccer).

If you're a British football fan and want to watch every live televised match, you'll need to pay £75 a month for subscriptions to both Sky Sports and TNT Sports. That won't actually allow you to watch all of the matches that are played, because for weird historical reasons there's a TV blackout on matches played on Saturday afternoon - even if you've paid for your subscriptions, you'll only be able to watch about half of all league matches on TV.

Alternatively, you can pay some bloke in the pub £50 for a Fire TV Stick pre-programmed with access to a bunch of pirated IPTV streams and a VPN to circumvent blocking, or get a mate to show you how to do it yourself - no subscription, no blackout. As a bonus, you get free access to Netflix and Disney+ and everything else.

Sellers of dodgy Fire Sticks occasionally get caught and imprisoned, a handful of users occasionally get nasty letters from the Federation Against Copyright Theft, but it's too widespread to really stop. Practically every workplace or secondary school class has someone who knows the ins-and-outs of circumventing DNS- and IP-level blocking; the lad who showed you how to watch live football on your phone or get free Netflix will be more than happy to show you how to access adult sites without verifying your age.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/illicit-streaming...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_football_on_television...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by SoftTalker on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:56AM (#44986114)
I've tried the "IPTV streams" to watch blacked out NHL games, and they are often terribly overloaded or just don't work at all. Not something I'd pay for.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by chatmasta on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:25PM (#44988767)
Just search for the name of the sport and “bite” and you’ll find some sketchy successor of the original subreddits for pirated sports streams (“r/nflbite,” “r/nbabite,” etc.) Or find the latest streameast mirror which is usually the best.

Make sure your ad blocker is working. Then it’s just a matter of finding the best stream, extracting the playlist, and opening VLC.

I documented [0] some useful tricks for this technique and the comments also include more useful snippets and bookmarklets.

[0] https://gist.github.com/milesrichardson/4661c311199b98023701...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by HPsquared on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:51AM (#44986064)
Copyright and censorship involve similar technological issues, but the ethics and legal aspects are totally different.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by hdgvhicv on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:29PM (#44987244)
£75 a month seems very reasonable for sports nerds, compared to the cost and availability in the past

People don’t want to ly for content, that’s as old as the hills.

I don’t do sport, and I wouldn’t fund such a terrible exploitative industry (televised sports is all about getting people hooked on gambling), but I’ve certainly spent that much for entertainment I do like in the past - and far more. A night at the theatre will cost a lot more than subscribing to all the sports channels. A weekly cinema visit too.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by thedrbrian on Saturday August 23, 2025 @06:49AM (#44994983)
>£75 a month seems very reasonable for sports nerds, compared to the cost and availability in the past

good that you ignore the actual point of the comment that you replied to

>That won't actually allow you to watch all of the matches that are played, because for weird historical reasons there's a TV blackout on matches played on Saturday afternoon - even if you've paid for your subscriptions, you'll only be able to watch about half of all league matches on TV.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by hdgvhicv on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:41PM (#45005653)
Given the cost was the first thing mentioned it seems that would be the actual point.

Personally I have no problem with people acquiring shows which are otherwise unavailable, as long as it’s not simply an excuse not to pay, which it so often is.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:50AM (#44983979)
https://mullvad.net/en/help/dns-over-https-and-dns-over-tls

The iOS instructions are the most onerous (IMO) but still easy enough to follow. It's 15 minutes of fumbling around for the non-technical person, then they're protected.

(Though, as others have pointed out, this is probably moot. The blocking is more effectively done by ISPs.)

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ramesh31 on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:54AM (#44985392)
>It's 15 minutes of fumbling around for the non-technical person, then they're protected.

You and I have very different ideas of what "non-technical" means. If it involves anything beyond pressing "download" on the app store, it's out of reach of the vast majority of users.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:40AM (#44985925)
Fair enough, there's a wide variance there. I'd still hesitate it's out of reach for most people as they'll likely have someone they know who would be able to follow those instructions for them. For the purpose of being able to access something they used to be able to access, I think most people will be able to figure this out. The point is that it's one-and-done in most instances. (To that end there's a reasonable worry that OS updates reset these settings but that's kind of a separate problem.)
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by saberience on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:22PM (#44987166)
Mulvad is totally non technical, you just download it and press “connect” and boom you’re on a vpn?

Is that really so complex the average person can’t do it? It’s less complex than sending an email.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Friday August 22, 2025 @07:28PM (#44991215)
The instructions I linked are to set up DoH/DoT with their (free!) service, so it's a little bit more involved than downloading an app; just not too much more involved to someone who's motivated to regain something they lost.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by aaomidi on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:44AM (#44985293)
In countries like Iran 80%+ of the population knows how to.

It’s all a matter of incentives.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by qingcharles on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:40PM (#44986640)
This. Practically the entire Middle East has blocks on sites like porn. Every household I know pays for a VPN that they share with all their family members.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by username332211 on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:45AM (#44983921)
Ehh, if a youth of digital piracy has taught me anything, it's that people will develop the necessary computer literacy to get the entertainment they want. Even if they've completely failed to develop that same skill in the pursuit of self improvement.

I feel that says something about human psychology. Probably something very unpleasant.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by anonym29 on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:02AM (#44985493)
Human adaptivity is perhaps both our biggest strength and biggest weakness. It's the same force behind our greatest innovations and our greatest tragedies, and even fuels the apathetic indifference towards those tragedies, too.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by sejje on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:21PM (#44986429)
My dad can hardly use a mouse, but the systems I put in place for him are pretty complex. He has no idea.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by CommanderData on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:22AM (#44985060)
step 6: Block non-compliant DNS servers
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by kps on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:46AM (#44985314)
Step 7: Camera AI that can catch the people scribbling “Sci-Hub is 190.115.31.218” on a bathroom wall.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:54AM (#44985390)
Does that even work anymore? I thought plain IP addresses were a thing of the past ever since we started doing virtual hosts 25 years ago. I just get a 503 when I use the address you posted...
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by CWuestefeld on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:15AM (#44985649)
If you just point your browser to https://<ip_address> then it won't work. You also need to have the correct hostname in the http request headers.

The easiest way to accomplish this is to add the address into your .hosts file (as sibling post says) and just use the name.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by CommanderData on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:27PM (#44986510)
As well as SNI, most reverse proxies need to know which TLS cert to serve. Lower than layer 7.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by thedrexster on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:59AM (#44985451)
Put it in your hosts file ;)
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by oneshtein on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:54AM (#44986095)
What domain name we need to put into hosts file?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by DaSHacka on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:46PM (#44986722)
Whatever is included on the bathroom wall

"scihub.invalid 192.168.19.17"

Literally DNS-over-sneakernet

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by bcrosby95 on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:08PM (#44987017)
There's literally no perfect law in the world. So I'm not exactly sure what your point is.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by raydev on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:49PM (#44988308)
And yet most people won't bother doing it.

Same way most attempts to stop piracy work. The people who are serious about getting around the blocks will find ways, but the less motivated will just give up (again, this is most people).

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by okasaki on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:44AM (#44983897)
UK site blocking isn't done with DNS. I think they mess with routes at the ISP level. There's not much you can do except use a VPN.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Bender on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:14AM (#44984952)
4chan uses Cloudflare. Blocking routes to Cloudflare may have an interesting impact unless CF are cooperating with the UK.

4chan could stop using CF but their moderators will have to step up their game as CF is being used to detect and block CSAM.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ovi256 on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:14AM (#44985634)
CF will cooperate with UK authorities because they're not in 4chan's business.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by const_cast on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:58PM (#44987589)
I doubt it heavily. CF has control over a large chunk of the global internet - they're not going to go thru their clients one by one and make sure they're doing age verification. That's absurd and far too expensive.

The alternative to that is either:

1. UK blocks cloudflare (unlikely, come on now)

2. UK gives cloudflare a pass (fairly common)

3. Somewhere in-between. Maybe UK cares about highly visible people behind cloudflare like 4Chan but not others.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by AuryGlenz on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:10PM (#44987727)
Won’t it just be the UK telling Cloudflare to block 4chan specifically for the UK (or we’ll fine you too)?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by const_cast on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:11PM (#44987741)
Yeah that's option 3, for now. But they won't go after cloudflare in the general case because it's too risky IMO. And cloudflare will only comply to the absolute minimum they can get away with, because they can't burn money auditing every single customer behind cloudflare.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ranger_danger on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:45PM (#44988241)
> they're not going to go thru their clients one by one and make sure they're doing age verification

no, they just drop customers when people complain that they host legal content they happen to disagree with (KF).

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by immibis on Sunday August 24, 2025 @01:12AM (#45001568)
You're complaining that Cloudflare doesn't want to host a site that literally killed people?

I think if you want cloudflare to host your site, don't kill people with your site. That seems fair IMO.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ranger_danger on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:10AM (#45004810)
I think if that were true, there would have at least been an attempt at a court case at the very least. But AFAIK every case they have been involved in, they've won. I am not defending their content, merely a right to exist, especially when you're not breaking any applicable laws.

If you want to talk about content that objectively breaks laws... 8chan hosts monkey torture videos.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by GoblinSlayer on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:45AM (#44985302)
AFAIK Cloudflare gives 4chan a dedicated ip to simplify blocking.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Bender on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:33AM (#44985848)
I think you may be right. [1] It's the same IP I've had in my hosts file for a long time.

[1] - https://whoisfreaks.com/tools/dns/history/lookup/4chan.org?t...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by donperignon on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:49AM (#44986042)
spain block CF every weekend to try to avoid football piracy. crazy, but its happening and nobody cares.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by astrange on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:32PM (#44986552)
Cloudflare isn't capable of that - it can only block downloading CSAM not uploading it. (Which means the moderators wouldn't be able to see it either.)
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ranger_danger on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:44PM (#44988226)
ironic how CF will host 4chan and 8chan but not kiwifarms
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by sunshine-o on Friday August 22, 2025 @09:01AM (#44984120)
This is the only power they have left.

The UK government has lost control of what happen in the physical world on their own island so now the bureaucrats play a fantasy game where they are gonna enforce their rules and dominion in their former colonies or the digital world.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by realo on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:17PM (#44986390)
So ... if the USA was ok with kid pornography then everyone else in the world would be forced to be ok with that too?

Sorry but other countries are totally right to block whatever they deem to be USA shit.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by dismalpedigree on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:19PM (#44986411)
Yes. UK has every right to block whatever they want. US has no obligation to assist them in any way.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by zahlman on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:52AM (#44985367)
> The UK government has lost control of what happen in the physical world on their own island so now the bureaucrats play a fantasy game...

It seems to me like said loss of control is largely the result of other actions by the same bureaucrats.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lokar on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:47AM (#44985325)
While I disapprove of what the gov is doing here, I think it’s incorrect and unhelpful to put all the blame on them. AIUI, the UK is a democracy and these policies are generally supported by the voters.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by sunshine-o on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:14PM (#44986352)
I understand the people might wanna block porn on their kids mobile internet and home WiFi.

So why don't they mandate their ISP to implement this as an optional feature ?

Why do they instead try to boil the ocean by going after every website on the planet and outside of their jurisdiction?

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by nemomarx on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:16PM (#44986376)
Their isps already offer this, actually. You have to show id to them to get it turned pff.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by hdgvhicv on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:15PM (#44987093)
I don’t have to show ID, but I do have to pay the bill, which means a direct debit, which means over 18.

The correct solution (in addition to bill layer control and arguably compulsory support for an “over 18” tag in dns which would be easy enough to implement for the same sites that currently demand over 18s, would be to help parents utilise parental controls (having recently been through it with Minecraft and fortnight it was a nightmarish gordian knot.

The hand wringing about how evil vpns are is the same. My son can’t install mullvad or whatever on his phone without my approval thanks to apple’s parental controls. I assume android has the same.

The goal has never been to empower parents though

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by J_McQuade on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:25PM (#44987944)
I think the correct solution would be to make parents responsible for actually using those controls, as they always have been for controlling a child's access to such materials in other media.

For example, if you have a stack of explicit DVDs and it becomes apparent that your child has access to them, then you will likely get a visit from social services and potentially suffer legal consequences up to and including removal of custody. I honestly have no idea why stuff on the internet is treated differently. Internet providers are already required to check that you are over 18 (much as the person selling you those DVDs is) - if you then share the content that this makes available with a child, then you should be held responsible in the same way. It was sufficient with print, VHS, Sky TV, etc. - why not the internet?

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by d4v3 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @05:47PM (#45008111)
Because then parents couldn't just shove a screen in front of their child's face and then proceed to ignore them anymore. Half-kidding, but there are real liability concerns. How much supervision is reasonable? My parents definitely didn't police my every moment on the internet. Actually, quite the opposite
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by RandomBacon on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:19PM (#44988712)
> direct debit, which means over 18

Incorrect. Source: I had a checking account before I was 18.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by waltbosz on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:40PM (#44987370)
My solution was to set my router to use the DNS server at 1.1.1.3 which blocks adult sites.

https://blog.cloudflare.com/introducing-1-1-1-1-for-families...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ImJamal on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:57PM (#44987582)
I assume this doesn't block porn on reddit or non-porn websites?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by waltbosz on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:20PM (#44987873)
No, it just blocks DNS requests from a list of porn hostnames.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ranger_danger on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:40PM (#44988166)
Many browsers/apps now will ignore the system/DHCP-provided DNS server and use their own though (often via TLS so you can't block it easily)... so while this might work for some situations, I can't in good conscious call it a great solution.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by waltbosz on Saturday August 23, 2025 @01:13AM (#44993377)
Wow I did not know that.

I agree. It's not a very robust solution, but it's better than nothing at all .

And it's annoying sometimes. One thing I found is that it somehow forces Google safe-search, which appears to block some non-pornographic search results.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ImJamal on Friday August 22, 2025 @07:27PM (#44991203)
I understand that. I just wasn't sure if Reddit and co used specific subdomains for porn images/videos.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by rapidaneurism on Saturday August 23, 2025 @12:25AM (#44993146)
Can they not set their device DNS to 1.1.1.1
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by waltbosz on Saturday August 23, 2025 @01:15AM (#44993385)
They're not that technically inclined ... Yet.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by spooky_deep on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:21PM (#44987879)
The ISPs already do this. Most mobile networks are even opt-out, not in, to this feature. The new law is unnecessary overreach. They either don’t know what they are doing technically (alarming) or are just authoritarian (very alarming)
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by prmoustache on Friday August 22, 2025 @05:47PM (#44990258)
I don't think ISP DNS solution is very effective when all major web browsers implement DoH by default.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by mathiaspoint on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:02PM (#44986196)
The people in charge are largely hated by the electorate. They won by default effectively due to a quirk of how UK elections work (which was less of a problem when the monarch/aristocracy was still involved to counter balance things like this, but now that that's gone the state is effectively out of control.)

Unless by "democracy" you mean "sleepwalking administration everyone hates" the current UK government is unusually undemocratic.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by 4ndrewl on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:09PM (#44986293)
Tell me about this "quirk" and winning by "default" (and how this never applied to other recent elections).
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by mathiaspoint on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:24PM (#44986470)
Less than 30% of the electorate voted labour. The problem is that the opposing party consistently ran as opposition but then executed on labour's policies instead so most people just didn't vote because they didn't see anyone running to vote for.

The electorate legitimately did not want these people or their policies, they effectively weren't given a choice. To call that democracy delegtimizes democratic elections.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by 4ndrewl on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:41PM (#44988936)
You say they weren't given a choice, but there are now more parties represented in parliament now than before.

What percent of the electorate voting for the biggest party would be acceptable to you?

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Symbiote on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:31PM (#44986545)
Everyone also had the choice to vote Green or Liberal Democrat. I believe both promise electoral reform.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by incone123 on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:48PM (#44986746)
They can promise whatever they like knowing there's very little chance they will be put to the test.

The last time the Lib Dems got a taste of power in 2010 it was by going into coalition with the Tories at the cost of dumping key election pledges. Next election they were dumped by the public and their leader Nick Clegg was hired by Meta - presumably for his connections as he has no particular talent to sell.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Symbiote on Friday August 22, 2025 @06:14PM (#44990511)
The Lib Dems made a referendum on a fairer voting method a condition of the coalition, and they got their referendum. I see no reason to doubt they'd implement electoral reform if elected.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by 4ndrewl on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:44PM (#44986699)
That's how our representative democracy works though. Even if just one person votes in each constituency.

I say that those who didn't vote knew it was a foregone conclusion and would have voted in the same proportion as those who did vote.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lawlessone on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:10PM (#44987026)
>The electorate legitimately did not want these people or their policies

> so most people just didn't vote because they didn't see anyone running to vote for.

Probably shoulda voted then

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by incone123 on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:44PM (#44986685)
It was a win under the rules but a memorably shallow one. Labour won a big majority of seats in 2024 on fewer votes (grand total) than when they lost handsomely in 2019.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by pyb on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:54PM (#44986818)
The paradox of politics : are hated whilst actually doing what the majority wants.

As we saw in the case of the Winter fuel Payments : if a policy is unpopular with voters, it is abandoned. The Online Safety Act is popular, so it will stay.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by rapidaneurism on Saturday August 23, 2025 @12:23AM (#44993136)
Being unpopular is not the opposite of popular.

The winter fuel payments were very unpopular with a very vocal part of the population, while any benefits were very thinly distributed on the rest of the electorate.

The cost of the online safety act is very small and almost invisible distributed across everyone. Any major effects (leaking of personal data) can be blamed on the victims (most people assume that only perverts will have to verify their age). Another effect where security conscious people will be excluded from online discussions is probably in invisible (if not a benefit) to most people.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lostlogin on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:10PM (#44987029)
> They won by default effectively due to a quirk of how UK elections work (which was less of a problem when the monarch/aristocracy was still involved to counter balance things like this, but now that that's gone the state is effectively out of control.)

I’m reading this as you saying that the system is worse now that the monarchy and aristocracy have less power. Is that correct? If so, how do these unelected groups make it better?

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by mathiaspoint on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:18PM (#44987128)
You have misread (in a very common way for, I believe, a very common reason.)

I said it's less democratic. That's not necessarily less bad unless you believe democracy is the ultimate measure of fitness for a state.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by hdgvhicv on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:18PM (#44987127)
No post war U.K. government aside from the 2010-15 coalition had a majority of voters voting for the parties in power. 1951 came close I think.

However opinion polls consistently put support for the “anti porn” bill up high amongst multiple demographics.

The cause for this is a lack of computer literacy, in both government and the population, but that doesn’t really matter.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Amezarak on Saturday August 23, 2025 @07:46PM (#45000035)
Opinion polling is largely bunk. In addition to the problem with getting a good polling sample today, questions are carefully crafted to achieve the desired results. Opinion polls are for shaping consensus, not reporting it.

Consider how badly off "will you vote R or D in 7 days" polling is in the US, even with the top national experts on the problem. Opinion polls are much, much more troublesome.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by charlieyu1 on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:20PM (#44987152)
The electorate hated the politicians, then they still vote for the same guys. The general public doesn't care about politics, those who cared treats it like tribalism and don't want to learn what are actually happening, they don't want to think they only want to be told whatever feeding their brain chemistry.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by macinjosh on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:40AM (#44985930)
Democracy is a form of government, not an ideology. Just because +50% of an electorate thinks something is OK, doesn't make it so.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lokar on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:50AM (#44986052)
I agree. But it does matter if you want to do more then rant on the internet. If there is public support you need to educate people and change minds.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by pegasus on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:50AM (#44986055)
Parent was correctly pointing out that responsibility for whatever troubles the UK might be actually encountering should be distributed as democratically as its form of government actually is.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by dpc050505 on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:50AM (#44986054)
The form of government that applies democracy is rooted in the ideology that the majority knows best, which is the ideological version of democracy.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by kibwen on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:59AM (#44986151)
> rooted in the ideology that the majority knows best

Let's be careful here, the point in favor of democracy is not that the majority knows best, but rather if that people are to be subject to laws, then those same people should have an equal share in determining what those laws are. IOW, the point of democracy is to give the people what they deserve, and no more.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by soraminazuki on Friday August 22, 2025 @09:13PM (#44992001)
When people talk about democracies, they almost always refer to liberal democracies.

With liberal democracies, I believe it's more about self-determination or fair representation than who knows best. The point is to prevent tyranny, including majority tyranny.

There can be no liberal democracy without the protection of human rights and the of law.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by kelseyfrog on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:56AM (#44986117)
Anything can be turned into an ideology, even democracy.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by rapidaneurism on Saturday August 23, 2025 @12:29AM (#44993162)
It's not 50% of the electorate, in the UK it is the plurality (second best plus 1 vote) of 50% of the electoral seats plus 1 seat. That gives absolute power.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by FirmwareBurner on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:18AM (#44985683)
> AIUI, the UK is a democracy and these policies are generally supported by the voters.

When were UK citizens polled on these policies before politicians started enforcing them? And I think after Brexit, the UK government learned never to ask the opinions of their citizens again, because they will vote in direct opposition of the political status quo out of sheer spite of their politicians.

There are huge flaws with our current democratic systems: like sure we can vote, but after the people we vote for get into power, we have no control over what they do until next election cycle. So you can be a democracy on paper while your government is doing things you don't approve of.

Most people I talk to in the west, both here in Europe and in North America, don't seem to approve of what their government is doing on important topics, and at the same time they feel hopeless in being able to change that because either the issues are never on the table, or if they are, the politicians do a 180 once they get voted to power or forget about them because political promises are worthless and non-binding, meaning they lied themselves into power.

So given these issues ask yourself, is that really a true democracy, or just an illusion of choice of direction while you're actually riding a trolly track?

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by hluska on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:24AM (#44985745)
That’s a form of political change - direct representation democracy and recall legislation are both possibilities. The solution is to make electoral change happen, not to complain that everything is hopeless on the internet.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by adiabatichottub on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:39AM (#44985904)
But how can those changes be made if the representatives don't act to make them? It would take a pretty big act of solidarity amongst various constituencies to send the message that failure to act is not an option.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by jlokier on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:19PM (#44986412)
Since we're talking about the UK, in 2010 negotations after a hung parliament produced an opportunity to move towards something a little more representative: The 2011 referendum on changing to AV voting from first-past-the-post.

Unfortunately, voters rejected that change quite strongly, and that probably set the trend for a while against further steps to proportional or more direct democratic systems.

AV is a type of transferable vote system, and a step closer to proportional representation. In AV you get two votes, so you can vote for your preferred candidate first (who may be niche but represents you better), and your tactical-vote candidate second (who doesn't represent you but are better than the even-worse candidate). As opposed to the current FPTP system, where you often have to tactical-vote for candidates who don't represent your interests much, and your actual preference is not recorded at all.

Even though AV is far from ideal, if voters had said yes then I think just the symbolism of changing the system, would have resulted in a greater inclination to change the system again later.

AV, STV and PR have been debated a number of times in the UK parliament in the last centery, so it does keep coming up, and will likely come up again, eventually.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by philjohn on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:18PM (#44989314)
Fun fact - the same people who managed to inch the Brexit vote over the line were also involved in killing AV ... a certain Dominic Cummings and his gang.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by andrepd on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:01PM (#44986936)
> Unfortunately, voters rejected that change quite strongly,

Both major parties united in a ridiculously aggressive campaign for the No (there were literally, I mean literally, billboards equating the electoral reform to killing babies).

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by depressedpanda on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:36PM (#44989508)
> the politicians do a 180 once they get voted to power or forget about them because political promises are worthless and non-binding, meaning they lied themselves into power.

Why is this allowed? Why aren't there laws in place to hold politicians accountable for the promises they make to get elected?

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by FirmwareBurner on Friday August 22, 2025 @05:16PM (#44989903)
Why haven't wolves made laws for themselves that prevent them from eating sheep?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by hkt on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:28AM (#44985789)
The UK hasn't elected a government on 50% or more of the vote since the 1950s:

https://www.statista.com/statistics/717004/general-elections...

It is hard to call minority rule democratic, really. I've no issue with your point on the OSA and think it is widely supported, but let's be realistic, representation in the UK is virtual on matters like this: widely supported, but mostly by coincidence.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by overfeed on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:38AM (#44985895)
2-party electoral systems (likely to bear >50% majority governments) are also not very democratic, in a way. There's no perfect system, but I prefer minority governments to a 2-party duopoly. YMMV.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by grues-dinner on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:39PM (#44986629)
The UK has been effectively a two party system anyway within living memory (Labour and Tories). Only rarely (e.g. 2010) does the token third party, the Lib Dems) get to be in coalition, and I think no one else has won anything since 1910.

In a monkey's paw moment for everyone who dislikes only having effectively two parties to choose from, this may soon be changing as Reform is poised to overtake the Tories.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by overfeed on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:15PM (#44989285)
> The UK has been effectively a two party system anyway within living memory

> ...this may soon be changing as Reform is poised to overtake the Tories.

How long has the Farage-shaped tail been wagging the dog? It probably was before 2010. He managed notch many wins without winning a majority government by getting the 2 major parties - especially the Tories - to adopt his parties' positions.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by hdgvhicv on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:23PM (#44987185)
Technically 2017-19 was a minority government where a party in Northern Ireland sold its votes for about £100k/mp/vote to prop up May.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by foldr on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:31PM (#44989464)
It's a two party system in the sense that only two parties have a chance of winning any given UK general election, but the popular vote is quite widely distributed among parties. In the last election, 33.7% of people voted Labour and 23.7% people voted for the second largest party (the Conservatives):

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1478478/uk-election-resu...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by cbsmith on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:35AM (#44985869)
I think you're making the original poster's point for them. It's very clear a minority government is not the one forcing OSA on people. They don't even have the power.

Arguably, minority rule is more democratic than majority rule, because minority rule isn't "the minority does whatever they want".

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by scythe on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:08PM (#44986278)
The goal of the policy is supported by the voters. The polls used to measure this are shifty at best about the implementation details. Who doesn't want to prevent kids from looking at pornography? But plenty of things are popular if you ask people in a way that makes them ignore how it plays out in real life. Laws against tall buildings are a pretty good example. Land reform was extremely popular in many socialist countries until it actually happened. I'm sure you can think of other examples.

In this case the ministers know what the problems are. The policy is not new or unique to the UK and it has been done better in Louisiana of all places:

https://reason.com/2024/03/18/pornhub-pulls-out-of-seventh-s...

> The difference is in the details of complying with Louisiana's law. Verifying visitor ages in Louisiana does not require porn sites to directly collect user IDs. Rather, the state's government helped develop a third-party service called LA Wallet, which stores digital driver's licenses and serves as an online age verification credential that affords some privacy.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by andrepd on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:24PM (#44988762)
> Land reform was extremely popular in many socialist countries until it actually happened

Actually, land reforms were spectacularly popular—and very successful—in many countries like Guatemala or Vietnam (coincidentally, two places that were invaded by the US in an attempt to revert those reforms, one successful and the other not).

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by scythe on Friday August 22, 2025 @06:25PM (#44990638)
That's not really the point. You can always think of another example. I was talking about the Online Safety Act.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by 123pie123 on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:52AM (#44985373)
really?

From my anecdotal evidence, is that it's fucking stupid and hated

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by jdietrich on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:02AM (#44985489)
Weirdly, the majority of the British public a) support age verification, b) aren't willing to use age verification themselves and c) don't think it'll actually work.

https://www.ipsos.com/en-uk/britons-back-online-safety-acts-...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by burkaman on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:24AM (#44985748)
Reading the polling questions, it doesn't actually seem that contradictory.

> To what extent do you support or oppose the introduction of age verification checks to access platforms that may host content related to suicide, self-harm, eating disorders and pornography?

Most people say support, presumably thinking "yeah those things seem bad and kids shouldn't be able to look at them".

> How likely or unlikely would you be to submit any proof of age (e.g. a photo/ video, photographic ID, using banking information, digital ID wallets etc) in order to access... Messaging apps / Social media websites / Online discussion forums / User-generated encyclopedias / Dating apps / Pornography websites

"Ok no I don't like this method, and obviously I'm not going to submit a photo of myself to look at porn." I don't think anybody hearing the first question was thinking "yes I support age verification even if it means blocking Wikipedia".

> And how confident, if at all, are you that the Online Safety Act will prevent children and people under 18 from seeing illegal and harmful material online?

Nothing contradictory about supporting a policy that you don't think will completely work, especially after realizing that you yourself would probably try to get around it.

I think combining or switching the first two questions might produce very different results.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by HPsquared on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:43AM (#44985967)
It's all very "how to lie with statistics".
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by WillPostForFood on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:04PM (#44986211)
The world is complicated, and normal to have conflicting ideas.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by const_cast on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:53PM (#44987513)
To an extent, but it's also priming, ie lying with statistics.

Obviously if you tell people you're doing something to protect children and that's its only for porn or whatever they'll say yes. You've primed them - you immediately put their minds on the focus of negative things like porn and children getting hurt. Nobody wants children hurt.

You need to ask the question more generically. "Do you support age verification to access certain categories of websites?"

Something tells me the numbers of agreeance will fall.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by stuartjohnson12 on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:19AM (#44985690)
The phrasing on these polls is really unhelpful because it doesn't include the actor.

"To what extent do you support or oppose the introduction of age verification checks to access platforms that may host content related to suicide, self-harm, eating disorders, and pornography"

is like asking me

"To what extent do you support the detainment of people suspected of theft"

and then concluding I support vigilante mobs dragging people out of their homes when I answer in the affirmative. The means IS the question - the sad meltdown we're all about to witness as the UK government realises their lack of jurisdiction is because the actor is wrong, not because the end is wrong.

The phrasing should be "To what extent do you support or oppose the British government enforcing the introduction of age verification checks to access platforms that may host content related to suicide, self-harm, eating disorders, and pornography"

Forcing major device manufacturers to implement these content blocks to a certain level of rigour is the obvious, enforceable, effective, minimally invasive way to achieve this entirely reasonable goal. I can believe that pornography consumption by preteens is not a good thing and that this implementation is stupid at the same time.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by mattnewton on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:07PM (#44986264)
Doesn’t seem weird at all, Britons are saying a) I agree children watching porn is bad but b) I value my privacy online and c) don’t think sending in photos of an ID is really going to stop kids. Actually seems pretty reasonable, and a reasonable democratic representative should look at that and say “well, how else can get A if method B is unpopular and unlikely to work?”

Instead they seem to have conflated B with A. Maybe they are afraid that any criticism on this method is interpreted as attack on doing anything at all for kids watching porn on the internet or even twisted into some kind of endorsement.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by o11c on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:49PM (#44988295)
> Instead they seem to have conflated B with A. Maybe they are afraid that any criticism on this method is interpreted as attack on doing anything at all for kids watching porn on the internet or even twisted into some kind of endorsement.

In all fairness, I have seen quite a few people explicitly arguing "I want kids to watch porn" of late.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by mattnewton on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:09PM (#44988568)
That’s not really being fair if you’re assuming that fringe argument by default though right?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by cbsmith on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:38AM (#44985896)
Behold, the power of the anecdote.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lokar on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:58AM (#44985433)
They have fair and competitive elections, no?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:23AM (#44985733)
Western democracies have fair and competitive elections in the same way they have fair and competitive markets for things like internet access or mobile phones. You are effectively only allowed to choose between a very carefully managed set of choice that are provided to you. This set of choices is often so dire and distant from people's actual desires that many just don't bother voting at all.

George Carlin used the analogy of restaurant to modern democracy. You have the appearance of choice because you are handed a menu where you can choose liberal or conversative or green party, etc. But all of the actual policies and laws are drawn up by the same chefs in the back and you eat what you are served.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lokar on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:52AM (#44986080)
This is my point. You need to identify the source of the problem if you want to take action. Blaming bureaucrats is not helpful.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by FirmwareBurner on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:09PM (#44986297)
> Blaming bureaucrats is not helpful.

Bureaucrats are the ones making the rules of the game we have to play. So why shouldn't we blame them?

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:25PM (#44986473)
Chain of events is the lobbyists write the policies that are handed to the politicians who vote them in, then to the bureaucrats to execute them.

But the lobbyists work for the rich and the power. They are ultimately the chefs and ones who decide what the rules will be.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by FirmwareBurner on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:28PM (#44986520)
You are correct. But I don't see how we can fix this. Revolutions or rioting, is not the right idea either.

A successful and well functioning democracy requires constant monitoring, involvement and pressure from citizens to hold it accountable, otherwise it gets captured by monopolies and malicious actors with money, who will steer politics in their favor instead of the citizens' favor.

The problem with that is that most citizens today are too burdened by the cost of living and sorting their own lives to have time and energy for political activism. The only ones who do are retired boomers and they only care that their pensions and house prices are going up.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lokar on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:49PM (#44986751)
Democracies can and do correct. It takes time and effort, but it happens. For example the progressive movement in the US.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by FirmwareBurner on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:55PM (#44986839)
>Democracies can and do correct.

Yes, but when you ignore citizens' demands for too long, they will then over-correct in the opposite direction: see Hitler, Brexit, Trump, AFD, LePenn, Meloni, etc. History has proved this to be correct 100% of the time.

>For example the progressive movement in the US

Can you provide more details, I'm not an US citizen.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lokar on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:09PM (#44987717)
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by stuaxo on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:29AM (#44985805)
First past the post, and not proportionally representative - so could be improved a lot.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by rwmj on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:28AM (#44985801)
First past the post, so no, not really.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by dijit on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:21AM (#44985719)
our two party system means that more often than not you are voting against some party having power.

The left wing has been vote split for some time, now the tight wing is getting vote split.

It’s not a fair characterisation to say that the UK government is popular, the last actually popular government was probably Tony Blair (though many regret him in hindsight), though Boris had his followers I guess.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by HPsquared on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:45AM (#44985995)
Popular politicians tend to do the most damage.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by rhdunn on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:05PM (#44989173)
I'd say it is the other way around. -- Support for the Tories/Conservatives has collapsed to the point where they are 4th or even 5th place! Reform have benefitted most from this shift. [1]-[4]

The left wing is seeing Labour voters shift to the Lib Dems, Greens, Jeremy Corbin's new party, and Reform.

[1] https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/services_lsdm.html (April)

[2] https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/blogs/ec_vipoll_20250625... (June)

[3] https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/prediction_main.html (July)

[4] https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/blogs/ec_rrose_20250731.... (August)

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by anikom15 on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:28PM (#44989437)
The People’s Republic of China has elections, no?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Barrin92 on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:59AM (#44985455)
there's a reason anecdotes aren't data. While people are more divided on the effectiveness, there's pretty overwhelming pubblic support for laws like the Online Safety Act.

https://yougov.co.uk/technology/articles/52693-how-have-brit...

It's always slightly surprising to see Americans online react to this thinking there is some Illuminati conspiracy happening. Britain and Europe are not the US, we don't have much of an interest of having 4chan dictate public policy.

It's also a good lesson in how effective platforms like Twitter can be in manipulating public perception, given that the same users now seem to be able to openly agitate over there.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by lenerdenator on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:08AM (#44985554)
> It's always slightly surprising to see Americans online react to this thinking there is some Illuminati conspiracy happening. Britain and Europe are not the US, we don't have much of an interest of having 4chan dictate public policy.

Too late by about nine years at the very least.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by dingnuts on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:09AM (#44985579)
> Britain and Europe are not the US, we don't have much of an interest of having 4chan dictate public policy.

Implying that Americans "have an interest in having 4chan dictate public policy" because we have different standards for freedom of expression is kind of racist, actually.

You got a license for that attitude? Don't train your pug to raise its paw! Fuck you, etc.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by quesera on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:37PM (#44986610)
Ignorant and dismissive, sure. But racist? What does that word mean, then?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by linuxftw on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:11AM (#44985589)
> AIUI, the UK is a democracy

The House of Lords disagrees and the Monarch disagree. Sometimes they cosplay as a democracy.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by jon-wood on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:28PM (#44986521)
Neither the House of Lords or the Monarch can actually stop Parliament passing a law. They can in some cases slow them down, but if Parliament really wants a law passed it will happen.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by apolitic on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:08PM (#44987703)
As shown by the proroguing of parliament by Boris Johnson on the September 9th, from September 10th to October 14th in 2019 (1), just a couple of months before the COVID19 pandemic landed and the first cases were being reported.

This action to prorogue was however later deemed unlawful by the Supreme Court on the 24th September 2019 (2). See recent changes to senior members, and subsequent rulings on matters of state importance by the Supreme Court for a look at what happens when they try to correct parliamentary actions by the ruling party. They have been singing from the governmental hymn sheet ever since.

Whither democracy? Whither justice?

1. https://labourheartlands.com/parliament-has-been-prorogued-a...

2. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/decision-of-the-supreme...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by anikom15 on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:27PM (#44989425)
Democracy cannot stop Parliament from passing a law either. UK is Parliament first, democracy second.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by kps on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:48PM (#44989628)
The House of Lords is part of Parliament.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by jonplackett on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:29PM (#44986527)
Most people are either blissfully unaware or don’t understand the ramifications of a policy until it becomes law
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ranger_danger on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:38PM (#44988134)
> generally supported by the voters

you could say the same about the US... that doesn't make it right and it doesn't mean people aren't violently voting against their own best interests.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by o11c on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:44PM (#44988225)
It's a huge stretch to call the existence of 4chan in anyone's best interests.

First they came for 4chan and I said nothing, because good riddance!

This is not a slippery slope; this is a spring trying to return to the center. The harder the resistance at the extremes, the more energetic the oscillation will be, so if we want to minimize that, work on undermining the intolerable extremes.

The sheer anarchy of the libertarian mindset that much of this site supports is not a good thing.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by m-s-y on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:09PM (#44988575)
>It's a huge stretch to call the existence of 4chan in anyone's best interests.

Absolutely, 100% incorrect. You obviously don't approve of 4chan's content or mission, but that's not the point. It benefits everyone when anyone takes a stand because their legal rights are under attack.

"I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it."

>This is not a slippery slope

Again, incorrect.

Any type of punishment for 4chan due to their legal content is damn close to the definition of "slippery slope". You're familiar with the "anti-slippery slope" argument already ("First they came for 4chan and I said nothing, because good riddance!"), so you're obviously cogent enough to understand what you're saying.

>The sheer anarchy of the libertarian mindset that much of this site supports is not a good thing.

This is not for you to decide. Your mindset is why free speech laws must exist in the first place.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by o11c on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:54PM (#44989057)
The whole point of this is that what counts as "legal" is permitted to change. In particular, "legal under some circumstances" is a thing.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ranger_danger on Saturday August 23, 2025 @11:58AM (#44996864)
> It's a huge stretch to call the existence of 4chan in anyone's best interests.

I wasn't trying to imply that at all... I just meant that voting for age verification laws themselves were against peoples' best interest, not the blocking of any particular website.

In any case... sites like 4chan itself existing (ignoring any actual moderation issues like CP/etc. or other clearly illegal stuff), to me, simply means that free speech still exists, and I will defend their (anyone's) right to exist and to free speech if I have to. It doesn't mean I agree with/support them or their content though.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by tmnvix on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:20PM (#44988720)
I've posted this before, but it's relevant here:

'The UK’s Online Safety Act didn’t come from Parliament or the public'

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lJ2AokZujC0 (watch from about 4:20)

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by klelatti on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:45PM (#44989603)
> 'The UK’s Online Safety Act didn’t come from Parliament or the public'

It was debated at length in parliament and it was voted into legislation by parliament. It was developed by a Tory government and has been implemented by a Labour one.

I don't like the OSA but the whole 'robber baron' organisation thing in that video is just .. well Andrew Carnegie died more than a hundred years ago. He funded a lot of charitable organisations including one that has funded work in this area.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by kevinventullo on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:11PM (#44989241)
“Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos”
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by anikom15 on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:24PM (#44989384)
Both major parties in the UK supported this.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by mintplant on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:34AM (#44985860)
> The UK government has lost control of what happen in the physical world on their own island

What do you mean by this?

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by monkey_monkey on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:55AM (#44986100)
Probably an dogwhistle about immigration
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by DaSHacka on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:41PM (#44986661)
Could just as easily be referring to brexit.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by input_sh on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:19PM (#44988709)
Racism with extra steps.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Ecstatify on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:23AM (#44985739)
Reads like narration from Adam Curtis.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by stuaxo on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:27AM (#44985768)
"What happened next..."
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by jonplackett on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:28PM (#44986519)
This is part of a wider trend of trying to solve real world problems with the stroke of a pen. It’s not going well.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by scarmig on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:53PM (#44986807)
Banning 4chan is just part of the UK's efforts to prevent drought. Every jpg shared and string written helps drain the oceans:

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/uk-government-ine...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by behringer on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:56PM (#44986861)
4chan and websites like it have never been the problem.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by immibis on Saturday August 23, 2025 @09:21PM (#45000465)
4chan is a major part of the reason why the guy who's currently destroying the USA has the power to currently destroy the USA. That's not nothing. That's very far from nothing.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by dlachausse on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:19PM (#44987135)
Just give up a few more rights…for everyone’s safety. Think of the children!
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by transcriptase on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:17PM (#44987820)
“just one more law bro. i promise bro just one more law and we’ll be safe bro. it’s just a little more surveillance bro. please just one more. one more law and we’ll stop all the threats bro. bro c’mon just give me access to your data and we’ll protect you i promise bro. think of the children bro. bro bro please we just need one more law bro, one more camera, one more database, and then we’ll all be safe bro”
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ethbr1 on Friday August 22, 2025 @05:45PM (#44990228)
sed 's/bro/mate/g'
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by akk0 on Saturday August 23, 2025 @02:06AM (#44993632)
That sounds more Australian, which still works but is a different story. I propose s/mate/chum/g
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by pojzon on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:50PM (#44988321)
But dont think of the children too much, coz we are behind grooming gangs.

Just think about children “a little”.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by boppo1 on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:28PM (#44991699)
Didn't that get investigated, little came of it, and now they won't investigate 'because we did already'?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by jonplackett on Saturday August 23, 2025 @06:03AM (#44994779)
You needed a /s for the very literal people downvoting you.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by hungmung on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:05PM (#44986980)
Same thing has been happening for a long time in America. Politicians are typically risk adverse and the real world has complicated problems so they make up a 'virtual' problem to 'fix', or to turn into a new political football.

Politics has become its own end: politicians have job security, and nothing changes except for the worse because constituents keep falling for the same tired shit.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ASalazarMX on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:45PM (#44987426)
This is demagogy 101: invent or exagerate a problem, and offer yourself as the only true solution. It's a recipe as old as bread, nothing particularly US centric.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by EasyMark on Saturday August 23, 2025 @12:31AM (#44993175)
It's peaking again in the USA though and it's immigrants. They have replaced the "Commie" (when it last peaked in the 50s) as an imagined threat that lies around every corner that seems to appeal to a certain large minority in the USA that needs something to blame for everything other than their own inaction and choice to not adapt.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by bko on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:12PM (#44988606)
I don't know if that's really it. In the US, sure, there was a direct line of communication between all the large social media companies and the federal government. It was used to censor what was deemed "conspiracy theories" around covid and election interference. That could be seen as protecting politicians.

But in the UK, what I read about is cases where it offended someone, like the case of a an autistic teenage girl who was arrested after she made a comment to a police officer, reportedly saying the officer looked like her "lesbian nana." Obviously this doesn't threaten government control or politicians, so it doesn't exactly fit the same mold.

https://mleverything.substack.com/p/what-would-government-ce...

https://www.reddit.com/r/ukpolitics/comments/15nddel/autisti...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by EasyMark on Saturday August 23, 2025 @12:29AM (#44993167)
That's so true with the current Republican controlled Congress bending a knee every time to the Mango in charge. Other than the occasional furrowed brow or momentary pause.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by cut3 on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:57PM (#44988412)
isnt this everyone in power?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by bko on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:06PM (#44988528)
I heard things about UK arresting people for social media posts but thought it was just a few cases cherry picked. But I recently looked up the scale of arrests and it's really insane.

Police are arresting over 12,000 people each year for social media posts and other online communications deemed “grossly offensive,” “indecent,” “obscene,” or “menacing.” This averages to around 33 arrests per day.

These arrests are primarily made under Section 127 of the Communications Act 2003 and Section 1 of the Malicious Communications Act 1988, laws which criminalize causing “annoyance,” “inconvenience,” or “anxiety” to others through digital messages.

Utterly insane.

https://nypost.com/2025/08/19/world-news/uk-free-speech-stru...

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by conradfr on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:37PM (#44988897)
It's more damning when you see who (and the cases) they don't arrest in the mean time.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by PieTime on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:12PM (#44988616)
Sadly this trend is echoed in the US as well since 2023 many have been arrested for their freedom of speech https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3rnzp4ye5zo
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by bko on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:18PM (#44988698)
I don't think that's the same thing:

> The DHS statement says that Ms Kordia had overstayed her student visa, which had been terminated in 2022 "for lack of attendance". It did not say whether she had been attending Columbia or another institution.

I think it's entirely different arresting people who overstay their visas or people on student visas that disrupt academic life. The UK regularly arrests citizens for offensive memes. There have even been cases where someone got a harsher sentence based on a tweet about sexual assault than the person who actually committed a sexual assault.

You can feel any way you'd like about free speech in America, but let's not conflate the two as being equal.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by verzali on Saturday August 23, 2025 @12:38AM (#44993211)
I'm far more worried that America will stop me at the border and mistreat me for something I wrote online than I am about the UK. Heck, I'm more worried about visiting the US than China at the moment. The America effort to suppress free speech is very real.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by foldr on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:37PM (#44989516)
The flip side of this is that convictions under the Communications Act have gone down compared to 2010, so it's a mixed picture:

https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/select-communications-off...

It is hard to get good data on this, but it is probably a combination of overzealous policing (which is indeed bad) and an increase in arrests for behavior that arguably is a police matter, such as domestic abuse, harassment, etc. I would not be surprised to discover that there is more online harassment now than there was in 2010.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by KETHERCORTEX on Friday August 22, 2025 @06:36PM (#44990740)
> I would not be surprised to discover that there is more online harassment now than there was in 2010.

There is simply more people online now than in 2010.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by foldr on Friday August 22, 2025 @07:17PM (#44991128)
That's a good point! The growth in arrests shown in the article I linked starts in 2017, though. I think internet usage has gone up significantly by some measures since 2017, but whether or not that's sufficient to explain the increase in arrests, I am not sure.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by sunshine-o on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:40PM (#44989543)
By the way at that scale it is very counterproductive.

If you are gonna end up being arrested for protesting or giving your opinion, it is funnier to do it in the streets than on facebook. And it is probably much easier to be anonymous nowadays in the streets with a mask than on social media.

This is probably why the UK went in flame recently, the government cracked down on the Internet and people just went in the streets instead.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by ethbr1 on Friday August 22, 2025 @05:49PM (#44990279)
Wasn't there some documentary a few years ago about UK citizens protesting in masks? Narrated by that guy from The Matrix?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by cyanydeez on Friday August 22, 2025 @07:42PM (#44991312)
America is like, 2 steps behind with an entire government following
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by rich_sasha on Friday August 22, 2025 @09:12AM (#44984248)
I mean, downstream from 1 it's all as it should be. 100% of the issue is #1, no?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Fanofilm on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:29AM (#44985133)
Step 6: The facebook / Instragram / X equivalents then lose their ad revenue. They then may capitulate to keep the ad revenue.

See BlueSky just rolled out Terms ToS that the automated UN Safety (censorship) laws they will accept. This is an automated pipeline for the "censorship demand data notice" can be applied in an automated why. It is plumbing for automating censorship. See "DSA" part of those laws and how BlueSky's ToS is responding.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by shkkmo on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:11AM (#44985590)
> See BlueSky just rolled out Terms ToS that the automated UN Safety (censorship) laws they will accept. This is an automated pipeline for the "censorship demand data notice" can be applied in an automated why.

I feel like you are missing some words or have some typos because this isn't comprehensible English.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by betaby on Friday August 22, 2025 @03:17PM (#44988687)
It's an understandable English even for non-native speaker like me. You are probably not very exposed to non-native speakers.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by jawilson2 on Friday August 22, 2025 @04:54PM (#44989677)
English speaker for approximately 43 of my 44+ years on this planet. I have almost no idea what this sentence is trying to convey.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by teaearlgraycold on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:30PM (#44991711)
Damn what’s up with that gap? You’re falling behind.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by machomaster on Friday August 22, 2025 @05:59PM (#44990370)
I am non-native speaker and I confirm that the post was gibberish.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by shkkmo on Friday August 22, 2025 @08:58PM (#44991879)
I've spent years living abroad and have had many long discussions and friendships with non-native english speakers.

This could be a non-native speaker, but the complexity of the attempted sentence structure leads me to think it is a native or fluent speaker who made some mistakes (I make those kinds of mistakes all the time.)

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by j_timberlake on Friday August 22, 2025 @10:33PM (#44992534)
"You are probably not very exposed to non-native speakers."

If native speakers have to talk to people of other languages to understand it, then it's not even English at that point. What it is, who knows.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by general1726 on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:22AM (#44985729)
Step 5 is problematic because when people won't put www.4chan.com but will type 4chan into address bar (90% users are doing exactly that) it will trigger search and will easily find some AMPed URL, URL shortener or subdomain to click on.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by gnfargbl on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:49AM (#44986039)
HMG can compel Google not to offer AMPed 4chan in the UK, and can compel ISPs to block mirrors in DNS and by IP. URL shorteners are just a client-side indirection and won't circumvent a block.

There's really nothing that they can realistically do about VPNs, however.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by piltdownman on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:32AM (#44985841)
Performative yes, but it's about controlling their subjects, not punishing the act or preventings its recurrence. Such as it ever was in UK politics.

Think about the logic of KYC/AML laws - introduced wehn HSBC were fined $1.9 billion for laundering Mexican drug cartels and Saudi terrorist cell money. The impact and burden were almost wholly on the consumer, and did nothing to stop institutional bad actors being malfeasant on a macro scale. This was beautifully illustrated HSBC were caught doing the exact same thing 10 years later. And again. And again.

Fast forward to UK culture and politics today and how they're dealing with a globalised world watching them post-Brexit.

Labour (and to an extent the BBC) were pilloried for having an anti-semitism problem over the last decade, and Northern Ireland is typified by proscribed terrorist groups doing public marches with large public terrorist murals. Rather than mitigate any of the causes, or engage with the problem on a societal level, the UKs answer is to arrest 80 and 89 year olds pleading to stop infanticide in Gaza, and charge native-Irish speaking Rappers and Sundance Award Winning actors under the terrorism act

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/jul/24/uk-police-de... https://edition.cnn.com/2025/08/20/uk/irish-rapper-terrorism...

When looking at the current passion for control and restriction of the internet under the guise of combatting CSAM, its important to understand the context under which these disingenuous ploys arise.

US and European readers might not realise that the BBC, the House of Lords, and specific Political Parties in the UK have a very serious child-grooming and paedophilia scandal they've been trying to keep under wraps for 50 years that had the lid blown off by the revelations following Jimmy Saville's death. This is outside the major child-grooming and abuse scandals in the cultural pillars and cultural groups of the UK - e.g. Church of England, The Boy Scouts, the British Public School system etc...

I can't even go into the more recent and utterly appalling Rotherham debacle - and the dereliction of duty of both the police and the legal system - as it would simply take too long.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotherham_child_sexual_exploit...

In 1981 Sir Peter Hayman - Diplomat and MI6 operative who held highly sensitive posts at the MOD and NATO - was called out for being a paedophile, using parliamentary privilege, as he had not been jailed after it was discovered he had left a package containing child pornography on a bus. The DPP and AG declined to prosecute, but Thatcher advised him that he would be stripped of his honours if was caught in a Public Toilet engaging in homosexual acts again, as he was in 1984.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westminster_paedophile_dossier... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/tory-mp-warned-o...

Now that the statute of limitations is running out, and official secrets acts files are due to be unsealed, its time for a pallaver about VPNs and protecting the children from the 'internet'. Given their age and new-found riches in a disenfranchised post-Brexit Britain, the ruling classes of the UK have never been in a more trepidatious position - some commentators even predicting civil war in the next 5 years - so time for some large-scale distractive measures.

Is the UK headed for civil war? | UK Politics | The New ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4urbhc_cOQk

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by Ajedi32 on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:34AM (#44985859)
IMO this whole situation is ridiculous.

#2-#4 are the government trying to impose its national laws on an entity in a completely different country, operating in a completely different country, with no business relationship whatsoever with your country. It's a futile and frankly rather insulting effort; no different from if Iran declared it was illegal for UK women living in the UK to leave the house without wearing a burka.

#5 is an authoritarian offense against your own citizens; trying to prevent them from being able to communicate with people in another country even if they want to do so.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by gherkinnn on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:54AM (#44986099)
Completely besides your point, but Iran mandates a hijab (head scarf, no veil). Burkas (often blue, net in front of face) are mainly found (not sure if mandated or expected) in Afghanistan, whereas the Saudis use niqabs (the black veils). The hijab mandate being the least repulsive.

I know it's an odd nitpick, consider it a compulsion of mine.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by sejje on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:19PM (#44986414)
To be fair, there's no logical problem with an example of Iran demanding UK women to wear burkas even if burkas aren't their cultural norm.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by M95D on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:50AM (#44986058)
We need a DNS server with a history database, not just a cache, preferably with a distributed history database.

Visit a website and it was blocked by the "official" DNS? Declare the IP invalid in the webUI (or the browser plugin) of the local DNS and it will get you the previous IP from the database.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by SoftTalker on Friday August 22, 2025 @11:52AM (#44986079)
/etc/hosts, and /etc/resolv.conf.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by M95D on Monday August 25, 2025 @05:08AM (#45011839)
And get the original IP from where?
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by patrickmay on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:04PM (#44986972)
Or teach people how to point to a different DNS server in an area with laws more amenable to their preferences.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by prmoustache on Friday August 22, 2025 @05:53PM (#44990306)
Until coutry implement the great firewall and it becomes a play of cat & mouse.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by M95D on Monday August 25, 2025 @05:09AM (#45011845)
... or until the blocking starts at the root name servers. There are only a few of them.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by immibis on Monday August 25, 2025 @02:48PM (#45017482)
The root zone file is publicly distributed by IANA [1] so you can download it and ignore the servers themselves. Then your lookup (from the resolver you're running yourself) starts at a particular country's top level.

As for censorship, because it's hierarchical, they'd have to remove an entire country code from the root servers.

[1] https://www.iana.org/domains/root/files

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by CodeArtisan on Friday August 22, 2025 @01:14PM (#44987080)
Brave browser launched a blockchain based domains registry IIRC.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by numpad0 on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:57PM (#44988404)
Domain Name System was an app on the Internet. It wasn't something that always existed. The purpose of it is to provide intuitive means to look up IP address from more intuitive domain name strings.

If you could come up with an alternative system to derive the IP address of desired remote host, or content, e.g. Magnet Link standard, you can just skip DNS and switch to that instead.

TLS can be a problem as a lot of moving parts of WWW now depends on DNS. But all of those can be solved.

Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by PartiallyTyped on Friday August 22, 2025 @12:39PM (#44986633)
Performative or outright extortion.
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by newsclues on Friday August 22, 2025 @02:30PM (#44988012)
6 the 4chan fans all know how to bypass the ban and it’s ultimately ineffective
Re:4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawye... by nly on Friday August 22, 2025 @07:32PM (#44991247)
And the irony is the law itself is encouraging more VPN use, which in turn will allow bypassing of any outright blocks.