News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by fabian2k on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @06:51AM (#41169579)
Doing this on a few weeks notice seems rather insane to me. Unless you have very good remote work options this is very disruptive for employees.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by TheAdamist on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:46AM (#41169901)
Thats generally the point with sudden disruptive moves - high attrition. Reduce the headcount without having to be in the news for layoffs.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by jsheard on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:54AM (#41169961)
They've already cut about 80% of their workforce since Elon took over, I'm not sure how much more attrition they can take. Sure the site still mostly works in the technical sense but their revenue and MAUs have declined significantly for various non-technical reasons.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by LightBug1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:59AM (#41169995)
Who cares?

Workers? They should know better and the best have already left or been culled.

Users?

Advertisers?

Who cares ...

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by optymizer on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:53AM (#41170395)
> Who cares?

> They should know better and the best have already left or been culled.

We should care, even if it's just a little. Some of them may not be able to leave for various reasons: health, family, immigration status, who knows.

Maybe if more of us showed a bit more empathy towards each other online, the Internet wouldn't be such a sociopathic cesspool. These are real people you're talking about, not inanimate objects.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by LightBug1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:15PM (#41172929)
Of course, I agree with you at the individual level.

However, at the macro level, I'm more than happy to see jobs destroyed at insert sh1tty company for the good of both individuals, and the good of the nation/world. Short term pain, long term gain. And don't tell me the workers X/twitter can't get re-hired or land on their feet elsewhere ... so actually, I'm not that sympathetic. Sometimes you have to take a stand.

And that sociopathic cesspool you're speaking of? ... yes, that's right, you could be talking about X/twitter.

So, I appreciate your words of empathy, they're much needed in these times. But I'll be the asshole who dismisses them on this occassion.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by mplewis on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:39PM (#41173829)
Most of the workers stuck at X are on H1B visas or similar, which require them to keep their job or immediately find new employment at a company that will sponsor them.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by LightBug1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:16PM (#41174867)
Ok, I've been too harsh, I accept that ... but there are still many, I'm sure, who choose to remain there ... I have contempt for them.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by shiroiushi on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @01:31AM (#41178501)
How do you feel about the contractors on the Death Star?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by LightBug1 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:10AM (#41179536)
Interesting question. Should have joined the Rebel Alliance, or at least actively worked to sabotage the Death Star. A little mis-solder here, a little wire pull there, and ...
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by nuz on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:00AM (#41169998)
They've cut out things like viewing who liked a tweet etc (for cost savings I suspect) so the site is probably dirt cheap. Can't imagine ads don't pay for the cost of running servers at this point, and a headcount reduction might bring it to profitability.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by kryptiskt on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:15AM (#41170123)
The ads may pay for the servers and reduced headcount[1], but there is no way that they pay for servicing the $10B of high-interest debt that the company was saddled with.

[1] Though with the NYT reporting that the American ad revenues was down 80% to $114M/quarter since the acquisition it might not be so obvious.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by jrpelkonen on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:37AM (#41170277)
Yes, the debt weighs heavily around their neck. If it eventually ends up in bankruptcy, will Elon Musk lose control of his beloved x.com domain name for the second time?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zinekeller on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:50AM (#41170368)
I would imagine that it was set up so that it is rented from Musk (instead of owning* outright), but it's Musk so who knows.

* I know it's still not owned owned but there is still a legal difference between X Corp directly renting x.com (from Verisign) versus leasing x.com by a different owner (maybe Musk, maybe a holding corp) to X Corp.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by chuckadams on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:51AM (#41170377)
He’ll probably name his next kid X. His history at PayPal shows how obsessed he is with that letter.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by deeth_starr_v on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:47AM (#41170837)
He calls his first kid with Grimes X
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ninininino on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:53AM (#41171418)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rahkiin on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:48AM (#41170355)
He’ll probably sell x.com to himself just before that happens
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by queuebert on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:32AM (#41170721)
Maybe they could declare bankruptcy and sell for pennies on the dollar to a mysterious new holding company: Ksum Nole, LLC.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by seanhunter on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:08PM (#41173499)
That's not how a bankruptcy works. In a bankruptcy, the company is owned by the creditors and gets resolved by them. Usually a business will attempt to avoid bankruptcy by filing Chapter 11[1] or similar so they get to propose a plan for restructuring that will pay back the creditors over time, but their actions as debtor in posession are scrutinized by the US trustee to ensure they meet a fiduciary obligation to the debtors, and the debtors can file a court case to appeal both the chap 11 and can try to get the debtor kicked out and a trustee appointed if they aren't acting in their interests.

[1] https://www.uscourts.gov/services-forms/bankruptcy/bankruptc...

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by bn-l on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:35PM (#41174404)
Nah uh. Mr Ksum would find a way.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by queuebert on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:52PM (#41177806)
Yes, I know. It was a joke.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by sebastiennight on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:41AM (#41191384)
Quick heads-up: I think you've written "debtor" instead of "creditor" a couple times in there.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:39AM (#41170776)
> American ad revenues was down 80% to $114M/quarter since the acquisition

Debt service was estimated at ~$100m/mo, with the likelihood that rates on some of the debt could increase substantially since the financing was initially booked in mid 2022.

If these numbers are directionally accurate (and they do not report, so we don't know for sure), this thing is probably closer to losing a billion $ annually than to breakeven.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by mistrial9 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:18AM (#41171086)
> Debt service was estimated at ~$100m/mo

source?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @11:03AM (#41171549)
Many sources for this, including:

https://www.thestreet.com/technology/elon-musk-has-a-huge-tw... and

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/30/technology/elon-musk-twit...

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-05-03/twitter-s...

If you don't like my choice of sources, any popular search engine will help you surface additional sources.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dragontamer on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:49PM (#41173952)
$13 Billion leveraged buyout means that Twitter took on $13 Billion in loans for the privilege of being bought out by Elon.

Assuming a rough interest rate of 10% to 15%, leaves 100million to 150million / month on debt alone.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by throwaway2037 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @02:56AM (#41178864)

    > Assuming a rough interest rate of 10% to 15%
Do you have a source on this? I couldn't find anything.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dragontamer on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @09:36AM (#41181333)
On Twitters specific loan terms? No.

But market rates are well known and well published. CCC class loans were 10% in April 2022 when these deals were likely. So 10% to 15% covers the possible range of loans if you know much about the market.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BAMLH0A3HYCEY

The higher end of 15% would be possible if the loans were finalized closer to May or June.

There is a big difference from Feb 2022 vs April 2022 though. But we know the rough timeline of Twitters acquisition as well as the rough timeline of when deals were signed. So I'm reasonably confident in an April 2022 deal.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @09:43AM (#41181405)
Lower tiers of non-investment-grade corporate bonds currently yielding ~14%:

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BAMLH0A3HYCEY

Looks like when he took down the financing, rates would have been in the 12% range. Possible some/all of the debt has been rolled over since then, possibly at higher rates.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by citizenkeen on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:40AM (#41170307)
I will wager a box of donuts the like-hiding was due to some combination of politics and Musk’s embarrassment for being called out every time he liked some cringe porn-adjacent tweet.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dragontamer on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:48PM (#41173934)
The issue is the $13 Billion loans and estimated $1.3 Billion/year interest payments.

I'm sure Elon can wipe those out himself, but it's still a lot of money that isn't accounted for. Twitter cannot merely float at barely profitability. Twitter needs at least $1.3 Billion/year to counteract interest payments.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by throwaway2037 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:02AM (#41178901)
Elon can either directly pay the loans himself, or lend money to Twitter/X.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dragontamer on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @10:16AM (#41181712)
He could, but hasn't done so yet.

Instead, Elon continues to make decisions like closing Twitters headquarters.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by wonderwonder on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:54PM (#41174019)
I actually don't think the removal of like views has anything to do with revenue.

I think they actually did this so users are free to like whatever they want without having to worry about getting vilified for liking something that is not supported by the majority. For example liking something political or anti whatever.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by chii on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @08:42AM (#41180798)
which i think is a good thing - but i wish there's a toggle to allow the user to choose.

Sometimes i find interesting twitter accounts or posts through likes, and that's now gone.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by throwaway290 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:17AM (#41170139)
I don't know if you are serious but because of LLMs trained on our work basically every tech company is scrambling for ways to get rid of programmers. Just yesterday I commented in a thread here where someone said 80% of their work is LLMable "bullshit" (somehow that guy, like many, didn't connect it to headcount or likelihood of keeping own job...)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ben_w on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:32AM (#41171191)
Even if it wasn't for LLMs, it feels like a long time since I did more than convert someone else's Figma (or Adobe XD, or Photoshop document) into code, and glue it to a pre-existing API.

I'm sure real estate lawyers feel much the same about how rote their work is.

People pay for that, and it's valuable, but it does feel like these tasks should've been automated away a decade ago, without LLMs.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by throwaway290 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @12:43PM (#41172561)
Lawyers or real engineers can only push a button and still have secure jobs because they have licenses/certifications/boards and liabilities with consequences. There is no such thing in programming. (Even though our mistakes can and do also lead to real people dying)

> it feels like a long time since I did more than convert someone else's Figma (or Adobe XD, or Photoshop document) into code, and glue it to a pre-existing API

That looks like webdev, that's like a minuscule part of all programming in question.

> automated away a decade ago, without LLMs.

I think LLMs is the worst part of it because literally what programmers do is used against them. It's like taxi drivers used to train self driving cabs to automate themselves out of jobs, except imagine self driving cars actually worked and there are no unions or protective gov regulation and taxi drivers all cheer for this because each thinks the whole firing and pay reduction is only for someone else not themselves:)

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ben_w on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:13PM (#41172897)
> That looks like webdev, that's like a minuscule part of all programming in question.

Mobile, even smaller.

> It's like taxi drivers used to train self driving cabs to automate themselves out of jobs

I was talking to a taxi driver pre-pandemic (from his passenger seat) who was enthusiastic about FSD even though it would end his career.

And if FSD AI don't perform some of their training by trying to predict what all the other cars will do, they're missing out on a huge opportunity.

More broadly, I think this pattern applies to all labour: surveillance is easy, humanoid robots exist.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by throwaway290 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @12:07AM (#41178152)
FSD is moot because it didn't work in the end.

> this pattern applies to all labour

Yup, that was the point of the taxi analogy.

It is why unions/gov protections/certifications exist... accountability and keeping society from unraveling

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ben_w on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @01:36AM (#41178517)
> FSD is moot because it didn't work in the end.

"Work" isn't Boolean — the self drive AI does exist, just not well enough to do everything and even the "F" (though the Waymo AI seems to be?)

The same quality may be worse or better in specific roles, but AI isn't stationary.

> It is why unions/gov protections/certifications exist... accountability and keeping society from unraveling

No, but it is why the Amish and literal communism existed — but in the latter case, they weren't opposed to the automation itself just the unfairness of using profit to make workers redundant.

Unions are more about fair pay for fair work, and safe conditions in that work. Certifications are consumer protection.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by throwaway290 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @02:44AM (#41178823)
Dunno much about the Amish. Communism was (in practice a power grab, but in theory) very much in favor of automation. Hyping LLM training without licensing original works and calling for banning copyright and patents is what reminds me of communism a lot these days. I saw someone call it "IP communism". Let's see how well it works for innovation;)

I am not against automation too. We all used autocomplete. But it is amusing to see people sawing off the branch on which they sit, encouraging each other to do so and spitting on people who point it out.

I don't believe in communism and I think anarchocapitalism is maybe as bad as communism.

> Certifications are consumer protection.

If you think certifications are just consumer protection then you are missing big part of the picture. In the end it is protection for every side.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ben_w on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:57AM (#41179192)
I've only seen half the stuff you're calling "IP communism", but many are inspired by the "fully automated luxury gay space communism" meme, so sure :)

> I don't believe in communism and I think anarchocapitalism is maybe as bad as communism.

I've met both, and yup; though the communists seemed more sociable, neither could really understand that the other existed except as caricature.

> If you think certifications are just consumer protection then you are missing big part of the picture.

I was unsure if I should have written "also" in that sentence; but I didn't write "just" ;)

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by throwaway290 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @04:05AM (#41179230)
> fully automated luxury gay space communism

Thanks, TIL!

Communists may be sociable but being a Russian I don't have a good impression from the ideology.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ben_w on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @04:25AM (#41179330)
Ah, understood :)

FWIW, I'm fairly sure the communists I know have a blind spot for all the failures of communist governments and not just the USSR's failures, they put Marx on a pedestal and insist the evidence to the contrary doesn't count somehow.

As I see equivalent blind spots in anarchocapitalism (any example of bad outcomes is dismissed as "not real free market"), that's why I don't think either communism or anarchocapitalism works.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by michaelt on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:28AM (#41170210)
To me "revenue and MAUs have declined significantly" sounds like a reason they would want to reduce employee numbers, rather than a reason they wouldn't.

At least in a conventional business that uses revenue to pay wages.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by brookst on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:55AM (#41170411)
Layoffs are expensive compared to making people miserable so they quit.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:34AM (#41170739)
Only if you pay severance/etc., which X doesn't.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:11PM (#41173525)
Terminating employees without cause (i.e. due to employee’s poor performance) entitles the employer to unemployment benefits, causing the state to increase the business’s unemployment insurance premiums.

If an employee quits or is terminated due to not coming into work, then they are not eligible for unemployment benefits, and hence the business’s unemployment insurance premiums are unaffected.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @01:20AM (#41178456)
Increased UI premiums on the remaining employees are not likely to approach the cost of "normal" severance for 80%+ of the original staff.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by brookst on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:54AM (#41170405)
There’s how much the company can take, and how much Elon thinks the company can take. He subscribes to the ubermensch view, where him and maybe two other superior specimens of manhood could single handedly run the entire company.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by tiahura on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:26AM (#41170676)
Did you think it would collapse when he canned the 80%
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:34AM (#41170734)
Revenue is down by a larger percentage than the headcount, right? I think that counts as "collapse" by any reasonable definition.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ryandrake on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:30PM (#41173093)
I thought the company would collapse after firing 80% of staff, and for a long time I kept arguing that Twitter was still in the "Wile E Coyote ran off the edge of the cliff but didn't fall yet" phase where they were running on pure momentum. I must admit, as time goes by, it's harder and harder to argue that. I just can't believe that 80% of the company was really just not needed. Every company I've ever worked at was lean to the point where they almost couldn't get anything done due to lack of people. I can't imagine a company that could lose 80% of their people and keep on trucking.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ghshephard on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:09PM (#41173509)
Twitter’s US revenue has dropped -83% from $661M in Q2 of 2022 to $114M in Q2 of 2024 according to: https://twitter.com/RealNeilC/status/1817562915634819464

That's a pretty dramatic collapse.

The thing about Infra - is that if all you want is 99% uptime - that's, with reasonable architectural decisions - relatively straightforward. You can run with a skeleton crew (particularly if you make really smart Infra Decisions like Midjourney, Whatsapp, others have done an outsource 95%+ of your infra to a third party (Discord, Platform Messaging APIs).

As time goes on though, and you go through incident review after incident review, and sharpen things up - and 99% becomes 99.9% you start to get diminishing returns on more Infra Employees - at some point they don't add much reliability value (but boy do they make pager rotation schedules pretty nice).

My sense (from both interviewing and working with them) is that the vast majority of people fired/laid off from Twitter weren't (for the most part - definitely lots of exceptions) core engineers or core infra-people -they were people on the periphery associated with making Twitter a friendly place for advertisers, and just maintaining a healthy work-life balance for the Infra people - a job where you could work your 30-32/hours week without it becoming all encompassing.

When they were fired, Twitter became a very unfriendly place, and the advertisers ran away, and the revenue crashed.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zdragnar on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:57PM (#41174068)
Don't forget that 2022 was still a good time for tech with people recovering from COVID lockdowns. It's not really much of a surprise that they're back to pre-COVID income.

Aside from that, there's the lawsuit the sibling mentioned, plus the coordinated campaigns from groups like Media Matters and others attempting to scare advertisers away.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by hcurtiss on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:56PM (#41174030)
Where would they get revenue numbers on a private company?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by mikeyouse on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:00PM (#41174089)
Musk took a bunch of outside money during the buyout so they're still reporting results to e.g. Fidelity and other debtholders. Hence why we broadly know that investors have lost >70% of their money: https://x.com/danprimack/status/1774456271871033823
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by wonderwonder on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:50PM (#41173968)
They just announced an anti-trust lawsuit regarding what they say is a coordinated effort to remove advertisers from the site. Not advocating one way or the other as to the merits of the claim but an interesting development regarding the revenue drop you mentioned.

https://x.com/lindayaX/status/1820838625245880634

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ghshephard on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:49PM (#41174574)
Companies have to be sensitive to the overton window of their customers. You make a mistake - it can be expensive. Let's ignore X/Twitter for a second - look at what happened to one of ABInBev's brands, Bud Light. They stepped outside that window and got smacked down pretty quickly.

I still don't understand why Musk believes he can dictate to his customers who they should do business with. I can kind of understand regulating what vendors do when interacting, particularly with (for the most part) completely powerless customers caught up in monopolies. But I'm looking forward to digging into the theory of law which suggests that vendors can regulate who/what type of business their customers do.

I've heard of Monosopny's - but it just doesn't feel like there is a "single buyer" in this scenario - and, companies are really, really profit seeking - if there was an opportunity for them to make a lot of money by advertising on Twitter/X, and increasing their revenue, and therefore their stock - I challenge you go find me 1 CFO/VP Marketing in 100 who wouldn't jump at the chance. Their political views would be irrelevant.

The problem is - when all these trust and safety and advertising people were let go -their was nobody left to reassure those CFO/VP Marketing types that something horrible wouldn't happen to their brand on Twitter/X. So they just decided to play it safe until things shook out.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @09:56AM (#41181525)
This lawsuit is ridiculous. If Twitter can sue companies for not advertising, can Tesla sue people for buying vehicles not made by Tesla? Can Google sue companies for advertising on Bing? Can Rivian sue Tesla buyers for not buying Rivians?

The whole notion that Twitter is owed a share of advertising spend (based on what?) is absurd.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by TrapLord_Rhodo on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:47PM (#41177472)
Those numbers don't mean anything. Revenue does not equal profit.

Tesla makes double what GM makes with a 1/3 of the revenue. Twitter was always a money loser. If they made $661M in revenue, but lost 700m, and now they make $114M a quarter with $80M in profits, i wouldn't call that a dramatic collapse but rather a dramatic revival.

Quote profit not revenue when it comes to Elon Companies.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Aperocky on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @06:52AM (#41180046)
So what's the profit?

Assuming all $114M is profit, Elon dropped what, $43B on this?

Which ever way you look at it, it looks pretty bad.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @09:52AM (#41181491)
> now they make $114M a quarter with $80M in profits

> Quote profit not revenue when it comes to Elon Companies.

Notably, the company does not release audited financials anymore. If the company were able to go from breakeven to netting 80% margins, great. But nobody should believe such a turnaround without evidence.

Separately, if the company were netting $320mm annually (using your hypothetical), AND we assign the P/E of best-in-class Meta (which is growing, not shrinking), the company would be worth $8B[1]. Under these generous assumptions, Musk has presided over a $36B (82%) destruction of value in under 2 years.

1 - That's not accounting for the outstanding debt used to finance the deal. Including that makes the value of the enterprise negative.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Lutger on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:32PM (#41173766)
Not able to comment on the technical side, but for sure a lot people who got sacked were on moderation. Some countries like mine eventually lost all moderators specifically working for that country. And it does show in the amount of spam an unchecked racism etc, which is a big reason why many advertisers left.

From a moderation point of view, Twitter arguably did collapse. The technical side is not all there is to it when running social media.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by valval on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @01:57AM (#41178608)
Moderation is just another word for cencorship
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by muddi900 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @09:45AM (#41181424)
Not all censorship is bad. For example, I doubt you would like to be exposed to CSAM or ISIS videos when scrolling Twitter.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by psd1 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @12:15PM (#41182822)
Bollocks. The word "censorship" has connotations of "suppressing truth". There's no uptick of truth. It's not censorship to flush a turd.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dang on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @01:24PM (#41183433)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by orblivion on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:20PM (#41173612)
Depends on your standards I guess. You could cut it down to one person and have a website running. As it stands if you look at most people's profiles when logged out you see tweets starting a couple years ago other than the pinned tweet. I haven't used it much since a bit before Elon took over but generally as I understand it's more buggy and spammy than before. If that's good enough, I guess you could say it's still trucking.

Funny thing is that I took the opposite side of that bet. I figured Elon would slash things that people thought were important but actually weren't, and make it more efficient. It's mostly played out, except that the site is still rickety. But maybe from a business perspective that's not important, which is a shame for us.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ljsprague on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @05:17PM (#41175480)
Definitely more spammy but I have not found it to be more buggy.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gopher_space on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:51PM (#41173981)
> I can't imagine a company that could lose 80% of their people and keep on trucking.

Musk didn't buy Twitter to make money or learn how to run a successful business. "Keep on trucking" isn't what Twitter is supposed to be doing right now. 20% workforce is more than enough to run the operation in maintenance mode, which is exactly what's being asked for.

How many dev-ops roles would it take to just keep the lights on at your org? A dozen? Three? You certainly wouldn't have a need for decision-makers or heavy lifters.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by durandal1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:54PM (#41174624)
By "maintenance mode" you mean shipping more features per year than the pre-Elon Twitter? Remember, the pre-Elon Twitter was completely stagnant and seemingly unable to ship even the most desired features.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by WheatMillington on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:47PM (#41175185)
Musk has openly said many times he wants X to be an "everything app" and sees huge growth in its future. What makes you think he ever intended to put it in "maintenance mode"?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by padthai on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:12PM (#41173531)
I think Twitter is down 60% in advertisers and 30% in users? Elon personality is part of it, but losing so many people handling community, clients, institutions… I am sure the company has lost most of its institutional knowledge.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Andrew_nenakhov on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:31PM (#41174378)
They have recently reported an all time high usage record, that unsurprisingly happened after the assassination attempt on Trump.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by irksomehails on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @01:27AM (#41178484)
I wonder if that record takes bots into account because the site is now teeming with bots, even more so than before.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by onion2k on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:28PM (#41174350)
80% was need to grow the business. If Twitter chooses not to grow them it doesn't need those people. It only needs enough to keep the lights on.

If Twitter ever gets a competitor with some traction it'll be dead in months because it won't be able to react. It seems like new social networks aren't a thing any more though so it's probably quite safe.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by recursive on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:10PM (#41173522)
People always find a way to justify their existence. In sufficiently large companies you can find people whose job is to satisfy policies invented by other people in other departments. In one sense, they were all "needed" because of the domino effects of some policy created long ago.

But if you get rid of all of it at the same time, it might be tough to see the difference from the outside.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by jokethrowaway on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:12PM (#41173535)
I thought the same when they fired a bunch of people at my old employer (and 98% of the developers left).

Well, they just outsourced everything to cheap devs in India and things kept rolling. No new features and some new bugs, but most things work.

Turns out you don't really need that much to keep lights on.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Lutger on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:39PM (#41173830)
That is true. But you'll:

a) slowly lose to competitors as you can't keep up with increased demands in the space. b) take on more and more existential risks

For a lot of companies, that is exactly what they want to do. Its called the exploit phase, I forgot what business lingo this came from. Do a practical feature freeze, cut costs to the max, and squeeze all the value out the product for as long as it lives. Informally known as enshittification. Its all about cost-cutting rather than market capture.

You can last a while though, especially because there aren't many changes so there's also less operational risk.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by lokar on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:54PM (#41174012)
This is the Broadcom business model
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Zigurd on Thursday August 15, 2024 @10:16AM (#41256386)
It's hilarious that Broadcom bought what was left of Computer Associates. It's like they needed to absorb that PE-with-a-tech-fig-leaf vibe.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by albedoa on Monday August 12, 2024 @10:07PM (#41231464)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by brabel on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:06PM (#41173483)
Not really, revenue seems to have fallen but not so much and it's growing again according to this: https://www.businessofapps.com/data/twitter-statistics/

    2014 1.4
    2015 2.2
    2016 2.5
    2017 2.4
    2018 3
    2019 3.4
    2020 3.7
    2021 5
    2022 4.4
    2023 3.4
Number of users is actually larger than ever now:

    2015 304
    2016 313
    2017 310
    2018 298
    2019 312
    2020 347
    2021 362
    2022 401
    2023 421
I think everyone can agree this looks nothing like "collapse".
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by AlexandrB on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:24PM (#41173658)
Where is this site getting revenue numbers for 2023 & 2024? The company is no longer public and doesn't issue public earnings reports AFAIK.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by edmundsauto on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:18PM (#41173583)
The linked article doesn’t seem to say anything about growth in revenue numbers - but it does say overall revenue has dropped 50% since Musks takeover. The quarterly chart doesn’t look great either.

Further, the brand has been tainted and Threads was allowed to pop up. Now threads is around 1/4 to 1/3 the size of Twitter MAU. It may not have replaced Twitter, but the door has been opened and that seems like an unforced error.

This election season looks poised to further drive long term disengagement as the platform is going to be very toxic and very unmoderated.

Otoh, profit might actually be up - if revenues are down 50% but costs down 80%, it may make more money. I suspect, like other private equity investments, this will not work for too long. With how much Musk has put his personal brand onto the site, it may also be difficult to unload the pieces at a profit as per the normal PE playbook.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zdragnar on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:37PM (#41173813)
Don't forget the peak happened during COVID- where it is at now isn't really much different than where it was before, if the numbers are accurate anyway.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by brabel on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:34PM (#41173785)
> if revenues are down 50%

Check the actual graphs! It went down by 50% briefly, but then increased again. It's still lower than before, but not by that much.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by bigstrat2003 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:52PM (#41175233)
> Further, the brand has been tainted

The brand was never not tainted. Twitter has long been known as one of the cesspools of the Internet, actively contributing to the degradation of the social fabric. It would be a great blessing if Elon did actually kill it the way his detractors predicted. Twitter delenda est.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by skissane on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:42PM (#41177085)
> Threads was allowed to pop up. Now threads is around 1/4 to 1/3 the size of Twitter MAU

Main thing I consume on X nowadays is space journalism. Plenty of big name space journalists seriously posting on X (e.g. Jeff Foust, Eric Berger). I had a look at Threads, I can't find any of that content, mostly just people posting silly memes and mind-numbingly misinformed takes on the topic, at best people just reposting stuff that you'll already find better coverage of on X.

> This election season looks poised to further drive long term disengagement as the platform is going to be very toxic and very unmoderated.

I don't find much "toxic" on X. If you only read stuff posted by people you follow, and are selective in who you follow, you can have a pretty curated experience.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by slashdave on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:53PM (#41174614)
> Number of users is actually larger than ever now

So... you mean the bot detection is now more broken?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:17PM (#41173575)
Is there a reason to assume this website has access to audited figures from a private business like Twitter?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by vecter on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:25PM (#41173670)
Isn't revenue declining according to that data?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by brabel on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:30PM (#41173751)
Look at the revenues per quarter. It was growing in 2023, but declined in the first quarter of 2024, but I wouldn't say you can make conclusions for 2024 from one quarter.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by vecter on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:43PM (#41173877)
That's the wrong way to read revenue graphs. You need to compare quarterly year over year. From that perspective, it's down across the board.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by brabel on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @02:33AM (#41178763)
No one is comparing year over year, there's been barely a year since the acquisition. I said the "arrow" over the latest few quarters was generally UP, in response to a mistaken argument that Twitter/X has collapsed. I am not trying to say Elon is great or something like that, I am making an observation of what the charts say, that's all. I don't know if the charts are 100% accurate, but I have no reason to doubt either... Why anything that may be positive about X is so controversial, even something as uncontroversial as the direction of an arrow on a damn graph? People seem to lose all rationality over this guy, what the hell is going on?! Do you actually have figures showing completely different results?? IF no, why all of a sudden people are so completely skeptical of it?! Sounds like discussions about climate change: someone shows a chart with temperatures way up, all of a sudden everyone is an expert and points out it was higher 60 million years ago or whatever, or the data cannot be fully trusted because they learned in high school that these are just estimates or other crap on the same vein. It's embarrassing for the human race.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by vecter on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @11:10AM (#41182230)
The point has nothing to do with Elon. It's just the correct way to analyze revenue graphs due to seasonality. Whether or not X is "collapsing" isn't obvious from the graphs either, and I made no such claim. We'd need to know other things that aren't public, and it's probably too early to tell anyway. But it's incorrect to say that revenue is growing. It's down quarterly YoY, which is the only real meaningful way to look at it.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by edmundsauto on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:22PM (#41176970)
Further, everything after Musk bought it is just a guess. Without public audited numbers, who knows what is going on. If I had to bet, I would guess the numbers are even lower than estimated - if things were hunky dory, I doubt they would be suing their customers (advertisers).
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @10:23AM (#41181778)
Let's assume we can trust these numbers. The user count is not material for a site that has already scaled and monetized, so focus on the actual money changing hands.

That is obviously in decline but does alone not capture how much worse off the company is today than before the acquisition. In 2022, the company did $4.4B in revenue and had negligible debt. In 2023, the company possibly had debt service payments in the range of $1.2B for the year. If you back out the mandatory debt service, 2023 looks more like $2B in topline.

Put another way: Twitter 2022 was significantly more capital-efficient than Twitter 2024.

Similarly, one can run a simple model of the value of the company now. Once you include the $13B in outstanding debt, you will end up with a negative number.

Yes, this business is currently in "collapse."

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by brightball on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:35PM (#41173790)
Well, based on today’s activity there is apparently some conspiracy involved.

https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1820849880283107725?s=46&t=alZ...

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by runako on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @10:15AM (#41181696)
If you're suing your customers? With frivolous lawsuits? You are admitting that your business is in collapse.

There's no mystery here. The company cut Trust & Safety so that people could post whatever they want under the guise of "free speech." This means more objectionable (to advertisers) content on the site. Advertisers do not want to run ads next to objectionable content.

Worse, Twitter was never big enough to really matter to big ad spenders. So it's small, doesn't have the ability to move the needle for any big advertiser, and now CMOs/ad agencies have to worry about their ads being run next to 4chan-quality posts? Easy decision to stop spending there. There's really no conspiracy involved here.

At base, this is a simple conflict of ideas. Twitter management wants to create a space where people can post ideas that may be broadly seen as objectionable, even if they are legal. Big advertisers are well-known for restricting their ads to more sanitized spaces (this practice predates the Internet). The goals of Twitter management are directly in conflict with the goals of big advertisers. This was the obvious way for this situation to unfold.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by chairmansteve on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:46PM (#41173909)
"where him and maybe two other superior specimens of manhood could single handedly run the entire company" - while driving their manly cyber trucks.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by sleepybrett on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @05:14PM (#41175452)
Correction: "While their manly cybertrucks drive them"
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by nicce on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:12PM (#41176513)
If they happen to work…
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dbbk on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:59AM (#41170930)
> Sure the site still mostly works in the technical sense

They just auto-banned everyone who downloaded their new Mac app so... no

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ben_w on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:01AM (#41170953)
Oh? I missed that news.

Edit:

This, I guess: https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/other/x-kills-its-mac-app-ac...

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by justinhj on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:11PM (#41176915)
“ If you're a Twitter diehard who's not willing to swap to X, it might be finally time to ditch X for Mastadon or Threads. On your way out, don't forget to delete your X account.” journalists are so biased against X
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by justinhj on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:04PM (#41177570)
ofc a “journalist” just outright tells people to delete their X accounts and I get a downvote

the anti musk shit on this site is counter to logic and ideological

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by amiantos on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @01:30AM (#41178500)
You're getting downvoted because you're just regurgitating the Elon Musk fanboy "journalists hate X because they're threatened by it!" and "journalists are biased and not trustworthy!" party line nonsense like a complete weirdo.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dbbk on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:48PM (#41177478)
Yep happened to me. 16 year old account. Oh well, Threads it is.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by jandrese on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:59PM (#41174079)
4Chan was run by like one guy using the change he found in the cushions of his couch.

Getting the pixels on people's screens is the easy part. Keeping the Nazis and bots at bay is the expensive part. You have to do the latter if you want to keep the advertisers on your site, which is why X switched to a more for-pay model and still loses money hand over fist. Being able to pay to have your voice amplified has been a real boon for the fascist users on X, they're having a great time.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rabuse on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:22PM (#41174290)
I much prefer the Twitter of today. Since I'm a grown adult, I can handle some mean words being seen by my eyes, and just ignoring what I don't like. It's nice seeing a balance of both sides of an argument now, rather than only seeing the left biased information.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by jandrese on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:49PM (#41174576)
"You and everyone like you should be rounded up and executed" is a just a mean message, but it's also dangerous. People will believe that stuff, and then try to do it. This isn't a theoretical danger, it has happened time and time again throughout history. These sorts of seductive messages that target out-groups and provide a sense of community have lead to real life horrors.

X has also gotten very bad about amplifying misinformation, especially on white supremacist topics. Just yesterday (maybe the day before?) that bullshit old paper that said sub-Saharan Africans had an average IQ of 55 made it to the top of the feed with no community notes. The comment section was full of great replacement theory blue check guys all agreeing with one another and making it sound like there was a consensus. People see stuff like this and actually believe it. Frankly I wouldn't be surprised if Elon himself re-Xed it at some point.

[dead]
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by mvdtnz on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:03AM (#41179509)
No. Left biased information is what was on twitter before. Not everything you disagree with can be classed as nazi.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Shocka1 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:33PM (#41184565)
I was a big Reddit user back in 2015/16 and also spent a lot of time in the NPR comments. Watching the insanity around the 2016 election in real time was an interesting experience. The mass suppression on Reddit and NPR shutting their comment section down was enough to form my opinion on this whole thing.

That being said, I've enjoyed it since the takeover. It still seems very similar to what it used to be, but feels very much like I'm seeing it from both ends now. For every crazy right leaning comment there are plenty of crazy leftists that counter, and vice versa.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by happyopossum on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:02PM (#41174113)
> but the way it works now has led to a significant decline in revenue and active users

I don' think that's completely true - MAUs are up this year, and hit 500M for the first time last Oct...

[1] https://www.socialmediatoday.com/news/x-formerly-twitter-sha...

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Starlevel004 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @05:24PM (#41175546)
Given the replies to every popular tweet, I don't really believe those are actual people.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by cyphertruck on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:03PM (#41174726)
Active users on the site is setting records pretty regularly, according to Linda. Usability and performance of the site is far higher than before in my experience as well. Revenue is down only due to an illegal cartel boycott, which X has recently filed a lawsuit to resolve.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by latentcall on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:08PM (#41174784)
"illegal cartel boycott"

I'm not sure what you're talking about, can you fill me in a little bit?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by BobAliceInATree on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:16PM (#41174861)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by cyphertruck on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @08:16AM (#41180594)
Except he is not suing advertisers. The Verge is fake news.

He is suing a literal cartel after their crime was exposed in congress.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by BobAliceInATree on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:50AM (#41191495)
And what is this supposed "cartel" composed of? Advertisers.

Yeah, congress "exposed" it, when it's right on their website (https://wfanet.org/leadership/garm/about-garm)

This is just another of Musk's "free speech for me, but not for you" lawsuits that never go anywhere and are designed to waste your money with lawyers.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by cyphertruck on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @08:29AM (#41180688)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by WheatMillington on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:38PM (#41175063)
Elon?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by verandaguy on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:40PM (#41176707)
I've only seen the words "illegal cartel boycott" being used (verbatim, as it were) by Musk, as well as the Twitter account of something called Rumble who are apparently joining Musk in trying to sue the advertisers who left the platform in response to it becoming too volatile to associate their brands with.

Is this the illegal cartel boycott you're talking about?

Would it not be an expression of free speech and advertisers' choice to disassociate from another entity, seen through the lens of Musk's famous free speech absolutism combined with corporate personhood? At worst, wouldn't it be the invisible hand of the free market acting to telegraph reduced demand in a resource by its previous consumers?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by cyphertruck on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @08:22AM (#41180633)
Government using force, whitewashed with a thin veneer of an NGO to cartelize advertisers and censor twitter is not “free speech”.

You pretended to be unaware of the situation then you straight up lie to push the dishonest narrative.

You support censorship.

This site literally bans anyone who defends conservative positions.

There’s nothing more hypocritical than leftists pretending to care about human rights.

I’m not going to indulge pretending otherwise.

You cannot lie your way into moral superiority.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by mmmmmbop on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @09:07AM (#41181032)
This take, which is taken straight from Elon, is plainly hilarious.

They claim to be the last bastion of free speech, but when advertisers exercise their free speech and go advertise someplace else, suddenly that's unacceptable.

Same way Elon goes on and on about how they won't moderate hate speech and will only ever delete content if it's illegal by law, 'cause "otherwise it'd be censorship". But then with the legal and publicly available information posted by ElonJet, that was different and everybody who ever mentioned it was banned.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by verandaguy on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @02:00PM (#41183736)
>Government using force, whitewashed with a thin veneer of an NGO to cartelize advertisers and censor twitter is not “free speech”.

This is squarely in conspiracy theory territory, but doesn't really justify the thought that association between any group of private entities could be compelled.

> You pretended to be unaware of the situation then you straight up lie to push the dishonest narrative.

I think this may have been in reference to another commenter.

> You support censorship.

I literally have spent much of my career on teams trying to find technical workarounds to online censorship in dictatorial regimes. What Musk's Twitter stands for these days is closer to the censorship seen in those places than it was before Musk took over.

I'll also add that what the US Right often decries as censorship is... jarringly hypocritical, at best. I won't get started on here.

> This site literally bans anyone who defends conservative positions.

Summarily incorrect. I don't know that there have been any high-profile bans since I joined, but HN does delete conversations where people who aren't constructively participating in the thread are. It wouldn't surprise me if this thread got removed, for example.

I'm not going to entertain your remaining points since those aren't really substantial enough to even talk about.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by llamaimperative on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:48AM (#41169918)
Or the company is just led by a highly erratic narcissist with a track record (across several companies) of not treating his employees well.

Build cult, treat like cult members.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by BirAdam on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:08AM (#41170063)
I dunno. He seems somewhat consistent. I think people just generally don’t like the things he’s consistent about.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ulfw on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:24AM (#41170182)
He is a consistent liar making fall promises that never come to fruition.

I think people just generally don’t like being constantly fooled.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ben_w on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:36AM (#41171221)
> making fall promises that never come to fruition

That's definitely not consistent; the SpaceX stuff may be always behind his schedule, but it does actually deliver, and even those delays are ahead of the rest of the entire industry planet-wide; and those cars he sells don't have FSD, but they do actually exist and are really electric (the sucess of electric cars over e.g. hydrogen wasn't a given even when he took over).

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by FireBeyond on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @11:58AM (#41172123)
> those cars he sells don't have FSD, but they do actually exist

Well, except the $30K Model 3, and the $35K CyberTruck (Musk can promise all he likes that it's coming next year, but I see it coming at all as a snowball's chance in hell).

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by llamaimperative on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @11:25AM (#41171822)
SpaceX seems mostly operated by Gwynn, and the electric cars existed before Musk ever bought into Tesla.

Directionally agreed though, he and his companies have achieved some really remarkable things. Makes the fall from grace, especially in such foreseeable ways (i.e. self-radicalizing on Twitter), all the more disappointing.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ben_w on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @11:57AM (#41172119)
> SpaceX seems mostly operated by Gwynn, and the electric cars existed before Musk ever bought into Tesla

Neither of which matters; the SpaceX promises are still Musk's, and the pre-Musk Tesla was losing money on each sale (all <= 147 of them).

> Makes the fall from grace, especially in such foreseeable ways (i.e. self-radicalizing on Twitter), all the more disappointing.

Agreed.

To me, colonising Mars has a huge romantic appeal… but there's no way I'd want to be in a disconnected space habitat with an (orbital position dependent) 6-30 month return-to-Earth delay, if he's in charge of it.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by toast0 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:23AM (#41170175)
I don't know what the established criteria are for 'reasonable commuting distance' in the SF Bay area, but seems like a big forced transfer like this might need a WARN act notice, which is going to get the company in the news for layoffs. And probably in the news for not providing the notice in a timely fashion, too.

This would be a bad look for a company that cared about how it looks.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by jorts on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:29AM (#41170215)
SF to San Jose would be a horrible commute via car, which not everyone has.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by nomdep on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:40AM (#41170784)
Because they are paying SF rents? If they moved to San Jose wouldn’t they solve two problems at the same time?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by TechnicolorByte on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:48AM (#41170847)
If you enjoy being bored to death, perhaps.

Somehow I think the group of people who choose to live in SF have particular interests and desired amenities that make high rent worth it. E.g., walkable and lively neighborhoods, access to parks, events, etc.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by saagarjha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @05:19PM (#41175497)
You should check what rent in San Jose is.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by deeth_starr_v on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:47AM (#41170843)
Not to bad via 280
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by toast0 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @12:34PM (#41172458)
From what I could tell, the 'standard' for reasonable commute measures from the employee's home, not from the original location to the other. But the federal WARN info says 'reasonable' varies by locale, and didn't offer any specifics.

Moving the office is probably neutral or better for people on the Penisula. And may be neutral for parts of the East Bay. Depends on where exactly in San Jose the new office is too.

Also, I was surprised by how light traffic was when I drove from Mountain View to SF last October during what I was expecting to be the morning rush hour. I don't recall what the reverse direction looked like, though.

But my point was kind of to raise the likelyhood that this action was taken without regard for how it looks, and without regard for required notifications.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by bijutoha on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @11:45PM (#41187910)
It's an exciting move by X! They seem to adapt to the changing work environment. I wonder how this relocation will impact their company culture and operations in the long run.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by anonzzzies on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @06:54AM (#41169596)
I cannot understand why anyone would work there, especially in office. but each their own.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by DevX101 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:37AM (#41169830)
I have him blocked but the CEO has 200 million followers. Even assuming 20% are real people, I'd imagine there's quite a few of those who'd love to work at his company.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rob74 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:15AM (#41170122)
The question is, how many of these "candidates" still love him while/after working at one of his companies?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zwily on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:38AM (#41170285)
Elon has an estimated 110,000+ employees across all his companies. Maybe you can find one and ask?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:30AM (#41170706)
I know one Twitter guy who was a big Elon fan and loved the energy, right up until he got arbitrarily cut in one of the previous rounds of don't-call-them-layoffs.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by AlexandrB on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:36PM (#41173801)
I doubt many of them would be honest with you out of fear of legal consequences: https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesfarrell/2024/03/21/elon-mu...
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rabuse on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:25PM (#41174313)
Yet, they still choose to work under him. I go by actions of people to get their real beliefs.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by educasean on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:31PM (#41174374)
Many people dislike their boss. I severely dislike Elon, but if they do move to the South Bay where I live and I happen to be out of a job, I'd entertain an offer from X.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by loceng on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:40AM (#41169848)
Why do you have him blocked, and just not following him?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by numpad0 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:07AM (#41170055)
Not following is for content you don't mind seeing, muting is for annoying friends you can't be screenshotted blocking, and blocking is for content you don't care.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by JohnMakin on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:44AM (#41169877)
I don’t know if you’ve been on X lately but even if not following him you can receive push notifications from his tweets. Tested this on multiple accounts now, he’s unavoidable unless blocked and sometimes not even then because of all the bootlicker accounts that screenshot and repost his tweets. Frankly it’s made the platform unusable to me, almost nothing he posts is interesting or worth reading.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Aeolun on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:50AM (#41169932)
Why be on X in the first place? I lost all reason to be there about around the time of the rename.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by 1oooqooq on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:02AM (#41170017)
exactly!

reading xitter today is worse than daytime television.

contributing to it's content pool is just counter intuitive.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by loceng on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:55PM (#41173363)
So my understanding is Elon reduced the algorithm's bubble effect - causing people to be exposed to contrarian content, content a person doesn't agree with, so that it would be witnessed by more people.

Do you think it's a problem that people are coddled in bubbles?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by lupire on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:34PM (#41173778)
Do you think it's a problem that people are inundated with rage bait and scams? That's it's own "bubble".

People aren't getting educational and uplifting material shoved into their feeds.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Washuu on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:34AM (#41170254)
If you are a content creator on Twitch or YouTube you pretty are being held hostage on Twitter due to critical mass. Migrating would require a mass protest of large content creators to choose a new platform and move over all at once.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by exe34 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:37AM (#41170280)
It's his personal blog, and he allows the plebs to post comments.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dorfsmay on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:42AM (#41170318)
A lot of scientists and journalists have not moved to other platforms. I tried to use instagram instead but the algorithmic injection of content and a terrible UI make it unusable for me.

I find using Twitter in the "following" mode, as opposed to the default "for you", I get a lot of value content and almost no noise.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by hcurtiss on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:01PM (#41174105)
Even Musk has recommended doing this.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by HKH2 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:21PM (#41177654)
Yeah Instagram's algorithm is garbage. I get repetitive generic content no matter what. It doesn't seem responsive at all.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rendall on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:50AM (#41169933)
I just have Musk muted and I never, ever see his posts nor retweets.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by wokwokwok on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:06AM (#41170042)
I stopped using X because it was literally impossible to not see his posts.

/shrug

My partner has the same. …but, to be fair, who knows what different variants of the platform are given to different people in different regions at different times.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by loceng on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:55PM (#41173364)
Should a person with the most followers in the world have more people seeing, to then be able to know what they are sharing or saying, to then have more eyeballs to scrutinize them?

Should they have more or less eyeballs witnessing them, and responding to them?

I'd rather see what they are saying directly vs. seeing other articles about him that are most likely propaganda nowadays with how corrupted the media currently is, hence partly why ELon felt compelled to buy Twitter-X to begin with.

But fair enough, blocking him then could make sense.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by bigallen on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:47AM (#41169907)
Dissenting opinions are Not Tolerated
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rsynnott on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:58AM (#41170438)
So after naughty ol' Mr Car took over Twitter, but before I stopped using the site (this would probably have been around Oct 22), I started, after never having followed or interacted with him, getting multiple inane tweets from Musk in my feed every day, along with constant suggestions to follow him. So I blocked him (I think he was one of three people in 15 years on the site who I felt the need to block). I assume this is fairly common for Twitter users; can't imagine it's gotten _better_ since.
[dead]
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rsynnott on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:33AM (#41170727)
I mean, they did ask why block him. That's why; the site will bombard you with his stuff until you do, so if you don't like his particular brand of weird loser, well, what you gonna do?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by lrvick on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:02AM (#41169634)
Anyone still using X, let alone working at X, is an Elon Musk fan, or trapped in an H1B.

Either way they are going to do whatever he says no matter how little sense it makes.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by miki123211 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:11AM (#41169677)
You might be right when it comes to employees, but definitely not when it comes to users.

There's a lot of people using X, and the vast, vast majority of them don't care much for Musk or actively dislike him.

THe problem with X is that it is (and always was) sort of an echo chamber, there's no average X user, everybody sees very different content based on what they follow. The average HNer probably won't notice the huge swathes of people who are on there just for sports content or their favorite celebrity. Those people usually don't care much for Musk, except when he appears in some funny meme.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by danielscrubs on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:57AM (#41169977)
Im there for finance news and compiler tech. It’s the only platform where I don’t feel like I am force fed Hollywood drama. You just have to follow people you respect instead of people you find amusing.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by 1oooqooq on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:06AM (#41170045)
even for niche topics i only recall "influencers" left there by the time i left.

i guess it's the new Facebook, social network for old people who will not open a different app ever, for some small groups?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by dmix on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:42AM (#41170316)
Twitter has always skewed older, in terms of not having kids on it, but it's still mostly people in their 20s and 30s. And there's far less 50+ yr olds in 2024 than FB according to statista:

Twitters largest demo is 25-34yr olds = 36%, 18-24 = 34.2%. While 50+ yr = 7%

https://www.statista.com/statistics/283119/age-distribution-...

Facebooks largest demo is 25-34yr olds = 24% followed by 35-44 = 19%. While 50+ yr = 24%

https://www.statista.com/statistics/187549/facebook-distribu...

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by 1oooqooq on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:16PM (#41172933)
16-28 is the gold of demographics. all those numbers skew A LOT to the lower end of the age range to pretend they have that demographic when in reality they do not.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by miki123211 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:53PM (#41173998)
If you look at "latest" and not "recommended", you don't see those, and if you do, you can just unfollow.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by andrewinardeer on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:23AM (#41169744)
Isn't it only an echo chamber if you follow people with the same outlook and idealogy?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by madeofpalk on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:32AM (#41169793)
Echo chamber might not be the right word, but most people are/were on Twitter for a relatively narrow usecase. You joined Twitter for Fortnite content, or for web development, or for local stuff. It's why these groups were described as "media twitter" or "Black twitter" or 'NBA twitter"
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by pjerem on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:30AM (#41169775)
It’s not like this anymore I think. I destroyed my Twitter account way before the acquisition by Musk.

But I recently created a disposable account because it happens that my regional train lines have hired good community managers and so I know I can reach them. Otherwise I just never use it.

Since I subscribed to basically nothing, I’ve got the full algorithm version. It’s frankly horrible. I’m submerged by far right content and civilization wars.

It’s perfect for my social media addiction because it make me want to leave as soon as I finished what I had to do but it really feels like an unsafe place for anyone who somehow still have some mental health left.

I imagine that people with more suscriptions are seeing less of this shit but I wouldn’t be so sure and also, I personally wouldn’t tolerate to use a platform with such dysfunctional moderation.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by anonzzzies on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:14AM (#41169692)
Musk pumps himself to the top though; I neither follow or click on his messages, but they still plop in my notifications. Further yes, for some reason people still use it so I have to as well or I sell nothing. However, if it would collapse or have Not Musk, it might be better. We will see eventually.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by orwin on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:19AM (#41169723)
I'm only on Twitter for Sport, but deranged political content tends to infect even that more regularly, so i finally bite the bullet and gave my data to Zuck through Instagram where I don't have to read conspiracy on athletes I actually like.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by 1oooqooq on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:09AM (#41170085)
it's just a matter of time.

when you stop dwelling on the random hot yoga posts while scrolling, after an ad scroll by, they will pump it up to other engagement content to feed the pavlovian cycle.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by orwin on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:35AM (#41171218)
My consumption isn't high enough, I often look up at the interesting sport stories of the week, maybe a dozen post every day during the Olympics, but I used to use Twitter once a month to follow the NBA stories (hopefully it will work on Instagram, else I will end up subscribing to a real sport news media).
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by camillomiller on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:38AM (#41169833)
Used to always be an echo chamber, that’s true. Yet the amount of alt-right, post-facts, no-vax, conspiracy theory shit I’m served on X despite me not following any of that has increased dramatically to the point of making X a cesspool of toxic content. Most of that is spewed or retweeted by Musk himself
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by hn1986 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:19PM (#41172971)
Nah, no matter what you follow, you get pushed extreme right-wing posts. Being on there only helps support Musk and his now Trump following.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Twitter/comments/1ehq5ig/why_are_99...

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by tenebrisalietum on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:19AM (#41170148)
My brother's weird friend, who I don't associate with much, says Twitter is still great for porn. If/when they pull a Tumblr will be the start of their irrelevancy,
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by wkat4242 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @11:37AM (#41171924)
It's great for people to advertise porn and sexual services. It's not very great at monetising them. Most of it is just teasers for OnlyFans et al and more personal services.

I wouldn't really go on Twitter for that.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by anonzzzies on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:04AM (#41169640)
Yeah, he fires people tweeting contrary to his views. Free Speech! Bizarre. Either they agree with that crap or they really need the money.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rwmj on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:54AM (#41169959)
There's free speech and there's amplification of speech. When Musk talks about "free speech" being denied what he's really complaining about is his views aren't being amplified. Obviously he can create a webpage somewhere and write whatever he wants on it (free speech), but that wouldn't be amplified so that's not what he wants. This is presumably also the reason he set fire to so much money buying Twitter.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by piyuv on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:09AM (#41169660)
Free speech is not without consequences.

It’s just that the consequences you face are reverse proportional to your wealth.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by numpad0 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:30AM (#41169779)
That's not free speech, that's just might makes right principle which don't need a fancy name.

Free speech, at least on the Internet, means say what don't get the majority nod and enjoy getting harassed to literal suicide, death, mental health consequences, or all of above. Right makes might, not the normal way around.

IOW, free speech do come with consequences, and it's super-proportional on the Internet.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by anonzzzies on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:11AM (#41169678)
Not for Elon or Trump? Say more insane things (which gets normies banned), get more money.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by hnlmorg on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:26AM (#41169756)
That’s the “reverse proportional” part of the GPs comment.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by anonzzzies on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:41AM (#41169854)
ah yes, I read something different. yep, agree.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gadders on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:32AM (#41170233)
When did that happen?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by anonzzzies on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @10:53AM (#41182076)
Think you can Google; there are multiple cases that made the news.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by anonzzzies on Saturday August 17, 2024 @05:36AM (#41273090)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ThunderSizzle on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:17AM (#41169713)
Couldn't the same be said when Twitter started banning conservatives (aka Trump) and engaged in election interference during the 2020 cycle?

Why would anyone work for an organization that purports to be a digital town square that bans conservatives for "wrong think" while still allowing rather grotesque messages?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by anonzzzies on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:24AM (#41169747)
It is the same thing. Not political, but as far as I know the previous guy didn't whine as much about free speech while not being free speech as the current guy.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by pjerem on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:39AM (#41169845)
Also free speech in law just means you can’t be prosecuted to say stupid things. It doesn’t mean that anyone owes you the canal to say your stupid things.

The previous twitter had (somehow) moderation. You would think what you want about it but you were free to use your free speech right elsewhere.

The difference is that Musk says that it gives you this canal but he lies because he is still moderating the network, except the moderation now favors far right content.

That’s not more free speech than before, that’s just a pro-fascist moderation.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by smcin on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:31AM (#41170230)
I think when you say 'canal' you mean 'channel' (translating from French?), or more commonly 'platform'.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by pjerem on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:30PM (#41174978)
You are right, thank you
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by bigstrat2003 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @05:13PM (#41175438)
Free speech is both an ideal, and something which is guaranteed by law (in some countries anyways). As a matter of law, you're correct. If you aren't prosecuted for your speech, then the law of free speech wasn't violated. But extralegal actions can still be (and often are) contrary to the ideal of free speech and are criticized on that basis. It is common, but erroneous, to conflate these two senses of "free speech".
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by andrewinardeer on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:33AM (#41169800)
It's weird to see people making spiteful comments about working for Musk.

I never see spiteful comments about people who work for British American Tobacco, BP or the Sacklers and these companies have, in my opinion, done far more damage to people, families and society in general.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by magicalist on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:49AM (#41169920)
Maybe you spend too much time in tech forums and not tobacco, petroleum or pharma forums?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by mazurnification on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:47AM (#41169909)
If I can try to explain it - it is overcorrection from times when Tesla and SpaceX were cool with appealing mission places to work on. Bcs of that they could get away with smaller salaries too (although Tesla meteoric rise in value compensate it if you got options as I understand it).
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by numpad0 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:01AM (#41170012)
Text-based hivemind social media like Twitter auto-excludes likes of Trump and Musk. They don't generate text in the Internet sub-language. Twitter users judge, cancel and ignore liberals and conservatives equally hard, I think largely by presentation.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:38AM (#41169836)
The difference is that Twitter didn’t ban conservatives for their political views but for violating their terms of service. In Trump’s case that was continued calls for violence and election interference, more than a hypothetical concern after his followers made an unprecedented violent attack on the U.S. electoral process. As you can easily verify, most conservatives were never banned: the people who were banned made repeated, deliberate violations of the legal agreement that they accepted.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zo1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:08AM (#41170068)
And if those "Terms of Service" heavily aligns with left-wing ideology? Do we then finally concede that Twitter did, in fact, target or disproportionately affect non-left-wing users? Is our next point of discussion about whether we can allow such a huge societal discussion/debate tool to be aligned with a pre-defined set of principles that 50% of people don't agree with? Or rather, on a set of principles that we can't find more than 50% consensus on?

Either way, this is just like normal government laws. One of the big criticisms that Libertarians have over laws is that they're not universally enforced, so they end up being selectively enforced, which just means that "those with power" wield the laws against those they don't like. Same goes here with platforms like Twitter. The rules are vague, opaque, and their enforcement is seemingly random and at the whims of some faceless entity behind their enforcement process. If we all knew these supposed "terms of service" and they did, in fact, have very clear rules and guidelines then there would be absolutely no room for conservatives or anyone else to cry about being targeted.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by MOARDONGZPLZ on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:37AM (#41170281)
But even if, as you argue, calling for violence against people is part of right wing ideology or culture, it still seems reasonable to prohibit that. We do have to draw a line somewhere even against things that may be ingrained in a particular culture and which may have a disproportionate effect on that culture.

But we should examine these choices in a principled way. Still, prohibiting calls for violence doesn’t seem like a gray area…

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zo1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:56AM (#41170914)
I will not use calls for violence as an example for this argument I'm making. I specifically left it vague so we could all apply our own minds on it.

But if i had to pick one it would be the Trans issue. Misgendering and having some rather "blunt" debates on this topic meant the platforms usually sided with the trans or left-wing party.

As for calls of violence: there are many examples where anti-white and anti-right calls for violence and extermination go unpunished and swept under the rug to be memory holed. Let's start by making this a bad thing across the board.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:20AM (#41171098)
> Misgendering and having some rather "blunt" debates on this topic meant the platforms usually sided with the trans or left-wing party.

Do you have an examples?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zo1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:39AM (#41171260)
It's written in their own documents/policies:

https://web.archive.org/web/20230407140923/https:/help.twitt...

The entire doc has an "aura" of being fair, and "protecting" the weak. But it ends up stifling debate and genuine discussion because report-brigades and coordinated attacks by left-wing institutions and left-wing activists (with way too much time on their hands because they are full-time activists) end up targeting right-wing individuals for benign and not-harassing behaviour. I've seen my fair share of anti-white and anti-republican hateful comments and calls for violence, that I don't know why you even need to see examples. Look for them everywhere, even on HN.

Look, this is a very diffuse topic. You're not going to get a clear example and we don't know what was happening behind the scenes at Twitter. But it's very telling that most tech companies are predominantly left-wing donors and have left-wing ideologies. Even if they act to be as impartial as they can, their bias will show because they have anti-republican discriminatory hiring practices.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:59AM (#41171490)
So, to be clear, you’re saying that conservatism is synonymous with directly attacking “other people on the basis of race, ethnicity, national origin, caste, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, religious affiliation, age, disability, or serious disease.”? I couldn’t agree with such a broad claim about millions of people.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zo1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:03PM (#41173452)
I'm not saying that at all.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:37PM (#41173811)
That was the only example you provided, and it contradicts your point.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zo1 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:57PM (#41174063)
"Misgendering and having some rather "blunt" debates" was my example, and that doc absolutely targets it even though arguably misgendering and having blunt debates on the trans issue is not "directly attacking “other people on the basis of race, ethnicity, national origin, caste, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, religious affiliation, age, disability, or serious disease.” according to your accusation.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ToValueFunfetti on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:38PM (#41174440)
Surely you can agree that, if the rule is no "misgendering or deadnaming of transgender individuals", a conservative who is arguing that personal pronouns are silly is either compelled to bow to their opposition or violate the rules. Or that, in an argument about illegal immigration, a conservative forbidden from "asserting that members of a protected category are more likely to take part in dangerous or illegal activities" will find it impossible to convey their belief that illegal immigrants are more likely to commit crime.

I don't personally agree with either position, but those rules clearly give conservatives an explicit disadvantage.

And the implicit advantage was more clear- I don't have a twitter account, but whenever I followed a link there, there were piles of recommended tweets about how white people are all racist, or complaining about toxic masculinity / mansplaining / manspreading, or how christians are evil and hate women, or how much boomers suck- all of this clearly in violation of the rules, none of it censored. Well, maybe some of it was censored, I wouldn't know. But they certainly left quite a lot untouched.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @03:09PM (#41184344)
> Surely you can agree that, if the rule is no "misgendering or deadnaming of transgender individuals", a conservative who is arguing that personal pronouns are silly is either compelled to bow to their opposition or violate the rules.

The only thing they are not allowed to do is make direct targeted attacks against a specific person. You can say this is a dumb policy, you can rant about the concept in general, all you can’t do is say “@alice you’re really named Bob”.

Similarly, you can rant about immigrants and they wouldn’t do a thing as long as you could resist specifically targeting people.

Again, my point isn’t that Twitter was perfect or that they had solved every issue for balancing freedom of speech in an open forum but simply that rules against targeted attacks are not anti-conservative unless you have a very negative view of conservatism. It’s popular to try to score in-group points by whining about censorship but there’s a reason why nobody has been able to provide examples of actual conservative ideas being censored, because they know as soon as they do it’ll turn out to be something else which most people consider reasonable or, like the NYPost ban for hacked materials, a decision affecting one account which was reversed.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by zo1 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:48AM (#41189099)
The rules are designed as such so that "well meaning" and well-thinking individuals such as yourself can provide an aura of protection over their actions, and "technically" be right. But in practice, the debate is definitely stifled in one direction.

Just look at the list of "notable Twitter bans", and you'll see a pattern. Among the clear "incitement of violence" and bot-accounts, there is a huge pattern of "we got banned and we don't know why, but we're vocal about X,Y,Z". One has to read between the lines. I'd be all for your argument and with you if we could have a clean-room look at the Twitter data to confirm, but we don't have that. Where is the twitter ban dataset that we can all have a look at?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_suspensions

Unfortunately, your beliefs align with that of the oppressor's side, so you don't see these and it'll be uncomfortable for you to go out on a limb. You think the system is "working as expected" and "they're only banning you if you target specific people".

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:38AM (#41170291)
> And if those "Terms of Service" heavily aligns with left-wing ideology?

First, they don’t - if they had, you would be able to provide an example rather than confabulating about imaginary scenarios.

Second, private companies are generally not obligated to provide you services on your own terms. If a bar kicks you out from screaming threats at other patrons, your rights are not being violated - go find a place which welcomes you.

Third, it’s not 50%, although I can understand why you’d make that up, but a fraction of a percent. Almost all conservatives were not banned because they didn’t repeatedly violate the terms of service. The ones who were kicked out were given warnings, chose to ignore them, and had the promised consequences.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gadders on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:33AM (#41170239)
>>The difference is that Twitter didn’t ban conservatives for their political views but for violating their terms of service.

LOL. They only enforced their terms of service on conservatives.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by sjsdaiuasgdia on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:07AM (#41170518)
Conservative: I have been censored for my conservative views!

Me: Holy shit! You were censored for wanting lower taxes?

Conservative: LOL no... not those views

Me: So... deregulation?

Conservative: Haha no not those views either

Me: Which views, exactly?

Conservative: Oh, you know the ones

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gadders on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:08AM (#41171005)
Me: Yes, but which ones?

Conservative: I thought Hunter Biden's laptop was genuine. I also thought COVID could have started in a lab in China and that there was no evidence that masks work to prevent spread of the virus. I'm pretty sure Biden has been suffering from cognitive decline for many years and doesn't just have a stutter. I think mail-in voting is open to abuse. Like XKCD, I don't trust electronic voting machines. Those views.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:55AM (#41170407)
Look, we all know you’re making that up but if we take you at face value, you just defined conservatism as the beliefs bad enough to get Twitter’s famously hands-off moderators to act. Nobody got blocked for advocating for smaller government, business-friendly policies, or talking about their religious or family values – it was threats of violence, slurs, targeted harassment, election misinformation, etc. None of the conservatives I know would claim those as defining their beliefs, and they’d be rather insulted to have you define them that way.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gadders on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:09AM (#41171012)
Such gaslighting. It's like the Twitter Files investigation has been memory-holed by the hard left.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:21AM (#41171118)
Surely you can provide specific details of this alleged censorship? It was heavily covered here but even pretty conservative people didn’t see it living up to the PR claims.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gadders on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:35AM (#41171216)
>> Surely you can provide specific details of this alleged censorship

Have you heard of Hunter Biden's laptop?

>>It was heavily covered here but even pretty conservative people didn’t see it living up to the PR claims

Another blatant falsehood.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:55AM (#41171453)
Hunter Biden’s laptop was all anyone was talking about for days. They blocked non-consensual nudity but that’s consistent with long-running policy and had no impact on the political aspects any more than we needed to see Trump and Daniels in action to discuss whether payoffs were appropriate.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gadders on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @11:50AM (#41172059)
They blocked the New York Post's twitter account for talking about it. Not nudity, but actual (alleged) corrupt business deals.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by labcomputer on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:35AM (#41170746)
> you just defined conservatism as the beliefs bad enough to get Twitter’s famously hands-off moderators to act.

This sort of disingenuous reply really isn’t helpful. The GP was clearly accusing Twitter of enforcing their TOS for righty accounts, while not enforcing their TOS when lefty accounts would do similar things.

I don’t think they are correct, but your rhetoric is just going to alienate people and makes your argument look weaker.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:28AM (#41171159)
Can you provide any examples? The poster rather has been rather conspicuously unable to do so, which is hard to reconcile with the broad policy they’re claiming, especially when there are counter examples of accounts which were not blocked because Twitter gave more leeway to political accounts.

The reason is simple: the things which got those accounts closed weren’t traditional conservative positions, and there were plenty of lefty/hard to classify accounts which were also suspended or banned for similar reasons but nobody is sticking up for their behavior and claiming it represents their larger political group.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gadders on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:35PM (#41173154)
Please stop lying. I gave you an example.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:44PM (#41173890)
Dude, you realize we can see the timestamps of your messages? You’re replying to a message left 4 hours ago claiming that something you wrote 2 hours later somehow contradicts it.

Now, as to that specific claim since you actually provided details we can see that it doesn’t support the claim. It’s a single account, not the imagined campaign account conservatives, and Twitter changed their policy around hacked materials specifically to allow what the NYPost did:

https://www.theverge.com/2020/10/30/21542801/twitter-lifts-n...

Again, nobody is saying that Twitter was perfect but there just isn’t evidence supporting the belief that they ran a discrimination campaign against conservatives. Even the much ballyhooed “Twitter Files” fizzled because it made it clear that they bent over backwards accommodating political figures.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by gadders on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:38PM (#41174442)
Yeah, I think the current phrase for this is "delulu".

I give you an example but apparently its not the example you wanted. You expect me to list every right wing account that got pulled? The Babylon Bee got banned as well if that helps you get a grip on reality.

The twitter files never fizzled out, except in the NYT. This is just your unfounded assertion. They were literally a smoking gun.

Twitter took 14 days to change their policy re the Hunter Laptop to slow roll the story breaking fully before the presidential election.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ImJamal on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:20AM (#41171101)
They did not ban Trump for "continued calls for violence and election interference".

Look at the two Tweets they used as a justification of his ban [1]

> The 75,000,000 great American Patriots who voted for me, AMERICA FIRST, and MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN, will have a GIANT VOICE long into the future. They will not be disrespected or treated unfairly in any way, shape or form!!!

And

> To all of those who have asked, I will not be going to the Inauguration on January 20th.

Of course, in the blog post, Twitter claims to have "assessed the two Tweets referenced above under our Glorification of Violence policy"

If those two tweets are glorification of violence, then your post is calling for genocide.

[1] https://blog.x.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspension

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by acdha on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:47PM (#41173925)
Again, if those were all he’d posted and his followers hadn’t just responded to his past calls with a violent assault on the election process, he’d never have gotten banned. As you can see by reading the page you linked, this decision was made with that context in mind after years of crossing the boundaries, and they did not want their corporate resources potentially being used for additional political violence.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by ImJamal on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:57PM (#41174062)
The problem is their claim was those two tweets were violent. If they just said they banned him for behavior outside of Twitter they wouldn't be lying. Instead they claimed two tweets that have literally nothing to do with violence are violent.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by BugsJustFindMe on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:35AM (#41169818)
> bans conservatives for "wrong think"

Which "wrong think" specifically got people banned? Because the vast majority of conservatives on the platform did not get banned, so I'm left wondering which exact people banned for what exact reasons you're thinking of. Trump was removed after the Jan 6 assault on the capital for provoking that violence and repeatedly lying to his followers about the election, which, weirdly, is quite different than for being a conservative.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by animuchan on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:06AM (#41170049)
I remember someone getting banned for a tweet saying "Men are different from women". Not even a conservative person, and a very mild take at that.

See e.g. https://www.nationalreview.com/news/journalist-sues-twitter-...

Getting banned for wrongthink on the old Twitter was a rite of passage, almost every content creator I follow (mostly gaming youtubers, nothing spicy or even controversial) got banned at least once.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by viraptor on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:44AM (#41170822)
What you quoted here and the article you linked are extremely different things. The article states "referring to a transgender individual by their biological sex and opining that “women aren’t men.”". You may not agree with that decision, but I hope you can understand that difference.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by animuchan on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:10AM (#41179533)
I might've linked a different story than the one I thought of — was a result of a quick google search, sorry.

The tweet I've seen wasn't directed at anyone, just a sentence to the effect of "Women are different from men". By a feminist, so likely not a conservative.

Harassing a trans person is terrible behavior, sure. Like with any other person. (I.e. that's not a wrongthink issue.)

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by cuttysnark on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:20AM (#41170154)
From where I'm standing, it looks like when Dorsey was CEO, leftist accounts got more leniency and were more likely to not be banned after being reported for offenses—be them legitimate or not; this was the opposite for accounts on the other end of the spectrum. When Musk took over, this phenomenon was completely and totally inverted. IMO.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by davedx on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:28AM (#41170207)
I'm not a fan, I don't follow him, I just have my timeline on "Following" and almost never see any Elon content unless I look for it. I follow a small carefully curated list of people and still get value from the site.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by hstan4 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:43AM (#41170324)
Oh yeah everyone that hates him went to Threads, right?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by DonHopkins on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:41AM (#41169855)
Because San Jose is the home of Bad Boy Bail Bonds!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZAY83HIL-Jg

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by mrweasel on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:34AM (#41169813)
The timeline is just crazy, but from a financial stance it makes sense to leave the more expensive location, if you already have the space else where (ignoring that they didn't pay their rent in San Francisco anyway).

I can understand why most wouldn't want to work at Twitter, sorry X, but if you're young with few obligations, I can see people doing it just for the experience of it, at least for a year or two. It has to be an insane ride to be on.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by jagermo on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:19AM (#41169721)
probably got kicked out since Elon did not want to pay rent. Maybe the locks got changed.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by andrewinardeer on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:39AM (#41169844)
Why would X have gotten kicked out for unpaid rent?

The building manager stopped any and all proceedings against X for the two months of alleged unpaid rent.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by vundercind on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:50AM (#41169927)
Just because you caught up with back payments doesn’t mean the landlord wants you around anymore.

Not all delinquencies may have reached the level of lawsuit, either, while still being a problem.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by infecto on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:52AM (#41169946)
Doubtful narrative. In a time when occupancy is going up you would not want to kick our your anchor. Having a large company like X can help boost the rest of the area.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by vundercind on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:22AM (#41170166)
Throw in any other factor and it fits. Another tenant already lined up, musk wanting to significantly reduce the space he was leasing (plausible, no?) or what have you. A slow commercial market might be the only reason it took as long as it did.

Not a certainty, but a real possibility.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by davedx on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:29AM (#41170219)
Because commercial real estate is just booming right now, right? People are fighting for that office space!
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by wesleywt on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:54AM (#41169958)
Because Twitter doesn't pay rent. IDK?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by chuckadams on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:15AM (#41170586)
Given the surrounding conditions of lower Market, the landlord would probably need to pay someone to occupy the building if X didn’t.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by SanjayMehta on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:22AM (#41169736)
Shifting offices is also a way to get rid of staff without having to fire or lay them off.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by Rinzler89 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:41AM (#41169858)
Didn't he already fire most of the staff there? Who's left to fire?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by lupire on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:36PM (#41173809)
Incorrect. Shifting office is a layoff (constructive dismissal).
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by SanjayMehta on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @10:46PM (#41177775)
First time I’ve heard the term, thanks.

Does it still apply if the company offers relocation benefits and a reasonable time for (say) school transfers?

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by greenthrow on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @06:56AM (#41169610)
Folks with H1B visas have an undue burden on any attempt to move jobs. Also interviewing is hell for many tech folks who are extremely introverted (myself included in that last part.)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by macintux on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @09:10AM (#41170550)
Just getting an interview isn't easy for most in this economy.

Or maybe I'm just thoroughly unlikable.

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by scheme271 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:56PM (#41174037)
Very true although anyone on a H1B may have to file a bunch of paperwork since their job location changed. Although I suppose the paperwork is going to be more something that twitter's attorneys need to do.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rty32 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:42AM (#41179708)
H1B is nothing compared to those who need to file a new PERM due to work location change. Going to be rough.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by phendrenad2 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:36AM (#41169819)
Nah, this is VERY common for YC startups (which is the size of X I guess now)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by resource_waste on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:31AM (#41169787)
Maybe the building lease was up?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by wesleywt on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:50AM (#41169925)
Since Musk took over Twitter one word we could use to describe the process is "disruptive to employees"
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by smsm42 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:11PM (#41174185)
That depends on how many X employees actually live in SF and how many commute each day back and forth from the same South Bay. When I worked in SF, I regularly shared a train with the latter crowd, and there are a lot of them. I'm not saying they all work for X, but I suspect for a lot of people there the move would actually be an improvement.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by pound on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:39PM (#41174458)
Sacramento data center shutdown happened without even a few weeks notice (just suddenly, on Christmas eve Saturday)
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by slashdave on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:50PM (#41174586)
Disruptive for employees? Have you been reading about the recent history of this company?
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by pie420 on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:19PM (#41174887)
"very good remote work options"

You realize Teams is pre-installed on like every windows machine, right? that's literally all you need for remote work. And most people agree that remote works is preferable/more more productive

Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by rty32 on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:40AM (#41179701)
You don't say that 2020-2022 proves that remote work definitely is ok for a lot of people and they want it to stay that way. And recently there have been multiple reports showing that more flexible working options help lowering attribution. Well, what a surprise. /s It is clear that CEOs force people back to office mostly to cut headcounts.
Re:X is closing San Francisco HQ and relocating staffers to ... by andsoitis on Wednesday August 07, 2024 @05:41AM (#41179706)
> that's literally all you need for remote work.

Effective remote work is as much, if not more, a social and collaboration problem, as it is a technological problem.